Российский капитализм и отмывание денег

реклама
ÃËÎÁÀËÜÍÀß ÏÐÎÃÐÀÌÌÀ ÁÎÐÜÁÛ Ñ ÎÒÌÛÂÀÍÈÅÌ ÄÅÍÅÃ
Ðîññèéñêèé êàïèòàëèçì
è îòìûâàíèå äåíåã
Óïðàâëåíèå Îðãàíèçàöèè Îáúåäèíåííûõ Íàöèé
ïî êîíòðîëþ íàä íàðêîòèêàìè
è ïðåäóïðåæäåíèþ ïðåñòóïíîñòè
ÃËÎÁÀËÜÍÀß ÏÐÎÃÐÀÌÌÀ ÁÎÐÜÁÛ Ñ ÎÒÌÛÂÀÍÈÅÌ ÄÅÍÅÃ
Ðîññèéñêèé êàïèòàëèçì
è îòìûâàíèå äåíåã
ÎÐÃÀÍÈÇÀÖÈß ÎÁÚÅÄÈÍÅÍÍÛÕ ÍÀÖÈÉ
Íüþ-Éîðê, 2001 ãîä
Baeh`_ggu_ \ gZklhys_f ^hdmf_gl_ fg_gby y\eyxlky fg_gbyfb Z\lhjh\ b g_ h[yaZl_evgh
hljZ`Zxl\a]ey^uK_dj_lZjbZlZHj]ZgbaZpbbH[t_^bg_gguoGZpbc
Baeh`_gb_ fZl_jbZeh\ b mihlj_[ey_fu_ h[hagZq_gby \ gZklhys_f ba^Zgbb g_ hagZqZxl
\ujZ`_gbykhklhjhguK_dj_lZjbZlZHj]ZgbaZpbbH[t_^bg_gguoGZpbcdZdh]h[ulhgb[ueh
fg_gby hlghkbl_evgh ijZ\h\h]h klZlmkZ dZdhceb[h kljZgu l_jjblhjbb ]hjh^Z beb jZchgZ
bebbo\eZkl_cbebhlghkbl_evgh^_ebfblZpbbbo]jZgbp
MihfbgZgb_ gZbf_gh\Zgbc dhfiZgbc b dhff_jq_kdbo ijh^mdlh\ g_ ih^jZamf_\Z_l bo
h^h[j_gbyHj]ZgbaZpb_cH[t_^bg_gguoGZpbc
Him[ebdh\Zggu_ \ gZklhys_f ba^Zgbb fZl_jbZeu y\eyxlky kh[kl\_gghklvx Hj]ZgbaZpbb
H[t_^bg_gguo GZpbc b ihevamxlky aZsblhc Z\lhjkdbo ijZ\ \ khhl\_lkl\bb k iheh`_gbyfb
IjhlhdheZ d <k_fbjghc dhg\_gpbb h[ Z\lhjkdhf ijZ\_ dZkZxs_]hky ijbf_g_gby
iheh`_gbc Dhg\_gpbb d jZ[hlZf ih^]hlh\e_gguf \ jZfdZo g_dhlhjuo f_`^mgZjh^guo
hj]ZgbaZpbc Ijhkv[u hlghkbl_evgh jZaj_r_gby gZ i_j_i_qZldm ih^ibkZgguo fZl_jbZeh\
ke_^m_lgZijZ\eylvK_dj_lZjxBa^Zl_evkdhcdhee_]bbHj]ZgbaZpbbH[t_^bg_gguoGZpbcih
Z^j_km6HFUHWDU\RIWKH3XEOLFDWLRQV%RDUG8QLWHG1DWLRQV1HZ<RUN1<8QLWHG6WDWHV
RI$PHULFD
BA>:GB?HJ=:GBA:PBBH;T?>BG?GGUOG:PBC
<ijh^Z`_ih^‹5;,
Mqj_`^_ggZy\]h^m=eh[ZevgZyijh]jZffZ[hjv[ukhlfu\Zgb_f^_g_]hkms_kl\ey_lky
MijZ\e_gb_f ih dhgljhex gZ^ gZjdhlbdZfb b ij_^mij_`^_gbx ij_klmighklb \ jZfdZo
^_yl_evghklb Hj]ZgbaZpbb H[t_^bg_gguo GZpbc ih [hjv[_ F hlfu\Zgb_f ^hoh^h\
ihemq_gguo \ j_amevlZl_ ij_klmighc ^_yl_evghklb Ijh]jZffZ ijh\h^bl bkke_^h\Zgby
h[_ki_qb\Z_l l_ogbq_kdh_ kh^_ckl\b_ hij_^_ey_l fZg^Zlu khhl\_lkl\mxsbo hj]Zgh\ b p_eb
iheblbdbHj]ZgbaZpbbH[t_^bg_gguoGZpbc
>he]hj &hehg]h Z\lhj gZklhys_]h bkke_^h\Zgby y\ey_lky khljm^gbp_c =eh[Zevghc
ijh]jZffu [hjv[u k hlfu\Zgb_f ^_g_] MijZ\e_gby ih dhgljhex gZ^ gZjdhlbdZfb b
ij_^mij_`^_gbx ij_klmighklb K Z\lhjhf fh`gh k\yaZlvky ih nZdkm b ih
we_dljhgghcihql_GROJRUVRORQJR#RGFFSRUJ
:\lhj \ujZ`Z_l [eZ]h^Zjghklv Ibgh :jeZddb Bkihegbl_evghfm ^bj_dlhjm MijZ\e_gby ih
dhgljhex gZ^ gZjdhlbdZfb b ij_^mij_`^_gbx ij_klmighklb Z lZd`_ WebaZ[_l >`hck b
NjZgpbkdhLmfbkhljm^gbdZfMijZ\e_gbyihdhgljhexgZ^gZjdhlbdZfbbij_^mij_`^_gbx
ij_klmighklbaZdjblbq_kdb_aZf_qZgbyihjmdhibkbbihe_agu_j_dhf_g^Zpbb
^&RS\ULJKW8QLWHG1DWLRQV±$OOULJKWVUHVHUYHG±3ULQWHGLQ$XVWULD
Kh^_j`Zgb_
=eZ\Z
Klj
,
<\_^_gb_
,,
;_]kl\hdZiblZeZbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_] ,,,
>heeZjbaZpbyjhkkbckdhcwdhghfbdb ,9
Ijb\ZlbaZpbybebijbo\ZlbaZpby
9
L_g_\ZywdhghfbdZmdehg_gb_hlgZeh]h\[_aaZdhgb_ 9,
NbgZgkh\Zyeb[_jZebaZpbyb[Zgdh\kdZykbkl_fZ 9,,
Ij_klmighklvb[bag_k\JhkkbckdhcN_^_jZpbb
9,,,
:j]mf_glZpby\ihevamb^_be_]ZebaZpbbbbebZfgbklbb
$
KblmZpby\JhkkbckdhcN_^_jZpbbdZdhkgh\ghcZj]mf_gl %
F_`^mgZjh^gu_Zki_dlu^ZgghcZj]mf_glZpbb ,;
;hjv[Zkhlfu\Zgb_f^_g_] ;
AZdexq_gb_ ;b[ebh]jZnby LZ[ebpZIj_^iheZ]Z_fucfZkrlZ[[_]kl\ZdZiblZeZbaJhkkbckdhcN_^_jZpbb±]h^u
Jbkmgdb
,
Ijyfu_bghkljZggu_bg\_klbpbbb[_]kl\hdZiblZeZbaJhkkbckdhcN_^_jZpbb
±]h^u ,,
DZd\uhlghkbl_kvddZiblZebafm\JhkkbckdhcN_^_jZpbb"
,,,
Ke_^m_lebijh^he`Zlvj_nhjfu\JhkkbckdhcN_^_jZpbb" LLL
JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
=eZ\Z,
<\_^_gb_
I_jbh^ i_j_oh^Z hl khpbZebafZ d dZiblZebafm
\Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb hldjue g_h]jZgbq_ggu_ \ha
fh`ghklb ^ey hlfu\Zgby ^_g_] \ f_`^mgZjh^ghf
fZkrlZ[_ Eb[_jZebaZpby nbgZgkh\uo jugdh\ ijb\Z
lbaZpbybmf_gvr_gb_]hkm^Zjkl\_ggh]h\f_rZl_evkl
\Z \ wdhghfbdm ijhbkoh^yl \ mkeh\byo hlkmlkl\by kh
hl\_lkl\mxs_c aZdhgh^Zl_evghc [Zau b bgklblmpbh
gZevguo f_oZgbafh\ dhgljhey aZ wlbfb ijhp_kkZfb
<j_amevlZl_ hldju\Z_lky \hafh`ghklv [_kij_iylkl
\_ggh]h ijblhdZ jZaf_s_gby ihemq_gguo g_aZdhg
guf iml_f gZebqguo kj_^kl\ \ nbgZgkh\mx kbkl_fm
kljZgu hldm^Z hgb fh]ml e_]dh i_j_f_sZlvky \ f_`
^mgZjh^gmx nbgZgkh\mx kbkl_fm AZ ihke_^gb_ g_
kdhevdh e_l kj_^kl\Z fZkkh\hc bgnhjfZpbb gZpbh
gZevgu_ b f_`^mgZjh^gu_ hnbpbZevgu_ bklhqgbdb
klZeb\k_qZs_]h\hjblvh[m]jha_^eyf_`^mgZjh^ghc
nbgZgkh\hc[_ahiZkghklbdhlhjmxkha^Z_lhlfu\Zgb_
^_g_]k\yau\Z_fh_kJhkkbckdhcN_^_jZpb_c<kZfhf
^_e_ ij_^iheZ]Z_fu_ h[t_fu hlfuluo ^_g_] lhevdh
\ ^_e_ dZkZxs_fky ;wgd hn GvxChjd nb]mjbjm_l
kmffZ\fej^^heeKR:boZjZdl_jhj]ZgbaZpbc
aZf_rZgguo \ wlbo ^_eZo k\b^_l_evkl\mxl h[ mya\b
fhklb f_`^mgZjh^ghc nbgZgkh\hc kbkl_fu h \ha
fh`ghklb fZgbimebjh\Zgby _x b \g_^j_gby \ __
kljmdlmjmdjbfbgZevguowe_f_glh\
Lhqguo ^Zgguo h[ h[s_f h[t_f_ hlfu\Zgby ^_
g_]\JhkkbckdhcN_^_jZpbbg_lihkdhevdmhghk\yaZ
gh k lZdbfb \b^Zfb ^_yl_evghklb dhlhju_ k ljm^hf
ih^^Zxlky hlke_`b\Zgbx b mq_lm H fZkrlZ[Zo wlh]h
y\e_gbyl_fg_f_g__fh`ghkm^blvihh[t_fmml_qdb
dZiblZeZ ba Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb ij_^iheh`bl_ev
gh k\yaZgghc k hlfu\Zgb_f ^_g_] dhlhjZy aZ i_jbh^
±]h^h\ khklZ\beZ ih hp_gdZf fej^
^hee LZdZy hp_gdZ mdZau\Z_l gZ gZebqb_ ]em[bgguo
nZdlhjh\ kihkh[kl\mxsbo wlhfm Hkgh\gZy fZkkZ
g_aZdhgguo ^hoh^h\ lj_[mxsbo hlfu\Zgby \ p_eyo
bo ojZg_gby beb ^Zevg_cr_]h bg\_klbjh\Zgby fh`_l
bf_lv g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh_ hlghr_gb_ d ^\mf oZjZdl_j
guf hkh[_gghklyf kh\j_f_ggh]h jhkkbckdh]h dZiblZ
ebafZ ± ij_klmighklb b l_g_\hc wdhghfbd_ Ih h[
s_fm fg_gbx \ Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb kms_kl\mxl
\hafh`ghklb ^ey f_`^mgZjh^gh]h hlfu\Zgby ^_g_]
lh _klv ^ey hlfu\Zgby ^hoh^h\ ihemq_gguo \ fbj_
ij_klmiguf iml_f Hkh[_ggh rbjhdbfb wlb \hafh`
ghklb [ueb gZ i_j\uo wlZiZo ijb\ZlbaZpbb \ Jhkkbc
kdhcN_^_jZpbbdh]^Z]hkm^Zjkl\_ggZykh[kl\_gghklv
jZkijh^Z\ZeZkv aZ ij_^ty\bl_evkdb_ p_ggu_ [mfZ]b
H^gZdhkhh[s_gbchijblhd_ij_klmiguo^hoh^h\g_
fgh]h <hafh`gh wlh hlqZklb h[tykgy_lky djbfb
gZevguf Z ke_^h\Zl_evgh lsZl_evgh aZfZkdbjh\Zg
gufoZjZdl_jhflZdbohi_jZpbcbebbohlghkbl_evgh
fZehc agZqbfhklvx \ kh\j_f_gghc Jhkkbb =hjZa^h
[hevr_ ]h\hjblky h ij_klmiguo ^hoh^Zo \ qZklghklb
ihemqZ_fuo \ j_amevlZl_ kh\_jr_gby wdhghfbq_kdbo
ij_klmie_gbc \ Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb dhlhju_ ih
\k_c\b^bfhklbgm`^Zxlky\hlfu\ZgbbIh hp_gdZf
jhkkbckdbo ijZ\hhojZgbl_evguo hj]Zgh\ d dhgpm
]h^Z hj]Zgbah\Zggu_ ij_klmigu_ ]jmiibjh\db
dhgljhebjh\Zeb hdheh iheh\bgu dhff_jq_kdbo [Zg
dh\ ijhp_glh\ ]hkm^Zjkl\_gguo b ijhp_glh\
qZklguo ij_^ijbylbc JhkkbckdZy N_^_jZpby ij_^hk
lZ\ey_l[e_klysb_\hafh`ghklb^eyl_odlhklj_fblky
d [ukljhfm ijbh[j_l_gbx djmiguo Zdlb\h\ g_aZdhg
guf iml_f hklZ\Zykv \g_ ihey aj_gby ijZ\hhojZgb
l_evguohj]Zgh\bebhnhjfeyyk^_edblZdbfh[jZahf
qlh[u bo g_aZdhgghklv [ueh ljm^gh beb ^Z`_ g_\ha
fh`gh ^hdZaZlv Ihwlhfm JhkkbckdZy N_^_jZpby \_
jhylgh y\ey_lky p_gljhf kh\_jr_gby hi_jZpbc ih
hlfu\Zgbx^_g_]g_lhevdh[eZ]h^Zjykms_kl\mxsbf
lZf [eZ]hijbylguf \hafh`ghklyf ^ey jZaf_s_gby
dZiblZeh\ gh b [eZ]h^Zjy gZebqbx \ kljZg_ g_aZdhg
guo^hoh^h\lj_[mxsbohlfu\Zgby
< ^Zgghc jZ[hl_ jZkkfZljb\Zxlky l_ Zki_dlu
wdhghfbq_kdhc j_nhjfu b l_g^_gpbb jZa\blby wdhgh
fbdbJhkkbckdhcN_^_jZpbbh dhlhjuo fh`gh k ihe
guf hkgh\Zgb_f ml\_j`^Zlv qlh hgb kihkh[kl\mxl
hlfu\Zgbx^_g_]Ijh[e_fubkeh`ghklbk\yaZggu_k
rbjhdhfZkrlZ[gufb j_nhjfZfb i_j_oh^gh]h i_jbh
^Zkha^Zxl\kljZg_[eZ]hijbylgu_mkeh\by^eyhlfu
\Zgby ^_g_] LZdb_ j_nhjfu \dexqZxl ijh\h^bfmx
[ukljufb l_fiZfb ijb\ZlbaZpbx i_j_kljhcdm [Zg
dh\kdh]h b nbgZgkh\h]h k_dlhjh\ Z lZd`_ iheblbq_
JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
kdb_ b Z^fbgbkljZlb\ghohayckl\_ggu_ ij_h[jZah\Z
gbyIhiuldbij_k_q_gbyhlfu\Zgby^_g_]kihfhsvx
jZaebqguo kj_^kl\ aZdhgh^Zl_evkl\h j_]mebjh\Zgb_
jZkke_^h\Zgb_km^_[gh_ij_ke_^h\Zgb_bl^aZ\bkyl
hl h[s_]h ijhp_kkZ iheblbq_kdbo b wdhghfbq_kdbo
ij_h[jZah\Zgbc b l_kgh k\yaZgu k gbf Ihwlhfm hgb
^he`gu ij_^ijbgbfZlvky \ khq_lZgbb k [he__ rbjh
dbfbf_jZfbgZijZ\e_ggufbgZmihjy^hq_gb_ wdhgh
fbq_kdbo j_nhjf b jZa\blb_ nmgdpbhgbjmxsbo jug
dh\ kha^Zgb_ g_h[oh^bfhc aZdhgh^Zl_evghc [Zau kh
\_jr_gkl\h\Zgb_]hkm^Zjkl\_gguobgklblmlh\bf_lh
^h\mijZ\e_gby
JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
=eZ\Z,,
;_]kl\hdZiblZeZbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
Hlfu\Zgb_ ^_g_] aZljZ]b\Z_l rbjhdbc djm] ^_y
l_evghklb b hkms_kl\ey_lky k bkihevah\Zgb_f nbgZg
kh\uo bgkljmf_glh\ kdjuluo hl gZ[ex^_gby qlh aZ
ljm^gy_l\k_klhjhggxxbkh^_j`Zl_evgmxhp_gdm_]h
fZkrlZ[h\ DZd b \ ^jm]bo kljZgZo \ Jhkkbckdhc N_
^_jZpbb gbdZdbo lhqguo hnbpbZevguo beb g_hnbpb
Zevguohp_ghdhlghkbl_evghh[t_fZhlfuluo^_g_]g_
kms_kl\m_l < Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb jZaf_ju hlfu
\Zgby^_g_]qZklhjZkkqblu\ZxlkygZhkgh\_^Zgguoh
[_]kl\_ dZiblZeZ ihkdhevdm ij_^iheZ]Z_lky qlh \
agZqbl_evghc k\h_c qZklb ba kljZgu [_]ml hlfulu_
g_aZdhggu_ ^hoh^u JZafZo [_]kl\Z dZiblZeZ \ k\hx
hq_j_^v gZ\h^bl gZ fukev hlghkbl_evgh fZkrlZ[h\
hlfu\Zgby^_g_]
< _ ]h^u [_]kl\h dZiblZeZ ba Jhkkbckdhc N_
^_jZpbb ^hklb]Zeh agZqbl_evguo jZaf_jh\ Wlh ijb
agZebfgh]b_ki_pbZebkluohlyfg_gbyihih\h^m_]h
ijbjh^u b fZkrlZ[h\ jZkoh^ylky < jZfdZo kh\f_kl
gh]h ijh_dlZ ih ZgZebam ijh[e_fu [_]kl\Z dZiblZeZ
ij_^ijbgylh]h fhkdh\kdbf Bgklblmlhf wdhghfbdb b
P_gljhf bamq_gby f_`^mgZjh^guo hlghr_gbc Mgb
\_jkbl_lZ AZiZ^gh]h HglZjbh DZgZ^Z jZkkfZljb\Z
ebkv jZaebqgu_ hp_gdb fZkrlZ[h\ [_]kl\Z dZiblZeZ
ij_^klZ\e_ggu_ jhkkbckdbfb n_^_jZevgufb \_^hfkl
\Zfb P_gljZevguf [Zgdhf Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb b
f_`^mgZjh^gufb nbgZgkh\ufb mqj_`^_gbyfb <ha
]eZ\ey_fZyE_hgb^hf:[Zedbguf]jmiiZjZ[hlZ\rZy
gZ^ ijh_dlhf ijbreZ d aZdexq_gbx qlh kj_^gyy
hp_gdZ bkoh^y ba ^Zgguo jZaebqguo hj]ZgbaZpbc aZ
i_jbh^±]h^h\khklZ\ey_l\p_ehffej^
^hee < i_j\u_ ]h^u i_j_oh^gh]h i_jbh^Z ±
dh]^Z fZkrlZ[u [_]kl\Z dZiblZeZ [ueb
hq_\b^gh gZfgh]h [hevr_ q_f \ ihke_^mxsb_ ]h^u
^hklh\_jgu_ ^Zggu_ h ieZl_`ghf [ZeZgk_ g_
ihklmiZeb JZ[hlZ\rZy gZ^ ijh_dlhf ]jmiiZ
bkdexqb\ wlhl i_jbh^ ijbreZ d \u\h^m qlh k
]h^Z ih k_gly[jv ]h^Z [_]kl\h dZiblZeZ ba
Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb _`_]h^gh ijhbkoh^beh gZ
mjh\g_ fej^ ^hee \ bkke_^h\Zgbb iheghklvx
mqblu\Z_lky klZlvy hrb[db b ijhimkdb ieZl_`gh]h
[ZeZgkZ Z lZd`_ wdkihjlgu_ lhj]h\u_ dj_^blu b
Z\Zgku ih bfihjlm < ]h^m ih hp_gdZf P_g
ljZevgh]h [ZgdZ Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb fZkrlZ[ [_]
kl\Z dZiblZeZ aZ i_jbh^ ± ]h^h\ bkqbkeyeky
kmffhc \ fej^ ^hee lh _klv hdheh fej^ \
]h^P_gljZevguc[Zgdbkoh^bebakmffug_ihemq_g
guo ihklmie_gbc hl wdkihjlZ g_ih]Zr_gguo Z\Zgkh\
ihbfihjlmg_wd\b\Ze_glgh]h [Zjl_jZ b ijhp_glh\
kmffu ih klZlv_ hrb[db b ijhimkdb >ey hp_gdb
hlfu\Z_fuokmffP_gljkljZl_]bq_kdbob]eh[Zevguo
bkke_^h\Zgbc ± gZmqghbkke_^h\Zl_evkdbc bgklblml
Jhkkbckdhc ZdZ^_fbb gZmd ± bkihevah\Ze dhk\_ggu_
ihdZaZl_eb lZdb_ dZd ij_^iheZ]Z_fZy ^hey l_g_\hc
wdhghfbdb \ h[t_f_ \Zeh\h]h \gmlj_gg_]h ijh^mdlZ
<<I ZgZeh]bqgu_ ihdZaZl_eb ih gZpbhgZevghfm
^hoh^m b ijhp_glm gZebqguo b [Zjl_jguo k^_ehd \
fZkrlZ[Zo \k_c wdhghfbdb hnbpbZevgu_ ^Zggu_ ih
hllhdmdZiblZeZbaJhkkbckdhcN_^_jZpbbh[t_fdmi
ebijh^Z`b djZldhkjhqguo h[eb]Zpbc \ jhkkbckdbo
dhff_jq_kdbo [ZgdZo ^bgZfbdZ \b^bfh]h \\haZ gZ
ebqguo^heeZjh\ZlZd`_h[t_fhkms_kl\ey_fhcjhk
kbygZfb q_eghqghc lhj]h\eb P_glj dhlhjuc
klhedgm\rbkv k g_^hklZldhf ^hklh\_jguo ^Zgguo
[ue \ugm`^_g \ ]h^m ij_djZlblv wlm jZ[hlm
ij_^iheh`be qlh kmffZ hlfu\Z_fuo ^_g_] fh`_l
gZoh^blvky\ij_^_eZohl^hfej^^heeLZdhc
]b]Zglkdbc jZa[jhk \ agZqbl_evghc f_j_ h[tykgy_lky
g_^hklZldhf^hklh\_jguo^ZgguobjZaebqbyfb\lhe
dh\Zgbb ihgylby hlfu\Zgb_ ^_g_] dhlhjh_ fh`_l
hij_^_eylvky\madhfb\rbjhdhfkfuke_
=jmiiZ ih^ jmdh\h^kl\hf E_hgb^Z :[ZedbgZ
ijh_dl ih bkke_^h\Zgbx ijh[e_fu [_]kl\Z dZiblZeZ
ijbreZ d aZdexq_gbx qlh \ i_jbh^ k yg\Zjy
]h^Z ih k_gly[jy ]h^Z gZ aZjm[_`guo
kq_lZo jhkkbyg gZoh^behkv hdheh fej^ ^hee ijb
wlhf ijhp_glZ [ueb ihemq_gu aZ kq_l g_aZdhggh]h
\u\haZ dZiblZeZ ihabpby ijhp_glh\ ± aZ kq_l
ihemaZdhgguo k^_ehd ihabpby Z hklZevgh_ khklZ\
eyeb ^hoh^u hl jZaebqguo nbgZgkh\uo hi_jZpbc k
hkgh\gufb nhg^Zfb kf lZ[ebpm gb`_ Wlm deZk
kbnbdZpbx fh`gh e_]dh hijh\_j]gmlv b ij_^eh`blv
^jm]b_ \ZjbZglu\aZ\bkbfhklbhllh]hdZd ihgb
JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
fZlv khhl\_lkl\mxsb_ l_jfbgu g_aZdhgguc ihem
aZdhgguc b l^ b qlh iheZ]Zlv klZlbklbq_kdbfb
hrb[dZfb GZebqb_ g_]Zlb\ghc aZibkb \ klZlv_
hrb[dbbijhimkdbdhlhjmxfh`ghijbgylvaZg_aZ
dhgguc \u\ha Zdlb\h\ fej^ ^hee gZ ^_e_ fh
`_l hdZaZlvky g_mql_gguf hllhdhf kj_^kl\ k l_dm
sbokq_lh\\qZklghklbihbfihjlm
KijZ\_^eb\h ij_^iheh`blv qlh dZiblZe moh^y
sbcbaJhkkbckdhcN_^_jZpbbg_aZdhggufiml_ffh
`_l\ha\jZsZlvky\kljZgmaZfZkdbjh\ZggucdZdaZdhg
gu_ bghkljZggu_ bg\_klbpbb Fh`gh gZ[ex^Zlv ijy
fmx\aZbfhk\yavf_`^m[_]kl\hfdZiblZeZ^Z`_bkoh^y
ba fbgbfZevguo hp_ghd _]h fZkrlZ[h\ b ijyfufb
bghkljZggufb bg\_klbpbyfb IBB kf jbkmghd ,
LZ[ebpZ
Ij_^iheZ]Z_fucfZkrlZ[[_]kl\ZdZiblZeZbaJhkkbckdhcN_^_jZpbb±]h^u
fbeebZj^u^heeZjh\
KlZlvy
Z
<k_]h
Z
\±
G_aZj_]bkljbjh\ZgguchllhddZiblZeZ
klZlvyHrb[dbbijhimkdb
AZ^he`_gghklvihwdkihjlmbg_ihdju
lu_Z\Zgkh\u_ieZl_`bihbfihjlm
Wdkihjlgu_lhj]h\u_dj_^blubZ\Zgku
ihbfihjlmjZagbpZf_`^mij_^eh`_g
gufbbihemq_ggufbkmffZfb
;_]kl\hdZiblZeZ
Bklhqgbd$EDONLQkljijb\h^blkykkhdjZs_gbyfb
Z
Ih]h^m^Zggu_ijb\h^ylkyaZi_j\u_^_\ylvf_kyp_\
Jbkmghd
Ijyfu_bghkljZggu_bg\_klbpbbb[_]kl\hdZiblZeZbaJhkkbckdhcN_^_jZpbb±]h^u
fbeebZj^u^heeZjh\
IBB
;_]kl\hdZiblZeZ
BklhqgbdP_gljZevguc[ZgdJhkkbckdhcN_^_jZpbb±^Zggu_ihIBBP_gljZevguc[ZgdJhkkbckdhcN_^_
jZpbbpblihF_`^mgZjh^guc\Zexlgucnhg^F<N±^Zggu_ih[_]kl\mdZiblZeZ
JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
WlZ \aZbfhk\yav hkh[_ggh q_ldh ijhke_`b\ZeZkv \
b]h^Zodh]^Zh[ZihdZaZl_eyh^gh\j_f_ggh
^_fhgkljbjh\Zeb agZqbl_evguc ih^t_f \ b kgb
`_gb_ \ ]h^m H^gZdh h[_ wlb l_g^_gpbb fh`gh
h[tykgblv h[sbfb j_amevlZlZfb nmgdpbhgbjh\Zgby
jhkkbckdhc wdhghfbdb \Zeh\hc gZpbhgZevguc ijh
^mdl<GIkljZgum\_ebqbeky\]h^m^hj_dhj^
gh]h mjh\gy fej^ ^hee Z \ ]h^m kgbabeky
^hfej^^heeJhklfZkrlZ[h\[_]kl\ZdZiblZeZ\
]h^m fh] y\blvky j_amevlZlhf [ukljh]h j_Z]bjh
\Zgby ihlhdh\ dZiblZeZ gZ mom^r_gb_ wdhghfbq_kdhc
bnbgZgkh\hckblmZpbbddhgpm]h^ZDjhf_lh]h
ijblhdIBB\JhkkbckdmxN_^_jZpbx[uefbgbfZev
guf ih kjZ\g_gbx k ij_^iheZ]Z_fuf fZkrlZ[hf [_]
kl\ZdZiblZeZ>eykjZ\g_gby\DblZ_]^_[_]kl\hdZ
iblZeZgZoh^behkvijbf_jghgZlhf`_mjh\g_qlhb\
Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb \ _ ]h^u gZ[ex^Zehkv
m\_ebq_gb_ijblhdZIBBdhlhjuc\]h^m^hklb]
fej^ ^hee < Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb ijblhd
IBB\]h^mkhklZ\eyefej^^hee
:\lhju bkke_^h\Zgbc ij_^eZ]Zxsb_ k\hb
hp_gdbfZkrlZ[h\[_]kl\ZdZiblZeZdZdb\kemqZ_k
^h]Z^dZfbhlghkbl_evghh[t_fh\ hlfu\Zgby ^_g_]
dZ`^uc jZa ij_^mij_`^Zxl qlh ijb\h^bfu_ bfb
pbnjuke_^m_ljZkkfZljb\ZlvdZd\_kvfZ]bihl_lbq_
kdh_ ijb[eb`_gb_ baaZ [hevrhc g_hij_^_e_gghklb
k\yaZgghc kh klZlbklbq_kdbfb hrb[dZfb b gbadbf
dZq_kl\hf ^Zgguo \ p_ehf LZdbf h[jZahf wlb pbn
juke_^m_l\hkijbgbfZlvg_dZdlhqgu_ihdZaZl_ebZ
dZd h[hagZq_gb_ ijh[e_fu L_f g_ f_g__ hp_gblv
fZkrlZ[u [_]kl\Z dZiblZeZ ]hjZa^h e_]q_ q_f h[t_
fu hlfu\Zgby ^_g_] qlh h[mkeh\e_gh \ukhdhc kl_
i_gvx k_dj_lghklb khklZ\eyxs_c g_hlt_fe_fmx
oZjZdl_jbklbdm ijhp_kkZ hlfu\Zgby ^_g_] Hp_gdZ
fZkrlZ[h\ [_]kl\Z dZiblZeZ ± wlh ihdZaZl_ev [he__
agZqbfuc ^ey wdhghfbklh\ iheblbdh\ b jy^h\uo
]jZ`^Zg Hg aZgbfZ_l \Z`gh_ f_klh \ ijZ\bl_evkl
\_gghc ijh]jZff_ nbgZgkh\hc klZ[bebaZpbb b kem
`bl ihimeyjghc l_fhc ^ey iheblbdh\ dhlhju_ klj_
fylky ij_^klZ\blv k_[y iZljbhlZfb [hjxsbfbky aZ
khojZg_gb_gZpbhgZevgh]h^hklhygby
FZeh dh]h \ Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb [_kihdhbl
hlfu\Zgb_ ^_g_] dZd lZdh\h_ gh fgh]bo \hegm_l ijh
[e_fZ dhehkkZevguo g_aZdhgguo ^hoh^h\ hl jZa\hjh
\u\Zgby b ijbk\h_gby g_aZdhgguf iml_f ]hkm^Zjkl
\_gguo b qZklguo kj_^kl\ WlZ h[_kihdh_gghklv hljZ
`Z_l b lhl nZdl qlh f_`^mgZjh^gh_ khh[s_kl\h \hk
ijbgbfZ_l Jhkkbckdmx N_^_jZpbx kdhj__ dZd bklhq
gbd g_aZdhgguo ^hoh^h\ g_`_eb dZd [_ahiZkgh_ m[_
`bs_ ^ey bo ojZg_gby Hi_jZpbb ih ihemq_gbx g_aZ
dhgguo^hoh^h\ih^iZ^Zxlih^rbjhdh_lhedh\Zgb_
hlfu\Zgby ^_g_] dhlhjh_ \dexqZ_l e_]ZebaZpbx
kj_^kl\ ihemq_gguo ba jZaghh[jZaguo bklhqgbdh\ \
lhf qbke_ hl jZagh]h jh^Z ki_dmeypbc b g_dhlhjuo
f_lh^h\ ijb\ZlbaZpbb ij_klmiguc oZjZdl_j dhlhjuo
g_\hafh`gh^hdZaZlvihkdhevdmgZfhf_glijbf_g_gby
hgbg_ijhlb\hj_qbebm]heh\ghfmaZdhgh^Zl_evkl\m
IulZykv g_ ^himklblv e_]ZebaZpbb g_aZdhgguo
^hoh^h\jhkkbckdb_\eZklbm`_klhqbeb]hkm^Zjkl\_g
guc dhgljhev \dexqZxsbc f_ju ih ij_djZs_gbx
nbgZgkh\hc eb[_jZebaZpbb b \\_^_gbx \Zexlgh]h
dhgljhey < ^Zevg_cr_f ijZ\bl_evkl\h ih\ukbeh
jZaf_ju h[yaZl_evghc ijh^Z`b \Zexlguo ihklmie_
gbck^hijhp_glh\b^hijhp_glh\m\_ebqb
eh jZaf_j h[yaZl_evguo ^_ihablh\ ih bfihjlm Gh
\eZklblZd`_mdj_ibebgZeh]h\h_\_^hfkl\hbmkbebeb
gZ^ahjaZnbgZgkh\ufk_dlhjhfIhlhj]h\ufk^_edZf
klZeZ lj_[h\Zlvky [he__ ih^jh[gZy hlq_lghklv [ueZ
kha^ZgZ kbkl_fZ h[f_gZ bgnhjfZpb_c b dhhj^bgZpbb
^_ckl\bcf_`^mP_gljZevguf[ZgdhfJhkkbckdhcN_
^_jZpbb b N_^_jZevguf mijZ\e_gb_f \Zexlgh]h dhg
ljheyP_gljZevguc[Zgdhij_^_ebedjbl_jbb\uy\e_
gby ih^hajbl_evguo k^_ehd b ^Ze ihjmq_gb_ dhff_j
q_kdbf [ZgdZf khh[sZlv h[h \k_o k^_edZo \uau\Zx
sboih^haj_gb_
<\_^_gu [ueb lZd`_ f_oZgbafu \Zexlgh]h dhg
ljhey \ lhf qbke_ ijbhklZgh\e_gb_ hi_jZpbc q_j_a
g_j_ab^_glh\ ± lZd gZau\Z_fuo ki_pbZevguo kq_lh\
KqlhkjZam`_ijb\_ehdihy\e_gbxgh\uonbgZgkh
\uo ko_f iha\heyxsbo h[oh^blv wlb h]jZgbq_gby <
wlbo ko_fZo aZ^_ckl\h\Zgu bghkljZggu_ ^_j`Zl_eb
jm[e_c b jhkkbckdb_ dhfiZgbb aZbgl_j_kh\Zggu_ \
^_eh\uo hlghr_gbyo k gbfb Ih lZdhc ko_f_ Zdpbb
jhkkbckdbo dhfiZgbc ijh^Zggu_ aZ jm[eb bghkljZg
guf dhfiZgbyf \udmiZebkv l_fb `_ jhkkbckdbfb
dhfiZgbyfb aZ l\_j^mx \Zexlm >ey ihdmidb Zdpbc
jhkkbckdb_ dhfiZgbb bkihevamxl k\hb \Zexlgu_
kj_^kl\ZjZaf_s_ggu_aZjm[_`hfKhh[sZehkvqlhk
ihfhsvx lZdh]h f_oZgbafZ dhfiZgby Emdhce ijh
^ZeZ feg ijhp_gl hl h[s_]h dhebq_kl\Z k\hbo
Zdpbc[ZgdmKblb[wgdaZfej^jm[e_cZdhfiZgby
Kb[g_nlv ijh^ZeZ Zdpbc gZ fej^ jm[e_c
ijhp_glZ hl h[s_]h dhebq_kl\Z [Zgdm KbWk
N_jkl ;hklhg Jhkkbckdb_ \eZklb hoZjZdl_jbah\Zeb
wlb hi_jZpbb dZd k^_edb h]jZgbq_ggh]h fZkrlZ[Z
dZd ZfhjZevgu_ gh g_ ghkysb_ ij_klmigh]h oZjZd
l_jZL_fg_f_g__[ueih^gyl\hijhkdZdbihq_fm
jhkkbckdb_ dhfiZgbb ihemqbeb \hafh`ghklv Zddmfm
ebjh\Zlv b ^_j`Zlv aZ jm[_`hf kj_^kl\Z \ lZdbo
jZaf_jZo
< j_amevlZl_ f_j gZijZ\e_gguo gZ k^_j`b\Zgb_
[_]kl\Z dZiblZeZ \ ]h^m _]h h[t_f kgbabeky gZ
ijhp_glh\ b khklZ\be fej^ ^hee ih kjZ\g_gbx
k fej^ \ ]h^m =eZ\gmx jhev \ wlhf ku]jZeh
khdjZs_gb_ fZkrlZ[h\ [_]kl\Z dZiblZeZ \ hnrhjgu_
JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
p_glju dhlhjh_ \ ±]h^Zo kgbabehkv gZ
ijhp_glh\ ± \ kj_^g_f k fej^ ^hee ^h feg
^hee \ d\ZjlZe H`b^Z_lky khdjZs_gb_ fZkrlZ[h\
[_]kl\Z dZiblZeZ aZ kq_l g_ihemq_gby wdkihjlguo ih
klmie_gbc g_ih]Zr_gguo Z\Zgkh\ ih bfihjlm b \u
ieZl nbdlb\guo rljZnh\ ih \g_rg_lhj]h\uf hi_jZ
pbyf<bxg_]h^ZP_gljZevguc[Zgdkhh[sbe
qlh hllhd kj_^kl\ \ hnrhjgu_ ahgu _s_ [hevr_ kgb
abekyb\i_j\hfd\ZjlZe_]h^ZkhklZ\befeg
^heeL_dh]h[_kihdhblijh[e_fZhlfu\Zgby^_g_]
gZ^_xlky qlh wlh kgb`_gb_ hagZqZ_l khdjZs_gb_
fZkrlZ[h\e_]ZebaZpbbg_aZdhgguo^hoh^h\dhlhjZy\
JhkkbckdhcN_^_jZpbbg_jZaju\ghk\yaZgZk[_]kl\hf
dZiblZeZ
JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
=eZ\Z,,,
>heeZjbaZpbyjhkkbckdhcwdhghfbdb
Fbjh\u_q_jgu_jugdb\k_\[hevr_ckl_i_gb
bkihevamxl ^heeZju KR: \ dZq_kl\_ kj_^kl\Z ^ey
kh\_jr_gbylZcguohilh\uok^_ehd^eykhdjulbyf_
`^mgZjh^guo nbgZgkh\uo ljZgkn_jlh\ b ojZg_gby
ih^ihevguo k[_j_`_gbc Wlh hlghkblky dh \k_fm
ki_dljm g_aZdhgghc b ih^ihevghc ^_yl_evghklb Q_f
[he__ jZkijhkljZg_gguf klZgh\blky bkihevah\Zgb_
^heeZjh\ KR: l_f e_]q_ dhg\_jlbjh\Zlv bo \ f_kl
gmx\ZexlmbebgZh[hjhl\aZ\bkbfhklbhlihlj_[gh
klb b lZdbf h[jZahf aZljm^gblv \ ^Zevg_cr_f hlke_
`b\Zgb_g_aZdhgguo^hoh^h\
<Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb ^heeZjbaZpby wdhghfb
db beb i_j_\h^ kj_^kl\ ^_ghfbgbjh\Zgguo \ gZpbh
gZevghc \Zexl_ \ bghkljZggmx \Zexlm ^heeZju
hkms_kl\ey_lky k ]h^Z dh]^Z gZqZeZkv eb[_jZeb
aZpby \g_rg_c lhj]h\eb K wlh]h \j_f_gb ihdZaZl_ev
^heeZjbaZpbb ^_fhgkljbjh\Ze mklhcqb\mx l_g^_gpbx
d ih\ur_gbx k g_dhlhjufb dhe_[Zgbyfb hljZ`Zx
sbfb^_ckl\byjhkkbckdbo\eZkl_cdhlhju_eb[hm`_
ij_^ijbgbfZxlky eb[h lhevdh h`b^Zxlky < hdly[j_
]h^Z j_Z]bjmy gZ q_jguc \lhjgbd dh]^Z jm[ev
h[_kp_gbekyaZh^bg^_gvgZijhp_glh\ihhlghr_
gbx d ^heeZjm KR: ihdZaZl_ev ^heeZjbaZpbb j_adh
ih^kdhqbe < ]h^m fZkkbjh\Zggu_ bgl_j\_gpbb
ij_^ijbgylu_P_gljZevguf;ZgdhfJhkkbckdhcN_^_
jZpbb k p_evx aZsblu jm[ey ijb\_eb d \hagbdgh\_
gbxh[jZlghcl_g^_gpbb±[_]kl\mhl^heeZjZdjm[
ex < ij_^\b^_gbb nbgZgkh\hc g_klZ[bevghklb b ^_
\Zev\Zpbb jm[ey kijhk gZ ^heeZju \gh\v ih^kdhqbe \
]h^mbijh^he`Z_ljZklb^hkboihj<]h^m
b\l_q_gb_i_j\uok_fbf_kyp_\]h^Zjhkkbckdb_
j_ab^_glu dmibeb fej^ ^heeZjh\ ± \ ^\Z jZaZ
[hevr_ q_f [ueh dmie_gh \ ij_^u^msb_ q_luj_ ]h
^Z NbgZgkh\uc djbabk ]h^Z lZd`_ kihkh[kl\h
\Ze ^Zevg_cr_c ^heeZjbaZpbb jhkkbckdhc wdhghfbdb
LZdbfh[jZahf\ukhdZykl_i_gv^heeZjbaZpbb\h\lh
jhciheh\bg_o]h^h\hljZ`Z_lmkbeb\rmxkyg_hi
j_^_e_gghklv hlghkbl_evgh gZ^_`ghklb ojZg_gby
kj_^kl\ \ gZpbhgZevghc \Zexl_ QZklu_ baf_g_gby
iheblbq_kdh]h dmjkZ b ijh\h^bfu_ jhkkbckdbfb \eZ
klyfb j_nhjfu ijb\_^rb_ d mf_gvr_gbx klhbfhklb
jm[ey jZaebqgu_ nbgZgkh\u_ ki_dmeylb\gu_ ko_fu
\dexqZy nbgZgkh\u_ ibjZfb^u Z lZd`_ nbgZgkh\u_
djbabku ih\e_drb_ fZkkh\u_ [Zgdjhlkl\Z ± \k_ wlh
kihkh[kl\h\Zehk_jv_aghc^bkdj_^blZpbbjm[ey
Kl_i_gv aZf_s_gby gZpbhgZevghc \Zexlu bgh
kljZgghc hljZ`_gZ \ khhlghr_gbb f_`^m gZebqghc
bghkljZgghc \Zexlhc b gZebqghklvx \ gZpbhgZevghc
\Zexl_ Kl_i_gv aZf_gu [Zgdh\kdbo ^_ihablh\ \ gZ
pbhgZevghc \Zexl_ ^_ihablZfb \ bghkljZgghc \Zexl_
ijhy\ey_lky\hlghr_gbbwlbo^_ihablh\d^_g_`ghfm
Z]j_]Zlm F dhlhjuc \dexqZ_l gZebqgu_ ^_gv]b \
h[jZs_gbb FH iexk ^_g_`gu_ jm[e_\u_ kj_^kl\Z
j_ab^_glh\ ^hfZrgbo ohayckl\ b g_[Zgdh\kdbo mqj_
`^_gbc gZ l_dmsbo b ^_ihablguo kq_lZo \ [ZgdZo
>heeZjbaZpby \ujZ`Z_lky \ bkihevah\Zgbb ^heeZjh\
KR:\dZq_kl\_kj_^kl\ZieZl_`Z\ZexlZbkj_^kl\Z
k[_j_`_gby Zdlb\u KjZ\g_gb_ ^\mo l_g^_gpbc ±
ojZg_gbykj_^kl\\dZq_kl\_gZebqghklbbojZg_gbybo
gZ [Zgdh\kdbo ^_ihablZo \ Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb ±
ihdZau\Z_l agZqbl_evguc b g_ij_ju\guc jhkl h[t_
fh\ gZebqghc bghkljZgghc \Zexlu ih hlghr_gbx d
^_ihablZf < ]h^m gZ ^hex bghkljZgghc \Zexlu
ijboh^behkv k\ur_ ijhp_glh\ \k_]h ^_g_`gh]h
ihlhdZ ba gbo ijhp_glh\ ijboh^behkv gZ gZebq
gmx bghkljZggmx \Zexlm Lhl nZdl qlh agZqbl_ev
gh_ ij_^ihql_gb_ hl^Z_lky gZebqghc bghkljZgghc \Z
exl_fh`_lhagZqZlvqlhm\_ebq_gb_h[t_fZl_g_\hc
^_yl_evghklby\ey_lkyhij_^_eyxsbf^eyl_g^_gpbbd
^heeZjbaZpbb wdhghfbdb Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb Ih
^ZggufP_gljZevgh]h[ZgdZJhkkbckdhcN_^_jZpbb\
]h^m q_j_a [Zgdh\kdmx kbkl_fm \ Jhkkbckdmx
N_^_jZpbx ihklmibeh gZebqghklb \ bghkljZgghc \Z
exl_ gZ kmffm fej^ ^hee \ lh \j_fy dZd hllhd
^_g_] ba kljZgu khklZ\be lhevdh feg ^hee [Z
eZgk fej^ ^hee < ]h^m jZagbpZ f_`^m
ijblhdhf b hllhdhf ^_g_] khklZ\beZ fej^ ^hee
Z \ ]h^m ± fej^ ^hee ijbq_f ihke_^gyy
pbnjZ hljZ`Z_l khdjZs_gb_ ijblhdZ ^_g_] \ kljZgm \
j_amevlZl_ [Zgdjhlkl\ ihke_^h\Z\rbo aZ nbgZgkh\uf
djbabkhf LZdbf h[jZahf \ i_jbh^ f_`^m b
]h^Zfb\JhkkbckdmxN_^_jZpbxihklmibehbgh
JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
kljZgghc gZebqghklb \ kj_^g_f gZ kmffm fej^
^hee qlh ij_\urZ_l g_dhlhju_ hp_gdb hlghkbl_evgh
fZkrlZ[h\ [_]kl\Z dZiblZeZ ba kljZgu < j_amevlZl_
dhebq_kl\h bghkljZgghc \Zexlu agZqbl_evgh ij_
\urZ_ljm[e_\mxgZebqghklv\ujZ`_ggmx\^heeZjZo
KR: ih l_dms_fm h[f_gghfm dmjkm Wlh dhebq_
kl\h ij_\urZ_l jm[e_\u_ kj_^kl\Z \ ^_kylv jZa _keb
mqblu\Zlv lhevdh [Zgdh\kdb_ hi_jZpbb b \ ljb jZaZ
_keb ijbgbfZlv \h \gbfZgb_ g_hj]Zgbah\Zgguc
bfihjl q_eghqgmx lhj]h\ex Kh]eZkgh hnbpbZev
guf hp_gdZf gZ ^hex q_eghdh\ ijboh^blky
ijhp_glh\ \k_]h bfihjlZ ijb wlhf hgb jZkoh^m
xl ±fej^ ^hee LZdbf h[jZahf _keb \uq_klv
klhbfhklv lh\Zjh\ \\habfuo q_eghdZfb hdheh
fej^ ^hee ba h[s_]h h[t_fZ gZebqghc bghkljZg
ghc\ZexlugZdhie_gghc\i_jbh^kih]h^
fej^ ^hee lh ihemqblky hklZlhd k\ur_
fej^^heeqlh\k_`_\ljbjZaZ[hevr_q_fdheb
q_kl\h jm[e_c \ h[jZs_gbb LZdh_ m\_ebq_gb_
dhebq_kl\Z gZebqghc bghkljZgghc \Zexlu aZkem`b\Z
_l bamq_gby dZd \hafh`guc kbfilhf beb dZlZebaZlhj
ij_klmighc b l_g_\hc ^_yl_evghklb h[e_]qZxs_c
ijh\_^_gb_ k^_ehd k g_aZdhggh ihemq_ggufb ^hoh^Z
fb J_amevlZlu lZdh]h bkke_^h\Zgby ke_^m_l mqblu
\Zlv \ kihjZo h ^heeZjbaZpbb wdhghfbdb Jhkkbckdhc
N_^_jZpbb
JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
=eZ\Z,9
Ijb\ZlbaZpbybebijbo\ZlbaZpby
Fbeebhgu jhkkbckdbo ]jZ`^Zg djZcg_ g_^h
\hevgu ijhp_kkhf jughqguo j_nhjf dhlhju_ [ueb
gZp_e_gu gZ \\_^_gb_ dZiblZebklbq_kdhc kbkl_fu
ohayckl\h\Zgby \ kljZg_ Kh]eZkgh j_amevlZlZf g_
^Z\gh ijh\_^_ggh]h hijhkZ h[s_kl\_ggh]h fg_gby
ijhp_glh\ jhkkbyg hlghkylky hljbpZl_evgh d dZib
lZebafm\JhkkbckdhcN_^_jZpbb\lh\j_fydZdlhev
dh ijhp_glh\ hlghkylky d g_fm iheh`bl_evgh b
ijhp_glh\aZljm^gbebkvkhl\_lhfkfjbk,,Ijb
hl\_l_gZ\hijhkhlhfke_^m_lebJhkkbbijh^he`Zlv
j_nhjfu beb ij_djZlblv bo ijhp_glh\ hijhr_g
guo aZy\beb qlh j_nhjfu g_h[oh^bfh ij_djZlblv \
lh \j_fy dZd ijhp_glZ iheZ]Zeb qlh j_nhjfu ke_
^m_l ijh^he`blv b ijhp_glh\ g_ hij_^_ebebkv k
fg_gb_fkfjbk,,,
DjmighfZkrlZ[gZy ijb\ZlbaZpby y\eyeZkv \Z`
g_crbf we_f_glhf jughqguo ij_h[jZah\Zgbc \ Jhk
kbckdhc N_^_jZpbb K kZfh]h gZqZeZ _c hl^Z\Zeky
ijbhjbl_l i_j_^ ^jm]bfb khklZ\eyxsbfb j_nhjfu
lZdbfbdZdkha^Zgb_bgklblmpbhgZevguobijZ\h\uo
f_oZgbafh\ j_]mebjh\Zgby jugdZ Ij_^iheZ]Zehkv
qlh[ukljh_kha^Zgb_deZkkZdZiblZebklh\±\eZ^_ev
Jbkmghd,,
DZd \u hlghkbl_kv d dZiblZebafm \ Jhkkbckdhc
N_^_jZpbb"
AZljm^gyxkvhl\_lblv±
ijhp_glZ
HljbpZl_evgh±
ijhp_glh\
Iheh`bl_evgh±
ijhp_glh\
Bklhqgbdj_amevlZluhijhkZh[s_kl\_ggh]hfg_gbyijh\_^_ggh
]hNhg^hfh[s_kl\_ggh]hfg_gbyhijhr_gguoijb\h^ylky
ih]Za_l_Dhff_jkZglaZn_\jZey]h^Z
p_\ kh[kl\_gghklb ± [ueh i_j\uf b j_rZxsbf rZ
]hfgZimlbihkljh_gbydZiblZebafZ;uebgZ^_`^u
qlh gh\u_ jhkkbckdb_ dZiblZebklu qm^_kguf h[jZ
ahfij_\jZlylg_wnn_dlb\gu_ijhba\h^kl\Z\wnn_d
lb\gu_ Ijb\ZlbaZpby b \ kZfhf ^_e_ ijb\_eZ d
ihy\e_gbxkh[kl\_ggbdh\\JhkkbckdhcN_^_jZpbb±
fZkku f_edbo Zdpbhg_jh\ g_ bf_xsbo dZdboeb[h
iheghfhqbc \ebylv gZ j_r_gby ijbgbfZ_fu_ \
hlghr_gbbij_^ijbylbcdhlhjufbhgbydh[u\eZ^_
eb HgZ lZd`_ ihjh^beZ g_fgh]hqbke_gguo gh\uo
jmkkdbo dhlhju_ ijbh[j_eb h]jhfgu_ khklhygby
eh\dh \hkihevah\Z\rbkv g_kh\_jr_gkl\Zfb i_j_oh^
gh]h i_jbh^Z lZdbfb dZd hlkmlkl\b_ ijhajZqguo
b q_ldbo ijZ\be b h]jZgbq_ggu_ \hafh`ghklb ]hkm
^Zjkl\Z \ ijZ\hhojZgbl_evghc kn_j_ < hlkmlkl\bb
gZ^e_`Zsbo ijZ\be j_]mebjh\Zgby beb f_oZgbafh\
ih hlke_`b\Zgbx wlhc ^_yl_evghklb jughqgu_ ij_
h[jZah\Zgby \ qZklghklb ijb\ZlbaZpby kihkh[kl\h
\Zeb[_kij_p_^_glghfmjhklmfZkrlZ[h\e_]ZebaZpbb
Zdlb\h\ b bfms_kl\Z ihemq_gguo g_aZdhgguf im
l_fIjb\ZlbaZpbxqZklhgZau\Zxlijbo\ZlbaZpb_c
hl ]eZ]heZ o\ZlZlv dhlhjuc lZd`_ bf__l agZq_gb_
]jZ[blv
Jbkmghd,,,
Ke_^m_l eb ijh^he`Zlv j_nhjfu \ Jhkkbckdhc
N_^_jZpbb"
AZljm^gyxkvhl\_lblv±
ijhp_glh\
G_ke_^m_l±
ijhp_glh\
Ke_^m_l±
ijhp_glZ
Bklhqgbdj_amevlZluhijhkZh[s_kl\_ggh]hfg_gbyijh\_^_ggh
]hNhg^hfh[s_kl\_ggh]hfg_gbyhijhr_gguoijb\h^ylky
ih]Za_l_Dhff_jkZglaZn_\jZey]h^Z
JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
FZkkh\Zy ijb\ZlbaZpby k\ur_ luk kj_^gbo b
djmiguo ij_^ijbylbc \ ±]h^Zo ijb\_eZ d
lhfmqlhk\ur_ijhp_glh\ijhfure_gghcjZ[hq_c
kbeu hdZaZehkv \ qZklghf k_dlhj_ < wlhl `_ i_jbh^
[ueh hlims_gh [hevrbgkl\h p_g mgbnbpbjh\Zg \Z
exlguc dmjk b hkms_kl\e_gZ eb[_jZebaZpby \g_rg_c
lhj]h\eb Ij_^iheZ]Zehkv qlh wlb f_ju ihfh]ml
\gh\v kha^Zgghfm qZklghfm k_dlhjm \klZlv gZ gh]b
b gZqZlv jZa\b\Zlvky Ih g_dhlhjuf ^Zgguf d
]h^m gZ ^hex qZklgh]h k_dlhjZ m`_ ijboh^behkv
ijhp_glh\ <<I < ]h^m ]hkm^Zjkl\_ggufb
kqblZebkv lhevdh ijhp_glZ dhfiZgbc b gZ ^hex
]hkm^Zjkl\_gguo ij_^ijbylbc ijboh^behkv lhevdh
ijhp_glh\\k_]hh[hjhlZjhagbqghclhj]h\ebDdhg
pm ]h^Z k\ur_ luk ij_^ijbylbc [ueb ijb\Z
lbabjh\Zgu
;eZ]Z hl ijb\ZlbaZpbb gZ dhlhju_ \haeZ]Zeb
klhev[hevrb_gZ^_`^u_s_g_ihemq_gughg_dhlh
ju_ __ f_lh^u b ko_fu m`_ klZeb h[t_dlhf djblbdb
FZkkh\Zyijb\ZlbaZpby±]h^h\k__ijb\Zlb
aZpbhggufb q_dZfb \Zmq_jZfb ij_^klZ\eyeZ kh[hc
hlebqgmx\hafh`ghklv^eye_]ZebaZpbbkj_^kl\ihem
q_gguo ij_klmiguf iml_f <Zmq_ju [ueb \u^Zgu dZ
`^hfm jhkkbckdhfm ]jZ`^Zgbgm b ij_^klZ\eyeb _]h
^hex\gZpbhgZevghf[h]Zlkl\_<Zmq_ju^Z\ZebijZ\h
bo^_j`Zl_eyfihdmiZlv^hexmqZklby\]hkm^Zjkl\_g
ghc kh[kl\_gghklb Ij_^ty\bl_evkdZy nhjfZ \Zmq_jh\
iha\heyeh [_ahiZkguf iml_f hlfu\Zlv ^_gv]b ih
kdhevdm gbdlh g_ kijZrb\Ze dZd b dZdbf kihkh[hf
ijb\ZlbaZpbhggu_ q_db [ueb ihemq_gu GZ i_j\hf
wlZi_ijb\ZlbaZpbbij_klmigbdbfh]ebdmiblvg_h]jZ
gbq_ggh_ dhebq_kl\h ijb\ZlbaZpbhgguo q_dh\ m h[
gbsZ\r_]hgZk_e_gbybbkihevah\ZlvbogZl_g^_jZob
ijb\ZlbaZpbhgguo ZmdpbhgZo ^ey ihdmidb dhgljhev
guo iZd_lh\ Zdpbc ]hkm^Zjkl\_gguo ij_^ijbylbc
WlZ ko_fZ ij_^hklZ\beZ ij_djZkgmx \hafh`ghklv eb
pZf mdju\Z\rbf [hevrb_ kmffu gZ`bluo ij_klmi
gufiml_f^_g_]klZlv[h]Zlufb]jZ`^ZgZfbkljZgu\
aZdhgghfihjy^d_
Ijh]jZffZ aZeh]h\uo Zmdpbhgh\ ]h^Z \u
a\ZeZ[hevrb_gZj_dZgby\k\yabkaZdjulhklvxijhp_
^mju bo ijh\_^_gby b ih^lZkh\dhc j_amevlZlh\ Kh
]eZkgh wlhc ijh]jZff_ `_fqm`bgu jhkkbckdhc wdh
ghfbdb ± kZfu_ i_jki_dlb\gu_ ij_^ijbylby \ ijh
fure_gghklbbwg_j]_lbd_±[uebijh^Zgudhff_jq_
kdbf dhfiZgbyf \ h[f_g gZ fbgbfZevgu_ kmffu
dj_^blh\ dhlhju_ hgb ^he`gu [ueb ij_^hklZ\blv
ijZ\bl_evkl\m IjbgZ^e_`Zsb_ ]hkm^Zjkl\m Zdpbb
ijb[uevguo dhfiZgbc h[eZ^Z\rbo [hevrbf ih
l_gpbZehf^ey^Zevg_cr_]hjhklZ[uebbkihevah\Zgu
\ dZq_kl\_ aZeh]Z ^ey ihemq_gby ijZ\bl_evkl\hf dj_
^blh\ hl djmiguo dhff_jq_kdbo [Zgdh\ < ijh]jZff_
mdZau\Zehkv qlh \ kemqZ_ _keb ijZ\bl_evkl\h j_rbl
g_ih]ZrZlvdj_^bluh[sZykmffZdhlhjuokhklZ\beZ
hdhehfej^^hee[Zgdbbf_xlijZ\hijh^ZlvgZoh
^ysb_ky\^h\_jbl_evghfmijZ\e_gbbZdpbbbhklZ\blv
k_[_ijhp_glh\hlijbjhklZdZiblZeZ
Mkeh\by ijh\_^_gby aZeh]h\uo Zmdpbhgh\ ijb
dhlhjuoh^bgblhl`_[Zgdh^gh\j_f_ggh\uklmiZe\
dZq_kl\_ hj]ZgbaZlhjZ b mqZklgbdZ lhj]h\ Z ij_^eh
`_gbygZihdmidmih[he__\ukhdhcp_g_kgbfZebkvk
lhj]h\ ih l_ogbq_kdbf ijbqbgZf \ua\Zeb j_admx
djblbdm \ jhkkbckdhf iZjeZf_gl_ b \ jhkkbckdhc
ij_kk_ L_f g_ f_g__ hkms_kl\e_gb_ ijh]jZffu ijh
^he`behkvbihke_hdhgqZgbymklZgh\e_ggh]hkjhdZ\
k_gly[j_ ]h^Z [Zgdb gZqZeb jZkijh^Z\Zlv iZd_lu
]hkm^Zjkl\_gguoZdpbc
< i_jbh^ f_`^m ghy[j_f b n_\jZe_f
]h^Z khklhyebkv ljb lZdbo ZmdpbhgZ ih ijh^Z`_
Zdpbclj_odhfiZgbc±XdhkKb^Zgdhb Kmj]ml
g_nl_]Za<dZ`^hfbawlbokemqZ_\wlbZdpbbdmibeb
eb[h kZfb aZeh]h^_j`Zl_eb eb[h bo ^hq_jgb_ dhfiZ
gbb < fgh]hqbke_gguo dhff_glZjbyo gZ wlm l_fm
khh[sZehkv qlh \ j_amevlZl_ wlbo Zmdpbhgh\ g_[hev
rZy ]jmiiZ dhfiZgbc bf_xsbo iheblbq_kdb_ k\yab
kfh]eZ ijbh[j_klb djmigu_ h[t_dlu ]hkm^Zjkl\_gghc
kh[kl\_gghklb\h[f_ggZfbgbfZevgu_kmffudj_^b
lh\bqlhijh]jZffZ\hafh`gh k kZfh]h gZqZeZ [ueZ
gZp_e_gZ gZ i_j_jZkij_^_e_gb_ kh[kl\_gghklb lZdbf
fhr_ggbq_kdbfkihkh[hf
>Z`_klhqdbaj_gbywdhghfbq_kdhcwnn_dlb\gh
klbijb\ZlbaZpbyg_\uihegbeZk\hbaZ^ZqbKlj_fe_
gb_ ^h[b\Zlvky djZldhkjhqguo ebqguo \u]h^ \f_klh
m\_ebq_gbyklhbfhklbZdpbhg_jgh]hdZiblZeZ\^he]h
kjhqghc i_jki_dlb\_ \hagbdZeh ^Z`_ lh]^Z dh]^Z
mijZ\eyxsbc b kh[kl\_ggbd y\eyeky h^gbf b l_f `_
ebphfqlh[uehh[uqghcijZdlbdhc\JhkkbckdhcN_
^_jZpbb NhjfZevgu_ ijZ\Z kh[kl\_gghklb [ueb ih
ij_`g_fm g_ hij_^_e_gu hlkmlkl\h\Zeh ^h\_jb_ d
km^_[ghc kbkl_f_ dZd kj_^kl\m aZsblu wlbo ijZ\ qlh
g_iha\heyehijbklmiblvdj_kljmdlmjbaZpbbij_^ijb
ylbc k p_evx klZ[bebaZpbb bo iheh`_gby \ [m^ms_f
KlZeh hq_\b^guf qlh lZf ]^_ g_ kms_kl\h\Zeh ijh
ajZqguo \uau\Zxsbo ^h\_jb_ q_klguo ijZ\be ju
ghqghc^_yl_evghklbgbh^gZbamqZkl\mxsboklhjhg
\dexqZy g_ lhevdh jZ[hqbo b mijZ\eyxsbo gh lZd`_
Zdpbhg_jh\ b dj_^blhjh\ g_ [ueZ aZbgl_j_kh\ZgZ \
ih^^_j`Zgbb b m\_ebq_gbb klhbfhklb Zdlb\h\ < j_
amevlZl_ ijbh[j_l_ggu_ ij_^ijbylby bkihevah\Zebkv
\ hkgh\ghf ^ey [ukljh]h ihemq_gby djZldhkjhqghc
ijb[uebhk_^Z\r_c\dZjfZgZomadh]hdjm]Zebpim
l_f bo fhr_ggbq_kdhc ijh^Z`b beb ^ey jZaebqguo
ih^ihevguo p_e_c IjZ\Z h[uqguo ]jZ`^Zg ± ^_j`Z
l_e_c g_dhgljhevguo iZd_lh\ Zdpbc ± ih\k_f_klgh
JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
gZjmrZebkv qlh \_eh d h[_kp_gb\Zgbx klhbfhklb bo
Zdlb\h\
Kha^ZggZy \ ]h^m N_^_jZevgZy dhfbkkby ih
jugdmp_gguo[mfZ]dZdijZ\behg_h[eZ^ZeZihegh
fhqbyfb g_h[oh^bfufb ^ey j_r_gby ijh[e_f k\y
aZgguo k gZjmr_gb_f ijZ\ Zdpbhg_jh\ < bxe_
]h^Z ijZ\bl_evkl\h h[ty\beh h[ mqj_`^_gbb
Ijh]jZffu ih aZsbl_ ijZ\ bg\_klhjh\ j_Zevgh_ \u
iheg_gb_dhlhjhc_s_lhevdhij_^klhblG_\uihegy
_lky\iheghcf_j_bgh\ucaZdhgh[Zgdjhlkl\_\klm
ib\rbc \ kbem \ fZjl_ ]h^Z ihkdhevdm wlhfm
f_rZxl ijhlb\hj_qb\u_ j_r_gby \eZkl_c GZijbf_j
\ yg\Zj_ ]h^Z ijZ\bl_evkl\h ijbgyeh j_r_gb_
ij_djZlblv \ha[m`^_gb_ ^_e h [Zgdjhlkl\_ ijhlb\
^he`gbdh\ ih mieZl_ gZeh]h\ Wlh j_r_gb_ ]jhabeh
mom^rblv gZeh]h\mx ^bkpbiebgm b aZ^_j`Zlv ijh\_
^_gb_ dhgkljmdlb\guo [Zgdjhlkl\ < ihke_^gb_ ]h^u
qbkeh[Zgdjhlkl\j_adhm\_ebqbehkvb \ ]h^m kh
klZ\beh ijbf_jgh luk H^gZdh wlZ pbnjZ \k_ jZ\gh
g_\_ebdZ k mq_lhf lh]h qlh \ k_j_^bg_ ]h^Z
ijhp_glh\ dhfiZgbc dZd khh[sZehkv jZ[hlZeb k
m[uldhf
=hkm^Zjkl\_gguc dhfbl_l ih Zglbfhghihevghc
iheblbd_hl\_qZ_laZih^^_j`dmij_^ijbgbfZl_evkl\Z
b kh^_ckl\b_ dhgdmj_gpbb H^gZdh hg bkiulu\Z_l
ojhgbq_kdmx g_o\Zldm nbgZgkbjh\Zgby b k ]h^Z
[ue\ugm`^_gaZdjulvk\hboj_]bhgZevguohl^_e_
gbc;he__lh]hj_]bhgZevgu_hl^_e_gbyh[\bgyebkv\
lhfqlhih^^Z\e_gb_ff_klguo\eZkl_c^_ckl\h\Zeb\
bgl_j_kZo f_klguo dhfiZgbc ihjh`^Zy ih^haj_gby h
rbjhdhf jZafZo_ dhjjmipbb gZ f_klghf mjh\g_ Lhl
nZdl qlh \ j_]bhgZo dexq_\u_ ij_^ijbylby [ueb aZ
o\Zq_gu ebpZfb k m]heh\guf ijhreuf \ agZqbl_ev
ghc f_j_ kihkh[kl\h\Ze dhjjmfibjh\Zgbx f_klguo
hj]Zgh\\eZklbDZ`^uc^_gvihy\eyxlkykhh[s_gbyh
ij_klmie_gbyo kh\_jrZ_fuo ba[jZggufb beb gZagZ
q_ggufb \ukhdhihklZ\e_ggufb qbgh\gbdZfb k m`_
aZiylgZggufijhreuf <jmkkdhfyaud_^Z`_ihy\b
ehkv gh\h_ h[hagZq_gb_ wlbo ^he`ghklguo ebp ± kb
gb_fwjulh_klvgZf_dgZlhqlhkj_^bgbo_klvg_
fZehm]heh\gbdh\kkbgbfblZlmbjh\dZfbgZl_e_
>Z`_ kZfu_ ihke_^h\Zl_evgu_ klhjhggbdb j_
nhjf \ Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb \ujZ`Zxl g_^h\hevkl
\h ijhp_kkhf ij_h[jZah\Zgbc \ Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZ
pbb mdZau\Zy gZ hlkmlkl\b_ \ kljZg_ ghjfZevghc ju
ghqghc kj_^u < k\h_c gh\hc dgb]_ ba\_klguc nb
gZgkbklbnbeZgljhi>`hj^`Khjhkhldjulhh[\bgbe
jhkkbckdmxiheblbq_kdmxweblm\dexqZyg_nlygh]hb
f_^bZ fZ]gZlZ ;hjbkZ ;_j_ah\kdh]h \ mqZklbb \ `_
kldhc w]hbklbq_kdhc ko\Zld_ heb]Zjoh\ `Z`^msbo
\eZklbb^_g_]Heb]Zjob\dexqZybl_odlhgZoh^bl
ky m \eZklb [ueb ihklhyggh aZgylu [hjv[hc f_`^m
kh[hchl\e_dZyh]jhfgu_j_kmjkul_f\j_f_g_fk_jv
_agu_ wdhghfbq_kdb_ b khpbZevgu_ ijh[e_fu h[uq
guo jhkkbckdbo ]jZ`^Zg hklZ\Zebkv g_j_r_ggufb
=gKhjhkhibku\Z_ldZdhgebqghklhedgmekykihab
pb_c heb]Zjoh\ ijb ihdmid_ gZ Zmdpbhg_ Zdpbc l_e_
nhgghc ohe^bg]h\hc dhfiZgbb K\yavbg\_kl DZd
ibr_l Khjhk ;_j_ah\kdbc ij_^ijbgbfZe fgh]hqbk
e_ggu_ihiuldbijbh[j_klbdhfiZgbx^hgZqZeZZmd
pbhgZ bkihevamy jZaebqgu_ kihkh[u \dexqZy iheb
lbq_kdh_ ^Z\e_gb_ ihkdhevdm kqblZe \eZ^_gb_ dhfiZ
gb_c \Z`guf bgkljmf_glhf \ [hjv[_ ijhlb\ \bp_
ij_fv_jZ Qm[ZckZ Iha^g__ g_m^ZqgZy ihiuldZ ;_j_
ah\kdh]h bkihevah\Zlv KhjhkZ \ k\hbo fZobgZpbyo k
p_evxihemqblvihklij_^k_^Zl_ey=ZaijhfZijb\_eZ
d jZaju\m hlghr_gbc f_`^m gbfb >`hj^` Khjhk
k]hj_qvxijbagZ_l qlh _fm g_ m^Zehkv hlklhylv b aZ
sblblv b^_x ihkljh_gby \ Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb dZ
iblZebafZ hkgh\Zggh]h gZ aZdhg_ \ hlebqb_ hl dZib
lZebafZ\hjh\b]jZ[bl_e_c
Ijb\ZlbaZpby \ p_ehf klZeZ [hevrbf jZahqZjh
\Zgb_fdZd^eyijhkluojhkkbckdbo]jZ`^ZglZdb^ey
fgh]boklhjhggbdh\j_nhjfaZjm[_`hfH]ey^u\Zykv
gZaZ^fgh]b_ijbagZxlqlhij_`^_q_fgZqbgZlvijb
\ZlbaZpbx g_h[oh^bfh [ueh kha^Zlv khhl\_lkl\mx
sb_bgklblmlubaZdhgh^Zl_evgmx[ZamIjh\_^_ggZy
\ Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb ijb\ZlbaZpby g_ lhevdh ij_
iylkl\h\ZeZ kha^Zgbx kijZ\_^eb\h]h wnn_dlb\gh]h
k\h[h^gh]h jugdZ gh b ijb\_eZ d kgb`_gbx wnn_d
lb\ghklbijhba\h^kl\Zb_s_[hevr_fmjZkijhkljZg_
gbx ijhba\heZ b [_aaZdhgby ;ukljZy b rbjhdhfZk
rlZ[gZy ijb\ZlbaZpby k __ fhr_ggbq_kdbfb ko_fZfb
ih^hj\ZeZ ^h\_jb_ d j_nhjfZf \ Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZ
pbb b _s_ [hevr_ aZljm^gbeZ ihiuldb kha^Zgby gZ^
e_`Zs_c aZdhgh^Zl_evghc b bgklblmpbhgZevghc [Zau
^eyih^^_j`dbjughqghcwdhghfbdbHgZkihkh[kl\h
\ZeZ aZo\Zlm hj]Zgh\ bkihegbl_evghc \eZklb gZ jZa
ebqguo mjh\gyo ]jmiiZfb ebp qvy hkgh\gZy aZ^ZqZ
aZdexqZeZkv \ lhf qlh[u bkihevah\Zlv ]hkm^Zjkl\h
^eyhlfu\Zgbyihemq_gguog_aZdhggufiml_f^hoh^h\
bkhdjulbyboijhbkoh`^_gby
JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
=eZ\Z9
L_g_\ZywdhghfbdZmdehg_gb_hlgZeh]h\[_aaZdhgb_
J_adbc jhkl l_g_\hc wdhghfbdb b __ \ebygby gZ
gZjh^gh_ ohayckl\h Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb hdZaZeky
\_kvfZ g_h`b^Zgguf ^ey ijb\_j`_gp_\ jughqguo
j_nhjf >h gZqZeZ jughqguo ij_h[jZah\Zgbc kqblZ
ehkv qlh l_g_\Zy wdhghfbdZ \ kh\_lkdbc i_jbh^ [ueZ
ke_^kl\b_f i_j_dhkh\ \ua\Zgguo p_gljZebah\Zgguf
ieZgbjh\Zgb_f b qlh ih f_j_ eb[_jZebaZpbb wdhgh
fbq_kdhc `bagb b \g_^j_gby ijbgpbih\ k\h[h^gh]h
jugdZ hgZ ihkl_i_ggh bkq_ag_l Ijhlb\ h`b^Zgbc \
i_j_oh^guc i_jbh^ l_g_\Zy wdhghfbdZ ^hklb]eZ jZa
f_jh\g_fukebfuo\mkeh\byoKh\_lkdh]hKhxaZHgZ
l_kghi_j_ie_eZkvkaZdhgghcwdhghfbdhcb[ueZijb
gylZ jhkkbygZfb dZd h^gZ ba oZjZdl_jbklbd dZiblZ
ebafZ\JhkkbckdhcN_^_jZpbb
Ih ^Zgguf Fbgbkl_jkl\Z \gmlj_ggbo ^_e Jhk
kbckdhc N_^_jZpbb \ ±]h^Zo gZ ^hex l_g_
\hc wdhghfbdb ijboh^behkv ±ijhp_glh\ ijh
ba\h^kl\Z <<I \ ]h^m ± ijhp_glh\ \
]h^m± ijhp_glh\ \ ]h^m± ijhp_glh\
Z\]h^m±ijhp_glh\IhbgnhjfZpbblh]h`_
bklhqgbdZ\l_g_\hcwdhghfbd_aZgylh ±feg jZ
[hlZxsbo =hkdhfklZl =hkm^Zjkl\_gguc dhfbl_l ih
klZlbklbd_ ijb\h^bl [he__ kdjhfgu_ pbnju ^hey
l_g_\hc wdhghfbdb \ ±]h^Zo g_ ij_\urZeZ
±ijhp_glh\ \ ]h^m ± ijhp_glh\ b \
]h^m±ijhp_glh\<<I
OZjZdl_jl_g_\hcwdhghfbdb\JhkkbckdhcN_^_
jZpbbijbdZiblZebaf_hlebqZ_lkyhlih^ihevghc^_y
l_evghklb\kh\_lkdbci_jbh^Lh]^Zex[h_ijhba\h^
kl\h \g_ ijyfh]h gZ^ahjZ beb [_a mdZaZgbc ieZgh\uo
hj]Zgh\ fh]eh d\Zebnbpbjh\Zlvky dZd l_g_\Zy wdhgh
fbdZ Kx^Z \oh^beb ijhba\_^_ggZy k\_jo ieZgh\uo
ihdZaZl_e_c ijh^mdpby dhlhjZy dZd ijZ\beh ij_^gZ
agZqZeZkv^eyijh^Z`b\dZq_kl\_e_\h]hlh\ZjZbeb
^ey j_ZebaZpbb q_j_a jZagh]h jh^Z [Zjl_jgu_ k^_edb
hj]ZgbaZpby k\_joieZgh\h]h ^hihegbl_evgh]h ijhba
\h^kl\Z±lh_klv\k_qlh\uoh^behaZjZfdbkimkdZ_
fuobap_gljZieZgh\uoaZ^ZgbcDjhf_lh]hihg_dh
lhjuf deZkkbnbdZpbyf jZaebqgu_ \b^u ij_klmighc
^_yl_evghklb gZijbf_j dhjjmipby \hjh\kl\h beb
fhr_ggbq_kl\h lZd`_ ijbqbkeyebkv d l_g_\hc wdhgh
fbd_ H^gZdh h[s_ijbagZggh qlh h^ghc ba ]eZ\guo
ijbqbg kms_kl\h\Zgby l_g_\hc wdhghfbdb kem`beh
bkdZ`_gb_ jughqguo hlghr_gbc ihjh`^Z_fh_ `_kl
dbf ieZgbjh\Zgb_f b mdZaZgbyfb k\_jom Z lZd`_ ih
lj_[ghklv ex^_c \ j_ZebaZpbb k\hbo ij_^ijbgbfZ
l_evkdbo kihkh[ghkl_c LZdbf h[jZahf jhev l_g_\hc
wdhghfbdb \ agZqbl_evghc kl_i_gb aZdexqZeZkv \ aZ
iheg_gbb ijh[_eh\ ieZgh\hc wdhghfbdb \ h[eZklb
kijhkZ b ij_^eh`_gby b dZd lZdh\Zy hgZ klZeZ g_hlt
_fe_fhc qZklvx h[s_kl\_gghwdhghfbq_kdhc `bagb
JhkkbckdhcN_^_jZpbb
K gZqZehf jughqguo j_nhjf fgh]b_ \b^u ^_y
l_evghklb d\Zebnbpbjh\Z\rb_ky dZd ij_klmigu_ ih
emqbeb aZdhgguc klZlmk Z fgh]b_ gZqbgZgby gZijb
f_j ij_^ijbgbfZl_evkl\h klZeb ihhsjylvky H^gZdh
gb \eZklb gb gZk_e_gb_ g_ fh]eb kjZam jZah[jZlvky
qlh ^he`gh kqblZlvky \ gh\hf h[s_kl\_ ij_klmie_gb
_f Z qlh ± aZdhgghc ^_yl_evghklvx >Z`_ dh]^Z wlh
m^Z\Zehkv hij_^_eblv g_\hafh`gh [ueh [ukljh ih^
]hlh\blv gh\mx aZdhgh^Zl_evgmx beb bgklblmpbh
gZevgmx [Zam ^ey j_]mebjh\Zgby wlbo gh\uo \b^h\
^_yl_evghklb beb kZfh]h ijhp_kkZ ij_h[jZah\Zgbc
EbpZba\e_dZ\rb_\u]h^mbahlkmlkl\byijhajZqguob
mgbnbpbjh\Zgguo aZdhgh\ \hafh`gh ku]jZeb k\hx
jhev \ aZly]b\Zgbb wlh]h ijhp_kkZ Hlkmlkl\b_ khhl
\_lkl\mxsbo ijZ\h\uo ghjf kha^Z\Zeh g_h]jZgbq_g
gu_ \hafh`ghklb ^ey \kydh]h jh^Z fZgbimeypbc jZ^b
ebqghc \u]h^u L_f \j_f_g_f ]hkm^Zjkl\h \ agZqb
l_evghcf_j_khdjZlbehk\hc ijZ\hhojZgbl_evguc ih
l_gpbZe ihkdhevdm _]h jhev \ `bagb h[s_kl\Z _]h
fhsv b kdehgghklv d ijbgm`^_gbx \hkijbgbfZebkv
h[s_kl\hfdZdqj_af_jgu_<i_j\u_]h^uijh\_^_gby
j_nhjf ihiuldb ]hkm^Zjkl\Z ijbf_gblv ijZ\hhojZg
gu_ f_ju \ hlghr_gbb wdhghfbq_kdbo ij_klmie_gbc
fgh]b_ ba dhlhjuo ^Z`_ g_ d\Zebnbpbjh\Zebkv \ lh
\j_fydZdm]heh\gu_ij_klmie_gby[_aljm^Zij_k_dZ
ebkv ijZ\hgZjmrbl_eyfb h[ty\ey\rbfb lZdb_ ^_ckl
\by Zglbjughqgufb \uklmie_gbyfb [u\rbo dhffm
gbklh\bZiiZjZlqbdh\
JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
Hlkmlkl\b_ ghjf hij_^_eyxsbo gh\mx jhev b
nmgdpbb]hkm^Zjkl\_gguomqj_`^_gbcijb\_ehdjZk
ijhkljZg_gbxdhjjmipbbkj_^bbokhljm^gbdh\G_hi
j_^_e_gghklv nmgdpbc ]hkm^Zjkl\_gguo qbgh\gbdh\
kihkh[kl\h\ZeZlZdgZau\Z_fhcijb\ZlbaZpbb]hkm^Zj
kl\_gguo ihklh\ >he`ghklgu_ ebpZ \k_ \ [hevr_c
kl_i_gb klZeb bkihegylv k\hb h[yaZgghklb bkdexqb
l_evgh \ p_eyo m^h\e_l\hj_gby k\hbo ebqguo fZl_jb
Zevguoihlj_[ghkl_cJ_r_gb_\hijhkh\q_j_aebqgu_
k\yabb\ayldbklZeh[he__wnn_dlb\gufq_f^_ckl\by
\ hnbpbZevghf ihjy^d_ DZd ke_^kl\b_ gZk_e_gb_ hl
\_j]Zehex[u_mklZgh\e_ggu_]hkm^Zjkl\hfijZ\beZb
ijhp_^mju dZd g_gm`gu_ Hkh[h_ g_]h^h\Zgb_ \uau
\ZeZ kbkl_fZ gZeh]hh[eh`_gby dhlhjZy nZdlbq_kdb
ihjh`^ZeZ^\hcgh_gZeh]hh[eh`_gb_ihkdhevdm]hkm
^Zjkl\_ggu_ mkem]b \ ex[hf kemqZ_ ihdmiZebkv \
bg^b\b^mZevghfihjy^d_
Ihwlhfm k gZqZehf \ Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb ju
ghqguo j_nhjf l_g_\Zy wdhghfbdZ g_ lhevdh kmf_eZ
\u`blv gh b ijbh[j_eZ _s_ [he__ hiZkguc oZjZdl_j
< i_j_oh^guc i_jbh^ \eZklb [ueb \ugm`^_gu kha^Z
\Zlv\j_f_ggu_f_oZgbafubebhj]Zgumiheghfhq_g
gu_ mqj_`^_gby gZ^_e_ggu_ rbjhdbfb ijZ\Zfb dh
lhju_ aZqZklmx bkihevamxlky bkdexqbl_evgh \ ebq
guop_eyoKhojZg_gb_g_dhlhjuowe_f_glh\ieZgh\hc
wdhghfbdb gZijbf_j ]hkm^Zjkl\_ggh]h km[kb^bjh\Z
gby hl^_evguo hljZke_c ijhfure_gghklb lZd`_ kha
^Z_l \hafh`ghklb ^ey jZagh]h jh^Z g_aZdhgghc ^_y
l_evghklb HljbpZl_evgu_ khpbZevgu_ ihke_^kl\by
i_j_oh^gh]h i_jbh^Z lZdb_ dZd [_kij_p_^_glgh_ m\_
ebq_gb_ qbkeZ [_^guo \ k\yab k ihl_j_c jZ[hlu k[_
j_`_gbcbghjfZevghcaZjieZlulZd`_y\eyxlky\Z`
guf nZdlhjhf jhklZ l_g_\hc wdhghfbdb JZ^b \u`b
\Zgby ex^b \ugm`^_gu bkdZlv bklhqgbdb ^hoh^Z
ijb[_]Zy d g_ebp_gabjh\Zgghc beb g_aZj_]bkljbjh
\Zgghc ^_yl_evghklb Kx^Z hlghkblky b ^_yl_evghklv
gZjZ[hq_ff_kl_\bguop_eyoq_f\uiheg_gb_^he`
ghklguoh[yaZgghkl_c
Ijh[e_fZ aZ^he`_gghklb ih ieZl_`Zf \ugm^beZ
ij_^ijbylby ijb[_]Zlv d jZaebqguf nhjfZf [_agZ
ebqguok^_ehdBkihevah\Zgb_[Zjl_jZj_adh\hajhkeh
k gZqZeZ i_j_oh^gh]h i_jbh^Z b d k_j_^bg_ ]h^Z
^hklb]eh j_dhj^ghc hlf_ldb ± [he__ ijhp_glh\
ijh^Z` ;Zjl_jgu_ k^_edb ih dhlhjuf e_]q_ ij_^
klZ\eylv g_^hklh\_jgmx hlq_lghklv beb g_ hlqblu
\Zlvky\hh[s_aZgbfZxlagZqbl_evgh_f_klh\l_g_\hc
wdhghfbd_ >ey h[_ki_q_gby ieZl_`_c beb ± \ [hev
rbgkl\_ kemqZ_\ ± qlh[u kijZ\blvky k aZ^_j`dZfb
ieZl_`_cdjmigu_ij_^ijbylbyijbf_gyxllZd`_jZa
gh]h jh^Z \_dk_ey H^gb jhkkbckdb_ ij_^ijbylby ih
khh[s_gbyf \uimkdZxl ^_g_`gu_ km[klblmlu ^ey
hieZlu k\hbo aZ^he`_gghkl_c ih jZkoh^Zf ^jm]b_
\uieZqb\Zxl aZjZ[hlgmx ieZlm gZlmjhc H^gZdh km
s_kl\m_l lZd`_ fg_gb_ qlh ij_^ijbylby gZf_j_ggh
k\h^yldfbgbfmfmk\hb^_g_`gu_kj_^kl\Z^h[b\Zykv
gZeh]h\uo ev]hl Wlh ij_^iheh`_gb_ dZkZ_lky l_o
ij_^ijbylbc dhlhju_ iulZxlky aZdhgguf iml_f
fbgbfbabjh\Zlvk\hbgZeh]h\u_h[yaZl_evkl\ZFgh
]b_ijhklhg_ieZlylgZeh]bIjbiehohhj]Zgbah\Zg
ghf ]hkm^Zjkl\_gghf mijZ\e_gbb b g_^hklZld_ ki_
pbZebklh\ ^ey h[_ki_q_gby kh[ex^_gby ijZ\be m
fZeh]h [bag_kZ kms_kl\m_l fgh`_kl\h \hafh`ghkl_c
mclb\l_gv B g_l gbdZdbo hq_\b^guo ijbqbg dhlh
ju_ ih[m^beb [u bo e_]Zebah\Zlvky Ihwlhfm ohly
agZqbl_evgZy qZklv ^_yl_evghklb \ l_g_\hc wdhghfb
d_ ghkbl aZdhgguc oZjZdl_j b \dexqZ_l lh qlh jZa
j_r_ghaZdhghf\hlebqb_hlij_klmighc^_yl_evgh
klb hgZ aZqZklmx \_^_lky [_a hnbpbZevgh]h jZaj_
r_gbybebj_]bkljZpbb
Ihg_dhlhjufhp_gdZfijhp_glh\jhkkbckdbo
ij_^ijbylbc g_ ieZlyl gZeh]h\ \hh[s_ Z [he__
ijhp_glh\ieZlylboebrvhlkemqZydkemqZxFgh
]b_ iheZ]Zxl qlh moh^m hl gZeh]h\ kihkh[kl\m_l
keh`ghklv gZeh]h\h]h aZdhgh^Zl_evkl\Z b _]h j_ij_k
kb\gucoZjZdl_jIhg_dhlhjufhp_gdZfij_^ijbylby
^he`guhl^Z\Zlv\\b^_gZeh]h\hl^hijhp_glh\
ijb[ueb B wlh \ mkeh\byo dh]^Z [hevrbgkl\h ij_^
ijbylbc kqblZxl qlh kijZ\_^eb\uc mjh\_gv gZeh]h
h[eh`_gbydhlhjuchgbkihkh[gu\u^_j`Zlvg_^he
`_gij_\urZlvijhp_glh\ijb[ueb
?s_[he__hkljhcq_fmoh^hlgZeh]h\y\ey_lky
ijh[e_fZ aZ^he`_gghklb ih gZeh]Zf baaZ dhlhjhc
jhkkbckdb_\eZklbg_\khklhygbbhklZgh\blvbih\_j
gmlv\kiylvl_g^_gpbxj_adh]hkhdjZs_gbygZeh]h\uo
ihklmie_gbc dhlhjZy gZ[ex^Z_lky k gZqZeZ i_j_oh^
gh]h i_jbh^Z AZ^he`_gghklb ih gZeh]Zf ^hklb]eb
lZdh]hmjh\gyqlhgZghkbfucbfbms_j[m`_kjZ\gbf
kms_j[hfhlmoh^ZhlgZeh]h\Ihkhh[s_gbyfgZeh
]h\hcihebpbbhgZh[_ki_qb\Z_lijZ\bl_evkl\mhdheh
ijhp_glh\ gZeh]h\uo ihklmie_gbc Z wlh hagZqZ_l
qlhijZ\bl_evkl\h\ugm`^_ghijbf_gylvkbem^eyih
emq_gby ihqlb iheh\bgu ^hoh^h\ hl k[hjZ gZeh]h\ K
mq_lhf h]jZgbq_gguo \hafh`ghkl_c wlhc hiZkghc
kem`[ufh`ghij_^iheh`blvqlh[hevrZy^heygZeh
]h\hklZ_lkyg_\uieZq_gghc\h\k_
Ijh[e_fZ g_ieZl_`_c b aZ^he`_gghklb ih gZeh
]Zfijb\_eZdg_h[oh^bfhklbijbf_gylv[_a^_g_`gu_
[x^`_lghnbgZgkh\uohi_jZpbbbebko_fugZeh]h\uo
aZq_lh\ dhlhju_ ih^\_j]Zebkv djblbd_ aZ lh qlh hgb
kha^Zxl gh\u_ \hafh`ghklb ^ey fhr_ggbq_kl\Z Ih
wlhc ko_f_ ijZ\bl_evkl\h klZeh ijbgbfZlv lh\Zju b
mkem]b \f_klh mieZlu gZeh]h\ Wlhl f_lh^ g_ lhevdh
ijb\_e d kgb`_gbx h`b^Z_fuo gZeh]h\uo ihklmie_
gbc [ueh ih^kqblZgh qlh k ihfhsvx wlh]h f_lh^Z
m^Zehkv kh[jZlv ebrv hl ^h ijhp_glh\ ghfb
gZevghc klhbfhklb gh qlh _s_ [he__ \Z`gh kih
JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
kh[kl\h\Ze ^Zevg_cr_fm jZkijhkljZg_gbx dhjjmipbb
b fhr_ggbq_kl\Z hkh[_ggh gZ j_]bhgZevghf b fmgb
pbiZevghf mjh\gyo Ijhba\hevgh_ ijbf_g_gb_ wlh]h
f_lh^Z iha\hebeh ij_^ijbylbyf gZdZieb\Zlv aZ^he
`_gghklbkp_evx\ugm^blvijZ\bl_evkl\hijbh[j_klb
bo lh\Zju LZdb_ ko_fu wnn_dlb\gh ^_ckl\h\Zeb b \
dZq_kl\_ gZeh]h\hc Zfgbklbb dhlhjZy hdZaZeZ g_]Z
lb\gh_ \ha^_ckl\b_ gZ kh[ex^_gb_ gZeh]h\hc ^bkpbi
ebgu;he__lh]hfhr_ggbq_kl\hqZklhaZdeZ^u\Zehkv
\ wlb kZfu_ ko_fu ihkdhevdm aZ\urZebkv mklZgZ\eb
\Z_fu_ p_gu beb dZq_kl\h ihklZ\ey_fuo lh\Zjh\ aZ
kq_l q_]h bkdmkkl\_ggh m\_ebqb\Zebkv jZaf_ju gZeh
]h\uo ieZl_`_c ;ueh fgh]h khh[s_gbc h lhf qlh
f_klgu_qbgh\gbdbebqghihemqZebohjhrmxdhfi_g
kZpbxq_j_a\ayldbaZg_^hihemq_gb_ijZ\bl_evkl\hf
ihklmie_gbc hl gZeh]h\ WlZ ko_fZ hdZaZeZkv _s_ h^
gbf f_oZgbafhf \uly]b\Zgb_ kj_^kl\ ba ]hkm^Zjkl
\_ggh]hdZjfZgZ
Kms_kl\h\Zgb_ djmighc l_g_\hc wdhghfbdb b
ijZdlbdZ moh^Z hl gZeh]h\ kihkh[kl\m_l ijhp\_lZ
gbx djur ± g_hnbpbZevguo beb ij_klmiguo ]jmi
ibjh\hddhgljhebjmxsbokhhl\_lkl\mxsb_k_]f_glu
jugdZ G_h[oh^bfhklv kdju\Zlv k\hx ^_yl_evghklv
beb h[_ki_qb\Zlv __ ijh^he`_gb_ qZklh \ugm`^Z_l
ij_^ijbgbfZl_e_c h[jZsZlvky aZ ihfhsvx d dju
rZf Wdhghfbq_kdbc kfuke djurb aZdexqZ_lky \
lhf qlh hgZ ihfh]Z_l k\hbf ih^hi_qguf ihemqZlv
ijb[uev iml_f h]jZgbq_gby ^ey dhgdmj_glh\ ^hklmiZ
gZdhgljhebjm_fucjughdQZklvbawlbogZoh^ysboky
ih^ aZsblhc ijb[ue_c b^_l l_f dlh h[_ki_qb\Z_l
djurm lh _klv ij_bfms_kl\_ggh ij_klmiguf ]jmi
ibjh\dZf H[uqghc ijZdlbdhc ^ey djur y\ey_lky
ijbf_g_gb_ nbabq_kdhc kbeu d l_f dlh hldZau\Z_lky
kh[ex^Zlv ijZ\beZ g_ ieZlbl aZ aZsblm b \k_ [he__
h[uqguf ^ey gbo klZgh\blky bkihevah\Zgb_ ]hkm^Zj
kl\_gguo kljmdlmj \ lhf qbke_ gZeh]h\hc ihebpbb \
dZq_kl\_ bgkljmf_glZ jZkijZ\u GZijbf_j fh`gh g_
ih^\_j]Zykv hiZkghklb khh[sblv h g_ihdhjghf ij_^
ijbylbb \ f_klgmx gZeh]h\mx ihebpbx dhlhjZy ijb
m^h[ghfkemqZ_kh\_jrbllm^Zj_c^bjZahjbl_]h>Z
`_ _keb gZeh]h\Zy ihebpby g_ y\ey_lky qZklvx dju
rb \_jhylghklv lh]h qlh ihebp_ckdb_ h[gZjm`Zl
gZjmr_gb_ gZeh]h\h]h dh^_dkZ gZklhevdh \_ebdZ qlh
lZdhc j_c^ \ ex[hf kemqZ_ gZg_k_l ij_^ijbylbx
k_jv_agucmjhg
JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
=eZ\Z9,
NbgZgkh\Zyeb[_jZebaZpbyb[Zgdh\kdZykbkl_fZ
NbgZgkh\Zy eb[_jZebaZpby \ Jhkkbckdhc N_^_
jZpbbih\e_deZaZkh[hcmijZa^g_gb_]hkm^Zjkl\_ggh
]h dhgljhey aZ \u^_e_gb_f dj_^blh\ b mklZgh\e_gb_f
ijhp_glguoklZ\hdijb\ZlbaZpbxnbgZgkh\uomqj_`
^_gbckgylb_h]jZgbq_gbckijblhdZdZiblZeZ\kljZ
gm b _]h \u\haZ aZ __ ij_^_eu \ua\ZeZ jZa\blb_ nhg
^h\h]hb^_g_`gh]hjugdh\\dZq_kl\_Zevl_jgZlb\guo
bklhqgbdh\b^_ihablZjb_\^_g_`guokj_^kl\H`b^Z
ehkvqlheb[_jZebaZpby[m^_lkihkh[kl\h\Zlvijblhdm
bg\_klbpbc g_h[oh^bfuo ^ey jZa\blby wdhghfbdb
H^gZdh\kdhj_klZehykghqlhwlbi_j_f_gug_khijh
\h`^Z\rb_ky h^gh\j_f_gguf jZa\blb_f \kihfh]Z
l_evghc^_g_`ghcbijZ\h\hcbgnjZkljmdlmjuijb\_
ebdlhfmqlh\wdhghfbdmoeugmebg_aZdhggu_^_gv
]bWlh\uy\behkeZ[hklb\hagbdr_cnbgZgkh\hckbk
l_fu ih^\_j]eh __ fgh]hqbke_gguf jbkdZf b m\_eb
qbeh __ aZ\bkbfhklv hl bghkljZgguo bklhqgbdh\ nb
gZgkbjh\Zgby\p_ehfbih\k_c\b^bfhklbhlbklhq
gbdh\khfgbl_evgh]hijhbkoh`^_gby Hkh[_ggh \i_qZleyxsbf ± ohly [u \ dhebq_kl
\_gghf hlghr_gbb ± \u]ey^_eh jZa\blb_ dhff_jq_
kdhc [Zgdh\kdhc kbkl_fu kqblZ\r__ky kbf\hehf mk
i_oZ j_nhjfu nbgZgkh\h]h k_dlhjZ Ihke_ ijh\_^_
gby \ ]h^m [Zgdh\kdhc j_nhjfu \ kljZg_ ihy\b
ehkv fgh`_kl\h dhff_jq_kdbo [Zgdh\ < ]h^m
qbkeh aZj_]bkljbjh\Zgguo [Zgdh\ khklZ\eyeh \
]h^m bo [ueh \ dhgp_ ]h^Z ± Z
\bxg_ ]h^Z ± DZd ij_^klZ\ey_lky lZdhc
jhkl ih [hevr_c qZklb klZe \hafh`_g [eZ]h^Zjy ijh
[_eZf \ aZdhgh^Zl_evkl\_ b hlkmlkl\bx dhgljhey GZ
ijbf_j g_dhlhju_ xjb^bq_kdb_ ebpZ aZj_]bkljbjh
\Zggu_ dZd [Zgdb ij_^klZ\eyeb kh[hc ijhklh imgdlu
h[f_gZ\Zexlbebhl^_e_gby]hkm^Zjkl\_gguo[Zgdh\
< gZqZe_ o ]h^h\ dhff_jq_kdb_ [Zgdb ihemqZeb
ijb[uev ]eZ\guf h[jZahf iml_f bg\_klbjh\Zgby ^_
r_\uo nbgZgkh\uo kj_^kl\ aZ kq_l ^_ihablh\ ij_^
ijbylbc ih dhlhjuf \uieZqb\Zebkv hljbpZl_evgu_
j_Zevgu_ ijhp_glgu_ klZ\db ;he__ lh]h bo f_lh^u
ba\e_q_gby^hoh^h\\[hevrhckl_i_gbfh`ghkqblZlv
g_aZdhggufbihkdhevdmbobklhqgbdhfqZklhkem`beb
mfure_ggu_ aZ^_j`db ijb \uiheg_gbb hi_jZpbc ±
jZkq_lh\ f_`^m ij_^ijbylbyfb b \uieZl ih khpbZev
ghfmh[_ki_q_gbx]jZ`^Zg
D]h^mjhkkbckdZy[Zgdh\kdZykbkl_fZklZeZ
hkh[_gghmya\bfhci_j_^\g_rgbfbb\Zexlgufbjbk
dZfb >Zggu_ gZ gZqZeh ]h^Z mdZau\Zxl qlh
kljmdlmjZ kjhdh\ ih]Zr_gby ih bghkljZgguf Zdlb\Zf
b iZkkb\Zf [ueZ g_k[ZeZgkbjh\Zgghc lZd dZd ^he]h
\u_h[yaZl_evkl\Zi_j_^g_j_ab^_glZfb\bghkljZgghc
\Zexl_ khklZ\eyeb fej^ ^hee KR: Z ZgZeh]bq
gu_Zdlb\u±ebrvfej^^heeG_kfhljygZlhqlh
[ZeZgkh\Zy klhbfhklv Zdlb\h\ dhff_jq_kdh]h [Zgdh\
kdh]h k_dlhjZ \ bghkljZgghc \Zexl_ ij_\urZeZ klhb
fhklv bo h[yaZl_evkl\ dZq_kl\_ggu_ oZjZdl_jbklbdb
wlbo Zdlb\h\ [ueb qj_a\uqZcgh gbadbfb ihkdhevdm
hl_q_kl\_gguf ij_^ijbylbyf \u^Z\Zebkv h]jhfgu_
\Zexlgu_ dj_^blu khfgbl_evgh]h dZq_kl\Z Djhf_
lh]h \_ebd [ue jbkd ihl_gpbZevguo \Zexlguo m[ul
dh\^ey\k_c[Zgdh\kdhckbkl_fu\p_ehflZddZdh[
sZy klhbfhklv Zdlb\h\ b iZkkb\h\ \ bghkljZgghc \Z
exl_ ij_\urZeZ fej^ ^hee Hdheh ijhp_glh\
h[yaZl_evkl\\bghkljZgghc\Zexl_bf_ehkjhdbih]Z
r_gby f_g__ h^gh]h f_kypZ Ih^\_j`_ggu_ agZqb
l_evguf jbkdZf k\yaZgguf k dmjkhf bghkljZgguo
\Zexl b ijhp_glgufb klZ\dZfb b \ \ukr_c kl_i_gb
aZ\bkysb_ hl ]hkm^Zjkl\_gguo p_gguo [mfZ] djZldh
kjhqguo h[yaZl_evkl\ hq_gv fgh]b_ dhff_jq_kdb_
[Zgdb hkh[_ggh fhkdh\kdb_ \ j_amevlZl_ nbgZgkh\h]h
djbabkZ]h^ZklZeb[ZgdjhlZfb
Ihke_djbabkZ]h^Zddhgpm]h^Zqbkeh
^_ckl\mxsbo [Zgdh\ khdjZlbehkv ^h ih ijbqbg_
lh]h qlh P_gljZevguc [Zgd hlha\Ze ebp_gabb [he__
q_fm[Zgdh\aZi_jbh^gZqbgZyk]h^ZDjh
f_ lh]h dhgp_gljZpbb [Zgdh\kdh]h k_dlhjZ kihkh[kl
\h\Zeb f_ju ijbgylu_ ijZ\bl_evkl\hf b [Zgdh\kdbf
k_dlhjhf \ i_jbh^ djbabkZ b ihke_ g_]h < dhgp_
]h^ZgZ^hexiylbkZfuodjmiguo[Zgdh\ijboh
^behkv ijhp_glh\ \k_c klhbfhklb Zdlb\h\ Z gZ ^h
exijhp_glh\\_^msbo[Zgdh\±ijhp_glKZfuc
\ebyl_evguc[ZgdnbgZgkh\hckbkl_fu±K[_j[ZgdgZ
^hex dhlhjh]h \ dhgp_ ]h^Z ijboh^beZkv ihqlb
JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
q_l\_jlv\k_oZdlb\h\±kmf_eg_lhevdhi_j_`blvnb
gZgkh\uc djbabk gh b m\_ebqblv k\hx ^hex gZ jha
gbqghfjugd_k^hijhp_glh\Zk\hcdj_^blguc
ihjln_ev±k^hijhp_glh\
<p_eyoebd\b^Zpbbihke_^kl\bcdjbabkZjhkkbc
kdb_\eZklbgZqZebhdZau\Zlvki_pbZevgmxih^^_j`dm
jy^m [Zgdh\ \ nhjf_ ha^hjh\bl_evguo dj_^blh\
P_gljZevguf[Zgdhf[uejZajZ[hlZgAZdhgh[Zgdjhl
kl\_ [Zgdh\ jZlbnbpbjh\Zgguc iZjeZf_glhf \
]h^m K ijbgylb_f AZdhgZ h j_kljmdlmjbaZpbb
[Zgdh\ \ky hl\_lkl\_gghklv aZ wlhl ijhp_kk [ueZ \ha
eh`_gZgZ:JDHZ]_glkl\hihj_kljmdlmjbaZpbb[Zg
dh\ I_j_^ZqZ [Zgdh\ \ \_^_gb_ :JDH fh`_l ijhba
\h^blvkylhevdhihmdZaZgbxP_gljZevgh]h[ZgdZJhk
kbckdhc N_^_jZpbb gZ hkgh\_ hkh[uo djbl_jb_\ ^ey
i_j_hp_gdb klhbfhklb Zdpbhg_jgh]h dZiblZeZ :JDH
miheghfhq_gh jZklhj]Zlv k^_edb aZdexq_ggu_ k p_
evxh[fZgZ\deZ^qbdh\bdj_^blhjh\h[Zgdjhlb\rbo
ky [Zgdh\ Hgh hdZau\Z_l ih^^_j`dm ebd\b^ghklb
lhevdh ieZl_`_kihkh[guf [ZgdZf beb l_f dhlhju_
hkms_kl\eyxl h^h[j_ggu_ bf ijh]jZffu j_kljmdlm
jbaZpbb DZd khh[sZehkv ihfhsv hl :JDH gZqZeb
ihemqZlv q_luj_ [ZgdZ j_Zebamxsb_ ih^h[gu_ ijh
]jZffuL_fg_f_g__^Z`_^_yl_evghklv:JDH\uau
\Z_l ih^haj_gby hlghkbl_evgh lh]h qlh dhjjmfibjh
\Zggu_ iheblbq_kdb_ b ^_eh\u_ djm]b hdZau\Zxl
\ebygb_gZ_]hj_r_gbyH^gbfbal_odlh\ur_eih
[_^bl_e_fbadjbabkZy\ey_lky:evnZ[Zgddhlhjuc
mkbebe k\hb ihabpbb gZ jugd_ iml_f ijb\e_q_gby
[hevrh]hqbkeZdeb_glh\k\hbo[u\rboZgug_h[Zg
djhlb\rbokydhgdmj_glh\Ihoh`_h^gZdhqlhg_fZ
emx \u]h^m :evnZ[Zgd ba\e_d b ba k\hbo k\ya_c k
\ukhdhihklZ\e_ggufbiheblbdZfbhq_fk\b^_l_evkl
\m_l nZdl ihemq_gby bf ^_g_`gh]h \eb\Zgby hl
:JDH\jZaf_j_feg^heeqlhkhklZ\ey_l^_kylmx
qZklvfbeebhggh]h[x^`_lZ:JDH
G_kfhljy gZ [_^kl\by ihklb]rb_ fgh]b_ [Zgdb
jhkkbyg_ ihij_`g_fm kqblZxl [Zgdbjh\ kZfufb [h
]Zlufb qe_gZfb h[s_kl\Z H[s_kl\_ggh_ fg_gb_
kdehgghk\yau\Zlv[h]Zlkl\h[Zgdbjh\\f_gvr_ckl_
i_gb k ^hoh^ghklvx aZdhgguo [Zgdh\kdbo hi_jZpbc b
\ [hevr_c ± k bo g_aZdhgghc beb djbfbgZevghc ^_y
l_evghklvxIh`Zemcemqr_\k_o[uebih^]hlh\e_gu
d djbabkm b ^Z`_ hdZaZebkv \ \ub]jur_ [Zgdbju
mf_xsb_ h[oh^blv beb gZjmrZlv aZdhg NbgZgkh\uc
djbabk ]h^Z \uy\be lhl nZdl qlh djbabkghc kj_
^hc e_]dh fZgbimebjmxl l_ dlh bf__l ^hklmi d [Zg
dh\kdbf Zdlb\Zf Bkihevamy jZaebqgu_ g_aZdhggu_
f_oZgbafu g_dhlhju_ [Zgdbju \ kblmZpbb djbabkZ b
g_ieZl_`_kihkh[ghklb kmf_eb ijbmfgh`blv k\hb Zd
lb\u IhklmiZeb khh[s_gby h kemqZyo ijbgylby \h
\eZ^_gb_ h[Zgdjhlb\rboky ij_^ijbylbc k p_evx bo
ijb[uevghc ijh^Z`b h i_j_f_s_gbb Zdlb\h\ \ nbd
lb\gu_ dhfiZgbb b bgbpbbjh\Zgbb \ h^ghklhjhgg_f
ihjy^d_ j_kljmdlmjbaZpbb k\hbo kh[kl\_gguo [ZeZg
kh\<eZ^_evpuihkljZ^Z\rbohldjbabkZ[Zgdh\i_j_
\h^beb k\hb ohjhrb_ Zdlb\u \ iZjZee_evgu_ [Zg
dh\kdb_ kljmdlmju [hevr_c qZklvx aZ kq_l aZjm[_`
guodj_^blhjh\bjhkkbckdbof_edbo\deZ^qbdh\
Ijbf_jhf lZdh]h jh^Z f_oZgbafh\ fh`_l kem
`blv kha^Zgb_ b ^_yl_evghklv [Zgdh\fhklh\ dhlh
ju_ij_^klZ\eyxlkh[hcobljhmfgh_bah[j_l_gb_\eZ
^_evp_\lZdbodgZklhys_fm\j_f_gbh[Zgdjhlb\rboky
[Zgdh\ dZd F_gZl_i Hgwdkbf[Zgd b K;K
:]jh <ha]eZ\ey_fu_ wlbfb `_ [ZgdbjZfb [Zgdb
fhklu[uebmqj_`^_gu^eyhk\h[h`^_gbyhlZdlb\h\b
bo i_j_f_s_gby H^gbf ba gZb[he__ yjdbo ijbf_jh\
lZdbo \hajh`^_gguo [Zgdh\ y\ey_lky ih fg_gbx
fgh]bo Jhk[Zgd l_g_\Zy kljmdlmjZ g_khklhyl_ev
gh]hHgwdkbf[ZgdZDJhk[Zgdmi_j_rebbgnjZ
kljmdlmjZ b hkgh\gu_ deb_glu Hgwdkbf[ZgdZ \
qZklghklb lZdZy ba\_klgZy dhfiZgby dZd Ijhfur
e_ggZy]jmiiZBgl_jjhkHgwdkbf[ZgdhklZekygb
k q_f aZ^he`Z\ k\hbf dj_^blhjZf ijb[ebabl_evgh
fej^ ^hee ba dhlhjuo fej^ ± ih nhj\Zj^
guf\Zexlguf dhgljZdlZf H[eZ^Zy hkgh\guf dZib
lZehf \ jZaf_j_ feg ^hee Jhk[Zgd \hr_e \
qbkeh\_^msbojhkkbckdbo[Zgdh\WlZko_fZkjZ
[hlZeZgZklhevdhohjhrh^eyJhk[ZgdZqlhiha^g__
hg hnbpbZevgh ih]ehlbe k\hc i_j\hbklhqgbd ±
Hgwdkbf[Zgd ij_\jZlb\ wlh kh[ulb_ \ [_kij_p_
^_glgmx ^_fhgkljZpbx ^h[jhc \heb kh klhjhgu
djmigh]h[ZgdZ
< gZqZe_ b k_j_^bg_ o ]h^h\ ij_klmighklv \
[Zgdh\kdhfbnbgZgkh\hfk_dlhjZobf_eZ[he__y\guc
b f_g__ bahsj_gguc oZjZdl_j < lhl i_jbh^ jhkkbc
kdb_ KFB [ueb ihegu khh[s_gbc h [ZgdZo
fhr_ggbdZo b nbgZgkh\uo fZobgZpbyo Fgh]b_ [Zg
db ih\b^bfhfm bagZqZevgh y\eyebkv ij_klmigufb
ij_^ijbylbyfb gZp_e_ggufb gZ h[djZ^u\Zgb_ deb
_glh\ GZijbf_j \ ]h^m khh[sZehkv h lhf qlh
fZe_gvdbcfhkdh\kdbc[Zgd:^_evnbdjmighgZ`b
\Z_lky gZ h[fZg_ deb_glh\ ;Zgd ijh^Z\Ze deb_glZf
Zdpbb i_qZevgh agZf_gblh]h nhg^Z FFF ± bg\_
klbpbhgghc ibjZfb^u ebrb\r_c gZdhie_gbc h]
jhfgh_ qbkeh jhkkbyg G_kfhljy gZ i_jbh^bq_kdmx
dhjj_dlbjh\dm p_g [Zgd :^_evnb ijh^he`Ze ijh
^Z`mdeb_glZfZdpbcFFFih[he__\ukhdhcklZ\
d_gZagZq_gghcjZg__bh^gh\j_f_gghkdmiZeboih
kgb`_gghckdhjj_dlbjh\ZgghcklZ\d_<lhlfhf_gl
Zdpbb FFF j_adh miZeb \ p_g_ \ k\yab k l_f qlh
ibjZfb^Z d lhfm \j_f_gb ^\Z`^u jmrbeZkv Z \k_
qe_guijZ\e_gbynhg^ZaZbkdexq_gb_fij_ab^_glZ
K_j]_y FZ\jh^b hdZaZebkv \ lxjvf_ <uc^y ba lxjv
fu ih^ aZeh] FZ\jh^b kmf_e ih[_^blv gZ \u[hjZo b
klZlv^_imlZlhf=hkm^Zjkl\_gghc>mfugb`g_ciZeZ
JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
lu iZjeZf_glZ ihemqb\ lZdbf h[jZahf bffmgbl_l
ijhlb\km^_[gh]hij_ke_^h\Zgby
I_jbh^fZkkh\h]hfhr_ggbq_kl\Z\[Zgdh\kdhfb
nbgZgkh\hf k_dlhjZo [ue lZd`_ i_jbh^hf fZkkh\h]h
gZkbeby\hlghr_gbb\ukhdhihklZ\e_gguo[Zgdh\kdbo
qbgh\gbdh\ Ih khh[s_gbyf :kkhpbZpbb jhkkbckdbo
[Zgdbjh\ aZ ljb k iheh\bghc ]h^Z ± k k_j_^bgu ih ]h^ ± gZ `bagv ij_ab^_glh\ [Zgdh\ b \b^guo
[Zgdh\kdboqbgh\gbdh\[uehkh\_jr_gh\hhjm`_g
guo ihdmr_gby Klhev \ukhdbc mjh\_gv gZkbeby
k\b^_l_evkl\h\Zehklj_fe_gbbdjbfbgZevguo]jmiib
jh\hdihklZ\blv[Zgdbih^k\hcdhgljhevIhfg_gbx
ij_^klZ\bl_e_c GZmqghbkke_^h\Zl_evkdh]h bgklblmlZ
Fbgbkl_jkl\Z \gmlj_ggbo ^_e <GBB F<> \
]h^mdjbfbgZevgu_]jmiibjh\dbdhgljhebjh\Zeb
[he__[Zgdh\b[bj`
Dhgljhev gZ^ [ZgdZfb kihkh[kl\m_l nhjfbjh\Z
gbx g_aZdhgguo ^hoh^h\ Hg agZqbl_evgh mijhsZ_l
kh\_jr_gb_ ij_klmiguo ^_ckl\bc gZijbf_j \ufh]Z
l_evkl\Zbeb ihobs_gby ex^_c k p_evx \udmiZ \ hl
ghr_gbbdeb_glh\[ZgdZWlhlZd`_h[e_]qZ_lijhgbd
gh\_gb_ ij_klmiguo ]jmiibjh\hd \ ^jm]b_ k_dlhju
wdhghfbdb \ k\yab k mijhs_gb_f nbgZgkh\h]h h[kem
`b\Zgby djbfbgZevguo hi_jZpbc Qlh dZkZ_lky ^_y
l_evghklb ih hlfu\Zgbx ^_g_] lh dhgljhev gZ^ [Zg
dZfb h[_ki_qb\Z_l bo \eZ^_evpZf ^he]hkjhqgu_ ij_
bfms_kl\ZbgZ^_`gmxaZsblm\kemqZ_\\_^_gbyf_j
j_]mebjh\Zgby[Zgdh\kdhc^_yl_evghklbDh]^ZdZdbf
eb[h[Zgdhf\eZ^__lbmijZ\ey_lij_klmigZyhj]ZgbaZ
pbygbdZdb_^Z`_kZfu_kljh]b_f_juj_]mebjh\Zgby
g_ kfh]ml ij_k_qv hlfu\Zgb_ ^_g_] ?keb \eZ^__rv
[Zgdhfg_gm`gh[_kihdhblvkyihih\h^mh[\bg_gbc\
ih^hajbl_evguok^_edZo
JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
=eZ\Z9,,
Ij_klmighklvb[bag_k\Jhkkbckdhcn_^_jZpbb
<_]h^u\JhkkbckdhcN_^_jZpbbgZ[ex^Zeky
agZqbl_evguc jhkl mjh\gy ij_klmighklb Kms_kl\_g
gmxjhev\mom^r_gbbdjbfbgZevghckblmZpbb\]hkm
^Zjkl\_ b]jZeZ wdhghfbq_kdZy ij_klmighklv Xjb^b
q_kdbc l_jfbg ij_klmighklv \ kn_j_ wdhghfbq_kdhc
^_yl_evghklb \ gZklhys_f ^hdmf_gl_ ± ijhklh wdh
ghfbq_kdZy ij_klmighklv [ue \\_^_g \ ]h^m k
ijbgylb_f=hkm^Zjkl\_gghc>mfhcgh\h]hM]heh\gh]h
dh^_dkZ Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb < MD _klv ]eZ\Z ih^
gZa\Zgb_fIj_klmie_gby\kn_j_wdhghfbq_kdhc ^_y
l_evghklb\dexqZxsZyklZlvx\dhlhjuonhjfm
ebjmxlky iheh`_gby hlghkbl_evgh rbjhdh]h djm]Z
ijZ\hgZjmr_gbc Kj_^b wlbo ijZ\hgZjmr_gbc ± e_]Z
ebaZpbybebhlfu\Zgb_^_g_`guokj_^kl\bebbgh]h
bfms_kl\Zijbh[j_l_gguog_aZdhggufiml_f\ayldb
dhgljZ[Zg^Z g_aZdhggh_ ij_^ijbgbfZl_evkl\h g_aZ
dhggZy[Zgdh\kdZy^_yl_evghklvg_aZdhggh_bkihevah
\Zgb_ lhj]h\uo agZdh\ mdehg_gb_ hl mieZlu gZeh]h\
mdehg_gb_hlmieZlulZfh`_gguoihrebggZjmr_gb_
ijZ\be k^Zqb ^jZ]hp_gguo f_lZeeh\ g_\ha\jZs_gb_
^_g_`guokj_^kl\\bghkljZgghc\Zexl_baaZjm[_`Z
\hkij_iylkl\h\Zgb_ \_^_gbx aZdhgghc ij_^ijbgbfZ
l_evkdhc ^_yl_evghklb ij_^gZf_j_ggh_ b nbdlb\gh_
[Zgdjhlkl\hbli
< ]h^m ih kjZ\g_gbx k ij_^r_kl\mxsbf
]h^hf qbkeh aZj_]bkljbjh\Zgguo wdhghfbq_kdbo ij_
klmie_gbcm\_ebqbehkvgZijhp_glh\\lh\j_fydZd
jhkl ij_klmighklb \ p_ehf khklZ\be ijhp_glZ <
]h^m [ueh aZj_]bkljbjh\Zgh ijbf_jgh luk
wdhghfbq_kdbo ij_klmie_gbc \ ]h^m ± ihqlb
luk\]h^m±hdhehlukZ\]h^m±
[he__lukKi_pbZebkluiheZ]ZxlqlhaZj_]bkljb
jh\Zggu_ kemqZb khklZ\eyxl ebrv g_agZqbl_evgmx
qZklv hl ^h ijhp_glh\ hl qbkeZ \k_o ij_klmie_
gbc kh\_jr_gguo \ kn_j_ wdhghfbdb < i_jbh^ k
ih ]h^ qbkeh ij_klmie_gbc \ [Zgdh\kdhf b
nbgZgkh\hf k_dlhjZo \ujhkeh \ jZa < ]h^m
m[uldbhlwdhghfbq_kdboij_klmie_gbchp_gb\Zebkv\
fej^ ^hee KR: Z k mq_lhf ms_j[Z ihg_k_ggh]h
`_jl\Zfb nbgZgkh\uo ibjZfb^ wlZ pbnjZ khklZ\beZ
fej^ ^hee beb ijhp_glh\ <<I < ]h^m
m[uldb bkqbkeyebkv kmffhc \ fej^ jm[e_c Z \
]h^m hgb m\_ebqbebkv \^\h_ khklZ\b\ fej^
jm[e_c ^_ghfbgbjh\Zgguo Ljb q_l\_jlb \k_o
m[uldh\ ihg_k_gguo \ j_amevlZl_ ij_klmiguo ^_ckl
\bcijboh^behkvgZ[Zgdh\kdbcbnbgZgkh\uck_dlhju
<k_ qZs_ ij_klmie_gby kh\_jrZxlky ij_klmigu
fb ]jmiibjh\dZfb \ qZklghklb hj]Zgbah\Zggufb
]jmiiZfb Qbkeh ij_klmie_gbc kh\_jr_gguo hj]Zgb
ah\Zggufb]jmiiZfbm\_ebqbehkv[he__q_f\q_luj_
jZaZ Ih ^Zgguf Fbgbkl_jkl\Z \gmlj_ggbo ^_e \
i_jbh^ k ih ]h^ dhebq_kl\h \uy\e_gguo
ij_klmiguo ]jmii \ujhkeh k ^h lh _klv \
k_fv jZa qbkeh ij_klmiguo ]jmii bf_xsbo f_`^m
gZjh^gu_k\yabm\_ebqbehkv\^\ZjZaZZqbkeh]jmii
k\yaZgguo k dhjjmfibjh\Zggufb ]hkm^Zjkl\_ggufb
kljmdlmjZfb ± [he__ q_f \ r_klv jZa < ]h^m \
kljZg_^_ckl\h\Zehlukhj]Zgbah\Zgguoij_klmiguo
]jmiibjh\hd dhlhju_ dhgljhebjh\Zeb luk ij_^
ijbylbc \ lhf qbke_ [Zgdh\ D dhgpm ]h^Z
ih^ dhgljhe_f hj]Zgbah\Zgguo ij_klmiguo ]jmii gZ
oh^beZkv iheh\bgZ dhff_jq_kdbo [Zgdh\ ijh
p_glh\ ]hkm^Zjkl\_gguo ij_^ijbylbc b ijhp_glh\
qZklguo dhfiZgbc Kh]eZkgh bkke_^h\Zgbx ijh\_
^_gghfm kj_^b jmdh\h^bl_e_c h[hjhgguo ij_^ijb
ylbc djbfbgZevgu_ we_f_glu dhgljhebjh\Zeb ijb
f_jgh ijhp_glh\ lZdbo ij_^ijbylbc b ih fg_gbx
ijhp_glh\ jmdh\h^bl_e_c wlZ pbnjZ kdhj__ \k_]h
[m^_lm\_ebqb\Zlvky
Hkgh\guf gZijZ\e_gb_f ^_yl_evghklb gZoh^y
sboky ih^ dhgljhe_f ij_klmiguo ]jmii ij_^ijbylbc
y\ey_lkyhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]K\ur_ luk hj]ZgbaZpbc
dZd ij_^klZ\ey_lky ki_pbZebabjmxlky gZ hlfu\Zgbb
^_g_] kha^Z\ ^ey wlbo p_e_c ki_pbZevgu_ kljmdlmju
Fgh]b_ ba gbo gZqZeb k\hx ^_yl_evghklv \ b
]h^Zo dh]^Z ih khh[s_gbyf q_j_a h[f_ggu_
imgdlu[uehhlfulh[he__fej^jm[e_cIjhp_kk
hlfu\Zgby ^_g_] \ Jhkkbb oZjZdl_jbam_lky l_f qlh
djbfbgZevgu_ we_f_glu dZd ijZ\beh \deZ^u\Zxl
^_gv]b \ aZdhgguc gZ i_j\uc \a]ey^ [bag_k aZ jm[_
`hf >ey ihemq_gby ^hoh^h\ b h[_ki_q_gby gZ^_`gh
JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
klbk\hbo\deZ^h\hgbijbh[j_lZxlZdpbbb^Z`_dhg
ljhevgu_ iZd_lu Zdpbc jZaebqguo dhfiZgbc AZqZk
lmxhgbihemqZxlbghkljZggh_]jZ`^Zgkl\hbebihev
amxlkyaZsblhcijZ\bl_evkl\aZjm[_`guokljZg
JhkkbckdZyhj]Zgbah\ZggZyij_klmighklvih\k_c
\b^bfhklbb]jZ_lagZqbl_evgmxjhevbh[eZ^Z_lfhs
guf\ebygb_f\wdhghfbq_kdhcbiheblbq_kdhc`bagb
kljZgu<__jZkihjy`_gbbgZoh^ylkydjmigu_nbgZg
kh\u_kj_^kl\ZbaZdhggh_bfms_kl\h±bgnhjfZpbhg
gu_ k_lb Z lZd`_ jZa\blu_ kljmdlmju aZgbfZxsb_ky
kljZl_]bq_kdbfieZgbjh\Zgb_fbhkms_kl\e_gb_fwlbo
ieZgh\ gZ ijZdlbd_ <k_ qZs_ ij_klmigu_ ]jmiiu h[
jZamxl [he__ rbjhdb_ h[t_^bg_gby Hgb bfblbjmxl
beb kha^Zxl kljmdlmju ZgZeh]bqgu_ ]hkm^Zjkl\_g
guf lZdbf gZijbf_j dZd kem`[u [_ahiZkghklb beb
jZa\_^dZHgbihevamxlkymkem]Zfbhiulguoxjbklh\
nbgZgkh\uowdki_jlh\bwdhghfbklh\GZb[he__hiZk
ghcl_g^_gpb_c\k_`_y\ey_lkyZdlb\gh_mqZklb_ij_
klmiguo]jmiibjh\hdg_lhevdh\aZdhgghcwdhghfbq_
kdhc ^_yl_evghklb gh b \ Z^fbgbkljZlb\guo b iheb
lbq_kdbokljmdlmjZo
N_ghf_g ba[jZgby djbfbgZevguo Z\lhjbl_lh\ \
hj]ZguaZdhgh^Zl_evghcbbkihegbl_evghc\eZklbrb
jhdh h[km`^Z_lky b ijbagZ_lky \ Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZ
pbb Khlgb b lukyqb ij_klmiguo we_f_glh\ \hkihev
ah\Z\rbkvijh\h^bfufbj_nhjfZfbkfh]ebg_lhevdh
e_]Zebah\Zlv k\hb ^hoh^u gh b ij_mfgh`blv bo Wlb
^hoh^u bkihevamxlky ^ey ih^dmiZ f_klgh]h we_dlhjZ
lZ b hj]Zgh\ bkihegbl_evghc \eZklb < j_amevlZl_
hnbpbZevgZy wdhghfbdZ g_j_^dh ihiZ^Z_l ih^ dhg
ljhev ij_klmiguo ]jmiibjh\hd b fhghihebabjm_lky
\ke_^kl\b_ ^Zevg_cr_]h mkbe_gby bo \ebygby \ iheb
lbq_kdbodjm]Zob]hkm^Zjkl\_gguokljmdlmjZo
Dh]^Z `_ j_qv b^_l h[ h]jhfguo kmffZo ^_g_]
ij_klmigu_ ]jmiiu ihij_`g_fm ijb[_]Zxl d gZkb
ebx Yjdbf ijbf_jhf kem`bl ^_eh Nhg^Z \_l_jZgh\
Zn]Zgkdhc\hcguG_kfhljygZlhqlh\wlhf^_e_nb
]mjbjm_lih]b[rbobjZg_guoZkhlgbfbeebZj
^h\ jm[e_c ba nhg^Z [_kke_^gh bkq_aeb hiulg_crb_
ke_^h\Zl_eb ih m]heh\guf ^_eZf ihke_ fgh]bo f_ky
p_\ ke_^kl\_gghc jZ[hlu kfh]eb ^hdZaZlv ebrv h^bg
kemqZc obs_gby \ jZaf_j_ feg jm[e_c b ihkZ^blv
gZ kdZfvx ih^km^bfuo ebrv lj_o h[\bgy_fuo lh]^Z
dZd \hijhk h [hevr_c qZklb ihobs_gguo kj_^kl\ kh
klZ\ey\r_c ih g_dhlhjuf khh[s_gbyf fej^
jm[e_clZdbhklZekyg_ijhykg_ggufDlhfm\j_f_gb
dexq_\u_ k\b^_l_eb b mqZklgbdb ij_klmie_gby [ueb
m[blu\lhfqbke_[u\rbcmijZ\eyxsbcnhg^Zb_]h
\^h\ZZlZd`_q_eh\_dkf_gb\rbc_]hgZwlhfihklm
Ihy\eyxlky hl^_evgu_ khh[s_gby h k\yab bkq_agm\
rbo ^_g_] k ^_yl_evghklvx jhkkbckdbo ki_pkem`[ b
ba[bjZl_evghc dZfiZgb_c [u\r_]h jhkkbckdh]h ij_
ab^_glZ ?s_ h^gh ihemqb\r__ rbjhdh_ hk\_s_gb_
^_eh dZkZ_lky Nhg^Z \hkklZgh\e_gby Q_qgb Khh[sZ
ehkv qlh ba fej^ jm[e_c \u^_e_gguo gZ \hkklZ
gh\e_gb_Q_q_gkdhcj_kim[ebdbfej^lZbgkl\_g
ghbkq_aehWlh^_ehk\yau\Z_lkykg_[u\ZeufihjZa
fZomfhr_ggbq_kl\hf\hjh\kl\hfbdhjjmipb_c
B \k_ `_ \ p_ehf i_jbh^ ^bdh]h dZiblZebafZ k
_]h [_kkfuke_gguf oZhkhf b gZkbeb_f ijhlb\ hl
^_evguo f_edbo ij_^ijbgbfZl_e_c ih\b^bfhfm aZ
dhgqbeky Jugdb ih^_e_gu f_`^m fh]ms_kl\_ggu
fb hj]Zgbah\Zggufb ij_klmigufb ]jmiibjh\dZfb
djurZfbm\_j_ggufb\k\h_ckihkh[ghklbhkms_
kl\eylvdhgljhevHgb\k_qZs_bg\_klbjmxlkj_^kl\Z
\ dhgljhebjm_fu_ bfb hljZkeb ijhfure_gghklb b
jugdbm\_ebqb\Zyl_fkZfufk\hb^hoh^ube_]Zebamy
Zdlb\uKh\_jrZxsb_ky\j_fyhl\j_f_gbZdlugZkb
eby k\yau\Zxl k [hjv[hc heb]Zjoh\ bkihevamxsbo
\hhjm`_ggu_ ]jmiiu dZd kj_^kl\h jZaj_r_gby dhg
nebdlh\ L_f g_ f_g__ ^Z`_ bfi_jbb heb]Zjoh\ ih
f_j_ jhklZ \ p_eyo khojZg_gby k\hbo ^hfbgbjmxsbo
ihabpbc klZgh\ylky \k_ [he__ aZbgl_j_kh\Zggufb \
klZ[bevghklb wdhghfbq_kdhc b iheblbq_kdhc `bagb
kbevghf p_gljZevghf ijZ\bl_evkl\_ b ijZ\hhojZgb
l_evguo hj]ZgZo kihkh[guo [hjhlvky k h[uqghc ij_
klmighklvx ;he__ bahsj_ggu_ ij_klmie_gby gZ
ijbf_j \ kn_j_ f_`^mgZjh^guo nbgZgkh\ ih [hev
r_cqZklbhklZxlkyg_jZkdjulufb
Hlkmlkl\b_ khhl\_lkl\mxs_c ijZ\h\hc [Zau \
Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb Z lZd`_ b \ ^jm]bo kljZgZo
^ey[hjv[ukbahsj_ggufbnbgZgkh\ufbij_klmie_
gbyfb g_j_^dh g_ iha\hey_l ij_^ty\blv h[\bg_gb_
ij_^iheZ]Z_fuf ij_klmigbdZf < bgl_j\vx k K_f_
ghf Fh]be_\bq_f kqblZxsbfky h^gbf ba djmig_c
rbofZnbhabfbjZhim[ebdh\Zgghf\h^ghcbajhk
kbckdbo ]Za_l \uykgbehkv qlh hg kihdhcgh `b\_l k
k_fv_c\ijb]hjh^_Fhkd\ulh]^ZdZdgZAZiZ^_kqb
lZxl qlh hg kdju\Z_lky beb gZoh^blky \ [_]Zo AZ
iZ^gu_ KFB m`_ hkm^beb Fh]be_\bqZ aZ hlfu\Z
gb_ h]jhfguo kmff ^_g_] fZobgZpbb b fhr_ggbq_
kl\h ?]h kqblZxl hiZkg_crbf ]Zg]kl_jhf Z h^bg
Zf_jbdZgkdbcZ\lhj^Z`_ihk\ylbe_fm]eZ\m\dgb]_
gZa\Zgghc ih bf_gb hj]Zgbah\Zgghc ij_klmighc
]jmiiu DjZkgZy fZnby dhlhjmx Fh]be_\bq ydh
[u\ha]eZ\eye
DhfiZgby MZc;bWf FZ]g_dk dhlhjmx hg hk
gh\Ze \ ijb]hjh^_ NbeZ^_evnbb ijbagZeZ k_[y \b
gh\ghc \ n_^_jZevghf hdjm`ghf km^_ NbeZ^_evnbb
ihke_ lh]h dZd [ueh ^hdZaZgh ihemq_gb_ _x ^hoh^h\
iml_f bkdmkkl\_ggh]h \a^m\Zgby klhbfhklb k\hbo Zd
pbc b h[fZgZ bg\_klhjh\ Djhf_ lh]h Fh]be_\bqZ
h[\bgyeb\dhgljZ[Zg^_hjm`bymqZklbb\g_aZdhgghf
h[hjhl_gZjdhlbdh\dhgljZ[Zg^_bihke_^mxs_cijh
^Z`_ gZ ZmdpbhgZo p_gg_crbo ijhba\_^_gbc bkdmkkl
\Z lhj]h\e_ q_eh\_q_kdbfb hj]ZgZfb b m[bckl\Zo
JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
=gFh]be_\bq kqblZ_l wlb h[\bg_gby [_ahkgh\Zl_ev
gufb b kkueZ_lky gZ lh qlh \ ]h^m njZgpmakdbc
km^ hlf_gbe gZeh`_gguc njZgpmakdbfb \eZklyfb aZ
ij_lgZ_]h\t_a^\kljZgm\]h^m[jblZgkdbckm^
\ug_k j_r_gb_ h \ha\jZl_ _fm dhgnbkdh\Zgguo Zdlb
\h\ Z \ ^_e_ ;wgd hn GvxChjd ke_^h\Zl_eb ih
\b^bfhfm g_ gZreb gbdZdbo ^hdZaZl_evkl\ k\b^_
l_evkl\mxsbo h _]h mqZklbb \ hi_jZpbyo ih hlfu\Z
gbx^_g_]Ihkeh\Zf]gZFh]be_\bqZ\^_e_dZkZx
s_fky ;wgd hn GvxChjd ih^haj_gby \ hlghr_gbb
g_]h \hagbdeb baaZ lh]h qlh kj_^kl\Z fZkkh\hc bg
nhjfZpbb kimlZeb gZa\Zgb_ nbjf hg \eZ^__l dhfiZ
gb_c ;_g_dkLj_c^ F_^bdZe Dhjihj_crg Z \ ^_e_
mihfbgZ_lky dhfiZgby ;_g_dk Mhje^mZc^ >h l_o
ihj ihdZ jhkkbckdb_ b f_`^mgZjh^gu_ ijZ\hhojZgb
l_evgu_hj]Zgug_gZc^ml[he__\_kdbohkgh\Zgbc^ey
Zj_klZK_f_gZFh]be_\bqZhgfh`_lfbjgh`blvgZ
^Zq_ih^Fhkd\hc
JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
=eZ\Z9,,,
:j]mf_glZpby\ihevamb^_be_]ZebaZpbbbbebZfgbklbb
: KblmZpby\Jhkkbckdhc
N_^_jZpbbdZdhkgh\ghc
Zj]mf_gl
<JhkkbckdhcN_^_jZpbbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]\k_]^Z
k\yaZghkijh[e_fhc[_]kl\ZdZiblZeZbdZdke_^kl\b_
g_^hklZldZ bg\_klbpbc Z lZd`_ k jughqgufb j_nhj
fZfb \hh[s_ H[uqgh \ukdZau\Z_lky fg_gb_ h lhf
qlh ihkdhevdm k_cqZk m`_ g_\hafh`gh hij_^_eblv
bklhqgbd ijhbkoh`^_gby Zdlb\h\ ijhs_ ij_^iheh
`blv qlh \_kv dZiblZe ihemq_g aZdhgguf iml_f Wlh
ml\_j`^_gb_ ebrZ_l kfukeZ kZfh ihgylb_ hlfu\Zgby
^_g_]
IhimeyjguciheblbdFboZbeIjmkZd]m[_jgZlhj
Gh\]hjh^kdhc h[eZklb \ p_gljZevghc qZklb Jhkkbc
kdhcN_^_jZpbbh^gh]hbaj_]bhgh\]^_j_nhjfu[u
ebijh\_^_gumki_rghih^^_j`Zggucfgh]bfbdZd\
k\h_c h[eZklb lZd b aZ __ ij_^_eZfb gZqZe h[s_gZ
pbhgZevgmx dZfiZgbx aZ h[ty\e_gb_ aZdhggufb \k_o
gZoh^ysboky k_]h^gy \ kh[kl\_gghklb Zdlb\h\ b ih^
]hlh\be iZd_l khhl\_lkl\mxsbo aZdhghijh_dlh\ Ih
_]h fg_gbx ihiuldZ jZah[jZlvky \ lhf dZdhc dZib
lZe[uegZ`blij_klmigufiml_fZdZdhcg_l[ueZ[u
kZfuf [_kihe_aguf rZ]hf ^ey ex[h]h jmdh\h^bl_
ey =gIjmkZd kqblZ_l qlh ebrv g_[hevrZy qZklv
±ijhp_glh\ [h]Zlkl\Z ihemq_gZ ij_klmiguf im
l_f LZdbf h[jZahf ^h l_o ihj ihdZ km^Zfb g_ mklZ
gh\e_ghqlh^Zggu_Zdlb\uij_^klZ\eyxlkh[hc^hoh
^u hl ij_klmighc ^_yl_evghklb \eZklb ^he`gu bkoh
^blv ba lh]h qlh wlb kj_^kl\Z aZjZ[hlZgu aZdhgguf
iml_f>eyGh\]hjh^kdhch[eZklbwlhhagZqZ_lqlh\k_
Zdlb\uihy\b\rb_ky\h[eZklbijbagZguaZdhggufb
K mq_lhf k_]h^gyrg_]h ieZq_\gh]h khklhygby km^_[
ghc kbkl_fu \ kljZg_ fh`gh k iheguf hkgh\Zgb_f
h`b^Zlv qlh _keb [m^_l ijbgyl lZdhc iheblbq_kdbc
dmjklh`_kZfh_ijhbahc^_lb\h\k_ckljZg_
Gh\]hjh^kdZy h[eZklv ijb wlhf ij_^hklZ\ey_l
[hevr_ ^hihegbl_evguo gZeh]h\uo ev]hl b aZdhgh^Z
l_evguo ]ZjZglbc bg\_klhjZf q_f [hevrbgkl\h ^jm
]boj_]bhgh\A^_kvbkoh^ylbaij_^iheh`_gbyqlhlh
qlh \u]ey^bl dZd hlfu\Zgb_ ^_g_] gZ kZfhf ^_e_ y\
ey_lky [_]kl\hf dZiblZeZ dhlhjh_ h[mkeh\e_gh g_kh
\_jr_gkl\hf aZdhgh^Zl_evkl\Z \ i_j\mx hq_j_^v
qj_af_jguf gZeh]hh[eh`_gb_f b g_mklhcqb\hklvx
wdhghfbq_kdhckblmZpbbIhwlhfmij_^hklZ\eyyklZ
[bevgu_ b [eZ]hijbylgu_ wdhghfbq_kdb_ mkeh\by b
]ZjZglbb ijhlb\ m]heh\gh]h ij_ke_^h\Zgby b dhgnb
kdZpbb Zdlb\h\ h[eZklv klZ\bl k\h_c p_evx ijb\e_
q_gb_dZiblZeh\moh^ysbo\hnrhjgu_ahgu>_ckl
\bl_evghGh\]hjh^kdZyh[eZklv±q_fibhgJhkkbbih
ijb\e_q_gbxbg\_klbpbc<g_ckZfZy\ukhdZy\Jhk
kbckdhc N_^_jZpbb ghjfZ bg\_klbpbc gZ _^bgbpm
ijbjh^guo j_kmjkh\ G_kfhljy gZ lh qlh h[eZklv g_
kZfuc ijb\e_dZl_evguc j_]bhg k lhqdb aj_gby ijb
jh^guo [h]Zlkl\ _c m^Z_lky ijb\e_dZlv rbjhdhfZk
rlZ[gu_hl_q_kl\_ggu_bbghkljZggu_bg\_klbpbbZ
wlh kihkh[kl\m_l wdhghfbq_kdhfm jhklm b kha^Zgbx
jZ[hqbof_kl
>ey h[hkgh\Zgby ij_^eh`_gby h e_]ZebaZpbb
dZiblZeZ ijb\h^ylky b gZmqgu_ Zj]mf_glu < wlhc
k\yab qZklh h[jZsZxlky d DZiblZem DZjeZ FZjdkZ
< ]eZ\_ h ijhbkoh`^_gbb ijhfure_ggh]h dZiblZeZ
hibku\Z_lky i_jbh^ i_j\hgZqZevgh]h gZdhie_gby dZ
iblZeZ \ ?\jhi_ \hk_fgZ^pZlh]h b ^_\ylgZ^pZlh]h
\_dh\Wlh[uei_jbh^dh]^Z\]eZaZoh[s_kl\_ggh]h
fg_gby ?\jhiZ mljZlbeZ ihke_^gb_ hklZldb klu^Z b
kh\_klb «pbgbqgh iho\Zeyykv ihklu^gufb ihklmi
dZfbdhlhju_ihkem`bebkj_^kl\hfgZdhie_gbydZib
lZeZ < lh \j_fy lZdbfb ihklmidZfb [ueb jZ[hlhj
]h\eybkihevah\Zgb_jZ[kdh]hljm^Z^_l_c]hkm^Zjkl
\_ggu_ ^he]b \u]h^gu_ ebrv madhc ]jmii_ ex^_c
ijhl_dpbhgbaf \ lhj]h\e_ dhff_jq_kdb_ \hcgu b lZd
^Ze__Hlkx^Zke_^m_lqlhjZggbci_jbh^dZiblZebafZ
dhlhjhfm khhl\_lkl\m_l gZqZeh o ]h^h\ \ Jhkkbc
kdhc N_^_jZpbb y\ey_lky j_\hexpbhgguf i_jbh^hf
[_aaZdhgby dh]^Z dZiblZe dZd ijZ\beh gZdZieb\Z_lky
g_aZdhggufbbbebfhr_ggbq_kdbfbkj_^kl\Zfb
<ihevame_]ZebaZpbb\u^\b]Zxlkyb[he__h[hk
gh\Zggu_ Zj]mf_glu GZijbf_j GZlZeby EhiZr_gdh
Z\lhj jy^Z dgb] h[ wdhghfbq_kdbo ij_klmie_gbyo \
JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb iheZ]Z_l qlh \_kv ij_klmigh
ihemq_gguc dZiblZe m`_ e_]Zebah\Zg Wlh ijhbahreh
gZ i_j\hf wlZi_ ijhp_kkZ ijb\ZlbaZpbb ijhoh^b\r_
]h ih ko_f_ fZkkh\hc \Zmq_jghc ijb\ZlbaZpbb ±
]h^h\Hlkx^ZhgZ^_eZ_l\u\h^qlhg_e_]Zebah
\Zgghc hklZeZkv ebrv g_[hevrZy qZklv ihemq_ggh]h
ij_klmigufiml_fdZiblZeZHkgh\gZyfZkkZkdjulh]h
dZiblZeZ _keb g_ ijhp_glh\ _]h ± wlh ijhklh l_
g_\hcdZiblZeiulZxsbckymclbhlgZeh]hh[eh`_gby
b g_[eZ]hijbylguo wdhghfbq_kdbo b iheblbq_kdbo
mkeh\bcBklhqgbdbgZdhie_gguoZdlb\h\±wlhl_\b
^u ^_yl_evghklb dhlhju_ g_evay [_ah]h\hjhqgh d\Z
ebnbpbjh\ZlvdZdij_klmigu_Hlkx^Zfh`ghk^_eZlv
\u\h^qlh[ueh[uwdhghfbq_kdbbxjb^bq_kdbp_e_
khh[jZaghh[ty\blv\_kvdZiblZeaZdhgguf
Fgh]b_ iheblbdb ih^^_j`b\Zxl b^_x e_]ZebaZ
pbb hkgh\Zggmx gZ ^hklZlhqgh ijZ]fZlbq_kdbo ^h\h
^Zo >h g_^Z\g_]h \j_f_gb g_ kms_kl\h\Zeh gbdZdbo
hnbpbZevguo ^hdmf_glh\ \ hlghr_gbb Zdlb\h\ ijb
gZ^e_`ZsbfjhkkbygZfIhwlhfmml\_j`^Zxlhgbg_l
\hafh`ghklbklZ\blvih^\hijhkaZdhgghklvwlboZdlb
\h\Ex^bfh]mlke_]dhklvxml\_j`^ZlvqlhwlbZdlb
\u ^Z\gh ijbgZ^e_`Zeb bo k_fvyf ohly gbdZdbo hnb
pbZevguo^hdmf_glh\gZwlhlkq_lg_bf__lkyIjbagZ
gb_ wlhc j_Zevghklb fh`_l ihkem`blv ^ey g_dhlhjuo
khljm^gbdh\ijZ\hhojZgbl_evguohj]Zgh\hijZ\^Zgb_f
^ey g_ijbgylby dZdboeb[h f_j gZijZ\e_gguo ijhlb\
kh[kl\_ggbdh\ dZiblZeZ g_ba\_klgh]h ijhbkoh`^_gby
G_ bf_y ^hklZlhqguo kj_^kl\ b d\Zebnbpbjh\Zgguo
khljm^gbdh\ kljmdlmju hojZgu ihjy^dZ b xklbpbb \
lhfqbke_fbebpbybkm^_[gu_hj]Zguihkhh[s_gbyf
g_ jZkiheZ]Zxl ^Z`_ fbgbfmfhf nmgdpbhgZevguo j_
kmjkh\<k\yabkwlbfkms_kl\m_lfg_gb_qlheh]bqgh
[ueh [u g_ kha^Z\Zlv ^hihegbl_evgu_ gZ]jmadb gZ
h]jZgbq_ggu_ j_kmjku kbkl_fu iulZykv gZqZlv [hjv
[maZjZg__h[j_q_ggmxgZijh\Ze
< F_`^mgZjh^gu_Zki_dlu
^ZgghcZj]mf_glZpbb
Ihfbfh fgh]hqbke_gguo \gmlj_ggbo ijh[e_f
jZ[hlZ ke_^h\Zl_e_c \ Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb hkeh`
gy_lky lZd`_ f_`^mgZjh^guf oZjZdl_jhf hlfu\Zgby
^_g_] Wdhghfbq_kdb_ ljm^ghklb b h]jZgbq_gguc
[x^`_l\ugm`^Zxljhkkbckdb_\eZklbijb^Z\Zlvi_j
\hhq_j_^gh_ agZq_gb_ ijh[e_f_ \ha\jZs_gby Zdlb\h\
Ihkdhevdm ih\b^bfhfm [hevr_ j_kmjkh\ moh^bl ba
Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb q_f \ g__ ihklmiZ_l \ p_glj_
\gbfZgby gZoh^blky ijh[e_fZ \ha\jZs_gby Zdlb\h\
jZaf_s_gguo \ ^jm]bo kljZgZo Wlh hagZqZ_l g_h[oh
^bfhklv ieh^hl\hjgh]h khljm^gbq_kl\Z jy^Z kljZg
dhlhjh_ aZqZklmxhlkmlkl\m_l Mki_o \ jZkke_^h\Zgbb
^_e k\yaZgguo k hlfu\Zgb_f ^_g_] b m]heh\ghf ij_
ke_^h\Zgbb \bgh\guo ^hklb]Z_lky \ j_amevlZl_ kh]eZ
kh\Zgguo ^_ckl\bc k ijZ\hhojZgbl_evgufb hj]ZgZfb
^jm]bokljZgghlZdb_^_eZkhklZ\eyxlkdhj__g_ijZ
\behZbkdexq_gb_
Jhkkbckdb_ ke_^h\Zl_eb b ijhdmjhju aZy\eyxl
qlh h[uqgh bf g_ m^Z_lky mklZgh\blv f_klhgZoh`^_
gb_ b dhgnbkdh\Zlv ^hoh^u hl ij_klmighc ^_yl_evgh
klbihkdhevdmhgbgZoh^ylkyaZij_^_eZfbJhkkbckdhc
N_^_jZpbb KZfb ij_klmigbdb lZd`_ aZqZklmx gZoh
^ylky\g_ij_^_eh\jhkkbckdhcxjbk^bdpbb JZaebqby
\ aZdhgh^Zl_evkl\_ jZaebqguo xjbk^bdpbc aZljm^gy
xlZbgh]^Zb\hh[s_g_iha\heyxlhkm^blvij_klmi
gbdh\ beb ^Z`_ gZqZlv jZkke_^h\Zgb_ ;he__ lh]h
ij_^klZ\bl_eb jhkkbckdbo ijZ\hhojZgbl_evguo hj]Z
gh\ ml\_j`^Zxl qlh g_ijZ\bevgh_ ij_^klZ\e_gb_ ]h
km^Zjkl\_gguohj]Zgh\aZjm[_`guokljZghiheblbq_
kdbo j_Zebyo Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb qZklh b]jZ_l gZ
jmdm ij_klmigbdZf dhlhjuf m^Z_lky ^h[b\Zlvky hl
wlbohj]Zgh\j_r_gbch[hldZa_\bowdkljZ^bpbbbeb
h ij_^hklZ\e_gbb bf iheblbq_kdhc aZsblu >Z`_ \
kemqZyo dh]^Z ij_klmigbdb \ dhgp_ dhgph\ [u\Zxl
hkm`^_gu Z Zdlb\u dhgnbkdh\Zgu ijb kh^_ckl\bb
jhkkbckdbo ijZ\hhojZgbl_evguo hj]Zgh\ \ Jhkkbc
kdmx N_^_jZpbx dhgnbkdh\Zggu_ Zdlb\u lZd b g_
\ha\jZsZxlky Hgb hklZxlky \ l_o kljZgZo ]^_ [ueb
dhgnbkdh\Zgu<wlhfhlghr_gbbJhkkbckdZyN_^_jZ
pbyg_mgbdZevgZ<p_ehfdZdhlf_qZ_lR_eebkms_
kl\mxsZyijZ\h\ZyiheblbdZkem`blh[h]Zs_gbxjZa
\bluo kljZg dhlhju_ m`_ ba\e_deb \u]h^m ba g_aZ
dhggh ihemq_ggh]h dZiblZeZ \ lh \j_fy dZd jZa\b
\Zxsbfky kljZgZf b kljZgZf k i_j_oh^ghc wdhghfb
dhc \ha\jZs_gb_ wlbo kj_^kl\ hkljh g_h[oh^bfh ^ey
^hklb`_gbymklhcqb\h]hjZa\blby
G_\hafh`ghklv \ha\jZs_gby Zdlb\h\ gZjy^m k
hlkmlkl\b_f \ jhkkbckdhc kbkl_f_ ijZ\hkm^by g_h[
oh^bfhc ijZ\h\hc [Zau ^ey \u^\b`_gby \_kdh]h
h[hkgh\Zgby h[\bg_gby b hkm`^_gby ij_klmigbdh\
kem`bl ^ey jhkkbckdbo \eZkl_c kbevg_crbf klbfm
ehf ^ey ihbkdh\ bguo iml_c ^hklb`_gby wlhc p_eb
H[km`^Z_lky fgh]h ij_^eh`_gbc b \u^\b]Z_lky g_
fZeh Zj]mf_glh\ \ ihevam aZdexq_gby kh]eZr_gbc k
ih^haj_\Z_fufb \ hlfu\Zgbb ^_g_] Hl ih^haj_\Z_
fuo h`b^Z_lky qlh \ hl\_l gZ h[_sZgb_ \eZkl_c g_
ijh\h^blvijhlb\ gbo m]heh\gh]h jZkke_^h\Zgby hgb
hl^Z^ml ijZ\bl_evkl\m qZklv hlfuluo kj_^kl\ Bf
fh]ml lZd`_ ij_^eh`blv bg\_klbjh\Zlv kj_^kl\Z \
Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb gZijbf_j \ ij_^ijbylby
dhlhju_ h[_ki_qZl ^hihegbl_evgmx aZgylhklv ^ey
[hevrh]hqbkeZjhkkbyg
B^_y \eb\Zgby g_e_]Zevguo ^_g_] \ e_]Zevgmx
wdhghfbdm±g_jhkkbckdh_bah[j_l_gb_Fgh]b_kljZ
gu m`_ iulZebkv bkihevah\Zlv jZaebqgu_ kljZl_]bb
JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
bkihevah\Zgby^_g_]gZ`bluoij_klmigufiml_f^ey
aZiheg_gbyijhj_ok\hbo]hkm^Zjkl\_gguo[x^`_lh\b
bg\_klbpbhgguonhg^h\ Wlh ^_eZehkv iml_f \uimkdZ
p_gguo[mfZ]kmdZaZgb_fbeb[_amdZaZgby\eZ^_evp_\
gZebqghklb h[ty\e_gby gZeh]h\uo Zfgbklbc beb Zf
gbklbb \ hlghr_gbb [_`Z\rbo ba kljZgu dZiblZ
eh\BkiZgby\]h^m\p_eyoihdjulby^_nbpblZ
\uimklbeZq_jgu_dZagZq_ckdb_\_dk_eyBg^byIZ
dbklZg b RjbEZgdZ \ ihke_^gb_ ^_kylbe_lby \uimk
lbeb g_kdhevdh \ZjbZglh\ p_gguo [mfZ] h[sbf ^ey
dhlhjuo [ueh h^gh mkeh\b_ ± gbdZdbo \hijhkh\ h[
bklhqgbd_ ijhbkoh`^_gby kj_^kl\;he__ lh]h IZdb
klZg g_ lhevdh g_ aZ^Z\Ze \hijhkh\ h ijhbkoh`^_gbb
^_g_] gh h[_sZe aZdjulv \k_ ^_eZ k\yaZggu_ k mdeh
g_gb_f hl mieZlu gZeh]h\ \ hlghr_gbb ebp b dhfiZ
gbc ijbh[j_lZxsbo wlb p_ggu_ [mfZ]b GZeh]h\u_
Zfgbklbbh[ty\eyebkv\:\kljbb:j]_glbg_;_ev]bb
Bg^bbBjeZg^bbBlZebb Dhemf[bb IZgZf_ gZ Nb
ebiibgZo NjZgpbb b Wd\Z^hj_ IhkljZ^Z\ hl [_]kl\Z
ihqlb fej^ ^heeZjh\ aZ i_jbh^ ± ]h^h\
F_dkbdZ \ ]h^m h[ty\beZ qlh __ ]jZ`^Zg_ fh]ml
ihemqblv ihegmx Zfgbklbx \uieZlb\ fZdkbfZevguc
ijhp_glguc gZeh] k ijhp_glh\ b ^b\b^_g^h\ ihem
q_gguo aZ i_jbh^ \ l_q_gb_ dhlhjh]h ^_gv]b gZoh^b
ebkvaZjm[_`hf
J_amevlZlulZdhciheblbdb[uebg_h^ghagZqgu
bkm^yihkhh[s_gbyfihke_^mxsbcijblhdkj_^kl\
[ue g_agZqbl_evguf H^gZdh lZdZy iheblbdZ hdZaZ
eZkv m^Zqguf kj_^kl\hf ^ey hlfu\Zgby ^_g_] ;he__
lh]h\g_dhlhjuokemqZyohgZ^Z`_ih[m`^ZeZex^_c
moh^blv \ ih^ihevgmx wdhghfbdm LZdb_ f_ju g_
lhevdhij_^eZ]Zebe_]ZebaZpbxijhrehcij_klmighc
b ^jm]hc g_aZdhgghc ^_yl_evghklb gh b \hagZ]jZ`
^_gb_ aZ ihemq_ggu_ \ j_amevlZl_ __ ^hoh^u LZdbf
h[jZahf ]eZ\gZy hiZkghklv iheblbdb e_]ZebaZpbb
aZdexqZ_lky\lhfqlhhgZfh`_l_s_[he__ aZlmr_
\ZlvjZaebqb_f_`^ml_fqlhaZdhgghbl_fqlhg_
aZdhgghLZdZyiheblbdZfh`_lbf_lv^Ze_dhb^msb_
b iZ]m[gu_ ihke_^kl\by Ohly hgZ fh`_l ijbg_klb
djZldh\j_f_ggu_ nbgZgkh\u_ \u]h^u wlZ iheblbdZ
kihkh[gZ ihjh`^Zlv _s_ [yevrb_ ijh[e_fu \ [m^m
s_fHgZfh`_lkihkh[kl\h\Zlvkha^ZgbxZlfhkn_ju
l_jibfhklb ih hlghr_gbx d ij_klmighklb kh^_ckl
\h\Zlv ^Zevg_cr_fm jZkdhem \ h[s_kl\_ b jZkijh
kljZg_gbx [he__ obsgbq_kdbo nhjf wdhghfbq_kdhc
^_yl_evghklb LZdbf h[jZahf f_`^mgZjh^guc hiul
e_]ZebaZpbb b Zfgbklbb mdZau\Z_l qlh ij_`^_ q_f
ijbgbfZlv j_r_gb_ h e_]ZebaZpbb bbeb Zfgbklbb
g_h[oh^bf lsZl_evguc ZgZeba jZaebqguo iheblbq_
kdboZevl_jgZlb\ JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
=eZ\Z,;
;hjv[Zkhlfu\Zgb_f^_g_]
JZajZ[hldZ ^_ckl\_ggh]h aZdhgh^Zl_evkl\Z gZ
ijZ\e_ggh]h ijhlb\ hlfu\Zgby ^_g_] b^_l f_^e_ggh
K ]h^Z [ueh ih^]hlh\e_gh g_kdhevdh \ZjbZglh\
N_^_jZevgh]h aZdhgZ H [hjv[_ k hlfu\Zgb_f ^_g_]
< bxg_ ]h^Z jhkkbckdbc iZjeZf_gl ^Z`_ ijbgye
wlb aZdhgu gh iha`_ ij_ab^_gl Jhkkbb gZeh`be gZ
gbo\_lhJy^^jm]boaZdhgh\gZijZ\e_gguogZ[hjv[m
k jZkijhkljZg_gb_f wdhghfbq_kdbo ij_klmie_gbc lZ
dbodZddhjjmipbyh[km`^ZekyghlZdbg_[ueijb
gyl =hkm^Zjkl\_gghc ^mfhc ± gb`g_c iZeZlhc jhk
kbckdh]h iZjeZf_glZ >_imlZlu ^bkdmlbjh\Zeb b \u
kdZau\Zeb \hajZ`_gby g_ lhevdh ijhlb\ dhgdj_lguo
Zki_dlh\ wlbo aZdhghijh_dlh\ gh b ih ih\h^m kn_ju
bo^_ckl\bybijZdlbq_kdh]hijbf_g_gby
GZb[he__ ]hjyqb_ kihju \ k\yab k aZdhghijh_d
lZfb ih [hjv[_ k hlfu\Zgb_f ^_g_] dbi_eb \hdjm]
lhedh\Zgby l_jfbgZ g_aZdhgguc ^hoh^ Ijhlb\gbdb
l_jfbgZ g_aZdhgguc ml\_j`^Zeb ihfbfh ijhq_]h
qlh hg ijhlb\hj_qbl iheh`_gbyf _\jhi_ckdhc Dhg
\_gpbb h[ hlfu\Zgbb ihbkd_ Zj_kl_ b dhgnbkdZpbb
^hoh^h\ hl ij_klmighc ^_yl_evghklb \ dhlhjhc ^ey
p_e_c ^Zgghc dhg\_gpbb ^hoh^u hij_^_eyxlky dZd
wdhghfbq_kdZy\u]h^Zba\e_dZ_fZybam]heh\guoijZ
\hgZjmr_gbcH^gZdh\ihke_^g__\j_fyfgh]b_\Jhk
kbckdhc N_^_jZpbb ml\_j`^Zxl qlh \hijhk khklhbl
lhevdh\i_j_\h^_keh\Zg_aZdhggucdhlhjucfh`gh
i_j_\_klb gZ Zg]ebckdbc dZd FULPLQDO ij_klmiguc
Wlhl kihj dZkZ_lky g_ ijhklh gZ^e_`Zs_]h xjb^bq_
kdh]h l_jfbgZ Hg hljZ`Z_l k_jv_agmx ^be_ffm \ha
gbdrmx \ j_amevlZl_ j_nhjf ijh\h^b\rboky \ ih
ke_^g__\j_fy\JhkkbckdhcN_^_jZpbbIjbgZb[he__
rbjhdhflhedh\Zgbbkhhl\_lkl\mxsbo\b^h\^hoh^h\
b ^_yl_evghklb aZdhg fh`_l aZljhgmlv fgh]bo \ Jhk
kbckdhc N_^_jZpbb Hg kdZ`_lky gZ f_edbo ijZ\hgZ
jmrbl_eyokh\_jrZxsbofZobgZpbbkgZeh]ZfbjZ^b
g_kdhevdbo khl_g jm[e_c Gh ijb _]h ihke_^h\Zl_ev
ghf ijbf_g_gbb k ijb^Zgb_f _fm h[jZlghc kbeu hg
fh`_l[ulvbkihevah\Zgijhlb\fgh]bo ^jm]bo \ lhf
qbke_ ijhlb\ ij_^klZ\bl_e_c iheblbq_kdhc weblu
ba\e_dZ\rbo\u]h^mbawdhghfbq_kdboj_nhjf\hkh
[_gghklbijb\ZlbaZpbb
Ml\_j`^Z_lky lZd`_ qlh wlh aZdhgh^Zl_evkl\h
y\blky gZjmr_gb_f ijZ\ q_eh\_dZ b iheh`_gbc Dhg
klblmpbb Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb hojZgyxsbo lZcgm
ebqguo ^Zgguo b k\h[h^m wdhghfbq_kdhc ^_yl_evgh
klb Iheh`_gby aZdhghijh_dlZ ij_^ibku\Zxl \_^_gb_
hlq_lghklbbdhgljhey aZ nbgZgkh\ufb k^_edZfb dZd
aZdhggufb lZd b g_aZdhggufb b jZkdjulb_ g_dhlh
juo ebqguo ^Zgguo jZa]eZr_gb_ dhlhjuo [_a kh]eZ
kby^Zggh]hebpZaZij_s_ghDhgklblmpb_c;he__lh]h
\khhl\_lkl\bbkaZdhghijh_dlhfklhjhguk^_edb h[y
aZgu dhgljhebjh\Zlv b hp_gb\Zlv ^_ckl\bl_evghklv
hi_jZpbc gZijbf_j \ p_eyo hij_^_e_gby ^_ckl\b
l_evghklb k^_ehd b khh[sZlv h l_o k^_edZo \ jZfdZo
dhlhjuo kh\_jrZxlky g_^_ckl\bl_evgu_ hi_jZpbb
Ihwlhfm ml\_j`^Z_lky ^Ze__ wlb klhjhgu [m^ml hkm
s_kl\eylv nmgdpbb ijZ\hhojZgbl_evghc kbkl_fu qlh
hiylvlZdb ijhlb\hj_qbl Dhgklblmpbb Ohly Zj]mf_g
lulZdh]hjh^Z[he__oZjZdl_jgu^eygZqZevgh]hwlZiZ
i_j_oh^gh]h i_jbh^Z \ mkh\_jr_gkl\h\Zgghf \b^_
hgb ijh^he`Zxl b k_]h^gy bkihevah\Zlvky ijhlb\gb
dZfbaZdhgh^Zl_evkl\ZgZijZ\e_ggh]hgZ[hjv[mkhl
fu\Zgb_f ^_g_] < wlbo Zj]mf_glZo keurblky hla\md
gZkljh_gbc \j_f_g ^_fhdjZlbq_kdbo j_nhjf gZqZeZ
o ]h^h\ dh]^Z \ aZdhgh^Zl_evkl\_ ijhba\h^bebkv
rbjhdb_ baf_g_gby gZijZ\e_ggu_ gZ h[_ki_q_gb_
ijZ\ q_eh\_dZ b ml\_j`^_gb_ ^_fhdjZlbq_kdbo ijbg
pbih\
H^bg ba ihke_^gbo \ZjbZglh\ aZdhghijh_dlZ ih
[hjv[_khlfu\Zgb_f^_g_]ih^]hlh\e_gguc:^fbgb
kljZpb_cIj_ab^_glZm`_ih^\_j]kyrbjhdhcdjblbd_
b l_i_jv ih \k_c \_jhylghklb \ hkgh\m gh\h]h aZdh
ghijh_dlZdhlhjuc^he`_g[ulv\ug_k_ggZh[km`^_
gb_ iZjeZf_glZ [m^_l iheh`_g \ZjbZgl ijbgyluc
iZjeZf_glhf \ ]h^m K_]h^gy dh]^Z \u^\bgmlu
gh\u_ bgbpbZlb\u gZijZ\e_ggu_ gZ mdj_ie_gb_ ijZ
\hhojZgbl_evguo nmgdpbc ]hkm^Zjkl\Z b mkbe_gb_
dhgljhey kh klhjhgu p_gljZevgh]h ijZ\bl_evkl\Z
fgh]b_\JhkkbckdhcN_^_jZpbbgZ^_xlkygZijbgylb_
khhl\_lkl\mxsboaZdhgh\<jmke_wlhcl_g^_gpbbjy^
\_^msbo iheblbdh\ \ bo qbke_ :e_dkZg^j =mjh\
ij_^k_^Zl_ev iZjeZf_glkdh]h Dhfbl_lZ ih [_ahiZk
JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
ghklb jZajZ[hlZ\r_]h aZdhghijh_dl ij_^iheZ]Zeb
qlh aZdhghijh_dl ijhc^_l h[km`^_gb_ b [m^_l ijbgyl
\ ]h^m H^gZdh ihkdhevdm aZdhgh^Zl_evkl\h ih
hlfu\Zgbx ^_g_] g_ jZkkfZljb\Z_lky dZd ijbhjbl_l
gh_ihkjZ\g_gbxk^jm]bfbaZdhghijh_dlZfbgZijb
f_j ih gZeh]hh[eh`_gbx wlb h`b^Zgby hdZaZebkv
baebrg_hilbfbklbqgufb
F_`^m l_f ihgylb_ ij_klmie_gby khklhys_]h \
hlfu\Zgbb ^_g_] \ Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb m`_ kms_
kl\m_l < M]heh\ghf dh^_dk_ Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb
ijbgylhf \ ]h^m _klv ]eZ\Z h[ wdhghfbq_kdbo
ij_klmie_gbyo ]eZ\Z kh^_j`ZsZy ljb^pZlv h^gm
klZlvx ij_^mkfZljb\Zxsmx jZaebqgu_ \b^u gZdZaZ
gby aZ rbjhdbc djm] ijZ\hgZjmr_gbc < KlZlv_
]eZ\uhe_]ZebaZpbbhlfu\Zgbb^_g_`guokj_^kl\
b ^jm]h]h bfms_kl\Z ijbh[j_l_gguo g_aZdhgguf im
l_f ij_^mkfZljb\Z_lky gZdZaZgb_ ^h q_luj_o e_l eb
r_gbyk\h[h^uaZnbgZgkh\u_hi_jZpbbk^_g_`gufb
kj_^kl\Zfbb^jm]bfbfms_kl\hfhdhlhjuoba\_klgh
qlh hgb [ueb ijbh[j_l_gu g_aZdhgguf iml_f < klZ
lv_ki_pbZevghg_h]h\Zjb\Z_lkyqlh^_gv]bbbfms_
kl\h^he`guij_^klZ\eylvkh[hc^hoh^hlij_klmighc
^_yl_evghklbZmdZau\Z_lkylhevdhqlhwlhfh]ml[ulv
ex[u_ g_aZdhggh ihemq_ggu_ Zdlb\u ?keb ijZ\hgZjm
r_gb_ kh\_jr_gh ]jmiihc ebp beb kh\_jrZehkv g_h^
ghdjZlgh hgh kqblZ_lky ly`dbf ij_klmie_gb_f aZ dh
lhjh_fh`_l[ulvgZagZq_gh[he__kmjh\h_gZdZaZgb_
>ZggZy klZlvy M]heh\gh]h dh^_dkZ ijbf_gy_lky
g_lhevdhhq_gvj_^dhghijbwlhfbg_ihke_^h\Zl_ev
gh qlh hljZ`Z_l g_ lhevdh k_]h^gyrgb_ wdhghfbq_
kdb_ b iheblbq_kdb_ j_Zebb gh b g_hij_^_e_gghklv
wlh]h iheh`_gby b kihju hlghkbl_evgh _]h ijbf_g_
gbyIhe_fbdZkj_^bijZdlbdh\b^_l\hdjm]\hafh`gh
klb hkm`^_gby ij_klmigbdZ \ kemqZ_ _keb g_ [ue \u
g_k_gh[\bgbl_evgucijb]h\hjihi_j\bqghfmij_klm
ie_gbx\j_amevlZl_dhlhjh]h[uebihemq_guZdlb\u
>h gZklhys_]h \j_f_gb ebpZ jZg__ hkm`^_ggu_ aZ
i_j\bqgh_ ij_klmie_gb_ hkm`^Zebkv b aZ hlfu\Zgb_
^_g_] >jm]b_ mqZklgbdb ihe_fbdb \hajZ`Zy ijhlb\
wlh]h ^h\h^Z ml\_j`^Zxl qlh h^gh b lh `_ ebph g_
fh`_l[ulvhkm`^_ghaZh[Z±i_j\bqgh_b\lhjbqgh_
hlfu\Zgb_ ^_g_] ± ij_klmie_gby B \ wlhf kemqZ_
kgh\Z g_l kh]eZkby ih ih\h^m l_jfbgZ g_aZdhgguc
^hoh^ ?keb h^gb jhkkbckdb_ ki_pbZebklu m[_`^_gu
qlh ^Zggh_ iheh`_gb_ hlghkblky lhevdh d ^hoh^Zf hl
ij_klmighc ^_yl_evghklb lh ^jm]b_ jZkijhkljZgyxl
_]h gZ ^hoh^u hl rbjhdh]h djm]Z ijZ\hgZjmr_gbc
ij_^mkfhlj_gguo Z^fbgbkljZlb\guf b gZeh]h\uf
dh^_dkZfb
Hijhkuijh\_^_ggu_GZmqghbkke_^h\Zl_evkdbf
bgklblmlhfFbgbkl_jkl\Z\gmlj_ggbo^_eJhkkbckdhc
N_^_jZpbb <GBB F<> kj_^b khljm^gbdh\ ijZ\hho
jZgbl_evguo hj]Zgh\ \uy\beb g_ihgbfZgb_ bfb ijh
p_kkZ hlfu\Zgby ^_g_] b kZfh_ ]eZ\gh_ jZkieu\qZ
lhklv iheh`_gbc M]heh\gh]h dh^_dkZ >_kylv ijh
p_glh\ j_kihg^_glh\ kqblZxl ihdmidm [be_lh\ ^ey
ihk_s_gby l_Zljh\ dbghl_Zljh\ b kihjlb\guo khj_\
gh\Zgbc gZ ^_gv]b ihemq_ggu_ g_aZdhgguf iml_f
qZklvx ijhp_kkZ hlfu\Zgby ^_g_] G_kdhevdh f_gvr_
ijhp_glZ \dexqbeb \ wlhl ijhp_kk hieZlm mkem]
ijhklblmlhd K_fgZ^pZlv ijhp_glh\ j_kihg^_glh\ ih
eZ]Zxl qlh lmjbklbq_kdb_ ih_a^db b ih^Zjdb jh^kl
\_ggbdZflZd`_^he`gud\Zebnbpbjh\ZlvkydZdhlfu
\Zgb_ ^_g_] F_g__ q_l\_jlb hijhr_gguo d\Zebnbpb
jh\Zeb ijbh[j_l_gb_ p_gguo [mfZ] dZd \hafh`guc
ijbagZdhi_jZpbbihhlfu\Zgbx^_g_]Zijhp_glh\
g_ hlg_keb d hlfu\Zgbx ^_g_] ijbh[j_l_gb_ g_^\b
`bfhklb <Z`gh hlf_lblv qlh j_amevlZlu hijhkZ
ijh\_^_ggh]h \ ]h^m g_fgh]bf hlebqZebkv hl
j_amevlZlh\ hijhkZ ]h^Z qlh ]h\hjbl h g_wnn_d
lb\ghklb ih^]hlh\db \ h[eZklb ih\ur_gby bgnhjfb
jh\Zgghklbhij_klmie_gbyok\yaZgguokhlfu\Zgb_f
^_g_]
< p_ehf kha^Z_lky \i_qZle_gb_ qlh wnn_dlb\
ghklvkbkl_fuijZ\hkm^byihdjZcg_cf_j_\hlghr_
gbb wdhghfbq_kdbo ij_klmie_gbc g_ ih\urZ_lky Z
ihgb`Z_lky GZijbf_j \ _ ]h^u kgbabehkv qbkeh
h[\bgbl_evguo ijb]h\hjh\ ih ^_eZf h dhjjmipbb \
]h^m ih h[\bg_gbx \ dhjjmipbb [ueh hkm`^_gh
ij_klmigbdZ Z \ ]h^m ± lhevdh ba gbo
ebrv lj_lv ijb]h\hj_gZ d ebr_gbx k\h[h^u <
]h^mihklZlv_M]heh\gh]hdh^_dkZ[ueh\ha
[m`^_gh \k_]h ^_eh b lhevdh ^_e ^h\_^_gu ^h
km^Z < ]h^m [ueh \ha[m`^_gh ^_eZ ih
fg_gbxwdki_jlh\wlhebrvijhp_glZ\k_okemqZ_\
wdhghfbq_kdboij_klmie_gbcZ\]h^m±^_e
ba dhlhjuo ^h\_^_gh ^h km^Z b hkm`^_gu \k_]h
ij_klmigbdZ FbgbfZevgh_ ijbf_g_gb_ iheh`_gbc
M]heh\gh]h dh^_dkZ ih [hjv[_ k hlfu\Zgb_f ^_g_]
hlqZklb h[tykgy_lky jZaebqbyfb \ bo lhedh\Zgbb
]eZ\guf h[jZahf hlghkbl_evgh bklhqgbdh\ ^hoh
^h\Ghg_ihke_^h\Zl_evghklv\ijZdlbd_boijbf_
g_gby dZkZ_lky g_ lhevdh jZaebqbc \ hij_^_e_gbb ih
gylby g_aZdhggh ihemq_ggu_ ^_g_`gu_ kj_^kl\Z b
bfms_kl\hghb\hij_^_e_gbblh]hdh]hfh`ghkqb
lZlv ij_klmigbdhf GZijbf_j khh[sZehkv h ^_e_ ih
dhlhjhfm h[\bgy_fhfm g_ [ueh ij_^ty\e_gh h[\bg_
gb_ \ kh\_jr_gbb ij_klmie_gby ih klZlv_ h[ hlfu\Z
gbb ^_g_] ihkdhevdm hg m`_ [ue h[\bg_g \ kh\_jr_
gbb ij_klmie_gby \ p_eyo ijbh[j_l_gby Zdlb\h\ dh
lhju_iha`_[uebhlfulu
JZaju\ f_`^m j_Zevguf iheh`_gb_f ^_e \ Jhk
kbckdhcN_^_jZpbbbj_amevlZlZfbf_jijbgbfZ_fuo
ijZ\hhojZgbl_evgufb hj]ZgZfb q_ldh hljZ`Z_lky
\khklZ\_ ijZ\hgZjmrbl_e_c b oZjZdl_j_ ij_klmie_
JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
gbc < ]h^m h[\bg_gby \ hlfu\Zgbb ^_g_] [ueb
ij_^ty\e_gu\k_]hebpZfbadhlhjuo[uebjZ
[hqbfb ± ]hkm^Zjkl\_ggufb kem`Zsbfb ±
ij_^ijbgbfZl_eyfb b ± [_ajZ[hlgufb Ijb [eb
`Zcr_f jZkkfhlj_gbb gZijZrb\Z_lky \u\h^ qlh kh
\_jr_ggu_ bfb ij_klmie_gby ± wlh [hevr_c qZklvx
f_edb_ ijZ\hgZjmr_gby dhlhju_ \jy^ eb fh`gh d\Z
ebnbpbjh\ZlvdZdhlfu\Zgb_^_g_];hevrbgkl\hZgZ
eblbdh\kqblZxlqlhj_ZevgZykblmZpbykhlfu\Zgb_f
^_g_] \ Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb bgZy lZf ^_ckl\mxl
ex^b^jm]h]hlbiZb\[he__rbjhdhffZkrlZ[_Jhk
kbckdb_ki_pbZebkluihijh[e_f_hlfu\Zgby^_g_]ba
ijZ\hhojZgbl_evguohj]Zgh\iheZ]Zxlqlh]eZ\gufb
lhqdZfbijh\_^_gbyhi_jZpbcihe_]ZebaZpbb^hoh^h\
kem`Zl dZabgh b ^bkdhl_db ijhp_glh\ j_kihg^_g
lh\ dhff_jq_kdb_ [Zgdb ijhp_glh\ j_kihg^_g
lh\ j_klhjZgu b [Zju ijhp_glZ j_kihg^_glh\ b
fZ]Zabgu ijhp_gl j_kihg^_glh\ Hl\_qZy gZ \h
ijhkdZd[m^mlihbofg_gbxbkihevah\Zlvky^hoh^u
j_kihg^_glu ij_^iheh`beb qlh lZdb_ ^hoh^u [m^ml
bkihevah\Zlvky^eyhkms_kl\e_gbyij_klmiguoieZgh\
ijhp_glh\ j_kihg^_glh\ ijbh[j_l_gby g_^\b`b
fhklb beb ihdmidm hjm`by b nbgZgkbjh\Zgb_ dhg
dj_lguoij_klmiguo^_ygbcijhp_glZ
G_h[oh^bfhklv j_r_gby keh`ghc ijh[e_fu hl
fu\Zgby ^_g_] dhlhjZy klZgh\blky djmig_cr_c gZ
pbhgZevghc ijh[e_fhc ih[m^beZ jhkkbckdh_ ijZ\b
l_evkl\h mqj_^blv \ ]h^m F_`\_^hfkl\_gguc
p_glj ih [hjv[_ k e_]ZebaZpb_c g_aZdhgguo ^hoh^h\
Hg[uehj]Zgbah\ZgijbFbgbkl_jkl\_\gmlj_ggbo^_e
j_r_gb_f^_\ylbfbgbkl_jkl\b\_^hfkl\\lhfqbke_
Fbgbkl_jkl\Z \gmlj_ggbo ^_e Fbgbkl_jkl\Z nbgZg
kh\ Fbgbkl_jkl\Z ih gZeh]Zf b k[hjZf =hkm^Zjkl
\_ggh]h lZfh`_ggh]h dhfbl_lZ N_^_jZevghc kem`[u
[_ahiZkghklb N_^_jZevghc gZeh]h\hc ihebpbb Dh
fbkkbb\Zexlgh]hdhgljheyFbgbkl_jkl\Zwdhghfbdb
b Fbgbkl_jkl\Z xklbpbb ih kh]eZkh\Zgbx k P_g
ljZevguf [Zgdhf b =_g_jZevghc ijhdmjZlmjhc Jhk
kbckdhc N_^_jZpbb < khklZ\ P_gljZ \oh^yl khljm^
gbdbkhhl\_lkl\mxsbofbgbkl_jkl\b\_^hfkl\<_]h
aZ^Zqb \oh^bl k[hj bgnhjfZpbb h g_aZdhgguo beb
wdhghfbq_kdb jbkdh\Zgguo k^_edZo k ^_g_`gufb
kj_^kl\Zfb b bfms_kl\hf hdZaZgb_ ZgZeblbq_kdhc
ihfhsb\\uy\e_gbbbij_k_q_gbbhi_jZpbcihhlfu
\Zgbx^_g_]dhhj^bgbjh\Zgb_ijh\h^bfuon_^_jZev
gufbkem`[Zfbf_jhijbylbcih[hjv[_khlfu\Zgb_f
^_g_] khljm^gbq_kl\h k aZjm[_`gufb kljmdlmjZfb
hkms_kl\eyxsbfbZgZeh]bqgu_nmgdpbbP_gljgZqZe
jZ[hlZlv\ihegmxkbemlhevdh\]h^mkh^_ckl\my
hi_jZlb\ghcjZ[hl_k\yaZgghck\uy\e_gb_fbjZkke_
^h\Zgb_f^_e\qZklghklb^_elj_[mxsbokh\f_klguo
^_ckl\bc g_kdhevdbo ]hkm^Zjkl\_gguo kljmdlmj Ih
eblbq_kdh_ agZq_gb_ P_gljZ b _]h jhev \ nhjfbjh\Z
gbbkljZl_]bb\wlhch[eZklbih\ukbebkv\k\yabkl_f
qlh _fm ihjmq_gZ jZajZ[hldZ jy^Z kljZl_]bq_kdbo ^h
dmf_glh\bij_^eh`_gbc
Ly`_eZy djbfbgZevgZy kblmZpby ih[m^beZ jhk
kbckdh_ ijZ\bl_evkl\h ijbgylv jy^ f_j ih [hjv[_ k
ij_klmighklvx GZijbf_j \ yg\Zj_ ]h^Z jhkkbc
kdb_ \eZklb ijbgyeb ^\_ ijh]jZffu ih [hjv[_ k ij_
klmighklvx klhbfhklvx [he__ fej^ jm[e_c I_j
\Zy ij_^mkfZljb\Z_l f_ju gZijZ\e_ggu_ gZ [hjv[m k
h[uqgufb\b^Zfbij_klmie_gbclZdbfbdZdm]hgZ\
lhfh[be_c]jZ[_`bebjZa[hcl_jjhjbaf[Zg^blbafb
^j<lhjZyijh]jZffZgZijZ\e_gZgZ[hjv[mkdhjjmi
pb_c b ex[ufb aehmihlj_[e_gbyfb kem`_[guf iheh
`_gb_f jZ^b ebqghc \u]h^u H^gZdh i_kkbfbaf \ hl
ghr_gbb wnn_dlb\ghklb ex[uo f_j ijZ\bl_evkl\Z ih
[hjv[_ k dhjjmipb_c b ij_klmighklvx jZkijhkljZg_g
gZklhevdh rbjhdh qlh fgh]b_ \ Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZ
pbb iheZ]Zxl qlh gZklmie_gb_ ij_ab^_glZ <ImlbgZ
gZ dhjjmipbx b ij_klmighklv fh`_l ij_\jZlblvky \
[hjv[m f_`^m heb]ZjoZfb klj_fysbfbky mgbqlh`blv
dhgdmj_glh\
JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
=eZ\ZO
AZdexq_gb_
Hlfu\Zgb_ ^_g_] \ Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb l_kgh
i_j_ie_l_gh k ijhbkoh^ysbfb \ kljZg_ rbjhdh
fZkrlZ[gufb iheblbq_kdbfb wdhghfbq_kdbfb b
khpbZevgufb ijhp_kkZfb b klZeh g_hlt_fe_fhc q_j
lhckh\j_f_ggh]hjhkkbckdh]hdZiblZebafZFZkrlZ
[u hlfu\Zgby ^_g_] j_adh \hajhkeb \ i_jbh^ hkms_
kl\e_gbyjughqguoj_nhjf\lhfqbke_nbgZgkh\hc
eb[_jZebaZpbb ijb\ZlbaZpbb b ^jm]bo f_jhijbylbc
IjZdlbdZ hlfu\Zgby ^_g_] \hagbdeZ \ Jhkkbckdhc
N_^_jZpbb\ke_^aZjZajmr_gb_fij_`gbo]hkm^Zjkl
\_gguobgklblmlh\\aZf_gdhlhjuo\hfgh]bokemqZ
yogbq_]hg_[uehkha^ZghHgZkms_kl\m_l[eZ]h^Zjy
hq_\b^ghfm hkeZ[e_gbx ]hkm^Zjkl\Z b _]h ijZ\hho
jZgbl_evguo kljmdlmj b k\yaZgZ k jhklhf [_ajZ[hlb
pu b dhehkkZevghc ih fZkrlZ[Zf l_g_\hc wdhghfb
dhcKj_^bhkgh\guoijbqbgkms_kl\h\Zgbyl_g_\h]h
dZiblZeZ \ Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb b _]h [_]kl\Z ba
kljZgu fh`gh gZa\Zlv wdhghfbq_kdmx g_klZ[bev
ghklv b ij_klmighklv IjZdlbdZ hlfu\Zgby ^_g_]
ijbh[j_eZ f_`^mgZjh^guc fZkrlZ[ b klZeZ ijh[e_
fhc g_ lhevdh ^ey Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb gh b ^ey
fbjh\h]hkhh[s_kl\Z
Wnn_dlb\gu_ f_ju ih [hjv[_ k hlfu\Zgb_f ^_
g_] \ Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb lj_[mxl jZkkfhlj_gby
\k_]h ijhp_kkZ j_nhjf \ qZklghklb g_h[oh^bfhklv
gZjZsb\Zgby ihl_gpbZeZ j_]mebjmxsbo b bgklblm
pbhgZevguo kljmdlmj ^ey nmgdpbhgbjmxsbo jugdh\
Kx^Z \oh^bl kh\_jr_gkl\h\Zgb_ gZ^ahjZ aZ [Zgdh\
kdhc ^_yl_evghklvx dhlhjuc \ [yevr_c kl_i_gb ^he
`_g khijy]Zlvky k mkbebyfb ijZ\hhojZgbl_evguo hj
]Zgh\DhgljhevaZ^_yl_evghklvx[Zgdh\\Jhkkbckdhc
N_^_jZpbbg_ ^he`_g h]jZgbqb\Zlvky ljZ^bpbhggufb
f_lh^Zfb dhlhju_ ijbf_gyxlky \ p_eyo h[_ki_q_gby
wdhghfbq_kdhc p_e_khh[jZaghklb nbgZgkh\uo hi_jZ
pbc ihkdhevdm j_rZxs__ agZq_gb_ ijbh[j_eh h[t_
^bg_gb_ mkbebc ih bkdhj_g_gbx g_aZdhgghc b ij_
klmighc^_yl_evghklb\[Zgdh\kdhfk_dlhj_
< k_]h^gyrg_c Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb ljm^gh
h`b^Zlv kdhjh]h ijbgylby f_j b kdhjuo j_amevlZlh\
\[hjv[_khlfu\Zgb_f^_g_]Wlh^ebl_evgucijhp_kk
lj_[mxsbc kh]eZkh\Zgguo ^_ckl\bc gZ gZpbhgZevghf
bf_`^mgZjh^ghfmjh\gyo;hjv[Zkhlfu\Zgb_f^_g_]
bwdhghfbq_kdbfbij_klmie_gbyfb\JhkkbckdhcN_^_
jZpbbhagZqZ_lj_r_gb_rbjhdh]hdhfie_dkZijh[e_f
<ex[uokdhevdhgb[m^vk_jv_aguoihiuldZoijh\_klb
lsZl_evgucZgZebadjbfbgZevghckblmZpbbkp_evx__
bkijZ\e_gby g_ba[_`gh \kieu\Z_l ^be_ffZ k\yaZggZy
k ijb\ZlbaZpb_c HgZ ij_^iheZ]Z_l i_j_hkfuke_gb_ b
i_j_kfhlj blh]h\ ijhp_kkZ ijb\ZlbaZpbb ± \hijhk
\_kvfZ qm\kl\bl_evguc b hiZkguc \ iheblbq_kdhf b
wdhghfbq_kdhf hlghr_gbb <uklmie_gb_ ijhlb\ fh
]ms_kl\_gguo fZ]gZlh\ ihij_`g_fm jbkdm_l aZdhg
qblvky gbq_f Ba\_klgh qlh baf_g_gb_ fure_gby ex
^_c gZqZ\rbo ijbgbfZlv [_aaZdhgb_ l_g_\mx wdhgh
fbdmbmdehg_gb_hlgZeh]h\dZdqZklvh[jZaZ`bagb±
ijhp_kk ^ebl_evguc b ihkl_i_gguc I_j_^ ebphf wdh
ghfbq_kdbo ly]hl jhkkbyg_ \hkijbbfqb\u d iheblbq_
kdbf f_jZf h[_sZxsbf g_f_^e_ggu_ nbgZgkh\u_
\u]h^u G_kfhljy gZ hiZkghklb k\yaZggu_ k ij_^eh
`_gb_f h[ Zfgbklbb bbeb e_]ZebaZpbb fgh]bo ]jZ`
^Zg Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb ijb\e_dZxl lZdb_ _]h Zk
i_dludZd\hafh`ghklv[ukljh]h\ha\jZs_gbyg_dhlh
juoZdlb\h\[_a`_klhdboiheblbq_kdboko\Zlhdbwdh
ghfbq_kdbo kiZ^h\ IheblbdZ e_]ZebaZpbb fh`_l kih
kh[kl\h\Zlv mkm]m[e_gbx djbfbgZevghc kblmZpbb b
^Zevg_cr_fm aZly]b\Zgbx ijbgylby ^_ckl\_gguo f_j
ih[hjv[_khlfu\Zgb_f^_g_]
>hg_^Z\g_]h\j_f_gbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]\Jhkkbc
kdhcN_^_jZpbbij_^klZ\eyehkh[hcijh[e_fmk\yaZg
gmxk^hoh^Zfbhlij_klmiguo^_ygbc\i_j\mxhq_
j_^v hl wdhghfbq_kdbo ij_klmie_gbc beb hl ohayckl
\_gguo b nbgZgkh\uo hi_jZpbc dhlhju_ g_ fh]ml
[ulv ijyfh d\Zebnbpbjh\Zgu dZd ij_klmigu_ Fbe
ebhgu jhkkbyg kqblZxl qlh \ _ ]h^u ijhbkoh^beh
fZkkh\h_ [_agZdZaZggh_ jZa\hjh\u\Zgb_ ]hkm^Zjkl
\_gguoZdlb\h\bbokhdjulb_aZjm[_`hfWlhfZkkh
\h_ \hjh\kl\h b khdjulb_ Zdlb\h\ ijb\e_dZ_l \gbfZ
gb_ d k_]h^gyrg_c kblmZpbb b \^hogh\ey_l gZ ijbau
\udijbgylbx^_ckl\_gguof_jJhkkbckdh_h[s_kl\h
iheghklvx jZa^_ey_l b^_x h lhf qlh ij_klmigbdb
^he`gu [ulv ihcfZgu b khhl\_lkl\mxsbf h[jZahf
JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
gZdZaZgu WlZ b^_y dZ`_lky bf _s_ [he__ ijb\e_dZ
l_evghc_kebhgZm\yaZgZk\hafh`ghklvxbkihevah\Z
gby dhgnbkdh\Zgguo kj_^kl\ gZ j_r_gb_ khpbZevguo
ijh[e_f < k\yab k jhklhf [_^ghklb b [_ajZ[hlbpu
aZ^ZqZihemq_gbyijyfuonbgZgkh\uo\u]h^\j_amev
lZl_ [hjv[u k hlfu\Zgb_f ^_g_] ijbh[j_lZ_l \k_
[yevrmx ZdlmZevghklv H`b^Z_lky qlh ihemq_ggu_
lZdbf iml_f kj_^kl\Z ^he`gu ijh^_fhgkljbjh\Zlv
mki_ob ^hklb]gmlu_ ijZ\hhojZgbl_evgufb hj]ZgZfb
b ihfhqv \ j_r_gbb hkljuo khpbZevguo ijh[e_f \
lhfqbke_\khdjZs_gbbfZkrlZ[h\[_^ghklbJhkkbc
kdb_ \eZklb h[jZsZxlky k ijbau\Zfb d f_`^mgZjh^
ghfm khh[s_kl\m h[ hdZaZgbb kh^_ckl\by \ \ha\jZs_
gbb Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb Zdlb\h\ Zj_klh\Zgguo \
^jm]bo kljZgZo Kh \j_f_g_f wlh fh`_l \g_klb [hev
rbc \deZ^ \ jZkrbj_gb_ dZfiZgbb b nhjfbjh\Zgb_
hljbpZl_evgh]h hlghr_gby h[s_kl\_gghklb d hlfu\Z
gbx^_g_]q_fex[u_^jm]b_f_ju
Hkm`^_gb_ hlfu\Zgby ^_g_] kZfh]h ih k_[_ dZd
ij_klmigh]h ^_ygby _s_ g_ mdhj_gbehkv kj_^b jhkkb
yg <Z`ghklv h[s_ijbgyluo f_j [hjv[u k wlbf aehf
lZdbo dZd ijbgylb_ aZdhgh\ ijhlb\ hlfu\Zgby ^_g_]
khhl\_lkl\mxsbo jmdh\h^ysbo ijbgpbih\ ^ey ijZ\h
hojZgbl_evguo hj]Zgh\ beb ghjfZlb\guo Zdlh\ ih
[Zgdh\kdhc ^_yl_evghklb _s_ ij_^klhbl hkhagZlv
ijbgylv b j_Zebah\Zlv >_ckl\by \ wlhf gZijZ\e_gbb
qZklh \hkijbgbfZxlky g_ lhevdh dZd f_ju \lhjhkl_
i_ggh]h agZq_gby gh b dZd ijZdlbq_kdb g_\uihegb
fu_ Kdm^gu_ j_kmjku b bkihjq_ggZy j_imlZpby ijZ
\hhojZgbl_evguohj]Zgh\ijhp\_lZgb_\[ZgdZo`mev
gbq_kl\Z b fhr_ggbq_kl\Z klZeb qZklvx `bagb \u
]ey^ys_c^h\hevghfjZqgh
Ijbf_qZgby
L_ dlh hl\_qZ_l aZ [hjv[m k hlfu\Zgb_f ^_g_]
aZqZklmxg_agZxldhgdj_lguoZki_dlh\aZdhgh^Zl_ev
kl\Z b f_lh^h\ ZgZebaZ ^Zgguo beb ijh\_^_gby jZk
ke_^h\Zgby G_h[oh^bfh h[_ki_qblv bf \hafh`ghklv
gZ[bjZlvky b h[f_gb\Zlvky hiulhf kha^Zgby dhf
ie_dkghc hkgh\u ^ey [hjv[u k hlfu\Zgb_f ^_g_] Z
lZd`_ \u[hjZ l_o __ we_f_glh\ dhlhju_ [m^ml jZ[h
lZlv\mkeh\byoJhkkbckdhcN_^_jZpbb<wlhfkhklhbl
h^gh ba gZqbgZgbc Jhkkbckdh]h f_`\_^hfkl\_ggh]h
p_gljZih[hjv[_ke_]ZebaZpb_cg_aZdhgguo^hoh^h\
dhlhjhfm ihjmq_gh aZgylvky ijh[e_fhc hlfu\Zgby
^_g_] AZ g_^he]bc kjhd k\h_]h kms_kl\h\Zgby P_glj
m`_ihdZaZek_[ymqj_`^_gb_f^hklZlhqghdhfi_l_gl
guf \ \hijhkZo jZajZ[hldb kljZl_]bq_kdbo f_j gZmq
guo bkke_^h\Zgbc f_`^mgZjh^gh]h khljm^gbq_kl\Z b
jZkke_^h\Zgby^_eihhlfu\Zgbx^_g_]Wlhki_pbZeb
abjh\Zggh_ mqj_`^_gb_ gZjy^m k ^jm]bfb kljmdlmjZ
fbhl\_qZxsbfbaZ[hjv[mkhlfu\Zgb_f^_g_]gm`
^Z_lky \ ih^^_j`d_ b kh^_ckl\bb \ p_eyo mkdhj_gby
^hklb`_gby j_amevlZlh\ \ [hjv[_ k wlbf g_]Zlb\guf
y\e_gb_f
DjZldhh[wlbo^h\h^Zokf6KD]HHGD
<]h^mfbjh\u_kj_^kl\ZfZkkh\hcbgnhjfZpbbrbjhdh
hk\_sZeb jZkke_^h\Zgb_ ijh\h^bfh_ ijZ\hhojZgbl_evgufb
hj]ZgZfb Kh_^bg_gguo RlZlh\ :f_jbdb \ hlghr_gbb i_j_
\h^h\jhkkbckdbo^_g_]gZh[smxkmffmfej^^heeq_j_a
;wgd hn GvxChjd G_dhlhjZy qZklv wlbo kmff ij_^iheh
`bl_evgh ihklmiZeZ hl eb^_jh\ jhkkbckdbo hj]Zgbah\Zgguo
ij_klmiguo ]jmiibjh\hd b oZjZdl_jbah\ZeZkv dZd we_f_gl
ko_fuhlfu\Zgby^_g_]gZijZ\e_gghc gZ khdjulb_ ijhbkoh
`^_gbyij_klmiguo^hoh^h\
Kj_^g__agZq_gb_jZaebqguohp_ghdjZaf_jh\[_]kl\ZdZiblZ
eZkf\$EDONLQklj
G_dhlhju_ ijbf_ju ijblhdZ djbfbgZevguo ^_g_] \ Jhkkbc
kdmx N_^_jZpbx ba Kh_^bg_gguo RlZlh\ gZ jZggbo wlZiZo
ijb\ZlbaZpbb±ijb\h^ylky\)LWXQL
JhkkbckdZy ]Za_lZ ^_dZ[jy ]h^Z pblbjm_lky ih
EhiZr_gdhklj
E_hgb^ :[Zedbg ± ^bj_dlhj BgklblmlZ wdhghfbdb Jhkkbc
kdhcZdZ^_fbbgZmd
$EDONLQklj
F_`^mgZjh^guc\Zexlgucnhg^klj
Q_eghdb±qZklgu_ebpZdhlhju__a^ylaZ]jZgbpmaZdmiZxl
lZf lh\Zju aZl_f ijb\hayl bo \ Jhkkbckdmx N_^_jZpbx b
ijh^Zxl k ijb[uevx <ujmq_ggmx f_klgmx \Zexlm hgb h[
f_gb\Zxl gZ bghkljZggmx dhlhjmx bkihevamxl ^ey ^Zev
g_crboih_a^hdaZ]jZgbpmqlh[uijb\_alb[hevr_lh\Zjh\
)LWXQLklj
Ih^jh[g__h[wlhf\ke_^mxs_c]eZ\_^ZgghcjZ[hlu
Hp_gdb[_]kl\ZdZiblZeZbaDblZy\ayluba*XQWHU
JmrZcehklj
Ba bgl_j\vx <bdlhjZ F_evgbdh\Z \bp_ij_ab^_glZ P_g
ljZevgh]h[ZgdZJhkkbckdhcN_^_jZpbbFhkdh\kdbcdhfkh
fhe_p
BaaZy\e_gby?e_guBs_gdhgZqZevgbdZ\Zexlgh]hmijZ\e_
gby P_gljZevgh]h [ZgdZ Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb Khh[s_gb_
jZ^bhK\h[h^gZy?\jhiZbxgy]h^Z
Jhkkbckdb_wdhghfbq_kdb_l_g^_gpbb±
P_gljZevguc [Zgd Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb ijbf_gy_l wlh
hij_^_e_gb_k]h^Z
P_gljZevguc[ZgdJhkkbckdhcN_^_jZpbb
Ihhp_gdZf%XFKVkmffZgZebqghklb_`_]h^gh\\hab
fhc \ Jhkkbckdmx N_^_jZpbx khklZ\ey_l ±fej^ ^hee
qlhjZ\gy_lkyijhp_glZf<<Ibkhhl\_lkl\_gghmjh\_gv
^heeZjbaZpbbkhklZ\ey_lijhp_glZ
MdZaZgh\Q_]h^Z_\
KihjudZkZxlkyaZljZlb\ub]jurZhl^heeZjbaZpbbGZijb
f_j ihegZy ^heeZjbaZpby wdhghfbdb jZkkfZljb\Z_lky dZd
kihkh[ h[_ki_q_gby jZa\b\Zxsbfky kljZgZf \hafh`ghklb
ij_h^he_gby g_klZ[bevghklb \Zexlgh^_g_`ghc kbkl_fu b
h[f_ggh]hdmjkZIh^jh[g__h[wlhfkf%HUJDQG%RUHQV]WHLQ
b&DOYRDQG5HLQKDUW
6LOYHUPDQDQG<DQRYLFKklj
Ml\_j`^Z_lkygZijbf_j)LWXQL
JZkkfZljb\Z_lky\6FKOHLIHUDQG7UHVLPDQ
F<Nklj±
GZijbf_j \ ]h^m \ jhkkbckdhf ]hjh^_ <he]h]jZ^_ j_
]bhgZevgh_[xjhih[hjv[_khj]Zgbah\Zgghcij_klmighklvx
\dhgp_dhgph\kmf_ehmklZgh\blvf_klhgZoh`^_gb_baZ^_j
`Zlv:e_dkZg^jZNZlvygh\Zdhlhjucg_aZdhggufiml_fijb
h[j_e \_dk_ev gZ feg jm[e_c m h^gh]h ba \he]h]jZ^kdbo
ij_^ijbylbc JZg__ \ hdly[j_ b ghy[j_ ]h^Z f_klguc
km^\jh^ghf]hjh^_NZlvygh\ZDjZkghyjkd_bh[eZklgZyijh
dmjZlmjZ h^gh\j_f_ggh \u^Zeb hj^_jZ gZ _]h Zj_kl gZ hkgh
\Zgbb jZkke_^h\Zgby ^\mo hl^_evguo m]heh\guo ^_e h fh
JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
r_ggbq_kl\_ b ijbk\h_gbb qm`hc kh[kl\_gghklb < lh `_
\j_fy dh]^Z djZkghyjkdb_ ke_^h\Zl_eb iulZebkv mklZgh\blv
f_klhgZoh`^_gb_NZlvygh\Zhg\^jm]hf]hjh^_±<he]h]jZ
^_±jmdh\h^bej_]bhgZevgufhl^_e_gb_fN_^_jZevgh]hp_gl
jZJhkkbckdhcN_^_jZpbbihaZ^he`_gghklyfHg[uegZagZ
q_g ]eZ\hc hl^_e_gby bxey ]h^Z dZd gZb[he__ d\Zeb
nbpbjh\ZggucdZg^b^ZlgZwlm^he`ghklvihij_^klZ\e_gbx
N_^_jZevgh]h p_gljZ ih aZ^he`_gghklyf ± mqj_`^_gby ijb
a\Zggh]hj_rZlvi_j\hhq_j_^gu_ijh[e_fuaZ^he`_gghkl_cb
g_ieZl_`_c f_klguo ij_^ijbylbc b mqj_`^_gbc Ba\_klby
n_\jZey]h^Z
=eZ\Zba_]hgh\hcdgb]bhim[ebdh\ZgZ\]Za_l_Fhkdh\kdb_
gh\hklbKhjhk
< ]h^m `mjgZe Nhj[k gZa\Ze ;_j_ah\kdh]h kZfuf [h
]Zluf q_eh\_dhf \ Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb bf_xsbf ih
hp_gdZfkhklhygb_\ljbfej^^hee<i_jbh^ij_ab^_glkl\Z
;hjbkZ ?evpbgZ kj_^kl\Z fZkkh\hc bgnhjfZpbb qZklh gZau
\Zeb;_j_ah\kdh]hgZb[he__\ebyl_evgufnbgZgkh\uffZ]gZ
lhf `_kldbf gh\uf jmkkdbf \eZ^_xsbf bkdmkkl\hf ij_
\jZsZlv^_gv]b\h\eZklv<ihke_^g__\j_fyihke_ba[jZgby
ij_ab^_glhf Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb <eZ^bfbjZ ImlbgZ ;h
jbk;_j_ah\kdbchldZaZekyhlk\h_]hf_klZ\jhkkbckdhfiZj
eZf_gl_ \ agZd ijhl_klZ ijhlb\ ih _]h fg_gbx ^_kljmdlb\
gh]hgZklmie_gbyijZ\bl_evkl\ZgZ[bag_k
KfgZijbf_j1HOOLVb7DQ]L
>Zggu_ GZmqghbkke_^h\Zl_evkdh]h bgklblmlZ Fbgbkl_jkl\Z
\gmlj_ggbo^_e<GBBF<>kf\jZ[hl_DZeZq_\
Jhkkbckdbcwdhghfbq_kdbc[Zjhf_lj
DhkZekklj
H[_a^_g_`guok^_edZobaZ^he`_gghklyokfF<N
Ml\_j`^Z_lkygZijbf_j\6KD]HHGDb)LWXQL
Wdki_jl
>Zggu_ih[ZgdZfbaF<Nklj±
Ml\_j`^Z_lky*UHJRU\
Ih^jh[g__ h ij_klmighc ^_yl_evghklb \ jhkkbckdhc [Zgdh\
kdhckbkl_f_gZibkZgh\%XUOLQJDPH
Pblbjm_lkyih%XUOLQJDPH
:LOOLDPVklj
>he]h\Zklj
EhiZr_gdhklj±
>he]h\Zklj
EhiZr_gdhklj
JZ^Z_\klj
EhiZr_gdhklj
DjZldbc h[ahj f_`^mgZjh^guo k\ya_c jhkkbckdhc fZnbb
ijb\h^blky\*DOHRWWL
;mdrbgklj
JZkkfZljb\Z_lky\jZ[hl_JZ^Z_\
E_^_g_\Z ^Ze__ ml\_j`^Z_l qlh \ j_amevlZl_ wnn_d
lb\ghklvfbebpbbbgZeh]h\hcihebpbb\hajZklZ_l
Fhkdh\kdb_gh\hklbklj±
<h^ghcba]eZ\gh\hcdgb]b5REHUW)ULHGPDQ5HG0DILD+RZ
WKH5XVVLDQ0RE+DV,QYDGHG$PHULFDDZdjhkkbckdb_]Zg]kl_
ju gZ\h^gbeb :f_jbdm hibku\Z_lky ^_yl_evghklv K_f_gZ
Fh]be_\bqZ
%XVLQHVVLQ5XVVLDklj
DZiblZeDjblbdZiheblbq_kdhcwdhghfbbDZjeZFZjdkZ \
dhlhjhc dZiblZebaf hkm`^Z_lky dZd wdkiemZlZlhjkdh_ h[s_
kl\h [ue \ kh\_lkdh_ \j_fy h[yaZl_evguf ^ey bamq_gby \
\ukrbo mq_[guo aZ\_^_gbyo ihwlhfm [hevrbgkl\h h[jZah
\ZgguojhkkbygagZdhfhk_]hkh^_j`Zgb_f
DFZjdkklj
Bgl_j\vxZ\lhjZkGZlZev_cEhiZr_gdhfZc]h^Z
AZy\e_gby gZ Dhgn_j_gpbb ih f_`^mgZjh^ghfm khljm^gbq_
kl\m\jZkke_^h\Zgbb^_eihhlfu\Zgbx^_g_]KI_l_j[mj]
±fZy]h^Z
GZijbf_j jhkkbckdhfm [Zgdbjm :e_dkZg^jm DhgZguobgm \
hlghr_gbbdhlhjh]hjhkkbckdZyijhdmjZlmjZ^h[b\ZeZkvwdk
ljZ^bpbbbaKh_^bg_gguoRlZlh\\JhkkbckdmxN_^_jZpbx
]^_hg^he`_g[ueij_^klZlvi_j_^km^hfaZnbgZgkh\u_ij_
klmie_gby[uehij_^hklZ\e_ghiheblbq_kdh_m[_`bs_\ Kh
_^bg_gguoRlZlZo
6KHOOH\klj
Ih^jh[g__h[wlhfkf1D\ORU
Bgl_j\vxZ\lhjZk:=mjh\uf
Kf h[ahj ^Zgguo Zj]mf_glh\ \ jZ[hl_ :eb_\ b ;hehpdbc
DZeZq_\b^j
>he]h\Zklj
EhiZr_gdhklj
JZkkfZljb\Zehkv\ur_\^ZgghcjZ[hl_
DZeZq_\b^j
>Zggu_ hijhkh\ ijh\_^_gguo <GBB F<> ijb\h^ylky \
jZ[hl_DZeZq_\
G_dhlhju_bagbo[uebhlf_g_gu\oh^_j_hj]ZgbaZpbbijZ
\bl_evkl\Z\]h^m
JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
;b[ebh]jZnby
$EDONLQ/DQG:KDOH\-7KHSUREOHPRIFDSLWDO
IOLJKW IURP 5XVVLD 7KH :RUOG (FRQRP\ 0D\
SS
%HUJ $ DQG %RUHQV]WHLQ ( 7KH GROODUL]DWLRQ
GHEDWH)LQDQFHDQG'HYHORSPHQW0DUFKSS
%XFKV7)LQDQFLDO&ULVLVLQWKH5XVVLDQ)HGHUD
WLRQ $UH WKH 5XVVLDQV OHDUQLQJ WR 7DQJR" (FRQRPLFV RI
7UDQVLWLRQSS
0DU[.&DSLWDODFULWLTXHRISROLWLFDOHFRQRP\
YRO/RQGRQ3HQJXLQ%RRNV
1D\ORU7)URPXQGHUZRUOGWRXQGHUJURXQG
&ULPH/DZDQG6RFLDO&KDQJHSS
1HOOLV-7LPHWRUHWKLQNSULYDWL]DWLRQLQWUDQVLWLRQ
HFRQRPLHV")LQDQFHDQG'HYHORSPHQW-XQHSS
1HZ<RUN7LPHVYDULRXVLVVXHV
%XUOLQJDPH 7 &ULPLQDO DFWLYLW\ LQ WKH 5XVVLDQ
EDQNLQJ V\VWHP 7UDQVQDWLRQDO 2UJDQL]HG &ULPH SS
4XLUN - 0DFURHFRQRPLF LPSOLFDWLRQV RI PRQH\
ODXQGHULQJ,0)ZRUNLQJSDSHU:DVKLQJWRQ'&
%XVLQHVV LQ 5XVVLD ,QWHUYLHZ ZLWK *RYHUQRU RI
1RYJRURG 5HJLRQ 0LNKDLO 3UXVDN E\ 9ODGLPLU 6FKHGULQ
SS
5XVVLDQ(FRQRPLF7UHQGVYDULRXVLVVXHV
&DOYR*DQG5HLQKDUW&&DSLWDOIORZUHYHUVDOV
WKH H[FKDQJH UDWH GHEDWH DQG GROODUL]DWLRQ )LQDQFH DQG
'HYHORSPHQW6HSWHPEHUSS
&HQWHUIRU6WUDWHJLFDQG,QWHUQDWLRQDO6WXGLHV5XV
VLDQ2UJDQL]HG&ULPH3URMHFW&6,67DVN)RUFH5HSRUW
)LWXQL / 5XVVLD RUJDQL]HG FULPH DQG PRQH\
ODXQGHULQJ -RXUQDO RI 0RQH\ /DXQGHULQJ &RQWURO SS
)ULHGPDQ55HGPDILDKRZWKH5XVVLDQPREKDV
LQYDGHG$PHULFD%RVWRQ/LWWOH%URZQDQG&RPSDQ\
*DOHRWWL 0 5XVVLD
V FULPLQDOV JR JOREDO LQ
-DQH
V,QWHOOLJHQFH5HYLHZ0DUFKRQOLQHLVVXH
*UHJRU\ , 3DUWLDO UHVXUUHFWLRQ &HQWUDO (XUR
SHDQ%DQNLQJ2FWREHUSS
*XQWHU)&DSLWDOIOLJKWIURPWKH3HRSOH
V5HSXE
OLFRI&KLQDLQ&KLQD(FRQRPLF5HYLHZ
SS
,QWHUQDWLRQDO 0RQHWDU\ )XQG 5XVVLDQ )HGHUDWLRQ
5HFHQWHFRQRPLFGHYHORSPHQWV,0)6WDII&RXQWU\5HSRUW
1R6HSWHPEHU:DVKLQJWRQ'&
/HGHQHYD $ 2UJDQL]HG &ULPH LQ 5XVVLD WRGD\
LQ35,60$ELZHHNO\RQWKHSRVW6RYLHW6WDWHVRQ
OLQHLVVXH
5XVVLDQ(FRQRPLF%DURPHWHU
6FKOHLIHU$DQG7UHVLPDQ'7KHHFRQRPLFVDQG
SROLWLFV RI WUDQVLWLRQ WR DQ RSHQ PDUNHW HFRQRP\ 5XVVLD
3DULV 2UJDQLVDWLRQ IRU (FRQRPLF &RRSHUDWLRQ DQG 'HYH
ORSPHQW
6KD]HHGD $ $ JDWHZD\ IRU PRQH\ ODXQGHULQJ"
)LQDQFLDO OLEHUDOL]DWLRQ LQ GHYHORSLQJ DQG WUDQVLWLRQDO
HFRQRPLHV -RXUQDO RI 0RQH\ /DXQGHULQJ &RQWURO SS
6KHOOH\ / 7KH GLVSRVDO RI VHL]HG ODXQGHUHG DV
VHWV LQ -RQHV $ DQG RWKHUV HGV .LOOLQJ GHYHORSPHQW
PRQH\ODXQGHULQJLQWKHJOREDOHFRQRP\&HQWUHIRU3RVW
&ROOHFWLYLVW6WXGLHV
6LOYHUPDQ % DQG <DQRYLFK 0 1HZ ULFK QHZ
SRRUQHZ5XVVLDZLQQHUVDQGORVHUVRQWKH5XVVLDQURDG
WRFDSLWDOLVP1HZ<RUN0(6KDUSH,QF
7DQ]L97UDQVLWLRQDQGWKHFKDQJLQJUROHRIJRY
HUQPHQW)LQDQFHDQG'HYHORSPHQW-XQHSS
7DQ]L90RQH\ODXQGHULQJDQGWKHLQWHUQDWLRQDO
ILQDQFLDO V\VWHP ,0) ZRUNLQJ SDSHU 0D\ :DVKLQJWRQ
'&
8QLWHG 1DWLRQV 2IILFH IRU 'UXJ &RQWURO DQG &ULPH 3UH
YHQWLRQ )LQDQFLDO +DYHQV %DQNLQJ 6HFUHF\ DQG 0RQH\
/DXQGHULQJ6DOHV1R(,9
8QLWHG 1DWLRQV 2IILFH IRU 'UXJ &RQWURO DQG &ULPH 3UH
YHQWLRQ5XVVLDQ)HGHUDWLRQ&RXQWU\5HSRUW-XQH
JhkkbckdbcdZiblZebafbhlfu\Zgb_^_g_]
:LOOLDPV 3 HG 5XVVLDQ RUJDQL]HG FULPH WKH
QHZWKUHDW"/RQGRQ)UDQN&DVV
:RUOG%DQN*OREDO'HYHORSPHQW )LQDQFH :DVK
LQJWRQ'&:RUOG%DQN
:eb_\ < b ;hehlkdbc ; ] JZajZ[hldZ jhkkbc
kdh]h aZdhgh^Zl_evkl\Z h ijhlb\h^_ckl\bb e_]ZebaZ
pbb hlfu\Zgbx ^hoh^h\ ihemq_gguo g_aZdhg
guf iml_f g_dhlhju_ ^bkdmkkbhggu_ \hijh
ku=hkm^Zjkl\hbijZ\hklj±
;mdrbgX]Ihedh\gbd=JMg_iham[ZfN_
fb^_:j]mf_glubnZdlun_\jZeyklj
;meZlh\:]<u\hadZiblZeZbaJhkkbb<hijh
ku j_]mebjh\Zgby<hijhku wdhghfbdb klj±
>he]h\Z : ] DjbfbgZevgZy kblmZpby \
JhkkbbDjbfbgheh]byklj±
>he]h\Z:j_^]Ij_klmighklvbj_nhjfu\
Jhkkbb GZmqghbkke_^h\Zl_evkdbc bgklblml ijh[e_f
mdj_ie_gby aZdhgghklb b ihjy^dZ Fhkd\Z Djbfbgh
eh]bq_kdZyZkkhpbZpby
Ba\_klby]jZaebqgu_ghf_jZ
DZeZq_\<b^j]Ijh[e_fZhlfu\Zgby^_g_]\
Jhkkbb <k_jhkkbckdbc gZmqghbkke_^h\Zl_evkdbc bg
klblml Fbgbkl_jkl\Z \gmlj_ggbo ^_e <GBB F<>
>hdeZ^ ih^]hlh\e_g ^ey MijZ\e_gby Hj]ZgbaZpbb
H[t_^bg_gguoGZpbcihdhgljhexgZ^gZjdhlbdZfbb
ij_^mij_`^_gbxij_klmighklb
Dhff_jkZglt±]]jZaebqgu_ghf_jZ
DhkZek E ] L_g_\Zy wdhghfbdZ dZd hkh[_g
ghklvjhkkbckdh]hdZiblZebafZ<hijhkuwdhghfbdb
klj±
EhiZr_gdh G ] Ij_klmie_gby \ kn_j_ wdhgh
fbq_kdhc ^_yl_evghklb Dhff_glZjbb d ]eZ\_
MDJNJhklh\gZ>hgmN_gbdk
FZdZjh\ > ] Wdhghfbq_kdb_ b ijZ\h\u_ Zk
i_dlu l_g_\hc wdhghfbdb \ Jhkkbb<hijhku wdhgh
fbdbklj±
Fhkdh\kdb_ gh\hklb ] Bgl_j\vx Xjby G_
kl_j_gdh k K_f_ghf Fh]be_\bq_f ± n_\jZey
klj±
Fhkdh\kdbcdhfkhfhe_p]Jmkkdb_ihdhcgb
dbfbeebZj^_ju Bgl_j\vx k <bdlhjhf F_evgbdh
\uf aZf_klbl_e_f ij_^k_^Zl_ey P_gljZevgh]h ;ZgdZ
JhkkbckdhcN_^_jZpbbn_\jZeyklj
JZ^Z_\<]HjhebgZkbeby\jhkkbckdbo^_eh
\uo hlghr_gbyo<hijhku wdhghfbdb klj±
JmrZceh I ] FZevqbdb ih \u\hamDhff_j
kZglt<eZklvklj±ghy[jy
Khjhk>`];_j_ah\kdbcImlbgAZiZ^]eZ
\Zbadgb]bhim[ebdh\ZggZygZjmkkdhfyaud_\]Za_l_
Fhkdh\kdb_gh\hklb±n_\jZeyklj
P_gljZevguc ;Zgd Jhkkbckdhc N_^_jZpbb ]
;xee_l_gv[Zgdh\kdhcklZlbklbdbFhkd\Z
Q_]h^Z_\>]<ZexlmgZ\u\haDhff_jkZglt
<eZklv^_dZ[jyklj
Wdki_jl]hdly[jy
Скачать