И.В.Кузнецов PONTICA CAUCASICA ETHNICA. II Северо

реклама
B<Dmag_ph\
PONTICA CAUCASICA ETHNICA. II
K_\_jhaZiZ^gucDZ\dZa\l_jjblhjbZevguo]jZgbpZokh\j_f_gguo
DjZkgh^Zjkdh]hdjZyJ_kim[ebdb:^u]_yDZjZqZ_\hQ_jd_kkdhcJ_kim[ebdb
qZklbKlZ\jhihevkdh]hdjZygZqbgZykZglbqghklbb\iehlv^hmklZgh\e_gby
\eZ^uq_kl\ZJhkkbckdhcbfi_jbbg_jZaij_^klZ\eyekh[hci_jbn_jbx
Ihglbckdhcbklhjbdhdmevlmjghch[eZklbWlhhljZabehkv\fhsguo
i_jbh^bq_kdb\hah[gh\eyxsbokyijyfuobebhihkj_^h\Zgguox`guodmevlmjguo
\ebygbyobijhy\behkv\qZklghklb\lhfqlhbgZwlhcl_jjblhjbbijb
[eb`Zcr_fjZkkfhlj_gbbfh`ghh[gZjm`blvdmevlmjgmxiZjZ^b]fmlZd
agZdhfmxgZfihIhglm³]hkih^kl\mxsbcbkeZfojbklbZgkdh_f_gvrbgkl\h´
³hjlh^hdkZevgu_ojbklbZg_]j_db²fhghnbkbluZjfyg_´ijhgbau\Zxsmx\k_
klhjhgu\aZbfhhlghr_gbckeh`b\rbokya^_kvdmevlmj
K_cqZkba\_klghqlh\h\j_fyg_ihkj_^kl\_gghij_^r_kl\mxs__
ihy\e_gbxgZk_\_jhaZiZ^ghfDZ\dZa_jmkkdhcZjfbbbdZaZq_kl\Zkj_^b
aZdm[ZgkdboZ^u]h\ijh`b\Zebij_^klZ\bl_eb^\mobghwlgbqguo]jmiilg
q_jd_kkdb_Zjfyg_q_jd_kh]Zbbq_jd_kkdb_]j_db<hl\u^_j`dbbalbibqgh]h
^eylh]h\j_f_gbhibkZgby²dgb]bba^Zgghc\=_jfZgbb\]
³9Dm[ZgvDjhf_gh]Z_\bq_jdZkkh\\kljZg_`b\ml_\j_bdhlhjuo
a^_kvhq_gvfgh]hZjfyg_b]j_db`b\msb_a^_kv]eZ\gufh[jZahfjZ^blhj]h\eb
pu]Zg_bij
=hjh^LZfZgv@bl_eb[hevr_xqZklvxykuhklZevgu_²Zjfyg_
]j_dblmjdbbl^
L_fjmdfZe_gvdbc]hjh^gZk_\_jh\hklhd_hlLZfZgb@bl_eb_]h
qZklvxykuqZklvx]j_db_\j_bbZjfyg_hgbk^Z\g_]h\j_f_gbieZlbeb^Zgv
djufkdhfmoZgm´LmgfZgg
H[_]jmiiu[uebZ^u]h]h\hjysbfb:^u]hyauqgu_nhjfubo
kZfhgZa\Zgbykhhl\_lkl\_ggh³_jfwe´b³mjuf´\Z^u]_ckdhfkem`ZllZd`_
l_jfbgZfb^eyh[hagZq_gbyZjfygb]j_dh\\hh[s_ijhbkoh^ylhllxjdh
lmj_pdbol_jfbgh\qlhhiylvlZdbhij_^_e_gghmdZau\Z_leb[hgZDjufeb[h
fbgmyDjufg_ihkj_^kl\_gghgZ:gZlhebxbIhgl\dZq_kl\_\hafh`guo
bklhqgbdh\aZbfkl\h\Zgby
;eZ]h^Zjyp_ehfmjy^mh[klhyl_evkl\bij_`^_\k_]h[hevr_c
qbke_gghklbq_jd_kh]ZbhdZaZebkvemqr_hibkZggufbbbamq_ggufbkf
;b[ebh]jZnbx\:jfyg_K_\_jgh]hDZ\dZaZQ_jd_kkdb_]j_db`_
ijh^he`ZxlhklZ\Zlvky[_eufiylghf\dZ\dZah\_^q_kdhcebl_jZlmj_
<hijhkh\j_f_gbihy\e_gbybokj_^baZdm[ZgkdboZ^u]h\^hkboihjg_
j_r_gKmkbe_gb_fihabpbcJhkkbbgZk_\_jhaZiZ^ghfDZ\dZa_\k_[hevr__b
[hevr__qbkehq_jd_kkdbo]j_dh\klj_fblkyihk_eblvkygZaZgylhcjmkkdbfb
\hckdZfbl_jjblhjbb<wlh\j_fyg_khfg_gghih^\ebygb_fgh\hchldju\r_cky
^eygboibkvf_gghcbklhjbbihkdhevdmkZfbq_jd_kkdb_]j_dblZd`_dZdb
Z^u]_cpu[ueb_kl_kl\_ggh[_kibkvf_gghcdmevlmjhc\bokj_^_
jZkijhkljZgyxlkyjhfZglbq_kdb_ij_^klZ\e_gbyhk\h_fijhrehfGZijbf_j
³]j_dbMjmikdh]hhdjm]ZkqblZxlk_[yihlhfdZfbZj]hgZ\lh\´Dm[Zgkdb_
h[eZklgu_\_^hfhklbbebjZkijhkljZg_ggh_^hkboihjfg_gb_h
g_ihkj_^kl\_gghcij__fkl\_gghklbbohlbhgbckdbo]j_dh\ijbq_jghfhjkdbo
Zglbqguodhehgbcbl^
G_q_]hb]h\hjblvqlhih^h[gu_ij_^iheh`_gby²ebrvdjZkb\u_
nZglZabbJ_Zevgh]j_q_kdZyh[sghklv\AZdm[Zgv_dZdbZjfygkdZyfh]eZ
knhjfbjh\Zlvky\j_amevlZl_jy^Zg_fgh]hqbke_gguoaZlmoZxsbo
i_j_k_e_gq_kdbo\hegbaDjufZbebFZehc:abb\i_jbh^Zdlb\gh]h
ijhgbdgh\_gbyojbklbZgkl\ZgZk_\_jhaZiZ^gucDZ\dZal_]^_lhf_`^m;b;9,
\\
I_j\uc\uoh^baAZdm[Zgvyq_jd_kkdbo]j_dh\\f_kl_kZjfygZfbb
kh[kl\_gghZ^u]kdbfbk_fvyfbih`_eZ\rbfbi_j_clb\jmkkdh_ih^^Zgkl\h
ijhbahr_em`_\kZfhfdhgp_;9,,,\;,]ihklmibeh<ukhqZcr__
ih\_e_gb_gZbfyGh\hjhkkbckdh]h\h_ggh]h]m[_jgZlhjZ]jZnZDhoh\kdh]hb
ihke_^g_]h²\hckdh\hfmZlZfZgmDhleyj_\kdhfmm^h\e_l\hjblv`_eZgb_
ijhkbl_e_cZ9,]hgbhkgh\u\ZxlgZ:g]_ebgkdhf_jbd_ijbdmj_gghf
k_e_gbbGh\hgb`_kl_[eb_\kdhfkh\j_f_ggZykl=jb\_gkdZyDZebgbgkdh]h
jZchgZDjZkgh^Zjkdh]hdjZy=jb\_gkdbcQ_jd_kkdbcZmeRZfjZc
=:DDnhi^^nhi^
<]]kx^ZgZijZ\ey_lky_s_jy^i_j_k_e_gq_kdboihlhdh\
=:DDnhi^^Bah^gh]h^hdmf_glZ^Zlbjm_fh]h,
]jZihjlAZ\h^h\kdhfmbkijZ\bl_ex^_eGZdZagh]h:lZfZgZQ_jghfhjkdh]h
dZaZqv_]h\hckdZ]_gfZchjmhl\hckdh\hcdZgp_eyjbbke_^m_lqlh\Zme_
ijh`b\Zehfm`qbg³q_jd_k:jfygb=j_dh\´=:DDnhi^
<^Zevg_cr_fbaaZa_f_evguokihjh\jmkkdZyZ^fbgbkljZpbyj_rbeZ
jZkkj_^hlhqblv]jb\_gkdboZjfygb]j_dh\ihjZagufklZgbpZf
Gh\h^fbljb_\kdhcMfZgkdhcKlZjh^_j_\ygdh\kdhcI_j_ykeh\kdhc
;jxoh\_pdhcgh\dhgp_dhgph\\k_`_mklmibeZbo`_eZgbxihk_eblvky\f_kl_
=:DDnhi^<]k_f_cZjfygq_ebk_f_c]j_dh\
q_ei_j_k_eyxl\klI_j_ykeh\kdmxgug_\;jxoh\_pdhfjZchg_
DjZkgh^Zjkdh]hdjZy]^_baZjfygnhjfbjmxlI_j_ykeh\kdbcihk_ehdb\
l_q_gbbo]]ihihegyxl_]haZkq_lgh\uo]j_q_kdbobZjfygkdbok_f_cba
AZdm[Zgvy=:DDnhi^
Iha`_\][hevrmxqZklvZjfygbg_dhlhjuo]j_dh\kgh\Z
i_j_f_sZxl²\Ijhqghhdhikdh_Zjfygkdh_k_e_gb_ijbklIjhqghhdhikdhcgZ
DZ\dZakdhcebgbbZhllm^Z²\:jfZ\bjg_kdhevdhk_f_cq_jd_kkdbo]j_dh\
a^_kvnbdkbjmxlkybklhqgbdZfb²=:DDnhi^HklZ\rZyky
g_[hevrZyqZklvZjfygb]j_dh\\k\yabkebd\b^Zpb_cI_j_ykeh\kdh]hihk_edZ
[ueZijbibkZgZg_ihkj_^kl\_gghdklI_j_ykeh\kdhcbijh^he`ZeZ`blv
ih[ebahklbhlg__g_[hevrbfbomlhjZfbDhjhe_gdh
Ihbf_gghfmkibkdm\^_e_^Zlbjm_fhf]]kj_^bdZaZdh\kl
I_j_ykeh\kdhcagZqbehkvk_f_c]j_dh\q_ek_f_cZjfygq_eZ
lZd`_q_edj_ihklguoZjfygkdhcagZlbwlgbq_kdZyb^_glbqghklvdhlhjuoih
bklhqgbdmg_\hkklZgh\bfZghkdhj__\k_]hZ^u]_cp_\=:DDnhi^
WlbZjfyg_b]j_dbijh^he`ZxlmihfbgZlvky\bklhqgbdZo\l_q_gb_\k_o
o]];,;\Zihlhfboke_^ubkq_aZxlHq_\b^ghihke_ijbgylby\\hckdh\h_
khkeh\b_iheghklvxZkkbfbebjh\Z\rbkvhgbjZkl\hjbebkvkj_^bdZaZqv_]h
gZk_e_gbykl=jb\_gkdhcbI_j_ykeh\kdhc>hkbo_s_g_dhlhju_dhj_ggu_
dZaZqvbk_fvbwlboklZgbpihfgylhk\h_fZ[hjb]_gghfijhbkoh`^_gbbb
\u^_eyxlkykj_^b^jm]bok\hbfZgljhiheh]bq_kdbf\b^hf
FuagZ_fdZdf_gyeZkvh[sZyqbke_gghklvgZk_e_gby=jb\_gkdh]h
Q_jd_kkdh]hZmeZaZwlhli_jbh^RZfjZc
=h^
1807
1809
1813
1825
1830
1834
1838
1842
1850
1852
1860
qbkehfm`qbg qbkeh`_gsbg h[sZyqbke_gghklv
366
359
292
651
344
301
645
137
121
258
163
119
282
177
118
295
240
170
410
449
320
769
400
132
532
206
170
376
109
78
187
<ihke_^mxsbci_jbh^hklZevgu_]jmiiuq_jd_kh]Z_\lZd`_mrebba
Z^u]kdboZmeh\bdZdba\_klghihkl_i_gghih^ihdjh\bl_evkl\hf]_g_jZe
e_cl_gZglZAZkkZkh[jZebkv\:jfygkdhfZme_²k:jfZ\bjhl^_evgu_k_fvb²
\Gh\hjhkkbckd_?dZl_jbgh^Zj_Iylb]hjkd_b^jQlh`_dZkZ_lkyq_jd_kkdbo
]j_dh\lh\]ke_^mxsb_^\_agZqbl_evgu_]jmiiuh^gZ\dhebq_kl\_q_e
baZW^_ikmdZc,Ik_dmikdh]hhdjm]ZDm[Zgkdhch[eZklbWnbikmdZcdZd\
bklhqgbd_bawlh]h`_ZmeZ\uk_eyebkvbq_jd_kh]ZbZ^jm]Zy²[he__q_e
baMjmikdh]hhdjm]Zh[jZah\Zebhl^_evguc]j_q_kdbcihk_ehdgZl_jjblhjbb
ihke_^g_]h\f_kl_[u\r_]hZOZ^`boZ[evhdhehkl=jb]hjhihebkkdhcdhlhjZy
gZoh^blkygug_\Gh\hZe_dkZg^jh\kdhfjZchg_KlZ\jhihevkdh]hdjZy=:DDn
hi^H^Zevg_cr_ckm^v[_wlh]hgZk_e_gbymgZklZd`_g_l^Zgguo
Ijbf_jgh\wlh`_\j_fy\^\momihfygmluohdjm]Zo]j_dbkhklZ\eyeb
K[hjgbdk\_^_gbchDZ\dZa_
hdjm]Z
Ik_dmikdbc
Mjmikdbc
<k_]h
qbkehfm`qbg qbkeh`_gsbg h[sZyqbke_gghklv
25
28
53
51
34
85
76
62
138
Hq_\b^ghqlhq_jd_kkdb_]j_dbij_^klZ\eyebkh[hcb\wlhli_jbh^b^h
k\h_]h\uoh^ZbaZ^u]_ckdboZmeh\]hjZa^h[he__fZehqbke_ggmx]jmiimq_f
q_jd_kkdb_Zjfyg_kh]eZkgh^hdeZ^ghcaZibkd_jmkkdh]h\h_ggh]hdhfZg^mxs_]h
\,ihe;,;\\]hjZog_[uehihqlbgbh^gh]hk_e_gby]^_[ug_ijh`b\Zeb
Zjfygkdb_k_fvb:D:DlIh]hkygihke_i_j_k_e_gby\
:jfZ\bjboqbke_gghklv^hklb]ZeZlukq_e:jZd_eygL_j
KZjdbkygpKhhl\_lkl\_gghh[sZyqbke_gghklvq_jd_kkdbo]j_dh\dZd
\b^ghba\ur_ijb\_^_gguobklhqgbdh\fh]eZ[ulv\k_]hebrvq_e
GZdhg_p\]\EZ[bgkdhfhdjm]_Dm[Zgkdhch[eZklb[uehkgh\ZgZ
;`_^m]oZ[ev\dhlhjhfihk_ebebkvq_jd_kkdb_]j_dbZjfyg_bZ^u]_cpu
Hkgh\gu_Z^fbgbkljZlb\ghl_jjblhjbZevgu_:mekhojZgbeky^h
gZrbo^g_cgug_DjZkgh]\Zj^_ckdbcjZchgJ_kim[ebdb:^u]_ybgZ
k_]h^gyrg__\j_fyij_^klZ\ey_lkh[hc_^bgkl\_ggh_f_klhdhfiZdlgh]h
ijh`b\Zgbyq_jd_kkdbo]j_dh\
Kh\j_f_ggu_]j_db;`_^m]oZ[eyg_ihfgylh[klhyl_evkl\k\h_]hihy\e_gby
\Zme_bg_agZxlgbq_]hh^jm]bojh^kl\_gguobf]jmiiZoHij_^_e_gguck\_lgZ
ijh[e_fmbo]_g_lbq_kdbok\ya_cijheb\Z_lkjZ\gbl_evgucZgZeba
q_jd_kh]j_q_kdhcZgljhihgbfbbnZfbebbq_jd_kkdbo]j_dh\klI_j_ykeh\kdhci
OZ^`boZ[ev\aylubaklZjuok_f_cguokibkdh\²=:DDnhi^n
hi^
klI_j_ykeh\kdZy
iOZ^`boZ[ev
K_jZnbfh\u>_fbljh\u
K_jZnbfh\u>_fbljh\u
>_nl_jh\u:keZgh\u
>hnlkbdh\uIhih\uDhdbk
Z;`_^m]oZ[ev
DhklZgh\uOZaZjh\u
K_jZnbfh\u>_flbjh\u
>_nl_jh\u:keZgh\u
;hevr__dhebq_kl\hh[sbonZfbebcm]j_dh\Z;`_^m]oZ[evbi
OZ^`boZ[evlZd`_dZdbbo]_h]jZnbq_kdZy[ebahklvfh`_lk\b^_l_evkl\h\Zlv\
ihevam]_g_lbq_kdh]hjh^kl\Zh[_bo]jmii;_amkeh\ghlZd`_gm`ghbf_lv\\b^m
qlhwlbnZfbebb\[hevrbgkl\_ij_^klZ\eyxlkh[hc\lhjbqgu_
jmkbnbpbjh\Zggu_h[jZah\ZgbyBgl_j_kghblhqlh_kebkjZ\gb\Zlv
q_jd_kh]j_q_kdmxZgljhihgbfbxkq_jd_khZjfygkdhclh[jhkZ_lky\]eZaZqlh
nZfbebbky\ghZ^u]_ckdhcwlbfheh]b_chq_gvqZklumZjfyg;Z]tZjkwdtm
LZethklwgb^jbijZdlbq_kdbhlkmlkl\mxlm]j_dh\
;,]fuih[u\Zebm]j_dh\Z;`_^m]oZ[evm^Zehkvkh[jZlv
^h\hevghnjZ]f_glZjgu_^Zggu_dhlhju_h^gZdh^Zxlg_dhlhjh_ij_^klZ\e_gb_h
lbi_dmevlmjuwlhchq_gvk\h_h[jZaghc]jmiiu
<gZklhys__\j_fy\Zme_`b\ml\hkgh\ghfjmkkdb_dhlhju_ihy\bebkv
a^_kviha^g__Djhf_lh]hjZgvr_jy^hfkZmehfjZkiheZ]ZekyoQ_jgh]hjdbgih
nZfbebba_fe_\eZ^_evpZK_cqZkhgkebekykZmehfWlh\i_j\mxhq_j_^vb
kihkh[kl\h\Zehhlghkbl_evghfmm\_ebq_gbxqbke_gghklbjmkkdh]hgZk_e_gby
<lhjufihqbke_gghklbdhfihg_glhfgZk_e_gbyy\eyxlkyq_jd_kkdb_]j_db
JZgvr_\_]]ihk\_^_gbyfbgnhjfZglh\hgbij_h[eZ^Zeb<Z
;`_^m]oZ[evbf_xlkyke_^mxsb_bonZfbebb:keZgh\uk_fvbq_e
>_flbjh\uk_fvbq_e>_nl_jh\uk_fvbq_eDhklZgh\uk_f_c
q_eOZaZjh\uk_fvbq_eH[sZyqbke_gghklv\k_oi_j_qbke_gguok_f_c
q_eijbq_f[hevrbgkl\hbagboq_edZdfbgbfmf]j_dbihemdjh\dbh[
wlgbq_kdbkf_rZgguok_fvyo^Zevr_Ij_^klZ\bl_ebr_klhcnZfbebb²
K_jZnbfh\uo²\gZklhys__\j_fyi_j_k_ebebkv\FZcdhib\Zme_[hevr_g_
ijh`b\ZxlDjhf_lh]hh^gZk_fvy:keZgh\uoi_j_k_ebeZkv\;_ehj_q_gkd
q_eb_s_h^bgq_eh\_d²\DjZkgh^ZjH^bgq_eh\_dba>_flbjh\uoi_j__oZe\
<he]h]jZ^_klvh^gZk_fvyklZdhcnZfbeb_c\DjZkgh^Zj_
Ihk_eb\rb_ky_s_\^hj_\hexpbhggh_\j_fy\kF_jqZgkdh_Djufkdbc
jZchgb\gZklhys__\j_fyiheghklvxweebgbabjh\Zggu_>_flbjh\uih
\b^bfhfmlZd`_y\eyxlkyjh^kl\_ggbdZfb[`_^m]oZ[evkdbo>_flbjh\uo<i
DZ[Zj^bgdZ`b\mlihlhfdbi_j_k_e_gp_\bakF_jqZgkdh]h]j_dh]h\hjysZy
OjbklbgZ>_flbjh\ZnZfbebydhlhjhc^hklZeZkv_chlfm`Z³q_jd_kZ´ZlZd`_
B\Zg>_flbjh\jZkkfZljb\Zxsbck_[ym`_³kZfkmgp_f´h^gZbakm[wlgbq_kdbo
]jmiiihglbckdbo]j_dh\ij_^klZ\bl_ebdhlhjhcijh`b\Zxl\F_jqZgkdhf
LZdbfh[jZahfgZl_dmsbcfhf_glh[sZyqbke_gghklvq_jd_kkdbo]j_dh\
khklZ\ey_lf_g__q_e
Kh\j_f_gbhkgh\ZgbyZ;`_^m]oZ[ev\g_fbebihkhk_^kl\mkgbflZd`_
ijh`b\Zebq_jd_kkdb_Zjfyg_;Zjhdh\u;h]Zjkmdh\uOZg`b_\uOZqZ^mjh\u
Iha`_dgbfijbkh_^bgbebkvnZfbebb:kiZ^mjvygbDZeZ^`Zgdhlhju_[ueb
Zjfygh]h\hjysbfb<hlghr_gbb_s_h^ghcZjfygkdhcnZfbebb²Dbjdh\uo²
g_l^hklZlhqghcykghklby\eyebkvebhgbq_jd_kh]Zyfbbebij_^klZ\bl_eyfb
[he__iha^gboZjfygh]h\hjysboi_j_k_e_gp_\"<gZklhys__\j_fy\Zme_
hklZeZkvlhevdhh^gZnZfbebyq_jd_kkdboZjfygblhkf_rZggZy²OZqZ^mjh\u
OZg`b_\u\ihke_^g__\j_fyi_j_k_ebebkv\FZcdhi
HklZebkvlZd`_ke_^mxsb_nZfbebbZ^u]_cp_\;_ja_]h\uk_fvy
<ZgZ\gmdh\uk_f_cFZfou]h\jh^hfbaZ:^Zfbc[u\rbcmqbl_ev
QbkZ[b_\jh^hfbaZ=Z[mdZc[u\rbcmqbl_ev
<ihke_^g__\j_fy\k\yabkZjfyghZa_j[Zc^`Zgkdbfdhgnebdlhf\Z
;`_^m]oZ[evZlZd`_\hdj_klgu_k_eZ;_eh_Ij_h[jZ`_gkdh_i_j_k_ebehkv
g_kdhevdhk_f_cdmj^h\ba:jf_gbb
I_j_k_eb\rbkv\;`_^m]oZ[ev]j_dbbZjfyg_\b^bfhijh^he`Zeb
]h\hjblvgZl_fbj]h_\kdhfd,wf]mc^bZe_dl_Z^u]_ckdh]hyaudZGZijhlb\
q_jd_kh]Zbh[jZah\Z\rb_:jfZ\bj\^Zevg_cr_f\ujZ[hlZebk\hchkh[uc
wlghe_dlgZhkgh\_^bZe_dlh\l_oaZiZ^ghZ^u]kdboie_f_gkj_^bdhlhjuohgb
ijh`b\Zeb\ijhrehfGZ[hdh\Z
>he]h_\j_fy[`_^m]oZ[evkdb_]j_dbg_[ueb^\myauqguZ^u]_ckdbcyaud
kem`be^eygbo_^bgkl\_ggufdhffmgbdZlb\gufkj_^kl\hfb_kl_kl\_gghc
hkgh\hcf_lZyaudZdmevlmjuHkgh\gu_nhevdehjgu_`Zgju[uebZ^u]_ckdbfb<
]j_q_kdhckj_^_pbjdmebjh\Zebl_`_l_dklubebbohq_gv[ebadb_\ZjbZgluqlh
bmhdjm`Zxs_]hZ^u]_ckdh]hgZk_e_gbyKj_^bq_jd_kh]Z_\^Z`_[uebba\_klgu
kdZabl_ebgZijbf_j?jf_evLZjZkhldhlhjuoaZibkZghg_kdhevdh\_jkbc
gZjlkdh]hwihkZ<wlhfkfuke_fh`gh]h\hjblvhnhevdehjghcljZ^bpbb
[`_^m]oZ[evkdbo]j_dh\bq_jd_kh]Z_\dZdhqZklbh[s_Z^u]kdhcnhevdehjghc
ljZ^bpbb
DZdbhklZevgu_]hjpu[hevrbgkl\hZjfygb]j_dh\ZmeZaZgbfZehkv
k_evkdbfohayckl\hfH^gZdh³wlgbq_kdhc´ijhn_kkb_c^eygbo[ueZlhj]h\ey<
^hkh\_lkdbci_jbh^]j_db>_nl_jh\ubf_ebfZ]Zabg\khk_^g_fjmkkdhfk_e_
<_qgh_gug_k<_ebdh\_qgh_;_ehj_q_gkdh]hjZchgZDjZkgh^Zjkdh]hdjZy
FZ]Zabg\kZfhfZme_ijbgZ^e_`ZeZjfygZf²[jZlvyf;h]hkmb;_^jhkm
Dbjdhjh\uf<u[jZggZybfbwdhghfbq_kdZygbrZ\b^bfhfh`_l
jZkkfZljb\Zlvky\dZq_kl\_h^gh]hbanZdlhjh\kihkh[kl\mxsbobaheypbbh[_bo
]jmiiihkdhevdm\kbkl_f_p_gghkl_c³ZjbklhdjZlbq_kdh]h´ljZ^bpbhggh
gZ_a^gbq_kdh]hh[s_kl\ZZ^u]h\keh`behkvdjZcg_hljbpZl_evgh_hlghr_gb_
<hijhkhklZlmk_]j_dh\bZjfyg\gmljbZ^u]kdh]hh[s_kl\Z^h\hevgh
keh`_gbg_fh`_lkqblZlvkyhdhgqZl_evghjZaj_r_ggufGug_rgb_]j_dbZmeZ
gbq_]hg_ihfgylhk\h_ckhkeh\ghcijbgZ^e_`ghklb
<p_ehfjy^_kemqZ_\\ukrZyZ^u]kdZyagZlvdgyavyirbljZ^bpbhggh
jZkkfZljb\ZeZij_^klZ\bl_e_ckhpbZevghc\_jomrdbih^\eZklguobfgZjh^h\\
dZq_kl\_k\hbo\ZkkZeh\LZdgZijbf_jZo,u²dgyavymZ[ZabggZ^dhlhjufb
Z^u]blZd`_mklZgh\bebk\h_ihdjh\bl_evkl\hihij_^klZ\e_gbyfihke_^gbo
ijbjZ\gb\ZebkvdZ^u]kdhfmkhkeh\bxle_dhle_r_c<wlhcb_jZjobbq_jd_kkdb_
]j_dbbZjfyg_nhjfZevghfh]eb[ulvlh^\hjygZfbgh[he__gbadh]hq_fmhjdb
jZg]ZmS_j[bgu²ma^_gb,ckl_i_gbS_j[bgZlhlnhdhleyfb
k\h[h^gufbdj_klvygZfb
<mihfygmlhfbf_gghfkibkd_klI_j_ykeh\kdhcnb]mjbjmxl^\_agZlgu_
]j_q_kdb_nZfbebb>_fbljh\uk_fvbb>hnlkbdh\uk_fvyIjbq_f
ih^q_jdb\Z_lkyqlhhgb³ihaZdm[Zgkdhfmh[uqZxihqblZxlkyaZ^\hjyggh
^hdmf_glh\g_bf__lkydjhf_gZklhys_]hqbgZ´=:DDnhi^e
Qbke_ghwlbnZfbebbij_\hkoh^ylhklZevguo]j_dh\³baijhkluo´^\_k_fvb
K_jZnbfh\uobh^gZ²DhdbkDj_ihklgufbmi_j_ykeh\kdbo]j_dh\[ueb
Z^u]bKj_^bq_jd_kh]Z_\³^\hjygkdb_´nZfbebb\klj_qZxlky_s_qZs_<lhc`_
klI_j_ykeh\kdhcgZ³ijhkluo´k_f_cijboh^blky³^\hjygkdbo´FuagZ_f
qlhba\hevghhlims_ggbdh\[u\rbodj_ihklguoq_jd_kh]Z_\:jfZ\bjZ
h[jZah\Zekyp_eucZ^u]_ckdbcZmeZMjmikdbcMki_gkdh]hjZchgZ
DjZkgh^ZjkdbcdjZc
<^Zevg_cr_fi_j_ykeh\kdb_Zjfygkdb_b]j_q_kdb_³^\hjyg_´[ueb
ijbagZgujmkkdhcZ^fbgbkljZpb_cbkhklZ\bebdZaZqvxklZjrbgm_kZmekhlgbd
ohjmg`bcmjy^gbdbkhhl\_lkl\mxsboklZgbp<Z;`_^m]oZ[evkblmZpbyfh]eZ
keh`blvkyih^jm]hfma^_kvZ[hjb]_ggZykbkl_fZkhkeh\bclZdbhklZeZkv[_a
\gbfZgbyjmkkdbo\eZkl_c<hafh`ghqlh\l_q_gb_ihke_^mxs_]hi_jbh^Z\
dhgl_dkl_m`_gh\hckhpbhdmevlmjghcj_Zevghklbkhkeh\gh_iheh`_gb_f_klguo
]j_dh\lZdbg_hij_^_ebehkvGhfh`_l[ulvblhqlh^ZggZy]jmiiZ]j_dh\g_
agZeZk\hbo³^\hjygkdbo´k_f_c<hlebqb_hlZ^u]_cp_\]j_dbbZjfyg_
;`_^m]oZ[eygbdh]^Zg_kljhbebki_pbZevguodmgZpdboovZd,wsWlh²hq_gv
ijbf_qZl_evgucnZdl?klvZ^u]_ckdZyihkeh\bpZ³Mdh]hdmgZpdhcg_llh]haZ
^\hjygbgZg_kqblZxl´:^u]_ckdb_ihkeh\bpubih]h\hjdb
DZdba\_klgh]j_dbbZjfyg_²wlhlbibqgucijbf_j³^_fhdjZlbq_kdbo´
gZjh^h\\ihglbckdhdZ\dZakdhfj_]bhg_GZqbgZyihdjZcg_cf_j_kdhj_ggh]h
baf_g_gbybklhjbq_kdbomkeh\bc\;9\Z\[hevrbgkl\_]jmiiZjfyg_s_
jZgvr_mgboi_j_klZxlijhke_`b\ZlvkyihlhfdbpZjkdbobdgy`_kdbojh^h\
bkq_aZxlaZ\bkbfu_khkeh\bybihhlghr_gbxd]hkih^kl\mxs_fm
fmkmevfZgkdhfmkehxhgbklZgh\ylkyqZklvxh^gh]h[hevrh]hih^Zlgh]h
khkeh\by²jZcylh\\kemqZ_kZjfygZfb_klvg_kdhevdhbkdexq_gbcHq_\b^gh
qlhgZwlhfnhg_khpbZevgZyhj]ZgbaZpbyq_jd_kkdbo]j_dh\bZjfygij_^klZ\ey_l
kh[hcj_adbcdhgljZkl
Hq_gvljm^ghij_^iheh`blvohlybwlh]hg_evaybkdexqblviheghklvxqlh
gZk_\_jhaZiZ^ghfDZ\dZa_\kbem_]hi_jbn_jbcghklb\h[_bo]jmiiZo
khojZgbebkvdZdb_lhj_ebdlh\u_nhjfukhpbZevghc`bagbKdhj__\k_]hhgb
i_j_gyebghjfuk\h_chj]ZgbaZpbb__dh^mkhk_^_cZ^u]h\_keblhevdhg_
k\yaZgukgbfb_s_[he__l_kghc]_g_lbq_kdhck\yavxh[wlhfkf^Zevr_
IhdjZcg_cf_j_qZklv³^\hjygkdbo´k_f_ckj_^baZdm[Zgkdbo]j_dh\b
q_jd_kh]Z_\fh]eZknhjfbjh\Zlvky\j_amevlZl_hlghr_gbcZlZeuq_kl\Zf_`^m
gbfbbZ^u]kdbfbirbmhjdZfb<hedh\Z
=hjkdZyn_h^ZevgZyagZlvhl^Z\ZeZk\hbo^_l_cgZ\hkiblZgb_\k_fvb
dmiph\²Zjfygb]j_dh\;eZ]h^ZjymklZgh\b\rbfkylZdbfh[jZahfZlZeuq_kdbf
k\yayf\hkiblZl_ebihemqZebhkh[u_ijZ\Z\lhfqbke_[hevrb_ijb\be_]bb\
lhj]h\e_<hafh`ghwlhh[tykgy_lblhlnZdlqlhkj_^b³^\hjyg´mq_jd_kh]Z_\
\klj_qZxlkynZfbebbgZklhys_cagZlbZ^u]h\gZijbf_j;h]Zjkmdh\u
DZieZgh\uLZf[b_\uFgh]b_hq_\b^pubjZggb_bkke_^h\Zl_ebZ^u]h\]h\hjyl
h[h[uqZ_ih^h[ghci_j_^ZqbnZfbebbkjgZijbf_jmGh\bpdh]h³ih^\eZklgu_
dgya_cb^\hjygghkylh[udgh\_gghbfy]hkih^bgZk\h_]hdhlhjh_khojZgyxl
^Z`_ijbi_j_k_e_gbb´Gh\bpdbcpblih<hedh\Z
GZi_j\uoihjZo]j_dbbZjfyg_;`_^m]oZ[ey\g_rg_ihk\hbf
dmevlmjgufijbagZdZfkbevghg_hlebqZebkvhlhdjm`Zxs_]hZ^u]_ckdh]h
gZk_e_gby
<b^bfhi_j\hgZqZevgh^hfZkZdebmgwrohmq_jd_kkdbo]j_dh\[ueb
h[s_Z^u]kdh]hlbiZlmjemqgu_kkhehf_gghcdjur_cb^jIjbi_j_k_e_gbb\
ZmegZqZebaZdeZ^ghcl_ogbdhckljhblvjm[e_ggu_^_j_\yggu_^hfZwlZ`_
gh\ZpbyijZ\^Zj_^dhijhke_`b\Z_lkyb\jy^_Z^u]kdboZmeh\IhgZqZemlhevdh
^\_k_fvb\Zme_bf_eb[he__ij_klb`gu_dbjibqgu_^hfZihlbimjmkkdbo
>hfZkljhbebkvh^ghb^\modZf_jgufb<^Zevg_fm]emmkljZb\ZekyhqZ]k
³q_jd_kkdhcljm[hc´baie_lgyh[fZaZggh]h]ebghcIha`_\i_j\hcdhfgZl_gZ
aZiZ^ghcklhjhg_klZebmkljZb\ZlvdjZkgucm]heihh[jZapmjmkkdbo]^_
gZoh^beZkvbdhgZbeZfiZ^db<^hf_\u^_eyeZkvfm`kdZyb`_gkdZyiheh\bgu
WlZljZ^bpbybkq_aeZdf]]
DmogykljhbeZkvhl^_evghhl`beh]hihf_s_gbyIbsm]hlh\beb\f_^ghf
dhle_gZlj_gh`gbd_dZdba\_klghlZdb_lj_gh`gbdb[uebhq_gvjZkijhkljZg_gu
\[ulmk_\_jhdZ\dZakdbo]hjp_\<^Zevg_cr_foe_[klZeb\ui_dZlvhl^_evgh\
jmkkdhci_qb
Ihh^_`^_g_evay[uehhlebqblv]j_dh\hlZ^u]_cp_\IjZ\^Zhq_gv[ukljh
klZeZjZaebqZlvkyjblmZevgZyh^_`^ZkZ\ZgihdhcgbdZk\Z^_[gucdhklxf
g_\_kludhlhju_m]j_dh\^_eZebkvgZjmkkdbc_\jhi_ckdbcfZg_j\lh\j_fy
dZdZ^u]bijh^he`Zebbkihevah\ZlvboljZ^bpbhggu_nhjfu
Kbkl_fZiblZgby[ueZlZd`_Z^u]kdhc=j_dbkh[ex^Zebb\k_ibs_\u_
aZij_ludhlhju_dlhfm\j_f_gbkijbgylb_fbkeZfZihemqbebjZkijhkljZg_gb_
kj_^baZiZ^ghZ^u]kdboie_f_gK\bgvykqblZeZkvg_qbkluf`b\hlgufihwlhfm__
fykhkh\k_fg_mihlj_[eyehkv\ibsmIhkeh\ZfGB>_flbjh\hc__^_^bf_e
h[udgh\_gb_dhehlv\beZfbex[mxk\bgvxkemqZcghaZ[j_^rmx\boh]hjh^
=hjZa^hf_gvr_q_fk_cqZkmihlj_[eyebkibjlgu_gZibldb\lhfqbke_\h\j_fy
k\Z^_[guoaZklhebc
;`_^m]oZ[evkdb_]j_dbkh[ex^Zeb\k_hkgh\gu_ijZ\beZZ^u]kdh]hwlbd_lZ
DZdba\_klghZ^u]_cpudZdb^jm]b_k_\_jhdZ\dZakdb_]hjpub\hlebqb_hl
jmkkdbo]j_dh\Zjfygh[eZ^Zebkh[kl\_gghckeh`ghckbkl_fhcwlbd_lguoijZ\be
²Z^u]woZ[awgZijbf_jdh]^Z\^hfijboh^beb]hklb\k_fiheZ]Zehkv\klZlv
beb`_aZij_s_gh[uehi_j_oh^blvdhfmeb[h^hjh]mhkh[_gghfm`qbg_g_evay
[uehfm`mb`_g_\f_kl_ihy\eylvkygZmebp_bl^
Ihk\b^_l_evkl\mgZb[he__klZjuobgnhjfZglh\i_j\hgZqZevghdZdb
Z^u]_cpu]j_dbijZdlbdh\Zeb[jZdq_j_amfudZgb_Hl_p\k_lhc`_GB
>_flbjh\hcmdjZe__fZlvb`_gbekygZg_c?fmlh]^Z][uehe_l^\Z^pZlv
_ce_l<_]]wlZljZ^bpbyiheghklvxbkq_aZ_lbihke_^mxsb_
ihdhe_gbyhg_cm`_gbq_]hg_agZxlbhlghkylkyj_adhhljbpZl_evgh
K\hbfbkljmdlmjgufbhkh[_gghklyfbk\Z^v[Zq_jd_kkdbo]j_dh\ih\lhjyeZ
Z^u]kdbclbi³k\Z^v[ukhkdju\Zgb_f´bkihevamyl_jfbgFKb]hjkdh]h
Kb]hjkdbck\Z^_[gh_lhj`_kl\hbhkgh\gu_h[jy^uijhoh^yllhevdh\^hf_
`_gboZZg_g_\_klujh^bl_ebg_\_klug_ijboh^yl\^hf`_gboZ`_gbog_
ijbkmlkl\m_l\h\j_fyk\Z^v[u\kh[kl\_gghf^hf_Zmoh^bldk\hbf
jh^kl\_ggbdZfg_\_klZgZoh^blky\h\j_fyk\Z^v[u\^hf_`_gboZ\kiZevg_gh
kdjulZhlh\k_ogZ\_kvi_jbh^jblmZeZb^Ze___s_\l_q_gb_^\mog_^_evaZl_f
g_\_klmgZdhjhldbci_jbh^aZ[bjZxlh[jZlgh\jh^bl_evkdbc^hfijb^Zggh_
i_j_\haylihke_k\Z^v[ubk\yau\Zxlwlhkijbfbj_gb_fklhjhgihke_mfudZgby
q_j_a]h^fheh^u_\ha\jZsZxlky\^hfg_\_kluba[_]Zgb_fheh^hck\_djZb
^jm]bojh^kl\_ggbdh\fm`Z^eblky\kx`bagv
I_j\h_\j_fy\h[jy^Zok\Z^_[gh]hpbdeZkh[kl\_gghk\Z^v[_
[`_^m]oZ[evkdbo]j_dh\_s_hsmlbfu[uebfgh]b_qbklhZ^u]kdb_jblmZevgh
b]jh\u_we_f_gludhgghkihjlb\gu_khklyaZgby\h\j_fyi_j_\haZg_\_klu\^hf
`_gboZ[hjv[ZaZkZnvygh\mxdh`mkmqZklb_f\_joh\uortha_ov[hc\kZ^gbdh\
^m[bgZfbijbijb[eb`_gbbd^hfm`_gboZdthjw]taZmHq_gvkdhjh\kljmdlmjm
]j_q_kdhck\Z^_[ghch[jy^ghklb\hrebgh\Zpbbk\yaZggu_kjZkijhkljZg_gb_f
\ebygbyojbklbZgkdhcp_jd\b\jblmZei_j_\haZg_\_klu[ueh\dexq_gh\_gqZgb_
\p_jd\bdthjw]taZmgZqbgZekyg_ij_f_gghihke_\ha\jZs_gbybap_jd\bkZfZ
k\Z^v[Zl_i_jvijb\yau\ZeZkvddZe_g^ZjghfmpbdemojbklbZgkdboijZa^gbdh\
ihke_k\Z^v[ufheh^mxklZebaZ[bjZlv\hlph\kdbc^hfaZg_^_ex^hgZqZeZ
FZke_gbpu
<h[jy^ZoihohjhgghihfbgZevgh]hpbdeZ]hjZa^hljm^g__\u^_eblv
bkdhgguckehcbgh\ZpbbHq_\b^ghwlZh[eZklvdmevlmjugZb[he__l_kgh
khijy`_gZkqbklhb^_heh]bq_kdbfbp_gghklyfbbdZdgbdZdZy^jm]ZyaZ\bkblhl
dhgn_kkbhgZevguomkeh\bcM`_\[ulghklvGB>_flbjh\hc]j_dbZmeZ
ohjhgbebk\hbomf_jrbo\]jh[mgZfh]bemklZ\bebdj_kl\lh\j_fydZd
Z^u]_cpuihevah\ZebkvlhevdhkZ\ZghfZ\h\k_f^jm]hfihklmiZeb\
khhl\_lkl\bbkij_^ibkZgbyfbbkeZfZDjhf_lh]hm]j_dh\g_[uehgbdZdbo
h]jZgbq_gbcgZihk_s_gb_deZ^[bsZ`_gsbgZfb
WlbljZ^bpbbg_fh]eb[ulvhq_gv^Z\gbfbihkdhevdmkiZ^_gb_f
<baZglbbbmoh^hf]_gmwap_\;9\²ihke_^gboih\j_f_gbojbklbZggZ
k_\_jhaZiZ^ghfDZ\dZa_ojbklbZgkl\ha^_kvkbevghmklmibehk\hbihabpbb
GZdZgmg_mklZgh\e_gbydhgljheyjmkkdbo\:^u]__m`_g_[uehojbklbZgkdbo
deZ^[bsdmevlh\uoh[t_dlh\gZk_e_gb_gZoh^behkv\g_\ebygbyp_jd\b
IhfbgZebihdhcgh]hgZ^_\yluc^_gvfZnb[o³^g_c´fZnw³^_gv´b
[]tm³^_\ylv´khjhdh\hc^_gvfZnZlnhqbln³^g_ckhjhd´l,hd,bl,m³khjhd´b
gZ ]h^h\sbgm;ebadb_h[yaZl_evghghkbebljZmjgmxh^_`^mq_jgh]hp\_lZDjhf_
wlh]h\agZdljZmjZ\l_q_gb_^g_cfm`qbgug_[jbebkvGhlh`_kZfh_ih
k\_^_gbyfbgnhjfZglh\[uehoZjZdl_jghb^eyihfbgZevguoljZ^bpbckhk_^gbo
Z^u]_cp_\Bgl_j_kghqlh\^jm]bojZchgZo:^u]_bi_j\u_ihfbgdbmkljZb\Zeb
g_gZ^_\ylucZgZk_^vfhc^_gvfZnb[e³^g_c´fZnw³^_gv´b[eu³k_fv´
BlZdihke_hibkZgby^Z`_lZdh]hih\_joghklgh]hi_j_^gZfbij_^klZ_l
hq_gvk\h_h[jZagZywlgbq_kdZyh[sghklvkhkhagZgb_fkh[kl\_gghcb^_glbqghklb
bkiheg_crbfhlkmlkl\b_fwlgbq_kdbfZjdbjh\Zgguowe_f_glh\dmevlmju
\dexqZyyaudHq_\b^ghlh`_kZfh_fh`ghkdZaZlvb\hlghr_gbbq_jd_kkdbo
ZjfyggZjZgg_fwlZi_bokms_kl\h\Zgbyiha^g__\:jfZ\bj_dZdfu\b^_ebm
gbo\k_lZdb\hagbdZ_lg_qlhki_pbnbq_kdh_ihdjZcg_cf_j_\yaud_H^bgba
i_j\uohq_\b^p_\ihk_lb\rbowlm]jmiimBOhajh\hlf_qZe³LZfhrgb_Zjfyg_
gbq_fg_hlebqZxlkyhlq_jd_kh\²lhl`_yaudh[uqZbgjZ\udmrZgvy
^hfZrgyyml\Zjvbh^_`^Z:jfygkdh]hyaudZg_agZxlbl_bf_xlg_[hevrh_
ihgylb_h\_j_dhlhju_gZoh^ylky\qZkluokghr_gbyokZjfygZfb`b\msbfb\
Q_jghfhjbb´Ohajh\
OhlylZdhclbidmevlmjub\u]ey^bl^eyh[u^_ggh]hkhagZgbyq_flh
g_ijb\uqguf\k_`_hgij_^klZ\ey_lkh[hc^h\hevghjZkijhkljZg_ggh_y\e_gb_\
ihglbckdhdZ\dZakdhfj_]bhg_<gmljbqmlvebg_dZ`^hc[hevrhc
wlghdmevlmjghch[sghklb_klvihoh`b_\kljmdlmjghfhlghr_gbb]jmiiu
[Zp[bcpub]jmabgkdb__\j[b\khklZ\_]jmabgahdbm^bgulZluojbklbZg_\
khklZ\_ZjfyggZjh^u³rZo^Z]kdhc]jmiiu´lZlufmkmevfZg_Zcjmfum
Za_j[Zc^`Zgp[\bl^
H[uqghih^jZamf_\Z_lkyqlh\hagbdgh\_gb_bobbfih^h[guoy\ey_lky
j_amevlZlhf^Ze_dhaZr_^r_]hijhp_kkZZkkbfbeypbbi_j\hgZqZevgh
³iheghp_ggh]h´wlgbq_kdh]hfZl_jbZeZGh\hlijbf_jkdhlhjuffuklhedgmebkv
\h\j_fywdki_^bpbb\:a_j[Zc^`Zgb>Z]_klZg²lg]hjkdb__\j_b<l_q_gb_
ihke_^g_ckhlgbe_lhgb`b\mlhl^_evgufb]jmiiZfbkj_^bjZaebqguogZjh^h\
m^bgk<ZjlZr_ggug_H]ma\k_\_jhaZiZ^ghcqZklb:a_j[Zc^`ZgZ
Za_j[Zc^`Zgp_\]Dm[Z\k_Z_jh\hkjhqghcqZklb:a_j[Zc^`ZgZ^Zj]bgp_\k
FZ^`Zebk\>Z]_klZg[
b^j
<dZ`^hfkemqZ_]hjkdb__\j_bdZdbq_jd_kkdb_]j_db\dmevlmjghfhlghr_gbb
ihqlbg_\u^_ey_fubakj_^udhlhjmxkhklZ\eyxlkhk_^b
n 2
2
$I
;I
˚ ˚
;I
$I
:2
2
I
I
I
• ` ` `
;I
2
I
2
$I
˙ l\_gghaZ\bkys_]hhlb^_heh]bb
bm^ZbafZZlZd`_hkh[h]hbjZgkdh]hyaudZghdhlhjuclh`_³g_k\hc´ihkdhevdm
y\ey_lkyjh^guf_s_^eyZjfyghlZlh\lZlh\ojbklbZglZlh\kmggblh\blZlh\
rbblh\
>_ckl\b_fh^gbolhevdhZkkbfbeypbhgguoijhp_kkh\g_h[tykgblvihq_fm
\dZ`^hfbakemqZ_\]hjkdb__\j_b\h^bgZdh\hckl_i_gbihl_jyeb³k\hx´
dmevlmjmbhdZaZebkvZkkbfbebjh\ZggufbkhklhjhgugZjh^h\klhevjZaguoih
dmevlmjghfmihl_gpbZembqbke_gghklb<bm^Zbd_[ulm_lkl_j_hlbikh]eZkgh
dhlhjhfmij_^dbgug_rgbo_\j__\[uebdh]^Zlh³ghjfZevguf´gZjh^hf
h[eZ^Zxsbfk\h_cljZ^bpbhgghck_evkdhcdmevlmjhcgh\ihke_^kl\bb`b\y\
mj[Zgbklbq_kdhckj_^_iha^g_cJbfkdhcbfi_jbbbebkj_^g_\_dh\hcAZiZ^ghc
?\jhiumljZlbeb__ih^h[gh^jm]bf]hjh^kdbfh[s_kl\Zf=hjkdb__\j_b\k\h_f
[hevrbgkl\_y\eyxlkylbibqgufk_evkdbfgZk_e_gb_fihwlhfmnZdlhj
mj[ZgbaZpbba^_kvlZd`_g_^_ckl\m_lHq_\b^ghke_^m_lij_^iheh`blvqlhwlZ
h[sghklvh[eZ^Z_lg_dhcihklhygghckljmdlmjhcba³yq__d´dZ`^Zybadhlhjuo
khhl\_lkl\m_llhcbebbghcnmgdpbbg_h[oh^bfhc^ey\u`b\Zgbygh\k_]^Z
aZihegy_lkybghc\g_rg_cdmevlmjhch[jZamykg_ck\h_h[jZaguckbf[bha
Ihwlhfmb]_g_abklZdhch[sghklbfh`ghij_^klZ\blvkh\_jr_gghih
^jm]hfmdZdijhp_kkijhlb\hiheh`gucihgZijZ\e_gghklb\f_klhjZajmr_gby
bkoh^ghcp_ehklghklbknhjfbjh\Z\r_ckydmevlmjuih^\g_rgbf\ha^_ckl\b_f
Zkkbfbeypbbkhklhjhguqm`^hcdmevlmjghckj_^ugZh[hjhlh[jZah\Zgb_
gZjZsb\Zgb_gZhkgh\_ihke_^g_cgh\hcdmevlmjghcp_ehklghklbl_kghk\yaZgghc
kwlhckj_^hc\k_ck\h_cldZgvxgh\f_kl_kl_fq_ldh\u^_eyxs_ck_[y
[eZ]h^ZjydZdhfmeb[hgh\hfm^bnn_j_gpbjmxs_fmnZdlhjmgZijbf_jj_eb]bb
B]hjkdb__\j_bbq_jd_kkdb_]j_dbhq_gvgZihfbgZxl
wlghdhgn_kkbhgZevgu_h[sghklbljZ^bpbhggh\u^_ey_fu_\gZr_c
wlgh]jZnbq_kdhcebl_jZlmj_GhgZ^hihfgblvqlhk\hyhkh[Zydhgn_kkby^ey
dZ`^hcbagbo^eyq_jd_kkdbo]j_dh\hkh[_ggh\_ebqbgZg_ihklhyggZy;ueb
p_eu_i_jbh^udh]^Zhgbg_nZdlbq_kdbZebrvghfbgZevgh\u^_eyebkvwlbf
ijbagZdhfgZnhg_khk_^_c<ij_^dhglZdlguci_jbh^q_jd_kkdb_]j_db\b^bfh
\hh[s_bf_ebhq_gvkfmlgu_ij_^klZ\e_gbyhojbklbZgkl\_Hgbg_agZeb
p_jdh\gh]hdZe_g^ZjybijZa^gbdh\bkdexqZyfh`_l[ulvIZkom\h\j_fy
dhlhjhcj_aZebbijbghkbeb\`_jl\m[ZjZgZdtmjfwg<h\kydhfkemqZ_\j_qb
^Z`_kZfuoklZjuobgnhjfZglh\aZbkdexq_gb_fl_jfbgZ³mlu`v´
Zkkhpbbjmxs_]hkykIZkohc\k_hklZevgu_ijZa^gbdbgZau\Zxlkyjmkkdbfb
keh\Zfb>jm]b_\hajZklgu_]jmiiuij_^ihqblZxlmihlj_[eylvjmkkdbcl_jfbgb
\wlhf_^bgkl\_gghfkemqZ_
KZfhkeh\h³mlu`v´\_jhylghg_lhqghaZnbdkbjh\Zghb\h\k_okemqZyok
ljm^hfih^^Z_lkywlbfheh]bbmlu`vmlu`vug³i_j_fhehlblvqlheb[h´mlug
³h[fhehlblv´beb`_mlow`vmlowg³[jua]Zlv´k`v²kmnnbdkhf
\ha\jZlgh]hagZq_gby<lhjhc\ZjbZglbgl_j_k_gl_fqlhmq_jd_kh]Z_\
aZnbdkbjh\Zgihoh`bcihgZa\ZgbxijZa^gbd³Ikuml`´iku³\h^Z´bmlowg²
lhl`_kZfuc]eZ]hekhagZq_gb_f³[jua]Zlv´\h\j_fydhlhjh]h[uehijbgylh
h[eb\Zlv^jm]^jm]Z\h^hcqlhgZihfbgZ_lj_fbgbkp_gpbbojbklbZgkdh]h
ijZa^gbdZ<hag_k_gby<Zj^Z\ZjL_jKZjdbkygp:jZd_eyg
K^jm]hcklhjhgum>m[jh\bgZZ\lhjZ,,hcihe;,;\klj_fys_]hky
ihdZaZlvi_j_`bldbojbklbZgkl\ZmZ^u]h\gZoh^bf³ijZa^gh\Zebdmlbr—
iZkomb\wlhl^_gvycpZkhklZ\eyebg_ij_f_ggmxijbgZ^e_`ghklvklheZlhqgh
lZd`_dZdg_[hevrhcir_gbqgucdjm]eucoe_[kbah[jZ`_gb_flj_o]heh\´
>m[jh\bg
HklZ_lkyg_ykguf\dZdb_nhjfuh[e_dZebkv\aZbfgu_
ijhlb\hihklZ\e_gbyq_jd_kkdbo]j_dh\bZjfyg^jm]^jm]mZlZd`_hdjm`Zxsbf
Z^u]_ckdbfie_f_gZf\i_jbh^udh]^Zdhgn_kkbhgZevgu_]jZgbf_`^mgbfb
gZqbgZebklbjZlvky<b^bfh\lZdbokblmZpbyoi_j\hkl_i_ggmxjhevb]jZeZ
bklhjbq_kdZyiZfylvH[_]jmiiuaZgyebhij_^_e_ggmxyq_cdmkhkeh\gmx
wdhghfbq_kdmxie_f_ggmx\hq_gvb_jZjobabjh\Zgghckljmdlmj_Z^u]kdh]h
h[s_kl\Zbwlh[uehij_iylkl\b_f^eyboihegh]hjZafu\Zgby
<k_kgh\Zihf_gyehkvkgZjmr_gb_f[ZeZgkZ\g_rgbokbeJhkkby\ureZd
DZ\dZamWlhih\e_dehaZkh[hcj_Zdpbxkhklhjhguf_klguo]hjp_\
ijhy\b\rmxky\lhfqbke_b\jZklms_fbgl_j_k_dbkeZfmDhgn_kkbhgZevgh
hdjZr_ggh_h[s_kl\hZ^u]h\ijbh[j_eh[he__`_kldmxkljmdlmjmb\ulhedgmeh
bak\h_ckj_^ufZj]bgZevgu_ihkms_kl\m]jmiiu]j_dh\bZjfygdhlhju_k
wlhcihjuklZgh\ylky]ymjZfbgZijbf_jlZdgZau\Zekyba\_klgucZjfygkdbcZme
kj_^bl_fbj]h_\p_\²>`ZmjovZ[e
Ihkeh\ZfGB>_flbjh\hc_s___^_^\b^bfhh^bgbai_j\hihk_e_gp_\
ZmeZihk\hbf\a]ey^Zfbijb\uqdZf[ue[eb`_dfmkmevfZgZfZ^u]_cpZfgh
m`_hl_pklZe³gZklhysbfijZ\hkeZ\guf´GZ^_gv]b[h]Zlh]hq_jd_kkdh]h
ZjfygbgZ;Zjhdh\Zihkljhbeb[hevrmxp_jdh\vG_kfhljygZlhqlh\Zme_
ij_h[eZ^Zebg_Zjfyg_Z]j_db²p_jdh\v[ueZZjfygh]jb]hjbZgkdhc
<hh[s_gZ^hkdZaZlvqlhdZdb\Ihgl_Zjfyg_AZdm[ZgvyjZgvr_b
Zdlb\g__\dexqbebkv\ijhp_kk\hkklZgh\e_gbyojbklbZgkl\Z\gmljbk\hboh[sbg
?s_\kZfhfgZqZe_;,;\ba\_klgucZjfyghdZlhebq_kdbcmq_gucbijhk\_lbl_ev
FbgZk;`rdygihk_lb\rbch^gm]jmiimq_jd_kh]Z_\`b\rbohdheh:gZiu
\klj_lbemgboZjfygkdbok\ys_ggbdh\;`rdyg<]kfbkkbhg_jkdhc
p_evx\Q_jd_kkbxijb[ueZjobfZg^jblDZjZi_l:jpb\ygdhlhjuck]
h[hkgh\Zeky\?dZl_jbgh^Zj_Zihke_khkj_^hlhq_gbyq_jd_kh]Z_\\:jfZ\bj_\
]i_j__oZelm^ZFZl_gZ^ZjZgjmd‹Ih]hkyg
I_j\h_\j_fyk\ys_ggbd[`_^m]oZ[evkdhcp_jd\bijb_a`Zeba:jfZ\bjZ
aZl_f\Zme_ihy\bekyk\hcf_klguck\ys_ggbdZjfygbg²hl_pbgnhjfZglZ
<_juOZg`b_\hcIjboh`ZgZfbZmevkdhcp_jd\b[uebbZjfyg_b]j_db
OjbklbZgkdZyb^_heh]by[ukljhaZljhgmeZjZaebqgu_h[eZklbbodmevlmju<k_
q_jd_kkdb_]j_dbklZebdj_klblvk\hbo^_l_cklZjZykv^_eZlvwlhdh]^Zj_[_gdm
_s_g_bkihegbehkvh^gh]h]h^ZH[yaZl_evgufwe_f_glhfk\Z^_[gh]hjblmZeZ
klZeh\_gqZgb_\p_jd\bMf_jr_]hl_i_jvhli_\ZebZgZihohjhguijb]eZrZeb
k\ys_ggbdZH^jm]boj_amevlZlZo\ebygbyp_jd\b]h\hjbehkv\ur_
Ih^\ha^_ckl\b_ffbkkbhg_jkdhcijhiZ]Zg^u]j_dbbZjfyg_;`_^m]oZ[ey
klZebhkhagZ\Zlvk\hbdhgn_kkbhgZevgu_jZaebqbyG_kfhljygZlhqlh\h\j_fy
k\Z^v[u]j_db\_gqZebkvh[uqgh\f_klghcZjfygkdhcp_jd\bhgbklZjZebkv
dj_klblvbhli_\Zlvihdhcgbdh\ihijZ\hkeZ\ghfmdZghgm>eywlh]hijb]eZrZeb
jmkkdh]hk\ys_ggbdZba[eb`Zcr_cijZ\hkeZ\ghcp_jd\b\gZqZe_bawdhghfbb
;h]Zjkmdh\ZaZl_fbak<_qgh_DZdb\^jm]bof_klZokh\f_klgh]hijh`b\Zgby\
hlebqb_hlijZ\hkeZ\guo]j_dh\Zjfyg_gZqZebklZ\blvgZfh]be_dj_kl\]heh\_
Zg_\gh]Zomih]j_[_ggh]hGZijhlb\]j_q_kdb_bgnhjfZgluih^q_jdb\Zxlqlh
boij_^db\hlebqb_hlZjfyg[hevr__\gbfZgb_m^_eyebijZa^gh\Zgbx
Jh`^_kl\ZOjbklh\Z
<f_kl_kl_fihkdhevdmijhp_kkojbklbZgbaZpbbh[_bo]jmii\
agZqbl_evghckl_i_gbaZ\bk_ehlkemqZcguoh[klhyl_evkl\wlhjZaf_`_\Zgb_reh
hq_gvg_ihke_^h\Zl_evghLZdb]j_dbbZjfyg_klZeb^_j`Zlv\^hfZojmkkdb_
bdhgug_kfhljygZlhqlhboihqblZgb_g_oZjZdl_jgh^eyZjfygkdhcp_jd\b
Hq_\b^ghih^\ebygb_fijZ\hkeZ\by[`_^m]oZ[evkdb_Zjfyg_gZqZebmkljZb\Zlv
ihfbgdbg_gZk_^vfhc^_gvZgZ^_\ylucmZjfZ\bjkdboq_jd_kh]Z_\
ihfbgZevguc^_gvijboh^bekygZk_^vfhc^_gvlZd`_dZdbmhklZevguo]jmii
Zjfyg:jZd_eygL_jKZjdbkygpG_bkdexq_ghqlh
hij_^_e_ggufhldehg_gb_fhlijZ\hkeZ\guoljZ^bpbc\klhjhgmfhghnbkblkl\Z
[uehlhqlhq_jd_kkdb_]j_dbhq_gv^he]hijh^he`Zebkh\_jrZlvgZIZkom
`_jl\hijbghr_gb_^Z`_\ijbkmlkl\b_ijZ\hkeZ\gh]hk\ys_ggbdZohlywlhfh]eh
h[tykgylvkyb^jm]bfbijbqbgZfbgZijbf_j\ebygb_fbkeZfZq_j_aZ^u]h\
<i_jbh^kh\_lbaZpbbp_jdh\v\Zme_[ueZaZdjulZk\ys_ggbdi_j__oZe\
kl;_ehj_q_gkdmxIj_j\Zebkv\k_k\yabkZjfZ\bjkdhcp_jdh\ghch[sbghc
H^gZdhb\gh\uoagZqbl_evghhkeh`gb\rbokyb^_heh]bq_kdbomkeh\byo
[`_^m]oZ[evkdb_]j_dbbZjfyg_ijh^he`Zebdj_klblv^_l_c\_gqZlvkyhli_\Zlv
ihdhcgbdh\Mqblu\ZyjZkklhygb_kZfhc^hklmighc^eyh[_bo]jmiiklZeZjmkkdZy
p_jdh\v\k<_qgh_Wlhijb\_ehdk]eZ`b\Zgbxdhgn_kkbhgZevguojZaebqbc
f_`^mijZ\hkeZ\b_fbZjfygkdbfbkih\_^Zgb_fb_s_[he__mkbebeh
\aZbfhijhgbdgh\_gb_ljZ^bpbc
<mkeh\byoJhkkbckdhcbfi_jbbhlghr_gbydijZ\hkeZ\bxdZdd
]hkm^Zjkl\_gghcb^_heh]bbbhj]ZgbaZpbhggh]hih^qbg_gby\k_oijZ\hkeZ\guo
p_jd\_cJmkkdhcp_jd\bojbklbZgbaZpbyq_jd_kkdbo]j_dh\g_fh]eZhagZqZlvbo
wlgbq_kdh]hh[hkh[e_gbyLZdbfnZdlhjhfghm`_\dhgl_dkl_kh\_lkdhc
gZpbhgZevghciheblbdbo]]klZehyaudh\h_kljhbl_evkl\h
Kfhf_glZhkgh\Zgby\Zme_gbdh]^Zg_[uehZ^u]_ckdhcrdheuKh\_lkdh_
jmdh\h^kl\hihiulZehkvhj]Zgbah\Zlvij_ih^Z\Zgb_]j_q_kdh]hyaudZ>eywlh]h
[ueZhldjulZrdheZjmkkdZy^hdeZkkZkij_ih^Z\Zgb_fgZpbhgZevgh]hyaudZ\
ihke_^mxsbodeZkkZobijbkeZgij_ih^Z\Zl_ev²DhgklZglbgI_ljZdlbklbk
Wlhlq_eh\_dku]jZehij_^_e_ggmxjhev\weebgbaZpbb[`_^m]oZ[evkdbo]j_dh\
Hgg_lhevdhij_ih^Z\Ze]j_q_kdbcyaudghbh[mqZe]j_q_kdbfi_kgyfblZgpZf
\uklmiZe\jhebdj_klgh]hhlpZijbkmlkl\h\ZegZk\Z^v[Zo\dZq_kl\_
jZkihjy^bl_eylZfZ^ubl^Iha`_]j_q_kdbcyaudij_ih^Z\ZeZlZd`_FmjZ
DhklZgh\Zijb_oZ\rZybakF_jqZgkdh]h]^_dlhfm\j_f_gbq_jd_kkdb_]j_db
[uebm`_iheghklvxweebgbabjh\Zgu
RdheZkij_ih^Z\Zgb_f]j_q_kdh]hyaudZ\Z;`_^m]oZ[ev[ueZaZdjulZ\h
\j_fyklZebgkdboj_ij_kkbc]ZDI_ljZdlbklbkih^\_j]ky\uk_e_gbxWlh
h[klhyl_evkl\hZlZd`_j_adh_m\_ebq_gb_^hebjmkkdh]hgZk_e_gby\
ihke_\h_gguci_jbh^hldjueh\hafh`ghklb^ey^Zevg_cr_cjmkbnbdZpbb
q_jd_kkdbo]j_dh\gZqZ\r_ckykboojbklbZgbaZpb_c_s_\^hkh\_lkdbci_jbh^
K_]h^gy[`_^m]oZ[evkdb_]j_dbijZdlbq_kdb\k_jmkkdhyauqgu
:^u]_ckdbcyaudbagboagZxlebrv^\Zq_eh\_dZ:e_dkZg^jDhklZgh\]
jh`^[jZlihdhcgh]hibkZl_ey>fbljbyDhklZgh\ZbGbgZBevbgbqgZ
>_flbjh\Z]jh`^²klZj_crbc`bl_evZmeZ<kF_jqZgkdh_
kjZ\gbl_evghg_^Z\ghmf_jeZGxgy>_flbjh\Z²_s_h^gZq_jd_kkdZy]j_qZgdZ
]h\hjysZyihZ^u]_ckdb?^bgbpui_j_k_eb\rb_ky\FZcdhib\ihke_^kl\bb
khklZ\b\rb_kf_rZggu_k_fvbiheghklvxjZkl\hjbebkvkj_^bZ^u]_cp_\
=j_q_kdbcyaudbagug_rgbo[`_^m]oZ[evkdbo]j_dh\g_agZ_lgbdlhf_jqZgkdb_
>_flbjh\udZdm`_hlf_qZehkvgZh[hjhl]j_dhyauqgulhqg__^\myauqgu\eZ^_y
lZd`_jmkkdbf
Hkl_i_gbbgl_]jbjh\Zgghklbjmkkdh]hyaudZ\fure_gb_bdmevlmjm
[`_^m]oZ[evkdbo]j_dh\k\b^_l_evkl\m_lke_^mxsbcijbf_j^Z`_klZj_crbc
bgnhjfZglGB>_flbjh\ZimlZ_lihgylby³dj_klblvky´\kfuke_³^_eZlv
dj_klgh_agZf_gb_´b³ijZa^gbdDj_s_gby=hkih^gy´mihlj_[eyy^eybo
h[hagZq_gbyh^bgblhl`_Z^u]_ckdbcl_jfbg^umvwg^umvw³fhebl\Z´
³aZdebgZgb_´baZjZ[q_j_almjGXD³fhebl\Z´kjZ[oZaZ^ZmovZ³fhebl\Z´
³aZdebgZgb_´RZ]bjh\lhk_l^mZ³fhebl\Z´Z[Za^mZ³fhebl\Z´
³Zfme_l´RZ]bjh\lDZdhlf_qZe\k\h_\j_fy;:Mki_gkdbc
³h^gbfbahij_^_eyxsboijbagZdh\jmkkdh]hj_eb]bhagh]hkhagZgby
ij_^klZ\ey_lkylhh[klhyl_evkl\hqlhkeh\h³dj_klblvky´_kl_kl\_gghk\yau\Z_lky
\yaud_khkeh\hf³dj_kl´Mki_gkdbc>eykjZ\g_gbygZijbf_j\
]j_q_kdhflZdZyk\yavhlkmlkl\m_lσταυρος ³dj_kl´bβαπτισµα³dj_s_gb_´bl^
<hkijbgy\jmkkdbcyauddmevlmjZ[`_^m]oZ[evkdbo]j_dh\hdZaZeZkv
k\yaZgghck[he__fhsghcjmkkdhcbhq_gv[ukljhklZeZ__qZklvxGZkf_gm
Z^u]_ckdbfljZ^bpbyfijbrebljZ^bpbbhdjm`Zxs_]hjmkkdh]hgZk_e_gby<
gZklhys__\j_fyk\Z^v[Zihohjhguihfbgdb]j_dh\ZmeZl_`_qlhbmf_klguo
jmkkdbo?s_kh\k_fg_^Z\ghgZklZjucGh\uc]h^lhqghlZd`_dZdbjmkkdb_
]j_q_kdb_^_\mrdb]Z^ZebkijZrb\Zy^jm]m^jm]Z³DZdfh_]h`_gboZa\Zlv"´
oh^bebih^hfZfbdhey^h\Zebkhkeh\Zfb³K_x\_xihk_\Zx´bl^bli
?^bgkl\_ggh_qlh^hkboihjohlvdZdlh\g_rg_\u^_ey_lbobah[s_ckj_^u²
wlhijb\_j`_gghklvklZjr_]hihdhe_gbydg_dhlhjufZ^u]_ckdbf[ex^Zfb
ghjfZfwlbd_lZ
Ih^h[gmxmqZklvbkiulZebbq_jd_kh]ZbdZd[`_^m]oZ[evkdb_lZdb
ZjfZ\bjkdb_dhlhju_g_kfhljygZk\hx[hevrmxqbke_gghklv\agZqbl_evghc
f_j_lZd`_jZkl\hjbebkv\jmkkdhcdmevlmj_
QlhdZkZ_lkywlgbq_kdhcb^_glbqghklbkh\j_f_gguoq_jd_kkdbo]j_dh\lh
ihke_g_kdhevdboihke_\h_gguo^_kylbe_lbc^hfbgbjh\ZgbykhagZgby
kh[kl\_gghcijbh[s_gghklbdh[s_jmkkdhcdmevlmjghch[sghklbijb
iZkihjlbaZpbb[hevrbgkl\hij_^klZ\bl_e_cwlhc]jmiiu[uehaZibkZgh
³jmkkdbfb´\_]]dZd[m^lhgZf_lbekyhij_^_e_ggucwlgbq_kdbcj_g_kkZgk
>_lbgZrbobgnhjfZglh\\kmsghklbihemdjh\dbebr_ggu_\k_owlgbq_kdbo
ijbagZdh\aZy\eyebhk\h_f`_eZgbb\hkklZgh\blv]j_q_kdmx³gZpbhgZevghklv´\
iZkihjl_\umqblv]j_q_kdbcyaudb^j
Q_jd_kkdb_]j_db[uebbhklZxlky[_kibkvf_gghcdmevlmjhch
lbiheh]bq_kdbojZaebqbyof_`^mibkvf_ggufbb[_kibkvf_ggufbdmevlmjZfb
kfEhlfZg<k_bagbo]jZfhlgugZjmkkdhfyaud_bg_dhlhju_²gZ
Z^u]_ckdhfbabokj_^u\ur_eZ^u]hyauqgucibkZl_ev>fbljbcDhklZgh\
H^gZdhkh\_jr_gghhq_\b^ghqlhkh[kl\_gghcibkvf_gghcljZ^bpbbmgbo
ihijhklmgbdh]^Zg_kms_kl\h\Zeh<wlhck\yabhkh[ucbgl_j_kij_^klZ\ey_llh\
dZdhckl_i_gbjZagu_khpbZevgu_kehbbebkm[dmevlmjugZijbf_jfm`kdZyb
`_gkdZyhl\_lkl\_gguaZljZgkeypbxljZ^bpbcghjfZevgh_nmgdpbhgbjh\Zgb_
iZfylbdmevlmju
Ijbbamq_gbb]hjkdbo_\j__\fu\b^_ebqlhmgbogZ[ex^Z_lkyq_ldh_
ijhlb\hihklZ\e_gb_fm`kdhcb`_gkdhckm[dmevlmjIjbq_ffm`kdZykm[dmevlmjZ
\uklmiZ_ldZdhnbpbZevgZybm^Zbklbq_kdZyZ`_gkdZydZd²g_hnbpbZevgZy
^_b^_heh]babjh\ZggZy<hlebqb_hl_\jhi_ckdbo_\j__\a^_kv`_gsbgZf\h\k_
[uehaZij_s_gh\oh^blv\kbgZ]h]mmqblvkydgb`ghklbbmqZkl\h\Zlv\^_eZo
dmevlZWlhijb\_ehdlhfmqlhijh\h^gbdZfbdhgn_kkbhgZevgh]hj_g_kkZgkZ
dhlhjucm]hjkdbo_\j__\lZd`_gZqZekykijboh^hfjmkkdbo[uebbkdexqbl_evgh
fm`qbguGZf\klj_qZebkv`_gsbgudhlhjufihjZagufijbqbgZfg_m^Zehkv
kha^Zlvk_fvbb\k_hgbgZoh^bebkv\Z[khexlghfg_\_^_gbbhlghkbl_evghh[sbo
bm^Zbklbq_kdboljZ^bpbcGZijbf_jh^gZ]hjkdZy_\j_cdZiulZeZkvh[tykgblv
qlhihklZ\Z[uemklZgh\e_gihke_lh]hdZd`_gsbgZihbf_gbFZjvyfjh^beZ
kugh\_ch^bgbadhlhjuoy\beky[h]hfbwlhl[h][uem[blVLF
<hlghr_gbbq_jd_kkdbo]j_dh\b\wlhfkemqZ_fh`ghijh\_klb
hij_^_e_ggmxZgZeh]bxDkh`Ze_gbxdjhf_mihfygmlh]hbf_ggh]hkibkdZ
]j_dh\klI_j_ykeh\kdhc=:DDnhi^fug_jZkiheZ]Z_f
^jm]bfbgZ^_`gufbbklhqgbdZfbiha\heyxsbfbm\b^_lvgZkdhevdhjZagylkyih
kl_i_gb\hkijbbfqb\hklbgh\hcijZ\hkeZ\ghcb^_heh]bbfm`kdZyb`_gkdZy
km[dmevlmju>Zgguc^hdmf_gl\k_`_nbdkbjm_ljZaebqby\kihkh[ZoghfbgZpbb
ij_^klZ\bl_e_cjZaguoiheh\hajZklguo]jmii
]eZ\uk_f_c
e_l
>_fbljh\
bo[jZlvy
e_l
Ihlp_jd
Nhlbc
>_fbljh\
IZ\eh
>_fbljh\
bokugh\vy
e_l
B\Zg
Kl_iZg
bofZl_jb
e_l
QbZgZ
bok_klju
e_l
bo`_gu
e_l
GZ]h
e_l
N_h^hkby
RZnbr
GbdheZc
:e_dk_c
Bhkbn
FZjvy
?dZl_jbgZ
>bfbljbc
OZgbr
Dhr_nb`
GZaZjbc
Ihih\
DZkiZj
K_jZnbfh\
Kl_iZg
K_jZnbfh\
:gZklZk
Dhdbk
:nZgZkbc
K_f_g
Lh\^bj
L_h^hj
GZaZj
K_jZnbfh\
K_f_g
bo^hq_jb
B\Zg
F_edhg
:g^j_c
B\Zg
:fb^
?dZl_jbgZ
Dhr
;mdZr`_gZ
kugZB\ZgZ
?dZl_jbgZ
>hnlkbdh\K GbdheZc
_f_g
FboZceh
PZZpk"
QbZgZ
<k_fm`qbgui_j_ykeh\kdbo]j_dh\g_aZ\bkbfhhl\hajZklZm`_bf_xl
ojbklbZgkdb_bf_gZGZijhlb\ih^Z\eyxs__[hevrbgkl\h`_gsbg\kibkd_
ijb\h^blkybf_ggZa\ZghihZ^u]_ckdbblhevdhlj_lvbagbo\hkgh\ghf
^_\hqdbb`_gsbgufheh^h]h\hajZklZ²ghkblojbklbZgkdb_bf_gZWlhg_
fh`_l[ulvijhklhckemqZcghklvxihkdhevdmbklhqgbdhljZ`Z_l^Zggu_o
]];,;\l_\j_f_gbdh]^Zq_jd_kkdb_]j_dbgZoh^bebkv\l_kghfdhglZdl_k
jmkkdbfbm`_[he__ihem\_dZbjZamf__lky^he`gu[ueb[ulvdj_s_gu
ih]heh\ghIh\b^bfhfmq_jd_kkdb_]j_dblZd`_dZd]hjkdb__\j_b[ueb
hjb_glbjh\ZgugZijbhjbl_lgmxjhevfm`kdhckm[dmevlmjuBf_gghfm`qbguZ
g_`_gsbguy\eyebkvijh\h^gbdZfbgh\uol_g^_gpbcbkhklZ\eyebdhklyd\k_c
h[sghklb
F_`^mijhqbflZdZy³fm`kdZy´hjb_glZpby\hafh`ghiha\heyeZbf
j_rblvh^gmba]eZ\guoijh[e_f\u`b\Z_fhklb²kh[exklbgm`gmxkl_i_gv
wdah]Zfghklb[jZdh\ijbnZdlbq_kdbg_^hklZlhqghfdhebq_kl\_ihl_gpbZevguo
[jZqguoiZjlg_jh\Ke_^myh[uqghc^eyojbklbZgkdbodmevlmjihglbckdh
dZ\dZakdh]hj_]bhgZb^_heh]bbbkljZl_]bbaZdexq_gby[jZdh\q_jd_kkdb_]j_db
k_cqZkgZklZb\ZxlgZg_\hafh`ghklbdjhkkdma_gZlZ[jZqguokhxah\
jh^kl\_ggbdh\bijhklhh^ghnZfbevp_\<Zme_gZfjZkkdZau\Zebhj_adh
g_]Zlb\ghchp_gd_khklhjhgugZk_e_gbyh^gh]hbf_\r_]hf_klhj_Zevgh]h
kemqZygZjmr_gby[jZqgh]hlZ[m
K^jm]hcklhjhgum`_\h\j_fyk\h_c`bagb\;`_^m]oZ[e_q_jd_kkdb_
]j_dbg_j_^dhh[jZah\u\Zebkf_rZggu_kq_jd_kh]ZyfbbZ^u]Zfbk_fvbG_
bkdexq_ghqlh\ij_^dhglZdlguci_jbh^lZdb_[jZdb[uebg_hldehg_gb_fhl
ijZ\beZZkdhj__ijZ\behfLh]^ZaZZ^u]_ckdbfbbf_gZfb`_gi_j_ykeh\kdbo
]j_dh\fh]ebkdju\Zlvkyg_ijhklhg_dj_s_gu_]j_qZgdbZgZklhysb_
³wlgbq_kdb_´q_jd_kkdb_`_gsbgu
;_awlh]h^hims_gbyg_\hafh`ghij_^klZ\blvk_[_dZdlZdZy
fZehqbke_ggZyh[sghklvg_ihihegyyihklhygghk\hbojy^h\ba\g_kfh]eZ
ijhkms_kl\h\Zlv\l_q_gbbg_kdhevdboklhe_lbck\h_cbklhjbbBgl_j_kghlhqlh
bk_]h^gygZ__gh\hf\bld_k_fvb[`_^m]oZ[evkdbo]j_dh\\hkgh\ghf
wlgbq_kdbkf_rZggu_<uoh^blqlhbwlhh[klhyl_evkl\hg_^h[Z\behgbq_]h
gh\h]hdijb\uqgufmkeh\byfkms_kl\h\ZgbylZdhckljZgghcZfhjnghcb\f_kl_
kl_fqj_a\uqZcghmklhcqb\hcdmevlmjuKha^Z_lky\i_qZle_gb_qlhg_kfhljygZ
\ukhqZcrmxkl_i_gvZkkbfbeypbbwlZh[sghklv_s_g_bkq_jiZeZ\k_o
\hafh`ghkl_ckZfhjZa\blbybfZehbaf_gbeZkv\kljmdlmjghlbiheh]bq_kdhf
hlghr_gbbaZihke_^gb_^\_klbe_l
Скачать