СТРАНИЦЫ ЭПОХИ РАСПАДА СССР: ГРАЖДАНСКАЯ ВОЙНА В

!" 316.482.3 : 94(575.3).192
.!. "#$#%&'
!"#$%&"'() *(+(,+ -%./"'010 10"23,."4$%&&010 4%5&(6%"'010 2&($%."(4%4,
"()* +,- ./01+ )*"/*2* """):
3)*42* "5*6 !07 * ! (*24+5+"(* 8
7&,+(8(.2%4"9 "0:(,+#&0-;0+(4(6%"',9 "(42,:(9 $ <,3=('("4,&% $ 90-% 103! XX $%',, 4(;0+01(9 .,8&!5 ;0+(4(6%"'(5 1.2;;, (3%0+01(6%"'(5 4%6%&(), 3%/01.,*(6%"'0%, >'0+01(6%"'0% ( >'0&0/(6%"'0% ;0+0=%&(% &,"%+%&(9. ?,""/,4.($,@4"9 ,&4,10&("4(6%"'(% ;.04($0.%6(9 ( ;0"+%3"4$(9 "0A!4() 90-5 1030$ XX $%',.
B+@6%$!% "+0$,: !"#$#%&'()* +!,-+), .$/#%&'(#&, ,&"#0#!1/2& 31)#4!!$/!5&/#*, 6,!(# #
!'"&7'$3#* ,)' )7) 8889.
#$%&'( $(')*+,)): -./+0 *(12+ – +/&(-.'2(% 3-(. 4(5'($6 2+726 2% & 2+7+-+ ) 2% & 8(2,+, + & &%9%:)2; – & '%< 9%+-=2;< >+8'(*, 8('(9;% )$%-) $%&'( *
<(9(?( &@-+2)9(*+22(1 89(*+*(1 /(12% * A+:B)8)&'+2% *9%$%2 1990–1996 C(:+.
D%-%2)% E+<6'): *;9%F+2( 73 7%-., )F 2)< 20 :%'%1. D%-%2)% 4+<'+8(9 –
40 7%-., 4+<'(8(9)-@(%2 – 35, * @(&%-8% G+@+%*( – 35 7%-., * 4+<'++/+:% – 170,
* @(&%-8% E%2)2C9+: – 28, * 8)?-+8% H)98%2' – 15, * C(9(:% I%C+9% – 130 7%-.
J(9(: "69C+2-A./% *;9%F+2 @(7') @(-2(&'=. ) &(BB%2 [1]. K(B2( @9(:(-B+'= ) @9(:(-B+'=…
49+8')86.'&0 @;'8) – )F6*%9&8)%, :)8)%. #;@(-20'= )< $(C6' '(-=8( <(9(?( (/67%22;% «@9(>%&&)(2+-;» &(('*%'&'*6.L%C( $%2'+-)'%'+ ) 5$(,)(2+-=2(-@&)<(-(C)7%&8(C( ')@+. M&'(72)8+$) :(86$%2')9(*+2; &-%:6.L)% &@(&(/; 6$%9L*-%2)0 -.:%1: ('9%F+2)% 6?%1 ) 2(&(*, *;8+-;*+2)% C-+F, &20')%
&8+-=@(*, 9+F:9(/-%2)% ) ('9%F+2)% 8(2%72(&'%1, @(-(*;< (9C+2(*, *;9%F+2)%
9+F-)72;< F2+8(* 2+ '%-%, */)*+2)% )C(-(8 @(: 2(C'), *;9;*+2)% 2(C'%1, &20')%
8(B) & B)*;< -.:%1, @9(&*%9-)*+2)% 7%9%@(* ) )F*-%7%2)% $(FC+ 6 B)*;<,
*&@+9;*+2)% B)*('(* /%9%$%22;< B%2L)2, 6'(@-%2)% &*0F+22;< 8(-.7%1 @9(*(-(8(1 -.:%1 * +9;8+<, F+8+@;*+2)% B)*=%$, F+-)*8+ ,%$%2'($, &*+9)*+2)%
* /+20<, 9+&@0')% @( &'%2+$ $%7%'%1, &(BB%2)% F+B)*( [2, &. 108].
J9+B:+2&8+0 *(12+ * A+:B)8)&'+2% 62%&-+ (8(-( 150 ';&. B)F2%1, (/6&-(*)-+ -+*)22;% $)C9+,)(22;% @9(,%&&;, 9+F96?)-+ &%$=) ) 9(:&'*%22;% &*0F)
$%B:6 -.:=$), @9)*%-+ 8 26-%*($6 @(9(C6 &(&'(02)% 2+9(:2(C( <(F01&'*+. N8(2($)7%&8)1 6L%9/, @( &+$;$ &89($2;$ @(:&7%'+$, &(&'+*)- 7 $-9: :(--. DHO.
K(9+-=2;1 ) 29+*&'*%22;1 – 2% @(:-%B)' 2)8+8)$ (,%28+$: (2 /%F$%9%2.
P+ *(%22($ B+9C(2% /%&@9%,%:%2'2( B%&'(8+0 C9+B:+2&8+0 (& 5-%$%2'+$) 5'2)7%&8(1) *(12+ * A+:B)8)&'+2% /;-+ (/(F2+7%2+ 8+8 «*(12+ *(*7)8(* ) .97)8(*».
«#(*7)8+$)» * A+:B)8)&'+2% 2+F;*+-) /(%*)8(* ) )< @(&(/2)8(*, 8('(9;% /;-) &*0F+2; & ):%(-(C)%1 *+<<+/)F$+ – &+$(1 +8')*2(1 ) +C9%&&)*2(1 $(25
:%-=. &+6:(*&8(C( )&-+$+. N')$(-(C)0 2($)2+,)) «.97)8)» 2%)F*%&'2+ 2)8($6, 0*-0%'&0 &(*%9?%22( 2%$(')*)9(*+22(1. 49(&'( '+8 2+F;*+-) *&%< '%<, 8'(
* /(%*;< :%1&'*)0< ('&'+)*+- &*%'&8)1 ')@ C(&6:+9&'*%22(&').
#(@9(& ( '($, 8+8 2+7)2+.'&0 C9+B:+2&8)% ) 5'2)7%&8)% *(12; * 2+?%$
2%&@(8(12($ $)9%, 8 &(B+-%2)., (8+F;*+%'&0 «*%72;$» – '+8)$, +8'6+-=2(&'=
8('(9(C( 2% 6/;*+%'. Q?&8)% &(/;')0 * ")9C)F)) 2010 C(:+ &-6B+' &*%B)$ @(:'*%9B:%2)%$ 5'(1 $;&-).
# 2+&'(0L%1 9+/('% 0 <(76 (7%9')'= ,%2'9+-=2;% @628'; 2%:+*2%1 )&'(9)), &*0F+22(1 & C9+B:+2&8(1 *(12(1 * A+:B)8)&'+2% * 90-% C(:; XX *%8+.
#(-@%9*;<, %% C-6/)22;% @9)7)2;. #(-*'(9;<, '(, 8+8 5'( '%<2)7%&8) (8+F+-(&=
*(F$(B2;$. R('%-(&= /; *;1') ) 2+ 2%8('(9;% @%9&(2+-)), @(8+F+* @9) 5'($
«9(-= -)72(&') * )&'(9))» – 8+8 &(F):+'%-=26., '+8 ) 9+F96?)'%-=26..
#-7%'*%9';<, <('%-(&= /; (&'+2(*)'=&0 2+ '%< 69(8+< – @(-)')7%&8)< ) 29+*&'*%22;<, – 8('(9;% :(-B2; /;-) /; )F*-%7= 2+?) @(-)')8) ) 2+?% (/L%&'*( )F
'+:B)8&8(1 '9+C%:)).
J9+B:+2&8+0 *(12+ * A+:B)8)&'+2% (2+7+*?+0&0 8+8 5'2)7%&8+0 %L%
* 1990 C(:6) 9+F2;$) &@%,)+-)&'+$) () 2%&@%,)+-)&'+$) '(B%) (/S0&20-+&= @(9+F2($6.
" @9)$%96, $(&8(*&8(-@%'%9/69C&8)% :%$(89+'; @%9*(1 *(-2; *((/L% 9+FS0&2)-) *&%$6 $)96 () '+:B)8)&'+2,+$ * '($ 7)&-%) :(&'6@2( ) @9(&'(: ):%', :%&8+'=, /(9=/+ $%B:6 2(&)'%-0$) 2(*;< :%$(89+')7%&8)< ):%1 ) F+8(9%2%-;$)
8($$62)&'+$) – «89+&2(-8(9)72%*;$)». P%/%F;F*%&'2;1 @(-)')7%&8)1 :%0'%-=
'%< *9%$%2 O2+'(-)1 O-%8&+2:9(*)7 D(/7+8, 2+@9)$%9, (&%2=. 1991 C(:+, @(/;*+* * A+:B)8)&'+2% ) @(?%@'+*?)&= & 8+F)8+-(2($22 O8/+9($ A69+:B(2F(:(1 –
):%(-(C($ *()2&'*6.L%C( )&-+$+, '+8 ) (/S0*)- $)96: «3:%&= 96&&8)< 2%', –
F:%&= 8($$62)&';» [3, 4]. M -):%9 :%$(89+'(* I(&&)) P)8(-+1 A9+*8)2 (* &*(1
(:2(:2%*2;1 @9)-%' * !6?+2/% * @%9)(: :-)'%-=2(C( $)')2C(*(C( $+9+>(2+)
*'(9)-: «!%$(89+')7%&8)% @(/%C) * A+:B)8)&'+2% '026'&0 **%9<» [5]. # 5'($ 09-;8% – «89+&2(-8(9)72%*;%» – /;-( *;9+B%2( 2% '(-=8( -)72(% ('2(?%2)% «:%$(89+'(*» 8 &*()$ (@@(2%2'+$. N'(' 09-;8 &@(&(/&'*(*+- >(9$)9(*+2). ) $%B:62+9(:2(C( $2%2)0 ( <+9+8'%9% «9+F:(9(*», @('90&?)< A+:B)8)&'+2.
T;-+ ) %L% (:2+ &$;&-(*+0 *%9&)0: * A+:B)8)&'+2% *(..' $%B:6 &(/(1
9+F2;% 8-+2;, '+8 8+8 &'968'69+ '+:B)8&8(C( (/L%&'*+ * (&2(*% &*(%1 8-+2(*+0.
#&% 5') (/S0&2%2)0 )&8+B+.' )&')22;1 &$;&- @9()&<(:)*?)< * 9%&@6/-)8% &'9+?2;< ) '9+C)7%&8)< &(/;')1.
4%9*(% +2+-)')7%&8(% )&&-%:(*+2)% @9)7)2 ) $%<+2)F$(* C9+B:+2&8(1
*(12; * A+:B)8)&'+2% @9(*%-+ @( @(967%2). #%9<(*2(C( D(*%'+ I(&&)1&8(1
U%:%9+,)) C96@@+ )F*%&'2(C( @(-)'(-(C+ D%9C%0 "69C)202+ [6]. 49(>%&&)(2+-=2( *;@(-2%22;1 +2+-)F @(8+F+-, 7'( '+:B)8&8+0 '9+C%:)0 /;-+ (/6&-(*-%2+, @( 89+12%1 $%9%, 7%';9=$0 >+8'(9+$).
22
26
"+F)8+-(2 – *;&?)1 :6<(*2;1 &+2 * 9%&@6/-)8%, )&@(*%:6.L%1 )&-+$.
Q:2)$ )F 2)< 0*-0-&0 C%(@(-)')7%&8)1 )2'%9%& DHO ) (':%-=2;< &'9+2
3+@+:2(1 V*9(@; (#%-)8(/9)'+2)) * @%9*6. (7%9%:=) * 9+F*+-% DDDI 8+8 $%B:62+9(:2(C( 8(2869%2'+. 46'%$ 62)7'(B%2)0 %C( 8($$62)&')7%&8(1 ):%(-(C))
@9) 5'($ *):%-+&= *&%@9(2)8+.L+0 ):%(-(C)0 )&-+$+.
!96C)$ >+8'(9($ 0*)-&0 C%(@(-)')7%&8)1 )2'%9%& &'9+2 «)&-+$&8(C( $)9+» (D+6:(*&8(1 O9+*)) * @%9*6. (7%9%:=) * 9+&?)9%2)) &*(%C( ):%(-(C)7%&8(C( *-)02)0 ) 8(2'9(-0 2+: &'9+2+$) D9%:2%1 OF)) (+ *(F$(B2(, ) W%2'9+-=2(1).
A9%'=)$ (/&'(0'%-=&'*($ /;- )2'%9%& $%B:62+9(:2(C( 2+98(/)F2%&+
(2+98('(9C(*,%* O>C+2)&'+2+ * @%9*6. (7%9%:=) * 9+&?)9%2)) 9;28(* &/;'+
&*(%1 @9(:68,)).
T;-( ) 7%'*%9'(%, &(/&'*%22( '+:B)8&8(%, (/&'(0'%-=&'*(, 2+F*+22(%
D. "69C)202($ @9(')*(9%7)%$ )2'%9%&(* 5-)'+92;< 896C(* '+:B)8&8(C( D%*%9+
) '+:B)8&8(C( XC+.
#$%&'% & '%$ 5') 8-+2(*;% @9(')*(9%7)0 ) 5') C%(@(-)')7%&8)% «:%&'+/)-)F+'(9;» 2)8(C:+ /; 2% *;-)-)&= * @9+8')86 *(%22;< :%1&'*)1, %&-) /; * &+$(1 &(,)+-=2(-58(2($)7%&8(1 &)'6+,)) A+:B)8)&'+2+ 80–90-< C(:(* 2% /;-(
/; B%&'(7+1?)< C-6/)22;< @9(/-%$.
4(-2+0 )< (/S%8')*+,)0, @9(*%:%22+0 * 9+$8+< >62:+$%2'+-=2(C( )&&-%:(*+2)0 #.M. T6?8(*+ ) !.#. K)86-=&8(C( [2], &*(:)'&0 8 '9%$.
#(-@%9*;<, 8 90-$ C(:+$ XX *%8+ * A+:B)8)&'+2% 9+F;C9;*+%'&0 2%8(2'9(-)96%$;1 :%$(C9+>)7%&8)1 *F9;*, '9%/6.L)1 &(('*%'&'*6.L%C( $+'%9)+-=2(C( (/%&@%7%2)0. P( 5'(C( (/%&@%7%2)0 2% /;-( ) 2% $(C-( /;'=.
#(-*'(9;<, 8 5'($6 *9%$%2) * 9%&@6/-)8% ('$%7+%'&0 F+@9%:%-=2(% )&@(-=F(*+2)% @+<('2;< ) @+&'/)L2;< F%$%-=, + '+8B% *(:2;< 9%&69&(*, 7'( @9)*(:)' 8 2+96?%2). 58(-(C)7%&8(C( 9+*2(*%&)0 ) %L% $%2=?%1 &@(&(/2(&') F%$-) ('*%7+'= )$@%9+')*+$ :%$(C9+>)7%&8(C( 9(&'+.
#-'9%'=)<, *2%:9%2)% 2+ '%99)'(9)) A+:B)8)&'+2+ &(*9%$%22(1 )2:6&'9)+-=2(1 )2>9+&'968'69;, 76B:(1 $%&'2($6 (/L%&'*6 ) &(@9(*(B:+%$(1 **(F($ «96&&8(0F;72;<», C('(*)-( &(,)+-=2;1 9+&8(- (/L%&'*+ 2+ «96&&8(0F;72;1» C(9(: ) &(/&'*%22( '+:B)8&8)1 8)?-+8.
#&% 5'( *$%&'% *F0'(% &(F:+-( 8(-(&&+-=26. @9(/-%$6 $+-(F%$%-=0 ) *(:2;< 9%&69&(*, 79%*+'6. 2%&@(&(/2(&'=. 9%&@6/-)8) ((&(/%22( %% &%-=&8(1 7+&')) @9(8(9$)'= &+$(% &%/0.
# &+$($ :%-%, @( '%$@+$ %&'%&'*%22(C( @9)9(&'+ 2+&%-%2)0 A+:B)8)&'+2
* 1961 C(:6 6*%9%22( (/(C2+- "+F+<&'+2 ) ")9C)F)., * 1965 C(:6 – F/%8)&'+2,
* 1967 – A698$%2). ) & '%< @(9 @9(:(-B+- (&'+*+'=&0 -):%9($ * 5'(1 (/-+&') 2+
*&%$ @9(&'9+2&'*% /;*?%C( DDDI. 49()F(?-( 5'( 2% )F-F+ &2)B%2)0 (/L%1
&$%9'2(&'), + F+ &7%' @(*;?%2)0 9(B:+%$(&') (* 1985–1990 C(:+< (2+ 8(-%/-%'&0 * @9%:%-+< 38,7–41,9 @9($)--%1).
!%$(C9+>)7%&8)1 «9+&,*%'» A+:B)8)&'+2+ (/%926-&0 @9(/-%$(1 $+-(F%$%-=0. " @9)$%96, %&-) * 1940 C(:6 * A+:B)8)&'+2% 2+ :6?6 2+&%-%2)0 @9)<(:)-(&=
0,6 C+ @(&%*2;< @-(L+:%1, '( * 1989 C(:6 – -)?= 0,17 C+ @+?2), * 1989 C(:6 A+:B)8)&'+2 @9()F*%- 2+ :6?6 2+&%-%2)0 *&%C( -)?= 60,1 8C F%92+ (5'( 160 C 2+ :%2=).
27
QC9($2(% *-)02)% 2+ &(&'(02)% '+:B)8)&'+2&8(C( (/L%&'*+ (8+F+-+ ) @(-)')8+ )2:6&'9)+-)F+,)). MF-F+ 2%*(F$(B2(&') * 89+'7+1?)% &9(8) (/%&@%7)'=
&(F:+*+*?6.&0 @9($;?-%22(&'= $%&'2;$) 8+:9+$) 2%(/<(:)$(1 8*+-)>)8+,))
(&6L%&'*-0-&0 @-+2($%92;1 F+*(F 8+:9(* )F I(&&)). # 9%F6-='+'% 6B% * 50-% C(:; * A+:B)8)&'+2% *(F2)8-+ /)2+92+0 &)&'%$+ 9+F$%L%2)0 2+&%-%2)0: * C(9(:+<
(8+F+-(&= &(&9%:('(7%22;$ @9+8')7%&8) *&% 2%8(9%22(% 2+&%-%2)%, @( *&%$ &*()$ &(,)+-=2;$ <+9+8'%9)&')8+$ 2%):%2')72(%, + '( ) @9(')*(&'(0L%% $%&'2($6
(0F;8, *%9+, 86-='69+, (/9+F(*+2)%, (/9+F ) 69(*%2= B)F2)).
"($@-%8&2(% +2'9(@(C%22(% *(F:%1&'*)% 2+ (896B+.L6. &9%:6 8(9%22;$
(/9+F($ )F$%2)-( 6&-(*)0 &6L%&'*(*+2)0 2+9(:+, F+'96:2)-( *(F$(B2(&'= *%:%2)0 '9+:),)(22(C( &%-=&8(C( <(F01&'*+.
I(&' 2+&%-%2)0 ) *(F9(&?)% (/S%$; 58&'%2&)*2(C( &8('(*(:&'*+ @9+8')7%&8) 62)7'(B)-) +97(*;% ) -)&'*%22;% -%&+. # '($ «@($(C-(» %L% ) )&@(-=F(*+2)% -%&+ 2+ B)-)L2(% &'9()'%-=&'*(, '(@-)*( ) $%'+--69C)7%&8)% 26B:;. Q:2)$ )F @(&-%:&'*)1 62)7'(B%2)0 -%&(* &'+-) &%-%*;% 9+F96?%2)0, 8('(9;%
8 80-$ C(:+$ XX *%8+ @9)20-) $+&?'+/; 2+,)(2+-=2(1 6C9(F;.
VL% (:2(1 @9)7)2(1 58(-(C)7%&8(C( 2%/-+C(@(-67)0 A+:B)8)&'+2+ &'+-+
)2'%2&)*2+0 :(/;7+ @(-%F2;< )&8(@+%$;<, $+&?'+/; 8('(9(1 *&% 6*%-)7)*+-)&= 2+7)2+0 & 40-< C(:(*. 49)$%20*?)%&0 @9) 5'($ '%<2(-(C)), 9+&&7)'+22;%
2+ )2;% C%(-(C)7%&8)% 6&-(*)0, &@(&(/&'*(*+-) :%C9+:+,)) @(*%9<2(&') ) 2+96?%2). &'+/)-=2(&') '%8'(2)7%&8)< F(2. 7+&')*?)%&0 * D9%:2%1 OF)) F%$-%'90&%2)0 *&% *(F9+&'+.L%1 $(L2(&') (1985 C(: – "+19+886$&8(%, 1989 C(: –
J)&&+9&8(%) 2+@90$6. &*0F;*+.'&0 (':%-=2;$) )&&-%:(*+'%-0$) & :(/;*+.L%1
@9($;?-%22(&'=..
K%-)(9+')*2+0 @(-)')8+ * A+:B)8)&'+2% @9)*%-+ 8 )F$%-=7+2). :*6< *%-)8)< 9%8 – O$6:+9=) ) D;9:+9=), 62)7'(B)-+ O9+-=&8(% $(9%, *;F*+-+ F+&(-%2)% @(7*. # 6&-(*)0< $+-(F%$%-=0 5'( &'+-( 8+'+&'9(>(1.
A+:B)8)&'+2&8(% (/L%&'*( 8 80-$ C(:+$ XX *%8+ *&'6@)-( * @(-(&6 &)&'%$2(C( 89)F)&+, 58(2($)7%&8(1 @(:(@-%8(1 8('(9(C( @(&-6B)- +/&(-.'2;1
F%$%-=2(-*(:2;1 C(-(:, + &(,)+-=2(1 – 2%8(2'9(-)96%$+0 9(B:+%$(&'= ) &*%9<*;&(8)1 %&'%&'*%22;1 @9)9(&' 2+&%-%2)0.
"9)F)& & 2%(/<(:)$(&'=. *;F*+- 8 B)F2) 6&)-%226. ,)986-0,). ):%1,
8('(9;% * $6&6-=$+2&8($ (/L%&'*% 2%)F/%B2( (>(9$-0-)&= * *):% )&-+$&8(1
):%(-(C)).
#(F2)8?+0 * (/L%&'*% (/&'+2(*8+ &(*@+-+ & @(-)')7%&8)$ 9+&@+:($
DDDI. Q&-+/-%2)% ,%2'9+ 6&)-)-( ,%2'9(/%B2;% &)-; *( $2(C)< &(.F2;< 9%&@6/-)8+< – * A+:B)8)&'+2% * '($ 7)&-%.
A+:B)8)&'+2&8(% (/L%&'*( 2+7+-( @(-)')F)9(*+'=&0, &'+-) *(F2)8+'= 9+F-)72;% (/L%&'*%22;% :*)B%2)0 ) @(-)')7%&8)% 8-6/;. N'(' @9(,%&& 2+7+«@(:(C9%*+'=&0» ) )F*2%.
A+8, * 1974–1975 C(:+< * *;&(8)< @9+*)'%-=&'*%22;< +2+-)')7%&8)< ,%2'9+< DHO, #%-)8(/9)'+2)) ) 90:+ )&-+$&8)< C(&6:+9&'* /;-+ 9+F9+/('+2+ &(*$%&'2+0 @9(C9+$$+ «M&-+$ @9(')* 8($$62)F$+». N'+ @9(C9+$$+ @9%:@(-+C+-+
28
&(*$%&'2(% >)2+2&)9(*+2)% +2')8($$62)&')7%&8)< (9C+2)F+,)1 * )&-+$&8)<
9%C)(2+< D(*%'&8(C( D(.F+. Q2+ @9%:@(-+C+-+ '+8B% )&@(-=F(*+2)% &@%,&-6B/
:-0 9+F*%9';*+2)0 )&-+$&8(C( @(:@(-=0 * DDDI, @9)7%$ *%:6L+0 9(-= * 5'($
:%-% ('*(:)-+&= &+6:(*,+$ ) +2C-)1&8(1 «M2'%--):B%2& &%9*)&» [6]. 3+$%76,
7'( 5'( @9()&<(:)' %L% :( 2+7+-+ *(12; * O>C+2)&'+2%. VL% D(*%'&8)1 D(.F 2%
2+F*+2 «)$@%9)%1 F-+», 2( * -%8&)8(2% F+96/%B2(1 @(-)')7%&8(1 86<2) 6B% @(0*-0%'&0 '%9$)2 «.B2(% @(:/9.?=% I(&&))» (&(*&%$ * :6<% )2&'(2+ G%97)--0, 8('(9;1 * &*(% *9%$0 2+F;*+- «$0C8)$ @(:/9.?=%$ V*9(@;» &'9+2; T+-8+2&8(C( @(-6(&'9(*+).
49(C9+$$+ «M&-+$ @9(')* 8($$62)F$+» F+9+/('+-+ 2+ '%99)'(9)) %L% &(*%'&8(C( A+:B)8)&'+2+ 6B% * 1976 C(:6. M$%22( '(C:+ * C. "69C+2-A./% $6--+
O/:6--( (9C+2)F(*+- +2')@9+*)'%-=&'*%22;1 $)')2C @%9%: (/8($($ "($$62)&')7%&8(1 @+9')) A+:B)8)&'+2+ – @( '%$ *9%$%2+$ &(/;')% /%&@9%,%:%2'2(%.
P( (2( 2% /;-( &-67+12;$: @9(,%&& «@(?%-» – *%92%%, %C( @(*%-), @9)7%$ @9(>%&&)(2+-=2( ) (9C+2)F(*+22(.
# 1978 C(:6 &)2<9(22( * 90:% 9%C)(2(* DDDI *(F2)8+%' @(:@(-=2+0 (9C+2)F+,)0, )$%26.L+0 &%/0 «M&-+$&8+0 @+9')0 *(F9(B:%2)0» (* A+:B)8)&'+2% (2+
/6:%' 8(289%')F)9(*+2+ 8+8 «M&-+$&8+0 @+9')0 *(F9(B:%2)0 A+:B)8)&'+2+»).
P( '+8(C( 9(:+ (9C+2)F+,)) * &'9+2% & $(L2;$) &@%,&-6B/+$) ) (:2(@+9')12(1 &)&'%$(1 @9(&'( 2% $(C-) &6L%&'*(*+'= /%F @9)89;')0 @+9')12;< 5-)'.
A(-=8( 2+ @+9')12(1 (&2(*%, '(-=8( @9) &(:%1&'*)) *;&?%1 @+9')12(1 5-)';
9%&@6/-)8) $(C-( @9()F(1') '(, 7'( @9()F(?-(.
"'( )$%22( @9)89;*+- * A+:B)8)&'+2% 2+&+B:+%$;1 *+<<+/)F$ – 5'6
*()2&'*6.L6. $(:%-= )&-+$+? "+8 5'( *((/L% $(C-( (&6L%&'*-0'=&0? "+8)%
-)72(&') *;&'6@+-) @%9&(2+-=2;$ (-),%'*(9%2)%$ 5'(1 ):%)? G'(/; @(20'=
*&% 5'(, *%92%$&0 :-0 2+7+-+ 8 *(@9(&6 ( &(,)+-=2(-58(2($)7%&8(1 &'9+')>)8+,)) A+:B)8)&'+2+ – ( %C( :%-%2)) 2+ '+:B)8&8)1 D%*%9 ) '+:B)8&8)1 XC.
R(:B%2'&8)1 8-+2, )-) -%2)2+/+:&8+0 C96@@+, – 5'( 5-)'2;1 D%*%9 A+:B)8)&'+2+, @9)7%$ D%*%9 2% '(-=8( C%(C9+>)7%&8)1, 2( ) &(,)+-=2(58(2($)7%&8)1 ) :+B% &(,)(86-='692;1. #%&= &(*%'&8)1 @%9)(: )&'(9)) A+:B)8)&'+2+ 9%&@6/-)8(1 6@9+*-0-+ -%2)2+/+:&8+0 C96@@+: 5'( ) 49('(@(@(*
* *(%22(% *9%$0, ) T(/(:B+2 J+>69(* (896@2%1?)1 67%2;1-*(&'(8(*%:), ) A69&62/+1 2:B+/(%* ) !B+/+9 I+&6-(*)7 I+&6-(*. R(:B%2'&8)1 8-+2 2% /;- -)?%2 2%8('(9(1 &(,)+-=2(1 2+:$%22(&'), (/(&(/-%22(&'), 8(9@(9+')*2(&'); 9%C)(2+-=2;% )2'%9%&; 2%9%:8( @9%*+-)9(*+-) 2+: 9%&@6/-)8+2&8)$). P( 5'( /;2+:%B2;1, «@9()$@%9&8)1» (@-(' *-+&').
XC B% A+:B)8)&'+2+ B)- &*(%1 B)F2=. ) &*()$) )2'%9%&+$), @(&'%@%22(
@9)(/9%'+0 7%'8( *;9+B%226. &'968'696.
# 9+*2)22(1 7+&') XC+ 9+&@(-+C+%'&0 "6-0/. 4-(:(9(:2%1?)% F%$-) "6-0/+ &(&'+*-0-) (&2(*2(% %C( /(C+'&'*(. D+$) 86-0/,; *&%C:+ '0C('%-) 8 «@9()$@%9&8($6» E%2)2+/+:6. MF 86-0/,%* – &$%-;<, *;2(&-)*;<, @9%:+22;< ,%2'96 – @9+*)'%-=&'*( A+:B)8)&'+2+ '9+:),)(22( >(9$)9(*+-( &)-; K#!.
29
# (/?)92(1 *(&'(72(1 7+&') XC+ *;:%-0-+&= @9%B:% *&%C( JTOQ – J(92(-T+:+<?+2&8+0 +*'(2($2+0 (/-+&'=. P+&%-0.' %% @+$)9,; – 2+9(:2(&'=, <+9+8'%9)F6.L+0&0 /(-=?(1 &@-(7%22(&'=., :9%*2)$), :(>%(:+-=2;$) >(9$+$)
(9C+2)F+,)) &(,)+-=2(1 B)F2). I+1(2 4+$)9+ – 5'( :('+,)(22;1 9+1(2: F:%&=
2%' 2) &%-=&8(C( <(F01&'*+, 2) &8('(*(:&'*+. 9(*%2= B)F2) – 2)B% *&08)< 8($$%2'+9)%*. &'(17)*6. <+9+8'%9)&')86 89)$)2+-)'%'+ 5'(C( 9%C)(2+ &(&'+*-0%'
F+20')% 2+98(')7%&8)$ @9($;&-($. 49(9;*+0&= * 6@9+*-%27%&8)% &'968'69;,
@+$)9,; @9(&'( 2% $(C-) 2% (/2+96B)*+'= (&'9(C( 2%:(*(-=&'*+ F+$826'(&'=.
) +$/),)(F2(&'=. <(:B%2'&8(C( 8-+2+. Q2) :(-B2; /;-) )&8+'= &(.F2)8(*
) 2+?-) )< * -),% &(@9%:%-=2(1 @( '%99)'(9)) ) ('2(&)'%-=2( *;&(8(C(92(1
C+9$&8(1 (/L)2;.
J+9$ &@%,)+-)F)9(*+-&0 2+ $%-8('(*+92;< *):+< &%-=&8(<(F01&'*%22(1
@9(:68,)). !(&'+'(72( /;&'9( ) 2% /%F @($(L) @+$)9&8(1 5-)'; ) %% 2+98(:%2%C J+9$ «(&%:-+-» '(9C(*-., @('9%/&(.F; ) (/9+F(*+- *'(96. (8(2869)96.L6. & -%2)2+/+:&8(1) /69B6+F).. 49+*:+, * ('-)7)% (' -%2)2+/+:&8(1 (2+ /;-+
F+$826'+ 2+ *26'9%22)1 9;2(8. P( <('%-(&= /(-=?%C(. M @(5'($6 C+9$,; &(&'+*)-) (@@(F),). «)$@%9&8($6» ,%2'96 ) %C( ):%(-(C)). !(&'+'(72( (/%&@%7%22+0 ) 8(2&(-):)9(*+22+0 5-)'+ J+9$+ * 8+8(1-'( $($%2' &(F9%-+ :-0 '(C(, 7'(/;
&(F2+'%-=2( &'9()'= &*(. @(-)')7%&86. )C96.
49(')*(&'(02)% D%*%9+ ) XC+, (/(F2+7)*?%%&0 * 70-% C(:;, K(&8*+ 9+&&$+'9)*+%' @9(&'( 8+8 8-+2(*(% ) @(5'($6 @;'+%'&0 2%1'9+-)F(*+'= %C( -)?=
&9%:&'*+$) &/+-+2&)9(*+22(1 8+:9(*(1 @(-)')8). # 7+&'2(&'), * @(:*)B2)8)
-%2)2+/+:,6 I+&6-(*6 – @%9*($6 &%89%'+9. "($@+9')) A+:B)8)&'+2+ – 2+
:(-B2(&'= 49%:&%:+'%-0 #%9<(*2(C( D(*%'+ A+:B)8)&'+2+ K(&8*+ *;:*)C+%'
@+$)9,+ J()/2+F+9+ 4+--+%*+. # '6 5@(<6 5'( /;-+ &8(9%% @(7%'2+0, 7%$ @(-)')7%&8) F2+7)$+0 :(-B2(&'=.
P( 8+8)%-'( &)-; &*%-) 4+--+%*+ & &%89%'+9%$ W" "4 A+:B)8)&'+2+ @(
):%(-(C)) J6-:B+<(2 T(/(&+:;8(*(1 – *-+&'2(1, 6$2(1, 9+&7%'-)*(1 B%2L)2(1
($+'%$+')8($ @( (/9+F(*+2).) [7]. N'(' +-=02& &-+B%22( ) 9+F$%9%22( F+9+/('+- 6B% * 5@(<6 I+&6-(*+. 4+--+%* @(&'%@%22( ) @-+2($%92( @9(*(:)- * '(9C(*-. «&*()<» C+9$,%*. 4( /;&'9('% ) &(C-+&(*+22(&') @9(,%&& F+<*+'+ '(9C(*;<
'(7%8 C+9$,+$) 2% F2+- &%/% 9+*2;<. 4+--+%* F+<*+')- 2% '(-=8( 2)B2)%, 2(
) *;&?)% 5'+B) '(9C(*(1 @)9+$):;. 49)89;')% (/%&@%7)*+-+ T(/(&+:;8(*+,
@(&'(022( *9+L+*?+0&0 * $(&8(*&8)< &>%9+<.
D*(/(:2;% >)2+2&(*;% &9%:&'*+ (' '(9C(*-) &(%:)2)-)&= & ):%(-(C)%1,
$+>)(F2;% &%') 2+ $%&'+< – & 6$%2)%$ -+*)9(*+'= * 8+/)2%'+< *;&(8(1 @(-)')7%&8(1 *-+&').
#&% 5'( &'+-( 2% 2+ ?6'86 /%&@(8()'= <(:B%2',%*. T(/(&+:;8(*+ B%, 8('(9+0 @9%B:% *&%C:+ :%1&'*(*+-+ & (C-0:8(1 2+ R(:B%2', *&% /(-=?% ) /(-=?% **0F;*+-+&= * )2'%9%&; @9%:@%9%&'9(%72;< $(&8(*&8)< 5-)'2;< C96@@. M 5'( @9)'($, 7'( *2%?2% @9(0*-0-+ @(:7%9826'6. 79%F$%92(&'= * *(@9(&+<, &*0F+22;<
& «7)&'('(1» +'%)&')7%&8)< ):%+-(* 968(*(:0L)< 9+/('2)8(*: B%&'(8( 8+9+-+
30
@( @+9')12(1 -)2)) F+ ('@9+*-%2)% :%:(*&8)< 9%-)C)(F2;< '9+:),)1, '%$ &+$;$ :)&89%:)')960 8($$62)&')7%&86. ):%(-(C). * C-+F+< *&% /(-%% ) /(-%%
)&-+$)F)9(*+*?%C(&0 2+&%-%2)0.
2 +@9%-0 1982 C(:+ 6$)9+%' '+:B)8&8)1 -):%9 I+&6-(*. E%2)2+/+:&8+0
C96@@+ &6$%-+ ) 2+ 5'(' 9+F @9(*%&') 2+ :(-B2(&'= @%9*(C( &%89%'+90 (7%9%:2(C( <(:B%2',+ – I+<$(2+ P+/)%*)7+ P+/)%*+. P( 5'( 2% *<(:)-( * @-+2; 4+--+%*+ ) T(/(&+:;8(*(1.
D+$ P+/)%*, /6:67) :(&'+'(72( $(-(:;$, 2% &(/)9+-&0 (':+*+'= ):%(-(C).
2+ ('86@ &*()$ (@@(2%2'+$, 2% &(/)9+-&0 (2 ) &-%@( *;@(-20'= :)9%8')*; K(&8*;
@( /(9=/% & )&-+$($ 8+8 '+8(*;$). P+&'6@+-) 2(*;% *9%$%2+, ) 2(*;% -):%9; <(9(?( @(2)$+-) :*6&$;&-%22(&'= 7%9%&769 -)2%12(C( )&@(-2%2)0 :)9%8')* ,%2'9+.
#$%&'% &( *'(9;$ &%89%'+9%$ W" "4 A+:B)8)&'+2+ X.4. T%-(*;$ P+/)%*
@;'+-&0 /-(8)9(*+'= @9(,%&& &'+2(*-%2)0 C+9$&8(1 '(9C(*(1 $+>)).
P( * 1985 C(:6, *&8(9% @(&-% @9)<(:+ 8 *-+&') K.D. J(9/+7%*+, 2+F2+7+%'&0 &@%,)+-=2+0 @9(*%98+ "($$62)&')7%&8(1 @+9')) A+:B)8)&'+2+ &( &'(9(2;
W" "4DD. A+8+0 @9(*%98+ (/;72( (F2+7+-+ &20')% *%9<2%C( 5?%-(2+ *-+&')
* 9%&@6/-)8%. D(/)9+%'&0 F+89;'(% /.9( W" "($$62)&')7%&8(1 @+9')) A+:B)8)&'+2+, 4+--+%* ) T(/(&+:;8(*+ ('89;'( *;&'6@+.' @9(')* P+/)%*+ – @(*(:
%&'=: @(F*(-)- &%/% *;@)'= * &+62% 2+ @9+F:2(*+2)) ./)-%0 JTOQ () 5'( * '(
*9%$0, 8(C:+ &'9+2+ /(9%'&0 & @=02&'*($). P( P+/)%*6 ) T%-(*6 6:+%'&0 6:%9B+'=&0 2+ F+2)$+%$;< @(&'+<.
#$%&'% & '%$ @(&-% &-67)*?%C(&0 P+/)%* @9%:-+C+%' T(/(&+:;8(*(1 61')
* ('&'+*86. # ('*%' – F*(2(8 )F K(&8*; & (89)8($: «P% '9(C+'=!». P+/)%* '%$ 2%
$%2%% @(*'(90%' &*(% @9%:-(B%2)% T(/(&+:;8(*(1. # ('*%' – F*(2(8 %L% /(-%%
*&%$(C6L%C( -),+. M *2(*= ('8+F *;@(-2)'= 68+F+2)%. M '(C:+ – '9%')1 F*(2(8.
Y%-%F2;1 C(-(& (:%9C)*+%' «>9(2:%9+»: «N'( -)72(% 68+F+2)% K.D. J(9/+7%*+»
[6]. M P+/)%* – «6<(:)'» 2+ @%2&)..
#$%&'( 2%C( @9)<(:)' -%2)2+/+:%, "+<<(9 K+<8+$(*. "+B%'&0, 7'( R(:B%2' &(<9+20%' &*() @(F),)). P( 2+ :%-% -%2)2+/+:&8(1 5-)'% 2+2%&%2( '0B%-(%
@(9+B%2)%: * (/$%2 2+ &(<9+2%2)% F+ &(/(1 @%9*(C( @(&'+ * C(&6:+9&'*% E%2)2+/+: *;26B:%2 (':+'= @+$)9,+$ ) C+9$,+$ 6B% 2% '(-=8( *%&= 4('9%/&(.F ,%-)8($, 2( ) K)2)&'%9&'*( *26'9%22)< :%-: 2+ @(&' $)2)&'9+ *26'9%22)< :%- 2+F2+7%2 @+$)9%, K+$+:+%F P+*:B6*+2(*. A%@%9= * (:2)< 968+< &(&9%:('(7%2;
) '(9C(*;% :%2=C), ) C96@@+ @9)89;')0, ) &)-(*+0 &'968'69+ – $)-),)0.
D 5')$ *26'9)@9+*)'%-=&'*%22;$ @%9%*(9('($ &(*@+:+%' ) 6&8(9%22(%,
9%F8(% &'+2(*-%2)% «@+9+--%-=2(C( )&-+$+» – *+<<+/)F$+ – (@0'=-'+8) F+ &7%'
@+9')12(C( @9)89;')0 &*%9<6 () 2% /%F /-+C(&-(*%2)0 K(&8*;).
# DDDI 1989 C(:6 @9(*(:)'&0 +$2)&')0 6C(-(*2;< @9%&'6@2)8(*, 8('(9;%
*(F*9+L+.'&0 * A+:B)8)&'+2 ) (8+F;*+.'&0 «@9) :%-%».
49)?%:?)1 2+ $%&'( *'(9(C( &%89%'+90 W" "4 A+:B)8)&'+2+ T%-(*+ 4%'9
E67)2&8)1 (8+:9 )F 49):2%&'9(*=0) F+*%9?+%' 9+FC9($ 8+:9(* @9) @(@6&')'%-=&'*% "+<<(9+ K+<8+$(*+. M$%22( E67)2&8)1 /-(8)9(*+- -./;% @(@(-F2(*%2)0
(&'+2(*)'= 2+/)9+*?)% (/(9('; +2')96&&8)% 2+&'9(%2)0. N'(' 7%-(*%8 )&7%F+%'
)F 9%&@6/-)8) 2%F+:(-C( :( >%*9+-0 1990 C(:+.
31
4(*(9('($ 8 >%*9+-=&8)$ &(/;')0$ * !6?+2/% 0*)-&0 2+$%9%22( 9+&@9(&'9+20%$;1 &-6< ( *;:%-%2)) /%B%2,+$-+9$02+$ 8*+9')9. O /;-(-'( *&%C(
47 &%$%1, 8('(9;% ) 9+F$%&')-)&= 6 &*()< 9(:&'*%22)8(*, 2% @($;?-00 2) ( 8+8)< B)-)L2;< @9)*)-%C)0<. P+@($2. :-0 F+/;*?)< )-) *((/L% 2% F2+.L)<:
13 02*+90 1990 C(:+ * T+86 (OF%9/+1:B+2) 2+7+-)&= &'9+?2;% 5'2)7%&8)% @(C9($;: +F%9/+1:B+2,; @-+2($%92( )&'9%/-0-) +9$02 ) 96&&8)<. !-0 2+C-0:2(&') '(C(, 8+8 ) 7'( @9()&<(:)-( * T+86, @9)*%:6 -)?= (:)2 89(?%72;1 >9+C$%2'
&*):%'%-=&'*+ J.M. – B%2L)2;, @(7') 6'9+')*?%1 &@(&(/2(&'= C(*(9)'= @(&-%
*&%C( &-67)*?%C(&0 & %% &%$=%1: «#;-($+-) :*%9=, $6B+ 6:+9)-) @( C(-(*%, (2
/%F &(F2+2)0 *+-0-&0 *&% 5'( *9%$0, $%20 /)-). 4('($ $%20 @9)896')-) 8 89(*+') ) 2+7+-) &'+9?%2=86. 2+&)-(*+'= – Q-=C6, 12 -%' %1 /;-(. #?%&'%9($. R(9(?(, 7'( K+9)286 7%';9%<-%'2.. * 86<2% F+@%9-), 2% *):%-+ 5'(C(… 4('($
@(/)-) *&% * 8*+9')9%, *;C9%/-) 7'( 2+:(, ('*0F+-) $%20 ) *%-%-) :( *%7%9+ 6/9+'=&0. "(C:+ $; /%B+-) * +59(@(9', $2% 76'= 2% @(: 2(C) 6@+-+ :%*7(2(78+ –
*;/9(&)-) & *%9<2)< 5'+B%1 ('86:+-'(. #:9;FC!.. V% 89(*= $2% *&% @-+'=% F+/9;FC+-+… 49)/%B+-) * +59(@(9', + '+$ C(*(90', 7'( $%&' 2+ K(&8*6 2%'. P+
'9%'=) &6'8) '(-=8( ) 6-%'%-). M *&% *9%$0, 8+8 9%1& 2+ K(&8*6, 0L)8) 8+9'(22;% & ,*%'+$) :%&0'8+$) 2+ 8+B:;1 9%1& F+C96B+-)…» [8].
49(')* $2)$(C( @9%:(&'+*-%2)0 B)-=0 '+8)$ *(' «(886@+2'+$» ) @(*%-)
&*()< -.:%1 &2+7+-+ 2+ $)')2C, + @('($ ) 2+ @(C9($; '9) &)-; – )&-+$&8)%
>62:+$%2'+-)&'; (R(:B+ O8/+9 A69+:B(2F(:+), '+8 2+F;*+%$+0 :%$(89+')7%&8+0 $(-(:%B= (H(:$(2 X&6>) ) @9%&'6@2;1 $)9 (Z86/ D+-)$(*). N'( (2) (9C+2)F(*+-) :6?+2/)2&8)1 $0'%B, 8('(9;1 2+7+-&0 & $)')2C+ 2+ @-(L+:) QF(:)
(D*(/(:;). @9+*-0- $0'%B($ 49%:&%:+'%-= #%9<(*2(C( D(*%'+ I%&@6/-)8)
A+:B)8)&'+2 4+--+%*. J. T(/(&+:;8(*6 @9%:6&$('9)'%-=2( 2+@9+*)-) 8 '($6
*9%$%2) 2+ @(*;?%2)% * K(&8*6, * (/L%&'*( «32+2)%». (# :+-=2%1?%$ (2+ &'+2%' «:%$(89+'8(1» ) @(-67)' '%@-(% $%&'( * XPVD"Q. A+8(% F+*%9?%2)% 8+9=%9; @(F*(-0%' (:2(F2+72( )&'(-8(*;*+'= %% $)&&). @( 9+F;C9;*+2). )&-+$&8(1 8+9'; * 9%&@6/-)8%, * 2+&'(0L%% *9%$0 *%926-+&= * A+:B)8)&'+2, 2% /%:&'*6%', :+%' )2'%9*=. ( &*(%$ /%F6@9%72($ &-6B%2)) '+:B)8&8($6 2+9(:6.)
!6?+2/)2&8)% @(C9($; @9(<(:)-) 12, 13, 14 >%*9+-0 1990 C(:+. Q2) 2(&)-) ('89(*%22( +2')96&&8)1 <+9+8'%9. «A+:B)8)&'+2 :-0 '+:B)8(*!», «I6&&8)%,
6/)9+1'%&= * &*(. I(&&).!» – 5'( /;-) C-+*2;% -(F62C) @(C9($L)8(*. 4(-'(9;
';&07) 96&&8)< $6B7)2 ) B%2L)2 * !6?+2/% 2+,)(2+--)&-+$)&'; /68*+-=2(
9+&'%9F+-) – 2+ 6-),+<, @-(L+:0< ) * )< &(/&'*%22;< 8*+9')9+<. 4%9%@+-( ) %*9(@%)F)9(*+22;$ '+:B)8+$. A+8(C( )F6*%9&'*+ A+:B)8)&'+2 %L% 2% F2+- (&$.:
#. D'+9)8(* «!(-C+0 :(9(C+ * I(&&).», !.Q. I(C(F)2 «#9+C 2+9(:+»).
# 2+C2%'+2)) +2')96&&8(1 )&'%9)) *( *&%< 9%&@6/-)8+< /;*?%C( DDDI
) A+:B)8)&'+2+ * '($ 7)&-% 2%$+-( @('96:)-)&= @9%:&'+*)'%-) «'*(97%&8(1 )2'%--)C%2,))». # A+:B)8)&'+2% 2+ 5'(1 2)*% (&(/%22( ('-)7)-+&= @(5'%&&+ J6-96<&(9 D+>)%*+. # 20 -%' (2+ *&'6@)-+ * "4DD, *(FC-+*)-+ &%8'(9 @%7+') '+:B)8&8(C( 8($&($(-+, * 24 C(:+ @(-67)-+ 7-%2&8)1 /)-%' D(.F+ @)&+'%-%1 A+:32
B)8)&'+2+ ) %L% 7%9%F 10 -%' &'+-+ &%89%'+9%$ @9+*-%2)0. #( *9%$0 @%9%&'9(18)
D+>)%*+ )F 6/%B:%22(1 8($$62)&'8) (/9+')-+&= * @-+$%226. 2+,)(2+-)&'86
) @9+*(*%926. $6&6-=$+286. P+ $)')2C+< )&-+$&8(-:%$(89+')7%&8(1 (@@(F),)) @(5'%&&+ @9()F2(&)-+ +2')96&&8)% 9%7), &(896?+-+&= ( «@(96C+22(1 &%*%92;$) *+9*+9+$) @9%89+&2(1 '%$2(C-+F(1 I(:)2%», 2+F;*+-+ #%-)86. Q'%7%&'*%226. *(126 «9(&&)1&8(1 $0&(96/8(1, 86:+ F+C2+-) '+:B)8(*», @9%:9%8+-+, 7'(
«7+& 9+&@-+'; 2+&'6@)-, ) @6&'= 89(*= &$(%' 96&&86. C90F=». MF '+8)< *('
«'*(97%&8)<» -.:%1 – @(5'(*, @)&+'%-%1, >)-(&(>(* – /;-( &>(9$)9(*+2( (/L%&'*( «I+&'(<%F» («#(F9(B:%2)%»), *(FC-+*-0%$(% A(<)9($ O/:6:B+//(9($.
49+*:+, * 1990 C(:6 5') C(*(962; %L% 2% :(C+:;*+-)&=, 7'( ) )$ 2%:(-C( (&'+-(&= &-(*(/-6:)'=, – >62:+$%2'+-)F$ @9%&%7%' *&% 5') /(C%$2;% «/+F+9;»,
), 8+8 @(/)';% &(/+8), @(/%C6' *7%9+?2)% «*(-=2(:6$,;» – 8'( * K(&8*6, + 8'(
2+ &%*%9 A+:B)8)&'+2+ – * R(:B%2'. J6-96<&(9 (/(&2(*+-+&= * K(&8*%, @%7+'+%'&0 * B692+-+< «&%*%92;< *+9*+9(*», 6&'9+)*+%' *%7%9+ @(5F))…
P( *%92%$&0 8 2+7+'($6: * !6?+2/% @9(?-) /%&@9%,%:%2'2;% +8,)) *+2:+-)F$+. T;-( @+9+-)F(*+2( @9()F*(:&'*(, -.:) 2% <(:)-) 2+ 9+/('6 )F-F+ /(0F2) F+ B)F2= &*()< &%$%1. 4(&-% >%*9+-0 1990 C(:+ 2+7)2+%'&0 $+&&(*;1 )&<(:
«96&&8(0F;72;<» )F 9%&@6/-)8).
Q@@(F),)%1 /;- &(F:+2 «"($)'%' 17-)», (2 *;9+F)- 2%:(*%9)% @%9*($6
&%89%'+9. "4 A+:B)8)&'+2+ ".K+<8+$(*6. 4(&-% '(C(, 8+8 K+<8+$(* @(::%9B+- * +*C6&'% 1991 C(:+ J"G4, + «@6'7» @9(*+-)-&0, &%89%'+9= "4 A+:B)8)&'+2+
/;- (/9%7%2: (' 2%C( $C2(*%22( :)&'+2,)9(*+-)&= *&% @(-)')7%&8)% &)-; 9%&@6/-)8), @9%'%2:6.L)% 2+ *-+&'=.
Q@@(F),)(22( 2+&'9(%22;% «:%$(89+';» *;:*)26-) 2+ @(&' @%9*(C( -),+
9%&@6/-)8) 2% '+8 6B ) :+*2( )$) B% 2)F-(B%22(C( I+<$(2+ P+/)%*+. D8(9(@+-)'%-=2( &'+-) C('(*)'= *;/(9; 49%F):%2'+. D9%:) 8+2:):+'69 2+ 5'(' @(&' /;-+
) 8+2:):+'69+ !(*-+'+ R6:(2+F+9(*+ – $(&8(*&8(C( 9%B)&&%9+, @(::%9B)*+%$(C(
$59($ D+28'-4%'%9/69C+ O2+'(-)%$ D(/7+8($. !%F(9)%2')9(*+22;1 2+9(:, :(
8(2,+ 2% @(2)$+.L)1, 7'( @9()&<(:)', @(::%9B+- 8+2:):+'696 «F2+8($(C(» P+/)%*+. O 8+2:):+'69+ /;-+ 6B% & 7%9*('(7)2(1. N'( /;- 6B% &-($-%22;1 7%-(*%8,
@(2)$+.L)1, 8+8 )$%22( )$ $(B2( )C9+'=. N'( /;- 7%-(*%8, «(/0F+22;1» &*()$
*(F*;?%2)%$ 2%:+*2)$ *9+C+$.
B% @%9*;% @(-)')7%&8)% ?+C) P+/)%*+ @(&-% %C( )F/9+2)0 49%F):%2'($
/;-) ?+C+$) * @9(@+&'=: )$%22( (2 689%@-0- @(F),)) )&-+$&8(-2+,)(2+-)&')7%&8(C( (/L%&'*+ «I+&'(<%F» («#(F9(B:%2)%») ) '+8(1 B% @( :6<6 «:%$(89+'))».
M$%22( (2 (& @(:+7) ) @( @90$(1 9%8($%2:+,)) O. D(/7+8+ ) V. #%-)<(*+ (&%2=.
1991 C(:+) @9)F2+- M&-+$&86. @+9'). *(F9(B:%2)0 A+:B)8)&'+2+ *( C-+*% & 8+F)8+-(2($ R(:B(1 O8/+9($ A69+:B(2F(:(1 (:( '(C( *9%$%2) (2+ 2+<(:)-+&= * @(:@(-=%), )$%22( (2 @(-2(&'=. 6'9+')- 8(2'9(-= 2+: &9%:&'*+$) $+&&(*(1 )2>(9$+,)), )$%22( (2 (&*(/(:)- C-+*+9%1 >%*9+-=&8)< &(/;')1 * !6?+2/%. P+/)%* F+)&8)*+- @%9%: '%$), 8'( <('%- %C( 62)7'(B)'=.
33
4(-2($+&?'+/2+0 C9+B:+2&8+0 *(12+ * A+:B)8)&'+2% 2+7)2+%'&0 * 1991 C(:6.
!%'(2+'(9($ &(/;')1 @(&-6B)-) :%$(89+')7%&8)% +8,)) * I(&&)) @(&-% &(/;')1
21 +*C6&'+ 1991 C(:+ * K(&8*%.
# &%2'0/9% '+:B)8&8)% &(.F2)8) K(&8(*&8(1 @(/%:)*?%1 :%$(89+'))
9%?)-) :%1&'*(*+'=: *-+&'= R(:B%2'&8(C( 8-+2+ :(-B2+ /;-+ /;'= &8)26'+ @(:
2+@(9($ +2')8($$62)&')7%&8)< &)-. P( 8-+2 (8+F+-&0 6&'(17)*;$ ) &+$ @%9%?%- * 2+&'6@-%2)%, ('89%L)*+0&= @9) 5'($ (' &*(%C( 2%:+*2%C( (*7%9+?2%C()
8($$62)&')7%&8(C( @9(?-(C(, *&% 9%?)'%-=2%% /%90 @(: &*(% F2+$0 9%-)C)(F2()&-+$&8)% -(F62C) (2% *+<<+/)'&8)%, @9+*:+, 2( '+8)%, 8('(9;% ('89;-) @6'=
&')<)) +2')96&&8)< 2+&'9(%2)1). # &%2'0/9% '(C( B% C(:+ -%2)2+/+:&8+0 C96@@+
('@9+*)-+ * ('&'+*86 &@)8%9+ @+9-+$%2'+, C+9$,+ @( @9()&<(B:%2).. # ('*%' 2+
5'( C+9$&8(-@+$)9&8+0 C96@@+ (9C+2)F(*+-+ &*(1 @%9*;1 $(L2;1 $)')2C 2+
@-(L+:) QF(:) (D*(/(:;) * !6?+2/%. K)')2C @9(*(:)-+ M&-+$&8+0 @+9')0 *(F9(B:%2)0 A+:B)8)&'+2+. !%$(89+')7%&8+0 @+9')0 -%C)')$)9(*+-+ %% :%0'%-=2(&'= * C-+F+< 3+@+:+. I(&&)1&8(% '%-%*):%2)% 2+F*+-( 5'(' $)')2C «$)')2C($
:%$(89+')7%&8)< &)- A+:B)8)&'+2+». T;- &/9(?%2 @+$0'2)8 E%2)26.
E):%9($ C+9$&8(-@+$)9&8(1 C96@@)9(*8) &'+2(*)'&0 !(*-+' R6:(2+F+9(* – 9%B)&&%9, 7%-(*%8, /-)F8)1 8 896C+$ )&-+$)&'&8(C( -):%9+ OC+-R+2+
* E(2:(2%, @(-)')7%&8)1 :%0'%-=, (@%8+%$;1 Z8(*-%*;$ ) J(9/+7%*;$. N'( (2
:)9)B)9(*+- @(-)')7%&8)$ C%2(,):($ * 9%&@6/-)8%. !(*-+'+ R6:(2+F+9(*+
@(::%9B)*+-+ K(&8*+.
#((/L% K(&8*+ F+20-+ F+$%7+'%-=2(% @( &*(%1 @(-)')7%&8(1 8(2>)C69+,)) @(F),).: &/9(& @+$0'2)8+ E%2)2+ @9()F*%- &'(-= C-6/(8(% *@%7+'-%2)% 2+
#%-)<(*+, 4(@(*+, D(/7+8+ ) :96C)<, 7'( *&% (&'+-=2;% 8($@(2%2'; @(-)')7%&8(C( @9(,%&&+ ('(?-) :-0 2)< 2+ F+:2)1 @-+2.
K(&8*+ * '( &$6'2(% *9%$0 @9)89;*+-+ ) (/%&@%7)*+-+ +8')*2(&'= -.:%1,
8('(9;< *%&=$+ 6&-(*2( $(B2( /;-( 2+F*+'= -.:=$) * C6$+2)&')7%&8($ @(2)$+2)) 5'(C( &-(*+. D9%:) 2)< H(:$(2 X&6> – /;*?)1 9+/('2)8 8+>%:9; $+98&)F$+--%2)2)F$+, /;*?)1 @+9'(9C O8+:%$)) 2+68, 968(*(:)'%-= 89(*+*(1 (9C+2)F+,)) «P+:B(') #+'+2» («O9$)0 2+,)(2+-=2(C( &@+&%2)0»). N'( (2 F+0*)-:
«I6&&8)% – 5'( 2+?) F+-(B2)8)». N'( %C( -.:) @(: 2%@(&9%:&'*%22;$ 968(*(:&'*($ $6--; O/:6-C+>69+ R6:(1:(:(*+ *F0-) * 8+7%&'*% F+-(B2)8(* :%'%1
* 96&&8(1 ?8(-%. N'(C( '%99(9)&'+ ) 6/)1,6 *F0- @(: &*(% 89;-( 2% '(-=8( $59
D+28'-4%'%9/69C+ O. D(/7+8, 2( ) /(-%% *;&(8)% )2&'+2,)), &$('9%*?)% &8*(F=
@+-=,; 2+ «?+-(&')» '+:B)8&8(C( «:%$(89+'+».
24 2(0/90 1991 C(:+ * A+:B)8)&'+2% &(&'(0-)&= *;/(9; 49%F):%2'+. !(*-+' R6:(2+F+9(* («9%B)&&%9») 2+/9+- *&%C( -)?= 30 % C(-(&(* (2% @($(C-+
) K(&8*+), I+<$(2 P+/)%* @(-67)- 60 %.
P+ @(&' 968(*(:)'%-0 #%9<(*2(C( D(*%'+ -%2)2+/+:,; @9(*%-) D+>+9+
"%2:B+%*+ – $(-(:(C( @(-)')8+ ,%2'9)&'&8(1 (9)%2'+,)), 0C2(/,+ @( @9()&<(B:%2)., -):%9+ $+-(7)&-%22(1 (/L)2;, @9(B)*+*?%1 *&% * '(1 B% E%2)2+/+:&8(1 (/-+&'). "%2:B+%* (* ('-)7)% (' P+/)%*+) 2% /;- &*0F+2 2)8+8)$) @9%:*;34
/(92;$) (/%L+2)0$). "%2:B+%* &'+- @(:@)&;*+'= F+8(2;, 2% *;F;*+*?)% *(&'(9C+ 6 M&-+$&8(1 @+9')) *(F9(B:%2)0 A+:B)8)&'+2+, + 25 $+9'+ 1992 C(:+ 2+
F+&%:+2)) #%9<(*2(C( D(*%'+ A+:B)8)&'+2+ (2 *((/L% (/*)2)- $)2)&'9+ *26'9%22)< :%- @+$)9,+ K+$+:+%F+ P+*:B6*+2(*+ * F-(6@('9%/-%2)) &-6B%/2;$
@(-(B%2)%$. 3+&%:+2)% '9+2&-)9(*+-(&= @( A#.
P+ &-%:6.L)1 :%2=, 26 $+9'+ 1992 C(:+, @-(L+:= H(<):(2 (K67%2)8(*)
6 F:+2)0 49+*)'%-=&'*+ A+:B)8)&'+2+ F+@(-2)-+ @+$)9&8+0 $(-(:%B=. VL% 7%9%F :%2= & 89)8+$) «M&'%>(!» («Q'&'+*8+!») 8 2)$ @9)&(%:)2)-)&= )&-+$&8+0
) «:%$(89+')7%&8+0» @+9')). " @%9*(2+7+-=2($6 -(F62C6 :(/+*)-)&= @9()9+2&8)% ) +2')-%2)2+/+:&8)% («P%' @('($8+$ 89(*+*(C( G)2C)&<+2+ * 968(*(:&'*%
A+:B)8)&'+2($!»)
20 +@9%-0 1992 C(:+ ('89;-+&= XIII &%&&)0 #%9<(*2(C( D(*%'+ A+:B)8)&'+2+. P+ 2%1 9%?%2( /;-( (&'+*)'= &@)8%9($ "%2:B+%*+. # 2(7= & 21 2+ 22 +@9%-0 F:+2)% @+9-+$%2'+ /;-( (896B%2( *((96B%22;$) ('90:+$) (@@(F),)).
23 +@9%-0 "%2:B+%* 6?%- * ('&'+*86, + 7-%2($ 49%F):)6$+ &'+2(*)'&0 8+F)8+-(2 9%&@6/-)8) R(:B+ O8/+9 A69+:B(2F(:+. N'( (2 2+ *&. &'9+26, (/9+L+0&= @( A# 8 /;*?%$6 @9%:&%:+'%-. (/-)&@(-8($+ JTOQ M&8+2:+9(*6 (2+8(2%,'( @+$)9,6, F+20*?%$6 $%&'( "%2:B+%*+!), &8+F+-: «P% &+:)&= * 5'( C26&2(%
8($$62)&')7%&8(% 89%&-(. Q2( F+C+B%2( '*()$) @9%:?%&'*%22)8+$). K; &:%-+%$ '%/% :96C(% 89%&-(». M 2+ $+2%9 &*()< %:)2($;?-%22)8(* @(:20- :*+ @+-=,+
**%9<: «4(/%:+!». M$%22( 5') B%&';, ) 5') &-(*+ *F(9*+-) "6-0/. # 2(7= 2+
23 +@9%-0 1992 C(:+ * !6?+2/% @9)/;-) 86-0/,;. Q2) F+20-) @-(L+:= QF(:),
2+ 8('(9(1 * &%2'0/9% 1991 C(:+ $)')2C(*+-) )< (@@(2%2';.
P+ :*6< @-(L+:0< (:2(1 ) '(1 B% 6-),; I6:+8), * @0')&'+< $%'9+< :96C ('
:96C+, ?-) :*+ $)')2C+. P+8+- &'9+&'%1 2+9+&'+-.
4%9*(1 @9(-)'(1 89(*=. /;-+ 89(*= 9%:+8'(9+ @9+*)'%-=&'*%22(1 C+F%';
«D+:() K+9:6$» («J(-(& 2+9(:+») K. H%9+-)%*+. VC( 6/)-) @90$( *( :*(9%
#%9<(*2(C( D(*%'+.
M 2+7+-(&= …
29 +@9%-0 1992 C(:+ 2+ XIV &%&&)) #%9<(*2(C( D(*%'+ "%2:B+%* /;- *(&&'+2(*-%2. # ('*%' (@@(F),)0 F+<*+')-+ '%-%*):%2)%, /-(8)9(*+-+ *&% @(:S%F:;
8 C(9(:6.
"($)'%' 2+,)(2+-=2(1 /%F(@+&2(&') ) K#! A+:B)8)&'+2+ F+0*)-)… ( 2%1'9+-)'%'%. P( 2+ &'(9(26 (@@(F),)) @%9%?%- &(*%'2)8 49%F):%2'+ @( (/(9(2%, &:+*
%1 200 &'*(-(* (C2%&'9%-=2(C( (96B)0 ) 4 /9(2%'9+2&@(9'%9+. # 9%F6-='+'% '(-=8(
7'( *(&&'+2(*-%22;1 "%2:B+%* 7%9%F 2%:%-. (8+F+-&0 &2(*+ &$%L%22;$.
K)')2C @-(L+:%1 H(<):(2 ) QF(:) F+8(27)-&0 '(-=8( 7%9%F 50 :2%1. G%$
5') $)')2C) &(@9(*(B:+-)&= – (':%-=2;1 9+FC(*(9.
7 $+0 & @-(L+:) QF(:) 6?-) 86-0/,;. <(:)-) & /(0$), '+8 8+8 *((96B%22+0 (@@(F),)0 @9%&-%:(*+-+ )<. M '(-=8( & 14 $+0 &'+-) 9+&&9%:('(7)*+'=&0
$)')2C6.L)% & @-(L+:) H(<):(2. #%926*?)&= :($(1, 86-0/,;, *):%*?)%, 7'(
@9()&<(:)-( 2+ H(<):(2%, F2+*?)% ( @;'8+< * @(:*+-+< ) $+&&(*;< 6/)1&'*+<
*( *9%$0 $)')2C+, (9C+2)F(*+-) 2+9(:2(% &(@9(')*-%2)%.
35
"(C:+ F+@+<-( 89(*=. ) @(9(<($, 2+ +9%26 &(/;')1 *;&'6@)- @9(&'(1 2+9(: ) %C( -):%9;.
Q:2)$ )F 2)< /;- $6--+ R+1:+9 H+9)>F(:+, *;&'6@)*?)1 @9(')* 8+F)8+-(2+, (/*)2)*?)1 %C( * *+<<+/)F$%, 76B:($ '+:B)8&8($6 2+9(:6, *;&'6@)(2 ) @9(')* ):%) «8+>)9&'*+» (2%7%&')*(&')). "(2>-)8' @9)(/9%- 2(*;% (7%9'+2)0: '%@%9= 6B% 2% -%2)2+/+:&8+0 2($%28-+'69+ /(9(-+&= & @+$)9&8(-C+9$&8(1
'(9C(*(1 $+>)%1, + 2+9(:2;1 )&-+$ – & 2+&)-=&'*%22( *2%:90%$(1 &+6:)&'&8(1
*%9&)%1 *+<<+/)F$+. !(&'+'(72( /;-( :(2%&') 5'( 2(*(% )F$%9%2)% 8(2>-)8'+
:( )&-+$&8)< 2+9(:(*, ) (2) 2% /;-) /; &'(-= (9)%2')9(*+2; 2+ «@9+*(*%92;<
*+<<+/)&'(*». P( 5'+ F+:+7+ 2% /;-+ 9%?%2+. P+9(:2;1 $6--+ R+1:+9 @9(8-08+F)8+-(2+ ), 8+8 ) @(-+C+%'&0 :6<(*2($6 -),6, @%9%:+- @(-)')7%&86. *-+&'=
2+9(:2;$ @9+*)'%-0$. P+9(:2;$ -):%9($ &'+2(*)'&0 D+2C+8 D+>+9(*. M$%22(
5'(' 7%-(*%8 – 2)8+8(1 2% @+9')%,, @9(&'(1 /6>%'7)8 ) 6B% 2%$(-(:(1 – 2+7+09(&'2( (/-)7+'= &'(9(22)8(* M&-+$&8(1 @+9')) *(F9(B:%2)0 A+:B)8)&'+2+,
F+L)L+'= 96&&8)<, @9)F;*+'= 8 ('@(96 &)-+$ @(-)')7%&8(C( '%99(9+. P+&'+-(
*9%$0 :96C)< -.:%1, *9%$0 2+9(:2(1 /(9=/;, *9%$0 *(12;.
E)72(&'= D+2C+8+ D+>+9(*+ (9(:)-&0 1 02*+90 1928 C(:+ * &%-% H6C2(*,
('%, %C( /;- 9%@9%&&)9(*+2, (/+ $-+:?)< /9+'+ 6$%9-) & C(-(:+, &'+9?)1 /;(&6B:%2 * 1939 C(:6) 2%F+690:2+. D (:2(1 &'(9(2;, %C( @9%:&'+*-0.' 8+8 6C(-(*2)8+: * 1951 C(:6 D+>+9(* @(-67)- 1 C(: -+C%9%1 F+ 6C(2 +*'($(/)-0,
* 1957-$ /;- (&6B:%2 F+ 2+%F: 2+ @%?%<(:+ &( &$%9'%-=2;$ )&<(:($, * 1964 C(:6, F+L)L+0&= (' 958%')9+-7%7%2,+, 6/)- %C(, F+ 7'( @(-67)- 2(*;1 &9(8; * )&@9+*)'%-=2(-'96:(*(1 8(-(2)) @(:20- *(&&'+2)% F+8-.7%22;< ) /;- (&6B:%2
2+ 6 -%'. Q/L)1 '.9%$2;1 &'+B 5'(C( 7%-(*%8+ – 23 C(:+. D :96C(1 &'(9(2;,
)$%22( 5'(' 7%-(*%8, )$%22( 5'+ -)72(&'= &;C9+-+ *;:+.L6.&0 9(-= * '+:B)8&8($ @9(')*(&'(02)). A(, 7'( A+:B)8)&'+2 (&'+-&0 &*%'&8)$ C(&6:+9&'*($, –
F+&-6C+ D+2C+8+ D+>+9(*+. D%17+& @9+*)'%-=&'*( A+:B)8)&'+2+ :)&'+2,)96%'&0
(' 5'(1 -)72(&'): 8+8 2)8+8 «6C(-(*2)8». P( &*):%'%-=&'*6. 8+8 7%-(*%8, @9%/;*+*?)1 2+ F%$-% A+:B)8)&'+2+ * 5'( &8(9/2(% *9%$0: )$%22( D+2C+8 &@+&
9%&@6/-)86, )$%22( %C( (9C+2)F+'(9&8)% &@(&(/2(&') ) -)72(% $6B%&'*( @(F*(-)-) &(F:+'= :(&'(12;1 @9(')*(*%& «:%$)&-+$)&'&8($6» 9+FC6-6 2+ F%$-% A+:B)8)&'+2+. 4(C)/2%' D+2C+8 *2%F+@2(, * 2(7= & 29 2+ 30 $+9'+ 1993 C(:+, @9)
2%*;0&2%22;< :( 8(2,+ (/&'(0'%-=&'*+<. 4(C)/2%' )$%22( '(C:+, 8(C:+ (&2(*2+0 «9+/('+» @( *;'%&2%2). )&-+$)&'(* ) )< ):%(-(C)) * A+:B)8)&'+2% /6:%'
&:%-+2+. #&% B)'%-) A+:B)8)&'+2+ * &8(9/) @9)20-) *%&'= ( &$%9') D+2C+8+.
Q '($, 8+8(% $%&'( -)72(&'= D+2C+8+ F+2)$+-+ * &(F2+2)) -.:%1, @%9%B)*?)<
6B+&; C9+B:+2&8(1 *(12;, $(B%' &*):%'%-=&'*(*+'= 2+F*+2)% &'+'=) 8(99%&@(2:%2'+ C+F%'; «E%2)2+/+:&8+0 @9+*:+» A. 4+-+')2&8(1: &'+'=0 & @9(L+-=2;$)
&-(*+$), (/9+L%22;$) 8 D+2C+86 D+>+9(*)76 D+>+9(*6, 2+F;*+%'&0 «VC( :+2+$ T(C». # &*(%$ 2%89(-(C% 4+-+')2&8+0 2+@)?%': «D '(1 7%92(1 $)26';, 8(C:+ 6&-;?+-+, 7'( D+2C+8 6/)', C(9% *(?-( * $(% &%9:,%. G'( /; '+$ 2) )F$;?-0-) ( 2%$ *9+C), 7'( /; 2) C(*(9)-) (/;*+'%-), 0, 96&&8+0, ) 2% 2+67%22+0 *%9)'= * T(C+ B%2L)2+, &8+B6: Q2 /;- &*0'(1 7%-(*%8. Q2 F+L)')- 2% '(-=8( &*(1
"6-0/, 2( ) 2+&, -%2)2+/+:,%*, (2 *%926- 2+$, 96&&8(0F;72;$, *%96 * '(, 7'( *&%
36
$;, '+:B)8)&'+2,;, – /9+'=0, *&% $; – :%') 5'(1 @9%89+&2(1 F%$-)… Q2 &@+&
2+?% Q'%7%&'*( (' &'9+?2(C( $9+8(/%&)0 )&-+$&8(C( >62:+$%2'+-)F$+… D+$
@9( &%/0 (2 C(*(9)-: “I(:)2+ – :(9(B% B)F2)”» [9, 10].
P( *%92%$&0 8 1992 C(:6. 7 &%2'0/90 1992 C(:+ (@@(F),)0 F+&'+*)-+ I+<$(2+ P+/)%*+ &-(B)'= &*() @(-2($(7)0. G%9%F $%&0, #%9<(*2;1 D(*%' A+:B)8)&'+2+ &(/9+-&0 2+ &%&&). * O9/(/% @(: R(:B%2'($: C-+*(1 9%&@6/-)8) & @(:+7) D+2C+8+ D+>+9(*+ /;- )F/9+2 N$($+-) I+<$(2(* («86-0/%,»), + @9%:&%:+'%-%$ D(*%'+ $)2)&'9(* – O/:6--(:B+2(* («-%2)2+/+:%,»).
#(%22;% :%1&'*)0 @(&-% !6?+2/)2&8(C( @9(')*(&'(02)0 @%9%$%&')-)&=
)F &'(-)72(C( ,%2'9+ * 9%C)(2;. Q@-('+$) )&-+$)&'(* /;-) '+8)% @628';, 8+8
"69C+2-A./%, "($&($(-+/+:, P(*+/+:, @(&%-(8 A698$%2)&'+2, J+9$, I($)' ) :9.
# "69C+2-A./% )&-+$)&'; *;9%F+.' (89+)22;1 C(9(:&8(1 8*+9'+- 9C6',
C:% B)-) 6F/%8), *;<(:,; )F D+$+98+2:+; * @(&%-8% A698$%2)&'+2, * /+2%, (2)
(9C+2)F6.' 2+&'(0L6. @;'(726.; 2+@+:+.' 2+ @(&%-(8 E($(2(&(*( ) 6&'9+)*+.' '+$ 9%F2..
Q'*%'2;$) :%1&'*)0$) 89+12% 9+F:9+B%22;< ) 9+FC2%*+22;< 86-0/,%*
&'+-( 2+@+:%2)% 2+ "69C+2-A./% ) F+&%*?6. '+$ (@@(F),).: /(%*(1 ('90: @(:
8($+2:(*+2)%$ E+2C+9) E+2C+9)%*+ *;/)*+%' )F C(9(:+ ) %C( @9)C(9(:(* *&%<
)&-+$)&'(*.
" (8'0/9. 1992 C(:+ @('%9) & (/%)< &'(9(2 &(&'+*)-) 15–20 ';&. 6/)';<,
2%&8(-=8( ';&07 9+2%2;<, & .C+ 6%<+-( @9+8')7%&8) *&% 2+&%-%2)%. MF 9%&@6/-)8) *;%<+-( F+ C(: 90 ';&. «96&&8(0F;72;<», + %&-) &7)'+'= & 1990 C(:+, '( @9)/-)F)'%-=2( 360 ';&.
G'(/; 7)'+'%-= @9%:&'+*-0- &%/% (/L6. +'$(&>%96 *(12;, * 8('(96. (8+F+-&0 @(C96B%22;$ @9(&'(1, (/;82(*%22;1, 2)8%$ ) 2)7%$ 2% F+L)L%22;1 7%-(*%8, @9)*%:6 >9+C$%2' )F F+$%'(8 :6?+2/)2,+ D. #(9(2,(*+ ( -)72;< @%9%B)*+2)0< ) 2+/-.:%2)0<: «# C(9(:% /%&@9%:%-. E.:) 2+@6C+2; B%&'(8)$)
6/)1&'*+$). #7%9+ F+ :($($, 2+ $6&(92(1 867% (8('(9;1 $%&0, 2% *;*(F0' 2+
&*+-86 ('<(:;) 2+1:%2 7%-(*%8 & (/(BB%22;$ -),($. P+?+ @0')5'+B8+ &'()' 2+
(89+)2%. 4(: (82+$) * /68*+-=2($ &$;&-% @9(<(:)' -)2)0 >9(2'+. K+9(:%9;
*9;*+.'&0 * 8*+9')9;, C9+/0', 6/)*+.'. D%:=$(1 $%&0, -.:) & +*'($+'+$) <(F012)7+.' * C(9(:%… Z *):%-, 8+8 '+L)-) 2+ /9(2. :%*6?86. Q2+ 89)7+-+. P)8'( 2% @(&$%- *&'6@)'=&0. 3+ :%2= :( 5'(C( &9%:= /%-+ :20 «2+8+F+-)» (:2(C( '+8(C( F+&'6@2)8+: F+*%-) F+ 6C(- ) @(-(&26-) +*'($+'2(1 (7%9%:=.. K(1 /9+' 8+8
9+F ?%- $)$(. G%-(*%8 6@+-, F+:%9C+-&0. H)9(8(@-%7)1 :%')2+ &2(*+ 2+B+- 869(8. Q&%78+… P% &@%?+ &$%2)- $+C+F)2, @%9%:%926- F+'*(9. #&'+*)- :6-( * @9)('89;';1 <9)@0L)1 9('… #8-.7+. '%-%*)F(9. # (&'+28)2&8)< «P(*(&'0<»
( 2+& (@0'= 2)8+8(1 )2>(9$+,))… #%&%-;% -),+, /)F2%&$%2; @=.' ?+$@+2&8(%. K(&8*% 2%' :%-+ :( 2+?)< &6:%/ ) @%9%B)*+2)1» [5].
D-%:&'*)%$ 89(*+*(1 /9+'(6/)1&'*%22(1 *(12; &'+-( '(, 7'( «:%$)&-+$)&';» @('%90-) &*(1 /%F6&-(*2;1 +*'(9)'%' * 2+9(:%. P+9(:2;% $+&&; &$%-%%
2+7)2+.' @(::%9B)*+'= «P+9(:2;1 >9(2'», *(FC-+*-0%$;1 D+2C+8($.
37
10 :%8+/90 1992 C(:+ * !6?+2/% 2+7+-&0 «/6$%9+2C(*;1» '%99(9 @9(')*
@+$)9,%* ) C+9$,%*.
# 02*+9%->%*9+-% 1993 C(:+ /;-) +9%&'(*+2; @9+8')7%&8) *&% :%0'%-) (@@(F),)) 2+ &%*%9% 9%&@6/-)8).
P+ .C% *(%22;% :%1&'*)0 @%9%$%&')-)&= * J+9$, I($)', !+9*+F. # 9+1(2%
I(C62+, "69C+2-A./%, Q/)C+9$+ (96:(*+-+ /+2:+ -.'(C( C(-(*(9%F+ I%F*(2+,
* A+*)-=:+9% – /+2:+ O/:6-C+>69+, * "+9+'%C)2% – /+2:; P+F)$+ ) M&$+'+.
Q '($, 8+8 /9+-) J+9$, (&(/;1 9+&&8+F. E%2)2+/+:&8)1 *(%22;1 :%&+2', *;&+:)*?)&= * J+9$% (2%&(&'(0*?%1&0 &'(-),% M&-+$&8(1 I%&@6/-)8)), &(@9(')*-%2)0 2% *&'9%')-. " /(1,+$ *;?-) @9%:&'+*)'%-) J+9$&8(C( 968(*(:&'*+ *( C-+*% & $6--(1 D++:):)2($. K6--+ @(8-0-&0 2+ "(9+2%, 7'( 2+ C+9$&8(1 F%$-% *(12;
2% /6:%'. Q9C+2)F(*+-) (?)-(?') – @-(* @9)$)9%2)0. 3+'%$ @9%:-(B)-) /(1,+$
C96F(*)8, 7'(/; '% ('@9+*)-)&= * !6?+2/% ) :(-(B)-) @9%F):%2'6 ( $)92($ )&<(:% (@%9+,))… M @(*%9)-) /(1,; 8-0'*% 2+ "(9+2%. P( *$%&'( !6?+2/% C+9$,;
@(*%F-) $(-(:%2=8)< /(1,(* * "($&($(-+/+: – @90$( * $%7%'=, * 8('(9(1 I%F*(2
9+F$%&')- &*(1 ?'+/… O '%@%9= :(86$%2'+-=2;% &'9(8) B692+-)&'+: «K2% @(8+F;*+-) 8+&&%'6, &20'6. :6?+2/)2&8)$ '%-%(@%9+'(9($… "+$%9+ $%:-%22( @-;*%' $%B:6 90:+$) )F6*%7%22;< '%- @(@+*?)< * @-%2 /(1,(*. !*+ '96@+ @9(&'(
&(BB%2;, (' (:2(C( (&'+-+&= *;&(<?+0 &$(9L%22+0 $6$)0. !96C(C( &B)C+-)
B)*=%$ * '+2:;9% – &'6@2), 8(-%2), /%:9+… 2%C( 2(C @9(&'( 2%' – *;C(9%-),
+ *;?% @(0&+ – '%-( %L% %&'=. $2(C)< ('9%F+2; 6?), @9('826'; @96'=0$) B)*(';, *;9*+2; 2(C'). !96C)% 8+&'9)9(*+2;… E%2)2+/+:,%*, %&-) @(@+:+-)&=, 2%
L+:)-), 6/)*+-) '+8, 7'(/; :96C)$ /;-( &'9+?2(» [11].
M %L% (:)2 +&@%8' *(12; – '(B% «7+&'2;1»: «# 9+FC+9 C%2(,):+, 9+F*0F+22(C( >62:+$%2'+-)&'+$), /%F *%&') @9(@+-( $2(C( -.:%1, * '($ 7)&-% :%*6?%8.
M< *;*(F)-) * O>C+2)&'+2 ) (/$%2)*+-) 2+ (96B)%. D2+7+-+ F+ :%*6?86 2%
&'+9?% 15 -%' :+*+-) :*+ C9+2+'($%'+ ) :*+ +*'($+'+. 4('($ ,%2+ 6@+-+ :( (:2(C( +*'($+'+. A+8 ) $%20-) ?'68+ 2+ ?'686…» [12].
U62:+$%2'+-)F$ * A+:B)8)&'+2% @9()C9+- 2% '(C:+, 8(C:+ %C( &'+-) '%&2)'= (96B)%$. Q2 @9()C9+- 6B% '(C:+, 8(C:+ 6B+&26- &+$)< '+:B)8(* &*(%1 )F6*%9&8(1 B%&'(8(&'=.. " @9)$%96, 8(C:+ ('90: /(<'+9,%* @(&%')- C+9$&86. $%7%'=, '( (/2+96B)-: «A+$ @( &'%2+$ /;-) 9+&@0'; @(@+*?)% * @-%2 /(1,;. #(&%$2+:,+'= 7%-(*%8 F+$67%2(. #(' '%/% ) &*0'(% $%&'(!» [12].
49+*)'%-=&'*( A+:B)8)&'+2+ (&6:)-( M&-+$&86. @+9'). *(F9(B:%2)0
A+:B)8)&'+2+ ) %% 968(*(:)'%-%1 (>),)+-=2(: 9 02*+90 1993 C(:+ @9(')* !(*-+'+ &$(2+, O8/+9+ A69+:B(2F(:; ) H(:$(2+ X&6>+ /;-) *(F/6B:%2; 6C(-(*2;% :%-+ @( (/*)2%2). * 9+F*0F;*+2)) C9+B:+2&8(1 *(12;.
21 ).20 1993 C(:+ 8(--%C)0 #%9<(*2(C( &6:+ A+:B)8)&'+2+ F+@9%')-+ :%0'%-=2(&'= M&-+$&8(1 @+9')) *(F9(B:%2)0 A+:B)8)&'+2+, !%$@+9')) A+:B)8)&'+2+, + '+8B% (/S%:)2%2)1 «I+&'(<%F» ) «E+-) T+:+<?(2».
#%&2+ 1993 C(:+ 6:+9)-+ @( A+:B)8)&'+26 &9+F6 & 2%&8(-=8)< &'(9(2: *(@%9*;<, A+:B)8)&'+2 (&'+-&0 * &'+9(1 96/-%*(1 F(2%, @9%89+')-)&= *&% *2%?2)%
'(9C(*;% &*0F) 9%&@6/-)8), 9+/(7)$ ) &-6B+L)$ 2% *;:+*+-+&= F+9+/('2+0 @-+38
'+, F/%8)&'+2 @9%89+')- @(&'+*8) C+F+; *(-*'(9;<, 2+ .C% *&-%:&'*)% &)-=2%1?)< &%-%1 (8(27+'%-=2( 9+F96?)-(&= &%-=&8(% <(F01&'*(; &'()$(&'= /6<+28)
<-%/+ * A+:B)8)&'+2% (* +*C6&'%) *F-%'+%' :( 165 96/-%1; /+28) F+$(9+B)*+.'
*&% *8-+:;; 2+7)2+%'&0 C(-(: – *&% @(-8) * $+C+F)2+< @6&';, + 2+ /+F+9+< 2)7%C(
2%-=F0 86@)'= )F-F+ ('&6'&'*)0 :%2%B2;< &9%:&'* [13–16]. I(-= :%2%C 2+7)2+.'
*;@(-20'= … @6&';% /6';-8), + 9(-= &:+7) @9) 9+&7%'+< – 86&(78) <-%/+.
# ).-% 1993 C(:+ F+96/%B2;% *:(<2(*)'%-) '+:B)8&8)< &(/;')1 2+7)2+.' $+&&)9(*+22( +'+8(*+'= '+:B)8&8(-+>C+2&86. C9+2),6. # 9%B)$% 79%F*;7+12(C( @(-(B%2)0 2%&6' &-6B/6 402:B&8)1, K(&8(*&8)1, "+-+)<6$/&8)1, R(9(C&8)1, M?8+?)$&8)1 ) K69C+/&8)1 @(C9+2('90:;. A9+C)7%&8)% &(/;')0 2+
12-1 @(C9+2)72(1 F+&'+*% K(&8(*&8(C( @(C9+2('90:+ ) 2+ 67+&'8% M?8+?)$+
(5'( '(-=8( '(, 7'( @(@+-( * DKM, 2( $2(C(% ) 2% @(@+-(: F+&'+*+ !+?')ZFC6-[$, 67+&'(8 R(9(C+).
201-0 $('(&'9%-8(*+0 :)*)F)0 (I(&&)0) @( &(C-+&(*+2). & K)2)&'%9&'*($
(/(9(2; I(&&)) 2%&%' (<9+26 P69%8&8(1 JND, Z*+2&8(C( 5-%8'9($%<+2)7%&8(C(
8($/)2+'+, #+<?&8(C( +F('2(-'68(*(C( F+*(:+, 90:+ (/S%8'(* *(%22(C( 2+F2+7%2)0, 67+&'8(* +*'(:(9(C 2+ C(92;% @%9%*+-; *:(-= C9+2), "6-0/&8(1 ) "69C+2A./)2&8(1 (/-+&'%1. 49) 5'($ $)9('*(97%&8+0 $)&&)0 :)*)F)) @(&'(022( )F*9+L+%'&0 * DKM.
49)$)9%2)% *(..L)< &'(9(2 * 9%&@6/-)8% ) 2+ %% C9+2),+< & O>C+2)&'+2($ (&6L%&'*-0-(&= (7%2= &-(B2(: )$%-( $%&'( 9 9+62:(* @%9%C(*(9(*. M '(-=8( 23 :%8+/90 1996 C(:+ * K(&8*% /;-( @(:@)&+2( &(C-+?%2)%, @(: 8('(9;$ @(&'+*)-) @(:@)&) N$($+-) I+<$(2(* ) D+1%: O/:6--+ P69) (@9%:&'+*)'%-= '+:B)8&8(C( @9+*)'%-=&'*+ «* )FC2+2))», * @9(?-($ C-+*2;1 9%:+8'(9 @%7+'2(C(
(9C+2+ 8+F)0'+ «K)2/+9) )&-($» – «"+>%:9+ )&-+$+»). N'( &(C-+?%2)% /;-(
>(9$+-=2;$ (8(27+2)%$ C9+B:+2&8(1 *(12; * A+:B)8)&'+2%.
27 ).20 1997 C(:+ * "9%$-% /;-( @(:@)&+2( %L% (:2( $)92(% &(C-+?%2)%
@9(')*(/(9&'*6.L)< &'(9(2. # &(('*%'&'*)) & 5')$ &(C-+?%2)%$ 49%F):%2'($
A+:B)8)&'+2+ (&'+-&0 &'(9(22)8 &*%'&8(C( @9+*-%2)0 N$($+-) I+<$(2(*. #$%&'% & '%$ (@@(F),)0 @(-67)-+ $%&'+ * @+9-+$%2'%, +:$)2)&'9+')*2;% :(-B2(&'), :)9%8'(9&8)% @(&'; 2+ 9+F-)72;< 896@2;< @9%:@9)0')0<.
D 1998 C(:+ 27 ).20 (/S0*-%2( C(&6:+9&'*%22;$ @9+F:2)8($ – !2%$ 2+,)(2+-=2(C( @9)$)9%2)0 * A+:B)8)&'+2%.
Q:2+8( '+8 2+F;*+%$;% «$+-;% C96@@;» (@@(F),)), 2% @(:@)&+*?)% &(C-+?%2)0, @9(:(-B+.' &*() 89(*+*;% *;-+F8) ) :( &)< @(9, * 7+&'2(&'), ('90:
K6--( O/:6--(, /+F)96.L)1&0 * '96:2(:(&'6@2;< 9+1(2+<.
Q/L)% )'(C) *(12;: A+:B)8)&'+2 &'+- (:2(1 )F /%:2%1?)< &'9+2 $)9+. QC9($2(% 8(-)7%&'*( /%B%2,%* @(8)26-( &'9+26. K2(C)% '+:B)8) 5$)C9)9(*+-)
* O>C+2)&'+2. 4(7') *&% 96&&8(% 2+&%-%2)%, + '+8B% 2%$,;, 689+)2,;, 8(9%1,;,
%*9%) ) @9%:&'+*)'%-) :96C)< 2%8(9%22;< 2+9(:(* *;26B:%2; /;-) )&8+'= 6/%B)L% * I(&&)) ) :96C)< &'9+2+<. "'(-'( &6$%- +:+@')9(*+'=&0 * 2(*(1 &9%:%. "'('( @(?%- 2+ &(,)+-=2(% :2( ) /%:&'*6%' :( &)< @(9. T(-=?(% 7)&-( '+:B)8(* )F-F+
2%&@(&(/2(&') @9(8(9$)'= &*() &%$=) *;26B:%2; 2%-%C+-=2( 9+/('+'= * I(&&)).
39
O 8+8(*; 69(8)?.. D+$;1 C-+*2;1 69(8 *&%$ – @9+*)'%-0$ ) -.:0$: 2)8(C:+, 2)8(C:+ 2% /6:='% 2+/-.:+'%-0$). V&-) F+$%')-) 3-(, 2% F+)C9;*+1'% & 2)$,
2% 9+F:6*+1'% %C( – C+&)'%, 9%?)'%-=2( ) B%&'8(. !(/9( :(-B2( /;'= & 86-+8+$)!..
!"#$% &"'()*'+),
1. T%-;< #., T69/;C+ P. "69C+2-A./% – C(9(: $%9'*;< // MF*%&')0. –1992. –
8 &%2'. – \ 200.
2. T6?8(* #.M., K)86-=&8)1 !.#. O2+'($)0 C9+B:+2&8(1 *(12; * A+:B)8)&'+2% (N'2(-&(,)+-=2;% @9(,%&&; ) @(-)')7%&8+0 /(9=/+, 1992–1995). – K.:
I(&. >(2: >62:. )&&-., 1996.
3. K+'+'(* K. I%*(-.,)0 &2)F6 (1917 C.) ) 8(2'99%*(-.,)0 &*%9<6 (1991–
1993 CC.) [N-%8'9(22;1 9%&69&]. – URL: ferghana.ru.
4. 4+-+')2&8+0 A. D,%2+9)1 :-0 A+:B)8)&'+2+ // E%2)2+/+:&8+0 @9+*:+. –
1993. – 27 ).-0. – \ 89.
5. #(9(2,(* D. MC9+ * 8-+&&)8) // E%2)2+/+:&8+0 @9+*:+. – 1993. –
5 +*C. – \ 93.
6. A+:B)8&8)1 6F%-: +2+-)F (&'9(1 &)'6+,)), 9%8($%2:+,)) *-+&'0$ // D(*%'&8+0 I(&&)0. – 1993. – 29 ).-0. – \ 89.
7. "69/+2(*+ K. J. T(/(&+:;8(*+ – «B%-%F2+0 -%:)» '+:B)8&8(C( W" //
Asia-Plus. – 2007. – 28 2(0/.
8. "(-0:+. J%2(,): 96&&8)< – T%-+0 82)C+ @+$0'). OF%9/+1:B+2 [N-%8'9(22;1 9%&69&]. – URL: http://radosvet/net/zdrava/genocide.
9. 4+-+')2&8+0 A. VC( :+- 2+$ T(C // E%2)2+/+:&8+0 @9+*:+. – 1993. –
1 +@9. – \ 39.
10. U9%1:8)2 T. J%9() 2% 6$)9+.' // E%2)2+/+:&8+0 @9+*:+. –1993. –
3 +@9. – \ 40.
11. 4+-+')2&8+0 A. J+9$. J(: :%*02(&'( '9%')1… // E%2)2+/+:&8+0 @9+*:+. – 1993. – 1 ).20. – \ 65.
12. 4+-+')2&8+0 A. J+9$. J(: :%*02(&'( '9%')1… // E%2)2+/+:&8+0 @9+*:+. – 1993. – 2 ).20. – \ 66.
13. O2 I. «G6*&'*6. &%/0 /;:-($…» // E%2)2+/+:&8+0 @9+*:+. – 1994. –
29 $+9'+. – \ 38.
14. O2 I. T(-= ) &';: F+ 8+B:;$ @)&=$($, F*(28($ '%-%>(22;$ // E%2)2+/+:&8+0 @9+*:+. –1994. – 14 +@9. – \ 45.
15. V&%28(* T. !(%:+.' &6<+9)… (&)C2+- /%:&'*)0) // E%2)2+/+:&8+0 @9+*:+. – 1994. – 14 +@9. – \ 45.
16. U+1F)%* I. T(C 9%?)- @9(67)'= $(1 2+9(:? (*$%&'( ('89;'(C( @)&=$+
968(*(:&'*6 9%&@6/-)8)) // E%2)2+/+:&8+0 @9+*:+. – 1994. – 2 +@9. – \ 40.
4(-67%2( 22.04.2011
40
N.V. Solonik
Lysva branch of Perm state technical university
PAGES OF THE USSR COLLAPSE: CIVIL WAR IN TAJIKISTAN
The article examines the socio-political situation in Tajikistan in the 90s of XX
century, a typology of different political groups, ideological trends as well as demographic, environmental and economic conditions of the population. Antagonistic contradictions and consequences of the events of that period are discussed.
Keywords: political struggle, ethnic, religious relations, lessons and consequences of the USSR collapse
41