танатология — наука о смерти

реклама
KH<J?F?GG:Y =MF:GBKLBQ?KD:YEBL?J:LMJ:
;b[ebhl_dZikbohZgZeblbq_kdhcebl_jZlmju
ih^h[s_cj_^Zdpb_cFFJ_r_lgbdh\Zb :B;_edbgZ
K_j]_cJyaZgp_\
L:G:LHEH=BY²G:MD:H KF?JLB
<hklhqgh?\jhi_ckdbcBgklblmlIkbohZgZebaZKZgdlI_l_j[mj] KH>?J@:GB?
=E:<: ,³0HPHQWRPRUL´
=E:<:,,Kf_jlvdebgbq_kdZyb [bheh]bq_kdZy
=E:<:,,,IjZ\hgZe_]dmxkf_jlv
=E:<: ,9Hiulkf_jlbbebl_dlh\_jgmebkv
=E:<:9@b\hcljmi
=E:<:9,Ih]j_[_gb_aZ`b\h
=E:<:9,,K\b^_l_evkl\m_lljmi
=E:<:9,,,G_le_ggu_fhsb
=E:<: ,;Fmfby\ fZ\ahe__
=E:<:;Ih]j_[Zevgu_h[jy^ui_j\h[ulguoie_f_g
=E:<:;,LZdaZ\_sZeAZjZlmrljZ
=E:<:;,,H]g_ggh_ih]j_[_gb_
=E:<:;,,,Kfbj_ggh_deZ^[bs_
=E:<:;,9LjZ^bpbb<hklhdZ
=E:<:;9Bkdmkkl\hwiblZnbb
=E:<:;9,DZagblvihdhcgbdZ
=E:<:;9,,Ijhdeylb_nZjZhgh\
=E:<:;9,,,Aeu_f_jl\_pu
=E:<:;,;=hehkZbaaZ]jh[gh]hfbjZ
=E:<:;;FZnmkZbeh\ \_d
=E:<:;;,< ihbkdZowebdkbjZ[_kkf_jlby
=E:<:;;,,I_j_k_e_gb_^mr
=E:<: ;;,,,?ebk_ckdb_iheyb jZckdb_kZ^uW^_fZ
=E:<:,
³0HPHQWRPRUL
GbgZkhegp_gb gZkf_jlvg_evaykfhlj_lv\ mihj
EZjhrnmdh
;hevrbgkl\mkh\j_f_gguoex^_ck\hckl\_gghklhjhgblvky\k_]hqlhk\yaZghkh
kf_jlvxK_]h^gy[hevrbgkl\hjh`^Z_lkyb mfbjZ_lm`_g_ih^djur_cjh^gh]h^hfZ
Z \debgbdZob [hevgbpZo I_j_^h\_jb\ k_[y Fbga^jZ\m q_eh\_d ihemqbe beexahjgh_
hk\h[h`^_gb_ hl ijh[e_f \_ebdh_ lZbgkl\h kf_jlb klZeh \ hkgh\ghf ly]hklghc
h[yaZgghklvx h kh[kl\_gghc dhgqbg_ g_ ijbgylh jZkkm`^Zlv Fu h[_j_]Z_f
ih^jZklZxs__ ihdhe_gb_ hl jZa^mfbc h kf_jlb mljZlbeb fm`_kl\h ]h\hjblv h g_c \
aj_ehf\hajZkl_\lbohfhedmijh\h`Z_f\ ihke_^gbcimlvk\hbojh^guob [ebadbo
Dh]^Zlh ih mebpZf ]hjh^h\ ke_^h\Zeb ihohjhggu_ ijhp_kkbb [h]Zlh
mdjZr_ggucdZlZnZedkhijh\h`^ZeZlhj`_kl\_ggZyfmaudZ^moh\uohjd_kljh\Z k_cqZk
^Z`_ ljZmjgu_ e_glu b l_ bkq_aeb k [hjlh\ Z\lh[mkh\dZlZnZedh\ \eb\Zxsboky
_`_^g_\gh\ g_kdhgqZ_fucihlhdfZrbg
<ijhq_fex^yf\k_]^Z[uehk\hckl\_gghba[_]ZlvjZa]h\hjh\h kf_jlbb ^Z`_
kZfh keh\h ³mf_j_lv´ \ ih\k_^g_\ghc j_qb klZjZebkv aZf_gylv dZdbfbeb[h ^jm]bfb
[he__ kfy]q_ggufb \ujZ`_gbyfb ³hlijZ\blvky \ emqrbc fbj´ ³ijbdZaZlv ^he]h
`blv´ ³ijhlygmlv gh]b´ :gZeh]bqgu_ yaudh\u_ lZ[m iZ keh\h ³mf_j_lv´ bf_ebkv b \
^jm]boyaudZo\ Zg]ebckdhf ² ³WRJR´mclb ³WRWDNHWKHIHUU\´ k_klvgZiZjhf ³WRKRS
RIIWKHWZLJ´ kiju]gmlvk \_ldb\ g_f_pdhf² ³GLH $XJHQVFKOLHVVHQ´ aZdjulv]eZaZ
³KHLPJHKHQ´ mclb^hfhc
Ihfgbh kf_jlbeZl
\ blZevygkdhf ² ³ULWRUQHUDUH DO QXOOD´ \_jgmlvky d gmex \ bkiZgkdhf ² ³LUVH DO RWUR
SRWUHUR´ hlijZ\blvkygZ^jm]h_iZkl[bs_\hnjZgpmakdhf² ³FDVVHUVDSLSH´kehfZlv
k\hx ljm[dm ³LO GLW ERQVRLU D
OD FRPSDJQLH´ hg ihijhsZeky k dhfiZgb_c LZd`_
klZjZebkv g_ ijhbaghkblv b keh\h ³deZ^[bs_´ <f_klh wlh]h \ jmkkdhf yaud_
mihlj_[eyebihgylb_³f_klhmkihdh_gby´\ Zg]ebckdhf² ³*RG
VDFUH´ ;h`v_ihe_\
g_f_pdhf ² ³GHU KHLOLJH 2UW´ k\ylh_ f_klh \ bkiZgkdhf ² ³FKDFDULWD´ fZe_gvdZy
n_jfZ\hnjZgpmakdhf² ³ERXOHYDUGGHVDOORSJHV´ m^ebg_gguc[mev\Zj
AZf_qZl_evgucjmkkdbcibkZl_evkZlbjbdFboZbeFboZceh\bqAhs_gdhibkZe\
k\h_cnbehkhnkdhcdgb]_³I_j_^\hkoh^hfkhegpZ´³Hlghr_gb_d kf_jlb²wlhh^gZ
ba \_ebqZcrbo ijh[e_f k dhlhjhc g_ij_f_ggh klZedb\Z_lky q_eh\_d \ k\h_c `bagb
H^gZdhwlZijh[e_fZg_lhevdhg_jZaj_r_gZ\ ebl_jZlmj_\ bkdmkkl\_\ nbehkhnbb
gh hgZ ^Z`_ fZeh ijh^mfZgZ J_r_gb_ __ ij_^hklZ\e_gh dZ`^hfm q_eh\_dm \
hl^_evghklb: mfq_eh\_q_kdbckeZ[im]eb\HghldeZ^u\Z_lwlhl\hijhk^hihke_^gbo
^g_c dh]^Z j_rZlv m`_ iha^gh B l_f [he__ iha^gh [hjhlvky iha^gh kh`Ze_lv qlh
fukebh kf_jlbaZklZeb\jZkieho´
³Ex^b kljZrZlky kf_jlb dZd fZeu_ ^_lb ihl_fhd² ]h\hjbe Zg]ebckdbc
nbehkhn Njwgkbk ;wdhg ²² b dZd m ^_l_c wlhl \jh`^_gguc kljZo
mkbeb\Z_lkykdZadZfblZd`_lhqghb kljZokf_jlb´
Kh\j_f_ggu_ bkke_^h\Zl_eb q_eh\_q_kdhc iZe_hikbobdb kh]eZkgu \ lhf qlh
kZfu_i_j\u_ijh[e_kdbfukebm ibl_dZgljhih\b g_Zg^_jlZevp_\fh]eb[ulv\ua\Zgu
`b\hlguf bgklbgdlhf kZfhkhojZg_gby klj_fe_gb_f ijh^eblv k\h_ kms_kl\h\Zgb_
ij_h^he_lv g_hl\jZlbfhklv kf_jlb ³M[_]Zy hl kf_jlb² ibkZe kh\_lkdbc agZlhd
Zglbqghc fbnheh]bb Ydh\ =hehkh\d_j² g_ ihgbfZy __ b q_f ^Zevr_ l_f \k_
khkj_^hlhq_gg_c fmqbl_evg_c b ljZ]bqg_c fukey h g_c b l_f kZfuf \k_ [he__ g_
ihgbfZy__ b[hgbdZdZygZmdZg_ihgyeZkf_jlbb g_ijbfbjbeZk g_xfukevq_eh\_d
[hjykvaZkms_kl\h\Zgb_aZk\hx`bagvaZk\hxfukevmklj_feyekyd \_qghc`bagbd
[_kkf_jlbx BgZq_ hg g_ fh] bgZq_ fukev g_ fh]eZ Hg `bagv g_ \u^_j`Ze [u [_a
fukebh \_qghc`bagb´
< rmf_jh\Z\behgkdhf wihk_ h =bev]Zf_r_ ,,, lukyq_e_lby ^h gZr_c wju fu
\i_j\u_ \klj_qZ_fky k ^hdmf_glZevguf k\b^_l_evkl\hf kljZoZ kf_jlb =_jhc wihkZ
=bev]Zf_rlZdhieZdb\Z_lkf_jlvk\h_]h^jm]ZWgdb^m
³Y ijheb\Zeke_auih^e__]hljmiZgZ^_ykvqlhWgdb^m\klZg_lGhgZk_^vfhc
^_gv\ _]hghkijhgbdebq_j\bb yihgyeqlhhgm`_g_\_jg_lkyb ihohjhgbe_]hK l_o
ihj y g_ agZx ihdhy L_eh fh_]h ^jm]Z jZkkuiZehkv \ ijZo b kf_rZehkv k a_fe_c Y
agZxqlhb fg_km`^_gZlZdZy`_mqZklvFh_l_ehlZd`_ij_\jZlblky\ ijZob ]ebgmY
kljZrmkvkf_jlb
Fgh]b_[hylkypbnju ohlyb g_fh]mlh[tykgblvq_fbokljZrblwlhqbkeh
Pbnjum jy^ZgZjh^h\h[hagZqZebkv[md\ZfbbhdZau\Z_lkym ^j_\gbo_\j__\qbkeh
b keh\h³kf_jlv´ibkZebkvh^gbfagZdhf<hlgZkdhevdhkbe_gkljZokf_jlbqlh^Z`_
g_\_^Zym`_agZq_gbyqbkeZfu\k_jZ\ghklZjZ_fkyba[_]Zlv_]h
< Yihgbb`_ba[_]Zxlpbnju ghihlhc`_ijbqbg_ijbql_gbbb_jh]ebnZ
²³kb´²hga\mqbldZd^jm]hcb_jh]ebnhagZqZxsbc³kf_jlv´< yihgkdbo[hevgbpZo
\ug_\klj_lbl_iZeZluk ghf_jhfZ _keba^Zgb_fgh]hwlZ`gh_lhb \mdZaZl_e_ebnlZ
\ug_gZc^_l_q_l\_jlh]hwlZ`Z
<_ebdbc]hkm^ZjvFhkdh\kdbcb \k_yJmkbkZfh^_j`_ppZjvFboZbeN_^hjh\bq
JhfZgh\ ² hl g_ij_klZgguo jZa^mfbc h kf_jlb ³\iZe \ g_ih^\b`ghklv´ b
mf_j³hldjmqbgu´
Ba\_klgh qlh jhkkbckdZy bfi_jZljbpZ ?ebaZ\_lZ I_ljh\gZ hq_gv [hyeZkv
ihdhcgbdh\hgZ^Z`_g_\oh^beZ\ lhl^hf]^_e_`ZeihdhcgbdDh]^Z]jZn:ijZdkbg
mf_j \ PZjkdhf K_e_ \ dZa_gghf a^Zgbb lh l_eh _]h \ug_keb ih^ rZl_j ;hevgh]h
Q_]ehdh\Z hlijZ\beb ^hfhc qlh[u hg g_ mf_j \h ^\hjp_ Ijb g_c \ ]h^m \ur_e
mdZaaZij_sZ\rbcghkblvfbfh^\hjpZihdhcgbdh\
Kh\j_f_gguc bg^bckdbc nbehkhn ;oZ]Z\Zg Rjb JZ^`g_r \ k\hbo
³JZafure_gbyo h[ baj_q_gbyo BbkmkZ´ ]h\hjbl ³ dh]^Z dlhgb[m^v dZdgb[m^v
mihfbgZeh kf_jlbNj_c^gZqbgZe^jh`Zlv>\Z`^uhg^Z`_l_jyekhagZgb_b iZ^Zekh
klmeZ lhevdh ihlhfm qlh dlhlh ]h\hjbe h fmfbyo \ ?]bil_ < ^jm]hc jZa Xg] lh`_
]h\hjbe h kf_jlb b h ljmiZo b \^jm] Nj_c^ aZ^jh`Ze miZe b ihl_jye khagZgb_ ?keb
kf_jlv lZd kljZrgZ ^ey Nj_c^Z qlh lh]^Z ]h\hjblv h _]h mq_gbdZo" B ihq_fm kf_jlv
\uau\Z_llZdhckljZo"Fh`_l_eb\uk_[_ij_^klZ\blv;m^^m[hysbfkykf_jlb"Lh]^Z
hg[hevr_q_f;m^^Z´
A^_kv ijZ\^Z m\e_drbkv ihe_fbdhc ^hklhihql_gguc ;oZ]Z\Zg Rjb JZ^`g_r
aZ[u\Z_lqlh;m^^Zb klZe;m^^hc[eZ]h^Zjy\hagbdr_fmm g_]hkljZomkf_jlbDZd\u
ihfgbl_bklhjbq_kdbc;m^^Z²pZj_\bq=ZmlZfZjh^beky\ f ]h^m^hgw\ h^ghf
bak_\_jguodgy`_kl\Bg^bb\ hdj_klghklyo]hjh^ZDZibeZ\Zklm=ZmlZfZjhk\_k_euf
b `bag_jZ^hklguf gh h^gZ`^u m[_`Z\ ba pZjkdh]h ^\hjpZ b hdZaZ\rbkv gZ mebpZo
]hjh^Z[_aijbkfhljZkem]hg\i_j\u_m\b^_ely`_eh[hevgh]hq_eh\_dZaZl_fm[h]h]h
gbs_]h b gZdhg_p l_eh mf_jr_]h q_eh\_dZ Ihljyk_gguc b ih^Z\e_gguc e_lgbc
=ZmlZfZj_rbeihdbgmlvjh^ghc^hfb k_fvxjZ^bkiZk_gbyk\h_c^mrbb ihke_^he]bo
kljZgkl\bc b bkdZgbc gZdhg_p ^hklb] lh]h hkh[h]h khklhygby dhlhjh_ gZau\Z_lky
³;m^oZ´²³ijhk\_le_gguc´
Hlghr_gb_ d kf_jlb f_gy_lky \ jZagu_ bklhjbq_kdb_ wihob Ih fg_gbx
g_dhlhjuo kh\j_f_gguo mq_guo N :jb_k hlghr_gb_ d kf_jlb kem`bl wlZehghf
bg^bdZlhjhfoZjZdl_jZpb\bebaZpbb
Kf_jlv KhdjZlZ gZ fgh]b_ klhe_lby ij_^hij_^_ebeZ hlghr_gb_ d kf_jlb
fukebl_e_c^j_\ghklb³Kf_jlv²]h\hjbeKhdjZl²^hgw ijb]h\hj_gguc
Znbgkdbfkm^hf d kf_jlghc dZagb b h`b^Zxsbc dh]^Z lxj_fsbd ih^g_k_l _fm qZrm
y^h\blhc pbdmlu² wlh h^gh ba ^\mo eb[h mf_j_lv agZqbl klZlv gbq_f lZd qlh
mf_jrbc gbq_]h m`_ g_ qm\kl\m_l eb[h `_ _keb \_jblv ij_^Zgbyf wlh dZdZylh
i_j_f_gZ ^ey ^mrb i_j_k_e_gb_ __ ba a^_rgbo f_kl \ ^jm]h_ f_klh ?keb gbq_]h g_
qm\kl\h\Zlvlhwlh\k_jZ\ghqlhkhgdh]^ZkibrvlZdqlh^Z`_gbq_]hg_\b^brv\h
kg_lh]^Zkf_jlvm^b\bl_evgh_ijbh[j_l_gb_K ^jm]hcklhjhgu _kebkf_jlv_klvdZd
[u i_j_k_e_gb_ hlkx^Z \ ^jm]h_ f_klh b \_jgh ij_^Zgb_ qlh lZf gZoh^ylky \k_
mf_jrb_lh_klvebqlhgb[m^vemqr_wlh]h">Zy ]hlh\mf_j_lvfgh]hjZa_keb\k_wlh
ijZ\^Z^eyf_gy[ueh[u\hkoblbl_evgh\_klblZf[_k_^u´
?s_[hevr__\ebygb_gZihlhfdh\hdZaZehhlghr_gb_d kf_jlbWibdmjZ²
^hgw< ibkvf_d k\h_fm^jm]mF_g_d_xhgibkZe³Ijb\udZc^mfZlvqlhkf_jlv
^eygZk²gbqlh\_^v\k_b ohjhr__b ^mjgh_aZdexqZ_lky\ hsms_gbbZ kf_jlv_klv
ebr_gb_ hsms_gbc KlZeh [ulv kZfh_ m`Zkgh_ ba ahe kf_jlv g_ bf__l d gZf
gbdZdh]hhlghr_gbydh]^Zfu_klvlhkf_jlb_s_g_lZ dh]^Zkf_jlvgZklmiZ_llhgZk
m`_g_l´
Wlhl l_abk WibdmjZ g_h^ghdjZlgh \Zjvbjh\Zeky \ fgh]hqbke_gguo wib]jZffZo
wihob<hajh`^_gbyb [he__iha^g_]h\j_f_gb< dZq_kl\_lbibqgh]hijbf_jZmdZ`_fgZ
wib]jZffmnjZgpmakdh]hihwlZ@ZgNjZgkmZ=brZjZ ²
Kf_jlvkh\_jr_gghg_lj_\h`bl<hh[jZ`_gb_fh_
IhdZy _kfv²g_fh`_l[ulv__: _klvhgZ²f_gym`[ulvg_fh`_l
< kh\j_f_gghf h[s_kl\_ gZ[ex^Z_lky l_g^_gpby d \ul_kg_gbx kf_jlb ba
dhee_dlb\gh]hkhagZgbydh]^Zih ml\_j`^_gbx aZiZ^guo khpbheh]h\ h[s_kl\h \_^_l
k_[ylZddZd[m^lh\hh[s_gbdlhg_mfbjZ_lb kf_jlvbg^b\b^Zg_ijh[b\Z_lgbdZdhc
[j_rb \ kljmdlmj_ h[s_kl\Z < gZb[he__ bg^mkljbZebabjh\Zgguo kljZgZo AZiZ^Z
dhgqbgZ q_eh\_dZ h[klZ\e_gZ lZd qlh hgZ klZgh\blky ^_ehf h^gbo lhevdh \jZq_c b
ij_^ijbgbfZl_e_c aZgyluo ihohjhgguf [bag_khf G_ emqr_ Z \h fgh]hf b
agZqbl_evghom`_h[klhbl^_ehm gZkQ_fm`_lmlm^b\eylvky"Ihqlbg_lebl_jZlmju
ml_jyghiulfgh]boihdhe_gbcmljZq_guwlbq_kdb_ghjfZlb\u
>j_\g__eZlbgkdh_baj_q_gb_³f_f_glhfhjb´^he`ghaZgylvih^h[Zxs__f_klh
\ `bagb dZ`^h]h q_eh\_dZ >Z\gh ihjZ jZajmrblv gZr bkdmkkl\_gguc ijbfblb\guc
hilbfbaf b g_]eZkgh \g_^jy\r__ky ³lZ[m kf_jlb´ <_ebdbc njZgpmakdbc fukebl_ev
Fbr_ev Fhgl_gv ² kh\_lh\Ze ³Ebrbf kf_jlv __ aZ]Z^hqghklb
ijbkfhljbfky d g_c ijbmqbfky d g_c jZafureyy h g_c qZs_ g_`_eb h q_feb[h
^jm]hfLZdihklmiZeb_]bilyg_m dhlhjuo[ueh[uqZc\ghkblv\ lhj`_kl\_ggmxaZem
gZjy^m k kZfufb emqrbfb y\kl\Zfb b gZibldZfb fmfbx dZdh]hgb[m^v ihdhcgbdZ
qlh[uhgZkem`beZgZihfbgZgb_f^eyibjmxsboDlhgZmqbekymfbjZlvlhljZamqbeky
[ulvjZ[hf=hlh\ghklvmf_j_lvba[Z\ey_lgZkhl\kydh]hih^qbg_gbyb ijbgm`^_gby´
>_ckl\bl_evgh ih^]hlh\e_gghfm q_eh\_dm kf_jlv ij_^klZ\ey_lky _kl_kl\_gguf
nbgZehf `bag_ggh]h imlb Z g_ [_aukoh^guf djZohf D lZdhfm \u\h^m ijboh^yl \h
fgh]bo kljZgZo JZa^Z_lky \k_ [hevr_ ]hehkh\ h g_h[oh^bfhklb ki_pbZevghc
ih^]hlh\db k ^_lkl\Z jZa\b\Z_lky ki_pbZevgZy gZmdZ ² lZgZlheh]by \ jy^_ kljZg
ki_pbZevgu_ dmjku ih ijh[e_fZf kf_jlb b mfbjZgby \dexq_gu \ mq_[gu_ ieZgu
fgh]bo mgb\_jkbl_lh\ g_ lhevdh gZ nZdmevl_lZo f_^bpbgu gh b ikboheh]bb
nbehkhnbbb ijZ\Z
Qlh`_lZdh_lZgZlheh]by"WlhgZmdZbamqZxsZykf_jlv__ ijbqbguijhp_kkb
ijhy\e_gby HdhgqZgb_ ³eh]by´ hagZqZxs__ ³gZmdZ´ ohjhrh \Zf ba\_klgh ih lZdbf
l_jfbgZf dZd [bheh]by nbabheh]by ahheh]by Keh\h `_ ³lZgZlhk´ \ i_j_\h^_ k
]j_q_kdh]h hagZqZ_l ³kf_jlv´ LZd \ bf_gb :nZgZkbc fu lZd`_ \klj_qZ_fky k wlbf
dhjg_f QZklbpZ ³Z´ \ ^Zgghf kemqZ_ hagZqZ_l hljbpZgb_ Z ³nZgZkbc´ ² wlh
baf_g_ggh_ ^h g_magZ\Z_fhklb ³lZgZlhk´ kjZ\gbl_ N_^hj b L_h^hj ² \k_ \f_kl_
hagZqZ_lZlZgZlhk[_kkf_jlguc
Gh f_gy g_ mkljZb\Z_l ijb\_^_ggh_ madh f_^bpbgkdh_ lhedh\Zgb_ l_jfbgZ
³lZgZlheh]by´ Ijh[e_fZ kf_jlb bamqZ_lky g_ lhevdh f_^bdZfb b [bheh]Zfb gh b
wlgh]jZnZfb ih]j_[Zevgu_ h[jy^u b k\yaZggu_ k gbfb kbf\hebdZ nhevdehj b
fbnheh]by ij_^klZ\eyxl kh[hc \Z`gh_ kj_^kl\h ^ey ihgbfZgby gZjh^guo h[uqZ_\ b
ljZ^bpbc G_ qm`^Z wlZ ijh[e_fZ b ^ey Zjo_heh]h\ dhlhju_ gZ hkgh\_ fZl_jbZevguo
hklZldh\ ^Ze_dbo wiho iulZxlky j_dhgkljmbjh\Zlv oZjZdl_j ih]j_[_gbc b
ij_^klZ\e_gby^j_\gbo ex^_c h kf_jlb b aZ]jh[ghf fbj_ Fgh]hdjZlgh \klj_qZebkv k
l_fhckf_jlbbklhjbdbebl_jZlmjuJ_ZevgZwlZijh[e_fZb ^eynbehkhnh\Kf_jlv²
h^bg ba dhj_gguo iZjZf_ljh\ dhee_dlb\gh]h khagZgby Z ihkdhevdm ihke_^g__ g_
hklZ_lky\ oh^_bklhjbbg_ih^\b`guflhbaf_g_gbywlbg_fh]mlg_\ujZablvkylZd`_b
\ k^\b]Zo \ hlghr_gbb q_eh\_dZ d kf_jlb Bamq_gb_ mklZgh\hd \ hlghr_gbb d kf_jlb
fh`_lijheblvk\_lgZmklZgh\dbex^_c\ hlghr_gbbd `bagbb hkgh\guf__ p_gghklyf
Ihwlhfm \hkijbylb_ kf_jlb aZ]jh[gh]h fbjZ k\ya_c f_`^m `b\ufb b f_jl\ufb ²
l_fu h[km`^_gb_ dhlhjuo fh]eh [u kms_kl\_ggh m]em[blv ihgbfZgb_ bklhjbdZfb
khpbZevghdmevlmjghcj_Zevghklbfbgm\rbowiho
D kh`Ze_gbx^hkboihjm gZkg_\uims_ghgb h^ghcdgb]bihlZgZlheh]bb\ __
rbjhdhf ihgbfZgbb Kh[jZ\ djmibpu k\_^_gbc ih lZgZlheh]bb ba jZaguo h[eZkl_c
agZgby ² f_^bpbgu [bheh]bb nbabheh]bb bklhjbb Zjo_heh]bb wlgh]jZnbb
nbeheh]bb²y ihiulZeky\hkihegblvwlhlijh[_e
EBL?J:LMJ:
NjZgkmZ ^_ EZjhrnmdh F_fmZju FZdkbfu F Iuey_\ F B KlZjuc
I_l_j[mj]Ba^:KKm\hjbgZKI_l_j[mj]
;oZ]Z\ZgRjbJZ^`g_r =hjqbqgh_a_jghJZafure_gbyh[baj_q_gbyoBbkmkZ
ImgZBg^byKB
: F DZp_\ Yaudh\u_ lZ[m b w\n_fby E J_^_j > = Fbnu b e_]_g^u
^j_\g_]h >\mj_qvy F =mj_\bq : Y Kf_jlv dZd ijh[e_fZ bklhjbq_kdhc
Zgljhiheh]bb h gh\hf gZijZ\e_gbb \ aZjm[_`ghc bklhjbh]jZnbb ³H^bkk_c´
Bkke_^h\ZgbyihkhpbZevghcbklhjbbb bklhjbbdmevlmju²F³GZmdZ´
=E:<:,,
Kf_jlvdebgbq_kdZyb [bheh]bq_kdZy
DZd wlh gb iZjZ^hdkZevgh a\mqbl f_`^m `bagvx b kf_jlvx g_l klhev q_ldh]h
i_j_oh^Z dZd wlh bgh]^Z ij_^klZ\ey_lky Qlh fh`_l kem`blv djbl_jb_f gZklmib\r_c
kf_jlb"
Hkgh\gufijbagZdhfkf_jlb\ ihke_^gb_klhe_lbykem`behhlkmlkl\b_^uoZgby
KqblZehkvqlh^hklZlhqghih^_j`Zlva_jdZevp_\hae_]m[qlh[um[_^blvky\ kf_jlb²
hlkmlkl\b_ aZihl_\Zgby ^hdZau\Zeh ij_djZs_gb_ ^uoZgby Bgh]^Z \jZq ihf_sZe
imrbgdm i_j_^ ghkhf beb jlhf q_eh\_dZ qlh[u hij_^_eblv g_hsmlbfh_ ^\b`_gb_
\ha^moZ \hagbdZxs__ ijb ^uoZgbb < ^jm]bo kemqZyo gZ ]jm^v mf_jr_fm klZ\beb
klZdZggZiheg_gguc\h^hc²ijb^uoZl_evguo^\b`_gbyo\h^ZjZkie_kdb\ZeZkv
Gh _s_ \ ijhrehf \_d_ gZ^_`ghklv wlbo ijh[ [ueZ hijh\_j]gmlZ MijZ`g_gby
ch]h\ iha\heyxl ijbhklZgh\blv ^uoZgb_ g_ l_jyy `bagb qlh ^Z_l bf \hafh`ghklv \
l_q_gb_ ^ebl_evgh]h \j_f_gb h[oh^blvky [_a \ha^moZ ² aZdhiZggufb \ a_fex \
]_jf_lbq_kdbo ysbdZo ih^ \h^hc Oj_klhfZlbcguf klZe ijbf_j ihedh\gbdZ
Lhmgk_g^Z ijhba\hevgh hklZgh\b\r_]h ^uoZgb_ i_j_^ dhgkbebmfhf ehg^hgkdbo
\jZq_cHkfhlj_\_]hb khklZ\b\k\b^_l_evkl\hh kf_jlbhgbjZahrebkvih^hfZfZ gZ
ke_^mxsbc^_gvhgih\lhjbei_j_^gbfblhl`_wdki_jbf_gl
>jm]bfb ijbagZdZfb kf_jlb kqblZebkv ij_djZs_gb_ djh\hh[jZs_gby
bkq_agh\_gb_ imevkZ b hklZgh\dZ ^_yl_evghklb k_j^pZ >ey ^hdZaZl_evkl\Z
ij_djZs_gbydjh\hh[jZs_gbym mf_jr_]hkly]b\ZebiZe_pgbldhc b _keb p\_l iZevpZ
baf_gyeky kbg_e beb gZh[hjhl [e_^g_e wlh hagZqZeh qlh djh\hh[jZs_gb_ g_
ij_djZlbehkvb q_eh\_dkqblZeky`b\uf< ]h^mnjZgpmakdbfaZdhgh^Zl_evkl\hf
[ueh ijbgylh iheh`_gb_ kh]eZkgh dhlhjhfm ^ey ih^l\_j`^_gby kf_jlb g_h[oh^bfh
[ueh jZkk_qv kdZevi_e_f \bkhqgmx beb emq_\mx Zjl_jbx ?keb ihke_ wlh]h g_
gZklmiZeh djh\hl_q_gb_ q_eh\_dZ ijbagZ\Zeb mf_jrbf AZdhghf ij_^mkfZljb\Zehkv
lZd`_ \gmljb\_ggh_ \\_^_gb_ nexhj_kpbjmxs_]h jZkl\hjZ _keb q_eh\_d [ue `b\
q_j_aiheqZkZkebabklu_h[hehqdb]eZaijbh[j_lZeba_e_gh\Zlh`_elucp\_l
H^gZdhb wlbdjbl_jbbkf_jlbhijh\_j]ZxlkynZdlZfbijhba\hevghchklZgh\db
k_j^pZ bg^bckdbfb ch]Zfb NjZgpmakdbc dZj^bheh] EbZev <Zlkhg \ >_eb ijh\h^be
hiulu k nZdbjhf k_j^p_ dhlhjh]h kh]eZkgh ihdZaZgbyf lhqguo ijb[hjh\ g_
nmgdpbhgbjh\Zeh \ l_q_gb_ lb fbgml L_ogbdZ wlh]h mijZ`g_gby ghkbl gZa\Zgb_
³\ZevkZev\Z´ Imevk lZd`_ fh`_l hlkmlkl\h\Zlv \ kemqZyo Zedh]hevghc dhfu beb
^ebl_evgh]h hoeZ`^_gby Ke_^m_l aZf_lblv qlh k jZa\blb_f f_lh^h\ ZmkdmevlZpbb
\ukemrb\Zgbyk_j^pZb we_dljhdZj^bh]jZnbb^bZ]ghklbdZkf_jlbklZeZhlghkbl_evgh
[_ahrb[hqghc
BlZd ij_djZs_gb_ lj_o [b_gbc `bagb jZ[hlu k_j^pZ ^uoZgby b
djh\hh[jZs_gby ^he]h_ \j_fy kqblZehkv kf_jlvx Gh jZa\blb_ j_ZgbfZlheh]bb kh
\lhjhc iheh\bgu ;; \_dZ aZklZ\beh hdhgqZl_evgh i_j_hp_gblv wlb y\e_gby K_]h^gy
k_j^p_ fh`_l jZ[hlZlv k ihfhsvx we_dljhklbfmeylhjZ e_]db_ fh]ml ^urZlv
\ke_^kl\b_ ^\b`_gbc f_oZgbq_kdh]h j_kibjZlhjZ pbjdmeypbx djh\b fh`gh
ijhba\h^blv q_j_a ZiiZjZl bkdmkkl\_ggh]h djh\hh[jZs_gby LZdbf h[jZahf klZjh_
hij_^_e_gb_kf_jlbmljZlbehkbemAZgbfhklZehkvgZa\Zgb_³debgbq_kdZykf_jlv´lh
_klv lZdh_ khklhygb_ dhlhjh_ fh`_l [ulv h[jZlbfh [eZ]h^Zjy mkbebyf \jZq_c ih
\hkklZgh\e_gbx^uoZgbyk_j^p_[b_gbydjh\hh[jZs_gby
< Zjk_gZe_ kh\j_f_gghc f_^bpbgu k_cqZk gZkqblu\Zxlky ^_kyldb ijb_fh\ ih
\u\h^mq_eh\_dZbakhklhygbydebgbq_kdhckf_jlbaZdjulucq_j_a]jm^gmxde_ldmb
hldjuluc fZkkZ` k_j^pZ we_dljhklbfmeypby k_j^pZ f_lh^u bkdmkkl\_ggh]h ^uoZgby
^uoZgb_jhl\jhlb l ^ bkdmkkl\_ggZy \_glbeypby e_]dbo k ihfhsvx ki_pbZevguo
ZiiZjZlh\?`_^g_\ghj_ZgbfZlheh]b\ha\jZsZxld `bagblukyqbex^_cqv_khklhygb_
jZg__jZkp_gb\Zehkv[udZdkf_jlv
Ihfbfh kf_jlb debgbq_kdhc kms_kl\m_l b kf_jlv [bheh]bq_kdZy lh _klv lZdh_
g_h[jZlbfh_ khklhygb_ hj]ZgbafZ dhlhjh_ khijh\h`^Z_lky ljmigufb y\e_gbyfb h
dhlhjuo fu jZkkdZ`_f iha^g__ KqblZ_lky qlh q_eh\_d f_jl\ _keb _]h fha] g_
nmgdpbhgbjm_l Z fha]h\u_ de_ldb g_ baemqZxl \heg nbdkbjm_fuo wgp_nZeh]jZnhf
Ghfh`_lkemqblvkyb lZdqlh\ j_amevlZl_^_ckl\byj_ZgbfZpbhgghc[jb]Z^um^Zehkv
\hkklZgh\blv ^_yl_evghklv k_j^pZ \gh\v gZeZ^blv djh\hh[jZs_gb_ k ihfhsvx
ZiiZjZlZ bkdmkkl\_gghc \_glbeypbb e_]dbo ih^^_j`b\Zlv ^uoZl_evgmx nmgdpbx gh
fha] ijb wlhf ih]b[ ijbq_f ih]b[ g_h[jZlbfh DZd lh]^Z jZkp_gb\Zlv khklhygb_
q_eh\_dZ"@b\hgbeb f_jl\"K lhqdb aj_gby klZjh]h hij_^_e_gby kf_jlb ² `b\ lZd
dZd m g_]h [v_lky k_j^p_ djh\v pbjdmebjm_l ih khkm^Zf ih^^_j`b\Z_lky ihklhyggZy
l_fi_jZlmjZ l_eZ K lhqdb aj_gby gh\h]h kh\j_f_ggh]h hij_^_e_gby ljZdlmxs_]h
gZklmie_gb_ kf_jlb dZd kf_jlv fha]Z ² lZdhc q_eh\_d f_jl\ Wlh gh\h_ hij_^_e_gb_
kf_jlb ² g_ kh\k_f f_^bpbgkdh_ b g_ kh\k_f [bheh]bq_kdh_ Hgh g_ ljZ^bpbhggh
f_^bpbgkdh_ ihlhfm qlh hl^_evgu_ `bag_ggu_ nmgdpbb khojZgyxlky b g_dhlhju_
hj]Zgu ijh^he`Zxl `blv G_ iheghklvx [bheh]bq_kdh_ ihlhfm qlh h[f_g \_s_kl\ \
de_ldZo g_ ij_djZsZ_lky Hgh kdhj__ ba h[eZklb f_lZnbabdb kf_jlv q_eh\_dZ
hlebqZ_lky hl kf_jlb \k_o ^jm]bo `b\uo kms_kl\ ?keb q_eh\_d kms_kl\m_l lhevdh
[bheh]bq_kdbb ebr_gkhagZgbyhgkqblZ_lkymf_jrbfb[hhgf_jl\dZdebqghklv
< j_amevlZl_]b[_ebfha]Zg_h[jZlbfhbkq_aZxl\k__]hnmgdpbb\dexqZy^Z`_
kZfhklhyl_evgh_ ^uoZgb_ >_yl_evghklv k_j^pZ ih^^_j`b\Z_lky l_i_jv lhevdh
[eZ]h^Zjy bkdmkkl\_gghc \_glbeypbb e_]dbo Klhbl lhevdh hldexqblv ZiiZjZl
bkdmkkl\_ggh]h^uoZgbyb k_j^p_hklZgh\blkygZklmibl[bheh]bq_kdZykf_jlv
Gh bf__l eb \jZq ijZ\h gZ wlhl rZ] ^Z`_ lhqgh agZy qlh ]heh\ghc fha]
[_a\ha\jZlghih]b["G_[m^_lebwlhm[bckl\hf"Dlh\havf_lgZk_[yhl\_lkl\_gghklvb
\udexqblZiiZjZl"
< j_amevlZl_ h[km`^_gby wlh]h \hijhkZ f_^bpbgkdhc h[s_kl\_gghklvx gZ jy^_
f_`^mgZjh^guo nhjmfh\ Z lZd`_ aZdhgh^Zl_evgufb hj]ZgZfb fgh]bo kljZg [ueh
ijbagZgh ijZ\bevguf mlhqgblv ihgylb_ kf_jlb k\yaZ\ __ k g_h[jZlbfufb
ihjZ`_gbyfb ]heh\gh]h fha]Z dZd km[kljZlZ ebqghklb q_eh\_dZ hij_^_eyxs_]h _]h
khpbZevgmx b [bheh]bq_kdmx kmsghklv G_h[jZlbfhfm ihjZ`_gbx ]heh\gh]h fha]Z
[ueh^ZghgZa\Zgb_kf_jlbfha]ZIhemqbehijbagZgb_kms_kl\h\Zgb_^\mof_oZgbafh\
jZa\blby [bheh]bq_kdhc kf_jlb q_eh\_dZ h[uqgh]h k i_j\bqguf ij_djZs_gb_f
k_j^_qghc ^_yl_evghklb b ^uoZgby \ l_q_gb_ kjhdZ bkdexqZxs_]h \hafh`ghklv
\hkklZgh\e_gbyfha]Zb gh\h]hhij_^_ey_fh]hkf_jlvxfha]Z
Gh\h_hij_^_e_gb_kf_jlbdZdkf_jlbfha]Z^Z`_ijbkhojZg_gbb^_yl_evghklb
k_j^pZ ihemqbeh ijbagZgb_ kj_^b f_^bdh\ aZ jm[_`hf \ _ ]h^u < [u\r_f KKKJ
\jZqb kfh]eb jmdh\h^kl\h\Zlvky wlbf hij_^_e_gb_f ebrv k ]h^Z dh]^Z \ureZ
ml\_j`^_ggZyFbga^jZ\hfKKKJb kh]eZkh\ZggZyk aZdhgh^Zl_evgufbhj]ZgZfbkljZgu
³Bgkljmdpby ih dhgklZlZpbb kf_jlb \ j_amevlZl_ ihegh]h g_h[jZlbfh]h ij_djZs_gby
nmgdpbc]heh\gh]hfha]Z´
Gh\h_ hij_^_e_gb_ kf_jlb dZd kf_jlb fha]Z \ua\Zeh p_euc jy^ keh`guo
wlbq_kdboijh[e_fIj_`^_\k_]hljm^ghhdZaZehkvbaf_gblvij_^klZ\e_gbyh kmsghklb
kf_jlbkdeZ^u\Zxsb_ky\ l_q_gb_lukyq_e_lbc\ kj_^_ex^_c^Ze_dbohlf_^bpbgub
hkh[_ggh\ k\yabk \hafh`ghklvx\aylbyhj]Zgh\m ih]b[rbok [vxsbfkyk_j^p_f^ey
i_j_kZ^dbbo^jm]hfmq_eh\_dm
H[s_ijbgylh_ xjb^bq_kdh_ hij_^_e_gb_ kf_jlb gZ hkgh\Zgbb ij_djZs_gby
^uoZgby b k_j^p_[b_gby \ k\yab k gh\hc dhgp_ipb_c kf_jlb fha]Z hdZaZehkv
mklZj_\rbf Ih wlhc ijbqbg_ \hagbdeh fgh`_kl\h dZambklbq_kdbo km^_[guo ^_e <
]h^m\ Ihjle_g^_rlZlHj_]hgkm^hfj_rZeky\hijhkh ijbqbg_kf_jlbq_eh\_dZ
k ime_\uf jZg_gb_f gZoh^b\r_]hky \ [_kkhagZl_evghf khklhygbb k ijbagZdZfb
we_dljbq_kdh]h fheqZgby fha]Z gZ we_dljhwgp_nZeh]jZff_ dhlhjhfm ijh\h^beZkv
bkdmkkl\_ggZy \_glbeypby e_]dbo Ihqdb [hevgh]h [ueb ba\e_q_gu ^ey i_j_kZ^db
<hijhkaZdexqZeky\ lhfqlhy\behkvijbqbghckf_jlbba\e_q_gb_hj]Zgh\bebljZ\fZ
gZg_k_ggZy ime_c" Ijbky`gu_ ijbreb d \u\h^m qlh g_ihkj_^kl\_gghc ijbqbghc
kf_jlby\behkvime_\h_jZg_gb_gh^_ckl\by\jZq_chp_gbeb\k_`_dZdm[bckl\hijb
kfy]qZxsboh[klhyl_evkl\ZoKhh[s_gbyh ih^h[guokm^_[guo^_eZoZ lZd`_h ^jm]bo
_s_[he__aZimlZgguohljZ`Zxll_ljm^ghklbdhlhjuofh`gh[ueh[uba[_`Zlv_keb
[ukhklhygb_kf_jlbfha]ZdZdijhy\e_gbykf_jlbq_eh\_dZh[j_ehxjb^bq_kdbcklZlmk
Bf_ggh\ k\yabk wlbfbljm^ghklyfb\ gZr_ckljZg_bkihevah\Zgb_³Bgkljmdpbb
ih dhgklZlZpbb kf_jlb \ j_amevlZl_ ihegh]h g_h[jZlbfh]h ij_djZs_gby nmgdpbc
]heh\gh]h fha]Z´ ihdZ jZaj_r_gh ebrv h]jZgbq_gghfm qbkem ^hklZlhqgh
ih^]hlh\e_gguo e_q_[guo mqj_`^_gbc qbkeh dhlhjuo fh`_l jZkrbjylvky ebrv
ihkl_i_ggh: ihdZk lhqdbaj_gbyaZdhgZijZ\hf_jguljb\ZjbZglZih\_^_gby\jZqZ
<hi_j\uo hg fh`_l ijh^he`Zlv j_ZgbfZpbhggu_ f_jhijbylby b bkdmkl\_ggmx
\_glbeypbxe_]dbo\iehlv^h_kl_kl\_gghchklZgh\dbk_j^pZqlhaZly]b\Z_lkygZfgh]h
^g_c Z bgh]^Z ^Z`_ gZ g_kdhevdh g_^_ev Wlh khijy`_gh k [_kkfuke_gghc ljZlhc
^hjh]hklhysbof_^bdZf_glh\b \j_f_gbZ lZd`_k khojZg_gb_fg_hijZ\^ZgguogZ^_`^
m jh^kl\_ggbdh\ iZpb_glZ aZlh hk\h[h`^Z_l \jZqZ hl ly`_ehc ikboheh]bq_kdhc
hl\_lkl\_gghklb ijb hldexq_gbb ZiiZjZlZ bkdmkkl\_gghc \_glbeypbb <jZq fh`_l
lZd`_hldexqblvj_kibjZlhjb khh[sblvjh^gufh kf_jlb[hevgh]hqlhij_^klZ\ey_lky
ijZ\hf_jguf dZd k wlbq_kdhc lZd b k wdhghfbq_kdhc lhq_d aj_gby gh hdZau\Z_lky
ikboheh]bq_kdb ly`_euf ^ey \jZqZ GZdhg_p \jZq mklZgh\b\ kf_jlv fh`_l i_j_^Zlv
iZpb_glZ k jZ[hlZxsbf k_j^p_f ljZgkieZglheh]Zf ^ey bkihevah\Zgby hj]Zgh\
hkh[_ggh k_j^pZ \ p_eyo i_j_kZ^db ^jm]bf [hevguf < wlhf kemqZ_ ij_djZs_gb_
j_ZgbfZpbhgguo f_jhijbylbc hkms_kl\ey_l \jZqljZgkieZglheh] <u[hj ex[h]h ba
wlbo \ZjbZglh\ hij_^_ey_lky dZd ikboheh]b_c \jZqZ lZd b \k_f dhfie_dkhf
h[klhyl_evkl\k\yaZgguok dhgdj_lgufdebgbq_kdbfkemqZ_f
< ihke_^gb_ ]h^u \k_ qZs_ ihy\eyxlky im[ebdZpbb hkm`^Zxsb_ j_ZgbfZpbx
[hevguo k ih]b[rbf fha]hf gZau\Zxsb_ lZdmx j_ZgbfZpbx [_kkfuke_gguf
l_jZi_\lbq_kdbfmijyfkl\hf;he__lh]hjZa^Zxlky]hehkZlj_[mxsb_ ^Zlv [hevghfm
ijZ\h kZfhfm jZkihjy`Zlvky k\h_c km^v[hc WlZ ijh[e_fZ gZklhevdh keh`gZ b
g_h`b^ZggZ^eygZr_]hh[s_kl\Zqlhfuj_rbebihk\ylblv_chl^_evgmx]eZ\m
EBL?J:LMJ:
Mhed_j:W Kf_jlvfha]ZI_jk Zg]eF³F_^bpbgZ´
=E:<: ,,,
IjZ\hgZe_]dmxkf_jlv
< ³Ebl_jZlmjghc]Za_l_´‹ hlZ\]mklZ]h^Z[uehgZi_qZlZghibkvfh
< Kb[bjkdh]h ³IjZ\h gZ e_]dmx kf_jlv´ :\lhj ij_^eZ]Ze h[km^blv \hijhk h
g_h[oh^bfhklb ij_^klZ\e_gby dZ`^hfm q_eh\_dm ijZ\Z gZ w\lZgZabx ² e_]dmx
[_a[he_ag_ggmxkf_jlvih_]h`_eZgbxk ihfhsvxf_^bdh\J_^ZdpbyihemqbeZ[he__
klZhldebdh\gZwlmim[ebdZpbx²agZqbl\hijhkwlhl]em[hdh\hegm_lgZr_h[s_kl\h
Ijh[e_fZ w\lZgZabb aZljZ]b\Z_l ^\Z \hijhkZ h ijZ\_ q_eh\_dZ gZ \u[hj f_`^m
`bagvxb kf_jlvx²b wlh]hijZ\Z_]hgbdlhb gbdh]^Zg_ebrZe²b ijZ\_q_eh\_dZ
\u[jZ\r_]hkf_jlvgZihfhsvf_^bdZKeh`ghklvijh[e_fubf_ggh\h\lhjhf
KZfhm[bckl\h ba\_klgh k ^j_\g_crbo \j_f_g gh gZ jZaguo wlZiZo jZa\blby
h[s_kl\Z ex^b hlghkbebkv d wlhfm y\e_gbx ihjZaghfm GZ wlZi_ i_j\h[ulgh
h[sbggh]hkljhyjZ^bkhojZg_gbyjh^Z\ ]heh^gu_]h^u^h[jh\hevghmf_js\eyebk_[y
klZjbdb< yihgkdhfnbevf_³E_]_g^Zh GZjZcyf_´ihdZaZguhl]hehkdbwlh]hh[uqZy²
^_lb hlghkyl klZjbdh\ gZ \_jrbgm k\ys_gghc ]hju ]^_ l_ ^h[jh\hevgh ijbgbfZxl
kf_jlvhl]heh^Z
< ^j_\ghklbijZdlbq_kdbm \k_ogZjh^h\kms_kl\h\Zeh^h[jh\hevgh_ijbg_k_gb_
k_[y\ `_jl\m[h]Zf\hbfyh[s_kl\_gguobgl_j_kh\
KZfhm[bckl\Z\^h\\hfgh]bokljZgZoy\eyebkv^hdZaZl_evkl\hf\_jghklbfm`m
< jbfkdhcbklhjbbba\_kl_gkemqZcdh]^ZIhjpby`_gZ;jmlZmagZ\h kf_jlbkmijm]Z
g_f_^ey ijh]ehlbeZ ]hjklv ]hjysbo m]e_c G F DZjZfabg \ k\h_c ³Bklhjbb
]hkm^Zjkl\Z Jhkkbckdh]h´ k\b^_l_evkl\m_l ³KeZ\ygdb g_ ohl_eb i_j_`b\Zlv fm`_c b
^h[jh\hevgh kh`b]Zebkv gZ dhklj_ k bo ljmiZfb <^h\Z `b\Zy [_kq_klbeZ k_f_ckl\h´
H[wlhf`_h[uqZ_kZfhkh``_gby\^h\m keZ\yg]h\hjylhibkZgbyZjZ[kdbfdmiphfB[g
NZ^eZghfihohjhg[h]Zlh]hjmkZ
H[uqZc `_jl\hijbghr_gby `_g mf_jrbo fm`_c \hh[s_ [ue rbjhdh
jZkijhkljZg_g m bg^hZjbcp_\ Wlh jblmZevgh_ kZfhkh``_gb_ [_j_l k\h_ gZqZeh m
iZljbZjoZevgh]hdmevlZ[h]Zh]gy:]gbKZfhkh``_gb_\^h\KZlb\ Bg^bbijbh[j_eh
ljZ^bpbhggh fZkkh\uc oZjZdl_j b khojZgyehkv ^h g_^Z\g_]h \j_f_gb Hkh[_ggh yjdh
ihdZaZgwlhlh[uqZb\ Zg]ebckdhfom^h`_kl\_gghfnbevf_³>Ze_db_rZlju´
M fm`qbg keh`beky k\hc dh^_dk q_klb kZfhm[bckl\h dZd bkdmie_gb_ ihahjZ
\h_gguo ihjZ`_gbc Ih^h[gu_ h[jZapu ih\_^_gby hibkZgu ^Z`_ \ <_lohf aZ\_l_ \
p_ehf hkm`^Zxs_f b^_x kZfhmgbqlh`_gby < qZklghklb j_eb]by bm^__\ mihfbgZ_l
KZmeZ aZdheh\r_]h k_[y ihke_ ihjZ`_gby gZ ihe_ [bl\u Jbfkdbc bfi_jZlhj G_jhg
ihl_ji_\ihjZ`_gb_\ [hjv[_ aZ \eZklv lZd`_ dhgqbe kq_lu k `bagvx [jhkb\rbkv gZ
\hldgmluc\ a_fexf_q
H[uqZc kZfhm[bckl\Z \hh[s_ [ue hq_gv rbjhdh jZkijhkljZg_g \ Zglbqgmx
wihomAZlhq_ggZy\eZklbl_e_fNb\Dj_hglhf\ dZf_gghfkde_i_:glb]hgZebrbeZk_[y
`bagblZddZdij_^ihqeZ^h[jh\hevgmxkf_jlvg_kijZ\_^eb\hcdZagb>j_\g_]j_q_kdbc
nbehkhndbgbd>bh]_gKbghikdbchd]]^hgwkh]eZkghe_]_g^_ihdhgqbe
`bagv kZfhm[bckl\hf aZ^_j`Z\ b hklZgh\b\ ^uoZgb_ Ijb]h\hj_gguc bfi_jZlhjhf
G_jhghfd kh\_jr_gbxkZfhm[bckl\Zk_fb^_kylbe_lgbfklZjp_f\kdjuek_[_\_gugZ
]he_gyob ih^dhe_gyfb^j_\g_jbfkdbcnbehkhnwibdmj__pEmpbc:gg_bK_g_dZIhdZ
kljmbeZkvdjh\vhgmki_eijh^bdlh\ZlvibkpZffgh]h_balh]hqlhg_gZibkZekZf?]h
kh\j_f_ggbdwibdmj__pI_ljhgbcZ\lhjagZf_gblh]h³KZlbjbdhgZ´lZd`_\kdjuek_[_
\_gugZijhsZevghfibjmk ^jmavyfbKeZ[_yhlihl_jbdjh\b hg ihijhkbe \j_f_ggh
i_j_\yaZlv k_[_ \kdjulu_ \_gu qlh[u \ ihke_^gbc jZa gZkeZ^blvky _s_ h^gbf
m^h\hevkl\b_f ² kghf Ijhkgm\rbkv hg \gh\v khj\Ze ih\yadb qlh[u mf_j_lv WlZ
kp_gZkf_jlbI_ljhgbyhibkZgZ\ jhfZg_=_gjboZK_gd_\bqZ³DZfh]jy^_rb´
<h \k_ \j_f_gZ djb\Zy kZfhm[bckl\Z gZijyfmx k\yaZgZ k h[s_kl\_ggufb
ih^t_fZfb b kiZ^Zfb \ iheblbd_ wdhghfbd_ b dmevlmj_ FZkkh\u_ j_eb]bhagu_
kZfhm[bckl\Z oZjZdl_jgu ^ey Jhkkbb dhgpZ ;9,, klhe_lby KZfhkh``_gby ³]Zjb´
ke_^h\Zebh^ghaZ^jm]bfaZ^\Z^pZlve_lk ih]h^bo[uehhdhehkhjhdZ\
h]g_ih]b[eb^h^\Z^pZlblukyqklZjhh[jy^p_\
IhjZaghfm hlghkylky d kZfhm[bckl\Zf jZaebqgu_ fbjh\u_ j_eb]bb IhiuldZ
ba[_`Zlv kljZ^Zgbc gbkihkeZgguo <k_\urgbf h[ty\eyeZkv j_eb]bhagufb
l_hj_lbdZfbojbklbZgkl\Z]j_ohfebrZxsbfm^Z\e_ggbdZbebmlhie_ggbdZijhs_gby
b kiZk_gby ^mrb Bf hldZau\Zeb \ ih]j_[_gbb gZ deZ^[bs_ b ihahjgh ohjhgbeb gZ
i_j_dj_kldZo ^hjh] KljZ^ZeZ b k_fvy ]j_rgbdZ ebrZykv aZdhggh]h gZke_^kl\Z :
qm^hfhklZ\rbcky\ `b\uoijb]h\Zjb\Zekyd aZdexq_gbxb dZlhj`gufjZ[hlZfdZdaZ
m[bckl\h < <h_gghf b Fhjkdhf Zjlbdme_ I_ljZ , bf_eZkv ^h\hevgh kmjh\Zy aZibkv
³?`_ebdlhk_[ym[v_llhf_jl\h__]hl_ehijb\yaZ\d ehrZ^b\hehqblvihmebpZfaZ
gh]b ih\_kblv ^Z[u kfhljy gZ lh ^jm]b_ lZdh]h [_aaZdhgby gZ^ kh[hc qbgblv g_
hl\Z`b\Zebkv´
>h[jh\hevguc moh^ ba `bagb b k_]h^gy ij_ke_^m_lky \ kljZgZo dZlhebpbafZ D
ijbf_jm\ Ihevr_k ih]h^aZj_]bkljbjh\Zgh\ kj_^g_f\k_]hkZfhm[bckl\
gZgZk_e_gby
BkeZf lZd`_ kljh]h hkm`^Z_l kZfh\hevgh_ ebr_gb_ k_[y `bagb Ihwlhfm \
kljZgZobkih\_^mxsbofmkmevfZgkdmxj_eb]bxwlhy\e_gb_\klj_qZ_lkydjZcg_j_^dh
Bm^_ckdZy\_jZlh`_klhblgZkljZ`_kZfhp_gghklb`bagbb aZij_sZ_lkZfhm[bckl\Z
IhdblZckdbfih\_jvyf^mrbkZfhm[bcpklZgh\ylky]heh^gufb[_kijbxlgufb
^moZfb²³]mc´b \k_[hylkybof_klb
IhmklZgh\e_gbyf^j_\gbol_dklh\kZfhm[bckl\hijZ\h\_jguobg^mbklh\kljh]h
hkm`^Zehkv dZd \_ebdbc ]j_o H^gZdh j_eb]bhagh_ kZfhm[bckl\h g_ lhevdh g_
hkm`^Zehkv gh b \ha\h^behkv \ ih^\b] dZd kZfhih`_jl\h\Zgb_ ;h]m beb hqbs_gb_ hl
]j_oh\ LZdh]h jh^Z kZfhm[bckl\Z ^bdrb kh\_jrZebkv iml_f kZfhkh``_gby beb
kZfhmlhie_gby <ky bg^bckdZy ebl_jZlmjZ gZkus_gZ ijbf_jZfb b nZdlZfb ih^h[gh]h
jh^Z< kj_^gb_\_dZg_j_^dhijhba\h^bebkvfZkkh\u_j_eb]bhagu_kZfhm[bckl\Z;ueb
b djh\Z\u_`_jl\hijbghr_gby\ ojZfZo[h]bgbDZebdh]^Zfheysb_kyhlj_aZebqZklb
l_eZbebm[b\Zebk_[y
Hkh[_gghfZkkh\ufb[uebj_eb]bhagu_kZfhmlhie_gby\h\j_fyiZehfgbq_kl\Z
d k\ys_gguf j_dZf ² lbjloZf Lhl dlh kh\_jrZ_l ^bdrm kZfhm[bckl\h ydh[u
^hklb]Z_l ³fhdrb´ l _ ihegh]h hk\h[h`^_gby hl kljZ^Zgbc a_fghc `bagb KZfuf
`_eZ_fuf ^ey kZfhmlhie_gby kqblZ_lky f_klh kebygby =Zg]Z k >`Zfghc m ]hjh^Z
:eeZoZ[Z^Z Kms_kl\mxl ^Z`_ mdZaZgby h lhf dZd ke_^m_l kh\_jrZlv kZfhm[bckl\Z Z
gZb[he__ ij_^ihqlbl_evguf kqblZ_lky kiju]b\Zgb_ \ j_dm k \_l\_c k\ys_ggh]h
[ZgvygZDlhwlhk^_eZ_llhlihih\_jvxihiZ^Z_l\ h[bl_ev[h]ZRb\u< :eeZoZ[Z^_
ih k_c ^_gv kms_kl\mxl lukyq_e_lgb_ [Zgvygu ijhklbjZxsb_ lheklu_ \_l\b gZ^
fmlgufb\hegZfb=Zg]ZDZdb \ijhrehfk wlbo^_j_\v_\b \gZrb^gbiju]Zxl\ \h^m
gZb[he__ j_\ghklgu_ bg^mbklu qlh[u ihdhgqblv \k_ kq_lu k `bagvx b l_f kZfuf
h[j_klb³kiZk_gb_´
?s_ h^gbf ^j_\gbf h[uqZ_f j_eb]bhagh]h kZfhm[bckl\Z bg^mbklh\ y\ey_lky
kf_jlv ih^ dhe_kZfb ly`_euo dhe_kgbp < k\yab k wlbf kms_kl\m_l ^jm]hc \b^
iZehfgbq_kl\Z ² d ojZfm >`Z]ZggZloZ \ Hjbkk_ A^_kv _`_]h^gh \ gZqZe_ k_ahgZ
^h`^_cijbh]jhfghfkl_q_gbbiZehfgbdh\klZlmb[h]h\baojZfZi_j_\haylky\ ^jm]hc
dhg_p ]hjh^Z < gZrb ^gb ijbgbfZxlky \k_ f_ju qlh[u ij_^hl\jZlblv wlb djh\Z\u_
fbkl_jbb H^gZdh hl^_evgu_ kemqZb ³kh_^bg_gby k [h`_kl\hf´ Z lZd`_ m\_qvy b
jZg_gby ijhbkoh^yl _`_]h^gh Dhe_kgbpu lygml dZgZlZfb fgh]hqbke_ggu_
ijbkem`gbdb ojZfZ Ih h[_bf klhjhgZf hl gbo r_kl\mxl kehgu \ yjdbo h[jy^h\uo
h^_`^Zo ;hevrb_ gZjy^u ihebpbb _^\Z kijZ\eyxlky k l_f qlh[u hll_kgylv lheiu hl
h]jhfguob ly`_euodhe_kd dhlhjufijbdh\Zgu\ahjunZgZlbdh\
DZdh\Z `_ klZlbklbdZ kZfhm[bckl\ \ gZr_c kljZg_ ih kjZ\g_gbx k ^jm]bfb
]hkm^Zjkl\Zfb"?`_]h^gh\ [u\r_fKKKJ^h[jh\hevghjZkklZ\Zebkvk `bagvxhdheh
lukyq q_eh\_d Ih ^Zgguf =hkdhfklZlZ wlh \ jZaZ [hevr_ q_f \ KR: <
^hj_\hexpbhgghc Jhkkbb gZ lukyq gZk_e_gby ijboh^behkv ljbq_luj_
kZfhm[bckl\Z\ ]h^wlh[uekZfucgbadbc ihdZaZl_ev \ ?\jhi_ < [u\r_f KKKJ ih
^ZggufXG?KDHwlhlmjh\_gvih^gyeky ^h < Nbgeyg^bb ² \ Yihgbb ² R\_pbb DZgZ^_ KR: Ihjlm]Zebb ² BlZebb ² F_dkbd_ ² =\Zl_fZe_²
Wib^_fbb kZfhm[bckl\ hkh[_ggh \ fheh^_`ghc kj_^_ fh`_l ihjh^blv
lZeZgleb\h_ ijhba\_^_gb_ bkdmkkl\Z >hdZaZl_evgh mklZgh\e_gh qlh ihy\e_gb_ \ ]h^m³KljZ^Zgbcxgh]h<_jl_jZ´=_l_]_gbZevgh]hhibkZgby`bagbb kf_jlbxghrbhl
g_kqZklghc ex[\b \ua\Zeh p_emx \hegm kZfhm[bckl\ kj_^b fheh^_`b \ ih^jZ`_gb_
ex[bfhfm ]_jhx Ijbf_jgh lZdhc `_ wnn_dl gZ jmkkdh_ h[s_kl\h gZqZeZ ;,; \_dZ
hdZaZeZ³;_^gZyEbaZ´GFDZjZfabgZKhlgbZf_jbdZgp_\\ k\h_\j_fy ihke_^h\Zeb
ijbf_jm dbgha\_a^u Fwjbebg Fhgjh \_jkby h[ hljZ\e_gbb dhlhjhc rbjhdh
h[km`^ZeZkv\ i_qZlb
Hkh[hc `_klhdhklvx b bahsj_gghklvx hlebqZxlky kZfhm[bckl\Z ikbobq_kdb
[hevguo ex^_c < gZrm debgbdm [ueZ ^hklZ\e_gZ [hevgZy rbahnj_gb_c ^_\mrdZ
ijh]ehlb\rZy [jbl\m ij_^\Zjbl_evgh k\_jgmlmx \ oe_[ghf fydbr_ < ibs_\h^_
[jbl\Z jZkijZ\beZkv b hklZ\beZ ]em[hdb_ j_aZgu_ jZgu kebabklhc <ke_^kl\b_
ihiZ^Zgby bgn_dpbb ba ibs_\h^Z gZqZehkv fZkkb\gh_ gZ]gh_gb_ ldZg_c b ^_\mrdm
kiZklbg_m^Zehkv
DZ`^uc [hevghc kh\_jrZxsbc ihiuldm kZfhm[bckl\Z i_j_^Z_lky ih^
gZ[ex^_gb_ ikbobZljZ Gh g_ \k_]^Z kZfhm[bckl\Z kh\_jrZxlky ex^vfb \ khklhygbb
hkljh]h beb ojhgbq_kdh]h ikbobq_kdh]h jZkkljhckl\Z J_rZxlky gZ jhdh\hc rZ] b
g_bae_qbfh[hevgu_h^bghdb_ex^bij_klZj_eu_bg\Zeb^uIh`Zemcgb]^_[hevr_\
fbj_ djhf_ gZr_c [_a]jZfhlghc \ wlhf \hijhk_ kljZgu \ p_eyo kZfhm[bckl\Z g_
bkihevamxl mdkmkgmx wkk_gpbx b dZj[hnhk Ihke_^kl\by hl ijb_fZ wlbo \_s_kl\
m`Zkgu b qZs_ \k_]h \uau\Zxl ebrv ^hihegbl_evgu_ kljZ^Zgby g_ ^hklb]Zy
ihklZ\e_gghcp_eb
<hllmlfui_j_c^_fdh\lhjhchkgh\ghcijh[e_f_gZr_]hjZa]h\hjZ²h ijZ\_
q_eh\_dZ\u[jZ\r_]hkf_jlvgZihfhsv\jZqZh ijZ\_gZw\lZgZabx³lbomxkf_jlv´
Ijh[e_fZ w\lZgZabb ² ^h[jh\hevgh]h moh^Z ba `bagb g_bae_qbfh [hevgh]h
q_eh\_dZ²rbjhdhh[km`^Z_lkygZAZiZ^_k dhgpZo ]h^h\< ]h^m^hdlhj>`_d
=_\hjdyghim[ebdh\Ze\ i_qZlbjy^klZl_c\ dhlhjuo ijbau\Ze[_a[he_ag_gghebrZlv
`bagb ij_klmigbdh\ ijb]h\hj_gguo d kf_jlghc dZagb Z bo l_eZ bkihevah\Zlv ^ey
gZmqguo hiulh\ hl^_evgu_ hj]Zgu ² ^ey i_j_kZ^hqguo hi_jZpbc Iha^g__ klZ\
k\b^_l_e_f [_kkfuke_ggh`_klhdbo kZfhm[bckl\ =_\hjdyg ijbr_e d fukeb qlh
hlqZy\rbfky[_agZ^_`gh[hevgufex^yfj_rb\rbfihdhgqblvk `bagvxg_h[oh^bfZ
\ wlhfihfhsv
Hlkeh\_kguob ]Za_lguo\uklmie_gbc=_\hjdygi_j_r_ed ^_emb aZiZl_glh\Ze
k\h_ bah[j_l_gb_ gZa\Zggh_ \ihke_^kl\bb `mjgZebklZfb ³fZrbghc kf_jlb´ K
ihfhsvx wlh]h ijbkihkh[e_gby \ \b^_ dZi_evgbpu fh`gh [ukljh b [_a[he_ag_ggh
mf_jl\eylv ex^_c < ZiiZjZl_ [ueh ij_^mkfhlj_gh b ki_pbZevgh_ mkljhckl\h ^ey
ij_ju\Zgbyijhp_^mju\ kemqZ__keb^h[jh\he_pg_h`b^Zgghbaf_gblk\h_j_r_gb_
Ihke_ ^he]bo ij_ibjZl_evkl\ h^gZ ba ³`_eluo´ ]Za_l \k_lZdb j_rbeZkv
him[ebdh\Zlv h[ty\e_gb_ >`_dZ =_\hjdygZ ijbf_jgh lZdh]h kh^_j`Zgby ³?keb \u
j_rbebmf_j_lvb ohlbl_wlhk^_eZlv[_a[he_ag_gghy ih^Zjx\Zfe_]dmxkf_jlv´
I_j\ufb ihke_^gbf_]hiZpb_glhfklZeZe_lgyy>`Zg_l:ldbgkkljZ^Z\rZy
g_bae_qbfhc[he_agvx< k\h_fh[hjm^h\Zgghfih^eZ[hjZlhjbxklZj_gvdhfZ\lh[mk_
=_\hjdygijb\_e\ ^_ckl\b_³fZrbgmkf_jlb´b ihke_^g__qlhmkeurZehl>`Zg_l²
wlh³kiZkb[h´Ihlhf[ue]jhfdbckm^_[gucijhp_kkdhgnbkdZpby³fZrbgu kf_jlb´
h[_sZgb_=_\hjdygZ[he__g_aZgbfZlvkyih^h[gufgbdh]^Z
< ]h^m<_joh\guckm^DZebnhjgbb\ug_kj_r_gb_^Zxs__[hevgufijZ\h
hldZaZlvky hl e_q_gby ih^^_j`b\Zxs_]h `bagv Wlhfm ijbf_jm ihke_^h\Zeb fgh]b_
^jm]b_ rlZlu K_cqZk ijZdlbdZ w\lZgZabb ihemqbeZ \ KR: ^h\hevgh rbjhdh_
jZkijhkljZg_gb_G_ijh\h^blkyj_ZgbfZpby_kebiZpb_glaZ[eZ]h\j_f_ggh\ukdZaZeky
ijhlb\ g__ Lh]^Z gZ^ _]h djh\Zlvx ihy\ey_lky lZ[ebqdZ k Zg]ebckdhc Z[[j_\bZlmjhc
hagZqZxs_c ³g_ h`b\eylv GH´ JZkkdZau\Zxl qlh agZf_gbluc objmj] D ;_jgZj^
bkihevah\Zew\lZgZabx^eyh[e_]q_gbyihke_^gbofbgml`bagbk\h_cfZl_jb>\Z]h^Z
gZaZ^aZdhgh ijZ\_gZ³e_]dmxkf_jlv´ijbgyl\ DblZ_
Ijb wlhf kms_kl\_ggh h dZdhc w\lZgZabb b^_l j_qv :dlb\gZy ² dh]^Z
bkihevamxl kj_^kl\Z mkdhjyxsb_ gZklmie_gb_ kf_jlb i_j_^habjh\dZ kghl\hjgh]h
kf_jl_evgZy bgt_dpby ih ijhkv[_ [hevgh]h b l ^ IZkkb\gZy ² [_a^_ckl\b_ \jZq_c
hldZa hl [hjv[u aZ `bagv iZpb_glZ LZd \hl \ KR: aZdhghf ijbagZgZ lhevdh \lhjZy
nhjfZZdlb\gZy`_xjb^bq_kdbaZij_s_gZ\h\k_orlZlZoZ \NJ=hgZij_ke_^m_lky\
m]heh\ghfihjy^d_
<ijhq_f ^bkdmkkbb g_ mlboZxl J_eb]bhagu_ ]jmiibjh\db \ KR:
ih^^_j`b\Zxl ijZ\h gZ ³]mfZggmx kf_jlv´ :f_jbdZgkdZy f_^bpbgkdZy ZkkhpbZpby
ijbagZ\Zy iZkkb\gmx w\lZgZabx h]h\Zjb\Z_l __ p_euf jy^hf mkeh\bb AZdhg wlb
mkeh\by ij_^mkfZljb\Z_l <he_baty\e_gb_ iZpb_glZ _]h aZ\_sZgb_ [ebadbf
h[yaZl_evguAZy\e_gb_^he`gh[ulvk^_eZgh\ khklhygbbdh]^Zq_eh\_d³wfhpbhgZevgh
b mfkl\_gghiheghklvxdhfi_l_gl_g´b ih^ibkZgh^\mfyk\b^_l_eyfb
< BkiZgbb :kkhpbZpby aZ ijZ\h mf_j_lv ^hklhcgh hkgh\ZgZ _s_ \ ]h^m
>ZlkdZy:kkhpbZpby^h[jh\hevghcw\lZgZabb^_ckl\m_l[he__^_kyldZe_lG_h^bg]h^
gZg_kdhevdboyaudZo\uoh^blf_`^mgZjh^guc`mjgZe³W\lZgZaby´
: dZd hlghkylky d wlhfm f_^bdb" IhjZaghfm >\_ lj_lb njZgpmakdbo \jZq_c
h^h[jyxl ^h[jh\hevguc moh^ \ kemqZ_ fmqbl_evghc b g_bae_qbfhc [he_agb <
=heeZg^bbw\lZgZabxhnbpbZevghijbf_gyxl\jZqbb ihaZdhgmaZwlhg_ij_ke_^mxlky
Ghh[s_kl\_gghklvR\_pbb=_jfZgbbBlZebb;_ev]bb:g]ebbgZkljh_gZj_rbl_evgh
ijhlb\w\lZgZabbAZ__ bkihevah\Zgb_ij_^mkfhlj_gZf_jZgZdZaZgby²kf_jlgZydZagv
: dZd j_rZ_lky ijh[e_fZ w\lZgZabb \ gZr_c kljZg_" IhdZ aZ jm[_`hf bsml
g_ijhklhc\uoh^gZrbf_^bpbgkdb_wlbdb]hj^hiZjylgZ^`bagvxgZau\Zyw\lZgZabx
g_ bgZq_ dZd ij_klmie_gb_f i_j_^ ]mfZgbafhf ³<jZq_[gZy wlbdZ b f_^bpbgkdZy
^_hglheh]by´Z\lhj::=jZg^hba^Zgh\ Db_\_\ ]h^m³H`b\eyy\k_o²ibr_l
Z\lhj²fukh\f_sZ_f]mfZggmxihfhsv[hevghfmk gZmqgufihbkdhf´
Gh \j_fy ^_deZjZlb\gh]h ]mfZgbafZ moh^bl GZr_ h[s_kl\h \k_ gZ]ey^g__
h[gZ`Z_l kdjulu_ jZgvr_ ya\u Z ihlhfm g_ klhbl ljZlblv \j_fy gZ ihe_fbdm k
gZq_lqbdZfbb imklha\hgZfb=hjZa^hihe_ag__ijbkemrZlvkyd k_jv_agufZj]mf_glZf
\u^\b]Z_fuf
ijhlb\gbdZfb
w\lZgZabb
GZb[he__
ihke_^h\Zl_evgh
hgb
knhjfmebjh\Zgu\ ibkvf_\jZqZ<Khdheh\Z³>_eh\ lhfqlhihkmlbw\lZgZaby_klv
m[bckl\h h^gh]h q_eh\_dZ ^jm]bf f_^bdhf : m[bckl\h ^Z`_ [_agZ^_`gh [hevgh]h
q_eh\_dZ^Z`_ih_]hkh[kl\_gghfm`_eZgbxb ijhkv[_ijhlb\hj_qblkZfhckmsghklb
\jZqZ b kj_^g_]h f_^jZ[hlgbdZ Ijba\Zgb_ dhlhjhfm hgb ihk\ysZxl `bagv² [hjv[Z
khkf_jlvxZ g_ihfhsv_c
?keb\jZqihex[ufkhh[jZ`_gbyfkihkh[_gebrblv`bagb^jm]h]hq_eh\_dZ²
_]hg_f_^e_gghgm`ghebrZlv^biehfZb[hhgij_\jZlbeky\ k\hxijhlb\hiheh`ghklv
\ m[bcpm G_evay lZd`_ aZ[u\Zlv qlh \jZqb lh`_ ex^b Z q_eh\_dm k\hckl\_ggh
ih^^Z\Zlvkykh[eZagm?keb\jZqkihkh[_gm[blvq_eh\_dZ\ _]hbgl_j_kZolhihemqb\
ijZ\h m[b\Zlv aZdhggh ihq_fm hg g_ fh`_l wlh ^_eZlv \ k\hbo kh[kl\_gguo" <jZqm
gZ^_e_gghfmijZ\hfm[b\ZlvjZghbebiha^ghex^bi_j_klZgml^h\_jylvk\hx`bagvB
lZdbfh[jZahfh[s_kl\hebrblkyk\h_cf_^bpbgu
Bf_gghihwlhcijbqbg_gb h^gha^jZ\hfukeys__l_f[he__]mfZggh_h[s_kl\h
gbdh]^Zg_iha\heblk_[_maZdhgblv\ k\h_ckljZg_w\lZgZabx
<hijhk h [_agZ^_`ghklb [hevgh]h lh`_ g_ ijhklhc Kljh]h ]h\hjy d wlhc
dZl_]hjbb ij_`^_ \k_]h ke_^m_l hlg_klb \k_o g_^hfh]Zxsbo klZjbdh\ \k_ hgb q_j_a
g_kdhevdhe_lg_ba[_`ghmfjmlQlhbflh`_hldZaZlv\ e_q_gbb"
M[bckl\h ]mfZgguf g_ [u\Z_l Hgh \k_]^Z m[bckl\h : ]mfZgbaf ihlhfm b
]mfZgbafqlhihfh]Z_l^jm]hfm\u`blvZ g_mf_j_lvB h[s_kl\h_kebhghohq_l[ulv
]mfZgguf g_ ^he`gh gZ\yau\Zlv \jZqm h[yaZgghklb ijhlb\hj_qZsb_ kmlb _]h
^_yl_evghklbIh^dZdbf[ulhgb [ueh[eZ]h\b^gufij_^eh]hfBa\_klghdm^Zhq_gv
qZklh\_^ml[eZ]b_gZf_j_gby´
Ijb\k_cgZr_cm\_j_gghklb\ ijZ\_[hevgh]hgZw\lZgZabxwlbZj]mf_gluklhbl
mqblu\Zlv Im[ebdZpby njZgpmakdh]h `mjgZebklZ @ZdZFZjb ;mj`_ \ ‹ ³IZjb
FZlq´ hl ]h^Z \ua\ZeZ wnn_dl jZahj\Z\r_cky [hf[u < g_c jZkkdZau\Zehkv h
km^_[ghf ijhp_kk_ gZ^ q_lujvfy f_^bpbgkdbfb k_kljZfb b kZgblZjdZfb kem`[u
]_jbZljbbf_^bpbgu^eyij_klZj_euoh^ghcba\_gkdbo[hevgbpWlb³bkqZ^byZ^Zba
iZ\bevhgZ ‹ ´ dZd bo hdj_klbeb `mjgZebklu m[b\Zeb gZ^h_\rbo bf ij_klZj_euo
iZpb_glh\< hkgh\ghfkihkh[hfm[bckl\Zkem`beZi_j_^habjh\dZkghl\hjguob ^jm]bo
kbevgh^_ckl\mxsbo ij_iZjZlh\ \\h^bfuo \gmljb\_ggh < gZqZe_ hgb m[b\Zeb jh[dh
\u[bjZy g_bae_qbfuo [hevguo hkeZ[e_gguo fmq_gbyfb Gh aZl_f hkhagZ\ qlh hgb
fh]ml ^_ckl\h\Zlv [_agZdZaZggh klZeb m[b\Zlv \k_o q_flh g_ ihgjZ\b\rboky bf beb
kebrdhflj_[h\Zl_evguoklZjbdh\GZ^hijhk_\ ihebpbbh^gZbaf_^k_kl_jKl_nZgby
FZc_j ijbagZeZkv qlh m`_ \ l_q_gb_ ^\mo e_l k ih kZgblZjdZ <Zevljh
<Z]g_jmqbeZ__ ^_eZlvaeh\_smxijhp_^mjmih^gZa\Zgb_f³ihehkdZgb_jlZ´aZ`bfZy
ghk `_jl\_ b aZihegyy \ lh `_ \j_fy jhl \h^hc Kf_jlv gZklmiZeZ \ j_amevlZl_ hl_dZ
e_]dbo
<Zevljh <Z]g_j g_m^Z\rZyky f_^k_kljZ ijbe_`gZy kZgblZjdZ ^_`mjysZy ih
ghqZf \ \_gkdhc [hevgbp_ [_a khfg_gby kZfZy kljZrgZy ij_klmigbpZ \k_o \j_f_g
Ihebpbyg_fh`_lmklZgh\blviheguckibkhd\k_oklZjbdh\²`_jl\wlhcm[bcpu
beb"< k\h_cp_ibm[bckl\<Z]g_jihdmrZeZkvg_lhevdhgZ[_a\_klguoiZpb_glh\
f_`^m__ jmdijhoh^bebb agZf_gblhklbLZdba\_klgucwdhghfbklb @xeby>jZiZev
[u\rZy[Ze_jbgZl_ZljZHi_jZ\ <_g_[uebmkljZg_guijbf_jghckZgblZjdhc
Wlb ij_klmigu_ ^_ckl\by dh]^Z klZjbdh\ ijbdZgqb\Zeb dZd ehrZ^_c \ua\Zeb
gZklhysbc rhd \ Z\kljbckdhf h[s_kl\_ DZgpe_j NjZgp <jZgbpdbc hoZjZdl_jbah\Ze
wlh ij_klmie_gb_ dZd ³kZfh_ `_klhdh_ b ly`_eh_ \ bklhjbb kljZgu´ Dmjl <Zev^oZcf
kdZaZe qlh ³wlh ij_klmie_gb_ gZklhevdh m`Zkgh qlh \hh[jZablv k_[_ lZdh_
g_\hafh`gh´
Gh ijb\_^_ggu_ ijbf_ju g_evay h^ghagZqgh lhedh\Zlv dZd [_ah]h\hjhqguc
Zj]mf_glijhlb\gbdh\w\lZgZabb;he__lh]hhgbg_bf_xlgbq_]hh[s_]hk w\lZgZab_c
dZdlZdh\hcGhd ]hehkZfijhlb\gbdh\w\lZgZabbklhblijbkemrZlvkyqlh[uba[_`Zlv
\hafh`guo hrb[hd HdhgqZl_evgh \hijhk h[ w\lZgZabb _s_ g_ j_r_g ?]h ij_^klhbl
j_rZlvgZfgZr_fmihdhe_gbx_kebfu^_ckl\bl_evghohlbfkqblZlvk_[yihdhe_gb_f
k\h[h^guoex^_ck\h[h^guo\ \u[hj_h[jZaZ`bagbb h[jZaZkf_jlb
]h^Z
EBL?J:LMJ:
.DSDZ-LL+ G F Ij_^Zgby\_dh\F©IjZ\^Zª
;m]Zgh\<B FbjbklhjbbJhkkby\ ;9,,klhl_lbbF³Fhqh^Zy]\Zj^by´
Jm^gh_<: Ihbklhjbq_kdbfb dmlvlh\uff_klZfBg^bb²EGZmdZ´
KZfhm[bckl\hij_ke_^m_lky"³DhfkhfhevkdZyijZ\^Z!‹ ghy[jy
GH
g_h`b\eylv³F_^bpbgkdZy]Za_lZ´‹ k_gly[jy
Ijhl_klmxdZd\jZq³Ebl_jZlmjgZy]Za_lZ´‹ ghy[jy
=E:<: ,9
Hiulkf_jlb beb l_dlh\_jgmebkv
JZa\blb_ j_ZgbfZlheh]bb b bgl_gkb\ghc l_jZibb \ ihke_^gb_ ^_kylbe_lby
iha\hebeh\_jgmlvd `bagbh]jhfgh_qbkehjZg__kqblZ\rboky[_agZ^_`gufb[hevguo
;eZ]h^Zjywlhfmm fgh]bolukyqex^_c\u\_^_gguo\jZqZfbbakhklhygbydebgbq_kdhc
kf_jlbihy\behkvlhqlhijbgylhgZau\Zlv³hiulhfkf_jlb´Hllm^ZbaaZdZaZ\r_cky
g_au[e_fhcq_jluhl^_ey\r_c`bagvhlkf_jlb\ha\jZsZebkvex^bb jZkkdZau\Zebh
k\hbohsms_gbyo
< k_j_^bg_o ]h^h\gZr_]h\_dZkibkhd[_klk_ee_jh\KR:\ha]eZ\beZdgb]Z
Zf_jbdZgkdh]h \jZqZ JZcfhg^Z Fhm^b ³@bagv ihke_ `bagb´ \ dhlhjhc bf
ijhZgZebabjh\Zgu ihjZabl_evgu_ k\b^_l_evkl\Z ex^_c i_j_`b\rbo khklhygb_
debgbq_kdhckf_jlb³HibkZgbyklhevkoh^guklhev`b\ub g_ij_h^hebfh^hklh\_jgu
qlh hgb fh]ml gZ\k_]^Z baf_gblv \a]ey^ q_eh\_q_kl\Z gZ kf_jlv `bagv b ihkf_jlgh_
kms_kl\h\Zgb_^mrb´²ibkZe`mjgZe³:f_jbdZ´\ bxg_]h^Z
< k\h_cdgb]_^hdlhjFhm^b\u\h^bllbibqgmxko_fmdebgbq_kdhckf_jlbijb
gZklmie_gbb kf_jlb [hevghc mki_\Z_l mkeurZlv keh\Z \jZqZ dhgklZlbjmxs_]h
e_lZevguc bkoh^ aZl_f keurbl g_ijb\uqguc rmf ]jhfdbc a\hg beb `m``Zgb_ b
qm\kl\m_l qlh k [hevrhc kdhjhklvx g_k_lky kd\hav ^ebgguc q_jguc lmgg_ev Ihke_
wlh]h hg \g_aZigh h[gZjm`b\Z_l k_[y \g_ k\h_]h nbabq_kdh]h l_eZ \b^bl k\_l i_j_^
gbf ijhoh^bl \ky `bagv d g_fm ijboh^yl ^mrb ^jm]bo ex^_c qlh[u \klj_lblv b
ihfhqv _fm hg magZ_l \ g_dhlhjuo kemqZyo k\hbo ^jma_c beb mf_jrbo jh^bl_e_c b
i_j_^ gbf ihy\ey_lky k\_lys__ky kms_kl\h hl dhlhjh]h bkoh^bl lZdZy ex[h\v b
^mr_\gZy l_iehlZ dZdhc hg gbdh]^Z g_ \klj_qZe AZl_f hg qm\kl\m_l ijb[eb`_gb_
]jZgbpubaaZdhlhjhc\ha\jZlZm`_g_[m^_lb\ha\jZsZ_lkyd `bagb
AZljhgmlZy JZcfhg^hf Fhm^b l_fZ lml `_ gZreZ wglmabZklh\ >hdlhj
ikboheh]bbD_gg_lJbg]kgZjy^bep_emxwdki_^bpbxihdebgbdZfrlZlZDhgg_dlbdml
Blh]bljbgZ^pZlbf_kyqguo bkke_^h\Zgbc ihdZaZeb n_ghf_g kms_kl\m_l b g_ k\yaZg k
dZdhceb[h iZlheh]b_c Gb bglhdkbdZpby gb kgh\b^_gby gb ]ZeexpbgZpbb a^_kv gb
ijbq_fIjhZgZebabjh\Z\kemqZydebgbq_kdhckf_jlb^hdlhjJbg]dhgklZlbjh\Ze
ijhp_glh\[hevguobkiulZebg_i_j_^Z\Z_fh_qm\kl\hihdhyijhp_glh\²iZjbeb
gZ^kh[kl\_ggufl_ehf²ihfgyljZaebqgu_iZghjZfgu_\b^_gby²\oh^beb\
lmgg_evrexaf_rhddheh^_pbeb ih]j_[ ² ^h kbo ihj \hklhj]Zxlky qZjmxsbf
k\_lhf ijhp_glh\ ml\_j`^Zxl qlh \klj_qZebkv k mf_jrbfb jh^kl\_ggbdZfb
IhdZaZgby\k_]^Zkh\iZ^Zxl[m^vlhiZpb_glubaKR:kljZg?\jhiubebba;mjmg^b
Zl_bklu ojbklbZg_ beb [m^^bklu kqblZxl eb hgb k\_l ijbjh^guf y\e_gb_f beb
[h`_kl\_gghc[eZ]h^Zlvx²\k_jZkkdZau\Zebh^gbb l_`_\_sb
GZ ^jm]hf dhgp_ Kh_^bg_gguo RlZlh\ fheh^hc dZj^bheh] ^hdlhj K_c[hf
jZpbhgZevguc b i_^Zglbqguc q_eh\_d ijhqblZ\ l_abku Fhm^b jZajZabeky
ya\bl_evgufb gZkf_rdZfb b qlh[u kh\k_f m` g_ hklZ\blv hl gbo dZfgy gZ dZfg_
ijh\_e kbkl_fZlbq_kdh_ Zgd_lbjh\Zgb_ kj_^b i_jkhgZeZ j_ZgbfZpbhgghc kem`[u \h
Nehjb^_Dh]^Z`_j_amevlZlu_]hbkke_^h\Zgbciheghklvxkh\iZebk ^ZggufbFhm^b
b Jbg]Z K_c[hf j_rbe ihk\ylblv k\hx `bagv bamq_gbx wlh]h n_ghf_gZ Hg ^Z`_
jZajZ[hlZe ^_kylbklmi_gqZlmx fh^_ev khklhygby debgbq_kdhc kf_jlb dhlhjZy l_i_jv
ghkbl_]hbfy
BlZd ^Zgguc n_ghf_g kms_kl\m_l b ihemqbe ki_pbZevgh_ gZa\Zgb_ ³n_ghf_g
G>?´ Zg]ebckdZy Z[[j_\bZlmjZ hagZqZxsZy khklhygb_ [ebadh_ d kf_jlb
Hj]Zgbah\ZgZ ^Z`_ F_`^mgZjh^gZy ZkkhpbZpby ih bamq_gbx n_ghf_gZ G>?
ij_^k_^Zl_e_f njZgpmakdh]h hl^_e_gby dhlhjhc y\ey_lky Emb<_gk_g LhfZ ij_ab^_gl
NjZgpmakdhclZgZlheh]bq_kdhcZkkhpbZpbb_klvb lZdZyBgl_j\vxk f_kv_LhfZ[ueh
him[ebdh\Zgh\ ‹_`_g_^_evgbdZ³AZjm[_`hf´aZ]h^
Kh\j_f_ggu_ bkke_^h\Zl_eb kqblZxl qlh lj_lv iZpb_glh\ i_j_`b\rbo
debgbq_kdmxkf_jlvgZoh^bebkv\ khklhygbbG>?h^gZdhfgh]b_hiulgu_\jZqb\kx
`bagvijhjZ[hlZ\rb_\ kem`[Zo³kdhjhcihfhsb´gbdh]^Zg_keurZebbebg_ohl_eb
kemrZlv" dZdboeb[h ih^h[guo k\b^_l_evkl\ H[tykgy_lky wlh l_f qlh ex^b
iulZxsb_kyh[km^blvi_j_`blucbfbij_^kf_jlguchiulqZs_\k_]hklZedb\Zxlkykh
kd_ilbpbafhf b iheguf g_ihgbfZgb_f Ihqlb dZ`^uc \ lZdhc kblmZpbb gZqbgZ_l
hsmsZlvqlhhgq_flhhldehgy_lkyhlghjfuihkdhevdmgbdlhg_i_j_`b\Zelh]hqlh
kemqbehkv k gbf Wlb ex^b aZfudZxlky \ k_[_ b klZjZxlky gbdhfm g_ hldju\Zlv qlh
ijhbahrehk gbfbaZ]jZgvx`bagb
H^gZdh n_ghf_g G>? ^he`_g [ue [ulv ba\_kl_g m`_ ^Z\gh aZ^he]h ^h
ihy\e_gby j_ZgbfZpbb ohly fh`_l [ulv b g_ \ lZdbo agZqbl_evguo fZkrlZ[Zo dZd
k_cqZk H[ wlhf k\b^_l_evkl\mxl hl^_evgu_ jZa[jhkZggu_ \ jZaebqguo bklhqgbdZo
k\b^_l_evkl\Z <hl gZijbf_j hibkZgb_ ihkf_jlgh]h khklhygby ;eZ`_gghc N_^hju
aZbfkl\h\Zggh_babklhqgbdZO \_dZ³Y h]eygmeZkvgZaZ^b m\b^_eZqlhfh_l_ehe_`bl
[_a qm\kl\Z b ^\b`_gby Ih^h[gh lhfm dZd _keb [u dlh k[jhkb\rb k k_[y h^_`^m
kfhlj_egZg__lZdb ykfhlj_eZgZk\h_l_eh[m^lh[ugZh^_`^mb hq_gvm^b\eyeZkv
wlhfm´ Wlh hibkZgb_ ihqlb ^hkeh\gh ih\lhjy_l fgh]hqbke_ggu_ k\b^_l_evkl\Z
ijb\_^_ggu_\ dgb]_Fhm^b
< [b[ebhl_d_ Ikdh\hI_q_jkdh]h fhgZklujy dhlhjmx fg_ ihkqZkleb\behkv
ihk_lblvojZgblkyhq_gvj_^dZydgb]Zih\_kl\mxsZyh lhfdZdg_dbcjmkkdbcq_eh\_d
ih[u\Ze³gZlhfk\_l_´Dgb]ZkrblZbakljZgbp³Ljhbpdh]hebkldZ´‹ ba^Zggh]h\
Ljhbp_K_j]b_\hc eZ\j_ \ ]h^m GZ lblme_ __ agZqblky D Bg_dmev ³G_\_jhylgh_
^ey fgh]bo gh bklbggh_ ijhbkr_kl\b_´ Ijb\_^_ggu_ \ g_c k\b^_l_evkl\Z lZd`_
kh\iZ^Zxlk m`_hibkZggufbgZfbkbfilhfZfbn_ghf_gZG>?
GZdZjlbg_³Wfibj_b´]heeZg^kdh]hom^h`gbdZ;hkoZ`b\r_]hiylv\_dh\lhfm
gZaZ^ihdZaZgh³\oh`^_gb_^mrmf_jrbo\ pZjkl\hg_[_kgh_´IhjZ`Z_lm^b\bl_evgh_
kh\iZ^_gb_ bah[jZ`_ggh]h k jZkkdZaZfb ex^_c i_j_g_krbo debgbq_kdmx kf_jlv
klj_fbl_evgh_ \jZsZxs__ky ^\b`_gb_ ^mr ih ^ebgghfm l_fghfm lmgg_ex \ dhgp_
dhlhjh]hkby_lg_\ujZabfhyjdbck\_l
G_khfg_gghl\hjq_kl\hfgh]boom^h`gbdh\ihwlh\ibkZl_e_ciblZehkvhiulhf
ex^_c agZdhfuo k n_ghf_ghf G>? I_j_qblZcl_ ³Kf_jlv B\ZgZ BevbqZ´ Ev\Z
GbdheZ_\bqZLheklh]h²ihljykZxs__hibkZgb_n_ghf_gZG>?
: \hl kp_gZ jZkklj_eZ Z^fbjZeZ DheqZdZ ba jhfZgZ ibkZl_eywfb]jZglZ
<eZ^bfbjZ ?f_evygh\bqZ FZdkbfh\Z ³AZ]eygmlv \ [_a^gm´ ³KljZggh gh :^fbjZe g_
mkeurZe \uklj_eZ b g_ ihqm\kl\h\Ze [heb Lhevdh qlhlh f]gh\_ggh lj_kgmeh b
gZ^ehfbehkv \ g_f Z kjZam \ke_^ aZ wlbf \hagbd moh^ysbc \^Zev \bglhh[jZaguc
dhjb^hjkhke_iysbfgh\ lh`_ \j_fy ijZa^gbqgh mfbjhl\hjyxsbf k\_lhf \ dhgp_
m\e_dZy _]h d wlhfm k\_lm b hkbygguc hllm^Z \klj_qghc \heghc hg jZ^hklgh b
hk\h[h`^_ggh jZkl\hjbeky \ g_c Ihke_^g__ qlh hg hlf_lbe k\h_c a_fghc iZfylvx
[ueh jZkijhkl_jlh_ gZ kbg_f kg_]m _]h kh[kl\_ggh_ l_eh \^jm] klZ\r__ ^ey g_]h
qm`bf´
IhjZabl_evgu lZd`_ ih lhqghklb om^h`_kl\_ggh]h \hiehs_gby kp_gu
debgbq_kdhckf_jlb]eZ\gh]h]_jhy\ nbevf_Wev^ZjZJyaZgh\Z³H^bghdZyf_eh^by^ey
ne_clu´ LZf ij_^klZ\e_gu \k_ dhfihg_glu n_ghf_gZ G>? ² g_ijb\uqguc rmf
^\b`_gb_ih ^ebgghfm iheml_fghfm dhjb^hjm \klj_qZ k ^mrZfb mf_jrbo jh^bl_e_c
iulZxsboky ihfhqv _fm ih^]hlh\blvky d i_j_oh^m \ gh\uc fbj khijh\h`^Zxsb_
]_jhy^mrbih]b[rboh^gh\j_f_gghk gbfex^_c²klZjbdh\\hbgh\Zn]Zgp_\`_jl\
q_jgh[uevkdhc Z\Zjbb \ ki_pbZevguo aZsblguo dhklxfZo b gZdhg_p² yjdbc k\_l \
dhgp_dhjb^hjZ]^_bkq_aZxl\k_^\b]Zxsb_kyd g_fm^mrb
< k\h_c dgb]_ ³@bagv ihke_ `bagb´ JZcfhg^ Fhm^b hibku\Z_l h^bggZ^pZlv
q_ldh jZaebqguo nZa hl ijhbag_k_gby \jZq_[gh]h \_j^bdlZ h gZklmib\r_c kf_jlb ^h
\ha\jZs_gbyd `bagbohly[hevrbgkl\h³\ha\jZs_gp_\´g_ijhoh^bliheghklvx\k_wlb
nZau>Z\Zcl_b fujZkkfhljbfih^jh[g__g_dhlhju_klmi_gbn_ghf_gZG>?
N_ghf_g G>? dZ`_lky bamq_g m`_ ohjhrh b \ dZ`^hf kemqZ_ _fm \k_]^Z
gZoh^blky dZdh_lh h[tykg_gb_ Gh h^gZ \_sv ^h kbo ihj g_ mdeZ^u\Z_lky gb \ dZdb_
ko_fmhl^_e_gb_hll_eZbeb^_dhjihjZpbyDZdhlghkblvkyd [hevgufdhlhju_ihke_
hi_jZpbbgZqbgZxljZkkdZau\Zlvh lhfqlhijhbkoh^beh\ khk_^g_cdhfgZl_": ke_iu_
[_ahrb[hqgh gZau\Zxsb_ p\_l ]ZeklmdZ m objmj]Z" G_dhlhju_ j_Zgbfbjh\Zggu_
jZkkdZau\Zxlqlh\ i_j\u_fbgmluhgbg_fh]ebihgylvqlhijhbahrehGZoh^ykv\g_
l_eZ hgb iulZebkv h[sZlvky k hdjm`Zxsbfb aZ]h\Zjb\Zlv k gbfb b k g_^hmf_gb_f
m[_`^Zebkv qlh l_ g_ \hkijbgbfZxl g_ keurZl bo ³Y \b^_eZ dZd hgb iulZxlky
\_jgmlvf_gyd `bagbY iulZeZkv]h\hjblvk gbfbghgbdlhf_gyg_keurZe´
HibkZgb_ ih^h[gh]h ihkf_jlgh]h i_j_`b\Zgby kh^_j`bl b lb[_lkdZy ³Dgb]Z
f_jl\uo´ Mf_jrbc ]h\hjblky \ g_c dZd [u kh klhjhgu \b^bl k\h_ l_eh b [ebadbo
hieZdb\Zxsbo _]h Hg lh`_ iulZ_lky hdebdgmlv bo aZ]h\hjblv k gbf gh gbdlh g_
keurbl _]h DZd b \ kemqZyo jZkkdZaZgguo j_Zgbfbjh\Zggufb hg g_ kjZam ihgbfZ_l
qlhk gbfijhbahreh
<h fgh]bo khh[s_gbyo mihfbgZ_lky h jZagh]h jh^Z g_h[uqguo kemoh\uo
hsms_gbyo \ fhf_gl kf_jlb beb i_j_^ wlbf Wlh fh`_l [ulv `m``Zgb_ ]jhfdh_
s_edZgv_ j_\ klmdb k\bklysbc a\md ihoh`bc gZ \_l_j dhehdhevguc a\hg
\_ebq_kl\_ggZyfmaudZ
QZklh h^gh\j_f_ggh k rmfh\uf wnn_dlhf m ex^_c \hagbdZ_l hsms_gb_
^\b`_gbyk hq_gv[hevrhckdhjhklvxq_j_adZdh_lhijhkljZgkl\h>eyhibkZgbywlh]h
ijhkljZgkl\Z bkihevam_lky fgh]h jZaebqguo \ujZ`_gbc i_s_jZ dheh^_p g_qlh
kd\hagh_ g_dh_ aZfdgmlh_ ijhkljZgkl\h lmgg_ev ^ufhoh^ \Zdmmf imklhlZ klhqgZy
ljm[Z^hebgZpbebg^jOhlyex^b\ wlhfkemqZ_ihevamxlkyjZaebqghcl_jfbgheh]b_c
ykghqlh\k_hgbiulZxlky\ujZablvh^gmb lm`_fukev
Fhm^bijb\h^bllZd`_g_kdhevdhjZkkdZah\j_Zgbfbjh\Zgguoh \klj_qZo^jm]bo
^moh\guokms_kl\Wlbkms_kl\Zhq_\b^ghijbkmlkl\h\Zebjy^hfk gbfbk l_fqlh[u
ihfhqvh[e_]qblvmfbjZxsbfi_j_oh^\ gh\h_khklhygb_
GZb[he__ g_\_jhylguf b \ lh `_ \j_fy gZb[he__ h[uqguf we_f_glhf \h \k_o
bamq_gguo ^hdlhjhf Fhm^b kemqZyo [ueZ \klj_qZ k hq_gv yjdbf k\_lhf G_kfhljy gZ
\kx g_h[uqghklv wlh]h \b^_gby gb h^bg ba iZpb_glh\ g_ khfg_\Zeky \ lhf qlh wlh
[ueh kms_kl\h k\_lys__ky kms_kl\h h[eZ^Zxs__ ebqghklvx B^_glbnbdZpby wlh]h
kms_kl\Z jZaebqgufb ex^vfb \_kvfZ jZaebqgZ b aZ\bkbl ]eZ\guf h[jZahf hl
j_eb]bhaghckj_^u\ dhlhjhcnhjfbjh\Zekyq_eh\_d_]h\hkiblZgbyb ebqghc\_ju
>Ze__ ih hibkZgbyf kh[jZgguf Fhm^b k\_lys__ky kms_kl\h ihdZau\Z_l
q_eh\_dmdZjlbgudZd[uh[ahj_]h`bagbWlhlh[ahj\k_]^Zhibku\Z_fucdZdg_dbc
wdjZg \b^bfuo h[jZah\ g_kfhljy gZ _]h kdhjhklv hdZau\Z_lky g_\_jhylgh `b\uf b
j_Zevguf \ wlhf kh]eZkgu \k_ hijhr_ggu_ k\b^_l_eb G_kfhljy gZ lh qlh dZjlbgu
[ukljh kf_gyeb ^jm] ^jm]Z dZ`^Zy ba gbo hlq_leb\h magZ\ZeZkv b \hkijbgbfZeZkv
>Z`_ wfhpbb b qm\kl\Z k\yaZggu_ k wlbfb dZjlbgZfb fh]eb i_j_`b\Zlvky aZgh\h
q_eh\_dhfdh]^Zhgbo\b^_e
< g_kdhevdbo kemqZyo iZpb_glu jZkkdZau\Zeb JZcfhg^m Fhm^b dZd \h \j_fy
k\h_]hij_^kf_jlgh]hhiulZhgbijb[eb`Zebkvd q_fmlhqlhfh`gh[ueh[ugZa\Zlv
]jZgbp_cbebdZdbflhij_^_ehf< jZaguok\b^_l_evkl\Zowlhy\e_gb_hibku\Z_lkyih
jZaghfm \ \b^_ dZdh]hlh \h^gh]h ijhkljZgkl\Z k_jh]h lmfZgZ ^\_jb h]jZ^u
lygms_ckyq_j_aihe_bebijhklhebgbbAZwlbfb\i_qZle_gbyfb\_jhylghklhblh^bg
b lhl `_ hiul beb b^_y b jZaebqgu_ ih nhjf_ jZkkdZau ij_^klZ\eyxl kh[hc ebrv
bg^b\b^mZevgu_ ihiuldb i_j_^Zlv k ihfhsvx keh\ \hkihfbgZgb_ h[ h^ghf b lhf `_
i_j_`b\Zgbb
LZd dZd q_jlZ i_j_oh^ q_j_a dhlhjmx hagZqZ_l qlh gZaZ^ \ha\jZlZ g_l qZklh
Zkkhpbbjm_lkyk dZdhclh\h^ghcij_]jZ^hclh\_jhylghbf_gghhlkx^Zkbf\he\h^u\
agZq_gbb ihke_^g_c ij_]jZ^u i_j_r_e \ kZfu_ jZaebqgu_ fbnheh]bb b dmevlmju
>hklZlhqgh\kihfgblvj_db:b^ZE_lmKlbdk:o_jhg\ Zglbqghffbn_j_dmK_g^amm
[m^^bklh\ Yihgbb b l ^ LZdZy ljZ^bpby [ueZ k\hckl\_ggZ b ^j_\gbf _]bilygZf GZ
jbkmgdZo ba ^j_\g__]bi_lkdhc ³Dgb]b f_jl\uo´ k\h^Z bgkljmdpbc b aZdebgZgbc ^ey
^mrbmf_jr_]h^mrZ]hlh\Zyd i_j_oh^mij_dehgy_ldhe_gbi_j_^j_dhchl^_eyxs_c
a_fghc fbj hl aZ]jh[guo Ihe_c ;eZ]hkeh\_gguo ]^_ \_qgh [h]Zlu_ mjh`Zb
h[_ki_qb\Zxlkulmxb [_ki_qZevgmx`bagv\k_fmf_jrbf
Gbh^bgbaiZpb_glh\^hdlhjZFhm^bg_i_j_klmibewlmq_jlm<_jhylghl_
dlh __ \k_lZdb i_j_klmibeb g_ kfh]eb \_jgmlvky b jZkkdZaZlv h[ wlhf <k_ `_ ex^b
\u\_^_ggu_ ba khklhygby debgbq_kdhc kf_jlb i_j_`beb \ha\jZs_gb_ h[jZlgh hl
dZdh]hlh fhf_glZ bo ij_^kf_jlgh]h hiulZ Ihqlb \k_ hijhr_ggu_ ihfgbeb qlh \
i_j\u_f]gh\_gbybokf_jlb^hfbgbjh\Zeh[_amfgh_`_eZgb_\_jgmlvkyh[jZlgh\ l_eh
b ]hj_klgh_ i_j_`b\Zgb_ k\h_c dhgqbgu H^gZdh dh]^Z mf_jrbc ^hklb]Ze
hij_^_e_gguo klZ^bc mfbjZgby hg g_ ohl_e \ha\jZsZlvky h[jZlgh hg ^Z`_
khijhlb\eyeky\ha\jZs_gbx\ k\h_l_ehWlh[uehhkh[_gghoZjZdl_jgh^eyl_okemqZ_\
\ dhlhjuobf_eZf_klh\klj_qZkhk\_lysbfkykms_kl\hf
< kj_^gb_ \_dZ kqblZeb qlh ijbagZdhf l_o dlh ih[u\Ze gZ lhf k\_l_ y\ey_lky
g_kihkh[ghklvkf_ylvkyG_dhlhju_baf_g_gbyikbobdbex^_c\ur_^rbobakhklhygby
debgbq_kdhckf_jlbhlf_qZxlijZdlbq_kdb\k_bkke_^h\Zl_ebJZcfhg^Fhm^bkqblZ_l
qlhi_j_`bluchiulhdZaZegZ`bagvj_Zgbfbjh\Zgguohq_gvlhgdh_mfbjhl\hjyxs__
\ha^_ckl\b_Fgh]b_ ^mfZxl qlh `bagv klZeZ ]em[`_ b kh^_j`Zl_evg__ baf_gbeky bo
\a]ey^gZkhhlghr_gb_p_gghklbnbabq_kdh]hl_eZb _]hjZamfZ
NjZgpmakdbc ikbobZlj IZljbd >vxZ\jbg lZd`_ bkke_^h\Z\rbc n_ghf_g G>?
ibr_lqlhikboheh]bq_kdZymjZ\gh\_r_gghklvj_Zgbfbgbjh\Zgguoebp\ur_kj_^g_]h
mjh\gy m gbo ]hjZa^h f_gvr_ ijhy\eyxlky ikbohiZlheh]bq_kdb_ y\e_gby dhlhju_
[u\Zeb \ ijhrehf hgb mihlj_[eyxl f_gvr_ e_dZjkl\ Zedh]hey g_ mihlj_[eyxl
gbdZdbogZjdhlbdh\
DZdb ke_^h\Zehh`b^ZlvhiulG>?hdZau\Z_l]em[hdh_ \ebygb_ gZ hlghr_gb_
i_j_`b\rbo_]hex^_cd nbabq_kdhckf_jlbhkh[_gghl_obagbodhlhju_^hwlh]hg_
^mfZeb qlh _klv qlheb[h ihke_ kf_jlb < lhc beb bghc nhjf_ ih^q_jdb\Z_l Fhm^b
\k_wlbex^b\ukdZau\Zebh^gmb lm`_fukevhgb[hevr_g_[hylkykf_jlb
KZfZy keh`gZy aZ^ZqZ dhlhjZy \klZ_l i_j_^ qblZl_e_f ihke_ agZdhfkl\Z k
ijb\_^_ggufbnZdlZfb²wlhbohp_gdZ;hevrbgkl\hdhff_glZlhjh\dgb]bJFhm^b
b klZl_c _]h ihke_^h\Zl_e_c _^bgh^mrgh aZy\eyxl ² wlZ dgb]Z hldju\Z_l gh\mx
kljZgbpm \ ihagZgbb q_eh\_dhf kZfh]h k_[y hgZ ^hdZau\Z_l qlh `bagv q_eh\_dZ g_
ij_djZsZ_lky kh kf_jlvx l_eZ b ke_^h\Zl_evgh mdj_iey_l \_jm \ kms_kl\h\Zgb_
aZ]jh[gh]hfbjZ
Gh \hafh`gu b ^jm]b_ fZl_jbZebklbq_kdb_ lhedh\Zgby ijb\_^_gguo gZfb
nZdlh\ Ebqgh y dZd q_eh\_d aZgbfZxsbcky l_hj_lbq_kdbfb b ijZdlbq_kdbfb
ijh[e_fZfb f_^bpbgu kqblZx qlh [hevrbgkl\h ba hibkZgguo n_ghf_gh\ \iheg_
fh`gh bgl_jij_lbjh\Zlv \ jZfdZo ba\_klguo [bheh]bq_kdbo y\e_gbc LZd ijb
gZklmie_gbb debgbq_kdhc kf_jlb \ke_^kl\b_ ij_djZs_gby ghjfZevgh]h
djh\hkgZ[`_gby j_p_ilhjh\ gZklmiZ_l j_adh_ bo dbkehjh^gh_ ]heh^Zgb_ gZ dhlhjh_
jZagu_j_p_ilhjuhl\_qZxlihjZaghfm< kemoh\uoj_p_ilhjZo\hagbdZxlhsms_gby
ihoh`b_ gZ rmf a\hg k\bkl \ ajbl_evguo ² \kiurdb yjdh]h k\_lZ HkljZy br_fby
h[_kdjh\eb\Zgb_ \_klb[meyjguo j_p_ilhjh\ \_jhylgh ijb\h^bl d hsms_gbx
iZ^_gby\jZs_gbyklj_fbl_evgh]h^\b`_gbyihlmgg_exG_^hklZlhddjh\hkgZ[`_gby
]heh\gh]h fha]Z fh`_l bgbpbbjh\Zlv jZ[hlm _]h dhju ijhy\eyxsmxky \ ihlhd_
\hkihfbgZgbcbebijh^mpbjh\Zgbbh[jZah\mr_^rboba`bagbex^_c
LZd dZd m \k_o ex^_c j_p_ilhju j_Z]bjmxl h^bgZdh\h gZ g_^hklZlhd
djh\hkgZ[`_gby lh b \hagbdZxsb_ hsms_gby \iheg_ b^_glbqgu m jZaebqguo ebp
i_j_g_krbowlhkhklhygb_Lh`_ fh`gh kdZaZlv b h \hagbdZxsbo h[jZaZo GZijbf_j
ba\_klgZ klZjbggZy gZjh^gZy ijbf_lZ qlh mf_jrb_ jh^kl\_ggbdb kgylky d i_j_f_g_
ih]h^u >_ckl\bl_evgh baf_g_gby Zlfhkn_jgh]h ^Z\e_gby ijb i_j_f_g_ ih]h^u
\uau\Zxl baf_g_gb_ kgZ k ih\_joghklgh]h gZ [he__ ]em[hdbc dh]^Z \ h[jZah\Zgb_
kgh\b^_gbc \dexqZxlky ]em[bggu_ f_oZgbafu iZfylb khojZgyxsb_ h[jZau dh]^Zlh
[ebadboghmf_jrboex^_c<_jhylghg_qlhih^h[gh_fh`_lijhbkoh^blvb \fhf_gl
gZklmie_gbydebgbq_kdhckf_jlb
Ohly y ^Ze_dh g_ \h \k_f kh]eZk_g k J Fhm^b b _]h _^bghfure_ggbdZfb y
ihklZjZeky gZb[he__ ihegh baeh`blv bo lhqdm aj_gby Fgh]hh[jZab_ lhq_d aj_gby
gbdh]^Z_s_g_ijbghkbeh\j_^ZagZgbxb ihbkdmbklbgu
Keh\h‹ EBL?J:LMJ:
=E:<: 9
³@b\hcljmi´
< ihke_^gb_ ]h^u \k_ qZs_ i_jkhgZ`Zfb nbevfh\ m`Zkh\ klZgh\ylky `b\u_
ljmiu ³ahf[b´ =eZ\guc ]_jhc Zf_jbdZgkdh]h ijbdexq_gq_kdh]h nbevfZ ³Af_c b
jZ^m]Z´DeZbj\bmk GZjpbkk ih^ ^_ckl\b_f y^h\blh]h ihjhrdZ ih]jm`Z_lky \ f_jl\uc
khg gh ijb wlhf hklZ_lky \ iheghf khagZgbb ?fm km`^_gh klZlv k\b^_l_e_f
kh[kl\_gguo ihohjhg Z aZl_f b wdk]mfZpbb < aZ\_jr_gb_ _fm ^Zxl ^mjfZg
ihemq_gguc ba jZkl_gby ih^ gZa\Zgb_f h]mj_p ³ahf[b´ GZjpbkk ³h`b\Z_l´ gh
\_jgmlvkyd ex^yfm`_g_fh`_lHggZ\k_]^ZhklZ_lky³ahf[b´
GZkdhevdh j_Zevgu jZkkdZau h ijZdlbd_ dhe^mgh\ h =Zblb ih ij_\jZs_gbx
q_eh\_dZ\ ³ahf[b´\ `b\hcljmi"
< ]h^m wlgh[hlZgbd =Zj\Zj^kdh]h mgb\_jkbl_lZ Mwc^ >w\bk \ha]eZ\be
wdki_^bpbx gZ =Zblb ;ueh h[gZjm`_gh qlh f_klgu_ dhe^mgu mf_xl ]hlh\blv y^
kihkh[guc\uau\Zlv]em[hdbce_lZj]bq_kdbckhg?kebihjhrhd\l_j_lv\ dh`mlhhg
iZjZebam_l g_j\gmx kbkl_fm ^uoZgb_ ihqlb bkq_aZ_l K ihfhsvx f_klguo ^moh\guo
kem`bl_e_c >w\bkm m^Zehkv \klj_lblvky k dhe^mgZfb b ihemqblv h[jZapu y^Z ^ey
ZgZebaZ ?]h ]eZ\guf bg]j_^b_glhf hdZaZeky l_ljZ^hdkbg h^bg ba kZfuo kbevguo \
fbj_ y^h\ g_j\ghiZjZeblbq_kdh]h ^_ckl\by ij_\urZxsbc \ha^_ckl\b_ pbZgbklh]h
dZeby \ jZa Y^ wlhl ihemqZxl ba ju[u ² ^\mam[Z ^bh^hg obkljbdk GZ =Zblb
j_p_il wlh]h y^h\blh]h ihjhrdZ [ue ba\_kl_g _s_ e_l lhfm gZaZ^ IhdZ g_l
m[_^bl_evguo k\b^_l_evkl\ lh]h dZd ^_ckl\m_l l_ljZ^hdkbg ihq_fm `_jl\Z hklZ_lky \
iheghfkhagZgbb
IjZdlbdZ ij_\jZs_gby q_eh\_dZ \ ³ahf[b´ [ueZ aZ\_a_gZ dh]^Zlh gZ hkljh\
`j_pZfb³\m^m´b ihlhfdZfbq_jguojZ[h\²\uoh^p_\ba;_gbgZjZg__²>Z]hf_y
KhklhblhgZba^\moa\_gv_\ kgZqZeZ m[bckl\Z Z aZl_f \ha\jZs_gby d `bagb @_jl\_
dhlhjmx gZf_j_gu ij_\jZlblv \ ³ahf[b´ ih^f_rb\Zxl \ ibsm y^ l_ljZ^hdkbg ih
^jm]bfk\_^_gbyfy^wlhl\lbjZxl\ dh`mM `_jl\ukjZam`_ij_djZsZ_lky^uoZgb_
kbg__lih\_joghklvl_eZkl_de_g_xl]eZaZ²gZklmiZ_ldebgbq_kdZykf_jlv
Q_j_a g_kdhevdh ^g_c mf_jr_]h hl y^Z ihobsZxl k deZ^[bsZ qlh[u ydh[u
\_jgmlvd `bagbLZdhgklZgh\blky³ahf[b´HkhagZgb_k\h_]h³y´\ha\jZsZ_lkyd g_fm
g_iheghklvxbebg_\ha\jZsZ_lky\hh[s_JZkkdZauhq_\b^p_\\klj_qZ\rbo³ahf[b´
]h\hjylh gbodZdh ex^yodhlhju_[_kkfuke_gghkfhljyli_j_^kh[hc
Ih gZ[ex^_gbx bkke_^h\Zl_ey ijh\_^r_]h gZ =Zblb ljb ]h^Z ^ey ³ahf[b´
aZjZg__ \u[bjZxl gZb[he__ kbevguo nbabq_kdb ex^_c qlh[u ihlhf \_jgm\ d `bagb
bkihevah\Zlv bo dZd jZ[h\ gZ ieZglZpbyo kZoZjgh]h ljhklgbdZ KljZo i_j_^
ij_\jZs_gb_f \ ³ahf[b´ gZklhevdh \_ebd qlh ihohjhgguc jblmZe gZ =Zblb \dexqZ_l
jy^ ^_ckl\bc p_ev dhlhjuo ² ihf_rZlv ihoblblv mf_jr_]h qlh[u \_jgmlv _]h d
`bagb
DZd m`_ ]h\hjbehkv ijZdlbdZ ³ahf[b´ [ueZ aZ\_a_gZ gZ =Zblb g_]jZfb
\uoh^pZfb ba ;_gbgZ Km^y ih \k_fm dZdb_lh ijb_fu \ha[m`^_gby d `bagb
ijh^he`Zxl ijZdlbdh\Zlvky \ ;_gbg_ b ih k_c ^_gv H[ wlhf jZkkdZau\Z_l
Zf_jbdZgkdbc \jZqiml_r_kl\_ggbd dhlhjhfm kemqbehkv ih[u\Zlv gZ h^ghf ba lZdbo
³k_Zgkh\´³GZa_fe_²ibr_lhg²e_`Zeq_eh\_dg_ih^Z\Z\rbcgbdZdboijbagZdh\
`bagbY k_elZdqlh[uaZkehgblv_]hk\hbfl_ehf[ukljuf^\b`_gb_fijbih^gye_fm
\_db qlh[u ijh\_jblv ajZqdh\mx j_Zdpbx J_Zdpbb g_ [ueh g_ [ueh b ijbagZdh\
[b_gby k_j^pZ Q_eh\_d [ue ^_ckl\bl_evgh f_jl\ Kh[jZ\rb_ky ih^ jmdh\h^kl\hf
`j_pZaZi_ebjblfbqgmxi_kgxWlh[uehg_qlhkj_^g__f_`^m\h_fb juqZgb_fHgb
i_eb\k_[uklj__b ]jhfq_DZaZehkva\mdbwlbmkeurblb f_jl\ucDZdh\h`_[uehfh_
m^b\e_gb_dh]^Zbf_gghlZdb kemqbehkv
³F_jl\uc´g_h`b^Zgghijh\_ejmdhcih]jm^bb ihiulZekyih\_jgmlvkydjbdb
hdjm`Z\rbo_]hex^_ckebebkv\ kiehrghc\hiev;ZjZ[ZgugZqZeb[blv_s_yjhklg__
GZdhg_pe_`Zsbcih\_jgmekyih^`Zeih^k_[ygh]bb f_^e_ggh\klZegZq_l\_j_gvdb
_]h]eZaZdhlhju_g_kdhevdhfbgmlgZaZ^g_j_Z]bjh\ZebgZk\_ll_i_jv[uebrbjhdh
jZkdjulub kfhlj_ebgZgZk´
G_ bkdexq_gh qlh hq_\b^_p hibku\Z_l a^_kv g_qlh ihoh`__ gZ jblmZe
]Zblygkdbo³ahf[b´
JblmZe ³ahf[b´ kljZgguf h[jZahf i_j_debdZ_lky k fZ]bq_kdhc ijZdlbdhc b ih
k_c ^_gv [ulmxs_c m Z[hjb]_gh\ :\kljZebb Ih bo jZkkdZaZf aZibkZgguf
wlgh]jZnZfb q_eh\_dZ aZjZg__ gZf_q_ggh]h \ dZq_kl\_ `_jl\u ihobsZ_l dhe^mg b
iheh`b\ gZ e_\uc [hd \hgaZ_l _fm \ k_j^p_ aZhklj_ggmx dhklv beb iZehqdm Dh]^Z
k_j^p_ hklZgZ\eb\Z_lky wlh agZqbl ² ^mrZ ihdbgmeZ l_eh Ihke_ wlh]h ihkj_^kl\hf
jZaebqguo fZgbimeypbc dhe^mg \ha\jZsZ_l _]h d `bagb ijbdZaZ\ aZ[ulv h lhf qlh
ijhbahreh k gbf Gh ijb wlhf _fm \gmrZ_lky qlh q_j_a ljb ^gy hg mfj_l LZdhc
q_eh\_d \ha\jZsZ_lky ^hfhc ^_ckl\bl_evgh g_ ^h]Z^u\Zykv h lhf qlh k gbf [ueh
ijh^_eZgh<g_rg_hggbq_fg_hlebqZ_lkyhl^jm]boex^_cghwlhg_q_eh\_dZ lhevdh
oh^yq__l_eh
?s_ [he__ ihjZabl_evgu_ ijbf_ju ijb\h^ylky \ dgb]_ bklhjbdZ b ibkZl_ey
:e_dkZg^jZ =hj[h\kdh]h ³< djm]_ \_qgh]h \ha\jZs_gby´ gZ hlju\db ba dhlhjhc
him[ebdh\Zggu_ \ `mjgZe_ ³GZmdZ b `bagv´ fu m`_ kkueZebkv : =hj[h\kdbc
ijb\h^bl jZkkdZa kh\_lkdh]h bkke_^h\Zl_ey dhlhjuc ijh\_e jy^ e_l \ Bg^bb \ lhf
qbke_ kj_^b ie_f_g b \ f_klZo kdju\Z_fuo hl \a]ey^Z klhjhgg_]h gZ[ex^Zl_ey <
h^ghf ba lb[_lkdbo fhgZkluj_c _fm ^h\_ehkv gZ[ex^Zlv kh\_jr_gb_ h[jy^Z ³jeZg]Z´
p_ev dhlhjh]h ² ihfhqv ^mr_ \ ihkf_jlghf __ khklhygbb Ijb [hevrhf kl_q_gbb
gZjh^Z`bl_e_c[eb`Zcrbo^_j_\_gvfhgZoh\jh^kl\_ggbdh\mf_jr_]h_]hijbghkyl
b deZ^ml gZ fhgZklujkdhf ^\hj_ I_j_^ gbf \ ³iha_ ehlhkZ´ jZkiheZ]Z_lky eZfZ <k_
kh\_jrZ_lky \ iheghc lbrbg_ Ijhoh^bl dZdh_lh \j_fy b mf_jrbc f_^e_ggh
ih^ufZ_lky =eZaZ _]h \k_ lZd `_ aZdjulu ebph hklZ_lky ebphf f_jl\h]h q_eh\_dZ
>\b]ZykvdZdZ\lhfZlhgljb`^uh[oh^blihdjm]mf_klh]^_e_`Zeeh`blkykgh\Zb
aZfbjZ_l]hlh\ucd ih]j_[_gbx
>ey gZ[ex^Zl_ey kh klhjhgu _\jhi_cpZ kZfuf im]Zxsbf [ueZ ihq_fmlh
g__kl_kl\_gghklvf_oZgbklbqghklv_]h^\b`_gbc ²wlh [ue dZd [u Z\lhfZl fZg_d_g
dmdeZdhlhjmxihgm^beb\^jm]b^lb
Kh[bjZyfZl_jbZe^eywlhcdgb]by gZlhedgmeky gZ ]Za_lgh_ bgl_j\vx k h^gbf
]bighlba_jhf dhlhjuc jZkkdZau\Ze qlh [eZ]h^Zjy jZajZ[hlZgghfm bf f_lh^m
\gmr_gby_fmm^Z_lkyaZklZ\eylv\klZ\Zlv b ^\b]Zlvky ljmiu g_^Z\gh mf_jrbo ex^_c
Dhjj_kihg^_gl [jZ\rbc bgl_j\vx [m^lh [u kZf y\eyeky k\b^_l_e_f wlbo hiulh\ B
ohly ^Zgguc fZl_jbZe dhk\_ggh hlghkbeky d bamqZ_fhc fghc l_f_ lZgZlheh]bb y
hl[jhkbe_]hdZdZ[khexlgh\a^hjgmx]Za_lgmxmldm<_kvhiulfh_c\jZq_[ghcjZ[hlu
ijhl_klh\Zeijhlb\lZdh]h\hibxs_]h³\jZgvy´Y [uem\_j_gb m\_j_g\ wlhf^hkbo
ihjqlhf_jl\ZyfZl_jbygbdZdg_fh`_lj_Z]bjh\ZlvgZ]bighlbq_kdh_\gmr_gb_L_f
g_ f_g__ nZdlu ^Z`_ dZaZehkv [u ijhlb\hj_qZsb_ a^jZ\hfm kfukem ^he`gu [ulv
lsZl_evghijh\_j_gub ijhZgZebabjh\Zgu
<hafh`gh ijb_f djZldh\j_f_ggh]h ³h`b\e_gby´ ljmih\ \ lb[_lkdbo
fhgZklujyo^Zb kh\_lkdbf]bighlba_jhfqvbdhhj^bgZluy klhevihki_rgh\u[jhkbe
hkgh\ZgugZm\_j_gghklbqlh^Z`_ijbhlkmlkl\bb`bag_gguonmgdpbcl_eZdZdb_lh
mjh\gbkhagZgbydZdh_lhgZqZeh\ q_eh\_d_ijh^he`Zxl\hkijbgbfZlvhdjm`Zxs__
?s_ \ k_j_^bg_ ;,; \_dZ Zf_jbdZgkdbf ibkZl_e_f W^]Zjhf Ih [ue gZibkZg
jZkkdZagZwlml_fmhaZ]eZ\e_gguc³IjZ\^Zh lhfqlhkemqbehkvk fhkv_<Zev^_fZjhf´
< jZkkdZa_ ih\_kl\m_lky h lhf dZd [eZ]h^Zjy fh^ghc lh]^Z f_kf_jbaZpbb ijhh[jZam
kh\j_f_ggh]h ]bighaZ m^Z\Zehkv ^he]h_ \j_fy ih^^_j`b\Zlv ]bighlbq_kdmx k\yav k
l_ehfmf_jr_]hq_eh\_dZ
Bkke_^h\Zgbyfbihke_^gboe_lmklZgh\e_ghqlhkf_jlvgZklmiZ_lg_kjZamWlh
ihkl_i_ggZy^ebl_evgZyw\hexpbyhj]ZgbafZk ba\_klghc\_jhylghklvxh[jZlbfhklb²
hkh[ucjh^kms_kl\h\ZgbyLjmig_bf__l[bhiheyghwlhlh`_g_ijbagZdlZddZd_]h
fh`_l ihl_jylv b `b\hc q_eh\_d b g_dhlhjh_ \j_fy `blv [_a g_]h Ljmi khojZgy_l
hij_^_e_ggmx we_dljbq_kdmx Zdlb\ghklv ih g_dhlhjuf ^Zgguf ^h ]h ^gy dh]^Z
j_]bkljbjm_lkyihke_^gbcagZqbl_evgucfha]h\hcbfimevk
>hdlhj wdhghfbq_kdbo gZmd nbabd ih h[jZah\Zgbx ;hjbk BkdZdh\ kha^Ze
kf_emx]bihl_amKmlv__ \ke_^mxs_f< kh\j_f_gghcgZmd_gZdZieb\Z_lky\k_[hevr_
^hdZaZl_evkl\ kms_kl\h\Zgby \ ijbjh^_ lZdh]h n_ghf_gZ dZd fbjh\hc e_ilhgguc ]Za
FE= ijhgbau\Zxsbc \k_ l_eZ \k_e_gghc Hg wlhl FE= khklhbl ba k\_joe_]dbo
fbdjhqZklbp k fZkkhc hl ^h ]jZffh\ < gZmqghc ebl_jZlmj_ hibkZgh fgh]h
^_kyldh\ jZagh\b^ghkl_c lZdbo qZklbp ² wlh we_dljhgu ihabljhgu fxhgu l_hgu
g_cljbghK_cqZk`_ba\_klgufgh]b_jZagh\b^ghklbqZklbpbf_xsbo_s_f_gvrmx
fZkkm
?keb]h\hjblvdjZcg_mijhs_gghe_ilhgu²wlhghkbl_ebq_eh\_q_kdbofuke_c
b qm\kl\bgnhjfZpbbh ij_^f_lZob y\e_gbyofZl_jbZevgh]hfbjZ< FE=kh^_j`Zlky
k\_^_gby h[h \k_f qlh [ueh _klv b [m^_l \h <k_e_gghc Bf_ggh \aZbfh^_ckl\b_f
fbjh\h]h e_ilhggh]h ]ZaZ k ij_^f_lhf fZl_jbZevgh]h fbjZ b q_eh\_q_kdbf fha]hf
fh`gh h[tykgblv fgh]b_ y\e_gby dhlhju_ ^h kbo ihj kqblZxlky lZbgkl\_ggufb Wlh
l_e_iZlbyykgh\b^_gb_b lZd^Ze__
GZih\_joghklbdh`bq_eh\_dZ_klvg_kdhevdhkhl[bheh]bq_kdbZdlb\guolhq_d
² bo baemq_gby kha^Zxl kmffZjgu_ d\Zglh\u_ h[hehqdb q_eh\_q_kdh]h l_eZ
jZkiheh`_ggu_h^gZ\gmljb^jm]hcihijbgpbimfZlj_rdbKh[kl\_ggh_l_eh²wlhg_
\_kv q_eh\_d Z lhevdh _]h \b^bfh_ y^jh \hdjm] dhlhjh]h jZkiheh`_gu _]h
bgnhjfZpbhgghwg_j]_lbq_kdb_³^\hcgbdb´Bamq_gb_d\Zglh\uoh[hehq_dfh`_l[ulv
k\yaZgh k gbadhwg_j]_lbq_kdbfb j_Zdpbyfb ³oheh^gh]h [_lZjZkiZ^Z´ lbiZ N_jfb
ijhbkoh^ysbfb\ g_j\guode_ldZo
Hiulu bkke_^h\Zl_e_c ² dZg^b^ZlZ nbabdhfZl_fZlbq_kdbo gZmd :gZlheby
HoZljbgZb dZg^b^ZlZ]_heh]hfbg_jZeh]bq_kdbogZmdGbdheZyKhq_\Zgh\Z²ihdZaZeb
ijb jZajmr_gbb ³y^jZ´ gZqbgZxl jZkkZku\Zlvky d\Zglh\u_ h[hehqdb ?keb hgb g_
ihemqZxl bgnhjfZpbhgghwg_j]_lbq_kdhc ih^ibldb lh i_jbh^ bo ihemjZkiZ^Z [m^_l
jZ\_g ijbf_jgh ^_\ylb ^gyf Z ihegh]h jZkiZ^Z ² khjhdZ kmldZf Wlh hlghkblky b d
`b\ufkms_kl\Zfb dg_h^mr_\e_ggufij_^f_lZf
Bgl_j_kgh qlh gZa\Zggu_ kjhdb kh\iZ^Zxl kh \j_f_g_f ihfbghd ih mkhirbf
M^j_\gbojmkh\kqblZehkvqlh^mrZr_klv^g_c³oh^bl´hdhehk\h_]h^hfZ_s_ljb^gy
² ih iheyf b h]hjh^Zf \hae_ jh^gh]h k_eZ Ihwlhfm hgb kijZ\eyeb ke_^mxsb_
ihfbgZevgu_h[jy^ugZlj_lbc^_gv²ih]j_[_gb_gZr_klhc²ijhsZgb_k ^hfhfgZ
^_\yluc²ijhsZgb_k k_e_gb_fgZkhjhdh\hc²ijhsZgb_k A_fe_cEx[hiulghqlh
\ [m^^baf_lZd`_nb]mjbjmxlkhjhd^g_c\ l_q_gb_dhlhjuo^mrZbs_lgh\h_l_eh^ey
i_j_\hiehs_gby < l_q_gb_ wlbo khjhdZ ^g_c eZfZ ^he`_g [ue qblZlv mf_jr_fm
gZklZ\e_gbyijbq_f]jhfdh\gylghb [_ahrb[hd<h\j_fyql_gbyg_evay[uehieZdZlv
b ijbqblZlvihkdhevdmwlhkqblZehkv\j_^gh^eymf_jr_]h
< khhl\_lkl\bb k l_hjb_c ; BkdZdh\Z fh`gh ij_^iheh`blv qlh k_gkblb\u
^j_\ghklbfh]ebgZ[ex^Zlvd\Zglh\u_h[hehqdbmf_jrboex^_cb \b^_lvdjblbq_kdb_
fhf_glu dh]^Z wlb mf_jrb_ gm`^Zebkv \ ih^ibld_ fukeyfb b qm\kl\Zfb
jh^kl\_ggbdh\b ^jma_c
Ijb ^Zevg_cr_c jZajZ[hld_ wlhc l_hjbb ih`Zemc fh`gh [ueh [u gZclb
h[tykg_gbyb lZbgkl\_ggufy\e_gbyflb[_lkdbofhgZkluj_c
EBL?J:LMJ:
AZ]Z^db]Zblygkdbodhe^mgh\³GZmdZb j_eb]by´‹ :=hj[h\kdbc L_
dlh\_jgmebkv³GZmdZb `bagv´‹ =JZcl K\b^_l_evdhe^h\kl\ZF
Ih W^]Zj JZkkdZau F Om^ ebl_jZlmjZ ; BkdZdh\ F >ufh\ L_eh mfbjZ_l
khagZgb_hklZ_lky³Dhfkhfhe_pAZ[ZcdZevy´hdly[jy
=E:<:9,
Ih]j_[_ggu_aZ`b\h
³?klv l_fu ijhgbdgmlu_ \k_ihdhjyxsbf bgl_j_khf gh kebrdhf m`Zkgu_
qlh[u klZlv aZdhgguf ^hklhygb_f ebl_jZlmju´ Wlbfb keh\Zfb gZqbgZ_lky h^bg ba
kZfuo kljZrguo jZkkdZah\ Zf_jbdZgkdh]h ibkZl_ey W^]ZjZ :eeZgZ Ih ²
³AZ`b\h ih]j_[_ggu_´ ³Ih]j_[_gb_ aZ`b\h g_khfg_ggh qm^h\bsg__ \k_o m`Zkh\
dZdb_\uiZebgZ^hexkf_jlgh]hB a^jZ\hfukeysbcq_eh\_d_^\ZebklZg_lhljbpZlv
qlh wlh kemqZehkv qZklh hq_gv qZklh =jZgv hl^_eyxsZy @bagv hl Kf_jlb \ emqr_f
kemqZ_h[fZgqb\Zb g_hij_^_e_ggZDlhfh`_lkdZaZlv]^_dhgqZ_lkyh^ghb gZqbgZ_lky
^jm]h_"Ba\_klghqlh_klv[he_agbijb dhlhjuo bkq_aZxl \k_ y\gu_ ijbagZdb `bagb
gh kljh]h ]h\hjy hgb g_ bkq_aZxl kh\_jr_ggh b ebrv ij_ju\Zxlky <hagbdZ_l
\j_f_ggZyhklZgh\dZ\ jZ[hl_g_\_^hfh]hf_oZgbafZGZklmiZ_lkjhdb g_dh_g_ajbfh_
lZbgkl\_ggh_ gZqZeh \gh\v ijb\h^bl \ ^\b`_gb_ \her_[gu_ djueZ b fZ]bq_kdb_
dhe_kZ´
W^]Zj Ih ijb\h^bl g_kdhevdh ijbf_jh\ ih]j_[_gby aZ`b\h kemqb\rboky k _]h
kh\j_f_ggbdZfb b ihq_jigmlufb \_jhylgh ba ]Za_l ³H^bg lZdhc kemqZc \_kvfZ
ijbf_qZl_evguc b \_jhylgh _s_ g_ ba]eZ^b\rbcky ba iZfylb g_dhlhjuo qblZl_e_c
bf_e f_klh g_ klhev ^Z\gh \ khk_^g_f ]hjh^_ ;Zelbfhj_ b ijhba\_e gZ fgh]bo
ihljykZxs__ g_ba]eZ^bfh_ \i_qZle_gb_´ ² lZdh_ gZqZeh ijb^Z_l dZ`^hfm
jZkkdZaZgghfm wibah^m hsms_gb_ ^hklh\_jghklb LZd qlh `_ kemqbehkv \ ;Zelbfhj_"
³Kmijm]m h^gh]h ba\_klgh]h xjbklZ b qe_gZ dhg]j_kkZ ihklb]eZ \g_aZigZy b
g_h[tykgbfZy [he_agv i_j_^ dhlhjhc hdZaZehkv [_kkbevgh \k_ bkdmkkl\h f_^bdh\
Ihke_ ly`dbo kljZ^Zgbc gZklmibeZ kf_jlv beb khklhygb_ dhlhjh_ khqeb kf_jlvx
Gbdlh^Z`_g_ih^haj_\Ze^Zb g_bf_eijbqbgih^haj_\ZlvqlhhgZ\h\k_g_mf_jeZ
H[gZjm`bebkv \k_ h[uqgu_ ijbagZdb kf_jlb Ebph hkmgmehkv q_jlu _]h aZhkljbebkv
=m[uklZeb[_e__fjZfhjZ=eZaZihfmlg_ebGZklmibehhdhq_g_gb_K_j^p_g_[behkv
LZdhgZijhe_`ZeZljb^gyb aZwlh\j_fyl_ehk^_eZehkvl\_j^ufdZddZf_gv
?_ ihohjhgbeb \ k_f_cghf kde_i_ b ljb ]h^Z gbdlh g_ lj_\h`be fh]bevguc
ihdhc Ih ijhr_kl\bb g_dhlhjh]h \j_f_gb kde_i hldjueb qlh[u mklZgh\blv lZf
kZjdhnZ]² gh m\u ² dZdh_ kljZrgh_ ihljyk_gb_ h`b^Zeh __ kmijm]Z dhlhjuc
k\hbfbjmdZfbhl\hjbe^\_jv?^\Zkl\hjdbjZkiZogmebkvgZjm`mqlhlhaZdmlZggh_\
[_eh_khklmdhfmiZehijyfh\ _]hh[tylbyLh[uekd_e_l_]h`_gu\ _s_g_bkle_\r_f
kZ\Zg_
LsZl_evgh_ jZkke_^h\Zgb_ ihdZaZeh qlh hgZ h`beZ q_j_a ^\Z ^gy ihke_
ih]j_[_gbyb [beZkv\ ]jh[mdhlhjucmiZegZihek\ha\ur_gbyb jZkdhehekylZdqlh
_c m^Zehkv \klZlv KemqZcgh aZ[uluc fZkeyguc nhgZjv gZebluc ^hihegZ l_i_jv
hdZaZekyimklGZ\_jog_cklmi_gbe_klgbpuijb\oh^_\ aeh\_smx]jh[gbpm\Zeyeky
[hevrhch[ehfhd]jh[ZdhlhjufhgZih\k_c\b^bfhklbdhehlbeZ\ `_e_agmx^\_jv
ijbau\Zy gZ ihfhsv Ijb wlhf hgZ \_jhylgh ebrbeZkv qm\kl\ beb mf_jeZ hl kljZoZ
iZ^ZyhgZaZp_ibeZkvkZ\ZghfaZdZdhclh`_e_agucdjxdlhjqZ\rbcbakl_gu LZd b
hklZeZkvhgZgZf_kl_lZdb bkle_eZklhy´
H dZdhc`_lZbgkl\_gghc[he_agbibr_lW^]ZjIh"Fh`_l[ulv\k_wlh²ieh^
fjZqghcnZglZabbibkZl_ey"D kh`Ze_gbxg_l;he_agvwlZohjhrhba\_klgZf_^bdZfb
ihemqbeZgZa\Zgb_³e_lZj]by´GZau\Zeb__ lZd`_bkl_jbq_kdbckhge_lZj]bq_kdbckhg
³fZeZy `bagv´ fgbfZy kf_jlv B I IZ\eh\ gZ[ex^Ze [hevgh]h < DZqZedbgZ
gZoh^b\r_]hky \ khklhygbb e_lZj]bq_kdh]h kgZ \ l_q_gb_ o e_l Hg aZkgme \ dhgp_
;,; \_dZ b ijhkiZe ^h ]h^Z <k_ wlh \j_fy hg gZoh^beky \ ikbobZljbq_kdhc
e_q_[gbp_
Ghj\_`dZ Ebg]]Zj^ aZkgmeZ \ ]h^m b ijhkiZeZ ^h ]h^Z <k_ klZjZgby
\jZq_cjZa[m^blv__ hdZau\Zebkvls_lgufb Dh]^Z `_ hgZ hldjueZ ]eZaZ m __ ihkl_eb
kb^_eb \ajhkeZy ^hqv b kh\k_f klZjuc fm` Z hgZ \u]ey^_eZ lZdhc `_ dZd b ]h^Z
gZaZ^ ?c dZaZehkv qlh ijhreZ ebrv h^gZ ghqv b hgZ lml `_ klZeZ ]h\hjblv h
\q_jZrgbo ^_eZo h lhf qlh gm`gh kdhj__ ihdhjfblv fZeurdm Gh m`_ q_j_a ]h^ hgZ
ihklZj_eZgZ\k_^\Z^_kyldZe_l
< h^ghc ba p_jd\_c IZe_jfh BlZeby ihdhblky l_eh JhaZebb EZf[Zj^h
fZe_gvdhc ^_\hqdb mf_jr_c ]h^Z gZaZ^ Khh[s_gby h kljZgguo kh[ulbyo \ wlhc
p_jd\b[m^hjZ`Zlh[s_kl\_gghklv\hlm`_hdhehe_lM[hjsbdbhldZaZebkvjZ[hlZlv
\ ihdhcgbpdhc ihke_ lh]h dZd ]eZaZ JhaZebb h^gZ`^u gZ f]gh\_gb_ hldjuebkv
F_klgu_ `bl_eb gZklZb\Zxl gZ lhf qlh \b^_eb g_h^ghdjZlgh dZd \_db ^_\hqdb
^jh`ZebZ fgh]b_keurZebdZd^_\hqdZ\a^uoZeZ
Ohlyk f_^bpbgkdhclhqdbaj_gby^_\hqdZkqblZeZkvf_jl\hc\ ]h^mmq_gu_
\ l_q_gb_ ^\mo g_^_ev ijh \h^beb djm]ehkmlhqgh_ gZ[ex^_gb_ aZ __ l_ehf k
ihklhygguf baf_j_gb_f we_dljbq_kdhc Zdlb\ghklb ]heh\gh]h fha]Z Dh]^Z hgb
aZnbdkbjh\Zebi_j\mx\kiurdmfha]h\hcZdlb\ghklb^eb\rmxkyk_dmg^uwlhklZeh
k_gkZpb_c\k_[uebihjZ`_gu<hegunbdkbjh\Z\rb_khklhygb_fha]Z[uebkeZ[ufb
ghykgufb<lhjZy\kiurdZ[ueZgZfgh]hdhjhq_b [ueZ\uy\e_gZq_j_aljh_kmlhd<
gZklhys__ \j_fy gZ[ex^_gby ijh^he`Zxlky <_jhylg__ \k_]h \ ^Zgghf kemqZ_ lZd`_
bf_ehf_klhdjZcg_j_^dh_ijhy\e_gb_]em[hdh]he_lZj]bq_kdh]hkgZ
;hevrZyf_^bpbgkdZywgpbdehi_^by_ ba^Zgb_]h^hij_^_ey_le_lZj]bx
dZd ³khklhygb_ iZlheh]bq_kdh]h kgZ k [he__ beb f_g__ \ujZ`_gguf hkeZ[e_gb_f
nbabq_kdboijhy\e_gbc`bagbk h[_a^\b`_gghklvxagZqbl_evgufihgb`_gb_fh[f_gZ
b hkeZ[e_gb_f beb hlkmlkl\b_f j_Zdpbb gZ a\mdh\u_ lZdlbevgu_ ijbdhkgh\_gb_ b
[he_\u_jZa^jZ`_gbyIjbqbgu\hagbdgh\_gbye_lZj]bblhqghg_mklZgh\e_gu´
;he_agv kms_kl\m_l Z ijbqbgu __ ihdZ g_ ba\_klgu Kh \j_f_g W^]ZjZ Ih
f_^bpbgZ ]Zd b g_ kfh]eZ mklZgh\blv ³ijbqbgu \j_f_gghc hklZgh\db \ jZ[hl_
g_\_^hfh]hf_oZgbafZ´
Ba\_klgu b kemqZb dh]^Z e_lZj]bq_kdbc khg \hagbdZe i_jbh^bq_kdb H^bg
Zg]ebckdbck\ys_ggbdkiZer_klv^g_c\ g_^_exghdZ`^h_\hkdj_k_gv_\klZ\Zeqlh[u
ih_klvb hlkem`blvfhe_[_g
H[uqgh \ e_]dbo kemqZyo e_lZj]bb gZ[ex^Zxlky g_ih^\b`ghklv jZkkeZ[e_gb_
furp jh\gh_ ^uoZgb_ Gh \ ly`_euo kemqZyo j_^dh \klj_qZxsboky bf__lky
^_ckl\bl_evghdZjlbgZfgbfhckf_jlbdh`Zoheh^gZyb [e_^gZyajZqdbg_j_Z]bjmxl
^uoZgb_ b imevk ljm^gh h[gZjm`blv kbevgu_ [he_\u_ jZa^jZ`_gby g_ \uau\Zxl
j_Zdpbbj_ne_dkuhlkmlkl\mxl< l_q_gb_g_kdhevdbokmlhd[hevgu_g_ivxlg__^yl
\u^_e_gb_fhqbb dZeZij_djZsZ_lky
A^_kv ihfbfh qbklh debgbq_kdh]h agZq_gby \hijhk e_lZj]bb ijbh[j_lZ_l b
km^_[ghf_^bpbgkdbc bgl_j_k Ijb\_^_f \uibkdm ba ]h ba^Zgby ;hevrhc
f_^bpbgkdhc wgpbdehi_^bb , ]h^ ³Ohly ijZ\beZ ij_^mkfZljb\Zxl ijhba\h^kl\h
\kdjulby ljmiZ q_j_a \hafh`gh dhjhldh_ \j_fy gh kqblZxl wlh \hafh`guf g_ jZg__
q_f q_j_a qZkh\ ihke_ kf_jlb <kdjulb_ ljmiZ debgbq_kdbfb b [hevgbqgufb
mqj_`^_gbyfb \ gZmqguo b gZmqghijZdlbq_kdbo p_eyo ^himkdZ_lky ^h bkl_q_gby qZkh\ghg_jZg__ihemqZkZihke_kf_jlb\ ijbkmlkl\bbg_f_g__lj_o\jZq_cdhlhju_
g_ihkj_^kl\_gghi_j_^\kdjulb_fkhklZ\eyxlijhlhdheh ijbqbgZojZgg_]h\kdjulbyb
^hdZaZl_evkl\Zo^_ckl\bl_evghckf_jlb
<hijhkh ydh[ukms_kl\mxs_chiZkghklbih]j_[_gbyaZ`b\hebpgZoh^ysboky
\ khklhygbb e_lZj]bb \ gZklhys__ \j_fy ihl_jye k\h_ agZq_gb_ < ebl_jZlmj_
ij_^r_kl\mxsbo klhe_lbc wlhl \hijhk bf_e hljZ`_gb_ gh im[ebdh\Z\rb_ky
khh[s_gbyg_h[eZ^Zxl^hklh\_jghklvx´
Bf_ggh lZd ² ³g_ h[eZ^Zxl ^hklh\_jghklvx´ Ih ijbgpbim ² wlh]h g_ fh]eh
[ulv ihlhfm qlh g_ fh]eh [ulv gbdh]^Z _ ba^Zgb_ ;hevrhc f_^bpbgkdhc
wgpbdehi_^bb g_ klhev dZl_]hjbqgh \ k\hbo \u\h^Zo hgh ijhklh himkdZ_l \hijhk h
k\b^_l_evkl\Zo klZjuo Z\lhjh\ Fu qblZ_f ³<hijhk h[ hiZkghklb ih]j_[_gby aZ`b\h
ebp gZoh^ysboky \ khklhygbb e_lZj]bb mljZlbe k\h_ agZq_gb_ lZd dZd ih]j_[_gb_
h[uqgh ijhba\h^blky q_j_a ² kmlhd ihke_ kf_jlb dh]^Z ^hklh\_jgu_ ljmigu_
y\e_gby[u\Zxlm`_ohjhrh\ujZ`_gu´
Gh dZd `_ [ulv k fgh]hqbke_ggufb k\b^_l_evkl\Zfb ijhreuo \_dh\"
Iheghklvx ijbagZlv bo \u^mfdZfb b ieh^hf nZglZabb" < k\h_f jZkkdZa_ ³AZ`b\h
ih]j_[_ggu_´ W^]Zj Ih ihfbfh m`_ jZah[jZggh]h gZfb ijbf_jZ ijb\h^bl _s_ ljb
wibah^Z ih]j_[_gby `b\uo ebp k\b^_l_evkl\h ba E_cipb]kdh]h ³Objmj]bq_kdh]h
`mjgZeZ´ h ij_`^_\j_f_gghf aZohjhg_gbb Zjlbee_jbckdh]h hnbp_jZ ihl_jy\r_]h
khagZgb_ hl mrb[Z ]heh\u kemqZc ih]j_[_gby aZ`b\h \ ]h^m \h NjZgpbb g_dhc
fZ^_fmZa_ev<bdlhjbguEZnmjdZ^\ujulhcbafh]beub kiZk_gghc__ \haex[e_gguf
b gZdhg_p ihjZabl_evguc kemqZc \ha\jZs_gby d `bagb \ ]h^m fheh^h]h
ehg^hgkdh]hkljyiq_]h^\Z^gyijhe_`Z\r_]h\ fh]be_?]h³ljmi´[uelZcgh\udhiZg
ghqvx\jZqZfb^eyijhba\h^kl\ZZgZlhfbq_kdh]h\kdjulbyb hiulh\k ]Zev\Zgbq_kdhc
[ZlZj__cb dZdh\u`_[uebbom^b\e_gb_b bkim]dh]^Z³f_jl\_p´khkdhevagmekhklheZ
gZiheihklhyeg_fgh]hlj_\h`ghhabjZykvb aZ]h\hjbe´
Gh \k_ wlh \k_lZdb fh`gh hlg_klb d ebl_jZlmjguf \ufukeZf \_ebdh]h
Zf_jbdZgkdh]hibkZl_eyH[jZlbfky`_d [he__^hklh\_jgufk\b^_l_evkl\Zf
< ]h^m Bh]Zgg =_hj] >Z\b^ ?eeba_g ^hdlhj f_^bpbgu dhee_`kdbc
kh\_lgbd ^_ckl\bl_evguc qe_g =hkm^Zjkl\_gghc f_^bpbgkdhc dhee_]bb \uimklbe \
KZgdlI_l_j[mj]_ dgb]m haZ]eZ\e_ggmx ³<jZq_[gu_ ba\_klby h ij_`^_\j_f_gghf
ih]j_[_gbb f_jl\uo´ >hdlhj ?eeba_g [ue \_kvfZ Z\lhjbl_lguf mq_guf k\h_]h
\j_f_gbihq_lgufqe_ghfBfi_jZlhjkdh]h\hevgh]hwdhghfbq_kdh]hh[s_kl\ZZ lZd`_
=_jph]kdh]h G_f_pdh]h B_gkdh]h Fbg_jZeh]bq_kdh]h b G_f_pdh]h h[s_kl\Z
bkiulZl_e_cijbjh^u?]hhlebqZebbkdexqbl_evgZykdjmime_aghklvb i_^Zglbqghklv\
ih^[hjd_ b bgl_jij_lZpbb nZdlh\ h q_f k\b^_l_evkl\mxl ^\_ ^jm]b_ _]h jZ[hlu
\ur_^rb_ \ Jhkkbb ³DjZldh_ gZklZ\e_gb_ h kdhlkdbo iZ^_`Zo b dZdbf h[jZahf \h
\j_fy hguo ihklmiZlv gZ^e_`bl k hibkZgb_f hldju\rboky gug_ kdhlkdbo [he_ag_c \
Nbgeyg^bbWkleyg^bbb Ebneyg^bb´]h^b ³DjZldbchl\_lgZfgh]b_bamklgu_b
ibkvf_ggu_\hijhkudZkZl_evgh:g^j_Zihevkdbofbg_jZevguo\h^´]h^
BlZd hldjh_f dgb]m ?eeba_gZ I_j\Zy ]eZ\Z wlhc dgb]b gZau\Z_lky ³H
\hafh`ghklb ij_`^_\j_f_ggh]h ih]j_[_gby ^hdZaZgghc ^_ckl\bl_evgufb hiulZfb´
³Fgh]b_ kh`Ze_gby ^hklhcgu_ ijbf_ju ^hdZau\Zxl qlh k_c m`Zkguc `j_[bc
ij_`^_\j_f_ggh]hih]j_[_gby^_ckl\bl_evghijbdexqZekyfgh]bfex^yfZ hlkx^Zg_
[_a hkgh\Zgby aZdexqZlv fh`gh qlh lZdh\uo ieZq_\guo kemqZ_\ ]hjZa^h [he__ fh]eh
ijbdexqblvky g_`_eb kdhevdh ij_^Zgh ba\_klbx´ =hjZa^h [he__ g_`_eb ij_^Zgh
ba\_klbx: kdhevdh`_\k_lZdb"
?eeba_g kkueZ_lky gZ ba^Zgguc \ ]h^m \ =_llbg]_g_ ljm^ ]^_ qblZl_eyf
ij_^eh`_g jblhjbq_kdbc \hijhk ³G_ ih]j_[Zxl eb b \ kZfuo [eZ]hmkljh_gguo
h[s_kl\Zo lj_lv_c qZklb ex^_c ij_`^_ g_`_eb ihke_^m_l ^_ckl\bl_evgZy kf_jlv"´ B
lml`_^h[Z\ey_l³M`Zkgh_ghijb\k_flhf\_kvfZ\_jhylgh_fg_gb_´
Kimkly ihe\_dZ ZgZeh]bqgu_ \a]ey^u \ukdZau\Z_l W^]Zj Ih ³g_ hklZ_lky
khfg_gbc qlh ex^_c \ kZfhf ^_e_ ohjhgyl aZ`b\h B _keb mq_klv dZd j_^dh \ kbem
k\h_]h oZjZdl_jZ lZdb_ kemqZb klZgh\ylky gZf ba\_klgu fu \ugm`^_gu [m^_f
ijbagZlvqlhhgb\_jhylghqZklhijhbkoh^ylg_\_^hfh^eygZkIjZ\h`__^\Zebg_
\kydbc jZa dZd a_fe_dhiZf kemqZ_lky jZ[hlZlv gZ deZ^[bs_ kd_e_lu h[gZjm`b\Zxl \
lZdboihaZoqlh\hagbdZxlkZfu_m`Zkgu_ih^haj_gby´
< gZqZe_ gug_rg_]h \_dZ Z\lhjbl_lgZy dhfbkkby Zg]ebckdbo \jZq_c gZ hkgh\_
ijh\_^_gguobfbbkke_^h\ZgbcijbreZd \u\h^mqlhlhevdh\ :g]ebb_`_]h^ghaZ`b\h
ih]j_[Z_lky^h^\mok iheh\bghclukyqex^_cDh]^Z\ dhgp_o ]h^h\\ :g]ebb[ue
kha^Zg i_j\uc ZiiZjZl iha\heyxsbc meh\blv \_kvfZ g_agZqbl_evgmx we_dljbq_kdhx
Zdlb\ghklv k_j^pZ ihqlb ijb i_j\hf `_ bkiulZgbb \ fhj]_ kj_^b ljmih\ [ueZ
\uy\e_gZ`b\Zy^_\mrdZ
B \ lh `_ \j_fy \ ³;hevrhc f_^bpbgkdhc wgpbdehi_^bb´ mdZaZgh ³<hijhk h[
hiZkghklb ih]j_[_gby aZ`b\h ebp gZoh^ysboky \ khklhygbb e_lZj]bb mljZlbe k\h_
agZq_gb_´=^_`_bklbgZ"
Ij_`^_ \k_]h hklZgh\bfky gZ ijbf_jZo ijb\_^_gguo \ nmg^Zf_glZevghf
ljZdlZl_ ?eeba_gZ Hg gZau\Z_l ke_^mxsb_ ijbqbgu hrb[hqgh]h ij_`^_\j_f_ggh]h
ih]j_[_gby qZohldZ bkl_jbq_kdb_ ijbiZ^db h[fhjhdb h[f_jl\_gb_ hl m]ZjZ
h[f_jl\_gb_hl\bgguoiZjh\\h\j_fy[jh`_gby\bgZ\ ih]j_[Zoihl_jykhagZgbyijb
agZqbl_evguo djh\hihl_jyo h[f_jl\_gb_ hl ^mr_\guo \hafms_gbc b bihohg^jbc hl
m^ZjZhlkm^hjh]hl]hjyq_dhlfhjh\hcya\ubgZdhg_phlkhgghc[he_agb³dhlhjhc
ijbf_juklhevh[udgh\_gguqlhhibku\Zxlky\hfgh]bo\jZq_[guogZ[ex^_gbyo´
< gZklhys__\j_fy[hevrbgkl\h ijb\_^_gguo^bZ]ghah\iheghklvxbkdexqZxl
\hafh`ghklv hrb[db b gZf dZ`_lky kljZgguf qlh \ ;9,,, \_d_ fh]eb hrb[hqgh
ohjhgblvex^_cgZoh^ysboky\ h[fhjhqghfkhklhygbbihke_djh\hl_q_gbydZdhceb[h
bgn_dpbhgghc [he_agb m]ZjZ b l ^ LZdb_ hrb[db fh`gh h[tykgblv lhevdh djZcg_
gbadbfmjh\g_fd\Zebnbpbjh\Zgghc\jZq_[ghcihfhsb\ wlhli_jbh^
Keh`g__ h[klhbl ^_eh k lZd gZau\Z_fhc ³khgghc [he_agvx´ G_khfg_ggh qlh
a^_kv ?eeba_g bf__l \ \b^m m`_ hibkZggmx gZfb e_lZj]bx b jy^ ^jm]bo aZ[he_\Zgbc
dhlhju_ fh]eb [u gZihfbgZlv e_lZj]bx Wlh iZjhdkbafu khgeb\hklb ijb wibe_ikbb
\_kvfZ g_j_^dh \klj_qZxsb_ky Wlh lZd`_ fh`_l [ulv \ujZ`_gguc dZlZlhgbq_kdbc
klmihj DZlZlhgbq_kdbc kbg^jhf ² wlh ikbobq_kdh_ jZkkljhckl\h k ij_h[eZ^Zgb_f
gZjmr_gbc \ ^\b]Zl_evghc kn_j_ \ujZ`Zxs__ky aZlhjfh`_gghklvx klmihjhf
Klmihj ijb wlhf g_j_^dh khijh\h`^Z_lky y\e_gbyfb \hkdh\hc ]b[dhklb ijb dhlhjhc
qZkl] l_eZ [hevgh]h ^ebl_evgh khojZgyxl ijb^Zggh_ bf iheh `_gb_ DZlZlhgbq_kdbc
kbg^jhf fh`_l jZa\b\Zlvky ij] jZaebqguo aZ[he_\Zgbyo ² rbahnj_gbb
jZaghh[jZaguoikbohaZohj]Zgbq_kdbob khkm^bkluoaZ[he_\Zgby"]heh\gh]hfha]ZG_
bkdexq_gh qlh ijb g_^hklZlhqghf mjh\g_ f_^bpbgkdbo agZgbc lZdb_ [hevgu_ fh]eb
ihiZ^Zlv\ qbkehaZ`b\hih]j_[_gguo
Kj_^b jZkkljhckl\ kgZ ba\_kl_g lZd gZau\Z_fu_ kbg^jhf De_cg_E_\bgZ
hlghkysbcky d ]bi_jkhfgbyf l _ aZ[he_\Zgbyf k\yaZgguf k iZlheh]bq_kdhc
qj_af_jghckhgeb\hklvxKbg^jhfDe_cg_E_\bgZijhy\ey_lkyijbklmiZfbg_h^hebfhc
khgeb\hklb ^ebl_evghklvx hl g_kdhevdbo qZkh\ ^h g_kdhevdbo kmlhd b gZ[ex^Z_lky
ihqlbbkdexqbl_evghm xghr_ckhq_lZykvk ikbohiZlheh]bq_kdbfbgZjmr_gbyfb
Hkh[uc bgl_j_k kj_^b aZ[he_\Zgbc gZihfbgZxsbo ih k\hbf ijhy\e_gbyf
e_lZj]bx ij_^klZ\ey_l wib^_fbq_kdbc e_lZj]bq_kdbc wgp_nZebl Wdhghfh Wlh
bgn_dpbhggZy [he_agv g_ykghc \_jhylg__ \k_]h \bjmkghc wlbheh]bb
oZjZdl_jbamxsZyky \ hkljhc klZ^bb ebohjZ^dhc b khgeb\hklvx I_j\u_ hibkZgby
[he_agbkoh^ghcihdebgbq_kdhcdZjlbg_k wib^_fbq_kdbfe_lZj]bq_kdbfwgp_nZeblhf
[ueb k^_eZgu \ ² ]h^Zo L Kb^_g]Zfhf khh[sb\r_f h kemqZyo ^ebl_evghc
khgeb\hklb b [j_^Z gZ nhg_ ih\lhjguo ih\ur_gbc l_fi_jZlmju < ihke_^mxs_f
hl^_evgu_ kemqZb b g_[hevrb_ \kiurdb aZ[he_\Zgbc ih^h[guo e_lZj]bq_kdhfm
wgp_nZeblm g_h^ghdjZlgh hibku\Zebkv ih^ jZaebqgufb gZa\Zgbyfb < ;9,, ;9,,, b
;,; \_dZo\ :g]ebbb =_jfZgbb [u\Zeb ^Z`_ wib^_fbb e_lZj]bq_kdh]h wgp_nZeblZ <
;; \_d_ i_j\u_ kemqZb aZ[he_\Zgby [ueb aZj_]bkljbjh\Zgu \h \j_fy i_j\hc fbjh\hc
\hcgu\ ]h^m\hnjZgpmakdhcZjfbbih^<_j^_ghfZ \²]h^Zo\kiurdb
[uebhlf_q_gugZ^jm]bomqZkldZonjZgpmakdh]hnjhglZb \jy^_kljZg?\jhiu< ]h^mba\_klgucZ\kljbckdbcg_\jhiZlheh]DhgklZglbgWdhghfhhibkZe^Zggmx[he_agv
dZd kZfhklhyl_evgh_ aZ[he_\Zgb_ < ihke_^mxsb_ ]h^u [he_agv rbjhdh
jZkijhkljZgbeZkv aZo\Zlb\ ihqlb \k_ kljZgu b dhglbg_glu Lhqguo ^Zgguo h
dhebq_kl\_ [he_\rbo \h \k_f fbj_ g_l gh fZdkbfmf aZ[he_\Z_fhklb ijboh^beky gZ
² ]h^u K ]h^Z ^ZggZy [he_agv klZeZ gZklhevdh j_^dZ qlh g_ m^Zehkv
bamqblvgb k_ijbqbgugb oh^jZa\blby
G_dhlhju_\jZqb^Z`_kqblZxlqlhe_lZj]bq_kdbcwgp_nZeblbkq_aiheghklvx
K\hb i_jbh^u ³jZkp\_lZ´ b bkq_agh\_gby [u\Zxl ^Z`_ m ikbobq_kdbo
aZ[he_\ZgbcGZijbf_jk_cqZkdjZcg_j_^dbkemqZbbkl_jbbZ \kj_^gb_\_dZhgZ[ueZ
hq_gv jZkijhkljZg_gZ Bgh]^Z bkl_jby ijbgbfZeZ ^Z`_ oZjZdl_j ³ikbobq_kdbo
wib^_fbc´dZdgZijbf_j³wib^_fbybkl_jbq_kdbolZgp_\´;,9\_dZ
Ijb bkl_jbb bgh]^Z \hagbdZ_l kbg^jhf i_jbh^bq_kdhc ik_\^h]bi_jkhfgbb
qj_af_jghc khgeb\hklb lZd gZau\Z_fZy ³bkl_jbq_kdZy kiyqdZ´ oZjZdl_jbamxsZyky
ih\lhjyxsbfbky kghih^h[gufb khklhygbyfb ^ebl_evghklvx hl g_kdhevdbo qZkh\ ^h
fgh]bo kmlhd h[uqgh \hagbdZxsbo \ k\yab k ikbohljZ\fbjmxsbfb kblmZpbyfb
Bkl_jby g_khfg_ggh \g_keZ [h]Zlmx e_ilm \ bklhjbx ih]j_[_gguo aZ`b\h G_fZeh
ih^h[guoijbf_jh\fh`ghijhq_klvb \dgb]_?eeba_gZ
BlZd ihagZdhfb\rbkv k [he_agyfb ijhy\e_gby dhlhjuo fh`gh [ueh [u
hrb[hqgh ijbgylv aZ khklhygb_ kf_jlb fu fh`_f k^_eZlv ke_^mxsb_ \u\h^u <h
i_j\uoke_^m_lkqblZlvg_khfg_ggufb nZdluagZqbl_evgh]hqbkeZih]j_[_gbc`b\uo
ex^_c \j_f_ggh \iZ^Z\rbo \ khklhygb_ ih^h[gh_ kf_jlb Wlhfm kihkh[kl\h\ZeZ
gbadZyf_^bpbgkdZydmevlmjZwihobkj_^g_\_dh\vyZ lZd`_qZklbqghb gh\h]h\j_f_gb
hlkmlkl\b_ ^he`gh]h dhebq_kl\Z \jZq_c dhlhju_ fh]eb [u hk\b^_l_evkl\h\Zlv
mf_jrbo <h\lhjuo \ kj_^gb_ \_dZ gZ[ex^Zehkv agZqbl_evgh [hevr__ dhebq_kl\h
bkl_jhb^guo [hevguo q_f \ gZklhys__ \j_fy Z lZd`_ \_jhylgh [hevguo e_lZj]b_c
wib^_fbq_kdbf e_lZj]bq_kdbf wgp_nZeblhf b jy^hf ^jm]bo aZ[he_\Zgbc ijhy\e_gby
dhlhjuoihjhcljm^gh[ueh^bnn_j_gpbjh\Zlvhlkhklhygbykf_jlb<lj_lvbo\_kvfZ
\_jhylgh kms_kl\h\Zgb_ bkq_agm\rbo g_ba\_klguo gZf l_i_jv [he_ag_c
khijh\h`^Z\rboky kbfilhfZfb \ujZ`_gghc e_lZj]bb LZd \ kj_^g_\_dh\uo ojhgbdZo
mihfbgZ_lkyaZ]Z^hqgZy[he_agvghkb\rZygZa\Zgb_³Zg]ebckdbcihl´
;he_agv hlebqZeZkv djZcg_ [ukljuf jZa\blb_f M kh\_jr_ggh a^hjh\uo ex^_c
\g_aZigh ihy\eyeZkv \ukhdZy l_fi_jZlmjZ bgh]^Z km^hjh]b ]heh\gZy [hev [hev \
kmklZ\Zok_j^p_[b_gb_g_ijbylguc\dmk\hjlmb hl\jZlbl_evgucaZiZobahjlZ<kdhj_
ihke_wlh]h\k_l_ehihdju\Zehkvh[bevgufihlhfk oZjZdl_jgufg_ijbylgufaZiZohf
;hevghc bkiulu\Ze khgeb\hklv b aZkgm\ g_j_^dh [hevr_ g_ ijhkuiZeky MfbjZeh ^h
b ^Z`_^hklZijhp_glh\aZ[he_\rbo<ky[he_agvaZgbfZeZhlg_kdhevdboqZkh\^h
g_kdhevdbo ^g_c ;he_eb ebrv ex^b kj_^g_]h \hajZklZ ^_lb b ih`beu_ ex^b g_
aZjZ`Zebkv
I_j\Zy wib^_fby wlhc [he_agb jZajZab\rZyky \ :g]ebb \ , ]h^m
ijh^he`ZeZkviylvg_^_evb \ua\ZeZh]jhfgu_ himklhr_gby Ke_^mxsZy \ ]h^m
ho\ZlbeZ ij_`^_ \k_]h Ehg^hg Lj_lvy wib^_fby \ ]h^m ijhl_dZeZ _s_ [he__
klj_fbl_evgh q_f i_j\u_ ^\_ HgZ jZkijhkljZgbeZkv gZ \kx :g]ebx fbgh\Z\
RhleZg^bxb BjeZg^bxb ^hreZ^hDZe_\hNjZgpbbQ_l\_jlZywib^_fby]h^
gZqZeZkv dZd b ij_^u^msZy \ Ehg^hg_ kgh\Z ho\ZlbeZ :g]ebx aZl_f ihy\beZkv \
=_jfZgbbIjmkkbbIhevr_Ebl\_b JhkkbbIhke_^gyywib^_fby³Zg]ebckdh]hihlZ´
jZajZabeZkv\ ]h^m[ueZkeZ[__ij_^u^msbob aZljhgmeZebrv:g]ebxK l_oihj
wlh aZ[he_\Zgb_ [hevr_ g_ ihy\eyehkv b k_cqZk fh`gh ebrv kljhblv ^h]Z^db h[ _]h
ijbjh^_
KlZlbklbdZ aZ`b\h ih]j_[_gguo g_ \_eZkv gbdh]^Z H[ bo dhebq_kl\_ fh`gh
km^blv lhevdh dhk\_ggh ih qbkem kemqZ_\ klZ\rbo ^hklhygb_f ]eZkghklb LZd \ m`_
mihfbgZ\r_cky dgb]_ Bh]ZggZ ?eeba_gZ ³<jZq_[gu_ ba\_klby h ij_`^_\j_f_gghf
ih]j_[_gbb f_jl\uo´ mihfbgZ_lky ^hdmf_glbjh\Zgguo kemqZ_\ ih]j_[_gby `b\uo
ebp g_ kqblZy ijbf_jh\ ba ^j_\gbo Z\lhjh\ ?eeba_g lZd`_ pblbjm_l ^jm]h]h
bkke_^h\Zl_ey ;9,,, \_dZ dhlhjuc ³ij_^klZ\ey_l ^hklh\_jg_crb_ ba\_klby h q_eh\_dZo dhlhju_ ih]j_[_gu [ueb `b\ufb h klZ k_fb^_kylb ^_\ylb dhb khql_gu
[ueb mf_jrbfb b ij_`^_ ih]j_[_gby ihemqbeb i_j\h[ulgh_ qm\kl\b_ h lj_o
ih]j_[_gguo`b\ufbb ijh]ehlb\rboqZklvihdju\ZeZh r_klgZ^pZlbbkpZjZiZ\rbob
ba]juarbok_[_\ ]jh[mjmdbb iZevpuh iyl_juojZa[b\rbok_[_]heh\ub ^jm]bodhb
\u^jZeb m k_[y \hehku b bkpZjZiZeb ebph b ]jm^v´ ³Kdhev \_ebdh fh`_l [ulv qbkeh
lZdh\uo g_kqZklguo ex^_c dhb ih^\_j`_gu [ueb jZ\ghc `_ mqZklb g_ hklZ\b\ k\_lm
gbdZdh]hk\_^_gby´²iZl_lbq_kdbaZdZgqb\Z_lwlmpblZlm?eeba_g
Y ^he]h_ \j_fy kh[bjZe \k_ bf_\rb_ky \ e_lhibkyo bklhjbq_kdbo ojhgbdZo
f_^bpbgkdbo dgb]Zo f_fmZjZo ij_^Zgbyo e_]_g^Zo nZdlu hlghkbl_evgh
e_lZj]bq_kdh]hkgZb aZ`b\hih]j_[_gguoIj_`^_\k_]hdZd\ <_lohf lZdb \Gh\hf
aZ\_l_ bf__lky h]jhfgh_ qbkeh ijbf_jh\ \hkdj_k_gby mf_jrbo dhlhju_ y\eyxlky \
[hevrbgkl\_ k\h_f gbq_f bguf dZd ijh[m`^_gb_f ex^_c ihke_ e_lZj]bq_kdh]h kgZ
beb j_ZgbfZpb_c ijb debgbq_kdhc kf_jlb LZd ijhjhd Beby gZoh^ykv \ KZj_il_
Kb^hgkdhc \hkdj_kbe mf_jr_]h kugZ \^h\u ³Lj_lvy dgb]Z PZjkl\´ =eZ\Z >jm]hc\_lohaZ\_lgucijhjhd?ebk_c\hkdj_kbekugZ[eZ]hq_klb\hcKhgZfblygdb³H
\hr_e?ebk_c\ ^hfb \hlj_[_ghdmf_jrbce_`blgZihkl_eb_]hB ih^gyekyb e_]
gZ^j_[_gdhfb ijbeh`bek\hbmklZd _]hmklZfb k\hb]eZaZd _]h]eZaZfb k\hbeZ^hgb
d _]h eZ^hgyf b ijhkl_jky gZ g_f b kh]j_ehkv l_eh j_[_gdZ B qbogme j_[_ghd jZa
k_fvb hldjuej_[_ghd]eZaZk\hb´³Q_l\_jlZydgb]ZPZjkl\´=eZ\Z>_ckl\by
ijhjhdZ?ebk_ya^_kvgZihfbgZxlhdZaZgb_i_j\hcf_^bpbgkdhcihfhsbgZoh^ysbfky
\ ]em[hdhfh[fhjhd_bebe_lZj]bb
?s_ [hevr_ wibah^h\ \hkdj_k_gby mf_jrbo \klj_qZ_lky \ Gh\hf AZ\_l_
<hkdj_k_gb_ mf_jrbo klZgh\blky h[yaZl_evguf Zljb[mlhf qm^_k BbkmkZ OjbklZ
³ke_iu_ ijhaj_\Zxl ojhfu_ oh^yl ijhdZ`_ggu_ hqbsZxlky ]emob_ keurZl
f_jl\u_\hkdj_kZxl gbsb_[eZ]h\_kl\mxl´?\Zg]_eb_hlEmdb=eZ\Z
< lj_o ?\Zg]_ebyo ba q_luj_o dZghgbq_kdbo hl FZln_y hl FZjdZ hl Emdb
jZkkdZau\Z_lkyh \hkdj_k_gbb^hq_jbBZbjZ³B dh]^Zijbr_eBbkmk\ ^hfgZqZevgbdZ
BZbjZ gZqZevgbdZ kbgZ]h]b ² K J b m\b^_e k\bj_evsbdh\ b gZjh^ \ kfyl_gbb
kdZaZebf³<uc^bl_\hgb[hg_mf_jeZ^_\bpZghkiblB kf_yebkvgZ^gbfDh]^Z`_
gZjh^[ue\ukeZghg\hc^y\aye__ aZjmdmb ^_\bpZ\klZeZB jZag_kkykemoh k_fih
\k_c a_fe_ lhc´ ?\Zg]_eb_ hl FZln_y =eZ\Z ² < Jmkkdhf fma__ gZoh^blky
[hevrh_ ihehlgh B ? J_ibgZ ³<hkdj_k_gb_ ^hq_jb BZbjZ´ D wlhfm kx`_lm
g_h^ghdjZlghh[jZsZebkvb ^jm]b_om^h`gbdb
< ?\Zg]_ebb hl Emdb jZkkdZau\Z_lky h \hkdj_r_gbb Bbkmkhf kugZ \^h\u ba
]hjh^Z GZbgZ ³Dh]^Z `_ Hg Bbkmk ² K J ijb[ebabeky d ]hjh^kdbf \hjhlZf lml
\ughkbeb mf_jr_]h _^bgkl\_ggh]h kugZ m fZl_jb Z hgZ [ueZ \^h\Z b fgh]h gZjh^Z
reh k g_x ba ]hjh^Z M\b^_\ __ =hkih^v k`Zebeky gZ^ g_x b kdZaZe _c g_ ieZqv B
ih^hc^yijbdhkgmekyd h^jmg_krb_hklZgh\bebkvb HgkdZaZeXghrZL_[_]h\hjx
\klZgv F_jl\uc ih^gy\rbkv k_e b klZe ]h\hjblv b hl^Ze _]h Bbkmk fZl_jb _]h´
?\Zg]_eb_hlEmdb=eZ\Z
< ³>_ygbb Zihklheh\´ ijb\h^blky wibah^ \hkdj_r_gby Zihklhehf I_ljhf \
]hjh^_Bhiibbk_cqZkwlh]hjh^YnnZfheh^hc^_\mrdb³< BhiibbgZoh^beZkvh^gZ
mq_gbpZbf_g_fLZ\bnZqlhagZqbl³k_jgZ´Kemqbehkv\ l_^gbqlhhgZaZg_fh]eZb
mf_jeZ ?_ hfueb b iheh`beb \ ]hjgbp_ : dZd Eb^^Z [ueZ [eba Bhiibb lh mq_gbdb
mkeurZ\ qlh I_lj gZoh^blky lZf ihkeZeb d g_fm ^\mo q_eh\_d ijhkblv qlh[u hg g_
aZf_^ebe ijbclb d gbf I_lj \ukeZe \k_o \hg b ij_dehgb\ dhe_gb ihfhebeky b
h[jZlb\rbkvd l_emkdZaZe
LZ\bnZ <klZgv B hgZ hldjueZ ]eZaZ k\hb b m\b^_\ I_ljZ k_eZ Hg ih^Z\ _c
jmdmih^gye__bijba\Z\k\yluob \^h\bpihklZ\be__ i_j_^gbfb`b\hx´³>_ygby
Zihklheh\´=eZ\Z
<k_ wibah^u \hkdj_k_gby mf_jrbo dZd \ <_lohf lZd b \ Gh\hf aZ\_l_ bf_xl
g_kdhevdh h[sbo q_jl bgl_j_kguo ^ey gZr_]h jZkkdZaZ <hi_j\uo \k_ fgbfh
mf_jrb_y\eyebkvfheh^ufbex^vfbLZd^hq_jbBZbjZkh]eZkghkhh[s_gbxEmdbb
FZjdZ [ueh e_l Lhqguc \hajZkl ^jm]bo g_ mdZau\Z_lky gh lZd dZd bo bf_gmxl
hljhd^_\bpZkug\^h\ulhihgylghqlhj_qvb^_lh ih^jhkldZoxghrZob ^_\mrdZo
AgZqbl kf_jlv bo g_ fh]eZ [ulv _kl_kl\_gghc <h\lhjuo g_ ]h\hjblky h dZdboeb[h
g_kqZklguokemqZyoljZ\fZojZgZowib^_fbq_kdbo[he_agyo<lj_lvbokZfbp_ebl_eb
jZkp_gb\Zxlbokhklhygb_g_dZdkf_jlvZ dZdkhg²³g_mf_jeZ^_\bpZghkibl´<
q_l\_jluo g_ mihfbgZ_lky gb h dZdbo ijbagZdZo le_gby g_l dhk\_gguo mdZaZgbc gZ
gZklmie_gb_ljmiguoy\e_gbc<iyluo\h\k_owibah^Zo;b[ebb\j_fyhlgZklmie_gby
kf_jlb ^h \hkdj_k_gby hq_gv g_agZqbl_evgh \ ij_^_eZo h^gh]h ^gy lZd dZd ih
bm^_ckdbf aZdhgZf ih]j_[_gb_ ^he`gh [ulv hkms_kl\e_gh \ ^_gv kf_jlb _keb lhevdh
wlhl^_gvg_[ueijZa^gbqguf<k_wlh^Z_lhkgh\Zgbyij_^iheh`blvqlhfu\ ^Zgghf
kemqZ_bf__f^j_\g_crb_k\b^_l_evkl\Zh e_lZj]bq_kdhfkg_
Ghbawlhch^ghlbighcihk\hbfijbagZdZfp_ibwibah^h\\hkdj_k_gbyf_jl\uo
\ <_lohf b Gh\hf aZ\_l_ \uiZ^Z_l h^bg gZb[he__ ba\_klguc gZb[he__ qZklh
hljZ`Z_fuc \ ijhba\_^_gbyo bkdmkkl\Z b ebl_jZlmju ² \hkdj_r_gb_ EZaZjy >Z`_
e_q_[gu_mqj_`^_gbygZau\Zxlbf_g_fEZaZjy²eZaZj_lu
³<h \k_c `bagb OjbklZ g_ [ueh [he__ \Z`gh]h kh[ulby q_f \hkdj_r_gb_
EZaZjy´²ibkZehjb]bgZevgucjmkkdbcfukebl_evGNN_^hjh\Q_f`_\hkdj_r_gb_
EZaZjy Ojbklhf hlebqZ_lky hl \hkdj_r_gby bf `_ ^hq_jb BZbjZ b kugZ \^h\u
gZbgkdhcIhq_fmwlhlwibah^klhblhkh[gydhf\ ijhq_fjy^mqm^_k"
>eygZqZeZgZihfgbf_\Zg]_evkdbckx`_lEZaZjv[ue[jZlhfFZjbbb FZjnu
\_jguoihke_^h\Zl_evgbpOjbklZBf_gghFZjbyk_kljZEZaZjy\ k\h_\j_fyihfZaZeZ
gh]bijbr_^r_]hd g_c\ ^hfBbkmkZfbjhfb \ul_jeZk\hbfb\hehkZfbDh]^ZEZaZjv
mf_jBbkmkZg_[ueh\ Bm^__hggZoh^bekyaZBhj^ZghfMkeurZ\h [he_agbEZaZjy
hgkjZam`_ihki_rbe\ <bnZgbxk_e_gb_]^_lhl`be\ klZ^byoijbf_jgh\ df
² K J hl B_jmkZebfZ Dh]^Z Bbkmk ijbr_e EZaZjv m`_ q_luj_ ^gy dZd [ue \
]jh[gbp_ < Bm^__ ]jh[gbpu ^_eZebkv \ i_s_jZo dhlhju_ aZ\Zeb\Zeb dZfg_f Bbkmk
ijbdZaZe hlh^\bgmlv dZf_gv hl \oh^Z gh FZjnZ hklZgh\beZ _]h ³=hkih^b M`_
kf_j^bl b[h q_luj_ ^gy dZd hg \h ]jh[_´ Gh dZf_gv \k_lZdb hlh^\bgmeb b Bbkmk
³\haa\Ze ]jhfdbf ]hehkhf EZaZjv B^b \hg B \ur_e mf_jrbc h[\bluc ih jmdZf b
gh]Zfih]j_[Zevgufbi_e_gZfbb ebph_]hh[\yaZgh[uehieZldhfBbkmk]h\hjblbf
jZa\y`bl__]himklvb^_l´?\Zg]_eb_hlBhZggZ=eZ\Z,,
Wlhl jZkkdZa h \hkdj_r_gbb \ hlebqb_ hl ij_^u^msbo fu gbdZd g_ fh`_f
k\yaZlv k y\e_gbyfb e_lZj]bb lZd dZd a^_kv g_^\mkfuke_ggh ]h\hjblky h ljmiguo
y\e_gbyo ³m`_ kf_j^bl´ qlh y\ey_lky ^hklh\_jguf ijbagZdhf ^_ckl\bl_evghc Z g_
fgbfhc kf_jlb D lhfm `_ k fhf_glZ gZklmie_gby kf_jlb ijhreh m`_ q_luj_ ^gy
ijhbahreb g_h[jZlbfu_ ijhp_kku @mjgZebkl ; >_^xobg \ klZlv_ ³K_j^pZ
khdjmr_ggu_´ ihk\ys_gghc hibkZgbx `bagb kh\j_f_gguo jmkkdbo fhgZkluj_c
ibr_l³?kebih\_jblv\ lhqlh\hkdj_r_gb_EZaZjy²nZdlbklhjbq_kdbclh\_^vwlh
fh`_liheghklvxi_j_\_jgmlv\ q_eh\_d_\k_ij_^klZ\e_gbyh `bagbb kf_jlb´
BlZd gZf hklZ_lky ijbagZlv qlh \hkdj_r_gb_ EZaZjy g_evay h[tykgblv k lhqdb
aj_gby gZmdb b ke_^m_l hlg_klb d qm^_kZf Kx`_l \hkdj_r_gby EZaZjy \klj_qZ_lky
lhevdh\ ?\Zg]_ebbhlBhZggZb iheghklvxhlkmlkl\m_lm EmdbFZjdZb FZln_y
?s_[hevr_k\b^_l_evkl\h[h`b\e_gbbfgbfhmf_jrbo\klj_qZ_lkym Zglbqguo
Z\lhjh\ ?s_ WkdmeZi ih ij_^Zgbyf ijb\h^be \ qm\kl\Z kqblZ\rboky mf_jrbfb
ex^_c :kde_ibZ^ \klj_lb\rbkv k ih]j_[Zevghc ijhp_kkb_c \kdjbqZe ³Lhl dh]h \u
a_fe_ij_^Zlvohlbl__s_`b\´
Iebgbc ih\_kl\m_l h fgh]bo kemqZyo dh]^Z ex^b \h \j_fy kZfh]h ih]j_[_gby
hiylvh`b\Zeb
Ba\_klgh qlh :iheehgbc LbZgkdbc m\b^_\ \ughk l_eZ h^ghc mf_jr_c d
kh`Ze_gbx \k_o jbfeyg ^_\mrdbg_\_klu agZlgh]h jh^Z ijbdZaZe ihklZ\blv ]jh[ gZ
a_fexb h`b\be__
:pbebc h`be gZ ih]j_[Zevghf dhklj_ b ijhkbe ihfhsb gh ieZf_gv [ue m`_
g_m]ZkbfIh^h[gZy`_mqZklvihklb]eZEEZfbx
>_fhdjbl lZd`_ ijb\h^bl \ ijbf_j h^gm ^_\mrdm dhlhjmx ij_`^_\j_f_ggh
khqebmf_jr_x
<baZglbckdb_]j_dbbf_ebh[udgh\_gb_ydh[umf_jrbob hiylvh`b\rboex^_c
lhj`_kl\_gghijbgbfZlv\ qbkeh`b\uo Hgb ih\lhjgh dj_klbeb bo b ^ey hlebqby hl
ijhqboex^_cgZau\ZeblZdh\uo³h[fbjZ\rbfb´+\IWHURSRWPL
< hlebqb_ hl \baZglbckdbo ]j_dh\ bg^mku hlghkbebkv d hqgm\rbfky ihke_
e_lZj]bq_kdh]h kgZ djZcg_ gZklhjh`_ggh H[ wlhf khh[sZ_l J_^vyj^ Dbiebg] ²
\_ebdhe_iguc agZlhd f_klgh]h [ulZ b gjZ\h\ fg_gb_f dhlhjh]h bgl_j_kh\Zeky
^Z`_ [jblZgkdbc ]eZ\ghdhfZg^mxsbc ]jZn Jh[_jl DZg^Z]Zjkdbc Ijhn_kkbhgZevgZy
j_ihjl_jkdZy \umqdZ ihfh]eZ Dbiebg]m ihemqblv ]em[hdh_ agZgb_ jZaguo klhjhg
bg^bckdhc`bagbdhlhju_^he]b_]h^ukem`beb_fmgZ^_`gufbklhqgbdhfl\hjq_kl\Z
< k[hjgbd ³JbdrZijbajZd´ \ur_^rbc \ ]h^m \ :eeZoZ[Z^_ \dexq_g
jZkkdZa ³G_h[uqZcgZy ijh]medZ Fhjjhm[b >`mdkZ´ Dbiebg] aZy\ey_l ³< ;hf[__ y
keurZeqlh]^_lh\ Bg^bbkms_kl\m_lf_klhdm^Zhl\hayll_obg^mkh\dhlhju_bf_eb
g_kqZklv_hijZ\blvkyhlkhklhygbyljZgkZbebdZlZe_ikbb´=_jhcjZkkdZaZhdZau\Z_lky
bf_ggh \ lZdhf f_kl_ ² i_kqZghf h\jZ]_ ijb`Zlhf d [ukljhc j_d_ Hqgm\rboky hl
fgbfhc kf_jlb k\hayl kx^Z kh \k_o dhgph\ Bg^bb b k[jZku\Zxl gZ ^gh I_kqZgu_
kdehgu h\jZ]Z ihklhyggh hkuiZxsb_ky g_ ^Zxl g_kqZklguf \hafh`ghklb \u[jZlvky
gZ\_jo Z [mjguc ihlhd ² i_j_ieulv j_dm Gh ^Z`_ _keb dZdhceb[h kf_evqZd
hl\Z`blky gZ ih[_] ² _]h ih^kl_j_]Z_l imey hojZggbdZ LZd b `b\ml wlb h`b\rb_
f_jl\_pu \ i_kqZguo ghjZo \uq_jdgmlu_ ba `bagb iblZykv ih^ZqdZfb kljZ`gbdh\ b
`Zj_gufb\hjhgZfbihdZbog_gZklb]g_lih^ebggZykf_jlvhl]heh^Zb [he_ag_c
H^bg ba h[blZl_e_c wlhc kljZrghc j_a_j\Zpbb [u\rbc [jZofZg =Zg] >ZgkZ
jZkkdZau\Z_l³<h\j_fyohe_jghcwib^_fbb\ZkmghkylgZkh``_gb__s_^hlh]hdZd\u
mf_jebDh]^Z\uihiZ^Z_l_gZ[_j_]j_db³=oZl´²kimkdd j_d_lZdgZau\Zehkvf_klh
jblmZevgh]hkh``_gbyihdhcgbdh\\ Bg^bbjZkiheZ]ZehkvgZkZfhf[_j_]mj_db²K
J [u\Z_l lZd qlh oheh^guc \ha^mo h`b\ey_l \Zk b lh]^Z _keb \u ebrv _^\Z_^\Z
`b\u\ZfgZeh`ZlbeZ\ gha^jbb \jhlihke_q_]h\umfj_l_hdhgqZl_evgh?keb\u
hdZ`_l_kvg_kdhevdhdj_iq_\ZfgZeh`Zl[hevr_beZgh_keb\uihgZklhys_fm`b\u
\Zf^Z^ml\ua^hjh\_lvZ aZl_faZ[_jmlkx^Z\ j_a_j\Zpbx²KJ´
NZdlue_lZj]bq_kdh]hkgZb ij_`^_\j_f_ggh]hih]j_[_gbyfgbfuoihdhcgbdh\
gZrebhljZ`_gb_b \i_jkb^kdhfnhevdehj_Ijb\h^bfh^bgbai_jkb^kdboZg_d^hlh\
³M h^gh]h qbgh\gbdZ g_h`b^Zggh mf_jeZ `_gZ ?_ meh`beb gZ ih]j_[Zevgu_
ghkbedbb g_kdhevdhq_eh\_d\f_kl_k fm`_fklZebkimkdZlvky\gbakh\lhjh]hwlZ`Z
GZ lj_lv_c klmi_gvd_ h^bg ba l_o dlh ^_j`Ze gZ ie_q_ ih]j_[Zevgu_ ghkbedb
ihkdhevagmeky b miZe Ghkbedb k\Zebebkv Z `_gZ qbgh\gbdZ hl kbevgh]h khljyk_gby
hqgmeZkvb \_jgmeZkv\ wlhlfbjIhke_wlh]hkemqZyhgZijh`beZ_s_^_kylve_lIhlhf
kdhgqZeZkvFm`kgh\Zijh^_eZe\k_dZdjZgvr___ meh`bebgZih]j_[Zevgu_ghkbedb
b ihg_kebDh]^ZklZebkimkdZlvkyb ^hreb^hlj_lv_cklmi_gvdblhfm`iheh`bejmdm
gZ ie_qh lh]h q_eh\_dZ dhlhjuc dh]^Zlh ihkdhevagmeky b r_igme _fm ³=ey^b \ h[Z
lj_lvyklmi_gvdZg_ihkdhevagbkv´
G_kfhljy gZ \_kv dhfbaf wlhc kblmZpbb g_ ih^e_`bl khfg_gbx qlh y\e_gb_
e_lZj]bq_kdh]hkgZ[uehohjhrhba\_klgh\ i_jkb^kdhf[ulm<_^vZg_d^hlukha^Zxlky
gZhkgh\_jZkijhkljZg_gguo[ulh\uokemqZ_\Wlhimklv^h\_^_ggu_^hZ[kmj^Zgh\k_
`_lbibqgu_kblmZpbb
H [ul_ kj_^g_\_dh\hc ?\jhiu fh`gh km^blv ih hq_gv bgl_j_kghfm `Zgjm
gZau\Z_fhfm ³H[HPSOD ² ³ijbf_ju´ ([HPSOD ² wlh dhjhldb_ jZkkdZau Zg_d^hlu
dhlhju_kem`bebh[yaZl_evgufwe_f_glhfp_jdh\ghcijhih\_^bkZfuf^hoh^qb\ufb
wnn_dlb\guf b ^he`gu [ueb mqblv gZab^Zlv \gmrZlv hl\jZs_gb_ d ]j_om b
ijb\_j`_gghklv d [eZ]hq_klbx Ijhih\_^gbd ij_l_g^h\Ze gZ jhev ³\eZklbl_ey ^mf´
k\hbo kh\j_f_ggbdh\ b ihwlhfm g_ h[oh^be ih kms_kl\m gb h^ghc klhjhgu `bagb
\Z`ghc k bo lhqdb aj_gby b \uau\Ze bamfe_gb_ \hklhj] beb m`Zk kemrZl_e_c
³Ijbf_ju´ gZkus_gu `bag_gguf fZl_jbZehf Z ihwlhfm bf_ggh kj_^b gbo fu
ihiulZ_fkygZclbbgl_j_kmxsb_gZknZdlu
<hl ³ijbf_j´ ba k[hjgbdZ ;,,, \_dZ P_aZjy =_ckl_j[Zokdh]h fhgZoZ
pbkl_jpbZgkdh]hhj^_gZH^bgq_eh\_dmf_j_]hiheh`bebgZih]j_[Zevgu_ghkbedbb
ihg_keb gZ deZ^[bs_ gh hg \g_aZigh \kdZdb\Z_l k gbo <k_ dlh kh[jZeky gZ _]h
hli_\Zgb_\ m`Zk_jZa[_]Zxlkyghf_jl\_p^h]hgy_ldZi_eeZgZb h[jZsZ_lkyd g_fmk
ijhkv[hcm g_]h_klvohjhrbc[ZjZglZdimklvk\ys_ggbd\havf_l_]hk_[_b ihfheblky
aZ mihdhc _]h ^mrb Baeh`b\ k\hx ijhkv[m ihdhcgbd \ha\jZsZ_lky gZ eh`_ b \gh\v
mfbjZ_lIjhih\_^gbdihykgy_lwlhl³ijbf_j´ke_^mxsbfdhff_glZjb_fkljZo i_j_^
aZ]jh[ghc ih]b[_evx i_j_kbebe \ ]j_rgbd_ kZfm kf_jlv b hg mki_e aZjmqblvky
ihfhsvxij_^klZ\bl_eyp_jd\bGhfubkihevam_fwlhl`_³ijbf_j´^ey^jm]bop_e_c
²^ey^hdZaZl_evkl\Zy\e_gbye_lZj]bb\ kj_^g_\_dh\hfh[s_kl\_
<hl ^jm]hc ³ijbf_j´ ;,,, \_dZ MfbjZe Zeqguc [h]Zq ]jZ`^Zgbg FbeZgZ
>jmavy kh]jZ`^Zg_ b khk_^b ijbau\Zeb _]h kiZklb k\hx ^mrm Hg `_ ij_g_[j_]Zy bo
kh\_lZfb ijhkbe k\h_]h khjh^bqZ iheh`blv _fm \ fh]bem ^_kylv fZjhd ahehlhf ^Z[u
_]hk_j^p_[uehkihdhcghDh]^ZihkeZggu_]hjh^kdbfkm^v_ckem]bohl_ebaZ[jZlvwlh
ahehlh ihdhcgbd \kdhqbe b aZ\hibe ³HklZ\vl_ ahehlh g_ \Zr_ hgh´ Km^vx `_
dhlhjuc kZf y\beky k l_f qlh[u \aylv ^_gv]b ba fh]beu f_jl\_p ko\Zlbe b aZ^mrbe
Ijb \k_c ³ebl_jZlmjghklb´ b gZab^Zl_evghklb ^Zggh]h ijbf_jZ \ i_j\hhkgh\_ _]h
dh]^Zlhfh]e_`Zlv^_ckl\bl_evgucwibah^ijh[m`^_gbyfgbfh]hihdhcgbdZ
Ba\_klghqlh\ kj_^gb_\_dZijhkluoex^_cohjhgbeb\ h[sbofh]beZodhlhju_
hldju\Zeb \kydbc jZa dh]^Z gm`gh [ueh iheh`blv gh\h]h ihdhcgbdZ Wlh fh]eh
kem`blv bklhqgbdhf gZdhie_gby ^_ckl\bl_evguo nZdlh\ h aZ`b\h ih]j_[_gguo
<_jhylgh lZdb_ kemqZb ^_ckl\bl_evgh bf_eb f_klh gh ^Z`_ ijb bo gZ[ex^_gbb
kh\j_f_ggbdb ljZdlh\Zeb bo kh\k_f k ^jm]bo ihabpbc g_ km^_[ghf_^bpbgkdbo Z
gjZ\kl\_gghgZab^Zl_evguo LZd \ h^ghf ³ijbf_j_´ jZkkdZau\Z_lky dZd ^\Z
dj_klvygkdbo jh^Z kf_jl_evgh \jZ`^h\Zeb f_`^m kh[hc b kemqbehkv lZd qlh ]eZ\u
h[_bo k_f_cguo ]jmii kdhgqZebkv \ h^bg b lhl `_ ^_gv b ihkdhevdm ijbgZ^e_`Zeb d
h^ghfm ijboh^m [ueb ih]j_[_gu \ h^ghc h[s_c fh]be_ Ijhbahreh ³g_keuoZggh_
qm^h´ bo l_eZ ih\_jgmebkv aZ^hf ^jm] d ^jm]m lhedZykv b ibgZykv lZd qlh \ [hjv[_
mqZkl\h\Zebb ]heh\ub gh]bb kibguIjbrehkvbo\udhiZlvb ihohjhgblv\ jZaguo
f_klZo <jZ`^Z f_jl\_ph\ ihkem`beZ mjhdhf ^ey hklZ\rboky \ `b\uo dhlhju_
^hklb]eb ijbfbj_gby M`_ agZdhfuc gZf fhgZoijhih\_^gbd ;,,, \_dZ P_aZjbc
=_ckl_j[Zokdbc ml\_j`^Z_l qlh wlZ bklhjby ih^ebggZy b ijhbahreZ g_^Z\gh \
D_evgkdhc _iZjobb DZd \b^bf ^Z`_ nZdl gZoh`^_gby aZohjhg_gguo l_e g_ \
dZghgbq_kdbo ihaZo g_ gZ\_e gbdh]h gZ ij_^iheh`_gb_ h \hafh`ghklb ih]j_[_gby
aZ`b\h Hq_\b^pu ij_^ihqeb ih\_jblv \ kh\_jr_ggh nZglZklbq_kdmx bklhjbx h
\jZ`^_f_jl\_ph\q_f^hdZiu\Zlvky^h^_ckl\bl_evghckmlb^Zggh]hkh[ulby
Fgh]b_ ³ijbf_ju´ khh[sZxl h \ha\jZs_gbb d `bagb ex^_c ih[u\Z\rbo ³gZ
lhfk\_l_´qlhlZd`_dhk\_gghk\b^_l_evkl\m_lh \hafh`ghklbe_lZj]bb
H^bgfhgZog_mki_emieZlblvdhjZ[_evsbdZfaZi_j_\hah^bgh[heb kdhgqZeky
aZ[u\ mihfygmlv gZ bkih\_^b h k\h_f imklyqghf ^he]_ Gh gZ lhf k\_l_ wlZ f_ehqv
\ujhkeZi_j_^_]h\ahjhf^hlZdhckl_i_gbqlhhgijhkbeZg]_eh\\_jgmlv_]h^mrm\
l_eh<hkdj_kgm\rbcfhgZobkih\_^ZekyZ[[ZlmbdZdlhevdh^he][ueih]Zr_g\gh\v
bkimklbe^moBa\_klb_\_jgh_b[hP_aZjx=_ckl_j[Zokohfmh g_fih\_^Zeh^bgZ[[Zl
[_k_^h\Z\rbck l_fZ[[Zlhfdhlhjhfmbkih\_^h\Zekyihdhcgbd
Lh]`_ P_aZjbc =_ckl_j[Zokdbc jZkkdZau\Z_l h \ha\jZs_gbb d `bagb q_eh\_dZ
ih[u\Z\r_]h ihke_ dhgqbgu gZ KljZrghf km^_ Hg keurZe h[ wlhf m^b\bl_evghf
ijhbkr_kl\bb hl kZfh]h _]h ]_jhy ² WcghevnZ k^_eZ\r_]hky \ihke_^kl\bb fhgZohf
Dh]^Zlhl[uefZevqbdhflhaZ[he_eb mf_j[_aijbqZklby³\hkdj_kgm\´lhevdhq_j_a
^ebl_evgh_\j_fy
< ^jm]hf³ijbf_j_´ih\_kl\m_lkyh[h^ghc`b\r_cijZa^ghc`bagvx`_gsbg_
dhlhjZy[ueZihljyk_gZ ijhih\_^gbdhf ^h lZdhc kl_i_gb qlh mf_jeZ h^gZdh _d [ueh
^Zgh\ha\jZlblvkyd `bagbb bkih\_^Zlvky
Rbjhdh ba\_kl_g ljZ]bq_kdbc kemqZc ijhbkr_^rbc k ]_gbZevguf \jZqhf
ZgZlhfhf b objmj]hf wihob <hajh`^_gby :g^j__f <_aZeb_f ² K\hbf
ljm^hf ³H kljh_gbb q_eh\_q_kdh]h l_eZ´ ba^Zgguf \ ]h^m <_aZebc iheh`be
gZqZeh kh\j_f_gghc ZgZlhfbb ;e_klysb_ bkke_^h\Zgby <_aZeby ijb\_eb _]h d
klhedgh\_gbx k dZlhebq_kdhc p_jdh\vx >h\_^_gguc k\hbfb \jZ]Zfb ^h hlqZygby hg
ij_djZlbe gZmqgmx ^_yl_evghklv \ BlZebb k`_] k\hb jmdhibkb b klZe ijb^\hjguf
\jZqhf\ FZ^jb^_]^_b kemqbehkvlhqlhijb\_ehwlh]h]_gbZevgh]hZgZlhfZd ]b[_eb
H ihke_^gbo ]h^Zo `bagb <_aZeby ba\_klgh g_fgh]h < ibkvfZo _]h
kh\j_f_ggbdh\ \ukdZau\Z_lky ij_^iheh`_gb_ qlh aZ \kdjulb_ mf_jr_]h m dhlhjh]h
_s_ khdjZsZehkv k_j^p_ bgd\babpby ijb]h\hjbeZ <_aZeby d kf_jlghc dZagb Ih
mdZaZgbx dhjhey BkiZgbb dZagv [ueZ aZf_g_gZ iZehfgbq_kl\hf \ IZe_klbgm ³^ey
bkdmie_gby]j_oh\´< ]h^m<_aZebck `_ghcb ^hq_jvxihdbgmeFZ^jb^HklZ\b\
k_fvx \ ;jxkkk_e_ hg h^bg hlijZ\beky \ ^Ze_dbc imlv GZ h[jZlghf imlb ba
B_jmkZebfZ [hevghc <_aZebc ijb dhjZ[e_djmr_gbb [ue \u[jhr_g gZ hkljh\ AZgl_
=j_pby]^_b mf_j\ ]h^m
Gh \ ijbf_j_ k <_aZeb_f ^Ze_dh g_ \k_ h^ghagZqgh KemqZc k gbf klZe
oj_klhfZlbcguf^eyh[tykg_gbyZ\lhfZlbq_kdhcjZ[hluk_j^pZBa\_klghqlh\ k_j^p_
kms_kl\mxl ^\Z g_j\guo maeZ \ dhlhjuo \hagbdZ_l \ha[m`^_gb_ h[mkeh\eb\Zxs__
jZ[hlmk_j^pZB _kebm^Z_lkykhojZgblv`bagvba\e_q_ggh]hbahj]ZgbafZ k_j^pZ beb
h`b\blvk_j^p_ljmiZlhwlh\ k\hxhq_j_^vk\yaZghk khojZg_gb_fbebijh[m`^_gb_f
^_yl_evghklbl_omqZkldh\k_j^pZ]^__klvmaeu<hla^_kvlhb djh_lkyjZa]Z^dZk_dj_lZ
jZ[hlu bahebjh\Zggh]h k_j^pZ Bgh]^Z m q_eh\_dZ ihke_ kf_jlb Z\lhfZlbq_kdZy
^_yl_evghklv k_j^_qguo maeh\ \ keZ[hf \b^_ khojZgy_lky _s_ g_dhlhjh_ \j_fy Wlh
[u\Z_lhq_gvj_^dh<b^bfh<_aZebcijb\kdjulbbljmiZgZlhedgmekybf_gghgZlZdhc
kemqZc Gh gb hg gb _]h kh\j_f_ggbdb gbq_]h g_ agZeb h k_j^_qguo maeZo b h[ bo
Z\lhfZlbq_kdhc^_yl_evghklb
?keb wlh ^_ckl\bl_evgh lZd lh ijbf_j k <_aZeb_f y\ey_lky g_ kh\k_f
dhjj_dlguf ^ey beexkljZpbb gZr_]h jZkkdZaZ h e_lZj]bb A^_kv fu klZedb\Z_fky k
kh\_jr_ggh bguf nbabheh]bq_kdbf y\e_gb_f g_ bf_xsbf gbdZdh]h hlghr_gby d
³fgbfhckf_jlb´
Gh ebklZy klZjbggu_ dgb]b y gZlhedgmeky gZ jZagu_ hlebqZxsb_ky hl
kh\j_f_gghc oj_klhfZlbcghc \_jkbb ijhbkr_kl\by k <_aZeb_f Ijb\_^_f ^hkeh\gh
g_dhlhju_bawlbo³Zg_d^hlh\´dZdlh]^Zijbgylh[uehgZau\Zlvih^h[gu_khh[s_gby
³KeZ\gucZgZlhfbd<_kZebc\kdju\Zeh^gm`_gsbgmkljZ^Z\rmxbkl_jbq_kdhx
[he_agvxdhlhjmxhgihqblZef_jl\hxb ebrvdhkgmekyk_j^pZlhgZqZehhgh_[blvky
Ijblhf m^hklh\_jyxl qlh ydh[u hgZ ihdZaZeZ agZdb `bagb q_j_a ^\b`_gb_ b djbd
JZkdZygb_ h k_f ij_`^_\j_f_gghf \kdjulbb ih\_j]eh kdhjh k_]h agZf_gblh]h fm`Z \
]jh[´
³KeZ\guc \jZq b ZgZlhfbd <_kZebc ohl_e \kdju\Zlv h^gh]h mf_jr_]h
bkiZgkdh]h^\hjygbgZghebrvlhevdhgZqZejZaj_au\Zlv]jm^gu_furpulhhg\^jm]
h`beKb_kemqbehkvg_ijhklhlhevdhijZdlbq_kdhfm\jZqmghdmigh`_b ZgZlhfbdm
dhlhjuc^eymqbg_gbyihe_aguogZ[ex^_gbcdZd_kl_kl\hbkiulZl_ev\kdju\Zefgh]b_
f_jl\u_l_eZgh\ k_fkemqZ_h[fZgmekyih_ebdm`b\h]hq_eh\_dZihqblZef_jl\uf´
?keb\ gZqZe_i_j\h]h\ZjbZglZjZkkdZaZh ijhbkr_kl\bbk <_aZeb_f_s_fh`gh
ij_^iheh`blv \hagbdgh\_gb_ Z\lhfZlbq_kdbo khdjZs_gbc k_j^pZ ljmiZ \ hl\_l gZ
ijbdhkgh\_gb_ Z lZdh_ ^_ckl\bl_evgh bgh]^Z kemqZ_lky lh dhgph\dZ _]h ykgh b
g_^\mkfuke_ggh]h\hjbl\ ihevame_lZj]bb²³ihdZaZeZagZdb`bagbq_j_a^\b`_gb_b
djbd´ D lhfm `_ ih^q_jdgmlh qlh `_gsbgZ kljZ^ZeZ ³bkl_jbq_kdhc [he_agvx´ Z
³bkl_jbq_kdZy kiyqdZ´ dZd fu m`_ jZkkdZau\Zeb y\eyeZkv h^ghc ba hkgh\guo ijbqbg
³fgbfhckf_jlb´\ kj_^gb_\_dZ
<h\lhjhf `_ ijbf_j_ fgbfhmf_jrbc h`b\Z_l _s_ ^h lh]h dZd _fm \kdjueb
]jm^gmxde_ldmb hkhdjZs_gbbk_j^pZg_]h\hjblkygbq_]h<k_wlh_s_jZa^hdZau\Z_l
qlh\ kemqZ_k <_aZeb_fbf_ef_klhe_lZj]bq_kdbckhg
D lhfm`_ljZ]bq_kdbckemqZc<_aZeby[ue^Ze_dhg__^bgkl\_ggufG_f_pdbc
\jZq ;9,,, \_dZ = ;jx]v_ \ fhgh]jZnbb him[ebdh\Zgghc \ ]h^m \ E_cipb]_
hibku\Z_l k_fv kemqZ_\ dh]^Z ijb \kdjulbb f_jl\uo l_e [ueb aZf_lgu g_dhlhju_
ijbagZdb`bagb
DZj^bgZeWkibghaZi_j\ucfbgbkljBkiZgkdh]hdhjheyNbebiiZ;,bf_e[he__
m`ZkgmxmqZklvq_fmihfygmlucgZfbbkiZgkdbc^\hjygbg³Hgebrb\rbkvfbehklb
=hkm^Zjyk\h_]h\iZe\ \_ebdmxi_qZevb\j_fyhl\j_f_gb[he__bag_fh]ZygZdhg_p
ih\b^bfhfm mf_j DZf_j^bg_j _]h dhlhjuc bf_e g_dhlhju_ e_dZjkdb_ ihagZgb_ b
ohl_e[ZevaZfbjh\Zlv_]hdh]^ZgZqZe\kdju\Zlv]jm^vlhm\b^_eqlhg_lhevdhk_j^p_
_s_ [behkv gh ijbf_lbe lZd`_ qlh dZj^bgZe ih^\bgme jmdm k\hx d m[bckl\_gghfm
gh`m_]hgh^Z[u\ kemqZ_h`b\e_gby_]hg_fh]hghkm`^_g[ulv\ k_f^_e_\Zj\Zjk_c
jZaj_aZe[hevrmx[h_\mx`bemK_ckemqZc\ lh\j_fy[ueh[gZjh^h\Zg´
Ba\_klghqlhihwlI_ljZjdZ[m^mqb\ N_jjZj_³h`be´aZq_luj_qZkZ^hk\hbo
ihohjhg b ijh`be ihke_ wlh]h _s_ e_l Emb^`b <bllhj_ h^bg ba kem`bl_e_c
<ZlbdZgZ ijb Ib_ ,; [ue ijbagZg mf_jrbf hl Zklfu Gh h^bg ba \jZq_c [he__
hklhjh`guc q_f _]h dhee_]b ih^g_k d _]h hkl_de_g_\rbf ]eZaZf k\_qm ³Ihdhcgbd´
j_adh^_jgmekyb ijh`be_s_^hklZlhqgh^he]hghkhrjZfhfhlh`h]ZgZghkm
K\b^_l_evkl\Z h e_lZj]bq_kdhf kg_ fu gZoh^bf b \ klZjbgguo jmkkdbo
e_lhibkyo H^ghc ba kZfuo ^jZfZlbqguo kljZgbp jmkkdhc bklhjbb y\ey_lky djh\Z\Zy
^\Z^pZlbk_fbe_lgyy f_`^hmkh[gZy [hjv[Z aZ \eZklv \gmdh\ >fbljby >hgkdh]h ²
<_ebdh]hdgyay<Zkbeby,, L_fgh]hb lj_okugh\_cklZjr_]hkugZ>fbljby>hgkdh]h
Xjby >fbljb_\bqZ² <Zkbeby Dhkh]h >fbljby R_fydb b >fbljby DjZkgh]h
Khi_jgbdb ihhq_j_^gh ijbau\Zeb gZ Jmkv lh Ebl\m lh lZlZj ]jZ[beb b `]eb jmkkdb_
]hjh^Zm[b\Zeb\ [jZlhm[bckl\_gguokluqdZokhlgbgb \q_fg_ih\bgguoex^_c
< ]h^m \ ]hjh^_ =Zebq_ kdhgqZeky feZ^rbc [jZl Dhkh]h b R_fydb
>fbljbcDjZkgucH[klhyl_evkl\Z_]hkf_jlb[uebhq_gvb hq_gvkljZggufb<hldZd
ih\_kl\m_l h[ wlbo kh[ulbyo G F DZjZfabg \ k\h_c ³Bklhjbb ]hkm^Zjkl\Z
Jhkkbckdh]h´ ³AZ \j_fy [he_agb >fbljbc ebrbeky kemoZ \dmkZ b kgZ ohl_e
ijbqZklblvky k\yluo lZcg b ^he]h g_ fh] b[h djh\v g_ij_klZggh ebeZ m g_]h ba ghkm
?fm aZldgmeb gha^jb qlh[u ^Zlv ijbqZklblvky >fbljbc mihdhbeky lj_[h\Ze ibsb
\bgZaZkgme²b dZaZekyf_jl\uf;hyj_hieZdZebdgyayaZdjuebh^_yehf\uibebih
g_kdhevdhklZdZgh\dj_idh]hf_^mb kZfbe_]ebkiZlvgZeZ\dZo\ lhc`_]hjgbp_<^jm]
fgbfuc f_jl\_p kdbgme k k_[y h^_yeh b g_ hldju\Zy ]eZaZ gZqZe i_lv klbobju
p_jdh\gu_ i_kghi_gby ² KJ <k_ hp_i_g_eb hl m`ZkZ JZag_kky kemo h k_f qm^_
^\hj_p gZihegbeky ex[hiulgufb P_eu_ ljb ^gy dgyav i_e b ]h\hjbe h
^mr_kiZkbl_evguo ij_^f_lZo magZ\Ze ex^_c gh g_ keuoZe gbq_]h gZdhg_p
^_ckl\bl_evgh mf_j k bf_g_f k\ylh]h b[h ² dZd kdZau\Zxl e_lhibkpu ² l_eh _]h
q_j_a ^gy hldjulh_ ^ey ih]j_[_gby \ Fhkdh\kdhf kh[hj_ ZjoZg]_eZ FboZbeZ
dZaZehkv`b\uf[_a\kydboagZdh\le_gbyb [_akbg_lu´
:gZeh]bqgu_ k\_^_gby fu gZoh^bf b \ dgb]_ ba\_klgh]h agZlhdZ jmkkdbo
p_jdh\guo ^j_\ghkl_c :g^j_y GbdheZ_\bqZ FmjZ\v_\Z ² ³Iml_r_kl\b_ ih
k\yluf f_klZf jmkkdbf´ Hibku\Zy \_ebdhdgy`_kdmx mkuiZevgbpm :joZg]_evkdh]h
kh[hjZ Fhkdh\kdh]h dj_fey hg \kihfbgZ_l wibah^u f_`^hmkh[ghc [hjv[u aZ \eZklv
f_`^m<_ebdbfdgya_f<Zkbeb_f,,L_fgufb ]Zebpdbfdgya_fXjb_f>fbljb_\bq_f
kughf >fbljby >hgkdh]h k kugh\vyfb ³FZe hkdhj[bl_e_g dZaZeky Xjbx m^_e _]h
ihke_ kf_jlb [jZlZ <_ebdh]h Dgyay <Zkbeby <Zkbeby , ² K J b \f_kl_ k ^_lvfb
k\hbfb Dhkuf b R_fydhx \ha[m^be hg ^\Z^pZlbk_fbe_lg__ f_`^hmkh[b_ \ a_fe_
Jmkkdhc DZaZehkv q_klhex[b\uc hl_p bkdZe k_[_ ij_klheZ lhevdh ^ey lh]h qlh[u ih
klmi_gyf _]h [ukljh khclb \ fh]bem b lm^Z `_ m\e_qv aZ kh[hx klZjr_]h kugZ
hke_ie_ggh]hki_j\Z[e_kdhf\_gpZZ ihlhfjmdhxkhi_jgbdZDhkhc[uehke_ie_gih
ijbdZam <Zkbeby ,, ² K J <hij_db ihjy^dZ :joZg]_evkdbo ]jh[gbp h^gZ fh]beZ
aZdexqZeZ h[hbo dhlhjuf l_kgh [ueh jh^h\h_ dgy`_gb_ b ^Z`_ lj_lbc kug Xjby
>bfbljbc djZkguc l_ehf b ^mrhx hims_g \ lhl `_ ]jh[² lZd ihkdmibeZkv a_fey
JmkkdZyihke_^gbf^eygboijbxlhf´
BlZd \ :joZg]_evkdhf kh[hj_ \ h^ghc fh]be_ e_`Zl kug >fbljby >hgkdh]h
Xjbckhk\hbfbfyl_`gufb^_lvfb²Dhkufb >fbljb_fDjZkguf: ]^_`_lj_lbc
gZb[he__ g_m]hfhgguc kug ]Zebpdh]h dgyay Xjby >fbljb_\bqZ ijbgy\rbc hl g_]h
wklZn_lm fyl_`_c ]jZ[_`_c b jZa[h_\ ² R_fydZ kZfh bfy dhlhjh]h klZeh kbf\hehf
g_ijZ\^u b ijbl_kg_gbc \kihfgbl_ jmkkdmx kZlbjbq_kdmx kdZadm ³R_fydbg km^´
HdZau\Z_lky b ihke_kf_jlbl_eh_]hbkiulZehg_f_g__ijbdexq_gbcq_fijb`bagb
b [uehh[gZjm`_ghebrv\ ]h^m\ Gh\]hjh^_ijbh[klhyl_evkl\ZogZihfbgZxsbo
m\e_dZl_evg_crbc ^_l_dlb\guc jhfZg Fu h[yaZl_evgh jZkkdZ`_f h[ wlhf \ \hkvfhc
]eZ\_Z ihdZijh^he`bfij_j\ZggmxpblZlm
³Gh _keb kh]j_rbeb ijhlb\ g__ Jmkkdhc a_feb ² K J dgyavy =ZebqZ Xjbc
Dhkhcb R_fydZlhh^bgDjZkgucfh]aZ]eZ^blvly`db_\bguk\h_]hk_f_ckl\Zqbklhx
fhebl\_gghx`bagvx<hp\_l_e_lij_klZ\bekyhgdZdlbobc:g]_eb g_h[uqZcgZy_]h
dhgqbgZbamfbeZkh\j_f_ggbdh\
Qm\kl\myijb[eb`_gb_kf_jlbhgijbh[sbekyk\yluolZcgbijbql_gbbdZghgZ
gZ bkoh^ ^mrb bkimklbe ihke_^g__ ^uoZgb_ h[jy`Zeb l_eh d ih]j_[_gbx gh \
iheghqv k[jhkb\ k k_[y ihdju\Zeh ]jhfdh \ha]eZkbe f_jl\_p ?\Zg]_evkdb_ keh\Z
³I_lj`_ihagZe_]hydh=hkih^v_klv´Hp_i_g_\hlm`ZkZ^bZdhgqblZ\rbcgZ^gbf
ikZelujv_^\Zfh]jZa[m^blvkiysbohdj_klf_jl\_p`_ih\lhjyeh^ghb lh`_hgg_
]ey^_e]eZaZfbghl_ehm g_]h[uehdZdm `b\h]hDjZkgucaZi_ep_jdh\gmxi_kgvb k
\hkdj_k_gvy^hkj_^u[ue`b\i_ek\ys_ggu_i_kgbqblZegZbamklvk\ylh_IbkZgb_g_
ihgbfZyqlh_fm]h\hjbebghmagZ\Zeex^_cohlyb hl\_qZe[_aihjy^dZ\ kj_^mmfhed
hgZ \q_l\_j]kdhgqZekykljZggucf_jl\_p\h \j_fy eblmj]bb L_eh _]h ijb\_a_gh ba
M]ebqZ\ kh[hj:joZg]_evkdbcb hdZaZehkvg_le_ggufijbih]j_[_gbb²lZdaZibkZeZ
kb_^b\gh_kh[ulb_kh\j_f_ggZye_lhibkv´
JZkkdZau G F DZjZfabgZ b : G FmjZ\v_\Z h[ wlhf kh[ulbb g_kdhevdh
hlebqZykv \ ^_lZeyo ihjZabl_evgh kh\iZ^Zxl \ ]eZ\ghf ^hihegyy ^jm]m ^jm]Z GZ
hkgh\Zgbb wlbo k\b^_l_evkl\ fu fh`_f ij_^iheZ]Zlv qlh >fbljbc DjZkguc kljZ^Ze
ihjZ`_gb_f p_gljZevghc g_j\ghc kbkl_fu ³ebrbeky kemoZ \dmkZ b kgZ´ gZ nhg_
agZqbl_evgh]h ih\ur_gby Zjl_jbZevgh]h ^Z\e_gby h q_f k\b^_l_evkl\m_l ly`_eh_
ghkh\h_djh\hl_q_gb_IhklZ\blvdZdhceb[hlhqguc^bZ]gha SRVWIDFWXP gZhkgh\Zgbb
hlju\hqguo k\_^_gbc ba e_lhibkb g_\hafh`gh gh \_jhylg__ \k_]h wlh fh] [ulv
e_lZj]bq_kdbc wgp_nZebl dhlhjuc ijb\_e [hevgh]h d khklhygbx e_lZj]bb hrb[hqgh
ijbgylhfmaZkf_jlvLhqlhihijh[m`^_gbbDjZkgucgbq_]hg_keurZeb g_ihgbfZe
fh`_l k\b^_l_evkl\h\Zlv h g_h[jZlbfhf ihjZ`_gbb kemoh\h]h ZgZebaZlhjZ qlh lZd`_
ih^l\_j`^Z_lgZr_ij_^iheh`_gb_h aZ[he_\Zgbbp_gljZevghcg_j\ghckbkl_fu
G_bkdexq_ghqlhih\lhjgZykf_jlv>fbljbyDjZkgh]h[ueZg_kf_jlvxZ ebrv
[he__ ly`_euf ih\lhjguf ijbklmihf e_lZj]bb <k_ e_lhibkb _^bgh^mrgh mdZau\Zxl
qlh gZ l_e_ DjZkgh]h g_ [ueh gb fZe_crbo ijbagZdh\ jZaeh`_gby b ^Z`_ ljmiguo
iyl_gZ aZ^gyimlbhlM]ebqZ^hFhkd\uljmigu_y\e_gbyg_ij_f_ggh^he`gu[ueb
[u bf_lv f_klh Lh qlh hgb g_ gZklmibeb ]h\hjbl g_ h k\ylhklb DjZkgh]h \_kvfZ
khfgbl_evghckm^yih_]h[h]Zlhc ijbdexq_gbyfb `bagb Z lhevdh h[ h^ghf \_kvfZ
\_jhylghqlh>fbljbcDjZkgucb ih\lhjgh[ueih]j_[_g`b\uf\ khklhygbbe_lZj]bb
Kms_kl\h\Zgb_n_ghf_gZe_lZj]bq_kdh]hkgZ\ ijhrehf^Zehih\h^d kha^Zgbx
fgh]hqbke_gguo kdZahd kx`_l dhlhjuo mkeh\gh fh`gh [ueh [u gZa\Zlv ³KiysZy
djZkZ\bpZ´ =_jhbgy kdZadb mdheh\rbkv aZdhe^h\Zgguf \_j_l_ghf beb gZ^dmkb\
\her_[gh_y[ehdhaZkuiZ_lgZfgh]hfgh]he_lb lhevdhihp_emcij_djZkgh]hijbgpZ
ijh[m`^Z_l__ hlhp_i_g_gby
<_kvfZ \hafh`gh qlh i_j\hhkgh\hc wlh]h kx`_lZ lheqdhf d gZjh^ghc
nZglZabb ihkem`beh ^_ckl\bl_evgh_ gZ[ex^_gb_ e_lZj]bq_kdh]h kgZ ohly b g_ klhev
^ebl_evgh]hdZd\ kdZad_Kx`_lkiys_cdjZkZ\bpu\klj_qZ_lkyhq_gvqZklhGZb[he__
ba\_kl_g hg ih kdZad_ RZjey I_jjh ³KiysZy djZkZ\bpZ´ b h^ghbf_gghfm [Ze_lm I B
QZcdh\kdh]hkha^ZgghfmgZhkgh\_wlhckdZadbihaZf_qZl_evghfmfmevlnbevfmMhelZ
>bkg_y ³;_ehkg_`dZ b k_fv ]ghfh\´ Z lZd`_ ih ³KdZad_ h f_jl\hc pZj_\g_ b k_fb
[h]Zlujyo´:KImrdbgZ
Kj_^b gh\_ee Zf_jbdZgkdh]h ibkZl_ey <Zrbg]lhgZ Bj\bg]Z ² _klv
h^gZ hl^Ze_ggh gZihfbgZxsZy kx`_l ³Kiys_c djZkZ\bpu´ GZau\Z_lky hgZ ³Jbi \Zg
<bgdev´BfyJbiZ\Zg<bgdeyklZehgZjbpZl_evgufhagZqZy³q_eh\_dhlhj\Z\rbckyhl
^_ckl\bl_evghklb mljZlb\rbc k\yab kh k\hbf \j_f_g_f´ < hkgh\_ gh\_eeu e_`Zl
e_]_g^ui_j\uo]heeZg^kdboihk_e_gp_\rlZlZGvxChjdJbi\Zg<bgdevhivyg_gguc
\her_[guf gZibldhf ijhkiZe \kx ghqv \ e_km Z dh]^Z \_jgmeky \ k\hx ^_j_\gx
\uykgbehkvqlhkiZehgfgh]hfgh]he_lb \_]hihk_ed_`b\ml l_i_jvkh\k_f^jm]b_
ex^baZ[u\rb_h Jbi\Zg<bgde_
DZd [u gb [ueh aZfZgqb\h k\yaZlv kx`_l ³Jbi \Zg <bgdey´ k e_lZj]bq_kdbf
kghf wlh [ueh [u g_ kh\k_f dhjj_dlgh < hlebqb_ hl ³Kiys_c djZkZ\bpu´ \ hkgh\_
³Jbi \Zg <bgdey´ e_`bl g_kdhevdh ^jm]Zy hlijZ\gZy lhqdZ Wlh ihdZ _s_ fZeh
bamq_gguc n_ghf_g km[t_dlb\gh]h i_j_`b\Zgby \j_f_gb g_j_^dh \klj_qZxsbcky \
kj_^g_\_dh\uokx`_lZoIjbklhedgh\_gbbfbjZ`b\uob fbjZf_jl\uoa_fgh_\j_fy
ih^gZihjhf\_qghklb\^jm]f_gy_lk\hcoZjZdl_j
Ihykgbf wlh g_kdhevdbfb ijbf_jZfb ba k[hjgbdh\ ³([HPSOD´ ;,,, \_dZ
Y\b\rbkvk lh]hk\_lZDZje<_ebdbcaZ[jZek kh[hc\ jZcg_dh_]hjupZjyb \ha\jZlbe
_]hkimklyljb]h^ZghjupZjv[uem[_`^_g\ lhfqlhijh\_ek ihdhcgufbfi_jZlhjhf
\k_]h lhevdh ljb ^gy < fhf_gl dh]^Z ^mrZ mf_jr_]h fhgZoZ ijhoh^beZ q_j_a
qbklbebs_ e_`Z\r__ \ fhgZkluj_ l_eh _]h \g_aZigh ih^gyehkv \ \ha^mo b lhlqZk
himklbehkvZ fhgZomihdZaZehkvqlhhgfmqbeky\ qbklbebs_lukyqme_l
=meyy \[ebab k\h_]h fhgZklujy [eZ]hq_klb\uc Z[[Zl jZafureye h ]jy^ms_c
`bagb b jZ^hklyo jZy <ha\jZlb\rbkv d \hjhlZf g_ magZe hg gb ijb\jZlgbdZ gb
fhgZoh\B l_g_magZeb_]hb [uebm^b\e_gumkeuoZ\hlg_]hqlhhg²gZklhyl_evbo
h[bl_eb lhevdh qlh \ur_^rbc qlh[u ihjZafureylv gZ_^bg_ Ihkfhlj_\ \ dgb]_ \
dhlhjmx[uebaZibkZgubf_gZij_`gboZ[[Zlh\hgbgZrebb _]hbfyK l_oihjfbgmeh
ljbklZe_l
K\ys_ggbd kem`b\rbc \ ^\mo ijboh^kdbo p_jd\yo hlijZ\b\ jh`^_kl\_gkdmx
kem`[m\ h^ghcbagbokh[jZekyb^lb\ ^jm]mxdh]^Z_]hijb]eZkbeZhlkem`blvf_kkm
ihkeZggbpZk\ylhcFZjbbHgijb_oZe\ ij_djZkgmxp_jdh\v]^_\klj_lbe;h]hfZl_jv
Z ihhdhgqZgbbkem`[uihemqbejZaj_r_gb_\ha\jZlblvky^hfhcGhhdZaZehkvqlhhg
hlkmlkl\h\Zeg_g_kdhevdhqZkh\Z klhe_l
Wlhl n_ghf_g km[t_dlb\gh]h \hkijbylby \j_f_gb klhev oZjZdl_jguc ^ey
ikboheh]bbkj_^g_\_dh\h]hq_eh\_dZ\_jhylghdZdbflhh[jZahfgZr_ek\h_hljZ`_gb_
b \ l_hjbb hlghkbl_evghklb :ev[_jlZ Wcgrl_cgZ Gh wlh m`_ l_fZ hl^_evgh]h
bkke_^h\Zgby g_ bf_xsZy gbdZdh]h hlghr_gby d jZa[bjZ_fhfm gZfb y\e_gbx
e_lZj]bq_kdh]h kgZ : ihlhfm ijh^he`bf gZr jZa]h\hj h[ hljZ`_gbb nZdlh\
e_lZj]bq_kdh]hkgZ\ gZjh^ghfnhevdehj_
<h\k_okljZgZoghkylky\ gZjh^_kemobh ijbf_q_gguormf_kl_gZgbbb \hieyo
[eba gh\uo fh]be b ]jh[gbp G_khfg_ggh qlh bf_\rb_ f_klh \ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb
m`Zkgu_ ijhbkr_kl\by k ih]j_[_ggufb b hiylv h`b\rbfb ex^vfb ^Z\Zeb ih\h^ d
kha^ZgbxkdZahde_]_g^[u\Zevsbgb ij_^Zgbch ijb\b^_gbyoh \klZxsboihghqZf
ba]jh[Zf_jl\_pZoh \mj^ZeZdZo\ZfibjZodhe^mgZo\_^vfZoGZjh^ghfml\hjq_kl\m
k\yaZgghfm k fbjhf f_jl\uo fu ihk\ylbf hl^_evgmx ]eZ\m a^_kv `_ ohl_ehkv [u
lhevdhdhkgmlvky\hijhkZh[hlghr_gbbex^_cd ³h`b\rbfihdhcgbdZf´G_khfg_ggh
lZdb_nZdlu\gmrZebg_ij_h^hebfucm`Zkb ex^_chqgm\rbokyihke_e_lZj]bq_kdh]h
kgZ ihqblZeb aZ ij_^klZ\bl_e_c ^vy\hevkdh]h fbjZ b klZjZebkv dZd fh`gh kdhj__ hl
gbo ba[Z\blvky GZb[he__ jZ^bdZevguf kj_^kl\hf kqblZehkv \h]gZlv hkbgh\uc dhe \
]jm^vlZdhfmh`b\r_fmihdhcgbdm
<hl deZkkbq_kdh_ hibkZgb_ \ZfibjZ miujy \mj^ZeZdZ \ jZajulhc fh]be_
hdZau\Z_lky l_eh [_a ijbagZdh\ jZaeh`_gby [he__ lh]h ² k jmfygufb s_dZfb k
hljhkrbfbgh]lyfb[hjh^hc\hehkZfbk aZi_dr_ckygZ]m[Zodjh\vxAZqZklmxdjh\v
ijbkmlkl\m_l^Z`_\ ]jh[m
: \hldjZkhqgh_hibkZgb_aZ`b\hih]j_[_ggh]hk^_eZggh_Bh]Zgghf?eeba_ghf
\ j_amevlZl_ ZgZebaZ fgh]hqbke_gguo jZkkdZah\ ih]j_[_gguo aZ`b\h ³hg qm\kl\m_l
k_[y kl_kg_gguf f_`^m ^hkdZfb dhb g_ ^himkdZxl _]h ijhklbjZlv jmd k\hbo Hg
kbeblky i_j_f_gylv iheh`_gb_ k\h_ gh \ lh kZfh_ \j_fy h^he_\Z_l _]h klj_fe_gb_
y^h\bluo iZjh\ hl [ebae_`Zsbo ljmih\ Lml gZqbgZ_l hg qm\kl\h\Zlv [_^kl\b_ k\h_ b
ihagZ\Zlv qlh _]h khqeb aZ f_jl\h]h b ij_^Zeb ih]j_[_gbx F_`^m l_f \ha^mo
k]msZ_lkykbeugZijy]Zxlky]jm^vih^gbfZ_lkyk ly`dbf^uoZgb_febphj^__ldjh\v
klj_fblkydh\k_fhl\_jklbyflhkdZmkm]m[ey_lkyhgj\_lm k_[y\hehkul_jaZ_ll_eh
k\h_b ieZ\Z_l\ djh\bGZihke_^hd\ kbom`ZkguokljZ^ZgbyomfbjZ_l´
Fh`gh hlf_lblv y\gh_ koh^kl\h \ hibkZgbb \g_rg_]h \b^Z miujy b q_eh\_dZ
ihohjhg_ggh]h aZ`b\h <_jhylgh bf_ggh gZoh^db ex^_c aZ^hogm\rboky \ ]jh[m b
ihkem`bebhkgh\guflheqdhfd kha^Zgbxh[jZaZmiujy: lZddZde_]_g^uh[miujyo
jZkijhkljZg_gu ih\k_f_klgh kemqZb wlbo gZoh^hd \b^bfh [ueb ^Ze_dh g_
_^bgbqgufb
H[gZjm`_gb_ ex^_c g_dh]^Z ih]j_[_gguo aZ`b\h ihkem`beb lZd`_ hkgh\hc d
kha^Zgbxh^gh]hbakZfuokljZrguoijhdeylbc³Qlh[lu\ ]jh[mi_j_\_jgmeky´
H km_\_jghf hlghr_gbb d gZoh^ysbfky \ e_lZj]bb k\b^_l_evkl\m_l nZdl
ijb\_^_gguc \ m`_ mihfbgZ\r_cky dgb]_ ?eeba_gZ ³G_dhlhjZy `_gsbgZ \ <_cfZj_
mihlj_[ey_fZy\ agZlguo^hfZo^eyh^_\Zgbymf_jrbo[m^mqb\_kvfZkm_\_jgZh^_\Zy
h^gh]hmf_jr_]hdh_]h\kdhj_ohl_ebih]j_[ZlvkdZau\ZeZqlh\ kdhjhf\j_f_gb_s_
dlhgb[m^v ba lh]h `_ k_f_ckl\Z mfj_l b[h mf_jrbc hldju\Ze \ ]jh[m ]eZaZ qlh ih
aZf_qZgbx__qZklhij_^\_sZehg_[eZ]hihemqgh_ijbdexq_gb_´
Q_eh\_d\ kbemk\hboijhn_kkbhgZevguoh[yaZgghkl_cqZklhklZedb\Zxsbckyk
mf_jrbfb \f_klh lh]h qlh[u hdZaZlv ihfhsv ijh[m`^Zxs_fmky hl khklhygby
e_lZj]bb ki_rbl kdhj__ ihohjhgblv _]h B lZdb_ kemqZb \b^bfh lZd`_ [ueb g_
_^bgbqgu
Gh \_jg_fky d dgb]_ ?eeba_gZ b ijb\_^_f _s_ g_kdhevdh ijbf_jh\ ba wlh]h
dZiblZevgh]hljm^Z
³Ijbf_j c < mgbqlh`_gghf fhgZkluj_ W gZc^_g \ dhgp_ ijhkljZggh]h
a^Zgby f_`^m jZa\Ze_ggufb ih]j_[Zfb k dj_idbfb ^\_jvfb b j_r_ldZfb ]em[hdh
e_`Zsbck\h^\ dhlhjhf^hlh]h\j_f_gbh[udgh\_gghdeZebf_jl\u_l_eZfhgZoh\^h
ih]j_[_gbyDh]^Zk_ck\h^\ dhlhjhfdjhf_g_kdhevdbo^_j_\ygguokdZf__dihdju\Ze
^ey f_jl\uo dj_klh\ b eZfiZ^ gbq_]h g_ [ueh gZqZeb h[klhyl_evg__ hkfZljb\Zlv lh
gZreb gZ kl_g_ ke_^mxsmx lsZl_evgh kl_dehf jZa[blhc eZfiZ^u h[ehfdb dh_c
e_`Zeb gZ a_fe_ gZq_jlZggmx gZ^ibkv gZ eZlbgkdhf yaud_ ² K J ³=hkih^b
IhfbemcfyHklZ\e_g`b\msbfb \ jmp_l\hbij_^Zx^mofhcKbeufhbbag_fh]eb
G_ \g_fexl \hiex fh_fm BklZ_\Zx ]eZ^hf L\hjvq_ <hgvfb fb Lj_lbc ^_gv m`_
bkl_dZ_l=hj_fg_mfbjZxs_fm´
³Ijbf_j c Ih ijbdZaZgbx ijZ\bl_evkl\Z \ ]hjh^_ I hij_^_e_gh [ueh
\ug_klb\k_gZoh^b\rb_kyih^k\h^Zfbp_jdh\gufb]jh[ub \ij_^vgbdh]^Zg_deZklv
hguo lm^Z F_`^m ijhqbfb ]jh[Zfb gZreb h^bg gh\uc hldjuluc ]jh[ \ dh_f \b^gh
[uehjZa\_jgmlh_ihdju\ZehK_c]jh[[ueimklhcb \aZ^g_fdhgp_hgZ]hgZoh^bebkv
dhklb dhb ijb ^jm]bo ijblhf ijbagZdZo ihdZau\Zeb [u\r__ f_jl\h_ l_eh dh_]h
h^gZdh`g_[ueh\ ]jh[_GZkbodhklyo[ueh_s_\ jZaguof_klZobkkhor__fykhih
dh_fmfh`gh[uehykgh\b^_lvdZd`b\hcih]j_[_gguchgh_]juaIeZlv_\ dh_f_]h
iheh`beb \k_ bahj\Zgh [ueh´ >Zgguc kemqZc lZd`_ hibkZg \h <k_h[sbo mq_guo
\_^hfhklyohlfZy]h^Z
³Ijbf_j c E_ De_jd Ijhdmjhj Ex^h\bdZ <_ebdh]h ih\_kl\m_l qlh \ lh
kZfh_\j_fydh]^Z\ Hje_Zg_mf_jrmxl_ldm_]hiheh`beb\ h[smx]jh[gbpmh^bgba
__ kem`bl_e_c\e_aghqvx\ hgmxb ohl_ekgylvm g__i_jkl_gvk jmdbFgbfZymf_jrZy
qm\kl\my kbevgmx [hev ijb j_aZgbb iZevpZ gZqZeZ djbqZlv ijbq_f \hj bkim]Zeky b
mr_e Ijbr_^rZy \ qm\kl\h `_gsbgZ \klZeZ ba ]jh[Z b hdmlZ\rbkv kZ\Zghf ijbreZ
^hfhcHgZ`beZihlhf_s_^_kylve_lb ijblhfjh^beZh^gh]hkugZ´
DklZlb g_j_^dh bf_ggh deZ^[bs_gkdb_ \hju b y\eyebkv i_j\ufb k\b^_l_eyfb
ih]j_[_gbc aZ`b\h b aZqZklmx bf_ggh bf h[yaZgu [ueb k\hbf kiZk_gb_f aZ`b\h
ih]j_[_ggu_ <h ³<jZq_[guo ba\_klbyo´ ?eeba_gZ bf_xlky _s_ ^\Z ZgZeh]bqguo
ijbf_jZ ² h ]jZ[_`_ \ kde_i_ Ydh[bgkdhc p_jd\b \ Lmema_ b h fh]bevsbd_
jZkdhiZ\r_f jZ^b ^hjh]h]h i_jklgy k\_`mx fh]bem `_gu [h]Zlh]h f_evgbdZ ba
FZ]^_[mj]Z < h[hbo kemqZyo ³ihdhcgbpu´ h`beb Z \hl km^v[Z ]jZ[bl_e_c keh`beZkv
ihjZaghfm i_j\uc kdhgqZeky hl bkim]Z Z \lhjhc ³ih kemqZx [eZ]hihemqgh]h
ihke_^kl\bymqbg_ggh]hbfobs_gby[uehk\h[h`^_ghlgZdZaZgby´
Ij_ih^h[gucR\ZjpojbklbZgkdbc fbkkbhg_j \ >_eb ijbr_e \ k_[y \h \j_fy
kh[kl\_gguo ihohjhg ijb a\mdZo ex[bfh]h ikZefZ b ijbkh_^bgbeky d ohjm ijyfh ba
]jh[ZGbdbnhj=ebdZk_ibkdhiE_k[hkkdbcijhe_`Z\^\Z^gy\ ]jh[m\klZebag_]h\
p_jd\bb ihiulZekyijbklmiblvd k\hbfh[yaZgghklyfk_j^blh\hijhrZyhdjm`Zxsbo
q_]hhgbgZg_]hmklZ\bebkv
H lhfqlhy\e_gb_ih]j_[_gbyaZ`b\h[ueh\_kvfZjZkijhkljZg_gh\ ;9,,,\_d_
k\b^_l_evkl\m_lb ih\_klvFboZbeZQmedh\Z³Kdmihcb \hj´bak[hjgbdZ³I_j_kf_rgbd
beb KeZ\ygkdb_ kdZadb´ \i_j\u_ him[ebdh\ZggZy \ KZgdlI_l_j[mj]_ \ ]h^m H
ih]j_[_gbbaZ`b\hZ\lhjjZkkdZau\Z_lg_khkljZohfZ kxfhjhfdZdh \_kvfZh[uqghf
b ^Z`_dhfbqghfy\e_gbbdZdh [ulh\hfZg_d^hl_hljZ`Zxs_fjZkoh`b_b lbibqgu_
`bl_ckdb_kblmZpbb
< ih\_klb ]h\hjblky dZd g_dbc fheh^hc fhl gbdZd g_ fh] ^h`^Zlvky dhgqbgu
k\h_]hkdmih]hhlpZqlh[uaZ\eZ^_lv\k_f_]h^h[jhf: klZjuckdjy]Z[uegZklhevdh
kdmi qlh gbdhfm g_ ^Z\Ze gb dexq_c gb i_qZlb hl deZ^h\hc >Z`_ \h \j_fy kgZ hg
dexqb ijb\yau\Ze d r__ b i_qZlv deZe \ jhl H^gZ`^u kem]Z b khh[sgbd fheh^h]h
]hkih^bgZ iulZeky mdjZklv i_qZlv bah jlZ kiys_]h klZjbdZ gh hgZ khj\ZeZkv b miZeZ
kdmipm\ ]hjlZgvLhlih^Z\bekyb mf_j
G_l_ji_eb\uc gZke_^gbd \ lhl `_ ^_gv ihohjhgbe k\h_]h hlpZ Z m`_ gZaZ\ljZ
aZl_ye k\Z^v[m K\Z^v[Z [ueZ \_k_e__ q_f ihohjhgu lZd dZd gZ g__ ^_g_] [ueh
bkljZq_gh g_ \ ijbf_j [hevr_ Ghqvx dh]^Z ohay_\Z b ]hklb gZib\rbkv ivygufb
mkgmeb kem]Z gZijZ\beky d fh]be_ kdmipZ qlh[u kgylv k g_]h ieZlv_ dklZlb dZd fu
m`_ g_ jZa m[_`^Zebkv gZ ijbf_jZo bf_ggh [eZ]h^Zjy deZ^[bs_gkdbf \hjZf \
hkgh\ghf b \kdju\Zebkv lZcgu aZ`b\h ih]j_[_gguo BlZd kem]Z jZajue fh]bem
\ulZsbeihdhcgbdZh[h[jZe_]hb klhedgmegZaZ^\ fh]bem³klhevbkijZ\ghqlhhlrb[
i_qZlvdhlhjhxihdhcgbdih^Z\beky´
³F_jl\_pbah\k_ckbeuaZdjbqZe³Ho´m \hjZih^dhkbebkvgh]bb miZebhgbh[Z
\ fh]bem ]^_ e_`Zeb hq_gv ^he]h [_a iZfylb GZdhg_p ihdhcgbd h[jZamfbeky ij_`^_
`b\h]h b ihlhf \a^mfZe h k\h_c deZ^h\hc \ue_a \_kvfZ ihki_rgh ba yfu b ih[_`Ze
^hfhc Ijb[_`Z\rb d ^\_jyf k\h_c ihdeZ`b gZr_e bo aZi_jlufb b [_a i_qZlb
[jhkbekybkdZlvk\h_]hkugZqlh[\aylvm g_]hdexqbb dh]^Z\[_`Zehg\ kiZevgxlh
fheh^Zy \ lh \j_fy g_ kiZeZ M\b^_\ f_jl\_pZ bkim]ZeZkv hgZ klhevdh ^h\hevgh qlh
khreZk mfZb hlijZ\beZkvgZlhlk\_lKlZjbdih^[_`Z\rbd kugmgZqZe_]h^_j]Zlv
\_kvfZ g_iheblbqgh Fheh^hc dgyav jZkl\hjb\ ]eZaZ b m\b^y f_jl\h]h i_j_^ kh[hc
hlpZ\kdhqbeb gZihegbe\_kv^hfhlqZyggufdjbdhf[_]Zy\_a^_b ijbau\Zy\k_ok_[_
gZihfhsvklZjbdaZgbf]hgyekyivygu_]hklbijh[m`^ZebkvkhkljZohfb [_`Zeb\k_
ba^_j_\gblZdbfh[jZahfdZdb dj_klvyg_< lh\j_fylmlgZoh^bekyZjf_ckdbchnbp_j
dhlhjucg_kh\k_f_s_ijhkiZekyb ^eylh]hg_bkim`ZekyklhevdhdZd^jm]b_[jhkbeky
\ lm]hjgbpm]^_gZoh^bebkvjm`vyih^o\Zlyh^ghaZjy^be_]hime_xb ^jh[vxb dh]^Z
[_`Zeb `b\hc kug k f_jl\uf hlphf ih ^\hjm fbfh hdhg lh hg \uklj_ebe b ^ey
ij_djZs_gby\k_]hkljZoZaZklj_ebeboh[hbo´
G_kfhljy gZ \kx Zg_d^hlbqghklv ^Zggh]h wibah^Z a^_kv fh`gh meh\blv b
g_dhlhju_lbibqgu_q_jlu^ZgghckblmZpbb\_jhylghg_h^ghdjZlghbf_\rb_f_klh
<hi_j\uowlhdjZcgyyihki_rghklvih]j_[_gbydhlhjZyijbiheghfhlkmlkl\bb
d\Zebnbpbjh\Zggh]h \jZq_[gh]h hkfhljZ ^_eh ijhbkoh^beh \ ^_j_\g_ y\eyeZkv
hkgh\ghc ijbqbghc ij_`^_\j_f_gguo aZohjhg_gbc <h\lhjuo deZ^[bs_gkdbc \hj
ijh[m`^Zxsbc ihdhcgbdZ <lj_lvbo g_ jZ^hklv Z m`Zk \k_c k_fvb ijb y\e_gbb
³h`b\r_]hf_jl\_pZ´BgZdhg_p\q_l\_jluom[bckl\hfgbfh]hihdhcgbdZ
Km^yihdhebq_kl\mkZfuojZaghh[jZaguok\b^_l_evkl\ibdih]j_[_gbcaZ`b\h
ijboh^blky gZ ;9,,, \_d B dZd fg_ dZ`_lky wlh \iheg_ aZdhghf_jgh ?keb fu
h[jZlbfkyd ebl_jZlmjgufijhba\_^_gbyflhcwihoblhm\b^bfqlh]_jhbihex[hfm
ih\h^m l_jyxl khagZgb_ iZ^Zxl \ h[fhjhd h[fbjZxl b l ^ B wlh g_ ijhklh ^Zgv
ebl_jZlmjghcfh^_Z hljZ`_gb_^_ckl\bl_evgh]hikbobq_kdh]h khklhygby h[s_kl\Z <
;,;\_d_h[fhjhdbklZgh\ylkylhevdhm^_ehf^ZfZ \;;fuijhgbom`_ijZdlbq_kdbb
g_ keurbf <_jhylgh \ ;9,,, \_d_ [ueb rbjhdh jZkijhkljZg_gu g_j\ghikbobq_kdb_
jZkkljhckl\Zihke_^kl\byfbdhlhjuoy\eyeZkve_lZj]byb ih^h[gu__ckhklhygby
< ;,;\_d_k\b^_l_evkl\h ih]j_[_gbyoaZ`b\hklZgh\blkyagZqbl_evghf_gvr_
Fh`gh\kihfgblvh kdZg^Ze_k >`hghfFZdbglZcjhfdhlhjuc \ ]h^mhqgmeky\
ehg^hgkdhf ZgZlhfbq_kdhf l_Zlj_ dh]^Z kdZevi_ev jZaj_aZe _]h ]jm^v Ke_^kl\b_
mklZgh\beh qlh l_eh _]h [ueh \udjZ^_gh ba fh]beu b ijh^Zgh \jZqZf Beb h
^jZfZlbq_kdhf kemqZ_ \ =_jfZgbb gZ deZ^[bs_ \ DZkl_g[Zmf_ dh]^Z jZa^Z\rbcky ba
fh]beurmfaZklZ\be__ jZkdhiZlv< ]jh[m[uegZc^_gaZ^hogm\rbckyq_eh\_djmdbb
]heh\Zdhlhjh]hk\b^_l_evkl\h\Zebh [_amki_rguoihiuldZojZkdjulv]jh[
< ] \ :c`_g[_j]_ rmf ba fh]beu mf_jr_c g_aZ^he]h ^h jh^h\ `_gsbgu
aZklZ\be jZkdhiZlv fh]bem HgZ [ueZ gZc^_gZ `b\hc gh hdjh\Z\e_gghc GZklmibeb
jh^u\ j_amevlZl_dhlhjuofZlvb j_[_ghdmf_jebq_j_ag_kdhevdhqZkh\
E_gbg]jZ^kdbc\jZqhlhg_\jheh]=:Mjxih\Zi_j_^ZeZfg_jZkkdZa__ ^_^ZF
I =_jZkbfh\Z mf_jr_]h \ ]h^m \ \hajZkl_ e_l F I =_jZkbfh\ jh^beky b
ijh\_e^_lkl\h\ ^_j_\g_ Hj^ugpu Fhkdh\kdhc ]m[_jgbb Dh]^Z _fm [ueh k_fv e_l \
]h^mm g_]hmf_jeZfZlv>_eh[uehhq_gv`Zjdbf e_lhfihwlhfmk ihohjhgZfb
j_rbeb ihlhjhiblvky J_[_gdZ hlhkeZeb \ e_k aZ p\_lZfb Z ihdhcgbpm l_f \j_f_g_f
iheh`bebgZklheihkj_^bba[uDh]^ZfZevqbd\_jgmekyg_ihgbfZy_s_hdhgqZl_evgh
qlhfZlvf_jl\Zhgijbgyekylhjfhrblv__ blygmlvaZjmdmB \^jm]ihdhcgbpZ\klZ_l
b^_l d ^\_jb iulZ_lky \uclb gZ mebpm gh aZigm\rbkv aZ ihjh] iZ^Z_l b \gh\v
aZklu\Z_l Bkim]Zggu_ jh^kl\_ggbdb ihlhjhibebkv ihohjhgblv __ \ lhl `_ ^_gv ^h
aZoh^ZkhegpZ
< ^Zgghf ijbf_j_ fu hiylv klZedb\Z_fky k g_\_`_kl\hf b km_\_jb_f
hdjm`Zxsbo dhlhju_ \f_klh lh]h qlh[u hdZaZlv ihfhsv [hevghfm klj_fylky dZd
fh`ghkdhj__ihohjhgblv_]hdZdihdhcgbdZ
=jhfZ^gh_ dhebq_kl\h im[ebdZpbc h ih]j_[_gguo aZ`b\h \uau\Zeh ihjhc
fZkkh\u_ kljZob i_j_^ wlbf y\e_gb_f HljZ`_gb_f wlbo kljZoh\ b y\ey_lky jZkkdZa
W^]ZjZ Ih ³AZ`b\h ih]j_[_ggu_´ =_jhc jZkkdZaZ ³h^_j`bfuc ijbklmiZfb
lZbgkl\_gghc [he_agb dhlhjmx \jZqb mkeh\gh gZau\Zxl dZlZe_ikb_c´ \_jhylgh j_qv
b^_lm`_h[ba\_klghcgZfe_lZj]bbiZgbq_kdb[hblky[ulvihohjhg_gguf`b\ufHg
lZd ³jZkihjy^beky i_j_kljhblv k\hc k_f_cguc kde_i qlh[u _]h fh`gh [ueh hldjulv
bagmljb Hl fZe_cr_]h gZ`bfZ gZ ^ebgguc juqZ] \u\_^_gguc ^Ze_dh \ ]em[bgm
]jh[gbpu `_e_agu_ ^\_jb lhlqZk jZkiZob\Zebkv ;ueb k^_eZgu hl^mrbgu
ijhimkdZ\rb_\ha^mob k\_lZ lZd`_m^h[gu_ojZgbebsZ^eyibsbb \h^u^hdhlhjuo
fh`gh[uehk\h[h^gh^hlygmlvkyba]jh[ZKZfuc]jh[[ue\ukleZgbagmljbfy]dhcb
l_iehch[b\dhcb djurdm_]hkgZ[^beblZdbf`_ijbkihkh[e_gb_fqlhb ^\_jbkde_iZ
k ijm`bgZfb dhlhju_ hldb^u\Zeb __ ijb fZe_cr_f ^\b`_gbb l_eZ Djhf_ lh]h ih^
k\h^hf kde_iZ [ue ih^\_r_g [hevrhc dhehdhe b \_j_\dm hl g_]h ^he`gu [ueb
ijhimklblv q_j_a hl\_jklb_ \ ]jh[m b ijb\yaZlv d jmd_´ Gh b wlb mobsj_gby g_
kiZkZeb[hevgh]hhlihklhyggh]hkljZoZqlhijbklmie_lZj]bbkemqblky]^_eb[h\ imlb
b hg[m^_lihohjhg_gg_agZdhfufbex^vfbgZh[uqghfdeZ^[bs_
Dhg_qgh wlh hibkZgb_ \aylh ba ebl_jZlmjgh]h ijhba\_^_gby gh hgh \iheg_
hljZ`Z_l ohly b k g_dhlhjhc ^he_c xfhjZ mfhgZkljh_gb_ lhc wihob <hl hibkZgb_
<_cfZjkdh]h ^hfZ ^ey mf_jrbo ijb\_^_ggh_ \ gZmqghf f_^bpbgkdhf ba^Zgbb ;9,,,
\_dZ³< <_cfZj_^hf^eymf_jrbo\ukljh_ggZdeZ^[bs_b khklhblba[hevrhcaZeu
\ dhlhjhc k\h[h^gh fh`gh ihf_klblv \hk_fv f_jl\uo l_e ;eba k_c aZeu gZoh^blky
ba[Z kh kl_deyggufb ^\_jvfb ^ey kljZ`Z ^Z[u hg [_kij_klZggh fh] kfhlj_lv gZ
f_jl\u_l_eZb dmogy^eyijb]hlh\e_gbygm`guoihkh[bcdh]^Zmf_jrbch`b\_ldZd
lh [Zgv b ijhq__ Hij_^_e_gh agZlgh_ gZ]jZ`^_gb_ lhfm dlh i_j\uc ijbf_lbl
ijbagZd`bagb<_^_ghijb\yau\Zlvgbldbdh\k_f^\b`bfufqZklyfd jmdZfb gh]Zf
ihdhcgbdZ dhbo fZe_cr__ ^\b`_gb_ magZ_lky ih a\hgm dhehdhevqbdZ d dh_fm
ijb\yau\Zxlhgu_gblb´
Ijh_dl wlh]h ^hfZ ijbgZ^e_`bl ba\_klghfm g_f_pdhfm \jZqm ;9,,, \_dZ =
=mn_eZg^m `b\r_fm b jZ[hlZ\r_fm \ <_cfZj_ b hl^Z\r_fm fgh]h kbe ^ey
ij_^hl\jZs_gby ij_`^_\j_f_gguo ih]j_[_gbc Hkh[u_ ^hfZ ^ey mf_jrbo ih h[jZapm
\_cfZjkdh]h[uebmqj_`^_gu\ =Zf[mj]_Jb]_b g_dhlhjuo^jm]bo]hjh^ZogZqZklgu_
ih`_jl\h\Zgby Z \ jy^_ f_kl [ueb hldjulu ZgZeh]bqgu_ ijZ\bl_evkl\_ggu_
mqj_`^_gby
< ^jm]bojmdh\h^kl\Zolh]h\j_f_gbfh`gh\klj_lblvb lZdb_kh\_lu³G_dh]^Z
ijb^_eu\Zeb d ]jh[Zf ljm[u dhb \uoh^beb gZjm`m ^Z[u mkeurZlv djbd h`b\r_]h
q_eh\_dZ >jm]b_ kh\_lh\Zeb deZklv ih]j_[_gghfm \ jmdb g_dhlhju_ bgkljmf_glu
^Z[uhgdh]^Zh`b\_lkZffh]\ue_albba]jh[Z´
< Jhkkbckdhc Bfi_jbb ihiuldb mqj_`^_gby hkh[uo ^hfh\ ^ey mf_jrbo k
p_evxij_^hl\jZs_gbyboij_`^_\j_f_ggh]hih]j_[_gby[uebij_^ijbgyluihq_lguf
qe_ghf =hkm^Zjkl\_gghc F_^bpbgkdhc Dhee_]bb ^hdlhjhf f_^bpbgu Bh]Zgghf
?eeba_ghf Gh ^ey ]jhfZ^ghc Bfi_jbb lZdh_ ij_^ijbylb_ \ lh \j_fy [ueh
g_\uihegbfhb ijh_dluwlbaZl_jyebkv\ [xjhdjZlbq_kdboeZ[bjbglZoM`_\ ]h^m
?eeba_gk ]hj_qvxdhgklZlbjm_l³KZfh_kb_mqj_`^_gb_ klhevfZehba\_klghqlhy
g_kfhljygZmqbg_ggu_fghxij_ihjmq_gby\hfgh]bof_klZob ihkb_\j_fyg_fh]m
ihemqblvhibkZgbyhgZ]h´
Lh]^Z?eeba_g^_eZ_lihiuldm³\hfgh]bo[hevrbob fZeuoh[eZklyohij_^_eylv
hkh[eb\uof_^bpbgkdboqbgh\^eyhk\b^_l_evkl\h\Zgbyf_jl\uo´Ghihkdhevdm\ lh
\j_fy g_hldm^Z [ueh \aylv lZdh_ dhebq_kl\h f_^bdh\ Z ³g_mq_guo ex^_c qZklbd´
ljm^ghZ qZklbqgh[_kihe_agh[ueh[ugZklZ\eylv\ gm`guoagZgbyo´lhb hlwlhcb^_b
ijbrehkv hldZaZlvky Gh ?eeba_g \k_p_eh m\e_q_gguc b^__c ij_^hl\jZs_gby
ij_`^_\j_f_gguoih]j_[_gbcg_ij_djZsZ_lk\hbomkbebc
JhkkbckdbfKbgh^hf³k ^Z\gbom`_\j_f_g[uehmqj_`^_gh^Z[ug_ih]j_[Zeb
f_jl\uo ij_`^_ ljb ^gy ihke_ kf_jlb´ ?eeba_g [hj_lky aZ g_mdhkgbl_evgZ
kh[ex^_gb_wlh]hihklZgh\e_gbyGhwlh[ueh^Ze_dg_ijhklh< JhkkbckdhcBfi_jbb
ijh`b\Zebex^bjZaebqguogZpbhgZevghkl_cjZaebqguo\_jhbkih\_^Zgbc
?eeba_g ibr_l ³F_`^m fgh]bfb gZjh^Zfb ih^\eZklgufb Jhkkbckdhfm
kdbi_ljm g_l gb h^gh]h bkdexqZy ?\j_ckdbc dh_]h [u \_jZ fh]eZ ij_^iheZ]Zlv
ij_iylkl\byb aZljm^g_gbyd \uiheg_gbxij_^eZ]Z_fuokh\_lh\^eyij_^hojZg_gbyhl
klhev m`Zkgh]h [_^kl\by `b\m [ulv ih]j_[_gguf ?\j_b bf_xl aeh\j_^gh_
h[udgh\_gb_ih]j_[Zlvmf_jrboij_^aZoh`^_gb_fkhegpZ\ lhkZfuc^_gv\ dhlhjuc
hgbmf_jeb´?eeba_ghrb[Z_lky²ZgZeh]bqguoh[uqZ_\ih]j_[_ijb^_j`b\Zebkvg_
lhevdh _\j_b gh b fmkmevfZgA gZjh^u djufkdb_ dZaZgkdb_ [Zrdbju gh]Zcpu ² K
J
K ^jm]hcklhjhgupZjkdZyZ^fbgbkljZpbykZfZg_j_^dhgZjmrZeZij_^ibkZgby
K\ys_ggh]h Kbgh^Z LZd \h \j_fy fZkkh\uo wib^_fbc hkiu qmfu ohe_ju b ^jm]bo
bgn_dpbhgguo [he_ag_c \ p_eyo ij_^hl\jZs_gb_ ^Zevg_cr_]h jZkijhkljZg_gby
aZ[he_\Zgbc [ueh ij_^ ibkZgh ohjhgblv mf_jrbo dZd fh`gh kdhj__ ?eeba_] kqblZe
qlh ijb wlhf g_ bkdexqZebkv kemqZb ij_`^_ \j_f_ggh]h ih]j_[_gby gZoh^b\rboky \
h[fhjhqghfkhklhygbb^Z\_jhylg__\k_]hlZdhghb [ueh
GZdhg_p ?eeba_g gZoh^bl kihkh[ ij_^hl\jZs_gb_ ij_`^_\j_f_ggh]h
ih]j_[_gby ³\_kvfZ m^h[guc dh \k_ h[s_fm \uiheg_gbx´ IjZ\^Z hg ijbagZ_lky qlh
³FP bah[j_l_gb_ mqbg_gh g_ fghx gh keZ\guf \jZqhf Ojbklhnhjhf Ex^h\bdhf
=hnfZghf lZcguf Kh\_lgbdhf b E_c[ F_^bdhf D_evgkdh]h DmjnbjklZ´ < q_f `_
aZdexqZ_lky wlh bah[j_l_gb_" Ih kms_kl\m ?eeba_] ij_^eZ]Z_l hkms_kl\eylv
ih]j_[_gb_ g_ jZg__ q_f [m^ml aZj_]bkljbjh\Zgu ljmigu_ y\e_gby y\eyxsb_ky
g_h[jZlbfufb h ljmiguo y\e_gbyo fu m`_ ibkZe´ \ ij_^u^msbo ]eZ\Zo : lZd dZd
lZdhc gZmdb dZd lZgZlheh]by \ijhq_f dZd y iZlheh]bq_kdZy ZgZlhfby b km^_[gZy
f_^bpbgZ \ lh \j_fy _s_ g_ kms_kl\h\Zeh l_ ba \k_o ljmiguo y\e_gbc [ue hlh[jZg
ebrv h^bg gZb[he__ yjdbc b g_khfg_gguc ijbagZd ² ]gb_gb_ Wib]jZnhf d k\h_c
dgb]_?eeba_g\ayebaj_q_gb_=mn_eZg^Z³=^_g_l]gbehklblZfgbdlhg_fh`_l[ulv
Km^v_xf_`^mkf_jlvxb `bagvx´DZd[ujZa\b\Zyfukev=mn_eZg^Z?eeba_g^_eZ_l
hkgh\ghc\u\h^k\h_]hdZiblZevgh]hjmdh\h^kl\Z³DZdkdhjhhdZ`_lkyf_jl\ucaZiZo
lh\ lh`_\j_fybkq_aZ_l\kygZ^_`^ZgZ\ha\jZs_gb_d `bagbDZdkdhjhihke_kf_jlb
hdZ`_lky beb mkbeblky f_jl\uc aZiZo lh lZdh\u_ f_jl\u_ l_eZ iheh`b\rb \ ]jh[ b
aZdj_ib\rbhgucdZdfh`ghkdhj__^he`ghih]j_[Zlv´
Bf_ggh k jZ[hl =mn_eZg^Z b ?eeba_gZ gZqbgZ_lky kha^Zgb_ km^_[gh
f_^bpbgkdhclZgZlheh]bb< gZklhys__\j_fy\hijhkh[hiZkghklbih]j_[_gbyaZ`b\h
ebp gZoh^ysboky \ khklhygbb e_lZj]bb iheghklvx mljZlbe k\h_ agZq_gb_ lZd dZd
ih]j_[_gb_ h[uqgh ijhba\h^blky q_j_a ² kmlhd ihke_ kf_jlb dh]^Z ^hklh\_jgu_
ljmigu_y\e_gby[u\Zxlm`_ohjhrh\ujZ`_gu
?keb e_lZj]by k\h_\j_f_ggh g_ mklZgh\e_gZ lh \hafh`gh hrb[hqgh_
ZgZlhfbq_kdh_ bkke_^h\Zgb_ ³ljmiZ´ fgbfhmf_jr_]h q_eh\_dZ qlh gZ[ex^Z_lky \
km^_[ghf_^bpbgkdhc ijZdlbd_ djZcg_ j_^dh G_ijZ\bevgZy dhgklZlZpby gZklmie_gby
bklbgghc kf_jlb \ke_^kl\b_ g_^hklZlhqgh]h h[ke_^h\Zgby fgbfhmf_jr_]h fh`_l
ijb\_klb d g_hdZaZgbx f_^bpbgkdhc ihfhsb qlh ijb mkeh\byo ij_^mkfhlj_gguo
m]heh\guf aZdhgh^Zl_evkl\hf klZgh\blky ijhn_kkbhgZevguf ijZ\hgZjmr_gb_f
>_ckl\mxsb_ ³IjZ\beZ km^_[ghf_^bpbgkdh]h bkke_^h\Zgby ljmih\´ mdZau\Zxl qlh
\kdjulb_g_^he`ghijhba\h^blvkyijbfZe_cr_fkhfg_gbb\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklbkf_jlb
\ lZdbokemqZyog_h[oh^bfhijbgbfZlv\k_f_jud h`b\e_gbx
B \k_lZdbg_kfhljygb gZqlhkemqZbih]j_[_gbyaZ`b\h\klj_qZxlkyb \gZrb
^gb < ^_dZ[j_ ] h^bg ba ehg^hgp_\ \ \hajZkl_ e_l ihl_jye khagZgb_ [ue
ijbagZg f_jl\uf b hqgmeky \ ]jh[m \ h^ghf ba ]hjh^kdbo fhj]h\ < lhf `_ ] \
h^ghf ba fhj]h\ GvxChjdZ ihke_ i_j\h]h ijbdhkgh\_gby kdZevi_ey h`b\rbc ³ljmi´
\p_ibeky\ ]hjehiZlheh]hZgZlhfmLhlmf_jhlrhdZZ ³\hkdj_krbc´\hafh`gh`b\_lb
ihgug_
< g_dhlhjuo m]hedZo :abb :njbdb EZlbgkdhc :f_jbdb ij_`^_\j_f_ggu_
ih]j_[_gby fh]ml \klj_lblvky g_kdhevdh qZs_ Wlhfm kihkh[kl\mxl l_ `_ nZdlhju
dhlhju_ fu mihfbgZeb \ k\h_ \j_fy ]h\hjy h[ ³wib^_fbb´ aZohjhg_gbc aZ`b\h \
kj_^gb_ \_dZ b \iehlv ^h dhgpZ ;9,,, \_dZ ² hlkmlkl\b_ kbkl_fu f_^bpbgkdh]h
hk\b^_l_evkl\h\Zgbymf_jrbob j_eb]bhagu_h[uqZblj_[mxsb_kebrdhfihki_rgh]h
ih]j_[_gby < ^hdZaZl_evkl\h wlh]h ijb\h^bf aZf_ldm ba ]Za_lu ³KhpbZebklbq_kdZy
bg^mkljby´
< ijh\bgpbb :kbj gZ x]_ KZm^h\kdhc :jZ\bb g_dbc FmZllZd AZnbj :r
RZojZgbih]j_[_gguck\hbfbjh^kl\_ggbdZfby\bekyd ^hfZrg_fmhqZ]mihke_lh]h
dZdijhe_`Ze\ fh]be_[he__kmlhd< j_amevlZl_klhevg_h`b^Zggh]h\bablZex[bfh]h
kugZb [jZlZfZlvb k_klju:rRZojZgbmf_jebhlihljyk_gby
Ijbqbghc ³kf_jlb´ kZm^h\pZ y\beky m^Zj djuehf \_ljyghc f_evgbpu \h \j_fy
ijh\_^_gby j_fhglguo jZ[hl baaZ q_]h hg ihl_jye khagZgb_ G_ kmf_\ ijb\_klb :r
RZojZgb\ qm\kl\hjh^kl\_ggbdbihkqblZ\_]hf_jl\ufaZ\_jgmebFmZllZdZ\ kZ\Zgb
ihohjhgbebIjhe_`Z\³f_jl\uf´\ a_fe_[he__qZkh\:rRZojZgbijbr_e\ k_[yhl
lhihlZ dhiul iZkmsboky h\_p b klZe djbqZlv IZklmob jZkdhiZeb fh]bem Dh]^Z hgb
m\b^_ebkZ\Zgboho\Zlbem`Zkb hgbm[_`Zeb
Gh\k_wlhebrvj_^db_bkdexq_gbyih^l\_j`^Zxsb_ijZ\behdhlhjh_]eZkbl
gZkh\j_f_gghfmjh\g_jZa\blbyf_^bpbgub hj]ZgbaZpbbf_^bpbgkdhcihfhsbkemqZb
ih]j_[_gby aZ`b\h iheghklvx bkdexq_gu Bf_\rb_ky \ ijhrehf nZdlu
ij_`^_\j_f_gguo aZohjhg_gbc ij_^klZ\eyxl \ gZklhys__ \j_fy g_ gZmqguc beb
f_^bpbgkdbcZ lhevdhbklhjbq_kdbcbgl_j_k
EBL?J:LMJ:
W^]ZjIh JZkkdZauF³Om^ebl_jZlmjZ´
F_a_gp_\<: Qm^_kZIhimeyjgZywgpbdehi_^by²:efZ:lZ
=ej_^DZakh\wgpbdehi_^bbLdgb]Z
S_j[Zdh\ZH KiysZydjZkZ\bpZijh[m`^Z_lky"ihfZl_jbZeZf`mjgZeZ³KZg^b
kihjl´:g]eby³Dhfkhfhevkdh_agZfy´Db_\n_\jZey
;hevrZyf_^bpbgkdZywgpbdehi_^byBa^Zgb_\lhjh_F³Kh\_lkdZy
wgpbdehi_^by´,lhf
;hevrZyf_^bpbgkdZywgpbdehi_^byBa^Zgb_lj_lv_F³Kh\_lkdZy
wgpbdehi_^by´lhf
I_qZevgh_\hkdj_r_gb_²³KhpbZebklbq_kdZybg^mkljby´Z\]mklZ
:GFmjZ\v_\ Iml_r_kl\b_ihk\yluff_klZfjmkkdbfKI;]h^
<jZq_[gu_ba\_klbyh ij_`^_\j_f_gghfih]j_[_gbbf_jl\uokh[jZggu_B=>
?eeba_ghfKZgdlI_l_j[mj]
Dbiebg]J JZkkdZauKlbohl\hj_gbyE³Om^h`ebl_jZlmjZ´
I_jkb^kdb_gZjh^gu_Zg_d^hluF³GZmdZ´
;>_^xobg K_j^pZkhdjmr_ggu_³<he]Z´‹ GFDZjZfabg Ij_^Zgby\_dh\F³IjZ\^Z´
Ih\_klbjZamfgu_b aZfukeh\Zlu_IhimeyjgZy[ulh\ZyijhaZ
;9, \_dZF³Kh\j_f_ggbd´
: E =mj_\bq DmevlmjZ b h[s_kl\h kj_^g_\_dh\hc ?\jhiu ]eZaZfb
kh\j_f_ggbdh\F³Bkdmkkl\h´
IjhfbgvkdZW Bkq_agm\rb_[he_agb³GZmdZb `bagv´ ‹ =E:<:9,,
K\b^_l_evkl\m_lljmi
?kebm`^hjh]hcqblZl_ev\u\ayebkvaZbamq_gb_lZgZlheh]bblh\ZfgbdZdg_
ijhclb fbfh h^gh]h ba __ jZa^_eh\ bamqZxs_]h ijhy\e_gby kf_jlb >ey
g_ih^]hlh\e_ggh]h qblZl_ey g_agZdhfh]h k hkgh\Zfb ghjfZevghc b iZlheh]bq_kdhc
ZgZlhfbb b nbabheh]bb gbdh]^Z g_ [u\Z\r_]h \ ZgZlhfbq_kdbo l_ZljZo f_^bpbgkdbo
bgklblmlh\ l_fZ wlZ fh`_l ihdZaZlvky q_j_kqmj fjZqghc b kljZrghc Z ihlhfm y [u
kh\_lh\Zebfijhimklblvwlm]eZ\mbijhebklgm\g_kdhevdhkljZgbpkjZam`_i_j_clbd
^jm]bfjZa^_eZfL_o`_dlhj_rbeke_^h\ZlvaZgZfb^hdhgpZy ijbau\ZxaZiZklbkv
l_ji_gb_f
Qlh `_ ijhbkoh^bl k l_ehf q_eh\_dZ kjZam ihke_ gZklmie_gby kf_jlb" L_eh
ij_\jZsZ_lky \ ljmi b ijhbkoh^ysb_ \ g_f baf_g_gby ihemqbeb gZa\Zgb_ ljmiguo
y\e_gbc Ljmigu_ y\e_gby h[uqgh ^_eyl gZ ^\_ ]jmiiu jZggb_ ljmigu_ y\e_gby
jZa\b\Zxsb_ky\ l_q_gb_i_j\uokmlhdihke_kf_jlbb iha^gb_gZqbgZxsb_kyh[uqgh
kh \lhjuo kmlhd b ^Z`_ iha`_ b jZa\b\Zxsb_ky \ l_q_gb_ [he__ beb f_g__
ijh^he`bl_evgh]hkjhdZ
D jZggbf ljmiguf y\e_gbyf hlghkylky hoeZ`^_gb_ ljmiZ _]h \ukuoZgb_
ihy\e_gb_ljmiguoiyl_gljmigh_hdhq_g_gb_b g_dhlhju_^jm]b_y\e_gbyAgZykjhdb
gZklmie_gby wlbo y\e_gbc b bo aZdhghf_jghklb fh`gh k [hevrhc lhqghklvx
hij_^_eblv \j_fy gZklmie_gby kf_jlb Hkh[_ggh [hevrh_ agZq_gb_ wlh bf__l ^ey
djbfbgZebklh\ <k_ fu \ [hevr_c beb f_gvr_c f_j_ m\e_dZebkv ^_l_dlb\Zfb l_i_jv
gZfij_^klhblhagZdhfblvkyk ZaZfbjZ[hlukm^_[ghf_^bpbgkdh]hwdki_jlZ
HoeZ`^_gb_ ljmiZ ijhbkoh^bl ^h\hevgh f_^e_ggh Hgh gZqbgZ_lky k
ih\_joghklb l_eZ l_fi_jZlmjZ dhlhjhc gZ hldjuluo f_klZo m`_ q_j_a r_klv^_kylv
qZkh\ fh`_l kjZ\gylvky k l_fi_jZlmjhc hdjm`Zxs_]h \ha^moZ Ijb dhfgZlghc
l_fi_jZlmj_ l_fi_jZlmjZ mf_jr_]h iZ^Z_l dZ`^uc qZk ijb[ebabl_evgh gZ ƒ ihwlhfm
^ey ihegh]h hoeZ`^_gby ljmiZ ^h l_fi_jZlmju hdjm`Zxs_c kj_^u lj_[m_lky hdheh
kmlhd
Gh ba wlh]h ijZ\beZ _klv fgh]h bkdexq_gbc dh]^Z hoeZ`^_gb_ mkdhjy_lky beb
aZf_^ey_lky²gZijbf_jgZfhjha_beb\ kbevgmx`Zjm< j_^dbokemqZyol_fi_jZlmjZ
ihke_ kf_jlb fh`_l g_dhlhjh_ \j_fy ih^gbfZlvky ijb kf_jlb hl ohe_ju klhe[gydZ
k_ikbkZb lhevdhaZl_fgZqbgZ_liZ^Zlv
< km^_[ghc f_^bpbg_ kqblZ_lky qlh lhevdh l_fi_jZlmjZ l_eZ \ ƒ b gb`_
ih^l\_j`^Z_l gZebqb_ kf_jlb LZdhc l_fi_jZlmju ljmi ^hklb]Z_l ^Z`_ ijb kZfuo
[eZ]hijbylguo ^ey hoeZ`^_gby mkeh\byo g_ jZgvr_ q_f q_j_a ² qZkh\ ihke_
kf_jlbLZdbfh[jZahfagZyaZdhguhoeZ`^_gbyljmiZ]jZ^mkaZqZkijbdhfgZlghc
l_fi_jZlmj_ djbfbgZebkl fh`_l hij_^_eblv \j_fy gZklmie_gby kf_jlb qlh [u\Z_l
qj_a\uqZcgh\Z`ghijbjZkke_^h\Zgbbm]heh\guo^_e
>jm]bfb g_hkihjbfufb gZb[he__ jZggbfb ijbagZdZfb gZklmib\r_c kf_jlb
kem`Zl lZd gZau\Z_fu_ ljmigu_ iylgZ Ljmigu_ iylgZ \hagbdZxl \ke_^kl\b_ kl_dZgby
djh\b \gba \ kbem ly`_klb hlq_]h \ur_e_`Zsb_ qZklb [e_^g_xl \ gb`_e_`Zsbo
qZklyo djh\v i_j_ihegy_l khkm^u b gZqbgZ_l ijhk\_qb\Zlv q_j_a dh`m \ \b^_
nbhe_lh\uobebebeh\uoiyl_gLjmigu_iylgZihy\eyxlkym`_q_j_a^\Zq_luj_ qZkZ
ihke_ kf_jlb Ijb gZ^Z\eb\Zgbb hgb [e_^g_xl Z ijb i_j_\hjZqb\Zgbb ljmiZ
i_j_f_sZxlkygZgh\h_e_`Zs__gb`_f_klh
Kh\lhjuokmlhdhlgZklmie_gbykf_jlb\ke_^kl\b_ijhiblu\Zgbyfy]dboldZg_c
b dh`b djh\vx ba khkm^h\ ljmigu_ iylgZ m`_ g_ i_j_f_sZxlky ijb i_j_f_g_
iheh`_gbyljmiZb g_f_gyxlk\hcp\_lijbgZ^Z\eb\ZgbbKlZ^bbljmiguoiyl_gfh]ml
^Zlvlhqgu_mdZaZgbyh \j_f_gbgZklmie_gbykf_jlbD lhfm`_qlhhkh[_ggh\Z`gh^ey
djbfbgZebklZ hgb jZa b gZ\k_]^Z nbdkbjmxl iheh`_gb_ ljmiZ LZd _keb ljmi [ue
h[gZjm`_g \ iheh`_gbb gZ kibg_ Z ljmigu_ iylgZ jZkiheZ]Zxlky gZ ebp_ ]jm^b b
`b\hl_lhkjZamklZgh\blkyykghqlhjZg__hggZoh^beky\ iheh`_gbbgZ]jm^bb ebrv
aZl_fk dZdhclhp_evxfh`_l [ulvk p_evx khdjulby ij_klmie_gby [ue i_j_\_jgml
iZkibgm
GZjy^m k ljmigufb iylgZfb h^gbf ba \Z`g_crbo jZggbo ljmiguo y\e_gbc
y\ey_lkyihkf_jlgh_hdhq_g_gb_<kdhj_ihke_kf_jlb\k_furpuljmiZjZkkeZ[eyxlky
klZgh\ylky fy]dbfb b ih^Zleb\ufb H^gZdh kimkly g_dhlhjh_ \j_fy \k_ furpu
ihkl_i_ggh klZgh\ylky [he__ iehlgufb l\_j^ufb ke_]dZ khdjZsZxlky b nbdkbjmxl
ljmi\ hij_^_e_gghfiheh`_gbbdhlhjh_hq_gvljm^ghbaf_gblvlZddZd^eywlh]hgZ^h
ijbeh`blv ^h\hevgh
[hevrmx kbem LZdh_ ljmigh_ hdhq_g_gb_ ^_j`blky g_dhlhjh_
\j_fyb aZl_fihkl_i_gghq_j_ah^bg^\Z^gybkq_aZ_l
<g_rgb_ ijbagZdb ljmigh]h hdhq_g_gby ihy\eyxlky m`_ q_j_a ^\Zq_luj_ qZkZ
ihke_ kf_jlb bgh]^Z ^Z`_ jZgvr_ b kem`Zl gZ^_`guf djbl_jb_f g_h[jZlbfhklb
gZklmib\rbo baf_g_gbc hj]ZgbafZ Hdhq_g_gb_ gZqbgZ_lky \ h[eZklb q_exklguo
furp dhlhju_ nbdkbjmxl q_exklv \ hij_^_e_gghf iheh`_gbb jZkdjuluc beb
aZdjuluc jhl AZl_f hdhq_g_gb_ ihkl_i_ggh jZkijhkljZgy_lky dgbam b aZo\Zlu\Z_l
r_xjmdb]jm^v`b\hlgh]bb ddhgpmkmlhdihke_kf_jlbbgh]^Z^Z`_q_j_a²
qZkh\ \_kv ljmi gZoh^blky \ khklhygbb hdhq_g_gby Ihwlhfm ih h[uqZx fgh]bo
gZjh^h\ kjZam ihke_ gZklmie_gby kf_jlb aZdju\Zxl ]eZaZ b deZ^ml gZ \_db ly`_eu_
fhg_lu qlh[u khojZgblv bo \_db \ wlhf iheh`_gbb ih^\yau\Zxl q_exklv
nbdkbjmxljmdbb gh]b
Ijb ljmighf hdhq_g_gbb g_j_^dh hq_gv ohjhrh khojZgy_lky ihaZ q_eh\_dZ \
fhf_gl kf_jlb Z ih kl_i_gb ho\ZlZ hl^_evguo ]jmii furp ljmiguf hdhq_g_gb_f
fh`ghihemqblvmdZaZgbyh \j_f_gbgZklmie_gbykf_jlb
JZ[hlZ km^_[ghf_^bpbgkdbo wdki_jlh\ ijb hkfhlj_ ljmiZ hdZau\Z_l
g_hp_gbfmx ihfhsv ke_^kl\bx < dZq_kl\_ ijbf_jZ ijb\_^_f rbjhdh ba\_klgh_ \
m]heh\guo e_lhibkyo Jhkkbb ^_eh =be_\bqZ kh\_jrb\r_]h a\_jkdh_ m[bckl\h \
I_l_j[mj]_
]h hdly[jy ]h^Z \ h^ghc ba d\Zjlbj ^hfZ ‹ ih E_rlmdh\m i_j_medm
h[gZjm`beb^hg_magZ\Z_fhklbh[_ah[jZ`_ggucb h[_a]eZ\e_ggucljmiHdhehdjh\Zlb
gZdhlhjhce_`ZeljmigZoh^behkvZddmjZlghkeh`_ggh_ieZlv_jy^hfklhyeb[hlbgdb
Ijbijbf_jd_g_lhevdh[hlbgdbijbrebkvihgh]ZfljmiZghb ieZlv_gZklhevdhlhqgh
ih^oh^behd jZaf_jZfl_eZm[blh]hqlhdZaZehkvkrblufgZg_]hihf_jd_
G_bkdmr_ggucq_eh\_dihke_wlh]hih`Zemc hl[jhkbe[u\kydb_khfg_gbygZ
qlh ij_klmigbd b jZkkqblu\Ze Ijhbahreh `_ gZh[hjhl Khfg_gby _s_ [he__
mkbebebkv Ij_klmigbd mimklbe ba \b^m qlh ihke_ kf_jlb hl^_evgu_ qZklb l_eZ
\uly]b\Zxlky \ke_^kl\b_ jZkkeZ[e_gby furp Ih wlhc ijbqbg_ ieZlv_ krblh_ ih
f_jd_kgylhck `b\h]h\k_]^ZhdZ`_lkyfZehljmim
WlZ i_j\Zy hiehrghklv ij_klmigbdZ iha\hebeZ \ ^Zevg_cr_f jZafhlZlv \_kv
dem[hd obljhmfgh]h aeh^_ckl\Z G_dlh :g^j_c =be_\bq aZkljZoh\Ze k\hx `bagv gZ
hq_gv djmigmx kmffm Ihke_ _]h kf_jlb kljZoh\h_ \hagZ]jZ`^_gb_ ^he`_g [ue
ihemqblv_]h[jZlDhgklZglbg =be_\bqK p_evx fhr_ggbq_kdh]h ihemq_gby ^_g_] :
=be_\bq ihr_e gZ m[bckl\h klm^_glZ IZ\eZ Ih^empdh]h g_aZ^he]h ^h lh]h
ihklmib\r_]h d g_fm gZ kem`[m k_dj_lZj_f Ljmi Ih^empdh]h hg mfure_ggh
h[_ah[jZabe ^h g_magZ\Z_fhklb Z kZf kdjueky aZ ]jZgbpm L_i_jv hklZ\Zehkv m[_^blv
\k_o\ lhfqlh:=be_\bqiZe³`_jl\hcij_klmie_gby´Ihwlhfmy\bekyD=be_\bqb
j_rbl_evgh ³hihagZe´ ljmi k\h_]h ³ih]b[r_]h´ [jZlZ b _]h h^_`^m Ij_klmigbdZf
dZaZehkv qlh \k_ bfb ij_^mkfhlj_gh \k_ ijh^mfZgh b klhlukyqgZy kljZoh\Zy ij_fby
kdhjhhdZ`_lky\ bojmdZoGhdZd]h\hjblkyg_lmllh[ueh
Mki_ob \jZq_c ijb h[ke_^h\Zgbb ljmih\ m[bluo ijb\_eb d \hagbdgh\_gbx
fgh]hqbke_gguoe_]_g^b fbnh\H^gZbalZdbogZb[he__jZkijhkljZg_gguob `b\mqbo
e_]_g^²wlhe_]_g^Zh lhfqlh\ ]eZamm[blh]hhli_qZlu\Z_lkyihjlj_lm[bcpu
E_]_g^Z wlZ gZreZ hljZ`_gb_ \ kx`_l_ jhfZgZ @xey <_jgZ ³;jZlvy Dbi´
Hibku\Zy m[bckl\h dZiblZgZ =Zjjb >`b[khgZ @xev ;_jg mihfbgZ_l h
nhlh]jZnbq_kdhf kgbfd_ k^_eZgghf k _s_ hklZ\rboky hldjulufb ]eZa m[blh]h Wlhl
kgbfhd ku]jZe j_rZxsmx jhev \ hijZ\^Zgbb [jZlv_\ Dbi g_\bggh h[\bg_gguo \
m[bckl\_b bah[ebqbeih^ebgguom[bcp²fZljhkh\Neyc^`Z;hevlZb MbgZFh^Zqvb
h[jZauaZi_qZle_ggu_gZk_lqZld_]eZam[blh]hhlh[jZabebkvgZnhlhkgbfd_
GZkdhevdh \_ebdZ [ueZ \_jZ \ j_Zevghklv hilh]jZnbb lZd gZau\Zeb y\e_gb_
khojZg_gby bah[jZ`_gby m[bcpu \ ]eZaZo ljmiZ ihdZau\Z_l ke_^mxsbc kemqZc <
yg\Zjkdbc \_q_j ] \ I_l_j[mj]_ ijhbahreh m[bckl\h b_jhfhgZoZ :e_dkZg^jh
G_\kdhc eZ\ju BeeZjbhgZ <hl dZdbf h[jZahf B > Imlbebg hq_\b^_p l_o kh[ulbc
jbkm_lh^bgbafhf_glh\hkfhljZf_klZijhbkr_kl\by³Hlhc^bl_]hkih^Z\ klhjhgm
²h[jZlbekyd gZf^hdlhjFuhlhrebhlhdgZ>hdlhjgbadhkdehgbekygZ^ljmihfb
ijbklZevghijbklZevghklZe\kfZljb\Zlvky\ f_jl\u_]eZaZBeeZjbhgZ
Ijhrehg_kdhevdhlhfbl_evguofbgml²Ijhklbl_^hdlhj²gZqZeijhdmjhj²
ihq_fm\ulZdijbklZevghkfhljbl_\ ]eZaZm[blhfm"²: \ug_^h]Z^u\Z_l_kv"<b^bl_
eb g_dhlhju_ kh\j_f_ggu_ mq_gu_ AZiZ^Z \ h[eZklb km^_[ghc f_^bpbgu k^_eZeb
\_kvfZ\Z`gh_b p_ggh_hldjulb_HdZau\Z_lkyihbogZ[ex^_gbyfqlh\ bguokemqZyo
]eZaZ m[bluo ih^h[gh nhlh]jZnbq_kdhc ieZklbgd_ aZi_qZle_\Zxl h[jZa m[bcpu
KemqZ_lky wlh lh]^Z dh]^Z ij_^kf_jlguc \ahj `_jl\u \klj_qZ_lky kh \a]ey^hf
m[bcpu D kh`Ze_gbx \ ^Zgghf kemqZ_ wlh]h hq_\b^gh g_ ijhbahreh AjZqhd ²
lmkdeucihl_fg_\rbc^Z^Zgbq_]hjh\ghgbq_]hg_\b^gh´
Bgl_j_kghgZdZdb_³gZmqgu_hldjulby´kkueZeky^hdlhj"< ]h^mg_f_pdbc
nbabheh] NjZgp ;he h[gZjm`be \ iZehqdZo k_lqZldb ey]mrdb yjdhdjZkguc ib]f_gl
iha`_ gZa\Zgguc ajbl_evguf imjimjhf beb jh^hikbghf Ib]f_gl wlhl l_jye k\hx
hdjZkdm ih^ \ebygb_f yjdbo emq_c k\_lZ qlh y\eyehkv gZqZevguf wlZihf j_Zdpbc
dhlhju_aZ\_jrZebkviZehqdh\ufaj_gb_f
Hkh[_ggh [hevrhc bgl_j_k d bamq_gbx jh^hikbgZ ijhy\beZ =_c^_ev[_j]kdZy
eZ[hjZlhjbyjmdh\h^bfZyijhn_kkhjhf<Dxg_Dxg_ihgyeqlhbkihevamyib]f_gl
dhlhjuc h[_kp\_qb\Z_lky gZ k\_lm fh`gh k^_eZlv nhlh]jZnbx k ihfhsvx `b\h]h
]eZaZ Hg gZa\Ze wlhl f_lh^ hilh]jZnb_c Z ihemq_ggu_ k _]h ihfhsvx kgbfdb ²
hilh]jZffZfb
H^gZ ba i_j\uo hilh]jZff Dxg_ [ueZ ihemq_gZ ke_^mxsbf h[jZahf ;_euc
djhebd [ue nbdkbjh\Zg \ iheh`_gbb ijb dhlhjhf ]heh\Z [ueZ h[jZs_gZ d
j_r_lqZlhfm hdgm Ihke_ wlh]h `b\hlghfm hlk_deb ]heh\m \ugmeb ]eZaZ k_lqZldm
nbdkbjh\Zeb\ jZkl\hj_d\Zkph\GZke_^mxsbc^_gvDxg_m\b^_egZk_lqZld_dZjlbgm
hdgZk q_ldbfjbkmgdhfj_r_ldb
< ghy[j_ ]h^Z Dxg_ bkke_^h\Ze k_lqZldm dZag_ggh]h ij_klmigbdZ Q_j_a
^_kylvfbgmlihke_dZagbhg\ugmep_ebdhfk_lqZldmbae_\h]h]eZaZb ihemqbeq_ldmx
hilh]jZffmgZihfbgZxsmxklmi_gbe_klgbpu
H^gZdh hdhgqZl_evgh hij_^_eblv qlh hagZqZ_l ihemq_ggZy hilh]jZffZ Dxg_
lZdb g_kfh]
Hldjulb_f Dxg_ kjZam `_ aZbgl_j_kh\Zebkv hj]Zgu \_^msb_ [hjv[m k
ij_klmighklvxH[_jihebpf_ckl_j;_jebgZFh^ZcijbdZaZebkke_^h\Zlv]eZaZh^gh]h
bam[bluok p_evxhldjulvebqghklvm[bcpuBkke_^h\Zgb_[uehijhba\_^_ghk_lqZldZ
knhlh]jZnbjh\ZgZ hilh]jZffZ ba]hlh\e_gZ gh bah[jZ`_gby m[bcpu gZ g_c g_
hdZaZehkv
L_f g_ f_g__ hldjulb_f Dxg_ \hkihevah\Zebkv hohlgbdb ^h k_gkZpbc ²
]Za_lgu_j_ihjl_ju< ]Za_lZob `mjgZeZojZaguokljZgklZebihy\eylvkykhh[s_gbyh
lhf qlh ^hdZaZgZ \hafh`ghklv mklZgh\e_gby ebqghklb m[bcpu ih hli_qZldm \ ]eZam
m[blh]h H^gZdh \k_ wlb khh[s_gby ijb [eb`Zcr_f ZgZeba_ hdZaZebkv ]Za_lgufb
mldZfb Bgh]^Z j_ihjl_jh\ \\h^beb \ aZ[em`^_gby b kZfb ke_^h\Zl_eb \u^Z\Zy
`_eZ_fh_aZ^_ckl\bl_evgh_
Ih^\h^y blh] klhe_lg_fm oh`^_gbx e_]_g^u h[ hilh]jZnbb fh`gh k iheghc
m\_j_gghklvx dhgklZlbjh\Zlv qlh ohly nhlh]jZnbjh\Zgb_ k ihfhsvx jh^hikbgZ \
ijbgpbi_ b \hafh`gh gh m g_]h g_l [m^ms_]h \ h[eZklb ijZdlbdb <hi_j\uo
\hafh`ghnbdkbjh\Zgb_k_lqZldblhevdhhq_gvyjdbob dhgljZklguobah[jZ`_gbclbiZ
j_r_ldb Dxg_ gh gbdZd g_ nhlh]jZnbq_kdbo ihjlj_lh\ : \h\lhjuo ^Z`_ ^ey
ihemq_gby b lZdbo ijbfblb\guo bah[jZ`_gbc g_h[oh^bfZ g_f_^e_ggZy ihke_
gZklmie_gbykf_jlbnbdkZpbyk_lqZldb\ obfbq_kdboj_Zdlb\Zo
Ihwlhfm hkgh\ghc bgl_j_k bamq_gby n_ghf_gZ jh^hikbgZ aZdexqZ_lky \
bkke_^h\Zgbb ijh[e_f obfbb aj_gby qlh gbdZd g_ fh`_l [ulv k\yaZgh k \hijhkZfb
djbfbgZebklbdb
EBL?J:LMJ:
ImlbebgB> AZibkdbKI[
Mhe^>` =eZab nhlhZiiZjZl< dg<hkijbylb_F_oZgbafub fh^_ebFFbj
Djueh\BN < fbj_djbfbgZebklbdbEBa^E_gbg]jZ^kdh]hmgb\_jkbl_lZ
=E:<:9,,,
G_le_ggu_fhsb
G_kdhevdh e_l gZaZ^ qblZl_eb [ueb ihljyk_gu im[ebdZpb_c \ ³Gh\hf fbj_´
ih\_klb K DZe_^bgZ ³Kfbj_ggh_ deZ^[bs_´ <i_j\u_ \ gZr_c ebl_jZlmj_ lZd
hldjh\_ggh [ueZ ihdZaZgZ ih\k_^g_\gZy jZ[hlZ fh]bevsbdh\ beb dZd bo aZkl_gqb\h
bf_gmxl\ hnbpbZevguo^hdmf_glZo²ih^kh[guojZ[hqbodeZ^[bs
<hlhlju\hdba^bZeh]Z]eZ\gh]h]_jhyih\_klbfh]bevsbdZE_rb<hjh[vyb _]h
gZiZjgbdZklm^_glZFbrb
³²E_rZ qlhk ihdhcgbdhfihlhf^_eZ_lky\ a_fe_"
²DZdq_]h"E_`blk_[_ke_^mxs_]h`^_l
²: qlhk gbfijhbkoh^blk ihdhcgbdhf"K l_ehf"
² E_`bl k_[_ Ki_j\Z gZ^m\Z_lky _keb g_ abfZ b g_ ijhf_jag_l ihlhf
ehiZ_lkyQ_j_a]h^ihelhjZihjZaghfmhll_eZaZ\bkblb hla_febKm]ebghd_keblZd
[ukljh _]h imqbl a_fey \h^m ^_j`bl dZd \kz jZ\gh \ dZkljxe_ ?keb i_khd ² _s_
ihe_`bl ;jxoh ehig_l ² hg l_qv gZqbgZ_l G_kdhevdh e_l l_d_l <ul_dZ_l \k_ ²
khog_l ;ukljh khog_l < a_fex ij_\jZsZ_lky H^gZ dhklv hklZ_lky E_l aZ \hk_fv
p_ebdhfk^_eZ_lky<k_qbklh< a_fexmr_e
²: aZq_flh]^ZiylgZ^pZlve_l`^Zlv"
² GZ \kydbc kemqZc fZeh eb qlh ;u\Z_l \h^Z ihq\_ggZy klhbl ² lZd hg
iZjblkyb \a_fexg_b^_lG_\b^_egbdh]^Z"M\b^brvGZlhcg_^_e_i_j_aZohjhgdZ
[m^_lG_h[^_eZ_rvkykhkljZomlh"´
>Z ij_^f_l dhlhjh]h dhkgmeky \ k\h_c ih\_klb K DZe_^bg ^_ckl\bl_evgh
m`Zk_g wlh lZcgZ aZ k_fvx i_qZlyfb dhlhjZy ebrv baj_^dZ ijbhldju\Z_lky
fh]bevsbdZf b km^_[ghf_^bpbgkdbf wdki_jlZf IjZ\^Z \ ihke_^gb_ ]h^u bgh]^Z b
rbjhdb_ kehb gZk_e_gby klZedb\Zxlky k g_c Y bf_x \ \b^m ihy\eyxsb_ky gZ
l_e_wdjZgZo ^hdmf_glZevgu_ kt_fdb ijhba\h^b\rboky wdk]mfZpbc b i_j_aZohjhg_gbc
`_jl\ klZebgkdbo j_ij_kkbc GZklhysbf hldjh\_gb_f ^ey f_gy klZeb dZ^ju jZ[hlu
f_`^mgZjh^ghc dhfbkkbb ih bkke_^h\Zgbx hklZgdh\ ihevkdbo hnbp_jh\
jZkklj_eygguo \ DZlugb nbevf wklhgkdbo ^hdmf_glZebklh\ ³KlZebg b =ble_j´
^_fhgkljbjh\Z\rbcky \ bxe_ ]h^Z ih jhkkbckdhfm l_e_\b^_gbx Dhfbkkby
jZ[hlZeZq_j_a^\Zljb]h^Zihke_aZohjhg_gbyjZkklj_eygguo
<hl m`_ g_kdhevdh e_l \ e_kZo b [hehlZo g_^Ze_dh hl ihk_edZ Fykghc ;hj
Gh\]hjh^kdZy h[eZklv jZ[hlZxl ^h[jh\hevpu ih ihbkdm b aZohjhg_gbx hklZgdh\
kh\_lkdbo[hcph\bahcm^ZjghcZjfbb]_g_jZeZ<eZkh\Zdhlhju_hdhehe_le_`Zl
g_ih]j_[_ggufb Fheh^u_ j_[ylZ \i_j\u_ klhedgmebkv a^_kv kh kljZrguf ebdhf
kf_jlb gh wlh g_ hlim]gmeh bo b a_fe_ m`_ ij_^Zgu lukyqb g_ih]j_[_gguo jmkkdbo
\hbgh\ QZs_ \k_]h dhg_qgh gZoh^yl ebrv dhklb hklZldb dh`Zghc ihjlmi_b b kZih]
ijhj`Z\_\r__ hjm`b_ Gh bgh]^Z gZoh^yl qZklb ljmih\ khojZgb\rb_ \iehlv ^h
f_evqZcrboih^jh[ghkl_ck\hxnhjfmb ^Z`_j_ev_ndh`bQlhwlhaZy\e_gb_"Q_fwlh
fh`ghh[tykgblv"Hl\_lZgZwlhl\hijhk\ug_gZc^_l_gb \h^ghfihimeyjghfba^Zgbb
Wdki_^bpbb \ Fykghc ;hj b [_k_^u k j_[ylZfb ba ]jmiiu ³Ihbkd´ \ dZdhclh f_j_ b
ihkem`bebh^gbfbaih[m`^_gbcd gZibkZgbxdgb]bh lZgZlheh]bb^Zxs_chl\_lugZ
klhevg_ijhklu_\hijhku
BlZd qlh `_ ijhbkoh^bl k l_ehf ihke_ ]b[_eb q_eh\_dZ" GZ yaud_ km^_[ghc
f_^bpbguwlha\mqbllZd²iha^gb_ljmigu_y\e_gbyIha^gb_ljmigu_y\e_gbyfh]ml
[ulv jZajmrZxsbfb gZijbf_j ]gb_gb_ b dhgk_j\bjmxsbfb fmfbnbdZpby
`bjh\hkdlhjnygh_^m[e_gb_
=gb_gb_f gZau\Z_lky ijhp_kk jZaeh`_gby [_edh\uo \_s_kl\ ih^ \ebygb_f
`bag_^_yl_evghklb fbdjhhj]Zgbafh\ <k_ fu g_h^ghdjZlgh fh]eb gZ[ex^Zlv ]gb_gb_
gZijbf_j_ibs_\uohloh^h\GhgZr_khagZgb_hldZau\Z_lkyi_j_\_klbwlhy\e_gb_gZ
hklZgdb lh]h qlh g_dh]^Z [ueh q_eh\_dhf Ijhp_kk wlhl ijhbkoh^bl ih^ ihdjh\hf
a_feb B \_ebdh_ kqZklv_ qlh hkgh\gZy qZklv gZr_]h ihdhe_gby dhlhjmx fbgh\ZeZ
\hcgZgbdh]^Zg_\b^_eZwlhlijhp_kk\hhqbx
< km^_[ghc f_^bpbg_ kms_kl\m_l ihgylb_ wdk]mfZpby dhlhjhc gZau\Zxl
ba\e_q_gb_ihohjhg_ggh]hljmiZbaa_febHgZijhba\h^blkydZd^eyi_j\hgZqZevgh]h
lZd b ^ey ih\lhjgh]h beb ^hihegbl_evgh]h bkke_^h\Zgby ljmiZ Lml fg_ ohq_lky
ih^_eblvkyk\hbfi_j\ufbd kqZklvxihke_^gbfhiulhfwdk]mfZpbb
Ihke_hdhgqZgbyf_^bpbgkdh]hbgklblmlZy \u_a`ZegZkljhbl_evkl\h;ZcdZeh
:fmjkdhc fZ]bkljZeb JZ[hlm \jZqhf klm^_gq_kdh]h kljhbl_evgh]h hljy^Z y khq_lZe k
jZ[hlhc objmj]hf \ Gb`g_Zg]Zjkdhc p_gljZevghc jZchgghc [hevgbp_ Wlh iha\heyeh
fg_ ihemqblv ohjhrmx objmj]bq_kdmx ijZdlbdm Z lZd`_ \ue_lZy gZ \_jlhe_l_ ih
\uah\Zf \ jZaebqgu_ hl^Ze_ggu_ ihk_edb ihagZdhfblvky k ijbjh^hc Ijb[ZcdZevy
Ihwlhfm y klZjZeky g_ ijhimkdZlv gb h^gh]h \ue_lZ kZgZ\bZpbb B \hl h^gZ`^u
km^_[ghf_^bpbgkdbc wdki_jl ij_^eh`be fg_ ih_oZlv ihfhsgbdhf gZ wdk]mfZpbx \
ihk_ehdDmfhjZaZl_jygguc\ ]emohcaZ[ZcdZevkdhclZc]_G_kdhevdhf_kyp_\gZaZ^lZf
\g_aZigh kdhgqZeky b [ue ihohjhg_g fheh^hc iZj_gv gh aZl_f \hagbdeb ih^haj_gby
qlh kf_jlv [ueZ gZkbevkl\_gghc I_j_^ aZohjhg_gb_f ljmi hk\b^_l_evkl\h\Zg g_ [ue
ihwlhfmihlj_[h\ZeZkvwdk]mfZpbyDhg_qghy g_fh]hldZaZlvkyhlwlh]hij_^eh`_gby
l_f[he__qlhaZ]h^umq_[u\ bgklblml_y gbjZamg_ijbkmlkl\h\ZegZwdk]mfZpbbdZd
\ijhq_fgb h^bgbafhbokhdmjkgbdh\
AZ beexfbgZlhjhf \_jlhe_lZ ijhieu\Zeb \_jrbgu khihd kb[bjkdb_ d_^ju
]hem[Zy e_glhqdZ <_jog_c :g]Zju <hl gZdhg_p b ba[mrdb Dmfhju IZoeb kfhehc
jZkdZe_ggu_ `Zjdbf bxevkdbf khegp_f khkgu ^_j_\_gkdh]h deZ^[bsZ `m``Zeb
rf_eb ehiZlu jZ[hqbo e_]dh hldb^u\Zeb kmomx i_kqZgmx ihq\m <hl m`_ jZkdhiZeb
fh]bemba\e_debijhklhc^_j_\ygguc]jh[\kdjueb_]h
GZlygm\^hkZfuo]eZafZje_\mxfZkdmklZjZykvg_\^uoZlvaeh\hggucaZiZo
k_jh\h^hjh^Zklbkgm\am[uy Zkkbklbjh\Zewdki_jlm\h\j_fy_]h\kdjulbyGh ihke_
wlh]hl\_j^hj_rbe²jZ[hlZlv\ km^_[ghcf_^bpbg_g_kfh]mgbdh]^ZIjhreb]h^ub
\hly kb`mgZ^qbklufebkldhf[mfZ]biulZykv^hg_klb^hqblZl_eylhqlhlZdkmohb
ihgylgh baeh`_gh yaudhf f_^bpbgkdbo l_jfbgh\ gh lZd keh`gh i_j_\_klb gZ
h[s_q_eh\_q_kdbcyaud
GZ kdhjhklv ]gb_gby hdZau\Z_l \ebygb_ fgh`_kl\h nZdlhjh\ ² l_fi_jZlmjZ
\eZ`ghklv k\hckl\Z ihq\u Q_f ijhqg__ k^_eZg ]jh[ b ]_jf_lbqg__ aZdjul l_f
f_^e_gg__ b^_l jZajmr_gb_ ljmiZ < ]_jf_lbq_kdb aZiZygguo f_lZeebq_kdbo ]jh[Zo
m^Z\Zehkv gZoh^blv ljmiu kjZ\gbl_evgh fZeh jZajmr_ggufb kimkly fgh]b_ ]h^u <
djmigha_jgbklhcihq\_]gb_gb_b^_lkdhj__q_f\ f_edha_jgbklhcZ \f_edha_jgbklhc
kdhj__q_f\ ]ebgbklhcQj_af_jgZy\eZ`ghklvbebqj_af_jgZykmohklvlh`_aZf_^ey_l
]gb_gb_< ]em[hdhcfh]be_]gb_gb_ijhbkoh^blf_^e_gg__q_f\ ih\_joghklghc
Gh\ jy^_kemqZ_\]gb_gbyfh`_lb g_[ulvkh\k_fIjbhlkmlkl\bbbebj_adhf
g_^hklZld_ \ha^moZ b ba[uld_ \eZ]b gZijbf_j dh]^Z ljmiu gZoh^ylky ih^ \h^hc \
j_dZoha_jZo[hehlZobebihohjhg_gu\ ihq\_[h]Zlhcihq\_ggufb\h^Zfb]gb_gb_
ijbhklZgZ\eb\Z_lky b ijhbkoh^bl k\h_h[jZagh_ ij_\jZs_gb_ ljmiZ dhlhjh_ ihemqbeh
gZa\Zgb_ `bjh\hkd beb ljmiguc \hkd Kha^Z_lky \i_qZle_gb_ qlh l_eh \ue_ie_gh ba
\hkdZ k_jh\Zlh]h beb k_jh\Zlha_e_gh]h p\_lZ \g_rgyy kljmdlmjZ hj]Zgh\ bgh]^Z \
lhqghklbkhojZgy_lky\iehlv^hf_evqZcrbohkh[_gghkl_cj_ev_nZdh`b@bjh\hkdg_
ih^^Z_lky ]gb_gbx b khojZgy_lky g_hij_^_e_ggh ^he]h_ \j_fy ijb gZ]j_\Zgbb
ieZ\blky
<i_j\u_ `bjh\hkd [ue gZc^_g ijb hqbkld_ h[sbo fh]be gZ h^ghf ba deZ^[bs
IZjb`Z \ ]h^m lh]^Z `_ mq_gu_ klZeb bamqZlv _]h k\hckl\Z b f_oZgbafu
h[jZah\Zgby >Zggu_ h kjhdZo h[jZah\Zgby `bjh\hkdZ ijhlb\hj_qb\u h[uqgh ijb
khhl\_lkl\mxsbo mkeh\byo ljmiu iheghklvx i_j_oh^yl \ `bjh\hkd q_j_a ²
f_kyp_\ohlyg_j_^dh^eywlh]hlj_[m_lky]h^b ^Z`_[hevr_
=hjZa^h [he__ j_^dbc \b^ dhgk_j\Zpbb ljmiZ ² lhjnygh_ ^m[e_gb_ Hgh
ijhbkoh^bllhevdh\ [hehlZok ykgh\ujZ`_gghcdbkehcj_Zdpb_cb lZdb_ljmiufh]ml
gZoh^blvkylZfg_baf_gyykvp_eu_klhe_lby
< h^bg ba \_k_ggbo ^g_c ]h^Z jZ[hqb_ ^h[u\Zxsb_ lhjn \ Lheemg^kdbo
[hehlZo \ P_gljZevghcXleZg^bb >ZgbygZldgmebkvgZljmiq_eh\_dZDZaZehkvhg
ih]b[kh\k_fg_^Z\gh²le_gb_g_dhkgmehkv_]hebpZDjhf_hkljhdhg_qghcdh`Zghc
rZidbb dh`Zgh]hj_fgygZg_fgbq_]hg_[ueh: r_xkly]b\Zej_f_gvm^Z\dZi_ley
\j_aZeZkv\ ]hjeh;uehykghqlhg_ba\_klgucih]b[gZkbevkl\_gghckf_jlvx
GZ lhjnygbd ijb[ueZ ihebpby Z \f_kl_ k g_c khljm^gbdb h^gh]h ba
djZ_\_^q_kdbo fma__\ <u\h^ mq_guo [ue g_h`b^Zgguf gb h dZdhf ij_klmie_gbb
]h\hjblv g_ ijboh^blky JZ[hqb_ gZreb q_eh\_dZ `_e_agh]h \_dZ Hg `be hdheh ^\mo
lukyq e_l gZaZ^ J_^dhklgmx gZoh^dm ^hklZ\beb \ Dhi_g]Z]_g ?_ lsZl_evgh
bkke_^h\Zeb \jZqb b km^_[ghf_^bpbgkdb_ wdki_jlu <kdjulb_ ihdZaZeh qlh b
\gmlj_ggb_ hj]Zgu khojZgbebkv ohjhrh < `_em^d_ b dbr_qgbd_ [ueb h[gZjm`_gu
hklZldb ibsb kt_^_gghc ijbf_jgh aZ qZkh\ ^h kf_jlb G_ba\_klguc q_eh\_d
\_jhylgh [ue ih\_r_g Z g_ m^mr_g h[gZjm`_gguf m g_]h gZ r__ j_fg_f L_i_jv
]heh\Z lheemg^kdh]h q_eh\_dZ gZoh^blky \ h^ghf ba ^Zlkdbo fma__\ =ey^y gZ g__
ljm^ghih\_jblvqlhwlhlq_eh\_d`belukyqbe_lgZaZ^
Q_j_a ^\Z ]h^Z \ l_o `_ f_klZo [eba k_e_gby =jZm[Zee_ ba lhjnyghc fh]beu
ba\e_deb_s_h^gh]hihdhcgbdZHglZd`_ih]b[gZkbevkl\_gghckf_jlvxhlmoZ^hmoZ
abyeZ [hevrZy gh`_\Zy jZgZ KhojZgghklv ljmiZ [ueZ bkdexqbl_evghc K hl^_evguo
iZevp_\ ^Z`_ m^Zehkv kgylv ^Zdlbehkdhibq_kdb_ hli_qZldb Mq_gu_ mklZgh\beb qlh
wlhl q_eh\_d `be k\ur_ ^\mo lukyq e_l gZaZ^ Q_eh\_d ba =jZm[Zee_ [ue ihf_s_g \
>hbklhjbq_kdbcfma_c\ Hjomk_]^_hge_`bl\ lhf`_\b^_\ dZdhf[ueh[gZjm`_g\
lhjnygbd_
< ijhrehf \_d_ \ l_o `_ ^Zlkdbo [hehlZo [ue h[gZjm`_g ihq_jg_\rbc ljmi
`_gsbgu h^_lhc \ [h]Zlu_ h^_`^u DZd hgZ ihiZeZ kx^Z" Hl\_l mq_gu_ ^Zeb ihke_
lh]h dZd bamqbeb khojZgb\r__ky h^_ygb_ Ih aZibkyf \ e_lhibkb mklZgh\beb qlh
^_\ylkhle_lgZaZ^aZdZdb_lhij_]j_r_gbydhjhev>ZgbbijbdZaZemlhiblvk\hx`_gm\
[hehl_
< aZfd_=hllhji\ Re_a\b]_NJ=ojZgblky]heh\Zfm`qbguk g_h[uqghc^ey
gZr_]h \j_f_gb ijbq_kdhc Ju`_\Zlu_ \hehku ^h\hevgh ^ebggu_ [ueb kh[jZgu k
ijZ\hc klhjhgu \ aZfukeh\Zluc bkdmkgh kdjmq_gguc ma_e Dh]^Z wlZ ]heh\Z [ueZ
gZc^_gZ\ h^ghfbalhjnygbdh\ mq_gu_\kihfgbebh lhfqlh^j_\g_jbfkdbc bklhjbd
LZpblhibkZ\rbc`bagv^j_\gbo]_jfZgp_\mihfbgZ_lbf_gghh lZdhcijbq_kd_²hgZ
[ueZ lbibqghc m fm`qbg r\Z[kdh]h ie_f_gb < k\h_f khqbg_gbb ³=_jfZgby´ LZpbl
ibr_l qlh gZkbevkl\_ggh_ ebr_gb_ q_eh\_dZ `bagb m wlbo ie_f_g [ueh eb[h
gZdZaZgb_f aZ ij_klmie_gby eb[h `_jl\hijbghr_gb_f [h]Zf Ij_^Zl_e_c b
i_j_[_`qbdh\\_rZebgZ^_j_\_Z ljmkh\b ij_klmigbdh\[jhkZeb\ [hehlh
Lhjnygbdb k_\_jhaZiZ^ghc ?\jhiu >Zgbb NJ= Ghj\_]bb b ^jm]bo kljZg
y\eyxlkyk\h_h[jZagufojZgbebs_fhklZgdh\ex^_c`_e_agh]h\_dZ< gboh[gZjm`_gh
m`_hdheh k_fbkhlfm`qbg `_gsbg ^_l_c AZdhgk_j\bjh\Zggu_ kZfhc ijbjh^hc hgb
ij_^klZxlq_j_alukyq_e_lby\ lZdhf\b^_qlhkihkh[gu\ua\Zlvkm_\_jguckljZo
Ijhp_kk lhjnygh]h ^m[e_gby _s_ g_evay kqblZlv ^hklZlhqgh bamq_gguf
=eZ\guf ^_ckl\mxsbf gZqZehf a^_kv y\eyxlky ih\b^bfhfm dbkehlu dhlhju_
miehlgyxl ^m[yl dh`m jZkl\hjyxl ihkl_i_ggh [_edb furp b \gmlj_ggbo hj]Zgh\
m[b\Zxl]gbehklgu_fbdjhhj]Zgbafub jZkl\hjyxlba\_klvdhkl_c
< kemqZ_lhjnygh]h^m[e_gbydh`ZljmiZl_fg__lklZgh\blkyhq_gviehlghcdZd
[u ^m[e_ghc \gmlj_ggb_ hj]Zgu b furpu kbevgh mf_gvrZxlky \ h[t_f_ b bgh]^Z
kh\k_fbkq_aZxldhklbl_jyxlba\_klvklZgh\ylkyfy]dbfbb ]b[dbfb
Kh\k_f m` j_^dbf \b^hf _kl_kl\_gghc dhgk_j\Zpbb ljmih\ y\ey_lky bo
aZf_jaZgb_ =gb_gb_ ijb wlhf hklZgZ\eb\Z_lky \ ex[hc klZ^bb b ljmi fh`_l
khojZgylvky \ aZf_jar_f \b^_ g_hij_^_e_ggh ^he]h_ \j_fy Wlh gZ[ex^Z_lky \
iheyjguokljZgZogZljmiZo`bl_e_cihohjhg_gguo\ f_jaehca_fe_
<
wihom pZjkl\h\Zgby GbdheZy , kb[bjkdbc ]_g_jZe]m[_jgZlhj
bgl_j_kh\Z\rbcky \hijhkZfb bklhjbb ij_^ibkZe ]hjh^gbq_fm ;_jzah\Z ]hjh^dZ ]^_
lb e_l hl jh^m ghy[jy ]h^Z \ kkued_ kdhgqZeky agZf_gbluc kih^\b`gbd
I_ljZ , dgyav F_gvrbdh\ ³hldjulv _]h fh]bem´ bf_y \ \b^m gZclb f_klh _]h
aZohjhg_gby Kh \j_f_gb kf_jlb F_gvrbdh\Z ijhreh m`_ hdheh klZ e_l aZ fh]behc
hiZevgh]hdgyaygbdlhg_moZ`b\ZehgZijbreZ\ ihegh_aZimkl_gb_b aZl_jyeZkvkj_^b
ijhqbo [_aufygguo fh]be K ihfhsvx klZjh`beh\ ]hjh^gbq_fm m^Zehkv hlukdZlv
f_klh aZohjhg_gby F_gvrbdh\Z gh iheguc kem`_[gh]h j\_gby hg i_j_mk_j^kl\h\Ze
keh\h³hldjulv´hgihgye[md\Zevghb\uju\]jh[F_gvrbdh\Z\kdjue_]hM\b^_ggh_
ihljykehk\b^_l_e_c²dgyavF_gvrbdh\gbqmlvg_baf_gbekyaZijhr_^r__klhe_lb_
< ]jh[me_`ZedZd[m^lh[ulhevdhqlhihohjhg_ggucq_eh\_debrvbg_cijbihjhrbe
_]hhljhkrmx\ kkued_[hjh^m
Bf__lky lZd`_ jy^ k\b^_l_evkl\ ba AZiheyjvy h gZc^_gguo aZohjhg_gbyo
j_ij_kkbjh\Zgguol_eZdhlhjuogbqmlvg_baf_gbebkvaZijhr_^rb_²e_l
< bklhjbb ba\_kl_g j_^qZcrbc kemqZc dh]^Z ijhbahreZ ihegZy dhgk_j\Zpby
ljmiZijbkh\_jr_gghg_h`b^Zgguoh[klhyl_evkl\ZoWlh[ueh\ ;9,,,\_d_\ :g]ebb
Kimklyihe\_dZihke_lh]hdZdgZEhg^hgkdhciehsZ^b[uedZag_gijhn_kkbhgZevguc
m[bcpZ ijbj_aZ\rbc hdheh ^\Z^pZlb `_jl\ ijb ihkljhcd_ gh\h]h a^Zgby gZ f_kl_
dZagb ij_klmigbdZ \ a_fe_ h[gZjm`beb hdZf_g_\rbc ljmi ^h lZdhc kl_i_gb
khojZgb\rbckyqlh_]hhihagZebihq_jlZfebpZK_dj_l³qm^Z´jZkdjuekykdhjh\ lhf
f_kl_ ]^_ [ue aZdhiZg dZag_gguc ijhl_dZe ih^\h^guc jh^gbd Z \ _]h \h^_
kh^_j`Zehkv fgh]h ba\_klb Ljmi ³h[ua\_kldh\Zeky´ ² ihdjueky ijhqghc ie_gdhc
ba\_klb²b ^hklmid g_fm]gbehklguf[Zdl_jbyf[ueaZdjul
G_h^ghdjZlgh fg_ ^h\h^behkv keurZlv jZkkdZau ydh[u h lhf qlh Zjo_heh]Zfb
[ueh \kdjulh ih]j_[_gb_ fgh]h\_dh\hc ^Z\ghklb ]^_ \ ]_jf_lbq_kdb aZdjulhf ]jh[m
bebiehlghaZfmjh\Zgghfkde_i_gZoh^behkvl_ehqZs_\k_]h\ jZkkdZaZonb]mjbjm_l
fheh^Zy`_gsbgZdZd[m^lh[ulhevdh\q_jZihohjhg_ggh_iheh`_ggu_\ ]jh[p\_lu
^Z`_g_aZ\yebGhklhbehlhevdhl_emkhijbdhkgmlvkyk \ha^mohfdZdhghlml`_ijyfh
gZ]eZaZoij_\jZsZehkv\ ijZo
Fg_ g_ m^Zehkv gZclb ^hdmf_glZevguo ih^l\_j`^_gbc wlbo jZkkdZah\ ohly
\iheg_fh`_l[ulvqlhqlhlhih^h[gh_b bf_ehf_klhY lZd`_g_\klj_qZejZ[hl]^_
[u jZkkdZau\Zehkv qlh ]_jf_lbqghklv ih]j_[_gby fh`_l iheghklvx aZdhgk_j\bjh\Zlv
ljmigZfgh]b_klhe_lbyGhy kfh]hlukdZlv^\Zk\b^_l_evkl\Zdhlhju_fh]eb[u[ulv
ijhlhlbiZfbmdZaZgghce_]_g^u
< ]h^m gZ :iib_\hc ^hjh]_ \ Jbf_ [ueZ \kdjulZ ^j_\gyy ]jh[gbpZ
ijbgZ^e_`Z\rZy ^hq_jb agZf_gblh]h hjZlhjZ Pbp_jhgZ ijb wlhf l_eh ihdhcgbpu
aZk\_lbehkvnhknhjbq_kdbf[e_kdhfb lml`_jZkkuiZehkv\ ijZo
Wlh mkljZrZxs__ y\e_gb_ dhlhjh_ ihjh^beh \ l_ ^Ze_db_ \j_f_gZ fgh]h
km_\_jguo\u^mfhdfh`gh[ueh[uijhdhff_glbjh\Zlvke_^mxsbfh[jZahf KemqZb
dh]^Z h]gb \kiuob\Zxl \g_aZigh ijb \kdjulbb fh]be ba\_klgu ^Z\gh HdZau\Z_lky
_klv lZdb_ \_s_kl\Z dhlhju_ aZ]hjZxlky gZ \ha^mo_ kZfb kh[hc D gbf hlghkblky
obfbq_kdh_kh_^bg_gb_nhknhjZb \h^hjh^Z²nhknhjbkluc\h^hjh^[_kp\_lguc]Zak
aZiZohf ]gbehc ju[u < e_lg__ \j_fy hg qZklh \u^_ey_lky ba ihq\u i_j_iheg_gghc
jZaeZ]Zxsbfbky `b\hlgufb beb jZklbl_evgufb hj]ZgbafZfb \ dhlhju_ \ dZq_kl\_
h[yaZl_evgh]hdhfihg_glZ\k_]^Z\oh^blnhknhjDh]^Zhj]ZgbafmfbjZ_lwlhlnhknhj
i_j_oh^bl\ ihq\mZ qZklv_]hijbwlhfkh_^bgy_lkyk \h^hjh^hfh[jZamynhknhjbkluc
\h^hjh^DZdlhevdhlZdhc]ZaihiZ^Z_lgZ\ha^mohgkZfhijhba\hevghaZ]hjZ_lkyq_fb
fh`gh h[tykgblv g_[hevrb_ [e_^gu_ h]hgvdb dhlhju_ lh ]Zkgml lh \kiuob\Zxl \
jZaguo f_klZo gZ [hehlZo b deZ^[bsZo Dh]^Z `_ ba a_feb \g_aZigh \uoh^bl fgh]h
nhknhjbklh]h\h^hjh^Zh]hgvfh`_l[ulv[hevrbfqlh\_jhylghb bf_ehf_klhijb
\kdjulbb]jh[gbpu^hq_jbPbp_jhgZ
>jm]hckemqZck\yaZgk bf_g_fjbfkdh]hiZiuKbev\_kljZ,,²ydh[u
aZdexqb\r_]h khxa k KZlZghc IZiZ Kbev\_klj ihjZ`Ze kh\j_f_ggbdh\
fZl_fZlbq_kdbfb b nbehkhnkdbfb ihagZgbyfb dhlhjufb hg [ue h[yaZg g_ bgZq_ dZd
^vy\hem Ih e_]_g^_ i_j_^ kf_jlvx iZiZ Kbev\_klj ihdZyeky qlh ^h]h\hj k KZlZghc
kms_kl\h\Zeb ihijhkbeijb[eb`_gguo\haeh`blv_]hljmigZdZlZnZedaZijy`_gguc
[_eufb ehrZ^vfb ^h[Z\b\ qlh dhgb hklZgh\ylky kZfb \ lhf f_kl_ ]^_ _]h gZ^e_`bl
ihohjhgblv <hey iZiu Kbev\_kljZ [ueZ bkiheg_gZ \ lhqghklb ² dhgb ydh[u
hklZgh\bebkv i_j_^ EZl_jZgkdbf ojZfhf ]^_ hklZgdb iZiu b [ueb ij_^Zgu a_fe_ kh
\k_fbkhhl\_lkl\mxsbfbihq_klyfb
³K lh]h \j_f_gb² ibr_l e_lhibk_p² [he__ r_klb \_dh\ ih^jy^ dZ`^uc jZa
gZdZgmg_ ^gy kf_jlb i_j\hk\ys_ggbdZ keh\gh ij_^\_sZy _]h dhgqbgm klmqZl dhklb
Kbev\_kljZb ieblZgZ]jh[gbp__]hihdju\Z_lkydjh\Z\ufbke_aZfb´
< k_j_^bg_;9,,\_dZijbi_j_kljhcd_EZl_jZgkdh]h^\hjpZhldjueb]jh[gbpmk
l_ehfiZiuKbev\_kljZ,,dhlhjmxihij_^Zgbyfihk_sZeKZlZgZDZd]h\hjble_]_g^Z
l_eh dZaZehkv _s_ `b\uf b [eZ]hmoZeh gh \^jm] emq k\_lZ haZjbe l_eh Z^kdh_ ieZfy
\uj\Zehkv ba g_]h hk\_sZy \k_ \hdjm] b l_eh ij_\jZlbehkv \ i_i_e hklZeky lhevdh
k_j_[jygucdj_kl^ZiZklujkdbci_jkl_gv
?kebhl[jhkblvijhqv\kxfbklbdmk\yaZggmxk bf_g_fiZiuKbev\_kljZ,,lh
kdhj__ \k_]h b a^_kv fu bf__f ^_eh k obfbq_kdhc j_Zdpb_c kZfh\ha]hjZgby
nhknhjbklh]h\h^hjh^Zkdhib\r_]hky\ ]jh[gbp_: dZd`_[ulvk ml\_j`^_gb_fqlh
l_eh iZiu dZaZehkv `b\uf" Y ^mfZx wlh]h g_ fh]eh [ulv DZd fu m`_ jZkkdZau\Zeb
nhknhjbkluc \h^hjh^ h[jZam_lky lhevdh ijb jZaeh`_gbb hj]Zgbq_kdbo \_s_kl\ ² \
^ZgghfkemqZ_hklZgdh\iZiu: ke_^h\Zl_evghgb hdZdhckhojZgghklbl_eZg_fh`_l
[ulv b j_qb Nhknhjbkluc \h^hjh^ ^he`_g [ue \kiuogmlv f]gh\_ggh ijb ihiZ^Zgbb
k\_`_]h\ha^moZ\h\kdjulmx]jh[gbpmZ agZqblk\b^_l_ebijb\k_f`_eZgbbg_fh]eb
mki_lv jZkkfhlj_lv l_eh iZiu <_jhylg__ \k_]h \ ]jh[gbp_ \ ^Zgguc fhf_gl b
gZoh^behkv lh qlh \ihke_^kl\bb khqeb aZ i_i_e kh``_ggh]h Z^kdbf h]g_f iZiu Z gZ
kZfhf^_e_y\eyehkvj_amevlZlhffgh]h\_dh\hc^_yl_evghklbfbdjhhj]Zgbafh\
H^bg ba kZfuo jZkijhkljZg_gguo \b^h\ _kl_kl\_gghc dhgk_j\Zpbb ljmih\ ²
fmfbnbdZpby y\eyxsZyky ke_^kl\b_f h[s_]h \ukuoZgby ljmiZ >ey wlh]h g_h[oh^bf
ij_`^_\k_]hba[ulhd\ha^moZb ohjhrZy\_glbeypbyFmfbnbdZpbyfh`_lijhbkoh^blv
g_ lhevdh gZ hldjulhf \ha^mo_ gh b \ fh]be_ gZijbf_j \ juoehc i_kqZghc ihq\_
ohjhrh \_glbebjm_fhc b \kZku\Zxs_c \eZ]m Z lZd`_ \ ihf_s_gbyo k ohjhr_c
\_glbeypb_c gZijbf_j gZ q_j^Zd_ Ijb fmfbnbdZpbb ljmi fZehihfZem gZqbgZ_l
kfhjsb\Zlvkyl_jylv\ \_k_b h[t_f_l_fg_lvb l\_j^_lvjZa\b\Z_lkyi_j]Zf_glghklv
dh`b\ukuoZgb_b kiZ^Zgb_\k_o\gmlj_ggbohj]Zgh\Ihl_jy\_kZ^hoh^bl^h b
[hevr_< lZdhfkhklhygbbljmifh`_lhklZ\Zlvkyg_hij_^_e_ggh^he]h_\j_fyKjhdb
g_h[oh^bfu_ ^ey fmfbnbdZpbb h[uqgh bkqbkeyxlky f_kypZfb Ijb hkh[h
[eZ]hijbylguo mkeh\byo ljmi \ajhkeh]h fh`_l fmfbnbpbjh\Zlvky aZ ² f_kypZ
Bgl_j_kghqlhebqghklvfmfbnbpbjh\Zgguoljmih\g_j_^dhohjhrhjZkihagZ_lky
< i_l_j[mj]kdhf Fma__ a^jZ\hhojZg_gby me ;hevrZy BlZevygkdZy ^ jZkiheh`_gghfg_ih^Ze_dmhlG_\kdh]hijhki_dlZojZgylkymgbdZevgu_wdkihgZlu²
^\Z iheghklvx fmfbnbpbjh\Zgguo `_gkdbo ljmiZ Fmfbb wlb [ueb h[gZjm`_gu \
kde_i_ihk_edZFZjlurdbghwlhlg_[hevrhcihk_ehdjZkiheh`_gf_`^mI_l_j]hnhfb
HjZgb_g[Zmfhf Ijbf_jguc kjhd aZohjhg_gby ² i_j\Zy q_l\_jlv ;9,,, \_dZ wihoZ
I_ljZ , >Zggu_ fmfbb gZoh^ylky \ fma__ k\ur_ e_l ijbq_f h[jZsZ_l gZ k_[y
\gbfZgb_ \_ebdhe_igZy khojZgghklv ldZg_c b ^_lZe_c h^_`^u H^gZ fmfby ² wlh
fheh^Zy`_gsbgZ\ klZjbgghfgZjy^ghfieZlv_qmedZolmneyok iurghcijbq_kdhcb
^h\hevgh ohjhrh khojZgb\rbfky djZkb\uf ebphf >jm]Zy fmfby ih`behc `_gsbgu
\u]ey^bl g_kdhevdh om`_ ² hlkmlkl\mxl \hehku gZ ]heh\_ ihqlb g_ khojZgbeZkv
h^_`^Z gh \h \k_f hklZevghf g_l gbdZdbo ke_^h\ jZajmr_gby ldZg_c l_eZ >bj_dlhj
Fma_y a^jZ\hhojZg_gby jZkkdZau\ZeZ fg_ qlh fmfbb [ueb h[gZjm`_gu ijb
jZajmr_gbbklZjbgguokde_ih\gZdeZ^[bs_ihk_edZFZjlurdbghklhevh[uqghf^ey
gZk \ ihke_j_\hexpbhggu_ ]h^u <k_]h \ ih^Zjhd fma_x [ueh ^hklZ\e_gh fmfbc [ueb \uklZ\e_gu ^ey wdkihabpbb Z hklZevgu_ i_j_^Zgu ^jm]bf fma_yf ke_^u bo
aZl_jyebkvFmfbnbdZpbyijhbahreZbkdexqbl_evgh[eZ]h^Zjymkeh\byfaZohjhg_gby
\ ohjhrh\_glbebjm_fuokde_iZo\ujuluo\ i_kqZghcihq\_
Bgh]^Zfmfbyfh`_lh[jZah\Zlvkyb \mkeh\byoh[uqghc]hjh^kdhcd\Zjlbju<
fZ_]h^Z:gZlhebcGbdheZ_\bqGZkhgh\ojhgbq_kdbcZedh]hebde_lfZrbgbkl
m[hjhqguo fZrbg fhkdh\kdhc klZgpbb f_ljh ³J_qghc \hdaZe´ ihemqbe iml_\dm \
e_q_[ghljm^h\hc ijhnbeZdlhjbc Gh e_qblvky g_ ih_oZe Z bkq_a Fbebpby bkdZlv g_
klZeZ²g_ij_klmigbd?]hkhk_^bihlj_odhfgZlghcdhffmgZevghcd\Zjlbj_ihmebp_
N_klb\Zevghc \ Fhkd\_ g_ kebrdhf i_j_`b\Zeb jh^guo g_ [ueh Q_j_a ljb k
iheh\bghc ]h^Z \klZe \hijhk h \uk_e_gbb GZkhgh\Z ba dhfgZlu yg\Zjy ]h^Z
mqZkldh\ucbgki_dlhj]hhl^_e_gby\aehfZe^\_jvb m\b^_edZjlbgm\ ^mo_fZkl_jZ
nbevfh\ m`Zkh\ ObqdhdZ fbjgh kdehgb\ ]heh\m gZ ^b\Zg_ kb^_eZ kZfZy h[uqgZy
fmfbyl_ieuc\_l_jhdbadhjb^hjZeZkdh\hb]jZeih`_el_\rbfb]Za_lZfb\_kgu
]h^ZDZdmklZgh\beihlhfwdki_jlfhj]Zkf_jlvgZklmibeZhdheh q_luj_o e_l gZaZ^
gh l_eh g_ jZaeh`behkv Z fmfbnbpbjh\Zehkv \ ijyfhf kfuke_ keh\Z ih^ [hdhf m
khk_^_cihdhffmgZevghcd\Zjlbj_
Bgh]^Z ijbqbghc fmfbnbdZpbb kem`Zl g_ mkeh\by fbdjhdebfZlZ Z g_dhlhju_
^jm]b_ijbqbgu<h^\hj_lob_gkdh]hojZfZ>Zm\ dfhlOZghy\hlm`_k ebrgbf
e_lkb^bl\ iha_ehlhkZfmfbygZklhyl_eyfhgZklujy %\ DoZdFbgy
Ml\_j`^Zeb qlh ijb ij_^ihke_^g_c \v_lgZfkdhc dhjhe_\kdhc ^bgZklbb E_ hg
^hklb] \_jrbg ijb^\hjghc dZjv_ju b l_f g_ f_g__ m^Zebeky \ wlhl fhgZklujv
hldZaZ\rbkv hl [h]Zlkl\Z b \eZklb D dhgpm `_ ^g_c k\hbo m_^bgb\rbkv \ djhohlghc
dbjibqghc qZkh\g_ gZ djZx fhgZklujy Fbgv ih]jmabeky \ ihkl b fhebl\m jZaj_rb\
mq_gbdZfijbclbd g_fmebrvlh]^Zdh]^Zi_j_klZg_la\mqZlvfhebl\_gguc[ZjZ[ZgKh
\j_f_gIbnZ]hjZba\_klghqlhq_eh\_dfh`_l\ha^_j`b\Zlvkyhlibsb[_ams_j[Z^ey
l_eZ g_ [he__ khjhdZ ^g_c ² gZklhyl_ev Fbgv ihklbeky \ l_q_gb_ klZ Dh]^Z kbeu
hdhgqZl_evghhklZ\beb_]hhgh[jZlbekyd klheib\rbfkyi_j_^gbffhgZoZf³Ijbreh
\j_fyihdbgmlvfg_wlhlfbjDh]^Zfhc^mohle_lblhll_eZih\j_f_gbl_f_kyp?keb
ihqm\kl\m_l_aZiZole_gby²ihohjhgbl_f_gydZdiheh`_ghihh[jy^m?keb`_le_gby
g_[m^_lhklZ\vl_f_gya^_kvqlh[uy \_qgh\haghkbefhebl\u;m^^_´
Bamfe_ggu_fhgZobih^qbgbebkvijbdZamihke_dhgqbgugZklhyl_eyle_gbyg_
[uehaZf_lghgb q_j_af_kypgb q_j_a^\Zb lh]^Zhgbihdjueb_]hl_ehdjZkdhc^Z[u
aZsblblv hl aeh\j_^guo gZk_dhfuo b hklZ\beb kb^_lv gZ g_[hevrhf \ha\ur_gbb \
gbr_dbjibqghcqZkh\_gdb]^_hgijh`bek\hbihke_^gb_^gb
Ihke_kf_jlbgZklhyl_eyijhrebklhe_lby< Jhkkbbmki_eZ\hpZjblvkyb mclb\
bklhjbx ^bgZklby JhfZgh\uo <h <v_lgZf_ ij_klhehf h\eZ^_eZ gh\Zy ^bgZklby
G]m_gh\ ihlhf ijbreb njZgpmau aZ gbfb ² yihgpu gZqZeZkv ZglbdhehgbZevgZy
\hcgZ __ kf_gbeZ [hjv[Z ijhlb\ Zf_jbdZgkdhc Z]j_kkbb ² Z gZklhyl_ev \k_ kb^_e \
k\h_cgbr_g_ih^\eZklgucoh^m\j_f_gb
Ihke_ h[j_l_gby <v_lgZfhf g_aZ\bkbfhklb e_]_g^Z h[ hdZf_g_\r_f fhgZo_
ijb\e_deZ \gbfZgb_ mq_guo ³klZlmx´ ih^\_j]eb j_gl]_gh\kdhfm bkke_^h\Zgbx \
]hkiblZe_\ ;ZdFZ_DZdh\h`_[uehbamfe_gb_ijbkmlkl\mxsbodh]^Zhgbm\b^_ebgZ
wdjZg_ dhglmju kd_e_lZ b m[_^bebkv qlh i_j_^ gbfb ^_ckl\bl_evgh g_ klZlmy Z
q_eh\_q_kdh_l_eh
Bkke_^h\Zgb_ ihdZaZeh qlh l_eh g_ [ueh [ZevaZfbjh\Zgh ² \ hlebqb_ hl
_]bi_lkdbo fmfbc \gmlj_gghklb b fha] hklZebkv g_ljhgmlufb DZdbf h[jZahf l_eh
gZklhyl_eykhojZgbehkv\ mkeh\byoljhibq_kdh]h<v_lgZfZ]^_\eZ`ghklv^_j`blkygZ
mjh\g_ ijhp_glh\ Z fmkkhggu_ ^h`^b ijh^he`Zxlky f_kypZfb² aZ]Z^dZ <_^v \
qZkh\g_]^_ojZgblkyl_ehgZklhyl_ey²\k_]hlhevdhljbkl_guZ gbrZaZ\_rb\Z_lky
aZgZ\_khfb fgh]b_klhe_lbyhldjulZ\k_f\_ljZfb ^h`^yfL_fg_f_g__hklZgdbg_
m\eZ`gyebkvZ mkuoZebijb\a\_rb\Zgbb\ ]hkiblZe_ %\ DoZdFbgv\_kbe\k_]hk_fv
dbeh]jZffh\²kebrdhffZeh^Z`__kebmqblu\Zlvhq_gv kdjhfguc jhkl \v_lgZfp_\
;9,,\_dZb klh^g_\gucihkl
KemqZcwlhl²^Ze_dhg__^bgkl\_ggucqlhaZklZ\ey_l^mfZlvh[hij_^_e_gghc
ljZ^bpbbkms_kl\h\Z\r_c\ kj_^_[m^^bklkdbofhgZoh\Kms_kl\m_lfgh`_kl\he_]_g^
h ex^yo[em`^Z\rbo^Ze_dh\ ]hjZob \^jm]gZoh^b\rbo\ dZdhclhm_^bg_gghci_s_j_
[m^^bckdh]h fhgZoZ m`_ fgh]b_ klhe_lby ³qblZxs_]h´ klZjmx kmljm beb fheys_]hky
;m^^_< lhf`_ojZf_hdhehOZghyojZgblkyfmfbyb ^jm]h]hgZklhyl_eyij__fgbdZb
ie_fyggbdZ %\ DoZdFbgy
>hkboihjhdhgqZl_evghg_ykguijbqbguklhev\_ebdhe_ighckhojZgghklbl_e
fhgZoh\ \ mkeh\byo \eZ`gh]h debfZlZ gbdZd g_ kihkh[kl\mxs_]h fmfbnbdZpbb
<v_lgZfkdb_ mq_gu_ bkke_^h\Z\rb_ l_eh gZklhyl_ey h[gZjm`beb gZ g_f
ijhf_`mlhqguckehck_j_[jyghcdjZkdbb iheZ]ZxlqlhhgZku]jZeZjhevdhgk_j\ZglZ
Fg_ dZ`_lky qlh ]hjZa^h [he__ \Z`gmx jhev \ ijhp_kkZo fmfbnbdZpbb ku]jZeh
klh^g_\gh_]heh^Zgb_kihkh[kl\h\Z\r__iheghfmh[_a\h`b\Zgbxhj]ZgbafZ
Wlh ij_^iheh`_gb_ ih^l\_j`^Z_lky ba^Z\gZ kms_kl\mxsbf \ Yihgbb h[uqZ_f
fmfbnbdZpbb Fmfbnbpbjh\Zgb_ m yihgp_\ gZqbgZ_lky _s_ ijb `bagb q_eh\_dZ
Ijhp_kkwlhljZkkqblZggZljb]h^ZDZg^b^Zl\ fmfbbi_j_klZ_l_klvjbkh\_kijhkh
oe_[ fmfbnbpbjh\Zgb_ ² ijb\be_]by [m^^bckdbo `j_ph\ ju[m b fykh hgb g_
mihlj_[eyeb b jZgvr_ Ibsm bo khklZ\eyxl ih[_]b ³k\ys_gguo´ ljZ\ a_jgZ djZkghc
khb Q_j_a ljb ]h^Z b wlhl jZpbhg k\h^yl d fbgbfmfm < blh]_ j_adh mf_gvrZxlky
`bjh\Zyb fur_qgZyldZgbnmgdpbhgbjmxlebrvkZfu_\Z`gu_\gmlj_ggb_hj]Zgu
Dh]^Z q_eh\_d khojZgy\rbc lZdhc j_`bf iblZgby mfbjZ_l _]h deZ^ml \
^_j_\ygguckmg^mdbalhekluo^hkhd\ kmohfih^a_f_ev_Bklhjbdbh^gZdhhlf_qZxl
g_klZ[bevghklv j_amevlZlh\ aZ\bkbfhklv bo hl fgh]bo kemqZcghkl_c Ihke_^gbf
m^Zqgufhiulhf[ueZfmfbnbdZpby[m^^bckdh]hfhgZoZ ;mdZy \ ]h^m Kh]eZkgh
\_jh\Zgbyf [m^^bckdhc k_dlu Rbg]hgrm qlh[u \hkdj_kblv fmfbx ^hklZlhqgh
ihoehiZlv__ ihie_qmijZ\^Zq_j_ae_lihke_kf_jlb;m^^u]^h
gw
< k\yabk g_dhlhjufbg_h[uqgufbnZdlhjZfbkihkh[kl\mxsbfbfmfbnbdZpbb
ohq_lky \kihfgblv b ihqlb ^_l_dlb\gmx bklhjbx kemqb\rmxky \h \j_fy jZ[hlu
ihke_^g_c Zjo_heh]bq_kdhc wdki_^bpbb ih h[ke_^h\Zgbx aZohjhg_gbc Khnbckdh]h
kh[hjZ]Gh\]hjh^Zih^jmdh\h^kl\hf<EYgbgZ
Gh gZqg_f fu gZr jZkkdZa ba^Ze_dZ k wihob Kfmlgh]h \j_f_gb < l_ ]h^u gZ
l_jjblhjbb Gh\]hjh^Z ohaycgbqZeZ Zjfby r\_^kdh]h ihedh\h^pZ Ydh[Z >_iheZ]Zj^b
g_dh]^Zijba\ZggZy^eyaZsbluhlihevkdbobgl_j\_glh\Z gug_ihevamykvkeZ[hklvx
jmkkdh]h ]hkm^Zjkl\Z kZfZ ij_\jZlb\rZyky \ hddmiZpbhggmx < ]h^m \ ihbkdZo
^h[uqb r\_^kdb_ fZjh^_ju jZa]jZ[beb aZohjhg_gby =_hj]b_\kdh]h kh[hjZ Xjv_\Z
fhgZklujy [eba Gh\]hjh^Z <hl dZd wlh kh[ulb_ hibkZgh \ ³Jhkibkb gh\]hjh^kdhc
k\ylugb´ khklZ\e_gghc \ ]h^m ³g_fpu \ p_jd\b \_ebdhfmq_gbdZ =_hj]by \
fhgZkluj_ bsmqb ihdeZ`_x b h[j_eb q_eh\_dZ p_eZ b g_jZajmr_gZ \ dgy`_kdhf
h^_ygbbb\ugy\ba]jh[gbpuydh`b\ZihklZ\bebm p_jdh\ghckl_gu´
BlZd ijb jZa]jZ[e_gbb aZohjhg_gbc Xjv_\Z fhgZklujy r\_^Zfb [ueZ
h[gZjm`_gZ ij_djZkgh khojZgb\rZyky fmfby dhlhjZy kh]eZkgh p_jdh\ghfm mq_gbx h
g_le_gguo fhsZo fh]eZ ijbgZ^e_`Zlv lhevdh k\ylhfm Gh dZdhfm" IjhZgZebabjh\Z\
lhih]jZnbx \kdjulh]h aZohjhg_gby fbljhihebl Bkb^hj ihkqblZe qlh fhsb
ijbgZ^e_`ZlklZjr_fm[jZlm:e_dkZg^jZG_\kdh]hdgyaxN_^hjmYjhkeZ\bqmxghr_
mf_jr_fm \ ^_gv kh[kl\_gghc k\Z^v[u Fhsb [ueb lhj`_kl\_ggh i_j_g_k_gu \
Khnbckdbckh[hjGh\]hjh^Z]^_aZl_f[he__e_l\_jmxsb_ihdehgyebkvg_le_gguf
hklZgdZfgh\h]hk\ylh]h
< ]h^mZjo_heh]bq_kdZy wdki_^bpby qe_gZdhjj_kihg^_glZ :G KKKJ < E
YgbgZ \kdjueZ aZohjhg_gb_ ³k\ylh]h dgy`bqZ N_^hjZ YjhkeZ\bqZ´ b ijhba\_eZ
km^_[ghf_^bpbgkdh_ bkke_^h\Zgb_ fmfbnbpbjh\Zgguo hklZgdh\ ;ueh mklZgh\e_gh
qlh hgb ijbgZ^e_`Zeb fm`qbg_ ² e_l ke_^h\Zl_evgh gbdZd g_ fh]eb
khhl\_lkl\h\Zlvdgyaxih^jhkldmN_^hjmYjhkeZ\bqm
;eZ]h^Zjy jZkdhidZf ijh\_^_gguf dZd \ =_hj]b_\kdhf kh[hj_ Xjv_\Z
fhgZklujylZdb \Khnbckdhfkh[hj_Gh\]hjh^kdh]hdj_fey[ueh^hdZaZghqlh^ZggZy
fmfby ijbgZ^e_`bl h^ghc ba kZfuo h^bhaguo nb]mj jmkkdhc bklhjbb ² dgyax
>fbljbxR_fyd_?s_ijb`bagbR_fydZ[ueij_^ZgZgZn_f_p_jdh\guckh[hj
]h^Zhkm`^Zyhke_ie_gb_bf<ZkbebyL_fgh]hb aZo\Zlfhkdh\kdh]hij_klheZ^h\h^be
^hh[s_]hk\_^_gbyqlhR_fydZ³khl\hjbegZ^gbfg_f_gvr_ij_`g_]h[jZlhm[bcpu
DZbgZb hdZyggh]hK\ylhihedZ´
DjZldhgZihfgbfkmlvkh[ulbc<lhjZyq_l\_jlv;9\_dZba\_klgZdjh\Z\hc
e_lg_c [hjv[hc aZ \eZklv f_`^m \gmdZfb >fbljby >hgkdh]h ² <_ebdbf dgya_f
fhkdh\kdbf<Zkbeb_f,,L_fgufb [jZlvyfb<Zkbeb_fDhkuf>fbljb_fR_fydhcb
>fbljb_f DjZkguf dhlhjZy khijh\h`^ZeZkv ]jZ[_`Zfb m[bckl\Zfb ihhq_j_^guf
aZo\Zlhf b hke_ie_gb_f khi_jgbdh\ GZdhg_p ihl_ji_\rbc ihjZ`_gb_ >fbljbc
R_fydZ mdj_ibeky \ Gh\]hjh^_ ]^_ b [ue kh]eZkgh e_]_g^_ hljZ\e_g ih^hkeZggufb
<Zkbeb_f L_fguf m[bcpZfb Hg [ue ihohjhg_g \ =_hj]b_\kdhf kh[hj_ Xjv_\Z
fhgZklujyb dgZqZem;9,,\_dZiheghklvxba]eZ^behkv\hkihfbgZgb_h lhqghff_kl_
_]hih]j_[_gby
IhwlhfmijbjZa]jZ[e_gbbr\_^ZfbaZohjhg_gbcXjv_\ZfhgZklujy\ ]h^m
aZfhsbN_^hjZYjhkeZ\bqZ[uebijbgyluhklZgdb>fbljbyR_fydbdhlhju_aZl_fb
ihqblZebkvih^qm`bfbf_g_fij_\jZlb\rbkv\ h^gmbaqlbfuoj_ebd\bc
Ihq_fm`_fmfbnbdZpbbih^\_j]ehkvl_ehh^gh]hebrv>fbljbyR_fydbdh]^Z
hl \k_o hklZevguo ih]j_[_gguo \ =_hj]b_\kdhf kh[hj_ \ lhf qbke_ b hl _]h ^hq_jb
e_`Z\r_ck gbf\ h^ghfkZjdhnZ]_khojZgbebkvebrvdhklb"<_^vmkeh\byih]j_[_gby
\ wlhf kh[hj_ dZaZehkv [u ^he`gu iheghklvx bkdexqZlv \hafh`ghklv _kl_kl\_gghc
fmfbnbdZpbb
<_jhylgh klhbl [he__ \gbfZl_evgh ijbkemrZlvky d k\b^_l_evkl\Zf e_lhibk_c
ih\_kl\mxsbo h dhgqbg_ >fbljby R_fydb M`_ \ ;9 \_d_ kms_kl\h\ZeZ mihjgZy
e_lhibkgZy\_jkbyh ij_^gZf_j_gghfhljZ\e_gbb>fbljbyR_fydbihijbdZam<Zkbeby
L_fgh]hE_lhibkpuml\_j`^Zxlqlhhg³mf_jk hljZ\u´ijh[he_\ij_^\Zjbl_evgh
^g_c
HdhgqZl_evguc hl\_l gZ wlm fgh]h\_dh\mx aZ]Z^dm ^ZeZ djbfbgZebklbq_kdZy
wdki_jlbaZhklZgdh\>fbljbyR_fydbijh\_^_ggZyhk_gvx]h^Z< bkke_^h\Zgguo
hj]ZgZob ldZgyo[ueh[gZjm`_gfurvydIjb`_em^hqghdbr_qghcnhjf_hljZ\e_gby
furvydhf [he_agv ijh^he`Z_lky ^h ^\mo g_^_ev ih e_lhibkb R_fydZ ³e_`Z ^g_c
ij_klZ\beky´ b aZdZgqb\Z_lky kf_jl_evguf bkoh^hf < ijhp_kk_ [he_agb ijhbkoh^bl
j_adh_h[_a\h`b\Zgb_hj]ZgbafZ\ke_^kl\b_ihklhygghcj\hlu b ihghkZb bf_gghwlh
h[_a\h`b\Zgb_b kem`blijbqbghcfmfbnbdZpbbldZg_cLZdbfh[jZahfdZdb \kemqZ_
k \v_lgZfkdbf fhgZohf fmfbnbdZpby R_fydb gZklmibeZ ih ijbqbg_ j_adh]h
ijb`bag_ggh]hh[_a\h`b\Zgbyhj]ZgbafZ
JZkkdZau\Zy h ijhp_kkZo _kl_kl\_gghc fmfbnbdZpbb y ohl_e [u mihfygmlv h
ijbdexq_gbyo_s_h^ghcfmfbbfmfbb]_jph]Z^_DjmZgZc^_gghc\ LZeebgg_Jy^hf
kha^Zgb_fp_jd\bGb]mebkl_ihkljh_gghc\ k_j_^bg_;,,,\_dZgZh^ghcbaklZjbgguo
mebp kj_^g_\_dh\h]h LZeebggZ ² JZlbkdZ_\m k k_\_jZ hl g__ gZoh^blky dZi_eeZ
Deh^lZdhlhjZygZg_dhlhjuoklZju"ieZgZogZau\ZeZkv³dZi_eehc^_DjmZ´GZa\Zgb_
wlh \ agZqbl_evghc kl_i_gb mkeh\gh b k\yaZgh k fmfb_c ]_jph]Z ^_ DjmZ Bklhjby
]_jph]Z lZdh\Z Dh]^Z \ ] fheh^hc jmkkdbc pZjv I_lj , \u_a`Ze ba :fkl_j^ZfZ
g_dbc ]_jph] ^_ DjmZ ih^Ze _fm ibkvfh =_jfZgkdh]h bfi_jZlhjZ \ dh_f
j_dhf_g^h\Zeky dZd ojZ[juc b hiulguc ]_g_jZe >\mfy ]h^Zfb iha`_ ]_jph] \gh\v
ij_^klZ_li_j_^pZj_fgZk_cjZa\ Gh\]hjh^_b \_kvfZ\h\j_fy²gZqZeZkvK_\_jgZy
\hcgZI_lj,[_j_l]_jph]ZgZkem`[mb gZijZ\ey_l_]hih^GZj\m<f_klhlh]hqlh[u
ojZ[jh kjZ`Zlvky aZ q_klv jmkkdh]h hjm`by ^_ DjmZ ³hl^Zeky gZ iZjhev´ ih^ q_klgh_
keh\hr\_^kdhfmihedh\gbdm]jZnmRl_cg[hdm
Ihke_^gb_]h^u`bagb]_jph]ijh\_e\ LZeebgg_]^_b mf_j\ ]h^m Gh d
wlhfm \j_f_gb hg kmf_e gZ^_eZlv klhevdh ^he]h\ qlh aZbfh^Z\pu aZij_lbeb _]h
ohjhgblv ² \ gZ^_`^_ qlh gZke_^gbdb \_jgml ^_gv]b g_ hklZ\yl _]h g_ih]j_[_gguf
L_eh ]_jph]Z l_f \j_f_g_f iheh`beb \ ih^\Ze p_jd\b Gb]mebkl_ b aZ[ueb h g_f gZ
p_eh_ klhe_lb_ H[gZjm`beb _]h ebrv \ gZqZe_ ;,; \_dZ < ] ijb[Zelbckdbc
]_g_jZe]m[_jgZlhjfZjdbaIZmemqqbijbdZaZeihf_klblvfmfbx]_jph]ZgZdZlZnZed_\
h^ghc ba dZi_ee p_jd\b Gb]mebkl_ b gZdjulv kl_deygguf dheiZdhf GZ^ibkv gZ
dZlZnZed_ h ihdhcgbd_ ^mjgh g_ ]h\hjyl ]eZkbeZ ³=_jph] k^_eZeky agZf_gbl dZd
keZ\hx]jhfdbo^_elZdb bojZaghjh^ghklvx´Fmfby^_DjmZg_baf_gghijb\e_dZeZ
\gbfZgb_iml_r_kl\_ggbdh\I_lj<ya_fkdbcihk\ylbe_fmk\h_klbohl\hj_gb_Z ^jm]
ImrdbgZ>_ev\b]\ h^ghfbaibk_fbaLZeebggZ^Z`_khh[sZeqlhagZf_gbluc]_jph]
³ebphf ihoh` gZ K_j]_y Ev\h\bqZ ImrdbgZ lhevdh ih\Z`g__´ < ] gh\uc
]_g_jZe]m[_jgZlhjdgyav<hedhgkdbcj_rbe³ij_djZlblvwlh[_ah[jZab_´GhhdZaZehkv
qlh ]_jph] i_j_^ kZfhc k^Zq_c \ ie_g ih^ GZj\hc kmf_e ihemqblv a\Zgb_
]_g_jZebkkbfmkZ : ]_g_jZebkkbfmkZ ih mklZ\m iheZ]Zehkv ohjhgblv kh \k_fb
ihq_klyfb \ ijbkmlkl\bb \k_c pZjkdhc nZfbebb \k_c ]\Zj^bb b ^biehfZlbq_kdh]h
dhjimkZ GZ jZihjl_ <hedhgkdh]h :e_dkZg^j ,, gZq_jlZe j_rbl_evgmx j_ahexpbx
³Ihohjhgblv lboh´ M`_ \ gZr_ \j_fy j_klZ\jZlhju p_jd\b Gb]bebkl_ h[gZjm`beb
fmfbx]_jph]Z\ kde_i_dZi_eeuDeh^lZHklZgdb]_jph]Z[uebih]j_[_gu\ ]h^m
< ojbklbZgkl\_ g_le_gghklv hklZgdh\ y\eyeZkv h^ghc ba kZfuo \ukrbo
ih[m^bl_evguoijbqbgijbqbke_gbyd ebdmk\yluo
Dh]^Z \ ]h^m ijb kljhbl_evguo jZ[hlZo hdheh Khnbckdh]h kh[hjZ \
Gh\]hjh^_ gZlhedgmebkv gZ klZjh_ deZ^[bs_ k khojZggufb q_eh\_q_kdbfb hklZgdZfb
i_j\uf^_ckl\b_fklZe^hdeZ^pZjxb fhkdh\kdhfmfbljhiheblm³ohjhgblbebl_e_kZ
bobebg_ohjhgblb´>eymjh\gykhagZgbylh]h\j_f_gbhq_\b^gufij_^klZ\ey_lkylhl
nZdlqlhkhojZgghklvhklZgdh\k\b^_l_evkl\m_lh[bok\ylhklbZ ihlhfmhgbg_fh]ml
[ulv ijhklh i_j_aZohjhg_gu Z ^he`gu [ulv ihf_s_gu \ ki_pbZevgmx jZdm ^ey
ihdehg_gby
< ijZ\hkeZ\ghc p_jd\b kqblZehkv h[yaZl_evguf ^hdZaZl_evkl\h khojZgghklb
fhs_c ijb dZghgbaZpbb gh\uo k\yluo M`_ \ ³@blbb ;hjbkZ b =e_[Z´ jZkkdZa_ h
i_j\uo jmkkdbo k\yluo ² dgyavyo ;hjbk_ b =e_[_ dh\Zjgh m[bluo bo [jZlhf
K\ylhihedhf hkh[h ih^q_jdb\Z_lky ² ³ljmi ;hjbkZ g_ jZaeZ]Zeky´ <hijhk h
dZghgbaZpbb pZj_\bqZ >bfbljby m[blh]h \ M]ebq_ j_rZeky gZ hkgh\Zgbb
hk\b^_l_evkl\h\Zgby_]hhklZgdh\ki_pbZevghcdhfbkkb_c
< i_s_jZo Db_\hI_q_jkdh]h fhgZklujy ihdhylky fmfbnbpbjh\Zggu_ hklZgdb
^_kyldh\ jmkkdbo fhgZoh\ ;hevrbgkl\h ba gbo ijbqbke_gh ijZ\hkeZ\ghc p_jdh\vx d
ebdm k\yluo FmfbnbdZpbb kihkh[kl\h\Ze hkh[uc kmohc fbdjhdebfZl ih^a_fguo
i_j_oh^h\<_jmxsb_fh]ebg_ihkj_^kl\_gghebp_aj_lvfhsbk\yluom]h^gbdh\b ^Z`_
p_eh\Zlv bo \ fmfbnbpbjh\Zggmx \ukhormx dbklv jmdb <k_ hklZevgh_ l_eh [ueh
aZdjulhki_pbZevgufbh^_`^Zfbb ^Z`_ebphijbdju\Zehkvhkh[hcaZgZ\_kdhc
Ijbgylh^mfZlvqlhfmfbnbdZpbyl_egZklmiZ_l\ ex[uoi_s_jZoghwlhg_lZd
< i_s_jZoIkdh\hI_q_jkdh]h fhgZklujy \g_rg_ gZihfbgZxsbo db_\kdb_ fmfbb g_
h[jZamxlky >ey aZohjhg_gby \ kl_gZo ih^a_fguo dhjb^hjh\ ijhjuluo \ fy]dhf
i_kqZgbd_ \u^Ze[eb\Zebkv gbrb < gbrm ihf_sZeky ]jh[ k l_ehf ihdhcgbdZ Z
hl\_jklb_ aZdju\Zehkv d_jZfb^hc ² d_jZfbq_kdhc ieblhc k bf_g_f b ]h^Zfb `bagb
mkhir_]h
< hlebqb_ hl db_\kdbo i_s_j aZohjhg_gby a^_kv hkfhljm g_^hklmigu b lhevdh
^_kyldbd_jZfbq_kdboieblihkl_gZfi_s_jguodhjb^hjh\gZihfbgZxlh lhfqlh\u
^\b`_l_kvq_j_a]b]Zglkdh_ih^a_fgh_deZ^[bs_Ihfbfhh[uqguoaZohjhg_gbcfbjyg
\ghkb\rbo [h]Zlu_ \deZ^u fhgZklujx bf_xlky b ^\Z ³[jZlkdbo deZ^[bsZ´ ]^_
ihohjhg_gubghdbklZjh_b gh\h_Hgbij_^klZ\eyxlkh[hcijhklhjgu_i_s_ju\hclb
\ dhlhju_ ba ih^a_fgh]h dhjb^hjZ fh`gh lhevdh q_j_a fZe_gvdbc eZa aZdjuluc
j_r_ldhc K\_jom ^hgbam wlb i_s_ju iehlgh aZklZ\e_gu ]jh[Zfb k l_eZfb fhgZoh\
h^bg gZ ^jm]hf k iheZ ^h ihlhedZ bgh]^Z \ ^_kylv b [he__ jy^h\ \ \ukhlm Ihwlhfm
gb`gb_ gZb[he__ klZju_ ]jh[u [u\Zxl bgh]^Z iheghklvx kiexs_gu GZ klZjhf
[jZlkdhf deZ^[bs_ \f_klh ]jh[h\ l_eZ e_`Zl \ hkgh\ghf \ ^m[h\uo dheh^Zo
ljZ^bpbhggh mihlj_[ey\rboky \ ^hi_ljh\kdh_ \j_fy gh lZd`_ gZ]jhfh`^_gguo h^gZ
gZ^jm]mx
G_kfhljy gZ agZqbl_evgh_ dhebq_kl\h aZohjhg_gbc \ha^mo i_s_j qbkl g_
hsmsZ_lky gb fZe_cr_]h aZiZoZ le_gby ^Z`_ hl g_^Z\gbo aZohjhg_gbc qlh b kha^Z_l
keZ\m I_q_jkdh]h fhgZklujy Gb]^_ \ ebl_jZlmj_ fg_ g_ m^Zehkv gZclb jZ[hl
h[tykgyxsbo f_oZgbaf ijhp_kkh\ ijhbkoh^ysbo \ i_s_jZo Fgh]b_ iml_\h^bl_eb
gZau\Zxl wlh fmfbnbdZpb_c qlh Z[khexlgh g_\_jgh Fg_ g_h^ghdjZlgh ijboh^behkv
[u\Zlv \ i_s_jZo Ikdh\hI_q_jkdh]h fhgZklujy fu \_eb ^he]b_ [_k_^u k hlphf
K_j]b_f b_jhfhgZohf ² kfhljbl_e_f i_s_jguo aZohjhg_gbc Ihevamxkv kemqZ_f
ijbg_klb]em[hqZcrmxijbagZl_evghklvwlhfmm^b\bl_evghfmq_eh\_dmGhhgdhg_qgh
`_g_fh]ijb\_klb_kl_kl\_ggh[bheh]bq_kdh]hh[tykg_gbywlbfy\e_gbyfljZdlmy\k_
k j_eb]bhaguoihabpbc
IulZykv gZclb hl\_l gZ bgl_j_kmxsb_ f_gy \hijhku \ h^ghf ba aZdhmedh\
klZjh]h [jZlkdh]h deZ^[bsZ y ijbhldjue klZjbggmx ^m[h\mx dheh^m hlghkb\rmxky
\_jhylghd wiho_Kfmlgh]h\j_f_gbdh]^ZgZ[jZlkdhfdeZ^[bs_ohjhgbebkvg_lhevdh
bghdbghb gZr_^rb_\ fhgZkluj_ijbxl\ ]h^bgmebohe_lvyfbjyg_B lmly \i_j\u_
ajbfhhsmlbeagZdhfu_\k_fgZfkeh\Z³le_g´b ³ijZo´< dheh^_hlihohjhg_ggh]hlZf
q_eh\_dZg_hklZehkvgbq_]hdjhf_g_kdhevdbo]hjklhddhjbqg_\h]hijZoZe_`Zsboih
dhglmjm l_eZ DZaZehkv g_hklhjh`gh_ j_adh_ ^\b`_gb_ dZr_ev ² b \k_ wlh \ah\v_lky
dZdiuev\ \ha^mo_i_s_jHklZebkvebrv]jhfZ^gu_dh`Zgu_kZih]bghgbldb^Z\gh
bkle_ebb hgbjZkkuiZebkvgZqZklbih^hr\Zhl^_evgh]he_gbsZhl^_evgh
G_kdhevdhe_lgbok_ahgh\y hljZ[hlZe\ Zjo_heh]bq_kdbowdki_^bpbyo\kdju\Ze
g_djhihev Zglbqgh]h Gbfn_y hdheh D_jqb b jZgg_ojbklbZgkdb_ aZohjhg_gby \
;_e]hjh^>g_ijh\kdhc dj_ihklb ihwlhfm i_j\h_ qlh fg_ a^_kv [jhkbehkv \ ]eZaZ ²
ihegh_hlkmlkl\b_dhklgh]hkd_e_lZOhlywlhaZohjhg_gb_[uehihqlbgZ^\_lukyqbe_l
³fheh`_´Zglbqguo\ g_djhihe_Gbfn_yij_djZkghijhkfZljb\Zebkvq_j_ib gZb[he__
djmigu_ dhklb a^_kv `_ \k_ ij_\jZlbehkv \ jZ\ghf_jguc ijZo <b^bfh mkeh\by
fbdjhdebfZlZIkdh\hI_q_jkdboi_s_jij_iylkl\mxlh[uqgufijhp_kkZf]gb_gbygh
\ gboijhbkoh^blg_fmfbnbdZpbyZ f_^e_ggh_le_gb_l_e
Ghfug_kdhevdhhlhreb\ klhjhgmhlij_^f_lZgZr_]hjZa]h\hjZGZihfgxqlh
jZkkm`^Zebfuh g_le_gguofhsZo< ijZ\hkeZ\ghcp_jd\bfhsbfh]ml[ulvhldjulu
^ey\_jmxsbodZdgZijbf_j\ Db_\hI_q_jkdhceZ\j_bebe_`Zlv³ih^kim^hf´
AgZq_gb_ keh\Z ³ih^ kim^hf´ k_cqZk ihqlb aZ[ulh ihwlhfm y iha\hex k_[_
djZldbc nbeheh]bq_kdbc wdkdmjk < ^j_\g_jmkkdhf yaud_ keh\h ³kim^t´ bf_eh ^\Z
agZq_gby ³khkm^´ b ³f_jZ kuimqbo l_e´ K [ebadhc k_fZglbdhc wlh keh\h ba\_klgh b
^jm]bf keZ\ygkdbf yaudZf dm^Z hgh ijbreh ba g_f_pdh]h Iha^g__ \ jmkkdhf yaud_
³kim^´ ihemqbeh gh\h_ agZq_gb_ \i_j\u_ aZnbdkbjh\Zggh_ ³Keh\Zj_f :dZ^_fbb
Jhkkbckdhc´²³khdjh\_ggh_f_klh´Bf_gghlZd²³kdjulh_f_klhlZcgbd´²
keh\hmihlj_[eyehkv\ ;,;\_d_
Bakdhjemihdevxlfhg_lm>ZimkdZxl\ oh^ihk\_lm
>_\dbkuiexlbamfjm^< deZ^h\u_^Zih^kim^
:KImrdbg ³KdZadZh pZj_KZelZg_´
Bf_ggh \ lZdhf agZq_gbb ³kdjulh_ f_klh´ b ke_^m_l ihgbfZlv p_jdh\guc
l_jfbg³fhsbih^kim^hf´²lh_klvg_^hklmigu_ijyfhfmhkfhljmZ kdjulu_eb[h\
aZohjhg_gbb eb[h \ jZd_ JZdhc gZau\Zxl ki_pbZevguc [h]Zlh mdjZr_gguc ysbd ^ey
ojZg_gbyfhs_cIh`ZemcgZb[he__iurgZyjZdZ²wlhfgh]him^h\ZyjZdZbaqbklh]h
k_j_[jZ ^ey ojZg_gby fhs_c k\ylh]h :e_dkZg^jZ G_\kdh]h ba :e_dkZg^jhG_\kdhc
eZ\juKI_l_j[mj]ZojZgysZykyk_cqZk\ WjfblZ`_
Fhsb g_ h[yaZl_evgh ^he`gu ij_^klZ\eylv kh[hc iheghklvx
fmfbnbpbjh\Zggh_ l_eh Bgh]^Z wlh [u\Zxl dZdb_lh hl^_evgu_ fmfbnbpbjh\Zggu_
njZ]f_glu ² dbklv jmdb iZevpu < ojbklbZgkl\_ fhsb y\eyxsb_ky ij_^f_lhf
ihdehg_gby\_jmxsboij_^klZ\eyxlkh[hcagZqbl_evgmxp_gghklv
LZd \ ]h^m bfi_jZlhj I_lj , \uf_gye m jbfkdh]h iZiu Debf_glZ ;,
[_kp_ggh_ ijhba\_^_gb_ bkdmkkl\Z ² Zglbqgmx klZlmx <_g_ju LZ\jbq_kdhc k_cqZk
wdkihgbjm_lky \ e_gbg]jZ^kdhf WjfblZ`_ gZ fhsb k\ylhc ;jb]bllu Ijhbahreh wlh
ke_^mxsbf h[jZahf < gZqZe_ ;9,,, \_dZ d jmkkdhfm ]hkm^Zjkl\m [ueZ ijbkh_^bg_gZ
Ijb[ZelbdZ < klhebp_ Wkleyg^bb J_\_e_ gug_ LZeebgg \ aZom^Zehf fhgZkluj_
h[gZjm`beb hklZgdb dZlhebq_kdhc k\ylhc ;jb]bllu kqblZ\r_cky ³ijhk\_lbl_evgbp_c
wklh\´ K ;9, \_dZ dh]^Z wklhgpu klZeb exl_jZgZfb hgb kh\_jr_ggh aZ[ueb k\ylmx
;jb]bllmb g_hdZau\Zeb__ hklZgdZfgbdZdh]h\gbfZgby: jmkkdhcp_jd\bl_f[he__g_
[ueh gbdZdh]h ^_eZ ^h qm`bo k\ylugv <hl lZd fhsb k\ylhc ;jb]bllu hdZaZebkv
aZ[ulufb
< wlh `_ \j_fy gZoh^b\rbcky \ Jbf_ dZiblZg Xjbc Dheh]jb\h\ \uihegyy
ihjmq_gb_ I_ljZ , ^h]h\hjbeky h ihdmid_ lhevdh qlh \udhiZgghc ba a_feb
\_ebdhe_ighc fjZfhjghc klZlmb Gh g_aZ^he]h i_j_^ wlbf iZiZ jbfkdbc Debf_gl ;,
[hevrhcagZlhdb ihdjh\bl_evbkdmkkl\dZl_]hjbq_kdbaZij_lbeijh^Z`mbghkljZgpZf
blZevygkdbo ^j_\ghkl_c <hl lmllh b ijb]h^bebkv aZ[ulu_ fhsb k\ylhc ;jb]bllu
Ijhk\ys_gguc ]eZ\Z dZlhebq_kdhc p_jd\b ij_djZkgh ihgbfZe om^h`_kl\_ggmx b
fZl_jbZevgmxklhbfhklvkdmevilmjudhlhjZyg_reZgb \dZdh_kjZ\g_gb_k hklZldZfb
g_\_^hfh]h ijZoZ Gh ^Z`_ hg g_ fh] ihclb \jZaj_a kh keh`b\r_cky ljZ^bpb_c
ihqblZgbyfhs_cbk^_edZkhklhyeZkv´
< ijZ\hkeZ\ghc p_jd\b ljZ^bpbhggh ihqblZebkv fhsb k\yluo m]h^gbdh\
³Kh[bjZl_e_f fhs_c k\yluo iZljbZjoh\´ gZau\Zeb pZjy :e_dk_y FboZceh\bqZ
i_j_g_kr_]h \ Mki_gkdbc kh[hj hklZgdb \k_o jmkkdbo iZljbZjoh\ Ijb hkgh\Zgbb
I_l_j[mj]Zba<eZ^bfbjZ\h\gh\vhldjulmx:e_dkZg^jhG_\kdmxeZ\jm\ ][ueb
lhj`_kl\_gghi_j_g_k_gufhsbk\ylh]h:e_dkZg^jZG_\kdh]h
KZf bfi_jZlhj I_lj , \klj_lbe r_kl\b_ m k_eZ MklvB`hju i_j_g_k fhsb
m]h^gbdZ d k_[_ \ eh^dm gZ dhlhjhc klZe m jmey Z k\hbo kih^\b`gbdh\ ij_\jZlbe \
ijhkluo]j_[ph\Eh^dZkhimlkl\m_fZyfgh`_kl\hfkm^h\ijb[ueZ\ I_l_j[mj]]^___
\klj_lbeb bfi_jZljbpZ \_kv ^\hj \k_ ^moh\_gkl\h \ky ]\Zj^by b gZjh^ I_lj k
ijb[eb`_ggufb ih^gye k eh^db k\ylugx b i_j_g_k \ hk\ys_ggmx lhevdh \ wlhl ^_gv
gh\mx :e_dkZg^jh\kdmx p_jdh\v ]^_ hgZ b ij_[u\ZeZ ^h ihkljhcdb ]eZ\gh]h kh[hjZ
Iha`_m`_ijbbfi_jZljbp_?dZl_jbg_,,\h\j_fyhk\_s_gbyLjhbpdh]hkh[hjZeZ\ju
Z\]mklZ ]h^Z fhsb :e_dkZg^jZ G_\kdh]h [ueb i_j_g_k_gu lm^Z Fhsb g_keb
dZ\Ze_ju hj^_gZ k\ :e_dkZg^jZ G_\kdh]h aZ fhsZfb reZ bfi_jZljbpZ <h \j_fy
r_kl\by ijhba\h^bebkv dhehdhevguc a\hg b iZev[Z ba imr_d ?s_ \ ]h^m
bfi_jZljbpZ ?ebaZ\_lZ mdjZkbeZ fhsb [h]Zlhx jZdhc ba k_j_[jZ \_khf \ ^_\yghklh
im^h\ K_cqZk wlZ jZdZ gZoh^blky \ WjfblZ`_ Z fhsb :e_dkZg^jZ G_\kdh]h \ [he__
kdjhfghcjZd_²\gh\v\ Ljhbpdhfkh[hj_:e_dkZg^jhG_\kdhceZ\ju
< jZdm]^_ihdhylkyfhsbk\ylh]hK_j]byJZ^hg_`kdh]hLjhbp_K_j]b_\ZeZ\jZ
ih^ Fhkd\hc gZ g_kdhevdh fbgml himkdZeb feZ^_gpZ I_ljZ [m^ms_]h bfi_jZlhjZ
I_ljZ , b p_kZj_\bqZ :e_dkZg^jZ [m^ms_]h bfi_jZlhjZ :e_dkZg^jZ ,, qlh[u
qm^h^_ckl\_ggZykbeZfhs_c[eZ]hkeh\beZbogZkqZkleb\h_pZjkl\h\Zgb_
Ihqlb \ dZ`^hf ba fgh]bo khl_g jmkkdbo fhgZkluj_c \ lukyqZo ijZ\hkeZ\guo
ojZfh\ ojZgbebkv fhsb k\yluo m]h^gbdh\ <kdhj_ ihke_ j_\hexpbb fhsb fgh]bo
k\yluo k\_aeb gZ Zl_bklbq_kdmx \uklZ\dm k l_o ihj bo ke_^u l_jyxlky G_^Z\gh ijb
ijh\_jd_nhg^h\\ ojZgbebs_DZaZgkdh]hkh[hjZ\ E_gbg]jZ^_Fma_cbklhjbbj_eb]bb
b Zl_bafZgZrebij_^f_lihoh`bcgZqZklvf_[_ebGZg_]hg_[uehgbdZdboZdlh\b
^hdmf_glh\: dh]^Z_]h\kdjuebh[gZjm`beblZffhsbk\ylh]hK_jZnbfZKZjh\kdh]h
k lhci_qZevghagZf_gblhcZl_bklbq_kdhc\uklZ\db
Ij_ih^h[guc K_jZnbf KZjh\kdbc \ fbjm Ijhohj Fhrdbg ² fhgZo
ih^\b`gbd dhgpZ ;9,,, \_dZ h^bg ba gZb[he__ qlbfuo jmkkdbo k\yluo gZb[he__
ihqblZ_fucm]h^gbdihke_^g_cpZjkdhck_fvbIhwlhfmijZ\hkeZ\gZyp_jdh\vljZdlm_l
\lhjh_h[j_l_gb_fhs_cdZdkh[ulb_fbjh\hc\Z`ghklb
GZ p_j_fhgbb i_j_^Zqb fhs_c k\ylh]h K_jZnbfZ KZjh\kdh]h ijZ\hkeZ\ghc
p_jd\b khklhy\r_cky yg\Zjy ]h^Z \ DZaZgkdhf kh[hj_ \ E_gbg]jZ^_
ijbkmlkl\h\ZeIZljbZjo:e_dkbc,,b fgh]b_\ukrb_b_jZjobijZ\hkeZ\ghcp_jd\bqlh
k\b^_l_evkl\m_lh g_hkeZ[_\Zxs_cljZ^bpbbihqblZgbyfhs_cb \gZklhys__\j_fy
<kdhj_ ihke_ j_\hexpbb \ _ ]h^u jZa\_jgmeZkv rbjhdZy dZfiZgby ih
\kdjulbx fhs_c ih \k_f p_jd\yf b fhgZklujyf Jhkkbb ;ueb h[gZjm`_gu
fgh`_kl\_ggu_ nZevkbnbdZpbb fhs_c \f_klh fmfbnbpbjh\Zgguo hklZgdh\ qZklh
h[gZjm`b\Zeb ebrv h^_`^u gZ[blu_ ljyidZfb b \_lhrvx beb ihembkle_\rb_ dhklb
Wlhbf_eh]jhfZ^gh_agZq_gb_^eyZl_bklbq_kdhcijhiZ]Zg^u\ lh\j_fyK_cqZk`_\k_
wlh jZkp_gb\Z_lky dZd ihjm]Zgb_ gZpbhgZevguo k\ylugv Imklv k lhqdb aj_gby
f_^bpbgu b [bheh]bb gZc^_ggu_ fhsb b g_ khhl\_lkl\h\Zeb ijbagZdZf _kl_kl\_gghc
fmfbnbdZpbbk dhlhjufb fu ihagZdhfbebkv \ wlhc ]eZ\_ gZjh^gZy \_jZ ij_\jZlbeZ
bo\ k\ylu_j_ebd\bbqlh[uihfgyh gjZ\kl\_gghfb^_Ze_q_eh\_dg_l_jyeky\ fhj_
aeZ
Gha^_kvfum`_dZkZ_fkyijh[e_fufgh]h\_dh\h]hdhgnebdlZgZmdbb j_eb]bb
^moh\gh]h b fZl_jbZevgh]h jZaj_rblv dhlhjuc ihdZ _s_ gbdhfm g_ m^Zehkv Fu `_
i_j_c^_f d g_ f_g__ keh`ghfm wlbq_kdhfm \hijhkm h ijZ\hf_jghklb aZohjhg_gby
fmfbc\h`^_c\ fZ\ahe_yo
EBL?J:LMJ:
K DZe_^bg Kfbj_ggh_ deZ^[bs_ ³Gh\uc fbj´ ‹ AZ[_ebg B HibkZgb_
gh\]hjh^kdhck\ylugb\ ]h^mQl_gbyHB>JDgKf_kv
IjhklZykljZrgZybklhjby ³IjZ\^Z´ ‹ n_\jZey ]h^Z B Ebk_\bq Meu[dZ
³[_kkf_jlgh]h´klZjpZ³GZmdZb j_eb]by´6 ‹
FmjZ\v_\:G Iml_r_kl\b_ihk\yluff_klZfjmkkdbfKI[
Fheb [h]Z h gZk ³<_q_jgbc E_gbg]jZ^´ ‹ yg\Zjy E_[_^bgkdbc < B <
m^b\bl_evghffbj_dZfgyF³G_^jZ´Iuey_\FB KlZjucI_l_j[mj]Ba^:
KKm\hjbgZKI_l_j[mj]
<Zebr_\kdbb D Kfmlgh_ \j_fy KI_l_j[mj] ? : JZggm Ijhreh_ klZjh]h
LZeebggZLZeebggI_jbh^bdZ
Ygbg<E G_djhihevGh\]hjh^kdh]hKhnbckdh]hkh[hjZF³GZmdZ´
F_a_gp_\ < : Qm^_kZ IhimeyjgZy wgpbdehi_^by :efZ:lZ =e j_^ DZa kh\
wgpbdehi_^bbldgb]Z
F_a_gp_\ < : Qm^_kZ IhimeyjgZy wgpbdehi_^by :efZ:lZ =e j_^ DZa kh\
wgpbdehi_^bbldgb]Z
DZd\hkdj_kblvfmfbx³GZmdZb j_eb]by´‹ LZdkbevE K\ys_gguc\_jl_iF³Iheblba^Zl´
=E:<:,;
Fmfby\ fZ\ahe__
>mrghcbxevkdhcghqvx]h^Zy \ur_eba\Z]hgZgZKhnbckdhf\hdaZe_>h
hlijZ\e_gby gm`gh]h fg_ ih_a^Z gZ Ieh\^b\ hklZ\Zehkv g_kdhevdh qZkh\ b y ihr_e
ih[jh^blv ih ghqghc Khnbb >h\hevgh [ukljh y ^h[jZeky ^h p_gljZevghc iehsZ^b
dhlhjmx h`b^Ze m\b^_lv lhj`_kl\_ggh ijblbor_c dZdhc \b^_e g_ jZa k g_ih^\b`gh
aZf_jrbfb nb]mjZfb ihq_lgh]h dZjZmeZ m ^\_j_c fZ\ahe_y k ijhklhc gZ^ibkvx gZ^
\oh^hf ³=_hj]bc >bfbljh\´ Ihfgx fheqZeb\mx hq_j_^v ex^_c b^msbo fbfh
kl_deyggh]h kZjdhnZ]Z \ dhlhjhf bkdmkgh kdjulufb ijh`_dlhjZfb hk\_sZehkv
[eZ]hjh^gh_ ebph b keh`_ggu_ jmdb gZpbhgZevgh]h ]_jhy ;he]Zjbb ih[_^bl_ey
e_cipb]kdh]hijhp_kkZDZaZehkvqlhlZd[m^_l\k_]^Z
Gh k_cqZk ijhbkoh^beh g_qlh kljZggh_ G_kfhljy gZ iha^gbc qZk iehsZ^v
[mjebeZ __ aZihegyeb ^_kyldb iZeZlhd \kx^m \bk_eb ehamg]b g_fukebfu_ a^_kv _s_
iylvr_klv f_kyp_\ gZaZ^ <hjhlZ fZ\ahe_y [ueb iehlgh aZi_jlu ihq_lguc dZjZme
hlkmlkl\h\Ze Z kl_gu [ueb hde__gu ieZdZlZfb ijbau\Zxsbfb ³\u[jhkblv \hg
fmfbx´ Dhg_qgh y [ue bgnhjfbjh\Zg h ijhp_kkZo ijhbkoh^ysbo \ ;he]Zjbb gh
lZdh]hklj_fbl_evgh]hjZa\blbykh[ulbcg_h`b^Ze
bxeyy \gh\vijb_oZebaIeh\^b\Z\ Khnbxb klZek\b^_l_e_fbklhjbq_kdh]h
kh[ulby²\ wlhl^_gvbafZ\ahe_y\ug_keb]jh[k l_ehf >bfbljh\Z GZ p_gljZevghf
khnbckdhf deZ^[bs_ [ueZ ijh\_^_gZ dj_fZpby gZ dhlhjhc ih `_eZgbx k_fvb
ijbkmlkl\h\Zeb lhevdh [ebadb_ = >bfbljh\Z Q_j_a g_kdhevdh ^g_c mjgm k i_iehf
>bfbljh\Zihohjhgbeb\ fh]bem_]hjh^guogZkhnbckdhfdeZ^[bs_Y kt_a^belm^ZD
fh_fmm^b\e_gbxgZfh]be_gbdh]hg_[uehdjhf_^\mofbebpbhg_jh\hojZgy\rbo__
AZlh [mr_\ZeZ lheiZ i_j_^ himkl_\rbf fZ\ahe__\ mkljhb\ hdheh ^\_j_c
]b]Zglkdmx bfijh\babjh\Zggmx k\Zedm G_keb \kydmx jmoey^v klmevy fmkhj gh
[hevr_\k_]h[uehdgb]JhklZb jhkeZ]hjZba \u[jhr_gguo ljm^h\ lh]h d dhfm _s_
lZd g_^Z\gh \ukljZb\ZeZkv ^ebggZy hq_j_^v [eZ]h]h\_cgh fheqZsbo ex^_c GZb[he__
eZdhgbqgh gZ wlh bklhjbq_kdh_ kh[ulb_ hlj_Z]bjh\Ze _`_g_^_evgbd ³ \_d´ Hj]Zg
JZ^bdZe^_fhdjZlbq_kdhciZjlbb;he]Zjbb‹ hlbxey]h^Z³<_ebdbckug´
gZdhg_pih]j_[_gFZ\ahe_cimklFZ]Zabgulh`_´Gh_s_[he__djZlhd[ueieZdZlgZ
^\_jyofZ\ahe_y³>bfbljh\k [h]hfBevbq[m^v]hlh\´
Y g_kh[bjZxkv^Zb g_kfh]mijhZgZebabjh\Zlv\ wlhcdgb]_\_kvoh^b ijbqbgu
djmr_gbydhffmgbklbq_kdhckbkl_fu \ <hklhqghc ?\jhi_ F_gy bgl_j_km_l \ ^Zgghf
kemqZ_ ebrv h^bg djhohlguc Zki_dl g_ihf_jgh_ \ha\_ebqb\Zgb_ Z aZl_f klhev `_
klj_fbl_evgh_gba\_j`_gb_ebqghklb\h`^yijhy\eyxs__ky\ jblmZe__]haZohjhg_gby
GhfZ\ahe_c>bfbljh\Z\ Khnbb²ebrvke_ihdk FZ\ahe_yjZkiheh`_ggh]h\ k_j^p_
gZr_cJh^bguIhwlhfmgZqZlvijb^_lkyba^Ze_dZ
S_i_lbevguc\hijhkh [m^ms_faZohjhg_gbbE_gbgZgZh[km`^Zekyg_dhlhjufb
qe_gZfb Ihebl[xjh aZ^he]h ^h dhgqbgu \h`^y hk_gvx ]h^Z K\_^_gby h[ wlRf
kh\_sZgbb bf_xlky \ \hkihfbgZgbyo Ljhpdh]h <Ze_glbgh\Z h[km`^Zxlky \
j_eb]bh\_^q_kdhcebl_jZlmj_AZiZ^ZAZ]h\hjbeh lhfqlh\ kemqZ_kf_jlbE_gbg´_]h
ke_^m_l ihohjhgblv gZ hkh[uc fZg_j F DZebgbg ?]h lml `_ ih^^_j`Ze B KlZebg
kdZaZ\rbc qlh ohjhgblv E_gbgZ gZ^h hq_\b^gh ih jmkkdhfm h[jy^m lh _klv ij_^Zlv
a_fe_ gh k wlbf ki_rblv g_evay Ljhpdbc ;moZjbg DZf_g_\ \uklmiZeb ijhlb\
khojZg_gbyl_eZ\h`^yihke__]hkf_jlbKlZebgDZebgbgb ^jm]b_²aZ
<b^bfh ihke_ wlh]h kh\_sZgby KlZebg ijh^he`Z\ h[^mfu\Zlv b^_x fZ\ahe_y
fmfbnbpbjh\Zgbyl_eZE_gbgZdZd\k_]^Z²lZcgh\ h^bghq_kl\_gb kd_fg_^_eykv
k\hbfbieZgZfbg_ihk\ysZy\ gbo^Z`__^bghfure_ggbdh\
BgbpbZlb\Z KlZebgZ j_r_gb_ Ij_ab^bmfZ <PBD ijhba\_eb gZ \k_o rhdh\h_
\i_qZle_gb_ K lhqdb aj_gby \k_o dhgn_kkbc \_jhbkih\_^Zgbc Jhkkbb lh [ueh
g_keuoZggh_ b g_\b^Zggh_ dhsmgkl\h gZ^jm]Zl_evkl\h gZ^ l_ehf \h`^y ?keb d lhfm
\j_f_gb^moh\_gkl\hkljZgug_[ueh[uhj]ZgbaZpbhgghjZa]jhfe_gh_keb[uij_klb`
ij_`gbo dhgn_kkbc g_ miZe lh lZdhc rZ] KlZebgZ g_ gZr_e [u gb ih^^_j`db gb
hijZ\^Zgby KlZebg \ub]jZe i_j\uc hldjuluc [hc \ j_eb]bhaghf khagZgbb kljZgu
aZeh`b\ hkgh\u gh\h]h dmevlZ Hg \klZe gZ^ fhgh[h`b_f gZ^ \k_fb dhgn_kkbyfb
kljZgu aZklZ\b\ j_eb]bhagh_ khagZgb_ fZkk hlklmiblv gZaZ^ \ ]em[v \_dh\ \ klhjhgm
yauq_kl\Z
BlZd\ ]h^ml_eh<BE_gbgZ[ueh[ZevaZfbjh\Zghihf_lh^mki_pbZevgh
jZajZ[hlZgghfmZgZlhfZfb²ijhn_kkhjZfb<<hjh[v_\ufb ;A[Zjkdbfb ihf_s_gh
\ ki_pbZevgh ihkljh_gguc gZ DjZkghc iehsZ^b fZ\ahe_c < dhgp_ ]h^Z [ueZ
kha^ZgZ GZmqghbkke_^h\Zl_evkdZy eZ[hjZlhjby Fbga^jZ\Z KKKJ ijb FZ\ahe__ < B
E_gbgZ Jmdh\h^kl\h wlhc g_[hevrhc q_eh\_dZ ]jmiihc bkke_^h\Zl_e_c
aZgbfZ\rboky\k_fdhfie_dkhfijh[e_fk\yaZgguok khojZg_gb_f l_eZ < B E_gbgZ
[uehihjmq_gh;BA[Zjkdhfm
<kdhj_ ihke_ gZqZeZ <_ebdhc Hl_q_kl\_gghc \hcgu lhqg__ bxey l_eh < B
E_gbgZ [ueh w\Zdmbjh\Zgh \ Lxf_gv ]^_ ih^ gZ[ex^_gb_f mq_guo eZ[hjZlhjbb hgh
gZoh^behkv\iehlv^hfZjlZ]h^Z]hk_gly[jy\gh\vhldjue^\_jbFZ\ahe_c<
B E_gbgZ < ihke_^mxsb_ ]h^u eZ[hjZlhjby ijb FZ\ahe__ [ueZ aZf_lgh jZkrbj_gZ
\hajhkb dhfie_dkklhysboi_j_^g_cgZmqguob gZmqghijZdlbq_kdboaZ^Zq
Qlhgh\h]h\g_k_gheZ[hjZlhjb_c\ ijh[e_fm[ZevaZfbjh\Zgbyb khojZg_gbyl_eZ
< B E_gbgZ" Djmigu_ mkh\_jr_gkl\h\Zgby dhkgmebkv ij_`^_ \k_]h l_ogbq_kdbo
klhjhg K^_eZg gZijbf_j [_amdhjbag_gguc k bg`_g_jghc lhqdb aj_gby b
\_ebdhe_iguc \ om^h`_kl\_gghf hlghr_gbb kZjdhnZ] Hk\_s_gb_ ebpZ b dbkl_c jmd
ijhba\h^blky \ g_f fgh]hqbke_ggufb imqdZfb k\_lZ dhlhju_ ih^Zxlky hl
bahebjh\Zggh]hfhsgh]hbklhqgbdZihkl_deyggufk\_lh\h^Zfih^djurdmkZjdhnZ]Zb
ihke_ hlk_q_gby mevljZnbhe_lh\uo b l_ieh\uo emq_c gZijZ\eyxlky \gba gZ l_eh
<gmljb ]_jf_lbq_kdh]h kZjdhnZ]Z ijZdlbq_kdb mkljZg_gu dhe_[Zgby l_fi_jZlmju b
\eZ`ghklb>eykjZ\g_gbyi_j\uckZjdhnZ]\ dhlhjucihf_klbeb l_ehE_gbgZbf_e
nhjfm kl_deygghc ijbafu [hdh\u_ iehkdhklb dhlhjhc a_jdZevgh i_j_^Z\Zeb
bah[jZ`_gb_ Hk\_s_gb_ \ g_f [ueh kZfuf ijhkluf k ihfhsvx h[uqguo
we_dljbq_kdbo eZfihq_d mdj_ie_gguo \^hev \_jog_c hkljhc ]jZgb ijbafu EZfihqdb
kbevghgZ]j_\Zebl_ehb ihwlhfmboijboh^behkvi_jbh^bq_kdb\udexqZlv
<Z`gh b lh qlh m^Zehkv mklZgh\blv hilbfZevgu_ kihkh[u ih^^_j`Zgby
ihklhygkl\Z\eZ]b\ ldZgyol_eZK wlhcp_evxj_]meyjghijhba\h^blky^hihegbl_evgh_
ijhiblu\Zgb__]h[ZevaZfbjmxsbfjZkl\hjhfb i_jbh^bq_kdbZwjhahevghm\eZ`gyxlky
dh`gu_ ihdjh\u Hkh[ufb ijb_fZfb \hkklZgh\e_gu gZijbf_j mljZq_ggu_ ij_`^_
h[t_fu fy]dbo ldZg_c Mq_guf m^Zehkv ^h[blvky lZd`_ jZ\ghf_jghc p\_lghklb
dh`gh]h ihdjh\Z Bfb jZajZ[hlZgu lhqgu_ kihkh[u nhlhj_]bkljZpbb h[t_fh\ b
j_ev_nZebpZb dbkl_cjmddhlhju_iha\heyxlmeh\blvg_aZf_lgu_^ey]eZaZbaf_g_gby
K ihfhsvx we_dljhgghc b k\_lh\hc fbdjhkdhibb kbkl_fZlbq_kdb bkke_^mxlky lZd`_
f_evqZcrb_dmkhqdbldZg_c
Fh`gh dhgklZlbjh\Zlv \ gZklhys__ \j_fy \ ldZgyo l_eZ gZklmibe i_jbh^
klZ[bebaZpbb \k_o nbabdhobfbq_kdbo ijhp_kkh\ <h \kydhf kemqZ_ bo qj_a\uqZcgh
f_^e_ggh_ l_q_gb_ ihqlb g_meh\bfh kh\j_f_ggufb obfbq_kdbfb nbabq_kdbfb beb
fbdjhkdhibq_kdbfb kihkh[Zfb IjZdlbq_kdb ijbhklZgh\e_gu lZd`_ gZbf_g__
klZ[bevgu_ijhp_kkuhdbke_gbyb ]b^jhebaZ`bjZ
< ]h^m Kh\_lhf Fbgbkljh\ KKKJ [ueZ kha^ZgZ ki_pbZevgZy
ijZ\bl_evkl\_ggZy dhfbkkby ^ey bamq_gby ^_yl_evghklb GZmqghbkke_^h\Zl_evkdhc
eZ[hjZlhjbb Fbga^jZ\Z KKKJ ijb FZ\ahe__ < B E_gbgZ < khklZ\ wlhc \_kvfZ
ij_^klZ\bl_evghc dhfbkkbb \oh^beh q_eh\_d djmig_crbo ki_pbZebklh\ gZr_c
kljZgu \ h[eZklb iZlheh]bq_kdhc ZgZlhfbb [bhobfbb fhe_dmeyjghc [bheh]bb
<u\h^u dhfbkkbb [ueb h^ghagZqgu l_eh < B E_gbgZ fh`_l khojZgylvky \
g_baf_g_gghf\b^_\_jhylgh_s_g_h^bg^_kylhde_l
< ]h^mihke_kf_jlbB<KlZebgZ_]hl_ehlZd`_[ueh[ZevaZfbjh\Zghb
ihf_s_gh\ FZ\ahe__jy^hfk kZjdhnZ]hf<BE_gbgZGhm`_q_j_ae_l\ hdly[j_
]h^ZgZ;;,,kt_a^_DIKK[uehijbgylhj_r_gb_h \ughk_l_eZB<KlZebgZba
FZ\ahe_yJ_r_gb_[uehijbgylhhdly[jyihij_^eh`_gbxBKibjb^hgh\Zhlbf_gb
E_gbg]jZ^kdhc iZjlbcghc hj]ZgbaZpbb I_j\hgZqZevgh ieZgbjh\Zehkv i_j_aZohjhgblv
KlZebgZ gZ Gh\h^_\bqv_f deZ^[bs_ iha`_ [ueh j_r_gh qlh aZohjhg_gb_ [m^_l aZ
FZ\ahe__fE_gbgZm Dj_fe_\kdhckl_gu
H lhf dZd ijhbkoh^beh i_j_aZohjhg_gb_ fh`gh magZlv ba \hkihfbgZgbc N
Dhg_\Z kem`b\r_]h \ lh \j_fy dhfZg^bjhf Dj_fe_\kdh]h ihedZ ³D qZkZf hdly[jy]h^ZgZjy^ufbebpbbhqbklbebDjZkgmxiehsZ^vb aZdjueb\k_\oh^ugZ
g__ih^l_fij_^eh]hfqlh[m^_lijhba\h^blvkyj_i_lbpbyl_ogbdb\hckdFhkdh\kdh]h
]ZjgbahgZd iZjZ^m
Dh]^Z kl_fg_eh f_klh ]^_ j_r_gh [ueh hljulv fh]bem h[g_keb nZg_jhc b
hk\_lbebwe_dljbq_kdbfijh`_dlhjhfIjbf_jghd qZkmkhe^Zlu\udhiZebfh]bemb
d g_cih^g_keb^_kylv`_e_ah[_lhgguoiebljZaf_jhfOkf KbeZfbkhljm^gbdh\
dhf_g^Zlmju FZ\ahe_y b gZmqguo jZ[hlgbdh\ l_eh KlZebgZ batyeb ba kZjdhnZ]Z b
i_j_eh`beb\ ^hsZluc]jh[h[blucdjZkghcfZl_jb_cGZfmg^bj_ahehlu_im]h\bpu
aZf_gbebgZeZlmggu_L_ehihdjueb\mZevxl_fgh]hp\_lZhklZ\b\hldjulufebphb
iheh\bgm]jm^b=jh[mklZgh\beb\ dhfgZl_jy^hfk ljZmjgufaZehf\ FZ\ahe__
< ijb[ueZ dhfbkkby ih i_j_aZohjhg_gbx dhlhjmx \ha]eZ\eye G
R\_jgbd Ba jh^kl\_ggbdh\ gbdh]h g_ [ueh Qm\kl\h\Zehkv qlh m \k_o djZcg_
ih^Z\e_ggh_khklhygb_hkh[_gghm GR\_jgbdZ
Dh]^Z aZdjueb ]jh[ djurdhc g_ hdZaZehkv ]\ha^_c qlh[u ijb[blv __ Wlhl
]jhfZo[ukljhmkljZgbeihedh\gbd;LZjZkh\gZqZevgbdohahl^_eZAZl_fijb]eZkbeb
\hk_fv hnbp_jh\ ihedZ dhlhju_ ih^gyeb ]jh[ gZ jmdb b \ug_keb ba FZ\ahe_y q_j_a
[hdh\hc\uoh^
< wlh \j_fy ih DjZkghc iehsZ^b ijhoh^beb kljhcgufb jy^Zfb Z\lhfh[beb
lj_gbjmykvd iZjZ^m
D qZkZf fbgmlZf ]jh[ ih^g_keb d fh]be_ b mklZgh\beb gZ ih^klZ\db GZ
^g_fh]beuba\hkvfb`_e_ah[_lhgguoiebl[uek^_eZgk\h_h[jZaguckZjdhnZ]Ihke_
fbgmlgh]h fheqZgby ]jh[ hklhjh`gh himklbeb \ fh]bem Ij_^iheZ]Zehkv ]jh[ k\_jom
ijbdjulv _s_ ^\mfy `_e_ah[_lhggufb ieblZfb Gh ihedh\gbd ; LZjZkh\ ij_^eh`be
ieblZfbg_aZdju\ZlvZ ijhklhaZkuiZlva_fe_c
Ihjmkkdhfmh[uqZxdh_dlhbahnbp_jh\\ lhfqbke_b ymdjZ^dhc[jhkbebih
]hjklb a_feb b khe^Zlu aZdhiZeb fh]bem meh`b\ gZ g_c ieblm k ]h^Zfb jh`^_gby b
kf_jlbKlZebgZdhlhjZyfgh]he_lijhe_`ZeZ\ lZdhf\b^_^hmklZgh\e_gbyiZfylgbdZ
[xklZ´
;ZevaZfbjh\Zgb_ l_e \h`^_c dhffmgbklbq_kdh]h ^\b`_gby b ihf_s_gb_ bo \
ki_pbZevgu_ fZ\ahe_b ^ey \k_h[s_]h h[haj_gby b ihdehg_gby ij_\jZsZehkv \
ljZ^bpbhgguc jblmZe < Zjobl_dlmj_ khpbZebklbq_kdbo kljZg [ue \ujZ[hlZg gh\uc
ijbgpbi kljhbl_evkl\Z fZ\ahe__\ \u^Zxsboky ^_yl_e_c kh\f_sZxsbo h^gh\j_f_ggh
b mkuiZevgbpm b ljb[mgm < ]h^m ihke_ kf_jlb =_hj]by >bfbljh\Z ijb ihfhsb
kh\_lkdboki_pbZebklh\baGZmqghbkke_^h\Zl_evkdhceZ[hjZlhjbbijbFZ\ahe__<B
E_gbgZ _]h l_eh lZd`_ [ueh [ZevaZfbjh\Zgh b \uklZ\e_gh \ ki_pbZevgh ihkljh_gghf
fZ\ahe__gZp_gljZevghciehsZ^bKhnbb
< klhebp_ Fhg]hebb MeZg;Zlhj_ \ fZ\ahe__ ihdhylky l_eZ hkgh\Zl_e_c
fhg]hevkdhc gZjh^ghj_\hexpbhgghc iZjlbb Kmow;ZlhjZ ² b ij_fv_j
fbgbkljZFGJk ]h^ZQhc[ZekZgZ²
k_gly[jy ]h^Z gZ ]h^m `bagb kdhgqZeky ij_ab^_gl <v_lgZfZ Oh Rb
Fbg< k\h_faZ\_sZgbbhim[ebdh\Zgghfebrve_lkimklyhgibkZe
³Dh]^Z y mfjm g_ gZ^h mkljZb\Zlv iurguo ihohjhg qlh[u g_ jZkoh^h\Zlv
ihgZijZkgm \j_fy b kj_^kl\Z gZjh^Z Y ijhrm qlh[u fhb hklZgdb [ueb kh``_gu lh
_klv dj_fbjh\Zgu GZ^_xkv qlh dj_fZpby klZg_l h[s_c ijZdlbdhc Wlh g_ lhevdh
ohjhrh^ey`b\uok lhqdbaj_gby]b]b_gughb iha\hebllZd`_kwdhghfblviZohlgmx
a_fex Dh]^Z m gZk [m^ml [hevrb_ aZiZku we_dljhwg_j]bb _s_ emqr_ ijh\h^blv
we_dljhdj_fZpbxJZa^_ebl_fhcijZogZljbqZklbb ihf_klbl__]h\ ljbd_jZfbq_kdb_
mjguh^gZ²^eyK_\_jZh^gZ²^eyP_gljZb h^gZ²^eyX]ZkljZgu< dZ`^hcba
qZkl_c aZohjhgbl_ mjgm k ijZohf gZ ohef_ GZ fh]be_ g_ gZ^h klZ\blv gb dZf_ggmx
kl_em gb [jhgah\mx klZlmx <f_klh wlh]h gZ^h ihkljhblv ijhklhc ijhklhjguc
ijhqguc b ijhoeZ^guc ^hf ]^_ imlgbdb fh]eb [u hl^hogmlv GZ^h jZajZ[hlZlv ieZg
ihkZ^db^_j_\v_\gZwlboohefZob \hdjm]gboImklv]hklbkZ`Zxl^_j_\vygZiZfylv
Kh\j_f_g_fwlbihkZ^dbh[jZamxl e_kZdhlhju_mdjZkyli_caZ`b [m^mlihe_agu^ey
k_evkdh]hohayckl\ZAZ[hlmh[wlbo^_j_\vyoke_^m_lihjmqblvf_klgufklZjbdZf´
H^gZdhihke_^gyy\heyIj_ab^_glZg_[ueZbkiheg_gZ
H^gbf ba ]eZ\guf mqZklgbdh\ ^Zevg_crbo kh[ulbc [ue ^bj_dlhj GZmqgh
bkke_^h\Zl_evkdhc eZ[hjZlhjbb :FG K_j]_c K_j]__\bq >_[h\ Hg \kihfbgZ_l ³<
OZghc fu ijb[ueb \ dhgp_ Z\]mklZ dh]^Z khklhygb_ Oh Rb FbgZ [ueh m`_ ih
kms_kl\m[_agZ^_`gufMljhfk_gly[jyaZgZfbijbreZfZrbgZb kjhqgh^hklZ\beZ\
c ]hkiblZevIhimlbgZfkhh[sbebh kf_jlb\v_lgZfkdh]hij_ab^_glZ< ]hkiblZe_
fu ijh\_eb \kdjulb_ b i_j\hgZqZevgh_ [ZevaZfbjh\Zgb_ qlh[u l_eh fh`gh [ueh
\uklZ\blv ^ey ijhsZgby \h >\hjp_ kh[jZgbc ;Z^bgv H lhf qlh \ aZ\_sZgbb Oh Rb
Fbgijhkbedj_fbjh\Zlv_]hhklZgdbfugbq_]hg_agZeb´
DZd `_ ihemqbehkv qlh kh\_lkdb_ ki_pbZebklu ih [ZevaZfbjh\Zgbx aZjZg__
hdZaZebkv \ OZgh_" Ba\_klgh qlh ^ey jZ[hl ih [ZevaZfbjh\Zgbx hklZgdh\ \b^guo
aZjm[_`guo ^_yl_e_c lj_[h\Zehkv j_r_gb_ Ihebl[xjh PD DIKK Fh`gh
ke_^h\Zl_evghij_^iheh`blvqlhlh]^Zrg__jmdh\h^kl\h<v_lgZfZbkoh^ybaemqrbo
ih[m`^_gbc aZ]h^y h[jZlbehkv d kh\_lkdhc klhjhg_ k ijhkv[hc hdZaZlv kh^_ckl\b_ \
khojZg_gbb l_eZ Oh Rb FbgZ <ihke_^kl\bb `_ \ ]h^m wlhfm rZ]m [ueh ^Zgh
lZdh_h[tykg_gb_\ dhfxgbd_ Ihebl[xjh PDDI<³IjbgbfZy\h\gbfZgb_qm\kl\Zb
ih`_eZgby gZjh^Z Ihebl[xjh PD iZjlbb ]h khau\Z khqeh g_h[oh^bfuf khojZgblv
l_eh Oh Rb FbgZ k l_f qlh[u \ [m^ms_f gZjh^ \k_c gZr_c kljZgu \ lhf qbke_
khhl_q_kl\_ggbdb gZ X]_ Z lZd`_ gZrb aZjm[_`gu_ ^jmavy fh]eb hl^Zlv _fm ^Zgv
iZfylbb \ujZablvk\hb]em[hdb_qm\kl\Zdg_fm´
BlZd\klZe\hijhkh ^Zevg_crbojZ[hlZoih[ZevaZfbjh\ZgbxhklZgdh\OhRb
FbgZ Ki_pbZebklu \ h^bg ]hehk ml\_j`^Zeb qlh l_eh gm`gh kjhqgh \u\hablv \
Fhkd\m b ijh\h^blv \k_ jZ[hlu lZf bgZq_ ^_eh h[j_q_gh gZ ijh\Ze <v_lgZfkdh_
jmdh\h^kl\h dZl_]hjbq_kdb \hkijhlb\behkv b gZklZb\Zeh gZ ijh\_^_gbb
[ZevaZfbjh\Zgby\ OZgh_
D m]h\hjZf \kihfbgZ_l ZdZ^_fbd >_[h\ ih^dexqbeky : G Dhku]bg dhlhjuc
\h]eZ\_kh\_lkdhciZjlbcghijZ\bl_evkl\_gghc^_e_]Zpbbijb[ue\ OZghc^eymqZklby
\ ljZmjguof_jhijbylbyoJmdh\h^kl\h<v_lgZfZijh^he`ZehklhylvgZk\h_fDhku]bg
\ue_l_e\ Fhkd\mb ^heh`beh keh`b\r_ckykblmZpbbgZIhebl[xjhPDDIKK;ueh
j_r_ghihclbgZ\klj_qmih`_eZgbx\v_lgZfkdhcklhjhgu< kqblZggu_^gb\ OZghcih
\ha^mom i_j_[jhkbeb h[hjm^h\Zgb_ g_h[oh^bfh_ ^ey [ZevaZfbjh\Zgby l_eZ b _]h
^Zevg_cr_]hkhojZg_gby
Kh\_lkdb_ ki_pbZebklu ijbklmibeb d jZ[hl_ gh \k_ gh\u_ keh`ghklb ijyfh
lZdb ij_ke_^h\Zeb ^_eh ijhlb\ dhlhjh]h dZd dZaZehkv hiheqbeZkv kZfZ km^v[Z
:f_jbdZgkdZyZ\bZpbygZqZeZfZkkbjh\Zggu_[hf[Zj^bjh\dbOZghyIjbrehkvkjhqgh
i_j_[jZku\Zlv eZ[hjZlhjbx gZ aZiZkghc k_dj_lguc imgdl dbehf_ljZo \ ² hl
klhebpu G_kfhljy gZ keh`g_crb_ mkeh\by hgZ [ueZ jZa\_jgmlZ gZ gh\hf f_kl_ aZ
dZdb_lh ^\_ g_^_eb Lhevdh \k_ gZqZeb mkihdZb\Zlvky dZd ihklmibeZ _s_ h^gZ
lj_\h`gZy \_klv g_ih^Ze_dm \ukZ^beky Zf_jbdZgkdbc \_jlhe_lguc ^_kZgl B hiylv
ijbrehkvki_rghk\hjZqb\ZlveZ[hjZlhjbxb i_j_\hablv__ gZgh\h_f_klh
GZk_cjZa__ j_rbebjZaf_klblvg_ih^Ze_dmhlj_dbQ_jghc\ [hevrhci_s_j_m
ih^gh`by h]jhfghc kdZeu kihkh[ghc dZd ml\_j`^Zeb \u^_j`Zlv fgh]hlhgguc
[hf[h\uc m^Zj Lhqgh_ f_klhgZoh`^_gb_ wlhc ³lhqdb´ gZ \kydbc kemqZc
aZdhgk_j\bjh\Zgghcb ihk_c^_gvkhojZgy_lky\ lZcg_Z m`lh]^Z\h\j_fy\hcgu\k_
k\yaZggh_ k g_c [ueh hdjm`_gh kljh`Zcr_c k_dj_lghklvx Kh\_lkdb_ khljm^gbdb
dhlhju_ kh]eZkgh jZajZ[hlZgghc e_]_g^_ \u^Z\Zeb k_[y aZ ki_pbZebklh\ ih e_kghfm
ohayckl\mijb_a`Zeblm^ZlhevdhihghqZfLZdijh^he`Zehkv^hdhgpZ\hcgu
Lhj`_kl\_ggZy p_j_fhgby hldjulby mkuiZevgbpu \h`^y khklhyeZkv m`_ ihke_
\hcgu Z\]mklZ ]h^Z \ dZgmg gZpbhgZevgh]h ijZa^gbdZ Kljh]b_ dhehggu
fZ\ahe_y ih^gyebkv gZ lhf kZfhf f_kl_ hldm^Z k_gly[jy ]h^Z Oh Rb Fbg
ijh\ha]eZkbe>_deZjZpbxg_aZ\bkbfhklb
Kljh]bc b \_ebq_kl\_gguc fZ\ahe_c Oh Rb FbgZ gZoh^ysbcky \ p_glj_
]eZ\ghc oZghckdhc iehsZ^b ;Z^bgv aZf_lgh ij_\hkoh^bl jZaf_jZfb e_gbgkdbc \
Fhkd\_ MkuiZevgbpZ ² wlh g_ lhevdh kZjdhnZ] k l_ehf gh b fhsgu_ oheh^bevgu_
mklZgh\db kbkl_fu dhg^bpbhgbjh\Zgby \ha^moZ l_e_dZf_ju b fhgblhju ebgbb
we_dljhkgZ[`_gby b ^jm]b_ kbkl_fu `bag_h[_ki_q_gby <k_ wlh keh`gh_ ohayckl\h
\dexqZy jZamf__lky hojZg fZ\ahe_y gZoh^blky \ \_^_gbb ki_pbZevgh]h Zjf_ckdh]h
mijZ\e_gby
AZ\_jrZ_l p_iv iurguo fZ\ahe__\ fZ\ahe_c FZh Pa_ >mgZ \ I_dbg_ ]^_ \
kZjdhnZ]_ ba ]hjgh]h ojmklZey [ueh ihf_s_gh gZ[ZevaZfbjh\Zggh_ l_eh dblZckdh]h
\h`^yihke__]hkf_jlb\ ]h^m
Gh dZd m`_ [ueh kdZaZgh \k_ wlb fZ\ahe_b ² ebrv ^Zgv ljZ^bpbb \i_j\u_
aZjh^b\r_cky \ Jhkkbb ihke_ kf_jlb < B E_gbgZ =^_ bkdZlv bklhdb wlhc ljZ^bpbb"
<_^v h^gZ ba kljZrg_crbo \h \k_ \j_f_gZ dZj ² g_ ij_^Z\Zlv l_eZ a_fe_ >Z\Zcl_
ihiulZ_fkyjZah[jZlvky\ wlhf\hijhk_\f_kl_
Dh]^Zfu]h\hjbfkeh\h³fmfby´lhhghm gZk\ i_j\mxhq_j_^vZkkhpbbjm_lkyk
dmevlmjhc>j_\g_]h?]bilZHq_\b^ghohlyhdhgqZl_evghb g_^hdZaZgh_]bilyg_^Z`_
b \ ^hbklhjbq_kdb_ \j_f_gZ [ZevaZfbjh\Zeb mf_jrbo >ey wlhc ijhp_^mju b ^ey
p_j_fhgbb ih]j_[_gby dZklZ `j_ph\ jZa\beZ ki_pbZevguc p_j_fhgbZe L_ogbdZ
[ZevaZfbjh\Zgbybaeh`_gZ\ g_dhlhjuol_dklZolh]h\j_f_gbij_`^_\k_]h\ ba\_klghc
³Dgb]_f_jl\uo´
FZgmkdjbil h kf_jlb b khojZg_gbb l_e mf_jrbo gZa\Zgguc iha^g__ ³Dgb]hc
f_jl\uo´ kha^Zeb `j_pu ba ^hebgu GbeZ \h \j_f_gZ i_j\hc _]bi_lkdhc ^bgZklbb
hdheh]h^Z^hgZr_cwjuHl^_evgu_njZ]f_gluwlh]hkhqbg_gbykhojZgbebkv^h
gZrbo ^g_c ;he__ iha^gb_ \_jkbb ³Dgb]b f_jl\uo´ [ueb ^hiheg_gu `j_pZfb
=_ebhihey b gZg_k_gu fgh`_kl\hf j_f_ke_ggbdh\ \ \b^_ b_jh]ebnh\ gZ kl_gZo
ihf_s_gbcb i_j_oh^h\\gmljbibjZfb^jZkiheh`_gguo\ KZoZj_\ i_jbh^hcb hc
^bgZklbc Wlb ijhba\_^_gby gZa\Zgu ³L_dklZfb ibjZfb^´ Gh\u_ l_dklu g_j_^dh k
bah[jZ`_gb_f jZaebqguo nb]mj \h \j_f_gZ hc b hc ^bgZklbc gZghkbeb gZ
[hdh\u_ kl_gdb kZjdhnZ]h\ lZd gZau\Z_fu_ ³L_dklu kZjdhnZ]h\´ Z \ i_jbh^ hc
^bgZklbb ² gZ iZibjmk ihkj_^kl\hf b_jZlbq_kdh]h beb b_jh]ebnbq_kdh]h \b^h\
ibkvfZ GZdhg_p \h \j_f_gZ Ilhehf_y kms_kl\h\Ze l_dkl gZ iZibjmk_ ih^h[guc
r_klhc\_jkbbWlhliZibjmkk l_dklhfg_ba\_klgh]hZ\lhjZ[ueh[gZjm`_g\ hl^_evghf
dhgl_cg_j_\g_kZjdhnZ]Z< dZq_kl\_ojZgbebsZ^eyiZibjmkh\bkihevah\ZebkvklZlmb
[h]h\ beb qmq_eZ ilbp h[uqgh yklj_[h\ Ihke_^gyy \_jkby hlghkysZyky d =j_dh
Jbfkdhcwiho_b kh^_j`ZsZy\u^_j`dbbal_dklh\gZdmkhqdZoiZibjmkZ[ueZgZibkZgZ
hq_gvg_jZa[hjqb\ufbagZdZfb
Kh\_jr_gghg_ihgylghihq_fm\_jkbb³Dgb]bf_jl\uo´\uiheg_ggu_klhe_lby
kimklylZdjZabl_evghhlebqZxlky^jm]hl^jm]Zihklbexkh^_j`ZgbxfZg_j_ibkvfZ
<hafh`gh qlh `_eZgb_ \eZklbl_e_c hc ^bgZklbb bf_lv k\hx \_jkbx fZgmkdjbilZ
h[mkeh\beh kha^Zgb_ `j_pZfb gh\h]h \ZjbZglZ i_j\hgZqZevgh]h l_dklZ Ihke_^mxsb_
\_jkbb \j_f_g Ilhehf_y [ueb f_g__ lhqgu \ gbo ijhims_gu \Z`gu_ njZ]f_glu
jZggbol_dklh\Djhf_lh]hjZagu_kibkdb³Dgb]bf_jl\uo´g_lh`^_kl\_ggu\u[hjb
ihjy^hd l_dklh\ qZklh [ue ijhba\hevguf Ijb\_klb \k_ wlb \a]ey^u \ kljhcgmx
ihke_^h\Zl_evgmxkbkl_fmg_\hafh`gh
>\_gZ^pZlbqe_ggZydhfihabpbyhq_jq_gZ gZb[he__ykgh\ ³Dgb]_:f^mZl´ HgZ
hljZ`Z_l b b^_x aZ]jh[gh]h \ha^Zygby rbjhdh ba\_klgmx p_gbl_eyf _]bi_lkdhc
dmevlmju ih hibkZgbyf ³ikbohklZabb´ ³\a\_rb\Zgby ^mrb´ gZ km^_ HabjbkZ kp_gu
dZjugZ^]j_rgbdZfbfu\b^bf\ ihke_^gboqZklyo³Dgb]b:f^mZl´Ghwlhqbrvh^bg
Zki_dl ³dgb] aZ]jh[gh]h fbjZ´ =eZ\guf `_ ij_^klZ\ey_lky ^jm]h_ ² hlh`^_kl\e_gb_
mkhir_]h- <_ebdbf;h]hf\ _]hjZaebqguobihklZkyoJZHabhbkl\_j^h_agZgb_bf_g
[h]h\b ^_fhgh\dhlhju_\klj_qZxlky\ aZij_^_evghffbj_
WlZ dhgp_ipby ² g_ ieh^ \hevgh]h fbnhl\hjq_kl\Z hgZ bf__l ]em[hdh_
ikboheh]bq_kdh_ h[hkgh\Zgb_ ?]bilyg_ kqblZeb qlh q_eh\_d _s_ ijb `bagb ^he`_g
ihagZlvlZcgu_imlbfbjZaZij_^_evgh]hqm`^h]h[ulh\hfmhiulm[he__lh]h^he`_g
keblvky k \ukrbfb ijhy\e_gbyfb wlh]h fbjZ ² bgZq_ g_\hafh`gh [eZ`_gkl\h \
aZ]jh[ghf pZjkl\_ WlZ b^_y gZoh^bl khhl\_lkl\b_ \ jh^kl\_gghf iZfylgbd_ fbjh\hc
dmevlmju²lb[_lkdhc³Dgb]_f_jl\uo´\hafh`ghhgZ\hkoh^bld lhfm`_bklhqgbdm
qlhb _]bi_lkdb_dgb]baZ]jh[gh]hfbjZ
Ijhp_kk fmfbnbpbjh\Zgby [ue ^h\hevgh ^he]bf b djhihleb\uf hg ^ebeky ^g_c KjZam `_ ihke_ ij_^iheZ]Z_fhc kf_jlb q_eh\_dZ `j_p ^_eZe gZ^j_a gZ e_\hc
iheh\bg_ `b\hlZ mf_jr_]h b ihki_rgh ba\e_dZe gh` qlh[u g_ gZ\e_qv gZ k_[y ]g_\
[ebadbo b jh^kl\_ggbdh\ ihdhcgh]h LZdhc h[uqZc \hagbd \ j_amevlZl_ kemqZ_\
ij_`^_\j_f_ggh]h hrb[hqgh]h mklZgh\e_gby kf_jlb AZl_f ihfhsgbdb ba\e_dZeb
\gmlj_ggb_ hj]Zgu aZ bkdexq_gb_f k_j^pZ kj_^hlhqby ^mrb b fukeb lsZl_evgh
ijhfu\Zeb bo ZjhfZlbq_kdbfb `b^dhklyfb b aZihegyeb bo fbjjhc b ZjhfZlbq_kdbfb
\_s_kl\ZfbAZl_f\k_\gh\vihf_sZebgZf_klhb aZrb\ZebgZl_j_\[ZevaZfbjmxsbfb
\_s_kl\Zfb K ihfhsvx obljhmfgh]h djxqdZ q_j_a gha^jb ihdhcgh]h ba\e_dZeb ih
qZklyf fha] Z ihehklv q_j_iZ lZd`_ aZihegyeb ki_pbyfb L_eh h[fu\Zeb khe_\uf
jZkl\hjhf b hklZ\eyeb gZ ^g_c aZl_f h[fu\Zeb _s_ jZa gZlbjZeb dZf_^vx
h[_jlu\ZebihehlgZfbldZg_cb ihf_sZeb\ ^_j_\ygguckZjdhnZ]
KZfhc^j_\g_cq_eh\_q_kdhcfmfbbe_lHgZgZc^_gZg_\ ?]bil_Z \Qbeb
b gZoh^blky\ gZklhys__\j_fy\ KZglvy]h\ GZpbhgZevghffma__bklhjbbijbjh^u
Fmfby ij_^klZ\ey_l kh[hc aZ[ZevaZfbjh\Zggh_ l_eh q_luj_oe_lg_]h j_[_gdZ
HgZ [ueZ h[gZjm`_gZ \ ]h^m ^\mfy qbebckdbfb Zgljhiheh]Zfb \ h^ghf ba
imklugguo jZchgh\ gZ k_\_j_ Qbeb < ]h^m fmfby [ueZ gZijZ\e_gZ \ KR: \
eZ[hjZlhjbxGvx>`_jkbgZijh\_^_gb_wdki_jlbaudhlhjZyih^l\_j^beZ__ \hajZkl
LmjO_c_j^Ze]h\hjyh dhglZdlZof_`^mGh\ufb KlZjufK\_lhf\ h[s_cp_ib
^hdZaZl_evkl\ ijb\h^bl b ke_^mxsb_ h[t_^bgyxsb_ ijbagZdb dhehkkZevgu_
khhjm`_gby ebr_ggu_ ijZdlbq_kdbo nmgdpbc gZijbf_j ibjZfb^u f_]Zeblbq_kdb_
kZjdhnZ]bk fZkkb\ghcdZf_gghcdjurdhcfmfbnbdZpbyk ijbf_g_gb_fkfhe[bglh\b
oehidh\hcgZ[b\dbLZdbfh[jZahfh[uqZc[ZevaZfbjh\Zgbymkhirbob ihf_s_gbybo
\ kZjdhnZ]bb ibjZfb^u\hkoh^bld kZfuf^j_\gbfwihoZfq_eh\_q_kdhcpb\bebaZpbb
Koh^kl\h ih]j_[Zevguo h[jy^h\ ^j_\g_crbo pb\bebaZpbc KlZjh]h b Gh\h]h K\_lZ
jZkp_gb\Z_lky g_dhlhjufb mq_gufb dZd ^hdZaZl_evkl\h \ebygby gZ wlb pb\bebaZpbb
g_dhc fbnbq_kdhc ijZpb\bebaZpbb jZkiheZ]Z\r_cky f_`^m wlbfb dhglbg_glZfb
gZijbf_jih]b[gm\r_c:leZglb^u
Dhj_ggh_ gZk_e_gb_ DZgZjkdbo hkljh\h\ ² ]mZgqb ² fgh]b_ ki_pbZebklu
kqblZxlijyfufbihlhfdZfb:leZglh\M`_d gZqZem;9,\_dZ]mZgqb[uebiheghklvx
bklj_[e_gu bkiZgkdbfb aZ\h_\Zl_eyfb ihwlhfm k\_^_gbc h[ wlhf gZjh^_ hklZehkv
g_fgh]h Gh b lh]h qlh hklZehkv aZnbdkbjh\Zgh \ g_fgh]hqbke_gguo bklhqgbdZo
^hklZlhqghqlh[uml\_j`^Zlvboh[uqZbh[gZjm`b\ZebkljZggh_koh^kl\hk h[uqZyfb
\ukhdhdmevlmjguo ^j_\gbo gZjh^h\ < qZklghklb hgb [ZevaZfbjh\Zeb f_jl\_ph\ dZd
_]bilyg_b ohjhgbebbo\ dmihehh[jZaguo]jh[gbpZodZd]j_db\ Fbd_gZo
< ]h^mZf_jbdZgkdZyZjo_heh]bq_kdZywdki_^bpbyijh\h^b\rZyjZkdhidb\
?]bil_ \ jZchg_ WevNZcxfZ h[gZjm`beZ deZ^[bs_ hlghkys__ky d ]j_dhjbfkdhfm
i_jbh^m bklhjbb ?]bilZ GZb[hevrbc bgl_j_k mq_guo \ua\ZeZ ij_djZkgh
khojZgb\rZyky fmfby `_gsbgu HgZ gZoh^beZkv \ ihahehq_gghf kZjdhnZ]_
bki_sj_gghf ibkvf_gZfb dhlhjuc [ue bkdmkgh h[\bl ihehlgygufb e_glZfb b
mdjZr_g \_gdhf ba gZlmjZevguo p\_lh\ <k_ wlh ihf_sZehkv \ [he__ ijhklhjghf
^_j_\ygghf kZjdhnZ]_ Jy^hf gZoh^beZkv fmfby feZ^_gpZ hq_\b^gh kugZ
aZohjhg_gghc`_gsbgu
³GZoh^dZ \ wevNZcxf_ hlghkblky d gZqZem i_j\h]h \_dZ gZr_c wju HgZ
bgl_j_kgZ g_ lhevdh k\h_c ij_djZkghc khojZgghklvx b [h]Zluf hnhjfe_gb_f Wlh
aZohjhg_gb_ bf__l [hevrh_ gZmqgh_ agZq_gb_´² ]h\hjbl ^bj_dlhj ^_iZjlZf_glZ
^j_\ghkl_c Kj_^g_]h ?]bilZ ^hdlhj :eb wevOheb² ³P_gghklv gZoh^db dZd wlh gb
iZjZ^hdkZevghg_\ __^j_\ghklbZ \kjZ\gbl_evghcfheh^hklbFum[_`^Z_fky\ lhf
qlh bkdmkkl\h [ZevaZfbjh\Zgby ijhp\_lZ\r__ \ >j_\g_f ?]bil_ aZ ^_kyldb \_dh\ ^h
gZr_c wju _s_ khojZgyehkv \h \j_f_gZ ihy\e_gby ojbklbZgkl\Z´ NZcxfkdZy fmfby
^hklZ\e_gZ \ DZbj \ GZpbhgZevguc fma_c ^ey bamq_gby b jZkrbnjh\db l_dklh\ gZ
ihahehq_gghfkZjdhnZ]_<hafh`gh\kdhj_fukfh`_fmagZlv[hevr_h[h[gZjm`_gghc
\ wevNZcxf_³FZ^hgg_k feZ^_gp_f´
Ijb\_^_ggu_ gZfb nZdlu k\b^_l_evkl\mxl h lhf qlh h[uqZc [ZevaZfbjh\Zgby
ihdhcgbdh\ kms_kl\h\Ze g_kdhevdh lukyq_e_lbc b [ue jZkijhkljZg_g kj_^b ^j_\gbo
pb\bebaZpbcdZdKlZjh]hlZdb Gh\h]hK\_lZH[uqZcwlhl\ ?]bil__s_khojZgyeky\
Zglbqgmxwihomb ^Z`_\h\j_f_gZihy\e_gbyojbklbZgkl\Z
Gb ]j_dhjbfkdZy dmevlmjZ gb ojbklbZgkl\h gb bkeZf m`_ g_ agZeb ljZ^bpbb
[ZevaZfbjh\Zgbyb khojZg_gbyljmih\IjZ\^Z\ bkdexqbl_evguokemqZyodhgk_j\Zpby
ljmih\\k_`_hkms_kl\eyeZkv
:glbqguc bklhjbd :jjbZg jZkkdZau\Z_l qlh dh]^Z :e_dkZg^j FZd_^hgkdbc
\g_aZighkdhgqZekygZh[jZlghfimlbbaBg^bb\ \hajZkl_e_l_]hkih^\b`gbdbg_
aZohl_eb hklZ\eylv ljmi \_ebdh]h ihedh\h^pZ gZ qm`[bg_ < lh `_ \j_fy \ mkeh\byo
`Zju [ueh g_\hafh`gh ljZgkihjlbjh\Zlv ljmi ba <Z\behgZ lZd dZd hg fhf_glZevgh
ih^\_j]ky [u jZaeh`_gbx <uoh^ [ue gZc^_g ]em[hdmx \Zggm gZihegbeb ^h\_jom
k\_`bf f_^hf Z \ f_^ ih]jmabeb ljmi :e_dkZg^jZ FZd_^hgkdh]h < lZdhf \b^_ _]h b
i_j_\_aeb ba <Z\behgZ \ ?]bi_l ]^_ b aZohjhgbeb Ljmi khojZgyeky g_ jZaeZ]Zykv
ljbklZ e_l Dh]^Z \ , \_d_ gZr_c wju jbfkdbc bfi_jZlhj HdlZ\bZg :\]mkl aZ\h_\Z\
?]bi_l\kdjueba\e_q_ggmxbak\ylbebsZ]jh[gbpmFZd_^hgkdh]hlhhg[uebamfe_g
l_f qlh ljmi hlebqgh khojZgbeky :\]mkl h^_e gZ ]heh\m agZf_gblh]h ihedh\h^pZ
\_g_pZ l_ehhkuiZep\_lZfb
KhojZg_gb_l_eihdhcgbdh\\ f_^m\ Zglbqgmxwihomijbf_gyehkvdjZcg_j_^dh
gh \k_lZdb ijbf_gyehkv Fg_ m^Zehkv hlukdZlv _s_ ^\Z k\b^_l_evkl\Z wlh]h h[uqZy
ihfbfhjZkkdZaZ:jjbZgZh[:e_dkZg^j_FZd_^hgkdhfLZd\ ,9\_d_^hgw\ KiZjlm
[ueh^hklZ\e_ghih]jm`_gguf\ f_^l_ehpZjy:]_kbeZymf_jr_]h\ :njbd_
< kZlbj_ ^j_\g_jbfkdh]h kZlbjbdZ FZjdZ L_j_gpby <ZjjhgZ ³E_[_^v beb h
Ih]j_[_gbb´hldhlhjhckhojZgbebkvebrvg_[hevrb_njZ]f_glubf__lkyke_^mxsZy
njZaZ³KlZeh[ulv=_jZdeb^IhglbckdbcjZamfg_cqlh\_eblk`b]Zlvihdhcgbdh\q_f
>_fhdjbl ² ojZgblv bo \ f_^m Dh]^Z [u \k_ ^_eZeb ih _]h lh ijhiZ^b y ijhiZ^hf
_keb[ufh`gh[uehqZrdmf_^h\hckuludmiblvaZklh^_gZjb_\´
Ih mp_e_\r_fm njZ]f_glm ljm^gh km^blv h q_f `_ dhgdj_lgh b^_l j_qv gh
g_khfg_gghhiylvmihfyg_lh[uqZcdhgk_j\Zpbbljmih\\ f_^m
Gh \k_ `_ ^Z`_ \ Zglbqgmx wihom h[uqZc dhgk_j\Zpbb l_eZ ihdhcgbdZ [ue
kdhj__ j_^dbf bkdexq_gb_f q_f ijZ\behf Hldm^Z `_ \^jm] \kieueZ b^_y
[ZevaZfbjh\Zgbyl_eZ<BE_gbgZ"Fh`_l[ulvihbkdZlvhl\_lgZwlhl\hijhk\ [he__
[ebadhc^eygZkjhkkbckdhcbklhjbb"
?^bgkl\_ggmx ijZ\^Z hq_gv hl^Ze_ggmx ZgZeh]bx m^Z_lky ijhke_^blv \
bklhjbbaZohjhg_gbyl_eZIhl_fdbgZDZdba\_klghnZ\hjbl?dZl_jbgu,,k\_le_crbc
dgyav =jb]hjbc :e_dkZg^jh\bq Ihl_fdbgLZ\jbq_kdbc kdhgqZeky \ ^hjh]_ gZ imlb ba
Ykk\ GbdheZ_\hdly[jy]h^ZLjmiIhl_fdbgZ[ueijb\_a_gh[jZlgh\ Ykkul_eh
[ueh ZgZlhfbjh\Zgh b [ZevaZfbjh\Zgh Hli_lh_ l_eh Ihl_fdbgZ klhyeh k YkkZo ^h
ghy[jyb aZl_f[uehi_j_\_a_gh\ O_jkhgb ihklZ\e_gh\ ih^ihevghfkde_i_dj_ihklghc
p_jd\bK\?dZl_jbgu=jh[hklZ\Zekyg_hims_gguf\ a_fexk ]hghy[jy]h^Z
ih Zij_ey ]h^Z @bl_eb O_jkhgZ a^_kv kem`beb iZgbob^u b ijboh^beb
ihdehgblvkyijZomIhl_fdbgZ
>hr_^rbc^hbfi_jZlhjZIZ\eZkemoqlhl_ehIhl_fdbgZ[he__k_fbe_lklhbl
g_ ij_^Zgguf a_fe_ \ua\Ze jZkihjy`_gb_ ihohjhgblv _]h dZd ]eZkbe mdZa ³[_a
^Zevg_cr_ch]eZkdb\ kZfhf`_lhff_kl_\hhkh[h\ujulmxyfmZ ih]j_[aZkuiZlvb
aZ]eZ^blva_fe_xlZddZd[u_]hgbdh]^Zg_[ueh´qlhb \uihegbeb
F B Iuey_\ khh[sb\rbc wlb nZdlu g_ ijb\h^bl ih[m^bl_evguo fhlb\h\
[ZevaZfbjh\Zgby l_eZ Ihl_fdbgZ b klhev ^he]h]h ojZg_gby _]h \ g_ih]j_[_gghf
khklhygbb Y ^mfZx qlh \k_ wlh b [ZevaZfbjh\Zgb_ b hlkjhqdZ aZohjhg_gby [ueh
k\yaZgh g_ k ihiuldhc baf_gblv ljZ^bpbx ijZ\hkeZ\gh]h ih]j_[_gby Z k g_ykghklvx
^Zevg_cr_c iheblbq_kdhc kblmZpbb <_evfh`m jZ\gh]h ih jZg]m b iheblbq_kdhfm
agZq_gbx Ihl_fdbgm iheZ]Zehkv ohjhgblv \ klhebp_ Gh hoeZ`^_gb_ ?dZl_jbgu d
[u\r_fm nZ\hjblm b mkbe_gb_ \ebygby nZ\hjblZ gh\h]h IeZlhgZ Am[h\Z
ij_iylkl\h\Zeb wlhfm < lh `_ \j_fy klhjhggbdb Ihl_fdbgZ \_jhylgh g_ hklZ\eyeb
gZ^_`^u i_j_\_alb l_eh \ I_l_j[mj] b ^hklhcgh aZohjhgblv _]h lZf ihq_fm b g_
ki_rbeb k ihohjhgZfb \ O_jkhg_ Ijboh^ d \eZklb bfi_jZlhjZ IZ\eZ , klZjh]h
ijhlb\gbdZ Ihl_fdbgZ hdhgqZl_evgh ebrbe bo wlhc gZ^_`^u b kihkh[kl\h\Ze
ih]j_[_gbx l_eZ k\_le_cr_]h dgyay LZdbf h[jZahf ^Zgguc bklhjbq_kdbc wibah^ g_
fh`_lkqblZlvkyijyfufij_^r_kl\_ggbdhffZ\ahe_yGh_klv_s_h^bg[he__[ebadbc
ihagZq_gbxZgZeh]\ jmkkdhcbklhjbb
FZehdhfmba\_klghqlh\ gZr_ckljZg_ojZgblkyb ^hklmi_ghkfhljm_s_h^bg
ljmi agZf_gblh]h q_eh\_dZ Y bf_x \ \b^m fmfbnbpbjh\Zggh_ l_eh lZeZgleb\_cr_]h
jmkkdh]hobjmj]ZGbdheZyB\Zgh\bqZIbjh]h\ZojZgys__ky\ kde_i__]hmkZ^v[u\ k_e_
<brgy ih^ <bggbp_c Ihevamykv i_j\hc `_ \hafh`ghklvx \ ^_dZ[j_ ]h^Z y
\u_oZe \ <bggbpm qlh[u jZamagZlv h[h \k_f ihih^jh[g__ KemqZc dh]^Z \_jmxsbc
ojbklbZgbghklZ\Zekyg_ih]j_[_gguf\ l_q_gb_[he__ klZ e_l gbdZd g_ mdeZ^u\Zeky \
jZfdbljZ^bpbhggh]hijZ\hkeZ\by
HdZau\Z_lky l_eh Ibjh]h\Z [ueh [ZevaZfbjh\Zgh ih bgbpbZlb\_ _]h \lhjhc
`_gu :e_dkZg^ju :glhgh\gu < k\h_ \j_fy hgZ ijhqeZ dgb]m h^gh]h ba mq_gbdh\
Ibjh]h\Z ijhn_kkhjZ >Z\b^Z BevbqZ <u\h^p_\Z ² h [ZevaZfbjh\Zgbb
dgb]Z wlZ b k_cqZk ojZgblky \ wdkihabpbb mkZ^v[ufma_y G B Ibjh]h\Z \ <brgyo
Dgb]Z wlZ gZklhevdh ihljykeZ __ qlh hgZ gZklhyl_evgh ijhkbeZ <u\h^p_\Z \ kemqZ_
kf_jlbfm`ZaZ[ZevaZfbjh\Zlv_]hl_ehihjZajZ[hlZgguf<u\h^p_\ufj_p_ilZf
Ke_^m_laZf_lblvqlh\ ;,;\_d_m`_[uebba\_klgukihkh[uijh^he`bl_evghc
dhgk_j\Zpbb ljmiZ iml_f \\_^_gby \ g_]h Zglbk_ilbq_kdbo \_s_kl\ hklZgZ\eb\Zxsbo
]gb_gb_ ihke_ q_]h g_ba[_`gh ke_^m_l fmfbnbdZpby ?s_ \ ;9,, \_d_ ZgZlhfm
Nj_^_jbdm Jxbrm \k_fbjgmx ba\_klghklv ijbg_k _]h kihkh[ ^ebl_evgh khojZgylv
ZgZlhfbq_kdb_ ij_iZjZlu b [ZevaZfbjh\Zlv ljmiu Jxbr hkgh\Ze \ >Zgbb
ZgZlhfbq_kdbcfma_c²ihhlau\Zfkh\j_f_ggbdh\³\hkvfh_qm^hk\_lZ´
< ]h^m I_lj , g_h^ghdjZlgh ihk_sZe ZgZlhfbq_kdbc l_Zlj JxbrZ \
:fkl_j^Zf_ijbkmlkl\h\ZegZ_]he_dpbyoZ iha`_i_j_ibku\Zekyk gbfb h[f_gb\Zeky
j_^dbfbdhee_dpbyfb<h\lhjhck\hcijb_a^\ :fkl_j^Zf\ ]h^mI_lj,dmibem
JxbrZ ^ey _kl_kl\_gghgZmqgh]h fma_y ² ³DmgkldZf_ju gZlmjZevguo \_s_c´ ²
[hevrmxdhee_dpbxZgZlhfbq_kdboij_iZjZlh\L_i_jv³DmgkldZf_jZ´i_j_bf_gh\ZgZ\
Fma_c Zgljhiheh]bb b wlgh]jZnbb bf_gb I_ljZ <_ebdh]h Jhkkbckdhc ZdZ^_fbb gZmd
=hklb KI_l_j[mj]Z fh]ml ihk_lblv wlhl fma_c b k\hbfb ]eZaZfb m[_^blvky \
\_ebdhe_ighckhojZgghklbZgZlhfbq_kdboij_iZjZlh\badhee_dpbbNj_^_jbdZJxbrZ
< gZklhys__ \j_fy kZfuf ijhkluf kihkh[hf dhgk_j\Zpbb ljmih\ y\ey_lky
kihkh[ ij_^eh`_gguc ijhn_kkhjhf I : FbgZdh\uf ² dhlhjuc
aZdexqZ_lky\ lhfqlh\ [jxrgmx]jm^gmxb q_j_igmxihehklvg_\kdjulh]hljmiZijb
ihfhsb rijbpZ \\h^blky \ h[s_c keh`ghklb ² e kf_kb nhjfZebgZ b
^_gZlmjbjh\Zggh]h kibjlZ ihjh\gm WlZ kf_kv ijhiblu\Z_l \_kv ljmi m[b\Z_l
]gbehklguo fbdjh[h\ hklZgZ\eb\Z_l ]gb_gb_ b miehlgy_l [_edb k\_jlu\Zy bo Ihke_
wlh]h ljmi gZqbgZ_l \ukuoZlv fmfbnbpbjm_lky ijb dhfgZlghc l_fi_jZlmj_ aZ ljb
f_kypZ b hklZ_lky \ lZdhf \b^_ gZ ^he]b_ ]h^u Ih^h[gh_ bkdmkkl\_ggh_
dhgk_j\bjh\Zgb_gZijh^he`bl_evguckjhdg_ijZ\bevghgZau\Z_lky[ZevaZfbjh\Zgb_f
b ijbf_gy_lky\ hkgh\ghf^eyba]hlh\e_gbyfmey`_c\ f_^bpbgkdbobgklblmlZo
GbdheZcB\Zgh\bqIbjh]h\kdhgqZekyghy[jy^_dZ[jy]h^Z\ qZkh\
fbgml \_q_jZ \ \hajZkl_ ]h^Z hl jZdh\hc dZo_dkbb \ua\Zgghc aehdZq_kl\_gghc
ya\hcgZkebabklhch[hehqd_l\_j^h]hg_[ZM`_gZlj_lbc^_gvihke_kf_jlbIbjh]h\Z
ba I_l_j[mj]Z \ <bggbpm ijb[u\Z_l ijhn_kkhj <u\h^p_\ b lml `_ hlijZ\ey_lky \
bf_gb_ <brgy ]^_ g_aZf_^ebl_evgh ijbklmiZ_l d [ZevaZfbjh\Zgbx Ijhp_^mjZ
[ZevaZfbjh\Zgby ^ebeZkv q_luj_ qZkZ D kh`Ze_gbx gZf g_ba\_klgu \k_ k_dj_lu
<u\h^p_\Z ohly hkgh\gu_ j_dhf_g^Zpbb ih bkdmkkl\m [ZevaZfbjh\Zgby kh^_j`Zlky \
_]hdgb]_@_gZohl_eZojZgblv[ZevaZfbjh\Zggh_l_ehIbjh]h\Zijyfh\ k\h_cmkZ^v[_
ghlml\f_rZebkvp_jdh\gu_\eZklbmkfhlj_\\ wlhfdhsmgkl\h
Ibjh]h\[uehli_l\ p_jd\b[ebae_`Zs_]hk_eZR_j_f_lv_\hb aZdjuluc]jh[k
_]h [ZevaZfbjh\Zgguf l_ehf \j_f_ggh ihf_klbeb \ ih^\Ze p_jd\b AZ ^\Z f_kypZ
dj_klvygZfbwlh]hk_eZ[ue\ukljh_gki_pbZevguckde_idm^Zb ihf_klbebl_i_jvm`_
hldjuluc]jh[k l_ehfIbjh]h\ZIha`_kde_ii_j_kljhbebb \ha\_ebgZ^gbfp_jdh\v
GbdheZy Qm^hl\hjpZ \ iZfylv k\ylh]h ihdjh\bl_ey GbdheZy B\Zgh\bqZ Ibjh]h\Z
p_jdh\vaZdjueb\ ]h^m
Reb ]h^u ^_kylbe_lby gZ^ <bggbp_c h^gZ aZ ^jm]hc ijhdZlu\Zebkv \hegu
j_\hexpbb dZca_jh\kdhc hddmiZpbb i_lexjh\sbgu ]jZ`^Zgkdhc \hcgu Z l_eh
Ibjh]h\Z dZd [m^lh aZdhe^h\Zggh_ qm^_kguf bkdmkkl\hf ijhn_kkhjZ <u\h^p_\Z
ijh^he`ZehhklZ\ZlvkylZdbf`_dZd\ ^_gvkf_jlb
< ]h^u<_ebdhcHl_q_kl\_gghc\hcgub nZrbklkdhchddmiZpbbp_jdh\vb kde_i
g_ ihkljZ^Zeb h^gZdh hl \aju\ghc \hegu lj_kgmeZ djurdZ kl_deyggh]h kZjdhnZ]Z
]_jf_lbaZpby [ueZ gZjmr_gZ b l_eh Ibjh]h\Z klZeh ihjlblvky hl ie_k_gb hkh[_ggh
jmdZ< ]h^Zoijh\h^beZkvj_[ZevaZfZpbyfmfbbgZf_kl_b lhevdh\
]h^m l_eh Ibjh]h\Z \i_j\u_ g_gZ^he]h ihdbgmeh <bggbpm b hlijZ\behkv \
Fhkd\m]^_[ueZijhba\_^_gZihke_^gyyj_[ZevaZfZpby
Kde_iIbjh]h\ZgZoh^blky\ dfhl_]hmkZ^v[u<brgyl_i_jvm`_gZhdjZbg_
kh\j_f_gghc<bggbpuK_cqZklZfmkljh_gnbebZefma_ymkZ^v[u<brgyY kimkdZxkv
ih ]jZgblguf klmi_gyf \ kde_i L_eh Ibjh]h\Z ihdhblky \ hldjulhf q_jghf
^_j_\ygghf ]jh[m k ihdjulufb k_j_[jyghc djZkdhc j_agufb mdjZr_gbyfb ² \blu_
jmqdb nb]mjdb Zg]_eh\ gZ djurd_ =jh[ [ue \uiheg_g ih aZdZam `_gu Ibjh]h\Z \
:\kljbb>hiheh\bgul_ehIbjh]h\Zijbdjulh[_ehciZjqhcjmdbkeh`_gugZ`b\hl_
ih\_jo ihdju\ZeZ ^h ihke_^g_c j_[ZevaZfZpbb \ jmdZo gZoh^beky dj_kl k_cqZk _]h
g_l
H^_l Ibjh]h\ \ q_jguc fmg^bj k rblv_f G_l klhev agZdhfuo ih ihjlj_lZf
Ibjh]h\Z iurguo [Zd_g[Zj^h\ \bkdb dhjhldh ih^kljb`_gu g_ijb\uqgh kfhljylky
k_^Zy [hjh^Z b mku Hldjuluc ]jh[ k l_ehf ihdjul kl_deygguf kZjdhnZ]hf
we_dljbq_kdZy ih^k\_ldZ \uo\Zlu\Z_l ebph Ibjh]h\Z ba ihemfjZdZ kde_iZ DjurdZ
]jh[ZklhblgZki_pbZevghf\ha\ur_gbbke_\ZhlkZjdhnZ]ZkijZ\ZhlkZjdhnZ]ZieblZ
ih^dhlhjhce_`blklZjrbckugIbjh]h\Z
Y ^he]hklhyegZ^kZjdhnZ]hf\_ebdh]hobjmj]Z\kfZljb\Zeky\ _]hebphghlZd
b g_ kfh] ihgylv qlh `_ aZklZ\beh _]h jh^kl\_ggbdh\ dhg_qgh `_ g_ [_a kh]eZkby
kZfh]h Ibjh]h\Z j_rblvky gZ klhev kljZgguc g_ bf_xsbc ZgZeh]h\ \ jmkkdhc
dmevlmj_ rZ] Gh ihgylg__ klZgh\beZkv b^_y mki_rgh]h [ZevaZfbjh\Zgby l_eZ < B
E_gbgZ Ij_p_^_gl m`_ kms_kl\h\Ze bf_eky hiul fmfbnbdZpbb b ^ebl_evgh]h
ojZg_gby l_eZ b \hl kimkly ihqlb ihe\_dZ _]h fh`gh [ueh ih\lhjblv G_ agZx
agZdhfu eb [ueb KlZebg DZebgbg b ^jm]b_ qe_gu Ihebl[xjh k bklhjb_c
[ZevaZfbjh\Zgby Ibjh]h\Z fh`_l [ulv b g_l gh \hl \jZqb b iZlheh]hZgZlhfu
[ZevaZfbjh\Z\rb_ l_eh < B E_gbgZ g_khfg_ggh ^he`gu [ueb agZlv jZ[hlu
ijhn_kkhjZ>B<u\h^p_\Zih[ZevaZfbjh\Zgbx
Dh]^Z m`_ [ueZ gZibkZgZ b ]hlh\beZkv \ i_qZlv wlZ dgb]Z fhb ij_^iheh`_gby
ih^l\_j^bebkv < bgl_j\vx ]Za_l_ ³:j]mf_glu b nZdlu´ dhf_g^Zgl FZ\ahe_y <
DZf_gguo aZy\be ³Kihkh[u aZohjhg_gby Ibjh]h\Z b E_gbgZ ijbgpbibZevgh
h^bgZdh\u H^gZdh f_lh^ ih dhlhjhfm aZ[ZevaZfbjh\Zeb l_eh < B E_gbgZ
bah[j_l_gguc \ ]h^m ijhn_kkhjZfb < <hjh[v_\uf b ; A[Zjkdbf [ue [he__
kh\_jr_gguf b hjb]bgZevguf´ < wlhf `_ bgl_j\vx dhf_g^Zgl FZ\ahe_y \i_j\u_
mihfbgZ_l h ^\mo ³ihdmr_gbyo´ gZ l_eh < B E_gbgZ ³LZdbo Äihdmr_gbc [ueh ^\Z
LZd fZjlZ ] h^bg ba ihk_lbl_e_c [jhkbe \ kZjdhnZ] f_lZeebq_kdmx qZklv
fhehldZ b jZa[be kl_deh =jZ`^ZgbgZ aZ^_j`Zeb DZd \uykgbehkv \ihke_^kl\bb hg
hdZaZeky^mr_\gh[hevgufb [uehlijZ\e_ggZe_q_gb_
<lhjh_ijhbahrehk_gly[jy]GZoh^ykv\ ihlhd_ihk_lbl_e_c\ LjZmjghf
aZe_ b g_ hldehgyykv hl fZjrjmlZ ^\b`_gby h^bg ]jZ`^Zgbg ijhba\_e \aju\
aZdj_ie_ggh]h gZ k_[_ kZfh^_evgh]h \aju\gh]h mkljhckl\Z Hg ih]b[ IhkljZ^Zeb b
^jm]b_ihk_lbl_ebKe_^kl\b_mklZgh\behqlhhglh`_y\eyeky^mr_\gh[hevguf´
< gZklhys__ \j_fy \ i_qZlb mkbe_ggh ^bkdmlbjm_lky \hijhk h g_h[oh^bfhklb
aZohjhg_gby l_eZ < B E_gbgZ gZ h^ghf ba deZ^[bs Fhkd\u beb I_l_j[mj]Z Fh`_l
[ulvd fhf_glm\uoh^Zdgb]b\ k\_l\hijhkwlhlhdZ`_lkyj_r_gguf?keb`_g_llh
fg_ohl_ehkv[u\ukdZaZlvk\h_fg_gb_ihwlhfmih\h^m
G_aZ\bkbfhhliheblbq_kdbohp_ghd^_yl_evghklb<BE_gbgZl_eh_]h^he`gh
[ulvkhojZg_gh ^ey\k_h[s_]hh[haj_gby < gZklhys__ \j_fy kZf nZdl kms_kl\h\Zgby
FZ\ahe_y klZe g_hlt_fe_fhc qZklvx dmevlmju gZr_c kljZgu kh\_lkdh]h i_jbh^Z
ihwlhfm _]h g_h[oh^bfh khojZgblv dZd \Z`guc bklhjbq_kdbc iZfylgbd GZ^h ebrv
baf_gblv j_`bf nmgdpbhgbjh\Zgby FZ\ahe_y ij_\jZlb\ _]h ba h[t_dlZ ihdehg_gby \
fma_ckf_gb\ihq_lgucdZjZmegZfma_cguoojZgbl_e_cb \Zol_jh\
EBL?J:LMJ:
JbfkdZy kZlbjZ F ³Om^h`_kl\_ggZy ebl_jZlmjZ´ Iuey_\ F B KlZjuc
I_l_j[mj]²Ba^:KKm\hjbgZKI_l_j[mj]
B:qbev^b_\ B^heHq_jdkhpbheh]bbdmevlZebqghklb³Xghklv´‹ <BS_j[Zdh\ =^_bkdZlv:leZglb^m"³AgZd\hijhkZ´‹
KF_^\_^dZ FZ^hgg_e_l³Ebl_jZlmjgZy]Za_lZ´‹ Z\]mklZ
<GbaZfml^bgh\ G_gZ^hiurguoihohjhg³WohieZg_lu´
KZfZy^j_\gyyfmfby³<_q_jgbcFbgkd´Z\]mklZ
GbdZdhclZcgug_l³=eZkghklv´hdly[jy
?EZaZj_\ Dgb]Zf_jl\uo³GZmdZb j_eb]by´‹ NDhg_\ DZdi_j_aZohjZgb\ZebKlZebgZ³:j]mf_glub nZdlu´‹ FZ\ahe_ckh^_j`blkygZkj_^kl\ZD=;³:j]mf_glub nZdlu´‹
:WMhed_j Kf_jlvfha]ZI_jk Zg]eF³F_^bpbgZ´
=E:<:O
Ih]j_[Zevgu_h[jy^ui_j\h[ulguoie_f_g
Ba^Z\gZ m ij_^klZ\bl_e_c jZaebqguo jZk gZjh^h\ jZaghh[jZaguo \_jh\Zgbc b
dmevlmjkf_jlv[ueZk\yaZgZk ljZ^bpbhggufbih]j_[Zevgufbh[jy^ZfbFh`gh[ueh
[u hklZ\blv \ wlhc njZa_ ij_djZkgh_ jmkkdh_ gZj_qb_ ³ba^Z\gZ´ klhev h[l_dZ_fh_ b
m^h[gh_ ^ey Z\lhjZ gh kljZklv d gZmqghc ^hklh\_jghklb b fh`_l [ulv baebrgbc
i_^Zglbaf ih[m`^Zxl gZk mlhqgblv Z dh]^Z `_ bf_ggh aZjh^bebkv ih]j_[Zevgu_
h[jy^uHl\_lblvgZwlhl\hijhkhdZaZehkvg_lZdlhijhklh
Ij_`^_q_faZ]eygmlv\ bklhdbq_eh\_q_kdhcpb\bebaZpbbgZfgm`gh\kihfgblv
hkgh\gu_ ijbgpbiu ojhgheh]bq_kdbo deZkkbnbdZpbc dZf_ggh]h \_dZ qlh[u aZl_f
k\h[h^gh hi_jbjh\Zlv bfb \ k\hbo jZkkm`^_gbyo BlZd dZf_gguc \_d ijbgylh ^_eblv
gZ ^j_\gbc iZe_hebl b gh\uc g_hebl hlebqZxsbcky l_f qlh ihy\eyxlky
a_fe_^_eb_ `b\hlgh\h^kl\h b ]hgqZjgh_ ijhba\h^kl\h F_`^m ^j_\gbf dZf_gguf
\_dhf iZe_heblhf b gh\uf dZf_gguf \_dhf g_heblhf [ueZ _s_ h^gZ dmevlmjgZy
wihoZ²kj_^gbcdZf_gguc\_dbebf_aheblQ_eh\_dwihobf_aheblZ[ueij_`^_\k_]h
ju[heh\hfb bah[j_eq_eghgi_j\ucijbjmqbekh[Zdm
;hevr_ \k_]h kihjh\ \_^_lky h \hafh`ghklb kms_kl\h\Zgby ih]j_[_gbc m`_ \
wihomiZe_heblZihwlhfmjZkkfhljbfwlhli_jbh^ih^jh[g__LZddZdwihoZiZe_heblZ
[ueZ hq_gv ^ebl_evghc _]h ih^jZa^_eyxl gZ jZaebqgu_ dmevlmjgu_ i_jbh^u I_j\h_
ih^jZa^_e_gb_ iZe_heblZ ij_^eh`be \ ]h^m =Z[jb_ev ^_ Fhjlbev_ ?]h
deZkkbnbdZpb_c fu b [m^_f ihevah\Zlvky lZd dZd kh\j_f_ggh_ [he__ keh`gh_
jZa^_e_gb_ iZe_heblZ baebrg_ ^ey ihklZ\e_gguo gZfb aZ^Zq BlZd jZggbc iZe_hebl
^_eblky gZ ke_^mxsb_ dmevlmjgu_ klmi_gb kgbam \\_jo Z[[_\bev Zr_ev b fmklv_
iha^gbc iZe_hebl kgbam \\_jo ² gZ hjbgvyd khexlj_ b fZ^e_g <k_ wlb klmi_gb
gZa\Zgu ih bf_gb ]jhlh\ b i_s_j \ hkgh\ghf gZ l_jjblhjbb NjZgpbb ]^_ [ueb
h[gZjm`_guke_^ulhcbebbghcdmevlmju
< >xkk_ev^hjn_\ aZiZ^ghc=_jfZgbb[eba\iZ^_gbyj_db>xkk_ev\ J_cg_klv
`b\hibkgZy ^hebgZ dhlhjmx \ ² ]] ex[be ihk_sZlv ^xkk_ev^hjnkdbc
_\Zg]_ebq_kdbcl_heh]b j_dlhjeZlbgkdhcrdheu
BhobfG_Zg^_j< q_klvwlh]hq_eh\_dZlh]^Zhq_gvba\_klgh]h\ l_odjZyohgZb
[ueZgZa\ZgZ³^hebghcG_Zg^_jZ´ihg_f_pdb³G_Zg^_jlZev´Bf_gghlZf\ ]h^m
\i_j\u_ h[gZjm`beb kd_e_lgu_ hklZgdb \uf_jr_]h lbiZ q_eh\_dZ gZa\Zggh]h \ q_klv
wlhc ^hebgu g_Zg^_jlZevp_f BlZd g_Zg^_jlZe_p ² wlh q_eh\_d wihob jZgg_]h
iZe_heblZij_^r_kl\_ggbdkh\j_f_ggh]hlbiZq_eh\_dZ
I_j\u_ \ bklhjbb q_eh\_q_kl\Z aZohjhg_gby ² wlh ih]j_[_gby g_Zg^_jlZevp_\
hlghkysb_ky d fmklv_jkdhfm dmevlmjghfm i_jbh^m kf deZkkbnbdZpbx < ]h^m
r\_cpZj_p Hllh =Zma_j k^_eZe hdheh ihk_edZ Fmklv_ \ ^hebg_ j_db <_a_ju X`gZy
NjZgpby bgl_j_kgh_ m^b\bl_evgh_ hldjulb_ hg gZr_e fh]bem g_Zg^_jlZevkdh]h
xghrb `b\r_]h g_kdhevdh ^_kyldh\ lukyq e_l gZaZ^ < g_]em[hdhc fh]be_ e_`Ze _]h
kd_e_l \ lhc iha_ \ dhlhjhc [ue ihohjhg_g wlhl xghrZ gZ ijZ\hf [hdm ijZ\Zy jmdZ
ih^ ]heh\hc gh]b kh]gmlu Hdheh kd_e_lZ e_`Zeb dj_fgb_\u_ hjm^by b g_kdhevdh
h[h``_gguoa\_jbguodhkl_chgb[ueb^Zguf_jl\hfmgZ^hjh]m\ \_qghklv
Ihke_wlhcgZoh^dbdhlhjZym[_^beZfgh]bo\ lhfqlhq_eh\_q_kdh_khqm\kl\b_
b m\Z`_gb_ d f_jl\hfm \hkoh^yl \ bklhjbb q_eh\_q_kl\Z d kZfuf ^j_\gbf \j_f_gZf
[ue k^_eZg p_euc jy^ ^jm]bo ih^h[guo hldjulbc GZb[he__ ba\_klguf ba gbo
ih`Zemc y\ey_lky hldjulb_ Zjo_heh]hf :e_dk__f IZ\eh\bq_f HdeZ^gbdh\uf \ ]h^m ih]j_[_gby g_Zg^_jlZevkdh]h fZevqbdZ wihob Fmklv_ \ ]jhl_ L_rbdLZr
Ma[_dbklZg?]hdhklbe_`Zeb\ f_edhf m]em[e_gbb <hdjm] q_j_iZ [ueb \hldgmlu \
a_fexjh]Zkb[bjkdh]hdhaeZijbq_fhgbh[jZah\u\Zeb\hdjm]q_j_iZfZevqbdZg_dh_
ih^h[b_ h]jZ^u G_^Ze_dh hl fh]beu [ueb ke_^u g_[hevrh]h dhkljZ dhlhjuc ]hj_e
hq_gvdhjhldh_\j_fy<hafh`ghqlhwlh[uejblmZevguch]hgvbf_\rbchlghr_gb_d
ih]j_[_gbx
<Z`guf Zj]mf_glhf \ ihevam kms_kl\h\Zgby ij_^gZf_j_gguo aZohjhg_gbc
g_Zg^_jlZevp_\ : I HdeZ^gbdh\ kqblZe gZebqb_ yf \ dhlhjuo gZoh^yl bo dhklydb
³DZd[ugb h[tykgblv ijhbkoh`^_gb_lZdboyf bo kms_kl\h\Zgb_ hklZ_lky nZdlhf ih
djZcg_c f_j_ \ ^\mo kemqZyo I_j\uc ² \ ey RZi_evhK_g \lhjhc kZfuc
jZabl_evguc²\ ]jhl_DbbdDh[Z\ Djufm´
Ih fg_gbx ijb\_j`_gp_\ dhgp_ipbb HdeZ^gbdh\Z oZjZdl_jgZy hkh[_gghklv
gZc^_gguog_Zg^_jlZevkdbodhklydh\²h^bgZdh\h_bojZkiheh`_gb_]heh\hcgZ\hklhd
beb gZ aZiZ^ Z g_ gZ x] beb k_\_j ijbq_f \_a^_ \ AZiZ^ghc ?\jhi_ \ Djufm \
IZe_klbg_:IHdeZ^gbdh\kqblZeqlhkemqZcgufwlh[ulvg_fh]ehb mdZau\ZehgZ
hkh[h_ hlghr_gb_ ex^_c lhc wihob d f_jl\uf b kf_jlb b ^Z`_ ij_^iheZ]Zeh
kms_kl\h\Zgb_m g_Zg^_jlZevp_\g_dh_]hkheg_qgh]hdmevlZ
³Kms_kl\_ggh h^gh² ibkZe : I HdeZ^gbdh\² g_Zg^_jlZe_p m`_ m[_^beky
qlh f_jl\_p g_ ijhklh ³kiysbc´ qlh ih hlghr_gbx d g_fm gm`gu hkh[u_ aZ[hlu
dZq_kl\_ggh bgu_ q_f ih hlghr_gbx d `b\hfm q_eh\_dm Hg g_ ijhklh hklZ\eye
f_jl\_pZgZih\_joghklba_feb\ lhciha_\ dZdhc_]haZklb]eZkf_jlvZ ijb^Z\Ze_fm
ihdZ_s_g_hdhq_g_ehl_ehhij_^_e_ggmxkljh]h\u^_j`ZggmxihamdeZe_]hg_dZd
ihiZehg_dZdijbrehkvZ \hij_^_e_gghfgZijZ\e_gbb²]heh\hcgZ\hklhdbebaZiZ^
gZdhg_pihf_sZe_]h\ yfmb aZkuiZea_fe_cHlkx^Zke_^m_lqlhm g_Zg^_jlZevpZm`_
\hagbdeb dZdb_lh b^_b h dZq_kl\_ggh bghc nhjf_ kms_kl\h\Zgby mf_jrbo ihke_
kf_jlbl_i_j\u_b^_bh ³`bagbaZ]jh[hf´
H^gZdh HdeZ^gbdh\ [ue m\_j_g qlh ³gb h dZdbo ih]j_[_gbyo \ ^hfmklv_jkdh_
\j_fy ihkfhljbl_ _s_ jZa gZ deZkkbnbdZpbx \ gZqZe_ ]eZ\u ² K J ]h\hjblv g_
ijboh^blky´ Hg kqblZe [_kkihjguf qlh \ klhev ^Ze_db_ \j_f_gZ ^he`gu [ueb
]hkih^kl\h\Zlv ihem`b\hlgu_ ihembgklbgdlb\gu_ nhjfu ljm^Z k khhl\_lkl\mxsbf
mjh\g_f jZa\blby khagZgby < , ]h^m ba\_klguc Zf_jbdZgkdbc Zgljhiheh] b
Zjo_heh] J Khe_pdb \ i_s_j_ RZgb^Zj \ BjZd_ h[gZjm`be hdZf_g_ehklb ^_\ylb
g_Zg^_jlZevp_\ Q_j_a g_kdhevdh e_l njZgpmakdbc iZe_h[hlZgbd :jg_l E_jmZ=mjZg
bkke_^my \ iZjb`kdhc eZ[hjZlhjbb ihq\m \aylmx ba jZkdhiZ \f_kl_ k q_l\_jluf
rZgb^Zjkdbf kd_e_lhf h[gZjm`beZ lZdh_ dhebq_kl\h iuevpu jZkl_gbc ³dhlhjh_
ij_\hkoh^beh\kydh_\_jhylb_´ijbq_fdh_]^_wlZiuevpZ[ueZ\ dhfhqdZoZ jy^hfk
g_dhlhjufb ba gbo khojZgbebkv ^Z`_ hklZldb qZkl_c p\_ldZ Ba wlh]h [ue k^_eZg
ihjZabl_evguc \u\h^ qlh fh]bem aZ[jhkZeb hoZidZfb p\_lh\ kh[jZgguo gZ kdehg_
]hjuij_^klZ\bl_eblhc]jmiiud dhlhjhcijbgZ^e_`Zemf_jrbchohlgbd
Fgh]b_ ^j_\gb_ gZjh^u deZeb \ fh]beu k\hbo khie_f_ggbdh\ p\_lu qvb
p_e_[gu_k\hckl\Z[uebbfohjhrhba\_klgu<gZqZe_wlhljblmZeij_ke_^h\Ze\iheg_
mlbeblZjgmxp_evmf_jr_fmij_^hklZ\eyeZkv\hafh`ghklvih^e_qblvky b \_jgmlvky \
ehgh jh^ghc k_fvb Z agZqbl ² \ ie_fy D lhfm `_ kbevguc ZjhfZl i_j_[b\Ze aZiZo
le_gby g_cljZebamy g_ijbylgh_ hsms_gb_ hl f_jl\h]h l_eZ Gh h^gZ`^u dlhlh
aZf_lbe qlh p\_lu ² wlh djZkb\h b hgb k^_eZebkv ij_^f_lhf ^Zj_gby MlbeblZjgh
j_eb]bhagZynmgdpbymklmibeZf_klhwkl_lbq_kdhcB fuih k_c ^_gv ijbghkbf p\_lu
gZfh]beudZd^Zgvex[\bb m\Z`_gby
>ey^j_\gbop\_lugZfh]be_^he`gu[uebkbf\hebabjh\ZlvkZfijhp_kk`bagb
b kf_jlb k\_`b_ hgb jZ^mxl ]eZa \uau\Zxl keh`gmx ]Zffm wkl_lbq_kdbo qm\kl\
ihlhf bo djZkdb ihkl_i_ggh [e_dgml e_i_kldb gZqbgZxl m\y^Zlv b hiZ^Zxl gZdhg_p
khdb iblZxsb_ `bagv p\_ldZ me_lmqb\Zxlky p\_lu mfbjZxl <_kv wlhl ijhp_kk ²
keh\gh fh^_ev q_eh\_q_kdh]h [ulby b ljm^gh kdZaZlv qlh bf_ggh ihjh^beh dmevl
jZkl_gbc²e_dZjkl\_ggu_nmgdpbbbebbokbf\hebdZ
<k_ wlh lZd k wlbf ljm^gh g_ kh]eZkblvky Gh hkgh\ghc \hijhk aZdexqZ_lky \
lhf gZkdhevdh hijZ\^Zgh i_j_g_k_gb_ h[uqZ_\ b \_jh\Zgbc iha^g_crbo dmevlmj gZ
g_Zg^_jlZevp_\ dhlhjuo fgh]b_ mq_gu_ mihjgh hldZau\Zebkv ijbagZ\Zlv jZ\gufb ih
mfkl\_gghfmb ikbobq_kdhfmjZa\blbxex^yf[he__iha^gbowiho
G_dhlhju_ mq_gu_ kqblZxl qlh m`_ \ ih\_^_gbb `b\hlguo fh`gh h[gZjm`blv
hij_^_e_ggu_ ^_ckl\by oZjZdl_jgu_ ^ey ij_^gZf_j_ggh]h aZohjhg_gby aZ[jZku\Zgb_
hklZgdh\khjh^bqZa_fe_c\_ldZfbgZdhlhjuofh]eb[ulvb p\_lub ijhq__lZdqlh\
^_ckl\byo g_Zg^_jlZevp_\ g_evay _s_ \b^_lv ijbagZdZ kh[kl\_ggh q_eh\_q_kdhc
ikbobdb b h[gZjm`_ggu_ hklZgdb g_evay kqblZlv ij_^gZf_j_ggufb aZohjhg_gbyfb
>jm]bf Zj]mf_glhf ijhlb\gbdh\ aZohjhg_gbc m g_Zg^_jlZevp_\ y\ey_lky fZeh_
dhebq_kl\h h[gZjm`_gguo aZohjhg_gbc hlkmlkl\b_ _^bguo h[jy^h\ \h \k_o
h[gZjm`_gguoaZohjhg_gbyo
Y kqblZx qlh \k_ wlb ml\_j`^_gby g_^hklZlhqgh m[_^bl_evgu >_ckl\bl_evgh
[hevrb_ \j_f_ggu_ ijhkljZgkl\Z iZe_heblZ wlgbq_kdb_ hkh[_gghklb h[blZ\rbo gZ
jZaghcl_jjblhjbbie_f_gih\j_`^_gbyaZohjhg_gbc\ iha^g_crb_dmevlmjgu_ wihob
fh]eb ih\ebylv gZ mdZaZggmx jZaghoZjZdl_jghklv aZohjhg_gbc Gh \b^bfh \k_lZdb
ke_^m_lijbagZlvqlhi_j\u_aZohjhg_gbyihy\bebkvm`_\ fmklv_jkdmxwihomjZgg_]h
iZe_heblZb ijbgZ^e_`Zebg_Zg^_jlZevpZf
K i_j\hcwihohciha^g_]hiZe_heblZlh_klvk hjbgvydkdhcdmevlmjghcwihohc
k\yaZgukd_e_lgu_hklZgdbq_eh\_dZdhlhju_kbevghhlebqZxlkyihnbabq_kdhfmlbim
hl g_Zg^_jlZevpZ l_f qlh ij_^klZ\eyxl [he__ \ukhdbc mjh\_gv jZa\blby
knhjfbjh\Zgguc [he__ lhgdh LZdbf h[jZahf k wihob hjbgvydZ gZqbgZ_lky gh\Zy
klZ^by \ bklhjbb jZa\blby q_eh\_dZ agZf_gmxsZyky ihy\e_gb_f kh\j_f_ggh]h
q_eh\_dZ dhlhjh]h fu h[hagZqZ_f dZd +RPR VDSLHQV IRVVLOLV Wlb ³jZamfgu_´ ex^b
gZau\Z_fu_ lZd`_ gh\ufb ex^vfb beb g_ZgljhiZfb [ueb ]hjZa^h rbj_
jZkijhkljZg_gu ih a_fe_ q_f g_Zg^_jlZevpu b hklZ\beb ihke_ k_[y fgh]hqbke_ggu_
k\b^_l_evkl\Z\ukhdh]hwdhghfbq_kdh]hh[s_kl\_ggh]hb dmevlmjgh]hjZa\blby
K wlh]h i_jbh^Z gZqbgZxlky m`_ [_kkihjgu_ ih]j_[Zevgu_ h[jy^u Ba\_klgh
fgh]hih]j_[_gbchlghkysbokyd hjbgvydm< h[s_fh gbofh`ghkdZaZlvqlhf_jl\uo
ohjhgbebqZklhlZf`_]^_hgb^hlh]h`bebZ kZfbex^bihdb^Zebwlhf_klhBgh]^Z
deZebljmiijyfhgZhqZ]_keb\ g_f_s_[ueh]hgvl_ehh[]hjZehbebij_\jZsZehkv\
i_i_e b ahem < ^jm]bo f_klZo f_jl\uo ohjhgbeb \ ki_pbZevgh \udhiZgguo fh]beZo
ijbq_f bgh]^Z h[deZ^u\Zeb ]heh\m b gh]b dZfgyfb Dh_]^_ gZ ]heh\m ]jm^v b gh]b
ihdhcgbdZ gZdeZ^u\Zeb dZfgb dZd [m^lh ohl_eb ij_^mij_^blv \hafh`ghklv ^ey
f_jl\h]h \klZlv Wlh \_jhylgh \uau\Zehkv kljZohf i_j_^ f_jl\ufb \ha\jZs_gbx
dhlhjuo gm`gh [ueh \k_fb \hafh`gufb kihkh[Zfb \hkij_iylkl\h\Zlv Ihwlhfm
f_jl\uo ih^qZk k\yau\Zeb b ohjhgbeb \ kbevgh kdhjq_gghf \b^_ F_jl\_ph\ bgh]^Z
hklZ\eyeb\ i_s_j_Z \oh^\ g__aZ\Zeb\Zeb[hevrbfdZfg_fG_j_^dhljmibeblhevdh
]heh\mihkuiZebdjZkghcdjZkdhcK f_jl\uf\ fh]bemdeZebfgh]hjZaebqguo^Zjh\²
mdjZr_gbydZf_ggu_hjm^byibsm
Ba hjbgvydkdbo ih]j_[_gbc hq_gv fgh]b_ ihemqbeb fbjh\mx ba\_klghklv \
qZklghklb ih]j_[_gb_ hohlgbdh\ gZ fZfhglh\ hldjulh_ \ ]h^m \ Ijr_^fhklb
hdhehIjr_jh\Z[u\rZyQ_ohkeh\ZdbyA^_kv[uehgZc^_ghkd_e_lh\ih]j_[_gguo
\ kdhjq_gghf iheh`_gbb b h[jZs_gguo ]heh\hc d k_\_jm Fh]beZ [ueZ h\Zevghc
nhjfu bf_eZ f_ljZ \ ^ebgm b f_ljZ \ rbjbgm H^gZ __ klhjhgZ [ueZ h[eh`_gZ
ehiZldZfbfZfhglh\^jm]Zy²boq_exklyfbK\_jomih]j_[_gb_[uehihdjulhkeh_f
ba\_kldh\uo dZfg_c lhesbghc ² kZglbf_ljh\ dhlhju_ ^he`gu [ueb kem`blv
aZsblhchljZajmr_gbyfh]beuobsgufba\_jyfbIj_^iheZ]Z_lkyqlh\ fh]bem\j_fy
hl\j_f_gbdeZebmfbjZ\rboqe_gh\ie_f_gb
< ]h^m \ kZfhf p_glj_ ] ;jgh \h \j_fy dZgZebaZpbhgguo jZ[hl jZ[hqb_
h[gZjm`beb gZ ]em[bg_ f_ljZ fh]bem hjbgvydkdh]h hohlgbdZ gZ fZfhglh\ <
g_]em[hdmx yfm dhlhjZy gZ\_jgh_ [ueZ \ukleZgZ fy]dbfb rdmjZfb iheh`beb
f_jl\h]hhohlgbdZhq_gvlsZl_evghh^_lh]h\ h^_`^mbardmjmdjZr_ggmxdhklygufb
djm`hqdZfb Hdheh jmd gZoh^bebkv dZf_ggu_ hjm^by b hjm`b_ F_jl\h]h ihkuiZeb
djZkghc hojhc ih lh]^Zrg_fm hq_gv jZkijhkljZg_gghfm h[uqZx aZdjueb ehiZldhc
fZfhglZih^i_jlhcfZfhglh\uf[b\g_fb aZkuiZeb]ebghc
< bxe_ ]h^Z \h \j_fy Zjo_heh]bq_kdbo jZkdhihd klhygdb hohlgbdh\ gZ
fZfhglh\ \ >hevgbo <_klhgbpZo [u\rZy Q_ohkeh\Zdby h[gZjm`beb aZohjhg_gb_
`_gsbgu @_gsbgZ [ueZ iheh`_gZ gZ [hd \ kdhjq_gghf iheh`_gbb \_jhylgh
k\yaZggZy ij_^\Zjbl_evgh j_fg_f < fh]bem [ue iheh`_g dj_fgb_\uc gh` fykgZy
ibsZl_ehmf_jr_cihkuiZebdjZkghcdjZkdhcb ijbdjueb^\mfyehiZldZfbfZfhglZ
gZ h^ghc ba dhlhjuo hdZaZeZkv aZ]Z^hqgZy j_av[Z fh`_l [ulv bf_\rZy hlghr_gb_ d
ih]j_[Zevghfmh[jy^m
Iha^g_iZe_heblbq_kdb_ hohlgbdb ohjhgbeb g_ lhevdh \ajhkeuo gh b ^_l_c
H^gZ ba lZdbo gZb[he__ ba\_klguo fh]be [ueZ h[gZjm`_gZ \ F_glhg_ NjZgpby \
kh\k_fg_[hevrhf=jhl_>_l_c< ih]j_[Zevgmxyfm[uebiheh`_gu^\h_^_l_chq_gv
[ebadhh^bg\hae_^jm]h]hb ihwlhfmdZ`_lkyqlhhgbmf_jebh^gh\j_f_gghKlZjr_fm
[ueh hdheh ^_kylb e_l >_lb [ueb iheh`_gu gZ kibgm jmdb \ulygmlu \^hev l_eZ
G_]em[hdh ih^ fh]behc ^_l_c hdZaZehkv ih]j_[_gb_ `_gsbgu b _s_ ]em[`_ [ue
ihohjhg_g \ajhkeuc fm`qbgZ kd_e_l dhlhjh]h e_`Ze gZ kibg_ q_j_i b dhklb gh]
ij_^hojZgyebkvhljZajmr_gby[hevrbfbdZf_ggufbieblZfbiheh`_ggufbgZdZfgb
Ih^ wlhc fh]behc [ueZ h[gZjm`_gZ _s_ h^gZ Ijyfh gZ f_kl_ dhkljZ e_`Ze
kd_e_lfheh^h]hfm`qbgugZijZ\hf[hdm\ kdhjq_gghfiheh`_gbblZdqlhiyldbihqlb
dZkZebkv lZaZ Iha`_ jy^hf [ueZ iheh`_gZ ih`beZy `_gsbgZ lh`_ \ kdhjq_gghf
iheh`_gbb __ dhe_gb ihqlb dZkZebkv ih^[hjh^dZ <k_ ih]j_[_gby hlghkbebkv d wiho_
hjbgvydZ
Wlhb ^jm]b_ih]j_[_gby]jhlh\F_glhgugZJb\v_j_[uebhldjulu_s_\ ²
]]ba\_klgufnjZgpmakdbfZjo_heh]hfWfbe_fJb\v_jhf
EBL?J:LMJ:
HdeZ^gbdh\:I H agZq_gbbaZohjhg_gbcg_Zg^_jlZevp_\^eybklhjbbi_j\h[ulghc
dmevlmju³Kh\_lkdZywlgh]jZnby´‹ <br_\B< Ijh[e_fZebqgh]h[_kkf_jlbyGh\hkb[bjkd³GZmdZ´
:m]mklZB;mjbZg @bagv^j_\g_]hq_eh\_dZ³:jlby´IjZ]Z
KgbkZj_gdh:; Lj_lbcihykfm^jhklb;e_kdyauq_kdhc?\jhiuE³E_gba^Zl´
=E:<:O,
LZdaZ\_sZeAZjZlmkljZ
Kj_^bfgh]hqbke_gguokdZahdijblqZg_d^hlh\h Oh^`_GZkj_^^bg__klvh^bg
\_kvfZ kljZgguc kx`_l ;h]Zl_c dhlhjuf GZkj_^^bg ihjy^dhf gZkhebe k\hbfb
ijh^_edZfb j_rZxl m[blv gZkf_rgbdZ gh ih hrb[d_ m[b\Zxl _]h fZlv GZkj_^^bg
aZ[bjZ_l ljmi fZl_jb b m_a`Z_l ba k_eZ Ijb_oZ\ \ khk_^gbc Zme hg aZoh^bl \ ^hf
fmeeu]^__]hih\hklhqgufh[uqZyf]hkl_ijbbfkl\ZkZ`ZxlaZklheb m]hsZxlLjmi
`_k\h_cfZl_jbobljucOh^`ZihklZ\begZe_klgbp_ih^i_j_\iZedhcGZkulb\rbkv
fgbfuc³kljZggbd´kdZaZe³GZe_klgbp_f_gyh`b^Z_lfZlvg_evayebb __gZdhjfblv"´
=hkl_ijbbfguc fmeeZ ihkueZ_l k\hx ^hqv aZ fZl_jvx GZkj_^^bgZ LZ ihlygmeZ __ aZ
jmdZ\ qlh[u aZ\_klb \ ^hf b ljmi miZe k e_klgbpu GZkj_^^bg ih^ufZ_l kljZrguc
djbdb ieZqh[\bgy_lfmeemqlh\ _]h^hf_m[bebfZlvkljZggbdZ]jhablkm^hfQlh[u
aZfylvkdZg^ZefmeeZhl^Z_lGZkj_^^bgmf_rhdahehlZb k\hxdjZkZ\bpm^hqvZ ljmi
fZl_jblZcghohjhgylgZdeZ^[bs_
<_jgm\rbkv\ jh^ghcZmeGZkj_^^bgo\ZklZ_lihemq_ggufahehlhfb ^_\mrdhc
m\_jyyqlh\uf_gyebogZljmik\h_cfZl_jbB lh]^Z\k_[h]Zl_c[jhkbebkvih^hfZfb
klZeb m[b\Zlv k\hbo fZl_j_cklZjmo b h[]hgyy ^jm] ^jm]Z imklbebkv \ lh k_eh KlZeb
hgboh^blvihk_emb ij_^eZ]Zlvljmiu\ h[f_ggZ^_\mr_db ahehlhghbo\ukf_yebb
ijh]gZebbak_eZaZy\b\qlhm gbob k\hboklZjmoo\ZlZ_l
? > Lmjkmgh\ mihfbgZy dZaZokdb_ dbj]bakdb_ lmjdf_gkdb_ fhg]hevkdb_
ydmlkdb_ b ^jm]b_ \ZjbZglu kx`_lZ ibr_l h ^j_\g_f ijhbkoh`^_gbb wibah^h\
ih\_kl\mxsboh fZgbimeypbyok l_ehfm[blhcfZl_jb
³< bklhjbb k f_jl\uf l_ehf ykgh ijh]ey^u\Z_l ^j_\gbc h[uqZc gZa_fgh]h
aZohjhg_gby mf_jr_]h [ulh\Z\rbc kh \j_f_g dhgpZ f_aheblZ ² gZqZeZ g_heblZ
=_jhc hlijZ\ey_lky \ imlv qlh[u kh\_jrblv gZa_fgh_ aZohjhg_gb_ m[blhc fZl_jb
^_eZ_lwlhlZddZdlh]hlj_[m_lh[uqZch^_\Z_l__kZ`Z_lb hlijZ\ey_lkyih^Zevr_hl
k_e_gby´ H^gZdh y\gh g_^ha\he_ggu_ fZgbimeypbb dhlhju_ ]_jhc ijh^_eu\Z_l k
ljmihf bkihevamy _]h ^ey h[fZgZ b obljhklb k\b^_l_evkl\m_l h lhf qlh ³kdZadZ
hljZabeZ m`_ ba`b\Zxsbc gh g_ ba`bluc h[jy^´ Wlh iha\hey_l hlg_klb
\hagbdgh\_gb_ wibah^Z dh \j_f_gb g_ iha^g__ jZgg_]h beb kj_^g_]h wlZiZ wihob
[jhgau´
Ba\_klguc Zg]ebckdbc mq_guc b wlgh]jZn >`_cfk >`hj^` Njwa_j \
\uims_gghc \ ]h^m dgb]_ ³Nhevdehj \ <_lohf aZ\_l_´ lZd`_ ijb\h^bl ijbf_j
gZa_fgh]h aZohjhg_gby m i_j\h[ulguo ie_f_g Z\kljZebckdbo Z[hjb]_gh\ Lma_fpu
ie_f_gb gZjjbgv_jb X`gZy :\kljZeby ih^kmrb\Zeb l_eZ k\hbo mf_jrbo gZ^
f_^e_gguf h]g_f kgbfZeb k gbo dh`m hdjZrb\Zeb hojhc b ihf_sZeb gZ]bfb gZ
ihfhkl_
M ie_f_g \Z^mfZg b fm^[mjjZ :\kljZeby l_eh ihdhcgh]h ihf_sZxl gZ
kie_l_gghf ba \_l\_c ihfhkl_ gZ kmqvyo ^_j_\Z b hklZ\eyxl lZf ihdZ g_ h[gZ`blky
\_kvkd_e_lIhke_wlh]hdhklbh[_jlu\Zxldhjhcb mghkylgZhkh[mxiheygm]^_qe_gu
ie_f_gb kZ^ylky \hdjm] gbo b ieZqml Ih hdhgqZgbb wlhc ljZmjghc p_j_fhgbb dhklb
hlghkylh[jZlghgZ^_j_\hb m`_hdhgqZl_evghhklZ\eyxllZf
:gZeh]bqgu_ h[jy^u ih]j_[_gby gZ \_jrbg_ ^_j_\v_\ kms_kl\h\Zeb b m
g_dhlhjuo bg^_ckdbo ie_f_g K_\_jghc :f_jbdb < Zf_jbdZgkdhf om^h`_kl\_gghf
nbevf_ ³GZ ljhi_ \hcgu´ jZkkdZau\Zxs_f h `bagb kh\j_f_gguo bg^_cp_\ \
j_a_j\Zpbb_klvlZdhcwibah^
=jmiiZ fheh^uo bg^_cp_\ \klmib\ \ dhgnebdl k [_eufb kiZkZ_lky hl
ij_ke_^h\Zgbyihebp_ckdboHgbihdeyebkv\h\k_fke_^h\Zlvh[uqZyfij_^dh\B \hl
dh]^Z \ i_j_klj_ed_ ih]b[Z_l bo lh\Zjbs hgb j_rZxl ihohjhgblv _]h ih klZjbgghfm
h[jy^m²\ iheghf\hhjm`_gbbgZ\_jrbg_khkgu
Lh qlh h[jy^u gZa_fguo aZohjhg_gbc k\hckl\_ggu fgh]bf gZjh^Zf
gZoh^ysbfky gZ klZ^bb i_j\h[ulgh]h h[s_kl\Z ih^l\_j`^Zxl aZibkdb Kl_iZgZ
DjZr_gbggbdh\Zihk_lb\r_]h\ ²]h^ZoDZfqZldm³< lh\j_fydZd^jm]b_
beb k`b]Zxl k\hbo ihdhcgbdh\ beb ih]j_[Zxl \ a_fe_ ihke_ hkh[uo h[jy^h\
dZfqZ^Zeu gZh[hjhl ijb\yaZ\ j_f_gv d r__ f_jl\_pZ \ulZkdb\Zxl _]h ba xjlu b
ihqlb lml `_ hklZ\eyxl gZ kt_^_gb_ kh[ZdZf Hgb kqblZxl qlh kt_^_gguc kh[ZdZfb
f_jl\_pgZlhfk\_l_[m^_lbf_lvohjhrmxkh[Zqvxmijy`dm´
Hl]hehkdb h[uqZ_\ gZa_fguo aZohjhg_gbc khojZgyxlky \ j_eb]bhaguo
\haaj_gbyo h]g_ihdehggbdh\ H]g_ihdehggbdb bkih\_^mxl mq_gb_ AZjZlmrlju
baeh`_ggh_ \ A_c^:\_kl_ ² k\ys_gguo l_dklZo k dhff_glZjbyfb _]h ijhjhq_kl\ b
ihmq_gbc< ZelZjyoojZfh\h]g_ihdehggbdh\b \bo^hfZoihdehgyxlkyhqbklbl_evghc
kbe_ h]gy J_eb]by aZij_sZ_l k`b]Zlv beb aZju\Zlv \ a_fex mf_jrbo qlh[u g_
hkd\_jgylvl_fkZfufh]hgvb a_fexihwlhfmbol_eZhl^ZxlgZkt_^_gb_ilbpZf
<i_j\u_h[wlbokljZgguoh[uqZyofg_^h\_ehkvmkeurZlv\ g_[hevrhfihk_ed_
g_nlygbdh\KmjZoZgujZkiheh`_gghf\ dfhl;ZdmLZfiheghklvxj_klZ\jbjh\Zgb
hldjul ^ey hkfhljZ ojZf b fhgZklujv bg^bckdbo h]g_ihdehggbdh\ ;9,,²;9,,,
klhe_lbc :l_r]yo K ,9 \_dZ g w \ ibkvf_gguo bklhqgbdZo bf_ebkv mihfbgZgby h
\_qghf h]g_ ]hjys_f \ wlbo f_klZo² b^ms_f q_j_a ihq\m b kZfh\hkieZf_gyxs_fky
]Za_[ebae_`Zsbo[h]Zluog_nlyguoaZe_`_cF_klgu_h]g_ihdehggbdbg_hklZ\beb[_a
\gbfZgby wlh ³qm^h´ Ijbr_^rb_ kx^Z ba ^Ze_dh]h Bg^hklZgZ h]g_ihdehggbdb
ihkljhbeb gZ wlhf f_kl_ ojZf b fhgZklujv k d_evyfb K_cqZk d_evb ² wlh
k\h_h[jZaguc fma_c Z \ p_glj_ fhgZklujkdh]h ^\hjbdZ gZ^ q_lujvfy m]eh\ufb
dhehggZfb ojZfZ ]hjbl \_qguc h]hgv ih^^_j`b\Z_fuc ]Zahf ihklmiZxsbf ba
ih^a_fguolj_sbgq_j_abkdmkghkijylZggu_\ kl_gZoojZfZljm[u
Gh ihq_fm fhgZklujkdbc dhfie_dk :l_r]yo hkgh\Zeb bg^bckdb_
h]g_ihdehggbdb" <_^v ljZ^bpbhggZy h[eZklv jZkijhkljZg_gby mq_gby AZjZlmrlju
ho\Zlu\ZeZ l_jjblhjbb kh\j_f_gguo BjZgZ b :a_j[Zc^`ZgZ >_eh \ lhf qlh j_eb]by
h]g_ihdehggbdh\ [ueZ iheghklvx \ul_kg_gZ gZklmiZxsbf bkeZfhf >j_\gb_ i_jku
ihke_^h\Zl_ebAZjZlmrlju[_`Zeb\ 9,,,\_d_hlij_ke_^h\ZgbybjZgkdbofmkmevfZg\h
\j_f_gZOZeb^ZHfZjZ,,,\ ]hjgu_m[_`bsZOhjZkZgZZ aZl_fi_j_k_ebebkvgZhkljh\
Hjeb Gh b a^_kv bo g_ hklZ\beb \ ihdh_ fmkmevfZgkdb_ Z\Zg]Zj^u B lh]^Z
h]g_ihdehggbdb i_j_ijZ\bebkv gZ iZjmkguo km^Zo \ >b^ gZ ih[_j_`v_ DZlobZ\ZjZ b
`beb\ wlhfjZchg_hdhehe_l< ]h^mgZdhjZ[eyohgbhlijZ\bebkvbkdZlv
gh\u_ihk_e_gbylZddZd\ >b^_bfklZeh^h\hevghl_kghKbevgucrlhjfijb[bebod
[_j_]ZfBg^bckdh]hdgy`_kl\Z=m^`_jZlIZjkulZdklZebgZau\Zlvihlhfdh\^j_\gbo
i_jkh\h]g_ihdehggbdh\ [ueb hq_gv bkdmkgu_ b ljm^hex[b\u_ j_f_ke_ggbdb b
lhj]h\pu ihwlhfm bg^bckdb_ dgyavy klj_fykv aZihemqblv bo \ k\h_ jZkihjy`_gb_
\h_\Zeb^jm]k ^jm]hfLZdsZo:ofZ^Z[Z^Zi_j_k_ebeiZjkh\\ k\hb\eZ^_gbyZ iha`_
ijb Zg]ebqZgZo iZjku khkj_^hlhqbebkv \ FZoZjZklj_ < gZklhys__ \j_fy hdheh lukyq iZjkh\ ijh`b\Zxl \ ;hf[__ Hgb aZgbfZxl ijb\be_]bjh\Zggh_ iheh`_gb_ \
lhj]h\e_b \nbgZgkh\hc`bagbwlh]hrlZlZlZddZd\ a_fghc`bagbiZjku[he__\k_]h
p_gyl fZl_jbZevgh_ [eZ]hihemqb_ b ba bo kj_^u \ureh fgh]h [h]Zluo lhj]h\p_\
dmiph\b ijhfure_ggbdh\
Dh]^Z fg_ ^h\_ehkv ih[u\Zlv \ ;hf[__ lh y kjZam `_ aZf_lbe gZ _]h mebpZo
iZjkh\ j_adh hlebqZxsboky ih h^_`^_ hl ijhqbo bg^mkh\ Fm`qbgu [ueb h^_lu \
q_jgu_ aZkl_]gmlu_ gZ \k_ im]h\bpu dZaZdbgu b ghkbeb gZ ]heh\_ ih^dh\hh[jZagu_
\ukhdb_rZidbA^_kv`_\ ;hf[__kms_kl\mxlb fjZqgu_;ZrgbfheqZgbykem`Zsb_
^eyih]j_[Zevguoh[jy^h\iZjkh\
<k_ ^_j_\vy gZ^ wlbfb ;Zrgyfb h[uqgh h[e_ie_gu lmqZfb ]jbnh\ b \hjhgvy
l_ji_eb\h`^msbfbk\h_]hqZkZ< ^gbihohjhg\ ;ZrgbfheqZgbybf_xl^hklmilhevdh
jh^kl\_ggbdb mf_jr_]h L_eh mf_jr_]h iZjkZ ih djmlhc e_klgbp_ ih^gbfZ_lky gZ
ghkbedZogZ\_jrbgm[Zrgbb deZ^_lkygZj_r_ldmkh\_jr_gghjZa^_lufGhkbevsbdb
klj_f]eZ\m[_]Zxl\gbalZddZd ]jbnu g_f_^e_ggh gZ[jZku\Zxlky gZ k\hx ^h[uqm <
l_q_gb_ qZkZ hl f_jl\h]h l_eZ hklZxlky ebrv dhklb Dh]^Z ]jbnu k^_eZxl k\h_ ^_eh
ijbkem`gbdb ;Zr_g fheqZgby ki_pbZevgufb sbipZfb k[jZku\Zxl hklZgdb ih^
j_r_ldb\ ]em[hdbcdheh^_pgZ^gh;ZrgbLZdbfh[jZahfkh[ex^Z_lkyg_hkd\_jg_gb_
q_luj_ok\ys_gguoklbobch]gy\h^ua_febb g_[Z
EBL?J:LMJ:
DjZr_gbggbh\K I HibkZgb_a_febDZfqZldb=eZ\Z³H ih]j_[_gbb
mf_jrbo´³]ba´³=_h]jZn]ba´F Lmjkmgh\? > =_g_abkdZaZokdhc[ulh\hckdZadb:efZ:lZ
Njwa_j>`>` Nhevdehj\ <_lohfaZ\_l_F³Iheblba^Zl´
>\Z^pZlvljbGZkj_^^bgZF =lZ\j_^\hklhqghcqbl_jZlmju³GZmdZ´
Jm^g_\< Ihbklhjbq_kdbfb dmevlh\uff_klZfBg^bbE ³GZmdZ´
=E:<:;,,
H]g_ggh_ih]j_[_gb_
Ba\_klguckh\_lkdbcbklhjbdb Zjo_heh];hjbk:e_dkZg^jh\bqJu[Zdh\hlf_qZe
qlh w\hexpby ih]j_[Zevghc h[jy^ghklb b jZagu_ ihjhx j_adh hlebqZxsb_ky ^jm] hl
^jm]Z nhjfu ih]j_[Zevgh]h h[jy^Z hlf_qZxl kms_kl\_ggu_ i_j_f_gu \ hkhagZgbb
fbjZ \ lhc dZjlbg_ fbjZ dhlhjmx ^j_\gbc q_eh\_d kha^Z\Ze k_[_ ba khq_lZgby
ihagZ\Z_fhc j_Zevghklb k baf_gyxsbfbky ij_^klZ\e_gbyfb h ij_^iheZ]Z_fuo
\ufure_gguokbeZojZkk_ygguodZd_fmdZaZehkv\ ijbjh^_
LZd m ij_^dh\ keZ\yg hl >g_ijZ ^h H^_jZ [ueh jZkijhkljZg_gh ih]j_[_gb_
ljmih\ \ kdhjq_gguo ihaZo Kdhjq_ggu_ ih]j_[_gby bfblbjh\Zeb iham wf[jbhgZ \
fZl_jbgkdhf qj_\_ kdhjq_gghklv ^hklb]ZeZkv bkdmkkl\_gguf k\yau\Zgb_f ljmiZ
Jh^bqb ]hlh\beb mf_jr_]h dh \lhjhfm jh`^_gbx gZ a_fe_ d i_j_\hiehs_gbx
j_bgdZjgZpbb _]h \ h^gh ba `b\uo kms_kl\ Kdhjq_gghklv ljmih\ dZd fZkkh\h_
y\e_gb_ khojZgy_lky ^h jm[_`Z [jhgah\h]h \_dZ b \_dZ `_e_agh]h Dh_]^_ ZjoZbqgZy
kdhjq_gghklv^h`b\Z_l^h9,\^hgwGZkf_gmkdhjq_gghklbijboh^blgh\ZynhjfZ
ih]j_[_gby ihdhcgbdh\ ohjhgyl \ \ulygmlhf iheh`_gbb mf_jrbc ³kibl´ hklZ\Zykv
q_eh\_dhf kihdhcguf q_eh\_dhf ² ³ihdhcgbdhf´ b g_ ]hlh\ykv dh \lhjhfm
jh`^_gbxd \hiehs_gbx\ ^jm]hfkms_kl\_
KZfZy jZabl_evgZy i_j_f_gZ \ ih]j_[Zevghf h[jy^_ k\yaZgZ k ihy\e_gb_f
dj_fZpbbihegh]hkh``_gbyljmih\B^_ydj_fZpbblZd`_k\yaZgZk ij_^klZ\e_gb_fh
`bag_gghc kbe_ h __ g_bklj_[bfhklb b \_qghklb gh l_i_jv _c gZoh^yl gh\h_
f_klh`bl_evkl\h²g_[hdm^Z^mrbmf_jrboihiZ^Zxlk ^ufhfih]j_[Zevgh]hdhkljZ
Ijb Zjo_heh]bq_kdbo jZkdhidZo gZ[ex^Z_lky khkms_kl\h\Zgb_ h[_bo nhjf
^j_\g_c bg]mfZpbb ² aZohjhg_gby ihdhcgbdh\ \ a_fe_ b gh\hc jh^b\r_cky ebrv \
k_j_^bg_ ,, lukyq_e_lby ^h g w² dj_fZpbb H[_ hgb k\yaZgu k h[s_c b^__c dmevlZ
ij_^dh\ghk jZaghcijZdlbq_kdhcgZijZ\e_gghklvxwlhcb^_bAZohjhg_gb_ij_^dh\\
a_fe_ fh]eh hagZqZlv \hi_j\uo lh qlh hgb dZd [u hojZgyxl a_f_evgu_ m]h^vy
ie_f_gb³k\ys_ggZya_feyij_^dh\´Z \h\lhjuoqlhhgbkihkh[kl\mxljh`^Zxs_cky
kbe_a_febIjbljmihkh``_gbb`_kh\_jr_gghhlq_leb\hijhklmiZeZgh\Zyb^_y^mr
ij_^dh\ dhlhju_ ^he`gu gZoh^blvky ]^_lh \ kj_^g_f g_[_ b kh^_ckl\h\Zlv \k_f
g_[_kguf hi_jZpbyf ^h`^v lmfZg kg_] gZ [eZ]h hklZ\rbfky gZ a_fe_ ihlhfdZf
Ljmihkh``_gb_ g_ lhevdh lhj`_kl\_gg__ ijhklhc bg]mfZpbb dZd h[jy^ gh b
agZqbl_evgh [h]Zq_ ih kmff_ \deZ^u\Z_fuo \ g_]h ij_^klZ\e_gbc Hkms_kl\b\
kh``_gb_hlhkeZ\^mrmmf_jr_]h\ khgf^jm]bo^mrij_^dh\^j_\gbckeZ\ygbgihke_
wlh]hih\lhjye\k_lhqlh^_eZehkvb lukyqbe_llhfmgZaZ^hgohjhgbeijZomf_jr_]h
\ jh^ghca_fe_b l_fkZfufh[_ki_qb\Zek_[_\k_l_fZ]bq_kdb_ij_bfms_kl\Zdhlhju_
[uebijbkmsbb ijhklhcbg]mfZpbb
Jmkkdbc bklhjbd ;,; \_dZ <Zkbebc Hkbih\bq Dexq_\kdbc lZd ibkZe h[
hojZgbl_evghc nmgdpbb aZohjhg_gbc m keZ\yg ³H[h]hl\hj_gguc ij_^hd q_kl\h\Zeky
ih^ bf_g_f qmjZ \ p_jdh\ghkeZ\ygkdhc nhjf_ smjZ wlZ nhjfZ ^hk_e_ mp_e_eZ \
keh`ghfkeh\_ijZsmjAgZq_gb_wlh]h^_^Z²jh^hgZqZevgbdZdZdhojZgbl_eyjh^bq_c
^hk_e_ khojZgbehkv \ aZdebgZgbb hl g_qbklhc kbeu beb g_`^Zgghc hiZkghklb Qmj
f_gyl_ojZgbf_gy^_^HojZgyyjh^bq_chl\kydh]heboZqmjh[_j_]Zeb bojh^h\h_
^hklhygb_ GZjmr_gb_ f_`b gZ^e_`Zs_c ]jZgbpu aZdhgghc f_ju fu b l_i_jv
\ujZ`Z_f keh\hf q_j_kqmj Wlbf agZq_gb_f qmjZ fh`gh h[tykgblv h^gm q_jlm
ih]j_[Zevgh]h h[jy^Z m jmkkdbo keZ\yg dZd _]h hibku\Z_l GZqZevgZy e_lhibkv
IhdhcgbdZkh\_jrb\gZ^gbfljbagmk`b]Zebdhklb_]hkh[bjZeb\ fZemxihkm^bgmb
klZ\beb gZ klhe[m gZ jZkimlbyo ]^_ kdj_sb\Zxlky imlb l _ koh^ylky f_`b jZaguo
\eZ^_gbc Hlkx^Z km_\_jguc kljZo h\eZ^_\Z\rbc jmkkdbf q_eh\_dhf gZ
i_j_dj_kldZo´
Kh\j_f_ggu_ Zjo_heh]b g_ jZa^_eyxl fg_gby < H Dexq_\kdh]h hlghkbl_evgh
keh\Z ³klhei´ ba e_lhibkb G_klhjZ ?keb [u mjgm k ijZohf \haghkbeb gZ dZdhclh
^_j_\yggucklhe[dhlhjuckh\j_f_g_fjZajmrZekylhgZ^hexZjo_heh]bbg_hklZehkv
[ugbq_]hh^gZdhwlhg_lZdKeh\h³klhei´hagZqZeh\ ^j_\g_jmkkdhfyaud_g_lhevdh
³klhe[ [j_\gh´ gh b gZ^fh]bevguc ^hfbd kZjdhnZ] IjZ\bevgmx fukev h ³klhe[Zo´
\ujZabeom^h`gbdGDJ_jbo\ k\h_cdZjlbg_³Ba[Zkf_jlb´]^_g_[hevrZyba[mrdZ
klhbl gZ q_luj_o eZiZo < jZkdhidZo I I ?nbf_gdh b I G Lj_lvydh\Z \ ;hjr_\_ \
dmj]ZgZo O \_dZ [ueb \i_j\u_ h[gZjm`_gu g_[hevrb_ ^_j_\yggu_ kjm[u k hklZldZfb
ljmihkh``_gbyb dhevp_\hch]jZ^hc\hdjm]gboIha`_wlhih^l\_j^behkvb ijb^jm]bo
Zjo_heh]bq_kdbo jZkdhidZo ; G Ju[Zdh\ ijb\h^bl fgh]h ijbf_jh\ khhjm`_gby
^_j_\ygguo^hfh\bgklheih\gZdeZ^[bsZohlZjoZg]_evkdh]hK_\_jZ^hdZaZqv_]h>hgZ
dZdi_j_`blhdwlh]h^j_\g_]hh[jy^Z
IjZo dj_fbjh\Zgguo aZohjZgb\Zeky \ ]ebgyguo mjgZo \ h[uqguo ]hjrdZo ^ey
ijb]hlh\e_gbyibsbqlh;:Ju[Zdh\k\yau\Z_lk fZ]bq_kdbfbdmevlZfb]hjrdh\^ey
i_j\uoieh^h\MjguaZohjZgb\Zeb\ m`_mihfygmluogZfb³klheiZo´l_^hfh\bgZo
kZjdhnZ]Zo\gmljbgZkuiguodmj]Zgh\Ba\_klgub lZdgZau\Z_fu_³iheyih]j_[_gbc´
³iheyih]j_[Zevguomjg´l_deZ^[bsZ[_a\g_rgbogZa_fguoijbagZdh\
Dhfie_dk ij_^klZ\e_gbc k\yaZgguc k ih]j_[_gb_f ij_^dh\ y\ey_lky
h[s_q_eh\_q_kdbf wlgbq_kdb_ hkh[_gghklb kdZau\Zxlky \ ^_lZeyo b \ khq_lZgbyo
\lhjhkl_i_gguo ijbagZdh\ beb \ jZagh\j_f_gghklb ihy\e_gby wlbo ijbagZdh\ lh`_ \
[hevrbgkl\_kemqZ_\h[sbo^eyfgh]bogZjh^h\
< wihomZglbqghklb\iehlv^hi_jbh^ZJbfkdhcbfi_jbbgZjy^mk ih]j_[_gb_f
kms_kl\h\ZeZlZd`_b dj_fZpby>hiha^g_fbghckdh]hi_jbh^Zl_eZf_jl\uoij_^Z\Zeb
a_fe_ gh m`_ =hf_j hibku\Z_l lhevdh dj_fZpbx ijhba\h^b\rmxky \ fZl_jbdh\hc
=j_pbb gZjZ\g_ k ih]j_[_gb_f Lhevdh mf_jrbo ^_l_c ohjhgbeb \ a_fe_ < >j_\g_c
BlZebb ij_^ihql_gb_ hl^Z\Zehkv dj_fZpbb ohly m`_ \ AZdhgZo lZ[ebp [ueb
aZnbdkbjh\Zgu h[Z \b^Z aZohjhg_gbc Ihke_ iZ^_gby J_kim[ebdb \iehlv ^h , \_dZ
dj_fZpby [ueZ hq_gv jZkijhkljZg_gZ \h ,, \_d_ hgZ klZeZ ijbf_gylvky j_`_ Jbfkdb_
mjgu k i_iehf h[uqgh mklZgZ\eb\Zebkv \ dhemf[Zjbb < i_j_\h^_ k eZlbgkdh]h
³dhemf[Zjbc´hagZqZ_lgbrm]hem[ylgbLZdgZau\Zebkvk dhgpZj_kim[ebdZgkdh]hJbfZ
^hk_j_^bgubfi_jZlhjkdhcwihob\ke_^kl\b_bokoh^kl\Zk gbrZfb]hem[ylgbgbrb\
dhlhjuo mklZgZ\eb\Zeb mjgu k i_iehf mf_jrbo Gbrb jZkiheZ]Zebkv \ ki_pbZevgh
\ukljh_gguo^eywlhcp_ebihf_s_gbyoijyfhm]hevghcbebh\Zevghcnhjfudhlhju_
kljhbebkv lZd`_ b ih^ a_fe_c b \f_sZeb ^h gbr k aZfmjh\Zggufb mjgZfb <
hkgh\ghf dhemf[Zjbb y\eyebkv f_klhf aZohjhg_gby [_^guo ]jZ`^Zg OjbklbZgkl\h
aZij_sZehdj_fZpbxdZdijhlb\hj_qZsmxmq_gbxh \hkdj_k_gbbbaf_jl\uoihwlhfm
d ]h^m \ jbfkdhc bfi_jbb dj_fZpby ijZdlbq_kdb ij_djZsZ_lky < ]h^m
ihke_^h\Ze hnbpbZevguc p_jdh\guc aZij_l dj_fZpbb LZd \ ]h^m \ ojbklbZgkl\h
i_j_reb\h`^bkZdkh\b aZy\bebh k\h_cihdhjghklb<kydbcbakZdkh\dlhg_ohjhgbe
gZp_jdh\ghfdeZ^[bs_mf_jrboZ k`b]ZeboljmiugZdZau\Zekykf_jlvx
M keZ\ygh[jy^ljmihkh``_gbyihy\ey_lkyihqlbh^gh\j_f_gghk h[hkh[e_gb_f
ijZkeZ\yghlh[s_]hbg^h_\jhi_ckdh]hfZkkb\Z\ ;9\_d_^hgwbkhkms_kl\my\ lhc
beb bghc f_j_ k bg]mfZpb_c [ulh\Ze ^\Z^pZlv k_fv klhe_lbc \iehlv ^h wihob
<eZ^bfbjZFhghfZoZdh]^ZdZdhlf_qZebkh\j_f_ggbdbbf_y\\b^mhdjZbguJmkblZd
³l\hjyl\ylbqbb gug_´Iha`_k hdhgqZl_evghcih[_^hcojbklbZgkl\ZgZ^yauq_kl\hf
dj_fZpby dZd b \ AZiZ^ghc ?\jhi_ iheghklvx \ul_kgy_lky ojbklbZgkdbfb
ih]j_[Zevgufbh[jy^ZfbIjZ\^Z^j_\gbc
FbghckdZy dmevlmjZ gZa\ZgZ ih bf_gb e_]_g^Zjgh]h pZjy FbghkZ dmevlmjZ
DjblZ^hklb]rZyjZkp\_lZ\ ²lukyq_xlbb^hgwhdZau\ZeZ kbevgh_ \ebygb_ gZ
fZl_jbdh\mx=j_pbx
AZdhgu lZ[ebp ² ^j_\g_crZy ibkvf_ggZy nbdkZpby jbfkdh]h ijZ\Z
hkms_kl\e_ggZy\ ²]]^hgw
h[jy^ljmihkh``_gby^h`b\rbc\ e_kghfdjZx\ylbq_c^h\j_f_ge_lhibkpZG_klhjZ
khojZgbeky \ x`ghc qZklb a_feb \ylbq_c LmevkdZy b DZem`kdZy ]m[_jgbb \
i_j_`bldZo ^h dhgpZ ;,; \_dZ gZ ojbklbZgkdhc fh]be_ ihke_ ihohjhg jZa\h^beb
h]jhfguc dhkl_j >j_\gb_ ih]j_[Zevgu_ ba[mrdb^hfh\bgu klheiu \_jg__ bo
bfblZpby gZ ojbklbZgkdbo fh]beZo k qZs_ \k_]h ihaZ[ulhc bagZqZevghc kbf\hebdhc
khojZgbebkv \ k_\_jguo h[eZklyo ^h gZqZeZ ;; \_dZ Gh wlh [ueb lhevdh hl]hehkdb
^j_\gboyauq_kdboh[jy^h\ijbqm^eb\h\ie_lZ\rb_ky\ ojbklbZgkdb_\_jh\Zgby
Kh \lhjhc iheh\bgu ;,; \_dZ \ k\yab k i_j_gZk_e_gghklvx ]hjh^h\ b dZd
ke_^kl\b_fwlh]h²i_j_iheg_gb_f]hjh^kdbodeZ^[bs\hfgh]bokljZgZoklZeb\gh\v
\ha\jZsZlvkyd h[jy^mdj_fZpbbLhevdhl_i_jvdj_fZpbyijhba\h^beZkv\ ki_pbZevgh
h[hjm^h\Zgguo i_qZo dj_fZlhjb_\ I_j\uc dj_fZlhjbc [ue hldjul \ FbeZg_ \ ]h^m
< Jhkkbb i_j\uc dj_fZlhjbc [ue ihkljh_g \ ]h^m iha`_ ihy\bebkv
dj_fZlhjbb \h fgh]bo djmiguo ]hjh^Zo kljZgu <hl dZd hibku\Zxl hldjulb_
dj_fZlhjby B Bevn b ? I_ljh\ \ k\h_f kZlbjbq_kdhf jhfZg_ ³Ahehlhc l_e_ghd´ ³<
Q_jghfhjkd_ kh[bjZebkv kljhblv dj_fZlhjbc k khhl\_lkl\mxsbf ihf_s_gb_f ^ey
]jh[h\uo mjg lh _klv dhemf[Zjb_f b wlh gh\r_kl\h kh klhjhgu deZ^[bs_gkdh]h
ih^hl^_eZ ihq_fmlh hq_gv \_k_ebeh ]jZ`^Zg Fh`_l [ulv kf_rbeb bo gh\u_ keh\Z
dj_fZlhjbcb dhemf[ZjbcZ fh`_l[ulvhkh[_gghaZ[Z\eyeZbokZfZyfukevh lhfqlh
q_eh\_dZ fh`gh k`_qv dZd ihe_gh² gh lhevdh hgb ijbklZ\Zeb dh \k_f klZjbdZf b
klZjmoZf\ ljZf\Zyob gZmebpZok djbdZfb³Ludm^ZklZjmrdZij_rvky"< dj_fZlhjbc
lhjhibrvky"´Beb
³Ijhimklbl_ klZjbqdZ \i_j_^ _fm \ dj_fZlhjbc ihjZ´ B m^b\bl_evgh_ ^_eh
b^_y h]g_ggh]h ih]j_[_gby klZjbdZf hq_gv ihgjZ\beZkv lZd qlh \_k_eu_ rmldb
\uau\Zebm gboihegh_h^h[j_gb_B \hh[s_jZa]h\hju h kf_jlb kqblZ\rb_ky ^h kbo
ihj g_m^h[gufb b g_\_`eb\ufb klZeb dhlbjh\Zlvky \ Q_jghfhjkd_ gZjZ\g_ k
Zg_d^hlZfbba_\j_ckdhcb dZ\dZakdhc`bagbb \uau\Zeb\k_h[sbcbgl_j_k´Ba\_klgZ
lZd`_b qZklmrdZlh]h\j_f_gb
Dj_fZlhjbchldju\Zeb;_kijbahjgbdZk`b]Zeb>\_jvhldjueb²hglZgpm_l
³HgaZdjhcl_Z lh^m_l
´
Gh gZb[he__ jZkijhkljZg_gZ dj_fZpby k ^j_\g_crbo \j_f_g ^h gZklhys_]h
\j_f_gb m bkih\_^mxsbo bg^mbaf Ih ^Zgguf ]Za_lu ³Mhje^ ^_\_ehif_gl nhjmk´
GvxChjd bxev ]h^Z _keb \ ^_j_\g_ k gZk_e_gb_f q_eh\_d
ijhihjpbhgZevgh ij_^klZ\blv gZk_e_gb_ \k_c ieZg_lu ih _]h j_eb]bhaghc
ijbgZ^e_`ghklb lh ihemqblky lZdZy dZjlbgZ ojbklbZg dZlhebdZ ijhl_klZglZ ijZ\hkeZ\guo fmkmevfZg bg^mbklh\ [m^^bklh\ Zgbfbklh\j_eb]bhagu_\_jh\Zgbyi_j\h[ulguogZjh^h\kqblZxsboqlhdZ`^Zy\_sv
bf__l k\hc ^mo Z]ghklbdh\ b Zl_bklh\ LZdbf h[jZahf dhebq_kl\h bg^mbklh\ \
fbj_\_kvfZagZqbl_evghbogZkqblu\Z_lkyfbeebhgh\q_eh\_d
Bg^mbklkdb_ h[uqZb dj_fZpbb khojZgbebkv g_baf_ggufb k g_aZiZfylguo
\j_f_g ;; \_d ijb\g_k \ wlhl jblmZe ebrv we_dljbq_kdb_ dj_fZlhjbb Gh
hjlh^hdkZevgu_ bg^mku ij_^ihqblZxl bf ljZ^bpbhgguc ih]j_[Zevguc dhkl_j ?]h
jZa`b]Zxl gZ ibjZfb^_ meh`_gguo \ g_kdhevdh jy^h\ ^jh\ ?keb k`b]Zxl l_eh
khklhyl_evgh]h q_eh\_dZ lh \ ^jh\Z g_ij_f_ggh ^h[Z\eyxl g_kdhevdh ihe_gv_\
ZjhfZlgh]hkZg^ZeZ
F_klhkh``_gbyf_jl\uo²rZfZrZg²jZkiheZ]Z_lkyh[uqghgZ[_j_]mj_db
H[uqgh gZ wlhf i_qZevghf f_kl_ khhjm`Z_lky g_kdhevdh g_\ukhdbo dZf_gguo
ieZlnhjf G_dhlhju_ ba gbo ih^ dZf_ggufb `_ djurZfb hibjZxsbfbky gZ q_luj_
klhe[Zg_dhlhju_hldjulug_[m
>ey ^hklZ\db l_eZ d f_klm dj_fZpbb bg^mku g_ bkihevamxl ]jh[ IhdhcgbdZ
mdeZ^u\ZxlgZ[Zf[mdh\u_ghkbedbb mdju\Zxlqbklhc[_ehcfZl_jb_c< aZ\bkbfhklb
hl ^hklZldZ wlh fh`_l [ulv oehihd r_jklv beb r_ed I_j_^ ghkbedZfb ^he`_g b^lb
kugihdhcgh]hHgjZa^Z_lgbsbffbehklugxb ljZ^bpbhggu_keZ^hklb< jmd_m g_]h
² ]hjrhq_d k ]hjysbfb m]eyfb hl dhlhjuo [m^_l jZah``_g dhkl_j <^h\Z kh]eZkgh
h[uqZyf g_ mqZkl\m_l \ ljZmjghc ijhp_kkbb ?keb mf_j q_eh\_d ij_dehgguo e_l lh
r_kl\b_ dZd ijZ\beh hj]Zgbah\u\Zxl f_g__ kdhj[gh_ < g_f mqZkl\mxl ^Z`_
fmaudZglub [ZjZ[Zgsbdbdhlhju_b]jZxlgZjh^gu_f_eh^bb
>hklZ\b\ ihdhcgbdZ d f_klm dj_fZpbb _]h mdeZ^u\Zxl gZ a_fex ;jZofZgu
gZqbgZxlqblZlvfZglju]hlh\y\k__s_aZlhq_ggmx\ l_e_^mrmd \hajh`^_gbxIhke_
wlh]h kh\_jrZxl ihke_^g__ hfh\_gb_ b l_eh \h^jm`Zxl gZ ibjZfb^m ^jh\ GZ dhe_gb
deZ^mlly`_eh_[j_\ghKugmkhir_]h^he`_gkZfhebqghaZ`_qvih]j_[Zevgucdhkl_j
?kebhgohjhgblfZlvlhh]hgvaZ`b]Z_l\ gh]Zo_kebhlpZ²lhm ]heh\u
Kug b \k_ ij_^klZ\bl_eb fm`kdh]h iheZ k_fvb k_fv jZa h[oh^yl \hdjm]
ih]j_[Zevgh]h dhkljZ Ijb wlhf hgb evxl \ h]hgv ZjhfZlbq_kdb_ fZkeZ k l_f qlh[u
jZa]hjZxs__kyieZfyho\Zlbeh\k_l_ehihdhcgh]h
Ijbkmlkl\mxsb_ gZ ljZmjghc p_j_fhgbb \gbfZl_evgh ke_^yl aZ q_j_ihf
mkhir_]h ?keb hg jZkdheheky agZqbl ^mrZ kfh]eZ gZclb \uoh^ gZjm`m b ihdbgmeZ
l_eh ?keb g_l lh kug ihdhcgh]h ^he`_g jZa[blv q_j_i jblmZevguf r_klhf k
f_lZeebq_kdbfgZdhg_qgbdhfqlh[u\uimklblv^mrm
Ihke_ lh]h dZd hklZgdb ijh]hjyl \ dhklj_ jh^gu_ b [ebadb_ ihdhcgh]h
\ha\jZsZxlky ^hfhc ]^_ kh\_jrZxl jblmZevgh_ hfh\_gb_ ^ey kZfhhqbs_gby GZ
lj_lbc^_gvhgb\ha\jZsZxlkyd f_klmdj_fZpbbb kh[bjZxli_i_e\ mjgmH[uqghijZo
\ukuiZxl\ \h^mh^ghcbak\ys_gguoj_d\u[jZgguoih\he_ihdhcgh]h
< l_q_gb_^_kylb^g_c\ ^hf_ihdhcgh]hg_]hlh\ylibsm?^mijbghkyl^jmavyb
[ebadb_ Wlb ^_kylv ^g_c ihke_ p_j_fhgbb dj_fZpbb kqblZxlky kZfufb \Z`gufb lZd
dZdbf_ggh\ wlb^gb^mrZgZoh^blk_[_gh\mxh[hehqdmGZi_j\uc^_gvhgZ^he`gZ
³\u[jZlv´gh\mx]heh\mgZ\lhjhc²r_xgZlj_lbc²k_j^p_gZq_l\_jluc²kibgm
AZl_f \ dZ`^uc ihke_^mxsbc ^_gv ^mrZ \u[bjZ_l imihd iheh\u_ hj]Zgu [_^jZ
dhe_gbgh]bbgZdhg_pjmdb?keb`_ ih]j_[Zevguc h[jy^ [ue \uiheg_g g_ ih \k_f
dZghgZflh^mrZg_gZc^_lk_[_gh\h]hl_eZb klZg_l[em`^ZlvdZdaehc^mo
< i_jbh^ f_`^m uf b uf ^g_f gZdju\Zxlky ijZa^gbqgu_ klheu
khau\Zxlky\k_jh^gu_b [ebadb_G_ij_f_gghijb]eZrZxlkyb ij_^klZ\bl_eb\ukr_c
dZklu bg^mbafZ ² [jZofZgu Bg^mku \_jyl qlh [eZ]hkeh\_gb_ [jZofZgh\ ihfh`_l
^mr_h[j_klb^hklhcgh_f_klh\ gh\hc`bagb
< >_eb ihfbfh h[uqguo rZfrZgh\ jZkiheh`_gguo gZ [_j_]m j_db >`Zfgu
h^ghcba\_ebdbok\ys_gguoj_dBg^bbbf__lkyki_pbZevguciZjd²f_klhdj_fZpbb
]hkm^Zjkl\_gguo eb^_jh\ A^_kv \ iZjd_ jZkiheh`_gghf gZ [_j_]m j_db YfmgZ
fhgmf_glZfb hlf_q_gu f_klZ dj_fZpbb FZoZlfu =Zg^b ² ³JZ^`]oZl´ ³PZjkdbc
[_j_]´>`Z\ZoZjeZeZG_jm²³RZglb<ZgZ´Bg^bju=Zg^b²³RZdlbklZe´³F_klh
kbeu´ Ijh]meb\Zykv ih wlhfm iZjdm \ l_ieuc ^_dZ[jvkdbc ^_gv gZdZgmg_ Jh`^_kl\Z
]h^Zy g_fh]ij_^klZ\blvqlh\k_]hebrvq_j_aihe]h^Za^_kv[m^_ldj_fbjh\Zgh
l_eh \u^Zxs_]hky ]hkm^Zjkl\_ggh]h b iheblbq_kdh]h ^_yl_ey Bg^bb JZ^`b\Z =Zg^b
m[blh]hl_jjhjbklZfb
< ^hf_fma__ Bg^bju =Zg^b \ >_eb m[blhc lml `_ gZ ^hjh`d_ k\h_]h kZ^Z hdly[jy ]h^Z y \b^_e j_^dmx nhlh]jZnbx ghy[jy ]h^Z JZ^`b\ =Zg^b
jZkk_b\Z_l k kZfhe_lZ gZ^ =bfZeZyfb b =Zg]hf i_i_e k\h_c fZl_jb dj_fbjh\Zgghc ghy[jy Nhlh]jZnby aZi_qZle_eZ wlhl fhf_gl hldjulZy ^\_jpZ kZfhe_lZ aZ dhlhjhc
\b^g_xlky[_ehkg_`gu_\_jrbgu]hjb JZ^`b\=Zg^b\ukuiZxsbci_i_ebamjgu
I_i_e FZoZlfu =Zg^b b >`Z\ZoZjeZeZ G_jm [ue jZa\_yg \ \h^Zo =Zg]Z b
>`Zfgu \ ] :eeZoZ[Z^_ gZ f_kl_ kebygby wlbo j_d \ ljZ^bpbhgghf p_glj_
iZehfgbq_kl\Zbg^mbklh\
Bkih^\hev fh`_l [ulv g_ kh\k_f hkhagZggh bg^mbklkdb_ \_jh\Zgby gZqbgZxl
ijhgbdZlv \ ojbklbZgkdbc fbj < ljZ^bpbhgghf ojbklbZgkl\_ ebrblv q_eh\_dZ f_klZ
ihke_^g_]h mkihdh_gby kqblZehkv kZfhc kljZrghc dZjhc <kihfgbf dZd ih e_]_g^_
jZa\_yebbaimrdbi_i_e>fbljbyKZfha\ZgpZ
Ihy\e_gb_ i_j\uo dj_fZlhjb_\ \ ?\jhi_ g_ mijZa^gyeh h[jy^Z aZohjhg_gby
mjgu \ fh]bem beb ihf_s_gby __ \ gbrm dhemf[Zjby < h[hbo kemqZyo khojZgyehkv
hij_^_e_ggh_f_klhaZohjhg_gbyf_klhihdehg_gbyijZommf_jr_]h
< k\yabk wlbfohq_lkyijb\_klbbgl_j_kgucnZdl< KI_l_j[mj]_\ Bgklblml_
wdki_jbf_glZevghcf_^bpbguojZgylkymjguk ijZohfkhljm^gbdh\ih]b[rbohlqmfu
GZ nhjl_ ³:e_dkZg^j ,´ jZkiheh`_gghf g_^Ze_dh hl DjhgrlZ^lZ \ Z\]mkl_ ]h^Z
gZqZeZ jZ[hlZlv bahebjh\ZggZy hl \k_]h \g_rg_]h fbjZ eZ[hjZlhjby BgklblmlZ
wdki_jbf_glZevghc f_^bpbgu ih bamq_gbx qmfu G_kfhljy gZ \k_ f_ju
ij_^hklhjh`ghklb\ g_cijhbahreb^\ZkemqZyaZjZ`_gbyqmfhcb h[Zkhkf_jl_evguf
bkoh^hf I_j\hc `_jl\hc hdZaZeky aZ\_^mxsbc eZ[hjZlhjb_c < B Lmjqbgh\bq
<u`gbd_\bq Z q_j_a ljb ]h^Z mf_j hl e_]hqghc nhjfu qmfu \h_gguc \jZq F N
Nj_c[_jH[Zmq_guo[uebdj_fbjh\ZguZ ijZobogZ\_qghkhojZgbebgklblml
Gh ihy\eyxlky b gh\u_ l_g^_gpbb <hl hkgh\ghc kx`_lguc oh^ ba\_klgh]h
nbevfZN_^_jbdhN_eebgb³: dhjZ[evieu\_l´agZf_gblZyhi_jgZyi_\bpZaZ\_sZeZ
jZa\_ylv __ ijZo \hae_ hkljh\Z \ Kj_^ba_fghf fhj_ ]^_ hgZ jh^beZkv B \hl
ki_pbZevgucdhjZ[evk ihdehggbdZfb\_a_lmjgmk i_iehfi_\bpud wlhfmhkljh\m
Ihfgh]hqbke_ggufnhlh]jZnbyfgZfohjhrhba\_klgZfh]beZDZjeZFZjdkZ\
Ehg^hg_ Njb^jbo Wg]_evk kdhgqZeky Z\]mklZ ]h^Z gZ e_l iha`_ DZjeZ
FZjdkZ b fh`gh [ueh h`b^Zlv qlh _]h ihohjhgyl ]^_lh jy^hf k _]h ^jm]hf b
khjZlgbdhfH^gZdhwlh]hg_kemqbehkv;he__lh]hfh]beuWg]_evkZg_kms_kl\m_l
=jh[ k l_ehf Njb^jboZ Wg]_evkZ ihke_ ljZmjghc p_j_fhgbb khklhy\r_cky Z\]mklZ]h^Z\ aZe_h`b^Zgbc`_e_agh^hjh`gh]h\hdaZeZ<Zl_jehh\ Ehg^hg_[ue
ki_pbZevgufih_a^hf^hklZ\e_g\ dj_fZlhjbc\ Mhdbg]_Wg]_evkih`_eZeqlh[uijZo
_]h[uehims_g\ fhj_Z\]mklZjh^gu_b [ebadb_i_j_\_aebi_i_ed ex[bfhfmf_klm
hl^uoZWg]_evkZ\ Bkl[hjb jZa\_yeb_]hgZ^fhj_f
< ^hdmf_glZevghf nbevf_ ³Wlh ² :f_jbdZ´ _klv g_kdhevdh bgl_j_kguo
kx`_lh\ :f_jbdZgkdb_ qm^Zdb ihjZaghfm aZ\_sZxl jZkihjy^blvky k\hbf i_iehf
jZa\_ylv gZ^ fhj_f gZ^ ]hjh^hf gZ^ a_fguf rZjhf aZimklb\ ki_pbZevgmx jZd_lm \
kljZlhkn_jmb ^Z`_²kij_kkh\Zlv\ _^bguc[ehdk ex[bfufZ\lhfh[be_fIjb\k_c
wdkljZ\Z]Zglghklbb g_h[uqghklb ih^h[guo aZ\_sZgbc qm\kl\m_lky qlh lml fu bf__f
^_eh k m`_ gZqbgZxs_c kdeZ^u\Zlvky ljZ^bpb_c fh`_l [ulv b g_ [_a \ebygby
bg^mbklkdh]hfbjh\haaj_gby
AgZf_gbluc jZa\_^qbd >`hj^` ;e_cd kh\_jrb\rbc k_gkZpbhgguc ih[_] \
hdly[j_ ]h^Z ba Zg]ebckdhc lxjvfu b ijh\h^b\rbc hklZlhd k\h_c `bagb \
Kh\_lkdhfKhxa_aZ\_sZejZa\_ylv_]hijZo\ e_kmhdhehk\h_c^Zqb
G_fgh]bf gZ\_jgh ba\_klgh qlh g_ kms_kl\m_l fh]beu b agZf_gblh]h
kh\_lkdh]hibkZl_eyDhgklZglbgZKbfhgh\Z<hlqlhjZkkdZau\Z_lh[wlhf\ k\h_cdgb]_
³Ki_pihohjhgu \ iheghqv´ E_\ DZq_j ³ihohjhgsbd´ fhkdh\kdbo ibkZl_e_c ³=^_
ohjhgblv" AZjZg__ [ueh j_r_gh qlh ³kh]eZkgh j_]Zebyf´ ² gZ Gh\h^_\bqv_f
<hijhkh\ g_l ² Kbfhgh\ _klv Kbfhgh\ B \^jm] a\hghd =hehk k_dj_lZjy KhxaZ
ibkZl_e_cKKKJXjby<_jq_gdh³Hl[hcG_hnhjfeycl_gbq_]hKjhqghdhfg_´
Ijb_oZegbq_]hg_ihgbfZx
² <kdjueb aZ\_sZgb_ <hey ihdhcgh]h lZdZy ² dj_fbjh\Zlv b ijZo jZa\_ylv
;m^_f\uihegylv
Ihq_fm jZa\_ylv" Ihq_fm bf_ggh ih^ =hf_e_f" ?]h ebqguc xjbkl jZkkdZaZe
fg_ lZf hg \h_\Ze ihiZe \ hdjm`_gb_ ba dhlhjh]h \uclb ijZdlbq_kdb [ueh
g_\hafh`gh LZf\ hdhi_DhgklZglbgKbfhgh\ihdeyekyh^ghfmihedh\gbdm
²?kebfu\k_lZdbijhj\_fkyb hklZg_fky`b\u²y k\hcijZojZa\_xa^_kv
Iha`_wlhlihedh\gbdklZegZqZevgbdhf;_ehjmkkdh]h\h_ggh]hhdjm]Z
Fg_gZ^h[ueh\k_k^_eZlv[ukljhHl\_al_eh\ >hgkdhcdj_fZlhjbcIhemqbe
h[_sZgb_²q_j_aljb^gyhl^Z^mlmjgmk i_iehfGhm gZkm`_[be_lgZaZ\ljZgZmljh
Ijh[mxm[_^blvjZklhedh\Zlv< hl\_l[m^gbqgh_
²Gbq_]hg_ihemqblky
AgZqblihjZij_^eZ]Zlv^_gv]b
JZggbf mljhf gZf k xjbklhf D_^e_jfZghf kem`bl_ev dj_fZlhjby ijhlygme
]hjrhq_d Fu \ h[f_g hl^Zeb fyl_gvdmx [mfZ`dm ² d\blZgpbx Wlh ijbagZxkv
kljZrg_gvdhb g_eh\dh²g_klbKbfhgh\Z\ ]hjrhqd_Dhg_qghijZoi_i_e^Zb _s_d
lhfm`_dlhfh`_llhqghkdZaZlvq_cGZk`_\ ³ij_bkih^gxx´]^_k`b]Zxl²gb gZ
iherZ]Z B^_f fheqbf >mfZ_f h[ h^ghf dZd `_ lZd \ky h]jhfgZy jZaghh[jZagZy
gZ[blZy kh[ulbyfb kljZklyfb `bagv ihwlZ b ibkZl_ey mf_klbeZkv \ blh]_ \hl \ wlhf
]hjrhqd_<hlb \k_"LhqdZ"
Q_j_a ljb f_kypZ mf_jeZ _]h `_gZ HgZ agZeZ qlh [hevgZ ^Z\gh agZeZ ?_
ijhkv[Z²jZkiueblvi_i_elZf`_³]^_Kbfhgh\´²[ueZ\uiheg_gZ
LZdbfh[jZahf m`_^hklZlhqgh Zj]mf_glbjh\Zggh fu fh`_f ml\_j`^Zlv qlh \
gZrb ^gb gZ gZrbo ]eZaZo aZjh`^Z_lky gh\h_ hlghr_gb_ d ljZ^bpbhgguf
ih]j_[Zevgufh[jy^Zfboi_j_hkfuke_gb_
EBL?J:LMJ:
LhdZj_\bqD
G=j_dh\ZL B Ihke_^Zffbgm\rbowib^_fbb³E_gba^Zl´ Dexq_\kdbc<H DmjkjmkkdhcbklhjbbFlhfJnbf_gdhI ILj_lvydh\I
G Dmj]Zgguc fh]bevgbd Y W ;hjr_\Z ³FB:´ 1 FE jbk ³AZ
jm[_`hf´ ‹ k Jhah\u_ jhau hl Kbfhgh\Z ³Gh\]hjh^kdZy ijZ\^Z´ bdiy Yjbdh\ : K
g_aZiZfylguo\j_f_g²³DjZkgZya\_a^Z´bxgy
Ju[Zdh\;: Yauq_kl\h^j_\g_cJmkbF³GZmdZ´BevnBI_ljh\? Ahehlhc
l_e_ghdF³Om^ebl´³Ljm^´hlfZy]h^Z
=E:<:;,,,
Kfbj_ggh_deZ^[bs_
< j_amevlZl_Zjo_heh]bq_kdbojZkdhihd²]]\ Dj_fe_[uehgZc^_gh
h[rbjgh_ deZ^[bs_ k ]jmiih\ufb fh]beZfb \_jhylgh k p_jdh\vx ijb g_f gZ f_kl_
[m^ms_]h Mki_gkdh]h kh[hjZ =hjh^kdh_ deZ^[bs_ jZkiheZ]Zehkv gZ iehsZ^b f_`^m
Mki_gkdbf kh[hjhf b IZljbZjrbfb iZeZlZfb ih^ nmg^Zf_glZfb wlbo a^Zgbc ;ueb
\kdjulu b bkke_^h\Zgu jZagh\j_f_gguo aZohjhg_gbc DZd \uykgbehkv gZ wlhc
l_jjblhjbb deZ^[bs_ kms_kl\h\Zeh ^ebl_evguc i_jbh^ \j_f_gb \iehlv ^h o ]h^h\
;,9\_dZl_^hlh]h\j_f_gbdh]^Zkx^Z[uei_j_g_k_gfbljhihebqbc^\hj
<kdjulb_ih]j_[_gbcjZagh]h\j_f_gbk ;,,ih;,9\_diha\hebeh^hg_dhlhjhc
kl_i_gb ijhke_^blv w\hexpbx ih]j_[Zevguo h[jy^h\ AZohjhg_gby ^Zlbjh\Zggu_
\lhjhciheh\bghc;,,\_dZij_^klZ\eyebkh[hcdhklydbh[_jgmlu_[_j_klhcLZdhclbi
dhklydb \ [_j_klyghf ihdjh\_ ba\_klgu ih dmj]Zgguf aZohjhg_gbyf \ylbq_c DZd
khh[sZ_l:Dhleyj_\kdbcihkeZ\ygkdhfmh[uqZxl_ehihdhcgbdZh[_jlu\Zehkv\ em[
hlq_]h ]jh[ \hh[s_ ghkbe gZa\Zgb_ ³dhjklu´ Ba\_klgh qlh fhsb Gbdblu
I_j_keZ\kdh]h[uebgZc^_gu\ ³[_j_klb´FbexlbgkdZyFbg_yfZc
Ihg_dhlhjuf^Zggufh[uqZcbkihevah\Zlv\ dZq_kl\_]jh[Zdhjmkms_kl\h\Ze
_s_ \ ;9 \_d_ LZd \ jZkkdZa_ h kf_jlb ij_ih^h[gh]h IZngmlby ;hjh\kdh]h ²
hkgh\Zl_ey b i_j\h]h b]mf_gZ IZngmlb_\Z ;hjh\kdh]h fhgZklujy gZibkZgghf
_]hmq_gbdhfbghdhfBgghd_glb_fkjZam`_ihke_dhgqbguij_ih^h[gh]hklZjpZ_klv
lZdhc^bZeh]
Lh]^Z y kijhkbe ³=^_ \_ebrv fh]bem k_[_ bkdhiZlv b \ a_fex l_[y iheh`blv"
KlZj_p `_ fg_ hl\_lbe ³=^_ y DebfZ ]mf_gsbdZ iheh`be k gbf f_gy ih]j_[bl_ :
]jh[Z^m[h\h]hg_ihdmiZcGZl_r_klv^_g_]dZeZq_cdmib^ZjZa^_ebgbsbf: f_gy
em[dhfh[_jgb^Zk[hdmhlg_]hihdhiZ\iheh`b´
Ijb jZkdhidZo deZ^[bsZ Fhkdh\kdh]h Dj_fey \ ^j_\g_cr_f ]hjbahgl_
^Zlbjh\Zgghf \lhjhc iheh\bghc ;,, \_dZ [ueb h[gZjm`_gu lZd`_ aZohjhg_gby k
hklZldZfb ^_j_\ygguo ]jh[h\ ² ^he[e_gguo dheh^ < keh_ ^Zlbjh\Zgghf i_j\hc
iheh\bghc;,,,\_dZ[ue\kdjul]hjbahglih]j_[_gbc\ ^m[h\uo]jh[Zoysbqgh]hlbiZ
k^_eZgguo ba dhehluo ieZo gZ rbiZo [_a ]\ha^_c <_a^_ hjb_glbjh\dZ b iheh`_gb_
ihdhcgbdh\[uebh[uqgu_\ulygmlu_gZkibg_ljmiheh`_gby]heh\hcgZaZiZ^LZdbf
h[jZahfijbmklhcqb\hfh[jy^_ijZ\hkeZ\gh]hih]j_[_gbygZjm[_`_;,,²;,,,\_dh\
fu \klj_qZ_f hlebqby \ lbiZo ]jh[h\ KhojZgyxlky ^j_\gb_ jblmZeu ih]j_[_gby \
[_j_kl_ghlZd`_jZkijhkljZg_gu^m[h\u_dheh^ub i_j\u_h[jZapu]jh[h\ysbqgh]h
lbiZ
Ih]j_[_gby\ ^m[h\uodheh^Zo[uebhq_gvjZkijhkljZg_gugZl_jjblhjbbJmkb
qlh gZreh hljZ`_gb_ \ nhevdehj_ \ fgh]hqbke_gguo kdZadZo kdZaZgbyo [uebgZo
ij_^ZgbyoY kZfgZ[ex^Ze^m[h\u_dheh^u\ i_s_jghfdeZ^[bs_Ikdh\hI_q_jkdh]h
fhgZklujy Dheh^Z ij_^klZ\ey_l kh[hc ke_]dZ hl_kZgguc fZkkb\guc kl\he ^_j_\Z
jZkibe_ggucihi_j_db \u^he[e_gguc\gmljbihdhglmjmq_eh\_q_kdh]hl_eZ
Dh]^Z I_lj , gZqZe kljhbl_evkl\h nehlZ klhev g_h[oh^bfh]h ^ey mdj_ie_gby
fh]ms_kl\ZJhkkbbhgh[jZlbek\hbaZ[hlugZkhojZg_gb_e_kZdhlhjuc[uegm`_g^ey
dhjZ[e_kljh_gby < wlbo p_eyo ghy[jy ]h^Z [ue ba^Zg mdZa aZij_sZxsbc \
hij_^_e_gguof_klghklyojm[dme_kZAZihjm[dm`_^m[h\h]he_kZ\bgh\gu_dZjZebkv
kf_jlghc dZagvx B ohlv gZ ijZdlbd_ kf_jlgZy dZagv aZ ihjm[dm e_kZ ijZdlbq_kdb g_
ijbf_gyeZkv ljZ^bpby ihohjhg \ ^m[h\uo dheh^Zo ihkl_i_ggh moh^bl \ g_[ulb_ GZ
kf_gm_cijboh^ylihohjhgu\ ]jh[Zokdhehq_gguoba^hkhd>hevr_\k_]hih]j_[_gb_
\ dheh^Zokms_kl\h\Zehm klZjhh[jy^p_\
DeZ^[bsZ h[uqgh jZkiheZ]Zebkv m kh[hjh\ b p_jd\_c AgZlguo ]hjh`Zg
ohjhgbeb\gmljbp_jd\_cGh\ wihomkj_^g_\_dh\vygZJmkbg_j_^dhkemqZebkv]heh^b
fhjh\u_ ih\_ljby mghkb\rb_ h^gh\j_f_ggh lukyqb `bag_c LZd fhj hl ]heh^Z ]h^Z ijh^he`Zeky [he__ ^\mo e_l G_ kqblZy l_o dhlhju_ ihemqbeb [he__ ihq_lgh_
ih]j_[_gb_ \ p_jd\Zo klhebpu gZ deZ^[bsZo [ueh ihohjhg_gh ljmih\ ²
lZdgZkqblu\Z_l:\jZZfbcIZebpug>jm]b_gZkqblu\Zxlqbkeh`_jl\^h
<h\j_f_gZfZkkh\uowib^_fbcb ]heh^ZijZdlbdh\ZehkvaZohjhg_gb_\ [jZlkdbo
fh]beZo[_a]jh[h\LZdb_[jZlkdb_fh]beugZau\Zebkvkdm^_evgbpZfb<hldZdh[wlhf
ih\_kl\m_l Gh\]hjh^kdZy e_lhibkv \ ² ]] ³\ kb ^\Z e_lZ [uklv ]eZ^ b fhj
\_ebdb gZf_lZrZf_jl\uoljbkdm^_evgbpu²h^gm\ k\ylhcKhnbbaZZelZj_fZ ^\_m
Jh`^_kl\ZgZihe_´
< wib^_fbx qmfu \ Ikdh\_ khh[sZ_l e_lhibkv k hdly[jy ]h^Z ^h hk_gb
]h^Z[uehih]j_[_ghlukyql_e\ kdm^_evgbpZodjhf_fgh`_kl\Zkohjhg_gguo
lZcgh\ e_kmb \h\jZ]Zo
< ?dZl_jbgbgkdhf iZjd_ ]hjh^Z ImrdbgZ [u\r__ PZjkdh_ K_eh ba jhah\h]h
fjZfhjZ\ha^\b]gmluHjeh\kdb_\hjhlZgZdhlhjuo\uk_q_gZbklhjbyih[_^unZ\hjblZ
?dZl_jbgu =jb]hjby Hjeh\Z gZ^ ³fhjh\hc ya\hc´ HnbpbZevguc hlq_l h ebd\b^Zpbb
wlhc wib^_fbb ij_^klZ\e_gguc [he__ q_f gZ kljZgbpZo haZ]eZ\e_g \_kvfZ
ijhkljZggh ³HibkZgb_ fhjh\hc ya\u [u\r_c \ klhebqghf ]hjh^_ Fhkd\_ k ih
]h^k ijbeh`_gb_f\k_o^eyij_djZs_gbyhghclh]^ZmklZgh\e_gguomqj_`^_gbc´
KI[ ] H^gbf ba lZdbo ihklZgh\e_gbc [ue k_gZlkdbc mdZa ]h^Z
aZij_sZ\rbc ohjhgblv \ q_jl_ ]hjh^Z ih \k_c l_jjblhjbb Jhkkbckdhc bfi_jbb ² \h
ba[_`Zgb_ wib^_fbc <k_ ]hjh^kdb_ deZ^[bsZ lh]^Z [ueb ebd\b^bjh\Zgu Z gh\u_
jZkiheZ]ZebkvlhevdhaZ]hjh^kdbfbaZklZ\Zfb
< k\yab k h[sghklvx ojbklbZgkdbo h[jy^h\ AZiZ^ghc b <hklhqghc p_jd\_c
ih]j_[ZevgZyh[jy^ghklvdZlhebdh\fZehq_fhlebqZeZkvhllZdh\hcm ijZ\hkeZ\guoGZ
aZj_ojbklbZgkl\Zdh]^Zihke_^h\Zl_ebwlhcgh\hcj_eb]bbij_ke_^h\Zebkvih]j_[_gby
ojbklbZgkh\_jrZebkvlZcgh\ ih^a_fguodeZ^[bsZo²dZlZdhf[Zo
L_ogbq_kdbdZlZdhf[ujZajZ[Zlu\ZebkvdZdjm^gbdb< aZ[jhr_gguojm^gbdZo
dZf_ghehfgyo \ i_jbh^ ]hg_gbc kh[bjZebkv qe_gu ojbklbZgkdbo h[sbg >ey
aZohjhg_gbc \ dZlZdhf[Zo bkihevah\Zeb kl_ggu_ gbrb ² bo kdju\Zeb ieblZfb beb
aZfmjh\u\Zeb Gbrb jZkiheZ]Z\rb_ky \ g_kdhevdh yjmkh\ khklZ\eyeb jZa\_l\e_ggmx
kbkl_fm]Ze_j_cDZlZdhf[uh[gZjm`_gu\ :e_dkZg^jbbKbjZdmaZoG_Zihe_Jbf_
K mklZgh\e_gb_f ojbklbZgkl\Z dZd ]hkm^Zjkl\_gghc j_eb]bb knhjfbjh\ZeZkv
_^bgZyklhevohjhrhgZfagZdhfZyih]j_[ZevgZyh[jy^ghklvBaf_gblvb ihdhe_[ZlvA_
g_kfh]eb^\b`_gbyfgh]hqbke_gguok_dlLZdk_dlZZev[b]hcp_\\hNjZgpbbkqblZeZ
\kxa_fex\ jZ\ghcf_j_k\ys_gghcb ij_g_[j_]ZeZdeZ^[bsZfb
< kj_^g_\_dh\hc?\jhi_ijhkluodj_klvygb ]hjh`Zgohjhgbeb\ h[sbofh]beZo
dhlhju_ hldju\Zeb \kydbc jZa dh]^Z gm`gh [ueh iheh`blv gh\h]h ihdhcgbdZ
I_jki_dlb\Z ihemqblv \ fh]bem ^mjgh]h khk_^Z [ueZ \iheg_ \_jhylgZ h[ wlhf
ih\_kl\mxl fgh]hqbke_ggu_ e_]_g^u b kdZaZgby LZd \ D_gl_ \h \j_f_gZ =_gjboZ ,,,
fheb\rZykygZdeZ^[bs_`_gsbgZmkeuoZeZklhgu
³Y ^mrZ ih]j_[_ggh]h a^_kv ojbklbZgbgZ KljZ^Zx y baaZ lh]h qlh \ fh_c
fh]be_ ihohjhgbeb l_eh hlemq_ggh]h hlq_]h fhb dhklb g_ ihemqZl ihdhy \iehlv ^h
km^gh]h^gy´
EBL?J:LMJ:
=mj_\bq:Y DmevlmjZb h[s_kl\hkj_^g_\_dh\hc?\jhiu]eZaZfbkh\j_f_ggbdh\F
³Bkdmkkl\h´
R_e_ibgZGK :jo_heh]bq_kdb_gZ[ex^_gby\ Fhkdh\kdhfDjjfe_\ ²]]<
dg>j_\ghklbFhkdh\kdh]hDj_feyF³GZmdZ´
Dhleyj_\kdbc: H ih]j_[Zevguoh[uqZyoyauq_kdbokeZ\ygF
<Zebr_\kdbcD Kfmlgh_\j_fyKI_l_j[mj]
BghdBgghd_glbc JZkkdZah kf_jlbIZngmlby;hjh\kdh]hL\h_a^hjh\v_ ‹ Kf_jlgZydZagvAZb ijhlb\F³Xjb^bq_kdZyebl_jZlmjZ´
=E:<:;,9
LjZ^bpbb<hklhdZ
Lmjdb lZd `_ mfbjZxl dZd b \k_ ex^b lhevdh ohjhgyl bo k g_dhlhjufb
hlf_ggufbihaZdhgmboh[jy^Zfb
FboZbeQmedh\ ³I_j_kf_rgbdbebKeZ\_gkdb_kdZadb´²
<lhjhc ih agZq_gbx fbjh\hc j_eb]b_c ihke_ ojbklbZgkl\Z y\ey_lky bkeZf
FmkmevfZg_j_\ghklghkh[ex^ZxlmklZgh\e_gbyk\h_cj_eb]bbihwlhfmih]j_[Zevgu_
h[jy^u \k_]h fmkmevfZgkdh]h fbjZ ijZdlbq_kdb b^_glbqgu g_aZ\bkbfh hl
]_h]jZnbq_kdh]hjZkiheh`_gby²b \ZjZ[kdbokljZgZo;eb`g_]h<hklhdZb \K_\_jghc
:njbd_ b \ BjZg_ :n]ZgbklZg_ IZdbklZg_ b \ Kj_^g_c :abb b gZ DZ\dZa_ b \
fmkmevfZgkdbo j_]bhgZo Ih\he`vy Kh]eZkgh fmkmevfZgkdbf ljZ^bpbyf l_eh
ihdhcgbdZ ^he`gh [ulv iheh`_gh gZ ki_pbZevgu_ ih]j_[Zevgu_ ghkbedb ² lh[ml b
hlg_k_gh gZ deZ^[bs_ \ ^_gv kf_jlb ^h aZoh^Z khegpZ wlh [ueh k\yaZgh k l_f qlh \
`ZjdhfdebfZl_l_eZmf_jrbohq_gv[ukljhih^\_j]ZebkvjZaeh`_gbx=jh[ugbdh]^Z
g_ bkihevah\Zebkv l_eh [ueh ebrv iheghklvx aZ\_jgmlh \ kZ\Zg <udZiu\ZeZkv
\_jlbdZevgZyfh]beZ² rZolZ \gbam dhlhjhc \u^Ze[eb\ZeZkv gbrZ dm^Z b ihf_sZeb
l_ehGbrmaZfmjh\u\Zebfh]bemaZkuiZeba_fe_cb mklZgZ\eb\Zeblbih\hcdZf_gguc
gZ^fh]bevgucklhe[
Dlh [u\Ze \ >Z]_klZg_ lhl ^he`_g ihfgblv wlb deZ^[bsZ khklhysb_ ba
fgh]hqbke_gguo h^bgZdh\uo dZf_gguo klhe[h\iebl Q_f [he__ ihdhkbebkv wlb
dZf_ggu_ klhe[u l_f ^j_\g__ deZ^[bs_ ih^ijZ\eylv bo \ ihke_^mxs_f kh]eZkgh
ljZ^bpbbg_iheZ]Zehkv
Ba wlbo ijZ\be bgh]^Z ijZ\^Z j_^dh ^_eZebkv bkdexq_gby LZd \ Ohj_afkdhc
h[eZklb Ma[_dbklZgZ fg_ ihklhyggh \klj_qZebkv ^jm]b_ lbiu fmkmevfZgkdbo
aZohjhg_gbc ² gZa_fgu_ ih]j_[Zevgu_ kZjdhnZ]b ba dbjibqZkujpZ dm^Z
g_ihkj_^kl\_gghihf_sZekyikdhcgbdF_klgu_`bl_ebh[tykgyebwlmljZ^bpbxl_f
qlh \ gbaf_gguo f_klZo Ohj_afZ \ke_^kl\b_ [ebahklb :fm>Zjvb \ukhdh klhyl
]jmglh\u_\h^uqlhf_rZ_lh[uqgufaZohjhg_gbyfLZdhc`_lbiaZohjhg_gbc\_kvfZ
^j_\gbc gZ[ex^Ze y b \ pblZ^_eb Ob\u qlh ]h\hjbl h ^Z\ghklb ljZ^bpbb \ wlhf
j_]bhg_
JZkkdZau\Zy h ih]j_[Zevguo khhjm`_gbyo Kj_^g_c :abb g_evay g_ \kihfgblv
\_ebdhe_igu_fZ\ahe_bKZfZjdZg^ZWlhij_`^_\k_]hagZf_gblucfZ\ahe_c=mjWfbj
l _ mkuiZevgbpZ wfbjZ ]^_ ihdhblky kdhgqZ\rbcky \ ]h^m LZf_jeZg Lbfmj
djh\Z\uc aZ\h_\Zl_ev gZjh^h\ :abb ³@_e_aguc ojhf_p´ Z lZd`_ dhfie_dk fZ\ahe__\
RZobAbg^ZgZf_qZ\rbckydZdmkuiZevgbpZjh^gbb agZlbLbfmjZIhfbfhwlbo^\mo
\_ebq_kl\_gguo dhfie_dkh\ \ KZfZjdZg^_ _klv b ^jm]b_ fZ\ahe_b ² gZijbf_j
fZ\ahe_c :dkZjZc dhlhjuc kqblZ_lky mkuiZevgbp_c fm`kdbo ij_^klZ\bl_e_c jh^Z
Lbfmjb^h\\lhjhciheh\bgu;9\_dZfZ\ahe_cJmoZ[Z^³h[bl_ev^moZ´ihkljh_gguc
\ o ]h^Zo ;,9 \_dZ fZ\ahe_c Oh^`Z :[^b >Zjmg \ha\_^_gguc gZ^ ijZohf
aZdhgh\_^Z\uoh^pZba:jZ\bb`b\r_]h\ ,;\_d_
Djhf_wlh]hba\_klgufgh]hqbke_ggu_fZ\ahe_b;moZjuOb\ub fgh]bo^jm]bo
^j_\gbo ]hjh^h\ Kj_^g_c :abb Bf_xlky fZ\ahe_b ij_^klZ\bl_e_c ^bgZklbb <_ebdbo
Fh]heh\ b \ Bg^bb gZijbf_j fZ\ahe_b ;9, \_dZ OmfZxgZ ijZ\gmdZ ;Z[mjZ \ >_eb
dhfie_dk fZ\ahe__\ :]ju b fgh]b_ fgh]b_ ^jm]b_ <k_ wlh ]h\hjbl h[ mklhcqb\hc
ljZ^bpbb aZohjhg_gby fmkmevfZgkdhc agZlb b k\yluo \ ki_pbZevguo ihfi_aguo
Zjobl_dlmjguo dhfie_dkZo gZau\Z_fuo fZ\ahe_yfb beb fZaZjZfb mkuiZevgbpZ
k\ylh]h
Fg_ohl_ehkv[ugZihfgblvbklhjbxijhbkoh`^_gbykZfh]hkeh\ZfZ\ahe_cLZd
i_j\hgZqZevgh gZau\ZeZkv ]jZg^bhagZy mkuiZevgbpZ FZ\kheZ i_jkb^kdh]h kZljZiZ
DZjbc h[eZklb gZ x]haZiZ^_ FZehc :abb gZ l_jjblhjbb kh\j_f_gghc Lmjpbb
\ha^\b]gmlZy \ k_j_^bg_ ,9 \_dZ ^h g w b kqblZ\rZyky h^gbf ba ³k_fb qm^_k k\_lZ´
Ihkljh_ggZy Ibnb_f ]jh[gbpZ khklhyeZ ba d\Z^jZlgh]h phdhey b dhehggZ^u kh
klmi_gqZlhc ibjZfb^hc m\_gqZgghc ba\Zygb_f FZ\kheZ b _]h kmijm]b :jl_fbabb
klhysbo gZ dhe_kgbp_ aZijy`_gghc q_l\_jdhc dhg_c Iha^g__ fZ\ahe_yfb klZeb
gZau\Zlv \k_ fhgmf_glZevgu_ ]jh[gbpu Ihfbfh mkuiZevgbpu FZ\kheZ d
fhgmf_glZevguf ih]j_[Zevguf khhjm`_gbyf Zglbqghklb hlghkylky fbd_gkdb_
dmihevgu_ ]jh[gbpu fZehZabZlkdb_ ih]j_[Zevgu_ khhjm`_gby ³GZ^]jh[b_ g_j_b^´
jbfkdb_ djm]eu_ ]jh[gbpu P_pbebb F_l_eeu AZfhd k\ylh]h :g]_eZ [Zrgb \
jbfkdboijh\bgpbyoB]_evkdZydhehggZ
Dh]^Z _^_rv gZ fZrbg_ ih kl_iyf DZaZoklZgZ lh h^ghh[jZab_ i_caZ`Z
ij_ju\Z_lky lh b ^_eh ihy\eyxsbfbky ]jmiiZfb ijbqm^eb\uo khhjm`_gbb
k\_jdZxsbo ahehq_gufb dmiheZfb k_j_[jygufb ihemf_kypZfb gZ ribeyo DZd \
kdZad_
Fh`_l [ulv wlh ^Z\gh ihdbgmlu_ ^\hjpu" >Z g_l gbq_]h kdZahqgh]h gbq_]h
klZjbggh]h Ih^hc^bl_ ih[eb`_ i_j_^ \Zfb ² kh\j_f_ggh_ dZaZokdh_ deZ^[bs_
DmiheZ b ribeb \_gqZx gZ^]jh[vy iha^_rg_fm ² fZaZju Bgu_ jZaf_jhf k
kheb^guc^\mowlZ`guc^hfBo\hajZkl²g_[he__²e_l?klvb kh\k_fgh\u_
Kj_^b wlbo \gmrbl_evguo khhjm`_gbc mdjZr_gguo jZaghp\_lgufb bajZapZfb
hdjm`_gguomahjgufbf_lZeebq_kdbfbh]jZ^Zfb\b^gub kdjhfgu_fh]beu²^Z\gb_
b k\_`b_LZdboijZ\^Zg_fgh]h< ihke_^g__\j_fykqblZ_lkyg_ijbebqgufohjhgblv
kdjhfgh \k_ klZjZxlky \ iurghklb fZaZjZ i_j_s_]heylv khk_^Z AZ ihke_^g__
^\Z^pZlbe_lb_ gZ dZaZoklZgkdbo ijhklhjZo jZa\_jgmehkv kljZggh_ khklyaZgb_ ² dZdhc
jh^dZdZyk_fvy\ha\_^mlk\hbfmf_jrbf[he__gZjy^gu_b ^hjh]b_fZaZju
K g_aZiZfylguo \j_f_g \ dZaZokdhc kl_ib dhq_\gbdb \_jbeb qlh `b\msbo
h[_j_]Zxl ^mob ij_^dh\ ² Zj\Zob kimkdZxsb_ky \j_fy hl \j_f_gb k g_[_k GZ wlhl
kemqZcgZfh]be_klZ\bebxjlmIha`___ aZf_gbehihoh`__khhjm`_gb_bakZfZgZbeb
^_j_\Z²fZaZj
Dh]^Z \ wlb djZy klZe ijhgbdZlv bkeZf _]h kem`bl_eb mf_eh kh_^bgbeb
fmkmevfZgkdmx j_eb]bx k ij_`gbfb \_jh\Zgbyfb b f_klgufb h[uqZyfb L_g]jb
\_joh\gh_[h`_kl\hdhq_\gbdZ\iheg_hlh`^_kl\eyekyb m`b\Zeky\ khagZgbbex^_ck
:eeZohf Ih hq_jlZgbyf k\hbf fZaZju klZeb g_j_^dh mih^h[eylvky fZ\ahe_yf
fmkmevfZgkdbo k\yluo \ha\_^_gguf \ KZfZjdZg^_ Ob\_ ;moZj_ Lmjd_klZg_ Gh
fZaZju KZfZjdZg^Z b ;moZju \ha\h^bebkv gZ^ fh]beZfb ^Ze_dh g_ \k_o mf_jrbo Z
lhevdhl_oqlhijhkeZ\beky[eZ]hq_klb\ufb^_eZfb
Gh\mx aZjh`^Zxsmxky \ DZaZoklZg_ ljZ^bpbx dhff_glbjm_l ij_^klZ\bl_ev
>moh\gh]hmijZ\e_gbyfmkmevfZgK_j^g_c:abbb DZaZoklZgZ\ :efZ:l_dZabJZl[_d
oZ^`b GukZg[Z_\ ³M fmkmevfZgbgZ q_luj_ ^he]Z i_j_^ ihdhcguf Hfulv l_eh
H[_jgmlv_]h\ ijhklmx[_emxfZl_jbxKhl\hjblvijhsZevgmxfhebl\mIj_^Zlvl_eh
a_fe_ Fh`gh h[g_klb fh]bem g_\ukhdhc kZfZgghc beb dZf_gghc h]jZ^hc gh g_
`_e_aghc beb [_lhgghc b[h ijhjhd FmoZff_^ kdZaZe qlh kh \j_f_g_f fh]beZ
ijZ\h\_jgh]h^he`gZkjh\gylvkyk a_fe_c<gmljbh]jZ^ujZaj_rZ_lkyihkZ^blv^_j_\h
gh khhjm`Zlv qlhlh gZ^ fh]behc fmkmevfZgbgZ rZjbZl g_ jZaj_rZ_l Ba\_klgu_ gZf
fZ\ahe_b gZ^ fh]beZfb k\yluo fm^j_ph\ ihkljh_gu q_j_a fgh]h e_l ihke_ bo kf_jlb
dh]^ZklZehykghqlhex^bihij_`g_fmihfgylbo[eZ]hq_klb\u_^_eZ´
KlZjbgguo `_ fZ\ahe__\ gZ l_jjblhjbb DZaZoklZgZ ijZdlbq_kdb g_l DZdb_ `_
ljZ^bpbb ih]j_[Zevguo h[jy^h\ kh[ex^Zebkv m kl_iguo dhq_\gbdh\ \ ^hbkeZfkdbc
i_jbh^"BgnhjfZpbxh[wlhffufh`_fihq_jigmlvbakhh[s_gbciml_r_kl\_ggbdh\
ihk_lb\rbokl_ib:abb\ kj_^gb_\_dZ
LZd h^bg ba hkgh\Zl_e_c fhgZr_kdh]h hj^_gZ njZgpbkdZgp_\ b [ebadbc ^jm]
kZfh]hk\ylh]hNjZgpbkdZ:kkbakdh]hIeZghDZjibgb\u_oZebaEbhgZZij_ey
]h^Z\ khklZ\_ fbkkbb kgZ[`_gghc [meehc iZiu Bgghd_glby ,9 d fhg]hevkdhfm oZgm
?]hfbkkby^ebeZkv[he__^\moe_lb hghklZ\bebgl_j_kgu_aZibkdbh[h[uqZyolZlZjh
fhg]heh\< qZklghklbhgibr_l
³dh]^Z dlhgb[m^v ba gbo mfbjZ_l lh _keb hg ba agZlguo ebp _]h ohjhgyl
lZcgh\ ihe_]^_bf[m^_lm]h^gh
ohjhgyl`__]hk _]hklZ\dhcbf_gghkb^ys_]hihk_j_^bg___b i_j_^gbfklZ\yl
klhe b dhjulh ihegh_ fykZ b qZrm k dh[uevbf fhehdhf b \f_kl_ k gbf ohjhgyl
dh[uemk `_j_[_gdhfb dhgyk ma^_qdhcb k_^ehfZ ^jm]h]hdhgykt_^Zxlb gZ[b\Zxl
dh`mkhehfhcb klZ\yl__ ih\ur_gZ^\mobebq_luj_o^_j_\yrdZoqlh[u[ueZm g_]h\
^jm]hffbj_klZ\dZ]^_`blvb dhgbgZdhbohgfh][u_a^blvAhehlhb k_j_[jhhgb
ohjhgyllZdbf`_h[jZahf\f_kl_k gbfIh\hadmgZdhlhjhc\_aml_]hehfZxlZ klZ\dm
_]hjZajmrZxlb gbdlh\iehlv^hlj_lv_]hihdhe_gbyg_^_jaZ_lgZau\Zlvmf_jr_]h_]h
kh[kl\_ggufbf_g_f
BghclZd`_kihkh[kms_kl\m_l^eyih]j_[_gbyg_dhlhjuoagZlguoebpHgbb^ml
lZcdhf \ ihe_ m^Zeyxl lZf ljZ\m k dhjg_f b ^_eZxl [hevrmx yfm b k[hdm wlhc yfu
^_eZxl yfm ih^ a_fe_x b deZ^ml ih^ ihdhcgbdZ lh]h jZ[Z dhlhjuc kqblZ_lky _]h
ex[bfp_fJZ[e_`blih^gbflZd^he]hqlhgZqbgZ_ldZd[u\iZ^Zlv\ Z]hgbxZ aZl_f
_]h\ulZkdb\Zxlqlh[uhgfh]\a^hogmlvb lZdihklmiZxlljb`^ub _kebhgmp_e__l
lh \ihke_^kl\bb klZgh\blky k\h[h^guf ^_eZ_l \k_ qlh _fm [m^_l m]h^gh b kqblZ_lky
\_ebdbf\ klZ\d_b \kj_^_jh^kl\_ggbdh\mkhir_]hF_jl\h]h`_deZ^ml\ yfmdhlhjZy
k^_eZgZ k[hdm \f_kl_ k l_fb \_sZfb h dhlhjuo kdZaZgh \ur_ aZl_f aZju\Zxl yfm
dhlhjZygZoh^blkyi_j_^_]hyfhcb k\_jomdeZ^mlljZ\mdZd[uehjZgvr_k lhcp_evx
qlh[u\ij_^vg_evay[uehgZclbwlhf_klh< hklZevghfhgbihklmiZxllZddZdh lhf
kdZaZgh\ur_ghgZjm`gZx _]hiZeZldmhklZ\eyxl\ ihe_< boa_fe_kms_kl\mxl^\Z
deZ^[bsZh^ghgZdhlhjhfohjhgylbfi_jZlhjh\dgya_cb \k_o\_evfh`b ]^_[uhgb
g_mf_jebboi_j_ghkyllm^Z_kebwlhfh`ghm^h[ghk^_eZlvZ \f_kl_k gbfbohjhgyl
fgh]h ahehlZ b k_j_[jZ >jm]h_ ² lh gZ dhlhjhf ihohjhg_gu l_ dlh [ue m[bl \
<_g]jbb b[h lZf [ueb mf_js\e_gu fgh]b_ D wlbf deZ^[bsZf g_ ^_jaZ_l ih^hclb
gbdlhdjhf_klhjh`_cdhlhju_ijbklZ\e_gulZf^eyhojZguZ _keb dlh ih^hc^_l lh
_]ho\ZlZxlh[gZ`Zxl[bqmxlb ih^\_j]Zxlhq_gvaeufih[hyf´
Khh[s_gb_ IeZgh DZjibgb h \Zj\Zjkdhf oZjZdl_j_ aZohjhg_gbc fhg]heh\
ih^l\_j`^Z_lky ^jm]bfb ebl_jZlmjgufb ^Zggufb lZd khh[sZy h ihohjhgZo ;Zlm \
] i_jkb^kdbc bklhjbd >`ma^`Zgb ibkZe ³Ihohjhgbeb _]h ih h[jy^m
fhg]hevkdhfm M wlh]h gZjh^Z ijbgylh qlh _keb dlh m gbo mfbjZ_l lh ih^ a_fe_x
mkljZb\Zxl f_klh \jh^_ ^hfZ beb gbrb khh[jZagh kZgm lh]h ijhdeylh]h dhlhjuc
hlijZ\beky \ ij_bkih^gxx F_klh wlh mdjZrZxl eh`_f dh\jhf khkm^Zfb b
fgh`_kl\hf\_s_clZf`_ohjhgyl_]hk hjm`b_fb kh\k_f_]hbfms_kl\hfOhjhgylk
gbfb\ wlhff_kl_b g_dhlhjuo`_gb kem]_]h´
FZjdh Iheh jZkkdZaZe h _s_ [he__ k\bj_ihf h[uqZ_ ijb ihohjhgZo
fhg]hevkdh]h \_ebdh]h oZgZ ³Dh]^Z ]hkm^Zjv mfbjZ_l \k_o _]h emqrbo ehrZ^_c hgb
m[b\Zxlqlh[uhgb[uebm g_]hgZlhfk\_l_Dh]^Zmf_jFhg]moZg[he__^\Z^pZlb
lukyqq_eh\_d\klj_q_gguoih^hjh]_]^_g_keb_]hl_ehohjhgblv[uehih[blh´
:jo_heh]bq_kdb_fZl_jbZeuihdZau\Zxlqlhih^h[guckihkh[aZohjhg_gby[ue
k\hckl\_g_gfgh]bfgZjh^Zfp_gljZevghc:abbK\_^_gbyDZjibgbh lhfqlhfhg]heu
klZjZebkv kdjulv f_klh aZohjhg_gby k\hbo oZgh\ kh\iZ^Zxl kh k\_^_gbyfb FZjdh
Iheh>`ma^`Zgbb jy^Z^jm]boZ\lhjh\
LZd\ ²]h^ZofhgZofbghjbl=bevhf^_Jm[jmd\ha]eZ\eyefbkkbx\
Fhg]hebxb hklZ\bebgl_j_kgu_aZibkdbh k\h_fiml_r_kl\bb< qZklghklbhgibr_l
³Ih]j_[_gb_lh]hdlhmfbjZ_lhklZ_lkyg_ba\_klgufb \k_]^Zhdhehl_of_kl]^_hgb
ih]j_[Zxlk\hboagZlguoebpbf__lky]hklbgbpZ^eyhojZgyxsboih]j_[_gby´
Fhg]heu ^_j`Zeb \ lZcg_ f_klh aZohjhg_gby k\hbo oZgh\ G_ba\_klgh ^h kbo
ihj]^_ihohjhg_gQbg]bkoZg< h^ghcbafhg]hevkdboe_lhibk_cjZkkdZaZghqlhgZ^
fh]behc Qbg]bkoZgZ [ue ijh]gZg lZ[mg \ ehrZ^_c qlh[u kjh\gylv f_klh
ih]j_[_gbyb qlh[ugbdlhg_fh]gZclb_]h
< ]h^mfhg]hevkdbfbb yihgkdbfbmq_gufb[ueZhj]Zgbah\ZgZwdki_^bpby
ihihbkdmfh]beuQbg]bkoZgZNbgZgkbjmxl__ ijZ\bl_evkl\hb :dZ^_fbygZmdFGJZ
lZd`_]Za_lZ³Bhfbmjb´b l_e_dhfiZgby³Gbohglwjw[b´
Ijh_dl gZau\Z_lky ³=mj\Zg]he´ qlh \ i_j_\h^_ k fhg]hevkdh]h hagZqZ_l
³Lj_oj_qv_´ Hg jZkkqblZg gZ ljb ]h^Z Ij_^klhbl bkke_^h\Zlv l_jjblhjbx f_`^m
j_dZfb D_jme_g Hjohg b LheZ a_feb h[s_c iehsZ^vx ijb[ebabl_evgh lukyq
d\Z^jZlguodbehf_ljh\
Ij_^iheZ]Zxl qlh bf_ggh a^_kv b ihohjhg_g [u\rbc ijZ\bl_ev bfi_jbb <h
\kydhfkemqZ_lZdhgaZ\_sZe
JZkkdZau\Zyh fmkmevfZgkdboih]j_[Zevguoh[jy^Zog_evayg_hlf_lblvqlhhgb
l_kguf h[jZahf k\yaZgu k ih]j_[Zevgufb h[uqZyfb ^j_\gbo bm^__\ ;ulv
g_ih]j_[_gguf hklZ\e_gguf \ ibsm ^bdbf a\_jyf kqblZehkv \ ^j_\g_f BajZbe_
\_ebqZcrbf g_kqZklb_f b hldZaZlv dhfmeb[h \ ih]j_[_gbb [ueh m`Zkguf
gZ^jm]Zl_evkl\hf >Z\b^ b =hebZn m]jh`Zeb ihklmiblv lZd ^jm] k ^jm]hf , Dgb]Z
PZjkl\ <b^ g_ih]j_[_gguo ljmih\ ^he`_g [ue [ulv ^ey _\j__\
hf_jabl_evguf lZd dZd h^gh ijb[eb`_gb_ beb ijbdhkgh\_gb_ d f_jl\uf ihgbfZehkv
ihaZdhgmdZdhkd\_jg_gb_b lj_[h\ZeZkvhkh[Zyp_j_fhgbyhqbs_gbyL_ieucdebfZl
kihkh[kl\h\ZejZaeh`_gbxljmiZb aZklZ\eyedZdfh`ghkdhj__ohjhgblvf_jl\uo
DZdlhevdhq_eh\_dmfbjZe_fmaZdju\Zeb]eZaZ\k_ijhsZebkvk gbfp_emy_]h
b hfu\Zeb l_eh =jh[u [ueb \ mihlj_[e_gbb \ ?]bil_ b <Z\behg_ gh g_ m gZjh^Z
bajZbevkdh]h L_eh h[_jlu\Zeb hkh[ufb i_e_gZfb \ dhlhju_ \deZ^u\Zebkv ^mrbklu_
\_s_kl\Z]heh\mih\yau\Zebhkh[ufieZldhfb gZghkbedZog_kebihdhcgbdZd fh]be_
Fh]beZfbm ^j_\gbobm^__\kem`bebbebijhklu_yfu\udhiZggu_\ a_fe_beb
i_s_judhlhjuolZdfgh]h\ IZe_klbg_<oh^\ i_s_jmaZ\Zeb\Zebhkh[ufdZfg_f²
]ZeZe_fBgh]^Zfh]beu\uk_dZebkv\ kdZeZob bf_eb\gmljb\b^h[rbjghcdhfgZluk
fZe_gvdbfb [hdh\ufb dZf_jZfb dhlhju_ kh_^bgyebkv dhjb^hjZfb Fh]beu hohlg__
\k_]h^_eZebih^l_gbklufb^_j_\vyfbb \kZ^Zo\g_]hjh^h\LhevdhpZjb b ijhjhdb
ih]j_[Zebkv \ ]hjh^Zo ;h]Zlu_ h[udgh\_ggh bf_eb nZfbevgu_ fh]beu b ex[beb
\uk_dZlvbo\ukhdh\ kdZeZoKqblZehkvmgbabl_evgufg_[ulvih]j_[_gguf\ fh]be_
k\hbo hlph\ Fh]beu \uk_q_ggu_ \ kdZeZo aZ\Zeb\Zebkv [hevrbfb dZfgyfb GZ^
fh]beZfbbgh]^ZklZ\bebiZfylgbdbk^_eZggu_badZfg_cbeb\uk_q_ggu_bakdZeu<
D_^jhgkdhc^hebg_a_feymkuiZgZklZjufbgZ^fh]bevgufbdZfgyfbb iZfylgbdZfb
Ihke_ abfgbo ^h`^_c fh]beu [_ebebkv f_ehf ^ey lh]h qlh[u ij_^mij_`^Zlv
_^bgh\_jp_\ hl hkd\_jg_gby ijb ijbdhkgh\_gbb d fh]be_ b ihlhfm Bbkmk Ojbklhk
mih^h[eyenZjbk__\hdjZr_ggufl_gZjm`ghdjZkb\uf]jh[Zf\gmljbgZiheg_gguo
dhklyfbf_jl\uob \kydhxg_qbklhlhx?\Zg]_eb_hlFZln_yb ^Ze__
I_qZevihmf_jrbf\ujZ`ZeZkv\_kvfZkeh`gufh[jZahfdjhf_]jhfdh]hieZqZ
m^Zjyeb k_[y ih [_^jZf jZa^bjZeb h^_`^m b [jhkZebkv gZ a_fex ihkuiZy ]heh\m
i_iehfbeba_fe_x< agZdi_qZebgZ^_\ZebgZk_[y\j_lbs_ba]jm[hcl_fgh]hp\_lZ
ldZgbj\Zebbebkljb]eb\hehkugZ]heh\_b [hjh^mihdju\Zeb]heh\mb jhlkgbfZebk
k_[y \kydb_ mdjZr_gby \k_ wlh bf_eh p_evx ijb^Zlv \g_rg_fm \b^m kdhj[ys_]h
hli_qZlhd g_jyreb\hklb lZd`_ pZjZiZeb b l_jaZeb k_[y ^h djh\b < aZdhgZo Fhbk_y
kms_kl\m_l fgh]h hij_^_e_gbc bf_xsbo p_evx h]jZgbqblv wlb g_ijbylgu_ b
g_gm`gu_ h[uqZb hkh[_ggh dZkZxsb_ky gZ^j_ah\ b ijhdZeu\Zgby k\h_]h l_eZ jZ^b
mf_jrbolZddZdwlh[uehaZbfkl\h\Zghm yauqgbdh\
< ihke_^gb_ ]h^u \ i_qZlb \k_ qZs_ b qZs_ klZeb ihy\eylvky khh[s_gby h
dmevlmj_ljZ^bpbyob h[uqZyo>j_\g_]hDblZy< lh`_\j_fyh ih]j_[Zevguoh[jy^Zo
DblZyrbjhdhfmdjm]mqblZl_e_cba\_klghdjZcg_fZeh
< klZjhf DblZ_ ohjhgblv mf_jrbo iheZ]Zehkv gZ jh^h\hf deZ^[bs_ beb gZ
ijbgZ^e_`Z\r_fk_fv_mqZkld_a_feb?kebq_eh\_dmfbjZe^Ze_dhhl^hfZlh_]hl_eh
\ fZkkb\ghf b qj_a\uqZcgh iehlghf ^_j_\ygghf ]jh[m \_aeb \ jh^gu_ f_klZ b lZf
ohjhgbeb =jh[u h[uqgh ^_eZebkv gZklhevdh ]_jf_lbqgufb qlh hgb ^he]h_ \j_fy
fh]eb klhylv g_aZjulufb \ a_fex <j_fy gZb[he__ [eZ]hijbylgh_ ^ey ih]j_[_gby
hij_^_eyehkv ki_pbZevgufb ]Z^Zl_eyfb]_hfZglZfb gZ hkgh\_ Zkljheh]bq_kdbo b
^jm]bo\uqbke_gbc
< dZq_kl\_ ijbf_jZ ih]j_[Zevgh]h h[jy^Z \ kj_^g_\_dh\hf DblZ_ fu ijb\_^_f
\u^_j`dm ba dblZckdh]h jhfZgZ ³Pabgv Ibg Fwc´ ©P\_lu keb\u \ ahehlhc \Za_ª
Dgb]Z [ueZ gZibkZgZ \ ;9, \_d_ ^h kbo ihj hgZ y\ey_lky h^gbf ba hkgh\guo
deZkkbq_kdbojhfZgh\DblZyghbfyZ\lhjZg_ba\_klghM ]eZ\gh]h]_jhyjhfZgZ[h]ZqZ
b jZa\jZlgbdZ Kbfugv PugZ mfbjZ_l h^gZ ba r_klb `_g djZkZ\bpZ Ibgwj <hl dZd
Z\lhjhibku\Z_l__ ihohjhgu
³Mkhirmx gZdjueb [mfZ`guf ihdju\Zehf \hkdmjbeb [eZ]h\hgby b aZ`]eb
g_m]Zkbfuc k\_lbevgbd AZl_f ijbklZ\beb d g_c ^\mo ih^jhkldh\ H^ghfm iheh`_gh
[ueh[blv\ dZf_ggh_[beh^jm]hfm²\ha`b]Zlv`_jl\_ggmx[mfZ]mGZjZkk\_l__^\Z
ijhi_eb i_lmob y\beky ]_hfZgl b kdZaZe ³<hkvfhc ^_gv ^_kylhc emgu ihem^_gguc
qZk ² kZfh_ ih^oh^ys__ \j_fy ^ey mkljhckl\Z mkuiZevgbpu Z ^\_gZ^pZluc ^_gv
ij_^ihem^_ggucqZk[m^ml[eZ]hijbylgu^ey\ughkZb g_ih\j_^ylgbdhfmba[ebadbo
Ijb iheh`_gbb \h ]jh[ g_ ^he`gu ijbkmlkl\h\Zlv [ebadb_ jh^b\rb_ky ih^ agZdhf
>jZdhgZLb]jZDmjbpub Af_bGZhklZevgmxjh^gxk_caZij_lg_jZkijhkljZgy_lky
<kdhj_ ihy\beky hkfhljsbd ljmih\ k ih^jmqgufb Hgb k\_jgmeb [mfZ`gh_
ihdju\Zeh b jZaeh`beb h^_`^u Kbfugv kh[kl\_gghjmqgh kh\_jrbe hfh\_gb_ ]eZa
mkhir_c Z Qwgv Pabgvpab gZ ijZ\Zo kugZ kf_`be _c \_db Ihke_ wlh]h Kbfugv
\eh`be\ jhlihdhcgbp_aZfhjkdmx`_fqm`bgmDZdlhevdhaZ\_jr_gh[uehiheh`_gb_
gZh^jb himklbeb iheh]\k_dlh a^_kv [ue hl fZeZ ^h \_ebdZ ijbgyebkv hieZdb\Zlv
mkhirmx
< ihohjhgghc eZ\d_ aZ]h^y dmibeb q_luj_ ihahehq_gguo nb]mjdb ^_\mr_d
kem`ZghdH^gZ^_j`ZeZlZa^jm]Zy²ihehl_gp_lj_lvy²]j_[_gvq_l\_jlZy²_s_
dZdb_lhij_^f_lulmZe_lZNb]mjdbkem`ZghddeZeb\ fh]bemij_^iheZ]Zehkvqlhwlb
kem`Zgdb[m^mlijbkem`b\Zlvmf_jr_cgZlhfk\_l_²KJNb]mjdbihklZ\bebjy^hf
k h^jhfA^_kv`_jZaf_klbeb`_jl\_ggu_khkm^udmjbevgbpub ^j_\gxxjblmZevgmx
ml\Zjv´
GZlj_lbc^_gvihke_dhgqbguIbgwjkhklhyeZkvp_j_fhgbyiheh`_gby\h]jh[
gZ dhlhjmx kh[jZehkv fgh`_kl\h ]hkl_c b [ueb ijb]eZr_gu [m^^bckdb_ fhgZob
³Ijb[u\rbc_s_jZg__]_hfZglKxc^h`b^Zekyiheh`_gby\ ]jh[dhlhjh_khklhyehkv
ihke_fhe_[gZb p_j_fhgbb`_jl\hijbghr_gbc IhijbdZamKbfugy \ ]jh[ iheh`beb
q_luj_kZfuoemqrboh^_ygbyb q_luj_k_j_[jyguokebldZihh^ghfm\ dZ`^ucm]he
GZ^gh]jh[Ziheh`beb^hkdmk_fba\_a^k k_fvxhl\_jklbyfbgZg__²ihdhcgbpmb
aZdjueb]jh[djurdhc´Ihke_wlh]hihagZdmhkfhljsbdZljmih\]jh[klZebaZ[b\Zlv
]\ha^yfb
GZ k_^vfhc ^_gv ihke_ dhgqbgu Ibgwj b gZ \lhjhc g_^_e_ ihke_ __ kf_jlb
khklhyebkviurgu_iZgbob^u
GZdhg_pdZd\ukqblZe]_hfZgl \ ^\_gZ^pZluc ^_gv ^_kylhc emgu l _ q_j_a g_^_eb ihke_ kf_jlb Ibgwj khklhyeky \ughk l_eZ mkhir_c < [h]Zlhc ihohjhgghc
ijhp_kkbb mqZkl\h\Zeb Zjlbklu bah[jZ`Zxsb_ jZaebqguo ^moh\ jZa]hgyxsbo
g_qbklv ^mo Imlb ^mo HiZkgh]h imlb ^moieZdZevsbd \hkvf_jdZ g_[h`bl_e_c \
khijh\h`^_gbb kbf\heh\ [_kkf_jlby ² `mjZ\ey b q_j_iZob b fgh]b_ ^jm]b_ <
iZeZgdbg_kie_l_gghfba`_eluogbl_cr_edZg_keb^mrmmkhir_cZ f_`ohjm]\yfb
ih^jZaghp\_lgufbahglZfb²h[lygmlucjhkdhrghciZjqhc]jh[
GZ deZ^[bs_ ]_hfZgl ]ey^y gZ dhfiZk hq_jlbe f_klh ih]j_[_gby b ih m]eZf
fh]beuihklZ\be`_jl\m^momA_febIhke_wlh]h]jh[himklbeb\ fh]bem
>Ze__ ke_^m_l hibkZgb_ _s_ h^gh]h \_kvfZ jZkijhkljZg_ggh]h h[uqZy
mihfbgZxs_]hky ihqlb \h \k_o kj_^g_\_dh\uo dblZckdbo ih\_klyo ² mklZgh\db
^hs_qdb mkhir_c K deZ^[bsZ \ ^hf ^hklZ\eyxl ^hs_qdm gZ dhlhjhc gZibkZgh bfy
ihdhcgbdZb mklZgZ\eb\Zxl__ beb\ dhfgZl_]^_hg`bebeb \ k_f_cghf ZelZj_ ]^_
hgZ b ojZgblky ihlhfdZfb KqblZ_lky qlh \ ^hs_qd_ \hiehsZ_lky ^mrZ mkhir_]h _c
ijbghkyl`_jl\ui_j_^g_ck`b]Zxlki_pbZevgu_`_jl\_ggu_[mfZ`gu_^_gv]b
JZkkdZau\Zy h dblZckdbo ih]j_[Zevguo h[jy^Zo ohq_lky mihfygmlv _s_
g_kdhevdh bgl_j_kguo hkh[_gghkl_c G_h[uqguf ^ey gZk _\jhi_cp_\ y\ey_lky p\_l
ljZmjZ²hgljZ^bpbhggh[_eucKljZgZkf_jlbm ^j_\gbodblZcp_\Zkkhpbbjh\ZeZkvk
AZiZ^hf ^ey kjZ\g_gby m fgh]bo _\jhi_ckdbo gZjh^h\ ² k K_\_jhf ² K J b
kbf\hehfkf_jlbkem`bekbf\heAZiZ^Z²;_euclb]jkbf\he@bagb\_kgu²kbf\he
<hklhdZA_e_guc>jZdhg²KJ
Qbgh\gbdihke_kf_jlbhlpZ^he`_g[uebkijhkblvhlimkdb \_jgmlvky^hfhcgZ
\_kvkjhdljZmjZfZdkbfZevgucljZmj²^hlj_oe_llhevdhihke_wlh]hhgfh]kgh\Z
hlijZ\blvkyd f_klmkem`[u
IhdblZckdbfih\_jvyf^mrbkZfhm[bcpbebmf_jrbogZkbevkl\_gghckf_jlvx
klZgh\bebkv]heh^gufb[_kijbxlgufb^moZfb²³]mc´b \k_[hyebkvbof_klb
K_^vfhc emgguc f_kyp \ klZjhf DblZ_ kqblZeky f_kyp_f ]heh^guo ^moh\
mf_jrbo gZqbgZy k iylgZ^pZlh]h qbkeZ wlh]h f_kypZ b ^h ljb^pZlh]h iheZ]Zehkv
ihk_sZlv fh]beu mf_jrbo ij_^dh\ b jh^guo b ijbghkblv gZ fh]beu _^m ^_gv]b b
\k_\hafh`gu_\_sbk^_eZggu_ba[mfZ]bgZijbf_jh^_`^mdheykdbb fgh]h_^jm]h_
ydh[ug_h[oh^bfh_^mr_ihdhcgbdZ\ aZ]jh[ghc`bagb
Ih^ebgghc Zjo_heh]bq_kdhc k_gkZpb_c klZeZ gZoh^dZ \ ]h^m aZohjhg_gby
dblZckdh]h bfi_jZlhjZ Pabgv Bfi_jZlhj Pabgv ijZ\b\rbc Kj_^bgguf PZjkl\hf kh
]h ^h ]h ]h^Z ^h gZr_c wju jZa]jhfbe \hckdZ k_fb g_ihdhjguo m^_evguo
dgya_c bf_e kugh\_c b \ha\_e dhgnmpbZgkl\h \ jZg] ]hkm^Zjkl\_gghc b^_heh]bb
Ijb^\hjgu_ ijha\Zeb _]h Fm^juf Wlbf dhjhldZy Z\lh[bh]jZnbq_kdZy kijZ\dZ fh]eZ
[u b h]jZgbqblvky _keb [u\ fZjl_ ]h^Z dj_klvyg_ ba ijh\bgpbb Rwgvkb g_
h[gZjm`beb g_^Ze_dhhl^j_\g_c klhebpu dblZckdbo \eZkl_ebgh\ KbZgv _]h ]jh[gbpm
GZ ]em[bg_ k_fb f_ljh\ bo \ahjm hldjueky eZ[bjbgl ^ebgZ dhlhjh]h ² f_lj Z
rbjbgZ ² q_luj_ <ky rlhevgy [ueZ aZklZ\e_gZ ]ebgygufb q_eh\_qdZfb kZglbf_ljh\hc\ukhluDhggu_b i_rb_\hbguZ bf_gghhgbkhklZ\eyebjZlvpZjkl\Z
l_g_c \k_ dZd h^bg bf_eb djZkghdj_fh\u_ ]heh\u q_jgu_ ]eZaZ b ^_lZevgh
ijhjZ[hlZggu_bg^b\b^mZevgu_q_jluebpZ
KgZqZeZgZk\_l[h`bc[uebba\e_q_gui_j\u_ljbklZb]jmr_qguoq_eh\_qdh\
<k_ hgb bf_eb oZjZdl_jgmx ijbgZ^e_`ghklv d fm`kdhfm ihem ohly dh]^Zlh [ueb
h[jy`_gu \ i_klju_ h^_`^u ba r_edZ EbpZ nb]mjhd g_ ih\lhjyebkv LZdh_
\i_qZle_gb_qlhboe_ibebk dhgdj_lguoijhlhlbih\
Wlhg_i_j\ZygZoh^dZgZdblZckdhca_fe_]jh[gbpk ]ebgygufb\hbgZfb>_eh\
lhf qlh k ^j_\g_crbo \j_f_g \ fh]beu dblZckdbo \eZkl_ebgh\ mdeZ^u\Zeb lukyqb
khijh\h`^ZxsboGZi_j\uoihjZowlh[uebie_ggu_dhlhjuo[_a`Zehklghm[b\Zeb\h
\j_fy jblmZeZ ih]j_[_gby Ihlhf gjZ\u klZeb fy]q_ b ex^_c aZf_gbeb ]ebgygu_
dhibb
< k_j_^bg_ k_fb^_kyluo ]h^h\ g_^Ze_dh hl lh]h `_ KbZgy [ueZ h[gZjm`_gZ
]jh[gbpZ h^gh]h ba \_ebqZcrbo bfi_jZlhjh\ DblZy Pbgv RbomZgZ JZkdhidb a^_kv
ijh^he`Zxlkyb \gZrb^gbGZiehsZ^b\ lukyqd\Z^jZlguof_ljh\\ukljhbeZkv
lukyqgZy jZlv ]ebgyguo nb]mj \uiheg_gguo \ gZlmjZevgmx q_eh\_q_kdmx \_ebqbgm
<ukhlZkZfh]h\ukhdh]h\hbgZ²kf
=jh[gbpm \ha\h^beb lukyq ih^^Zgguo \ l_q_gb_ e_l Kljhbl_evkl\hf
jmdh\h^be kZf bfi_jZlhj Pbgv RbomZg DklZlb ih lh]^Zrg_c ljZ^bpbb _keb [u hg
mf_j ^h aZ\_jr_gby \k_o jZ[hl lh _]h l_eh [ueh [u aZ[ZevaZfbjh\Zgh Z h[jy^
ih]j_[_gbyi_j_g_keb[u^hk^Zqbihohjhggh]hh[t_dlZ³ih^dexq´LZdb_]jZg^bhagu_
kljhcdb [ueb \hafh`gu ihlhfm qlh m`_ \ lh]^Zrg_f DblZ_ ijh`b\Zeh hdheh fbeebhgh\q_eh\_d
B \k_`_ihoh`_]jh[gbpZbfi_jZlhjZPabgvaZlfblihk\h_fmZjobl_dlmjghfm
agZq_gbx \k_ ^jm]b_ EZ[bjbgl kh^_j`bl fgh]h lZcg ;hevrbgkl\h \hbgh\ gZijbf_j
g_bf_xljmd?klv\_jkbyqlhhgbfh]eb[ulvk^_eZgubadZdh]hgb[m^v^jZ]hp_ggh]h
f_lZeeZ>jm]b_iheZ]Zxlqlhjmdbm b]jmr_qguokhe^Zlbdh\[uebba^_j_\Zdhlhjh_
aZ\_dZij_\jZlbehkv\ ljmom
<hh[s_lh aZohjhg_gby dblZckdbo bfi_jZlhjh\ ihjZ`Zxl k\hbfb fZkrlZ[Zfb
Ljm^gh ih\_jblv qlh \eZkl_ebgu kihdhcgh gZ[ex^Zeb aZ l_f dZd b^_l ih^]hlh\dZ
h[jy^Z bo ih]j_[_gby Ih k\_^_gbyf ^hr_^rbf ^h gZk ba ]em[hdhc ^j_\ghklb
bfi_jZlhj Pbgv RbomZg fZgbZdZevgh [hyeky kf_jlb Ba\_klgh _]h baj_q_gb_ dlh \
fh_fijbkmlkl\bbaZ]h\hjblh kf_jlb^he`_g[ulvm[blB keh\hk\h_hg^_j`Ze
GZ wlhf fu aZ\_jrZ_f gZr djZldbc b ^Ze_dh g_ iheguc h[ahj ih]j_[Zevguo
h[jy^h\ jZaebqguo dmevlmjghbklhjbq_kdbo wiho b jZkkfhljbf _s_ h^bg \Z`guc b
bgl_j_kguch[t_dlk\yaZgguck bklhjb_cih]j_[_gbc²bkdmkkl\hwiblZnbb
EBL?J:LMJ:
;b[e_ckdbcwgpbdehi_^bq_kdbckeh\ZjvFbjh\ZyojbklbZgkdZyfbkkbyLhjhglh
DZgZ^Z 6
=bevhf^_Jm[jmd Iml_r_kl\b_\ \hklhqgu_kljZgu< dgIml_r_kl\b_\ \hklhqgu_
kljZguIeZghDZjibgbb Jm[jmdZF³=hkba^]_h]jZneblju´³IjZ\^Z´
fZy
>`bh\Zggb^_evIeZghDZjibgb Bklhjbyfhg]heh\< dgIml_r_kl\b_\ \hklhqgu_
kljZguIeZghDZjiygub Jm[jmdZF³=hkba^]_h]jZneblju´
Lba_g]Zma_g<= K[hjgbdfZl_jbZeh\hlghkysbokyd bklhjbbAhehlhcHj^ul,,
Ba\e_q_gbybai_jkb^kdbokhqbg_gbcFEBa^:G KKKJ
FbgZ_\BI Iml_r_kl\b_FZjdhIhehKI[
JhaZgh\: Q_ch[uqZc"³GZmdZb j_eb]by´ 6 ‹ P\_lukeb\u\ ahehlhc\Za_bebPabgvIbgFwcF³Om^ebl_jZlmjZ´l
=E:<:;9
Bkdmkkl\hwiblZnbb
QlhlZdh_wiblZnby"Keh\hwlhkhklhblba ^\mo ]j_q_kdbo ³wib´ ² ³gZ gZ^´ b
³lZnhk´²³fh]beZ´LZd\ >j_\g_c=j_pbbi_j\hgZqZevghgZau\ZeZkvgZ^]jh[gZyj_qv
Z iha`_²gZ^]jh[gZygZ^ibkvqZklh\ klbohl\hjghcnhjf_
< D_jqb \ p_jd\b BhZggZ Ij_^l_qb p_gg_cr_f iZfylgbd_ Zjobl_dlmju 9,,,
\_dZojZgblkyg_f_g__p_ggZydhee_dpbyZglbqguogZ^]jh[guodZfg_ch^gZbakZfuo
[hevrbo\ fbj_GZlZevyK_j]__\gZ;_eh\Z\b^gucki_pbZebklihZglbqghcwiblZnbd_
\ lh\j_fyaZ\_^h\Z\rZydZn_^jhceZlbgkdh]hyaudZ]hE_gbg]jZ^kdh]hf_^bpbgkdh]h
bgklblmlZ \ ]h^m ijb]eZkbeZ f_gy klm^_glZi_j\hdmjkgbdZ wlh]h bgklblmlZ
mqZkl\h\Zlv\ ;hkihjkdhcZjo_heh]bq_kdhcwdki_^bpbbIhfgxdZdi_j\ucjZay \hr_e
ih^ ijhoeZ^gu_ k\h^u p_jd\b BhZggZ Ij_^l_qb Z GZlZevy K_j]__\gZ \h^beZ f_gy hl
h^gh]h dZfgy d ^jm]hfm qblZeZ b lml `_ i_j_\h^beZ fgh]hqbke_ggu_ wiblZnbb B y
j_rbe qlh jZgh beb iha^gh g_ij_f_ggh djhf_ f_^bpbgu aZcfmkv bklhjb_c b
ihiulZxkv dZd fh`gh [hevr_ jZamagZlv h lhf h q_f ]h\hjbeb Zglbqgu_ wiblZnbb
Bf_gghlh]^Ze_lgZaZ^b aZjh^bekyaZfuk_ewlhcdgb]b
KqblZ_lky qlh bkdmkkl\h wiblZnbb \hagbdeh \ >j_\g_c =j_pbb b wlh
^_ckl\bl_evgh lZd H^gZdh k\h_h[jZagufb wiblZnbyfb fh`gh kqblZlv b
fgh]hqbke_ggu_ b_jh]ebnu ihdju\Z\rb_ kZjdhnZ]b ^j_\gbo _]bilyg Ihfbfh
j_eb]bhaguo ih]j_[Zevguo l_dklh\ \ gbo kh^_j`ZeZkv b g_dhlhjZy bgnhjfZpby h
ebqghklbihdhcgbdZ
Ba\_klgu [ueb wiblZnbb b \ >j_\g_c Bm^__ ;b[e_ckdbc Zjo_heh] ;mdhlhjn \
dZq_kl\_ijbf_jZijb\h^blke_^mxsb_gZ^ibkbgZ_\j_ckdboiZfylgbdZo
³WlhldZf_gvy ihklZ\be\ iZfylvm\Z`Z_fh]hihdhcgh]h?ebZdbfZ>Z^Zkl_fm
;h] ihdhc \ ?^_f_ f_`^m ^jm]bfb k\ylufb a_feb :fbgv :fbgv K_eZ´ IZfylgbd
h^ghc ^_\mrdb bf__l lZdmx gZ^ibkv ³Wlhl iZfylgbd y ihklZ\be gZ^ k\yl_cr_c
qbkl_cr_c^h[jh^_l_evghcb gjZ\kl\_gghcJ_\_ddhc^hq_jvxk\ylh]hjZ\\bgZe_\blZ
KZfmbeZh dhlhjhc\k_ohjhrhhlau\ZebkvMf_jeZhgZ^_dZ[jy]h^Z>Zihdhblky
__ ^mrZ\ ?^_fkdhfkZ^m´
< Jhkkbb wiblZnbb ihy\bebkv ^h\hevgh iha^gh Ojhgheh]bq_kdb b
klbebklbq_kdb gZ^]jh[byf k wiblZnbyfb ij_^r_kl\h\Zeb ]eZ^db_ gZfh]bevgu_
[_ehdZf_ggu_ ieblu KZfh_ ^j_\g__ aZohjhg_gb_ ih^ lZdhc ieblhc [ueh \kdjulh \
Fhkdh\kdhfDj_fe_\ keh_i_j\hciheh\bgu;,,,\_dZIha`_gZwlboieblZoihy\ey_lky
hjgZf_glihkljh_ggucbadhf[bgZpbcjZagh]h^bZf_ljZdjm]h\HjgZf_glwlhl\ k\hx
hq_j_^vl_kghk\yaZgk [_ehdZf_ggufbgZ^]jh[byfbFhkd\u;9²;9,,\_dh\B ebrv
aZl_frbjhdh_jZkijhkljZg_gb_ihemqZxlgZ^]jh[byk gZ^ibkyfb
Ba\_klguc agZlhd bklhjbb I_l_j[mj]Z F B Iuey_\ ijb\h^bl bgl_j_kg_crb_
klbohl\hjgu_ wiblZnbb gZ fh]beZo agZf_gbluo \h_gZqZevgbdh\ ]hkm^Zjkl\_gguo b
p_jdh\guo ^_yl_e_c ihwlh\ ;9,,,²;,; \_dh\ ihohjhg_gguo \ :e_dkZg^jhG_\kdhc
eZ\j_ LZd gZ fh]be_ ijZ^_^Z : K ImrdbgZ : I =Zggb[ZeZ \u[blZ ke_^mxsZy
wiblZnby
³Aghc:njbdbjh^beoeZ^djh\v_]hihdhbeJhkkbbhgkem`be²imlvd
\_qghklbmkljhbe´
GZ gZ^]jh[guo iZfylgbdZo EZ\ju g_fZeh klbohl\hjguo wiblZnbc
ijbgZ^e_`Zsboba\_klgufihwlZf;9,,,\_dZBB>fbljb_\m=J>_j`Z\bgmb ^Z`_
bfi_jZljbp_?dZl_jbg_,,gZfh]be_Z^fbjZeZQbqZ]h\Z
Gh g_fZeh \ EZ\j_ \klj_qZ_lky wiblZnbc y\gh h[gZjm`b\Zxsbo g_\_`_kl\h b
fZeh]jZfhlghklv [hevrZy bo qZklv ijbgZ^e_`bl mf_jr_fm dmi_q_kl\m <hl h^gZ ba
lZdbowiblZnbc
³A^_kv e_`bl ex[_agu_ fhb ^_lb fZlv \ZrZ dhlhjZy gZ iZfylv \Zf
hklZ\beZihke_^g__kb_aZ\_sZgb_`b\bl_^jm`_ex[ghijblhfihfgbl_b lhqlh
Bjbghc a\Zeb __ \ kmijm`_kl\_ [ueZ aZ i_l_j[mj]kdbf dmiphf <Zkbeb_f
DjZib\bguf e_l b ]h^Z f_kyp_\ b ^g_c d g_kdZaZgghc fh_c b \Zr_c
i_qZebjZaemqbeZkvk \ZfbhklZ\yfbjk \Zfbb [eZ]hkeh\_gb_´
Beb^jm]Zy
³Ih^ kbf dZfg_f \ha^\b]gmluf i_l_j[mj]kdbf c ]bev^bb dmiphf GbdheZ_f
B\Zgh\bq_f Ihohlbguf ih]j_[_gh l_eh _]h ijh\_^rZ]h `bagv \ I_l_j[mj]_
[_afyl_`gh ]h^Z kh[kl\_ggufb ljm^Zfb b [_a ihdjh\Z fgbfuo ijbyl_e_c \h keZ\m
`_;h`bxb ljm^h\k\hbo´
< qbke_wiblZnbcg_\hevgh\uau\Zxsbomeu[dmgZoh^bfke_^mxsmx
³Ijh\ DhgklZglbgh\bq dgyav <hehkkdbc ]jZn :\kljbckdbc
ijhbkoh^b\rbc hl jh^Z ]j_q_kdh]h bfi_jZlhjZ BhZggZ DZglZdmabgZ dhlhjuc
pZjkl\h\Ze\ ]h^mb ijZijZ\gmd[u\r_]h\ <ZeZobb ]hkih^Zj_f \ ]h^m
K_j[ZgZDhgklZglbgh\bqZDZglZdmabgZjh^b\r_]hky\ LjZglZ\Zgbb bf_gghlZd
g_ LjZgkbev\Zgbb ² K J hl Ih]hgu FboZbeh\gu mjh`^_gghc dgy]bgb
DhglZdmabghc \ Z\]mkl_ f_kyp_ ij_[u\rbc \ kem`[_ ijb jhkkbckdhf
bfi_jZlhjkdhf ^\hj_ iZ`_f b bf_\rbc gZke_^kl\_ggh_ ijZ\h gZ hj^_g
DhgklZglbgh\bqZK\<_ebdbf_gghlZdg_DhgklZglbgZ²KJb ih[_^hghkpZ
=_hj]bymf_jf]h^Z\ p\_l_fheh^uok\hboe_lHljh^mbf_eef_k´
GZh^ghcfh]be_hlpZgZoh^bfeZdhgbqgmxgZ^ibkvkugZ
³Dh]hjh^belhlk_cb khhjm^be´
< k\h_cdgb]_³I_j_^\hkoh^hfkhegpZ´FboZbeAhs_gdh\kihfbgZy`b\r_]h\
dhgp_ ;9,,, klhe_lby \ I_l_j[mj]_ [b[ebhl_dZjy WjfblZ`Z B N Em`dh\Z ijb\h^bl
k\b^_l_evkl\Z_]hkh\j_f_ggbdh\jZkkdZau\Z\rboqlhlhlk g_h[udgh\_ggufj\_gb_f
hlghkbekydh\kydbfihohjhgguf^_eZfb ihqlb_`_^g_\ghijbkmlkl\h\ZegZhli_\Zgbb
kh\_jr_ggh g_agZdhfuo _fm ihdhcgbdh\ [_kieZlgh jue gZ deZ^[bsZo fh]beu ^ey
[_^guo ex[be ibkZlv wiblZnbb b \uk_d gZ gZ^]jh[ghc iebl_ h^gh]h k\h_]h
jh^kl\_ggbdZ
³IZrZ]^_lu"²A^_ky²: <Zgy"²Ih^Ze__g_fgh]h²: DZly"²HklZeZkv\
km_lZo´
JZkkdZau\Zy h jZaebqguo dmjv_aguo wiblZnbyo ohq_lky ijb\_klb g_dhlhju_
gZb[he__ bgl_j_kgu_ gZ^]jh[gu_ gZ^ibkb kh[jZggu_ b i_j_\_^_ggu_ =
:e_dkZg^jh\bq_f
³Hg \hae_]Z_l \ ]jh[m ba dbiZjbkh\h]h ^_j_\Z b jZa\e_dZ_l kZfuo baukdZgguo
q_j\_c´
WiblZnbygZfh]be_[h]ZqZ\ Zg]ebckdhf]hjh^_Eb^k_
³A^_kvklZjucFZjlbgWe]bg[jh^IhdhblkygZ`_kldhfeh`_Ihfbemc^mrm
]j_rgmx_]hh [h`_L_[y[ug_ij_f_gghhg\ jZxijbkljhbeDh]^Z[ulu[uebfZ
hglh[hx´
WiblZnbygZfh]be_FZjlbgZWe]bg[jh^Z\ rhleZg^kdhf]hjh^_W[_j^bg_
³< wlhf ^hf_ g_ ieZlyl gZeh]h\ gZ i_qgu_ ljm[u Klhbl eb m^b\eylvky qlh
klZjZyJ_[_ddZg_kfh]eZmklhylvijhlb\lZdh]h`bebsZ´
WiblZnbygZfh]be_J_[_ddb;h]]_k\ Zg]ebckdhf]hjh^_Nhevdklhg_
³KljZrg__\k_ofmdZ^Z^eyg_]hlhqlhluqblZ_rvwlmwiblZnbxgZ_]hfh]be_
[_kieZlgh´
WiblZnbygZfh]be_jhklh\sbdZDeZ^[bs_I_jEZr_a³Hgihdhjbe\k_p\_lu
djhf_[_kkf_jlgbdZ´
WiblZnbygZfh]be_kZ^h\gbdZLZf`_Ba³>`ZfZ´KR:]l‹ ³>Z ijhklbl _fm =hkih^v qZklv _]h ij_]j_r_gbc aZ l_ fgh]b_ lukyqb lmjbklh\
dhlhju_hgijb\e_dZ_l\ gZr]hjh^´
GZ^ibkvgZfh]be_agZf_gblh]hjZa[hcgbdZ>bdZL_jibgZ\ Zg]ebckdhf]hjh^_
Chjd_³Chjdrbjihkl´bxey
³Hggbdh]^Zg_hl^Z\ZegbdZdbo^he]h\djhf_^he]h\ijbjh^_´
WiblZnbygZfh]be_fhlZDeZ^[bs_I_jEZr_a³Dhgkl_eykvhg´IZjb`
fZc
³Ohlv[_klZeZggufih\k_f_klgh
ijbagZg
<k_` \:dZ^_fbxhgg_[ueba[jZg´
:\lhwiblZnbynjZgpmakdh]hihwlZkZlbjbdZ]hklhe_lbyIbjjhgZDeZ^[bs_
I_jEZr_a³Dhgkl_eykvhg´IZjb`fZc
³A^_kv e_`bl Wkl_j JZcl dhlhjmx ;h] ijba\Ze d k_[_ ?_ [_aml_rguc kmijm]
LhfZk JZcl emqrbc dZf_ghl_k :f_jbdb kh[kl\_gghjmqgh \uihegbe wlm gZ^ibkv b
]hlh\k^_eZlvlh`_kZfh_^ey\ZkaZ^heeZjh\´
WiblZnby gZ fh]be_ Wkl_j JZcl \ Zf_jbdZgkdhf ]hjh^_ Fbg_Zihebk_
³Fbg_ZihebkklZj´bxey
³A^_kv ih]j_[_g fbkl_j >`_jZev^ ;wclk qvy [_aml_rgZy \^h\Z Wgg ;wclk
ijh`b\Z_lihWefkljblb \k\hb]h^Zh[eZ^Z_l \k_fqlhlhevdhfh`ghlj_[h\Zlvhl
b^_Zevghc`_gu´
WiblZnbygZfh]be_>`;wclkZ\ ]QZjevklhg_X`gZyDZjhebgZ³Jb^_jk
^Zc^`_kl´Ie_a_gl\bevKR:‹ @Zgj wiblZnbb y\beky jh^hgZqZevgbdhf wib]jZffu Q_f [ueZ ZglbqgZy
wib]jZffZ"I_j\hgZqZevgh²gZ^ibkvxgZfh]bevghciebl_`_jl\_gghflj_gh`gbd_
klZlm_ [h`_kl\Z l _ fZeh q_f hlebqZeZkv hl h[uqghc wiblZnbb Ba lZdbo gZ^ibk_c
ihkl_i_gghjh^bebkvk_gl_gpbb²dhjhldb_fhjZevgu_jZkkm`^_gbyih^\h^ysb_blh]
`bag_gghfmhiulmAZl_fbokf_gbebhklju_[ulh\u_aZjbkh\dboZjZdl_jheh]bq_kdb_
wlx^u kZlbjbq_kdb_ h[h[s_gby ² lZdbf h[jZahf jh^beZkv deZkkbq_kdZy ZglbqgZy
wib]jZffZ klZ\rZy jh^hgZqZevgbp_c \k_o ^jm]bo wib]jZff ² njZgpmakdhc
Zg]ebckdhcjmkkdhc
< oh^_ jZa\blby bkdmkkl\Z wib]jZffu gZ[ex^Z_lky b h[jZlguc ijhp_kk ²
h[jZs_gb_ wib]jZffu d `Zgjm wiblZnbb Gh gZ wlhl jZa wiblZnby ² ebrv ij_^eh]
ebrv m^ZqgZy ebl_jZlmjgZy nhjfZ qlh[u \ujZablv k\hb fukeb IjZ\^Z g_j_^dh
g_dhlhju_ ebl_jZlmjgu_ wiblZnbb Z hkh[_ggh qZklh ² Z\lhwiblZnbb ^_ckl\bl_evgh
ihf_sZebkvgZgZ^]jh[guoiZfylgbdZo
Wib]jZffugh\h]h\j_f_gbgZb[hevr__jZa\blb_ihemqbeb\hNjZgpbbgZqbgZy
k ;9, klhe_lgy hldm^Z wlhl `Zgj rZ]gme \ ^jm]b_ ebl_jZlmju Ihwlhfm fu ijb\_^_f
g_kdhevdh gZb[he__ lbibqguo njZgpmakdbo ebl_jZlmjguo wiblZnbc \ i_j_\h^_ <
<Zkbev_\Z
A^_kvkiblfhykmijm]Z:odZdhcB _cihdhcb fg_ihdhc
@Zd>xEhjZg 6²,
Ih^k_cieblhcihqbeb]mf_gHg[ue^hg_evayg_jZamf_g
Mfjbg_^_e_xiha^g_cHg`be[u^hevr_gZk_fv^g_c
IhevKdZjjhg²
WiblZnbyDhev[_jmkdhgqZ\r_fmkyhldZf_gghc[he_agb
@Zg;ZliklDhev[_j²[uebgl_g^ZglhfnbgZgkh\ijb³wlhjhf[ueZ
\\_^_gZ`_klhdZykbkl_fZgZeh]hh[eh`_gby²KJ
A^_kvklZeDhev[_j^h[uq_xa_feb@_klhdZy[he_agv_]hkjZabeZ
<h\kdjulhfljmi_iylvdZfg_cgZrebBadhbokZfufl\_j^ufk_j^p_[ueh
:ghgbf;9,,,\_dZ
WiblZnbyagZlghfmiml_r_kl\_ggbdm
G_ieZqvl_qlhiheh`_g\ mjgmwlmA_fe_ijhoh^pZIv_jZ[j_ggucijZoIv_j
fgh]himl_r_kl\h\Zeihk\_lmGhg_[u\Ze_s_gZg_[_kZo
:glmZgEmbE_[j_g²WiblZnbyZil_dZjx
A^_kvlhlihqb_ldlh\kx`bagv[_ae_gbAZ]jhr\klZ\Zeij_^aZ^hfgZdhe_gb
:ghgbf;9,,, \_dZ
@Zgj ebl_jZlmjghc wiblZnbb l _ klboh\ bjhgbabjmxsbo gZ^ kf_jlvx ²
\_kvfZiZjZ^hdkZevguc`ZgjHkh[_gghhg[ebahdagZf_gblhfmZg]ebckdhfm³q_jghfm
xfhjm´Ihwlhfm \ :g]ebb `Zgj ebl_jZlmjguo kZlbjbq_kdbo wiblZnbc ihemqbe hq_gv
rbjhdh_jZkijhkljZg_gb_Fuijb\_^_fg_dhlhju_bawlbowiblZnbc\ i_j_\h^_KY
FZjrZdZ
E_`mih^dZfg_fy ²\^h\Z<eZ^_evpZ³Ahehlh]hev\Z´Ihdhjguc\he_
ijh\b^_gvyFhckugkh^_j`blaZ\_^_gv_
Khr_eih^]jh[h\mxk_gv;_ki_qguc^y^yIdlwjEbrvhllh]hqlh\ fZckdbc
^_gvHklZ\be^hfZk\bl_j
²Wcdlhlmlih]j_[_g"
²Gmy: dlh` bghc"
²LZdwlhlufhc>`hg"
²>Z[uedh]^Zlhfghc
Y]j_gZ^_je_`m\ a_fe_kujhcY ijhklm^beky\uib\djm`dmib\ZG_i_cl_
ib\Z `Zjdhxihjhc: i_cl_kibjl²b [m^_l_\u `b\u
GZ wlhc `bag_ml\_j`^Zxs_c wiblZnbb kZfh keh\hkhq_lZgb_ a\mqbl g_kdhevdh
iZjZ^hdkZevghy [ub ohl_eaZdhgqblvdjZldbch[ahjbkdmkkl\ZwiblZnbbgbkdhevdhg_
ij_l_g^mxsbc gZ gZmqgmx iheghlm Z lhevdh beexkljbjmxsbc h^bg ba Zki_dlh\
lZgZlheh]bb
EBL?J:LMJ:
Gxklj_fW ;b[e_ckdbcwgpbdehi_^bq_kdbckeh\Zjv
Fbjh\ZyojbklbZgkdZy
fbkkbyLhjhglhDZgZ^Z
>j_\ghklbFhkdh\kdh]hDj_fey F³GZmdZ´
Iuey_\FB KlZjucI_l_j[mj] KI_l_j[mj]Ba^:KKm\hjbgZ
NjZgpmakdb_deZkkbq_kdb_wib]jZffuF³Om^ebl´´ =E:<:;9,
DZagblvihdhcgbdZ
< nbevf_ L_g]baZ :[meZ^a_ ³IhdZygb_´ =jmabynbevf ] jZaebqgu_
fgh]hieZgh\u_ ijblqb ]jmiibjmxlky \hdjm] p_gljZevgh]h dhgnebdlZ ijhoh^ys_]h
q_j_a \kx dZjlbgm ² h \hafh`ghklb ij_^Zgby a_fe_ l_eZ LbjZgZ >hqv Om^h`gbdZ
\udZiu\Z_lbafh]beuljmiLbjZgZb ih^[jZku\Z_l_]hjh^kl\_ggbdZfLbjZgZLbjZgZ
\gh\vohjhgyl²b \gh\vljmihdZau\Z_lky\u[jhr_ggufbafh]beuKm^kdjmime_agh
ZgZebabjm_l ij_klmie_gby LbjZgZ b j_rZ_l \hijhk h ijZ\hfhqghklb ^_ckl\bc >hq_jb
Om^h`gbdZ < dhgp_ dhgph\ ljmi LbjZgZ \gh\v \udZiu\Zxl ba fh]beu b [jhkZxl \
h\jZ]gZjZkl_jaZgb_\hjhgvx
Nbevf\ua\Zehq_gv]hjyqb_kihjuh[km`^_gbyFgh]b_h[\bgyebj_`bkk_jZ\
bahsj_gghc nZglZabb djblbdmy _]h aZ gZlmjZebklbq_kdb_ kp_gu k ljmihf LbjZgZ Gh
\jy^ebkihjb\rb_agZebqlhf_g__\k_]h:[meZ^a_\ ^ZgghfkemqZ_fh`ghh[\bgblv\
³bahsj_gghc nZglZabb´ ?^bgkl\_ggh_ qlh hg k^_eZe ² wlh yjdh \uk\_lbe h^bg ba
Zki_dlh\ fgh]h\_dh\hc ikboheh]bb q_eh\_dZ bklhdb dhlhjh]h l_jyxlky \ ]em[hdhf
]em[hdhfijhrehf
Ba^Z\gZ [ueh ijbgylh aZ ij_klmie_gby q_eh\_dZ ³gZdZau\Zlv´ _]h hklZgdb
Ih^l\_j`^_gb_wlhfmfugZoh^bf\ fgh]hqbke_gguobklhjbq_kdbok\b^_l_evkl\Zo
< ]h^m gZ k\ys_gguc jbfkdbc ij_klhe \klmibe iZiZ Kl_nZg 9,, < gZqZe_
ijZ\e_gby hg ijbdZaZe \ujulv ba fh]beu l_eh k\yl_cr_]h iZiu NhjfhaZ , k\h_]h
ij_^r_kl\_ggbdZ ijhe_`Z\r__ \ a_fe_ m`_ k_fv f_kyp_\ b ihdZjZlv [u\r_]h
mamjiZlhjZp_jdh\ghc\eZklb
I_j_^ kh[jZgb_f \ukrbo p_jdh\gbdh\ \ Jbf_ jZau]jZeky hf_jabl_evguc
ki_dlZdev ljmi NhjfhaZ ijh\hehdeb aZ gh]b b mkZ^beb gZ ljhg _]h h[eZqbeb \
iZjZ^gmxh^_`^mgZ]heh\m\haeh`beblbZjmZ \jmdb\eh`beb`_aeIhdhcgbdm^Zeb
Z^\hdZlZ²ijZ\^Zg_klhevdh^eyaZsblukdhevdh^eyim[ebqgh]hihdZygby<uklmiZy
hlbf_gbdeb_glZdhlhjucg_fh]ih^l\_j^blvbebhijh\_j]gmlvh[\bg_gbchgh[\bgye
k\h_]h ih^hi_qgh]h \h \k_o kf_jlguo ]j_oZo Ihke_ hdhgqZgby j_qb iZiZ Kl_nZg 9,,
ijh\ha]eZkbe ijb]h\hj hlemqb\rbc NhjfhaZ hl p_jd\b b h^gbf m^Zjhf gh]b k\Zebe
[u\r_]h iZim k ij_klheZ Ih _]h jZkihjy`_gbx k ljmiZ kgyeb k\ys_ggu_ jbau
hljm[beb ljb iZevpZ ijZ\hc jmdb i_j_ehfZeb jmdb b gh]b b lhevdh ihke_ lh]h dZd
iZeZqhlk_d_fm]heh\mbamjh^h\Zggu_hklZgdb[jhkbeb\ Lb[j
< O \_d_ iZiZ BhZgg ;,,, ² ijbdZaZe \ujulv ba fh]beu l_eh ]_jph]Z
Jhnj_^Z k\h_]h iheblbq_kdh]h ijhlb\gbdZ ba[jZggh]h dhgkmehf JbfZ b m[blh]h
ih^hkeZggufb iZihc gZ_fgufb m[bcpZfb \u\Zeylv _]h \ ]jyab b \u[jhkblv gZ
]hjh^kdmxk\Zedm<kdhj_ihke_wlh]h\ ]h^miZiZ;hgbnZpbc9,,aZfhjb\]heh^hf
k\h_]hk\_j]gmlh]hij_^r_kl\_ggbdZiZimBhZggZ;,9ijb\yaZeljmik\h_c`_jl\u\
iZjZ^ghfh[eZq_gbbd ih^t_fghfmfhklm^\hjph\hcdj_ihklbH^gZdhm`_q_j_a]h^\
]h^miZiZ;hgbnZpbc 9,, kZfkdhgqZekyhlZihie_dkbq_kdh]hm^ZjZLh]^Z\ k\hx
hq_j_^v]jZ`^Zg_JbfZ\ulZsbebljmii_j\hk\ys_ggbdZba]jh[Zg_sZ^gh ba[beb b
kgy\ k bamjh^h\Zggh]h ihdhcgbdZ kZ\Zg ih\hehdeb ih mebpZf ^h iehsZ^b FZjdZ
:\j_ebyLZf_]hih^\_kbebaZgh]bk^_eZ\fbr_gvx^eyie_\dh\GZke_^mxsbc^_gv
j_r_gh[uehmkljhblv_fm³^hklhcgu_´ihohjhguk[jhkb\iZim\ klhd^eyg_qbklhlgh
g_kdhevdh k\ys_ggbdh\ qlh[u kiZklb hl ihahjZ ]eZ\m ojbklbZgkdhc p_jd\b ghqvx
\udjZebljmib gZki_oihohjhgbebaZij_^_eZfb]hjh^Z
Ih j_r_gbx kha\Zggh]h jbfkdbf iZihc Empb_f ,,, ² kh[hjZ dhklb
mf_jrbo _j_lbdh\ dZd hkd\_jgyxsb_ ojbklbZgkdb_ deZ^[bsZ ih^e_`Zeb \ujulbx b
kh``_gbx
<h\j_fy[hjv[uk Zev[b]hckdhc_j_kvxgZX]_NjZgpbb\ i_j\hciheh\bg_;,,,
\_dZ \ Lmema_ jZag_kky kemo qlh gZ^ dZghgbdhf p_jd\b k\ylh]h K_jg_gZ gZ kf_jlghf
h^j_ [ue kh\_jr_g _j_lbq_kdbc h[jy^ Lh]^Z ^hfbgbdZg_p JheZg^ \ujue k ihfhsvx
fhgZoh\l_eh_j_lbdZb k`_]_]hgZ]eZaZom \k_o
NjZgpmakdbc dhjhev Ex^h\bd ;,9 ² jZajmrbe ygk_gbklkdbc
fhgZklujvIhjJhyevb ijbdZaZe\udhiZlv^Z`_ljmiuihohjhg_gguolZfygk_gbklh\
G_fZehih^h[guoijbf_jh\ojZgblb jmkkdZybklhjbyfZy]h^Z[uem[bl
aZo\Zlb\rbcjmkkdbcij_klhekZfha\Zg_pgZa\Z\rbck_[ypZj_\bq_f>bfbljb_fL_eh
kZfha\ZgpZhllZsbebgZDjZkgmxiehsZ^vb ihf_klbebgZih^fhkldbgZEh[ghff_kl_
GZ^m[bluf\k_\j_fy ba^_\Zebkv kh\j_f_ggbdb k\b^_l_evkl\mxl qlh ^Z`_ `_gsbgu
³aZgbfZebkv g_ijbklhcguf ihjm]Zgb_f g_kqZklgh]h ljmiZ´ H^bg aZ]h\hjsbd \klZ\be
_fm\ jhl^m^dm^jm]hcaZdjue_fmebphmjh^eb\hcfZkdhcgZc^_gghc\h^\hjp_
Q_j_aljb^gyljmi\u\_aebaZ]hjh^b [jhkbeb\ h[smxfh]bem\ m[h]hf^hf_
Gh lml `_ jZkijhkljZgbeky kemo qlh f_jl\_p \uoh^be ba a_feb b im]Ze ijhoh`bo
IjbdZaZeb aZjulv _]h ih]em[`_ Z hg hiylv \ur_e <hdjm] _]h fh]beu jhbebkv
kljZrgu_ijb\b^_gbyLh]^Zj_rbeb_]hk`_qvI_iehfaZjy^bebimrdmb \uklj_ebeb
gZaZiZ^\ klhjhgmIhevrbhldm^Zihy\bekywlhlkZfha\Zg_p
Ke_^m_laZf_lblvqlhh[uqZck`b]Zlvl_ehij_klmigbdZb jZa\_b\Zlv_]hijZoih
\_ljmklhev`_^Z\gbc dZdb gZ^jm]Zl_evkl\hgZ^ljmihfLZd:jghev^;j_rbZgkdbc
h^bg ba \h`^_c Zglbn_h^Zevgh]h b ZglbdZlhebq_kdh]h ^_fhdjZlbq_kdh]h ^\b`_gby \
BlZebb[ue\ ]h^mkh``_gdZd_j_lbdZ ijZo_]h[jhkbeb\ Lb[jqlh[ufh]beZ_]h
g_fh]eZklZlvij_^f_lhfihdehg_gbyfgh]hqbke_gguoijb\_j`_gp_\
Ijbf_jghlZdZy`_km^v[Z[ueZm l_eZ=jb]hjbyJZkimlbgZJZkimlbg[uem[bl\
ghqvk gZ^_dZ[jy]h^Z\ Xkmih\kdhf^\hjp_Z ljmi_]hmlhie_g\ G_\_Ih
h^ghc ba \_jkbc aZohjhg_gb_ = ? JZkimlbgZ [ueh ijhba\_^_gh \ k\bgph\hf ]jh[m
ba]hlh\e_gghfihki_pbZevghfmijh_dlm\hNjZgpbbD fh]be_JZkimlbgZg_ij_ju\gh
reb iZehfgbdb ijhp_kkbb khijh\h`^Zebkv ieZq_f bkl_jbdZfb \_jmxsbo [ueb
kemqZb kZfhm[bckl\Z < k\yab k wlbf ]jh[ k l_ehf JZkimlbgZ lZcgh i_j_aZohjhgbeb m
ijZ\h]hneb]_ey:e_dkZg^jh\kdh]h^\hjpZ\ PZjkdhfK_e_ih^^m[hfghb wlh f_klh
klZehihk_sZlvkyiZehfgbdZfb
fZjlZ ]h^Z D_j_gkdbc ijbdZaZe hlukdZlv f_klh ih]j_[_gby = ?
JZkimlbgZGh\uo b mgbqlh`blv ljmi k l_f qlh[u fh]beZ _]h g_ klZeZ f_klhf
iZehfgbq_kl\Z gZjh^Z Qe_g dhfbl_lZ `mjgZebklh\ hj]Zgbah\Zggh]h ijb
=hkm^Zjkl\_gghc ^mf_ \ ]h^m ? B EZ]Zgkdbc hklZ\b\rbc k\hb \hkihfbgZgby
hlijZ\beky \ PZjkdh_ K_eh ]^_ \ kljhys_cky <ujm[h\kdhc qZkh\_gd_ h[gZjm`be
fh]bemJZkimlbgZ
< lm `_ ghqv ]jh[ ih mdZaZgbx D_j_gkdh]h \ujueb ba fh]beu ihf_klbeb \
]jhfZ^gucysbdhljhyeyb ih^\b^hffmaudZevgh]hbgkljmf_glZhlijZ\beb\ lh\Zjghf
\Z]hg_ \ I_ljh]jZ^ \ ijb^\hjgu_ dhgxrgb gZ Dhgxr_gghc iehsZ^b LZf hg e_`Ze
g_kdhevdh ^g_c Ih ihjmq_gbx D_j_gkdh]h `mjgZebkl Dmiqbgkdbc ih\_a l_eh \
hdj_klghklb I_ljh]jZ^Z qlh[u lZf mgbqlh`blv GZ Ihdehgghc ]hj_ fZrbgZ klZeZ
Kh[jZeZkvlheiZa_\ZdEx^bj_rbebqlh³[hevr_\bdbg_fpZfahehlh\_aml\ ysbd_´
Ysbd\kdjueblheiZZogmeZb ijblboeZ²=jbrdZDmiqbgkdbcj_rbelml`_
gZf_kl_k`_qvl_ehJZkimlbgZL_eh[uehij_^Zghh]gxZ i_i_ejZa\_ygih\_ljm
Ih kemoZf ljmi ;_jbb lZd`_ [ue kh``_g Z i_i_e _]h \uklj_ehf ba hjm^by
jZa\_yg
< Zij_e_ ]h^Z kdhgqZeky ;hjbk =h^mgh\ b [ue lhj`_kl\_ggh ih]j_[_g \
:joZg]_evkdhf kh[hj_ Dj_fey \ pZjkdhc mkuiZevgbp_ dZd jh^hgZqZevgbd gh\hc
^bgZklbb Gh m`_ q_j_a [ g_^_ev ihke_ ih]j_[_gby ih ijbdZam E`_^fbljby hg [ue
\udbgml kd\hav ijhehf kh[hjghc kl_gu dZd g_^hklhcguc ijhclb qj_a hk\ys_ggu_
\jZlZ
Ljb k iheh\bghc \_dZ kimkly \ ghqv gZ ghy[jy ]h^Z ba FZ\ahe_y [ueh
\ug_k_gh l_eh B < KlZebgZ ihfi_agh ihohjhg_ggh]h aZ e_l ^h wlh]h DZd \b^gh
q_eh\_q_kdZyikboheh]byfZehbaf_gbeZkvaZ e_l Eh]bdZ iheblbq_kdbo kh[ulbc b
hiul bklhjbb ihdZau\Zxl qlh \kdhj_ \_jhylgh fu klZg_f k\b^_l_eyfb fZkkh\uo
i_j_aZohjhg_gbc^_yl_e_cJ_\hexpbbwihobklZebgbafZb [he__iha^g_]h\j_f_gbM`_
k_cqZkjZa^Zxlkyfgh]hqbke_ggu_ijbau\ud wlhfm
³Mjgu[_amfguomjhd\iZygu\ fhgheblDj_fe_\kdb_am[u[heylih^
iehf[ZfbDh]hlhlj_[mxlm^Zeblv´
G_kfhljygZk\hbijh]j_kkb\gu_ijhaZiZ^gu_\a]ey^uI_lj,lh`_[ue^Ze_dh
g_qm`^bahsj_ggufgZ^jm]Zl_evkl\ZfgZ^l_eZfbk\hbomf_jrboijhlb\gbdh\
Dh]^Z ijb ^hijhkZo klj_e_pdh]h ihedh\gbdZ Pbde_jZ \ ]h^m \uykgbehkv
qlh ihdhcguc [hyjbg B\Zg FbehkeZ\kdbc [ue ijbqZkl_g d aZ]h\hjm pZj_\gu Khnvb
I_lj ijbdZaZe \ujulv ba a_feb ]jh[ FbehkeZ\kdh]h b ijb\_alb \ Ij_h[jZ`_gkdh_ gZ
k\bgvyo=jh[hldjuebKhdh\gbgmb Pbde_jm]eZ\gufaZ]h\hjsbdZfjm[bebij_`^_
jmdbb gh]bihlhfhljm[beb]heh\udjh\vboebeZkv\ ]jh[FbehkeZ\kdh]h
Hkh[uf gZ^jm]Zl_evkl\Zf ih^\_j]Zebkv l_eZ dZag_gguo ij_klmigbdh\ Ljmiu
beb qZklb l_eZ dZag_gguo \uklZ\eyebkv gZ f_kl_ dZagb k l_f qlh[u \b^ dZag_gguo
ijhba\h^be gZ ijhoh`bo mkljZrbl_evgh_ \i_qZle_gb_ Bgh]^Z dZag_ggu_ ih^he]m
hklZ\ZebkvgZdhemgZ\bk_ebpZobebgZdhe_k_ijbq_l\_jlh\Zgbbhljm[e_ggu_qe_gu
\uklZ\eyebkv\ jZaguodhgpZo]hjh^Zbebijb[b\Zebkvd ^_j_\vyfih^hjh]ZfZ ]heh\Z
dZag_ggh]h\h^jm`ZeZkv\ im[ebqghff_kl_\hldgmlhcgZdhe
< MdZa_hl yg\Zjy ][ueh kdZaZgh ³Im]Zq_\m mqbgblv kf_jlgmx dZagv
q_l\_jlh\Zlv]heh\m\ahldgmlvgZdheqZklbl_eZjZag_klbihq_luj_fqZklyf]hjh^Zb
iheh`blv gZ dhe_kZ Z ihke_ gZ l_o `_ f_klZo k`_qv Qbd_ hg `_ b AZjm[bg hlk_qv
]heh\mb \ahldgmlv__ gZdhe^ey\k_gZjh^gh]haj_ebsZZ ljmi_]hk`_qvk wrZnhlhf
dmigh´
< k\hbo \hkihfbgZgbyo hq_\b^_p dZagb :g^j_c ;hehlh\ mlhqgy_l ³GZ^e_`Zeh
ihlhf \k_ qZklb ljmiZ k_]h ba\_j]Z Im]Zq_\Z ² K J jZa\hablv ih jZaguf qZklyf
]hjh^Zb lZfkh`b]ZlvbogZf_klZogZagZq_gguoZ ihlhfijZojZkk_b\Zlvih\ha^mom
K ih^h[guf `_klhdbf hlghr_gb_f d l_eZf dZag_gguo iulZeky [hjhlvky
khjZlgbd I_ljZ , k\_le_crbc dgyav : > F_gvrbdh\ M`_ ihke_ kf_jlb I_ljZ klZ\
\k_fh]msbf \eZ^udhx hl bf_gb <_joh\gh]h lZcgh]h kh\_lZ bxey ]h^Z hg
ijbdZaZejZah[jZlvklhe[uihklZ\e_ggu_\ jZaguof_klZo\ I_l_j[mj]_k \ahldgmlufb
]heh\ZfbdZag_gguoZ kZfb]heh\ukgy\rbihohjhgblvH^gZdhm`_\h\j_f_gZ:ggu
BhZggh\gu \Zj\Zjkdbc h[uqZc \hah[gh\ey_lky kgh\Z b dZd fu lhevdh qlh \b^_eb ba
\hkihfbgZgbc:g^j_y;hehlh\Zkms_kl\m_l\iehlv^hdhgpZ;9,,,\_dZ
< ;,; \_d_ l_eZ dZag_gguo m`_ g_ \uklZ\eyebkv gZ mebpZo Jhkkbb ^Z b kZfZ
kf_jlgZy dZagv ijhba\h^beZkv djZcg_ j_^dh Gh klj_fe_gb_ gZdZaZlv g_ lhevdh
q_eh\_dZghb _]hhklZgdbfh`ghijhke_^blvb \wlhijhk\_s_ggh_\j_fyLZd^hkbo
ihjg_kfhljygZg_dhlhju_k_gkZpbhggu_im[ebdZpbbg_gZc^_ghf_klhaZohjhg_gby
dZag_gguo ^_dZ[jbklh\ Ih g_dhlhjuf k\b^_l_evkl\Zf bklhjbdh\ bo g_ lhevdh
aZohjhgbeb lZcgh \^Zeb hl ojbklbZgkdbo deZ^[bs gh b aZebeb l_eZ ba\_klvx qlh[u
iheghklvxmgbqlh`blvljmiu
< ?\jhi_gZqbgZyk wihob<hajh`^_gbyb iha`_l_eZdZag_gguoij_klmigbdh\
hl^Z\Zebkv \ ZgZlhfbq_kdb_ l_Zlju ^ey ijhba\h^kl\Z im[ebqguo \kdjulbc <k_f
ohjhrhba\_klgZdZjlbgZJ_f[jZg^lZ³MjhdZgZlhfbb^hdlhjZLmeviZ´gZibkZggZybf\
]h^m \ =ZZ]_ DZjlbgZ bah[jZ`Z_l im[ebqgh_ \kdjulb_ \ aZe_ kh[jZgbc
Objmj]bq_kdhc ]bev^bb \ :fkl_j^Zf_ \ yg\Zj_ ]h^Z dZag_ggh]h ij_klmigbdZ ²
\hjZ:jbkZDbg^lZba\_klgh]h\ m]heh\guoZggZeZoih^debqdhc³FeZ^_g_p´
Bgl_j_kmxsb_ky bklhjb_c Jhkkbb ;9,, \_dZ gZ\_jgydZ agZxl khqbg_gb_
=jb]hjby DhlhrbobgZ ³H Jhkkbb \ pZjkl\h\Zgb_ :e_dk_y FboZceh\bqZ´ Hgh
g_h^ghdjZlgh i_j_ba^Z\Zehkv =jb]hjbc DZjih\bq Dhlhrbobg ih^tyqbc Ihkhevkdh]h
ijbdZaZ [_`Ze \ R\_pbx ]^_ b gZibkZe k\hb bgl_j_kg_crb_ aZibkdb Ijh`b\Zy \
Klhd]hevf_hg\ k_gly[j_ ]h^Z\ ivyghf\b^_m[bek\h_]h^hfhohaybgZaZqlhb
[ue ijb]h\hj_g d kf_jlghc dZagb Ihke_ dZagb l_eh DhlhrbobgZ [ueh i_j_\_a_gh \
MikZemb ZgZlhfbjh\ZghlZfijhn_kkhjhfHeZnhfJm^[_dhfDhklb_]h[uebgZgbaZgu
gZf_^gu_b klZevgu_ijh\hehdbb ihemqb\rbckylZdbfh[jZahfkd_e_lbkihevah\Zeky
dZd gZ]ey^gh_ ihkh[b_ fgh]bfb ihdhe_gbyfb klm^_glh\ f_^bpbgkdh]h nZdmevl_lZ
^j_\g_cr_]h r\_^kdh]h mgb\_jkbl_lZ \ MikZe_ LZdbf h[jZahf _keb [u dlhgb[m^v
\a^mfZe jZaukdb\Zlv \ R\_pbb fh]bem Z\lhjZ khqbg_gby ³H Jhkkbb \ pZjkl\h\Zgb_
:e_dk_yFboZceh\bqZ´_]hihbkdbg_^Zeb[uj_amevlZlh\Dhlhrbobggbdh]^Zg_[ue
ih]j_[_g
AZdhghf_j_g bgl_j_k qblZl_e_c d xjb^bq_kdbf ghjfZf kh\j_f_ggh]h
hl_q_kl\_ggh]h aZdhgh^Zl_evkl\Z ih \hijhkm h km^v[_ l_e dZag_gguo ij_klmigbdh\
>he]h_ \j_fy kZfZ l_fZ wlZ y\eyeZkv lZcghc aZ k_fvx i_qZlyfb Gh \hl [ue
him[ebdh\Zg hl\_l khljm^gbdZ ij_kkkem`[u [u\r_]h F<> KKKJ B <Zkbev_\Z gZ
fgh]hqbke_ggu_ibkvfZqblZl_e_cihk\ys_ggu_wlhcl_f_
³>_ckl\mxsbf aZdhgh^Zl_evkl\hf wlhl \hijhk g_ j_]eZf_glbjh\Zg
<_^hfkl\_ggufb bgkljmdpbyfb ij_^mkfhlj_gh qlh \ kemqZ_ kf_jlb hkm`^_ggh]h beb
ih^ke_^kl\_ggh]h Z^fbgbkljZpby bkijZ\bl_evghljm^h\h]h mqj_`^_gby beb
ke_^kl\_ggh]hbaheylhjZg_f_^e_gghba\_sZ_lh[wlhfjh^kl\_ggbdh\K\b^_l_evkl\hh
kf_jlbgZijZ\ey_lky\ hl^_eaZ]kihf_klmihklhyggh]hijh`b\Zgby?kebjh^kl\_ggbdb
mf_jr_]h \ lj_o^g_\guc kjhd khh[sZxl Z^fbgbkljZpbb mqj_`^_gby h `_eZgbb
hkms_kl\blvaZohjhg_gb_kZfhklhyl_evghlhbf\u^Z_lkyl_ehmf_jr_]hb \k_jZkoh^u
ihaZohjhg_gbxhgbg_kmlkZfbHkgh\Zgb_f^eyhldZaZ\ \u^Zq_l_eZmf_jr_]hfh`_l
kem`blv ebrv mklZgh\e_ggZy f_^bdZfb bgn_dpbhggZy [he_agv Wlh h[s_ijbgylZy
ijZdlbdZ Ijb hlkmlkl\bb jh^kl\_ggbdh\ beb ijb bo hldZa_ ohjhgblv mf_jr_]h ²
dj_fZpby aZohjhg_gb_ ijhba\h^blky gZ [ebae_`Zs_f deZ^[bs_ aZ kq_l mqj_`^_gby
Ijbkmlkl\b_jh^kl\_ggbdh\ijbwlhfg_aZij_sZ_lky
WlbijZ\beZg_jZkijhkljZgyxlkygZebpd dhlhjufijbf_g_gZbkdexqbl_evgZy
f_jZ gZdZaZgby ² jZkklj_e Bo l_eZ jh^kl\_ggbdZf g_ \u^Zxlky h f_kl_ bo
aZohjhg_gbyg_khh[sZ_lky´
Ba hl\_lZ lZd b g_ ykgh dm^Z `_ ^_\Zxl l_eZ dZag_gguo ² hl^Zxl \
ZgZlhfbq_kdb_ l_Zlju f_^bpbgkdbo bgklblmlh\ dj_fbjmxl aZohjZgb\Zxl gZ h[sbo
deZ^[bsZobeb\ ki_pbZevghhl\_^_gguof_klZo"
Kdhj__ \k_]h ² ihke_^g__ LZd \ ijb]hjh^Zo E_gbg]jZ^Z gZ E_\Zrh\kdhc
imklhrb ^he]b_ ]h^u klhye h[g_k_gguc a_e_guf aZ[hjhf [hevrhc mqZklhd e_kZ B
ijhoh^b\rb_fbfh]jb[gbdb^Z`_g_^h]Z^u\ZebkvqlhaZaZ[hjhfgZoh^ylkygbq_fg_
hlf_q_ggu_ aZl_jy\rb_ky kj_^b \ujhkrbo a^_kv khk_g aZohjhg_gby lukyq b lukyq
e_gbg]jZ^p_\ dZag_gguo \ _ ]h^u Ebrv \ ]h^m lZcgZ E_\Zrh\kdhc imklhrb
klZeZ^hklhygb_f]eZkghklb<hlm`_fgh]hf_kyp_\\ ]Za_l_³<_q_jgbcE_gbg]jZ^´ba
ghf_jZ \ ghf_j i_qZlZ_lky kdhj[guc fZjlbjheh] ² kibkhd \k_o ih]j_[_gguo gZ
E_\Zrh\kdhcimklhrbKdhevdh`_bolZfihohjhg_ghaZa_e_g_gvdbf^ZqgufaZ[hjhf
E_\Zrh\kdhcimklhrb"
Dh]^Z \klZe \hijhk h kha^Zgbb f_fhjbZeZ gZ f_kl_ aZohjhg_gby
j_ij_kkbjh\Zguo\ E_\Zrh\kdhcimklhrb\kieueZg_h`b^ZggZyljm^ghklvHdZaZehkv
qlh \f_kl_ k g_\bggh ihkljZ^Z\rbfb a^_kv aZohjhg_gu b gZklhysb_ m]heh\gu_
ij_klmigbdb ² [Zg^blu m[bcpu gZkbevgbdb B jZah[jZlvky k_cqZk ]^_ dlh e_`bl
kj_^b g_fZjdbjh\Zgguo ^Z`_ g_ hlf_q_gguo ohefbdZfb aZohjhg_gbc ijhklh
g_fukebfhLZdqlh`_\k_obo^he`_gh[t_^bgblvh^bgh[sbcf_fhjbZe"
Bgh]^Zij_klmigbdZfq_feb[hijh\bgb\rbfkyi_j_^]hkm^Zjkl\hfb p_jdh\vx
hldZau\Zeb\ ih]j_[_gbbb wlh[uehh^gbfbakZfuokljZrguogZdZaZgbc
^_dZ[jy ]h^Z dj_s_guc lZlZjbg I_lj Mjmkh\ m[be \h \j_fy hohlu
E`_^fbljby ,, agZf_gblh]h ³lmrbgkdh]h \hjZ´ ijbgy\r_]h wklZn_lm kZfha\Zgkl\Z hl
E`_^fbljby , G_kdhevdh g_^_ev ljmi E`_^fbljby ,, e_`Ze \ dZem`kdhc p_jd\b k
]heh\hc hl^_e_gghc hl lmeh\bsZ b lhevdh \u[hju gZ pZjkl\h ³\hjzgdZ´ _]h kugZ hl
FZjbguFgbr_db baf_g_gb_\ k\yabk wlbfiheblbq_kdhckblmZpbbiha\hebebij_^Zlv
l_eha_fe_
?s_ [he__ ^jZfZlbqgu ihkf_jlgu_ kdblZgby agZf_gblh]h kdjbiZqZ Gbddheh
IZ]Zgbgb ;_a[h`gbd ijb `bagb hg hldZaZeky ihdZylvky i_j_^ kf_jlvx b p_jdh\gu_
\eZklb aZij_lbeb ij_^Z\Zlv _]h l_eh a_fe_ IZ]Zgbgb mf_j \ ]h^m gh \iehlv ^h
]h^Z _]h gZ[ZevaZfbjh\Zggh_ l_eh \ugm`^_gh [ueh kljZgkl\h\Zlv ih NjZgpbb b
BlZebbb _fm\_a^_hldZau\Zeb\ ihke_^g_fijbxl_IhijbdZamdZlhebq_kdhcp_jd\b
l_ehIZ]Zgbgbq_luj_]h^ZgZoh^behkv^Z`_\ ]hkiblZe_^eyijhdZ`_gguo
Hkh[uf \gbfZgb_f ih[_^bl_e_c ihevah\Zebkv q_j_iZ ih\_j`_gguo \jZ]h\
Ba\_klgucdblZckdbcibkZl_ev`b\rbcgZjm[_`_^bgZklbcFbgb PbgEbXc²
\ k\h_c gh\_ee_ ³;Zrgy Kh[jZgby baukdZgghkl_c´ jZkkdZau\Z_l h^gm ba lZdbo
bklhjbc
=_jhy gh\_eeu fheh^h]h lhj]h\pZ ^j_\gbfb dgb]Zfb PxZgv @mkx dh\Zjgh
hkdhibe aehc kZgh\gbd Ygv RmnZgv bklhjbq_kdZy ebqghklv \b^guc pZj_^\hj_p
dblZckdh]h bfi_jZlhjZ ^bgZklbb Fbg RbpmamgZ ² kgbkdZ\rbc ^mjgmx
keZ\m k\hbfb bgljb]Zfb ebohbfkl\hf b jZkimlghc `bagvx Dh]^Z ijhbkdb aeh^_y
m^ZehkvjZah[eZqblvb hg[uedZag_g³PxZgxm^ZehkvjZa^h[ulv_]hq_j_ib hgk^_eZe
ba g_]h khkm^ ^ey fhqb < fbgmlu ^h\hevkl\Z xghrZ qZklh ie_\Ze gZ q_j_i b
fgh]hdjZlghihevah\ZekybfihgZagZq_gbx´
Oj_klhfZlbcgufklZejZkkdZae_lhibkpZG_klhjZba³Ih\_klb\j_f_gguoe_l´h
lhf dZd iheh\pu ih^dZjZmeb\ gZ ^g_ijh\kdbo ihjh]Zo dgyay K\ylhkeZ\Z
\ha\jZsZxs_]hky\ Db_\k g_[hevrhc^jm`bghcm[beb_]hZ baq_j_iZk^_eZebqZrm
H[uqZcwlhl\b^bfh[uerbjhdhjZkijhkljZg_g³KZ]Zh <hekmg]Zo´mihfbgZ_l
³q_j_iZ bo ij_\jZs_ggu_\ qZrbb kZfluibebodjh\vk \bghfkf_rZggmx´
FhgZo =bevhf ^_ Jm[jmd \ha]eZ\ey\rbc dZlhebq_kdmx fbkkbx d fhg]hevkdbf
oZgZf\ ²]h^ZohklZ\begZflZdh_k\b^_l_evkl\hh[h[uqZyo`bl_e_cLb[_lZ
³Lb[_lpu\k__s_^_eZxldjZkb\u_qZrbba]heh\jh^bl_e_cqlh[uijbiblv_bawlbo
qZr \kihfbgZlv h jh^bl_eyo \h \j_fy k\h_]h gZkeZ`^_gby Wlh jZkkdZaZe fg_
hq_\b^_p´
H[uqZc ^_eZlv qZrb ba q_eh\_q_kdbo q_j_ih\ kms_kl\h\Ze b m fhg]heh\
Ba\_klgh qlh Qbg]bkoZg \_e_e h[^_eZlv \ ahehlh q_j_i Hg]oZgZ k\h_]h [u\r_]h
ihdjh\bl_eyZ aZl_fihdhj_ggh]h\jZ]Zb ihevah\ZekywlhcqZr_c\h\j_fyibjh\
Ih ij_^Zgbx h^bg ba kZfuo `_klhdbo ^_kihlh\ bklhjbb LZf_jeZg Lbfmj
ihke_\aylby;Z]^Z^Zkeh`bebaq_j_ih\ibjZfb^Fgh`_kl\hih^h[guoibjZfb^b
[Zr_g hg ihkljhbe \ Bg^bb ihke_ iZ^_gby >_eb Ih^ ljhghf LZf_jeZgZ gZoh^beZkv
³fZeZy ibjZfb^Z´ keh`_ggZy ba q_j_ih\ ih\_j`_gguo \eZ^ud H^gZ ba kZfuo
mkljZrZxsbo ibjZfb^ ihkljh_ggZy LZf_jeZghf ih
ke_ iZ^_gby BknZoZgZ \ I_jkbb
gZkqblu\ZeZq_j_ih\
Bgh]^Z \ dZq_kl\_ ljhn_y ojZgbeb g_ lhevdh q_j_i gh b p_emx aZkmr_ggmx
]heh\mm[blh]h\jZ]Zqlhrbjhdhba\_klghbah[uqZ_\jy^Zbg^_ckdboie_f_gX`ghc
:f_jbdb
Ghg_lhevdhm bg^_cp_\kms_kl\h\Zewlhl\Zj\Zjkdbch[uqZcI_lj,ijb]h\hjbe
d dZagbk\hx\haex[e_ggmxFZjbx=ZfbevlhgaZ__ ex[h\vd ^_gsbdmB\ZgmHjeh\m
HibjZykv gZ jmdm pZjy \ahreZ hgZ gZ wrZnhl b ijbk_eZ \ j_\_jZgk_ I_lj ju\dhf
ijb\e_d __ d k_[_ gh m\b^_\ \ ]eZaZo exlmx g_gZ\bklv ^jh]gme khagZ\Zy k\h_
[_kkbeb_ Hl\_j]gm\ pZjkdmx ex[h\v b ihsZ^m fheh^Zy rhleZg^dZ kf_eh ih^hreZ d
ihfhklm b kdehgbeZ ]heh\m d ieZo_ : ihlhf gZ \b^m m \k_c kh[jZ\r_cky lheiu k
hdjh\Z\e_ggh]h wrZnhlZ I_lj ih^gye hljm[e_ggmx ]heh\m lhc dhlhjmx [_amfgh
ex[beIhp_eh\Z\__ \]m[uhgih\_e_egZ\_dbkhojZgblv]heh\m\ DmgkldZf_j_
^_dZ[jy]h^Z\ ihf_s_gbbBgklblmlZwdki_jbf_glZevghcf_^bpbgu[ue
m[bli_l_j[mj]kdbc]jZ^hgZqZevgbd]_g_jZefZchjnhg^zjEZmgbpijbkmlkl\h\Z\rbc
gZlhj`_kl\_gghfhldjulbbdebgbdb dh`guo[he_ag_cM[bcpZhlklj_eb\Zekygh[ue
aZjm[e_g gZ f_kl_ hnbp_jZfb k\blu ]jZ^hgZqZevgbdZ Ebqghklv _]h \uykgblv g_
m^Zehkv
Km^_[ghfmke_^h\Zl_exihhkh[h\Z`guf^_eZfG<AZcp_\mjZkke_^h\Z\r_fm
wlh ^_eh ijbreZ \ ]heh\m fukev hl^_eblv ]heh\m ij_klmigbdZ hl lmeh\bsZ
aZdhgk_j\bjh\Zlv __ ih f_lh^bdZf ij_^eh`_gguf g_aZ^he]h ^h wlh]h ZgZlhfZfb b
\uklZ\blv ^ey \k_h[s_]h h[haj_gby k p_evx hihagZgby ebqghklb ij_klmigbdZ L_eh
m[bcpu[uehihohjhg_ghZ [ZevaZfbjh\ZggZy]heh\Z_]h^he]h_s_ijb\e_dZeZlheiu
a_\Zd \uklZ\e_ggZy \ \_klb[xe_ BgklblmlZ wdki_jbf_glZevghc f_^bpbgu H^gZdh
hihagZlv m[bcpm lZd b g_ m^Zehkv Ebrv agZqbl_evgh iha`_ \ k\hbo ³<hkihfbgZgbyo
l_jjhjbklZ´ ;hjbk KZ\_gdh\ mdZaZe qlh m[bcp_c [ue qe_g l_jjhjbklbq_kdhc ]jmiiu
iZjlbbkhpbZebklh\j_\hexpbhg_jh\wk_jh\ihdebqd_³:^fbjZe´b ih^jh[ghhibkZe
dZd]hlh\behkvihdmr_gb_
< ;,; \_d_ kdeZ^u\Z_lky g_kdhevdh e_]dhfuke_ggh_ hlghr_gb_ d hklZgdZf
ijboh^blfh^ZgZdhee_dpbhgbjh\Zgb_q_j_ih\<kihfgbfohly[uimrdbgkdh_
Ijbfb` k_cq_j_i>_ev\b]hgIjbgZ^e_`bll_[_ihijZ\mH[^_eZclu_]h
[Zjhg< [eZ]hijbklhcgmxhijZ\mBa^_ev_]jh[Zij_\jZlb< m\_k_ebl_evgmxqZrm
<bghfdbiysbfhk\ylb>ZaZib\Zcmom^ZdZrm
Ijbf_jgh\ wlh`_\j_fy;ZcjhghfgZibkZghklbohl\hj_gb_³GZ^ibkvgZdm[d_
ba q_j_iZ´ KlZjZykv \hkdj_kblv ^j_\gbc jhfZglbq_kdbc h[uqZc ihwlu \hki_\Zxl
\_jh\ZgbykdZg^bgZ\h\kh]eZkghdhlhjuf^mrbm[bluo ojZ[juo\hbgh\ivxl\bghba
q_j_ih\ih\_j`_gguo\jZ]h\\ g_[_kghf^\hjp_[h]ZH^bgZ²<Ze]Zee_
<k_ wlh fh`gh [ueh [u hlg_klb d h[uqguf ihwlbq_kdbf f_lZnhjZf b
]bi_j[heZf _keb [u h^gh\j_f_ggh kh klboZfb : K Imrdbg g_ \jmqbe >_ev\b]m b
q_j_iydh[uijbgZ^e_`Z\rbcij_^dmihke_^g_]hb ihobs_gguc\ h^ghfbap_jdh\guo
kde_ih\ Jb]b Imrdbgm wlhl q_j_i ^hklZeky hl _]h ijbyl_ey : G <mevnZ dhlhjuc
^_j`Ze\ g_flZ[Zdlh`_oZjZdl_jgZy^_lZevwihob
Fgh]h lhedh\ \ua\ZeZ fhe\Z h ³q_j_i_ FhpZjlZ´ Fh]bevsbd k deZ^[bsZ
K\ylh]hFZjdZ\ <_g_ih^Zjbe_]hk\h_fmagZdhfhfmYdh[mOxjlex\ ]h^m
>hklh\_jghba\_klghqlh<hevn]Zg]:fZ^_cFhpZjlmf_j^_dZ[jy]h^Z\
<_g_\ \hajZkl_e_lKqblZ_lkyqlhZ\lhjk\ur_lbhi_jb hdhehlbkbfnhgbc
Z lZd`_ dhgp_jlh\ khgZl f_kk [ue ihohjhg_g ^g_f iha`_ gZ deZ^[bs_ ^ey [_^gydh\
R_ekg_]k ^h`^_fGb`_gZgb ^jmavyg_[uebgZihohjhgZo?]hfh]beZydh[ulZdb
hklZeZkvg_ba\_klghc
Ydh[ ihdZaZe gZoh^dm [jZlm ijhn_kkhjm ZgZlhfbb dhlhjuc hl^_ebe ^ey
bkke_^h\Zgby qZklv dhkl_c q_j_iZ b gb`gxx q_exklv iha`_ mljZq_ggu_ ;jZlvy
gZklhevdh [ueb m[_`^_gu \ ih^ebgghklb k\h_]h ijbh[j_l_gby qlh ^Zevg_crbo
bkke_^h\Zgbcg_ij_^ijbgbfZebGhdh]^Z\ ]h^mq_j_iihiZegZjh^bgmFhpZjlZ
\ AZevp[mj]Z\kljbckdb_wdki_jlu\ ih^ebgghklb_fmhldZaZebm[jZ\\ kZfu_^Zevgb_
ojZgbebsZ
B \hl m`_ \ gZrb ^gb iZe_hglheh] ba AZevp[mj]kdh]h mgb\_jkbl_lZ =hlnjb^
Lbob kfZogme k g_]h fma_cgmx iuev Hg ijbklmiZe d jZ[hl_ k bajy^guf kd_ikbkhf
h^gZdh k ykguf khagZgb_f qlh kh\j_f_ggu_ f_lh^u dhlhju_ bkihevamxl
djbfbgZebklu\ bkke_^h\Zgbb³q_j_iZFhpZjlZ´g_ijbf_gyebkvG_dhlhju_bak\hbo
\u\h^h\mq_gucbaeh`be\ [jblZgkdhf`mjgZe_³Wdhghfbkl´BlZd
NhjfZ q_j_iZ ² hdjm]eZy qlh dZd b _]h g_[hevrZy \_ebqbgZ oZjZdl_jgh ^ey
`bl_e_c X`ghc =_jfZgbb IjbgZ^e_`Ze hg fbgbZlxjghfm nbabq_kdb keZ[hfm
fm`qbg_\ \hajZkl_hl^he_lKhklhygb_am[h\iha\hey_lmlhqgblv]h^u²hl
^hH[t_fq_j_ighcdhjh[db²dm[bq_kdbokZglbf_ljh\lh_klvkjZ\gbl_evgh
[hevrhc Hdjm]eh_ ebph \uimdehklb e[Z m^ebg_gguc ghk b \u^ZxsZyky \_jogyy
q_exklv \ hkgh\ghf ijhke_`b\Zxlky gZ \k_o ba\_klguo bah[jZ`_gbyo dhfihablhjZ
Kh\iZ^ZxllZd`_gbadbcjhklb keZ[h_keh`_gb_kZfFhpZjlgZau\Zek_[yfZe_gvdbf
: kh\j_f_ggbdbhlf_qZebqlhijbwlhf]heh\Zm g_]h[ueZdjmighc
<k_wlhhijh\_j]Z_lbkke_^h\ZgbygZqZeZgug_rg_]h\_dZb ih^l\_j`^Z_ll_qlh
hlghkylky d k_j_^bg_ ijhreh]h D lhfm `_ kebrdhf fgh]h kh\iZ^_gbc qlh[u
aZih^hajblv \_gkdh]h fh]bevsbdZ \ ijhklhc fbklbnbdZpbb Gh kZfuc \i_qZleyxsbc
blh]jZ[hluijhn_kkhjZLbobkhklhbl\ ihiuld_hij_^_eblvijbqbgmkf_jlbFhpZjlZ
HiylvlZdbkZfdhfihablhjijbagZ\Zeky\ Zij_e_b fZ_]h^Zk\h_fm[jZlm
ihfZkkhgkdhceh`_Imo[_j]mqlhfmqZ_lky]heh\ghcb am[ghc[hevx?]hkh\j_f_ggbd
blZevyg_p >Z Ihgl_ hlf_qZe \ ibkvf_ hl Z\]mklZ ]h^Z qlh FhpZjl bkiulu\Z_l
]heh\hdjm`_gby : f_`^m l_f Z\kljbckdbc mq_guc h[gZjm`be gZ q_j_i_ lhgdmx
lj_sbgm^ebghckZglbf_ljZdhlhjZylyg_lkyhle_\h]h\bkdZd fZdmrd_Ihemq_ggZy
ijb m^Zj_beb iZ^_gbbd fhf_glmkf_jlblj_sbgZm`_ijZdlbq_kdbaZjhkeZ h^gZdh \
kZfhc gb`g_c qZklb q_j_iZ hklZebkv ke_^u djh\hl_q_gby <ua^hjh\e_gb_ gbdZd g_
fh]ehaZgylvf_gvr_ ]h^Z Z \ lZdhf kemqZ_ ^Zggu_ kdmiuo bklhqgbdh\ ih^l\_j`^Zxl
\_jkbx ijhn_kkhjZ Hg kqblZ_l qlh FhpZjl mf_j hl ihke_^kl\bc q_j_ighfha]h\hc
ljZ\fu]_fZlhfub bgn_dpbbZ g_[uehljZ\e_gKZev_jbdZd]eZkble_]_g^Z
< k\yab k jZkkdZahf h q_j_i_ FhpZjlZ ohq_lky _s_ jZa \kihfgblv e_]_g^m h
q_j_i_=h]heyhdZaZ\r_fky\ ;Zojmrbgkdhfl_ZljZevghffma__\f_kl_k q_j_ihfZdl_jZ
S_idbgZ
E_lhf]h^ZdeZ^[bs_>Zgbeh\ZfhgZklujy]^_\ ]h^m[ueihohjhg_g
G<=h]hev[uehmijZa^g_ghgZl_jjblhjbbfhgZklujy[ueZhj]Zgbah\ZgZlxjvfZ^ey
g_kh\_jr_gghe_lgbo< l_]h^u\f_kl_k jZajmr_ggufdeZ^[bs_ffhgZklujyih]b[eb
fh]beu^_kyldh\ex^_ckhklZ\ey\rbog_dh]^ZkeZ\mJhkkbbIjZo`_=h]heyOhfydh\Z
b Yaudh\Z[uei_j_g_k_ggZdeZ^[bs_Gh\h^_\bqv_]hfhgZklujy
< ]Za_l_³Kh\_lkdZyJhkkby´hlZ\]mklZ]h^Z[ueb\i_j\u_him[ebdh\Zgu
^g_\gbdh\u_ aZibkb qe_gZ <h_gghj_\hexpbhggh]h dhfbl_lZ \ Fhkd\_ ^biehfZlZ
ibkZl_ey:e_dkZg^jZYdh\e_\bqZ:jhk_\Z³>h`_klhdhklbhldjh\_ggu´³ fZy
]h^GZ^gyo[uem <kB\Zgh\ZIZ\e_gdhGLbohgh\ZJZkkdZau\ZebqlhhljuebijZo
=h]heyOhfydh\Zb Yaudh\ZM =h]hey]heh\ug_gZreb´
=heh\u g_ gZreb DZdZylh [me]Zdh\kdZy q_jlh\sbgZ Ihfgbl_ \ _]h jhfZg_
³FZkl_jb FZj]ZjblZ´FZj]ZjblZ\ ljhee_c[mk_kemrZ_ldZdhclhg_ihgylgucjZa]h\hj
^\mo]jZ`^Zg=jZ`^Zg_r_ilZebkvh lhfqlhm dZdh]hlhihdhcgbdZk_]h^gymljhfba
]jh[Z mdjZeb ]heh\m b qlh ijbrehkv aZdjulv ]jh[ q_jguf ihdju\Zehf Iha`_
klZgh\blky ykgh qlh wlh ]heh\Z ij_^k_^Zl_ey ijZ\e_gby F:KKHEBLZ aZj_aZggh]h
ljZf\Z_fgZIZljbZjrboijm^Zo
Fh`_l [ulv \ k\h_f jhfZg_ F : ;me]Zdh\ bkihevah\Ze kemob ghkb\rb_ky
\hdjm]mdjZ^_gghc]heh\uG<=h]hey"
Ijhn_kkhj Ebl_jZlmjgh]h bgklblmlZ ibkZl_ev <eZ^bfbj =_jfZgh\bq Eb^bg
ijbkmlkl\h\Ze gZ \kdjulbb fh]beu G < =h]hey b ^Z`_ hklZ\be \hkihfbgZgby
haZ]eZ\e_ggu_ ³I_j_g_k_gb_ ijZoZ =h]hey´ ³< bxg_ ]h^Z fg_ iha\hgbe ih
l_e_nhgm h^bg ba khljm^gbdh\ Bklhjbq_kdh]h fma_y² AZ\ljZ gZ deZ^[bs_ >hgkdh]h
fhgZklujy [m^_l ijhbkoh^blv \kdjulb_ fh]beu =h]hey ² kdZaZe hg fg_ ²
ijb_a`Zcl_
Y ih_oZe;uel_ieuce_lgbc^_gvIhijb\uqd_y aZo\Zlbek kh[hcnhlhZiiZjZl
Kgbfdb dhlhju_ y k^_eZe gZ deZ^[bs_ hdZaZebkv _^bgkl\_ggufb H^gh\j_f_ggh k
fh]behc =h]hey \kdju\Zeb \ wlhl ^_gv fh]beu Ohfydh\Z b Yaudh\Z ijZo bo lh`_
ih^e_`Ze i_j_g_k_gbx DeZ^[bs_ >Zgbeh\Z fhgZklujy mijZa^gyehkv GZ l_jjblhjbb
fhgZklujy[uehj]Zgbah\Zgijb_fgbd^eyg_kh\_jr_gghe_lgboijZ\hgZjmrbl_e_c
Fh]bem =h]hey \kdju\Zeb ihqlb p_euc ^_gv HgZ hdZaZeZkv gZ agZqbl_evgh
[hevr_c ]em[bg_ q_f h[uqgu_ aZohjhg_gby GZqZ\ __ jZkdZiu\Zlv gZldgmebkv gZ
dbjibqguc kde_i g_h[uqghc ijhqghklb gh aZfmjh\Zggh]h hl\_jklby \ g_f g_
h[gZjm`beb lh]^Z klZeb jZkdZiu\Zlv \ ihi_j_qghf gZijZ\e_gbb k lZdbf jZkq_lhf
qlh[ujZkdhidZijboh^beZkvgZ\hklhdb lhevdhd \_q_jm[ueh[gZjm`_g_s_[hdh\hc
ijb^_ekde_iZq_j_adhlhjuc\ hkgh\ghckde_ib [ue\ k\h_\j_fy\^\bgml]jh[
JZ[hlZ ih \kdjulbx kde_iZ aZlygmeZkv GZqZebkv m`_ kmf_jdb dh]^Z fh]beZ
[ueZ gZdhg_p \kdjulZ <_jogb_ ^hkdb ]jh[Z ijh]gbeb gh [hdh\u_ k khojZgb\r_cky
nhev]hcf_lZeebq_kdbfbm]eZfbb jmqdZfbb qZklbqghmp_e_\rbf]hem[h\Zlhebeh\uf
ihamf_glhf [ueb p_eu <hl qlh ij_^klZ\eye kh[hc ijZo =h]hey q_j_iZ \ ]jh[m g_
hdZaZehkv b hklZgdb =h]hey gZqbgZebkv k r_cguo iha\hgdh\ \_kv hklh\ kd_e_lZ [ue
aZdexq_g\ ohjhrhkhojZgb\rbckykxjlmdlZ[Zqgh]hp\_lZih^kxjlmdhfmp_e_eh^Z`_
[_ev_ k dhklygufb im]h\bpZfb gZ gh]Zo [ueb [ZrfZdb lh`_ iheghklvx
khojZgb\rb_ky lhevdh ^jZl\Z kh_^bgyxsZy ih^hr\m k \_johf ijh]gbeZ gZ ghkdZo b
dh`Zg_kdhevdhaZ\_jgmeZkvd\_jomh[gZ`Zydhklbklhiu
;ZrfZdb[uebgZhq_gv\ukhdbodZ[emdZoijb[ebabl_evghkZglbf_ljh\wlh
^Z_l[_amkeh\gh_hkgh\Zgb_ij_^iheZ]Zlvqlh=h]hev[ueg_\ukhdh]hjhklZ
Dh]^Z b ijb dZdbo h[klhyl_evkl\Zo bkq_a q_j_i =h]hey hklZ_lky aZ]Z^dhc Ijb
gZqZe_\kdjulbyfh]beugZfZehc]em[bg_agZqbl_evgh\ur_kde_iZk aZfmjh\Zgguf
]jh[hf [ue h[gZjm`_g q_j_i gh Zjo_heh]b ijbagZeb _]h ijbgZ^e_`Zsbf fheh^hfm
q_eh\_dm
IjZoYaudh\Zb Ohfydh\Zfg_m^Zehkvknhlh]jZnbjh\ZlvHklZgdh\=h]heyyd
kh`Ze_gbx kgylv g_ fh] lZd dZd [ueb m`_ kmf_jdb Z gZ ke_^mxs__ mljh hgb [ueb
i_j_\_a_gugZdeZ^[bs_Gh\h^_\bqv_]hfhgZklujy]^_b ij_^Zgua_fe_
Y iha\hebe k_[_ \aylv dmkhd kxjlmdZ =h]hey dhlhjuc \ihke_^kl\bb bkdmkguc
i_j_ie_lqbd \^_eZe \ nmleyj ^ey i_j\h]h ba^Zgby ³F_jl\uo ^mr´ Dgb]Z \ nmleyj_ k
wlhcj_ebd\b_cgZoh^blky\ fh_c[b[ebhl_d_
Gh dm^Z `_ \k_lZdb ih^_\ZeZkv ]heh\Z =h]hey" Q_f fh`gh h[tykgblv klhev
^jZfZlbq_kdmxkblmZpbx"Kms_kl\mxl^h]Z^db\_jkbbH[h^ghcbagbojZkkdZau\Zeb
<eZ^bfbj=_jfZgh\bqEb^bg³< ]h^mdh]^ZijbmklZgh\d_iZfylgbdZ=h]hexgZ
Ij_qbkl_gkdhf [mev\Zj_ \ Fhkd\_ ijhba\h^beZkv j_klZ\jZpby fh]beu =h]hey
;Zojmrbg ih^]h\hjbe [m^lh [u fhgZoh\ >Zgbeh\Z fhgZklujy ^h[ulv ^ey g_]h q_j_i
=h]heyb qlh^_ckl\bl_evgh\ ;Zojmrbgkdhfl_ZljZevghffma__\ Fhkd\_bf_xlkyljb
g_ba\_klgh dhfm ijbgZ^e_`Zsb_ q_j_iZ h^bg ba gbo ih ij_^iheh`_gbx ² q_j_i
ZjlbklZS_idbgZ^jm]hc²=h]heyh lj_lv_f²gbq_]hg_ba\_klgh´
³?klveb\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb\ fma__lZdb_q_j_iZ²g_agZx²mlhqgy_l^Ze__<
= Eb^bg² gh e_]_g^m wlm khijh\h`^Z\rmx bkq_agh\_gb_ q_j_iZ =h]hey y keurZe
ebqgh²d kh`Ze_gbxg_ihfgxhldh]h´;ulvfh`_l\ [m^ms_fm^Zklkyijbhldjulv
aZ\_kmb gZ^wlhclZcghc
Djhf_ < = Eb^bgZ gZ i_j_aZohjhg_gbb ijZoZ G < =h]hey ijbkmlkl\h\Zeb b
^jm]b_ibkZl_ebb \k_hgblZd`_ijbo\Zlbebk kh[hcg_[hevrb_³km\_gbju´
<k_\heh^ B\Zgh\ ² j_[jh kha^Zl_ey ³F_jl\uo ^mr´ :e_dkZg^j FZeurdbg ²
nhev]m ba ]jh[Z Z \ha]eZ\ey\rbc jZ[hlm ih i_j_aZohjhg_gbx ^bj_dlhj deZ^[bsZ
fheh^hcdhfkhfhe_pihnZfbebb:jZdq__\ijbk\hbek_[_kZih]b\_ebdh]hibkZl_ey
Bgl_j_kgh hlf_lblv qlh bklhjbd > G ;ZglurDZf_gkdbc \kdju\rbc \ wihom
GbdheZy,fh]bemdgyay:>F_gvrbdh\Z\ ;_j_ah\_b \ay\rbck_[_gZiZfylvrZihqdm
kih^\b`gbdZ I_ljZ _^\Z g_ aZ]m[be k\hx dZjv_jm h[\bg_gguc qmlv eb g_ \
h[\hjh\u\Zgbbf_jl\uob \dhsmgkl\_
Gh fh`_l [ulv g_ klhbl kebrdhf kljh]h km^blv kh\_lkdbo ibkZl_e_c aZ
bkdexq_gb_f y\gh]h fZjh^_jZ :jZdq__\Z Dmevl hklZgdh\ gZklhevdh ijhqgh \hr_e \
jmkkdmxbklhjbxb dmevlmjmqlhaZe_lkh\_lkdhc\eZklbdZj^bgZevguobaf_g_gbc\
ikbobd_^Z`_m i_j_^h\h]hhljy^Zkh\_lkdhcbgl_eeb]_gpbbfh]ehb g_ijhbahclb
< ]eZ\_ ³G_le_ggu_ fhsb´ fu m`_ dZkZebkv \hijhkZ h dmevl_ k\yluo fhs_c
H^gZdhjZkijhkljZg_gb_dmevlZhklZgdh\]hjZa^hrbj_LZdgZKfhe_gkdhfdeZ^[bs_
I_l_j[mj]Z hkh[uf ihqblZgb_f ihevam_lky fh]beZ [eZ`_gghc Dk_gbb hnbpbZevgh
dZghgbabjh\Zgghc ebrv \ ]h^m < kdhjhf \j_f_gb ihke_ __ ihohjhg \ dhgp_
;9,,,\_dZihk_lbl_ebjZah[jZeb\kxfh]bevgmxgZkuivdh]^Z`_gZfh]bemiheh`beb
ieblmlh__ jZaehfZebb ihdmkhqdZfjZag_kebih^hfZfK^_eZgZ[ueZ^jm]ZyieblZgh
b lZg_^he]hhklZ\ZeZkvp_ehx
Hkh[uf ihqblZgb_f ihevah\Zebkv klZju_ ]jh[h\u_ ^hkdb LZd \ Ljhbp_
K_j]b_\hcimklugbgZhdjZbg_I_l_j[mj]Z\ d_ev_ZjobfZg^jblZ<ZjeZZfZ^moh\gh]h
hlpZ bfi_jZljbpu :ggu BhZgh\gu ojZgbeky h[jZa k\ylh]h K_j]by JZ^hg_`kdh]h
ibkZgucgZ^hkd_hl]jh[Zqm^hl\hjpZ\aylhclhlqZkihhldjulbb_]hfhs_c
< Mki_gkdhf kh[hj_ Fhkdh\kdh]h Dj_fey hdheh x`guo ^\_j_c \bk_eZ
aZf_qZl_evgZybdhgZK\ylh]h>bfbljbyKhemgkdh]hibkZggZygZ]jh[h\hc^hkd_dgyay
>bfbljby>hgkdh]hqvbfihdjh\bl_e_fy\eyeky^Zgguck\ylhc
: \hl_s_h^bg\_kvfZoZjZdl_jguc^eyh[km`^Z_fhcl_funZdl
Ih ij_^Zgbx B\Zg :g^j__\bq ;blh\ jmkkdbc KljZ^b\Zjbmk k^_eZe ih ^jm`[_
=Zg^hrdbgmagZf_gblhfmkdjbiZqmb [ZeZeZ_qgbdmdgyayIhl_fdbgZlZdmx[ZeZeZcdm
ba klZjhc \ujulhc ba fh]beu ]jh[h\hc ^hkdb qlh aZ g__ ]jZn : = Hjeh\ ij_^eZ]Ze
_fmjm[e_c
Ij_^f_lZfb dmevlZ lZd`_ fh]ml kem`blv g_dhlhju_ ih]j_[Zevgu_
ijbgZ^e_`ghklb \ qZklghklb kZ\Zg beb ihdju\Zeh f_jl\_pZ AZf_qZl_evguc
kh[bjZl_ev jmkkdh]h nhevdehjZ I B Ydmrdbg ² hklZ\be bgl_j_kgh_
k\b^_l_evkl\hgZ^Zggmxl_fm³^he`ghaZf_lblvqlh^_j_\_gkdb_dhe^mguihaeh[_
beb ih ^jm]bf dZdbf ijbqbgZf ^_eZxl m fheh^h]h bfihl_gpbx Y keurZe qlh
g_^Ze_dh hl KZ[mjh\Z \ FZehZjoZg]_evkdhf m_a^_ `b\_l dhe^mg dhlhjuc fh`_l
k^_eZlvdZdmxm]h^ghg_\klZgbomgZh^gm`_gsbgmgZ\k_ogZ]h^gZ\_dHg[_j_l
gbldm ba ihdju\ZeZ f_jl\_pZ \eZ]Z_l __ \ b]em dhlhjmx b \^_\Z_l \ ih^he jm[Zrdb
ba\_klghc `_gsbgu ihdZ wlZ b]eZ g_ \ugmlZ lh fm`qbg_ gbq_]h g_evay k g_x
k^_eZlv´
<hl lZd ihkl_i_ggh hl gZ^jm]Zl_evkl\Z gZ^ l_eZfb f_jl\uo fu i_j_reb d
nZdlZfboh[h`_kl\e_gbyb dmevlZGbq_]hkljZggh]hlmlg_lh[_wlbdjZcghklb²^\_
klhjhgu h^ghc f_^Zeb oZjZdl_jbamxsb_ ih\ur_gguc bgh]^Z ^Z`_ [he_ag_gguc
bgl_j_k d f_jl\hfm l_em GZjy^m k \Zj\Zjkdbf gZ^jm]Zl_evkl\hf gZ^ ihdhcgbdZfb
ijba\Zggufb hlhfklblv aZ kh\_jr_ggh_ ijb `bagb aeh \ bklhjbb \klj_qZ_lky g_fZeh
ijbf_jh\b [eZ]h]h\_cgh]hhlghr_gbyd f_jl\uf
LZdagZf_gbluciZjb`kdbciZeZqKZgkhg[uehlkljZg_ghl^he`ghklbaZlhqlh
hljm[b\ ]heh\m RZjehll_ Dhj^_ m[b\r_c FZjZlZ hg ^hklZe wlm ]heh\m ba dhjabgu b
gZg_k _c ihs_qbgm q_]h g_ bf_e ijZ\Z ^_eZlv ³GZdZau\Zlv g_ mgb`Zy´ ² lZdh\ [ue
aZdhglhcwihob
< dhgp_ ]h^Z dh]^Z kdhgqZeky keZ\guc jmkkdbc n_ev^fZjrZe I_lj
K_f_gh\bq KZeludh\ fhkdh\kdh_ gZqZevkl\h agZy qlh ihdhcguc [ue \ hiZe_ m
pZj_^\hjp_\g_^ZehgbdZdbojZkihjy`_gbc^ey_]hihohjhg
Wlh dhsmgkl\h ihljykeh I_ljZ B\Zgh\bqZ IZgbgZ ba\_klgh]h jmkkdh]h
ihedh\h^pZ]eZ\mijZ\bl_evkl\_gguo\hckdijbmkfbj_gbb\hkklZgbyIm]Zq_\Z@_eZy
hl^Zlvihke_^gxxihq_klvaZkem`_gghfmb Z\lhjbl_lghfmihedh\h^pmhgohlyb [ue\
hlklZ\d_ gZ^_e k\hc ]_g_jZevkdbc fmg^bj \ :g^j__\kdhc b =_hj]b_\kdhc e_glZo b
g_f_^e_gghhlijZ\beky\ ^hfKZeludh\ZIh^hc^yd ]jh[mn_ev^fZjrZeZhgh[gZ`be
riZ]m b kdZaZe ³>h l_o ihj [m^m klhylv a^_kv gZ qZkZo ihdZ g_ ijbrexl ihq_lgh]h
dZjZmeZ^eykf_gu´
WlZ³\uoh^dZ´klZeZba\_klgZbfi_jZljbp_b fhkdh\kdhfm]m[_jgZlhjm>eylh]h
qlh[u k ijbebqbyfb ihohjhgblv klZjh]h \h_gZqZevgbdZ \kdhj_ [ueh \u^_e_gh
ih^jZa^_e_gb_\hbgh\kf_gb\rbo]_g_jZeZIZgbgZgZljZ^bpbhgghc\Zol_
H lhf kdhev [hevrh_ agZq_gb_ ijb^Z\Zehkv jblmZem ihohjhg b hl^Zgbx
ihke_^g_]h ^he]Z k\b^_l_evkl\m_l b rmleb\uc jZkkdZa ba dgb]b kj_^g_\_dh\h]h
ZjZ[kdh]hibkZl_eyB[g:[^JZ[[bob²]]³Qm^_kgh_h`_j_ev_´
³M :[m:[^ZevFZebdZkijhkbeb
² Ihq_fm ex^b kqblZxl qlh :[m :eb Zev:k\Zjb [ue [he__ ^hklhcguf
q_eh\_dhfq_fKZeZf:[mevFmgabj"
²Ihlhfmqlhdh]^Zmf_jKZeZf:[mevFmgabg:[m:ebr_eaZ_]h]jh[hfZ
dh]^ZkdhgqZeky:[m:ebKZeZfg_mqZkl\h\Ze\ _]hihohjhgZo´
AZqZklmx \ hkd\_jg_gbb fh]be \bgh\Zlu [ueb g_ ex^b Z klbobcgu_ kbeu
ijbjh^u Hkh[Zy jhev a^_kv ijbgZ^e_`bl agZf_gbluf i_l_j[mj]kdbf gZ\h^g_gbyf
dhlhju_jZafu\ZebjZkiheh`_ggu_\ gbabgZodeZ^[bsZ]hjh^Z
Hq_\b^_pgZ\h^g_gby]h^ZKZfmbe:ee_j]h\hjblqlhmebpZi_j_^E_lgbf
kZ^hf ^Z b kZf kZ^ aZ\Ze_gu [ueb dj_klZfb k fh]be aZg_k_ggufb k deZ^[bsZ GZ
Kfhe_gkdhf deZ^[bs_ fgh]h k\_`bo fh]be [ueh jZafulh \h^hx b fgh`_kl\h ]jh[h\
\kieueh Hl ihebpbb [ueZ ih\_kldZ k h[ty\e_gb_f ³dlh ba h[u\Zl_e_c gZr_e ]jh[ k
ihdhcgbdhf mg_k_gguc kh Kfhe_gkdh]h deZ^[bsZ b dlh ij_^klZ\bl _]h lhfm ^Zgh
[m^_ljm[e_c´D h^ghfmZg]ebqZgbgmijbg_keh\h^hx\ujulucbaa_feb]jh[_]h
ijbyl_eydhlhjh]hhgihohjhgbeaZ^\Z^gy^hgZ\h^g_gby
:dl_j I : DZjZlu]bg jZkkdZau\Z_l qlh h^gZ fheh^Zy \^h\Z ijh`b\Z\rZy gZ
h^ghcbaebgbc<Zkbev_\kdh]hhkljh\ZgZdZgmg_gZ\h^g_gby]h^ZihohjhgbeZgZ
Kfhe_gkdhf deZ^[bs_ k\h_]h klZjh]h kmijm]Z gZ^ ijZohf dhlhjh]h g_ jZkiheh`_gZ
[ueZ ^he]h ieZdZlv b l_jaZlvky ihlhfm qlh ihdhcguc fmqbe __ k\h_c j_\ghklvx
Ijh\h^b\ _]h gZ f_klh \_qgh]h mkihdh_gby hgZ ^mfZeZ gZclb gZdhg_p ^mr_\gh_
kihdhckl\b_ gh dZdh\ `_ [ue __ m`Zk dh]^Z \_q_jhf jhdh\h]h ^gy hgZ m\b^_eZ ]jh[
k\h_]h kmijm]Z m kZfh]h djuevpZ ^hfZ G_q_]h ^_eZlv ijbrehkv [_^ghc \^h\mrd_
\lhjbqghohjhgblvk\h_]hg_m]hfhggh]hfm`Z
<ijhq_f gbq_]h hkh[_ggh m^b\bl_evgh]h \ ijb\_^_gguo a^_kv wibah^Zo g_l
<iheg_ \hafh`gh qlh ]jh[ kh Kfhe_gkdh]h deZ^[bsZ jZkiheh`_ggh]h gZ
<Zkbev_\kdhfhkljh\_fh]ehaZg_klb\hegZfbgZh^gmba ebgbc wlh]h hkljh\Z ]^_ ih
qbklhckemqZcghklbijh`b\Zeb^jmavybebjh^kl\_ggbdbihdhcgbdZ
=hjZa^h[he__g_\_jhylgZybklhjby\ k\h_\j_fy\a\hegh\Z\rZy\_kvkm_\_jguc
fbj ijhbahreZ k l_ehf ba\_klgh]h Zf_jbdZgkdh]h Zdl_jZ dhgpZ ijhreh]h klhe_lby
QZjevaZDh]e_gZQZjevaDh]e_gjh^bekygZhkljh\_IjbgpZW^mZj^Z\ aZeb\_K\ylh]h
EZ\j_glby DZgZ^Z < ]h^m gZ ]Zkljheyo \ Zf_jbdZgkdhf ]hjh^_ =Ze\_klhg hg
mf_jIhohjhgbeb_]ha^_kv`_iheh`b\\ ]_jf_lbq_kdbcheh\ygguc]jh[Q_j_a]h^\
]h^m ljhibq_kdbc mjZ]Zg g_\b^Zgghc kbeu gZa\Zgguc iha^g__ ³mjZ]Zghf \_dZ´
h[jmrbeky gZ =Ze\_klhg Ih^ gZihjhf \_ljZ \h^u F_dkbdZgkdh]h aZeb\Z jbgmebkv gZ
ih[_j_`v_ DZd h]jhfgu_ lZjZgu hgb kghkbeb mebpm aZ mebp_c Yjhklguc \_l_j
^h\_jrZe jZajmrbl_evgmx jZ[hlm Ihlhdb [mrmxs_c \h^u jZafueb deZ^[bs_gkdb_
fh]beub ]jh[k l_ehfDh]e_gZ[uemg_k_g\ fhj_
HgihiZe\ =hevnkljbfb l_q_gb_f\_ljZ[ueaZg_k_g\ aZeb\K\ylh]hEZ\j_glby
]^_ _]h h[gZjm`beb ju[Zdb k hkljh\Z IjbgpZ W^mZj^Z GZoh^ykv ihqlb ^_\ylv e_l \
hd_Zg_ysbd[ueihdjuljZdmrdZfbb \h^hjhkeyfbJu[Zdbhqbklbeb_]hb ijhqebgZ
djurd_ bfy mf_jr_]h >hf ]^_ hg dh]^Zlh jh^beky gZoh^beky \k_]h \ g_kdhevdbo
fbeyo
Kdhevdh fbklbq_kdbo dhff_glZjb_\ fh`gh [ueh [u jZa\_jgmlv \hdjm] wlhc
bklhjbb H^gZdh wlh \uoh^bl aZ jZfdb p_e_c b aZ^Zq ihklZ\e_gguo \ wlhc dgb]_
<_jhylg__ \k_]h lml fu bf__f ^_eh k m^b\bl_evguf kh\iZ^_gb_f dZdbo g_fZeh
kemqZehkv \ bklhjbb >hklZlhqgh \kihfgblv fgh]hqbke_ggu_ jZkkdZau h ³[mluehqghc
ihql_´dh]^Z[jhr_ggh_\ fhj_ihkeZgb_gZoh^behZ^j_kZlZgZ^jm]hfdjZxA_feb
EBL?J:LMJ:
Iuey_\F B KlZjucI_l_j[mj]KI_l_j[mj]Ba^:KKm\hjbgZ
Kh[jZgb_ gZjh^guo i_k_g I < Dbj__\kdh]h E ³GZmdZ´ lhf , AZibkdb I B
YdmrdbgZ
EhabgkdbcK= BklhjbyiZikl\ZF³Iheblba^Zl´AZibkdb>1;ZglurZ
DZf_gkdh]h ²]]JmkkdZyklZjbgZl9,,
K DZf_g_\ < q_f ijh\bgbeky =h]hev ³Sbl b f_q´ ‹ Dmq_jh\ = Bklhjby k
kZih]Zfb=h]hey³Fheh^hce_gbg_p´I_gaZbxgy
<Zebr_\kdbc D Kfmlgh_\j_fyKI_l_j[mj] LZdkqev E K\ys_gguc \_jl_i F
Iheblba^ZlMoZgh\BK : bklbgZ^hjh`_Keh\h‹ B[g :[^ JZ[[boq
Qm^_kgh_h`_j_ev_F³Om^h`_kl\_ggZyebl_jZlmjZ´
GZaZjh\: Hlq_]hmf_jFhpZjl"WohieZg_lu‹ FmjZ\v_\:G Iml_r_kl\b_
ihk\yluff_klZfjmkkdbfKI_l_j[mj]
F_a_gp_\ < : Qm^_kZ IhimeyjgZy wgpbdehi_^by :efZ:lZ =e j_^ DZa kh\
wgpbdehi_^bbldg
I_j_k\_lh\JL LZcgu\up\_lrbokljhdF³>_lkdZyebl_jZlmjZ´
Bgkljmdpb_cij_^mkfhlj_gh²:j]mf_glub nZdlu‹ AZ]hkdbgGI Hq_jd
ihbklhjbbkf_jlghcdZagb\ JhkkbbDZaZgv
@bagvb ijbdexq_gby:g^j_y;hehlh\ZhibkZggu_bfkZfbf^eyk\hboihlhfdh\Lhf
lj_lbc]]F
AZkhkh\ > : Iuabg < B Ba `bagb I_l_j[mj]Z ²o ]h^h\ E_gba^Zl ³:j]mf_glub nZdlu´‹ bxey
FmjZ\v_\:G Iml_r_kl\b_ihk\yluff_klZfjmkkdbfKI_l_j[mj]
<hag_k_gkdbc: :[kmj^baf³Ebl_jZlmjgZy]Za_lZ´‹ hdly[jy
DhklhfZjh\G Bklhjbq_kdb_fhgh]jZnbbb bkke_^h\ZgbyFDgb]Z
KZ\_gdh\; <hkihfbgZgbyl_jjhjbklZE³E_gba^Zl´: K Imrdbg Kh[khq\
lhfZo F ³IjZ\^Z´ l Eb Xc >\_gZ^pZlv [Zr_g F ³Om^h`_kl\_ggZy
ebl_jZlmjZ´
KgbkZj_gdh:; Lj_lbcihykfm^jhklb;e_kdyauq_kdhc?\jhiuE³E_gba^Zl´
Iml_r_kl\b_\ \hklhqgu_kljZguIeZghDZjibgbb Jm[jmdZF=hkba^]_h]jZnebl
ju=eZ\Z
F:;me]Zdh\ Ba[jZb^h_F³Om^h`_kl\_ggZyebl_jZlmjZ´
=E:<:;9,,
Ijhdeylb_nZjZhgh\
³< p_eyo bamq_gby wihob :ebr_jZ GZ\hb x[be_cghfm dhfbl_lm jZaj_r_gh
\kdjulvfZ\ahe_cLbfmjZ\kdjulb_fZ\ahe_yij_^iheZ]Z_lkyijhba\_klbbxgy´
WlZg_[hevrZy]Za_lgZyaZf_ldZ\jy^ebijb\e_deZ[uqv_eb[h\gbfZgb_djhf_
ex[bl_e_c bklhjbb Gh gZ kZfZjdZg^kdbo [ZaZjZo lj_\h`gh i_j_r_ilu\Zebkv f_`^m
kh[hc klZjbdb b gZdhg_p j_rbebkv hlijZ\blv k\hbo ij_^klZ\bl_e_c d jmdh\h^bl_ex
Zjo_heh]bq_kdhc wdki_^bpbb >_eh \ lhf qlh ^j_\g__ ij_^Zgb_ ]eZkbeh dh]^Z [m^ml
ihlj_\h`_gu dhklb ³<_ebdh]h ojhfh]h´ gZqg_lky djh\hijheblg_crZy ba \hcg gZ
A_fe_ FZklblu_ Zjo_heh]b bklhjbdb Zgljhiheh]b lhevdh ihkf_b\Zebkv gZ^ ]emiufb
km_\_jbyfbkZfZjdZg^kdboklZjp_\b ijh^he`ZebjZ[hlu
bxgy ]Za_lu khh[sZxl ³KZfZjdZg^ bxgyK_]h^gy gZqbgZ_lky \kdjulb_
fh]beuLbfmjZ´< ]Za_l_³Ba\_klbyhlbxgy]h^Zi_qZlZ_lkyaZf_ldZ
³JZkdhidb fZ\ahe_y Lbfmjb^h\ ijh^he`Zxlky GZ q_j_i_ LbfmjZ h[gZjm`_gu
hklZldb\hehk´
< ghqvk gZbxgy]h^Zba\_klguckh\_lkdbcZjo_heh]b Zgljhiheh]F
F=_jZkbfh\himkdZ_lky\ lhevdhqlh\kdjulmx]jh[gbpmLbfmjZb [_j_l\ jmdbq_j_i
kZfh]hdjh\h`Z^gh]hba\k_oaZ\h_\Zl_e_cijhreh]hqlh[uj_dhgkljmbjh\Zlvq_jlu_]h
ebpZ ih ki_pbZevgh jZajZ[hlZgghc f_lh^bd_ Q_j_a g_kdhevdh qZkh\ gZiZ^_gb_f
nZrbklkdbo\hckdih\k_ckh\_lkdhc]jZgbp_gZqbgZ_lky<_ebdZyHl_q_kl\_ggZy\hcgZ
kZfZydjh\hijheblgZy\ bklhjbbgZr_ckljZgu
DZd lml g_ ih\_jblv \ kijZ\_^eb\hklv ^j_\gbo ijhjhq_kl\ Dh]^Z y \i_j\u_
mkeurZe wlm bklhjbx \ fZe_gvdhc qZcoZg_ KZfZjdZg^Z g_^Ze_dh hl jZa\Zebg f_q_lb
;b[boZgmf y _c q_klgh ]h\hjy g_ ih\_jbe b hlg_k d jZajy^m djZkhqguo e_]_g^
<hklhdZdhlhjuom`_g_fZehgZdhibehkv\ fh_caZibkghcdgb`d_DZdh\h`_[uehfh_
m^b\e_gb_ dh]^Z \_jgm\rbkv \ E_gbg]jZ^ b ijh\_jb\ \k_ kdZaZggh_ ih ]Za_lguf b
`mjgZevgufim[ebdZpbyfy m[_^beky\ ih^ebgghklbbaeh`_gguonZdlh\
LZdqlh`_ih\_jblv\ qm^_kgmxkbemklZjbgguoijhdeylbc"H^gZdh^Z\Zcl_g_
[m^_f lhjhiblvky KZfZy djh\hijheblgZy ba \hcg fbjh\hc bklhjbb <lhjZy fbjh\Zy
\hcgZdZdba\_klghgZqZeZkvg_bxgy]h^ZZ k_gly[jy]h^Zk gZiZ^_gby
nZrbklkdhc=_jfZgbbgZIhevrmB iheuoZeZhgZm`_k\ur_ihemlhjZe_lohlyijZo
³<_ebdh]h ojhfh]h´ gbdlh _s_ ^Z`_ g_ kh[bjZeky lj_\h`blv <_ebdZy Hl_q_kl\_ggZy
\hcgZ ih^[bjZeZkv d gZrbf ]jZgbpZf \ke_^kl\b_ g_mfhebfhc eh]bdb iheblbq_kdbo
kh[ulbc lh]h i_jbh^Z b \jy^ eb aZ\bk_eZ hl mkbebc x[be_cgh]h dhfbl_lZ :ebr_jZ
GZ\hb G_ba[_`ghklv __ qm\kl\h\ZeZkv fgh]bfb aZ bkdexq_gb_f kZfh\ex[e_ggh]h
]jmabgkdh]h fZgvydZ \_jrb\r_]h km^v[u gZr_c kljZgu ?keb [u wdki_^bpby \kdjueZ
]jh[gbpm LbfmjZ \k_]h ebrv gZ h^bg ^_gv iha`_ lh e_]_g^Z ihl_jyeZ [u \_kv k\hc
kfuke
>Z gh ]jh[gbpZ [ueZ \k_lZdb \kdjulZ aZ g_kdhevdh qZkh\ ^h gZqZeZ \hcgu b
ihwlhfm klZjbggh_ ij_^Zgb_ `b\_l b k ]h^Zfb [m^_l a\mqZlv \k_ [he__ b [he__
m[_^bl_evgh ohly fu lhevdh qlh m[_^bebkv \ kemqZcgh bf_\r_f f_klh kh\iZ^_gbb
nZdlh\
>jm]hc lZdhc lZcghc k\yaZgghc k aZohjhg_gbyfb y\ey_lky lZcgZ _]bi_lkdbo
nZjZhgh\dhlhjZy\hlm`_fgh]he_l[m^hjZ`blmfuq_eh\_q_kl\Z
Ijhdeylb_nZjZhgh\²h^gZbaaZ]Z^hd^j_\g__]bi_lkdhcpb\bebaZpbbklZ\rZy
h[s_ba\_klghc ihke_ h[gZjm`_gby \ ]h^m ]jh[gbpu nZjZhgZ LmlZgoZfhgZ GZ
gZc^_gghc ijb \oh^_ \ g__ ^hs_qd_ [ueh gZibkZgh ij_^hkl_j_`_gb_ ³KF?JLV
G:KLB=G?L D:@>H=H DLH G:JMRBL IHDHC N:J:HGH<´ >jm]Zy lZ[ebqdZ
gZc^_ggZy lZf `_ ]eZkbeZ ³>MR: MF?JR?=H N:J:HG: K<?JG?L R?X
=J:;BL?EYFH=BEUD:D?KEB;UWLH;UE:R?Y=MKY´
Kemqbehkv lZd qlh fgh`_kl\h ba\_klg_crbo Zjo_heh]h\ fbjZ mf_jeb m`Zkghc
fmqbl_evghckf_jlvxihke_jZ[hluk _]bi_lkdbfbfmfbyfb
Ih fg_gbx g_f_pdbo bkke_^h\Zl_e_c ba =hiibg]_gZ ijbqbghc kljZ^Zgbc
Zjo_heh]h\[ueZg_f_klv^j_\gbofmfbcZ ]jb[hddhlhjuc[_afbdjhkdhiZjZa]ey^_lv
g_\hafh`gh < _]bi_lkdbo ih]j_[Zevguo dZf_jZo hg gZoh^beky \ [_a^_ckl\bb fgh]b_
lukyqbe_l^h`b^Zykv^gydh]^Zkde_iu[m^mlhldjulu\gh\v
<_jmy \ `bagv ihke_ kf_jlb ^j_\gb_ _]bilyg_ ihf_sZeb \ ]jh[gbpu jy^hf k
fmfbyfb _^m Ijh^mdlu jZaeZ]Zebkv b kf_jlhghkgu_ kihju jZafgh`Zebkv \gmljb
ibjZfb^ Dh]^Z \ aZohjhg_gby ijhgbdZeb bkke_^h\Zl_eb kihju [ukljh ihjZ`Zeb bo
hj]Zgub klZgh\bebkvijbqbghcjZdh\h]haZ[he_\Zgby
Kimkly ]h^u wlhl djhr_qguc ]jb[hd m[be _s_ g_kdhevdbo q_eh\_d Kj_^b gbo
Zg]ebckdbcZjo_heh]Ehj^D_jg_j\hgb ^\_gZ^pZlvqe_gh\_]hwdki_^bpbbHgbmf_jeb
\ l_q_gb_r_klbe_lihke_h[gZjm`_gbybfb]jh[gbpuLmlZgoZfhgZ\ ]h^m
>\Zqe_gZwdbiZ`Z^hklZ\ey\r_]hfhsbnZjZhgZLmlZbaDZbjZ\ Ehg^hg\ ]h^mHgb[ueb\iheg_a^hjh\ufbex^vfbb bokf_jlv[ueZg_h`b^Zgghc
>\_gZ^pZlv qe_gh\ ihevkdhc Zgljhiheh]bq_kdhc wdki_^bpbb D gbf kf_jlv
ijbreZihke_lh]hdZd\ ]h^mhgbh[gZjm`beb]jh[gbpm^jm]h]hnZjZhgZ
< ^hiheg_gb_ dh \k_fm k_cqZk [he_xl khjhd g_f_pdbo fma_cguo jZ[hlgbdh\
IjbqbghcbokljZ^Zgbcy\eyxlkykf_jlhghkgu_kihju
>j_\g__]bi_lkdb_fmfbb\k_qZs_\f_kl_k Zjo_heh]Zfbbkke_^mxlb f_^bdb<
]h^m ]jmiihc q_ohkeh\Zpdbo b Zf_jbdZgkdbo mq_guo [ueh ijhba\_^_gh \kdjulb_
fmfbb \hajZkl dhlhjhc ij_\urZ_l ^\Z^pZlv \_dh\ H^ghc ba p_e_c bkke_^h\Zl_e_c
[ueh hij_^_eblv dZdbfb bgn_dpbhggufb aZ[he_\Zgbyfb [he_eb `bl_eb >j_\g_]h
?]bilZ MagZlv q_f [he_e q_eh\_d fh`gh ih Zglbl_eZf kh^_j`Zsbfky \ _]h djh\b
Hgb bf_xl [_edh\mx kljmdlmjm b fh]ml khojZgylvky \ fmfbb lukyq_e_lbyfb <
hl^_evguo kemqZyo dh]^Z l_eh [ueh fmfbnbpbjh\Zgh kjZam ihke_ kf_jlb ^h gZrbo
^g_c fh]eb khojZgblvky b kZfb [he_ag_l\hjgu_ [Zdl_jbb b \bjmku Fbdjhh[jZapu
\aylu_ba\gmlj_ggbohj]Zgh\b q_j_iZih^\_j]Zebkvki_pbZevguf[Zdl_jbheh]bq_kdbf
bkke_^h\Zgbyf ;hevr_ \k_]h \ i_j_i_qZlZgghc ³GZmdhc b `bagvx´ aZf_ld_ ba
q_ohkeh\Zpdh]h `mjgZeZ ³9HV PLU´ ‹ aZ ]h^ f_gy ihjZabeZ nhlh]jZnby
r_kl_jh ³mq_guo´ ij_iZjbjmxl e_`Zsmx gZ hi_jZpbhgghf klhe_ fmfbx F_gy
objmj]Z ijhklh rhdbjh\Ze \g_rgbc \b^ wlbo ³bkke_^h\Zl_e_c´ gbdZdbo kl_jbevguo
f_^bpbgkdbo rZihq_d fZkhd iurgu_ dm^jb jZkdbgmebkv ih \hjhlgbdZf oZeZlh\ ba
ih^jmdZ\h\oZeZlZ\u[b\ZxlkyfZg`_lujm[Zr_db ljmlkyihih\_joghklbfmfbbg_lb
\ ihfbg_ j_abgh\uo i_jqZlhd nZjlmdh\ : \_^v wlb ³mq_gu_f_^bdb´ \b^bfh kh\k_f
g_agZdhfu_k we_f_glZjgufbijZ\beZfbZk_ilbdbihklZ\bebk\h_caZ^Zq_cgb fgh]h
gb fZehbkke_^h\Zlv³dZdbfbbgn_dpbhggufb[he_agyfbkljZ^Zeb^j_\gb__]bilyg_´
?keb bf ³ih\_a_l´ b ^Zgguc _]bilygbg ^_ckl\bl_evgh kdhgqZeky hl dZdh]heb[h
g_ba\_klgh]h gZmd_ Z fh`_l [ulv ^Z`_ ohjhrh ba\_klgh]h [Zdl_jbZevgh]h beb
\bjmkgh]haZ[he_\Zgbylhm gbo_klv\k_hkgh\ZgbybkiulZlvkbfilhfuwlhcbgn_dpbb
gZ k_[_ : `mjgZebklu \ klZlvyog_djheh]Zo g_ ij_fbgml \ dhlhjuc jZa fmkkbjh\Zlv
e_]_g^mh ³ijhdeylbyonZjZhgh\´
Ohjhrh ba\_klgh qlh hl g_ihgylguo [he_ag_c kdhgqZehkv m`_ fgh]h
bkke_^h\Zl_e_c _]bi_lkdbo ^j_\ghkl_c G_\j_^bfufb hklZebkv l_ dlh \ k\h_c jZ[hl_
jmdh\h^kl\h\ZekylsZl_evgufbijZ\beZfbZk_ilbdbdZdijbjZ[hl_k hkh[hhiZkgufb
bgn_dpbyfbki_pbZevgu_dhklxfufZkdbj_kibjZlhjuihegZykl_jbevghklvIjZ\^Z
i_j\hgZqZevgh wlb f_ju ij_^ijbgbfZebkv \ p_eyo ij_^hojZg_gby ldZg_c fmfbb hl
ihiZ^Zgby \ gbo kh\j_f_gguo fbdjhhj]Zgbafh\ b ]jb[dh\ kihkh[guo jZajmrblv wlb
ldZgbGhl_fg_f_g__wlhkiZkehbkke_^h\Zl_e_chl\hafh`gh]haZjZ`_gby
Ba\_klgh qlh kms_kl\mxl lZd gZau\Z_fu_ nZdmevlZlb\gu_ iZjZablu g_
mljZlb\rb_ iheghklvx k\yab k \g_rg_c kj_^hc Wlb fbdjhhj]Zgbafu fh]ml \_klb dZd
iZjZablbq_kdbc lZd b kZijhnblguc h[jZa `bagb lh _klv iblZlvky b f_jl\ufb
hj]Zgbq_kdbfb \_s_kl\Zfb ;he_agb h[mkeh\e_ggu_ ^Zggufb fbdjhhj]ZgbafZfb
khklZ\eyxl h[rbjgmx ]jmiim lZd gZau\Z_fuo kZijhghah\ h[sb_ ij_^klZ\e_gby h
dhlhjuo _s_ iheghklvx nhjfbjmxlky GZb[he__ ohjhrh ba wlhc ]jmiiu bamq_gZ
kb[bjkdZyya\Z
H^ghc ba hkh[_gghkl_c kb[bj_ya\_gghc bgn_dpbb y\ey_lky bkdexqbl_evgZy
klhcdhklv__ ihq\_gguohqZ]h\Ihwlhfm\ l_of_klZo]^_aZohjhg_guljmiuih]b[rbo
`b\hlguo \k_]^Z kms_kl\m_l hiZkghklv gh\uo \kiur_d GZijbf_j \ Qblbgkdhc
h[eZklb_klviZ^vdhlhjmxf_klgu_[mjylukqblZxlhiZkguff_klhfb g_imkdZxllm^Z
kdhl Ih ij_^Zgbx \ wlhf f_kl_ [ueZ klhygdZ \hckd Qbg]bkoZgZ Kb[bjkdZy ya\Z
ih]m[beZ lh]^Z [hevrbgkl\h ehrZ^_c b aZo\Zq_ggh]h \hckdZfb kdhlZ b iZ^v
ij_\jZlbeZkv\ [hevrh_deZ^[bs_Ij_^Zgb_wlhg_ebr_ghhkgh\Zgbc²^Z`_ljb^pZlv
e_lgZaZ^a^_kv_s_hlf_qZebkemqZbiZ^_`Z`b\hlguo
?s_ IZkl_j h[jZlbe \gbfZgb_ gZ lh qlh ^h`^_\u_ q_j\b \ughkyl kihju
kb[bj_ya\_gghc iZehqdb \ \_jogb_ kehb ihq\u b gZ __ ih\_joghklv b \ k\yab k wlbf
j_dhf_g^h\ZeaZju\Zlvljmiu`b\hlguo\ kmohci_kqZghcbebba\_kldh\hcihq\_Ihq\Z
jZkkfZljb\Z_lkyg_lhevdhdZdiZkkb\gucojZgbl_ev\ha[m^bl_eyghb dZd\lhjZyihke_
hj]ZgbafZ `b\hlguo kj_^Z h[blZgby G_dhlhjh_ h`b\e_gb_ wlhc k\h_h[jZaghc
ihq\_gghc bgn_dpbb fh`_l gZ[ex^Zlvky ijb kljhbl_evguo jZ[hlZo k\yaZgguo k
ih^t_fhf]jmglZbebijbZjo_heh]bq_kdbojZkdhidZo
< mkuiZevgbp_ ihevkdbo dhjhe_c \ DjZdh\_ \ aZfd_ <Z\_ev y keurZe
bgl_j_kgmx bklhjbx H^bg ba ihevkdbo fhgZjoh\ ihohjhg_gguo lml kdhgqZeky hl
g_ihgylgh]haZ[he_\ZgbyE_lhibkb^hklZlhqghih^jh[ghaZnbdkbjh\Zeb_]hkbfilhfu
h^gZdh hgb g_ khhl\_lkl\h\Zeb gb h^ghc ba ba\_klguo \ gZklhys__ \j_fy [he_ag_c
Mq_gu_ j_rbeb bkke_^h\Zlv hklZgdb dhjhey b ^ey wlhc p_eb ba\e_deb ba ]jh[gbpu
dhe_gguc kmklZ\ ]^_ khojZgbehkv [he__ \k_]h ldZg_c <ha[m^bl_ey lZbgkl\_gghc
[he_agb gZclb g_ m^Zehkv gh g_kdhevdh q_eh\_d mqZkl\h\Z\rbo \ bkke_^h\Zgbb
kdhgqZehkv ijb lhqgh lZdbo `_ kbfilhfZo dZdb_ [ueb aZnbdkbjh\Zgu \ klZjbgghc
e_lhibkb Wdki_jbf_gl j_rbeb kjhqgh ij_djZlblv b aehihemqguc kmklZ\ kh`]eb \
dj_fZlhjbbMq_gu_kqblZxlqlh\ ^ZgghfkemqZ_hgbklhedgmebkvk _s_g_ba\_klguf
gZmd_\bjmkhf
Jmdh\h^kl\mykv \b^bfh khh[jZ`_gbyfb h \hafh`ghklb \ [m^ms_f aZjZ`_gbc
g_ba\_klghcijbjh^u\bjmkZfbhlmf_jrbo]hjh^kdb_\eZklbIZ^mbih\_e_ebmqj_^blv
hl^_evgh_ deZ^[bs_ ^ey mf_jrbo hl KIB>Z Wlh ih]j_[Zevgh_ ]_llh hl^_e_gh hl
h[uqgh]h deZ^[bsZ ^\hcgufb j_r_ldZfb Ihdhcgbdh\ ohjhgyl ]heufb aZ\_jgmlufb
lhevdh\ ijhiblZggu_^_abgnbpbjmxsbfkhklZ\hfkZ\Zgu
<iheg_\_jhylghqlhwlhj_r_gb_y\ey_lky\_kvfZ^Zevgh\b^gufh^gZdhk_cqZk
[hevrbgkl\hf `mjgZebklh\ hgh hp_gb\Z_lky djZcg_ hljbpZl_evgh b ijbjZ\gb\Z_lky d
ihkf_jlghc^bkdjbfbgZpbb
AZ]Z^dZ kf_jlb kljZo i_j_^ g_c ihjh^beb \ ^j_\g_f q_eh\_d_ b hl\jZs_gb_ d
f_jl\hfml_emb [hyagv_]hJ_eb]byih^^_j`b\ZeZb mdj_ieyeZ wlb qm\kl\Z Ex^b ih
jh^m ijhn_kkbb khijbdZkZ\rb_ky k ih]j_[_gb_f ljmih\² [ZevaZfbjh\sbdb b
fh]bevsbdb ² klZgh\bebkv hls_i_gpZfb Bo ^_lb g_ bf_eb ijZ\Z aZgbfZlvky gbq_f
^jm]bfdjhf_ijhn_kkbbhlph\LZdb_hls_i_gpu[ueb\ ^j_\g_f?]bil_< Bg^bbhgb
khklZ\beb dZklm g_ijbdZkZ_fuo FZeh dlh agZ_l qlh ba\_klgZy \ jmkkdhc bklhjbb
nZfbeby Fhj^Zkh\ ijhbkoh^bl hl i_jkb^kdh]h keh\Z ³fhj^Zk´ ³PXUGHVXM´ ²
q_eh\_d h[fu\Zxsbc f_jl\uo < >j_\g_c Bm^__ q_eh\_d ijbdhkgm\rbcky d
f_jl\hfml_emkqblZekyhkd\_jg_ggufb ^he`_g[ueijhclbki_pbZevgu_h[jy^u
hqbs_gby
Ebrv \ ;9,, \_d_ dh]^Z mq_gu_ ^h[bebkv ijZ\Z \kdju\Zlv ljmiu mf_jrbo k
gZmqgufb p_eyfb [ukljufb rZ]Zfb ^\bgmebkv \i_j_^ ZgZlhfby b iZlZgZlhfby Gh
fbn h g_qbklhl_ f_jl\h]h l_eZ ijh^he`Ze `blv Hg ijbgye nhjfm mq_gby h lZd
gZau\Z_fuo³ljmiguoy^Zo´ohlygbdlhlhedhfg_agZeqlhlZdh_ljmigucy^b dZdhg
aZghkblky\ jZgm
<kihfgbfh[h^ghfbakZfuoba\_klguo]_jh_\jmkkdhcebl_jZlmju²;ZaZjh\_
Ijb\kdjulbbljmiZhgihjZgbek_[_iZe_pb kjZam`_ihgyeqlhh[j_q_gDZdb dZ`^uc
\jZq_]h\j_f_gb hg ^mfZeqlhq_j_aihj_a\ _]hl_eh\hr_ekf_jl_evgucljmigucy^
³;ZaZjh\\hr_ed hlpm\ dhfgZlmb kijhkbeg_lebm g_]hZ^kdh]hdZfgy"
²?klv gZqlhl_[_"
²Gm`ghjZgmijb`_qv
²Dhfm"
²K_[_
²DZdk_[_AZq_f`_wlh"DZdZywlhjZgdZ"=^_hgZ"
² <hl lml gZ iZevp_ Y k_]h^gy _a^be \ ^_j_\gx agZ_rv ² hldm^Z lbnhagh]h
fm`bdZ ijb\_aeb Hgb ihq_fmlh \kdju\Zlv _]h kh[bjZebkv Z y ^Z\gh \ wlhf g_
mijZ`gyeky
²Gm"
²Gm\hly bihijhkbem_a^gh]h\jZqZgmb ihj_aZeky
<Zkbebc B\Zgh\bq \^jm] ih[e_^g_e \_kv b gb keh\Z g_ ]h\hjy [jhkbeky \
dZ[bg_lhldm^ZlhlqZk`_\_jgmekyk dmkhqdhfZ^kdh]hdZfgy\ jmd_
²DZdluiheZ]Z_rv?\]_gbcg_emqr_ebgZfijb`_qv`_e_ahf"
² Wlh [u jZgvr_ gZ^h k^_eZlv Z l_i_jv ihgZklhys_fm b Z^kdbc dZf_gv g_
gm`_g?keby aZjZabekylZdl_i_jvm`_iha^gh
²DZdiha^gh²_^\Zfh]ijhbag_klb<ZkbebcB\Zgh\bq
²?s_[uK l_oihjq_luj_qZkZijhrehk ebrdhf´
Hlq_]h `_ \k_lZdb \ l_dkl_ jhfZgZ ³Hlpu b ^_lb´ fu g_ \klj_qZ_f l_jfbgZ
³ljmiguc y^´" < g_q_ldhklb hij_^_e_gby ijbqbg ]b[_eb ;ZaZjh\Z ih\b^bfhfm
kdZaZeZkvg_ykghklv\ wlhf\hijhk_pZjb\rZy\ gZmd_\ ihjmdh]^ZibkZekyjhfZg
LZcgZ ih^h[guo kf_jl_c jZkdjueZkv ihke_ lh]h dZd k^_eZe k\hb hldjulby
IZkl_j G_ ³ljmiguc y^´ Z g_dhlhju_ lbiu fbdjhhj]Zgbafh\ dhlhju_ [ukljh
jZafgh`Zxlky \ ldZgyo ihke_ kf_jlb b ijhgbdZxl \ hj]Zgbaf q_j_a kemqZcguc ihj_a
\uau\Zeb h[s__ aZjZ`_gb_ djh\b ² k_ikbk ² b kf_jlv Hl aZjZ`_gby djh\b mf_j b
;ZaZjh\Lhevdhhldjulb_kihkh[h\[hjv[uk [he_ag_l\hjgufbfbdjh[Zfb²Zk_ilbdb
b Zglbk_ilbdb²jZa\_yehfbnh ljmighfy^_
H^gZdhdh_]^_fbnwlhl^h`be^hgZrbo^g_ch q_f k\b^_l_evkl\m_l hlju\hd
ba ih\_klb K_j]_y DZe_^bgZ ³Kfbj_ggh_ deZ^[bs_´ H^bg ba ]_jh_\ ih\_klb
fh]bevsbdE_rdZ<hjh[_c\kihfbgZ_llZdhcwibah^bak\h_cijZdlbdb
³IhaZijhrehc \_kghc hg dhiZe gZ iylgZ^pZlhf mqZkld_ b klhy \gbam \ ]jyab
kZ^Zgmeg_]ey^y\ aZieu\rbcijb[u\Zxs_c`b`_cih^[hcBa]jh[Zqmlv[juagmehb
\hgvj\Zgm\rZykybas_eb\uibogmeZ_]hbayfu
DhiZedZdex[be[_a\_johghdjmdZ\bp²[jua]bqbjdgmebihiZevpZfih_]h
\k_]^ZjZah^jZgguf\ djh\vaZmk_gbpZf
Ihlhf hg [he_e <jZ]m g_ ih`_eZe [u lZdh]h ;he_eh \k_ ]eZaZ jmdb \hehku
lmeh\bs_gmljh²[he_eh[_kij_ju\ghly`_ehlmihdZf_ggh
J_[ylZ ]h\hjbeb aZjZ`_gb_ lmoeuf y^hf <jZqZ g_ a\Ze [hyeky ih^l\_j^bl
<h^dZklhyeZ\ ]jZnbg_dZd\h^Z\k_\j_fyLhfdZlh]^Zrgyy_]hih^eb\ZeZ\ klZdZgb
^_gvb ghqv´
H^gZdh \_jg_fky d l_f_ gZr_]h jZa]h\hjZ ² \kdjulbx aZohjhg_gbc mq_gufb
beb]jZ[bl_eyfb
GbkljZoi_j_^f_jl\ufbgb [hyagvijhdeylbyg_hklZgZ\eb\Zebl_odlhbkdZe
khdjh\bsZWlhhgbhkd\_jgbl_ebb ]jZ[bl_ebfh]beaZlukyqbe_l^h³deZ^hbkdZl_e_c
hl gZmdb´ ² Zjo_heh]h\ \aeZfu\Zeb i_qZlb ]jh[gbp ijhgbdZeb \ aZ[ulu_ lZcgbdb
³]hjh^Z f_jl\uo´ < ?]bil_ himklhr_gb_ pZjkdbo ]jh[gbp ijbgyeh klhev fZkkh\uc
oZjZdl_j b gZqZehkv lZd ^Z\gh qlh m`_ e_l gZaZ^ nZjZhgu \ugm`^_gu [ueb
mklZgh\blv \hae_ mkuiZevgbp djm]ehkmlhqgmx kljZ`m Z \gmljb ² khhjm`Zlv eh`gu_
\oh^u lZcgu_ oh^u obljhmfgu_ ijbkihkh[e_gby dhlhju_ ^he`gu [ueb ih]m[blv
\kydh]hdlhhkf_eb\Zekyijhgbdgmlv\gmljvibjZfb^u
< ]h^m ]jmiiZ _]bi_lkdbo rdhevgbdh\ h[gZjm`beZ \ hdj_klghklyo ]hjh^Z
:[mAZZ[Zev lZcgbd <oh^ \ g_]h aZ]hjZ`b\Ze ]ebgyguc dm\rbg mdjZr_gguc
jbkmgdZfbbah[jZ`Zxsbfbex^_cb `b\hlguoDm\rbgg_h`b^Zgghe_]dhhldjuekyb
ba g_]h \ue_l_eh g_kdhevdh ^_kyldh\ kmobo l_fguo dhfhqdh\ Ijb [eb`Zcr_f
jZkkfhlj_gbb hgb hdZaZebkv \ukhorbfb kdhjibhgZfb \_kvfZ djmiguo jZaf_jh\
AZfuk_e^j_\gbo\_jhylgh[uelZdbf\hjuij_evklb\rbkvdm\rbghfhldjhxl_]hb
[m^mlkf_jl_evghm`Ze_gukdhjibhgZfbQlh[uh[e_]qblv\uoh^ihke_^gbo\ dm\rbg_
[ueZmklZgh\e_gZg_[hevrZy\ulZedb\ZxsZyijm`bgZkjZ[Zlu\ZxsZyijbhldju\Zgbb
djurdb
Fh`gh eb ^h]Z^Zlvky qlh kx`_l ba\_klghc kdZadb h[ :eeZ^bg_ b \her_[ghc
eZfi_ ba ³Lukyqb b h^ghc ghqb´ \hkijhba\h^bl kblmZpbx h]jZ[e_gby pZjkdhc
]jh[gbpu" HdZau\Z_lky wlh ^_ckl\bl_evgh lZd JZkiheh`_gb_ ih^a_fghc
khdjh\bsgbpu \ dhlhjmxihiZ^Z_l:eeZ^bgqbkehb ihke_^h\Zl_evghklvihf_s_gbc
dhlhju__fmijboh^blkyij_^\Zjbl_evghijhclb²g_ieh^nZglZabbb g_kemqZcghklv
HibkZgb_ bo \hkijhba\h^bl \gmlj_ggxx kljmdlmjm ]jh[gbp lZd gZau\Z_fhc >hebgu
PZj_c\ ?]bil_hlghkysbokyd ³iha^g_fmi_jbh^m´
<k_kbevgu_ijb `bagb\eZ^udbihke_kf_jlbhdZau\Zebkv\h\eZklbbkdZl_e_c
khdjh\bs hohlgbdh\ aZ ahehlhf B \hl g_ `_eZy ^_eZlv k\h_ ihke_^g__ ijbklZgbs_
^h[uq_c qm`hc Zeqghklb hgb gZqbgZxl b]jm \ ijyldb dhlhjZy ijh^he`Z_lky \_dZ
f_jl\u_ijyqmlky`b\u_bsml
< ]h^m \ DZeZ[jbb mf_j dhjhev \_kl]hlh\ :eZjbo , Lhl kZfuc :eZjbo
dhlhjuc\ ]h^k\h_ckf_jlbmki_eaZo\Zlblvb jZa]jZ[blvJbfK l_oihjijhreb\_dZ
>Z\gh m`_ g_l gZjh^Z gZau\Z\r_]h k_[y ]hlZfb Gh aZ ihelhju lukyqb e_l gb jmdZ
]jZ[bl_ey gb ehiZlZ Zjo_heh]Z g_ dhkgmebkv fh]beu bo \h`^y B wlh g_kfhljy gZ lh
qlh ba\_klgh kdhev fgh]h ahehlZ ^jZ]hp_gguo dZfg_c b ijhqbo khdjh\bs
gZ]jZ[e_gguoih\k_c?\jhi_[uehkeh`_gh\ fh]bem:eZjboZ
Dhg_qgh ]hlu ohjhrh agZeb h[ hohlgbdZo aZ deZ^Zfb <hl ihq_fm hgb
ihklZjZebkv k^_eZlv g_^hklmiguf f_klh aZohjhg_gby k\h_]h \h`^y >ey wlh]h hgb
i_j_]hjh^beb iehlbghc l_q_gb_ j_db b dh]^Z jmkeh h[gZ`behkv \ujueb ]em[hdmx
fh]bem gZ ^g_ Ihlhf himklb\ \ g__ ahehlhc ]jh[ b \k_ khdjh\bsZ hgb jZajmrbeb
iehlbgmb j_dZ\_jgmeZkv\ k\h_jmkehFgh]hf_ljh\uckehc\h^u b [ukljh_ l_q_gb_
klZebkljZ`Zfbih]j_[_gguokhdjh\bs: qlh[ul_dlh]hlh\beih]j_[_gb_\h`^yg_
fh]ebgbdhfmjZkdjulvlZcgm\k_hgb[uebm[blu\ lm`_ghqv
< ]h^m mf_j \h`^v ]mggh\ :llbeZ gZ\h^b\rbc m`Zk gZ \kx ?\jhim b
ijha\Zgguc ³[bq [h`bc´ ?]h l_eh [ueh ihf_s_gh \ ahehlhc ]jh[ ahehlhc ]jh[ ² \
k_j_[jyguc Z k_j_[jyguc ² \ `_e_aguc @_e_aguc ]jh[ \f_kl_ k g_kf_lgufb
khdjh\bsZfb[ueaZl_fij_^Zga_fe_>eylh]hqlh[uf_klh]^_ihohjhg_gbo\h`^v
hklZehkvg_ba\_klguf]mggulZd`_m[beb\k_odlhmqZkl\h\Ze\ ihohjhgZo
BklhjbydeZ^[bs_gkdbo\hjh\]jh[hdhiZl_e_cbebdZdbogZau\Zeb]jh[hahjh\
klhev`_klZjZdZdb bklhjbykZfboih]j_[_gbcGZqbgZyhl_]bi_lkdbonZjZhgh\l_fZ
wlZ ijhoh^bl \ nhevdehj_ ijZdlbq_kdb \k_o gZjh^h\ <hl gZijbf_j klZjbgguc
i_jkb^kdbcZg_d^hl
³H^bg q_eh\_d `be l_f qlh kgbfZe kZ\Zgu k f_jl\_ph\ b ijh^Z\Ze bo <kydbc
jZadh]^Zdlhgb[m^vmfbjZehgghqvxr_ed fh]be_jZaju\Ze__ bmghkbekZ\ZgB \hl
i_j_^kf_jlvxhgjZkdZyeky\ k\hbo]j_oZob klZekh`Ze_lvqlhgbdlhg_ihfyg_l_]h
^h[juf keh\hf Kug `_ _]h ihh[_sZe ³Hl_p y k^_eZx \k_ qlh[u ex^b \kihfbgZeb
l_[ylhevdhohjhrbf´
B \hl ihke_ kf_jlb hlpZ kug ghqvx lbohgvdh ijh[jZeky gZ deZ^[bs_ kgye k
hlpZkZ\Zg\ulZsbeljmibafh]beub [jhkbejy^hf
GZ ^jm]hc ^_gv ex^b ijbreb gZ deZ^[bs_ qlh[u qblZlv fhebl\m ih mkhir_f
M\b^_ebhgbqlhkemqbehkvb ]h\hjyl
² Ihfbemc ]hkih^b mf_jr_]h ]jh[h\hjZ Hg ohlv \hjh\Ze kZ\Zg gh g_
\u[jZku\Zeihdhcgbdh\bafh]beu´
H^gZdh \kdhj_ ]jh[h\hju klZeb \hjh\Zlv g_ lhevdh h^_`^m b mdjZr_gby gh b
l_eZmf_jrbo>_eZebhgbwlh\ hkgh\ghfihaZdZamkj_^g_\_dh\uo\jZq_cb ZgZlhfh\
lZd dZd p_jdh\v aZij_sZeZ \kdju\Zlv ljmiu ex^_c kqblZy wlh dhsmgkl\hf Ba\_klgh
qlh \_ebdbc \jZqZgZlhf wihob <hajh`^_gby :g^j_c <_aZebc ² gZ aZj_
k\h_c ^_yl_evghklb ih ghqZf ihobsZe dhklb gZ deZ^[bsZo qlh[u bamqblv kd_e_l
q_eh\_dZbjbkdmy`bagvxkgbfZek \bk_ebpuljmiudZag_gguoij_klmigbdh\b ^hfZ
ZgZlhfbjh\Zebo
DeZkkbq_kdhc klZeZ kp_gZ ba ³Ijbdexq_gbc LhfZ Khc_jZ´ ]^_ ghqvx gZ
deZ^[bs_klZjucivygqm`dZF_nnIhll_jb aeh\_sbcf_lbkihijha\bsmBg^__p>`h
\udZiu\Zxl^ey^hdlhjZJh[bgkhgZg_^Z\ghihohjhg_ggucljmi³G_dhlhjh_\j_fy[ue
keur_g ebrv kdj_`_l ehiZl hl[jZku\Zxsbo \ klhjhgm f_edb_ dZf_rdb b dhfvy
a_feb²a\mdh^ghh[jZagucb mgueucGZdhg_pjZa^Zeky]emohcklmdh ^_j_\hehiZlZ
gZldgmeZkv gZ ]jh[ b q_j_a g_kdhevdh fbgml dhiZ\rb_ ih^gyeb _]h gZ\_jo L_fb `_
ehiZlZfbhgbk[jhkbebdjurdm\ulZsbebl_ehb [_kp_j_fhggh[jhkbeb_]hgZa_fex
< wlm fbgmlm emgZ \ureZ baaZ lmq b hk\_lbeZ [e_^gh_ ebph f_jl\_pZ Ijb^\bgmeb
ghkbedbiheh`bebgZgboljmiihdjuebh^_yehfb ijb\yaZeb\_j_\dhc´
Klhev `_ deZkkbq_kdhc ^ey dbg_fZlh]jZnZ klZeZ kp_gZ \ h^ghf ba i_j\uo
Zf_jbdZgkdbo nbevfh\ m`Zkh\ ³NjZgd_grl_cg´ ]^_ fheh^hc ^hdlhj NjZgd_grl_cg \
khijh\h`^_gbb]hj[mgZih^jmqgh]h\udZiu\Z_lghqvxgZdeZ^[bs_ihdhcgbdZqlh[u
khl\hjblvbag_]hfhgkljZ
DZd m`_ [ueh kdZaZgh ]jh[hdhiZl_evkl\h kms_kl\h\Zeh \h \k_ \j_f_gZ b
ijZdlbq_kdb m \k_o gZjh^h\ Bf_ggh [eZ]h^Zjy ]jh[h\hjZf m^Z\Zehkv g_h^ghdjZlgh
kiZkZlv aZ`b\h ih]j_[_gguo h q_f fu jZkkdZau\Zeb \ khhl\_lkl\mxs_c ]eZ\_ H
jZkijhkljZg_gbb ]jh[hdhiZl_evkl\Z \ I_l_j[mj]_ \ wihom :ggu BhZgh\gu
k\b^_l_evkl\m_l bklhjbd F B Iuey_\ ³;u\Zeb kemqZb ]jZ[bl_evkl\Z \ I_l_j[mj]_
dhlhju_gZa\Zgu³]jh[hdhiZl_evkl\hf´LZd\ h^ghcdbjd_hklZ\e_gh[uehgZghqvl_eh
dZdh]hlhagZlgh]hbghkljZggh]hq_eh\_dZ<hjuijh[jZebkv\ dbjdm\udbgmebl_ehba
]jh[Zb h]jZ[beb<hjh\hlukdZebb dZagbebkf_jlbx´
M agZf_gblh]h \ ;,; \_d_ i_l_j[mj]kdh]h `b\hibkpZ F : Abqb ²
\uoh^pZ ba <_g]jbb _klv h^gZ Zd\Zj_ev ihk\ys_ggZy l_f_ ]jh[hdhiZl_evkl\Z
Ba\_klguc njZgpmakdbc ibkZl_ev L_hnbev =hlv_ ihk_lb\ \ ]h^m I_l_j[mj]
\klj_qZekyk Abqbb hklZ\behibkZgb_wlh]hjbkmgdZ
³Kp_gZ ijhbkoh^bl gZ deZ^[bs_ Ghqv KeZ[uc emgguc k\_l ijhgbdZ_l kd\hav
ly`_eu_^h`^_\u_lmqbQ_jgu_^_j_\yggu_dj_klugZ^]jh[gu_iZfylgbdbdhehggu
mjgu GZ i_j\hf ieZg_ kj_^b jZkdb^Zgghc a_feb klhyl ^\Z aZklmiZ \hldgmlu_ \
]ebgm DeZ^[bs_gkdb_ \hju jhxlky \ fh]beZo qlh[u mdjZklv m kf_jlb __ ihke_^g__
^hklhygb_ ahehlh_ dhevph m `_gsbgu k_j_[jygmx ih]j_fmrdm m j_[_gdZ f_^Zevhg
\haex[e_gghc beb \haex[e_ggh]h h[jZahd m \_jmxs_]h Hgb hldjueb [h]Zluc ]jh[
ijbhldjulZy djurdZ dhlhjh]h h[blZ q_jguf [ZjoZlhf k k_j_[jygufb mdjZr_gbyfb
Ih^ djurdhc \b^gZ ]heh\Z fheh^hc `_gsbgu e_`ZsZy gZ djm`_\ghc ih^mrd_
K^\bgmluc kZ\Zg ijbhldju\Z_l hims_gguc gZ ]jm^v ih^[hjh^hd HgZ \ lhf kZfhf
iheh`_gbb]em[hdh]hjZa^mfvydhlhjh_gZihegy_l]jh[h\mx`bagvH^bgba\hjh\kh
a\_jbguf \ujZ`_gb_f ebpZ k \b^hf dZlhj`gbdZ \ hl\jZlbl_evghf dZjlma_ ^_j`bl
h]Zjhd k\_qb dhlhjuc hg ijbdju\Z_l jmdhc hl ihju\h\ ghqgh]h \_ljZ >jh`Zsbc
f_jl\_ggh[e_^guc lmkdeuc k\_l iZ^Z_l gZ [e_^gh_ ebph mf_jr_c >jm]hc
ihemkdjuluc\ yf_[Zg^blk ^bdbfbq_jlZfbebpZih^gbfZ_lk\hbfbeZiZfbojmidmx
[e_^gmxdZd\hkdjmdmdhlhjmxljmihl^Z_l_fmk [_ajZaebqb_fijbajZdZHgkju\Z_l
k [_aufyggh]hiZevpZdhlhjucfh`_l[ulvehfZ_lkyhl_]hk\ylhlZlkl\Z^jZ]hp_ggh_
dhevphdhg_qghh[jmqZevgh_Lj_lbcg_]h^yc²gZkljZ`_gZ]hjd_fh]bevghca_feb
ijbeh`b\d momk\hcdheiZdhgijbkemrb\Z_lkyd hl^Ze_gghfmeZxkh[Zdbihqmy\r_c
[Zg^blh\ beb d _e_ jZaebqbfuf rZ]Zf klhjh`Z ^_eZxs_]h k\hc ghqghc ^hahjguc
h[oh^ F_jadbc kljZo bkdZ`Z_l _]h q_jlu _]h q_jgh_ \ ghqghc l_gb ebph Z ]gmkgu_
gZfhdrb_ hl jhku kdeZ^db _]h rlZgh\ bafZaZgguo \ `bjghc deZ^[bs_gkdhc a_fe_
h[e_ieyxl_]hh[_avygvbgh]bG_\hafh`ghihclb^Zevr_\ bah[jZ`_gbbjhfZglbq_kdb
m`ZkZxs_ckp_gu´
GhgZklhysZywib^_fby]jh[hdhiZl_evkl\ZgZqZeZkvgZi_l_j[mj]kdbodeZ^[bsZo
\ kh\_lkdh_ \j_fy Ke_^m_l hlf_lblv qlh aZohjhg_gby [h]Zluo i_l_j[mj`p_\ [ueh
ijbgylh ijhba\h^blv g_ ijhklh \ a_fex Z \ ki_pbZevgh \ukljh_gguc kde_i qlh
agZqbl_evghh[e_]qZeh^_ckl\by]jZ[bl_e_cKlhbehlhevdhijh[blvk\h^kde_iZb \hj
hdZau\Zeky ih^e_ ]jh[Z ]^_ gbdlh b gbqlh g_ f_rZeh _]h ^_yl_evghklb ?s_ \
ihklZgh\e_gbbK\yl_cr_]hKbgh^Zhlhdly[jy]h^Zh[hldjulbbdeZ^[bsZijb
p_jd\b;eZ]h\_s_gbygZ<Zkbev_\kdhfhkljh\_ij_^ibku\Zehkv³<k_fh]beuijbhghc
p_jd\b \udeZ^u\Zlv dbjibqhf b k\h^blv k\h^u \ p_euc dbjibq Z ihlhf mlZilu\Zlv
gZdj_idha_fexqlh[u^momg_ijhbahreh[_aq_]hijbhghcp_jd\bih]j_[Zlvhlgx^v
gbdh]h g_ ^himkdZlv´ Iha`_ wlZ ljZ^bpby jZkijhkljZgbeZkv b gZ \gh\v hldjulu_
i_l_j[mj]kdb_deZ^[bsZ
< o ]h^ZogZr_]h\_dZgZ\k_odeZ^[bsZoklZjh]hI_l_j[mj]Zih\_q_jZfb
ih ghqZf klmqZeb fhehldb ² ]jZ`^Zg_ \kdju\Zeb kde_iu Wlh fg_ jZkkdZau\Zeb
fgh]hqbke_ggu_ k\b^_l_eb klZju_ i_l_j[mj`pu KZf `_ y \b^_e fgh`_kl\h
\aehfZgguo kde_ih\ gZ klZjbgguo deZ^[bsZo ]hjh^Z ² Kfhe_gkdhf <hedh\hf
deZ^[bsZo :e_dkZg^jhG_\kdhc eZ\ju b i_l_j[mj]kdh]h Gh\h^_\bqv_]h fhgZklujy
KgZjm`b kde_iu [ueb h[ebph\Zgu dZj_evkdbf ]jZgblhf Z \gmljb gZ kl_gdZo fh`gh
[ueh \b^_lv hklZldb \_ebdhe_iguo d_jZfbq_kdbo ieblhd HklZldb ihlhfm qlh
ihke_^h\Zl_eb b ihlhfdb ]jh[hdhiZl_e_c wihob i_j\uo iylbe_lhd g_ ]gmrZebkv
ih^[bjZlv `Zedb_ hklZldb bo ^_yl_evghklb b \ wihom aZklhy b ^Z`_ _s_ \ ]h^u
i_j_kljhcdb hl^bjZeb h[ebph\dm kde_ih\ \udh\ujb\Zeb qm^hf khojZgb\rb_ky
fhaZbqgu_bdhgdbb dj_klbdb
>h[uqZ l_o i_j\uo ]jh[hdhiZl_e_c [ueZ g_kjZ\g_ggh [h]Zq_ hj^_gZ
x\_ebjgu_ mdjZr_gby hnbp_jkdb_ dhjlbdb rblu_ ahehlhf wihe_lu k_j_[jygu_
im]h\bpu^jZ]hp_ggu_dZfgb
IhljykZxl fZkrlZ[u \Zj\Zjkdhc ^_yl_evghklb ]jh[h\hjh\ ² \ ]hjh^_ g_
khojZgbehkvijZdlbq_kdbgb h^ghcfZehfZevkdhc[h]Zlhcg_h[h[jZgghcfh]beuOhly
fg_ g_h^ghdjZlgh b ]h\hjbeb qlh e_gbg]jZ^kdb_ \eZklb lh]h i_jbh^Z kZfb
ih^^_j`b\Zebb gZijZ\eyebwlm³^_yl_evghklv´gbdZdg_\hafh`gh[ueh\ wlhih\_jblv
H^gZdh]Za_lgu_im[ebdZpbbihke_^g_]h\j_f_gbd kh`Ze_gbxih^l\_j`^Zxlwlh³GZ
deZ^[bsZ :e_dkZg^jhG_\kdhc eZ\ju y\bebkv [jb]Z^u gZ[jZgguo \ lxjvf_
m]heh\gbdh\ dhlhju_ gZqZeb ijh\h^blv Zdpbx ih batylbx p_gghkl_c Hgb \kdju\Zeb
kde_iuehfZeb]jh[u@Z^gu_jmdbh[ukdb\Zebl_eZmkhirbo< DZaZgkdhfkh[hj_g_
ihsZ^beb ^Z`_ l_eZ F B Dmlmah\Z : \h \j_fy hq_j_^gh]h batylby \ ]h^m
ihevklbebkvgZpbebg^jbq_kdbckhkm^k _]hk_j^p_f
G_ mgbqlh`_ggu_ iZfylgbdb i_j_lZkdb\Zebkv b k\habebkv \ h^gh dZdh_gb[m^v
f_klhDZdke_^kl\b_lZdh]hjh^Z^_yl_evghklbb ihy\bekygZk\_llZdgZau\Z_fuc
³Fma_c ]hjh^kdhc kdmevilmju´ ² gZa\Zgb_ [he__ q_f kljZggh_ ?keb ]hjh^m
gm`_g [ue dZf_gv ^ey h[ebph\db ljhlmZjh\ beb kljhbl_evkl\Z iZfylgbdh\ \h`^yf ²
reb gZ deZ^[bs_ <_ebdhe_igu_ f_lZeebq_kdb_ mdjZr_gby ehfZebkv dh]^Z kljZg_
gm`_g[uef_lZee<k_p_jd\beZ\ju]^_gZoh^bebkvih]j_[_gby^Z\ghhkd\_jg_guZ \
kde_i_]jmabgkdhcpZjbpujZaf_klbebkvwdkdmjkh\h^ujZkkdZau\Zxsb_h dmevlmj_Lh
`_kZfh_b \DZaZgkdhfkh[hj_´
LZdZy ³^_yl_evghklv´ g_fbgm_fh ^he`gZ [ueZ kdZaZlvky gZ ikboheh]bb gZjh^Z
Ihwlhfm f_gy kh\k_f g_ m^b\be ihjZab\rbc fgh]bo nZdl hkd\_jg_gby b h]jZ[e_gby
fh]beu g_^Z\gh kdhgqZ\r_]hky FZjrZeZ Kh\_lkdh]h KhxaZ K N :ojhf__\Z
ihohjhg_ggh]hgZLjh_dmjh\kdhfdeZ^[bs_Fhkd\u< ghqvk Z\]mklZ gZk_gly[jy
]h^ZaZohjhg_gb_[uehjZkdhiZghk ihdhcgbdZ kgyeb fZjrZevkdbcfmg^bjLZdZy
`_mqZklvihklb]eZb fh]bem]_g_jZeihedh\gbdZKj_^bgZihohjhg_ggh]hg_kdhevdbfb
^gyfbjZgvr_Fh]bevsbdbjZkkdZaZebqlhh[Z]jh[Z[bebebrv^ey\b^ZijbkuiZgu
a_fe_c²ij_klmigbdbg_kebrdhfklZjZebkvaZf_klbke_^uNmjZ`dbdhlhju_h[uqgh
ijbdheZqb\Zxlkyd djurd_]jh[Zhlh^jZgu
I_j\Zy fukev dh]^Z ijbreZ wlZ `mldZy gh\hklv ihklZjZeky dlhlh ba gZrbo
iheblbq_kdboiZjZghbdh\g_\Z`gh²ijZ\uobebe_\uo
Gh \uykgbehkv qlh \k_ ]hjZa^h ijhs_ b ihwlhfm ih`Zemc _s_ kljZrg__ DZd
khh[sbe ijhdmjhj =Z]Zjbgkdh]h jZchgZ klhebpu <eZ^bfbj Bevbg fZjrZevkdbc b
]_g_jZevkdbc fmg^bju ihevamxlky hij_^_e_gguf kijhkhf m wdkp_gljbqguo
hl_q_kl\_gguo b aZiZ^guo dhee_dpbhg_jh\ Hq_gv fh`_l [ulv qlh \kdhj_ nhjfZ k
ahehlufb ]ZemgZfb ³\kieu\_l´ \ dZdhfgb[m^v lbohf qZklghf kh[jZgbb J_rbl_evgh
^Ze_dhfhl[hevrhciheblbdb: lZd`_²hl\k_]hq_eh\_q_kdh]h
GZ Ljh_dmjh\kdhf deZ^[bs_ m`_ kgylh fbebp_ckdh_ hp_ie_gb_ meZ`_gu \k_
g_ijbylgu_ghg_h[oh^bfu_\ wlhckblmZpbbnhjfZevghklbL_eZFZjrZeZKh\_lkdh]h
KhxaZ:ojhf__\Zb ]_g_jZeihedh\gbdZKj_^bgZ[ueb\gh\vij_^Zgua_fe_L_i_jv²
\ ]jZ`^Zgkdhch^_`^_
Kj_^b ]jh[hdhiZl_e_c fh`gh \u^_eblv ]jmiim kebrdhf g_h[uqgmx ^Z`_ ^ey
wlh]hwdahlbq_kdh]hj_f_keZJ_qvb^_lh g_djhnbeZoL_fZwlZklhevs_dhleb\Zyqlh\h
ba[_`Zgb_djb\hlhedh\b g_^hfhe\hdfu^hkeh\ghijhpblbjm_fkhh[s_gb_`mjgZebklZ
:e_dkZg^jZLZjZkh\Z
bxey hdheh qZkh\ gZ ;mjdh\kdhf deZ^[bs_ ^\h_ khljm^gbdh\ fbebpbb
hklZgh\beb \_ehkbi_^bklZ jZat_a`Z\r_]h ih ljhibgdZf ^_j_\_gkdh]h ih]hklZ GZ
\hijhk qlh hg ^_eZ_l gZ deZ^[bs_ \ klhev g_mjhqguc qZk ih`behc fm`qbgZ gbq_]h
\jZamfbl_evgh]h g_ hl\_lbe < hl^_e_ \gmlj_ggbo ^_e m aZ^_j`Zggh]h batyeb nhgZjv
gh`klZf_kdmb ihebwlbe_gh\uciZd_lihke_q_]hdeZ^[bs_gkdbc\_eh]hgsbd>ZfZdb
ijbagZekyqlhhg\ hq_j_^ghcjZagZf_j_\Zeky\aehfZlv]jh[^eykh\_jr_gbyiheh\h]h
ZdlZk ljmihf
<hehku^u[hf\klZxldh]^ZqblZ_rvaZijhlhdhebjh\Zggu_hldjh\_gby>ZfZdb
³K ]h^Zy ijh`b\Zx\ Fhkdh\kdhch[eZklbJZ[hlZx\ kh\oha_\ ^he`ghklb
kdhlgbdZiZklmoZIjh`b\Zek `_ghcHl[jZdZbf__fkugZ
Ihke_^g__\j_fyk `_ghc`b\_fiehoh\ k\yabk q_fk fZjlZ]ijh`b\Zx
hl^_evgh< fZjl_Zij_e_]m f_gyklZeb\hagbdZlvkbevgu_iheh\u_\ha[m`^_gby
J_rbe m^h\e_l\hjblv iheh\mx kljZklv k ljmihf `_gsbgu Ihr_e gZ Jh]h`kdh_
deZ^[bs_\ay\\_ehkbi_^klZf_kdm^ey\aehfZ]jh[Zb nhgZjvIjb_oZey gZdeZ^[bs_
hdheh qZkh\ M[_^b\rbkv qlh gbdh]h g_l gZr_e fh]bem g_^Z\g_]h aZohjhg_gby ih
k\_`bf\_gdZf>hju\^h]jh[Zy klZf_kdhcihiulZekyhldjulvdjurdmh^gZdhwlh]h
k^_eZlv g_ kfh] ihke_ q_]h kehfZe \_jogxx qZklv djurdb ]jh[Z b q_j_a
h[jZah\Z\rbckyijhehfaZgh]b\ulZsbeba]jh[Zljmi
< Z\]mkl_]\ f_klghcjZchgghc]Za_l_ijhq_eg_djheh]Hg[ueih^ibkZg
³Dhee_dlb\ mqbebsZ´ Y gZr_e wlm fh]bem JZajue __ ehiZlhc ihlhf ijb ihfhsb
klZf_kdb\aehfZedjurdm]jh[Zb aZgh]mklZe\ulZkdb\Zlvljmi<ulZsblv_]hg_kfh]
ihke_q_]hk deZ^[bsZmr_e
< gZqZe_ hdly[jy ih_oZe gZ Ghnb_\kdh_ deZ^[bs_ K djZx y m\b^_e k\_`mx
fh]bemQlhihohjhg_gZ`_gsbgZhij_^_ebeihgZ^ibkyfgZ\_gdZoG_\^Ze_d_y gZr_e
ehiZlm dhlhjhc klZe jZaju\Zlv fh]bem MkeurZ\ kh klhjhgu ^_j_\gb ]hehkZ
ijb[eb`Z\rbokyex^_cbkim]ZekyaZkuiZeg_fgh]hfh]bema_fe_cb m[_`Ze
< fZjl_ ] y \gh\v ijb_oZe gZ ;mjdh\kdh_ deZ^[bs_ < gbabg_ m\b^_e
k\_`mx fh]bem gZ dhlhjhc gZoh^beZkv nhlh]jZnby fheh^hc ^_\mrdb Ebph ^_\mrdb
ihgjZ\behkv b y j_rbe \kdjulv fh]bem JZaju\ __ gZ ]em[bgm hdheh f_ljZ y
h[gZjm`be qlh ^Zevr_ gZoh^blky \h^Z Z a_fey f_jaeZy b __ ljm^gh dhiZlv Ihwlhfm
j_rbehldZaZlvkyhlaZfukeZ
Q_j_a g_kdhevdh ^g_c ijb_oZe gZ ;mjdh\kdh_ deZ^[bs_ GZr_e ehiZlm b klZe
jZaju\Zlvfh]bemGZqZekykbevguc^h`^vdhiZlvklZehljm^g__b yk deZ^[bsZm_oZe
ke_]dZaZkuiZ\fh]bema_fe_c
LZdbfh[jZahfy iheghklvxijbagZxk_[y\bgh\guf\ kemqZyojZajulby
fh]be´
Fh`_l eb a^jZ\hfukeysbc q_eh\_d himklblvky ^h i_j_qbke_gghc
f_jahiZdhklb" Ih\b^bfhfm g_l Hij_^_e_gb_f gZjh^gh]h km^Z >ZfZdb ]h^Z
jh`^_gby mjh`_g_p OZjvdh\kdhc h[eZklb mdjZbg_p [ue hk\h[h`^_g hl m]heh\ghc
hl\_lkl\_gghklbaZkh^_yggh_b gZijZ\e_g^eyijhoh`^_gbyijbgm^bl_evgh]he_q_gby\
ikbobZljbq_kdmx[hevgbpmki_pbZevgh]hlbiZ
G_djhnbeby [md\Zevgh ² ³ex[h\v d f_jl\uf´ hlghkblky d ^h\hevgh j_^dbf
iheh\ufba\jZs_gbyfb kqblZ_lkyikbobq_kdbfjZkkljhckl\hfIjb\_^_foZjZdl_jgh_
hibkZgb_ [hevgh]h g_djhnbeb_c ² Zil_dZjy ImZevn`jZ ² ba kZlbjbq_kdh]h jhfZgZ
njZgpmakdh]hibkZl_ey=Z[jbweyR_\Zev_³Dehrf_jev´
:il_dZjvImZevnZj\_kvfZkljZggh\_ek_[yk ^_\bpZfbe_]dh]hih\_^_gby³Hg
ijhkbe bo jZa^_lvky ^hgZ]Z aZdjulv ]eZaZ b aZ\_jgm\rbkv \ ijhklugb aZklulv
bfblbjmyljmigh_hdhq_g_gb_< jmdZohgb^he`gu[uebk`bfZlvfZe_gvdh_jZkiylb_
dhlhjh_ hg \k_]^Z ghkbe ijb k_[_ Himklb\rbkv gZ dhe_gb i_j_^ ihkl_evx ]hkih^bg
ImZevnZj^he]hieZdZegZ\aju^Z ihlhfihdb^Ze\hkdj_krbodjZkhlhdb hlijZ\eyeky
gZ deZ^[bs_ ]^_ \u[bjZe j_^db_ wiblZnbb b i_j_ibku\Ze bo \ aZibkgmx dgb`dm´
Ihke_ fgh]hqbke_gguo wjhlbq_kdbo ijbdexq_gbc ImZevnZj ihiZ^Z_l \
ikbobZljbq_kdmx debgbdm ]^_ ³g_dbc ikbobZlj gh\_cr_c rdheu´ jZkdjuelZdb
ijbqbgu _]h g_^m]Z ³\ \hajZkl_ q_lujgZ^pZlb e_l Zil_dZjv bkiulZe k\h_ i_j\h_
k_dkmZevgh_ \heg_gb_ m ihkl_eb mf_jr_c dmabgu ^\Z^pZlblj_oe_lg_c djZkZ\bpu
dhlhjmxhgh[h`Ze\lZcg_Kf_rZggucaZiZop\_lh\\ f_jl\h]hl_eZk lZdhckeZ^hklghc
kbehc aZiZe \ iZfylv fheh^h]h ImZevnZjZ qlh \ihke_^kl\bb _]h l_fgu_ bgklbgdlu
g_ij_klZgghklj_fbebkv\_jgmlvkyd wlhfmhsms_gbx´
< gZklhys__\j_fy\ M]heh\ghfDh^_dk_Jhkkbbkms_kl\m_lki_pbZevgZyklZlvy
h[ hkd\_jg_gbb b h]jZ[e_gbb fh]be Ih^ wlm klZlvx fh`gh ih^\_klb b kZfhqbggu_
i_j_aZohjhg_gby ohly bgh]^Z ih[m^bl_evgufb ijbqbgZfb d wlbf ^_ckl\byf kem`Zl b
[eZ]hjh^gu_ ih[m`^_gby LZd lZcdhf ghqvx [ueZ i_j_aZohjhg_gZ mf_jrZy \ ]h^m\^h\ZibkZl_ey:e_dkZg^jZ=jbgZGbgZGbdheZ_\gZ=jbgIjhba\heqbgh\gbdh\g_
iha\hebe\uihegblv__ ihke_^gxx\hex²[ulvihohjhg_gghcjy^hfk fm`_fLh]^Z
^jmavy b ihdehggbdb l\hjq_kl\Z =jbgZ jbkdmy fgh]bf ijbreb ghqvx gZ deZ^[bs_
KlZjh]hDjufZ\ujueb__ ]jh[b ih^ohjhgbeb\ h]jZ^md fm`mEbrve_lkimklyhgb
j_rbebkvjZkkdZaZlvh[wlhf\ `mjgZe_³Jh^bgZ´
GZ kljZgbpZo wlhc ]eZ\u l_kgh i_j_ie_ebkv jZkkdZau h[ Zjo_heh]Zo b
deZ^[bs_gkdbo \hjZo [eZ]hjh^guo ex^yo b hkd\_jgbl_eyo h gZmd_ b km_\_jbyo h
ijZ\^_b \ufukeZoGh_s_[he__i_kljucdZe_c^hkdhim^b\bl_evguonZdlh\`^_ll_[y
qblZl_ev\ ke_^mxs_c]eZ\_
EBL?J:LMJ:
FZjdL\_g Ijbdexq_gbyLhfZKhc_jZKh[jkhq\ \hkvfblhfZoFÄl,9
Iuey_\FB KlZjucI_l_j[mj]KI_l_j[mj]Ba^:KKm\hjbgZ
R_\Zev_ = Dehrf_jev F ³Om^h`_kl\_ggZy ebl_jZlmjZ´ Ghqv gZ KlZjh
Djufkdhf deZ^[bs_ ³Jh^bgZ´ ‹ Fmfby \ hi_jZpbhgghc ³GZmdZ b `bagv´
1 Fbjhg_gdh H KqZklv_ gZ g_kqZklv_ g_ ihkljhbrv ³<_q_jgbc E_gbg]jZ^´
‹ n_\jZey
=hj[h\kdbc:K_f_gh\X AZdjulu_kljZgbpubklhjbbF³Fukev´
I_jkb^kdb_gZjh^gu_Zg_d^hluF³GZmdZ´
=hlv_ L Iml_r_kl\b_ \ Jhkkbx F ³Fukev´ Dhkmevgbdh\ : GZrbf f_jl\uf
gm`guqZkh\u_³DhfkhfhevkdZyijZ\^Z´k_gly[jy
LhdZj_\bq D G =j_dh\Z L B Ih ke_^Zf fbgm\rbo wib^_fbc E_gba^Zl Ihkf_jlgZy^bkdjbfbgZpby³Dhjjv_j_^_eeZk_jZ´BlZebyfZy
³IjZ\^Z´‹ bxgyAeh^hj_´> Kms_kl\mxlebijhdeylbynZjZhgh\"
ihfZl_jbZeZf³B^`oir_g]Za_ll´³Kh\_lkdZydmevlmjZ´fZy
LZjZkh\: Hkd\_jgbl_ev²³Sblb f_q´‹ DZe_^bgK Kfbj_ggh_deZ^[bs_³Gh\ucfbj´‹ Lmj]_g_\BK Hlpub ^_lbE³E_gba^Zl´
=E:<:;9,,,
Aeu_f_jl\_pu
DZd [ueh ihdZaZgh \ ]eZ\Zo ihk\ys_gguo ih]j_[Zevguf h[jy^Zf ihohjhgguc
h[jy^ hdZaZeky h^gbf ba gZb[he__ dhgk_j\Zlb\guo we_f_glh\ dmevlmju [eZ]h^Zjy
mklhcqb\hklb hij_^_eyxsbo ij_^klZ\e_gbc gZ [Za_ dhlhjuo hg knhjfbjh\Zeky G_
kemqZcgh ojbklbZgbaZpby bf_ggh \ wlhc h[eZklb g_ ijbg_keZ kdhevdhgb[m^v
kms_kl\_gguo j_amevlZlh\ < p_glj_ ih]j_[Zevgh]h jblmZeZ hdZaZeky kljZo ijbq_f g_
kljZo i_j_^ kf_jlvx Z kljZo i_j_^ f_jl\uf hglh b ih^^_j`b\Ze kljh]hklv
kh[ex^_gby b ihjZabl_evgmx mklhcqb\hklv ^Zggh]h jblmZeZ \ l_q_gb_ fgh]bo \_dh\
JblmZevgu_h[jy^ubf_ebij_^hojZgbl_evgmxp_evhgb^he`gu[ueb kihkh[kl\h\Zlv
lhfmqlh[uh]jZ^blv`b\uohlaeh]hZ ih^qZkb ]m[bl_evgh]h\ebygbyf_jl\uo
>Z`_^hk_]h^gyrg_]h^gy\ ih]j_[ZevghcljZ^bpbbkhojZgbebkvhl]hehkdbwlbo
^j_\gbo jblmZeh\ b \_jh\Zgbc LZd kqblZ_lky h[yaZl_evguf \ughkblv ihdhcgbdZ ba
^\_j_c\i_j_^gh]Zfb<jy^ebdlhk_]h^gyjZa^mfu\Z_lgZ^bklhdZfbwlh]hh[jy^Z:
ijbqbgZ_]h\k_\ lhf`_kljZo_i_j_^f_jl\ufb²gZ^h\ug_klb_]h lZd qlh[uhgg_
gZr_e ^hjh]b gZaZ^ g_ \_jgmeky ?s_ \ ijhrehf \_d_ \ wlbo `_ p_eyo jZa[bjZeb ^ey
\ughkZihdhcgbdZihlhehdbebkl_guba[u²f_jl\ucg_^he`_gagZlv]^_gZoh^blky
^\_jvbgZq_hgkfh`_l\ha\jZlblvky
Bklhdb wlbo jblmZeh\ ke_^m_l bkdZlv \ ij_^klZ\e_gbyo i_j\h[ulguo ie_f_g <
khhl\_lkl\mxs_c]eZ\_fum`_jZkkdZau\Zebh ih\k_f_klgh jZkijhkljZg_gghf h[uqZ_
wihob g_heblZ k\yau\Zlv f_jl\h]h i_j_^ ih]j_[_gb_f qlh[u hg g_ fh] \_jgmlvky b
\j_^blv`b\uf
KhojZgbebkvwlbjblmZeub mg_dhlhjuokh\j_f_gguogZjh^h\gZoh^ysbokygZ
gZqZevguo wlZiZo dmevlmjgh]h jZa\blby Wlgh]jZn gZqZeZ ;; \_dZ >`_cfk >`hj^`
Njwa_j khh[sZ_l qlh m fZg]Zjh\ \hbgkl\_ggh]h ie_f_gb \ G_iZe_ hieZdb\Zxsb_
ihdhcgbdZ jh^kl\_ggbdb lsZl_evgh aZ]hjZ`b\Zxl ^hjh]m hl _]h fh]beu d ^hfm
dhexqbfo\hjhklhfhiZkZykvdZd[uihdhcgbdg_\a^mfZe\_jgmlvky\ jh^gmxk_fvx
< nhevdehj_b fbnheh]bbfgh]bogZjh^h\\klj_qZxlkyij_^klZ\e_gbyh ³`b\uo
f_jl\_pZo´gZ^_e_gguohkh[hck\_jot_kl_kl\_gghckbehcdhlhju_fh]eb\uoh^blvba
fh]beu Wlh [ueb aeu_ f_jl\_pu hgb gZiZ^Zeb gZ ex^_c ih_^Zeb bo beb ibeb bo
djh\v fh]eb gZkueZlv [he_agb b kf_jlv G_dhlhju_ bkke_^h\Zl_eb kqblZxl qlh
ijhbkoh`^_gb_wlbo\_jh\ZgbcaZ\bk_ehhlbklhjbq_kdboijbqbghlijhlb\hj_qbybeb
[hjv[u^\moih]j_[Zevguoh[uqZ_\²kh``_gbyb ih]j_[_gby
<_kvfZ fgh]hqbke_ggu nhevdehjgu_ ij_^klZ\e_gby h aeuo f_jl\_pZo ² wlh b
gZjh^gu_i_kgbb kdZadbb [uebgub [uebqdbb [u\ZevsbguQZs_\k_]h\ jZkkdZaZo
h aeuof_jl\_pZofu\klj_qZ_fkyk \ZfibjZfbmiujyfb\mj^ZeZdZfb
Keh\h \Zfibj ihy\behkv \ aZiZ^gh_\jhi_ckdbo yaudZo k ;9,, \_dZ Gb \
kj_^g_\_dh\hc eZlugb gb ^Z`_ \ ^j_\g_ b kj_^g_g_f_pdhf yaudZo _]h _s_ g_l GZ
AZiZ^ ?\jhiu hgh i_j_reh ba =_jfZgbb dhlhjZy \ k\hx hq_j_^v i_j_gyeZ _]h m
x`ghkeZ\ygkdbo gZjh^h\ m dhlhjuo hgh ba\_klgh k ;9 \_dZ Keh\h \Zfibj m keZ\yg
h[jZah\Zehkv hl [he__ ^j_\g_]h l_jfbgZ miujv Miujv ² wlh fbnheh]bq_kdbc h[jZa
keZ\ygkdbo gZjh^guo ih\_jbc Hg ba\_kl_g m mdjZbgp_\ mibj \Zfibj [_ehjmkh\
\miZj iheydh\ XSLRU q_oh\ XSLU k_j[h\ \ ;9²;9, \_d_ ² mibj iha`_ ²
\Zfibj [he]Zj \Zfibj \Zibj \tibj < nhjf_ ³\Zfibj´ wlh keh\h \hreh ih
\b^bfhfmq_j_ak_j[h\\h\k__\jhi_ckdb_yaudb< ^j_\g_keZ\ygkdbo^hojbklbZgkdbo
\_jh\Zgbyomiujv[ueh^gbfbaij_^f_lh\dmevlZihkeh\ZfGZqZevgh]he_lhibkgh]h
k\h^Z keZ\yg_ ij_`^_ q_f ihdehgylvky I_jmgm ijbghkbeb `_jl\u ³miujyf b
[_j_]bgyf´
< [hevrbgkl\_ kemqZ_\ \Zfibj b miujv bf_xl h^gh agZq_gb_ b h[hagZqZxl
\klZ\r_]h ba fh]beu f_jl\_pZ dhlhjuc \ukZku\Z_l djh\v m kiysbo ex^_c Ih
gZjh^gufih\_jvyf_kebdZdhcgb[m^vq_eh\_dklZemiuj_fb oh^blghqvxiha_fe_lh
gZ^hkgh\Z\ujulv_]hl_ehbaa_febb ijhgablvk_j^p_hkbgh\ufdhehfLh]^Zf_jl\_p
i_j_klZg_l [ulv miuj_f KqblZ_lky qlh mdmr_gguc miuj_f kZf \ k\hx hq_j_^v
klZgh\blky\ZfibjhfFh`ghaZjZg__agZlvdlh[m^_l\Zfibjhf²lZdhcq_eh\_dbf__l
^\hcghcjy^am[h\\hjlmwlhhkh[_gghqZklh\klj_qZehkvm fZe_gvdbo^_l_cihy\e_gb_
dhj_gguo am[h\ ijb _s_ g_\uiZ\rbo fhehqguo dhlhju_ ih ih\_jvx qZs_ \k_]h \
lZdhfkemqZ_jZghmfbjZxlb ihke_kf_jlbe_lZxlghqvxih^h[ghe_lmqbffurZf
Ihke_^g__ih\_jv_[uehjZkijhkljZg_gh\ hkgh\ghf\ Ihevr_]^_lZdbo^_l_c
\Zfibjh\gZau\Zeb³kljb]Zfb´ VWU]\JD
M k_j[h\b jmkkdboh[jZamiujy\ZfibjZkf_rZekyk fbnheh]bq_kdbfh[jZahf
\hedZh[hjhlgy ² ³\mdh^eZdZ´ hlkx^Z b bkdZ`_ggh_ ³\mj^ZeZd´ \hr_^r__ \
om^h`_kl\_ggmxebl_jZlmjm
Ih\_jvyk\yaZggu_k h[hjhlgyfbgZklhevdhjZkijhkljZg_gu\ bklhjbb?\jhiu
qlh wlhl n_ghf_g ^Z`_ ihemqbe kh[kl\_gguc l_jfbg ² ebdZgljhiby EbdZgljhiu \
nhevdehj_ [he__ ^j_\gb_ nb]mju g_`_eb \Zfibju Hgb hibkZgu \ ^_lZeyo _s_
^j_\g_jbfkdbfb ebl_jZlhjZfb :glbqgu_ Z\lhju ml\_j`^Zxl qlh h[hjhlgb ² wlh
fm`qbgubeb`_gsbgudhlhju_fh]mlij_\jZsZlvky\ \hedh\Z aZl_f[jh^blv\ lZdhf
\b^_ihghqZfhohlykv^eyijhiblZgbyaZq_eh\_q_kdbffykhf
Fgh]b_\h\j_f_gZjbfkdbobfi_jZlhjh\\_jbebqlhg_dbc\her_[gucihjhrhd
fh`_lij_\jZlblvq_eh\_dZ\ h[hjhlgyIjbihevah\Zgbbihjhrdhfgm`ghh[yaZl_evgh
klhylvijbemgghfk\_l_]heufgZdju\rbkv\heqv_crdmjhcb ijhbaghkyhij_^_e_ggu_
aZdebgZgby
<ijhq_f b wlh ² e_]_g^u Qlh fh`_l e_`Zlv \ bo hkgh\_" >Z \hl ohly [u l_
g_[_aua\_klgu_kemqZbdh]^Zikbobq_kdbg_ghjfZevgu_ex^bbf_xlijb\uqdmjuqZlv
iheaZlv gZ q_l\_j_gvdZo b ^Z`_ gZiZ^Zlv gZ hdjm`Zxsbo pZjZiZykv b dmkZykv A^_kv
q_eh\_dklZgh\blky[he__\k_]hihoh`bfgZ\hedZ
Djhf_ lh]h \hed ² h^gh ba g_fgh]bo `b\hlguo \ ?\jhi_ dhlhju_ \ ]heh^gh_
\j_fygZiZ^ZxlgZex^_c
G_kfhljy gZ lh qlh \_jZ \ fklbl_evguo ihdhcgbdh\ \klj_qZ_lky ih\k_f_klgh \
?\jhi_ b ^jm]bo qZklyo k\_lZ deZkkbq_kdhx kljZghx \_ju \ miuj_c gm`gh ijbagZlv
Jhkkbx b \hh[s_ keZ\ygkdb_ a_feb hkh[_ggh ;_ehjmkkbx MdjZbgm b h[eZklv x`guo
keZ\yg <_jZ \ miuj_c mihfbgZ_lky \ ^j_\g_jmkkdbo ojbklbZgkdbo ihmq_gbyo \
e_lhibkb\ EZ\j_glv_\kdhfkibkd_
< yauq_kdb_ \j_f_gZ keh`bebkv ij_^klZ\e_gby h ^\mo \b^Zo ihdhcgbdh\ ²
k\hbo ij_^dh\ ijZsmjh\ ihfh]Zxsbo ihlhfdZf ^h[juo ihdjh\bl_e_c jh^Z b ³aeuo
f_jl\_pZo´ miujyo \ dhlhjuo ij_\jZsZebkv ³qm`b_´ bghie_f_ggu_ ihdhcgbdb
mf_jrb_g_\ k\h_fjh^_ie_f_gb
Miujyfb kqblZeb lZd`_ ex^_c mf_jrbo ^h kjhdZ \ j_amevlZl_ g_kqZklbc l _
ih[_`^_gguo aeufb kbeZfb b ihdhcgbdh\ ebr_gguo ljZ^bpbhgghc ih]j_[Zevghc
h[jy^ghklb
³AZeh`guo ihdhcgbdh\´ l _ \k_o g__kl_kl\_ggh mf_jrbo ² ³m[bluo
aZ[em^b\rboky k ^_j_\Z iZ^rbo´ g_ ohjhgbeb ih h[uqghfm h[jy^m b \ wlhf g_
ke_^m_l\bgblvp_jdh\vlZddZdhgZhldZau\ZeZ\ ih]j_[_gbbebrvkZfhm[bcpZf?keb
`_ lZdhc ³f_jl\yd´ hdZau\Zeky ihohjhg_gguf gZ h[s_f deZ^[bs_ lh hg fh] ih
gZjh^guf ij_^klZ\e_gbyf klZlv ijbqbghc [hevrbo h[sbo g_kqZklbc ?keb g_kqZklv_
ijhbkoh^beh lh gZ^e_`Zeh \udhiZlv miujy ba fh]beu ijhgablv _]h hkbgh\uf dhehf
bebh[eblv\h^hc\ kemqZ_aZkmobb \u[jhkblvljmi\hgk deZ^[bsZ
<eZ^bfbjkdbc _ibkdhi K_jZibhg \ ]h^m \h \j_fy \_ebdhc ³kdm^hklb´
hkm`^Zeih^h[gu_^_ckl\by
³H [_amfv_aeh_hfZeh\_jv_Kbfeb[h]Zmfhebl_qlhmlhieZbebm^Z\e_ggbdZ
\u]j_klb"Kbfeb[h]Zohs_l_mlbrblb"´
H ih^h[guoh[uqZyoibkZe\ ;9,\_d_FZdkbf=j_d
³L_e_kZ mlhie_gguo beb m[b_gguo b ih\_j`_gguo g_ kih^h[eyxs_ y
ih]j_[ZgbxghgZihe_ba\e_dr_bohlugy_fdheb_f´lh_klvijhludZ_fdhevyfb
Wlhl kihkh[ [hjv[u k miujyfb b aeufb f_jl\_pZfb ² \h]gZlv \ fh]bem
hkbgh\uc dhe ijhldgmlv dhehf \ujuluc ba fh]beu ljmi mihfbgZ_lky m \k_o
keZ\ygkdbo gZjh^h\ \ kZfu_ jZaebqgu_ dmevlmjgu_ wihob ;uebqdb b [u\Zevsbgu
aZibkZggu_ \ ;; \_d_ jZkkdZau\Zxl h[ mki_rghf ^_ckl\bb wlh]h jblmZeZ \ [hjv[_ k
\klZxsbfb ba fh]be f_jl\_pZfb m`_ \ gZrb ^gb H[uqgh lZdZy [u\ZevsbgZ
aZdZgqb\Z_lkykeh\Zfb
³?fm lh _klv \klZxs_fm ba fh]beu ih ghqZf f_jl\_pm lh]^Z \ fh]bem dhe
hkbgh\uc\[beb²hgb g_ijboh^be[hevr_<b^ghhkbgZa^hjh\h\ebyeZ´
H^gZdh iheghklvx ^h\_jylvky k\b^_l_evkl\Zf lZdbo [uebq_d b [u\Zevsbg
g_evay ² \ gbo fh]ml ijbkmlkl\h\Zlv we_f_glu \ufukeZ klhcdb_ nhevdehjgu_
rlZfiu
Gh h l_o `_ kihkh[Zo [hjv[u kh ³aeufb f_jl\_pZfb´ k\b^_l_evkl\mxl b
hnbpbZevgu_^hdmf_glu< ]h^m\ dZaZqv_cklZgbp_<_leygd_\kiuogmeZwib^_fby
qmfuKj_^bgZk_e_gbygZqZeZkviZgbdZDlhlh\kihfgbeqlh:e_dkZg^jFZjl_fvygh\
keu\rbc \ gZjh^_ dhe^mghf mf_j kZfuf i_j\uf _s_ e_lhf b ydh[u mfbjZy
ijhjhqbe qlh \kdhj_ \k_ ihc^ml \ke_^ aZ gbf Qlh[u kgylv ^_ckl\b_ _]h ijhdeylby
klZjbdb j_rbeb \ujulv ]jh[ b \[blv \ ljmi dhe^mgZ hkbgh\uc dhe WlZ Zdpby ebrv
kihkh[kl\h\ZeZjZkijhkljZg_gbxbgn_dpbb
< ]h^m \ f_kl_qd_ ;_^__\h dj_klvyg_ q_j_fbku ihklZgh\beb gZ k_evkdhf
koh^_?rdbrfmFmjheb_\mi_j\mx`_jl\mohe_ju\udhiZlvbafh]beui_j_\_jgmlv
\gba ebphf b aZ[blv _c dhe \ kibgm >_eh \ lhf qlh ihdhcgZy ijb `bagb keueZ
dhe^mgv_c b ihlhfm jZkijZ\Z k __ ljmihf ^he`gZ [ueZ ih fg_gbx dj_klvyg
hklZgh\blvwib^_fbx
Rbjhdh jZkijhkljZg_ggu_ m fgh]bo _\jhi_ckdbo gZjh^h\ hkh[_ggh m keZ\yg
\_jh\Zgby h[ hojZgyxs_c jheb hkbgh\h]h dheZ \[blh]h \ fh]bem ³[em`^Zxs_]h´
ihdhcgbdZ qZs_ \k_]h ² dhe^mgZ bf_xl hq_gv ^Z\gxx ljZ^bpbx Fu m`_ \b^_eb
qlh h[ wlhf h[uqZ_ mihfbgZxl b FZdkbf =j_d \ ;9, \_d_ b \eZ^bfbjkdbc _ibkdhi
K_jZibhg\ ;,,,\_d_AZnbdkbjh\Zghgb \[he__^j_\gbo nhevdehjguo fZl_jbZeZo²
[uebgZob kdZadZoLZd]^_`_bkdZlvbklhdbwlh]h`b\mq_]hh[uqZy"
<b^bfh \ jblmZe_ k\yau\Zgby ihdhcgbdZ m i_j\h[ulguo ie_f_g qlh[u
aZklZ\blv f_jl\h]h hklZ\Zlvky \ fh]be_ ?s_ \ br_\Zjkdhc Zjo_heh]bq_kdhc dmevlmj_
kj_^gyy?\jhiZ,lukyq_e_lb_^hgZr_cwjurbjhdhaZnbdkbjh\Zgh[uqZc\[b\Zlv\
fh]beuhjm`b_bebhjm^byljm^Zijh[b\ZyhklZgdbihdhcgbdZihf_s_ggu_\ mjgmbeb
\ yfmqlh[ugZdj_idhijb\yaZlvbod a_fe_
H[uqZc jZajmrZlv ih]j_[_gby ba^Z\gZ [ue jZkijhkljZg_g m fgh]bo gZjh^h\
fbjZP_evwlbojZajmr_gbc[ueZg_h^ghagZqghcgh\k_]^ZfZ]bq_kdhc²lZdhc\u\h^
[ue k^_eZg Zjo_heh]hf W : Kufhgh\bq_f bamqZ\rbf ih]j_[_gb_ q_jgyoh\kdhc
Zjo_heh]bq_kdhc wihob ³FZkkh\u_ jZajmr_gby jZggbo Q_jgyoh\kdbo fh]be
ijhba\h^bebkv g_khfg_ggh k fZ]bq_kdbfb p_eyfb ² ^ey lh]h qlh[u ij_^hojZgblv
`b\uohl\hh[jZ`Z_fh]h\ebygbymf_jrbo´
LZdbf h[jZahf \_jZ \ ³aeuo f_jl\_ph\´ \Zfibjh\ miuj_c ^hklZeZkv
q_eh\_q_kl\m\ gZke_^kl\hhli_j\h[ulgh]hi_jbh^Z _]h bklhjbb
< ;,; \_d_ ihy\eyxlky i_j\u_ ebl_jZlmjgu_ h[jZ[hldb gZjh^guo kdZaZgbc h
³aeuo f_jl\_pZo´ b k l_o ihj kx`_l wlhl klZgh\blky \_kvfZ jZkijhkljZg_gguf \
jZkkdZaZoih\_klyojhfZgZo
< ]h^m Ijhki_j F_jbf_ ba^Z_l ³K[hjgbd beebjbikdbo klbohl\hj_gbc
Ä=maeZkh[jZgguo\ >ZefZpbb;hkgbbOhj\Zlbbb =_jp_]h\bg_´GZkZfhf^_e_wlb
i_kgb [ueb gZibkZgu kZfbf Ijhki_jhf F_jbf_ gh \ wlm m^Zqgmx ebl_jZlmjgmx
fbklbnbdZpbx ih\_jbeb fgh]b_ \ lhf qbke_ :^Zf Fbpd_\bq b :e_dkZg^j K_j]__\bq
Imrdbg dhlhjuc i_j_\_e [hevrbgkl\h i_k_g k[hjgbdZ b ba^Ze bo \ ]h^m ih^
gZa\Zgb_f ³I_kgb aZiZ^guo keZ\yg´ Fgh]b_ i_kgb k[hjgbdZ \ qZklghklb ³=Zc^md
Ojbabq´³FZjdhYdm[h\bq´³<mj^ZeZd´[uebihk\ys_gu\ZfibjZfb miujyf
L_fZ ³aeuo f_jl\_ph\´ gZb[he__ ihegh_ hljZ`_gb_ gZreZ \ l\hjq_kl\_ G <
=h]hey b : D Lheklh]h Ihke_^gbc gZibkZe p_euc jy^ ih\_kl_c b jZkkdZah\
hkgh\ZgguogZgZjh^guoih\_jvyoh \ZfibjZogZijbf_jih\_klv³Miujv´
< ]h^m \ @_g_\_ kh[jZeky g_[hevrhc djm`hd \ dhlhjuc \oh^beb
agZf_gblucZg]ebckdbcihwljhfZglbd;Zcjhg_]h\jZqfheh^hcblZevyg_pIheb^hjb
Zg]ebckdbcihwlI_jkb;brbR_eebkhk\h_c`_ghce_lg_cFwjbR_eebb k\h^ghc
k_kljhc Fwjb ² Dewj < g_gZklgu_ ^gb ^jmavy jZa\e_dZebkv jZkkdZau\Zy ^jm] ^jm]m
kljZrgu_ bklhjbb h ijb\b^_gbyo f_jl\_pZo \ZfibjZo ;ueh j_r_gh khqbgylv
kh[kl\_ggu_ jZkkdZau R_eeb b Dewj ihqlb kjZam hldZaZebkv hl wlhc aZl_b ;Zcjhg
hklZ\beebrvnjZ]f_gluih\_klb³<Zfibj´Z Fwjbb Iheb^hjb^h\_ebk\hcaZfuk_e^h
dhgpZ JhfZg Fwjb R_eeb ³NjZgd_grl_cg´ klZe deZkkbdhc ]hlbq_kdh]h jhfZgZ b
g_h^ghdjZlgh wdjZgbabjh\Zeky \ nbevfZo m`Zkh\ Ih\_klv Iheb^hjb ³<Zfibj´
ba^ZggZy \ ]h^m lh`_ gZreZ k\hbo qblZl_e_c LZd \ aZiZ^gh_\jhi_ckdhc
ebl_jZlmj_\i_j\u_ijha\mqZeZl_fZ\Zfibjh\
Gh gZklhys_c k_gkZpb_c klZe \uoh^ \ k\_l \ ]h^m jhfZgZ ;jwfZ Klhdd_jZ
³=jZn>jZdmeZ´\u^_j`Z\rbcaZl_fg_bkqbkebfh_dhebq_kl\hi_j_ba^Zgbc
Bklhjbq_kdbc>jZdmeZ :ODG'UDFXO [uedgya_f<ZeZobbbklhjbq_kdhch[eZklb
gZl_jjblhjbbkh\j_f_gghcJmfugbb< ]h^mhgaZo\Zlbe\eZklvebrb\ij_klheZ
JZ^m ,,, b ijbagZe k_[y \ZkkZehf \_g]_jkdh]h dhjhey Kb]bafmg^Z >jZdmeZ hlebqZeky
n_ghf_gZevghc ^Z`_ ^ey lh]h \j_f_gb bahsj_gghc `_klhdhklvx h q_f khojZgbebkv
fgh]hqbke_ggu_e_]_g^ub kdZaZgbygZijbf_j^j_\g_jmkkdh_³KdZaZgb_h fmlvygkdhf
\h_\h^_ >jZdme_´ KZfh ijha\bs_ ² >jZdmeZ ² hagZqZ_l kug ^jZdhgZ beb ^vy\heZ
>jZdmeZ ;jwfZ Klhdd_jZ bf__l fZeh h[s_]h kh k\hbf bklhjbq_kdbf ijhlhlbihf Wlh
ij_`^_\k_]hdeZkkbq_kdbch[jZaf_jl\_pZ\ZfibjZ
Dgb]Z h >jZdme_\Zfibj_ ihevah\ZeZkv h]jhfg_crbf mki_ohf gh _s_ [hevr_c
ihimeyjghklvx ihevah\Zebkv kgylu_ \ _ ]h^u \ =heeb\m^_ fgh]hqbke_ggu_
nbevfum`Zkh\ihfhlb\ZfjhfZgZKlhdd_jZ>jZdmeZ\Zfibjhldjue\ dbg_fZlh]jZn_
gh\h_gZijZ\e_gb_dhlhjh_y [umkeh\ghgZa\Ze³\Zfibjbafhf´D gZklhys_fm\j_f_gb
kha^Zgukhlgbnbevfh\h \ZfibjZokj_^bgbodhg_qgh`_fZkkZ^_r_\uob [_a^Zjguo
ih^_ehdghbf_xlkyb ^_ckl\bl_evghlZeZgleb\u_ijhba\_^_gbylZdb_dZdagZf_gbluc
\b^_hdebi FZcdeZ >`_dkhgZ ³Ljbee_j´ beb Zf_jbdZgkdbc nbevf ³=heh^´ k DZljbg
>_gz\ \ ]eZ\ghc jheb Knhjfbjh\Zebkv b hij_^_e_ggu_ aZdhgu `ZgjZ Z g_dhlhju_
Zljb[mlu nbevfh\ h \ZfibjZo lZdb_ dZd ieZklfZkkh\u_ deudb ij_\jZlbebkv \
ihimeyjgmxb]jmrdm
BlZd\ gZklhys__\j_fy[eZ]h^Zjydbg_fZlh]jZnml_fZ\Zfibjh\klZeZ\_kvfZ
ihimeyjgZ gZ AZiZ^_ < gZr_c kljZg_ \Zfibjh\ \mj^ZeZdh\ ³aeuo f_jl\_ph\´ ^he]h_
\j_fy g_ imkdZeb gZ wdjZgu b gZ kljZgbpu dgb] b `mjgZeh\ h[_j_]Zy gZrm ikbobdm
klhev`_lhihjghb g_mf_ehdZdb gZrmgjZ\kl\_gghklvBkdexq_gb_fy\eyebkvebrv
³rdhevgu_´ deZkkbdb =h]hev b Imrdbg Ih\_klb h[ miujyo : D Lheklh]h
kgbkoh^bl_evgh³^himkdZebkv´ebrv\ iheguokh[jZgbyokhqbg_gbc
WjZ ]eZkghklb jZajmrbeZ b wlb g_e_iu_ aZij_lu Gh gZ g_ih^]hlh\e_ggh]h
ajbl_ey b qblZl_ey h[jmrbeZkv fZkkZ g_dZq_kl\_gghc ijh^mdpbb gZ l_fm h ³aeuo
f_jl\_pZo´ ij_`^_ \k_]h q_j_a \b^_hkZehgu <ur_e gZ wdjZgu \ ]h^m b i_j\uc
kh\_lkdbc nbevf m`Zkh\ ³K_fvy \mj^ZeZdh\´ L\hjq_kdh_ h[t_^bg_gb_ ³:bkl´
j_`bkk_ju=_ggZ^bc Debfh\ b B]hjv RZ\ebg djZcg_ ]emiuc b [_a^Zjguc Bgl_j_kZ
ba\k_]hwlh]hfmlgh]hihlhdZ³\ZfibjbafZ´aZkem`b\Z_lih`Zemcebrvim[ebdZpby\
³Gh\hf fbj_´ ih^[hjdb jZkkdZah\ E I_ljmr_\kdhc ³I_kgb \hklhqguo keZ\yg´
hkgh\ZgguogZ[uebqdZoh ³[em`^Zxsbo´ihdhcgbdZo
Y ^mfZx qlh hagZdhfb\rbkv k wlhc ]eZ\hc qblZl_ev l_i_jv kZf kfh`_l
hjb_glbjh\Zlvky \ gZoeugm\rbo gZ g_]h fZl_jbZeZo h ³aeuo f_jl\_pZo´ b hlebqblv
^_ckl\bl_evgh lZeZgleb\u_ ijhba\_^_gby hkgh\Zggu_ gZ ohjhr_f agZgbb
nhevdehjgh]hfZl_jbZeZhl[_kqbke_gguoebl_jZlmjguob dbgh\b^_hih^_ehd
EBL?J:LMJ:
LhdZj_\bqDG=j_dh\ZLB Ihke_^Zffbgm\rbowib^_fbcE³E_gba^Zl´
?j_fbgZ<B JblmZeb nhevdehjE³GZmdZ´Ih]j_[Zevguch[jy^ie_f_g
K_\_jghc?\jhiu\ ,lukyq_e_lbb^hgw²,lukyq_e_lbbgwF
Kbfhgh\bqW: FZ]byb h[jy^ih]j_[_gby\ q_jgyoh\kdmxwihom³Kh\_lkdZy
Zjo_heh]by´‹ I_lmoh\?< K_jZibhg<eZ^bfbjkdbcjmkkdbcijhih\_^gbd;,,,\_dZKI_l_j[mj]
A_e_gbg>D Hq_jdbjmkkdhcfbnheh]bbMf_jrb_g__kl_kl\_gghckf_jlvxb jmkZedb
³I_ljh]jZ^´\ui,Fbnheh]bq_kdb_jZkkdZaujmkkdh]hgZk_e_gby<hklhqghc
Kb[bjbGh\hkb[bjkd³GZmdZ´kx`_lu‹‹ Njwa_j>`>` Nhevdehj\ <_lohfaZ\_l_F³Iheblba^Zl´
Dhleyj_\kdbc::H ih]j_[Zevguoh[uqZyoyauq_kdbokeZ\ygF
Ju[Zdh\;: Yauq_kl\h^j_\gbokeZ\ygF³GZmdZ´
Klhdd_j; =jZn>jZdmeZKI_l_j[mj]
I_ljmr_\kdZyE I_kgb\hklhqguokeZ\yg³Gh\ucfbj´‹ =E:<:;,;
=hehkZbaaZ]jh[gh]hfbjZ
IjZdlbdZ g_djhfZglbb l _ h[s_gby k ^mrZfb mf_jrbo [ueZ hq_gv rbjhdh
jZkijhkljZg_gZ kj_^b jZaebqguo gZjh^h\ H^gh ba ^j_\g_crbo b ih`Zemc gZb[he__
rbjhdh ba\_klguo khh[s_gbc h g_djhfZglbb fu \klj_qZ_f \ ;b[ebb , dgb]Z PZjkl\
KZme i_j\uc pZjv bajZbevlyg ijb[ebabl_evgh ² ]] ^h g w
hdjm`_gguc\jZ]Zfbijb]eZrZ_l\her_[gbpmbafZe_gvdh]h]hjh^dZ:wg^hjub ijhkbl
__ \ua\Zlv^momf_jr_]hijhjhdZKZfmbeZ:wg^hjkdZydhe^mgvyijbf_gbeZk\hbqZju
b m\b^_eZ³dZd[u[h]Z\uoh^ys_]hbaa_feb´KZmeihijhkbehibkZlv_]hb dhe^mgvy
hl\_lbeZ qlh ³\b^bl fm`Z ij_klZj_eh]h h^_lh]h \ ^ebggmx h^_`^m´ Lh]^Z KZme
ihdehgbekyb \gh\vmkeurZebamklijbajZdZKZfmbeZkljZrgh_ij_^kdZaZgb_BajZbev
[m^_lihjZ`_g nbebklbfeygZfbZ kZfKZmekhk\hbfb kugh\vyfb gZ ke_^mxsbc ^_gv
ih]b[g_l
Ba wlh]h [b[e_ckdh]h jZkkdZaZ \b^gh qlh ^j_\g_fm BajZbex [ueb ohjhrh
agZdhfu ijZdlbdZ \uau\Zgby ^moh\ mf_jrbo beb g_djhfZglby b h[jZs_gb_ d gbf aZ
kh\_lZfbGbdZdb_kljh]b_ihklZgh\e_gbyijhlb\g_djhfZglbbg_fh]ebmgbqlh`blv__
gZklhevdh ]em[hdh hgZ mdhj_gbeZkv \ gjZ\Zo b j_eb]bb gZjh^Z H^bg ba _\jhi_ckdbo
aZdhgh\ dZjZe kf_jlvx q_j_a ih[b\Zgb_ dZfgyfb \kydh]h dlh [jZeky \uau\Zlv ^moh\
mf_jrbob h[jZsZlvkyd gbfaZijhjbpZgbyfbWlhg_kfh]ehbkdhj_gblvg_djhfZglbx
b kj_^b yauq_kdbo h[uqZ_\ \hajh`^_gguo kimkly ^he]h_ \j_fy ihke_ KZmeZ pZj_f
FZgZkkb_c [ue b h[uqZc \uau\Zgby f_jl\uo Hlh\kx^m dm^Z kljZo i_j_^ kmjh\uf
aZdhghfaZ]gZe kem`bl_e_c q_jghc fZ]bb km_\_jguc pZjv \u\_e bo gZ ^g_\ghc k\_l b
maZdhgbe bo j_f_keh H^gZdh kimkly dhjhldh_ \j_fy [eZ]hq_klb\uc pZjv Bhkby kgh\Z
ijbqbkebe\k_og_djhfZglh\d jZajy^mij_klmigbdh\
H[uqZc \uau\Zlv mf_jrbo kms_kl\h\Ze b m ij_^r_kl\h\Z\r_c BajZbex
\Z\behgkdhrmf_jkdhc dmevlmju < ^\_gZ^pZlhc i_kg_ ihwfu h =bev]Zf_r_ ]_jhc
hieZdb\Z_lk\h_]hf_jl\h]h^jm]ZWZ[Zgbb ijhkbl[h]Zf_jl\uoG_jkZem \ua\Zlv _fm
ba ih^a_fgh]h fbjZ ^mo ih]b[r_]h lh\ZjbsZ ³<aehfZc fh]bevguc kde_i b hldjhc
a_fex^Z[u^moWZ[Zgbfh]ih^h[gh\_ljmih^gylvky\\_jo´;h]\gye_]hijhkv[_b d
=bev]Zr_fm y\beky ^mo WZ[Zgb b ih\_^Ze _fm h ]hj_klghf iheh`_gbb f_jl\uo \
ih^a_fghffbj_]^_³boih`bjZ_lq_j\vb ]^_\k_ihdjulhijZohf´
KZfuc jZggbc ijbf_j g_djhfZglbb \ Zglbqghc ebl_jZlmj_ fu \klj_qZ_f \
agZf_gblhfwibah^_baH^bkk_b]^_Mebkkijbieu\Z_ld i_qZevguf[_j_]ZfgZkZfhf
djZxHd_ZgZb a^_kv\uau\Z_l^moh\baih^a_fgh]hfbjZQlh[uaZklZ\blvbo]h\hjblv
hgdhiZ_ljh\b aZdZeu\Z_lgZ^gbf\ `_jl\mh\_plZdqlh[udjh\vbokl_dZeZgZ^gh
yfu Bklhfe_ggu_ `Z`^hc ^mob kh[bjZxlky m j\Z b \uib\ \kx djh\v baj_dZxl ^ey
]_jhyk\hbijhjbpZgby
M g_djhfZglh\>j_\g_c=j_pbb^ey\uah\Z^moh\mf_jrbokms_kl\h\Zeblhevdh
kljh]h hij_^_e_ggu_ f_klZ bf_\rb_ g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh_ khh[s_gb_ k ih^a_fguf
pZjkl\hf q_j_a ijhoh^u b lj_sbgu \ a_fe_ kd\hav dhlhju_ ^mob ih\bgmykv
ijbdZaZgbx fh]eb \uoh^blv gZ ih\_joghklv LZdb_ f_klZ gZau\Zebkv hjZdmeZfb
mf_jrbo
< qbke_ wlbo hjZdmeh\ h^bg gZoh^beky [eba :hjgmfZ \ N_k]jhlbb lZf ih
ij_^Zgbx e_]_g^Zjguc fmaudZgl Hjn_c \uau\Ze ^mrm ex[bfhc b ihl_jygghc bf
W\jb^bdb < iha^g_cr__ \j_fy dhjbgnkdbc lbjZg I_jbZg^j lZd`_ ihkueZe d wlhfm
hjZdmemqlh[u\ua\Zlvl_gvk\h_cmf_jr_c`_guF_ebkkuY\b\rZykyl_gvih\_^ZeZ
qlh hgZ gZ]Zy b _c oheh^gh lZd dZd h^_`^u dhlhju_ [ueb ihohjhg_gu \f_kl_ k __
l_ehfg_^Zxl_cl_ieZb[hg_[uebkh``_guLh]^ZI_jbZg^j\_e_e\k_f`_gsbgZf
DhjbgnZ kh[jZlvky \ k\ylbebs_ =_ju L_ ihkemrgh bkihegbeb ijbdZaZgb_
gZjy^b\rbkv \ k\hb emqrb_ h^_`^u dZd ^ey ijZa^gbdZ gh dZd lhevdh hgb kh[jZebkv
lbjZg\_e_ek\hbfl_ehojZgbl_eyfkhj\Zlvkh\k_o`_gsbgh^_`^ukeh`blvbo\ dmqmb
k`_qvgZ[eZ]hk\h_cihdhcghckmijm]b
>jm]hchjZdmemf_jrbogZoh^beky[eba=_jZde_b\ <bnbgbbKiZjlZgkdbcpZjv
IZ\kZgbcjZa[b\i_jkh\\ [bl\_ijbIeZl__ihk_lbewlhf_klhb a^_kviulZeky\ua\Zlv
b mfbehklb\blv^mokemqZcghbfm[blhc\baZglbckdhc^_\mrdbihbf_gbDe_hgbdZ?_
^moy\beky_fmb ^\mkfuke_gghaZy\beqlh\k__]haZ[hlubkq_agmldh]^Zhg\_jg_lky\
KiZjlmIjhjhq_kl\hwlhk[uehkvkhkf_jlvxpZjy\kdhj_ihke_^h\Z\r_c
GZb[he__ihegh_hibkZgb_ijhp_^mju \uau\Zgby ^moh\ \ ]j_q_kdhc ebl_jZlmj_
fu gZoh^bf \ ljZ]_^bb WkobeZ ³I_jku´ >_ckl\b_ ijhbkoh^bl m fh]beu i_jkb^kdh]h
pZjy >Zjby PZjbpZ :lhkkZ `_gZ Dk_jdkZ k lj_\h]hc `^_l ba\_klbc h fm`_ b h[
h]jhfghcZjfbbdhlhjmxhgih\_eijhlb\=j_pbbIhy\ey_lky]hg_pkhh[sZxsbch[
hdhgqZl_evghfihjZ`_gbbi_jkh\ijb KZeZfbg_Ihljyk_ggZym`Zkhf b ]hj_f pZjbpZ
j_rZ_lky \ua\Zlv ba fh]beu ^mo >Zjby b kijhkblv _]h kh\_lZ K wlhc p_evx hgZ
kh\_jrZ_lgZ^fh]behc\haebygbybafhehdZf_^Z\h^u\bgZb heb\dh\h]hfZkeZZ ohj
\ wlh\j_fyih_l]bfgu\au\Zxsb_d ih^a_fguf[h]Zfijhkybo\ukeZlvgZ\_jo^mrm
mf_jr_]hpZjy>moihkemrgh\ujZklZ_lbaih^a_febb ^Z_lh]hjq_gghfmgZjh^mkh\_l
b ij_^mij_`^_gby <_jhylgh qlh Wkobe hkgh\u\Zeky \ k\h_f hibkZgbb gZ jblmZe_
h[uqghf^ey]j_q_kdbog_djhfZglh\
IbnZ]hj_ckdbcnbehkhn:iheehgbcLbZgkdbcdZdi_j_^Z_l_]h[bh]jZnNeZ\bc
NbehkljZl\ua\ZeaZdebgZgbyfb^mo:obee_kZba_]hfh]beu\ N_kkZebb=_jhc\ur_e
bak\h_c]jh[gbpu\ h[jZa_\ukhdh]hb djZkb\h]hfheh^h]hq_eh\_dZb \klmibe\ [_k_^m
k fm^j_phf
< fheh^hklbIebgbyg_dbc]jZffZlbd:ibhgm\_jyeqlhhg\ua\Zel_gv=hf_jZ
Ihwl EmdZg hklZ\be gZf jZkkdZa h k\b^Zgbb K_dklZ Ihfi_y kugZ Ihfi_y
<_ebdh]h k n_kkZebckdhc dhe^mgv_c i_j_^ [bl\hc ijb NZjkZe_ Ih ijhkv[_ Ihfi_y
klZjZy dhe^mgvy `b\rZy kj_^b fh]be h`b\beZ q_flh g_ih]j_[_ggh_ l_eh dhlhjh_
jZkkdZaZeh h lj_\h]_ ho\Zlb\r_c ih^a_fgu_ l_gb ih ih\h^m [ebadhc dZlZkljhnu
ij_^klhys_cjbfkdhfmfbjm
=hjZpbc jZkkdZau\Z_l h ^\mo \_^vfZo \uimkdZ\rbo djh\v q_jgh]h y]g_gdZ gZ^
yfhc k p_evx \ua\Zlv ^moh\ b ihemqblv hl gbo hl\_l gZ h[jZs_ggu_ d gbf \hijhku
Lb[meelZd`_]h\hjblh dhe^mgv_k\hbfi_gb_f\uau\Z\r_cbafh]beul_gbmf_jrbo
Ba\_klguc Zg]ebckdbc wlgh]jZn >`_cfk >`hj^` Njwa_j ijb\h^bl
fgh]hqbke_ggu_ ijbf_ju lh]h qlh g_djhfZglby rbjhdh ijZdlbdh\ZeZkv m
i_j\h[ulguogZjh^h\]^_\_jhylghb klhblbkdZlvbklhdbwlh]h\_jh\Zgby
LZd ZnjbdZgkdb_ ie_f_gZ [Zglm \_jyl qlh ^mob mf_jrbo \h`^_c bgh]^Z
\k_eyxlky\ l_eZ`b\uoex^_cb ijhjhq_kl\mxlbomklZfb
G_]ju X`gh]h Lh]h lZd`_ ih k\b^_l_evkl\m Njwa_jZ bf_xl h[udgh\_gb_
\uau\Zlv ^mrm mf_jr_]h @j_p aZi_jrbkv \ dhfgZl_ \uau\Z_l ^moZ dhlhjuc
ihy\b\rbkvgZqbgZ_lieZdZlvb \klmiZ_l\ jZa]h\hjkh`j_phf
Ie_fy fZjbg^Zgbf gZ x`ghf [_j_]m Gh\hc =\bg_b \h \j_fy _`_]h^guo
h[jy^h\ihk\ys_gby\uau\Z_l^mrbk\hboij_^dh\baih^a_fgh]hfbjZkbevghklmqZh
a_fex \ ijh^he`_gbb p_eh]h qZkZ gb`gbf dhgphf ebklZ dhdhkh\hc iZevfu
Ijhbkoh^bl wlh \k_]^Z ghqvx Ih^h[guf `_ h[jZahf g_dhlhju_ ie_f_gZ gZ hkljh\_
KmeZ\_kb Bg^hg_aby \uau\Zxl \h \j_fy ijZa^gbdZ ^mrb mf_jrbo \h`^_c b ]_jh_\
dhehlyh[iheojZfZ^ebgghciZedhc
GZ FZjdbakdbo hkljh\Zo Ihebg_aby `j_pu \uau\Zxl ^mrb f_jl\_ph\
i_j_k_eyxsboky \ wlh \j_fy \ l_eZ f_^bmfh\ b q_j_a gbo [_k_^mxsbo kh k\hbfb
`b\ufbjh^kl\_ggbdZfbIh\h^hf^eyh[jZs_gbyd ^momkem`blh[udgh\_ggh[he_agv
qe_gZk_fvbdh]^Z^jmavy_]h`_eZxlihemqblvkh\_lbaaZ]jh[gh]hfbjZ
Rbjhdh ijZdlbdh\ZeZkv g_djhfZglby \ >j_\g_f DblZ_ <h fgh]bo
ijhba\_^_gbyo ^j_\g_c b kj_^g_\_dh\hc dblZckdhc ebl_jZlmju bf_xlky kp_gu \uah\Z
^moh\ mf_jrbo Ijb wlhf ihjZabl_evgh kh\iZ^Zxl hibkZgby wlh]h y\e_gby \ jZaguo
ebl_jZlmjguo bklhqgbdZo hl^Ze_gguo ^jm] hl ^jm]Z bgh]^Z i_jbh^hf \ g_kdhevdh
klhe_lbc :\lhju mdZau\Zxl qlh ihy\e_gbx ^moZ ij_^r_kl\m_l oheh^ b aZiZo le_gZ
H[uqgh^momf_jr_]hfh`gh\b^_lvZ g_lhevdhh[sZlvkyk gbfq_j_af_^bmfZ
< DblZ_ ihdehg_gb_ ij_^dZf y\ey_lky hkgh\guf we_f_glhf gZpbhgZevghc
j_eb]bbihwlhfmijZdlbdZg_djhfZglbbbf_eZ_kl_kl\_ggh\k_h[s__jZkijhkljZg_gb_
Fgh]b_wlgh]jZnu;,;\_dZaZnbdkbjh\Zebrbjhdh_jZkijhkljZg_gb_wlh]hh[uqZyb \
kh\j_f_gghfbfDblZ_
G_djhfZglby [ueZ hq_gv rbjhdh jZkijhkljZg_gZ b \ Kj_^g_\_dh\hc ?\jhi_
DeZkkbq_kdbfijbf_jhfg_djhfZglbbfh`ghgZa\Zlvihy\e_gb_ijbajZdZhlpZ=Zfe_lZ
jZkkdZau\Zxs_]h kugm h k\hbo m[bcpZo IjZ\^Z =Zfe_l g_ ijb[_]Z_l d mkem]Zf
g_djhfZglh\ijbajZdihy\ey_lky\ aZfd_kZf\au\Zyh[hlfs_gbb
Ih^jh[gh_hibkZgb_g_djhfZglbbfh`ghgZclbb \³NZmkl_´\_ebdh]h=zl_
AgZf_gbluc blZevygkdbc kdmevilhj ;9, \_dZ ;_g\_gmlh Q_eebgb \ k\h_c
Z\lh[bh]jZnbb lZd hibku\Z_l k_Zgk g_djhfZglbb mqZklgbdhf dhlhjh]h _fm ijbrehkv
klZlv ³Fu hlijZ\bebkv \ Dheba_c b lZf k\ys_ggbd gZjy^b\rbkv ih kihkh[m
g_djhfZglh\ ijbgyeky q_jlblv djm]b gZ a_fe_ k kZfufb qm^_kgufb p_j_fhgbyfb
dZdb_lhevdhfh`gh\hh[jZablvDh]^Zhg[ue]hlh\hgk^_eZe\ djm]m\hjhlZb\ay\
gZk aZ jmdm h^gh]h aZ ^jm]bf ihklZ\be gZk \ djm] AZl_f ijbklmibe d aZdebgZgbyf
>ebeZkvwlZrlmdZihelhjZk ebrgbfqZkZy\behkvg_kdhevdhe_]bhgh\^moh\²KJ
lZdqlhDheba_c[ue\_kvi_j_iheg_g´
: l_i_jv ihiulZ_fky jZkdjulv g_dhlhju_ k_dj_lu g_djhfZglh\
ijhZgZebabjh\Z\ mihfygmlu_ ijbf_ju ;b[e_ckdbc jZkkdZa h [_k_^_ KZmeZ k ^mohf
KZfmbeZ ykgh ihdZau\Z_l qlh ijbajZd [ue \b^_g lhevdh kZfhc dhe^mgv_ kZf `_ pZjv
fh] lhevdh keurZlv _]h ]hehk b hl\_qZlv _fm <b^bfh lml bf_eh f_klh ohjhrh \
gZklhys__\j_fybamq_ggh_y\e_gb_qj_\h\_sZgby
Qj_\h\_sZgb_gZmqgh_gZa\Zgb_²\_gljbehd\by²wlhkihkh[ghklv]h\hjblv
g_r_\_ey]m[Zfb\ke_^kl\b_q_]hijhbaghkbfu_keh\ZdZ`mlkybkoh^ysbfbhl^jm]bo
ebp Ijb qj_\h\_sZgbb g_h[uq_g f_oZgbaf ]hehkhh[jZah\Zgby ^\b`_gby hj]Zgh\
jhlh\hcihehklbijhba\h^ylkylZdqlh^eyihklhjhggbohgbg_aZf_lguZ ]m[uhklZxlky
kh\_jr_gghg_ih^\b`gufb=hehkijbqj_\h\_sZgbbhlebqZ_lkyf_gvr_c\gylghklvx
fhghlhgghklvx b hkeZ[e_gghc kbehc qlh dklZlb ]h\hjy \_kvfZ oZjZdl_jgh ^ey
³aZfh]bevguo´ ]hehkh\ Y ih^jh[gh ZgZebabjh\Ze f_oZgbaf qj_\h\_sZgby \ dgb]_
³Kj_^b aZiZoh\ b a\mdh\´ >ey hiulguo qj_\h\_sZl_e_c g_ khklZ\ey_l hkh[h]h ljm^Z
kha^Z\Zlv beexabx \hagbdgh\_gby ]hehkZ ba ex[h]h f_klZ dhfgZlu ijbq_f hgb
ijhba\hevghfh]mlf_gylvdZdl_f[juwlbo³]hehkh\´lZdb gZijZ\e_gb_boa\mqZgby
BlZd]hehkZba³aZ]jh[gh]h´fbjZfh]ml[ulv\ jy^_kemqZ_\Z kdhj__\k_]h²
ihqlb \k_]^Z ebrv eh\dbf pbjdh\uf ljxdhf Gh dZd `_ lh]^Z hlghkblvky d
k\b^_l_evkl\Zf ihy\e_gby h[jZah\ mf_jrbo ex^_c \hagbdZxsbo ih ijbdZam
g_djhfZglh\"
< ;9,klhe_lbb\ DjZdh\_`beiZgL\Zj^h\kdbc²]_jhcihevkdboe_]_g^i_k_g
gZjh^guo jZkkdZah\ ?]h \hki_\Zeb ihwlu h g_f ibkZeb ba\_klgu_ ijhaZbdb Hg
aZgbfZeky Zkljheh]b_c \uau\Zgb_f ^moh\ b \kydbfb ih^h[gufb ³g_djhfZglkdbfb´
^_eZfbKhojZgbebkvk\b^_l_evkl\Zkh\j_f_ggbdh\h lhfqlhhgihijhkv[_ihevkdh]h
dhjhey Kb]bafmg^Z:\]mklZ \uau\Ze ijbajZd ;Zj[Zju JZ^ab\beem\gu _]h fheh^hc
`_gug_aZ^he]hi_j_^l_fkdhgqZ\r_cky
Dh]^Zlh^Z\ghdZdkhh[sZxlklZjbggu_ojhgbdb\ h^ghfbadhkl_eh\Ihevrb
ijhbahreh hq_gv kljZggh_ kh[ulb_ ² \h \j_fy [h]hkem`_gby i_j_^ fheysbfbky gZ
nhg_dZ^bevgh]h^ufZ\^jm]ihy\bekyq_jl>_kyldbfheysbokyy\kl\_gghjZa]ey^_ebm
g_]h jh]Z o\hkl b gh]b k dhiulZfb Ihiju]Z\ \ \ha^mo_ ³\jZ] jh^Z q_eh\_q_kdh]h
bkq_a´
Ijhrehg_fZehe_lihkl_i_gghh[wlhfijhbkr_kl\bbaZ[uebb \hlkgh\Z\ lhf
`_dhkl_e_q_jlihdZaZek\hxf_jadmxjh`mIjZ\^ZgZwlhljZahq_\b^p_f[uelhevdh
h^bgbafhgZoh\²ijb\jZlgbdfhgZklujy
I_j_im]Zgguc \lhjbqguf ihy\e_gb_f q_jlZ hg r\ujgme \ g_]h p_jdh\gufb
dexqZfb
AZ]Z^hqgufijhbkr_kl\b_f\ dhkl_e_aZbgl_j_kh\Zebkvex[bl_ebklZjbguHgb
h[jZlbeb\gbfZgb_gZlhqlh\ dhkl_e_gZihq_lghff_kl_\bk_ehaZiue_ggh_a_jdZeh
Hgh [ueh hq_gv klZjuf b hlghkbehkv d l_f \j_f_gZf dh]^Z kl_deygguo a_jdZe \
Ihevr_ _s_ g_ agZeb Z ba]hlh\eyeb bo ba ki_pbZevguo f_lZeebq_kdbo kieZ\h\ b d
k\h_fm m^b\e_gbx m\b^_eb gZ jZf_ gZ^ibkv gZ eZlbgkdhf yaud_ ba dh_c y\kl\h\Zeh
qlh a_jdZeh ijbgZ^e_`Zeh dhfm [u \u ^mfZeb" ² agZf_gblhfm g_djhfZglm iZgm
L\Zj^h\kdhfm³dhlhjuc_]hmihlj_[eyeijbk\hbofZ]bq_kdboaZgylbyo´Ex[hiulgZy
^_lZev bkke_^h\Zl_eb gZreb k\b^_l_evkl\Z kh\j_f_ggbdh\ qlh ijb ³g_djhfZglkdhf
k_Zgk_´\h\j_fydhlhjh]hL\Zj^h\kdbc\uau\Ze^modhjhe_\ugZklhebd_hdhehq_j_iZ
gZoh^behkvjZkiylb_b a_jdZeh
MklZgh\b\ k\yav f_`^m lZbgkl\_ggufb y\e_gbyfb h dhlhjuo jZkkdZau\Zeb
e_]_g^u b a_jdZehf L\Zj^h\kdh]h bkke_^h\Zl_eb aZreb \ lmibd Ijhreb _s_
^_kylbe_lby B \hl g_ lZd ^Z\gh a_jdZeh L\Zj^h\kdh]h kgh\Z ijb\e_deh \gbfZgb_
mq_guoDh]^Zijbgyebkv_]hbkke_^h\ZlvlhhdZaZehkvqlhgZg_f\u]jZ\bjh\Zguih^
hij_^_e_gguf m]ehf jbkmgdb hljZ`Zxsb_ hl k_[y k\_l < lhf qbke_ [ue jbkmghd
bah[jZ`Zxsbc nb]mjm fheh^hc `_gsbgu ² \hl ]^_ kdju\Zeky k_dj_l ijbajZdZ
;Zj[ZjuJZ^ab\beem\gu;ueZlZfb nb]mjZq_jlZdhlhjuclZdkfmlbefheysbokyb lZd
i_j_im]ZefhgZoZ
Dhjhq_ ]h\hjy a_jdZeh hdZaZehkv ³\her_[guf a_jdZehf´ ba\_klguf \ kj_^gb_
\_dZ gZ <hklhd_ hldm^Z hgh ijhgbdeh aZl_f gZ AZiZ^ Ijb ihfhsb lZdbo a_jdZe
kj_^g_\_dh\ufbfZ]Zfbkh\_jrZebkvfgh]b_³qm^_kZ´
LsZl_evghh[ke_^h\Z\ a_jdZeh mq_gu_ mklZgh\beb qlh ^ey mki_rgh]h ³k_ZgkZ´
[ueh g_h[oh^bfh qlh[u a_jdZeh gZoh^behkv ih^ kljh]h hij_^_e_gguf m]ehf ih
hlghr_gbx d kbevghfm bklhqgbdm k\_lZ gZijbf_j d fgh]hk\_qghfm k\_lbevgbdm Z
i_j_^a_jdZehfrZ]Zo\ ljb^pZlbkhjhdZhlg_]h^he`_g[uedem[blvkyeb[hiZjeb[h
^ufdZ^bevgbpaZf_gyxsbowdjZgLZd\ dem[Zo^ufZihy\eyebkvi_j_^ihjZ`_ggufb
ajbl_eyfb\uoh^puk lh]hk\_lZ
< bklhjbb k ³y\e_gbyfb´ dhjhe_\kdhc `_gu \k_ [ueh aZjZg__ ij_^mkfhlj_gh
iZghfL\Zj^h\kdbf: kq_jlhf²kemqZcghklvIh\b^bfhfm]hlh\ykvd ijZa^gbqghc
kem`[_fhgZobhqbklbeba_jdZehhliueb< ^_gvijZa^gbdZdhkl_e[ueyjdhhk\_s_g
Emqbk\_lZiZ^ZebgZa_jdZehD ihlhedmih^gbfZekydZ^bevguc^ufB ³mijylZgguc´\
a_jdZe_q_jlbdihy\bekyi_j_^fheysbfbky
Ijb koh^guo mkeh\byo hg ihy\beky b \h \lhjhc jZa ² i_j_^ ijb\jZlgbdhf
fhgZklujyB wlh[ue_]hihke_^gbc³\uoh^\ k\_l´I_j_im]ZggucfhgZohl[jhkbehl
k_[y k\yadm dexq_c hgb ihiZeb \ a_jdZeh b ih\j_^beb ]jZ\xjm mdjulmx \ lhes_
a_jdZevgh]hkehy
G_khfg_ggh hilbq_kdbc wnn_dl ijh_dpbhggh]h ³\her_[gh]h nhgZjy´ beb
³\her_[gh]h a_jdZeZ´ ijbf_gyeky gZ fgh]bo k_ZgkZo g_djhfZglh\ ?s_ \ >j_\g_f
?]bil_\ ihemfjZd_ojZfh\`j_puijh^_eu\Zebg_[hevrmxs_evdhlhjZyhldju\ZeZkv
\ gm`gucfhf_glGZdjurmojZfZ\a[bjZeky`j_pb aZgbfZelZdh_iheh`_gb_qlh_]h
bah[jZ`_gb_ ijhc^y s_ev iZ^Zeh gZ h^gm ba kl_g ojZfZ Dh]^Z `j_p gZqbgZe
^\b]Zlvky ijboh^beZ \ ^\b`_gb_ b _]h ]jhfZ^gZy l_gv \ ojZf_ AZdju\ZeZkv s_ev ²
\b^_gb_bkq_aZeh
H k_dj_l_ k\_lh\hc ijh_dpbb ibkZe ^j_\g_]j_q_kdbc nbehkhn IeZlhg < k\h_c
dgb]_ ³:ee_]hjby h i_s_j_´ hg h[tykgbe mkljhckl\h lZdh]h ZiiZjZlZ : IbnZ]hj
ih[u\Z\rbc\ ?]bil_^_fhgkljbjh\Zem k_[ygZjh^bg_dZdfh`gh³\ua\Zlv^moh\´
Ohly k_dj_l ijh_dpbhggh]h nhgZjy b _]h ZgZeh]h\ [ue ba\_kl_g hq_gv ^Z\gh b
g_h^ghdjZlgh bkihevah\Zeky \ ijZdlbd_ g_djhfZglh\ iZl_gl gZ _]h bah[j_l_gb_ [ue
\u^Zglhevdh\ ]h^mnbabdmJh[_jlkhgmIj_`^_q_fh[gZjh^h\Zlvk\hxgh\bgdm
hg g_fZeh ihihevah\Zeky _x \ p_eyo e`_g_djhfZglbb < ]h^m hg hj]Zgbah\Ze \
IZjb`_ g_qlh \jh^_ aj_ebsgh]h ij_^ijbylby dh]^Z dZ`^uc dmib\rbc [be_l fh]
ihkfhlj_lv³^mo´ex[h]hmf_jr_]hq_eh\_dZmf_jrbojh^bl_e_c
D gZqZem ;,; \_dZ bkdmkkl\h g_djhfZglbb hdZaZehkv iheghklvx
kdhfijhf_lbjh\Zgguf Gh m`_ \kdhj_ ^bZeh] k l_gyfb mf_jrbo [ue kgh\Z
\hah[gh\e_gWlhk^_eZeb^\_^_\hqdb²FZj]Zj_lb DwclNhd_^_dZ[jy]h^Z
gZn_jf_=Zc^k\beevqlh\hae_GvxChjdZ
IjbajZdijhy\b\rbckyk ihfhsvxklmdh\b s_eqdh\jZa^Z\Z\rboky\ kl_gZob
ij_^f_lZo h[klZgh\db gbkdhevdh bo g_ bkim]Ze @_eZy _]h ih^jZagblv feZ^rZy ba
k_kl_j²Dwlblh`_ijbgyeZkvklmqZlvgZqlhg_ajbfuckh[_k_^gbdhl\_lbelZdbf`_
qbkehfm^Zjh\
B lh]^ZihdZdhfmlhgZblbx^_\hqdZkdZaZeZ_fm
³?kebluq_eh\_dlhklmdgbh^bgjZaZ _keb^molh^\Z´Lml`_ijha\mqZeb^\Z
kmobom^ZjZiheh`b\rbogZqZehlhcZa[md_dhlhjhcklZebihevah\Zlvkyk_kljuNhd_Z
\ke_^aZgbfbb kibjblu\k_]hfbjZ
K_fvx]h^Zfbiha`_\ ]h^m\ KR:gZkqblu\Zehkvm`_f_^bmfh\b
hdheh fbeebhgh\ klhjhggbdh\ kibjblbafZ L_f \j_f_g_f i_j\uc kibjblbq_kdbc
dhg]j_kk kh[jZ\rbcky \ Deb\e_g^_ j_rbe ihkeZlv fbkkbhg_jh\ kgZqZeZ \ :g]ebx Z
aZl_f \ =_jfZgbx hldm^Z gh\h_ ^\b`_gb_ ^hreh gZdhg_p ^h NjZgpbb ]^_ \ kZfuo
jZaebqguodjm]Zoijb\e_dehg_fZehklhjhggbdh\< Jhkkbbg_aZ^he]h^hHdly[jvkdhc
j_\hexpbb gZkqblu\Zehkv [he__ ^\mo lukyq hnbpbZevgh aZj_]bkljbjh\Zgguo
kibjblbq_kdbodjm`dh\
Gh\h_mq_gb_ihemqbehgZa\Zgb_kibjblbafZhleZlbgkdh]hkeh\Z³kibjblmk´²
^molh_klvmq_gb_h ^moZo< Jhkkbbkibjblbafbgh]^ZgZau\Zebklheh\_jq_gb_fqlh
[ueh k\yaZgh k h[uqghc ijZdlbdhc h[s_gby k ^moZfb k\yaZgghc k fZgbimeypbyfb kh
klhehf
>_eh \ lhf qlh ^h\hevgh kdhjh hldZaZebkv hl ijZdlbdb h[s_gby k ^moZfb ih
f_lh^bd_ k_kl_j Nhd_ l _ klmdZfb GZb[hevr__ jZkijhkljZg_gb_ ihemqbeb hiulu kh
klheZfbb k[ex^pZfb>_eZehkvwlhlZdGZ[hevrhfebkl_[mfZ]bbebdZjlhgZibkZeb
ihdjm]m[md\uZenZ\blZgZk_j_^bgmdeZebi_j_\_jgmlh_\\_jo^ghf[ex^p_gZg_]h
iZevpu ² lZd qlh[u jmdb g_ dZkZebkv klheZ b aZfbjZeb \ gZijy`_gghc iha_ Reb
fbgmlu jmdbhlgZijy`_gbygZqbgZeb ^jh`Zlv b [ex^p_ ijboh^beh \ ^\b`_gb_ Wlh
hagZqZeh qlh \ua\Zgguc ³^mo´ y\beky L_i_jv hklZ\Zehkv aZ^Z\Zlv _fm \hijhku b
ijbr_e_p ³k lh]h k\_lZ´ hl\_qZe gZ gbo Ihdehggbdb kibjblbq_kdbo k_Zgkh\ kqblZeb
qlhbf_ggh³^mo´ih^lZedb\Z_l[ex^p_d gm`ghc[md\_aZl_f²d ^jm]hclj_lv_cLZd
ba[md\kdeZ^u\Zebkvkeh\Zbakeh\²njZau
Ih^jm]hcf_lh^bd_³deZkkbq_kdhf´klheh\_jq_gbbg_kdhevdhq_eh\_dkZ^bebkv
\hdjm]klheZhibjZykvgZ_]hdjZyjmdZfbJmdbmqZklgbdh\k_ZgkZgZqbgZebqmlvqmlv
ih^jZ]b\Zlv hl \ha[m`^_gby keZ[u_ ^\b`_gby hl^_evguo bg^b\b^mfh\ kh \j_f_g_f
kbgojhgbabjh\Zebkvb g_aZf_lgh^eymqZklgbdh\ly`_eu_klheugZqbgZebijboh^blv\
^\b`_gb_ ih^iju]b\Zlv klmqZlv klmdZfb mdZau\Zy gm`gu_ [md\u Ba [md\ lZd`_
kdeZ^u\Zebkvkeh\Zbakeh\²^ebggu_ihkeZgbybaihlmklhjhgg_]hfbjZljZdlmxsb_
kZfu_ keh`gu_ b lhgdb_ \hijhku nbehkhnbb l_heh]bb fhjZeb gZmdb b l i Ba
ihke_^g_c kh \j_f_g_f khklZ\behkv gjZ\kl\_ggh_ mq_gb_ ba dhlhjh]h klhjhggbdb
kibjblbafZklj_fbebkvkha^Zlvj_eb]bx
M \kydhcj_eb]bb^he`_g[ulvk\hchkgh\Zl_evqvyi_j\ZyaZ^ZqZ²gZq_jlZlv
kdjb`Zeb aZdhgh\ K wlhc fbkkb_c b \uklmibe \h NjZgpbb :eeZg DZj^_d ik_\^hgbf
BiiheblZJ_\Zy²^_ehdhlhjh]h\ gh\uobklhjbq_kdbomkeh\byoijh^he`be
E_hg>_gb²
H^gZdhkibjblbaf²wlhg_h^ghbagh\uomq_gbc\hagbdrbolhevdh\ ;,;\_d_
hg kms_kl\h\Ze gZjy^m k g_djhfZglb_c b \ ^j_\g_f fbj_ >` >` Njwa_j khh[sZ_l
qlh g_]jblygkdh_ ie_fy dbkb `b\ms__ gZ ]jZgbp_ Eb[_jbb h[jZsZ_lky aZ kh\_lhf d
^moZf mf_jrbo \h`^_c dZd d hjZdmem >ey wlh]h bkihevamxlky klZlmwldb
mklZgZ\eb\Z_fu_ gZ bo fh]beZo Qlh[u magZlv fg_gb_ ^moZ wlb klZlmwldb klZ\ylky gZ
^hkdm dhlhjmx ^_j`Zl gZ ]heh\_ ^\Z q_eh\_dZ ?keb klZlmwldb ijb wlhf hklZxlky
g_ih^\b`gulhkqblZ_lkyqlh^mohl\_lbe³g_l´_keb`_hgbdZqZxlky\aZ^b \i_j_^
lhhl\_lhagZqZ_l³^Z´
< Zglbqgu_\j_f_gZijbh[s_gbbk ^moZfbijb[_]Zebd ke_^mxs_fmf_lh^m²d
gbld_ ijb\yau\Zeb dhevph Z ih djm]m ibkZeb [md\u Dh]^Z gbldm ^_j`Zeb lh dhevph
gZqbgZehdZqZlvkyb dZkZlvkylhh^ghclh^jm]hc[md\uBklhjbdFZjp_ebgkhh[sZ_l
qlh \ ,9 \_d_ gZr_c wju \h \j_f_gZ ijZ\e_gby <Ze_glZ bfi_jZlhjZ \hklhqghc qZklb
Jbfkdhc bfi_jbb fZ]b iulZebkv k ihfhsvx \jZsZxs_]hky klhebdZ k [md\Zfb gZ^
dhlhjuf[uehih^\_r_ghgZr_edh\hfrgmjd_dhevphmagZlvdlhgZke_^m_lij_klhe
DklZlbhiuluk ³fZ]bq_kdbffZylgbdhf´ZgZeh]bqguflhfmqlhbkihevah\Zeb
Zglbqgu_kibjblu^eyh[s_gbyk ^moZfbb ihfh]ebh[tykgblvmq_guffgh]b_aZ]Z^db
kibjblbafZ
< dhgp_ijhreh]h\_dZ\ g_dhlhjuo_\jhi_ckdbokljZgZogZqZeZ\oh^blv\ fh^m
b]jZ gZa\ZggZy ³fZ]bq_kdbf fZylgbdhf´ ³<her_[guc fZylgbd´ ² h[udgh\_ggmx
gbldm k ]jmabdhf ² ihf_sZeb \ p_glj djm]Z k gZibkZgguf ih _]h i_jbf_ljm gZ
hij_^_e_gghf jZkklhygbb ^jm] hl ^jm]Z [md\Zfb ZenZ\blZ Ijb wlhf ^_j`Zs_fm
\_j_\hqdm fZylgbdZ aZ^Z\Zeb \hijhku Z hl\_lu kdeZ^u\Zebkv ba [md\ gZ dhlhju_
mdZau\Zedhe_[exsbcky]jmabdIhq_fmwlhijhbkoh^beh"
Ihijh[m_f kZfb \hkijhba\_klb wlhl hiul <havfbl_ \ \ulygmlmx jmdm gbldm k
ih^\_r_gguf gZ dhgp_ ]jmabdhf L_i_jv fuke_ggh ij_^klZ\vl_ k_[_ qlh hg gZqbgZ_l
jZkdZqb\Zlvky \ dZdhflh hij_^_e_gghf gZijZ\e_gbb kdZ`_f kijZ\Z gZe_\h eb[h ih
djm]m B ]jmabd g_kfhljy gZ lh qlh jmdZ \k_ \j_fy hklZ_lky \ ihdh_ \k_ aZf_lg__
gZqbgZ_ljZkdZqb\Zlvky\ wlhfgZijZ\e_gbbdZd[uih\lhjyy\Zrmfukev
Wlh y\e_gb_ \ gZklhys__ \j_fy ohjhrh bamq_ggh_ nbabheh]Zfb ihemqbeh
gZa\Zgb_ b^_hfhlhjgh]h ZdlZ hl ]j_q_kdh]h keh\Z ³b^_y´ ² fukev ij_^klZ\e_gb_ b
eZlbgkdh]h ³fhlhjguc´ ² lh _klv ^\b]Zl_evguc ijb\h^bfuc \ ^\b`_gb_ GZf
dZ`_lky qlh jmdZ \k_ \j_fy hklZ_lky \ ihdh_ Z \ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb hgZ dZd [u
khijh\h`^Z_l gZrm fukev g_agZqbl_evgufb g_aZf_lgufb ^ey ]eZa ^\b`_gbyfb
<i_j\u_ b^_x h lhf qlh gZrm ikbobq_kdmx ^_yl_evghklv fh]ml khijh\h`^Zlv
^\b`_gby furp \ukdZaZe B F K_q_gh\ \ k\h_f agZf_gblhf ljm^_ ³J_ne_dku
]heh\gh]h fha]Z´ <ihke_^kl\bb wlh [ueh g_h^ghdjZlgh ^hdZaZgh fgh]hqbke_ggufb
nbabheh]bq_kdbfbhiulZfb
K ih^h[gufb `_ y\e_gbyfb fu klZedb\Z_fky b gZ kibjblbq_kdbo k_ZgkZo
keZ[u_ g_aZf_lgu_ gZ ]eZa ^\b`_gby jmd dZdh]hgb[m^v ba gZb[he__ \hkijbbfqb\uo
mqZklgbdh\ ih^o\Zlu\Zxlky ^jm]bfb b i_j_^Zxlky klhem ² hg gZqbgZ_l ihklmdb\Zlv
Dh]^Zijbkmlkl\mxsb_gZkibjblbq_kdhfk_Zgk_aZ^Zxl³^moZfmf_jrbo´\hijhkhgb
aZjZg__ ij_^m]Z^u\Zxl ijbf_jguc hl\_l GZkljZb\Zykv gZ g_]h lZd gZau\Z_fu_
f_^bmfu kZfb lh]h g_ ih^haj_\Zy g_ijhba\hevgh \uklmdb\Zxl _]h I_j\hgZqZevgu_
[md\u b keh\Z \u[b\Zxlky h[uqgh hq_gv g_m\_j_ggh Z aZl_f dh]^Z keh\h m`_
m]Z^u\Z_lky dZ`^uf mqZklgbdhf bo ^_ckl\by klZgh\ylky [he__ kh]eZkh\Zggufb b
lhqgufbBa\_kl_ggZijbf_jlZdhckemqZcg_hq_gv]jZfhlgucq_eh\_d³\ua\Ze´^moZ
ba\_klgh]hagZlhdZ]jZffZlbdbDZdh\h`_[uehm^b\e_gb_ijbkmlkl\mxsbodh]^Zlhl
\ k\h_fhl\_l_^himklbe]jZffZlbq_kdb_hrb[db
K\yavkibjblbafZk g_ijhba\hevgufbb^_hfhlhjgufbfur_qgufb^\b`_gbyfb
[ueZ^hdZaZgZhiulZfbjmkkdbomq_guo_s_\ _ ]h^uijhreh]h\_dZ
< ]h^mihgZklhyl_evghcijhkv[_ba\_klgh]hobfbdZ>BF_g^_e__\Z[ueZ
kha^ZgZ dhfbkkby ba ^\_gZ^pZlb Z\lhjbl_lguo mq_guo dhlhju_ j_rbeb \k_jv_a
jZah[jZlvky\ kibjblbq_kdbo³qm^_kZo´H[t_dlb\ghklbjZ^b\ __jZ[hl_mqZkl\h\Zebb
ljbklhjhggbdZkibjblbafZ
>ey hiulh\ [ueh kdhgkljmbjh\Zgh ^\Z ki_pbZevguo klhebdZ H^bg ba gbo
fZghf_ljbq_kdbc iha\heye aZf_jylv b lhqgh nbdkbjh\Zlv qvb mkbeby lhedZxl _]h
>jm]hc ² ibjZfb^Zevguc ² bf_e dhku_ jZkoh^ysb_ky gh`db [eZ]h^Zjy q_fm
gZeh`_ggufbgZklhebdjmdZfbg_evay[uehgb ijbih^gylvgb gZdehgblv_]hijbwlhf
ibjZfb^Zevguc klhebd [ue g_ ly`_e__ h[udgh\_ggh]h bkihevamxs_]hky \
kibjblbq_kdbok_ZgkZoWdki_jbf_gluk kZfufbagZf_gblufbf_^bmfZfblh]h\j_f_gb
m[_^bl_evghihdZaZebklheuijb\h^bebkv\ ^\b`_gb_g_dZdhclhlZbgkl\_gghckbehc
Z kZfbff_^bmfhf
Dhfbkkbb > B F_g^_e__\Z ijbrehkv klhedgmlvky b k nZdlZfb ]jm[h]h
ij_^gZf_j_ggh]h h[fZgZ ;_kkihjgh_ rZjeZlZgkl\h h[gZjm`b\Zehkv \h \k_o l_o
kemqZyodh]^Z^mobydh[u\ue_ieb\Zebba\hkdZnb]mjua\hgbeb\ e_`ZsbcgZklhe_
dhehdhevqbd nhlh]jZnbjh\Zebkv b l i DZd lhevdh ijb ijh\_^_gbb kibjblbq_kdbo
hiulh\ ijbgbfZebkv f_ju ij_^mij_`^Zxsb_ h[fZg beb jZah[eZqZxsb_ _]h \k_
³qm^_kZ´bkq_aZeb
Hkh[hkdZg^Zevghcj_imlZpb_cihevah\ZeZkvfZl_jbZebaZpby^moh\Wlb³qm^_kZ´
ijh^he`Zebkv ^h l_o ihj ihdZ g_ [ueh bah[j_l_gh bgnjZdjZkgh_ hilbq_kdh_
mkljhckl\h iha\heyxs__ gZ[ex^Zlv \k_ qlh ^_eZ_lky \ lsZl_evgh aZl_fg_gghc
dhfgZl_³>mob´[hylkyg_lhevdhhk\_s_gbyghb bgnjZdjZkguo[bghde_c< ]h^m
\ NJ= ]Zkljhebjh\ZeZ agZf_gbluc [jZabevkdbc f_^bmf >hgb Bjbk dhlhjZy
^_fhgkljbjh\ZeZ³fZl_jbZebaZpbx^moZ´< aZe_kZgZlhjbyO_jj_gZev[_\ ijbkmlkl\bb
hdheh lukyqb ajbl_e_c ijhbahr_e kdZg^Ze G_dhlhju_ ajbl_eb [m^mqb \hhjm`_gu
bgnjZdjZkgufbhilbq_kdbfbijb[hjZfbm\b^_ebdZd>hgZBjbkgZaZl_fg_gghckp_g_
hk\h[h^beZkv hl k\hbo iml gZdbgmeZ gZ k_[y lxev ih^\_kbeZ nZevrb\mx [hjh^m b
gZqZeZbah[jZ`Zlv^moZWlhij_\jZs_gb_[uehknhlh]jZnbjh\Zgh
H^gZdh ohly lZdbo jZah[eZq_gbc [ueh fgh`_kl\h b \ gZrb ^gb gZijbf_j \
Ehg^hg_ dZ`^uc `_eZxsbc fh`_l ijbclb \ kibjblbq_kdbc dem[ b aZ ^\Z nmglZ
\jmq_ggu_ f_^bmfm \klmiblv \ dhglZdl k ³^moZfb´ < ghy[j_ \ ^_gv ihfbgh\_gby
mkhirbo \ ehg^hgkdhf :ev[_jlohee_ ² ljZ^bpbhgghf f_kl_ fZkkh\uo fblbg]h\ b
kh[jZgbc²^mobmf_jrbo³[_k_^mxl´khk\hbfb^jmavyfbb jh^kl\_ggbdZfb<b^bfh
hdhgqZl_evgh³ohjhgblv´kibjblbaf_s_jZgh;he__lh]h\ g_^Z\ghhim[ebdh\Zgghc\
`mjgZe_ ³GZmdZ b j_eb]by´ klZlv_ ³<ha\jZs_gb_ kibjblbafZ´ nbehkhnkibjbl I :
=_e_\Z hl^_eyy \mev]Zjguc kibjblbaf ² kZehggh_ jZa\e_q_gb_ ² hl mq_gby dhlhjh_
ih_]hm[_`^_gbxk\yau\Z_lQ_eh\_dZkh<k_e_gghc\gh\viulZ_lkyijb\h^blv\_kdb_
Zj]mf_glu\ aZsblmkibjblbafZ
<ha\jZs_gbxkibjblbafZkihkh[kl\m_llhqlhg_dhlhju_lZbgkl\_ggu_y\e_gby
gZijbf_j ihel_j]_ckl kh\j_f_ggZy gZmdZ ^h kbo ihj g_ \ khklhygbb h[tykgblv DZd
hlghkblvky d kibjblbafm gZ kh\j_f_gghf wlZi_" B K Lmj]_g_\ \ k\h_ \j_fy aZf_lbe
³Kd_ilbpbaf\k_]^ZhlebqZ_lky[_kieh^ghklvxb [_kkbeb_f´ : ihlhfm ^Z^bf keh\h b
gZrbfhiihg_glZfkh\j_f_ggufklhjhggbdZfkibjblbafZ
³NbehkhnbykibjblbafZmqblqlh`bagvq_eh\_dZg_aZdZgqb\Z_lkykhkf_jlvx
Wlh \hafh`gh [eZ]h^Zjy kljh_gbx q_eh\_dZ dhlhjh_ lj_oqZklgh nbabq_kdh_ l_eh wg_j]_lbq_kdh_l_ehi_jbkijbl^mrZbeb^mo<k_g_^hjZamf_gbyijhbkoh^ylbaaZ
lh]hqlhq_eh\_dijbgug_rg_fmjh\g__]hjZa\blbyg_khagZ_lk\h_c^_ckl\bl_evghc
ijbjh^uhgkqblZ_lb \_jbl[m^lhhg_klvnbabq_kdh_l_ehlh]^ZdZdgZkZfhf^_e_hg
² [_kkf_jlguc ^mo dhlhjuc ihhq_j_^gh ihevam_lky jZagufb l_eZfb i_j_oh^y ba
h^ghcklZ^bbk\h_]hkms_kl\h\Zgby\ ^jm]mx
G_dhlhju_ba^moh\\j_f_gghebr_gguol_eZfh]ml`_eZlv\klmiblv\ h[s_gb_
k gZfbh[blZl_eyfba_fgh]hfZl_jbZevgh]hfbjZH[s_gb_wlhfh`_lijhbkoh^blvih
gZr_fm `_eZgbx b ijhkv[_ q_j_a ihkj_^gbdZf_^bmfZ \h \j_fy lZd gZau\Z_fh]h
kibjblbq_kdh]h k_ZgkZ Dh]^Z `_ wlh h[s_gb_ ijhbkoh^bl [_a gZr_]h kh]eZkby b
\_^hfZlhbf__lf_klhlhqlhgZau\Z_lkyihel_j]_ckl³rmfguc^mo´³^hfh\hc´
Kh]eZkgh mq_gbx kibjblbafZ ihel_j]_ckl ² wlh nbabq_kdh_ ijhy\e_gb_ ^mrb
mf_jr_]h q_eh\_dZ \ gZr_f fZl_jbZevghf fbj_ Nhjfu _]h \ujZ`_gby \_kvfZ
jZaghh[jZagu klmdb b ki_pbnbq_kdb_ s_eqdb \ f_[_eb kl_gZo b ihem hkyaZl_evgu_
hsms_gby q_eh\_dZ ih^\_j]Zxs_]hky \ha^_ckl\bx dZkZgbx m^Zju b lheqdb
i_j_^\b`_gb_ \ \ha^mo_ e_\blZpby g_h^mr_\e_gguo ij_^f_lh\ b `b\uo kms_kl\
a\mdbq_eh\_q_kdh]h]hehkZb j_qbbgZdhg_pjZaebqgh]hjh^Z\b^_gby²hlihy\e_gby
jmd beb ]heh\u ^h fZl_jbZebaZpbb iheghc q_eh\_q_kdhc nb]mju iehlghklv wlbo
fZl_jbZebaZpbbfh`_l[ulvjZaebqgZhl]Zahh[jZaghc^hhkyaZ_fhl\_j^hc
?keb^moijhy\ey_lkykZfhijhba\hevghlhwlhfh`_lbf_lvlhevdh^\_ijbqbgu
eb[hhg`_eZ_lgZim]Zlvex^_cy\eyxsbokyg_\hevgufbk\b^_l_eyfbkljZgguobdZd
bfdZ`_lkyijhlb\h_kl_kl\_gguoy\e_gbceb[hhg`_eZ_l\klmiblvk gZfb\ h[s_gb_
< ex[hfkemqZ_ihel_j]_cklZg_ke_^m_lim]ZlvkyihkdhevdmhggbdZdhchiZkghklb^ey
`bagbb a^hjh\vyex^_cg_ij_^klZ\ey_l´
Gh jZkkdZa h lZbgkl\_gguo y\e_gbyo ijhbkoh^ysbo \ kh\j_f_gghf fbj_ h
ihel_j]_ckl_ e_\blZpbb l_e_iZlbb b l_e_dbg_a_ iZjZikboheh]bb i_j_k_e_gbb ^mr
GEH b h fgh]hffgh]hf ^jm]hf lj_[m_l hl^_evghc dgb]b Ihwlhfm k_cqZk fu
ijhsZ_fky k gZrbf qblZl_e_f b gZ^__fky gZ gh\mx k gbf \klj_qm ^ey h[km`^_gby
aZljhgmluo\hijhkh\
EBL?J:LMJ:
F_a_gp_\<: Qm^_kZIhimeyjgZywgpbdehi_^by:efZ:lZ=ej_^DZakh\
wgpbdehi_^bbldgb]Z
=_e_\ZI: <ha\jZs_gb_kibjblbafZ³GZmdZb j_eb]by´k
Njwa_j>`>` Nhevdehj\ <_lohfaZ\_l_F³Iheblba^Zl´
Q_eebgb; @bagv;_g\_gmlhF³Om^h`_kl\_ggZyebl_jZlmjZ´
Iem`gbdh\FJyaZgP_\K Kj_^baZiZoh\b a\mdh\F³Fhe]\Zj^by´
=_e_\ZI: QlhlZdh_³ihel_j]_bkl"´³:j]mf_glub nZdlu´‹ =E:<:;;
FZnmkZbeh\<_d
Kbghgbfhf ^he]h`bl_ey klZeh bfy [b[e_ckdh]h iZljbZjoZ FZnmkZbeZ ydh[u
ijh`b\r_]he_lWlhkZfucagZqbl_evgucbamihfbgZ_fuo\ jZaebqguoj_eb]byo
fbnZo b kdZaZgbyo \hajZkl q_eh\_dZ _keb g_ kqblZlv e_]_g^Zjgh]h IZg Dm
ij_^iheZ]Z_fh]h l\hjpZ fbjZ dhlhjuc kh]eZkgh fbnZf >j_\g_]h DblZy ijh`be lukyqe_l\ujZklZyaZ^_gvgZf
Gh \hajZkl FZnmkZbeZ g_ dZaZeky q_flh ba jy^Z \hg \uoh^ysbf kj_^b ^jm]bo
[b[e_ckdboiZljbZjoh\<k_]hgZk_fve_lf_gvr_`be_]hjh^ghc^_^BZj_^Ihwlhfm
]h\hjyh ^he]h`bl_eyo\ ;9,,,²;,;\_dZoihevah\Zebkvl_jfbghf:j_^h\u\_dbbf_y
\ \b^m\hajZkliZljbZjoZBZj_^Z:j_^Zijh`b\r_]h]h^ZBlZdkh]eZkgh<_lohfm
AZ\_lmex^b^h<_ebdh]hIhlhiZh[uqgh`bebg_kdhevdhkhl_ge_li_j\ucq_eh\_dgZ
A_fe_:^Zf²e_l_]hkugKbn²e_l_]h\gmd?ghk²e_l_]hijZ\gmd
DZbgZg ² e_l kug DZbgZgZ FZe_e_be ² e_l kug FZe_e_beZ BZj_^ m`_
ba\_klguc gZf :j_^ ² ]h^Z Kug :j_^Z b hl_p FZnmkZbeZ ?gho ² e_l kug
FZnmkZbeZ EZf_o ² ]h^Z <gmd FZnmkZbeZ Ghc i_j_`b\rbc <_ebdbc Ihlhi
mf_j\ \hajZkl_e_l
IjZ\^Z g_dhlhju_ kh\j_f_ggu_ dhff_glZlhju ;b[ebb kqblZxl qlh \hajZkl
\_lohaZ\_lguo iZljbZjoh\ fh]eb baf_jylv ih ^j_\g_fm _]bi_lkdhfm h[uqZx ² ba
jZkq_lZh^bgf_kypaZ]h^beb ihh[uqZx^j_\gbo _\j__\ ² ^\Z f_kypZ aZ ]h^ Lh]^Z
gbq_]hk\_jot_kl_kl\_ggh]h\ \hajZkl_[b[e_ckdboiZljbZjoh\g_l
<ihke_^kl\bb dZd ]h\hjblky \ ;b[ebb baaZ \hajZklZgby ]j_oh\ghklb
ijh^he`bl_evghklv `bagb q_eh\_dZ khdjZsZeZkv b gZdhg_p kh]eZkgh Fhbk_x [ueZ
mklZgh\e_gZ³\ ljbkjhdZb ^_kylv´ljbjZaZih^\Z^pZlvb ^_kylvl_k_fv^_kyle_l
G_kfhljygZwlhliheh`_gguc;h]hfkjhdfgh]b_i_jkhgZ`b;b[ebbi_j_klmiZeb_]h
LZdkZfFhbk_c^h`be^he_lijbq_f³aj_gb__]hg_ijblmibehkvb dj_ihklv\ g_f
g_bklhsbeZkv´:\jZZf`bee_l_]h`_gZKZjjZ²e_lBhkbnIj_djZkgucb
BbkmkGZ\bg²ihe_l
Kh]eZkghfbnZf>j_\g_]hDblZyihlhfdbG_[_kgh]h<eZ^udblZd`_hlebqZebkv
qj_a\uqZcguf ^he]he_lb_f Ij_^Zgb_ ]eZkbl qlh g_dbc q_eh\_d ih bf_gb Paygv b ih
ijha\ZgbxDwgijh`be[he__\hkvfbkhle_l²kh\j_f_gbYhb Rmgy\iehlv^hi_j\uo
e_l^bgZklbbQ`hmghhgl_fg_f_g__k_lh\Zei_j_^kf_jlvxgZlhqlh`bagv_]h[ueZ
kebrdhfdhjhldZ
JZkkdZau\ZxlqlhIwgpamd dhgpm^bgZklbbBgvm`_[uehk_fvkhlr_klv^_kyl
k_fv e_l gh hg g_ \u]ey^_e klZjuf b g_fhsguf Iwgpam g_ ohl_e \u^Zlv k_dj_lZ
k\h_]h^he]he_lbyb ex^bkljhbeb\k_\hafh`gu_^h]Z^dbG_dhlhju_kqblZebqlhhg
ijbgbfZee_dZjkl\hba]jb[Zdhjbqgh]h^_j_\Z^jm]b_\b^_ebk_dj_l_]h^he]he_lby\
mf_gbb ]em[hdh ^urZlv H^gZdh wlh g_ lZd Ijhklh hg mf_e ]hlh\blv ij_djZkguc
nZaZgbckmiWlhlkmihgij_ih^g_kG_[_kghfm<eZ^ud_dhlhjhfmlhlihdZaZekyhq_gv
\dmkgufb hgih`Zeh\ZeIwgpam\hk_fvkhle_l`bagbH^gZdh`bag_ex[b\ucIwgpam
i_j_^kf_jlvxbkiulu\Zeg_h[uqZcgh_kh`Ze_gb_kqblZyqlhg_ih`be\^h\hevb qlh
_]h `bagv h[hj\ZeZkv \ kZfhf jZkp\_l_ AZ k\hx ^he]mx `bagv Iwgpam ihohjhgbe `_gb ebrbekykugh\_c
Dhg_qgh`_iheghklvx^h\_jylvfbnZfb kdZaZgbyfg_evayQlh[uhdhgqZl_evgh
ijhykgblv \hijhk h fZdkbfZevghc ijh^he`bl_evghklb `bagb h[jZlbfky d gZb[he__
Z\lhjbl_lghfm ba^Zgbx ih klZlbklbd_ ² Dgb]_ j_dhj^h\ =bgg_kZ JZa^_e h
ijh^he`bl_evghklb `bagb hldju\Z_lky \_kvfZ i_kkbfbklbq_kdbf \klmie_gb_f ]^_
]h\hjblky qlh gb h^bg \hijhk klZlbklbdb g_ kh^_j`bl klhevdh \ufukeh\ kemoh\
g_lhqghkl_cdZd\hijhkh ijh^he`bl_evghklb`bagbIhwlhfmhjb_glbjh\Zlvkyfh`gh
lhevdh gZ ^hdmf_glZevgh aZnbdkbjh\Zggu_ i_j_ibkvx gZk_e_gby kjhdb `bagb
dhgdj_lgh]h q_eh\_dZ \k_ `_ hklZevgu_ nZdlu ke_^m_l hlg_klb d jZajy^m \ufukeZ b
nZglZabb Kh]eZkgh ml\_j`^_gbx Dgb]b j_dhj^h\ aZj_]bkljbjh\Zgguc ij_^_e
q_eh\_q_kdhc `bagb khklZ\ey_l e_l Wlhl j_dhj^ ijbgZ^e_`bl `bl_ex Yihgbb
Rb]_qbh Bamfb jh^b\r_fmky \ ]h^m b kdhgqZ\r_fmky hl ig_\fhgbb \ KlZj_crbc ba gug_ `b\msbo `bl_e_c A_feb aZj_]bkljbjh\Zgguc \ Dgb]_ j_dhj^h\
=bgg_kZaZ]h^²wlhe_lgbcD_jjb;ZclKR:jh^b\rbckyghy[jy
]h^Z
Ijb\k_fm\Z`_gbbd Z\lhjbl_lmDgb]bj_dhj^h\=bgg_kZy g_fh]mkh]eZkblvky
k wlbfb^Zggufbdhlhju_ihfh_fmfg_gbxy\eyxlky\_kvfZg_ihegufb
LZd j_ihjl_j dZbjkdhc ]Za_lu ³:ev:o[Zj´ gZr_e q_eh\_dZ dhlhjhfm ih _]h
aZ\_j_gbyfe_lB[jZ]bfZevDZjbfbdhlhjucydh[ujh^beky_s_\ \hk_fgZ^pZlhf
\_d_ihfgblb kljhbl_evkl\hb hldjulb_Kmwpdh]hdZgZeZ
K_gkZpbxijbg_keZb g_^Z\gyyi_j_ibkvgZk_e_gby\h<v_lgZf_< m_a^_Dmgohe
ijh\bgpbb G]_lbgv h[gZjm`beb q_eh\_dZ dhlhjhfm g_^Z\gh bkihegbehkv ]h^Z
>he]h`bl_evgbpZG]ZgLobDmZg]jh^beZkv\ ]h^mHgZljb`^u\klmiZeZ\ [jZdb
i_j_`beZljhbok\hbofm`_cBafgh`_kl\Z^_l_cG]ZgLobDmZg][hevrbgkl\hbagbo
^h`beb^hij_dehggh]h\hajZklZgug_a^jZ\kl\m_lq_l\_jhLjbk_klju[Z[mrdbG]Zg
lZd`_ijh`beb[he__e_l
Gh h[Z wlbo khh[s_gby ^hdmf_glZevgh g_ ih^l\_j`^_gu ihwlhfm klZj_cr_c
`bl_evgbp_c A_feb \_jhylgh ke_^m_l kqblZlv `bl_evgbpm Ebl\u ;Zj[hjmWfbebx
YkZcl_dhlhjhcihr_ec ]h^Khljm^gbdb=hkm^Zjkl\_ggh]hbklhjbq_kdh]hZjob\Z
Ebl\u h[gZjm`beb aZibkv \ f_ljbq_kdhc dgb]_ J_lZ\kdhc jbfkdhdZlhebq_kdhc
ijboh^kdhc p_jd\b Kh]eZkgh wlhfm ^hdmf_glm ;Zj[hjZWfbeby YkZcl_ ihy\beZkv gZ
k\_lyg\Zjy]h^Z
Ih g_ih^^Zxsbfky ijh\_jd_ ^Zgguf klZj_crbg `bl_e_f gZr_c ieZg_lu
y\ey_lky ]jZ`^Zgbg DblZy Eb Qmg]yg jh^b\rbcky \ b mf_jrbc \ ]h^m \
\hajZkl_e_l
G_dbc @Zg L_j_ev \klmibe \h njZgpmakdmx Zjfbx \ ;9,, \_d_ Z \ur_e \
hlklZ\dm \ ;,; Wlh dZ`_lky g_\_jhylguf hg kem`be \ Zjfbb gZ ijhly`_gbb lj_o
\_dh\ LZd kdhevdh `_ hg ijh`be" G_ lZd fZeh ohly b g_ hdheh lj_okhl dZd fh`_l
ihdZaZlvky @Zg L_j_ev jh^beky \ >b`hg_ \ ]h^m \klmibe \ Zjfbx r_klgZ^pZlb
e_l \ ]h^m gZ bkoh^_ \_dZ MqZkl\h\Ze [he__ q_f \ klZ kjZ`_gbyo < ]h^m
dh]^Z _fm [ueh ]h^Z dhjhev Ex^h\bd ;,9 ih`Zeh\Ze klZjhfm kem`Zd_ a\Zgb_
dZiblZgZ < ]h^m L_j_ex [ueh m`_ e_l h g_f magZe GZihe_hg <hij_db
g_`_eZgbx\_l_jZgZhgm\hebe_]h\ ihq_lgmxhlklZ\dmgZagZqb\_`_]h^gmxi_gkbx\
njZgdh\@ZgL_j_evmf_j\ ]h^mgZklh^\Z^pZlvlj_lv_f]h^m`bagb
< lj_o klhe_lbyo `be b rhleZg^_p >`hg Fblq_ee ² mf_jrbc \
\hajZkl_e_l
< q_klv OZ\v_jZ I_j_cjZ ijh`b\r_]h e_l \ Dhemf[bb [ueZ \uims_gZ
ki_pbZevgZyihqlh\ZyfZjdZ
Wlhkemqbehkvdh]^ZI_j_cj_bkihegbehkve_l< ^_gvjh`^_gby_]hijbreb
iha^jZ\blv ]hkm^Zjkl\_ggu_ ^_yl_eb Dhemf[bb b ihijhkbeb kh]eZkby x[beyjZ
\uimklblviZfylgmxfZjdmk _]hbah[jZ`_gb_fI_j_cjZg_hldZaZe\ukhdbf]hklyfgh
ihklZ\beh^ghmkeh\b_\gbam\ m]emfZjdb^he`gh[ulvgZibkZgh³B ivxb dmjx´
>jm]Zy fZjdZ [ueZ \uims_gZ \ gZr_c kljZg_ \ ]h^m \ q_klv klZj_cr_]h
`bl_eyKKKJFmoZf_^ZWc\Zah\Zdh]^Zlhfmbkihegbehkve_lKdhgqZekyFmoZf_^
Wc\Zah\\ \hajZkl_]h^Z\ Z\]mkl_]h^Z
H^gbf ba gZb[he__ ba\_klguo \ bklhjbb ^he]h`bl_e_c y\ey_lky Zg]ebckdbc
dj_klvygbg LhfZk IZjj Hg ijb[ue ba RjhirbjZ \ Ehg^hg \ ]h^m qlh[u
ij_^klZlvi_j_^dhjhe_fDZjehfdZdqm^h^he]he_lbyLhfZkIZjjml\_j`^Zeqlh_fm
]h^Zb f_kyp_\qlhhgi_j_`be^_\yl_juodhjhe_cb `bek ;9ih;9,,klhe_lb_
IZjj mf_j \g_aZigh \ Ehg^hg_ >ey _]h \kdjulby [ue ijb]eZr_g ijb^\hjguc \jZq
<bevyf =Zj\_c ² ² agZf_gbluc mq_guc hldju\rbc djh\hh[jZs_gb_ Hg
gZibkZe ljZdlZl h j_amevlZlZo \kdjulby \ dhlhjhf g_ ih^\_j]Z_l khfg_gbx \hajZkl
IZjjZ Kf_jlv ijhbahreZ hl ig_\fhgbb IjZ\^Z e_]_g^Z ml\_j`^Z_l qlh dhjhev
ih`_eZeihqlblvkZfh]hklZjh]hq_eh\_dZ\ :g]ebbb LhfZkIZjjkdhgqZekyhlaZ\hjhlZ
dbrhd ihke_ ibjr_kl\Z mkljh_ggh]h \ _]h q_klv IZjj [ue lhj`_kl\_ggh ih]j_[_g \
<_klfbgq_jkdhfZ[[Zlkl\_
Qlh[u g_ mlhfeylv qblZl_ey fu ijhklh i_j_qbkebf g_dhlhjuo gZb[he__
ba\_klguo^he]h`bl_e_cBlZd
e_lijh`be`bl_ev<_g]jbbAhelZgI_ljZ`
e_l²^jm]hc\_g]jI_ljAhjlZc²
e_l `be b hkgh\Zl_ev Z[[Zlkl\Z \ =eZa]h ² Dwglb]_jg ba\_klguc ih^
bf_g_fk\ylh]hFmg]hkdhgqZ\rbckyyg\Zjy]h^Z
e_l ² \h`^v ie_f_gb FZoZffZ^ :naby IZdbklZg Ml\_j`^Zxl qlh _]h
hl_pmf_j\ \hajZkl_[he__e_l
e_l ijh`beZ lZd`_ hk_lbgdZ Lwgk_ :[ab\_ b jh\gh klhevdh `_ `bl_ev
=jhag_gkdhch[eZklb:jkb]bjbOZabl_\
e_l[uehb fbkl_jmChjZlmih^^Zgghfm__ \_ebq_kl\Zdhjhe_\uZg]ebckdhc
e_lijh`beZ_]h\_jgZy`_gZFwjnbChjZl
e_l²Ze[Zg_pOm^b_aZwlh\j_fy_]hihlhfkl\h^hklb]eh^\mokhlq_eh\_d
e_l[uehOZg^`_jGbg_LmjpbykdhgqZ\r_cky\ ]h^m\ :gdZj_
e_lijh`belZd`_=_gjb>`_ggbdkZg]ebckdbcju[ZdbaChjdrbjZ
e_l²RbjZgbFmkebfh\ba;ZjaZ\m:a_j[Zc^`Zg< ]h^mhghlf_lbe
klhe_lb_k\h_clj_lv_c`_guZ \Z\]mkl_]h^Z²h^gh]hbaijZ\gmdh\
e_l`beiZdbklZg_pKZcy^:[^meFZ[m^
e_l²lmjhdAZjh:]ZH^bgba_]hkugh\_cmf_j\ ]h^m\ \hajZkl_
e_l<k_]hhgbf_e^_l_cb \gmdZ[m^mqb`_gZlufljbgZ^pZlvjZa
e_l`beDjbklbZgYdh[k_g>jZd_g[_j]Jh^bekyhg\ KlZ\Zg]_j_Ghj\_]by
ghy[jy ]h^Z Z mf_j \ Hjomk_ >Zgby hdly[jy ]h^Z Hg [ue ijha\Zg
³k_\_jgufklZjp_f´< fheh^hklb_]haZo\Zlbeb\ ie_gZnjbdZgkdb_ibjZlum dhlhjuo
hg ijh`be e_l \ g_\he_ AZl_f hg ijhkem`be ]h^ fZljhkhf ?]h jhfZglbq_kdZy
bklhjby ijb\e_dZeZ \gbfZgb_ kh\j_f_ggbdh\ \ ]Za_lZo lh]h \j_f_gb fh`gh gZclb h
g_fg_fZehk\_^_gbc
DZd ^he]h `b\ml jmkkdb_" Ih ijh^he`bl_evghklb `bagb \ ?\jhi_ gug_ hgb
aZgbfZxl ihke_^g__ _ f_klh ² f_g__ e_l >he]h`bl_e_c g_ qZklh \klj_lbrv \
kh\j_f_gghcJhkkbb?keb[ugZrb ij_^db magZebh[wlhf bom^b\e_gbx g_ [ueh [u
ij_^_eZ\ ijhrehf^he]h`bl_evkl\h[ueh\_kvfZjZkijhkljZg_ggufy\e_gb_f
F_fmZjgZy ebl_jZlmjZ ;9²;9,, \_dh\ kh^_j`bl ^h\hevgh ex[hiulgu_
k\b^_l_evkl\ZLZddZiblZgFZj`_j_lgZgy\rbckygZkem`[md pZjx;hjbkm=h^mgh\m
ibkZe \ k\h_c dgb]_ ³Khklhygb_ Jhkkbckdhc ^_j`Z\u b <_ebdh]h dgy`_kl\Z
Fhkdh\kdh]h´\ ]h^m
³Fgh]b_ jmkkdb_ ^h`b\Zxl ^h e_l b lhevdh \ klZjhklb agZdhfu k
[he_agyfb AZ bkdexq_gb_f pZjy b ]eZ\g_crbo \_evfh` gbdlh g_ ijbagZ_l e_dZjkl\
Qm\kl\my k_[y [hevguf ijhklhex^bg h[udgh\_ggh \uib\Z_l ^h[jmx qZjdm \h^db
\kuiZ\ \ g__ aZjy^ jm`_cgh]h ihjhoZ beb kf_rZ\ gZiblhd k lheq_guf q_kghdhf b
lhlqZkb^_l\ [Zgx]^_\ kbevg_cr_f`Zjmihl__lqZkZ^\Zbebljb´
< k\h_c³Bklhjbb=hkm^Zjkl\ZJhkkbckdh]h´G:DZjZfabgk\b^_l_evkl\m_l³M
keZ\yg klhe_lb_ gZau\Zehkv \_dhf lh _klv `bagvx q_eh\_q_kdhx \h k\b^_l_evkl\h
kdhev ij_^db gZrb h[udgh\_ggh ^he]h^_gkl\h\Zeb h^Zj_ggu_ dj_idbf keh`_gb_f b
a^jZ\hxnbabq_kdhx^_yl_evghklbx´
:e_dkZg^j K_j]__\bq Imrdbg hibkZe k\hx \klj_qm kh e_lgbf dZaZdhf
ij_djZkgh ihfgb\rbf \hkklZgb_ Kl_iZgZ JZabgZ ² ]] \ dhlhjhf lhl kZf
ijbgbfZemqZklb_
< :e_dkZg^jhG_\kdhc eZ\j_ KZgdlI_l_j[mj]Z fh`gh [ueh \klj_lblv fh]beu
ebp hlebqZ\rboky g_h[udgh\_gguf ^he]he_lb_f fhgZoZ fheqZevgbdZ IZl_jfmnby
kdhgqZ\r_]hkygZ]h^mk\h_c`bagbaZl_ffh]bembghdZ:\jZZfbyijh`b\r_]h
e_l b ba\_klgh]h ?ebaZ\_lbgkdh]h b ?dZl_jbgbgkdh]h ]_jhy e_lg_]h klZjbdZ
<Zkbeby JhfZgh\bqZ S_]eh\kdh]h khkeZggh]h \ Kb[bjv Ihl_fdbguf ba j_\ghklb hg
ijh[ue\ kkued_e_l
< gZqZe_ gZr_]h \_dZ dh]^Z hlf_qZehkv e_lb_ jZa]jhfZ GZihe_hgZ ih^
Fhkd\hc jmkkdZy ij_kkZ ibkZeZ h[ hq_\b^pZo b mqZklgbdZo kh[ulbc ]h^Z
ijh^he`Z\rbo `blv b a^jZ\kl\h\Zlv \ ]h^m² e_lg_f n_ev^n_[_e_ B\Zg_
Ahjbg_e_lg_cGZ^_`^_Kmjbghce_lg_fJh^bhg_F_^\_^_\_
Ba fgh`_kl\Z bf_xsboky k\b^_l_evkl\ l_o ^Ze_dbo \j_f_g y\kl\m_l qlh
gZk_e_gb_ Jhkkbb \ kbem k\h_]h ]_ghlbiZ \ kbem ijbjh^guo mkeh\bc b a^hjh\h]h
iblZgby bf_eh \hafh`ghklv `blv ^he]hc b [h^jhc `bagvx ^h`b\Zy ^h g_h[uqZcgh
ij_dehggh]h\hajZklZkhojZgyyijbwlhfb ^mr_\gh_jZ\gh\_kb_b ykghklvmfZ
: fgh]hebk_cqZkijh`b\Z_l\ fbj_ex^_ci_j_rZ]gm\rboe_lgbcjm[_`"
Ih^ZggufnjZgpmakdh]h_`_g_^_evgbdZ³Imwg´ihZ[khexlgufpbnjZf^he]h`bl_e_c
l _ ex^_c q_c \hajZkl ij_\urZ_l e_l \ AZiZ^ghc ?\jhi_ \ gZklhys__ \j_fy
eb^bjm_l NjZgpby q_eh\_d AZ g_c k g_[hevrbf hlklZ\Zgb_f ke_^mxl
<_ebdh[jblZgbyq_eh\_db =_jfZgby q_eh\_d?keb`_[jZlvijhp_glgu_
ihdZaZl_ebqbkeh^he]h`bl_e_cgZq_eh\_dlha^_kvi_j\_gkl\hijbgZ^e_`bl
=j_pbb<lhjh_b lj_lv_f_klZaZgbfZxlkhhl\_lkl\_gghIhjlm]Zebyb >Zgby
< AZiZ^ghf;_jebg_ih^Zggufi_j_ibkb]h^ZgZkqblu\Zehkv`bl_e_c
\ \hajZkl_klZjr_e_l²[hevr_q_f\ ex[hf^jm]hf]hjh^_fbjZbadZ`^uo
]jZ`^ZgAZiZ^gh]h;_jebgZhlijZa^gh\Zebk\hce_lgbcx[be_c
< Kh_^bg_gguo RlZlZo :f_jbdb qbkeh ^he]h`bl_e_c i_j_rZ]gm\rbo e_lgbcjm[_`khklZ\ey_lq_eh\_dIj_^iheh`bl_evgh d dhgpml_dms_]h\_dZ\
:f_jbd_[m^_lijh`b\Zlvijbf_jgh^he]h`bl_e_c
< Yihgbb\ gZklhys__\j_fyaZj_]bkljbjh\Zgh`bl_e_c\ \hajZkl_e_lb
klZjr_²gZq_eh\_d[hevr_q_f\ ]h^mb \jZa[hevr_q_f\ ]h^m
E_]bhg klhe_lgbo gZkqblu\Z_l `_gsbg b fm`qbg ?]h klZj_crbgZ ² e_lgyyFblpmNm^abkZ\Zba]GZ]ZghGZdZ`^u_`bl_e_c\ Yihgbbijboh^blky\
kj_^g_f q_eh\_dZ \ \hajZkl_ e_l b klZjr_ Wlh kZfuc \ukhdbc mjh\_gv
^he]he_lby\ fbj_
Ih ^Zgguf ihke_^g_]h ^_fh]jZnbq_kdh]h hlq_lZ P_gljZevgh]h klZlbklbq_kdh]h
[xjh >_fhdjZlbq_kdhc J_kim[ebdb <v_lgZf \ kljZg_ ijh`b\Z_l \v_lgZfpZ
ij_h^he_\rboe_lgbcjm[_`
AZdhghf_jgh \hagbdZ_l \hijhk Z dZdh\Z `_ kj_^gyy ijh^he`bl_evghklv `bagb
\hh[s_Z g_lhevdhm ^he]h`bl_e_cEb^_jkl\hihijh^he`bl_evghklb`bagbdZdkj_^b
fm`qbg lZd b kj_^b `_gsbg aZo\ZlbeZ Yihgby < ]h^m kj_^gyy
ijh^he`bl_evghklv `bagb yihghd khklZ\eyeZ ]h^Z b gZ ^g_c ij_\urZeZ
kj_^gxxijh^he`bl_evghklv`bagbm ij_^klZ\bl_evgbpij_djZkgh]hiheZR\_cpZjbb
b^msbogZ\lhjhff_kl_>Ze__ke_^h\Zebr\_^dbnjZgpm`_gdbb ]heeZg^db
Kj_^gyyijh^he`bl_evghklv`bagbyihgp_\\ ]h^mkhklZ\eyeZ]h^Zih
kjZ\g_gbx k ]h^Z m r\_^h\ b^msbo gZ \lhjhf f_kl_ ih ^he]he_lbx >Ze__
ke_^mxlbkeZg^pur\_cpZjpub ]heeZg^pu
AZihke_^gb_^_kylbe_lbyqbkehyihgp_\\ \hajZkl_klZjr_e_lm\_ebqbehkv
\^\h_ Jhkl ijh^he`bl_evghklb `bagb \ Yihgbb \ agZqbl_evghc f_j_ h[mkeh\e_g
kgb`_gb_fkf_jlghklbhljZdZb bgkmevlZ
H`b^Z_fZy ijh^he`bl_evghklv `bagb gZk_e_gby KKKJ \ ² ]]
khklZ\eyeZ]h^ZAZi_jbh^k ²]]hgZm\_ebqbeZkvgZ]h^Z
GZb[he__ \ukhdb_ l_fiu jhklZ h`b^Z_fhc ijh^he`bl_evghklb `bagb
gZ[ex^Zebkv \ dhgp_ o b i_j\hc iheh\bg_ o ]h^h\ ?`_]h^gh_ ih\ur_gb_ __ \
kj_^g_f gZ ^\Z ]h^Z [ueh \ua\Zgh \g_^j_gb_f \ ijZdlbdm hj]Zgh\ a^jZ\hhojZg_gby
kmevnZfb^guo ij_iZjZlh\ b Zglb[bhlbdh\ bo ^hklmighklvx kZfuf rbjhdbf kehyf
gZk_e_gby Kgb`_gb_ kf_jlghklb ijhbkoh^beh \iehlv ^h o ]h^h\ dh]^Z \ KKKJ
ijh^he`bl_evghklv`bagbm fm`qbg[ueZebrvgZ]h^ZZ m`_gsbggZ]h^Zgb`_
q_f\ kj_^g_f\ jZa\bluodZiblZebklbq_kdbokljZgZofbjZ
< KR:kj_^gyyijh^he`bl_evghklv`bagbm\_ebqbeZkvk e_l\ ]^h
e_l\ gZklhys__\j_fy
:gZeh]bqgu_ ijhp_kku m\_ebq_gby ijh^he`bl_evghklb `bagb gZ[ex^Zxlky b
^Z`__s_[uklj__g_lhevdh\ jZa\bluokljZgZoghb \jy^_jZa\b\ZxsbokykljZgLZd
\ H[t_^bg_gguo :jZ[kdbo WfbjZlZo kj_^gyy ijh^he`bl_evghklv `bagb m\_ebqbeZkv
^h]h^ZLjb^_kylbe_lbygZaZ^hgZg_ij_\urZeZe_l< jZa\b\ZxsbokykljZgZo
m\_ebq_gb_ kj_^g_c ijh^he`bl_evghklb `bagb ^hklb]Z_l \ hkgh\ghf aZ kq_l
mf_gvr_gby ^_lkdhc kf_jlghklb ?keb \ ]h^m wlhl ihdZaZl_ev \ H[t_^bg_gguo
:jZ[kdboWfbjZlZo^hklb]ZekemqZ_\gZ ^_l_clh\ gZklhys__\j_fy^_lkdZy
kf_jlghklvg_ij_\urZ_llZfkemqZ_\gZ^_l_c
< jZa\bluo dZiblZebklbq_kdbo kljZgZo ijh[e_fZ ^_lkdhc kf_jlghklb ^Z\gh
hlklmibeZ gZ \lhjhc ieZg b m\_ebq_gb_ ijh^he`bl_evghklb `bagb ^hklb]Z_lky \
hkgh\ghf aZ kq_l kgb`_gby kf_jlghklb hl k_j^_qghkhkm^bkluo b hgdheh]bq_kdbo
aZ[he_\ZgbcWlhg_fbgm_fh\_^_ld ³klZj_gbx´gZk_e_gby
>hdeZ^]_g_jZevgh]hk_dj_lZjyHHG hklZj_gbbjZkijhkljZg_g\ rlZ[d\Zjlbj_
khh[s_kl\Z gZpbc DZ`^uc f_kyp fbeebhg `bl_e_c gZr_c ieZg_lu i_j_oh^bl jm[_`
e_lg_]h \hajZklZ Z k\ur_ luk² jm[_` e_l hlf_qZ_lky \ ^hdmf_gl_ Wlb
ihdZaZl_eb aZ ihke_^gb_ ]h^u g_mdehggh \hajZklZeb b l_g^_gpby khojZgblky \
[m^ms_f< k\yabk wlbffgh]bfkljZgZfijboh^blkyhjb_glbjh\Zlvkyg_gZfheh^_`vZ
gZex^_c[he__aj_eh]h\hajZklZ
Ijhp_kk klZj_gby gZk_e_gby ij_^klZ\ey_l kh[hc bklhjbq_kdmx i_j_f_gm
hlf_qZ_lky\ ^hdmf_gl_dhlhjZylj_[m_lbaf_g_gbc\ klbe_`bagbhl^_evgh]hq_eh\_dZ
k_fvbkljZguj_]bhgZ
L_g^_gpby ³klZj_gby´ gZk_e_gby \uau\ZxsZy m`_ k_]h^gy hij_^_e_ggmx
haZ[hq_gghklv\ AZiZ^ghc?\jhi_[m^_lihij_`g_fmkdZau\Zlvkyb \gZqZe_;;,\_dZ
lZdh\ijh]ghanjZgpmakdh]h_`_g_^_evgbdZ³Imwg´< ]^heyex^_cklZjr_e_l
\ NJ= khklZ\bl hl h[s_]h qbkeZ `bl_e_c kljZgu < BlZebb hgZ khklZ\bl
khhl\_lkl\_ggh \ =j_pbb ² \ >Zgbb ² \h NjZgpbb ² \
;_ev]bb²\ BkiZgbb²\ Gb^_jeZg^Zo²\ <_ebdh[jblZgbb²
\ Ihjlm]Zebb²b \BjeZg^bb²
LZdbf h[jZahf ih[_`^Zy [he_agb q_eh\_q_kl\h g_mdehggh ijb[eb`Z_lky d
^hklb`_gbx\_jog_]hij_^_eZq_eh\_q_kdhc`bagb: dZdh\`_hgwlhl\_jogbcij_^_e"
E_hgZj^ O_cnebd ijhn_kkhj ZgZlhfbb f_^bpbgkdhc rdheu DZebnhjgbckdh]h
mgb\_jkbl_lZ gZ hkgh\Zgbb khihklZ\e_gby khklZ\e_gguo bf ]jZnbdh\ \u`b\Zgby
q_eh\_dZ ^ey hl^_evguo kljZg b jZaguo i_jbh^h\ ihemqbe l_hj_lbq_kdmx djb\mx k
\_jogbfij_^_ehf\ e_l
H^gh\j_f_ggh E O_cnebd h[gZjm`be _s_ h^gm bgl_j_kgmx aZdhghf_jghklv
hdZau\Z_lky ijh^he`bl_evghklv `bagb q_eh\_dZ ijhihjpbhgZevgh k\yaZgZ k
hlghr_gb_f\_kZfha]Zd \_km_]hl_eZQ_f[hevr_wlhhlghr_gb_l_f^ebgg__`bagvZ
hgZ^h\hevghj_adhf_gyeZkv\ hij_^_e_ggu_i_jbh^u\ l_q_gb_w\hexpbbIhke_^gbc
jZakbevgh___ m\_ebq_gb_ijhbahrehlukyqe_lgZaZ^ihke_q_]hhgZijZdlbq_kdb
g_f_gyeZkvdZdg_f_gyehkvb hlghr_gb_\_kZfha]Zd \_kml_eZ
E_hgZj^ O_cnebd bf__l lZd`_ hlebqgmx hl h[s_ijbgylhc lhqdm aj_gby gZ
klZj_gb_ hj]ZgbafZ b gZoh^bl wlhfm ^hdZaZl_evkl\Z \ ijbjh^_ HdZau\Z_lky klZj_gb_
gZklmiZ_l ihke_ ij_djZs_gby jhklZ b l_ kms_kl\Z gZijbf_j ZdmeZ hk_lj
]ZeZiZ]hkkdZy q_j_iZoZ jZaf_ju dhlhjuo g_h]jZgbq_gu g_ klZj_xl ohly b g_
[_kkf_jlgu
BlZd e_l Gh b wlh \k_lZdb g_ ij_^_e AgZf_gbluc kj_^g_dh\uc mq_guc
f_^bdIZjZp_evkkqblZeqlhq_eh\_dfh`_l`blv^he_lIhfg_gbxmq_guo;9,,,
\_dZ;=mn_eZg^Zb :=Zee_jZ_kl_kl\_ggucij_^_eq_eh\_q_kdhc`bagb²e_lB
F_qgbdh\ @ Hjbghc b : ;h]hfhe_p iheZ]Zxl qlh wlhl ij_^_e g_ ij_\urZ_l ²
e_l
< dhgp_ o ]h^h\ \ <_ebdh[jblZgbb [ueZ ba^ZgZ dgb]Z Zg]ebckdh]h \jZqZ
Xklbgu=eZk_³>h`blv^hklZ\hkvfb^_kylb´dhlhjZykjZamklZeZ[_klk_ee_jhf:\lhj
klZ\beZ i_j_^ qblZl_e_f aZ^Zqm ^h`blv ^h klZ \hkvfb^_kylb e_l g_ mljZqb\Zy
`bag_gguokbeb \k_]hlh]hqlhijbgylhkqblZlv³jZ^hklvx`bagb´
DZdb_ `_ Zj]mf_glu ijb\h^yl mq_gu_ \ aZsblm k\hbo l_hjbc ^himklbfhc
ijh^he`bl_evghklb`bagb"
Kh]eZkgh jZkq_lZf [bheh]h\ ijh^he`bl_evghklv `bagb ex[h]h \b^Z `b\hlguo
khklZ\ey_l hl ^h i_jbh^h\ \j_f_gb ^hklb`_gby aj_ehklb ^Zggh]h \b^Z Q_eh\_d
^hklb]Z_l aj_ehklb f_`^m b ]h^Zfb b h`b^Z_fZy ijh^he`bl_evghklv gZr_c
`bagbihwlbfjZkq_lZffh`_l^hklb]Zlve_lHl^_evgu_]_jhglheh]bki_pbZebklu
ih^he]h`bl_evkl\mih^gbfZxlwlm]jZgbpm_s_\ur_
GZijbf_j _keb ehrZ^b qlh[u \ujZklb gm`gh ² ]h^Z Z `b\_l hgZ ²
e_l_kebkh[Zd_qlh[u\ujZklbgm`gh²]h^ZZ `b\_lhgZ²e_llhq_eh\_d
dhlhjucjZkl_le_l^he`_gkhhl\_lkl\_ggh`blvhdheh^\mokhle_l
DZd wlh gb iZjZ^hdkZevgh a\mqbl qj_a\uqZcgh j_^dh dlheb[h mfbjZ_l
_kl_kl\_gghc kf_jlvx hl klZjhklb IjZdlbq_kdb \k_]^Z ijbqbghc kf_jlb y\eyxlky
jZaebqgu_aZ[he_\Zgby²k_j^_qghkhkm^bklu_hgdheh]bq_kdb_bgn_dpbhggu_
< k\hbo³Wlx^ZohilbfbafZ´BBF_qgbdh\mdZau\Z_lqlh³\ ]\ IZjb`_
gZkf_jlguokemqZ_\f_`^mb ]h^ZfbhlklZjhklbmf_jeh\k_]hq_eh\_d
;hevrbgkl\hklZjbdh\mfbjZehhlaZjZaguo[he_ag_c\hkiZe_gb_e_]dbob qZohldbhl
[he_ag_ck_j^pZihq_db djh\hbaebygbc\ fha]m´
>Z`_ mihfbgZ\rb_ky gZfb agZf_gblu_ ^he]h`bl_eb Zg]ebqZgbg LhfZk IZjj
]h^Zb lmjhdAZjh:]Ze_lmf_jebg_hl\hajZklZZ hl[he_ag_cI_j\uc²hl
ig_\fhgbbZ \lhjhc²hlmj_fbq_kdhcdhfu\ua\Zgghc]bi_jljhnb_cijhklZlu
BlZd h^bg ba iml_c ijh^e_gby `bagb hq_\b^_g ² wlh ijh]j_kk f_^bpbgu
[hjv[Z k jZaebqgufb aZ[he_\Zgbyfb Bf_ggh [eZ]h^Zjy wlhfm klhev mki_rgh
m\_ebqb\ZeZkv ijh^he`bl_evghklv `bagb \ jZa\bluo b dZiblZebklbq_kdbo kljZgZo Gh
\k_wlh²ebrv^hba\_klgh]hij_^_eZ
³Ba\_klgh qlh kj_^gyy ijh^he`bl_evghklv `bagb q_eh\_dZ \ l_q_gb_
lukyq_e_lbc \ kmsghklb g_ baf_gbeZkv F_gy_lky lh qlh \ klZlbklbd_ gZau\Zxl
ij_^iheZ]Z_fhc ijh^he`bl_evghklvx `bagb HgZ m\_qbqb\Z_lky ihkdhevdm
q_eh\_q_kl\hih[_^beh^_lkdb_b ^jm]b_[he_agbhkh[_gghbgn_dpbhggu_>Zevg_cr__
m\_ebq_gb_ ijh^he`bl_evghklb `bagb ijhbahc^_l [eZ]h^Zjy ih[_^_ gZ^
hgdheh]bq_kdbfb
b
k_j^_qghkhkm^bklufb
aZ[he_\Zgbyfb
gh
kj_^gyy
ijh^he`bl_evghklv `bagb hq_\b^gh g_ baf_gblky K_]h^gyrgbc e_lgbc q_eh\_d
bf__lklhevdh`_rZgkh\ijh`blv_s_g_kdhevdhe_ldZdb _]hjh\_kgbde_lgZaZ^
AZdexq_gby
ki_pbZebklh\
bkke_^h\Z\rbo
^he]h`bl_e_c
^bZf_ljZevgh
ijhlb\hiheh`gu Ex^_c ^h`b\rbo ^h e_l fh`gh gZclb \ ljhibdZo b \ Kb[bjb
@b\ml aZy^eu_ e_lgb_ dmjbevsbdb b e_lgb_ ijhlb\gbdb lZ[ZdZ >h e_l
a^jZ\kl\mxlex[bl_ebfykghcibsbb \_]_lZjbZgpu´
Klhev g_h[uqgh_ aZdexq_gb_ ijbgZ^e_`bl q_rkdhfm ]_jhglheh]m ki_pbZebklm
ih ijh[e_fZf klZj_gby YjhkeZ\m =h\hjd_ DZd [u wlh gb iZjZ^hdkZevgh a\mqZeh
mki_ob \ ijh^e_gbb `bagb ijZdlbq_kdb g_ ih\ebyeb gZ \b^h\mx ijh^he`bl_evghklv
`bagb =hfh kZib_gk Bgufb keh\Zfb ijb hlghkbl_evghc klZ[bevghklb fZl_jbZevguo
mklh\bc ijh^he`bl_evghklv `bagb ex^_c nZdlbq_kdb hklZ_lky g_baf_gghc gZ
ijhly`_gbbklhe_lbcZ \hafh`ghb \k_cbklhjbbIh^kqblZghqlhkj_^gbc\hajZkl
agZf_gbluo ex^_c wihob deZkkbq_kdhc ^j_\ghklb jZ\gyeky ]h^Z Z agZf_gblhkl_c mf_jrbo \ i_j\hf ^_kylbe_lbb ;; \_dZ ijh`beb \ kj_^g_f ]h^
Ke_^h\Zl_evghkdhjhklvklZj_gbykms_kl\_gghg_baf_gbeZkvkf_jlghklvkj_^bex^_c
ih`beh]hb klZjq_kdh]h\hajZklZhklZeZkvijb[ebabl_evghgZlhf`_mjh\g_b kZfZih
k_[_ g_[hevrZy qbke_gghklv l_o dlh ijh`be [he__ klZ e_l ih mlhqg_gguf ^Zgguf
k_]h^gy g_ \ur_ q_f klh beb ^\_klb e_l gZaZ^ <uoh^bl qlh f_oZgbaf klZj_gby
g_kfhljygZ\k_ijbgylu_^hkboihjf_juhklZekyij_`gbfDklZlbiZjZ^hdkZevghklv
lZdh]hfg_gbyg_jZah[u]ju\ZeZkv\ Zg_d^hlZo
J_ihjl_j ² BlZd \Zf k_]h^gy bkihegbehkv e_l Q_f \u h[tykgbl_ klhev
j_^dhklgh_^he]he_lb_"
>he]h`bl_ev ² GZ wlhl \hijhk y \Zf kfh]m hl\_lblv lhevdh aZ\ljZ K_cqZk y
aZdZgqb\Zx i_j_]h\hju k hl^_eZfb j_deZfu nZ[jbdb \blZfbgh\ ib\aZ\h^Z b nbjfu
fhehqguoijh^mdlh\
:IQ_oh\\ ]h^m\ ]Za_l_³Gh\h_\j_fy´him[ebdh\Zeg_[hevrhcn_ev_lhg
³H ^he]h\_qghklb´ ]^_ h[km`^Zxlky aZljhgmlu_ gZfb ijh[e_fu ³;_a khfg_gby
hij_^_e_gguc lbi klhe_lg_]h q_eh\_dZ ljm^gh ij_^klZ\blv k_[_ ³;jblZgkdZy
f_^bpbgkdZyZkkhpbZpby´k wlhcp_evx^_eZeZjZaukdZgbyghhl\_lZ^hklZ\e_ggu_
gZ __ \hijhku g_ fh]ml ^Zlv ihgylby h klhe_lgbo fm`qbgZo b `_gsbgZo ^Z`_ ^ey
h^ghc :g]ebb HdZaZehkv qlh \ qbke_ klhe_lgbo _klv \kydb_ km[t_dlu ² lmqgu_ b
lhsb_ijyfu_b k]hj[e_ggu_kbevgu_b keZ[u_dmjysb_b g_dmjysb_k am[Zfbb [_a
hguo iheghdjh\gu_ b fZehdjh\gu_ [h]Zlu_ b [_^gu_ ;he__ ^\mo lj_l_c ba wlbo klhe_lgbo [ueb `_gsbgu : \ h[s_f blh]_ wlZ klZlbklbdZ h[ Zg]ebckdbo klZjbdZo
ijb\h^bllhevdhd lhfmaZdexq_gbxqlhhj]Zgbafq_eh\_dZ_klvg_qlhlZdh_qlh^Z_l
\hafh`ghklv`blv^he]h^Z`_g_aZ\bkbfhhlkbevghcdhgkbkl_gpbbb h[jZaZ`bagb
DZdijhkeZ\eyebgZijbf_jjZklbl_evgmxibsmB h^gZdh` ihqlb\k_klhe_lgb_
Zg]ebqZg_ iblZebkv `b\hlghc ibs_c b bgh]^Z \ [hevrhf dhebq_kl\_ H^gZ klhe_lgyy
klZjmoZbf_eZlZdhckeZ\gucZii_lblqlh^hreZ^hkt_^Zgbylj_o`Zj_guopuieylaZ
aZ\ljZdhfGhaZlhhgZibeZfZehb \bgZgbdh]^Zg_ibeZGZijhlb\h^bgbafm`qbg\
Zg]ebckdhcdhee_dpbb\ ]h^Zibe[hevr_q_ffh]´
DZ`^ucbanZdlhjh\dhlhjhfmdZaZehkv[uk i_j\h]h\a]ey^Zfh`ghijbibkZlv
\ebygb_ gZ ^he]h\_qghklv mkdhevaZ_l ijb jZkkfhlj_gbb ^hklZlhqgh]h dhebq_kl\Z
ijbf_jh\ Mf_j_gghklv g_khfg_ggh y\ey_lky h^ghc ba ijbqbg ^he]he_lby ohly
dhg_qgh`_g__^bgkl\_gghc
LZd f_`^m klhe_lgbfb klZjpZfb g_ hkh[_ggh j_^dh \klj_qZxlky ivygbpu
Objmj] IheblbfZg mf_j e_l ² k e_l hg bf_e h[udgh\_gb_ ih
hdhgqZgbb k\hbo ^g_\guo aZgylbc _`_^g_\gh gZib\Zlvky =Zkdhgv fykgbd \ Ljb_
\ukhdboIbj_g_yomf_jrbc\ ]h^m\ \hajZkl_e_lgZib\ZekyjZaZ\ g_^_ex
IhjZabl_e_gijbf_jh^gh]hbjeZg^kdh]ha_fe_\eZ^_evpZ;jZmgZ^h`b\r_]h^he_l
HgaZ\_sZek^_eZlv_fmgZ^]jh[gmxgZ^ibkv]eZkysmxqlh³hg[ue\k_]^Zivygb lZd
kljZr_g\ wlhfkhklhygbbqlhkZfZkf_jlv[hyeZkv_]h´
G_dhlhju_ klZjbdb ivxl fgh]h dhn_ <kihfgbf hl\_l <hevl_jZ k\h_fm \jZqm
dhlhjuchibku\Ze_fm\j_^dhn_^_ckl\mxs_]hdZdgZklhysbcy^³<hlkdhjhe_l
dZd y hljZ\eyxkv wlbf y^hf´² kdZaZe _fm \_ebdbc ibkZl_ev KlZjbdb `b\rb_ ^he__
<hevl_jZ bgh]^Z ibeb _s_ [hevr_ dhn_ q_f hg KZ\hyjdZ ?ebaZ\_lZ >xjbwg `beZ
[he__ e_l Kh\j_f_ggbdb k\b^_evkl\mxl ³?_ ]eZ\gmx ibsm khklZ\eye dhn_ hgZ
ibeZ _]h ^h qZr_d \ ^_gv HgZ [ueZ \_k_eh]h gjZ\Z ohjhrh _eZ b _`_^g_\gh ibeZ
q_jgucdhn_\ lZdhfdhebq_kl\_qlhkZfucyjucZjZ[g_m]gZeky[uaZg_cDhn_cgbd
\k_]^ZklhyegZh]g_dZdqZcgbdm Zg]ebqZg´
AZf_q_gh qlh [hevrbgkl\h klhe_lgbo klZjp_\ g_ dmjbl Gh b wlh ijZ\beh dZd
fgh]b_^jm]b_g_\k_]^Zijbeh`bfhJhkkihemqb\rbcij_fbx^he]he_lby\ ]h^Z
\ ]h^m[ueg_bkijZ\bfucdmjbevsbd< ]h^m \ EZDZjjv_j \ \hajZkl_ e_lmf_jeZklZjZy\^h\ZEZa_ggwdHgZ`beZ\ gZklhys_cljmsh[_i_j_[b\ZeZkvh^gbf
ih^Zygb_fb kjZggboe_ldmjbeZljm[dm
:f_jbdZgkdbc mq_guc : Ebn bamqZe jZaebqgu_ nZdlhju \ebyxsb_ gZ
ijh^he`bl_evghklv `bagb \ lZd gZau\Z_fuo ³hqZ]Zo ^he]he_lby´ ² h[hkh[e_gguo
ij_bfms_kl\_ggh ]hjguo jZchgZo ]^_ ex^b `b\ml agZqbl_evgh ^hevr_ b hklZxlky \
klZjhklb [he__ wg_j]bqgufb b `bag_kihkh[gufb q_f \ [hevrbgkl\_ kh\j_f_gguo
h[s_kl\ LZd \ :[oZabb \hajZkl gZk_e_gby ij_\urZ_l e_l qlh \ jZaZ
[hevr_q_fZgZeh]bqgh_khhlghr_gb_\ KR:Hgh[ke_^h\Ze]hjgu_jZchgu:[oZabb
^_j_\mrdm<bevdZ[Zf[Z\ :g^ZoWd\Z^hjb ]hjgucwfbjZlOmgamgZoj_[l_DZjZdhjmf
\ DZrfbj_ <u\h^u _]h g_h[uqgu ihkdhevdm mkeh\by `bagb \ ³hqZ]Zo ^he]he_lby´ b
hdjm`Zxsbobo³h[uqguo´jZchgZohq_gvkoh`bex[u_\uy\e_ggu_jZaebqbyfh`ghk
m\_j_gghklvx hlg_klb aZ kq_l gZke_^kl\_gghklb GZmd_ g_ ba\_kl_g ³]_g ^he]he_lby´
fh`gh ]h\hjblv ebrv h[ hlkmlkl\bb ³\j_^guo´ ]_gh\ ² lZdbo dhlhju_ m\_ebqb\Zxl
hiZkghklv g_ba[_`guo aZ[he_\Zgbc < fZe_gvdbo aZfdgmluo khh[s_kl\Zo ih^h[guo
bahebjh\Zgguf]hjgufk_eZfg_dhlhju_bg^b\b^mmfum dhlhjuohlkmlkl\h\ZeblZdb_
]_gu klZeb jh^hgZqZevgbdZfb p_ehc ]jmiiu ^he]h`bl_e_c H[hkh[e_gghklv wlh]h
]hjgh]h ihk_e_gby kihkh[kl\h\ZeZ khojZg_gbx ]_g_lbq_kdbo qbkluo ebgbc b
ij_iylkl\h\ZeZ\dexq_gbx\ ]_ghlbi³\j_^guo´]_gh\
M`_\ ;9,,,\_d_=Zee_jh[jZlbe\gbfZgb_gZlhqlhklhe_lg_]h\hajZklZqZklh
^hklb]Zxl qe_gu h^ghc b lhc `_ k_fvb qlh ih^Zeh ih\h^ kqblZlv ^he]h\_qghklv
gZke_^kl\_gghcKugagZf_gblh]hZg]ebckdh]h^he]h`bl_eyLhfZkZIZjjZ^h`be^h
e_l b\ ]h^m mf_j \ Fbr_eklZmg_ \iheg_ khojZgb\ ^h dhgpZ mfkl\_ggu_
kihkh[ghklb
< ]h^m dZj^bgZe ^
:jfZgvyd ijhoh^y ih mebp_ aZf_lbe ieZqms_]h e_lg_]h klZjbdZ GZ \hijhk dZj^bgZeZ klZjbd hl\_lbe qlh hg ieZq_l ihlhfm qlh _]h
ih[be hl_p M^b\e_gguc dZj^bgZe kdZaZe qlh ohq_l \b^_lv hlpZ ?fm ij_^klZ\beb
klZjbdZ e_lhq_gv[h^jh]h^ey_]h\hajZklZ ³Y ih[be kugZ² kdZaZe klZjbd² aZ
g_m\Z`_gb_d ^_^mHgijhr_efbfhg_]hg_ihdehgb\rbkv´< ^hf_dZj^bgZem\b^_eb
wlh]h^_^Zdhlhjhfm[ueh]h^Z
BlZd\iheg_hq_\b^ghqlhgZke_^kl\_gghklvb]jZ_l\_kvfZkms_kl\_ggmxjhev\
ijh^he`bl_evghklb
`bagb
>jm]hc
klhjhghc
l_hjbb
h
\jh`^_gghc
ij_^jZkiheh`_gghklb d ijh^he`bl_evghklb `bagb y\ey_lky ihiuldZ hij_^_eblv
ij_^iheZ]Z_fu_kjhdb`bagbk ihfhsvxebgbcjmdbhkh[_gghlZdgZau\Z_fhc³ebgbb
`bagb´ < hnbpbZevghf `mjgZe_ Zg]ebckdh]h Dhjhe_\kdh]h f_^bpbgkdh]h h[s_kl\Z
g_^Z\gh ihy\beZkv klZlvy \ua\Z\rZy h`b\e_ggmx ihe_fbdm ?_ Z\lhj ^hdlhj Ihe
Gvxjbd ba ;jbklhey ml\_j`^Z_l qlh kms_kl\m_l ijyfZy k\yav f_`^m ^ebghc ³ebgbb
`bagb´ gZ jmd_ q_eh\_dZ b ijh^he`bl_evghklvx _]h `bagb Wlhl \u\h^ k^_eZg gZ
hkgh\Zgbbh[ke_^h\Zgbyljmih\²fm`qbgb `_gsbg
Dhee_]bj_adhdjblbdmxl^hdlhjZGvxjbdZghk jZaguoihabpbcH^gb]h\hjyl
qlh ^ey ih^h[guo ml\_j`^_gbc g_h[oh^bfh ijh\_klb bkke_^h\Zgb_ ih f_gvr_c f_j_
ljmih\ >jm]b_ h[jZsZxl \gbfZgb_ gZ lh qlh ³ebgby `bagb´ dZd b fhjsbgu gZ
dh`_ ebpZ q_eh\_dZ kh\_jr_ggh _kl_kl\_ggh m\_ebqb\Z_lky k \hajZklhf ihwlhfm m
ex^_cmf_jrboih`beufbhgZ\k_]^Z[m^_l^ebgg__Z mfheh^uo²dhjhq_
G_kfhljy gZ lh qlh ljm^gh \u^_eblv dZdb_lh nZdlhju g_khfg_ggh
kihkh[kl\mxsb_ijh^he`bl_evghklb`bagb\k_`_mq_gu_iulZxlky^Z\Zlvg_dhlhju_
j_dhf_g^Zpbb Fu ijb\_^_f g_[hevrmx lZ[ebpm ba dgb]b q_rkdh]h ]_jhglheh]Z
YjhkeZ\Z =h\hjdb ³>hjh]Z d ^he]he_lbx´ K ihfhsvx wlhc lZ[ebpu \u kZfb
ih^kqblZ_l_gZkdhevdhe_l\ufh`_l_ijh^eblvk_[_`bagvbgZh[hjhlkdhevdhe_l\u
kZfbm k_[ydjZ^_l_
;hevrbgkl\hbkke_^h\Zl_e_ckqblZxlqlhkms_kl\mxl^\Zg_aZ\bkbfuoy\e_gby
hij_^_eyxsbo ^ebl_evghklv `bagb² nbabheh]bq_kdbc ijhp_kk klZj_gby b [he_agb
dhlhju_ \k_ \ [hevr_c kl_i_gb ihjZ`Z_l q_eh\_dZ ih f_j_ m\_ebq_gby \hajZklZ
JZkkm`^_gby a^_kv kljhylky ke_^mxsbf h[jZahf ?keb [m^ml mkljZg_gu hkgh\gu_
[he_agb klZj_gby ² Zl_jhkde_jha b jZd lh dZd \uqbkebeb ijb\_j`_gpu wlhc lhqdb
aj_gby^ebl_evghklv`bagbq_eh\_dZm\_ebqblkygZe_l_keb`_[m^mlmkljZg_gu\k_
[he_agb ih`beh]h \hajZklZ lh wlh ^Zkl \ kj_^g_f ^hihegbl_evgh hl ^\mo ^h iylb e_l
`bagb GZ wlhf hkgh\Zgbb ij_^iheZ]Z_lky qlh \ mkeh\byo klZj_gby gh [_a [he_ag_c
q_eh\_d[m^_lmfbjZlv\ \hajZkl_[ebadhfd ]h^Zf
Ghwlhlhevdhh^gZklhjhgZf_^Zeb<lhjh_b[ulvfh`_lhkgh\gh_gZijZ\e_gb_
iml_cijh^e_gby`bagb²wlhihbkdf_oZgbafh\_kl_kl\_ggh]hklZj_gbyhj]ZgbafZGZ
k_]h^gyrgbc ^_gv gZmd_ ba\_klgh hdheh ]bihl_a klZj_gby Z gm`gZ \k_]h h^gZ
l_hjby
JZkkfhljbf g_dhlhju_ ba wlbo l_hjbc b \ul_dZxsb_ ba gbo j_dhf_g^Zpbb ih
imlyfijh^e_gby`bagb
< ]h^m mfbjZe iZiZ Bgghd_glbc 9,,, Ih keh\Zf bklhjbdh\ Bgn_kkmju b
^jm]bo_]h\jZqiulZykvijh[m^blv\ g_f`bag_ggu_kbeuijb[_]gmed ij_klmighfm
kj_^kl\m²\imklbe\ `beumfbjZxs_]hdjh\vlj_ofZevqbdh\IZiZagZeh[m[bckl\_
wlbofZevqbdh\b kh]eZkbekygZwlhH^gZdhwlhlkihkh[ijh^e_gby`bagbBgghd_glbx
9,,,g_ihfh]b iha`_d g_fmm`_g_\ha\jZsZebkv
< [b[e_ckdb_ \j_f_gZ ^mfZeb qlh khijbdhkgh\_gb_ hkeZ[e_gguo klZjbdh\ k
fheh^ufb^_\mrdZfbfheh^blb m^ebgy_l`bagv< Dgb]_PZjkl\gZoh^bfke_^mxs__
ih\_kl\h\Zgb_ ³B khklZjbeky pZjv >Z\b^ b ^hklb] ij_^_evgh]h \hajZklZ b ohly _]h
ihdju\Zebh^_`^ZfbhggbdZdg_fh]kh]j_lvkyB kdZaZeb_fm_]hkem]b³^Zijb\_^ml
h pZjvfheh^mx^_\kl\_ggbpmqlh[u[ueZhgZijbpZj_b oh^beZ[uaZgbfb kiZeZ[u
gZ]jm^b_]hb kh]j_eky[upZjvgZr\eZklbl_ev´Wlhlkihkh[ba\_klguciha^g__ih^
bf_g_f]_jhdhfbbmihlj_[eyeky]j_dZfbb jbfeygZfbb gZr_eihke_^h\Zl_e_c^Z`_\
gh\_crb_ \j_f_gZ Ih kh\_lm agZf_gblh]h ]heeZg^kdh]h \jZqZ ;mj]Z\_ ²
h^bg klZjuc Zfkl_j^Zfkdbc [mj]hfbklj kiZe f_`^m ^\mfy fheh^ufb ^_\mrdZfb qlh
ihm\_j_gbx\jZqZ\ agZqbl_evghckl_i_gb\_jgmeh_fmkbeub \_k_ehklv
<jZq ;9,,, \_dZ DhoZma_g gZi_qZlZe ^bkk_jlZpbx h jbfeygbg_ =_jfbiiZmk_
mf_jr_f lb e_l dhlhjuc [ue mqbl_e_f \ `_gkdhc rdhe_ b ijh`be lZd ^he]h
[eZ]h^Zjy ihklhygghfm h[s_gbx k fheh^ufb ^_\mrdZfb <\b^m wlh]h \jZq b mq_guc
;9,,,\_dZ=mn_eZg^Z\lhjba\_klghc³FZdjh[bhlbdb´^Z_lke_^mxsbckh\_l\^uoZlv
mljhfb \_q_jhf^uoZgb_fheh^uo^_\mr_db m\_jy_lqlhwlh[_kdhg_qghkihkh[kl\m_l
mdj_ie_gbx b ih^^_j`Zgbx `bag_gguo kbe lZd dZd ^uoZgb_ \ wlhf \hajZkl_ _s_
kh^_j`bli_j\bqgmxfZl_jbx\h\k_c__ qbklhl_
< k\hbo ³Wlx^Zo hilbfbafZ´ B B F_qgbdh\ h[tykgy_l n_ghf_g ]_jhdhfbb
g_kdhevdhbgZq_;ebahklvfheh^uo^_\mr_dih_]hfg_gbx^he`gZ\ua\Zlv\u^_e_gb_
khdZ ij_^klZl_evghc `_e_au dhlhjuc \kZku\Zykv \ djh\v klZjbdZ ijhba\h^bl
\ha[m^bl_evgh_^_ckl\b_gZg_j\gmxkbkl_fm
?s_ \ >j_\g_c Bg^bb h^gbf ba ^_ckl\_gguo kj_^kl\ hfheh`_gby kqblZebkv
ki_pbZevgu_ ibexeb ba k_f_gguo `_e_a lb]jh\ b djhdh^beh\ h[\Zeyggu_ \ ahehlhc
im^j_
AgZf_gbluc nbabheh] ;,; \_dZ ;jhmgK_dZj kqblZ\rbc qlh klZjq_kdZy
keZ[hklv aZ\bkbl hl mf_gvr_gby \u^_ebl_evghc kihkh[ghklb k_f_gguo `_e_a ohl_e
ihfhqv wlhfm ih^dh`guf \kijukdb\Zgb_f wfmevkbb ijb]hlh\e_gghc ba k_f_gguo
`_e_a`b\hlguokh[Zdb fhjkdbok\bghd;jhmgK_dZj^hklb]rbcd wlhfm\j_f_gb
e_l\ijukdb\Zek_[_g_kdhevdhjZawlm`b^dhklvbih_]hm\_j_gbyfqm\kl\h\Zek_[y
ihke_wlh]h[h^j__b fheh`_Fgh]b_ih^\_j]Zebk_[ylhfm`_e_q_gbxdhlhjh_\hreh
gZg_dhlhjh_\j_fy\ fh^mHl]hehkdbwlhcfh^ufh`gh\klj_lblvgZkljZgbpZoih\_klb
F : ;me]Zdh\Z ³Kh[Zqv_ k_j^p_´ H^gZdh gh\uc f_lh^ g_ hijZ\^Ze iheghklvx
\haeZ]Z\rboky gZ g_]h gZ^_`^ i_jbh^ memqr_gby kZfhqm\kl\by m klZjbdh\ [ue
hlghkbl_evgh djZldh\j_f_gguf b lj_[h\Ze ihklhygguo \\_^_gbc ku\hjhldb k_f_gguo
`_e_a Ihwlhfm e_q_gb_ ;jhmgK_dZjZ \kdhj_ [ueh \uq_jdgmlh ba qbkeZ gZmqguo
ijb_fh\ ohly _s_ ^he]h ijbf_gyehkv hl^_evgufb qZklgh ijZdlbdmxsbfb \jZqZfb
hkh[_ggh\hNjZgpbb
GZ jm[_`_ ;,; b ;; \_dh\ \ I_l_j[mj]_ rbjhdh j_deZfbjh\Zeky ij_iZjZl
ki_jfbgijb]hlh\ey\rbckyijhn_kkhjhfI_e_fHgij_^klZ\eyekh[hclZd`_\uly`dm
ba k_f_gguo `_e_a b \kijukgmluc ih^ dh`m beb ijhklh ijbgyluc \gmljv \ \b^_
ihjhrdZ\hkklZgZ\eb\Ze^hba\_klghckl_i_gbkbeuhkeZ[e_ggu_\hajZklhf
;hevrh_ agZq_gb_ k\yayf iheh\hc nmgdpbb q_eh\_dZ b _]h ^he]he_lby
ijb^Z\Zehkv \ ^j_\g_dblZckdhf nbehkhnkdhf mq_gbb ^Zhkbaf_ Z lhqg__ \ _]h
kjZ\gbl_evghg_[hevrhckhklZ\ghcqZklbbf_gm_fhch[uqghdZd³>Zhex[\b´
KqblZ_lkyqlhq_f[hevr_fm`qbgZl_jy_lk_f_gbl_q_f[hevr_b qZs_hg
bf__l iheh\uo kghr_gbc hdZgqb\Zxsboky wydmeypb_c l _ k_fyba\_j`_gb_f l_f
[uklj__ hg klZj__l b mfbjZ_l H^gZdh ba\_klgh qlh ^j_\gb_ ^Zhku ^he]h`bl_evkl\h
kj_^b dhlhjuo [ueh h[uqguf y\e_gb_f g_ lhevdh g_ h]jZgbqb\Zeb k_[y \ ex[\b b
iheh\hc `bagb gh ^Z`_ kqblZeb aZgylb_ ex[h\vx h^gbf ba \Z`g_crbo nZdlhjh\
^he]he_lby Hgb \b^_eb \ fZdkbfZevguo aZgylbyo ex[h\vx hq_gv [eZ]hl\hjguc
wnn_dl aZdexqZxsbcky \ a^hjh\hf ]hjfhgZevghf [ZeZgk_ dhlhjuc `bag_ggh \Z`_g
^eyiheghp_ggh]ha^hjh\vyq_eh\_dZ
Ghh^gZdh\ q_fa^_kvk_dj_lb ]^_jZa]Z^dZlZdh]hdZaZehkv[ug_jZaj_r_ggh]h
ijhlb\hj_qbyk h^ghcklhjhgug_mf_j_gghklv\ k_dk_ijb\h^bld bklhs_gbxk_f_gbb
]b[_eb fm`qbgu Z k ^jm]hc ² kh]eZkgh ^Zhkbafm k_dk y\ey_lky \Z`guf nZdlhjhf
^he]he_lby"
Hl\_l ^Z_lgZfgZb[he__agZqbl_evguc^Zhkdbc\jZqwihobLZg²]]g
w Kmgv Kx Fh kZf ijh`b\rbc [he__ \_dZ b [u\rbc kljh]bf ijb\_j`_gp_f mq_gby
³>Zhex[\b´Hgibr_l³K_fyfm`qbguy\ey_lkyh^ghcba`bag_gguokmsghkl_cb g_
^he`gh jZklhqZlvky g_dhgljhebjm_fuf kihkh[hf ?keb fm`qbgZ jZklhqZ_l k\h_ k_fy
hg[m^_lbkiulu\ZlvkeZ[hklvZ _kebhg[_aaZ[hlghbkq_jiZ_lk\h_k_fylhhgmfj_l´
KmgvKxFhmdZaZehilbfZevgucdjbl_jbcqZklhluwydmeypbb\ aZ\bkbfhklbhl
\hajZklZfm`qbgu³Fm`qbgZe_lfh`_lbf_lvh^ghhimkdZgb_dZ`^u_q_luj_^gy
Fm`qbgZ e_l ² jZa \ \hk_fv ^g_c Fm`qbgZ e_l ² dZ`^u_ ^_kylv ^g_c²
Fm`qbgZe_l²dZ`^u_^\Z^pZlv^g_cFm`qbgZe_lg_^he`_gkimkdZlvk_fy\h
\j_fy iheh\uo Zdlh\ \hh[s_ gh _keb hg bkdexqbl_evgh a^hjh\ b dj_ihd lh fh`_l
iha\heblvk_[_h^ghhimkdZgb_\ f_kypFm`qbgZijh`b\Z_l^he]mxb a^hjh\mx`bagv
_keb [m^_l ih^^_j`b\Zlv hilbfZevgmx kj_^gxx qZklhlm himkdZgbb ih _`_f_kyqgh
m^_eyy\ lh`_\j_fy\gbfZgb_a^hjh\hcibs_b nbabq_kdbfmijZ`g_gbyf
Kh]eZkghKmgvKxFhfm`qbgZg_^he`_g`blv^he]h[_a`_gsbguZ `_gsbgZ
g_ fh`_l [ulv kqZkleb\Z [_a fm`qbgu ;_a `_gsbgu hg [m^_l \k_]^Z klj_fblvky d
`_gkdhfml_emqlhmlhfbl_]h^mo: dh]^Z_]h^momlhfe_ghgg_fh`_l`blv^he]h
Ba\_klguc \jZq ,, \_dZ g w =Ze_g ibkZe ³ihke_ kghr_gby ^Zhkkdbc \jZq
aZf_gye [u wlh keh\h gZ ³ihke_ wydmeypbb´ \k_ `b\hlgu_ ]jmklgu djhf_ `_gsbg b
i_lmoh\´ Ihqlb \kydbc fm`qbgZ bkiulZe gZ k_[_ jZajmrbl_evguc ihklwnn_dl
wydmeypbb²\g_aZigh_qm\kl\hqlhhgihl_jyeihqlb\kydbcbgl_j_kd k\h_c`_gsbg_
dhlhjh_fh`_l^Z`_ijb\_klb_]hd \hijhkmihq_fm`_hgdh]^Zeb[hex[be__
>j_\gb_ ^Zhku ih^q_jdb\Zeb \Z`ghklv ^ey fm`qbgu \eZ^_lv kihkh[ghklvx d
dhgljhex k\h_]h k_fybkimkdZgby ^ey q_]h [ue ij_^eh`_g p_euc dhfie_dk
ki_pbZevguo mijZ`g_gbc ih^jh[gh baeh`_gguc \ ³>Zh ex[\b´ AgZy dZd mf_gvrblv
gZijy`_gb_khojZgylvk\hc³\gmlj_ggbcwebdkbj´b [ulv\ fbjghfjZkiheh`_gbb^moZ
gZkljh_gbb mfZ \ ex[hc fhf_gl q_eh\_d h[uqgh gZkeZ`^Z_lky k\h_c `bagvx b \
j_amevlZl_bf__l[he__Zdlb\gmx^he]mxb a^hjh\mx`bagv
³>Zhex[\b´g_j_dhf_g^m_lfm`qbgZfdjhf_hq_gvklZjuobeb[hevguoex^_c
ihegh]h hldZaZ hl k_fyba\_j`_gby g_h[oh^bfh ebrv ijb^_j`b\Zlvky hilbfZevghc \
aZ\bkbfhklbhl\hajZklZ_]hqZklhluDZd\Z`gucZki_dlk_dkhl_jZibbb ihgZklhys__
\j_fy³>Zhex[\b´hklZ_lky\Z`ghc\_l\vxdblZckdhcf_^bpbgu
Fgh]b_ bkke_^h\Zl_eb kqblZxl qlh ijh^he`bl_evghklv `bagb k\yaZgZ k
nmgdpbhgbjh\Zgb_f ]heh\gh]h fha]Z Q_f bgl_gkb\g__ b q_f ^hevr_ nmgdpbhgbjm_l
]heh\ghc fha] q_f ^hevr_ khojZgy_lky bgl_ee_dlmZevgZy `bagv q_eh\_dZ l_f ^hevr_
gZ[ex^Z_lky m g_]h ijh^he`bl_evghklv `bagb < ih^l\_j`^_gb_ wlhc l_hjbb fh`gh
ijb\_klbfgh`_kl\hijbf_jh\LZd:jobf_^ ijb^mfZe\h]gmlh_a_jdZeh\ ^_gvdh]^Z
_fmbkihegbehkve_l
FZjdLmeebcPbp_jhgkhqbgbek\hc³LjZdlZlh klZjhklb´r_klb^_kylblj_oe_l
aZ]h^^hk\h_cgZkbevkl\_gghckf_jlb
=Zebe_h=Zebe_caZdhgqbek\hb³>bZeh]bh ^\b`_gbb´k_fb^_kylb^\moe_l
Fbd_eZg^`_eh ;mZgZjjhlb gZqZe k\hc ³KljZrguc km^´ \ iylv^_kyl \hk_fv e_l
aZdhgqbe\ r_klv^_kylr_klv<_ebdhfmklZjpm[ueh\hk_fv^_kylk_fve_ldh]^Zih_]h
ijh_dlm[ue\ha^\b]gmldmihegZkh[hj_k\I_ljZ
>j_\g_]j_q_kdbc nbehkhn IeZlhg kdhgqZeky k ljhklvx ^ey ibkvfZ \ jmd_ \
\hajZkl_\hkvfb^_kylbh^gh]h]h^Z
BkZZdGvxlhggZibkZegh\h_ij_^bkeh\b_d k\hbf³3ULQFLSLD´ \ \hk_fv^_kylljb
]h^Z
LbpbZgijh^he`ZejZ[hlZlvgZ^k\hbfbdZjlbgZfb^h^_\yghklZ^_\ylbe_l
G_f_pdbc ihwl Bh]Zgg <hevn]Zg] =zl_ \ r_klv^_kyl q_luj_ ]h^Z gZqZe
aZgbfZlvky\hklhqghcebl_jZlmjhc\ \hk_fv^_kyl^\Z]h^ZhggZibkZeihke_^gxxqZklv
³NZmklZ´Mf_j=zl_\hkvfb^_kylblj_oe_l
B\Zg:g^j__\bqDjueh\\ r_klv^_kyl\hk_fve_lgZqZebamqZlv]j_q_kdbcyaudb
h\eZ^_ewlbfyaudhfaZ^\Z]h^Z>hdhgpZk\h_c`bagbe_lDjueh\k gZkeZ`^_gb_f
qblZe]j_q_kdboihwlh\\ ih^ebggbd_
W^bkhgaZiZl_glh\Zegh\uobah[j_l_gbcihke_e_l
Hjb]bgZevgZy ]bihl_aZ klZj_gby [ueZ ij_^eh`_gZ agZf_gbluf jmkkdbf
nbabheh]hf B B F_qgbdh\uf ² Hg kqblZe qlh klZj_gb_ b kf_jlv
hj]ZgbafZ y\eyxlky ke_^kl\b_f _]h kZfhhljZ\e_gby baaZ ijhp_kkh\ ]gb_gby b
[jh`_gby ijhbkoh^ysbo \ lheklhf dbr_qgbd_ Ij_^hl\jZlblv ]gb_gb_ b [jh`_gb_ \
lheklhcdbrd_Z ke_^h\Zl_evghijbhklZgh\blvkZfhhljZ\e_gb_hj]ZgbafZb l_fkZfuf
m\_ebqblv ijh^he`bl_evghklv `bagb fh`_l dmevlmjZ fhehqghdbkehc iZehqdb
Ihwlhfm \ p_eyo ijh^e_gby `bagb hg gZklhyl_evgh j_dhf_g^h\Ze _`_^g_\gh_
mihlj_[e_gb_\ ibsmdbkeh]hfhehdZb d_nbjZWlhl\u\h^F_qgbdh\Zih^l\_j`^Zeky
³ijbf_jZfb ^he]h\_qghklb gZjh^h\ iblZxsboky ]eZ\guf h[jZahf dbkeuf fhehdhf´
KZf F_qgbdh\ [he__ e_l ihklhyggh mihlj_[eye dbkeh_ fhehdh ijb]hlh\e_ggh_ ih
ij_^eh`_gguf bf j_p_ilZf beb qbklmx dmevlmjm fhehqghdbkehc iZehqdb H^gZdh
g_kfhljygZwlh_fmg_m^Zehkvi_j_rZ]gmlv\hajZklghcjm[_`\ e_l²hgkdhgqZeky
hl[he_agbk_j^pZ
Kj_^b klZjbgguo yihgkdbo e_]_g^ _klv lZdZy DZdlh jZa bfi_jZlhj ih`_eZe
ihagZdhfblvkyk kZfufih`beufbak\hboih^^ZgguoD g_fmijb\_ebdj_klvygbgZih
bf_gbFZfiwdhlhjhfmg_^Z\ghbkihegbehkv]h^ZKlZjbdijbr_eg_h^bgK gbf
[ueb e_lgyy `_gZ e_lgbc kug b _]h e_lgyy `_gZ Lj_lv_ ihdhe_gb_
ij_^klZ\eyeb\gmdb _]h`_gZdhlhjuf\f_kl_i_j_\ZebehaZ
Ihqlb q_j_a ihe\_dZ gZ lhj`_kl\_gghf hldjulbb fhklZ q_j_a j_dm W^h
ijb]eZkbeb ^he]h`bl_e_c kljZgu <hkoh^ys_]h KhegpZ Kj_^b ihq_lguo ]hkl_c \gh\v
hdZaZeky l_i_jv m`_ e_lgbc klZjbd FZfiw <ky k_fvy FZfiw lh`_ ijb_oZeZ gZ
lhj`_kl\Z Dh]^Z klZj_crbgm k_fvb kijhkbeb qlh ihfh]eh bf ^h`blv ^h klhev
ij_dehggh]h \hajZklZ klZj_p hl\_lbe ³Fu k_fv jZa \ f_kyp ijb`b]Zeb lhqdm klZ
[he_ag_c´ B klZjbd ihdZaZe f_klh wlhc lhqdb ^he]he_lby ² dgbam hl gb`g_]h djZy
dhe_gghc qZr_qdb kZglbf_ljh\ gZ ^_\ylv K_]h^gy wlZ lhqdZ \gh\v bgl_j_km_l
ki_pbZebklh\\hfgh]bobgklblmlZoljZ^bpbhgghcdblZckdhcf_^bpbguaZgbfZxlky__
bamq_gb_f
GZb[he__ jZkijhkljZg_gguf \haaj_gb_f gZ ijhbkoh`^_gb_ ebfblZ
h]jZgbqb\Zxs_]hijh^he`bl_evghklv`bagby\ey_lkyl_hjby³de_lhqghckf_jlb´WlZ
l_hjbyhkgh\ZgZ]eZ\gufh[jZahfgZjZ[hlZoEOZcnebdZKR:dhlhjucihdZaZeqlh
\ dmevlmj_ldZgbl_\g_hj]ZgbafZg_dhlhju_de_ldbieh^Zq_eh\_dZfh]ml^_eblvky
iexkfbgmkjZaZ aZl_fih]b[Zxl?kebde_ldb\aylvhlq_eh\_dZ[he__klZjr_]h
\hajZklZbebhlebpk ij_`^_\j_f_ggufklZj_gb_flhqbkeh^_e_gbcij_^r_kl\mxsbo
]b[_eb de_ldb mf_gvrZ_lky GZ hkgh\Zgbb wlbo ^Zgguo klZeh fh^guf kqblZlv qlh
qZku hlkqblu\Zxsb_ \j_fy `bagb aZdexq_gu \ dZ`^hc de_ld_ =b[_ev de_lhd beb
hkeZ[e_gb_ nmgdpbb \ l_o de_ldZo dhlhju_ g_ ih^\_j`_gu ^_e_gbx ihke_ hdhgqZgby
jZa\blby \ dhg_qghf blh]_ ijb\h^bl d hkeZ[e_gbx hj]ZgbafZ b ]b[_eb Mq_gu_
kqblZxlqlhbf_gghkf_jlvgZde_lhqghfmjh\g_\uau\Z_lkf_jlvhj]ZgbafZ
< `b\hcijbjh^_kms_kl\mxlijbf_juf_oZgbafZkf_jlby\ghg_k\yaZggh]hk
\ebygb_f \g_rgbo ijbqbg <k_f ba\_kl_g \b^ kf_jlb k\hckl\_gguc [Z[hqd_
h^gh^g_\d_ LZdZy [Z[hqdZ \hagbdgm\ ba ebqbgdb ihmljm d dhgpm i_j\uo kmlhd
aZdhgqb\pbdejZafgh`_gby\g_aZighih]b[Z_lKf_jlvgZklmiZ_lhlmkeh\bc\g_rg_c
kj_^uDZd[m^lhdhgqZ_lkyaZ\h^qZkh\b m`_\gmlj_ggyyijbqbgZhkljhh[ju\Z_lgblv
`bagb
Ih^h[guc \b^ kf_jlb hl \gmlj_gg_c ijbqbgu g_ y\ey_lky bkdexq_gb_f
Hkh[_ggh hlq_leb\h hg \ujZ`_g m [he__ keh`gh]h hj]ZgbafZ ² ]hj[mrb < l_q_gb_
q_luj_oiylbe_lm wlhcju[uihdZhgZ`b\_l\ Lbohfhd_Zg_ijhbkoh^blkhaj_\Zgb_b
m\_ebq_gb_jZaf_jZl_eZZ \i_q_gbgZdZieb\Z_lky`bjGh\hlgZklmiZ_l\j_fydh]^Z
ijb[eb`Z_lky i_jbh^ jZafgh`_gby b ]hj[mrZ hlijZ\ey_lky \ ^ebgguc imlv bgh]^Z \
lukyqbdbehf_ljh\d mklvxlhcj_db\ dhlhjhchgZihy\beZkvgZk\_lDZdlhevdhju[Z
gZijZ\ey_lkyd j_d_hgZgZqbgZ_lbkihevah\Zlvi_q_ghqgu_j_a_j\u`bjZdZdbklhqgbd
wg_j]bb AZiZk i_q_ghqguo `bjh\ kgb`Z_lky gh jZkl_l dhgp_gljZpby \ djh\b
ohe_kl_jbgZ dhlhjuc kbgl_abjm_lky ba `bjZ < l_q_gb_ dhjhldh]h i_jbh^Z \j_f_gb
h^gh]h^\mof_kyp_\ju[Z³klZj__l´
< hd_Zg_m ]hj[mrbg_lgbdZdh]h]hj[Z^Z\r_]hgZa\Zgb_wlhfm\b^mGha^_kv
ihkl_i_ggh jZkl_l ]hj[ ba]b[Zxlky q_exklb aZiZ^Zxl ]eZaZ bklhgqZ_lky dh`Z <
hj]Zgbaf_ ]hj[mrb ijhbkoh^yl hq_gv ]em[hdb_ k^\b]b ² ihy\eyxlky ijbagZdb
k\hckl\_ggu_kZoZjghfm^bZ[_lmb Zl_jhkde_jhamkgb`Z_lkymklhcqb\hklvd bgn_dpbb
GZdhg_p ]hj[mrbkZfdb hldeZ^u\Zxl bdjm dhlhjZy hk_f_gy_lky fm`kdbfb hkh[yfb
]hj[mr Q_j_a g_^_eb ju[ujh^bl_eb ih]b[Zxl Ijbqbghc kf_jlb klZgh\ylky
fgh`_kl\_ggu_ bgnZjdlu k_j^pZ fha]Z e_]dbo ihq_d Wlh ihgylgh lZd dZd
dhgp_gljZpbyohe_kl_jbgZ\ djh\bm ]hj[mrb\ i_jbh^ g_j_klZ m\_ebqb\Z_lky ^h f] lh _klv ijbf_jgh \ jZa F_oZgbaf ]b[_eb ]hj[mrb ² wlh lbibqguc ijbf_j
kf_jlbhl\gmlj_ggboijbqbg ijbq_fijbf_jkha^Zxsbc\i_qZle_gb_kms_kl\h\Zgby
aZijh]jZffbjh\Zgghc kf_jlb @bagv ju[u dZd [u hdZgqb\Z_lky \ khhl\_lkl\bb k
ijh]jZffhc ojZgys_cky \ ]_gZo DZd [m^lh \ gbo aZibkZg kb]gZe ³klhi´ dhlhjuc b
h[ju\Z_l`bagvwlh]h\b^Zju[u
Bgh]^Z wlb ³qZku `bagb´ gZqbgZxl ³ki_rblv´ DblZckdb_ f_^bdb
aZj_]bkljbjh\Zeb \ gZqZe_ ]h^Z \ RZgoZ_ j_^qZcrbc kemqZc M r_klbe_lg_]h
fZevqbdZ jh^b\r_]hky m ijZdlbq_kdb a^hjh\uo jh^bl_e_c h[gZjm`_gu \k_ ijbagZdb
ij_`^_\j_f_ggh]h klZj_gby Jhkl j_[_gdZ kZglbf_ljh\ Z \_k \k_]h ebrv iylv
dbeh]jZffh\ Dh]^Z _fm [ue lhevdh ]h^ m g_]h gZqZeb ihy\eylvky fhjsbgu gZ ebp_
\uiZ^Zlv\hehkuJh^gZyk_kljZfZevqbdZdhlhjZy[ueZklZjr__]hgZiylve_lmf_jeZ
\ \hajZkl_^_\ylbe_lhllhqghlZdhc`_[he_agbKi_pbZebkluiheZ]Zxlqlhwlh\lhjhc
kemqZc \ fbjh\hc f_^bpbgkdhc ijZdlbd_ dh]^Z m a^hjh\uo jh^bl_e_c k ohjhr_c
gZke_^kl\_gghklvx h[Z j_[_gdZ [hevgu lZdbf ly`_euf g_^m]hf I_j\uc kemqZc [ue
hlf_q_gg_kdhevdhe_lgZaZ^\ NJ=Ihk\b^_l_evkl\mZ]_glkl\ZKbgvomZi_j_^Z\r_]h
wlmbgnhjfZpbx\k_]h\ jZaebqguokljZgZofbjZaZj_]bkljbjh\ZghgZgZqZeh]h^Z
[he__kemqZ_\ij_`^_\j_f_ggh]hklZj_gby
Kms_kl\mxl lZd`_ g_dhlhju_ ]_g_lbq_kdb_ aZ[he_\Zgby l_q_gb_ dhlhjuo
ijb\_eh mq_guo d \u\h^m qlh klZjhklv ² wlh [he_agv KZfuf gZ]ey^guf ijbf_jhf
y\ey_lky
kbg^jhf
=_lqbgkhgZ=benhj^Z
gZau\Z_fuc
lZd`_
ijh]_jb_c
ij_`^_\j_f_gghcklZjhklvxAZ[he_\Zgb_wlhihkqZklvxdjZcg_j_^dh_aZdexqZ_lky
\ lhf qlh aZ^_j`b\Zxs__ky nbabq_kdh_ jZa\blb_ j_[_gdZ khq_lZ_lky k
ij_`^_\j_f_ggufb ijbagZdZfb klZj_gby Wlb ijbagZdb ² ihk_^_gb_ h[euk_gb_
fhjsbgu ² gZqbgZxl ihy\eylvky m`_ \ i_j\u_ f_kypu `bagb D iylb ]h^Zf j_[_ghd
[hevghcijh]_jb_ckljZ^Z_l\k_fbklZjq_kdbfbg_^m]Zfbkgb`_gb_fkemoZZjljblhf
Zl_jhkde_jhahfIjh^he`bl_evghklv`bagbijbwlhc[he_agbh[uqghg_[he__lbe_l
kf_jlvgZklmiZ_lhlbgnZjdlZ
D kemqZyf ijh]_jbb ij_`^_\j_f_gghc klZjhklb fh`gh hlg_klb b kbg^jhf
<_jg_jZ \i_j\u_ hibkZgguc \ ]h^m Ijb wlhf kbg^jhf_ fheh^u_ ex^b \ e_l
gZqbgZxl klj_fbl_evgh klZj_lv ² m gbo k_^_xl b \uiZ^Zxl \hehku ihy\eyxlky
fhjsbgub ijhqb_ijbagZdbij_`^_\j_f_gghcklZjhklbH[uqghm`_d ]h^ZflZdb_
[hevgu_mfbjZxlijb\k_okbfilhfZo]em[hdhcklZjhklb
Gh qlh kh\k_f m^b\bl_evgh bgh]^Z ³qZku `bagb´ fh]ml ihclb \kiylv
Kj_^g_\_dh\uc ZjZ[kdbc ibkZl_ev B[g :[m JZ[[bob ² \ k\h_c dgb]_
³Qm^_kgh_h`_j_ev_´ijb\h^blm^b\bl_evguckemqZc
JZkkdZau\Zxlqlh\ ^Z\gb_\j_f_gZ\h`^_fie_f_gb=ZlZnZg[ueg_dbcq_eh\_d
ih bf_gb GZkj b[g >ZofZg Dh]^Z _fm bkihegbehkv e_l m g_]h \gh\v ihq_jg_eb
\hehku b \ujhkeb gh\u_ am[u lZd qlh hg ij_\jZlbeky hiylv \ xghrm B wlh [ueh
qm^hf\_klvh dhlhjhfi_j_^Z\ZeZkvbamkl\ mklZkj_^bZjZ[kdboie_f_g
Khh[s_gb_B[g:[mJZ[[bobfh`gh[ueh[ujZkp_gb\ZlvdZdh^gmbaZjZ[kdbo
kdZahd ohly ijhqb_ nZdlu baeh`_ggu_ \ ³Qm^_kghf h`_j_ev_´ hlebqZxlky
kdjmime_aghklvxb bklhjbq_kdhc^hklh\_jghklvx_keb[u\ ij_kk_\j_fyhl\j_f_gbb
k_cqZk g_ ihy\eyebkv ZgZeh]bqgu_ khh[s_gby LZd g_^Z\gh g_dhlhju_ ]Za_lu
i_j_i_qZlZebke_^mxsmxaZf_ldmba`mjgZeZ³Djm]´B_jmkZebf
JhaZ NZjhc jh^beZkv fZy ]h^Z _c ihqlb ]h^Z Gh m g__ nb]mjZ
^_\mrdbb hgZg_lhevdhg_klZj__lghk dZ`^uf^g_f\u]ey^blfheh`_
<jZqbh[_kdmjZ`_guhgbihlj_[h\Zebijh\_jblvg_lebh[fZgZGh\k_ lhqgh
³WlZ `_gsbgZ ihljykZ_l HgZ gbdh]^Z g_ ihevah\ZeZkv dhkf_lbdhc g_ ijb[_]ZeZ d
ieZklbq_kdhc hi_jZpbb gh \u]ey^bl gZ e_l fheh`_ k\h_]h \hajZklZ ² m^b\eyeky
ihljyk_gguc ^hdlhj =jZaZ gZ f_^bpbgkdhc dhgn_j_gpbb \ =_gm_² ?_ iZfylv b fha]
hkljub ykguWlhgZb[he__aZ]Z^hqgucn_ghf_gk dhlhjuffg_dh]^Zeb[h^h\h^behkv
\klj_qZlvky´
<i_j\u_hgijhqblZeh Jha_\ blZevygkdhc]Za_l_GZnhlh²³djZkb\Zyfheh^Zy
`_gsbgZ hdjm`_ggZy \gmdZfb ijZ\gmdZfb b ijZijZ\gmdZfb Fbkkbk NZjhg
\u]ey^_eZ fheh`_ k\h_c e_lg_c ijZ\gmqdb Ijh\_jdZ i_q_gb k_j^pZ b ^Z\e_gby
djh\b ihdZaZeb qlh b ZgZebau ijZ[Z[mrdb g_ om`_ q_f m ^_\mrdb Gh qlh _s_
m^b\bl_evgh_²hgbemqr_q_f[ueb\ ,]h^mKeh\gh\j_fyihl_deh\kiylv
Wdki_jl ih ijh[e_fZf klZj_gby [m^_l gZ[ex^Zlv aZ `_gsbghc gZ^_ykv gZclb
jZa]Z^dm \ __ ]_g_lbd_ : ihdZ hg lhevdh jZa\h^bl jmdZfb KZfZ `_ \bgh\gbpZ
i_j_ihehoZ\jZq_ch[tykgy_l\k_[eZ]hkeh\_gb_fk\ur_³Y _f\k_dmjxb ivx[hevr_
q_fgm`gh?^bgkl\_ggh_qlhf_gyh[_kdmjZ`b\Z_lwlhkljZoaZ[_j_f_g_lv²kf_rgh
jh`Zlvdh]^Zl_[_ih^klhb y\ugm`^_gZijbgbfZlvijhlb\haZqZlhqgu_ibexeb´
M`_ ^h\hevgh ^Z\gh [ueh \u^\bgmlh ij_^iheh`_gb_ qlh kms_kl\m_l ]_g beb
g_kdhevdh ]_gh\ klZjhklb dhlhjuc \_^_l k_[y [he__ beb f_g__ ghjfZevgh Z baj_^dZ
dZd[u³\aju\Z_lky´B^_ywlZdZaZeZkvqbklhmfhajbl_evghcihdZ\ ]h^mlZdhc]_g
g_ [ue h[gZjm`_g m h^gh]h ]jb[Z JZ[hlZxsbc ]_g klZjhklb ba klZjh]h ]jb[Z
i_j_kZ`_ggucfheh^hfmaZklZ\ey_lwlhlihke_^gbc[ukljhklZj_lvb hlfbjZlv
K_cqZk\ g_kdhevdboeZ[hjZlhjbyofbjZ\_^mlkyihbkdb]_gZklZjhklbq_eh\_dZ
IhdZg_\hafh`ghij_^iheZ]Zlvqlhwlbihbkdb^Z^ml[ukljucijZdlbq_kdbcj_amevlZl
Gh fh`gh gZ^_ylvky qlh \u^_eb\ ]_g mijZ\eyxsbc klZj_gb_f mq_gu_ gZc^ml b
kihkh[ghklvaZf_^eblv_]hjZ[hlm
Mki_ob ]_gghc bg`_g_jbb ijb\_eb d lhfm qlh ihfbfh ]_gZ klZj_gby mq_guf
g_^Z\ghm^Zehkv\u^_eblvb ]_g^he]he_lby
DZd klZeh ba\_klgh ]jmii_ mq_guo ba ;Za_evkdh]h mgb\_jkbl_lZ ih^
jmdh\h^kl\hf^hdlhjZ<Zevl_jZ=_jbg]Zm^Zehkv\uy\blvg_h[uqZcgu_ihl_gpbZevgu_
\hafh`ghklb`b\h]hhj]ZgbafZiha\heyxsb_ijh^eblv`bagvMqZklgbdwdki_jbf_glZ
^hdlhjM\_<Zev^hjnkhh[sbedhjj_kihg^_glm L:KK qlh\ oh^_hiulh\[ue\u^_e_g
]_g dhlhjuc ih fg_gbx mq_guo hl\_qZ_l aZ khojZg_gb_ `bag_gguo kbe \ hj]Zgbaf_
LZd ijh^he`bl_evghklv `bagb gZk_dhfuo dhlhjuf [ue \`b\e_g ^Zgguc ]_g
g_baf_gghm\_ebqb\ZeZkvgZijhp_glh\
G_h`b^Zggh_ hldjulb_ dhlhjh_ _s_ g_ klZeh ^hklhygb_f rbjhdhc
h[s_kl\_gghklb [ueh k^_eZgh \h \j_fy bamq_gby hkh[_gghkl_c obfbq_kdh]h khklZ\Z
de_lhd fheh^h]h jZklms_]h hj]ZgbafZ <gbfZgb_ < =_jbg]Z ijb\e_d n_ghf_g
khdjZs_gbyihf_j_jZa\blby`b\h]hkms_kl\Zdhebq_kl\Zde_lhdhij_^_e_ggh]hlbiZ
Ijb [he__ ]em[hdhf ZgZeba_ hdZaZehkv qlh wlhl ijhp_kk \ua\Zg ijh]j_kkbjmxsbf
mf_gvr_gb_f hkh[uo \b^h\ [_edZ ;ueh k^_eZgh ij_^iheh`_gb_ h \hafh`ghklb
\iehlgmxijb[ebablvkyd lZcg_ijh^e_gby`bagbiml_fh[gZjm`_gbyb \ha^_ckl\bygZ
]_gdhlhjuchl\_qZ_laZ\ujZ[hldmwlbo[_edh\
=jmiiZ mq_guo bkke_^mxsbo hkgh\u q_eh\_q_kdhc `bagb jZ[hlZ_l \
;bhp_gljmf_²\_^ms_fgZmqghf[bheh]bq_kdhfp_glj_R\_cpZjbbkha^Zgghf\ ]h^m ijb ;Za_evkdhf mgb\_jkbl_l_ A^_kv klZ\yl wdki_jbf_glu mq_gu_ k fbjh\ufb
bf_gZfb< ihke_^gb_^_kylbe_lbybf_ggh\ ;Za_e_[bheh]bq_kdZyb f_^bpbgkdZygZmdb
ihemqbeb rbjhdh_ jZa\blb_ ij_\jZlb\ wlhl ]hjh^ \ i_j_^h\hc f_`^mgZjh^guc
gZmqguc p_glj AZ ihke_^gb_ q_luj_ ]h^Z [Za_evkdbf mq_guf ^\Z`^u ijbkm`^Zebkv
Gh[_e_\kdb_ij_fbb\ h[eZklbf_^bpbgu
Fh`gh ij_^klZ\blv kblmZpbx dh]^Z [m^ml kha^Zgu ki_pbZevgu_ e_dZjkl\Z
Zdlb\babjmxsb_ ^_yl_evghklv khhl\_lkl\mxsbo ]_gh\ kqblZ_l ^hdlhj < =_jbg]
=jmiiZijh^he`Z_lm]em[e_ggu_gZmqgu_bkke_^h\Zgby
Mq_gu_ \k_]h fbjZ ijh^he`Zxl bkdZlv wnn_dlb\gu_ imlb ijh^e_gby
q_eh\_q_kdhc `bagb <hl m`_ g_kdhevdh e_l \ h^ghc ba r\_^kdbo debgbd \_^mlky
mki_rgu_jZ[hluk ]hjfhghflbfhabghfHiulugZfurZoij_\ahreb\k_h`b^Zgbyb
gZ^_`^u=hjfhgaZf_^ebem gboijhp_kkklZj_gbygZklhevdhqlh\j_fy^eygbodZd[u
hklZgh\behkv Bgt_dpbb ]hjfhgZ ^_eZeb b iZpb_glZf Dhjj_kihg^_gl ih[u\Z\rbc \
debgbd_\klj_lbelZf`_gsbgmdhlhjhcgZ\b^[uehe_lHdZaZehkvqlhgZkZfhf
^_e__ce_lKZf\jZqaZgbfZxsbckywlbfbhiulZfbkqblZ_lqlhkbkl_fZlbq_kdh_
\\_^_gb_]hjfhgZfh]eh[um\_ebqblvijh^he`bl_evghklv`bagb^he_l
?klvb ^jm]b_gZijZ\e_gbyB hgbh[_sZxl_s_[hevr_
?keb \ l_jfhklZl gZr_]h l_eZ ² ]bihlZeZfmk ² \\_klb jZkl\hj gZljby b
dZevpby fh`gh hij_^_e_gguf h[jZahf j_]mebjh\Zlv l_fi_jZlmjm \k_]h hj]ZgbafZ
Ijh^_eu\Zy wlm fZgbimeypbx k h[_avygZfb m^Zehkv kgbablv l_fi_jZlmjm bo l_eZ gZ
p_euo ƒ Ijb wlhf kZfb h[_avygu g_ f_jaeb g_ [ueb gb khggufb gb \yeufb ²
gbdZdboih[hqguoy\e_gbcaZf_q_ghg_[uehL_i_jvgZhq_j_^b²hiulugZq_eh\_d_
Kfuke wlbo hiulh\ ² ijh^e_gb_ `bagb ?keb ihgbablv l_fi_jZlmjm l_eZ
q_eh\_dZ\k_]hgZƒijh^he`bl_evghklv_]h`bagb\hajZkl_l\ kj_^g_f^he_lIjb
l_fi_jZlmj_ `_ l_eZ ƒ q_eh\_d dZd h`b^Z_lky [m^_l `blv hdheh e_l
Ij_^iheZ]Z_lky qlh kj_^kl\h ^ey lZdh]h kgb`_gby l_fi_jZlmju [m^_l \uimkdZlvky \
\b^_ibexevdmiblvdhlhju_kfh`_ldZ`^uc
<hagbdZ_l aZdhghf_jguc bgl_j_kmxsbc dZ`^h]h \hijhk ² dh]^Z `_ gZdhg_p
mq_gufm^Zklkyj_rblvijh[e_fum\_ebq_gbyijh^he`bl_evghklb`bagbb ^h`b\_feb
fu^hwlh]h\j_f_gb"
< j_amevlZl_ hijhkZ ijh\_^_ggh]h ]hkm^Zjkl\_gguf Z]_glkl\hf ih gZmd_ b
l_ogbd_Yihgbbyihgkdb_ki_pbZebklukqblZxlqlhke_^mxsb_ijh[e_fufh]ml[ulv
mki_rgh j_r_gu \ [eb`Zcrb_ e_l ]² ih[_^Z gZ^ KIB >hf ]²
mf_gb_hklZgh\blvjhkljZdh\uode_lhdb ij_\jZlblvbo\ ghjfZevgu_]²gZqZeh
lmjbklkdbowdki_^bpbc \ dhkfhk ]² ih[_^Z gZ^ ^bZ[_lhf ]² ihgbfZgb_
f_oZgbafh\iZfylbb klZj_gby
BlZd]h^²\k_]hebrvhdhehe_lY ^mfZx^hjh]hcqblZl_evqlhfuk
\Zfbkmf__f^h`blv^hi_j\uoh[gZ^_`b\Zxsboj_amevlZlh\Ih`b\_f²m\b^bf
EBL?J:LMJ:
>ZgvDw Fbnu>j_\g_]hDblZyF³GZmdZ´*XLQQHVVERRNRI:RUOG+HFRUGV %DQWDP%RRNV1HZ<RUN S =h\hjdZY >hjh]Zd ^he]he_lbxF³Ijhnba^Zl´
<br_\B< Ijh[e_fZebqgh]h[_kkf_jlbyGh\hkb[bjkd³GZmdZ´
LmeZ_\> @begZjh^^he]h\_qguc²<_klgbd³IhKh\_lkdhfmKhxam´Z\]mklZ
³:j]mf_glub nZdlu´‹ ³LZ]_krib]_ev´hlfZy
³:j]mf_glub nZdlu´‹ DZjZfabgGF Ij_^Zgby\_dh\³IjZ\^Z´F
Iuey_\ F B KlZjuc I_l_j[mj] KI_l_j[mj] 66 :]_glkl\h ³NjZgk Ij_kk´
bxey³F_^bpbgkdZy]Za_lZ´‹ hdly[jy
B[gE[mJZ[[boq Qm^_kgh_h`_j_ev_F³Om^h`_kl\_ggZy
ebl_jZlmjZ´
M]eh\N>jha^h\B @b\_febfuk\hc\_dF³Fheh^Zy]\Zj^by´
Kihjh objhfZglbb²³AZjm[_`hf´ 1V Ebn: K_dj_lu^he]h`bl_e_c
³GZmdZ b `bagv´ ‹ H[jZlgh \ fheh^hklv ³IhebgZ´ E_gbg]jZ^ k_gly[jy< ihbkdZo]_gZklZjhklb³GZmdZb `bagv´‹ =hj[h\kdbc : : K_f_gh\ X K AZdjulu_ kljZgbpu bklhjbb F ³Fukev´ ³Ihbkd´‹ FZdZjq_\< =_g^he]he_lby³F_^bpbgkdZy]Za_lZ´ ‹ k_gly[jy
³>bZjbm^bihlbkbZr´EbkkZ[hgk_gly[jy³KmZj´;jxkk_evbxgy
:Ik_gly[jy
: ^Zevr_²g_ihfgx³>Zc^`_kl´LZeebgg‹ ³GZmdZb `bagv´‹ F_qgbdh\ B B Wlx^u hilbfbafZ F ³GZmdZ´ @bagv ^ebghx \ ^\Z \_dZ
³E_gbg]jZ^kdZyijZ\^Z´hdly[jy
;Z[mrd_²]h^Z³Mevygh\kdZyijZ\^Z´Z\]mklZ³<_klgbdklZlbklbdb´
‹ ³;BGLB´fZy
LZdkbev E K\ys_gguc \_jl_i F ³Iheblba^Zl´ F_a_gp_\ < : Qm^_kZ
IhimeyjgZywgpbdehi_^by:efZ:lZ=ej_^DZakh\wgpbdehi_^bbldgb]Z
>bevfZg < AZ]Z^db `b\hc ijbjh^u ³GZmdZ b `bagv´ ‹ H ^he]h\_qghklb
³Gh\h_\j_fy´‹ Z\]mklZ
=E:<:;;,
< ihbkdZowebdkbjZ[_kkf_jlby
K ^Z\gbo ihj ex^b f_qlZeb h [_kkf_jlbb Wlb f_qlu gZreb k\h_ hljZ`_gb_ \
fgh]hqbke_gguofbnZob kdZaZgbyogZjh^h\\k_]hfbjZ
H ihbkdZo iml_c ^hklb`_gby [_kkf_jlby ih\_kl\m_lky \ ^j_\g_cr_f ba
^hr_^rbo ^h gZk rmf_jh\Z\behgkdhf wihk_ =ebgygu_ lZ[ebqdb kh kdZaZgb_f h
=bev]Zf_r_^Zlbjmxlkymq_gufbijbf_jgh,,,lukyq_e_lb_f^hgZr_cwjuijbq_fgZ
gbobf_xlkyihf_ldbh lhfqlhwlhdhibbk [he__^j_\g_]hhjb]bgZeZ
< rmf_jkdhfwihk_jZkkdZau\Z_lkyh lhfqlh\h\eZ^_gbyo[h]Zfm^jhklbWgdb
ih^gyeky ba \heg Gb`g_]h fhjy hkljh\ >bevfmg dhlhjuc [ue gZk_e_g ie_f_g_f
[_kkf_jlguo<g_rgbf\b^hfgZihfbgZebhgbex^_cghh[eZ^Zeb\_qghc`bagvxHgb
g_agZebqlhlZdh_[he_agbb klZjhklvKj_^bgbog_[uehgb h^ghc\^h\ub gbh^gh]h
\^h\pZHgbg_agZebqlhlZdh_]heh\gZy[hevb ]eZagu_[he_agb@_gsbgZ^hklb]ZeZ
ij_dehggh]h\hajZklZghhklZ\ZeZkvxghcb k\_`_cFm`qbgZklZgh\beky\k_klZjr_b
klZjr_ghg_qm\kl\h\Zek_[yklZjbdhf
Gh lZdhc `bagvx gZkeZ`^Zebkv g_ ex^b Z [h]b H[j_q_gghklv gZ [he_agb b
ebr_gbyklZjhklvb kf_jlv²\hlqlhhlebqZehex^_chl[h]h\ghk wlbfljm^gh[ueh
ijbfbjblvky <hl ihq_fm p_evx kljZgkl\bc ]_jhy \Z\behgkdh]h wihkZ =bev]Zf_rZ b
klZeh h[j_l_gb_ [_kkf_jlby =bev]Zf_r ijZ\bl_ev ]hjh^Z MjmdZ ;;9,,, \ ^h g w
[uekughf[_kkf_jlghc[h]bgbGbgkmgb kf_jlgh]hfm`ZEm]Zev[Zg^uHg[uegZ^\_
lj_lb[h]hfb ebrvgZlj_lvq_eh\_dhfgh^Z`_wlZlj_lvklZeZ^eyg_]hjhdh\hcb hg
^he`_g [ue jZgh beb iha^gh ihdbgmlv a_fex GZ ihbkdb [_kkf_jlby =bev]Zf_rZ
ih^\b]eZdhgqbgZex[bfh]h^jm]Z²Wgdb^m
B =bev]Zf_r hlijZ\beky gZ ihbkdb k\h_]h ij_^dZ MlgZibrlbfZ dhlhjhfm
\f_kl_ k _]h kmijm]hc _^bgkl\_gghc kj_^b ex^_c [h]b ^Zjh\Zeb \_qgmx `bagv Hg
gZ^_yeky\u\_^Zlvm [_kkf_jlgh]hij_^dZk_dj_luh[j_l_gby[_kkf_jlbyIhke_^he]bo
kljZgkl\bcb ijbdexq_gbc=bev]Zf_rmm^ZehkvgZdhg_phlukdZlvMlgZibrlbfZ
³H MlgZibrlbf ² \hkdebdgme hg² ?keb lu klZe [_kkf_jlguf lh [ulv
fh`_l b fg_ ^Zjmxl [h]b \_qgmx `bagv" Q_f fh]m y aZkem`blv bo fbehklv"´ ³G_
h[hevsZcky² hl\_lbe MlgZibrlbf² G_ klZgml [h]b jZ^b l_[y kh[bjZlvky gZ kh\_l
Fgh]h ex^_c m]h`^Zeb [h]Zf gh djhf_ f_gy b fh_c `_gu gbdlh g_ [ue gZ]jZ`^_g
\_qghc`bagvx´
B \k_`_hgij_^hklZ\be=bev]Zf_rmh^bgrZgk^hklbqv[_kkf_jlby³<ijhq_f
fh`gh bkiulZlv l\hb kbeu ?keb lu kmf__rv ih[hjhlv khg [ulv fh`_l l_[_ m^Zklky
ih[_^blv kf_jlv Ihijh[mc g_ kiZlv r_klv ^g_c b k_fv ghq_c´ Gh qlh agZqbl
[_kkf_jlb_ [_a \_qghc fheh^hklb B lh]^Z MlgZibrlbf ihkh\_lh\Ze =bev]Zf_rm
himklblvky gZ ^gh fhjy b khj\Zlv jZklmsbc lZf dhexqbc l_jg qlh lZbl \ k_[_ khd
hk\_`Zxsbckbeub hfheZ`b\Zxsbcl_eh=bev]Zf_rmm^Zehkv^hklZlvwlhllZebkfZg
³LsZl_evgh [_j_] hg \her_[guc dmkl ojZgysbc \ k_[_ lZcgm fheh^hklb Hg j_rbe
ijb\_alb _]h \ Mjmd b ^Zlv hl\_^Zlv _]h khdZ kZfhfm \_lohfm klZjbdm ?keb lhl
ihfheh^__llhb hgkZf\dmkblhlqm^_kgh]hjZkl_gbyb \_jg_lk_[_xgu_kbeu
I_j_ieu\\_ebdh_fhj_b \uc^ygZ[_j_]m\b^_e=bev]Zf_r[Zkk_cgkeh`_gguc
ba[_eh]hdZfgyb gZiheg_gguck\_`_c\h^hcAZohl_ehkv_fmhdmgmlvky\ \h^mb kfulv
k mlhfe_ggh]h l_eZ ihl b iuev Gh ihdZ ih]jm`Zeky hg \ [Zkk_cg \uihea ba ghju
obljucaf_c b \ h^gh f]gh\_gb_ ihoblbe \her_[guc dmkl kdju\rbkv \f_kl_ k gbf \
g_^jZo a_feb =hjvdh aZieZdZe =bev]Zf_r Ihgye hg ls_lghklv k\hbo mkbebc Ihgye
qlh g_ hl\jZlblv _fm gZ^\b]Zxsmxky klZjhklv b g_ hl^Zeblv qZk kf_jlb
ij_^hij_^_e_gguc _fm [h]Zfb K ]hj_qvx \ k_j^p_ \_jgmeky hg \ k\hc ]hjh^ Mjmd b
ihdhjghklZeh`b^ZlvkljZrgh]hb g_ba[_`gh]hdhgpZ´
Af_c ihoblb\rbc m =bev]Zf_rZ k ljm^hf ^h[ulh_ [_kkf_jlb_ _s_ g_ jZa
ihy\ey_lky \ fbnZo jZaguo gZjh^h\ Wlh ijhh[jZa lh]h [b[e_ckdh]h af_ybkdmkbl_ey
dhlhjuc kh[eZagb\ :^ZfZ b ?\m hl\_^Zlv ieh^h\ ^j_\Z ihagZgby ^h[jZ b aeZ lZd`_
ebrbebo[_kkf_jlby
Bgl_j_kgh hlf_lblv qlh m`_ \ rmf_jkdmx wihom ^hklb`_gb_ [_kkf_jlby
k\yau\Zehkv k h[j_l_gb_f \_qghc fheh^hklb Ijh^he`Zeb f_qlZlv h[ wlhf b \ wihom
Zglbqghklb < ^hdZaZl_evkl\h wlh]h fh`gh khkeZlvky gZ \_kvfZ oZjZdl_jguc fbn h
[h]bg_mlj_gg_caZjbWhkb __\haex[e_gghfLbnhg_
Jhahi_jklZy Whk [h]bgy jZkk\_lZ \ex[beZkv \ ij_djZkgh]h kugZ ljhygkdh]h
pZjy LbnhgZ Qlh[u gbdh]^Z g_ jZkklZ\Zlvky k ex[bfuf hgZ mfhebeZ hebfibckdbo
[h]h\ ^Zjh\Zlv _fm [_kkf_jlb_ Dh\Zjgu_ [h]b ^Zeb Lbnhgm [_kkf_jlb_ gh g_
^Zjh\Zeb\_qghcfheh^hklbLbnhg`be^he]h=heh\Z_]hklZgh\beZkv[_ehcl_ehlZyeh
b kkuoZehkv\k_j_`_a\mqZe_]hkf_oFheh^hklvbkq_aeZ\ djhgZokljhcguodbiZjbkh\
b ex[h\v Whk hklueZ H^gZ`^u aZi_jeZ jmfygZy Whk k\hbfb jhah\ufb iZevqbdZfb
kiZevgxb LbnhgZ\ g_cGZreZk_[_^jm]h_eh`_: Lbnhg\ukhorbcb kfhjs_gguc
ij_\jZlbeky \ k\_jqdZ b klj_dhq_l lZf b k_cqZkFm^juc fbn h Lbnhg_ klZg_l \h
fgh]hf e_clfhlb\hf gZrbo jZafure_gbc h ihbkdZo [_kkf_jlby ³M gZk \k_ \j_fy
lhedmxlh ijh^e_gbb`bagb²ibr_lba\_klgucjmkkdbcmq_gucEG=mfbe_\²Z ih
kms_kl\mhgbaZgbfZxlkyijh^e_gb_fklZjhklb: wlhg_lZdh_[hevrh_m^h\hevkl\b_
Ih`Zemcemqr_lZddZd_klvimklvihdhe_gbyf_gyxlkyb `bagvh[gh\ey_lky´
Ihwlhfm\ fbnZo[hevrbgkl\ZgZjh^h\[_kkf_jlb_\k_]^Z[uehk\yaZghk \_qghc
fheh^hklvx
Kh]eZkghfbnZf>j_\g_]hDblZygZ]hj_Dmgvemgvjhkeh^_j_\h[_kkf_jlbyGZ
g_faj_eieh^b lhldlh_]hkt_^Ze`be\_qghHghdZdb ^jm]b_^_j_\vy^Zjmxsb_
^he]he_lb_p\_ehb ijbghkbehieh^ulhevdhh^bgjZaaZg_kdhevdhlukyqe_lBawlbo
ieh^h\ ]hlh\behkv kgZ^h[v_ [_kkf_jlby dhlhjh_ ojZgbehkv m [h]bgb Kb\Zgfm ²
<eZ^uqbpu AZiZ^Z KqZkleb\_p ijh]ehlb\rbc _]h fh] `blv \_qgh Gh ^h[jZlvky ^h
\_jrbgu ]hju Dmgvemgv ]^_ `beZ [h]bgy Kb\Zgfm [ueh g_ijhklh Ih^gh`b_ ]hju
hdjm`ZeZimqbgZj_db@hrmc²KeZ[Zy\h^Z>hklZlhqgh[uehi_jurdmmiZklvgZ\h^m
b hgh kjZam lhgmeh Z eh^dZ k ex^vfb b ih^Z\gh Dmgvemgv hdjm`Zeb h]g_^urZsb_
]hju H]hgv \ gbo ]hj_e g_ i_j_klZ\Zy b ^g_f b ghqvx b \k_ qlh ihiZ^Zeh lm^Z
k]hjZeh Gb h^bg q_eh\_d g_ ^hklb]Ze aZ\_lghc p_eb b ebrv klj_edm B m^Zehkv
ij_h^he_lv \k_ ij_iylkl\by b ihemqblv hl [h]bgb Kb\Zgfm kgZ^h[v_ [_kkf_jlby
Ijhly]b\Zy klj_edm B lud\m]hjeygdm k \her_[guf kgZ^h[v_f <eZ^uqbpZ AZiZ^Z
kdZaZeZ ³Wlh]h ^hklZlhqgh qlh[u \Zf k `_ghc ihemqblv [_kkf_jlb_ ?keb \k_
kh^_j`bfh_ijbf_lh^bgq_eh\_dlhhgkfh`_l\hag_klbkvgZg_[hb klZlv[h`_kl\hf
?keb_]h\uivxl^\Zq_eh\_dZlhhgbklZgml[_kkf_jlgufbgZa_fe_´
@_gZ klj_edZ B ij_djZkgZy b dh\ZjgZy M QZgtw j_rbeZ h[fZgmlv fm`Z b
\udjZ\m g_]hlud\mijbgyeZ\k_\her_[gh_kgZ^h[v_h^gZqlh[uklZlv[h]bg_c
KlZ\ [h]bg_c M QZgtw ihk_ebeZkv gZ emg_ \ oheh^ghf b imklugghf emgghf
^\hjp_ LZf [ue lhevdh [_euc aZyp dhlhjuc djm]euc ]h^ lhehd \ klmid_ kgZ^h[v_
[_kkf_jlby B q_f ^hevr_ M QZgtw `beZ \ emgghf ^\hjp_ l_f \k_ i_qZevg__
klZgh\behkv __ h^bghq_kl\h Fukeb __ qZklh \ha\jZsZebkv \ fbj ex^_c M QZgtw
jZkdZyeZkv_chq_gvohl_ehkv\_jgmlvky^hfhcijbagZlvk\hx\bgmihijhkblvm fm`Z
ijhs_gby Gh \k_ [ueh ls_lgh b _c gbq_]h ^jm]h]h g_ hklZ\Zehkv dZd `blv \_qgh \
emgghf^\hjp_gbdh]^Zg_kimkdZykvgZa_fex
Ebrv fgh]h e_l kimkly gZ emg_ ihy\beky _s_ h^bg q_eh\_d lZd`_ dZd M QZgtw
klj_fb\rbcky g_dh]^Z d [_kkf_jlbx Wlh [ue M =Zg dhlhjuc aZ k\hb ijhklmidb [ue
ihkeZg[h]Zfb\ emgguc^\hj_pkjm[blvdhjbqgh_^_j_\hhgjm[be^_j_\hZ hgh\gh\v
kjZklZehkvb _fmg_m^Z\Zehkvkjm[blv_]hp_emx\_qghklv
< ^j_\g_dblZckdbo fbnZo b kdZaZgbyo hq_gv fgh]h \gbfZgby m^_ey_lky ihbkdm
jZaghh[jZaguo kgZ^h[bc b webdkbjh\ [_kkf_jlby LZd jZkkdZau\Zehkv qlh ^Ze_dh gZ
AZiZ^_ m k\ys_gghc ]hju Dmgvemgv gZ dhlhjhc jZkl_l ^_j_\h [_kkf_jlby ieh^u
dhlhjh]hkfh]^h[ulvlhevdhh^bgklj_ehdB`behr_klvrZfZgh\dhlhju_kh[bjZeb
\her_[gu_ljZ\uhdheh^_j_\Zb ]hlh\bebbagbowebdkbj[_kkf_jlby
JZkkdZau\Zehkvb h\her_[ghf]jb[_`hmq`bdhlhjucijbghkbeex^yf^he]mx
`bagv b hl^Zeye klZjhklv M Qwgtwgv \ jhfZg_ ³Iml_r_kl\b_ gZ AZiZ^´ gZau\Z_l wlb
]jb[uieh^Zfb`_gvr_gyb hibku\Z_ldZdbfbiblZekyk\bghih^h[gucQ`m;Zpa_
< dgb]_`_=wOmgZ³;ZhImpau´\ ]eZ\_³KgZ^h[vy[_kkf_jlby´ml\_j`^Z_lky
qlhqm^_kgu_]jb[u`hmq`b_klvg_dlhbgu_dZddZjebdbjhklhfk_fv\hk_fv\_jrdh\
<klj_qm k gbfb g_evay mimkdZlv GZ^h ijb ihfhsb dhe^h\kl\Z fheqZ h[hclb bo kaZ^b
dh\ueys_cihoh^dhcb ko\ZlblvAZl_fg_h[oh^bfhkh^jZlvk dZjebdZp_ebdhfdh`mb
ijh]ehlblv_]h<kdhj_ihke_wlh]hfh`ghgZ^_ylvkykj_^v[_eZ^gy\hag_klbkvgZg_[h
<h fgh]bo g_h[uqZcguo kljZgZo aZ fhjyfb kh]eZkgh dblZckdbf fbnZf `beb
ex^bh[eZ^Z\rb_[_kkf_jlb_fbeb^he]he_lb_fGZijbf_jgZ\hklhd_\ kljZg_Pax
gvsau]h ² KljZg_ [eZ]hjh^guo `beb ^he]he_lgb_ dhlhju_ mihlj_[eyeb \ ibsm
ijb]hlh\e_ggu_ gZ iZjm p\_lu fmpabgv ² djZkgu_ nbhe_lh\u_ b [_eu_ < X`ghc
imklhrb `be q_jghdh`bc gZjh^ [_kkf_jlguo ² [mkufbgv < wlhc kljZg_ [ueZ ]hjZ
XZgvpx ² Djm]euc ohef GZ ]hj_ jhkeh ^_j_\h [_kkf_jlby ]Zgvfm ² ³keZ^dh_
^_j_\h´ >hklZlhqgh [ueh kt_klv _]h ieh^ qlh[u klZlv [_kkf_jlguf Ih^ ]hjhc
ijhl_dZe QbpxZgv ² DjZkguc bklhqgbd =ehlhd \h^u ba wlh]h bklhqgbdZ ^Z\Ze
^he]he_lb_Ihwlhfmex^blZf `beb g_ agZy kf_jlb < AZiZ^ghc imklhrb gZoh^beZkv
kljZgZ KZgvfygvb[b ² KljZgZ lj_oebdbo b h^ghjmdbo Ih ij_^Zgbx hgb [ueb
[_kkf_jlgufbKms_kl\h\ZeZ_s_kljZgZOm`wgv`bl_ebdhlhjhc[uebk q_eh\_qvbfb
ebpZfb b ju[vbfb lmeh\bsZfb b fh]eb ih^gbfZlvky gZ g_[h b kimkdZlvky gZ a_fex
Hgbbeb`beb[_kdhg_qgh^he]hbeb[ueb[_kkf_jlgufb
KZfhcex[hiulghckljZghc]^_ `beb [_kkf_jlgu_ fh`gh kqblZlv kljZgm Mpb
² KljZgm ex^_c [_a ihlhfkl\Z \ K_\_jhAZiZ^ghc imklug_ Ex^b \ wlhc kljZg_ g_
jZa^_eyebkvgZfm`qbgb `_gsbgIhke_kf_jlbbol_eZaZdZiu\Zeb\ a_fexghk_j^p_
m gbo ijh^he`Zeh [blvky Q_j_a klh ^\Z^pZlv e_l hgb h`b\Zeb b \uoh^beb gZjm`m
qlh[u kgh\Z gZkeZ`^Zlvky jZ^hklyfb `bagb AZ `bagvx m gbo ke_^h\ZeZ kf_jlv aZ
kf_jlvx ² `bagv Z kZfZ kf_jlv [ueZ ^he]bf kghf ihwlhfm bo fh`gh kqblZlv
[_kkf_jlgufbKljZgZMpbijhp\_lZeZohlyihlhfkl\Zm __`bl_e_cg_[ueh
Gh kZfhc agZf_gblhc kljZghc [_kkf_jlguo y\eyebkv iylv k\ys_gguo ]hj
>xcxcXZgvpwyhNZgomBgq`hmbhkh[_gghIwgeZc
=hju wlb ieZ\Zeb \ <hklhqghf fhj_ b ih^^_j`b\Zeb bo iylgZ^pZlv ]jhfZ^guo
q_jguo q_j_iZo ² ih ljb gZ dZ`^mx ieZ\mqmx ]hjm GZ \_jrbgZo wlbo k\ys_gguo
ieZ\Zxsbo ]hj \ukbebkv ahehlu_ ^\hjpu k e_klgbpZfb ba [_eh]h g_njblZ < wlbo
^\hjpZo `beb[_kkf_jlgu_ Ih\kx^m lZf jhkeb g_njblh\u_ b `_fqm`gu_ ^_j_\vy gZ
dhlhjuo khaj_\Zeb ieh^u dhlhju_ [ueb ohjhrb gZ \dmk b l_ dlh bo _e klZgh\bebkv
[_kkf_jlgufb GZ h^ghf ba wlbo hkljh\h\ ml\_j`^Zeh ij_^Zgb_ [v_l bklhqgbd \bgZ
p\_lZg_njblZ<uib\rbcwlh]h\bgZh[j_lZ_l[_kkf_jlb_
Dh]^Zex^bgZa_fe_magZebqlhg_^Ze_dh\ fhj_\ha\urZxlkyklhevij_djZkgu_
b lZbgkl\_ggu_ ]hju m `bl_e_c dhlhjuo ojZgblky e_dZjkl\h ^Zxs__ [_kkf_jlb_
fgh]b_aZohl_ebih[u\ZlvlZfWlZe_]_g^Z\ dhgp_dhgph\klZeZba\_klgZijZ\bl_eyfb
\eZklbl_eyfdhlhju_gZqZebkgZjy`Zlvh^bgaZ^jm]bf[hevrb_dhjZ[ebkgZ[`Zebbo
ijh\bZglhf b ihkueZeb ^Zhkh\ \ fhj_ d k\ys_gguf ]hjZf klj_fykv ex[ufb
kj_^kl\ZfbaZihemqblvkZfmx[hevrmx\ fbj_^jZ]hp_gghklv²kgZ^h[v_[_kkf_jlby
Wlhl\her_[gucwebdkbjiulZebkv^hklZlv\ i_jbh^;hjxsbokypZjkl\,9²,,,\\^h
d w <wc\Zg b KxZgv\Zg ijZ\bl_eb pZjk]\Z Pb Q`Zk\Zg ijZ\bl_ev pZjkl\Z Ygv
Pbgv RbomZg^b ² I_j\uc pbgvkdbc bfi_jZlhj ² ]] ^h g w oZgvkdbc
bfi_jZlhjM^b²]]^hgwb fgh]b_fgh]b_^jm]b_Gh\k_[_amki_rgh<k_
hgb mf_jeb dZd h[uqgu_ ex^b lZd b g_ jZa^h[u\ kgZ^h[vy [_kkf_jlby b ^Z`_ g_
m\b^_\hq_jlZgbck\ys_gguo]hj
AgZf_gbluc dblZckdbc bklhjbd KufZ Pygv ² ]] ^h g w \ k\hbo
³Bklhjbq_kdboaZibkdZo´ibkZe
³Kh\j_f_gb]hkm^Zj_c<wc\ZgZKxZgv\ZgZb Ygvkdh]hQ`Zh\ZgZihkueZebkv
\ fhj_ ex^b qlh[u hlukdZlv k\ys_ggu_ ]hju IwgeZc NZgq`Zg b Bgq`hm Ih
ij_^ZgbxhgbgZoh^ylky\ ;hoZ_b dlh^h[_j_lkylm^ZgZc^_llZfk\yluob e_dZjkl\h
[_kkf_jlby Ba^Zeb hgb ih^h[gu lmqZf dh]^Z `_ ijb[ebabrvky ]hju moh^yl \ \h^m
ohq_rvih^ieulvgh\_l_j]hgblijhqvlZdgbdlhb g_^h[jZeky^h]hjG_[uehkj_^b
\eZklbl_e_clZdh]hdlh[ug_f_qlZeh gbo´
GZb[he__ ih^]hlh\e_ggu_ wdki_^bpbb gZ ihbkdb hkljh\h\ [_kkf_jlguo
kgZjy`Zebkv \ pZjkl\h\Zgb_ bfi_jZlhjZ Pbgv RbomZg^b ² ]] ^h g w Wlh
[ue bfi_jZlhj dhlhjuc h[t_^bgbe kljZgm b gZqZe kljhbl_evkl\h <_ebdhc DblZckdhc
kl_gu h]jZ^b\r_c Ih^g_[_kgmx bfi_jbx hl dhq_\gbdh\ Nehlbeby ba ^\Z^pZlb
]jhfZ^guodhjZ[e_cih^dhfZg^h\Zgb_fKmRmg_kyljblukyqbxghr_cb ^_\mr_dZ
lZd`_ [hevrh_ qbkeh jZaebqguo jZ[hlgbdh\ kem] b fZkl_jh\uo [ueZ gZijZ\e_gZ
bfi_jZlhjhfPbgvRbomZg^b\ <hklhqgh_fhj_d hkljh\Zf[_kkf_jlby
Reb^gbg_^_ebf_kypuHlKmR_g_ihklmiZehgbdZdbo\_kl_cFgh]b_qZku
bfi_jZlhjijh\h^begZ[_j_]m\kfZljb\Zykv\ g_ykguc]hjbahglGhdhjZ[eblZdb g_
\_jgmebkvIh]h\Zjb\Zebqlhwdki_^bpbyKmR_gZreZ\k_lZdbhkljh\Z[_kkf_jlguob
\uib\ \her_[guc webdkbj [_kkf_jlby \k_ __ mqZklgbdh\ gZ\_qgh hklZebkv gZ
qm^_kguo hkljh\Zo g_ aZohl_\ \ha\jZsZlvky \ Ih^g_[_kgmx bfi_jbx DblZckdb_ `_
bklhjbdb ijb^_j`b\Zebkv g_kdhevdh bgh]h fg_gby < h^ghc ba klZjbgguo ojhgbd
qblZ_f ³Km Rk hlijZ\beky \ ieZ\Zgb_ gh hldjue a_feb aZf_qZl_evgu_ k\hbf
fbjhex[b_fb ieh^hjh^b_f LZf hgihk_ebekyklZedhjhe_fb g_\_jgmekyh[jZlgh´
>j_\g_crb_ e_]_g^u fgh]bo gZjh^h\ mihfbgZeb ijh ³webdkbj [_kkf_jlby´
dhlhjuc\dmrZeb[h]b< jZaguokljZgZo_]hgZau\ZebihjZaghfm;h]b^j_\gbo]j_dh\
mihlj_[eyeb ^Zjmxsmx \_qgmx `bagv Zf[jhabx bg^bckdb_ [h]b ² Zfjblm [h]b
bjZgp_\²oZhfZ[h]b>j_\g_]h?]bilZ²\h^m[_kkf_jlby
Ih^jZ`Zy [h]Zf ex^b lZd`_ iulZebkv ijb]hlh\blv webdkbj [_kkf_jlby <h
fgh]bo klZjbgguo dgb]Zo ihy\eyebkv j_p_ilu ijb]hlh\e_gby wlh]h \her_[gh]h
webdkbjZ LZd \ dgbg]_ =w OmgZ ³;Zh Impau´ \ ]eZ\_ ³Kygvyhgygv´ ² ³KgZ^h[vy
[_kkf_jlby´ _klv fgh]h j_p_ilh\ ba]hlh\e_gby wlh]h webdkbjZ J_dhf_g^h\Zehkv \aylv
`Z[mdhlhjZyijh`beZ^_kylvlukyqe_lb e_lmqmxfurvdhlhjZyijh`beZlukyqme_l
\ukmrblvbo\ l_gbjZklhehqv\ ihjhrhdb ijbgbfZlv\gmljv²lh]^Zfh`ghijh`blv
^hkhjhdZlukyqe_l
: \hl j_p_il ba ^j_\g_i_jkb^kdh]h l_dklZ ³GZ^h \aylv q_eh\_dZ ju`_]h b
\_kgmrqZlh]hb dhjfblv_]hieh^Zfb^he_laZl_fhimklblv_]h\ dZf_gguckhkm^k
f_^hfb ^jm]bfbkhklZ\ZfbaZdexqblvwlhlkhkm^\ h[jmqbb ]_jf_lbq_kdbaZdmihjblv
Q_j_ae_l_]hl_ehh[jZlblky\ fmfbx´Ihke_wlh]hkh^_j`bfh_khkm^Z\dexqZylh
qlhklZehfmfb_cfh`gh[uehijbgbfZlv\ dZq_kl\_kj_^kl\Zijh^e_\Zxs_]h`bagv
>h gZk ^hr_e j_p_il webdkbjZ [_kkf_jlby khklZ\e_gguc ebqguf \jZqhf iZiu
;hgbnZpby 9,,, ² ³gZ^h kf_rZlv \ baf_evq_gghf \b^_ ahehlh `_fqm]
kZinbju bamfjm^u jm[bgu lhiZau [_eu_ b djZkgu_ dhjZeeu kehgh\mx dhklv
kZg^Zeh\h_^_j_\hk_j^p_he_gydhj_gvZehwfmkdmkb Zf[jm´
H^bg njZgpmakdbc mq_guc ;9 \_dZ \ ihbkdZo `bag_ggh]h webdkbjZ k\Zjbe ybphl^_ebe[_edbhl`_eldh\bkf_rb\Zybok \h^hcfgh]hdjZlghi_j_]hgyegZ^_ykv
lZdbfiml_fba\e_qvbkdhfmxkm[klZgpbx`bagb
Fgh]b_dblZckdb_bfi_jZlhjum\e_dZebkvihbkdZfbkgZ^h[vy[_kkf_jlbyM^b
bfi_jZlhj ^bgZklbb OZgv ijZ\be k ih ]h^ ^h g w hdjm`be k_[y fZ]Zfb b
dm^_kgbdZfbdhlhju_^he`gu[uebba]hlZ\eb\Zlvh^gbfbf\_^hfu_khklZ\ub lZcgu_
kgZ^h[vyM^bf_qlZegZclbqm^hl\hjgmxjhkmdhlhjhcydh[uiblZebkv[_kkf_jlgu_
beb^h[ulvqm^_kgu_i_jkbdbhl\_^Z\dhlhju_fh`ghijbh[sblvkyd \_qghc`bagb
>jm]hc dblZckdbc bfi_jZlhj KxZgvpamg ² ]] hlijZ\beky d k\hbf
pZjkl\_gguf ij_^dZf gZfgh]h jZgvr_ iheh`_ggh]h kjhdZ lhevdh ihlhfm qlh bf_e
g_hklhjh`ghklvijbgylvwebdkbj[_kkf_jlbyba]hlh\e_gguc_]hijb^\hjgufe_dZj_f
JZkkdZau\Zxl qlh ijb ^bgZklbb OZgv [ue \ OmZcgZgb dgyav Ex :gv
m\e_dZ\rbcky mq_gb_f h [_kkf_jlguo Hg gZklhevdh ihklb] mq_gb_ h >Zh Imlb qlh
k^_eZekZfibexeb[_kkf_jlbyijbgyeh^gmb kj_^v[_eZ^gyih^gyekygZg_[hIbexeb
k\hbhghklZ\be^hfZ\ ]ebgyghcqZr_bokde_\Zebdmjub kt_ebkh[Zdbb \fb]bkq_aeb
Lhevdh k g_[Z ^hghkbehkv dm^ZolZgv_ ^Z ly\dZgv_ kh[Zd \ h[eZdZo WlZ e_]_g^Z
ex[hiulgZ gh b lhevdh <_^v ba ³Bklhjbq_kdbo aZibkhd´ KufZ Pygy ba\_klgh qlh
omZcgZgvkdbcdgyavEx:gvihdhgqbek kh[hcihlhfmqlhdlhlh^hg_kgZg_]hh[\bgb\
\ baf_g_Hgbkim]ZekygZdZaZgbyb i_j_j_aZek_[_]hjeh
: m^Z\Zehkv eb ^_ckl\bl_evgh ohlv dhfmgb[m^v hldjulv lZcgu webdkbjZ
[_kkf_jlby"Ih\k_c\_jhylghklbdhg_qgh`_g_lH^gZdh\ bklhjbb\j_fyhl\j_f_gb
ihy\eyebkvaZ]Z^hqgu_ebqghklbdhlhjufydh[um^Z\Zehkv\hclb\ ^\_jb[_kkf_jlby
H^ghc ba lZdbo lZbgkl\_gguo ebqghkl_c [ue nbehkhn ibnZ]hj_ckdhc rdheu
:iheehgbcLbZgkdbcjh\_kgbdBbkmkZOjbklZjh^b\rbckyaZljb]h^Z^hGh\hcwju
:iheehgbc LbZgkdbc ihk_lbe fgh]b_ kljZgu Zglbqgh]h fbjZ bamqZe k_dj_lu `j_ph\
Bg^bb b <Z\behgZ kh\j_f_ggbdb ijbibku\Zeb _fm fgh]b_ qm^_kZ I_j_`b\ ^_kylv
bfi_jZlhjh\ \ \hajZkl_ e_l :iheehgbc LbZgkdbc \_jgmeky \ Jbf ]^_ ih ijbdZam
bfi_jZlhjZ>hfbpbZgZ[uehl^Zgih^km^ihh[\bg_gbx\ q_jghdgb`bbGhkemqbehkv
qm^hgZ]eZaZom \k_o:iheehgbcbkq_abai_j_iheg_ggh]haZeZkm^Z
< l_q_gb_ jy^Z \_dh\ kqblZehkv qlh :iheehgbc kmf_\ ijb]hlh\blv webdkbj
[_kkf_jlby ijh^he`Z_l kdju\Zlvky kj_^b ex^_c < ;,, \_d_ `be nbehkhn b Zeobfbd
gZau\Z\rbck_[y:jl_nbmkhfhldhlhjh]h^hgZr_]h\j_f_gb^hreh^\ZlZbgkl\_gguo
ljm^Z iheguo aZ]Z^hd b g_^hfhe\hd ² ljZdlZl h nbehkhnkdhf dZfg_ b khqbg_gb_ h
imlyo ijh^e_gby `bagb Fgh]b_ kh\j_f_ggbdb iheZ]Zeb qlh ih^ bf_g_f :jl_nbmkZ
kdju\Z_lky :iheehgbc LbZgkdbc b ijb\h^beb \_kdb_ Zj]mf_glu \ aZsblm k\hbo
ih^haj_gbc
E_]_g^u ijbibku\Zxl ^hklb`_gb_ ihegh]h [_kkf_jlby b_jmkZebfkdhfm bm^_x
:]Zkn_jm ² agZf_gblhfm <_qghfm @b^m Kh]eZkgh j_eb]bhaguf kdZaZgbyf Ojbklhk
\h \j_fy k\h_]h dj_klgh]h imlb gZ =he]hnm \ djZcg_f bag_fh`_gbb ijbkehgbeky d
kl_g_ ^hfZ ijbgZ^e_`Zs_]h :]Zkn_jm Gh `_klhdbc bm^_c g_ ^Ze gb k_dmg^u
i_j_^hogmlvOjbklmg_kr_fmly`_euc^_j_\yggucdj_klb ijh]gZe_]hLh]^ZOjbklhk
h[j_d:]Zkn_jZgZ\_qgu_kdblZgby[_agZ^_`^udh]^Zeb[hh[j_klbihdhcbebkf_jlv
B \hl lh lZf lh a^_kv ba \_dZ \ \_d ihy\ey_lky q_eh\_d dhlhjh]h fgh]b_
hlh`^_kl\eyxl k ebqghklvx [_kkf_jlgh]h :]Zkn_jZ BlZevygkdbc Zkljheh] =\b^h
;hgZllb\ ]h^m\klj_lbe_]hijbbkiZgkdhf^\hj_
Iylvx]h^Zfbiha`_h g_fmihfbgZ_laZibkvk^_eZggZy\ ojhgbd_Z[[Zlkl\Zk\
:ev[ZgZ :g]eby Kh keh\ Zjfygkdh]h Zjob_ibkdhiZ ihk_lb\r_]h Z[[Zlkl\h
jZkkdZau\Z_lky h \klj_qZo k :]Zkn_jhf gZoh^b\rbfky \ lh \j_fy \ :jf_gbb Ydh[u
q_eh\_d\u^Z\Z\rbck_[yaZ:]Zkn_jZohjhrhihfgblkh[ulby[he__q_flukyq_e_lg_c
^Z\ghklbihfgbl\g_rghklvZihklheh\b fgh]b_ih^jh[ghklb`bagbl_oe_lh dhlhjuo
g_agZ_lgbdlhbagug_`b\msbo
< ]h^mwlhlq_eh\_dihy\ey_lky\hNjZgpbbaZl_fgZ^\Zk iheh\bghc\_dZ
\hpZjy_lkyfheqZgb_bklhjbq_kdboojhgbd< ]h^m:]Zkn_jh[ty\ey_lky\ ;h]_fbb
q_j_ag_kdhevdhe_l_]h\b^ylgZ:jZ[kdhf<hklhd_Z \]h^mhgkgh\Z\ ?\jhi_\
=Zf[mj]_
H \klj_q_ b jZa]h\hj_ k gbf jZkkdZau\Z_l \ k\hbo aZibkdZo _ibkdhi Re_a\b]Z
IZmev nhg Wcla_g ² Ih _]h k\b^_l_evkl\m q_eh\_d wlhl ]h\hjbe gZ \k_o
yaudZo[_afZe_cr_]hZdp_glZHg\_eaZfdgmlucb Zkd_lbq_kdbch[jZa`bagbb g_bf_e
gbdZdh]h bfms_kl\Z djhf_ ieZlvy dhlhjh_ [ueh gZ g_f < ]h^m _]h \b^_eb \
BkiZgbb a^_kv k gbf [_k_^h\Zeb iZikdb_ e_]Zlu ijb bkiZgkdhf ^\hj_ ² Djbklhnhj
DjZma_ b Ydh[ Ohevkl_cg < ]h^m _]h \b^_eb \ <_g_ hldm^Z hg gZijZ\eyeky \
Ihevrm kh[bjZykv ^h[jZlvky ^h Fhkd\u <kdhj_ hg ^_ckl\bl_evgh h[ty\ey_lky \
Fhkd\_ ]^_ fgh]b_ ydh[u lZd`_ \b^_eb _]h b jZa]h\Zjb\Zeb k gbf < ]h^m hg
ihy\ey_lky \ Ex[_d_ qlh [ueh aZk\b^_l_evkl\h\Zgh [mj]hfbkljhf Dhe_jmkhf
bklhjbdhf b [h]hkeh\hf Dfh\_jhf b ^jm]bfb hnbpbZevgufb ebpZfb < ]h^m
<_qguc @b^ ihy\ey_lky \ IZjb`_ \ ]h^m ² \ =Zf[mj]_ \ ]h^m ² \
;jxkk_e_\ ]h^m²\ E_cipb]_\ ]h^m²\ KlZfnhj^_<_ebdh[jblZgby
Dh]^Z \ dhgp_ ;9,, \_dZ \_qguc kljZggbd kgh\Z h[ty\beky \ :g]ebb
kd_ilbq_kdb gZkljh_ggu_ Zg]ebqZg_ j_rbeb mkljhblv _fm wdaZf_g k mqZklb_f
ijhn_kkhjh\ Hdknhj^Z b D_f[jb^`Z H^gZdh ihagZgby _]h \ ^j_\g_cr_c bklhjbb \
]_h]jZnbb kZfuo hl^Ze_gguo m]hedh\ A_feb dhlhju_ hg ihk_lbe beb ydh[u ihk_lbe
[uebihjZabl_evguDh]^Z_fm\g_aZighaZ^Zeb\hijhkgZZjZ[kdhfhg[_afZe_cr_]h
Zdp_glZhl\_qZegZwlhfyaud_Hg]h\hjbeqmlvebg_gZ\k_oyaudZdZd_\jhi_ckdbo
lZdb \hklhqguo
<kdhj_q_eh\_dwlhlh[ty\beky\ >ZgbbZ aZl_f\ R\_pbb ]^_ke_^u_]hkgh\Z
l_jyxlky < b ]h^Zo hg `_ beb g_dlh \u^Z\Zrbc k_[y aZ g_]h
ihy\ey_lky\ :g]ebbb kl_oihjkgh\ZgZ^he]hbkq_aZ_lbaiheyaj_gby
<h \lhjhc iheh\bg_ ;9,,, \_dZ \gbfZgb_ kh\j_f_ggbdh\ ijb\e_dZeb ^\_
lZbgkl\_ggu_ ebqghklb ydh[u \eZ^_\rb_ webdkbjhf [_kkf_jlby ² ]jZn DZebhkljh
²b ]jZnK_g@_jf_g"²"
Hlghkbl_evgh]jZnZDZebhkljh\ gZklhys__\j_fym [hevrbgkl\Zbkke_^h\Zl_e_c
g_\hagbdZ_lgbdZdbokhfg_gbc >hdmf_glZevgh^hdZaZghqlhwlhleh\dbcZ\Zglxjbkl
[uemjh`_gp_fIZe_jfhBhkbnhf;ZevaZfhk fZeuoe_lijhkeZ\b\rbfkyjZaebqgufb
obljufb ijh^_edZfb b fZobgZpbyfb K\hbfb ihagZgbyfb \ fZ]bb b Zeobfbb hg [ue
h[yaZg Zjfygbgm :evlhlZkm k dhlhjuf ihk_lbe jZaebqgu_ k\ylbebsZ ?]bilZ Z ihlhf
ijZdlbdh\Zeky \ Zeobfbb ijb ^\hj_ Ibglh <_ebdh]h FZ]bkljZ FZevlbckdh]h hj^_gZ
bf_\r_]h[hevrmxkdehgghklvd lZbgkl\_ggufgZmdZfIhdbgm\FZevlmb jZkklZ\rbkv
k :evlhlZkhf ]jZn DZebhkljh lZd hg klZe k_[y gZau\Zlv kZfh\hevgh ijbk\hb\
]jZnkdbc lblme klZe ^_fhgkljbjh\Zlv k\hb fZ]bq_kdb_ ihagZgby ijb dhjhe_\kdbo
^\hjZo?\jhiub ^Z`_\ Jhkkbb<_jhylghbf_gghd wlhfm\j_f_gbhlghkylkykemobh
ydh[u bf_\r_fky m g_]h qm^_kghf webdkbj_ [_kkf_jlby b \_qghc fheh^hklb H^gZdh
[_kkf_jlby aZf_qZl_evghfm Z\Zglxjbklm ^hklbqv lZd b g_ m^Zehkv b hg mf_j \ ]h^mijbdh\Zggucp_ivxd kl_g_fjZqgh]hih^\ZeZaZfdZk\ylh]h:g]_eZ\ Jbf_dm^Z
[ue[jhr_gihijb]h\hjmbgd\babpbbdZd_j_lbdfZ]h[fZgsbdb njZgdfZkhg
=hjZa^h[hevrZylZcgZhdjm`Z_l]jZnZK_g@_jf_gZkh\j_f_ggbdZDZebhkljh
< ijhlhdheZokm^Zbgd\babpbbkhojZgbekyaZibkZgguckhkeh\DZebhkljhjZkkdZah _]h
ihk_s_gbb K_g@_jf_gZ ]^_ hg ml\_j`^Ze [m^lh [u \b^_e khkm^ \ dhlhjhf ]jZn
ojZgbe webdkbj [_kkf_jlby =jZn K_g@_jf_g ihjZ`Ze kh\j_f_ggbdh\ k\h_c
g_h[uqZcghc hk\_^hfe_gghklvx h ijhrehf ?]h ihy\e_gb_ ijb\h^beh \ bamfe_gb_ b
jZkl_jygghklv ih`beuo ZjbklhdjZlh\ dhlhju_ ijbihfbgZeb \^jm] qlh \b^_eb m`_
wlh]h q_eh\_dZ \b^_eb ^Z\gh \ ^_lkl\_ \ kZehgZo k\hbo [Z[mr_d B k l_o ihj
ihjZ`Zebkvhgbhgkh\_jr_gghg_baf_gbeky\g_rg_
K_g@_jf_gh[ty\beky\g_aZighg_bf_ygbdZdh]hijhreh]hH g_fkZfhfb h
ijhbkoh`^_gbb _]h nZglZklbq_kdh]h [h]Zlkl\Z fu agZ_f lZd `_ fZeh dZd b _]h
kh\j_f_ggbdb Klhev `_ lZbgkl\_ggZ b kf_jlv _]h ydh[u gZklmib\rZy \ ]h^m \
m_^bg_gghf aZfd_ \ =herlbgbb H^bg ba kh\j_f_ggbdh\ agZ\rbc ]jZnZ gZa\Ze __
³fgbfhc kf_jlvx´ hg ibkZe qlh gb gZ h^ghc ba fh]bevguo iebl \ hdjm]_ g_l bf_gb
K_g@_jf_gZ
Fgh]b_ ]h^u kimkly ihke_ wlhc ³kf_jlb´ agZdhfu_ K_g@_jf_gZ \klj_qZeb
]jZnZ \h fgh]bo ]hjh^Zo ?\jhiu LZd K_g@_jf_g ijbkmlkl\h\Ze gZ \klj_q_
njZgdfZkhgh\\ IZjb`_q_j_a]h^ihke_k\h_c³fgbfhckf_jlb´?s_q_j_aljb]h^Z\
]h^mnjZgpmakdbcihkeZggbd\ <_g_pbb]jZnRZehg_\klj_qZ_lK_g@_jf_gZgZ
iehsZ^bK\ylh]hFZjdZb [_k_^m_lk gbf< ]h^unjZgpmakdhcj_\hexpbb]jZnZydh[u
hihagZeb \ h^ghc ba lxj_f ]^_ kh^_j`Zebkv ZjbklhdjZlu Q_j_a e_l ihke_ kf_jlb
K_g@_jf_gZ ij_klZj_eZy ZjbklhdjZldZ fZ^Zf @Zgebk ohjhrh agZ\rZy ]jZnZ \
fheh^hklb \klj_qZ_l wlh]h q_eh\_dZ gbqmlv g_ baf_gb\r_]hky \ dmemZjZo <_gkdh]h
dhg]j_kkZ < ihke_^gb_ ]h^u ijZ\e_gby EmbNbebiiZ dh]^Z m`_ ihqlb gbdh]h ba
ex^_c agZ\rbo K_g@_jf_gZ ebqgh g_ hklZehkv \ `b\uo lZbgkl\_ggh]h ]jZnZ \k_
lZd`_gbqmlvg_ihklZj_\r_]h\klj_lbe\ IZjb`_h^bghlklZ\ghckZgh\gbd
?klv _s_ ^\Z [he__ iha^gbo khh[s_gby k\yaZgguo k bf_g_f K_g@_jf_gZ Hg
ydh[u hiylv ihy\beky \ IZjb`_ m`_ \ ]h^m B ihke_^gbc jZa ² \ ^_dZ[j_ ]h^ZIhkdhevdmh^gZdhd lhfm\j_f_gbg_hklZehkvex^_cebqghagZdhfuok ]jZnhf
khh[s_gbywlbljm^ghkqblZlv^hklh\_jgufb
KZfh_ kljZggh_ b nZglZklbq_kdh_ ba kh\j_f_gguo khh[s_gbc h [_kkf_jlbb
k\yaZgh k bf_g_f bg^bcpZ LZiZk\b^`b ijh`b\r_]h ydh[u e_l ² <
\hajZkl_ lb e_l hg [m^mqb jZ^`hc \ IZlbZe_ j_rbe m^Zeblvky \ =bfZeZb Ihke_
fgh]he_lgbo mijZ`g_gbc LZiZk\b^`b gZmqbeky ih]jm`Zlvky \ lZd gZau\Z_fh_
khklhygb_ ³kZfZ^ob´ dh]^Z `bagv dZaZehkv iheghklvx ihdb^ZeZ _]h l_eh b fh]
ih^he]m g_ ijbgbfZlv gb iblv_ gb ibsm H^gZ`^u jZkkdZaZe LZiZk\b^`b m hljh]h\
=bfZeZ_\ _fm \klj_lbeky klZjbdhlr_evgbd Hg iblZeky ebrv njmdlZfb b fhehdhf Z
\u]ey^_e gZ j_^dhklv wg_j]bqguf b [h^juf Gh kZfh_ m^b\bl_evgh_ hlr_evgbd g_
]h\hjbegb gZh^ghfbakh\j_f_gguobg^bckdboyaudh\batykgyykvlhevdhgZkZgkdjbl_
²yaud_>j_\g_cBg^bb HdZaZehkvqlh k l_o ihj dZd hg ijbr_e kx^Z ijhreh e_l Ijh^eblv k\hx `bagv ^h lZdbo ij_^_eh\ _fm m^Zehkv ydh[u [eZ]h^Zjy g_dh_fm
khklZ\mlZcghcdhlhjh]hhg\eZ^_e
Gh \k_lZdb klhbl ijbagZlv qlh \k_ hibkZggh_ \ur_ kemqZb ^hklb`_gby d_f
eb[h[_kkf_jlbyhlghkylkykdhj__d e_]_g^Zf>Z\Zcl_\klZg_fgZ[he__l\_j^mxihq\m
kms_kl\mxs_cj_Zevghklbb ijhZgZebabjm_fdZdbfbkj_^kl\Zfb\ h[eZklb^hklb`_gby
ijZdlbq_kdh]h[_kkf_jlbyjZkiheZ]Z_lkh\j_f_ggZygZmdZgZgZklhysbcfhf_glKjZam
`_ hl[jhkbf \ klhjhgm \k_ f_lh^u m\_ebq_gby ijh^he`bl_evghklb `bagb <hi_j\uo
fum`_jZkkdZau\Zebh gbo\ ij_^u^ms_c]eZ\_Z \h\lhjuo\ gboj_qvb^_lebrvh[
m\_ebq_gbb kjhdh\ kms_kl\h\Zgby hj]ZgbafZ Z g_ h ijbgpbibZevguo ihbkdZo
[_kkf_jlby
< gZklhys__ \j_fy ihbkdb [_kkf_jlby b^ml ih g_kdhevdbf ^bZf_ljZevgh
ijhlb\hiheh`guf gZijZ\e_gbyf H^gh ba gbo ² i_j_kZ^dZ ]heh\gh]h fha]Z <
gZklhys__ \j_fy y\ey_lky [_amkeh\gh ^hdZaZgguf qlh bf_ggh ]heh\ghc fha] y\ey_lky
ghkbl_e_f bg^b\b^mZevghklb q_eh\_dZ _]h fure_gby \hkijbylby fbjZ iZfylb
hkhagZgbyk_[ydZdebqghklb
M`_ \ ]h^m nbabheh]b ijh^_fhgkljbjh\Zeb m^b\bl_evgu_ hiulu ih
i_j_kZ^d_ fha]Z `Z[u \ ]heh\m ey]mrdb IhemqbeZkv hq_gv kljZggZy b m^b\bl_evgZy
ey]mrdZ k ih\Z^dZfb `Z[u <f_klh lh]h qlh[u iju]Zlv \ \h^m ih^h[gh ^jm]bf
ij_^klZ\bl_eyfk\h_]h\b^ZhgZdZdkZfZygZklhysZy`Z[ZijbgbfZeZkvbkdZlv\ a_fe_
ghjmqlh[uaZjulvky\ g__
K fhf_glZ wlbo hiulh\ ijhreh ihqlb e_l AZ wlb ]h^u [ueb mki_rgh
hkms_kl\e_gu ^_kyldb hi_jZpbc ih i_j_kZ^d_ k_j^pZ i_q_gb ihq_d m q_eh\_dZ
gZqbgZxlj_rZlvkyijh[e_fuldZg_\hcg_kh\f_klbfhklbi_j_kZ`_gguohj]Zgh\LZdbf
h[jZahf gZmdZ \iehlgmx ih^hreZ d i_j_kZ^d_ ]heh\gh]h fha]Z Ohly jZ[hlu \ wlhf
gZijZ\e_gbb \_^mlky ^h\hevgh bgl_gkb\gh ljm^gh kdZaZlv dh]^Z lhqgh m^Zklky
\hiehlblvgZmqgu_wdki_jbf_glu\ ijZdlbdm<h\kydhfkemqZ_wlh\j_fyg_aZ]hjZfb
b \iheg_ \hafh`gh qlh m`_ gZr_ ihdhe_gb_ klZg_l k\b^_l_e_f mki_rghc i_j_kZ^db
fha]Zq_eh\_dZ
Ihwlhfml_hj_lbq_kdbm`_k_cqZkfh`ghij_^klZ\blvex^_cq_cfha]Z agZqblb
ebqghklv [m^ml fgh]h jZa i_j_oh^blv ba h^gh]h l_eZ \ ^jm]h_ Hl[jZku\Zy h^gh aZ
^jm]bf g_gm`gu_ khklZjb\rb_ky l_eZ q_eh\_d [m^_l mghkblvky ba \_dZ \ \_d ba
lukyq_e_lby \ lukyq_e_lby @bagv h^ghc ebqghklb __ iZfylv \f_klyl \ k_[y p_eu_
wihob q_eh\_q_kdhc bklhjbb H^gZdh \hagbdZ_l aZdhghf_jguc \hijhk ² Z qvb l_eZ
kh[bjZ_lky hl[jZku\Zlv dZd g_gm`gu_ b hljZ[hlZggu_ wlZ ³ebqghklv´" B dlh [m^_l
hij_^_eylv ijZ\h gZ [_kkf_jlb_ h^ghc ebqghklb aZ kq_l hj]Zgbafh\ ^jm]bo ex^_c" <
f_gvr_c kl_i_gb wlb \hijhku m`_ \klZeb i_j_^ \jZqZfb b mq_gufb ijb i_j_kZ^d_
^hghjkdboihq_db k_j^pZK ]hjZa^h[hevr_chkljhlhchgb\klZgmlijbihiuld_ihbkdZ
³^hghjkdbo´ l_e ^ey i_j_kZ^db fha]Z GZ^h l\_j^h mk\hblv qlh g_kfhljy gZ lh qlh
h[ebd q_eh\_dZ q_jlu _]h ebpZ kljh_gb_ l_eZ [m^ml iheghklvx khhl\_lkl\h\Zlv l_em
³^hghjZ´ _]h ebqghklv b kZfhkhagZgb_ [m^ml hij_^_eylvky bkdexqbl_evgh
i_j_kZ`_gguffha]hf
WlZ ijh[e_fZ [ueZ ij_^\hkobs_gZ ]_gb_f F : ;me]Zdh\Z \ ih\_klb ³Kh[Zqv_
k_j^p_´ >h[juc i_k RZjbd ih^ \ebygb_f i_j_kZ`_gghc rbrdh\b^ghc `_e_au
]heh\gh]h fha]Z ih]b[r_]h [Zg^blZ b Zedh]hebdZ ij_\jZsZ_lky \ lhqgh_ ih^h[b_
ihke_^g_]h K_cqZk wlhl \hijhk jZajZ[Zlu\Z_lky Zf_jbdZgkdbf dbg_fZlh]jZnhf
@_gsbg_ q_c fha] [ue g_h[jZlbfh ljZ\fbjh\Zg \ dZlZkljhn_ i_j_kZ`b\Zxl fha]
^jm]hc`_gsbguqv_l_ehih]b[ehD_f`_y\ey_lkygh\h_kms_kl\hk h[ebdhfi_j\hc
`_gsbgub fha]hf\lhjhc"DZdhgh^he`ghhlghkblvkyd k\hbf[ebadbffm`m^_lyf"
Wlhg_bkq_jiZ_fucfZl_jbZe^ey^jZfZlmj]bq_kdbodheebabc
<hafh`gh \ [m^ms_f mq_gu_ kfh]ml kdhgkljmbjh\Zlv bkdmkkl\_ggh_ l_eh ^ey
]heh\gh]hfha]ZojZgbl_eyebqghklbWlh[m^_ldb[hj]jh[hlk fha]hfq_eh\_dZLZdbf
h[jZahf \hafh`gh ^hklb`_gb_ [_kkf_jlby aZ kq_l ihl_jb k\h_]h l_eZ =hlh\h eb
ikboheh]bq_kdb q_eh\_q_kl\h d ih^h[guf hiulZf" : ]hlh\u eb \u ebqgh" WlZ
nbehkhnkdZyijh[e_fZg_jZaih^ufZeZkv\ fgh]hqbke_gguonZglZklbq_kdbojhfZgZo
gZqbgZy kh agZf_gblhc ³=heh\u ijhn_kkhjZ >hmwey´ kh\_lkdh]h ibkZl_ey
nZglZklZ:J;_ey_\Z²
<lhjhc imlv ^hklb`_gby ijZdlbq_kdh]h [_kkf_jlby ² wlh ]_ggZy bg`_g_jby
DZ`^Zy de_ldZ `b\h]h kms_kl\Z ojZgbl \ k\h_f y^j_ \kx ]_g_lbq_kdmx bgnhjfZpbx
g_h[oh^bfmx ^ey h[jZah\Zgby gh\h]h hj]ZgbafZ G_kdhevdh e_l gZaZ^ mq_gu_
Hdknhj^kdh]hmgb\_jkbl_lZ\ <_ebdh[jblZgbb ijh\_ebbgl_j_kgucwdki_jbf_gl ² ba
de_ldbwibl_ebyey]mrdb[ueZ\ujZs_gZgh\Zyey]mrdZlhqgZydhibyi_j\hcIhwlhfm
l_hj_lbq_kdb \ [eb`Zcr__ \j_fy klZg_l \hafh`guf fZkkh\h_ \hkijhba\h^kl\h
Z[khexlgh bg^_glbqguo [ebag_ph\ \ lhf qbke_ q q_eh\_dZ Wlh agZqbl qlh dh]^Z
q_eh\_dm bkihegblky beb e_l fh`gh [m^_l \aylv m g_]h y^jZ de_lhd ba ex[h]h
hj]ZgZ b \ujZklb\ bo \ de_ldZo ebr_gguo y^jZ ihemqblv lhqgmx [bheh]bq_kdmx
dhibx ^Zggh]h q_eh\_dZ Lh _klv fh`gh [m^_l iheghklvx ih\lhjblv kZfh]h k_[y gh
y\b\rbkv \ dZq_kl\_ gh\hjh`^_ggh]h b \ hij_^_e_gghf kfuke_ h[_ki_qblv k\h_
[_kkf_jlb_ ihkdhevdm wlm hi_jZpbx fh`gh [ueh [u ih\lhjylv g_h]jZgbq_ggh_ qbkeh
jZa
;he__lh]h\ [m^ms_fl_hj_lbq_kdb\hafh`gh [ueh [u bkihevah\Zlv g_ lhevdh
³`b\hc´ ]_g_lbq_kdbc fZl_jbZe de_lhd gh b ³aZdhgk_j\bjh\Zgguc´ kdZ`_f \ ldZgyo
fmfbb B fh`gh [m^_l \hkijhba\_klb ihegmx [bheh]bq_kdmx dhibx ^Zgghc fmfbb k
fhf_glZ jh`^_gby Gh lZd dZd fmfbnbdZpbb m^hklZb\Zebkv \ hkgh\ghf lbjZgu lh
\hagbdZ_l\hijhk²Z gZ^heb\hkijhba\h^blvbokgh\Z"
Klhbl mlhqgblv qlh \k_ wlb [bheh]bq_kdb_ dhibb ih\lhjyy \ f_evqZcrbo
^_lZeyoh[ebddhgdj_lguoex^_c\k_lZdb[m^mlgZ^_e_gukh[kl\_ggufkhagZgb_fWlh
[m^_likboheh]bq_kdbkh\_jr_ggh^jm]hcbg^b\b^b _]hiZfylv_]hjZ^hklbb i_qZeb
ex[h\v b g_gZ\bklv [m^ml ^Ze_db hl ijhlhlbiZ ?]h bgl_ee_dlmZevguc h[ebd [m^_l
kdeZ^u\Zlvky ih^ \ebygb_f ^jm]h]h \hkiblZgby h[jZah\Zgby b gZdhg_p ijhklh
q_eh\_q_kdh]hhdjm`_gbygh\h]hihdhe_gbyex^_cB ^Z`__kebgZfm^Zklky\hkkha^Zlv
gh\h]h LmlZgohfhgZ ih k\h_fm ikboheh]bq_kdhfm kdeZ^m wlh [m^_l g_ ^j_\gbc
_]bilygbg Z gZr kh\j_f_ggbd Ke_^h\Zl_evgh b lml fu g_ ^hklb]Z_f ihegh]h
[_kkf_jlby?kebijbi_j_kZ^d_fha]ZfukhojZgy_febqghklvghl_jy_fl_ehb h[ebd
lhijb]_gghcbg`_g_jbbfukhojZgy_flhqgh_ih^h[b_^Zggh]hq_eh\_dZghl_jy_f_]h
ebqghklviZfylvhiulZ fh`_l[ulvb lZeZgl
IjZ\^Zba\_klguckh\_lkdbcmq_gucID:ghobg\u^\bgme]bihl_amkh]eZkgh
dhlhjhc ijbgpbibZevgh \hafh`gZ gZke_^kl\_ggZy i_j_^ZqZ bgnhjfZpbb ihemq_gghc
q_eh\_dhf\ l_q_gb_`bagb< wlhfkemqZ_³q_eh\_ddhiby´[m^_lghkblv\ k_[_iZfylv
h[h \k_f qlh ijhbahreh k ³hjb]bgZehf´ [m^_l ojZgblv wlh \ k_[_ dZd \hkihfbgZgby
k\h_c kh[kl\_gghc `bagb L_f kZfuf hdZ`_lky \hafh`guf ^h[blvky iheghc
b^_glbqghklbbg^b\b^mZevghkl_c P_ivbg^b\b^mZevgh]hkhagZgbyi_j_oh^ybal_eZ\
l_eh g_ [m^_l ij_ju\Zlvky IZfylv h `bagb ijhreuo m`_ khklZjb\rboky b g_
kms_kl\mxsbol_e_kguoh[hehq_d[m^_llZd`_[_kij_ju\gZdZdgZrb\hkihfbgZgbyh
^g_ijh`blhf\q_jZf_kypgZaZ^beb\ ijhrehf]h^m
Ke_^mxsbf b ijbq_f \_kvfZ b \_kvfZ i_jki_dlb\guf gZijZ\e_gb_f ihbkdh\
[_kkf_jlby aZgbfZ_lky gZmdZ djbh[bheh]by bamqZxsZy `bag_^_yl_evghklv hj]ZgbafZ
ijbhq_gvgbadbol_fi_jZlmjZo
L_hj_lbdhfb hkgh\hiheh`gbdhfdjbh]_g_aZpbbl_aZfhjZ`b\ZgbykqblZ_lky
Zf_jbdZgkdbcijhn_kkhjnbabdbb fZl_fZlbdbJh[_jlWllbg^`_j\uimklb\rbc\ _
]h^u dgb]m ³Hldjulb_ [_kkf_jlby´ kjZam `_ klZ\rmx [_klk_ee_jhf b aZ\h_\Z\rmx
khlgb ihdehggbdh\ f_lh^Z djbh]_g_aZpbb ³Dh]^Z dh]heb[h h[ty\eyxl h[j_q_gguf
b[h kh\j_f_ggZy f_^bpbgZ g_ \ khklhygbb ihfhqv² q_eh\_d _s_ `b\ gZ ijhp_glh\² ibr_l J Wllbg^`_j² <_^v wlh nZdl qlh fgh]b_ [he_agb g_dh]^Z
kqblZ\rb_kykf_jl_evgufbk_]h^gybae_qb\ZxlkyKhojZgyyl_eh\ oheh^_^hklZlhqgh
ebrv^h`^Zlvkydh]^Zgh\u_agZgbyb l_ogheh]bbihfh]ml\Zf\_jgmlvky´
D
gZklhys_fm \j_f_gb bf_xlky m[_^bl_evgu_ wdki_jbf_glZevgu_
ih^l\_j`^_gby djbh]_gbaZpbb X]hkeZ\kdbf mq_guf m^Zehkv h`b\blv djuk
hoeZ`^_gguo ^h ]jZ^mkh\ Objmj]b =Zj^\Zj^kdh]h mgb\_jkbl_lZ KR: h`b\beb
ohfydh\ ihke_ lh]h dZd hgb gZoh^bebkv \ aZfhjh`_gghf khklhygbb [he__ iylb qZkh\
Wdki_jbf_glZlhju g_h^ghdjZlgh h`b\eyeb h[_avyg gZoh^ysboky \ i_j_hoeZ`^_gghf
khklhygbbdh]^Z`b\hlgu_m`_g_^urZebb k_j^p_g_[behkv
Fgh`_kl\h m^b\bl_evguo nZdlh\ \ha\jZs_gby d `bagb aZfhjh`_gguo ex^_c
gZdhibeZ kh\j_f_ggZy f_^bpbgZ H^bg ba lZdbo kemqZ_\ k\yaZg k yihgkdbf rhn_jhf
FZkZjmKZcljZ[hlZ\rbfgZj_njb`_jZlhj_²Z\lhfZrbg_i_j_\hays_choeZ`^_ggu_
ijh^mdlu < lhl ^_gv hg ijb_oZe \ Lhdbh ba Km^amhdb aZ ihemq_gb_f ]jmaZ
fhjh`_ggh]hLy`_eZyih_a^dZb `ZjZmlhfbeZ\h^bl_eyb hgj_rbemdjulvkyhl`Zju
b hl^hogmlv ^h ihemq_gby ]jmaZ \ dmah\_ k\h_c oheh^bevghc fZrbgu Ijhreh \j_fy
DlhlhaZf_lbeklhysmx[_a\h^bl_eyZ\lhfZrbgmDh]^Zhldjueb__lhh[gZjm`beb\
g_crhn_jZghm`_³aZfhjh`_ggh]h´L_jfhf_lj\gmljbihdZau\ZeƒK gb`_gmey
L_eh\h^bl_ey[uehkjhqgh^hklZ\e_gh\ [eb`Zcrmx[hevgbpmG_kdhevdhqZkh\
ljm^bebkv \jZqb gZ^ aZfhjh`_gguf q_eh\_dhf b h`b\beb _]h Ih fg_gbx \jZq_c
KZclh \gZqZe_ hljZ\beky ]Zahf dhlhjuc \u^_eyeky ijb lZygbb kmoh]h ev^Z Z aZl_f
³aZfhjhabeky´ @bagv rhn_jm kiZkeh lh qlh \ Zlfhkn_j_ aZdjulh]h nmj]hgZ [ueh
ih\ur_ggh_kh^_j`Zgb_m]e_dbkeh]h]ZaZ\u^_ey\r_]hkyijbbkiZj_gbbkmoh]hev^Zb
ihgb`_ggh_ kh^_j`Zgb_ dbkehjh^Z _]h aZiZku jZkoh^h\Zebkv \k_ \j_fy ihdZ rhn_j
^urZe
Wdki_jbf_glu \ h[eZklb djbh[bheh]bb iha\hebeb gZdhg_p j_rblvky gZ
aZfhjZ`b\Zgb_ q_eh\_dZ < ]h^m \kx fbjh\mx ij_kkm h[hreh k_gkZpbhggh_
khh[s_gb_ijhn_kkhj>;w^nhj^baEhk:g^`_e_kZagZyqlhmfbjZ_lhljZdZe_]dbo
kh]eZkbekygZlhqlh[u_]haZfhjhabeb\ `b^dhfZahl_ijbl_fi_jZlmj_[ebadhcd ]jZ^mkZf gb`_ gmey b \ha\jZlbeb d `bagb dh]^Z f_^bpbgZ gZc^_l wnn_dlb\gh_
kj_^kl\h[hjv[uk _]h[he_agvx
: q_j_ag_kdhevdhe_l\ KR:ihy\behkvm`_qbklhdhff_jq_kdh_ ij_^ijbylb_
ohay_\Zdhlhjh]hij_^eZ]Zeb\k_f`_eZxsbflm`_ijhp_^mjmaZfhjZ`b\Zlvb ojZgblv
q_eh\_dZ ih _]h `_eZgbx ^_kyldb beb khlgb e_l Fgh]b_ b fgh]b_ Zf_jbdZgpu
ih`_eZeb ih^\_j]gmlvky ijhp_^mj_ aZfhjZ`b\Zgby b lZdbf h[jZahf hlijZ\blvky \
iml_r_kl\b_\ [m^ms__
H^gZdh \ dhgp_ o ]h^h\ jZajZabeky djmiguc kdZg^Ze ihebpb_c \ h^ghf ba
p_gljh\ aZfhjZ`b\Zgby [ueb h[gZjm`_gu l_eZ ihemlhjZ ^_kyldh\ q_eh\_d \ klZ^bb
]em[hdh]h jZaeh`_gby h q_f gZ^h iheZ]Zlv m]h\hjZ g_ [ueh ijb aZdexq_gbb bfb
dhgljZdlh\gZ[_kkf_jlb_?kl_kl\_ggh^h\_jb_d kZfhcb^__[ueha^hjh\hih^hj\Zgh
Mreb]h^uqlh[u\k_\_jgmehkvgZdjm]bk\hy
< gZklhys__ \j_fy \ Kh_^bg_gguo RlZlZo nmgdpbhgbjmxl q_luj_ p_gljZ
djbh]_g_aZpbb ^\Z \ DZebnhjgbb ih h^ghfm \ Fbqb]Zg_ b Nehjb^_ \ dhlhjuo
ojZgylky \ h[s_c keh`ghklb ³aZfhjh`_gguo´ Zf_jbdZgp_\ Kms_kl\mxl ih^h[gh
p_gljulZd`_\hNjZgpbbb Yihgbb
GZ^haZf_lblvqlhdjbh]_g_aZpby²^_eh\_kvfZ^hjh]hklhys__ihwlhfmi_j\u_
njZgpmah\ j_rb\rbo ijbh[j_klb rZgk gZ [_kkf_jlb_² fbeebhg_ju < KR:
`_eZxsb_^he`guaZieZlblv lukyq^heeZjh\aZaZfhjZ`b\Zgb_l_eZbeb lukyq
²aZaZfhjZ`b\Zgb_lhevdh]heh\u
G_dhlhju_ ijZdlbqgu_ Zf_jbdZgpu ij_^ihqblZxl \lhjhc \ZjbZgl ² b klhbl
^_r_\e_ b e_]q_ ljZgkihjlbjh\Zlv \ kemqZ_ g_ij_^\b^_gguo h[klhyl_evkl\ : _keb
ihlhfdb kfh]ml ³jZafhjhablv´ ]heh\m lh hgb gZ\_jgydZ kmf_xl ih^h[jZlv ^ey
khojZgb\r_]hkyfha]ZZ agZqblb ebqghklbkhhl\_lkl\mxs__l_eh
IjZdlbqgu_ Zf_jbdZgpu h[jZlbeb \gbfZgb_ _s_ gZ h^bg bgl_j_kguc nZdl
HdZau\Z_lky ^ey lh]h qlh[u q_j_a e_l ijhkgmlvky fbeebhg_jhf ^hklZlhqgh
k_]h^gyiheh`blv\ [Zgd^heeZjh\Ljbijhp_glZ]h^h\uoq_j_aklhe_lij_\jZlyl
wlm kmffm \ q_j_a ^\_klb ² \ Z d fhf_glm ij_^iheZ]Z_fh]h
ijh[m`^_gbydZ`^uclZdhch[blZl_evoheh^bevghcdZf_ju kh]eZkgh jZkkq_lZf [m^_l
jZkiheZ]Zlvm`_^heeZjh\
Iml_r_kl\b_ \ [_kkf_jlb_ gZqbgZ_lky \k_]^Z ih djZcg_c f_j_ hnbpbZevgh k
debgbq_kdhc kf_jlb DhfZg^Z ba dhfiZgbb ³LjZgk lZcf´ lml `_ [_j_lky aZ deb_glZ <
i_j\mxhq_j_^vgZ^hh[_ki_qblvbkdmkkl\_ggmxpbjdmeypbxdjh\bijhp_kkhdbke_gby
g_^he`_gij_ju\Zlvky>eywlh]h\\h^ylkyki_pbZevgu_nZjfZdheh]bq_kdb_jZkl\hju
Ihke_ l_eh ihdju\Z_lky ev^hf AZl_f djh\v aZf_gyxl khe_\uf jZkl\hjhf \ dhlhjuc
^h[Z\ey_lky `b^dhklv k \_s_kl\hf ij_^hl\jZsZxsbf ijhp_kk djbklZeebaZpbb \
hj]Zgbaf_HoeZ`^_ggh_l_eh^Ze__aZ\hjZqb\Zxl\ ki_pbZevgh_ihehlghb himkdZxl\
e_^]^_l_fi_jZlmjZ_]hkgb`Z_lky^hfbgmk]jZ^mkh\Bf_ggh\ wlhlfhf_glfh`gh
ijbklmiblv d hl^_e_gbx ]heh\u _keb lZdh\Z [ueZ \hey deb_glZ H[uqgh `_ l_eh
p_ebdhfihf_sZxl\ f_rhdgZih^h[b_kiZevgh]hb ]heh\hc\gbahimkdZxl\ dhgl_cg_j
aZiheg_gguc`b^dbfZahlhf
H^gZdh gZ^h aZf_lblv qlh :f_jbdZgkdh_ h[s_kl\h djbhgbdb gbadbo
l_fi_jZlmj ]ZjZglbjm_l ^hjh]m lhevdh ³lm^Z´ Z \hl ³h[jZlgh´ ² gbdZdbo
hij_^_e_gguo ]ZjZglbc Ijb jZafhjZ`b\Zgbb fh]ml \hagbdgmlv lZdb_ k_jv_agu_
ijh[e_fu dhlhju_ g_ \ khklhygbb ihdZ _s_ j_rblv kh\j_f_ggZy f_^bpbgZ <ky
gZ^_`^Z²gZ^hklb`_gbyf_^bpbgu[m^ms_]h
Dh]^Z\i_j\u_\ bklhjbbaZfhjhabebe_lg_]h>`_cfkZ;_^nhj^Zijhn_kkhjZ
ikboheh]bb ba Ehk:g^`_e_kZ g_dhlhju_ `mjgZebklu hkljbeb ³Gm b m^b\blky `_
;_^nhj^dh]^ZhklZg_lkyihdhcgbdhf´
³GZ^_`^Z gZ lh qlh dh]hlh fh`gh \_jgmlv d `bagb ihke_ aZfhjhadb
jZ\ghkbevgZ klj_fe_gbx ihemqblv dhjh\m ba ]Zf[mj]_jZ² bjhgbabjm_l ih wlhfm
ih\h^m :jlmj Jhm ba Gvxchjdkdh]h mgb\_jkbl_lZ b ^h[Z\ey_l ² Ijb aZfhjhad_
g_ihijZ\bfucms_j[gZghkblkyde_ldZf´
Bgh]h fg_gby ijb^_j`b\Z_lky ^hdlhj :\b [_g :[jZoZf ij_ab^_gl
Zf_jbdZgkdh]hh[s_kl\ZdjbhgbdbaZgbfZxsbckygZmqgufbbkke_^h\Zgbyfb\ h[eZklb
bkihevah\Zgby gbadbo l_fi_jZlmj \ f_^bpbg_ Kf_jlv kqblZ_l hg gZklmiZ_l
ihkl_i_ggh Ohly k_j^p_ b hklZgZ\eb\Z_lky de_ldb ldZgb b \gmlj_ggb_ hj]Zgu
ijh^he`Zxl `blv >jm]hfm mq_ghfm ² djbh[bheh]m I Kb]Zem m`_ m^Z\Zehkv
j_Zgbfbjh\Zlv ohfydh\ ihke_ ^\moqZkh\hc aZfhjhadb M g_]h lZd`_ ihemqbeky
wdki_jbf_gl k _ghlh\b^ghc kh[Zdhc D g_c \_jgmeZkv ghjfZevgZy l_fi_jZlmjZ ihke_
ijhp_^mjdhlhjufih^\_j]Zxlkyijbdjbh]_gbaZpbbl_eZex^_cDklZlbh[Zmq_guoZ
lZd`_b qe_gubok_f_c²dZg^b^ZlugZaZfhjZ`b\Zgb_jZ^b[_kkf_jlby
:g]ebckdbcZgZlhfOZgl_j_s_\ ;9,,,\_d_ibkZe
³?kebq_eh\_dohq_lhl^Zlv^_kylvihke_^gboe_lk\h_c`bagbq_j_^h\ZgbxkgZb
Zdlb\ghklb lh _]h `bagv fh]eZ [u [ulv ijh^e_gZ ^h e_l ijb jZafhjZ`b\Zgbb
dZ`^u_ e_l gZ h^bg ]h^ hg fh] [u \kydbc jZa magZ\Zlv qlh ijhbahreh aZ \j_fy
ihdZhg[ue\ ZgZ[bha_´
LZd qlh \iheg_ fh`_l [ulv qlh g_kdhevdh ^_kyldh\ gZrbo kh\j_f_ggbdh\
aZdexq_gguo\ ijhajZqgu_dZikmeudhlhju_h[l_dZ_l`b^dbcZahlhoeZ`^_gguc^h
ƒKieu\mlih\hegZf\j_f_gb\ [m^ms__gZ\klj_qm[_kkf_jlbx
Kms_kl\mxl b g_dhlhju_ ^jm]b_ gZijZ\e_gby ihbkdh\ [_kkf_jlby < ]h^m
ijhn_kkhj ba =>J W Eb[[_jl hibkZe hiul k Z]Z\hc f_dkbdZgkdhc \ dhlhjhf m^Zehkv
m\_ebqblv \b^h\hc ij_^_e ^ebl_evghklb `bagb \ ^_kylv jZa >ey ]_jhglheh]h\
aZgbfZxsboky ijh[e_fhc klZj_gby wlhl hiul hklZeky g_aZf_q_gguf < ]h^m
ihy\beZkv klZlvy fhkdh\kdh]h mq_gh]h < B =m^hrgbdh\Z \ k[hjgbd_ ljm^h\
Fhkdh\kdh]h h[s_kl\Z bkiulZl_e_c ijbjh^u h[ hiulZo gZ djukZo dhlhjuf m^Zehkv
hklZgh\blv jZa\blb_ \ ^bgZfbd_ f_`^m , b ,, klZ^byfb debfZdl_jbq_kdh]h i_jbh^Z b
m^_j`b\Zlvhj]Zgbaff_`^mgbfb\ l_q_gb_^g_c
< j_amevlZl_ ZgZebaZ wlbo ^\mo hiulh\ b kh[kl\_gguo wdki_jbf_glh\ qe_gm
dhjj_kihg^_glmFhkdh\kdh]hh[s_kl\ZbkiulZl_e_cijbjh^uGbdheZxBkZ_\mm^Zehkv
kha^Zlvkh[kl\_ggmxl_hjbxm\_ebq_gby\b^h\hcijh^he`bl_evghklb`bagb
Kmlvl_hjbb\ ke_^mxs_fqlh[uijh^eblv`bagvex[hfmhj]Zgbafm\ ^_kylvjZa
b [he__ ^hklZlhqgh \ ex[hf f_kl_ ijh]jZffu hglh]_g_aZ l _ ]_g_lbq_kdb
hij_^_e_gghc ko_fu jZa\blby ^Zggh]h hj]ZgbafZ \ ijhp_kk_ __ j_ZebaZpbb k^_eZlv b
ih^^_j`b\Zlv ³aZbdZgb_´ Fu klZj__f ihlhfm qlh \ hj]Zgbaf_ ih^^_j`b\Z_lky
hij_^_e_gguc mjh\_gv dexq_\uo f_lZ[heblh\ ijh^mdlh\ `bag_^_yl_evghklb
hj]ZgbafZ k Zdlb\ghklvx g_ ^himkdZxs_c ³aZbdZgby´ \ ijhp_kk_ j_ZebaZpbb
ijh]jZffu hglh]_g_aZ DZd lhevdh mjh\_gv dexq_\uo f_lZ[heblh\ ihgb`Z_lky
gZijbf_j\ hiul_k Z]Z\hcm^Zeyebijh^mdlu\ujZ[Zlu\Z_fu_]_g_lb\ghckbkl_fhc
lZd hj]Zgbaf [_a aZf_^e_gby i_j_oh^bl gZ ij_^u^msbc [he__ fheh^hc wlZi k\h_c
`bagbK wlh]hij_^u^ms_]hwlZiZkgh\ZgZqbgZ_lkyihkljh_gb_ijh^mdlh\b kljmdlmj
]_g_jZlb\gh]hwlZiZ`bagbKgh\Zm^Ze_gb_ijh^mdlh\b lZdgZijhly`_gbbe_l<
j_amevlZl_Z]Z\_m\_ebqbeb\b^h\mxijh^he`bl_evghklv`bagbk ^he_llh_klv\
^_kylvjZaWlhlhiulfh`gh [ueh [u ijh^he`Zlv ^h [_kdhg_qghklb lZd dZd klZj_gby
dZd lZdh\h]h g_l ihlhfm qlh hj]Zgbaf gZoh^blky \ mkeh\byo dh]^Z hlkmlkl\m_l
fZl_jbZevgZy hkgh\Z klZj_gby ² dexq_\u_ f_lZ[heblu g_ ih^^_j`b\Zxlky lml gZ
aZ^Zgghfijbjh^hcmjh\g_
GZ k_]h^gyrgbc ^_gv G G BkZ_\uf ijZdlbq_kdb jZajZ[hlZgu b \hiehs_gu \
`bagv jZaebqgu_ \ZjbZglu ³aZpbdeb\Zgby´ g_dhlhjuo jZkl_gbc ² dZjlhn_ey de_gZ
iha\heyxsb_ ^hklb]gmlv \b^h\h]h ³[_kkf_jlby´ < i_jki_dlb\_ ² jZ[hlZ gZ^
^hklb`_gb_f\b^h\h]h[_kkf_jlbyq_eh\_dZKmlv__ \hklZgh\d_klZj_gbym q_eh\_dZ\
ex[hf \hajZkl_ gZijbf_j f_`^m b ]h^Zfb K wlh]h fhf_glZ ^Zgguc hj]Zgbaf
[m^_lijhoh^blvkdhevm]h^gh^he]hhlj_ahdk\h_c`bagb\gmljbmdZaZggh]hbgl_j\ZeZ
LZdbf h[jZahf kha^Zgu l_hj_lbq_kdb_ ij_^ihkuedb ^hklb`_gby \b^h\h]h
[_kkf_jlby q_eh\_dZ >jm]h_ ^_eh qlh imlv hl m^Zqguo hiulh\ gZ jZkl_gbyo ^h
ijZdlbq_kdh]h \hiehs_gby ^Zgghc l_hjbb gZ q_eh\_d_ fh`_l [ulv hq_gv b hq_gv
^he]bf
M ijh[e_fu [_kkf_jlby q_eh\_dZ _klv ^\Z hkgh\guo Zki_dlZ gZmqgh
[bheh]bq_kdbc b nbehkhnkdhgjZ\kl\_gguc < [bheh]bq_kdhf kfuke_ dZd fu lhevdh
qlh\b^_eb\iheg_\hafh`ghjZghbebiha^ghk ijh]j_kkhfgZmdb^h[blvkydZdboeb[h
ijZdlbq_kdboj_amevlZlh\ih^hklb`_gbxebqgh]h[_kkf_jlby>jm]h_^_ehZ gm`gheb
gZfljZlblvkbeub gZmqgucihl_gpbZe^eyj_r_gbywlboaZ^Zq"
GZ i_j\uc \a]ey^ \hijhk wlhl fh`_l ihdZaZlvky iZjZ^hdkZevguf ohly gbq_]h
iZjZ^hdkZevgh]h \ g_f g_l >Z\Zcl_ aZ^mfZ_fky Z ]hlh\h eb q_eh\_q_kl\h d
^hklb`_gbx[_kkf_jlby"
IhiulZ_fky jZkkfhlj_lv wlhl \hijhk k jZaebqguo klhjhg ij_`^_ \k_]h ² k
^_fh]jZnbq_kdhc Ih jZkq_lZf njZgpmakdbo ^_fh]jZnh\ \ ]h^m jh^beky fbeebZj^guc k gZqZeZjh^Zq_eh\_q_kdh]h`bl_evgZr_cieZg_lu dhg_qgh wlZ pbnjZ
\_kvfZmkeh\gZ;m^_lebij_^_ejhklmq_eh\_q_kl\Zb gZdZdhfmjh\g_mklZgh\blky_]h
ieZgdZ\ ij_^klhysb_^_kylbe_lbyb \_dZ"
I_j\u_ ex^b dhlhjuo \_jhylgh [ueh \k_]h g_kdhevdh ^_kyldh\ lukyq
[em`^Zeb ih a_fe_ \ ihbkdZo ibsb [m^mqb aZ\bkbfufb hl kf_gu \j_f_g ]h^Z hl
debfZlbq_kdbo baf_g_gbc I_j\u_ l_ogbq_kdb_ ih[_^u hk\h_gb_ h]gy ih\e_deb aZ
kh[hcm\_ebq_gb_gZk_e_gbydhlhjh_e_lgZaZ^ijb[ebabehkvd pbnj_\ q_eh\_d
D ]h^m ^h g w \k_ dhglbg_glu \dexqZy :f_jbdm b :\kljZebx [ueb
gZk_e_gub dhebq_kl\hex^_cgZa_fghfrZj_^hklb]ehiylbfbeebhgh\q_eh\_d
D gZqZem,9lukyq_e_lby^hgw\k_gZk_e_gb_a_febbkqbkeyehkvijbf_jgh
fbeebhgh\ q_eh\_d < oh^_ ³\_dZ I_jbdeZ´ 9 \ ^h g w q_eh\_q_kl\h i_j_rZ]gmeh
q_j_akhlgxfbeebhgh\D wiho_DZjeZ<_ebdh]hdhebq_kl\hgZk_e_gby\ fbj_\ujhkeh
^hfbeebhgh\Z \wihom<hajh`^_gby²^hfbeebhgh\q_eh\_d
< ;9,,, \_d_ gZk_e_gb_ A_feb ^hklb]eh h^gh]h fbeebZj^Z < ]h^m hgh
khklZ\eyeh fbeebZj^Z \ ² fbeebZj^Z q_eh\_d < gZqZe_ ]h^Z
gZk_e_gb_ a_fgh]h rZjZ ^hklb]eh fbeebZj^h\ Z \ ]h^m q_eh\_q_kl\h
i_j_rZ]gmeh aZ iyluc fbeebZj^ DZdh\Z `_ [m^_l km^v[Z q_eh\_q_kl\Z \ [eb`Zcr_f
[m^ms_f"
>_fh]jZnuiulZxlky^Zlvijh]ghauHnbpbZevgucijh]ghaijbgylki_pbZevguf
Hl^_ehf gZjh^hgZk_e_gby ijb HHG Wlh gZb[he__ hilbfbklbq_kdZy ]bihl_aZ lZd dZd
hgZ ij_^iheZ]Z_l qlh \k_ kljZgu kdhjh ijb^ml d mjh\gx ieh^h\blhklb
h[_ki_qb\Zxs_fmebrvh[gh\e_gb_ihdhe_gbc[_ajhklZqbke_gghklb²j_[_gdZgZ
`_gsbgm ?keb fh`gh ij_^iheh`blv qlh jZa\b\Zxsb_ky kljZgu ]^_ jh`^Z_fhklv
ihkl_i_ggh kgb`Z_lky ^_ckl\bl_evgh ijb^ml d wlhfm mjh\gx \ [m^ms_f \_d_ lh \
ijhfure_gghjZa\bluokljZgZo^_ehh[klhblih^jm]hfmJh`^Z_fhklv\ gbom`_miZeZ
gb`_ wlh]h ihjh]Z b bf__l l_g^_gpbx iZ^Zlv ^Zevr_ HklZ_lky gZ^_ylvky qlh
mf_gvr_gb_ gZk_e_gby gZqg_l ihgZklhys_fm hsmsZlvky \ wlbo kljZgZo ebrv ihke_
]h^Z b wdki_jlu HHG kqblZxl qlh lh]^Z ba ]jZ`^Zgkdbo ih[m`^_gbc fgh]b_
kmijm`_kdb_iZjuj_rZlbf_lv[hevr_^_l_cbebh[_kihdh_ggu_ijZ\bl_evkl\Zijbfml
khhl\_lkl\mxsb_f_juklbfmebjmxsb_jh`^Z_fhklv?keb^_eZihc^mlbf_gghlZdlh
fbjh\h_ gZjh^hgZk_e_gb_ klZ[bebabjm_lky d ]h^m b [m^_l khklZ\eylv hdheh fbeebZj^h\q_eh\_d
Kms_kl\_ggh_m\_ebq_gb_ ijh^he`bl_evghklb `bagb h dhlhjhf fu ]h\hjbeb \
ij_^u^ms_c ]eZ\_ fh`_l kbevgh baf_gblv wlhl kp_gZjbc HHG < j_amevlZl_ wlh]h
gZk_e_gb_ijhfure_gghjZa\bluokljZggZqZeh[umf_gvrZlvkylhevdhd ]h^mZ
j_Zdpby kmijm`_kdbo iZj gZ iZ^_gb_ jh`^Z_fhklb ijhy\beZkv [u iha`_ ?\jhi_ckdh_
gZk_e_gb_ijbwlbomkeh\byoklZ[bebabjm_lkyd ]h^mgZmjh\g_]h^ZZ \fbj_
[m^_l gZ[ex^Zlvky agZqbl_evgZy ^bkijhihjpby f_`^m gZk_e_gb_f :abb :njbdb
EZlbgkdhc:f_jbdbb ?\jhiu
?keb jh`^Z_fhklv \ jZa\bluo kljZgZo [m^_l ijh^he`Zlv kgb`Zlvky ^hklb]Zy
ih\kx^m kh\j_f_ggh]h mjh\gy NJ= _keb hgZ \ jZa\b\Zxsboky kljZgZo \ dhlhjuo
ij_djZlblky^_fh]jZnbq_kdbc\aju\b _kebijh^he`bl_evghklv`bagbh]jZgbqblky
x ]h^Zfb q_eh\_q_kl\h d ]h^m bkq_ag_l Bkke_^h\Z\rbc wlhl \ZjbZgl jZa\blby
q_eh\_q_kl\Z njZgpmakdbc ^_fh]jZn ;mj`mZIblh kqblZ_l qlh fbjh\h_
gZjh^hgZk_e_gb_ ^hklb]g_l k\h_]h ibdZ \ fbeebZj^Z q_eh\_d \ ]h^m Z ihlhf
ihkl_i_gghbkq_ag_l
H^gZdh \hafh`_g b ^jm]hc oh^ l_q_gby kh[ulbc mf_gvr_gb_ gZk_e_gby
jZa\bluokljZg\uah\_lijblhdgZk_e_gbybakljZg[hevrh]h^_fh]jZnbq_kdh]h\aju\Z
GZjh^u gZoh^ysb_ky \ g_[eZ]hijbylguo mkeh\byo gh gZ ih^t_f_ jhklZ gZk_e_gby
fh]ml ijbk\hblv k_[_ ^h[jhf beb kbehc a_feb b j_kmjku gZjh^h\ [h]Zluo gh
gZoh^ysboky gZ kiZ^_ Wlb ihke_^gb_ [m^ml ihkl_i_ggh kf_rb\Zlvky k ijbr_evpZfb
ihdZ g_ ihl_jyxl k\hx bg^b\b^mZevghklv Hgb bkq_agml dZd bkq_aeb m`_ fgh]b_
gZjh^uihiZ\\ ih^h[gmxkblmZpbx
DZdh_ `_ \ebygb_ gZ baf_g_gb_ ^_fh]jZnbq_kdhc dZjlbgu fh`_l hdZaZlv
^hklb`_gb_ gZmdhc [_kkf_jlby" KZfh_ g_ij_^kdZam_fh_ Mqblu\Zy qlh \hijhk h
\ebygbb [_kkf_jlby gZ dhebq_kl\h gZk_e_gby gbdh]^Z _s_ k_jv_agh g_ klZ\beky gZ
ih\_kldm^gydZdboeb[hgZmqguojZkq_lh\b ijh]ghah\hlukdZlvg_m^Zehkv
Gh dZd fu \b^_eb ^hklb`_gb_ ebqgh]h [_kkf_jlby \iheg_ \hafh`gh m`_ \
i_j\u_klhe_lby[m^ms_]hlukyq_e_lbyB wlhlihdZ_s_g_mqblu\Z_fucnZdlfh`_l
\g_klb kms_kl\_ggmx dhjj_dpbx \ h[km`^Z\rb_ky gZfb ijh]ghau ^_fh]jZnh\ B \
i_j\mx hq_j_^v hg hdZ`_l \ebygb_ g_ gZ h[smx qbke_gghklv gZk_e_gby ohly kh
\j_f_g_fb gZg__lh`_Z gZkhhlghr_gb_gZk_e_gbyjZa\bluob jZa\b\ZxsbokykljZg
<_^v g_ k_dj_l qlh ^hklb`_gbyfb gZmdb \ i_j\mx hq_j_^v \hkihevam_lky gZk_e_gb_
jZa\bluo dZiblZebklbq_kdbo kljZg Fh`gh [ueh [u ihjZkkm`^Zlv h \hafh`guo imlyo
baf_g_gby ^_fh]jZnbq_kdhc kblmZpbb \ mkeh\byo ^hklb`_gby \b^h\h]h [_kkf_jlby
q_eh\_dZghwlh[ueh[ubaebrgbflZddZdfu_s_g_j_rbeb\hijhk²Z gm`gheb
ebqgh_[_kkf_jlb_b klhbleb_]h^h[b\Zlvky
<_jhylg__ \k_]h [_kkf_jlb_ ex^_c g_\_jhylgh fmqbl_evgh b iZ]m[gh kdZ`_lky
gZ`bagbh[s_kl\ZIjh]j_kkkhklhbl\ kf_g_ihdhe_gbcdZ`^h_ihdhe_gb_ijbghkbl\
h[s_kl\h qlhlh gh\h_ Ih^h[gZy fukev \ukdZaZgZ b \ ke_^mxsbo klboZ Jh[_jlZ
Jh`^_kl\_gkdh]h
?keb[ lhevdhex^b`beb\_qgh
Wlh[ueh[u[_kq_eh\_qgh
DZdmagZlvq_]hlu\ `bagbklhbrv"
DZdihgylvqlhlZdh_jbkd"
< fhj_[jhkblvky"
LZdg_mlhg_rv
GZdhkl_j\ahclb"
LZdg_k]hjbrvIhe_jZkiZoZlv"
Ihlhfmki_x
Ihjho\u^mfZlv"
: ^eyq_]h"
GZkeZ`^Zebkv[ue_gb\hcki_kvx
Ie_ggbdb[_kkf_jlvyk\h_]h
Gbq_]hhgb[ug_k\_jrbeb
Gbdh]^Z[ g_\ue_aebbalvfu
Fh`_lkZfuc]eZ\gucklbfme`bagb
< ]hjvdhcbklbg_
Qlhkf_jlgufu
Hiul bklhjbb ihdZau\Z_l qlh ijh]j_kk gZmdb \k_]^Z h[]hgye gjZ\kl\_ggh_
jZa\blb_ q_eh\_q_kl\Z G_ bkdexq_gb_f y\ey_lky b \hijhk h [_kkf_jlbb <iheg_
\hafh`gh b ^Z`_ hq_gv \_jhylgh qlh k [bheh]bq_kdhc lhqdb aj_gby aZ]Z^dm
[_kkf_jlby m^Zklky jZa]Z^Zlv mq_guf m`_ \ [eb`Zcrb_ klhe_lby Gh dZdh\h `_ [m^_l
gjZ\kl\_ggh_ ebph ihdhe_gby dhlhjhfm ijb^_lky ih^Zjblv [_kkf_jlb_" G_m`_eb
bkq_agmlgZkbevgbdbm[bcpu\hju"<_jhylg__\k_]h²g_l^mfZlvbgZq_²[ueh[u
khpbZevghc mlhib_c LZd g_m`_eb ^hklhbg [_kkf_jlby lhl dlh hlgye `bagv k_[_
ih^h[gh]h"B g_dZeZf[mjhfeba\mqbllh]^ZkZfhihgylb_³ih`bag_ggh_aZdexq_gb_"´
GhkljZrg__\k_]h²wlh^Zjh\Zlvdhfmeb[hijZ\hj_rZlv^hklhbgeb^Zggucq_eh\_d
`blv \_qgh beb g_l Wlh g_fbgm_fh ijb\_^_l d aehmihlj_[e_gbyf ]jmiih\uf
deZkkh\ufiZjlbcgufgZpbhgZevgufjZkh\ufih^oh^ZfZ hlkx^Zebrvh^bgrZ]^h
lhcbebbghcjZagh\b^ghklbnZrbafZ
BlZd\hijhk[_kkf_jlby²wlhijh[gucdZf_gvdhlhjucfh`_lhdZaZlvkyg_ih^
kbemkh\j_f_gghfmq_eh\_q_kl\m
Gh ihijh[m_f i_j_\_klb \hijhk h [_kkf_jlbb g_kdhevdh \ bgmx iehkdhklv
Ij_^iheh`bf \k_ hdhgqZl_evgh m[_^bebkv qlh ebqgh_ [_kkf_jlb_ \k_]h q_eh\_q_kl\Z
y\ey_lky lhjfhahf d _]h ijh]j_kkm dZd gZmqghfm khpbZevghfm lZd b we_f_glZjghfm
[bheh]bq_kdhfm Gh \_^v _klv `_ hl^_evgu_ ebqghklb [_amkeh\gh aZkem`b\Zxsb_
[_kkf_jlby ² \u^Zxsb_ky mq_gu_ om^h`gbdb bah[j_lZl_eb ihwlu fukebl_eb
nbehkhnu : ihkdhevdm gZmdZ m`_ \ khklhygbb ^Zjh\Zlv [_kkf_jlb_ lZd ^Z\Zcl_ `_
ij_^hklZ\bf _]h lhevdh hl^_evguf ebqghklyf kljh]h h]jZgbq_gghfm qbkem
\u^Zxsbokyex^_c
Y g_ ohqm gZ\yau\Zlv dhfmeb[h k\h_]h fg_gby Imklv dZ`^uc ihijh[m_l kZf
hij_^_eblv gZb[he__ \_jhylguc djm] wlbo ex^_c bkoh^y ba ij_^ihql_gbc ohly [u
ihke_^gbo iylbk_fb ^_kylbe_lbc Ih^mfZeb" <u ohl_eb [u qlh[u g_ lhevdh \
ehamg]Zo gh b \ `bagb ³`b\__ \k_o `b\uo´ [ueb [u wlb ebqghklb" GZrb fg_gby h
aZkem]Zo lh]h beb bgh]h ^_yl_ey fh]ml f_gylvky \ aZ\bkbfhklb hl iheblbq_kdhc
h[klZgh\db: \hl^Zjh\Z\_fm[_kkf_jlb_fufh`_fihemqblvg_ijhklhih`bag_ggh]h
^bdlZlhjZ Z qlh ]hjZa^h kljZrg__ b ^Z`_ ljm^gh \hh[jZablv ² ^bdlZlhjZ
[_kkf_jlgh]h
Qlh[ug_]h\hjbebnbehkhnuh jhebebqghklb\ bklhjbbghwihoZklZebgbafZ
dhgqbeZkv bf_ggh kh kf_jlvx KlZebgZ B h^bg ;h] \_^Z_l kdhevdh [u _s_ gZf
ijbrehkvh`b^Zlv³h[t_dlb\guoij_^ihkuehd´^eybaf_g_gbyoh^Zbklhjbbijb\_qgh
`b\hflh\Zjbs_KlZebg_
Ihwlhfm fg_ dZ`_lky qlh g_ klhbl ki_rblv j_rZlv g_f_^e_ggh ijh[e_fm
ebqgh]h[_kkf_jlbyFulZdb_dZdfu_klv_s_g_]hlh\u`blv\_qghFu^eywlh]h
_s_ hdhgqZl_evgh g_ khaj_eb b ^mfZ_lky g_ kmf__f _s_ \iheg_ hkhagZggh
jZkihjy^blvky\_qghklvx
EBL?J:LMJ:
RZ]d [_kkf_jlbx"³GLLF²Mf_e_p´‹ XZgvDw Fbnu>j_\g_]hDblZyF³GZmdZ´
J_^_j>= Fbnub e_]_g^u^j_\g_]h>\mj_qvyF
=mfbe_\ E G GbdZdhc fbklbdb ³Xghklv´ ‹ GZk [ueh fbeebZj^h\ :
kdhevdh[m^_l"³GZmdZb `bagv´‹ =hj[h\kdbc::K_f_gh\XK AZdjulu_kljZgbpubklhjbbFFukev
Ijhdhnv_\< aZfhjh`_gguoZf_jbdZgp_\³Ljm^´ghy[jy
F_a_gp_\ < : Qm^_kZ IhimeyjgZy wgpbdehi_^by :efZ:lZ =e j_^ DZakh\
wgpbdehi_^bbldgb]Z
=E:<:;;,,
I_j_k_e_gb_^mr
M`_ gZ jZaguo wlZiZo jZa\blby q_eh\_q_kdh]h h[s_kl\Z h^gh\j_f_ggh k
\hagbdgh\_gb_f kZfuo i_j\uo ih]j_[Zevguo jblmZeh\ h dhlhjuo fu jZkkdZau\Zeb \
]eZ\_;gZqbgZxl\hagbdZlvij_^klZ\e_gbyh kms_kl\h\Zgbb^mrbihke_kf_jlb
Ij_^klZ\e_gby wlb ihgZqZem [ueb qj_a\uqZcgh kfmlgu_ Hkh[h]h fbjZ ^mr
³aZ]jh[gh]hfbjZ´dZdijZ\behg_kms_kl\h\ZehIj_h[eZ^Zeh\b^bfhij_^klZ\e_gb_
qlh^mrbmf_jrbo\blZxl]^_lh\[ebabf_klZih]j_[_gbybebf_klZ]^_ijhl_dZeZbo
a_fgZy`bagvIhwlhfmm fgh]boie_f_g^hkboihjkhojZgbebkvh[uqZbihdb^Zlv^hf
ob`bgma_feygdm]^_ijh`b\Ze mf_jrbc kqblZy qlh ^mrZ _]h ijh^he`Z_l h[blZlv \
wlhf`bebs_KeZ[u_i_j_`bldbwlboi_j\h[ulguoij_^klZ\e_gbci_j_oh^ylbgh]^Zb
\ gh\_crmx pb\bebaZpbx bgh]^Z ^hf ihk_sZ_fuc ijbajZdZfb hklZ\ey_lky gZ
jZajmr_gb_ [m^mqb ij_^hklZ\e_g ijbajZqghfm `bevpm K\b^_l_evkl\h wlhfm fh`gh
gZclb\ fgh]hqbke_gguokdZadZoe_]_g^Zoij_^ZgbyogZjh^h\?\jhiu
I_j\h[ulgu_ `_ ij_^klZ\e_gby h lhf qlh ^mob mf_jrbo ^_j`Zlky ]^_lh
ih[ebahklbhlk\hboih]j_[_gguol_eijhc^yq_j_alukyq_e_lbykZfuojZaghh[jZaguo
j_eb]bc b \_jh\Zgbc ^h kbo ihj klhcdh ^_j`blky \ gZr_f ih^khagZgbb Bf_ggh wlb
[jh^ysb_ ^mob mf_jrbo ^_eZxl ba deZ^[bsZ \ iheghqv f_klh ]^_ dhq_g__l hl m`ZkZ
kh\j_f_gguc q_eh\_d [m^v lh m[_`^_gguc Zl_bkl beb ojbklbZgbg l\_j^h \_jmxsbc
qlh^mrZihke_kf_jlbhlijZ\ey_lky\ ³pZjkl\hg_[_kgh_´Z g_[em`^Z_l\[ebabk\hbo
[j_gguohklZgdh\
Ihkl_i_ggh ij_^klZ\e_gby h ihkf_jlghf kms_kl\h\Zgbb klZgh\ylky [he__
hnhjfe_ggufb b kbkl_fZlbabjh\Zggufb <_jh\Zgb_ \ [m^msmx `bagv jZkiZ^Z_lky gZ
^\Z]eZ\guogZijZ\e_gbyh[ZbadhlhjuoijbgZ^e_`Zld kZfhchl^Ze_gghc^j_\ghklbb
bf_xl]em[hdb_dhjgb\ kZfuogbadbokehyoq_eh\_q_kdhcdmevlmjuH[Zwlbomq_gby
l_kgh k\yaZggu_ f_`^m kh[hc b ^Z`_ i_j_oh^ysb_ ^jm] \ ^jm]Z h^bgZdh\h
jZkijhkljZg_guih\k_fmfbjmb ^Z`_i_j_reb\ kh\j_f_ggh_gZf h[s_kl\h H^gh ba
^Zgguo gZijZ\e_gbc ² wlh mq_gb_ h i_j_k_e_gbb ^mr Z ^jm]h_ ² mq_gb_ h
kZfhklhyl_evghfkms_kl\h\Zgbbebqghc^mrbihke_kf_jlbl_eZ
Bklhdb b^_b j_bgdZjgZpbb l _ \_ju \ lh qlh ^mrZ ihdhcgbdZ \gh\v
\hiehsZ_lky \ `b\hlgh_ jZkl_gb_ beb gh\h_ q_eh\_q_kdh_ l_eh ke_^m_l bkdZlv m`_ m
i_j\h[ulguo ie_f_g GZb[he__ jZkijhkljZg_gguf y\eyehkv ih\_jv_ h lhf qlh ^mrZ
mf_jr_]h q_eh\_dZ h`b\ey_l kh[hc j_[_gdZ K_\_jhZf_jbdZgkdb_ bg^_cpu ohjhgbeb
mf_jrbo^_l_c\hae_^hjh]bqlh[ubo^mrbfh]ebi_j_clb\ ijhoh^ysbofbfhfZl_j_c
b lZdbf h[jZahf jh^blvky \gh\v < K_\_jhAZiZ^ghc :f_jbd_ m bg^_cp_\ lZdmeeb
e_dZjv³i_j_ghkbe´^mrmhlmf_jr_]h\haeh`b\jmdbgZ_]h]jm^vZ aZl_fijhklbjZybo
gZ^ ]heh\hc jh^kl\_ggbdZ b ^my q_j_a gbo I_j\uc j_[_ghd jh`^Zxsbcky m wlh]h
ij__fgbdZ hle_l_\r_c ^mrb ihemqZe bfy b h[s_kl\_ggh_ iheh`_gb_ ihdhcgbdZ GZ
hkljh\_ <Zgdm\_j \ ]h^m h^bg xghrZ ihevah\Zeky [hevrbf ihq_lhf m bg^_cp_\
ihlhfm qlh bf_e gZ [_^j_ agZd ih^h[guc rjZfm hl h]g_klj_evghc jZgu Hlkx^Z
aZdexqbeb qlh dZdhclh \h`^v mf_jrbc q_luj_ ihdhe_gby lhfm gZaZ^ b ihemqb\rbc
lZdmxjZgm\_jgmeky\ kj_^mk\hbo
I_j\h[ulgu_ ie_f_gZ h[uqgh kqblZeb qlh ^mrZ mf_jr_]h ij_^dZ h`b\ey_l
j_[_gdZ b qlh \ wlhf ijbqbgZ _]h koh^kl\Z k hlphf beb fZl_jvx Ie_f_gZ chjm[Z
Gb]_jbyijb\_lkl\mygh\hjh`^_ggh_^blykeh\Zfb³Lu\_jgmeky´bsmldZdb_gb[m^v
ijbf_luqlh[umagZlv^mrZdhlhjh]hbaij_^dh\\_jgmeZkv\ _]hh[jZa_
<_jh\Zgb_ \ \hajh`^_gb_ hlhr_^r_c ^mrb \ ^jm]hf q_eh\_q_kdhf h[jZa_
ih[m`^Zeh aZiZ^ghZnjbdZgkdbo g_]jh\ gZoh^b\rboky \ jZ[kl\_ \^Zeb hl jh^bgu d
kZfhm[bckl\m\ gZ^_`^_\hkdj_kgmlv\gh\vgZjh^bg_
H^ghcbanhjfwlh]hmq_gbyy\ey_lkyl_hjbyl_fghdh`boie_f_gh ihy\e_gbbgZ
a_fe_ [_euo ;m^mqb ihjZ`_gu bo [e_^gufb ebpZfb b ihqlb k\_jot_kl_kl\_gguf
fh]ms_kl\hfwlbie_f_gZj_rbebqlh^mrbboihdhcgbdh\\_jgmebkvgZa_fex\ wlhc
kljZgghcnhjf_:\kljZebckdbclma_f_pih\_r_gguc[_eufb\ F_ev[mjg_\ujZabe\
ihke_^gb_fbgmlum[_`^_gb_qlhhg\_jg_lkygZa_fex[_eufq_eh\_dhfb [m^_lbf_lv
fgh`_kl\hr_klbi_gkh\uofhg_l
I_j\ufba[_euoijbgyluoaZh`b\r_]hihdhcgbdZ[ueMbevyf;zdeb[_]euc
kkuevgucfgh]he_lijh`b\rbckj_^bZ[hjb]_gh\:\kljZebbIhke_^gb_gZreb\ g_f
dZdh_lhkoh^kl\hk h^gbfbag_^Z\ghmf_jrbokhie_f_ggbdh\b j_rbebqlhwlhhgb
_klvZ aZl_fwlZb^_yjZkijhkljZgbeZkvb gZ^jm]bo[_euo
LZddZdi_j\h[ulgu_ie_f_gZg_ijh\h^bebhij_^_e_gghcq_jluf_`^m^mrZfb
ex^_c b `b\hlguo lh [_a aZljm^g_gby ^himkdZeky i_j_oh^ q_eh\_q_kdbo ^mr \ l_eZ
gbarbo `b\hlguo Ba\_klguc Zg]ebckdbc wlgh]jZn ;,; \_dZ W^mZj^ ;_jg_ll LZcehj
²hklZ\bek\b^_l_evkl\hqlhbg^_ckdb_ie_f_gZK_\_jhAZiZ^ghc:f_jbdb
\_jbebqlh^mrbmf_jrboi_j_oh^yl\ f_^\_^_cIml_r_kl\_ggbdbkeurZebdZdh^gh
ie_fy mfheyeh ihsZ^blv `bagv klZjhc k_^hc f_^\_^bpu kh kfhjs_gghc fhj^hc
ihlhfm qlh \b^_eh \ ihke_^g_c \hkijb_fgbpm ^mrb dZdhclh ijZ[Z[mrdb bf_\r_c
koh^kl\h k wlbf `b\hlguf M wkdbfhkh\ wlgh]jZn \b^_e \^h\m dhlhjZy iblZeZkv
bkdexqbl_evghilbpZfbb g_ohl_eZ^hljhgmlvky^hfhj`h\h]hfykZihlhfmqlhdhe^mg
m\_jbe__qlh^mrZ__ ihdhcgh]hfm`Zi_j_k_ebeZkv\ fhj`Z
< F_dkbd_leZkdZeZguiheZ]Zebqlhihke_kf_jlb^mrb[eZ]hjh^guo[m^ml`blv
\ \_ebdhe_iguoi_\qboilbpZolh]^ZdZd^mrbie_[__\i_j_c^ml\ eZkhd`mdh\b lhfm
ih^h[gu_ kms_kl\Z < :njbd_ ie_fy fZjZ\b \_jbeh qlh ^mrb aeuo ij_\jZsZxlky \
rZdZeh\Z ^mrb^h[juo²\ af_c
< fbnZo jZaguo gZjh^h\ fbjZ ij_\jZs_gb_ \ dZf_gv kqblZehkv ly`_e_crbf
gZdZaZgb_flZddZd\ wlhfkemqZ_^mrZhklZ\ZeZkvlZfgZ\k_]^Z< nhevdehj_ih^h[gZy
f_lZfhjnhaZg_bf__lijbgpbibZevgh]hhlebqbyhlijhqbo\hiehs_gbc ^mrbKf_jlv
hdZau\Z_lkya^_kvij_h^he_gghck ihfhsvx\her_[gh]hkj_^kl\Zbeb³`b\hc\h^u´
GZ [he__ \ukhdbo klmi_gyo dmevlmju mq_gb_ h \lhjbqghf \hiehs_gbb ^mr
\uklmiZeh m`_ \ k\h_f iheghf b fgh]hklhjhgg_f jZa\blbb B^_y ³i_j_k_e_gby ^mr´
f_l_fikbohau \hreZ dZd ba\_klgh \ g_dhlhju_ keh`gu_ j_eb]bhaghnbehkhnkdb_
kbkl_fuhkh[_ggh\ Bg^bb]^_hgZkhklZ\beZh^bgbahkgh\guo^h]fZlh\[jZofZgbafZ
bg^mbafZ b e_]eZ \ hkgh\m [m^^bklkdh]h mq_gby LZ `_ b^_y [ueZ mk\h_gZ \ Zglbqghf
fbj_ ibnZ]hj_cpZfb iha`_ fZgbo_yfb HgZ khojZgbeZkv \ g_dhlhjuo fmkmevfZgkdbo
k_dlZohkh[_gghm bkfZbeblh\
Kh]eZkghnbehkhnbbbg^mkh\ihke_^h\Zl_evgu_jh`^_gby^he`gug_klbgZk_[_
\ebygb_ j_amevlZlh\ ijhr_^r_c `bagb b kem`blv ih^]hlh\dhc d ihke_^mxs_c
=j_rgu_^mrbijhoh^ylq_j_ajZaebqgu_l_eZb fbj\ dhlhjhfhgbg_kmlaZkem`_ggmx
dZjmaZk\hb]j_ob\h\j_fyij_`gbokms_kl\h\Zgbbij_^klZ\ey_lkh[hcdhehkkZevgh_
qbklbebs_ b kZfZ `bagv ² g_ qlh bgh_ dZd ^he]bc b ljm^guc imlv jZa\blby aeZ \
^h[jh >mrb h[eZ^Zxsb_ ^h[jufb dZq_kl\Zfb ijbh[j_lZxl [h`_kl\_ggmx ijbjh^m
lh]^Z dZd ^mrb dhlhju_ mijZ\eyxlky lhevdh k\hbfb kljZklyfb ijbgbfZxl \gh\v
q_eh\_q_kdbc h[jZa b gZdhg_p ^mrb ih]jm`_ggu_ \h fjZd aeZ ihgb`Zxlky ^h
kl_i_gb `b\hlguo Jy^ i_j_k_e_gbc ^mrb b^_l \ gbkoh^ys_f ihjy^d_ hl [h]h\ b
k\yluo q_j_a jy^u \ukrbo Zkd_lh\ [jZofZgh\ gbfn pZj_c b fbgbkljh\ d Zdl_jZf
ivygbpZf ilbpZf fhr_ggbdZf kehgZf ehrZ^yf \Zj\ZjZf ^bdbf a\_jyf af_yf
q_j\yfgZk_dhfufb g_h^mr_\e_ggufij_^f_lZf
Ohlyhlghr_gb_f_`^mij_klmie_gb_f\ h^ghc`bagbb gZdZaZgb_f\ ^jm]hcih
[hevr_c qZklb l_fgh \ dh^_dk_ bkdmibl_evgh]h kljZgkl\h\Zgby ^mr fh`gh h^gZdh
mkfhlj_lv klj_fe_gb_ d khhl\_lkl\bx f_`^m ]j_ohf b \haf_a^b_f Z lZd`_ gZf_j_gb_
gZdZaZlv ]j_rgbdZ _]h `_ kh[kl\_gguf ]j_ohf LZd q_eh\_d \hjh\Z\rbc ibsm [m^_l
kljZ^Zlvhlg_k\Zj_gby`_em^dZde_\_lgbd[m^_lbf_lv]gbeh_^uoZgb_dhghdjZ^[m^_l
ojhfZlv@_klhdb_ex^bk^_eZxlkydjh\h`Z^gufb`b\hlgufb\hjmxsb_oe_[b fykh
ij_\jZlylky\ djukb dhjrmgh\
<hagbdr__ \ 9,9 \_dZo ^h g w mq_gb_ [m^^bafZ hl^_eb\r__ky hl
^j_\g_bg^bckdh]h [jZofZgbafZ g_ klZeh hijh\_j]Zlv mq_gb_ h i_j_k_e_gbb ^mr
H^gZdh [m^^baf \g_k \ mq_gb_ [jZofZgbafZ kms_kl\_ggu_ baf_g_gby ?keb [jZofZgu
ml\_j`^Zeb qlh iml_f jZaebqguo h[jy^h\ `_jl\ b aZdebgZgbc fh`gh ^hklbqv
³ohjhrbo i_j_jh`^_gbc´ lh [m^^baf h[ty\be \k_ \b^u i_j_\hiehs_gby g_ba[_`guf
g_kqZklv_f b aehf Ihwlhfm \ukr_c p_evx ^he`gh [ulv ihegh_ ij_djZs_gb_
i_j_jh`^_gbcb ^hklb`_gb_gbj\Zgug_[ulby
;m^^baf\hkijbgyem [jZofZgbafZ³aZdhg\haf_a^by´dZjfmgh^Ze_fmgh\h_
kh^_j`Zgb_DZjfZ[m^^bafZ²wlhkmffZ\k_oihklmidh\b ihfukeh\kms_kl\Z\h\k_o
_]h ij_^u^msbo i_j_jh`^_gbyo Ohly \k_ \ ^Zgghc `bagb q_eh\_dZ hij_^_e_gh _]h
dZjfhc hg bf__l ba\_klgmx k\h[h^m \u[hjZ \ k\hbo ihklmidZo ihfukeZo keh\Zo
^_ckl\byo Q_eh\_d kZf kha^Z_l k\hx km^v[m nhjfm dZ`^h]h k\h_]h gh\h]h
i_j_jh`^_gby>_eh\h\k_g_\ `_jl\Zoh[jy^Zob aZij_lZoq_fmm^_eyehkvhkgh\gh_
\gbfZgb_\ [jZofZgbaf_Z \ih\_^_gbbkZfh]hq_eh\_dZBf_ggh_]hihklmidbb fukeb
\ ^Zgghc `bagb hij_^_eyxl _]h ^Zevg_crmx dZjfm nhjfm _]h gh\h]h
³i_j_\hiehs_gby´
KZf;m^^Zijhr_eq_j_ajh`^_gbcij_l_ji_\ZykljZ^Zgbyb gm`^m\ l_q_gb_
[_kqbke_gguo \_dh\ qlh[u ijbh[j_klb lZdbf h[jZahf \hafh`ghklv hk\h[h^blv
qm\kl\mxsb_kms_kl\ZhlkljZ^Zgbcijbkmsbo\k_fm`b\hfmQ_luj_jZaZhgy\eyeky\
\b^_ FZ]Z;jZfu jZa ² \ \b^_ ^moZ K_dju b fgh]h jZa ijhoh^be q_j_a khklhygb_
hlr_evgbdZpZjy[h]ZqZjZ[Z]hjr_qgbdZb]jhdZe_dZjyaf_bguomdmkh\h[_avygu
kehgZ [udZ af_b [_dZkZ ju[u ey]mrdb b ^j_\_kgh]h ^moZ >ey ihke_^g_]h k\h_]h
jh`^_gbyhgba[jZepZjkdmxk_fvx\ agZlghfjh^_=hlZfZie_f_gbrZdv_\`b\rbo\
K_\_jghc Bg^bb Ihwlhfm ;m^^m gZau\Zxl bgh]^Z =ZmlZfhc beb RZdvyfmgb ²
³hlr_evgbdbajh^ZrZdv_\´
< i_j_\hiehs_gb_ ^mr \_jmxl b ihke_^h\Zl_eb fZeh ba\_klghc m gZk j_eb]bb
^`ZcgbafZ WlZ j_eb]by lZd `_ dZd b [m^^baf \hagbdeZ ba ^j_\g_]h bg^bckdh]h´
[jZofZgbafZ \ 9, \_d_ ^h g w H[t_dlhf ihqblZgby ^`Zcgh\ y\eyxlky bo ijhjhdZ
Hkgh\Zl_e_f ^`ZcgbafZ kqblZ_lky bo ;;,9 ijhjhd <Zj^oZfZg FZoZ\bj ihemqb\rbc
bfy>`bguqlh\ i_j_\h^_k kZgkdjblZhagZqZ_l³ih[_^bl_ev´Hlwlh]hbf_gbihreh
gZa\Zgb_j_eb]bb³^`bgbaf´beb³^`Zcgbaf´
J_eb]by^`ZcgbafZy\ey_lky[he__^j_\g_cq_f
[m^^baf Z kZf ;m^^Z =ZmlZfZ
hkgh\Zl_ev [m^^bafZ y\ey_lky ebrv feZ^rbf kh\j_f_ggbdhf FZoZ\bju hkgh\Zl_e_f
^`ZcgbafZ G_kfhljy gZ wlh \ hlebqb_ hl [m^^bafZ klZ\r_]h fbjh\hc j_eb]b_c
^`Zcgbaf jZkijhkljZg_g ebrv \ Bg^bb ]^_ gZkqblu\Z_lky \ gZklhys__ \j_fy fbeebhgZihke_^h\Zl_e_cwlhcj_eb]bb
Kh]eZkgh ]eZ\ghfm ijbgpbim ^`ZcgbafZ `bagv ex^_c b `b\hlguo _klv nhjfZ
kms_kl\h\Zgby ^mrb ihhq_j_^gh i_j_k_eyxs_cky ba h^ghc `b\hc h[ehqdb \ ^jm]mx
=eZ\gZy b^_y ^`ZcgbafZ khklhbl \ ^hklb`_gbb gbj\Zgu g_[ulby ^h dhlhjhc
g_h[oh^bfhijhclbimlv fgh]boa_fguoi_j_jh`^_gbcb i_j_\hiehs_gbcih[_^blvb
ih^Z\blv \k_ a_fgu_ keZ[hklb b ]j_ob K\ylh \_jy \ b^_x i_j_k_e_gby ^mr ^`Zcgu
k\h_c hkgh\ghc aZih\_^vx kqblZxl g_ m[b\Zlv gbq_]h `b\h]h [m^v lh q_eh\_d
`b\hlgh_gZk_dhfh_bebfbdjh[²\_^v\ ex[hfbawlbokha^ZgbcaZdexq_gZh^gZb lZ
`_^mrZke_^mxsZyq_j_ap_ivi_j_\hiehs_gbcIhwlhfm^`Zcgugbdh]^Zg__^ylgb
fykZgb ju[u Z lhevdhnjmdlub h\hsbKZfh_ljm^gh_b keh`gh_ ^ey ^`ZcgbklZ ²
wlh ihklhyggZy hiZkghklv ih hrb[d_ beb ih g_\_^_gbx kt_klv qlheb[h lZdh_ \ q_f
kh^_j`blky `b\h_ mebldZ q_j\yd gZk_dhfh_ >himklb\ lZdmx hiehrghklv ]j_o hg
l_jy_l\k_lhqlhijbh[j_ejZg__gZ^he]hfb l_jgbklhfimlbd kiZk_gbxIjh]ehlb\ih
hrb[d_ q_j\yqdZ ijblZb\r_]hky \ fydhlb y[ehdZ ^`Zcgbkl kh]eZkgh k\hbf
j_eb]bhagufij_^klZ\e_gbyfkh\_jrZ_lkZfh_gZklhys__m[bckl\h²\_^v\ [m^msbo
i_j_jh`^_gbyo wlhl q_j\yd g_ij_f_ggh fh] klZlv q_eh\_dhf beb [ue bf \ h^ghf ba
k\hboijhreuojh`^_gbc
GZ mebpZo ;hf[_y fg_ \klj_qZebkv ex^b aZ\_jgmlu_ ^h kZfhc r_b \ [_emx
ldZgv Wlh [ueb ^`Zcgbklkdb_ fhgZob ² r\_lZf[Zju \ i_j_\h^_ k kZgkdjblZ ²
³h^_lu_ \ [_eu_ h^_`^u´ Bo e_]dh [ueh hlebqblv \ i_kljhc bg^bckdhc lhei_ ih
[_ehfm ieZldm aZdju\Zxs_fm ghk b jhl qlh[u kemqZcgh g_ aZ]ehlblv fhrdm b g_
ih]m[blv`b\h_Ij_`^_q_fk_klvgZa_fexlZdhcfhgZolsZl_evghh[f_lZe\k_\hdjm]
f_l_ehqdhcbaiZ\ebgv_\i_jv_\^Z[ug_gZjhdhfg_jZa^Z\blv\kydbo[mdZr_dDZ`^mx
[mdZrdmhg[ueh[yaZghlg_klb\ l_gvqlh[uhgZg_ih]b[eZih_]h\bg_b[h\ dZ`^hc
lZdhc [mdZrd_ fh`_l ij_[u\Zlv bgZy ^mrZ LZd`_ ^`Zcgu gbdh]^Z g_ _^yl kujuo
h\hs_c b njmdlh\ qlh[u g_ ijh]ehlblv kh^_j`Zsboky \ gbo \b^bfuo b g_\b^bfuo
`b\uohj]Zgbafh\Z lsZl_evghijh\Zjb\Zxl\k_h\hsbgZh]g_
Ihfbfh fhgZoh\r\_lZf[Zjh\ ³h^_luo \ [_eu_ h^_`^u´ m ^`Zcgh\
kms_kl\mxl b fhgZob^b]Zf[Zju \ i_j_\h^_ k kZgkdjblZ ² ³h^_lu_ \ha^mohf´ l _
]heu_ Hgb gZb[he__ ihegh \ujZ`Zxl hkgh\gmx ^h]fZlbq_kdmx b^_x ^`ZcgbafZ ²
ihegh_ hk\h[h`^_gb_ hl \kydbo fbjkdbo \h`^_e_gbc \ lhf qbke_ b lZdbo dZd
klj_fe_gb_ `blv ih^ djur_c b ghkblv h^_`^m ³H^_luo \ha^mohf´ hklZehkv kh\k_f
g_fgh]h gh _keb \Zf ^h\_^_lky \klj_lblv gZ mebpZo bg^bckdbo ]hjh^h\ Z[khexlgh
]heh]hq_eh\_dZ²g_im]Zcl_kvwlh\_jhylg__\k_]h^`ZcgbklkdbcfhgZo^b]Zf[Zj
Mq_gb_ h i_j_\hiehs_gbb ^mr [ueh agZdhfh b Zglbqguf nbehkhnZf IeZlhgm
ba\_klghfbnbq_kdh_mq_gb_h \hiehs_gbb^mr\ nhjfZokhhl\_lkl\mxsbodZq_kl\Zf
ijbh[j_l_gguf \ gZklhys_c `bagb h ^mrZo i_j_k_eyxsboky \ `b\hlguo b
ih^gbfZxsboky \gh\v ^h q_eh\_q_kdh]h ^hklhbgkl\Z kfhljy ih `bagb dhlhjmx hgb
\_eb h ilbpZo \ dhlhjuo `b\ml e_]dhfuke_ggu_ ^mrb h[ mkljbpZo g_kmsbo \
ba]gZgbb gZdZaZgb_ aZ ]em[hdh_ g_\_`_kl\h Mq_gb_ h i_j_k_e_gbb ^mr ih^jh[gh
baeZ]Z_lky \ ^bZeh]Zo IeZlhgZ ³N_^jZ´ b ³=hkm^Zjkl\h´ < gbo fu gZoh^bf
ml\_j`^_gb_IeZlhgZqlhi_j_k_e_gb_^mrbijhbkoh^blh^bgjZa\ lukyqme_l
GZb[he__ ihke_^h\Zl_evgh ba nbehkhnh\ Zglbqghklb l_hjbx i_j_k_e_gby ^mr
baeZ]Ze IbnZ]hj [he__ ba\_klguc gZf ih k\h_c agZf_gblhc ]_hf_ljbq_kdhc l_hj_f_
:glbqguc bklhjbd Ihjnbjbc hd hd ]] g w \ k\h_c [bh]jZnbb IbnZ]hjZ
k\b^_l_evkl\m_lqlh³fgh]bfdlhijboh^bed g_fmIbnZ]hjgZihfbgZeh ijhrehcbo
`bagb dhlhjmx \_eZ bo ^mrZ ij_`^_ q_f h[e_qvky \ bo l_eh´ >j_\g_]j_q_kdbc
nbehkhn >bh]_g EZwjlkdbc ,,²,,, \\ g w kkueZykv gZ =_jZdeb^Z Ihglbckdh]h
jZkkdZau\Z_lqlhkZfIbnZ]hjijhr_eq_j_afgh]b_djm]bi_j_jh`^_gby^mrIbnZ]hj
ml\_j`^Ze qlh g_dh]^Z hg [ue WnZeb^hf b ihqblZeky kughf [h]Z =_jf_kZ =_jf_k
ij_^eh`be _fm gZ \u[hj ex[hc ^Zj djhf_ [_kkf_jlby b IbnZ]hj ihijhkbe hklZ\blv
_fm iZfylv h lhf qlh [ueh \ ijhreuo jh`^_gbyo < ke_^mxs_f jh`^_gbb hg [ue
?\nhj[hf dhlhjh]h m[be F_g_eZc ijb hkZ^_ Ljhb Ihke_ kf_jlb ?\nhj[Z ^mrZ _]h
i_j_reZ\ =_jfhlbfZdhlhjuc`_eZy^hdZaZlvijZ\^mh k\h_fij_^u^ms_fjh`^_gbb
y\beky\ ojZf:iheehgZb mdZaZesblihk\ys_gguc[h]mF_g_eZ_fdh]^Zlhlhlieu\Ze
baLjhbIhke_kf_jlb=_jfhlbfZhgklZeIbjjhf^_ehkkdbfju[Zdhfb ihij_`g_fm
\k_ihfgbedZdhg[ueki_j\ZWnZeb^hfihlhf?\nhj[hfihlhf=_jfhlbfhfihlhf
Ibjjhf : ihke_ kf_jlb IbjjZ hg klZe IbnZ]hjhf b lh`_ khojZgbe iZfylv h k\hbo
ijhreuojh`^_gbyo
Fgh]b_ Z\lhju jZkkdZau\Zy h l_hjbb f_l_fikbohaZ i_j_k_e_gbb ^mr
IbnZ]hjZh[uqghijb\h^ylijbf_jij_\jZs_gby\hbgZ?\nhj[Z\ nbehkhnZIbnZ]hjZ
aZl_f\ ]_l_jm:kiZkbx ex[h\gbpm I_jbdeZ ihke_ wlh]h \ nbehkhnZdbgbdZ DjZl_lZ
aZl_f\ pZjyihlhf\ gbs_]hihke_wlh]h²\ kZljZiZdhgy]Zedmey]mrdmbgZdhg_p
\ I_lmoZ Gh ijb wlhf hgb aZ[u\Zxl qlh k\_^_gby wlb ihq_jigmlu ba ^bZeh]Z
^j_\g_]j_q_kdh]hkZlbjbdZEmdbZgZhd²]]gw³Kgh\b^_gb_bebI_lmo´<
³I_lmo_´ hkljhmfghc djblbd_ ih^\_j]Z_lky fbklbq_kdZy nbehkhnby ibnZ]hjbafZ WlZ
[e_klysZykZlbjZij_^klZ\ey_lkh[hc^bZeh]f_`^m[_^gydhfFbdbeehfb _]hi_lmohf
\ dhlhjh]h\k_ebeky^moIbnZ]hjZBf_gghi_lmob jZkkdZau\Z_lh[h\k_cmihfygmlhc
\ur_qm^_kghcq_j_^_ij_\jZs_gbcIbnZ]hjZ\ dhgy]Zedmey]mrdmb l^Gh\_^vwlh
gbdZd g_ hljZ`Z_l bklbgguo \a]ey^h\ IbnZ]hjZ Z ij_^klZ\ey_l ebrv gZkf_reb\mx
iZjh^bx gZ _]h mq_gb_ baeh`_ggh_ gZfb ih >bh]_gm EZwjlkdhfm D kh`Ze_gbx ba
dgb]b \ dgb]m dZd beexkljZpby ibnZ]hjbckdh]h f_l_fikbohaZ dhqm_l wlZ [Zkgy h
I_lmo_ g_ bf_xsZy gbq_]h h[s_]h kh \a]ey^Zfb IbnZ]hjZ KkueZykv gZ EmdbZgZ
Z\lhju aZ[u\Zxl qlh wlh g_ ^hdmf_gl bklhjbdZ Z iZjh^by kZlbjbdZ G_ ba[_`Ze wlhc
hrb[db ^Z`_ lZdhc Z\lhjbl_lguc bkke_^h\Zl_ev bklhjbb j_eb]bhaguo ij_^klZ\e_gbc
dZdW^mZj^;_jg_llLZcehj
: ^bZeh] EmdbZgZ ij_^klZ\ey_l kh[hc ^_ckl\bl_evgh m[bckl\_ggmx kZlbjm gZ
l_hjbxi_j_k_e_gby^mrLZdgZijbf_jFbdbeekijZrb\Z_lk\h_]hqm^_kgh]hi_lmoZ
[u\r_]hg_dh]^ZIbnZ]hjhfZ _s_jZgvr_²ljhygkdbf\hbghf³JZkkdZ`bfg_ki_j\Z
h lhfqlhijhbkoh^beh\ Bebhg_LZd\k_wlhb [uehdZdih\_kl\m_l=hf_j"´
GZ qlh i_lmo hl\_qZ_l ³Hldm^Z `_ hg fh] agZlv Fbdbee dh]^Z \h \j_fy wlbo
kh[ulbchg[ue\_j[ex^hf\ ;Zdljbb"´
K \hagbdgh\_gb_fojbklbZgkl\Zb g_kdhevdhiha^g__bkeZfZ\_jZ\ i_j_k_e_gb_
^mr [ueZ ijhqgh aZ[ulZ b hklZeZkv ebrv \ f_klZo ljZ^bpbhggh]h jZkijhkljZg_gby
bg^mbafZ b [m^^bafZ ² \ X]h<hklhqghc :abb H^gZdh hl]hehkdb wlh]h \_jhmq_gby
_s_ g_ jZa ^Z\Zeb h k_[_ agZlv LZd \ iha^g_cr_c _\j_ckdhc nbehkhnbb mq_gb_ h
i_j_k_e_gbb ^mr ijbgyeb dZ[[Zebklu b ih^^_j`b\Zeb _]h ihkj_^kl\hf hkh[h]h
lhedh\Zgby ;b[ebb Hgb kqblZeb qlh ^mrZ :^ZfZ i_j_reZ \ >Z\b^Z b i_j_c^_l \
f_kkbx^mrZDZbgZi_j_reZ\ BhnhjZZ ^mrZ:\_ey²\ Fhbk_yb ihlhfmlhBhnhj
hl^Z_lk\hx^hqv\ `_guFhbk_x
< ojbklbZgkl\_ gZb[he__ aZf_qZl_evgufb ij_^klZ\bl_eyfb mq_gby h
i_j_k_e_gbb ^mr y\eyebkv fZgbo_b K_dlZ fZgbo__\ ml\_j`^ZeZ qlh ^mrb ]j_rgbdh\
i_j_oh^yl \ ^bdbo a\_j_c l_f [he__ hl\jZlbl_evguo q_f ]j_rg__ ^mrb >mrb fh]ml
lZd`_i_j_clb\ jZkl_gbydhlhju_bf_xlydh[ug_lhevdh`bagvghb kfuke
Mq_gb_h i_j_k_e_gbb^mr[uehjZkijhkljZg_ghm kj_^g_\_dh\uog_klhjbZgp_\
m ^jmah\Z lZd`_\ fmkmevfZgkdhck_dl_bkfZbeblh\
< ;9,,, \_d_ Zg]ebckdbc ibkZl_ev =_gjb Nbe^bg] ² \ k\h_f
³Iml_r_kl\bb\ aZ]jh[gucfbj´\gh\v\ha\jZsZ_lkyd l_hjbbi_j_k_e_gby^mrKfuke
aZ]jh[gh]himl_r_kl\byihNbe^bg]mkhklhbl\ lhfqlh^mobg_^hklhcgu_[eZ`_gkl\Z
[m^ml\ha\jZs_gugZa_fex^Z[u\ gh\hc`bagbbkdmiblvij_]j_r_gbyij_`g_cJ_^dh
dhfmwlhm^Z_lkykjZam²bgu_iml_r_kl\mxlihfgh]mjZa< dZdhfdZq_kl\_ij_^klhbl
\lhjbqgh jh^blvky ² j_rbl `_j_[v_\dZ m Dhe_kZ Nhjlmgu Gh gZ wlhl jZa fu
\klj_qZ_fky g_ k nbehkhnkdhc dhgp_ipb_c f_l_fikbohaZ dZd m IbnZ]hjZ b g_ k
kZlbjhc gZ g__ dZd m EmdbZgZ Z kh k\h_h[jZaguf ebl_jZlmjguf ijb_fhf LZd
gZijbf_j\kylj_lvyqZklv³Iml_r_kl\by\ aZ]jh[gucfbj´ihk\ys_gZfgh]hqbke_gguf
f_lZfhjnhaZf jbfkdh]h bfi_jZlhjZ XebZgZ HlklmigbdZ ² ]] g w
=hj_fuqguc bfi_jZlhj gZ gZrbo ]eZaZo jZa i_j_\hiehsZ_lky \ jZaebqgu_ h[jZau
hggZqZejZ[hf\ dhgp_,9\_dZZ dhgqbemqbl_e_flZgp_\\ k_j_^bg_;,9\_dZXebZg
ihke_^h\Zl_evghij_\jZsZ_lkybabfi_jZlhjZ\ jZ[ZaZl_f\ kdmih]h`b^Z\ ]_g_jZeZ\
gZke_^gbdZ\ iehlgbdZ\ s_]hey\ fhgZoZ\ kdjbiZqZ\ ij_fm^jh]hfm`Z\ dhjhey\
rmlZ \ gbs_]h \ fbgbkljZ \ khe^ZlZ \ ihjlgh]h \ qbgh\gbdZ \ ihwlZ \ jupZjy \
mqbl_eylZgp_\
<kydhfm ij_\jZs_gbx ihk\ys_gZ hl^_evgZy ]eZ\Z b dZ`^Zy ba gbo y\ey_lky
bgl_j_kg_crbf ikboheh]bq_kdbf wlx^hf <u[jZggZy Z\lhjhf l_fZ i_j_k_e_gby ^mr
iha\hey_l k\h[h^gh i_j_rZ]b\Zlv ba h^ghc bklhjbq_kdhc wihob \ ^jm]mx ijbohleb\h
lZkh\Zlv \baZglbckdb_ bkiZgkdb_ Zg]ebckdb_ b njZgpmakdb_ kljZgbpu wlhc
ex[hiulghcojhgbdb
Lh qlh q_eh\_d i_j_`b\Z_l [_kqbke_ggh_ dhebq_kl\h jh`^_gbc b kf_jl_c \
gZklhys__ \j_fy ijbgbfZ_lky ih^Z\eyxsbf [hevrbgkl\hf `bl_e_c X]h<hklhqghc
:abb Gh wlhfm n_ghf_gm j_bgdZjgZpbb ih\lhjgh]h jh`^_gby \ ihke_^gb_ ]h^u \k_
[hevr__\gbfZgb_m^_ey_lky\ bkke_^h\Zgbyo_\jhi_ckdbob Zf_jbdZgkdbomq_guo
NjZgpmakdZy bkke_^h\Zl_evgbpZ : >w\b^Ghwev dhlhjZy ihke_ hdhgqZgby
Khj[hggu [he__ e_l ijh\_eZ \ Lb[_l_ ih^ \b^hf [jh^yq_c gbs_gdbiZehfgbpu \
k\h_c dgb]_ ³Kj_^b fbklbdh\ b fZ]h\ Lb[_lZ´ jZkkdZau\Z_l h lhf dZd \ Lb[_l_ ihke_
kf_jlbgZklhyl_eyfhgZklujy²eZfu²\k_fhgZobhlijZ\eyxlkygZihbkdb_]hgh\h]h
\hiehs_gbyLZdb_ihbkdbbgh]^Z^eylkyihe_l<k_fb^_eZfbfhgZklujy\ lZdb_
i_jbh^u \_^Z_l mijZ\eyxsbc Dh]^Z gZoh^blky fZevqbd ij_l_g^mxsbc gZ jhev
\hiehs_ggh]heZfu_fmmkljZb\Zxlk\h_h[jZagucwdaZf_g\ imklhcdhfgZl__fm^Zxl
f_rhd k \_sZfb dhlhjuo ijbgZ^e_`Zeb mf_jr_fm eZf_ FZevqbd ^he`_g bo
magZlvb hdZ`^hcqlhgb[m^vjZkkdZaZlv
: >w\b^Ghwev hibku\Z_l kemqZc dhlhjhfm hgZ kZfZ [ueZ k\b^_l_evgbp_c
H^gZ`^u g_[hevrhc dZjZ\Zg \ khklZ\_ dhlhjh]h hgZ iml_r_kl\h\ZeZ ih \gmlj_gg_c
Fhg]hebb hklZgh\beky gZ ghqe_] \ klhc[bs_ h^gh]h dhq_\gbdZ Ijb dZjZ\Zg_
gZoh^beky mijZ\eyxsbc fhgZklujy dhlhjuc m`_ [he__ lb e_l hklZ\Zeky [_a eZfu
Dh]^Z\k_\hreb\ ob`bgmdhq_\gbdZmijZ\eyxsbcmk_\rbkvgZihem^hklZe^hjh]mx
lZ[Zd_jdmb klZeaZibob\Zlv\ ghkgxoZl_evguc lZ[Zd < wlhl fhf_gl d g_fm ih^hr_e
e_lgbc kug dhq_\gbdZ b kljh]h kijhkbe ³Hldm^Z m l_[y fhy lZ[Zd_jdZ"´
MijZ\eyxsbc f]gh\_ggh \kdhqb\ gZ gh]b jmogme i_j_^ gbf gZ dhe_gb Wlh [ueh
[_ah]h\hjhqgh_ijbagZgb_fZevqbdZ\hiehs_gb_fklZjh]heZfu
< ^Zevg_cr_f dh]^Z dZjZ\Zg k fZevqbdhf lhj`_kl\_ggh \t_a`Ze \ ijZa^gbqgh
mdjZr_gguc fhgZklujv j_[_ghd \^jm] aZy\be qlh bf gZ^h _oZlv gZijZ\h HdZaZehkv
qlhjZgvr_lZf^_ckl\bl_evgh[ueijh_a^ghhg[ueaZeh`_ge_lgZaZ^BgZdhg_p
dh]^Z fZevqbd m`_ kb^_e gZ ljhg_ eZfu b _fm ih^Zeb jblmZevgh_ iblv_ hg hldZaZeky
\aylv qZrm aZy\b\ qlh hgZ _fm g_ ijbgZ^e_`bl b mdZaZe ]^_ ^he`gZ gZoh^blvky _]h
qZrZb dZdhgZ\u]ey^bl
Gh _s_ [he__ m[_^bl_evgh a\mqZl ijbf_ju \aylu_ ba fhgh]jZnbb YgZ
Klb\_gkhgZ Y Klb\_gkhg him[ebdh\Ze lj_olhfgmx fhgh]jZnbx ihk\ys_ggmx
ijh[e_fZf j_bgdZjgZpbb ?]h f_lh^ bamq_gby j_bgdZjgZpbhgghbgl_jij_lbjm_fuo
kemqZ_\ ghkbl ^hdmf_glZevguc oZjZdl_j \dexqZxsbc hijhk k\b^_l_e_c bamq_gb_
Zjob\guo fZl_jbZeh\ lsZl_evguc ZgZeba hrb[hd \hafh`guo bkdZ`_gbc b l i <
fhgh]jZnbb kh^_j`blky kemqZ_\ j_bgdZjgZpbb \ jZaebqguo qZklyo fbjZ Wlb
jZ[hlugm`^Zxlky\ gZmqghfhkfuke_gbb
KemqZb ^hklmigu_ k_jv_aghc gZmqghc ijh\_jd_ k\yaZgu k ijbihfbgZgb_f
ijhreuo\hiehs_gbc^_lvfb\ \hajZkl_hl^\mo^hq_luj_oe_lD gZklhys_fm\j_f_gb
bkke_^h\Zgh [he__ ih^h[guo kemqZ_\ b kh[jZgh \gmrbl_evgh_ dhebq_kl\h
k\b^_l_evkl\ < dZq_kl\_ ijbf_jZ kh\j_f_ggh]h bkke_^h\Zgby fh`gh ijb\_klb kemqZc
K\ZjgeZluFbr_jZ
K\ZjgeZlZ jh^beZkv fZjlZ ]h^Z \ k_fv_ bgki_dlhjZ jZchgghc rdheu \
QoZlZjimj_rlZlFZ^ovyIjZ^_r²Bg^byDZdlh\ \hajZkl_lj_ok iheh\bghce_lhgZ
ijh_a`ZeZk hlphf]hjh^DZlgbb k^_eZeZijbwlhfjy^kijZ\_^eb\uoaZf_qZgbch ^hf_
\ dhlhjhfhgZydh[u`beZ< ^_ckl\bl_evghklb`_k_fvyFbr_jgbdh]^Zg_`beZ[eb`_
q_f\ klZfbeyohlwlh]hf_klZIha`_K\ZjgeZlZ jZkkdZaZeZ ^jmavyf b jh^kl\_ggbdZf
^_lZebk\h_cij_^u^ms_c`bagbhgZml\_j`^ZeZqlhnZfbeby__ [ueZIZloZdDjhf_
lh]h__ lZgpub i_kgb[uebg_oZjZdl_jgu^ey^Zggh]hjZchgZZ kZfZhgZh[mqblvkybf
g_fh]eZ
< \hajZkl_ ^_kylb e_l K\ZjgeZlZ aZy\beZ qlh gh\Zy agZdhfZy bo k_fvb `_gZ
ijhn_kkhjZ dhee_^`Z [ueZ \ ij_^u^ms_c `bagb __ ih^jm`dhc G_kdhevdh f_kyp_\
kimkly h[ wlhf kemqZ_ magZe Rjb ; G ;Zdd_j^`b k dZn_^ju iZjZikboheh]bb
mgb\_jkbl_lZ \ >`Zcimj_ Hg \klj_lbeky k k_fv_c Fbr_j Z aZl_f jmdh\h^kl\mykv
mdZaZgbyfb K\ZjgeZlu jZaukdZe ^hf IZloZgh\ Hg h[gZjm`be qlh jZkkdZau ^_\hqdb
\_kvfZgZihfbgZxlbklhjbx`bagb;bbdhlhjZy[ueZ^hq_jvxIZloZdh\b `_ghcRjb
QbglZfbgbIZg^Zy;bymf_jeZ\ ]h^m
E_lhf ] k_fvy IZloZdh\ b jh^kl\_ggbdb ;bb ih fm`m ihk_lbeb k_fvx
Fbr_j \ QoZlZjimj_ K\ZjgeZlZ g_ lhevdh magZeZ bo gh b mdZaZeZ dlh _klv dlh HgZ
hldZaZeZkv ijbagZlv ^\mo ihklhjhggbo ex^_c dhlhjuo \ wdki_jbf_glZevguo p_eyo
iulZebkv\u^ZlvaZ__ jh^kl\_ggbdh\Iha`_^_\hqdmijb\_aeb\ DZlebLZfhgZmagZeZ
fgh]boex^_cb f_klZhlf_qZyi_j_f_guijhbkr_^rb_kh\j_f_gbkf_jlb;bb
E_lhf ] \b^guc ikbobZlj bkke_^h\Zl_ev ikbobq_kdbo n_ghf_gh\ ba
<bj^`bgkdh]h mgb\_jkbl_lZ Yg Klb\_gkhg ihk_lbe h[_ k_fvb b ihiulZeky ijh\_jblv
^hklh\_jghklvwlh]hkemqZyKlb\_gkhg\uykgbeqlhbaaZy\e_gbcK\ZjgeZlulhevdh
g_ khhl\_lkl\h\Zeb ^_ckl\bl_evghklb HgZ ^_lZevgh hibkZeZ ^hf ;bb khk_^gb_
ihkljhcdb\ lhf\b^_dZdbfbhgb[ueb^h]hibkZeZ^hdlhjZe_qb\r_]h;bxZ
lZd`_ih^jh[ghklb__ [he_agbb kf_jlbHgZ[ueZkihkh[gZijbihfgblvlZdb_kemqZbba
`bagb ;bb dhlhju_ [ueb ba\_klgu ^Ze_dh g_ \k_f jh^kl\_ggbdZf HgZ [_ahrb[hqgh
gZoh^beZkj_^bijbkmlkl\h\Z\rbok\hbo^Z\gbo[ebadbo^jma_cjh^kl\_ggbdh\b kem]
g_kfhljy gZ ihiuldb k[blv __ k lhedm Bgl_j_kgh qlh \ hlghr_gbyo k ³[jZlvyfb´
dhlhju_[uebklZjr___ gZe_lhgZ\_eZk_[ydZdklZjrZyk_kljZ
K\ZjgeZlZjZkkdZau\ZeZb h^jm]hfijhf_`mlhqghf\hiehs_gbb\ dhlhjhfhgZ
[ueZj_[_gdhfihbf_gbDZfe_f`b\r_f\ Kbgd_l_;_g]Zebyb mf_jr_f\ \hajZkl_
^_\ylb e_l Fgh]b_ ba __ jZkkdZah\ \_jgh hibku\Zxl f_klgu_ ]_h]jZnbq_kdb_
hkh[_gghklb ;_g]Zebb \uykgbehkv lZd`_ qlh __ i_kgb b lZgpu y\eyxlky
[_g]ZevkdbfbohlyhgZ\kx`bagvijh\_eZkj_^bex^_c]h\hjysbolhevdhgZobg^b
< ]h^mNjwgdW^\Zj^_\uimklbedgb]m³KljZggu_ex^b´]^_[uebkh[jZgu
fgh]hqbke_ggu_ijbf_jug_ihgylguob g_ih^^Zxsbokyh[tykg_gbxy\e_gbc< wlhc
dgb]_ ijb\h^behkv ljb ^hdmf_glZevgh ih^l\_j`^_gguo kemqZy j_bgdZjgZpbb
ih^h[guo hibkZgghfm \ur_ gZ[ex^_gbx H^bg ba gbo hibku\Ze jh^b\rmxky \ ]h^m \ Bg^bb \ >_eb ^_\hqdm ih bf_gb RZglb >w\b dhlhjZy ml\_j`^ZeZ qlh hgZ \
ijhrehf jh`^_gbb `beZ kh k\hbf fm`_f D_^ZjgZlhf \ ]hjh^_ Fmlljb b mf_jeZ \h
\j_fyjh^h\\ ]h^mM^ZehkvjZaukdZlvwlh]hD_^ZjgZlZb k_]hihfhsvxijh\_jblv
ml\_j`^_gbyRZglb>w\bG_kfhljygZkZfu_ijbkljZklgu_^hijhkufgh]hqbke_gguo
bkke_^h\Zl_e_c RZglb >w\b gb jZam g_ hrb[eZkv \ bglbfguo ih^jh[ghklyo k_fvb
`b\ms_c \ Fmllj_ b g_agZdhfhc ^Z`_ __ jh^bl_eyf Mq_gu_ ijbgy\rb_ mqZklb_ \
wdki_jbf_gl_ b aZk\b^_l_evkl\h\Z\rb_ m\b^_ggh_ [ueb hklhjh`gu \ \u\h^Zo Hgb
kh]eZkbebkvqlhj_[_ghdjh^b\rbcky\ ]h^m\ >_ebdZdbflhh[jZahfihfgblkh
\k_c ykghklvx b \k_fb ih^jh[ghklyfb `bagv \ Fmllj_ Mq_gu_ g_ gZreb gb h^gh]h
^hdZaZl_evkl\Zh[fZgZghhgblZd`_g_gZrebh[tykg_gbym\b^_gghfm
< ]h^m]Za_lZ³<Zrbg]lhgihkl´b ]Za_lu^jm]bokljZggZi_qZlZebbgl_j\vx
k RZglZ >w\b @beZ hgZ lboh b g_aZf_lgh jZ[hlZy \ ]hkm^Zjkl\_gghf mqj_`^_gbb \
Gvx>_eb Ij_`gb_ `_eZgby \_jgmlv ijhreh_ [ueb ih^Z\e_gu mihjghc \gmlj_gg_c
[hjv[hcb hgZm`_gbq_]hg_ij_^ijbgbfZeZqlh[uh`b\blvbo
Khh[s_gbyh j_bgdZjgZpbbijh^he`Zxli_jbh^bq_kdbihy\eylvkygZkljZgbpZo
]Za_l<hlh^gZbag_^Z\gbok_gkZpbc
>\_gZ^pZlbe_lgZy ?e_gZ FZjdZj^ ba AZiZ^gh]h ;_jebgZ ijb^y \ k_[y ihke_
ly`_ehc ljZ\fu aZ]h\hjbeZ gZ [_amij_qghf blZevygkdhf yaud_ dhlhjh]h jZgvr_ g_
agZeZ Ijb wlhf ^_\hqdZ ml\_j`^ZeZ qlh ah\ml __ Jha_llZ DZkl_evygb `beZ hgZ \
BlZebbjh^beZkv\ ]h^mZ mf_jeZ\ Dh]^Z^_\hqdmhl\_aebihmdZaZgghfm_x
Z^j_km^\_jvhldjueZ^hqv^Z\ghmf_jr_cJha_llu?e_gZmagZ\__kdZaZeZ³<hlfhy
^hqvNjZgkZ´
G_dhlhju_ bkke_^h\Zl_eb kdehggu hlghkblv d \ujZ`_gghc \ g_agZqbl_evghc
kl_i_gb iZfylb h ijhreuo jh`^_gbyo y\e_gby k dhlhjufb klZedb\Zeky qmlv eb g_
dZ`^ucbagZkLZdfgh]bfbgh]^ZdZaZekym^b\bl_evghagZdhfufdZdhclhi_j_mehd\
qm`hf ]hjh^_ beb dZdZyeb[h kblmZpby gZihfbgZeZ ^Z\gh i_j_`blh_ Ba\_klgh
gZijbf_j qlh fheh^hc E_\ Lheklhc h^gZ`^u gZ hohl_ ih]gZ\rbkv aZ aZcp_f miZe k
dhgyDh]^Zhgih^gyeky_fmihdZaZehkvqlhdh]^ZlhdZdhg]h\hjbe³hq_gv^Z\gh´hg
lZd`__oZe\_johfih]gZekyaZaZcp_fi_j_e_l_eq_j_adhgyHijhkuijh\_^_ggu_aZ
jm[_`hf ihdZaZeb qlh ljb q_l\_jlb ex^_c bkiulu\Zeb wlh qm\kl\h magZ\Zgby :
g_h[tykgbfu_`_kluihklmidbFm`qbgZi_j_iju]b\Zyq_j_aem`mih^gbfZ_liheu
ib^`ZdZ [m^lh gZ g_f ^ebggh_ ieZlv_ >jm]hc bf__l kljZggmx ijb\uqdm djmlblv
g_kms_kl\mxsb_mkuohlygbdh]^Zmkh\g_ghkbe
< ]h^m njZgpmakdbc \jZq]bighlba_j : ^_ Jhlr k^_eZe bgl_j_kgh_
hldjulb_ qlh \ hq_gv ]em[hdhf ]bigha_ [m^lh [u fh]ml h`blv b ijhy\blvky
\hkihfbgZgby h ij_^r_kl\mxs_f i_j_\hiehs_gbb ^mrb AZ]bighlbabjh\Zgguc \^jm]
gZqbgZ_l ]h\hjblv g_ k\hbf ]hehkhf hl bf_gb dZdh]hlh ^jm]h]h ebpZ dhlhjh_
ih\_kl\m_lh k\h_c^Z\ghm]Zkr_c`bagb
< djm]Zoihk\ys_gguo³iml_r_kl\b_\ ijhreh_´ih^]bighahf²^_ehh[uqgh_
Hgh^Z_l\hafh`ghklv^hklbqvlh]hqlh[u]bighlbabjm_fucrZ]aZrZ]hf\ha\jZsZeky
\ k\hxxghklv^_lkl\h ² \iehlv ^h fhf_glZ jh`^_gby Z aZl_f fh`_l [ulv b \ _s_
[he__hl^Ze_ggh_ijhreh_
Wlhm^ZehkvgZijbf_j\ kemqZ_k fheh^ufZf_jbdZgp_f>`hj^`_fNbe^hf
=bighlba_j Ehjbg] Mbevyfk \\_e wlh]h e_lg_]h Zf_jbdZgpZ \ khklhygb_
]em[hdh]h ]bighlbq_kdh]h kgZ Mbevyfk ihwlZigh \_jgme fZevqbdZ d fhf_glm _]h
jh`^_gbyZ aZl_f[he__q_fgZklhe_l\ ijhreh_<kdhj_fZevqbdaZ]h\hjbe
²Y [ue>`hgZlZgIZmweeijhklhcdj_klvygbgbaK_\_jghcDZjhebgu@be
lZf h^bg g_ih^Ze_dm hl ]hjh^Z >`_nn_jkhg Jh^beky \ ]h^m <h \j_fy
]jZ`^Zgkdhc \hcgu \ ]h^m f_gy m[beb fyl_`gu_ khe^Zlu Hgb \uklj_ebeb \
f_gy< `b\hl
GZkdhevdh iha\hebeb bklhjbq_kdb_ ^hdmf_glu dhlhju_ m^Zehkv jZa^h[ulv
Mbevyfkmhgijh\_jbeih^jh[ghklbjZkkdZaZggu_ih^]bighahf>`hj^`_fNbe^hfb
dZkZ\rb_ky>`hgZlZgZIZmweeZIjbwlhf\uykgbehkvqlh]bighlbabjm_fuckhh[sZeh
lZdbohkh[_gghklyowlhcf_klghklbb ]hjh^dZdhlhju_g_evay[uehijb^mfZlvZ fh`gh
[uehlhevdhmagZlv
AZl_f Ehjbg] Mbevyfk k fZevqbdhf ih_oZeb \ >`_nn_jkhg Dh]^Z hg ijh\_e
k_Zgk ]bighaZ \ ijbkmlkl\bb bklhjbdZ ki_pbZevgh bamqZ\r_]h wlhl djZc \uykgbehkv
ihjZabl_evgh_ ]h\hjy hl bf_gb dj_klvygbgZ IZmweeZ >`hj^` Nbe^ kmf_e gZa\Zlv ih
bf_gZf \k_o f_klguo ³hlph\ ]hjh^Z´ ijhreh]h \_dZ Hg lZd`_ hibkZe bo ^hfZ \
f_evqZcrboih^jh[ghklyo
H^gZdh ^hdmf_glZevgh kms_kl\h\Zgb_ >`hgZlZgZ IZmweeZ ^hdZaZlv g_ m^Zehkv
ihkdhevdm \ wlhc h[eZklb gZqZeb j_]bkljbjh\Zlv jh^b\rboky b mf_jrbo ebrv k ]h^Z
Mbevyfk him[ebdh\Ze jZkkdZa h[ wlhf \i_qZleyxs_f ohly b g_ kh\k_f
^hdZam_fhf]bighlbq_kdhf\ha\jZl_\ ijhreh_Kimklyg_fgh]h\j_f_gb>`hj^`Nbe^
ihemqbe ibkvfh @_gsbgZ k ^_\bqv_c nZfbeb_c IZmwee ibkZeZ _fm qlh hgZ y\ey_lky
\gmqZlhc ie_fyggbp_c >`hgZlZgZ IZmweeZ HgZ jZkkdZaZeZ _fm h ih^jh[ghklyo `bagb
>`hgZlZgZIZmweeZdhlhju_[uebba\_klguihmklgufjZkkdZaZf\ bok_fv_GZjy^mkh
\k_fhklZevgufhgZibkZeZ³>`hgZlZgIZmweeijboh^bekyfg_^\hxjh^guf^_^hf?]h
m[bebygdb´
M^b\bl_evguc kemqZc hibkZg \ dgb]_ YgZ Dmjv_ ³Gbdlh g_ mfbjZ_l gZ\k_]^Z´
H^bg \jZq ba NbeZ^_evnbb \j_fy hl \j_f_gb ijbf_gye ]bigha \ dZq_kl\_ f_lh^Z
e_q_gby< ]h^mhggZagZqbek_jbx]bighlbq_kdbok_Zgkh\k\h_ce_lg_c`_g_
M\b^_\ qlh hgZ e_]dh ih^^Z_lky ]bigham hg iulZeky \_jgmlv __ \ ijhreh_ < oh^_
h^gh]hbak_Zgkh\`_gZ\^jm]aZ]h\hjbeZgbadbffm`kdbf]hehkhfk yjdh\ujZ`_gguf
kdZg^bgZ\kdbf Zdp_glhf HgZ ml\_j`^ZeZ qlh hgZ fm`qbgZ dhlhjh]h ah\ml C_gk_g
Ydh[b AZl_f hgZ \hh[s_ klZeZ hl\_qZlv gZ \hijhku gZ qm`hf yaud_ dZd ihgye \jZq
dZdhflhkdZg^bgZ\kdhf
GZke_^mxsbck_Zgk[uebijb]eZr_gug_kdhevdhkdZg^bgZ\kdboki_pbZebklh\
\ lhf qbke_ r\_^kdbc mq_guc Gbevk KZebg [u\rbc ^bj_dlhj :f_jbdZghr\_^kdh]h
bklhjbq_kdh]hfma_y\ NbeZ^_evnbbHgmklZgh\beqlh\oh^y\ h[jZaC_gk_gZYdh[b
`_gsbgZ]h\hjbeZgZmklZj_\r_fr\_^kdhfyaud_ghihgbfZeZ\hijhkuaZ^Zggu__c
gZkh\j_f_gghfr\_^kdhf
G_h[uqguckemqZcijhbahr_egZk_Zgk_kh\_lkdh]hZjlbklZ]bighlba_jZ<Ze_jby
:\^__\Z <gmrZy ajbl_eyf ih`_eZ\rbf mqZkl\h\Zlv \ wdki_jbf_gl_ j_]j_kkbx
\j_f_gbdh]^ZdZ`^ucbagbo^he`_ggZqZlv`blvijhrehc`bagvxZjlbklkdZaZe³:
k_cqZk]h^^hgh\hcwjuQlhijhbkoh^blk \Zfb"´D bamfe_gbxi_j_iheg_ggh]h
aZeZ h^bg ba bkiulm_fuo kheb^guc fm`qbgZ e_l khjhdZ \ kljh]hf q_jghf dhklxf_
ijb]Zeklmd_g_h`b^Zggh\klZegZq_l\_j_gvdbaZijhdbgme]heh\m\\_jobaZ\ueih
\heqvb >Z lZd ]jhfdh b _kl_kl\_ggh qlh m fgh]bo gZ[ex^Z\rbo wlm kp_gm fmjZrdb
ih[_`Zebihdh`_
E I =jbfZd ki_pbZebkl ih ]bigham b j_a_j\guf \hafh`ghklyf q_eh\_q_kdhc
ikbobdb h[tykgyy kemqZc ijhbkr_^rbc gZ k_Zgk_ <Ze_jby :\^__\Z kqblZ_l qlh \
^ZgghfkemqZ_ijhy\bekyohlyb \mk_q_gghf\b^_wnn_dlj_bgdZjgZpbbi_j_k_e_gby
^mr
Dhgp_ipby j_bgdZjgZpbb ijbgylZy g_dhlhjufb kh\j_f_ggufb mq_gufb b
ikbobZljZfbiha\hey_lmki_rghkijZ\eylvkyk g_dhlhjufbikbobq_kdbfb[he_agyfb²
g_\jhaZfbnh[byfbLZde_lgbcbg`_g_jbkiulu\Zeg_h[tykgbfuckljZob [hev\
kibg_ _keb aZ gbf reb ^\Zljb q_eh\_dZ <h \j_fy j_]j_kkbb \ha\jZs_gby iZfylb h
ijhreuo `bagyo hg m\b^_e qlh dh]^Zlh [ue m[bl \uklj_ehf \ kibgm < lhf f_kl_
dm^Z\hreZimeym g_]h[ueZjh^bgdZIhke_jZatykgbl_evghc[_k_^ukljZoijhr_e
L_hjb_c j_bgdZjgZpbb g_dhlhju_ bkke_^h\Zl_eb iulZxlky h[tykgblv b
ihjZabl_evgu_iZjZee_eb\ `bagbg_dhlhjuoagZf_gbluoebqghkl_cLZdGZihe_hgZb
=ble_jZ ihqlb \h \k_o djmiguo kh[ulbyo `bagb jZa^_eyxl e_l Z Zf_jbdZgkdbo
ij_ab^_glh\ :\jZZfZ EbgdhevgZ b >`hgZ D_gg_^b ² e_l I_j\uc dZd ba\_klgh
klZe ij_ab^_glhf \ , ]h^m \lhjhc \ , ]h^m B lhl b ^jm]hc [ueb ba[jZgu \
dhg]j_kkgZf ]h^m`bagbI_j_^\klmie_gb_f\ ^he`ghklvij_ab^_glZb Ebgdhevgb
D_gg_^b [ueb qe_gZfb iZeZlu ij_^klZ\bl_e_c < k\hbo j_qZo hgb hohlgh pblbjh\Zeb
R_dkibjZb ;b[ebxH[Z\uklmiZebaZjZ\ghijZ\b_g_]jh\H[Zihevah\Zebkvdj_kehf
dZqZedhc Ebgdhevg ² qlh[u jZkkeZ[blvky Z D_gg_^b ² qlh[u h[e_]qblv [heb \
iha\hghqgbd_ DZ`^uc bf_e ih ljb j_[_gdZ ba dhlhjuo h^bg mf_j \ i_jbh^
ij_ab^_glkl\ZhlpZH[Z[uebm[blu\uklj_ehf\ ]heh\mb lhlb ^jm]hc²\ iylgbpm
L_Zlj\ dhlhjhf[uem[blEbgdhevggZau\Zekyl_ZljhfNhj^ZFZrbgZ\ dhlhjhc_oZe
D_gg_^b[ueZfZjdb³Nhj^Ebgdhevg´K_dj_lZjvEbgdhevgZghkbenZfbebxD_gg_^b
b g_ kh\_lh\Ze ij_ab^_glm b^lb \ l_Zlj K_dj_lZjv D_gg_^b ghkbe lhqg__ ghkbeZ
nZfbebxEbgdhevgb hgZm]h\Zjb\ZeZD_gg_^bg__oZlv\ >ZeeZkIj_ab^_glhf ihke_
EbgdhevgZ klZe Wg^jx >`hgkhg ]h^ jh`^_gby ² ij_ab^_glhf ihke_ D_gg_^b
klZeEbg^hg>`hgkhg]h^jh`^_gby²
M qblZl_ey_kl_kl\_gghfh`_l\hagbdgmlvaZdhghf_jguc\hijhkZ dZdke_^m_l
hlghkblvky dh \k_f ijb\_^_gguf nZdlZf \jh^_ [u iheghklvx ih^l\_j`^Zxsbf
j_bgdZjgZpbx"LZdqlh`_^_ckl\bl_evghkms_kl\m_li_j_\hiehs_gb_^mr"G_[m^_f
hdhgqZl_evghml\_j`^ZlvqlhlZdhghb _klvWlhebrvh^ghbah[tykg_gbcqj_a\uqZcgh
keh`guob g_kh\k_f_s_ihgylguoijhy\e_gbcg_hkhagZ\Z_fhckn_ju\ukr_cg_j\ghc
^_yl_evghklbGZmdZ_s_g_\ khklhygbb^Zlvbkq_jiu\Zxsbohl\_lh\gZ\k_aZljhgmlu_
\ wlhc ]eZ\_ \hijhku >Z\Zcl_ emqr_ jZkkfhljbf ^jm]b_ \a]ey^u gZ ihkf_jlgh_
kms_kl\h\Zgb_^mrb
EBL?J:LMJ:
Djmr_evgbpdbc ? Q_]h g_ [ueh kh fghc ² ihfgx ³Kljhbl_evgZy ]Za_lZ´ Z\]mklZ³BklhjZfZ´IZjb`yg\Zjy
ChoZgg_k;mleZj ;ueZeb`_gsbgZfm`qbghc"D\bdFxgo_g²pblih³FZjbckdZy
ijZ\^Z´fZjlZ
>bh]_gEZwjlkdbc H `bagbmq_gbyob baj_q_gbyoagZf_gbluonbehkhnh\F
Fukev LhdZj_\K: JZggb_nhjfuj_eb]bbF³Iheblba^Zl´
EmdqZg Ba[jZggZyijhaZFIjZ\^Z
<Zkbev_\EE LZbgkl\_ggu_y\e_gbyq_eh\_q_kdhcikbobdbF
W^\Zj^njwgd KljZggu_ex^bEkh\f_klgh_kh\_lkdhnbgkdh_ij_^ijbylb_³KfZjl´
³GhlZ[_g_´³Kljhbl_evgZy]Za_lZ´Z\]mklZ
Dhgh\Zeh\<N @_eZ_fh_beb^_ckl\bl_evgh_"³AgZd\hijhkZ´‹ FZjlugh\: Bkih\_^bfucimlvF³Ijhf_l_c´F=IBbfE_gbgZ
LZcehjW; I_j\h[ulgZydmevlmjZF³Iheblba^Zl´
?j_fbgZ<B JblmZeb nhevdehjE³GZmdZ´
Nbe^bg]=_gjb Ba[jZggu_khqbg_gbyF³Om^h`_kl\_ggZyebl_jZlmjZ´
=E:<:;;,,,
?ebk_ckdb_iheyb jZckdb_kZ^uW^_fZ
< wlhc ]eZ\_ fu ihiulZ_fky jZkkfhlj_lv \lhjh_ [he__ jZkijhkljZg_ggh_
ij_^klZ\e_gb_ dZkZxs__ky km^v[u ^mr ihdhcgbdh\ dhlhjh_ khklhbl \ \_j_ \ hkh[uc
fbj^mr³lhlk\_l´dm^ZhgbhlijZ\eyxlkyihke_l_e_kghckf_jlbq_eh\_dZWlZ\_jZ
_klv_^\Zebg_m \k_ogZjh^h\a_fgh]hrZjZohlyb k[hevrbfbjZaebqbyfb
DZd m`_ ]h\hjbehkv \ ;,, ]eZ\_ ^Zgghc dgb]b Zf_jbdZgkdb_ klZlbklbdb
ih^kqblZeb qlh _keb gZk_e_gb_ \k_c ieZg_lu ijhihjpbhgZevgh ij_^klZ\blv \ \b^_
^_j_\gb k gZk_e_gb_f \ q_eh\_d lh \ g_c khhl\_lkl\_ggh [m^ml ijh`b\Zlv ojbklbZg dZlhebdZ ijhl_klZglZ ijZ\hkeZ\guo fmkmevfZg bg^mbklh\ [m^^bklh\ Zgbfbklh\ Zgbfbaf ² j_eb]bhagu_ \_jh\Zgby
i_j\h[ulguogZjh^h\kqblZxsboqlhdZ`^Zy\_svbf__lk\hc^mob Zl_bklh\
LZd \hl _keb bkdexqblv Zgbfbklh\ qvb ij_^klZ\e_gby h ihkf_jlghf
kms_kl\h\Zgbb^mrb\_kvfZjZaghh[jZagub g_^hklZlhqghhnhjfe_gulhhdZ`_lkyqlh
\ i_j_k_e_gb_ ^mr \_jbl q_eh\_dZ ba lukyqb ijh`b\Zxsbo \ wlhc ]eh[Zevghc
^_j_\g_ bg^mbklh\ b [m^^bklh\ Z hnhjfe_ggufb ij_^klZ\e_gbyfb h
kms_kl\h\ZgbbaZ]jh[gh]hfbjZh[eZ^Zxlq_eh\_dojbklbZgb fmkmevfZg
l_ihqlbiheh\bgZgZk_e_gbygZr_cieZg_lu
Hq_gv ljm^gh kbkl_fZlbabjh\Zlv jZaghh[jZagu_ ij_^klZ\e_gby bf_xsb_ky ih
wlhfmij_^f_lm\ \_jh\ZgbyojZaguogZjh^h\l_f[he__qlhb b^_bdZ`^h]hhl^_evgh
\aylh]hgZjh^Zh aZ]jh[ghffbj_^mrh[uqgh^Ze_dbhlykghklb
M gZb[he__ hlklZeuo gZjh^h\ b^_b h f_klhij_[u\Zgbb fbjZ ^mr ^h djZcghklb
kfmlgu fbj ^mr gZoh^blky ]^_lh ^Ze_dh ijb wlhf bgh]^Z mdZau\Z_lky hij_^_e_ggh_
gZijZ\e_gb_ gZ k_\_j_ gZ aZiZ^_ gZ \hklhd_ ?klv hkgh\Zgby ^mfZlv qlh wlh
gZijZ\e_gb_ mdZau\Z_lky g_ kemqZcgh hgh \b^bfh khhl\_lkl\m_l lhfm gZijZ\e_gbx
hldm^Z\ ijhrehfrehi_j_k_e_gb_ie_f_gbeb[hdZdh_lhdmevlmjgh_\ebygb_
M ijbfhjkdbo gZjh^h\ b hkljh\blyg hkh[_ggh \ Hd_Zgbb rbjhdh
jZkijhkljZg_gh ij_^klZ\e_gb_ h aZ]jh[ghf fbj_ gZoh^ys_fky ]^_lh aZ fhj_f gZ
hkljh\_ Dhjgb wlbo ij_^klZ\e_gbc ^\hydb k h^ghc klhjhgu a^_kv g_khfg_ggh
kdZaZebkv kfmlgu_ \hkihfbgZgby fhjkdbo i_j_k_e_gbc dhlhju_ hklZ\beb \ khagZgbb
ex^_ciZfylvh kljZg_ij_^dh\e_`Zs_caZfhj_fK ^jm]hcklhjhgua^_kv\hafh`gh
hljZabehkv\ebygb_ijZdlbdb\h^ygh]hih]j_[_gbyhkh[_ggh\ __[he__keh`ghcnhjf_
²hlijZ\e_gb_ljmiZ\ eh^d_\ hldjulh_fhj__]hdZd [u ihkueZxl \ aZfhjkdbc fbj
^mr < lhc `_ Hd_Zgbb ba\_klgh b [ebadh_ d ij_^u^ms_fm ih\_jv_ h fbj_ ^mr ih^
\h^hc <_jhylg__ \k_]h qlh lZdh_ ij_^klZ\e_gb_ lZd`_ ijyfh ihjh`^_gh ijZdlbdhc
\h^ygh]hih]j_[_gby
Hq_gvrbjhdhjZkijhkljZg_ghm gZjh^h\\k_okljZgij_^klZ\e_gb_h ih^a_fghf
fbj_ ^mr <iheg_ ijZ\^hih^h[gh ij_^iheh`_gb_ g_dhlhjuo Z\lhjh\ qlh gZ wlh
ij_^klZ\e_gb_ ih\ebye h[uqZc aZju\Zlv ihdhcgbdh\ \ a_fex eb[h ohjhgblv bo \
i_s_jZo <i_j\u_ wlZ b^_y [ueZ \ukdZaZgZ _s_ Pbp_jhghf Gh [ueb b ^jm]b_ dhjgb
lZdh]h ih\_jvy \ qZklghklb mdZau\Zxl gZ k\yav _]h k \medZgbafhf ]^_ _klv
^_ckl\mxsb_\medZgulZfg_j_^dhbf__lky\_jh\Zgb_qlh^mrbmf_jrboq_j_adjZl_j
\medZgZ kimkdZxlky \ ih^a_fguc fbj LZd h[klhbl ^_eh gZijbf_j \ X`ghc
F_eZg_abb <_am\bc WlgZ b =_deZ ^Z`_ \h \j_f_gZ ojbklbZgkl\Z kqblZebkv f_klZfb
qbklbebsZ beb ^Z`_ hl\_jklbyfb lhc ijhiZklb \ dhlhjmx gba\_j]Zebkv ^mrb
]j_rgbdh\
GZdhg_p\ ^j_\gb_b gh\u_ \j_f_gZ ex^yf ijboh^beh \ ]heh\m ba[bjZlv g_[h
khegp_emgmb a\_a^uf_klhfij_[u\Zgbyhlhr_^rbo^mr
Kj_^b h[jZah\ \ dhlhjuo q_eh\_q_kl\h jbkm_l k_[_ [m^msmx `bagv ke_^m_l
jZaebqZlv^\Z]eZ\g_crboij_^klZ\e_gbyH^ghbagbobah[jZ`Z_l[m^msmx`bagvdZd
hljZ`_gb_ gZklhys_c \ gh\hf fbj_ q_eh\_d m^_j`b\Z_l a_fgmx nhjfm b mkeh\by
ij_`g_]h kms_kl\h\Zgby `b\_l f_`^m a_fgufb ^jmavyfb \eZ^__l k\h_c a_fghc
kh[kl\_gghklvx b aZgbfZ_lky h[uqgufb a_fgufb ^_eZfb Ih ^jm]hfm ij_^klZ\e_gbx
[m^msZy `bagv _klv \hagZ]jZ`^_gb_ aZ gZklhysmx b m^_e q_eh\_dZ lZf y\ey_lky
ke_^kl\b_f _]h a_fghc `bagb gZ]jZ^hc beb gZdZaZgb_f aZ g__ W ; LZcehj h^bg ba
\u^Zxsboky bklhjbdh\ dmevlmju b j_eb]bb i_j\mx ba wlbo b^_c gZau\Ze ³l_hjb_c
ijh^he`_gby kms_kl\h\Zgby´ Z \lhjmx ijhlb\hihklZ\eyy __ i_j\hc² ³l_hjb_c
\haf_a^by´
D mq_gbxh ijh^he`_gbbkms_kl\h\Zgbyhlghkblkyij_bfms_kl\_ggh\haaj_gb_
^bdZj_c gZ kljZgm ^moh\ dZd gZ ijbajZqgmx h[eZklv ³]^_ ^mrZ mf_jr_]h dZj_gZ k
ihfhsvx ^mr _]h lhihjZ b k_jiZ kljhbl k_[_ ^hf b kj_aZ_l jbk L_gv Ze]hgdbgkdh]h
hohlgbdZ hohlblky aZ ^mrZfb [h[jZ b ehky kdhevay ih ^mr_ kg_]Z gZ ^mr_ eu`
AZdmlZgguc \ rm[m dZfqZ^Ze _a^bl \ kZgyo gZ kh[ZdZo Amemk ^hbl k\hx dhjh\m b
aZ]hgy_lkdhlbgm\ djZZev´
M gZjh^h\ijhkeZ\b\rbokyk\h_c\hbgkl\_gghklvx\_jZ\ \hafh`ghklvihiZklv
ihke_ kf_jlb \ [he__ kqZkleb\h_ f_klh kem`bl dZd [u j_eb]bhaguf hljZ`_gb_f b
hk\_s_gb_f \hbgkdhc wlbdb ih^h[gh_ f_klh m]hlh\Zgh ojZ[juf \hbgZf ih]b[rbf \
[hxLZdh_ih\_jv_hkh[_ggh[uehjZkijhkljZg_ghm bg^_cp_\K_\_jghc:f_jbdbhgh
ba\_klgh b m gZjh^h\ ^jm]bo qZkl_c k\_lZ GZb[he__ ba\_klguc ijbf_j ² ^j_\gb_
kdZg^bgZ\u k bo \_jhc \ k\_lemx <Ze]Zeem h[bl_ev ^mr iZ\rbo \hbgh\ Hllm^Z hgb
dZ`^h_mljh\ [h_\hfihjy^d_\u_a`ZxlgZjZ\gbgmH^bgZb [vxlky^jm]k ^jm]hfihdZ
`j_[bcg_gZf_lbl`_jl\dZdb \a_fguokjZ`_gbyoDh]^ZgZklmiZ_lh[_^_ggh_\j_fy
ih[_^bl_ebb ih[_`^_ggu_kZ^ylkygZdhg_cb \ha\jZsZxlky^hfhc_klv\_qgh]hdZ[ZgZ
b iblvf_^b ib\h
H[_ khi_jgbqZxsb_ f_`^m kh[hc l_hjbb ² ijh^he`_gby ij_`g_]h
kms_kl\h\Zgbyb \haf_a^by²\klj_qZxlky\ ihmqbl_evghfkh_^bg_gbb\ deZkkbq_kdhc
=j_pbb b Jbf_ ;he__ klZjuf \_jh\Zgbyf khhl\_lkl\m_l pZjkl\h :b^Z \ jbfkdhc
fbnheh]bb ² Hjdmk beb Hjd WlZ fjZqgZy h[eZklv [_kl_e_kguo iZjhh[jZaguo ^moh\
y\ey_lky h[blZebs_f [_ajZaebqghc mkj_^g_gghc lheiu H^gh\j_f_ggh k wlbf \
Zglbqguo ij_^klZ\e_gbyo m`_ nb]mjbjm_l km^bebs_ FbghkZ JZ^ZfZglZ b WZdZ
[eZ`_gkl\h ?ebk_ckdbo ihe_c ^ey kijZ\_^eb\uo b ^h[juo \ jbfkdhc fbnheh]bb ²
Webabmf b h]g_gguc LZjlZj gZiheg_gguc klhgZfb ]j_rgbdh\ hljZ`Zxsb_ [he__
iha^gb_mq_gbyh gjZ\kl\_gghf\ha^Zygbb
>Z\Zcl_hklZgh\bfkyg_kdhevdhih^jh[g__gZij_^klZ\e_gbyoZglbqgh]hfbjZh
ihkf_jlghf kms_kl\h\Zgbb ^mrb >j_\gb_ ]j_db ij_^klZ\eyeb k_[_ pZjkl\h :b^Z
pZjkl\h ^mr mf_jrbo fjZqguf b kljZrguf Z ³aZ]jh[gmx `bagv´ ² g_kqZklv_f
G_^Zjhf l_gv :obeeZ \ua\ZggZy H^bkk__f ba ih^a_fgh]h fbjZ ]h\hjbl qlh emqr_
[ulvihke_^gbf[ZljZdhfgZa_fe_q_fpZj_f\ pZjkl\_:b^Z
< i_qZevgh_pZjkl\h:b^Zgbdh]^Zg_ijhgbdZxlemqbkhegpZhghiheghfjZdZb
m`Zkh\;_a^hggu_ijhiZklb\_^mllm^Zk ih\_joghklba_febQ_j_afjZqgmxjZks_ebgm
m k_e_gby DhehgZ hdheh :nbg ijhgbdeb \ pZjkl\h l_g_c Zglbqgu_ ]_jhb L_k_c b
I_cjbnhc k gZf_j_gb_f ihoblblv kmijm]m :b^Z I_jk_nhgm Q_j_a l_fgmx i_s_jm m
fukZLwgZjl_i_jvfukFZlZiZggZx`ghchdhg_qghklbI_ehihgg_kZkimkdZeky\ :b^
Hjn_c gZ^_ykv \_jgmlv W\jb^bdm Q_j_a lm `_ ijhiZklv m fukZ LwgZj \ EZdhgbb
ijh[jZeky d [_j_]Zf k\ys_ggh]h KlbdkZ =_jZde klj_fykv m\_klb ba :b^Z kljZrgh]h
D_j[_jZ
FjZqgu_j_dbl_dml\ :b^_LZfijhl_dZ_l\k_e_^_gysZyk\ys_ggZyj_dZKlbdk
\h^Zfb dhlhjhc deygmlky kZfb [h]b DZlyl lZf k\hb \hegu Dhpbl b :o_jhgl ^mrb
mf_jrboh]eZrZxlk\hbfkl_gZgb_fihegufi_qZebbofjZqgu_[_j_]Z< ih^a_fghf
pZjkl\_ kljmylky b ^Zxsb_ aZ[\_gb_ \k_]h a_fgh]h \h^u bklhqgbdZ E_lu >mrb
mf_jrbo oe_[gm\rb_ ebrv h^bg ]ehlhd ba E_lu aZ[u\Zxl h k\h_c ijhrehc `bagb
hlkx^Z\ujZ`_gb_³dZgmeh\ E_lm´l_aZ[ulhgZ\k_]^Z
IhfjZqgufiheyfpZjkl\Z:b^ZaZjhkrbf[e_^gufbp\_lZfb^bdh]hlxeviZgZ
Zknh^_eZghkylky[_kiehlgu_l_gbmf_jrboHgbk_lmxlgZk\hx[_ajZ^hklgmx`bagv
[_a k\_lZ b [_a `_eZgbc Lboh jZa^Zxlky bo klhgu _^\Z meh\bfu_ ih^h[gu_ r_e_klm
m\y^rbo ebklv_\ ]hgbfuo hk_ggbf \_ljhf G_l gbdhfm \ha\jZlZ ba wlh]h pZjkl\Z
i_qZeb Lj_o]heh\uc [_kkhgguc i_k D_j[_j P_j[_j klhjh`bl \uoh^ ba :b^Z K
dZ`^hc ba lj_o r_c wlh]h ikZ kiZ^Z_l \gba ]mklZy ]jb\Z ba kljZrguo y^h\bluo af_b
<f_klh o\hklZ m D_j[_jZ \ujhk k\bj_iuc ^jZdhg dhlhjuc k\b\Z_lky \ dhevpZ
\ukh\u\Z_lhkljh_`Zehb rbibl
Q_j_a \h^u k\ys_ggh]h KlbdkZ gZ eZ^v_ ^mrb mf_jrbo i_j_\habl kmjh\uc
klZjuc OZjhg IeZlhc aZ i_j_\ha kem`bl f_edZy f_^gZy fhg_ldZ h[he dhlhjmx
\deZ^u\Zeb \ jhl mf_jr_fm Bgl_j_kgh qlh wlhl ^j_\gbc h[uqZc ijhc^y q_j_a ^\Z
lukyq_e_lbyojbklbZgkl\Z\k_lZdbdh_]^_khojZgbekyBa\_klgucjmkkdbcbklhjbdF
B Iuey_\ k\b^_l_evkl\m_l ³< klZjbgm kms_kl\h\Ze _s_ hklZlhd yauq_kl\Z dhlhjuc
dZ`_lkym g_dhlhjuodmiph\\ I_l_j[mj]_kms_kl\m_lihk_cqZk< jhlmf_jr_]hdeZ^ml
f_edb_^_gv]b[m^lh[u^eyba^_j`_d\ ^Zevg_c^hjh]_´
Ghgb aZdZdb_khdjh\bsZOZjhgg_ih\_a_lgb h^gm^mrmh[jZlghlm^Z]^_yjdh
k\_lblkhegp_`bagbGZ\_qgh_[_ajZ^hklgh_kms_kl\h\Zgb_h[j_q_gu^mrbmf_jrbo\
fjZqghfpZjkl\_:b^Z
< wlhf pZjkl\_ ^h dhlhjh]h g_ ^hoh^yl gb k\_l gb jZ^hklb gb i_qZeb a_fghc
`bagb ijZ\bl [jZl A_\kZ :b^ Iemlhg Hg kb^bl gZ ahehlhf ljhg_ kh k\h_c `_ghc
I_jk_nhghc ?fm kem`Zl g_mfhebfu_ [h]bgb fs_gby Wjbgbb =jhagu_ k [bqZfb b
af_yfb ij_ke_^mxl hgb ij_klmigbdZ g_ ^Zxl _fm gb fbgmlu ihdhy b l_jaZxl _]h
m]jua_gbyfbkh\_klb
M ljhgZ:b^Zkb^ylkm^vbpZjkl\Zmf_jrbo²FbghkJZ^ZfZglb WZdKugh\vy
A_\kZ b kf_jlguo `_gsbg [m^mqb fm^jufb ijZ\bl_eyfb gZ A_fe_ ihke_ kf_jlb hgb
k^_eZebkvkm^vyfbaZ]jh[gh]hfbjZKh]eZkghIeZlhgmWZdkm^be_\jhi_cp_\JZ^ZfZgl
²ZabZlh\Z Fbghkj_rZekhfgbl_evgu_kemqZb
A^_kv`_m ljhgZ :b^Z gZoh^blky [h] kf_jlb LZgZl k f_qhf \ jmdZo \ q_jghf
ieZs_k ]jhfZ^gufbq_jgufbdjuevyfbIjbe_lZ_lLZgZld eh`mmfbjZxs_]hqlh[u
kj_aZlvk\hbff_qhfijy^v\hehkk _]h]heh\ub bklhj]gmlv^mrmEbrv_^bgkl\_gghfm
ba kf_jlguo obljhmfghfm pZjx DhjbgnZ Kbabnm m^Zehkv h[fZgmlv LZgZlZ
Ihqm\kl\h\Z\ijb[eb`_gb_[h]Zkf_jlbKbabndh\ZjghaZdh\Ze_]h\ hdh\uI_j_klZeb
lh]^Z gZ a_fe_ mfbjZlv ex^b gb]^_ [hevr_ g_ kh\_jrZebkv iurgu_ ihohjhgu
i_j_klZeb ijbghkblv `_jl\u [h]Zf ih^a_fgh]h pZjkl\Z GZjmrbeky gZ a_fe_ ihjy^hd
aZ\_^_gguc A_\khf Lh]^Z ]jhfh\_j`_p ihkeZe d Kbabnm fh]mq_]h [h]Z \hcgu :j_kZ
dhlhjuc hk\h[h^be LZgZlZ ba hdh\ LZgZl bklhj] ^mrm KbabnZ b hl\_e __ \ pZjkl\h
l_g_c ]^_ hgZ [ueZ hkm`^_gZ \_qgh \dZlu\Zlv gZ \ukhdmx djmlmx ]hjm ]jhfZ^guc
dZf_gvdhlhjucgbdh]^Zg_m^Z_lkyaZdZlu\ZlvgZ\_jrbgm
Jy^hfk LZgZlhf\ :b^_ gZoh^ylky b fjZqgu_ D_ju GZ k\hbo djuevyo ghkylky
hgb g_bklh\u_ ih ihex [bl\u D_ju ebdmxl \b^y dZd h^bg aZ ^jm]bf iZ^Zxl
kjZ`_ggu_ ]_jhb k\hbfb djh\Z\hdjZkgufb ]m[Zfb ijbiZ^Zxl hgb d jZgZf `Z^gh
ivxl]hjyqmxdjh\vkjZ`_gguob \uju\Zxlbal_eZbo^mrb
< j_eb]bb^j_\gbo_\j__\f_klhij_[u\Zgb_mf_jrboR_he[uehl_kghk\yaZgh
k BjdZehc\Z\behghZkkbjbckdhcj_eb]bbfjZqgufih^a_fgufm[_`bs_fkhklhysbf
ba k_fb djm]h\hldm^Zq_eh\_dmg_l\ha\jZlZWlh²i_s_jZijhiZklvih^a_fgZy]em[v
[_a ^gZ LZd dZd ^j_\gb_ _\j_ckdb_ ibkZl_eb b ijhjhdb g_ h[ty\eyeb jmdh\h^ysbfb
gZqZeZfb a_fghc `bagb q_eh\_dZ gZ^_`^u gZ \_qgh_ [eZ`_gkl\h beb kljZo \_qguo
fmq_gbclhhgbebrvg_ykghhq_jlbebmq_gb_h [m^ms_c`bagbghl_fg_f_g__fukeb
\ukdZaZggu_ bfb fbfhoh^hf \iheg_ hijZ\^u\Zxl i_j_\h^qbdh\ i_j_^Zxsbo R_he
keh\hf³:b^´gZijbf_j\ agZf_gblhf]j_q_kdhfi_j_\h^_<_loh]hAZ\_lZK_ilmZ]bglZ
²³i_j_\h^_k_fb^_kylblhedh\gbdh\´
BlZdR_he^j_\gbobm^__\hq_gvgZihfbgZ_lZglbqguc:b^b _fmkhhl\_lkl\m_l
l_hjby ³ijh^he`_gby kms_kl\h\Zgby´ Ih^h[gu_ ij_^klZ\e_gby h `bagb l_g_c ih^
a_fe_cg_bkq_aebb lh]^Zdh]^Z\ [he__iha^gbci_jbh^m _\j__\ijhbahr_edhj_gghc
i_j_\hjhl \ \_jh\Zgbyo dh]^Z ij_`gb_ mq_gby h ijbajZqghf ijh^he`_gbb `bagb
mklmibeb f_klh mq_gbx h \hkdj_k_gbb b \haf_a^bb >j_\g__ ij_^klZ\e_gby ijhgbdeb
^Z`_ \ dZlhebq_kdmx e_]_g^m gZc^y hljZ`_gb_ \ bdhgZo bah[jZ`Zxsbo OjbklZ
gbkoh^ysbf\ Z^qlh[u\u\_klbhllm^ZiZljbZjoh\
GZb[he__ ihegh ³l_hjby \haf_a^by´ jZajZ[hlZgZ \ ojbklbZgkdhc j_eb]bb b
bkeZf_
Kh]eZkghojbklbZgkdhfm\_jhmq_gbxh ihkf_jlghckm^v[_^mrbhgZijh^he`Z_l
`blv ihke_ kf_jlb b ihfgbl \k_ qlh k g_c [ueh < l_q_gb_ i_j\uo ^\mo ^g_c ihke_
kf_jlb ^mrZ gZkeZ`^Z_lky hlghkbl_evghc k\h[h^hc b fh`_l \f_kl_ k gZoh^ysbfbky
ijb g_c :g]_eZfb ihk_sZlv gZ a_fe_ l_ f_klZ dhlhju_ _c ^hjh]b Ihwlhfm ^mrZ
ex[ysZy l_eh kdblZ_lky bgh]^Z hdheh ^hfZ \ dhlhjhf jZaemqbeZkv k l_ehf bgh]^Z
hdheh ]jh[Z \ dhlhjuc iheh`_gh l_eh b lZdbf h[jZahf ijh\h^bl ^\Z ^gy dZd ilbpZ
bsZk_[_]g_a^h< lj_lbc`_^_gv=hkih^vih\_e_\Z_l\hag_klbkv\kydhcojbklbZgkdhc
^mr_gZg_[_kZ
< wlh\j_fygZlj_lbc^_gv^mrZijhoh^blihimlbd g_[mq_j_ae_]bhguaeuo
^moh\ dhlhju_ ij_]jZ`^Zxl _c imlv b h[\bgyxl \ jZaebqguo ]j_oZo Wlh bkiulZgb_
gZau\Z_lky ³\ha^mrgufb fulZjkl\Zfb´ ^mrb < gZr_f ihgylbb keh\h ³fulZjkl\h´
h[uqghk\yaZghk lZdbfbihgylbyfbdZd³kdblZgb_´³fmq_gb_´H^gZdhwlhg_kh\k_f
lZd <kihfgbf _\Zg]_evkdb_ ijblqb h fulZjyo Dlh lZdhc ³fulZjv´ ² k[hjsbd
ih^Zl_c" < [he]Zjkdhf yaud_ khojZgb\r_f \ hlebqb_ hl jmkkdh]h ]hjZa^h [hevr_
klZjhkeZ\ygkdbo dhjg_c ³fblgbpZ´ hagZqZ_l lZfh`gx BlZd fulZjkl\Z ^mrb fh`gh
jZkkfZljb\ZlvdZdijhoh`^_gb__xk\h_h[jZaguolZfh`_gguodhj^hgh\gZimlbd g_[m
Kh]eZkgh jZaebqguf hldjh\_gbyf k\yluo kms_kl\m_l ^\Z^pZlv lZdbo ij_iylkl\bc
³fulZjkl\´ gZ dZ`^hf ba dhlhjuo bkiulu\Z_lky lhl beb bghc ]j_o ijZa^ghkeh\by
e`b hkm`^_gby b de_\_lu qj_\hm]h^by e_ghklb djZ`b kj_[jhex[by b kdmihklb
ebohbfkl\Z g_ijZ\^u aZ\bklb ]hj^hklb ]g_\Z b yjhklb aeZ gZ [eb`g_]h m[bckl\Z
qZjh^_ckl\Z [em^Z ij_ex[h^_ygby kh^hfbb _j_k_c `_klhdhk_j^by Ijhc^y h^gh
fulZjkl\h ^mrZ ijboh^bl gZ ke_^mxs__ b lhevdh ijhc^y mki_rgh \k_ bo fh`_l
ijh^he`blvk\hcimlvg_[m^mqbg_f_^e_ggh\\_j]gmlhc\ Z^
Mki_rgh ijhc^y q_j_a fulZjkl\Z b ihdehgb\rbkv ;h]m ^mrZ _s_ gZ
ijhly`_gbb^g_cihk_sZ_lg_[_kgu_h[bl_ebb Z^kdb_[_a^gu_s_g_agZy]^_hgZ
hklZg_lky b lhevdh gZ khjhdh\hc ^_gv gZagZqZ_lky _c f_klh ^h \hkdj_k_gby f_jl\uo
Kh]eZkgh hldjh\_gbx Zg]_eZ ij_ih^h[ghfm FZdZjbx :e_dkZg^jbckdhfm hkh[h_
p_jdh\gh_ ihfbgh\_gb_ mkhirbo gZ ^_\yluc ^_gv ihke_ kf_jlb k\yaZgh k l_f qlh ^h
k_]h \j_f_gb k lj_lv_]h ih ^_\yluc ^_gv ^Zevr_ ihdZau\Zeb djZkhlu jZy b lhevdh
ihke_wlh]hk ^_\ylh]hihkhjhdh\hc^_gv_cihdZau\Zxlfmq_gbyb m`ZkuZ^ZBlZd
kh]eZkgh ijZ\hkeZ\ghfm ojbklbZgkdhfm dZghgm ^ey ih^^_j`Zgby ^mrb g_h[oh^bfh
kh\_jrZlvihfbgZgbygZcc bc ^gbihke_kf_jlb
< ij_^^\_jbb \k_e_gkdh]h KljZrgh]h km^Z agZf_gmxs_]h Dhg_p K\_lZ
\hkdj_k_gb_ ba f_jl\uo b hdhgqZl_evgh_ b \_qgh_ hkm`^_gb_ ]j_rgbdh\ \
ojbklbZgkdbo^h]fZlZokms_kl\m_lb hij_^_e_gb_qZklgh]hkm^Zihf_sZxs_]h^mrb^h
KljZrgh]hKm^Z\ :^beb\ JZc
:^ kh]eZkgh ojbklbZgkdbf dhgp_ipbyf ² wlh f_klh ihkf_jlguo fmq_gbc
]j_rgbdh\ DZd fu m`_ ibkZeb \ <_lohf aZ\_l_ _fm khhl\_lkl\m_l _\j_ckdh_ keh\h
³r_he´beb]j_q_kdh_³]Z^_k´dhlhjh_h[udgh\_gghi_j_\h^blkykeh\hf³ij_bkih^gyy´
< Gh\hf AZ\_l_ \klj_qZ_lky keh\h ³]__ggZ´ ² ]j_q_kdZy nhjfZ _\j_ckdh]h keh\Z
³]_o_ggZ´ beb ³=_Obgghf´ qlh hagZqZ_l ³?gghfh\Z ^hebgZ´ < ?gghfh\hc ^hebg_ d
x]m hl B_jmkZebfZ gZoh^behkv f_klh gZau\Z_fh_ Lhn_l ]^_ b^hehihdehggbdb _\j_b
k`b]Zeb\ q_klvFhehoZk\hbo^_l_cPZjvBhkbyk p_evxbkdhj_gblvb^hehihdehgkl\h
ij_\jZlbe wlm ^hebgm \ k\Zedm g_qbklhl KfjZ^ r_^rbc ba ^hebgu k^_eZe __
\ihke_^kl\bb kbf\hehf Z^Z < lZdhf agZq_gbb mihlj_[ey_lky keh\h ³]__ggZ´ \ Gh\hf
AZ\_l_ \ f_klZo m lj_o i_j\uo _\Zg]_ebklh\ Bgh]^Z \klj_qZ_lky gZa\Zgb_ ³]__ggZ
h]g_ggZy´hghh[hagZqZ_l\_qguch]hgvZ^Z
IjZ\_^gbdbij_[u\Zxl\ jZxIhke_i_j_\h^Z<_loh]hAZ\_lZgZ]j_q_kdbcyaud
lhedh\gbdZfbK_ilmZ]bglZkeh\hjZcklZehh[uqgufgZa\Zgb_fW^_fkdh]hkZ^ZZ
\ iha^g_cr_f bm^_ckl\_ ² h[uqguf gZa\Zgb_f lh]h hl^_e_gby pZjkl\Z mf_jrbo ]^_
^mrb ijZ\_^gbdh\ h`b^Zxl \hkdj_k_gby I_j\hgZqZevgh W^_f l _ ³ijbylghklv´
h[hagZqZef_klhgZ<hklhd_]^_;h]gZkZ^bekZ^dhlhjufhl^Ze:^Zfm^ey`bl_evkl\Z
Ghdh]^Zex^bkh]j_rbebkt_\aZij_lgucieh^;h]ba]gZebobaW^_fkdh]hkZ^Z
>h\hevgh [ebadb d ojbklbZgkdbf fmkmevfZgkdb_ ij_^klZ\e_gby h aZ]jh[ghf
fbj_ hgb lZd`_ hkgh\Zgu gZ ³l_hjbb \haf_a^by´ < fmkmevfZgkdhc fbnheh]bb Zg]_e
kf_jlbBajZbe:ajZbeh^bgbaq_luj_o]eZ\guo Zg]_eh\ agZ_l km^v[u ex^_c gh g_
agZ_l kjhdb dhgqbgu dZ`^h]h Dh]^Z wlhl kjhd gZklmiZ_l k ^_j_\Z jZklms_]h m ljhgZ
:eeZoZke_lZ_lebklhdk bf_g_fh[j_q_ggh]hihke_q_]hBajZbe\ l_q_gb_khjhdZ^g_c
^he`_g jZaemqblv ^mrm b l_eh q_eh\_dZ Q_eh\_d fh`_l jZaebqgufb kihkh[Zfb
khijhlb\eylvkyBajZbemghlhl\k_]^Zih[_`^Z_l
M`_kjZamihke_kf_jlb\ fh]be_mf_jrbo^hijZrb\Zxl^\ZZg]_eZ²FmgdZj
b GZdbjIhwlhfmfh]beZm fmkmevfZg^_eZ_lkyih\hafh`ghklbijhklhjghch[uqghk
gbr_c \ [hdh\hc kl_g_ beb m]em[e_gb_f gZ ^g_ qlh[u mf_jrbc fh] ³k_klv´ ijb
ihy\e_gbbwlbo^\moZg]_eh\kf_jlb<_jmxsboZg]_eukf_jlbg_ljh]ZxlZ g_\_jguo
ba[b\Zxlklhevdh \j_f_gb kdhevdh ih`_eZ_l :eeZo Bgh]^Z bo kqblZxl b^_glbqgufb
Zg]_eZfojZgbl_eyf khijh\h`^Zxsbf dZ`^h]h q_eh\_dZ Bf_gZ FmgdZjZ b GZdbjZ
mihfbgZxlkylhevdh\ ij_^Zgbyo\ DhjZg_bf_gZwlboZg]_eh\g_gZau\Zxlky
< m]h^gh_ ^ey k_[y \j_fy :eeZo mgbqlh`Z_l \k_ kms__ gZ a_fe_ \hkdj_kbl
f_jl\uo b [m^_l \_jrblv km^ gZ^ ex^vfb =j_rgbdb [m^ml gba\_j]gmlu \ Z^
ijZ\_^gbdbh[j_lml[eZ`_gkl\h\ jZckdbokZ^Zo
H^gh ba hkgh\guo gZa\Zgbc :^Z l _ f_klZ dm^Z ihiZ^Zxl ihke_ kf_jlb
g_\_jgu_b ]j_rgbdb\ bkeZf_²^`ZoZggZfhl^j_\g__\j_ckdh]h=_Obgghf]__ggZ
Kbghgbfu ^`ZoZggZfZ ² ³h]hgv´ ³ieZfy´ ³ijhiZklv´ b l ^ @_jl\u ^`ZoZggZfZ
]hjyl\ h]g_³<kydbcjZadZdk]hlh\blkybodh`ZfuaZf_gbfbf^jm]hcdh`_cqlh[u
hgb \dmkbeb gZdZaZgb_´² ]h\hjblky \ DhjZg_ =j_rgbdb \ ^`ZoZggZf k\yaZgu
p_iyfb Hgb _^yl ieh^u ^_j_\Z aZddmf ih^h[gu_ ]heh\Zf rZclZgh\ ivxl dbiylhd
dhlhjuc ³jZkk_dZ_l bo \gmlj_gghklb´ b ]ghcgmx \h^m >jm]hc \b^ Z^kdbo fmd ²
`]mqbcoheh^
JZagu_ dZl_]hjbb ]j_rgbdh\ ihf_sZxl \ jZagu_ kehb Z^Z \oh^yl \ g_]h q_j_a
jZagu_ \hjhlZ >`ZoZggZf hojZgy_l Zg]_evkdZy kljZ`Z ³]jm[u_ b kbevgu_´ qbkeh
dhlhjuo²Bo\ha]eZ\ey_lZg]_eih bf_gb FZebd
< DhjZg_ h[gZjm`b\Zxlky we_f_glu ^\mo ij_^klZ\e_gbc h ijbjh^_ Z^Z
Kh]eZkgh h^ghfm wlh g_qlh \jh^_ kljZrgh]h juqZs_]h ³]hlh\h]h ehigmlv hl ]g_\Z´
`b\hlgh]h ih]ehsZxs_]h ]j_rgbdh\ Kh]eZkgh ^jm]hfm ij_^klZ\e_gbx wlh ]em[hdZy
ijhiZklv dm^Z \_^ml k_fv \hjhl Ihkl_i_ggh wlhl h[jZa [ue ^_lZebabjh\Zg dZd
\hjhgdhh[jZagucdjZl_jk dhgp_gljbq_kdbfbdjm]ZfbjZa^_eyxsbfbjZagu_dZl_]hjbb
]j_rgbdh\ LZdhc h[jZa Z^Z \hkoh^bl d ^j_\g_\hklhqghc ljZ^bpbb < fmkmevfZgkdhc
nhjf_ hg hdZaZe \ebygb_ b gZ kj_^g_\_dh\u_ _\jhi_ckdb_ ij_^klZ\e_gby h kljmdlmj_
Z^Z\ qZklghklbgZl_dhlhju_hljZabebkv\ ³;h`_kl\_gghcdhf_^bb´>Zgl_
< ihke_dhjZgghc ljZ^bpbb ijbh[j_e ihimeyjghklv h[jZa imlb ³kbjZl´ ²
lhgdh]h dZd \hehk b hkljh]h dZd f_q fhklZ ijhlygmlh]h gZ^ Z^hf b kem`Zs_]h ^ey
bkiulZgby \_jmxsbo IjZ\_^gbdb ijhoh^yl ih wlhfm fhklm ³k [ukljhlhc fhegbb´ Z
]j_rgbdb k\Zeb\Zxlky k g_]h \ ³abyxs__ Z^kdh_ [hehlh´ B^_y fhklZ ^ey bkiulZgby
\_jmxsbo aZbfkl\h\ZgZ fmkmevfZgZfb \b^bfh ba kbkl_fu ij_^klZ\e_gbc
ahjhZkljbcp_\ LZf [eZ]h_ [h`_kl\h <Zc \uklmiZxs__ aZsblgbdhf ijZ\_^guo
ijh\h^bl^mrbmf_jrboihfhklmQbg\Zl
F_klh ]^_ ijZ\_^gbdb h[j_lml \_qgh_ [eZ`_gkl\h \ DhjZg_ gZau\Z_lky
³>`ZggZ´³kZ^´IhDhjZgm>`ZggZ²wlhl_gbklu_kZ^uk bklhqgbdZfbdZgZeZfbb
ijm^Zfb LZf l_dml ³j_db ba \h^u g_ihjlys_cky b j_db ba fhehdZ \dmk dhlhjh]h g_
f_gy_lky b j_db ba \bgZ ijbylgh]h ^ey ivxsbo b j_db ba f_^m hqbs_ggh]h´ LZf
³ieh^u b iZevfu b ]jZgZlu´ H[blZl_eb fmkmevfZgkdh]h jZy \ [h]Zluo h^_`^Zo
\hae_`Zl gZ ³eh`Zo jZkrbluo´ Hgb _^yl qlh ih`_eZxl ivxl g_h[udgh\_ggu_
gZibldbBfijbkem`b\Zxl³fZevqbdb\_qghxgu_´
IjZ\_^gbdZf ^Zgu \ kmijm]b q_jghhdb_ [hevr_]eZau_ ^_\kl\_ggbpu]mjbb
³dhlhjuo g_ dhkgmeky ^h gbo gb q_eh\_d gb ^`bgg´ =mjbc hibku\Zxl dZd kms_kl\Z
jZaebqguop\_lh\kha^Zggu_barZnjZgZfmkdmkZZf[jubf_xsboijhajZqgmxdh`m
b l_eh mkuiZggh_ ^jZ]hp_gghklyfb GZ ]jm^b m ]mjbc gZ^ibkb k bf_g_f :eeZoZ b
bf_g_f k\h_]h kmijm]Z =mjbb \klj_qZxlky ]eZ\guf h[jZahf \ jZggbo qZklyo DhjZgZ
Iha`_jy^hfk ijZ\_^gbdZfbihy\eyxlkybo³qbklu_lhqg__²hqbs_ggu_kmijm]b´
hgb `_ ³^_\kl\_ggbpu fm`Z ex[ysb_ k\_jklgbpu´ Khh[sZ_lky qlh `_gu
ijZ\_^gbdh\ \f_kl_ k gbfb ihiZ^ml \ jZc Qm\kl\_ggu_ h[jZau ]mjbc b kmijm]
^_\kl\_ggbp m[eZ`Zxsbo ijZ\_^gbdh\ ² h^gh ba dhj_gguo hlebqbc fmkmevfZgkdh]h
jZyhlojbklbZgkdh]h]^_\k_^mrby\eyxlky[_kiheufb
BlZd hkgh\gu_ gZkeZ`^_gby fmkmevfZgkdh]h jZy ² wlh ijhoeZ^Z ihdhb
jhkdhrgu_h^_`^uijbylgu__^Zb iblv_\_qghfheh^u_kmijm]bbajZckdbo^_\b ba
kh[kl\_gguo `_g dhlhju_ klZgml ^_\kl\_ggufb b \_qgh fheh^ufb <hajZkl \k_o
h[blZl_e_cjZykh]eZkghihke_dhjZgghfmij_^Zgbx²]h^Z
G_lkhfg_gby\ lhfqlhfmkmevfZgkdbch[jZajZyijh^he`Z_l^j_\g_\hklhqgmx
ljZ^bpbx ij_^klZ\e_gbc h aZ]jh[ghf pZjkl\_ < DhjZg_ nb]mjbjmxl [b[e_ckdbc
W^_fb i_jkb^kdbcZenbj^Zmkl_jfbgu^eyh[hagZq_gbyjZyG_dhlhju_hibkZgby\
DhjZg_ gZoh^yl k_[_ iZjZee_eb \ bm^_ckdbo ojbklbZgkdbo b ^j_\g_f_khihlZfkdbo
l_dklZo < p_ehf fmkmevfZgkdbc h[jZa jZy fh`gh kqblZlv ZjZ\bckdbf jZa\blb_f
gZjh^guo ij_^klZ\e_gbc h jZ_ [ulh\Z\rbo kj_^b ihke_^h\Zl_e_c jZaguo
[eb`g_\hklhqguoj_eb]bc\ qZklghklbojbklbZgkl\Zbm^ZbafZahjhZkljbafZ
DZd fu lhevdh qlh \b^_eb h[jZa aZ]jh[gh]h fbjZ \ DhjZg_ ]hjZa^h [he__
^_lZebabjh\Zg q_f \ ;b[ebb >_ckl\bl_evgh ij_^klZ\e_gby h ihkf_jlghf
kms_kl\h\Zgbb \ <_lohf AZ\_l_ \_kvfZ g_hij_^_e_ggu Z Gh\uc AZ\_l lZd`_ ba[_]Z_l
kdhevdhgb[m^v ih^jh[guo hibkZgbc kp_g ihkf_jlghc `bagb Dhgdj_lgu_ h[jZau
ojbklbZgkdh]h jZy b Z^Z kdeZ^u\Zxlky ba k\_^_gbc ijb\_^_gguo \ jZaebqguo
hldjh\_gbyo b \b^_gbyo k\yluo Ebrv \ gZqZe_ ;,9 \_dZ aZiZ^ghfm fbjm [ueZ ^ZgZ
i_j\Zy aZ lukyqm k ebrgbf e_l kms_kl\h\Zgby ojbklbZgkl\Z kZfZy h[t_fgZy
aZdhgq_ggZy p_evgZy djZkghj_qb\Zy b \^hogh\_ggZy dZjlbgZ `bagb aZ kf_jlvx
bf_xs_cp_evkfukeb kljmdlmjm²³;h`_kl\_ggZydhf_^by´>Zgl_:eb]v_jb²
>Zgl_ ihr_e gZklhevdh ^Zevr_ \k_]h ij_`^_ kqblZ\r_]hky ba\_klguf qlh _]h
ihqblZl_eb klZeb jZkkfZljb\Zlv ³;h`_kl\_ggmx dhf_^bx´ dZd ih^ebggh_ hldjh\_gb_
Bkihevamy fbnheh]bq_kdb_ h[jZau Zglbqgh]h :b^Z Z lZd`_ ojbklbZgkdb_
ij_^klZ\e_gbyh aZ]jh[ghffbj_aZbfkl\myfgh]h_m Nhfu:d\bgkdh]h:jbklhl_eyb
jbfkdhdZlhebq_kdhc ljZ^bpbb >Zgl_ kha^Z_l q_ldmx ijh^mfZggmx dhgp_ipbx
ihlmklhjhgg_]hkms_kl\h\Zgby
?]hihlmklhjhggbcfbjjZkiZ^Z_lkygZljbhkgh\gu_qZklb²:^Qbklbebs_b
JZc >Zglh\kdbc :^ bgn_jgh ij_^klZ\ey_l kh[hc ih^a_fgmx \hjhgdhh[jZagmx
ijhiZklv dhlhjZy km`Zykv ^hklb]Z_l p_gljZ a_fgh]h rZjZ ?_ kdehgu hihykZgu
^_\ylvx dhgp_gljbq_kdbfb mklmiZfb ³djm]Zfb :^Z´ dZ`^hfm ba dhlhjuo
khhl\_lkl\mxlk\hb]j_obijbq_fq_fly`_e__]j_ol_f\ [he__]em[hdhfdjm]_b [he__
ly`dbfbfmdZfbhgbkdmiZ_lky
< >Zglh\hf:^mijhl_dZxlj_dbZglbqghcij_bkih^g_c< kmsghklbwlh²h^bg
ihlhdh[jZah\Zggucke_aZfbDjblkdh]hKlZjpZb ijhgbdZxsbc\ g_^jZa_febKgZqZeZ
hg y\ey_lky dZd :o_jhg ]j_q j_dZ kdhj[b b hihyku\Z_l i_j\uc djm] :^Z AZl_f
kl_dZy \gba hg h[jZam_l [hehlh KlbdkZ ]j_q g_gZ\bklguc bgZq_ ² Klb]bckdh_
[hehlh \ dhlhjhf dZagylky ]g_\gu_ ?s_ gb`_ hg klZgh\blky Ne_]_lhghf ]j_q
`]mqbc dhevp_h[jZaghc j_dhc dbiys_c djh\b \ dhlhjmx ih]jm`_gu gZkbevgbdb
ijhlb\ [eb`g_]h Ihlhf \ \b^_ djh\Z\h]h jmqvy ijh^he`Zxs_]h gZau\Zlvky
Ne_]_lhghf hg i_j_k_dZ_l e_k kZfhm[bcp b imklugx ]^_ iZ^Z_l h]g_gguc ^h`^v
Hlkx^Zrmfguf\h^hiZ^hfhgk\_j]Z_lky\]em[vqlh[u\ p_glj_a_febij_\jZlblvky\
e_^ygh_ha_jhDhpbl]j_qieZq
< i_j\hfdjm]m:^Z>Zgl_ihf_sZ_lg_dj_s_gguofeZ^_gp_\b ^h[jh^_l_evguo
g_ojbklbZgWlhEbf[eZl³ebf[mk´²dZcfZdZlhebq_kdh]hZ^Z]^_ihp_jdh\ghfm
mq_gbxij_[u\Zeb^mrb\_lohaZ\_lguoijZ\_^gbdh\^hlh]hdZdOjbklhkf_`^mk\h_c
kf_jlvx b \hkdj_k_gb_f khr_e \ Z^ b \u\_e hllm^Z \_lohaZ\_lguo k\yluo \ jZc
hldju\Z\rbcky^eyex^_clhevdhk bkdmie_gb_fi_j\hjh^gh]h]j_oZ
<h \lhjhf djm]m >Zglh\Z Z^Z g_kml gZdZaZgb_ keZ^hkljZklgbdb \ lj_lv_f ²
qj_\hm]h^gbdb\ q_l\_jlhf²kdmipub jZklhqbl_eb\ iylhf\ Klb]bckdhf[hehl_²
]g_\gu_\ r_klhf²_j_lbdb\ k_^vfhf²gZkbevgbdbK_^vfhcdjm]jZa^_e_ggZljb
ihykZ\ dhlhjuokhhl\_lkl\_gghjZaf_s_gugZkbevgbdbgZ^[eb`gbfgZkbevgbdbgZ^
kh[hxb gZkbevgbdbgZ^[h`_kl\hfb gZ^_kl_kl\hfkh^hfblu
<hkvfhcdjm]Aeu_S_ebij_^klZ\ey_lrbjhdbcdhevp_h[jZagucmklmiZ^kdhc
\hjhgdbhihykZggucdjmlhckl_ghch[ju\ZHgba[hjh`^_g^_kylvxdhgp_gljbq_kdbfb
j\Zfb\iZ^bgZfbs_eyfbdhlhju_hl^_e_gu^jm]hl^jm]Z\ZeZfbI_j\ucihkq_lm
\ZeijbfudZ_ld djm]h\hckl_g_Z \p_glj_aby_l]em[bgZrbjhdh]hb l_fgh]hdheh^pZ
gZ ^g_ dhlhjh]h e_`bl ihke_^gbc ^_\yluc djm] :^Z e_^ygh_ ha_jh Dhpbl < Aeuo
S_eyodZjZxlkyh[fZgsbdbdhlhju_h[fZgu\Zebex^_cg_k\yaZgguok gbfbhkh[ufb
maZfb^h\_jbyk\h^gbdbb h[hevklbl_ebevkl_puk\ylhdmipuijhjbpZl_ebfa^hbfpu
ebp_f_ju \hju emdZ\u_ kh\_lqbdb aZqbgsbdb jZa^hjZ ih^^_evsbdb ex^_c ^_g_] b
keh\
>ghf]b]Zglkdh]hZ^kdh]hdheh^pZb h^gh\j_f_ggh^_\ylufdjm]hf>Zglh\Z:^Z
kem`bl e_^ygh_ ha_jh Dhpbl \ dhlhjh_ \f_jaeb h[fZgm\rb_ ^h\_jb\rboky l _
ij_^Zl_eb Wlhl ihke_^gbc djm] :^Z jZa^_e_g [_a \b^bfuo ]jZgbp gZ q_luj_
dhgp_gljbq_kdbo ihykZ < i_j\hf \f_kl_ k DZbghf dZagylky ij_^Zl_eb jh^guo \h
\lhjhf ² ij_^Zl_eb jh^bgu b _^bghfure_ggbdh\ \ lj_lv_f ² ij_^Zl_eb ^jma_c b
khljZi_agbdh\ b gZdhg_p \ q_l\_jlhf ² ij_^Zl_eb [eZ]h^_l_e_c Bf_ggh lZf \
p_glj_ q_l\_jlh]h djm]Z ih ]jm^v \ha\urZ_lky bah ev^Z Expbn_j \ lj_o iZklyo
dhlhjh]h dZagylky l_ q_c ]j_o ih fukeb >Zgl_ m`Zkg__ \k_o hklZevguo ij_^Zl_eb
\_ebq_kl\Z [h`_kdh]h Bm^Z b \_ebq_kl\Z q_eh\_q_kdh]h ;jml b DZkkbc m[b\rb_
XebyP_aZjy
<lhjh_ pZjkl\h Qbklbebs_ >Zgl_ bah[jZ`Z_l \ \b^_ h]jhfghc ]hju
\ha\urZxs_cky \ x`ghf ihemrZjbb ihkj_^b Hd_ZgZ HgZ bf__l \b^ mk_q_ggh]h
dhgmkZ ;_j_]h\Zy ihehkZ b gb`gyy qZklv ]hju h[jZam_l Ij_^qbklbebs_ Z \_jogyy
hihykZgZk_fvxmklmiZfbk_fvxdjm]Zfbkh[kl\_gghQbklbebsZGZiehkdhc\_jrbg_
]hju>Zgl_ihf_sZ_limklugguce_kA_fgh]hJZy
M qblZl_ey fh`_l \hagbdgmlv \hijhk hldm^Z `_ \hh[s_ m >Zgl_ \ayehkv
Qbklbebs_ \_^v h g_f g_ mihfbgZehkv \ jZkkdZa_ h ojbklbZgkdbo ij_^klZ\e_gbyo h
aZ]jh[ghf fbj_ >_eh \ lhf qlh \ k\h_f jZkkdZa_ y ke_^h\Ze ijZ\hkeZ\ghfm
\_jhmq_gbx iheghklvx hl\_j]Zxs_fm ij_^klZ\e_gb_ h Qbklbebs_ lZd `_ dZd b
mq_gb_ ijhl_klZglkl\Z Ihgylb_ QbklbebsZ ijbkmlkl\m_l lhevdh \ dZlhebq_kdhf
\_jhmq_gbb ]^_ hgh y\ey_lky ijhf_`mlhqguf f_klhf f_`^m jZ_f b Z^hf b ]^_ ^mrb
]j_rgbdh\ g_ ihemqb\rb_ ijhs_gby \ a_fghc `bagb gh g_ hly]hs_ggu_ kf_jlgufb
]j_oZfb ij_`^_ q_f ihemqblv ^hklmi \ jZc ]hjyl \ hqbsZxs_f h]g_ Wlh bkiulZgb_
dZlhebq_kdb_ [h]hkeh\u ihgbfZxl ihjZaghfm H^gb ljZdlmxl h]hgv QbklbebsZ dZd
kbf\heb \b^yl\ g_ffmdbkh\_klbb jZkdZygby^jm]b_ijbagZxlj_Zevghklvwlh]hh]gy
Km^v[Z ^mrb \ Qbklbebs_ fh`_l [ulv h[e_]q_gZ Z kjhd ij_[u\Zgby __ lZf
khdjZs_g³^h[jufb^_eZfb´fhebl\Zfbb ih`_jl\h\Zgbyfb\ ihevamp_jd\b\ iZfylv
mf_jr_]hhklZ\rbfbkygZa_fe_jh^gufbb [ebadbfb
Ij_^klZ\e_gb_h Qbklbebs_keh`behkvm`_\ ,\_d_ojbklbZgkl\ZMq_gb_h g_f
jZajZ[hlZe NhfZ :d\bgkdbc ² >h]fZl h Qbklbebs_ [ue ijbgyl
Nehj_glbckdbfkh[hjhf\ ]h^mb ih^l\_j`^_g\ ]h^mLjb^_glkdbfkh[hjhf
M ih^gh`by ]hju >Zglh\Z QbklbebsZ lheiylky mf_jrb_ ih^ p_jdh\guf
hlemq_gb_fgZmklmiZoIj_^qbklbebsZ²g_jZ^b\u_< i_j\hfdjm]_QbklbebsZ>Zgl_
jZkiheh`be]hj^_ph\\h\lhjhf²aZ\bklgbdh\\ lj_lv_f²]g_\guo\ q_l\_jlhf²
mgueuo\ iylhf²kdmiph\b jZklhqbl_e_c\ r_klhf²qj_\hm]h^gbdh\\ k_^vfhf²
keZ^hkljZklgbdh\ < Qbklbebs_ ^mrZ fh`_l hqbklblvky hl ]b[_evguo ijbkljZklbc b
ijb\uq_db ijbh[j_klbgh\h_\^hogh\_gb_gZimlb\_^ms_f\\_jod jZxIhwlhfmk_fv
djm]h\ qbklbebsZ khhl\_lkl\mxl k_fb kf_jlguf ]j_oZf Ijhc^y k\hbfb djm]Zfb
hqbklb\rb_ky ^mrb \u\h^ylky \ ih^h[b_ a_fgh]h jZy gZ \_jrbg_ qbklbebsZ L_i_jv
^mrZ ^hklb]eZ iehkdhklb a_fghc ^h[jh^_l_eb gh _s_ g_ ^hklhcgZ \ukrbo ij_^_eh\
jZy
Iml_r_kl\b_ ^mrb ihwlZ q_j_a jZc d g_[_kZf kbf\hebabjm_lky hklZgh\dZfb
imlgbdh\ gZ jZaebqguo Zkljhghfbq_kdbo l_eZo k\h_]h jh^Z ³iml_\uo klZgpbyo´ ^ey
^mrij_[u\Zxsbo\ pZjkl\_jZ^hklbgh_s_^Ze_dbohlg_[_kgh]hkh\_jr_gkl\ZWlb
wlZiu ij_^klZ\eyxl kh[hc ]eZ\gu_ q_eh\_q_kdb_ ^h[jh^_l_eb kijZ\_^eb\hklv
[eZ]hjZamfb_ mf_j_gghklv klhcdhklv \_jm gZ^_`^m fbehk_j^b_ I_j\h_ g_[h JZy
>Zgl_jZkiheZ]Z_lgZEmg_\lhjh_²gZF_jdmjbblj_lv_²gZ<_g_j_q_l\_jlh_²gZ
Khegp_iylh_²gZFZjk_r_klh_²gZXibl_j_k_^vfh_²gZKZlmjg_\hkvfh_²
A\_a^gh_ g_[h ^_\ylh_ ² djbklZevgh_ g_[h GZ^ ^_\ylvx g_[_kZfb Ilhehf__\hc
kbkl_fu>Zgl_kh]eZkghk p_jdh\gufmq_gb_fihf_sZ_l^_kylh_g_^\b`gucWfibj_c
]j_q ieZf_gguc h[bl_ev [h`_kl\Z Ijhc^y \k_ wlZiu ^mrZ \ wdklZa_ ^hklb]Z_l
Wfibjby]^_bkq_aZxlihgylby\j_f_gbb ijhkljZgkl\Z
Dhg_qgh \ wlhf djZldhf i_j_kdZa_ g_evay \hkijhba\_klb [h]Zlkl\Z b
mlhgq_gghklb fukeb ]em[bgu ijhaj_gby ² \k_]h lh]h qlh ^_eZ_l hibkZgb_ >Zgl_
`bagb ihke_ kf_jlb \k_fbjgh ijbagZgguf r_^_\jhf gh qblZl_ev fh`_l kZf \ ex[hc
fhf_glh[jZlblvkyd wlhfmm^b\bl_evghfmijhba\_^_gbx
Ihfbfh dZghgbq_kdbo ojbklbZgkdbo ij_^klZ\e_gbc h
ihkf_jlghf
kms_kl\h\Zgbb ^mrb \ gh\h_ b gh\_cr__ \j_fy ihemqbeb jZkijhkljZg_gb_ b lZd
gZau\Z_fu_ fbklbq_kdb_ hldjh\_gby GZb[he__ kbkl_fZlbabjh\Zgguc b ih^jh[guc
jZkkdZa h ihlmklhjhgg_f fbj_ ijbgZ^e_`bl r\_^kdhfm _kl_kl\hbkiulZl_ex b
nbehkhnmfbklbdm WffZgmbem K\_^_g[hj]m ² dhlhjuc kqblZ_lky
hkgh\Zl_e_fkh\j_f_ggh]hkibjblbafZH kibjblbaf_fum`_jZkkdZau\Zeb\ ]eZ\_;,;
ihwlhfm k_cqZk fu dhkg_fky lhevdh l_o jZa^_eh\ nbehkhnbb kibjblbafZ dhlhju_
dZkZxlkyij_^klZ\e_gbch ihkf_jlghfkms_kl\h\Zgbbq_eh\_dZ
BlZd K\_^_g[hj] [ue gZlmjZebklhf b fZl_fZlbdhf ba\_klgu _]h ljm^u ih
Ze]_[j_f_ljheh]bbdhkfheh]bbf_oZgbd_bg`_g_jbb]_heh]bbGh\ o ]h^Zo;9,,,
\_dZ \ _]h `bagb ijhbkoh^bl i_j_ehf hg hklZ\ey_l gZmdm b h[jZsZ_lky d fbklbd_
h[ty\ey_l k_[y ^moh\b^p_f b ijhih\_^m_l kh[kl\_ggh_ l_hkhnkdh_ mq_gb_ Ohly kZf
K\_^_g[hj]gbdh]^Zg_iulZekykha^Zlvk\hxk_dlm_]hihke_^h\Zl_eyfb[ueZkha^ZgZ
hkh[Zyk\_^_g[hj]bZgkdZyp_jdh\v
KZf K\_^_g[hj] ]h\hjbe qlh \ \hajZkl_ e_l hg bkiulZe hr_ehfeyxs__
^moh\gh_ij_\jZs_gb_gZ^gbf³jZa\_jaehkvg_[h´b hgihemqbek\h[h^guc ^hklmi \
pZjkl\h^moh\fh]i_j_f_sZlvky\ g_f[_k_^h\Zlvk _]hh[blZl_eyfbbkke_^h\Zlvwlhl
fbj AZ ihke_^gb_ e_l `bagb K\_^_g[hj] kha^Ze h]jhfgh_ dhebq_kl\h j_eb]bhaguo
ijhba\_^_gbc hibku\Zxsbo G_[h Z^ Zg]_eh\ b ^moh\ ² b \k_ wlh gZ hkgh\Zgbb
kh[kl\_ggh]h hiulZ ?]h hibkZgby \ hkgh\ghf kh]eZkmxlky k hibkZgbyfb hddmevlghc
ebl_jZlmju
Dh]^Z q_eh\_d mfbjZ_l lh kh]eZkgh mq_gbx K\_^_g[hj]Z hg \oh^bl \ ³fbj
^moh\´gZoh^ysbckygZiheimlbf_`^mg_[_kZfbb Z^hfWlhlfbjhq_gvihoh`gZgZr
a_fghc lZf q_eh\_d \klj_qZ_lky k mf_jrbfb ^jmavyfb b agZdhfufb DZd lhevdh
q_eh\_dijb\udZ_ld ij_[u\Zgbx\ fbj_^moh\_]h^jmavyjZkkdZau\Zxl_fmh G_[_kZo
b Z^_b hl\h^yl\ jZaebqgu_]hjh^ZkZ^ub iZjdb< wlhfijhf_`mlhqghf³fbj_^moh\´
q_eh\_d\ oh^_h[mq_gby^eys_]hkyhlg_kdhevdbo^g_c^h]h^Z³ijb]hlh\ey_lky´^ey
G_[ZGhkZfh³G_[h´dZd_]hhibku\Z_lK\_^_g[hj]g_kebrdhfhlebqZ_lkyhl³fbjZ
^moh\´ b h[Z hq_gv koh`b k a_fe_c LZf _klv \gmlj_ggb_ ^\hju b aZeu dZd gZ a_fe_
iZjdb b kZ^u ^hfZ b kiZevgb ³Zg]_eh\´ b fZkkZ i_j_f_g ieZlvy ^ey gbo LZf _klv
ijZ\bl_evkl\Z aZdhgu km^u p_jdh\gu_ a^Zgby kem`[u [jZdb rdheu h[s_kl\_ggZy
`bagv²\k_qlh\klj_qZ_lkygZa_fe_HibkZgb_Z^ZlZd`_gZihfbgZ_ldZdh_lhf_klh
gZa_fe__]hh[blZl_eboZjZdl_jbamxlkyw]hbafhfb ^mjgufbihklmidZfb
;hevrbgkl\hf k\hbo kh\j_f_ggbdh\ K\_^_g[hj] [ue hl\_j]gml dZd
kmfZkr_^rbc b \iehlv ^h gZrbo ^g_c _]h \b^_gby j_^dh \hkijbgbfZebkv \k_jv_a
KijZ\_^eb\hklb jZ^b klhbl hlf_lblv qlh g_f_pdbc nbehkhn BffZgmbe DZgl b
Zf_jbdZgkdbcnbehkhnJWf_jkhg\ukhdhhp_gb\Zebfbklbq_kdb_ljm^uK\_^_g[hj]Zb
\_jbeb\ g_dhlhju_ijbf_ju _]h³ykgh\b^_gby´H`b\e_gb_ bgl_j_kZ d hddmevlbafm \
gZr_ \j_fy \u^\bgmeh K\_^_g[hj]Z \i_j_^ dZd ³fbklbdZ´ b ³ykgh\b^pZ´ g_
h]jZgbq_ggh]h dZghgbq_kdbf ojbklbZgkl\hf Hkh[uc `_ bgl_j_k d _]h ljm^Zf
ijh[m^beky ihke_ lh]h dZd [ueb gZc^_gu fgh]hqbke_ggu_ bgl_j_kgu_ iZjZee_eb
f_`^m hldjh\_gbyfb K\_^_g[hj]Z b hibkZgbyfb i_j\uo fhf_glh\ ihke_ kf_jlb
ba\_klguobajZkkdZah\j_Zgbfbjh\Zgguoex^_cfuibkZebh[wlhf\ ]eZ\_,9
K_cqZk ihy\behkv p_eh_ fbklbq_kdh_ gZijZ\e_gb_ iulZxs__ky kha^Zlv k\hx
dZjlbgmihkf_jlgh]hkms_kl\h\ZgbygZhkgh\ZgbbjZ[hlK\_^_g[hj]Zfgh]hqbke_gguo
kibjblbq_kdbohiulh\ihh[s_gbxk ^mrZfbmf_jrbob hibkZgbcex^_ci_j_`b\rbo
debgbq_kdmxkf_jlvKh]eZkghbo mq_gbx g_ kms_kl\m_l Z^Z b jZy \ lhf \b^_ dZd bo
hibku\Z_l P_jdh\v Z ^mrb ihke_ kf_jlb ijh^he`Zxl \_klb bkdexqbl_evgh ijbylgh_
kms_kl\h\Zgb_ khojZgyy iZfylv h[h \k_f i_j_`blhf b ihkl_i_ggh kh\_jr_gkl\mykv \
k\h_f jZa\blbb L_hjbb wlb j_adh djblbdmxlky ij_^klZ\bl_eyfb hnbpbZevgh]h
ojbklbZgkl\Z ml\_j`^Zxsbfb qlh \k_ wlb \b^_gby kibjblbq_kdbo k_Zgkh\ b
³ijbylguc´ihkf_jlguchiulj_Zgbfbjh\Zgguo_klvg_qlhbgh_dZd[_kh\kdbch[fZg
gZijZ\e_ggucgZih]b[_ev^mrb
Mq_gb_K\_^_g[hj]Zb _]hihke_^h\Zl_e_cijbgZ^e_`bll_hkhnbbL_hkhnb_chl
]j_q_kdbo keh\ ³l_hk´ ² [h] b ³khnby´ ² fm^jhklv agZgb_ gZau\Zxl j_eb]bhagh
nbehkhnkdh_ mq_gb_ h \hafh`ghklb g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh]h ihklb`_gby ;h]Z k ihfhsvx
fbklbq_kdhc bglmbpbb IjbagZgb_ \hafh`ghklb g_ihkj_^kl\_gguo dhglZdlh\ kh
k\_jot_kl_kl\_ggufb kbeZfb k[eb`Z_l l_hkhnbx k hddmevlbafhf b kibjblbafhf
Bklhjbdb l_hkhnbb moh^yl \ ]em[hdmx ^j_\ghklv we_f_glu __ fh`gh h[gZjm`blv \
[jZofZgbaf_ [m^^baf_ dZ[[Ze_ ^mohf l_hkhnbb [ueb ijhgbdgmlu g_hieZlhgbaf b
]ghklbpbaf^j_\g_]hfbjZmq_gb_Zeobfbdh\kj_^g_\_dh\vy
< gZklhys__ \j_fy mq_gb_ l_hkhnbb gZb[he__ ihegh \ujZ`_gh \ ^_yl_evghklb
³L_hkhnkdh]h h[s_kl\Z´ hkgh\Zggh]h \ ]h^m \ GvxChjd_ gZr_c
khhl_q_kl\_ggbp_c ? I ;eZ\Zlkdhc ² K_cqZk \ l_hkhnkdhf h[s_kl\_
nbebZeu dhlhjh]h bf_xlky \h fgh]bo kljZgZo fbjZ gZkqblu\Z_lky hdheh q_eh\_d Fg_ ^h\_ehkv ih[u\Zlv \ =eZ\ghf p_glj_ l_hkhnkdh]h h[s_kl\Z dhlhjuc \
gZklhys__ \j_fy [Zabjm_lky \ FZ^jZk_ Bg^by Wlhl P_glj jZkiheh`_g \ h]jhfghf
iZjd_ gZihfbgZxs_f [hlZgbq_kdbc kZ^ b a^Zgby _]h iheghklvx kdjulu \ a_e_gb
p\_lmsbowdahlbq_kdbo^_j_\v_\
Kh\j_f_ggu_ l_hkhnu ijhih\_^mxl b^_b l_jibfhklb dh \k_f j_eb]byf
ihkdhevdm\ dZ`^hcbagboydh[ukdjulZ_^bgZy[h`_kl\_ggZykmsghklvHlghkbl_evgh
b^_b ihkf_jlgh]h kms_kl\h\Zgby hgb ijb^_j`b\Zxlky keh`gh]h dhg]ehf_jZlZ ba
jZaebqguo j_eb]bhaguo mq_gbc \ hkgh\_ dhlhjh]h \k_lZdb e_`bl b^_y h
i_j_\hiehs_gbb ^mr Kh]eZkgh \a]ey^Zf ihke_^h\Zl_e_c ;eZ\Zlkdhc \k_ ex^b
y\eyxlky ³bkdjZfb h^gh]h ieZf_gb´ h^gh]h bklhqgbdZ hldm^Z \k_ \ureb b dm^Z
g_ij_f_ggh^he`gu\_jgmlvky
Ih^jh[guc jZkkdZa h l_hkhnkdbo mq_gbyo ² wlh l_fZ hl^_evghc dgb]b b
ihwlhfm^_lZevghZgZebabjh\Zlvboy g_[m^m
Fu k \Zfb jZkkfhlj_eb \k_ hkgh\gu_ \a]ey^u gZ ihkf_jlgh_ kms_kl\h\Zgb_
^mrbgZqbgZyhli_j\h[ulgh]hZg_fbafZ^hij_^klZ\e_gbclZdbofbjh\uoj_eb]bcdZd
[m^^baf ojbklbZgkl\h bkeZf < hkgh\_ \k_o wlbo mq_gbc e_`bl ^h]fZl h [_kkf_jlbb
^mrb b [eZ]h^Zjy wlhfm g_kfhljy gZ fgh]hqbke_ggu_ jZaebqby mq_gby wlb bf_xl b
fgh]hh[s_]h
>jm]bf ihexkhf ij_^klZ\e_gbc q_eh\_q_kl\Z y\ey_lky Zl_baf ml\_j`^Zxsbc
qlh`bagv_klvlhevdhkihkh[kms_kl\h\Zgby[_edh\uol_eb iheghklvxij_djZsZ_lkyk
jZkiZ^hf[_edZ<hkiblZggu_\ ^mo_fZl_jbZebafZy bf_x\ \b^m[hevrbgkl\hgZrbo
qblZl_e_c fu bgh]^Z hdZau\Z_fky ihjZabl_evgh g_k\_^msbfb \ j_eb]bhaguo
ij_^klZ\e_gbyo h kf_jlb b ihijhklm ]h\hjy gbdh]^Z g_ aZ^mfu\Z_fky h[ wlbo
ihgylbyo Y g_ klZ\be k\h_c p_evx q_fmlh gZmqblv qblZl_ey ijhih\_^h\Zlv beb
gZh[hjhl djblbdh\Zlv dZdmxlh ba baeh`_gguo a^_kv b^_c G_l Y lhevdh ohl_e qmlv
qmlv jZa^\bgmlv ]hjbahglu gZr_]h agZgby b ihklZ\blv \hijhku hl\_lu gZ dhlhju_
dZ`^uc[m^_lbkdZlvkZfhklhyl_evgh
EBL?J:LMJ:
Nhj^ : @bagv ihke_ kf_jlb DZd h[ wlhf [ueh jZkkdZaZgh >`_jhfm Weebkhgm E
³E_gba^Zl´FI³<_klgbd´
B_jhfhgZoK_jZnbfJhma >mrZihke_kf_jlbFhkd\Z³FZkZiDQG&R Mhje^^_\_ehif_glnhjmfGvxChjdbxevIuey_\FB KlZjucI_l_j[mj]K
I_l_j[mj]Ba^:KKm\hjbgZ
LZcehj W ; I_j\h[ulgZy dmevlmjZ F ³Iheblba^Zl´ LhdZj_\ K E JZggb_
nhjfuj_lZ]bbF³Iheblba^Zl´DmgG: E_]_g^ub fbnu>j_\g_c=j_pbbF
³=hkmqi_^ba^Zl_evkl\h´
Похожие документы
Скачать