ВКЛАД ГЕНОТИП-СРЕДОВЫХ ЭФФЕКТОВ В ФОРМИРОВАНИЕ

141
!"#$%& '(%), 2010, *+, 14, - 1
!"#$ %&'()*+-,-&$( ./ 011&!)(
1(-2*-( #'*& !("*3&,) &''./ +-*4'#!(
5 *'6-&$'./ * #5)6-&$'./ -#,)&'*7
. . ,89:;, &. . 2<=>9?@, $. . !:ABC9:;
!" #$%$&'()* +$,-+.-)''/01.2$30/4'()* )+'3)3,3 '0/4'(.5. 6.78*'32$
)%. !.9. :,/$*(.2$ ;<#=!, >070+-,(, ;.'')8, 0-mail: samniish@samtel.ru
?@'($7$+. ) .A.'+.2$+. B&01B./.C0+)0 .A DB)50+03)-0'(.% 6$&$(30&0 27$)%.10*'32)8 «50+.3)B–'&01$». E&) .F0+(0 50+03)-0'()6 2$&)$+' , &$7+.2.7&$'3+@6 B.3.%(.2 D3. 27$)%.10*'32)0 G)(')&,03'8
($( DB)'3$3)-0'()0 DGG0(3@. E.($7$+$ +$ )+A&01+.% (8&.2$8 %85($8 BH0+)F$) ) $,3A&01+.% (5)A&)1+$8 (,(,&,7$) .AI0(3$6 7$(.+.%0&+.'34 A./00 +)7(.5. ,&.2+8 2(/$1$ 50+.3)B-'&01.2@6 DGG0(3.2
2 G.&%)&.2$+)0 (./)-0'320++@6 B&)7+$(.2 , 5)A&)1.2 B. '&$2+0+)J ' 5.%.7)5.3+@%) G.&%$%).
"-)3@2$8 2 7+$-)30/4+.* '30B0+) DB)50+03)-0'()* 6$&$(30& 27$)%.10*'32)8 «50+.3)B–'&01$», D3,
7$(.+.%0&+.'34 %.C+. .AI8'+)34 ' B.7)F)* 5)B.307@ «DB)50+03)-0'(.5. A$/$+'$».
!D8AB;EB FD:;<: 27$)%.10*'32)0 «50+.3)B–'&01$», DB)50+03)-0'($8 )7%0+-)2.'34, DB)'3$7, DB)50+03)-0'()* A$/$+', BH0+)F$, (,(,&,7$.
;B=B@?B
? '3&,(3,&0 G0+.3)B)-0'(.* )7%0+-)2.'3)
(./)-0'320++@6 B&)7+$(.2, ' (.3.&.* )%003
10/. '0/0(F).+0&, .'.A.0 %0'3. 7$+)%$03 27$)%.10*'32)0 50+.3)B–'&01$. KL0 !.M. ?$2)/.2
(1935) ,($7@2$/ +$ +$/)-)0 '.&3.2@6 &$7/)-)*
, BH0+)F@ B. D(./.5)-0'(.* B/$'3)-+.'3),
-3. 1$2$/. A./4H.* B&.'3.& 2 D3.% .3+.H0+))
1/8 '0/0(F).++.* &$A.3@, ) +$ +0.A6.1)%.'34
)7,-0+)8 B&)&.1@ D3)6 &$7/)-)*. !., 0'/)
2 .3+.H0+)) 'B0F)G)-0'(.* $1$B3)2+.'3)
)/) ,'3.*-)2.'3) ( '3&0''.2.%, 2.710*'32)J
.B&010/0++.5. G$(3.&$ 2+0H+0* '&01@ 2 7.+0
3$('.+.%)-0'(.5. (2)1.2.5., &.1.2.5.) D('3&0%,%$ ) ',AD('3&0%,%$ (%.&.7.-, C$&.'3.*(.'34,
7$',6.-, './0,'3.*-)2.'34, ,'3.*-)2.'34 ( A./07+8% ) 3. 1.) %.C+. 5.2.&)34 .A .B&010/0++@6
G)7)./.5)-0'()6 ) 50+03)-0'()6 %06$+)7%$6
$1$B3)2+.'3), 3. %06$+)7%@ D(./.5)-0'(.*
$1$B3)2+.'3) 2 H)&.(.% '%@'/0 '/.2$ ($( 'B.'.A+.'3) 50+.3)B$ ( H)&.(.* +.&%0 &0$(F)) +$
(.%B/0(' G$(3.&.2 '&01@ )720'3+@ +$% 1.2./4+. B.20&6+.'3+. (N)/4-02'()*, =.3@/02$, 1997).
? 3. C0 2&0%8 )720'3+., -3. '&01+00 7+$-0+)0
B&)7+$($ ) -,2'32)30/4+.'34 ( '&010 +$6.183'8
B.1 '$%.'3.830/4+@% 50+03)-0'()% (.+3&./0%
) .3+.')30/4+. +07$2)')%@ (Caligari, Mather,
1975; Connoly, Jinks, 1975; Hill, 1975; Jinks et al.,
1977; Jinks, Pooni, 1982; O&$5$2F02 ) 1&., 1984;
N)/4-02'()*, =.3@/02$, 1997; Dorn, Schmitt,
1997). C.R. Landry ' '.$23. (2006) +$ 6 H3$%%$6
1&.CC02@6 5&)A.2 2 3&06 D(./.5)-0'()6 ,'/.2)86 +$H/) 221 3&$+'(&)B3, .3203'320++@* 7$
27$)%.10*'32)0 «50+.3)B–'&01$». E.7C0 +$
3.% C0 .AI0(30 1/8 2 H3$%%.2 ) 109 &0(.%A)+$+3.2 .3 '(&0L)2$+)8 D3)6 H3$%%.2 +$ 12,6
G.+$6 ,5/0&.1)'3.5. B)3$+)8 2@82/0+. 1555
50+03)-0'()6 'F0B/0+)* 1/8 1382 3&$+'(&)B3.2,
(.3.&@0 B.($7@2$/) ',L0'320++.0 50+.3)B-'&01.2.0 27$)%.10*'32)0 (Smith, Kruglyak, 2008).
Y. Li ' '.$23. (2006) +$ Caenorhabditis elegans
+$ G.+0 12,6 30%B0&$3,&+@6 &0C)%.2 2@82)/)
197 50+03)-0'()6 'F0B/0+)*, .3203'320++@6 7$
B.1.A+@0 27$)%.10*'32)8.
E. M. Rutter ' '.$23. (2006), «genotypeenvironment interplay» – D3. .AL)* 30&%)+,
(.3.&@* B.(&@2$03 +0'(./4(. &$'6.18L)6'8
B.+83)* ' &$7/)-+@% '.10&C$+)0%. ?.-B0&2@6,
D3. 27$)%.10*'32)0 'B0F)G)-0'()6 )10+3)G)F)&.2$++@6 50+.2 ) .B&010/0++@6 '3&0''.2@6
,'/.2)* '&01@, 3. 0. 'B0F)G)-0'($8 $1$B3)2-
142
+.'34, (.3.&$8 +0 82/803'8 .AI0(3.% +$H05.
&$''%.3&0+)8. ?.-23.&@6, D3. 3$( +$7@2$0%@0
50+.3)B-'&01.2@0 (.&&0/8F)), 2'0 3&) 3)B$
(.3.&@6 (B$'')2+$8, &0$(3)2+$8 ) $(3)2+$8,
Plomin et al., 1977) .3+.'83'8 ( B.2010+-0'()%
G,+(F)8% -0/.20($ ) +0 '2.*'320++$ (./)-0'320++@% B&)7+$($% &$'30+)*.
N 3&0340%, 2)1, 50+.3)B-'&01.2@6 DGG0(3.2 .3+.'83'8 )7%0+0+)8 D('B&0'')) 50+.2 B.1
2/)8+)0% G$(3.&.2 '&01@, 2@72$++@0 DB)50+03)-0'()%) %06$+)7%$%). E&) D3.% )%0J3'8 2
2)1, 3$()0 DB)50+03)-0'()0 )7%0+0+)8, (.3.&@0
B0&01$J3'8 B. +$'/01'32,. ?B0&2@0 B.1.A+@0
G0+.%0+@ A@/) 2@82/0+@ A. Durrant (1958,
1962). P+ .A+$&,C)/, -3. +0(.3.&@0 '.&3$
/4+$ +$ G.+$6 %)+0&$/4+.5. B)3$+)8 'B.'.A+@
A@/) B&).A&03$34 B0&01$2$0%@0 B. B.3.%'32,
+.2..A&$7.2$+)8, '6.1+@0 )/) )10+3)-+@0
&$+00 2@82/0++@% B$&$%,3$F)8% (Brink, 1956,
1960). :$()0 C0 )7%0+0+)8 A@/) .A+$&,C0+@
B.7C0 , 3$A$($ (Hill, 1967; Hill, Perkins, 1969).
G.M. Evans (1968) .A+$&,C)/ '2874 «'&01.2@6»
)7%0+0+)* ' )7%0+0+)8%) 2 '.10&C$+)) O!N.
!@+0 2@82/0+@ A).6)%)-0'()0 %06$+)7%@
(%03)/)&.2$+)0 F)3.7)+.2@6 .'+.2$+)*, $F03)/)&.2$+)0 5)'3.+.2), .3+.'8L)0'8 ( 3&$+'(&)BF).++.%, 3)B, B.1$2/0+)8 D('B&0''))
50+.2 (Chang, Whitelaw, 2004; N.&.-()+, 2006), $
3$(C0 .A+$&,C0+@ %)(&.-;!N, .B&010/8JL)0
B.'33&$+'(&)BF).++.0 &05,/)&.2$+)0 $(3)2+.'3) 50+.2 (N$3.6)+ ) 1&., 2006).
P1+$(. DB)50+03)-0'()* 6$&$(30& )%0J3 )
50+.3)B-'&01.2@0 DGG0(3@, '287$++@0 ' )7%0+0+)0% D('B&0'')) 50+.2 2 B&.F0''0 )+1)2)1,$/4+.5. &$72)3)8 ) G.&%)&.2$+)8 F0+.7.2 A07
7$(&0B/0+)8 D3)6 DGG0(3.2 2 B.3.%'320. :$(,
A.H. Paterson ' '.$23. (1991) +$ 3.%$3$6 2@82)/),
-3. 1/8 .1+.5. ) 3.5. C0 B&)7+$($ 2 &$7+@6 D(./.5)-0'()6 ,'/.2)86 B&.82/8J3'8 &$7+@0 QTL
(quantitative trait loci). <+$/.5)-+@0 &07,/43$3@
B./,-0+@ M.C. Ungerer ' '.$23. (2003) +$ $&$A)1.B')'0 ) A. Börner ' '.$23. (2002) ) Q.?. R0'+.(.2@% ) 1&. (2008) +$ BH0+)F0. S3) 1$++@0
6.&.H. 2B)'@2$J3'8 2 (.+F0BF)J ?.<. O&$5$2F02$ (O&$5$2F02, <20&48+.2$, 1983$, A; O&$5$2F02 ) 1&., 1984) B0&0.B&010/0+)8 50+03)-0'()6 G.&%,/, .'+.2$++,J +$ B&01'3$2/0+)86
. '/.C+.* D(./.5.-50+03)-0'(.* .&5$+)7$F))
(./)-0'320++@6 B&)7+$(.2, 201,L,J &./4 2
(.3.&.* )5&$03 ')'30%$ &05,/83.&+@6 50+.2.
!"#$%& '(%), 2010, *+, 14, - 1
T.5)-+. B&01B./.C)34, -3. B.1.A+.5. &.1$
DB)50+03)-0'(.0 B0&0&$'B&010/0+)0 D('B&0''))
&05,/83.&+@6 50+.2 B&) (/$'')-0'(.% (./)-0'320++.-50+03)-0'(.% $+$/)70 &$7+.2.7&$'3+@6
B.3.%(.2 A,103 '3$3)'3)-0'() (.+'3)3,)&.2$34'8 ($( DB)'3$3)-0'(.0 27$)%.10*'32)0.
? D3.* '287) '/01,03 .5.2.&)34, -3. 2 +$,(0
',L0'32,J3 120 &$7/)-$JL)0'8 )+30&B&03$F))
30&%)+$ «DB)'3$7». E0&2.0 B.+83)0 (A)./.5)-0'()* DB)'3$7) 22010+. >D3'.+.% (Batson, 1909)
) .B&010/0+. ($( B.1$2/0+)0 10*'32)8 .1+.*
$//0/) 1&,5.*, +0$//0/4+.* B0&2.*. J.B. Holland
(2001) .B&010/)/ %06$+)7%@ 10*'32)8 A)./.5)-0'(.5. DB)'3$7$ ($( 27$)%.10*'32)0 D+7)%.2 –
B&.1,(3.2 '..3203'32,JL)6 $//0/0*, (.3.&.0 2
G0+.3)B0 B&.82/803'8 ($( 1,B/)($3+@* DB)'3$7
(2 ($C1.% )7 12,6 /.(,'.2 .1+$ )7 $//0/0* .A0'B0-)2$03 &$2+.F0++@* A).6)%)-0'()* DGG0(3
) .3',3'32)0 .A.)6 D+7)%.2 .1+.2&0%0++.
B&.82/803'8 ($( DB)'3$7), (.%B/0%0+3$&+@*
DB)'3$7 ($//0/) 12,6 /.(,'.2 +0&$2+.F0++@,
+,C+@* A).6)%)-0'()* DGG0(3 1.'3)5$03'8
/)H4 B&) +$/)-)) .A.)6 D+7)%.2) ) '/.C+@*
DB)'3$7 (A).6)%)-0'()* DGG0(3 1.'3)5$03'8
B&) 27$)%.10*'32)) .B&010/0++.* B$&@ $//0/0* 12,6 /.(,'.2).
?3.&.0 B.+83)0 – '3$3)'3)-0'()* DB)'3$7 –
($( /JA.0 +0$//0/4+.0 27$)%.10*'32)0 50+.2
220/ R.A. Fisher (1918). M.J. Wade ' '.$23. (2001),
'&$2+)2$8 B.+83)8 «DB)'3$7» 2 12,6 30.&03)-0'()6 3&$1)F)86 D2./JF).++.* 50+03)(),
50+03)() B.B,/8F)* ) (./)-0'320++.* 50+03)(), B.($7$/), ($( +07$2)')%.'34 10*'32)8 50+$
(B&01'3$2/0++$8 %,/43)B/)($3)2+.* %.10/4J
B.B,/8F).++.* 50+03)()) %.C03 .3/)-$34'8 .3
.3',3'32)8 DB)'3$7$ 2 B&01'3$2/0+)) (./)-0'320++.* 50+03)(). P+) 10/$J3 2@2.1 . B&8%.*
$+$/.5)) '3$3)'3)-0'(.5. DB)'3$7$ 27$)%.10*'32)J 50+.3)B-'&01$.
E&) )'B./47.2$+)) %./0(,/8&+@6 %$&(0&.2
+$ (,(,&,70 (Blanc et al., 2006) ) $&$A)1.B')'0
(Juengei et al., 2005; Malmberg et al., 2006) 2@82/0+. 7+$-)30/4+.0 (./)-0'32. QTL-QTL DB)'3$3)-0'()6 27$)%.10*'32)* B. '$%@% &$7+@% B&)7+$($%. E&)-0% 20/)-)+$ DB)'3$3)-0'()6 (3. 0.
50+.3)B-'&01.2@6) 27$)%.10*'32)* B&)%0&+. 2
12$ &$7$ B&02@H$03 $11)3)2+@0 DGG0(3@. E&)
D3.% '/01,03 7$%03)34, -3. 0L0 2 (.+F0 1950-6–
+$-$/0 1960-6 55. A@/. 2@82/0+. +$ 1&.7.G)/0
(Parsons, 1959) ) 1.%$H+0* B3)F0 (Hull et al.,
143
!"#$%& '(%), 2010, *+, 14, - 1
1963), -3. DGG0(3@ 50+.3)B-'&01.2@6 27$)%.10*'32)* , 5030&.7)5.3 +0)7%0++. +)C0, -0% ,
5.%.7)5.3+@6 &.1)30/4'()6 G.&%.
9@ B.'3$2)/) F0/4J B&.20&)34 D3, 7$(.+.%0&+.'34 +$ $,3A&01+.% ((,(,&,7$) ) )+A&01+.%
(BH0+)F$) &$'3)30/4+@6 .AI0(3$6. ;$+00 +$%)
(#J(.2, 2006) 2 (.+3&$'3+@6 ,'/.2)86 +$ 8&.2.*
BH0+)F0 A@/$ 2@82/0+$ 7$(.+.%0&+.'34 ,20/)-0+)8 1./) DB)'3$3)-0'()6 DGG0(3.2 2 1030&%)+$F)) (./)-0'320++@6 B&)7+$(.2 2 7$2)')%.'3)
.3 ,20/)-0+)8 +$5&,7.( G$(3.&.2 '&01@, /)%)3)&,JL)6 &.'3 ) &$72)3)0 &$'30+)*.
2BC:=?9<
>./4H)+'32. &,(.2.1'32 B. 2$&)$F).++.*
'3$3)'3)(0 %0&.* 2(/$1$ .310/4+@6 DGG0(3.2 2
G0+.3)B)-0'(,J )7%0+-)2.'34 '-)3$J3 ',%%,
(2$1&$3.2 .3(/.+0+)* .3 '&01+0* (SSY = SSA +
+ SS + SSA/B + SSP + SSZ, 510 . – B0&2@* G$(3.&, – 23.&.* G$(3.&, A/B – 27$)%.10*'32)0,
/ – B.23.&0+)8, Z – .H)A($) 2 12,6G$(3.&+.%
1)'B0&').++.% (.%B/0('0 (E/.6)+'()*, 1978).
P1+$(., ,-)3@2$8, -3. %0&.* )7%0+-)2.'3)
(./)-0'320++.5. B&)7+$($ 2 B.B,/8F)86 82/803'8 1)'B0&')8 (U2ph = U2g + U2e + U2g/e; Falconer,
1981), F0/0'..A&$7+00 )'B./47.2$34 B$&$%03&@
V2, B&01'3$2/8JL)0 )7 '0A8 %$30%$3)-0'()0
.C)1$+)8 '..3203'32,JL)6 1)'B0&')*, &$''-)3@2$0%@6 +$ .'+.20 '3&,(3,&@ '&01+)6
msA – msZ 2
(2$1&$3.2 .3(/.+0+)* (V2g =
n·c ; V e =
msA/B – msZ 2
msB – msZ 2
=
; V z = msZ, 510 n –
n·r
n·r ; V g/e =
(./)-0'32. B.23.&0+)*, c – (./)-0'32. D(./.5)-0'()6 3.-0(, r – (./)-0'32. 50+.3)B.2;
;.()F()*, 1973). "-)3@2$8, -3. 2.72010+)0
.3(/.+0+)* 2 (2$1&$3 82/803'8 'B.'.A.% )6
%.1,/)7$F)) ) -3. B.1.A+$8 F0/4 1.'3)5$03'8
2.72010+)0% 2..AL0 2 /JA,J -03+,J '30B0+4,
1/8 2.72&$L0+)8 (&)30&)8 )7%0+-)2.'3) 2
)'6.1+,J 01)+)-+,J '30B0+4 ' F0/4J )'B./47.2$+)8 2 ($-0'320 %0&@ 2(/$1$ .310/4+@6
DGG0(3.2 2 G0+.3)B)-0'(,J )7%0+-)2.'34 %@
B&)%0+8/) B.($7$30/4 V.
? ($-0'320 )+A&01+.5. .AI0(3$ )''/01.2$+)* A@/) 2783@ '.&3$ 8&.2.* %85(.* BH0+)F@
E&.6.&.2($, :,/$*(.2'($8 5, :,/$*(.2'($8 10,
:,/$*(.2'($8 100, :,/$*(.2'($8 7./.3)'3$8,
:,/$*(.2'($8 .'3)'3$8 ) Q5.-?.'3.-+$8 2, (.3.&@0 )'B@3@2$/)'4 2 8 D(./.5)-0'()6 '&01$6.
PB@3@ 7$(/$1@2$/) +$ B./86 #$%$&'(.5. !MM#=
)%. !.9. :,/$*(.2$ 2 2006–2008 55. +$ 12,6
G.+$6 (B. B$&.2.%, ) 70&+.2.%, B&01H0'320++)($%). E/.L$14 10/8+() 25 %2, B.23.&+.'34 –
3&06(&$3+$8. E.'02 B&.2.1)/'8 '08/(.* #!-10W,
,A.&($ – '0/0(F).++@% (.%A$*+.% Sampo 130.
# ($C1.* 10/8+() &0+1.%)7)&.2$++. .3A)&$/'8 B&.A+@* '+.B ' B/.L$1) 1 %2. <+$/)7,
B.120&5$/.'4 B. 50 B&.1,(3)2+@6 '30A/0*. E.
2'0% B&)7+$($% B&.2.1)/'8 .1+.G$(3.&+@*
1)'B0&').++@* $+$/)7. E. B&)7+$($%, &$7/)-)8
%0C1, 2$&)$+3$%) B. (.3.&@% A@/) 1.'3.20&+@, B&.2.1)/'8 12,6G$(3.&+@* 1)'B0&').++@*
$+$/)7 (G$(3.& < – '.&3$, G$(3.& ? – 5.1@ ×
G.+@).
? ($-0'320 $,3A&01+.5. .AI0(3$ A@/ 2783
+$A.& 16 5)A&)1.2 (,(,&,7@ 5&,BB@ 'B0/.'3)
X<P 200–250 '0/0(F)) &$7/)-+@6 ,-&0C10+)*
;.'')). PB@3 7$(/$1@2$/'8 2 2.'4%) D(./.5)-0'()6 3.-($6 (#$%$&'()* !MM#= – #$%$&'($8
.A/$'34, ?!MM (,(,&,7@ ) PPP ME< <5&.G)&%$ «P3A.&» – N$A$&1)+.->$/($&)8, X)/)$/
«E.2./C'($8 '0/0(F).++.-.B@3+$8 '3$+F)8»
!" ?!MMPY – ?./5.5&$1'($8 .A/$'34, X !"
«;.''.&5.» – #$&$3.2'($8 .A/$'34, N&$'+.1$&'()* !MM#= ) !E#X «!MN<#» – N&$'+.1$&'()* (&$*, ?.&.+0C'()* G)/)$/ ?!MMN –
?.&.+0C'($8 .A/$'34). E/.L$14 10/8+() 10 %2,
B.23.&+.'34 3&06(&$3+$8. E.'02 B&.2.1)/'8
'08/(.* «Hege-95».
?@-/0+0+)0 50+.3)B)-0'()6, '&01.2@6 )
50+.3)B-'&01.2@6 DGG0(3.2 B&.2.1)/'8 B.
B&)2010++.%, 2@H0 $/5.&)3%,. E.1'-03@
B&.2.1)/)'4 +$ B0&'.+$/4+.% (.%B4J30&0 ' )'B./47.2$+)0% B$(03$ B&.5&$%% «Agros-2.09».
-BGHDIC<CE ? :JFHK=B@?B
N$( 2)1+. )7 3$A/. 1, B. 2'0% )7,-$2H)%'8 B&)7+$($% 1./8 50+.3)B$ 2 G.&%)&.2$+))
G0+.3)B$ 8&.2.* BH0+)F@ B&)%0&+. .1)+$(.2$ ) &$2+$ 10,0–15,5 %. E. 12,% B&)7+$($%
((./)-0'32. 70&0+ 2 (./.'0 ) 2@'.3$ &$'30+)8)
1./8 DGG0(3.2 27$)%.10*'32)8 «50+.3)B/'&01$» 7+$-)30/4+. +)C0, -0% 50+.3)B)-0'()0 )
.'.A0++. '&01.2@0 2(/$1@. E. D3)% B&)7+$($%
.3A.& %.C03 A@34 DGG0(3)2+@% 2 /.($/4+@6
,'/.2)86 B&) +$/)-)) (.+3&$'3+@6 B. G0+.3)B, &0(.%A)+$+3.2 2 5)A&)1+@6 B.B,/8F)86.
PA$ D3) B&)7+$($ 2 (.+(&03+.% 'B0(3&0 G/J(3,-
144
!"#$%& '(%), 2010, *+, 14, - 1
)<JD?L< 1
SGG0(3@ (V) ) 1./8 2/)8+)8 (%) 50+.3)B$, '&01@ ) 27$)%.10*'32)8 «50+.3)B/'&01$»
+$ G.&%)&.2$+)0 (./)-0'320++@6 B&)7+$(.2 , 8&.2.* %85(.* BH0+)F@
M'3.-+)(
2$&4)&.2$+)8
#.&3$ (<)
"'/.2)8 '&01@ (?)
?7$)%.10*'32)0 (< × ?)
PH)A($ (Z)
9$''$ 70&+$
?@'.3$
O/)+$ 20&6+05.
"&.C$* 70&+$, N./)-0'32.
70&0+ 2 (./.'0 ' (./.'$, 5 &$'30+)8, '% %0C1.,7/)8, '%
5/%2
V
%
V
%
V
%
V
%
V
%
8,24
30,7
24,8
18,7
10,0
37,1
30,0
22,9
0,51
1,67
0,15
2,31
11,0
35,9
3,3
49,8
0,026
0,059
0,050
0,094
11,5
25,8
21,7
41,0
1,97
5,88
0,74
4,09
15,5
46,4
5,8
32,3
1,21
3,60
3,42
2,52
11,3
33,5
31,8
23,4
)&,JL)6 G$(3.&.2 '&01@ B. H($/0 +$B&8C0++.'3) '0/0(3)&,0%@6 B&)7+$(.2 1./C+@ A@34
.3+0'0+@ ( '&01+0+$B&8C0++@%.
:&) B&)7+$($ (,&.C$* 70&+$, %$''$ 70&+$ '
(./.'$ ) 1/)+$ 20&6+05. %0C1.,7/)8) )%0J3
',L0'320++@0 +$5&,7() DGG0(3.2 50+.3)B'&01.2.5. 27$)%.10*'32)8 (2 2–3 &$7$ B&02@H$JL)6 2(/$1 50+.3)B$) ) B.D3.%, .3+.'83'8
( .3+.')30/4+. +$B&8C0++@% B&)7+$($%, .3A.&
B. (.3.&@% %.C03 A@34 DGG0(3)2+@% /)H4
21./4 'B0F)$/4+.5. D(./.5)-0'(.5. 20(3.&$
(#J(.2 ) 1&., 2008).
? .3/)-)0 .3 BH0+)F@ 2 D('B0&)%0+3$6 '
5)A&)1+.* (,(,&,7.* B. A./4H)+'32, B&)7+$(.2 1.'3.20&+@6 DGG0(3.2 50+.3)B-'&01.2@6
27$)%.10*'32)* .3%0-0+. +0 A@/.. E. B&)7+$($% «,&.C$* 70&+$» ) «(./)-0'32. 1+0* 1.
2@+.'$ +)30*» %0C'.&3.2@0 &$7/)-)8 2+.')/)
7+$-)30/4+. A./4H)* 2(/$1 2 G.&%)&.2$+)0
G0+.3)B$, +0C0/) 2'0 )7,-$2H)0'8 (./)-0'320++@0 B&)7+$() , )+A&01+.5. .AI0(3$ (3$A/. 2).
0+.3)B-'&01.2$8 '.'3$2/8JL$8 , (,(,&,7@ B.
D3)% B&)7+$($% A@/$ %0+00 7+$-)%$, -0% %0C-
'.&3.2$8. E. B&)7+$(, «,A.&.-+$8 2/$C+.'34
70&+$» '..3+.H0+)0 50+.3)B)-0'(.* ) 50+.3)B'&01.2.* '.'3$2/8JL0* A@/. $+$/.5)-+@%
3$(.2.%, , A./4H)+'32$ (./)-0'320++@6 B&)7+$(.2, +$A/J1$0%@6 , )+A&01+.* (,/43,&@.
P1+$(. 2(/$1 27$)%.10*'32)8 «50+.3)B–'&01$»
2'0 C0 212.0 +)C0, -0% , BH0+)F@.
:. 0'34 2 F0/.% B.1320&C1$03'8 .3%0-0++$8
&$+00 +$ C)2.3+@6 .AI0(3$6 (Parsons, 1959; Hull
et al., 1963) 30+10+F)8 ( +0)7%0++. A./00 +)7(.%, ,&.2+J 2(/$1$ 50+.3)B-'&01.2@6 DGG0(3.2
2 G.&%)&.2$+)0 (./)-0'320++@6 B&)7+$(.2
, 5)A&)1.2 B. '&$2+0+)J ' 5.%.7)5.3+@%)
G.&%$%). "-)3@2$8 2 7+$-)30/4+.* '30B0+)
DB)50+03)-0'()* 6$&$(30& 27$)%.10*'32)8
«50+.3)B–'&01$», D3, 7$(.+.%0&+.'34 %.C+.
.AI8'+)34 ' B.7)F)* 5)B.307@ «MN?OB@BC?ABF9:O: J<D<@F<».
#,34 D3.* 5)B.307@ 7$(/J-$03'8 2 3.%, -3.
2 /JA.* (.+(&03+.* '.2.(,B+.'3) G$(3.&.2
'&01@ 50+.G.+1 B.B,/8F)) &0$/)7,03 .B&010/0++,J '.2.(,B+.'34 3&$+'(&)A)&,0%@6 B.'/01.2$30/4+.'30* ) &05,/83.&+@6 50+.2, .A0'-
)<JD?L< 2
SGG0(3@ (V) ) 1./8 2/)8+)8 (%) 50+.3)B$, '&01@ ) 27$)%.10*'32)8 «50+.3)B/'&01$»
+$ G.&%)&.2$+)0 (./)-0'320++@6 B&)7+$(.2 , (,(,&,7@
M'3.-+)( 2$&4)&.2$+)8
#.&3$ (<)
"'/.2)8 '&01@ (?)
?7$)%.10*'32)0 (< × ?)
PH)A($ (Z)
"&.C$* 70&+$, 5/%2
V
0,2927
0,3320
0,2500
0,3887
%
23,2
26,3
19,8
30,7
"A.&.-+$8 2/$C+.'34
70&+$, %
V
%
0,6437
8,4
5,0904
66,0
1,1420
14,8
0,8342
10,8
N./)-0'32. 1+0*
1. 2@+.'$ +)30*
V
%
0,8533
16,4
3,0680
58,5
0,5309
10,1
0,7884
15,0
!"#$%& '(%), 2010, *+, 14, - 1
B0-)2$JL)6 .B3)%$/4+,J G)7)./.5)-0'(,J
F0/.'3+.'34 F0+.7$ 2. 2&0%0+) ) B&.'3&$+'320
' +$)%0+4H)%) D+0&503)-0'()%) 7$3&$3$%).
:$(.0 '.'3.8+)0 ')'30%@ «50+.3)B–'&01$»
%@ +$7@2$0% DB)50+03)-0'()% A$/$+'.%. E&)
)+)F)$F)) )7%0+0+)8 /JA.5. )7 D/0%0+3.2
DB)50+.3)B$ ('.2.(,B+.'3) G$(3.&.2 2+0H+0*
'&01@ )/) 50+03)-0'(.* '&01@) B&.)'6.1)3
)+1,(F)8 D('B&0'')) 1.B./+)30/4+@6 3&$+'(&)B3.+.2, .A0'B0-)2$JL)6 G.&%)&.2$+)0
+.2.5. DB)50+03)-0'(.5. A$/$+'$. E.'(./4(,
2 5030&.7)5.3+@6 5)A&)1$6 ,C0 &0$/)7.2$+$
-$'34 DB)50+03)-0'(.* )7%0+-)2.'3), 3. D3$
-$'34 +0 A,103 7$G)(')&.2$+$ 2 '3$3)'3)(0 V ($(
%0&0 27$)%.10*'32)8 «50+.3)B–'&01$».
Z'+., -3. +0 B. 2'0% (./)-0'320++@% B&)7+$($% D3$ 7$(.+.%0&+.'34 A,103 &$A.3$34 .1)+$(.2. ,'B0H+.. E&.82/0+)0 D3.* 30+10+F))
A,103 7$2)'034 ($( .3 +$B&$2/0+)8 ) H)&.3@
)7%0+-)2.'3) D(./.5)-0'(.5. G$(3.&$, 3$( )
.3 'B0F)G)() 50+.3)B)-0'(.* 2$&)$A0/4+.'3)
)7,-$0%.5. .AI0(3$. !$B&)%0&, +)7(.0 7+$-0+)0
'3$3)'3)() V B. B&)7+$(, «2@'.3$ &$'30+)8» ,
8&.2.* BH0+)F@ %.C03 .B&010/834'8 2@'.(.*
1./0* $11)3)2+.* 2$&)$A0/4+.'3) 2 /.(,'0
RhtB1. :&) '.&3$ (:,/$*(.2'($8 5, :,/$*(.2'($8
100 ) E&.6.&.2($) +0',3 2@'.(.D('B&0'')2+,J
$//0/4 RhtB1b, .'3$/4+@0 – RhtB1a.
:$()% .A&$7.%, B./02@0 D('B0&)%0+3@ +$ 5030&.7)5.3+.% $,3A&01+.% &$'3)30/4+.% .AI0(30
(5)A&)1@ (,(,&,7@) 2 '&$2+0+)) ' )+A&01+@% 5.%.7)5.3+@% .AI0(3.% B.1320&C1$J3
7$(.+.%0&+.'34 A./00 +)7(.5. ,&.2+8 2(/$1$
50+.3)B-'&01.2@6 DGG0(3.2 2 G.&%)&.2$+)0
(./)-0'320++@6 B&)7+$(.2 , 5)A&)1.2 B. '&$2+0+)J ' 5.%.7)5.3+@%) G.&%$%). "-)3@2$8
2 7+$-)30/4+.* '30B0+) DB)50+03)-0'()* 6$&$(30& 27$)%.10*'32)8 «50+.3)B–'&01$», D3,
7$(.+.%0&+.'34 %.C+. .AI8'+)34 ' B.7)F)*
5)B.307@ «DB)50+03)-0'(.5. A$/$+'$».
"?CBP<CHP<
?$2)/.2 !.M. !$,-+@0 .'+.2@ '0/0(F)) BH0+)F@
// :0.&03)-0'()0 .'+.2@ '0/0(F)) &$'30+)*.
:. 2. 9.; T., 1935. #. 3–214.
O&$5$2F02 ?.<., <20&48+.2$ <.X. 906$+)7%@ 27$)%.10*'32)8 50+.3)B–'&01$ ) 5.%0.'3$7 (./)-0'320++@6 B&)7+$(.2 &$'30+)* // 0+03)($. 1983$.
:. 19. [ 11. #. 1806–1810.
O&$5$2F02 ?.<., <20&48+.2$ <.X. E0&0.B&010/0+)0
145
50+03)-0'()6 G.&%,/ (./)-0'320++@6 B&)7+$(.2
2 &$7+@6 ,'/.2)86 '&01@ // 0+03)($. 1983A.
:. 19. [ 11. #. 1811.
O&$5$2F02 ?.<., W)/4(0 ;.<., ;0*30& >. . ) 1&. 0+03)($ B&)7+$(.2 B&.1,(3)2+.'3) 8&.2@6 BH0+)F
2 Y$B$1+.* #)A)&). !.2.')A)&'(, 1984. 230 '.
N$3.6)+ <.?., N,7+0F.2$ :.!., P%0/48+-,( !.<.
9)-;!N – +.2@0 &05,/83.&@ $(3)2+.'3) 50+.2
, D,($&).3 // M+G.&%. 20'3+)( ?P )#. 2006.
:. 10. [ 2. #. 241–272.
N)/4-02'()* <.?., =.3@/02$ T.?. S(./.5)-0'($8
'0/0(F)8 &$'30+)*. 9)+'(: :D6+$/.5i8, 1997.
372 '.
N.&.-()+ T.M. R3. 3$(.0 DB)50+03)($ // 0+03)($.
2006. :. 42. [ 9. #. 1156–1164.
E/.6)+'()* !.<. 9$30%$3)-0'()0 %03.1@ 2 A)./.5)). 9.: M71-2. 9 ", 1978. 265 '.
;.()F()* E.X. >)./.5)-0'($8 '3$3)'3)($. 9)+'(:
?@HD*H. H(., 1973. 320 '.
#J(.2 ?.?. 0+03)-0'(.0 .A.'+.2$+)0 2@A.&$ G.+.2 B&) .3A.&0 B. (./)-0'320++@% B&)7+$($% //
E&.A/0%@ )+30+')G)($F)) ) D(./.5)7$F)) 70%/010/)8 ;.'')): 9$30&. +$,-.-B&$(3. (.+G. 14–15
)J+8 2006 5. ;$''203, 2006. #. 458–462.
#J(.2 ?.?., Y$6$&.2 ?. ., N&)2.A.-0( ?. . ) 1&.
903.1 .3A.&$ 50+.3)B.2 8&.2.* %85(.* BH0+)F@
+$ 5.%0.$1$B3)2+.'34: 903.1. ,($7$+)8. #$%$&$,
2008. 18 '.
R0'+.(.2 Q.?., E.-0B+8 !.?., >0&+0& <. ) 1&. S(./.5.-50+03)-0'($8 .&5$+)7$F)8 (./)-0'320++@6
B&)7+$(.2 &$'30+)* ) ($&3)&.2$+)0 /.(,'.2,
.B&010/8JL)6 $5&.+.%)-0'() 2$C+@0 B&)7+$()
, %85(.* BH0+)F@ // O.(/. ;<!. 2008. :. 418.
[ 5. #. 693–696.
Batson W. Mendel’s principles of heredity / Ed. W. Batson. Cambridge, 1909.
Blanc G., Charcosset A., Mangin B. et al. Connected
populations for detecting quantitative trait loci and
testing for epistasis: an application in maize // Theor.
Appl. Genet. 2006. V. 113. [ 2. ;. 206–224.
Börner A., Schumann E., Fürste A. et al. Mapping
of quantitative trait loci determining agronomic
important characters in hexaploid wheat (Triticum
aestivum L.) // Theor. Appl. Genet. 2002. V. 105.
;. 921–936.
Brink R.A. A genetic change associated with the R locus
in maize which is directed and potentially reversible
// Genetics. 1956. V. 41. ;. 872–889.
Brink R.A. Paramutation and chromosome organization
// Quart. Rev. Biol. 1960. V. 35. ;. 120–137.
Caligari P.D.S., Mather K. Genotype × environment interaction. III. Interactions in Drosophila melanogaster //
Proc. R. Soc. Lond. 1975. B. 191. ;. 387–411.
Connoly V., Jinks I.L. The genetical architecture of
general and speciÞc environmental sensitivity //
146
Heredity. 1975. V. 35. P. 2. ;. 249–259.
Chang S., Whitelaw E. Epigenetic germline inheritance
// Curr. Opin. Genet. and Developm. 2004. V. 14.
;. 692–696.
Dorn L.A., Schmitt J. Do plasticity genes exist or not?
// Progr. Abstr. of 6th Congr. Eur. Soc. Evol. Biol.
Arnehm, 24–28 Aug., 1997. Wageningen, 1997.
Durrant A. The environmental induction of heritable
changes in Linum // Heredity. 1962. V. 17. ;. 27–61.
Durrant A. Environmental conditioning of ßax // Nature.
1958. V. 181. ;. 928–929.
Evans G.M. Nuclear changes in ßax // Heredity. 1968.
V. 23. ;. 25–28.
Falconer D.S. Introduction to quantitative genetics. 2nd
ed. N.Y.: Longman Sci. Techn., 1981. 438 p.
Fisher R.A. The correlations between relatives on the
supposition of Mendelian inheritance // Trans. Roy.
Soc. Edinbourg, 1918. V. 52. ;. 399–433.
Hill J. The environmental induction of heritable changes
in Nicotiana rustica: Parental and selection lines //
Genetics. 1967. V. 55. ;. 735–754.
Hill J., Perkins J.M. The environmental induction of
heritable changes in Nicotiana rustica: 0ffect of
genotype-environment interactions // Genetics. 1969.
V. 61. ;. 661–675.
Hill J. Genotype–environment interactions – a challenge
for plant breeding // J. Agric. Sci. 1975. V. 85. P. 3.
;. 477–498.
Holland J.B. Epistasis and plant breeding // Plant Breed.
Rev. 2001. V. 21. ;. 27–92.
Hull P., Gove R.S., Slen S.B., Crawford R.D. A comparison of the interaction, with two types of environment,
of pure strains or strain crosses of poultry // Genet.
Res. 1963. V. 4. ;. 370–381.
Jinks J.L., Jayasekara N.E.M., Boughey H. Joint selection for both extremes of mean performance and
of sensitivity to a macroenvironmental variable.
I. Single seed descent // Heredity. 1977. V. 39. P. 3.
;. 345–355.
Jinks J.L., Pooni H.S. Determination of the environmental sensitivity of selection lines of Nicotiana rustica
by the selection environment // Heredity. 1982.
V. 49. P. 3. ;. 291–294.
Juengei T.E., Son S., Stowe K.A., Simms E.L. Epistasis
!"#$%& '(%), 2010, *+, 14, - 1
and genotype-environment interaction for quantitative trait loci affecting ßowering time in Arabidopsis thaliana // Genetica. 2005. V. 123. [ 1/2.
;. 87–105.
Landry C.R., Oh J., Hartl D.L., Cavalieri D. Genome-wide scan reveals that genetic variation for
transcriptional plasticity in yeast is biased towards
multi-copy and dispensable genes // Gene. 2006.
V. 366. ;. 343–351.
Li Y., Alvarez O.A., Gutteling F.W. et al. Mapping determinants of gene expression plasticity by genetical
genomics in C. elegans // PLOS Genet. 2006. V. 2.
e222.
Malmberg R.L., Held S., Waits A., Mauricio R. Epistasis
for Þtness-related quantitative traits in Arabidopsis
thaliana grown in the Þeld and the greenhouse //
Genetics. 2006. V. 171. [ 4. ;. 2013–2027.
Parsons P.A. Genotypic-environmental interactions for
various temperatures in Drosophila melanogaster //
Genetics. 1959. V. 44. [ 6. ;. 1325–1333.
Paterson A.H., Damon S., Hewitt J.D. et al. Mendelian
factors ungerlying quantitative traits in tomato:
Comparison across species, generations, and environments // Genetics. 1991. V. 127. ;. 181–197.
Plomin R., DeFries J.C., Loehlin J.C. Genotypic-environmental interactions and correlation in the analysis
of human behavior // Psychol. Bull. 1977. V. 84.
[ 2. ;. 309–322.
Rutter M., MofÞtt T.E., Caspi A. Gene-environment
interplay and psychopathology: multiple varieties
but real effects // J. Child Psychol. Psychiatry. 2006.
V. 47. [ 3/4. ;. 226–261.
Smith E.N., Kruglyak L. Gene-environment interaction
in yeast gene expression // PLOS Biol. 2008. V. 6.
[ 4. e83.
Ungerer M.C., Halldorsdottir S.S., Purugganon M.D.,
Mackay T.F. Genotype-environmental interactions at
quantitative trait loci affecting inßorescence development in Arabidopsis thaliana // Genetics. 2003.
V. 165. ;. 353–365.
Wade M.J., Winther R.G., Agrawal A.F., Goodnight C.J.
Alternative deÞnitions of epistasis: dependence and
interaction // Trends Ecol. Evol. 201. V. 16. [ 9.
;. 498–504.
147
!"#$%& '(%), 2010, *+, 14, - 1
THE CONTRIBUTION OF GENOTYPE-ENVIRONMENTAL EFFECTS
TO THE FORMATION OF QUANTITATIVE TRAITS IN INBRED
AND OUTBRED PLANTS
V.V. Syukov, E.V. Madyakin, D.V. Kochetkov
Samara ScientiÞc Research Institute of Agriculture, Bezenchuk, Russia,
0-mail: samniish@samtel.ru
Summary
The assumption about the epigenetic nature of the genotype–environment interaction is made and proven.
When genetic variances in descendants of various ages are analyzed, this interaction manifests itself as epistasis.
Study of inbred (common spring wheat) and outbred (hybrid maize) forms shows that ther contribution of
genotype–environmental factors to quantitative traits in hybrids is less than in homozygous forms. With regard to
the substantially epigenetic nature of the genotype–environment interaction, this trend can be explained in terms
of the epigenetic balance hypothesis.
Key words: «genotype–environment» interaction, epigenetical variability, epistasis, epigenetical balance,
wheat, corn.