Еще раз о критерии "качества" лазерных пучков

!"#$%&'($')*+',$'-. #/- 012 #'+2"-(2$
1.'202-.1 3-%2,.2*3$2'-'.1-3)+-$23-,2
,20'$202-.1 3-%*222&'-(--$,.)(202
,'-$'-%,3$*2(20-+1 3%+&'-2"-$, '")()2"(
42,25678+02"2&'-(-$12, 01229'+2"-(2$-1.'202-.1 3-%3/
02 &2(-1-"&'($'8'+2"-(2$&2 '2#7*:-$-2$-'+2"-(2$&2 '2#7*:;-20"7*6<='0--')(-.-+%1%$%>-'-
5$'1202(,-( ( 012202'&'"1-%*-.('%&2 '2#*2$1%#/(
&212- (,-(129-$-2$-*$2')( 012%>-'-,2 * $'-,2$2'202
2'"2$23&212-;-1-67?<2/02&2$2,-.1 3-%
",2&'2!-$($-3,2'(2$'-@2'() 012202'&'"1-%
'.1-3)+,20'$)+-$23-,2AB*CD&2,.12*3$2&2&)$,-'-$&',$-3, #
52$'.1-3)+-$23-,2&2.3-#1->2"202-.=$-+" +&'($'210,2
(20 $&'-$-,.1 !"-%(',$')(&'-('2((20 $&21 !-$ 012)
'&'"1-%*2.-,#/-'. 1$$"-@',5--&12,2921),' 012(2$'$-"-($'2(-,215+$(!>-("-($'2(- $'-(-"-($'(-22$$$ #/-'3$)&'-2"%$,1" #/-('. 1$$(E 012%'+2"-(2$
-.1 3-%=$-+$'+-$23-,2* " 3--.('&2 '2#7*:-$-2$-*"--5+
2$1%$-7*FG22$$$2H&2 '2#7*:='0--8B*7I*C*G-:*C:
/-9)2"2$2(*3$21#)&2&)$,-+',$'-.2$'+2"-(2$()+
'.1-3)+-$ 5-%+&2(2/#1->,,20281-22"202&'($'%1%#$%
&23)(-*)12'>223-";(2$'-*&'-('*ACD<(2$'%=$2*,25
678+02"2.&")&5-1-$)&21.'29$+-,31-3-$$*3$2&2"2)(
-'1)(&'($'2(%1%$%$,.)(2,3$2& 3, $2%/
'(%-(2=$2$&'($'%1%$%222922$$$ #/02'2&9,202$"'$H
$2' !-.$)1 3-*,20"'",5--.&")+! '122$,12%1-$$-*
,2$2')+ 012%'+2"-(2$-.1 3-%+',$'-.21,,-(81-2-)(&222(
2,21, 2$3$%1-$'$ '"-9&2=$2( &22" &23$-2"'!-$*")9
2&'2.1 !-$2&'"1)+,2(($'-
/02-&21. (21-$'$ '2&'"1-,3$& 3,;21$'20 #
$2'-#(
<22)$%)3-1--$"'$)+2$,12-92'(-'2)+
'&'"1-9-$-2$-1-!9-"19.2+
H." 8&'2$'$2- 0122'&'"1-%-$-2$-*
*2 2&"$&'%(29*&2,2$2'29
"-!$%& $2(&'2$'$5$'$%!$-& 3,
*-$0'-'2-."2 /$1%$%&2
&12,2$-*&'&"-, 1%'29 2&'"1)+&12,2$%+*%1%#/-+%1202(&12,2$-&'$%!,-"1%0 2
& 3,*1-3-) - "2$-0#$2-+(--(1)+.3-9 - (2=$.3-%-+2"%$'. 1$-' #/)'!-"1%,'-$'-%,3$ J2!-$1 .""21"1%$202*3$2)1
3-"1)+
0 2)+& 3,2;,1#3%$-0($-3,-<1-3-) - 2,.1-
')(-"--5H"1%+"' 0-+& 3,2=$-&'($')&')>#$"--5 *-3(
21>*$(-!,3$2
!(22&'"1-,3$& 3,3'.$"'$)2$,12-%*,"'$)
,2$2')+%1%#$%(2($(-$2'202&2'%",2$-$-2$-*022'-$2$2(*3$2."
%2.)>292,.)$%'21"1-++2$2'&'"1-%*"1%,2$2')+229
(2!-$1*')9,"'$ "1-%2$2-*3'.('21-,K21-($1)91-.
"9$-$12&2,.)$*3$2,3$2& 3,,,,'-$'-9"1%'-%&',$-3,29
52$-'.1-3)+-$23-,2,20'$202-.1 3-%21"$2'0-3,-(
"2$$,2(*,2$2'2021->)&'($')* &2(% $)31412$2(*3$2"1%1#)+
&',$-3,-!)+-$23-,2-.1 3-%'+2"-(2$*-.('%&2,,2( 81-2
'2#-$-2$--1-='0--*0"-($&212&'"1 #-,23 #
1-3- $2!'(%,3$2& 3,-($,23)'. ().3-%1->&')&21--(!$,-+ 12-9*,1")()+@2'( '&'"1-%&21%41%
21>-$'1)+-$23-,2,20'$202-.1 3-%=$- 12-%@2'(12
)&21%#$%
,*1-2&21.2$%$(*3$2'&'"1-%,2(&1,29(&1-$ ")1-!9"19.2+%.)L '8&'2'.2-(*$2(2!2&2,.$*3$2"1%1 3%& 3,
&12,-(212)(@'2$2(&'$%!,&'"1-@2'( 1
-120-3%@2'( 1"1% $#"1" $*
3$2&'-1-3--'.')2.--(2$--$-2$-2$&2&'3)+,22'"-$$2')
(2($) 012202'&'"1-%*-(--,3$2& 3,*$2%$%20'-32
21>-(-($-$(*$,-'.')) (21-(22.-,#$&'-"-@',5--0"
-(#/-+%'1)+2&$-3,-+-$(+!$,-+"-@'0(+
2"2%$' "2$&'-5-&(2!$)$229"&2(2/#"-%
&2"-.-' #/02(2!-$1%&'-$2'$-3,2('(2$'---1-20'-3-%&'$ ')
&'--.('--'&'"1-%"19.2*2",2&'-=$2('. 1$$3-$.-$
2$>-'-)-@2'()22$$$ #/9@ ,5--&'2& ,-%$' "2&2,.$*3$2
,.)@,$2')(20 $&2'"$2,.$%'. 1$$+'-%'.1-3)+
-.1 3$19
$($-(3$2&2=$-(&'-3-(' ,291-$'$ '&2%$-2,3$& 3,"1%
'1)+1.'2&',$-3,--,20"-&21.212(2$'%$2*3$2&')
&2&)$,+',$'-.2$1.'2-.1 3-%.),(2($2)12 /$1-(2
2--A
2!1 9*-21 "-$1)(&'-('2($202*3$22&2$1-52$
'.1-3)+-$23-,2&21-3- (2!$&'-$-, '"2( '. 1$$ *%1%$%
$$%-0(AD")1-)&21)&2"3$),3$& 3,2.,2&'()(
'&'"1-((&1-$ ")2$3$29&12,2$-"2-&21@.229,2'',5--
M,&'-($122 /$1-$,29,2'',5--)12)&212&')($2"(02120'@--AD-&2(2/#@.229&1$-,-AD"%,2'',5--2"-$%,$2( *3$2
'. 1$$"-%"2&21-$1)+,3,2@.)(!" 2"-(-&%$(-*')+
*.,
(&1-$ ")(3--2,.)$%2"-(-$(!*3$2&'-2"-$,'.,2(
(>-#'+2"-(2$--.1 3-%
2"3$)-0(*)&21)-("1%1 3%3-$2- 2-"1202'&'"1-%
(&1-$ ")$2202&21%*&2,.1-*3$21-3- "2-&21@.229,2'',5--
-.(%$%M$2$'. 1$$*,$$-*(2!$)$&21 3(2(2/(-"H51#
&'2/-%@2'( 1-"2$-!-%(,-(12901%"2$-20'-3-(%'(2$'-(
,'$-)$21,2"212"29-.&2&'3)+,22'"-$
20"22$$$ #/-),1",&'-2"%$,1" #/9@2'( 1"1%1 3%&'2-.21202"9$-$1202'&'"1-%
&21%&'$%!, =$202)'!-%&2'"$2-"2*3$2-.(-., .
2$"1)+
3$,+'&'"1-%(%$1-3-)-$0'1*-(-.3-% $2'(%,,-0()&21-12-'3$)*,, ! ,.)12*"1%3-$2
- 2-"1202'&'"1-%(&1-$ ")*,2$2'2-,20"'1-. $%&',$-,*()
)&21-1-120-3)'3$)"1%'&'"1-9&219*22$$$ #/-+)>-(
(2"( $293-202'.2$2'M$2%1%$%$(212&'")(&2$2( *3$2
2 !"()9($2"@.229,2'',5--)1&'"12!2'(%-(2"1%
(>-% 01229'+2"-(2$--.1 3-%1.' $293-)('.2$2'2(*
'2$#/-(2$"129&2&'329(2")2,202&2'%",
-B
'-(''. 1$$&'2"-%@.229,2'',5--1 3(2")BC802&2'%",
&'-"'- ,B&12>%,'-%22$$$ $ 0122( '&'"1-#-.1 3-%
"2@.229,2'',5--*>$'-+2%8$2(!(>$&22-(2%(8&21()9
01)9.01%"'- 2,&2,.)$*3$2@.2%,2'',5-%'.-$1)(2'.2(
1 3>$ 0122'&'"1--.1 3-%H5$'1)91&$2,($2-(>-+%"2
,2'',5--N8+&'25$22/9(2/2$-3-$-"$-F7?($$(*1-3- &21,2'',5--*,,-"2*&'2"21!$2$1%$C:-%1%$%*$,-(2'.2(*(
)2,29$21,2102"'%$2( *3$2-3$2!%"21%-.1 3-%2,.)$%'%29
21>- 01)'2-+2!"-=$202-.1 3-%%.2$(*3$2@ ,5-% 2"'!-$*,'2(21>29&2$2%293--& 3,2$1%#/9*,2(&2$)2"2
21)2,-(-&'2$'$)(-3$2$(-*3( ;2'>2120-32$2( *3$2
)&'%(12&'%!-&'--+2"293$2$$-:7O5-($.3-$1)& 15-3$2$29B77O5<
$($-(/*3$2"1%&'2$2$)>&'-('2$2-1%,,2'',5--1->&22"2( -.
&2&'3)+&'1-9H&'- 3$-"' 0202&'1-%'. 1$$)1)/(202
21'.-$1)(",2-$,2&'"$1%$%"2$$232 "-$1)(
-"$1$2($202*3$2&11-'2$,,3$ & 3,"1,20"'. (2*
(2$'-,, 329*$,-$+-3,291-$'$ ')&2,$229=1,$'2-,
&2,.)$*3$2$-"' 0-&'-(')&2"2202'2"
,*,'-$11-3,-+'"+
$'"2$1)+1.'23$2&'- $$ #$(1,2(>$)2&$-3,-2"2'2"2$-
1--+1->,2((202*$22-&'-2"%$,'%-#(129"21-2/02&2$2,
1.'202-.1 3-%&2"'-$1221>-(- 01(-;&2"'2)"-%2&2"2)+
%1-%+-22$$$ #/ #-1-20'@-#(2!29$-AGD<>-)3-1-%
-&21.2-(&'-")+AB7*BBD=,&'-($1)+")+&2,.1-*3$21-3-
=$2(1 3&21(2!$2$-$,21,2"%$,2"!$20"*,20"
&2"1%#/%3$2/02&2$2,-.1 3-%2'"2$23"-@',5-2220'-32(
,'
=$2&2,.)$*3$2"2$2') !"-%252$-$+-1--)+-$23-,2
22.-%1-3-) (2!2)'2$$$21,2$20"*,20"=$--$23-,&'".3)-(2"1%0'5--3-$20 2)+& 3,2-2(1-.,-,
2'>$ *$,3$2.3-% (20-(2$1-3#$%2$"--5)
(2$'%29>-%-%*$2' &28&'!( &'"$1%$%*3$2-21
-'1)(&'($'2(*+',$'-. #/-( 0122'&'"1-2+$+1 3%+*
,20")+2"%&'$ '1.''1220'-3-$3-& 3,-$(()(."$
1-3- "-@',5-2202&'"1'+2"-(2$-*%1%$%-&21. ()9AB*C*GD
''5-2)9@,$2'-!$%-&'- >-'--5$'12021&$, 012202
'&'"1-%*-$2(1 3*,20"$,202 >-'-%&'2-+2"-$*2.($%3$
='0--3-$&'+2"-$2,2)1&$,-M$2@,$2''2$2>-#229-1)
$;-$-2$-5$' 012202'&'"1-%<,(,-(122.(2!2( &'"29)+2"29(2/2$-.3-#&2(-(*3$2&21""2$-0$%$2(1 3*
,20"21229@'2$%1%$%&12,-(*&12$2$-.1 3-%'2('2'&'"1&2
9&'$ 'H-(2$20"2&3-$%(,-(12"12"9$--$(
$212,5--*&'"1%,25$'5-%='0--5$'@2, -'2202&%$-$&
-C
'-"(,2$2')")"1%& 3,0 2)('&'"1-(-$-2$-
-C2$2-$%,1 3#*,20"$,29& 32,&-
,' 01 #&'$ ' "-($'2( &12>29,'-29-.2'!.--(2$
''5-2202@,$2'2$2$2>-%
"!1-3--$-2$-
,'#&'$ ')&22$2>-#,(,-(12( .3-#;& ,$-'%,'-%<
.'- ,-"2*3$22&'"12("-&.2-.(-%
1-3-
''5-2202@,$2'"2$$2321-.,,"--5-$2!'(%-$-2$
,'#"-@'0()((1*3$2-"$1$ $212$-&223)+1&$,2*
&2%1%#/-+%.3$2'.-%+2$20 2'&'"1-%
,-(2'.2(*."
-$ 5-%%1%$%"2$$232 "21$2'-$129$23,-.'-%,,$+*,$2$'(-$%,
21>29229-1$*$,-$+*,$2201 01$-$2' &223)((,-( ((-M$-(&'-('2(-&21.2-%''5-2202@,$2'&'-)2'
&'($'2-$()@2'(-'2-%& 3,()-20'-3-(%
(12(2!2 $'!"$*3$22)9'2&9,-9$"'$;P
2$11#"(-*&12+22"2(1)(--$2'-92&'2-.,2()(-1->
( .,-(-,1(-1.'2-'>()+-+&2(2/#."3
&$-3,-'.2$2')-&'21('+2"-(2$-1.'202-.1 3-%
JE ,*BGFGQC6
&$-3,-'.2$2')-1.')& 3,-J ,*BGG7CIN
!" #$"#%&%'%() *+ %#,%* -$./!&'*012%*3
4
/#$5%%3%() *6.*%4',!%##$6.78&!,9%*.8& : !#',
4,!&;9*<8#"#$#,# !,;=%.#,-#& ! >*(,?* !%#%(
.$-%82*"-2@-.-,*BGFB*$BN*BQ:Q
4,!" &,,* ?4
RR-(SM
L*BGFB*$BN*CF
4,%..8#?4
!) *+ %#,%* #$6.>!?*'#"*%5&.-$./!&'*6*! ,%&
!&$&4!#$012%*34
*J,*"2KJRRSM
L*BGIF*$:C*BC
*#-(2*"2KJRRS ''-,1&,$'*BGI6*$6*G::
*K,>RR&$-,-&,$'2,2&-%*BGGN*$FI*ICN